AI assistant
Orange Belgium S.A. — Annual Report 2012
Mar 29, 2013
3986_10-k_2013-03-29_84223b27-8e62-44bf-9c5c-d0d2775a675a.pdf
Annual Report
Open in viewerOpens in your device viewer
Annual report 2012
Mobistar focuses on transparency for its customers
Annual Results 2012
Information for Mobistar shareholders
Shareholders' structure
Situation on 31-12-2012
Financial calendar
Press release results FY 2012: 06/02/2013 Annual report 2012 available on the internet website: 29/03/2013 Press release financial results Q1 2013: 22/04/2013 General Assembly of shareholders: 02/05/2013 Payment of ordinary dividend: 24/05/2013
Press release financial results 1H 2013: 23/07/2013 Press release financial results Q3 2013: 21/10/2013
Share price evolution
| Key figures | 2012 | 2011 | 2010 | 2009 | 2008 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Number of shares end of year | 60,014,414 | 60,014,414 | 60,014,414 | 60,014,414 | 60,014,414 |
| Number of shares free float end of year | 28,261,314 | 28,261,314 | 28,261,314 | 28,261,314 | 28,261,314 |
| Mobistar stock market capitalisation end of year (in €) | 1,163,679,487 | 2,385,572,957 | 2,911,299,223 | 2,874,390,359 | 3,099,144,339 |
Brussels Stock Exchange data (in €)
| Highest price | 40.98 | 53.33 | 49.20 | 59.00 | 63.50 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lowest price | 18.70 | 37.73 | 39.51 | 41.19 | 45.00 |
| Price end of year | 19.39 | 39.75 | 48.51 | 47.90 | 51.64 |
| Total volume for the period* | 44,150,505 | 45,717,610 | 42,058,634 | 53,685,388 | 78,556,036 |
| Average daily trading volume* | 172,463 | 177,890 | 163,018 | 209,709 | 309,276 |
| Turnover of free float/year | 1.56 | 1.62 | 1.49 | 1.90 | 2.78 |
*Number of shares
(if approved by GA)
Annual Results 2012
2012 key figures
Service revenue (in mio €)
EBITDA (in mio €)
| 1450.0 | 2012 | 494.1 |
|---|---|---|
| 1505.8 | 2011 | 1999 - 1999 - 1999 - 1990 - 1990 - 1990 - 1990 - 1990 - 1990 - 1990 - 1990 - 1990 - 1990 - 1990 - 1990 - 199 |
| 1523.5 | 2010 | 548.7 |
| 1444.8 | 2009 | $-567.0$ |
| 1443.7 | 2008 | 591. -555 |
| 1445.3 | 2007 | 222222222222223 592. |
| 1496.1 | 2006 | TELEVISION (1984) 614 |
| 1404.3 | 2005 | 22 (22 22 22 23 375) |
| 276.3 | 2004 | 555.5 |
| 6.5 | 2003 | FERRER 434.7 |
| 2002 | 316.8 | |
| 2001 | 154.7 | |
| 2000 77.9 | ||
| 1999 | 16.9 | |
Cumulated capital expenditures (in mio €)
| 2012 | ,,,,,,,,, 320 |
|---|---|
| 2011 | 22222222222222223016 |
| 2010 | Children (1975) 2812 |
| 2009 | 1999 - 2573.0 2573.0 |
| 2008 | 2426.9 |
| 2007 | 12267.0 2267.0 |
| 2006 | Communication 2120.2 |
| 2005 | 1955 0 1955 0 |
| 2004 | 1756.4 |
| 2003 | $\blacksquare$ 1585.2 |
| 2002 | 1449.2 |
| 2001 | 12907 |
| 2000 | 9210 |
| 1999 | 744.8 |
Mobistar active customer base evolution - MVNO & MaTMa excl. (x 000)
Consolidated net income
(in mio €)
Evolution customer base Mobistar S.A.
Evolution mobile data (in mio €)
Advanced data as % of service revenue
Distribution of turnover
Capex* (in mio €) ■ Orange Com Lux ■ MES ■ Network ■ Devices ■ CAPEX (licence
| Consolidated Statement of | Mobistar Group | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Comprehensive Income (in mio €) | 2012 | 2011 | 2010 | 2009 | 2008 | |
| Service revenue | 1,450.0 | 1,505.8 | 1,523.5 | 1,444.8 | 1,443.7 | |
| Handsets sales | 200.5 | 151.8 | 141.1 | 122.4 | 89.0 | |
| Total turnover | 1,650.5 | 1,657.6 | 1,664.6 | 1,567.2 | 1,532.7 | |
| Other operating revenue | 51.9 | 42.0 | 33.2 | 37.6 | 34.1 | |
| Total revenue | 1,702.4 | 1,699.6 | 1,697.8 | 1,604.8 | 1,566.8 | |
| Interconnection costs | -390.5 | -396.4 | -416.4 | -358.1 | -328.7 | |
| Costs of equipment and goods sold | -353.0 | -297.1 | -265.4 | -250.2 | -219.2 | |
| Services and other goods | -281.8 | -297.5 | -306.9 | -271.5 | -278.9 | |
| Employee benefits expenses | -156.1 | -150.0 | -140.8 | -133.1 | -132.2 | |
| Depreciation, amortisation and impairment | -217.2 | -190.3 | -170.7 | -164.3 | -173.1 | |
| Other operating charges | -27.0 | -28.6 | -19.6 | -24.9 | -16.2 | |
| Total operating expenses | -1,425.6 | -1,359.9 | -1,319.8 | -1,202.1 | -1,148.3 | |
| EBITDA | 494.1 | 530.1 | 548.7 | 567.0 | 591.6 | |
| EBITDA margin in % of service revenue | 34.1% | 35.2% | 36.0% | 39.2% | 41.0% | |
| EBIT | 276.8 | 339.7 | 378.0 | 402.7 | 418.5 | |
| Finance income | 0.5 | 0.9 | 0.6 | 1.4 | 1.9 | |
| Finance costs | -11.2 | -11.8 | -5.1 | -6.1 | -7.4 | |
| Result of operating activities after net finance costs | 266.1 | 328.8 | 373.5 | 398.0 | 413.0 | |
| Tax expense | -80.5 | -107.9 | -109.9 | -137.7 | -132.9 | |
| Net profit of the period | 185.7 | 221.0 | 263.6 | 260.3 | 280.1 | |
| Profit attributable to equity holders of the parent | 185.7 | 221.0 | 263.6 | 260.3 | 280.1 | |
| Basic earnings per share in € | 3.09 | 3.68 | 4.39 | 4.34 | 4.54 | |
| Weighted average number of ordinary shares | 60,014,414 | 60,014,414 | 60,014,414 | 60,014,414 | 61,754,776 | |
| Diluted earnings per share in € | 3.09 | 3.68 | 4.39 | 4.34 | 4.54 | |
| Diluted weighted average number of ordinary shares | 60,014,414 | 60,014,414 | 60,014,414 | 60,014,414 | 61,754,776 |
| Consolidated Balance Sheet (in mio €) | 31.12.2012 | 31.12.2011 | 31.12.2010 | 31.12.2009 | 31.12.2008 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Non-current assets | 1,045.8 | 1,070.3 | 1,020.0 | 882.5 | 898.0 |
| Current assets | 288.9 | 304.1 | 270.2 | 260.6 | 295.5 |
| Cash and cash equivalents | 12.3 | 7.1 | 13.0 | 10.0 | 6.8 |
| Total assets | 1,347.0 | 1,381.5 | 1,303.2 | 1,153.1 | 1,200.3 |
| Equity | 357.8 | 394.0 | 431.2 | 440.8 | 452.5 |
| Long-term borrowings | 383.7 | 293.2 | 267.9 | 0.0 | 75.0 |
| Long-term trade payables | 13.4 | 28.3 | 43.2 | 0.0 | 0.0 |
| Long-term provisions | 67.4 | 61.6 | 18.6 | 14.6 | 15.1 |
| Deferred taxes | 0.0 | 1.2 | 1.7 | 0.0 | 1.7 |
| Short-term borrowings | 22.6 | 18.4 | 32.9 | 298.0 | 243.3 |
| Other payables | 502.1 | 584.8 | 507.7 | 399.7 | 412.7 |
| Total equity and liabilities | 1,347.0 | 1,381.5 | 1,303.2 | 1,153.1 | 1,200.3 |
| Consolidated Cash Flow Statement (in mio €) | 2012 | 2011 | 2010 | 2009 | 2008 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| EBITDA | 500.0 | 521.8 | 545.7 | 563.6 | 587.4 |
| Change in working capital | -32.8 | -8.0 | 23.1 | 10.0 | -17.8 |
| Tax expense | -154.9 | -79.4 | -58.5 | -137.7 | -132.9 |
| Net cash used in investing activities | -179.6 | -192.8 | -236.9 | -139.1 | -151.9 |
| Loans and borrowings | 94.6 | 10.8 | 2.7 | -20.3 | 312.2 |
| Share capital and share premium | 0.2 | -0.2 | -0.1 | -0.2 | -248.8 |
| Net purchase of treasury shares | 0.0 | 0.0 | 0.0 | 0.0 | -175.0 |
| Dividend paid | -222.4 | -258.1 | -273.1 | -273.1 | -173.6 |
| Free Cash Flow | 5.1 | -5.9 | 2.9 | 3.2 | -0.4 |
| Consolidated Statement of Comprehensive Income | 2012 | 2011 | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Segment reporting (in mio €) | Belgium | Luxembourg | Mobistar Group |
Belgium | Luxembourg Mobistar | Group | |
| Service revenue | 1,400.4 | 65.5 | 1,450.0 | 1,456.4 | 60.7 | 1,505.8 | |
| Handsets sales | 204.9 | 10.0 | 200.5 | 154.6 | 5.1 | 151.8 | |
| Total operating revenues | 1,605.3 | 75.5 | 1,650.5 | 1,611.0 | 65.7 | 1,657.6 | |
| EBITDA | 482.6 | 11.5 | 494.1 | 521.6 | 8.5 | 530.1 | |
| EBITDA margin in % of service revenue | 34.5% | 17.6% | 34.1% | 35.8% | 14.0% | 35.2% | |
| EBIT | 273.2 | 3.6 | 276.8 | 341.7 | -1.9 | 339.7 |
ANNUAL REPORT 2012
Mobistar focuses on transparency for its customers
The year 2012 was full of challenges, to say the least. The telecom sector underwent major changes, which had an important impact on the ecosystem of operators, partners and customers alike. Mobistar addressed the numerous challenges head-on with a powerful, fresh strategy. It was also a year of transparency for the customer. In this area Mobistar introduced a series of new subscriptions, and its service was thoroughly revised, which led among other things to the creation of an internal ombudsman. Since the results of this new approach are encouraging, Mobistar will take it into 2013. All the details are included in this annual report.
Table of contents
- Message from the Chairman 4
- 5 questions for Jean-Marc Harion 6
- Highlights 2012 10
- Mobistar strategy 12
- A dynamic telecom market 16
- The customer in the centre 18
- Getting started at Mobistar 30
- Corporate social responsibility 36
- Activity report 2012 57
- Annual accounts Mobistar S.A. 2012 85
- IFRS consolidated financial statements 2012 107
- Declaration by the responsible persons 153
Message from the Chairman
Mobistar is becoming a 'SuperMobile' operator
2012 saw radical changes in the telecom market. Federal and European rulings disadvantaged our mobile activities while at the same time leaving the position of the historic operator and cable companies unaffected.
The new Belgian telecom law that came into force on 1 October, six months before the planned date, further strengthened this distortion and destroyed value in the market for mobile activities.
The great flexibility of our organisation means that Mobistar has rapidly adapted to this market data. It has adapted to the needs of the market and simplified matters. In order to work on an additional far-reaching internal transformation of our operations, the management and the Board of Directors have charted the problems with which Mobistar was and is confronted.
We have once again defined our priorities and our strategy: Mobistar will become a 'SuperMobile' operator in the future. Our vision is thus very simple: we put the customer first, opting for simple solutions and offering them services that meet their needs, available anytime and anywhere.
Thanks to the devotion, passion and talents of our employees in 2012, we have fully achieved the forecasted results. The fact that Mobistar has managed to give a sterling performance in spite of the difficult environment has erroneously not been valued on the stock market.
In 2013 the market data will become even more difficult. In spite of all our efforts, this year our results will also be affected by the influence of the regulation and the resulting destruction of value.
Fortunately, Mobistar's entire team is extremely enthusiastic about dealing with this challenge and the Board of Directors is prepared to use the necessary means to guarantee the quality of our services to our customers.
Jan Steyaert Chairman of the Board of Directors
"In 2013 Mobistar will continue to invest in a powerful mobile network."
Jan Steyaert Chairman of the Board of Directors
Interview with the CEO
In December 2011, Mobistar's Board of Directors appointed Jean-Marc Harion as the new CEO (Chief Executive Officer). It must not have been easy, because the telecoms sector faced an eventful year, in Belgium too. How does he see his first year? And above all, how does he see the future? A conversation in five questions.
Question 1
How was your first year as CEO of Mobistar?
"It was a year of discoveries. I became CEO during a period in which the whole telecoms sector was undergoing a transformation: not just in Belgium, but worldwide. In 2012, we chose to anticipate the market evolution. The mobile market in Belgium was already very competitive and the new telecoms law, which had come into force sooner than expected, only exacerbated matters.
It was Mobistar that introduced competition to Belgian mobiles telecoms and we're certainly not afraid of it. I think Mobistar better assimilated the new context than the competitors: we prepared for the arrival of the new telecoms law by launching animal tariffs in April. The result was that we saw the number of post-paid customers increase in 2012, and this was far from easy. I am extremely grateful to our employees for this great result."
Question 2
It was an eventful year.
"Indeed, and on different levels. The mobile termination and roaming tariffs continued to decline in 2012, which again negatively impacted on our revenues and our EBITDA margin. Internally, we worked to improve the performance of our IT infrastructure and certain processes, including the activation of digital TV and ADSL for our customers. At the same time, we also simplified our organisation. We created a wholesale division and we renewed our MVNO contract with Telenet. In the B2B market we concluded an agreement with the Brussels Region for the joint management of the Irisnet fibre optic network. And we achieved the objectives we set as regards our turnover, EBITDA and net result.
Our shares have not taken a very positive path, but it is the same for all telecom operators in Europe. Perhaps the stock market has not understood that our industry today is at the end of one cycle and the beginning of a new one. And this new cycle has enormous growth potential for Mobistar. Just think of the opportunities opening up with 4G or cable regulation, which should be liberalised in 2013."
"Mobistar introduced competition to Belgian mobile telecoms. We're certainly not afraid of it."
Jean-Marc Harion Chief Executive Officer
Interview with the CEO, continued
Question 3
Mobistar cannot (yet) offer a total package. Isn't that a disadvantage?
"Indeed, traditional fixed operators offer packages that include fixed voice, Internet and digital television, to which they offer to add mobile. A kind of 'all you can eat' buffet, where you pay a high fixed price regardless of what you eat. At Mobistar, we don't want to force the customer to buy the complete formula. More and more, telecommunications usage differs from one individual to another: everyone should be able to build their own convergence 'à la carte' based on the services they really need, how they want and where they want: at the office, at home, on the bus or with friends. That's where mobility is at the heart of convergence: our whole strategy is built upon our leadership in mobile communications. For individuals, of course, but also for professionals. For businesses, Machine-To-Machine – connectivity between devices and machines – represents a huge growth potential. This market is changing at a very fast pace and in this area we are also leading the way."
Question 4
In terms of mobility, 4G seems to be the Holy Grail.
"With equal or superior quality to that of fixed Internet, 4G is a very promising technology. People watch less and less television in a linear and passive way: 4G will allow them, for example, to watch what they want, when they want, where they want it and on the screen of their choice. We've started the deployment of our 4G network and we opened two pilot networks, one in Antwerp, and one in Luxembourg City through our subsidiary Orange Luxembourg. We foresee the opening of our commercial 4G network in 2013, which will be the year of preparation for the future. We're not only investing in 4G, but also in improving the speed of our 3G network. This isn't easy within the current economic climate. So we also need to continue reducing our cost structure and internal operations. We choose to simplify our processes and get
as close as possible to our customers. We offer them a real bond of trust, committing ourselves to adapting what we can offer to their changing needs and answering their questions via all our channels, including the web. We're primarily a service provider, and to provide the best service to our clients we also ensure that our employees are happy to work at Mobistar."
Question 5
How do you see the Mobistar of tomorrow?
"We see ourselves as a 'SuperMobile' operator: simple, close to the customer and providing the services they need, whenever and wherever they need them. Because it's a strategy that matches the evolution of usage and society, I think we still have a great story to write."
Mobile broadband network 4G
4G is up to 10 times faster than 3G. Chatting, downloading, surfing – everything's possible at speeds comparable to that of fixed Internet.
With 4G our customers can easily chat and play games in real-time while on the move, at the same speed as at home. They can surf at an incredible speed and on top of this they can enjoy the extraordinary quality of video and music applications.
Highlights
video on demand. Introduction of animals 2 april
In order to make it easier for customers to choose, Mobistar developed new transparent subscriptions, represented by animals (Squirrel, Kangaroo, Dolphin and Panther).
Launch of Plug Mobile 12 MARCH
RTL and Mobistar have joined forces to launch Plug Mobile, a low-cost alternative for prepaid customers with free access to the three channels of RTL Belgium, exclusive competitions and
Polar expedition ended well 10 FEBRUARY
After their groundbreaking expedition of 5,000 km and over 74 days on the South Pole, polar explorers Dixie Dansercoer and Sam Deltour return safely.
2012 JAN FEB MAR APR MAY
Helpline for missing children 25 may
116 000 is the European helpline for missing children. On the occasion of the International Missing Children's Day, Mobistar promotes MyStart giving this toll-free number in Belgium.
Mobistar is Top Employer 5 MARCH
Mobistar received the certificate of Top Employer Belgium 2012, given to companies with outstanding working conditions.
New: Panther Pro and Kangaroo Pro 30 mAY
Mobistar launches two new plans for entrepreneurs. In addition to many handy services, they also contain a dedicated and specialised customer service.
customers a helping hand 13 FEBRUARY
Mobistar introduces MyStart: a service which, with the help of an expert at a Mobistar Centre, configures users' smartphones in no more than 20 minutes.
Mobistar offers Internet On Mobile 20 august
Mobistar launches Internet On Mobile, a new online prepaid deal where customers receive 1 or 2 GB of data for every recharge.
Recharge via Facebook 6 november
Internet On Mobile customers can simply recharge their card on the Facebook page of Mobistar Belgium, a first in the Belgian market.
Launch of Travel Data Control 4 JUNE
Mobistar customers no longer need to worry about using mobile internet abroad: using Travel Data Control, customers can set themselves a limit.
Thanks to its partnership with Orange, Mobistar offers its business customers in the corporate segment convergent telecommunication solutions through its own IP VPN platform.
Telecommuting reduces CO2 emissions 21 november
Mobistar had been promoting home working since 2008, and these initiatives are starting to bear fruit. The company CO2logic calculated that Mobistar reduced its CO2 emissions by 400 tons annually through home working.
Mobistar innovates with green cars 5 junE
Mobistar is the first company in Belgium to provide, in addition to a list of company cars available to its employees, a separate list consisting of exclusively electric and hybrid models.
Animals were a success 23 july
Squirrel, Kangaroo, Dolphin and Panther. More than 160,000 Belgians have already opted for one of these new mobile subscriptions, launched in April.
Big event for new iPhone 5 28 september
Mobistar started selling the iPhone 5 at a special event at Brussels Expo. Mobistar customers, who had taken part in the iSwap campaign and had won the competition, were able to collect their new iPhone there.
4G pilot project 24 julY
Mobistar opens its 4G pilot network in Antwerp backed by the experience and technical support of the Orange Group which has also implemented 4G in the French cities of Marseille, Lyon and Nantes.
"Nobody knows to what extent mobile technologies will influence our daily lives."
Olivier Ysewijn Chief Strategy Officer
Interview with Olivier Ysewijn, Chief Strategy Officer at Mobistar
We want to become the mobile reference network in Belgium in 2015
Olivier Ysewijn, Chief Strategy Officer, is not afraid to admit that Mobistar has had an eventful year. And it's been all hands on deck to prepare for the landslides awaiting the telecom world. 'Consumers have no idea what is going to happen in the next few years,' he says. This led to a conversation about the near and the (not so) distant future.
"Last year we had to take our foot off the accelerator a little, internally speaking,' Olivier Ysewijn says as he looks back on 2012. 'Along with the coming into force of the new telecom law introduced on 1 October, it was quite a turbulent year. The market for mobile telephony had been stable for years. This was much less the case this year, if only because of the fall in prices due to fierce competition. At Mobistar, we need to focus particularly on our DNA—the SuperMobile for the sake of Mobistar's future position. We can only do this with an excellent network, which means that we will invest more in it this year. This year we're dealing with 1,000 sites—new ones, as well as existing ones which are to be upgraded. Our old mobile radio sites will be replaced with hybrid sites that can handle 2G, 3G and 4G. 2G will certainly still be used for voice communication until after 2020. A combination of 2G for voice calls and 3G and 4G for data communication constitutes an efficient strategy."
Obtaining permits remains an issue for new sites.
"Indeed. The fact that we are renewing or building 1,000 sites this year is primarily due to the fact that this is the maximum our suppliers can physically handle, but also has to do with building permits. The government wants perfect coverage everywhere, but the authorisation needed from local authorities is hard to come by. You only have to take Brussels as an example, with its new, stringent
emission standards. To bring the quality back to the same level that it was prior to the stringent radiation regulations, approximately 120 sites would need to be added. When you consider the fact that it can take up to 24 months to obtain a licence, you realise that it may not be solved overnight. We started rolling out the 4G network last year. Despite the issue with permits, our objective is to have 4G coverage of 80% of the population by 2015— a very ambitious goal. Either way, we want to be the Belgian mobile telephone reference network by 2015."
Interview with Olivier Ysewijn, continued
With 4G as the cream of the crop, is this the new revolution?
"4G is a technology that allows very fast broadband internet to be used everywhere. In terms of download speed and latency, 4G almost approaches the quality of wired internet. Video will remain the main driver with consumers in the next few years. On the other hand, we need to be realistic. The use of smartphones and tablets will mix 4G and wifi usage.
There are also professional applications. Under tests carried out with ATV, a television channel in Antwerp, where we now have 45 4G sites, we demonstrated that journalists can now broadcast their reports live."
How long will it take for 4G to make a breakthrough?
"People do not buy technology—they buy services and experiences. So it's all about the applications and the iPhone has taught us that this can happen quickly. There is a tendency in the sector to overestimate the short term and underestimate the long term. I expect 4G to experience a double acceleration, such as that of the iPhone, with more phones and contracts being sold, and a growing intensity in usage. We need to be ready with our network to take advantage of this double trend."
Are great times ahead for telecommunications companies?
"The transition to 4G creates a discontinuity in the market that provides an opportunity for mobile operators to reposition their brand, renew their price structure and generally revive their competitiveness in the market. It is an opportunity that generally only arises once every decade.
There are certainly great times ahead for consumers. They really have no idea how radically mobile technologies will impact on their daily lives. For example, there's the importance of mobile telephony in road charging. Mobility in traffic is an ever-increasing problem. The issue of an ageing population and a shortage of affordable infrastructure to provide welfare for everyone, will lead to new technologies being developed in which mobile technologies will play an important role."
Is Mobistar more than just an intermediary for providing those kinds of services?
"It's true that we primarily ensure connectivity between the hardware vendor and service provider. But we have an important core competitive advantage that you should not forget: throughout the years, we have had tremendous experience in managing customer data for a very large group of clients. Consumers consider us to be a very reliable provider when it comes to personal data. This is a very important asset for future services."
At a price. So there will be new business opportunities.
"If you downloaded a ringtone five years ago, everyone thought it was quite normal to pay for that and that part of the charge went to the content provider and another part to the telecom company. Now you can download a video that requires a thousand times more capacity, without the content provider being charged. Obviously, telecom operators can't constantly invest in making that possible without being paid for the use of their network. This model is no longer viable in the long term, if only for the issue of capacity."
Why?
"Everyone can drive 120 km per hour on the Brussels ring road, but if there's a traffic jam, nobody can. If we want to continue to guarantee "quality of service" to our customers, we need to segment them. This means some customers will take precedence over others at peak times. Segmentations can also be made in the case of wired internet. So why can't we do that for mobile internet? Technically speaking, that is already possible. Should the data traffic needed by paramedics accessing the medical records of a road accident victim be given the same priority as those for someone who is killing time watching YouTube video clips or downloading an entire video?"
If you can identify network usage, you know who is watching what on digital television.
"Identity management is one of our most important assets. Watching television will become an experience more and more individual and personalised. We watch television when and wherever we want and on the device of our choice. This means there will be a total shift in the industry. Whenever I say this, some people feel threatened. We own the data required for targeted advertising and this means we could sell it. But on the other hand, we can help channels offer to each user the programmes that suit them best. In this area too, a new model is coming."
2012: a dynamic telecom market
2012, a very dynamic year
The new telecom law entered into force on 1 October 2012. The telecom market was thoroughly shaken up, especially in the area of mobile telephony. Mobistar anticipated the entry into force of this new law by launching new tariff plans in April.
A new telecom law
Among other things, the new telecom law provides for the abolition of a cancellation fee after six months. Only those who terminate their contracts within the first six months are obliged to pay a fee. The latter is limited to the price of the contract for that period.
Smartphones and tablets experiencing a breakthrough
The adoption of smartphones and tablets among Belgian consumers continued in 2012, according to calculations carried out by the GfK consultancy. According to GfK, about 800,000 tablets and 1.8 million smartphones were sold in 2012. The penetration of smartphones thus increased to 27%, while the penetration of tablets lagged behind the Western Europe average slightly, with an estimated 7% in the fourth quarter of 2012.
Discounts on mobile devices such as smartphones, are exempt from these regulations. Operators are still using linear depreciation tables to determine charges for customers who wish to cancel their contract prematurely.
The telecom law was only one factor that increased competition in the mobile phone market.
The economic downturn had both a direct and indirect impact on the entire telecom market ecosystem
- Customers are paying more and more attention to their budget. This has caused cable companies to make use of increasingly aggressive pricing.
- Investments by telecom operators are subject to an increasing level of assessment and analysis.
- At the European level, Belgium is performing better than some of its neighbours. The inflation rate showed signs of improvement towards the end of the year.
New roaming charges came into effect as of 1 July:
There have been maximum rates for phone calls and text messages for years. These fell even further this summer. Maximum rates for mobile phone data were also introduced in 2012.
0.09 euro (plus VAT) to send
0.08 euro per minute (plus VAT) to receive a phone call,
0.70 euro per MB (plus VAT) for mobile data.
There is also a roaming ceiling of 50 euros per month. Customers can decide what happens when their budget has reached 50 euro (before VAT): either the service is interrupted, or the limit can be increased.
17
The customer in the centre
The main concern for the customer? Simplicity and transparancy. It sounds simple, but at Mobistar we do not take this lightly. Accordingly, last year's range was given a thorough overhaul to make it simpler and more transparent. We also fine-tuned our services so that we can give our customers even better support.
The customer in the centre
The residential customer enjoyed even more transparency and benefits in 2012
On 1 October 2012, the new telecom law came into force. But Mobistar naturally didn't wait until then to take action. In April, the company launched an innovative subscription formula based on trust and transparency that anticipated the requirements of this law.
In 2012, Mobistar introduced a new series of subscriptions. Four tariffs tailored to a variety of different communication profiles were successfully put on the market.
The Belgians' favourite pets? Squirrel, Kangaroo, Dolphin and Panther
The consumers were clear: they wanted to be able to choose from an attractive, favourable range of made-to-measure mobile phones and this in all transparency. They also wanted to have control of their data consumption. Mobistar met these aspirations with a new series of subscriptions without any contractual obligation. Squirrel, Kangaroo, Dolphin and Panther were an immediate success.
An approach that fits the needs of existing and new customers
The new subscriptions Squirrel, Kangaroo, Dolphin and Panther don't just offer extremely competitive tariffs, they also include major innovations which satisfied the criteria of the new telecom law, long before that law even came into force:
- Customers can now opt for an obligation-free contract.
- All the benefits remain valid lifelong.
- No more unwelcome surprises when using mobile internet. If the customer opts for a subscription without surf volume then his access to mobile internet is automatically blocked.
- Calls between all Mobistar numbers on the same invoice are free.
- An 'unlimited' option is offered in almost
all the tariff plans, whether in relation to unlimited calls, text messages, surfing or access to social networks.
In November 2012, Mobistar launched 'Personal Check Up'. Every 6 months this free service provides subscribers with the offer that best meets their requirements.
Mobistar ended 2012 with 8,340 active clients with a subscription, more than at the end of December 2011. At the end of 2012, 43% of all the residential subscribers clients had an 'animal' tariff scheme.
RESIDENTIAL MARKET
In order to enable these numerous mobile surfers to enjoy their smartphone or tablet in an even more carefree way, Mobistar has developed two smart services.
Mobistar MyStart: ready immediately to call and surf
Everyone with a smartphone can call on the services of Mobistar MyStart. This service means an expert in a Mobistar Center makes your smartphone call and surf ready. This saves the customer a lot of time and he can immediately get full benefit from his new phone. This service is accessible for all customers, regardless of their mobile operator or smartphone.
Travel Data Control: 100% control while abroad
A lot of smartphone and tablet users have no overview of their data consumption while abroad. With Travel Data Control by Mobistar the customer decides upon his own limit, 20 euros per month, for example. Once that amount is attained, they receive a text notification and access to the mobile internet is blocked. A simple way of staying in control of their budget.
can reload their card via a Facebook app. This was a first in Belgium.
Plug Mobile is a good example of how Mobistar joins forces with other brands. The objective is to tap into new market segments where the company has less of a presence. With Plug Mobile, which Mobistar launched in collaboration with RTL, the company is aiming at a younger, female target audience. These customers now enjoy an inexpensive and simple prepaid formula and can watch three RTL Belgium channels for free via the 3G network. They can also look at videos on demand on their mobile phone, participate in exclusive competitions and a whole lot more.
Mobistar has strengthened its prepaid range with 'Internet On Mobile' and 'Plug Mobile'
The reload card market is extremely competitive. So Mobistar looked for innovative ways to tap into new segments of it in 2012. Two new formulas
Internet On Mobile has been specially developed for heavy mobile users who want the best price and the best network. With this formula everything goes via internet: ordering a SIM card, communicating with the customer service desk, getting involved
Since November 2012, Internet On Mobile customers
in social media and even reloading.
ensured our success:
Mobistar remains strong in mobile data services
The demand for mobile internet, driven by the use of smartphones and tablets increased significantly in 2012. More and more Belgian consumers want access to the internet, Facebook, Twitter and their email inboxes, anywhere and at any time. Approximately 80% of the 'animal subscriptions' sold include mobile data and consumers are also buying more smartphones. In Mobistar Centers, the share of smartphones in mobile phone sales rose to 50% in 2012. The number of customers with a smartphone on our network increased by 52% within one year, rising from 19% in January to 26% by the end of the year. The great success of the iPhone 5, the combined offer with the Samsung Galaxy S3 and the Samsung 'Gio' offer, a subsidised limited edition offer in the fourth quarter, confirmed this trend. The strongest growth in mobile data traffic was recorded in the fourth quarter of 2012. This increased by 70% compared to the third quarter
of 2012. By late December 2012, the share of mobile data service in Mobistar's telephony revenues amounted to 41.4%, compared to 37.1% a year earlier.
Landline services are stagnating
The fixed and convergent contracts remain dominated by cable operators and the incumbents. This is a matter of waiting for the cable to be opened in order to strengthen competition in landline activities. Even though the activation process for landline services is becoming more efficient, Mobistar decided not to relaunch Digital TV and ADSL in the fourth quarter of 2012. In October, Mobistar launched the 'combine & save' programme for its mobile
phone customers—a new offer for internet, digital TV and landline. It is very straightforward and transparent, the more landline services the mobile client combines, the more financial benefits he enjoys.
By the end of December 2012, Mobistar nv had 71,985 ADSL customers as compared to 79,497 ADSL customers a year earlier a decrease of 9.4%. The number of digital TV customers with Mobistar nv totalled 27,846 on 31 December 2012—18.6% fewer than the 34,194 digital TV customers a year earlier. Mobistar nv saw an increase of 3.2% in the number of active landlines in 2012 as they climbed from 226,160 active lines in late December 2011 to 233,342 active lines a year later.
INTERVIEW WITH DIRK SEGERS
Director of Regulatory Affairs, Dirk Segers, closely follows all telecom legislation on behalf of Mobistar, the new telecom law did not come as a surprise to him.
"While more than 80% of this new legislation transposes European directives into Belgian law, the other 20% is mainly about consumer protection. We were therefore prepared. The telecom law has given the market a new dynamic, as a result of which many mobile customers have changed operator.
However, for fixed services, including television and broadband internet, the market remains closed. As long as the cable operators are not required to open that market in a workable way, the customer will continue to pay over the odds, something which was once again confirmed in a recent study of the BIPT. This is why opening up the cable networks is an absolute necessity for us."
"The mobile market has clearly become more competitive. Now it is high time for the broadband and television market to also open up."
professional market
A year full of challenges and... achievements
The year 2012 was very eventful for the business department of Mobistar; with a new organisation, new deals and emerging trends. An overview.
1. A dedicated business unit for the professional market
From an organisational point of view 2012 was a milestone. The Business Department was divided into two entities to be more flexible and better focus on the professional market: a B2B business unit and a Sales Channels department. The new B2B business unit will be responsible for the professional (B2B) services, direct sales to companies, B2B marketing and the M2M (Machine-To-Machine) subdivision. The new Sales Channels department will be responsible for the different sales channels. With this reorganisation, Mobistar aims to focus on structure and accelerate its growth in the B2B market, and to put distribution networks on a professional footing and prepare them for future developments within the Belgian market.
2. Market leader in Machine-to-Machine (M2M)
Despite increasing competition in Belgium and Europe, with a market share of 70% Mobistar managed to remain market leader in M2M applications. Mobistar is based in the International M2M Centre (IMC) in Brussels.
At the end of 2012, Mobistar, including the IMC, had counted 518,098 active M2M SIM cards. This is a 24.3% increase compared to the previous year, with 416,971 active M2M SIM cards. In total, Orange Business Services signed contracts in collaboration with Mobistar for a total of 4.5 million M2M SIM cards. This means that there will soon be as many M2M cards as traditional cards for voice traffic at Mobistar. Emerging markets are sectors like the health sector and the automotive industry. In 2012, Mobistar took part in some thirty symposia and workshops that focused on the automotive industry.
This allowed us, inter alia, to join forces with knowledge centres such as Flanders Drive and Eurogreen IT partner in a pilot project for charging batteries for electrical vehicles and congestion charging.
3. New telecom law, more end users
In the lower part of the market, the new telecom law caused the necessary commotion. Thanks to this new law, from now on customers with five SIM cards or less can change operators without incurring a cancellation fee, provided they have been with an operator for six months.
Mobistar responded to this new law by adjusting its processes, applications and range accordingly. Successfully, because we ended 2012 with a total of 775,000 end users, some 25,000 more than in the beginning of the year.
4. Upgrade of fixed and mobile range of services
In the mobile portfolio too, Mobistar came up with a more competitive and simplified split-bill option to separate the employer's telephone bill from that of the employee.
Its range of fixed data and internet was expanded thanks to the Mobistar IP VPN service to international destinations (representing over 180 countries). Via this platform, different sites of a business can be linked in a secure way. In addition, there was a further improvement of the national 'fix data' portfolio with high-speed VDSL connections and new options involving Ethernet (a standard which allows computers in a network to communicate). All these initiatives help Mobistar meet the needs of our business customers even better, both nationally and internationally.
5. Deals and partnerships
After a European tender, the Brussels Government decided to allocate the public contract for the Irisnet 2 broadband telecommunications network to Mobistar, which intends to set up a company together with the Brussels Capital Region and the Centre for Informatics of the Brussels Region (CIBG). This company, the CVBA Irisnet, will be responsible for the operation of the Irisnet 2 optical fibre network and for the provision of fixed telephony, data transmission services (internet, e-mail) and other network-related services (video-conferencing, video surveillance, etc.).
In the M2M subdivision, Mobistar also managed to secure cooperation agreements with Atos Worldline (electronic payments), BF Engineering (for Tracking and Tracing) and also with Transics, an international specialist in fleet management.
Managers who do not support BYOD, wish to implement a solution in the next 12 months.
The trend: BYOD
The year 2012 also saw two acronyms established. There was BYOD (Bring Your Own Device), which suggests that staff prefer to use their own appliances (smartphone, tablet, etc.), even while working. Following this trend, there is MDM, or Mobile Device Management: the application which manages and secures the arsenal of mobile appliances within an organisation.
Mobistar as a telecom operator is considered the most preferred and trusted party to help address the challenges involving BYOD, for we are certain that those challenges exist: 62% of the managers who have not yet embraced the BYOD phenomenon intend to do so in the next twelve months. This is evident from our own research. A figure which has not fallen on deaf ears at Mobistar. In 2012, Mobistar set up a marketing team, with a focus on B2B services, tasked to develop the right portfolio to be able to provide a solution to meet these needs in 2013 (and beyond). This portfolio will also contain existing services, including the B2B Customer portal, the Device Care Services and the Split-Invoice solutions.
Customer service
In 2012 Mobistar went a long way to moving closer to its customers
The fact that the customer is central key to Mobistar was also proven in 2012 with numerous initiatives which increased customer satisfaction. An overview.
1. There is something for all customers
April 2012. Mobistar is the first telecoms operator in Belgium to launch a series of exceptionally transparent subscriptions without any contractual obligation. As many as 612,000 customers have opted for a subscription that perfectly suits their needs and expectations: Squirrel, Kangaroo, Dolphin or Panther.
2. All of the contact channels have been made more accessible
Mobistar considers contact with the customers to be of paramount importance. That is why the company has improved its three major contact channels.
- In the call centers, Mobistar has introduced improved work protocols, took on additional staff and simplified the telephone menus.
- In the sales outlets, remuneration is now linked to customer satisfaction, Mobistar has launched "Handset Care" (a new series of services) and improved the repair and replacement process of defective mobile phones.
- On the website, customers can contact Mobistar via a form. The residential website was completely updated in December 2012 (see below).
3. The more articulate the customers, the better…
How can Mobistar discover the needs and expectations of its customers? Simply let them have their say in 2012… and Mobistar listened to what they had to say via:
- the Customer Test Center, where customers can share their thoughts on new products and services;
- "Voice of the Customer", a service which deals with the customers' calls and complaints efficiently;
- Mister Simplicity, who focuses on the simplification of the product range, and trims it down whenever needed. This is how Mobistar knows exactly how happy its customers are.
4. A better network makes Mobistar even more user-friendly
Mobistar made significant investments in improving the quality of its services in 2012:
- A reduction in the number of 'dropped calls' by improving the 2G network
- 3G mobile data speed has increased by 25%
- 80% of the 3G infrastructure is now linked via high speed IP lines
- The risk of interference is reduced by 50% following the introduction of shared sites for 2G and 3G
- The new generation IMS platform (IP Multimedia Subsystem, a standardised infrastructure for telephony providers who want to offer multimedia services) with better Voice Over IP services, was installed
- The old systems for Voice Mail, SMS, MMS and USSD have been replaced by a new generation with added value such as Visual Voice Mail services.
The result? User-friendliness and customer satisfaction are on the rise.
5. Mobistar signs the customerfriendliness charter
For Mobistar customer satisfaction and customer focus are of utmost importance, and it endorses the Charter for Customer-friendliness that came into effect on 1 January 2012.
Since its signature, Mobistar has taken varied initiatives to comply with the challenging conditions involved. In this way, Mobistar has significantly reduced the telephone waiting times, there is a more rapid response to letters and emails, the choice menu of the telephone customer service department has been simplified,… Mobistar strives to satisfy at the very least all the conditions in the charter.
See on the right for an overview of the measured core results.
Customer service
Mobistar, made huge progress in online communications in 2012
The residential website was completely revamped in December 2012. In addition, Mobistar has strengthened its presence on social media. In other words: also in digital terms Mobistar made a lot of progress last year.
Completely new www.mobistar.be
In 2012, Mobistar modified its range and service provision. Naturally, the Mobistar website had to follow suit. That was of course the ideal opportunity for Mobistar to get its website ready for the coming years. With a completely new design and better ergonomics, customers can find more specific information about the products and services and they have easier access to their own customer area. That ensures even more opportunities and user-friendliness for the 3 million unique visitors who visit the Mobistar website each month.
In addition, the customers can now make more rapid purchases online, for example in the brand-new web shop for accessories. Also new are the blog full of information and useful tips and a forum where clients can exchange their experiences and help one another.
In 2013, Mobistar wants to improve the user experience on all the digital platforms, both for private and professional customers.
Even closer to clients via social media
More and more customers are actively present on social media. That is why, in 2012, Mobistar put together an internal and expert team that has mapped out the digital strategy. Via Twitter, Facebook and LinkedIn, Mobistar can now build up communities, rapidly communicate about its activities and quickly react to questions from its customers.
Social media makes it easier for Mobistar customers to request support or to give their opinion about products and services. Mobistar can then once again react more rapidly, and immediately answer or do what is required. That is precisely what 'being closer to the customer' means.
Look up product information, order, pay, pick up or have it delivered, the after sales service … Nowadays everything goes via offline and online channels. That is why our website is the vital link between the client, the Mobistar Centers and the customer service department. So it was important to optimise the Mobistar site.
Getting started at Mobistar
The success of Mobistar hinges largely on its staff. This is why Mobistar would like to attract talented people. Not just anybody, but men and women who are not afraid to roll up their sleeves and get down to business. Since the job market is extremely competitive, Mobistar are working on an attractive identity as an employer.
HUMAN RESOURCES
Mobistar invests in human capital
Mobistar is a strong brand. This is mainly attributable to Mobistar being a commercial business. Mobistar's image as an employer was strengthened in order to attract competent new forces, and thus to offer the best products and services.
Mobistar set itself an ambitious goal: to be one of the best employers by 2015. This is why Mobistar is investing in its human capital. In 2012, a Chief People Officer was appointed to improve satisfaction levels and pride among the staff. In line with the general strategy, the HR strategy focuses on competence and career development, language development and actively promoting Mobistar values. Last year, efforts were made to that effect in the work environment, skills development, corporate social responsibility, communication to the job market and recognition of the talent within the company.
'Your talent & Mobistar' an HR concept that hits the spot
As a company seeking to improve its image as an employer with a strong image, you need to show off your assets, while making it clear why it would work between you and any talented new staff. To this end, Mobistar developed a positive, fresh recruitment campaign in 2012 with the theme: 'Your talent & Mobistar'. In a nutshell: Mobistar wants to attract the right people by making it clear that they can reach their full potential within the business. This message was sent to the labour market and its many channels: in newspapers and magazines, via Mobistar's website, on social media and online banners. This is how a fruitful interaction was established between the company and many talented candidates.
That was not all. Mobistar also involved its current workforce in this well thought through concept, with the intention of proving that their talents can really come into their own in the company. That was the subject of internal communication, and a positive atmosphere was created around the subject of recruitment. This is how staff started to promote Mobistar as a good employer within the labour market. Moreover, they share their positive work experiences through a variety of platforms, in and outside of the company. 'Your talent & Mobistar' is a success, and is set to feature again in 2013.
Mobistar's values and identity
According to Mobistar, values are a personal conviction of what should guide the employees in everything the company decides and does. These values were, in fact, clearly and concretely articulated in four pillars. Thanks to them, current and future employees know exactly what Mobistar stands for, both as an employer and service provider.
Respectful
In all my working relationships, I take people and their values into consideration
- I greet my colleagues
- I confirm my presence at meetings, I stick to my promise and respect meeting times
- I give my full attention to people who take the floor
- I show an interest in colleagues, even outside work, and respect my colleagues' personal boundaries
- I express my appreciation for the work, the expertise, the proposals, the opinions and the character of my colleagues
Straightforward
I communicate openly and take responsibility for my own actions
- I do as I say and say as I do sales pitches are unacceptable
- I give feedback to the person in question quickly and directly
- If something is not clear, I do not hesitate to ask for clarification
- I am open about my intentions, goals and actions and avoid manipulation
- I own up to my mistakes and explain how I intend to solve problems
Empowered
I take responsibility and I stand up for what I do
- I am totally committed to what I do
- I achieve good results and do not give up at the first hurdle
- My enthusiasm inspires others
- I grab opportunities in my work without waiting for someone else to prompt me
- I understand the mission, vision and values of Mobistar and quite happily explain them to others
- I am passionate about love, work & play
Dynamic
I encourage new ideas, I encourage learning and trying things differently
- I look at a problem from different angles
- I share good and bad experiences with colleagues, so that we can all learn from them
- I focus on the possible advantages of new initiatives or a new approach
- I regularly put myself in the customer's shoes
- I continue to learn and remain eager to do so, without wanting to please others by doing so
Everything hinges on satisfied employees
The fact that current Mobistar employees speak positively about their employer within the 'Your talent & Mobistar' concept is a bonus. But it is just as important for those employees to feel good about themselves, and relay this to the customer. This is with a view of them representing the Mobistar brand with the necessary expertise, enthusiasm
and a smile. In order to achieve this, Mobistar invested heavily in the 'Employer Value Proposition'. With this, the company wants to position itself as an employer and communicate what the company can offer current and new employees, and what it expects from them in exchange. Mobistar's leitmotiv - 'love, work, play, Mobistar' - comes alive and is brought to the fore in a dynamic way.
LOVE
Mobistar happily welcomes strong candidates who are looking for a company that offers them opportunities to develop personally and professionally. One that encourages initiative and where diversity is inherent in the corporate values. A company that cares about people, society and the environment.
WORK
Whoever starts to work at Mobistar, can rely on the combination of professionalism and stability of an international group with a healthy helping of entrepreneurial spirit. It is a place where every employee shares in the success of the company and where everyone is open to feedback. There is also room for change and innovation, so that every employee can enjoy growth with, and in, the company.
PLAY MOBISTAR
Mobistar is convinced that the staff should be the masters of their own destiny. Provided there is enough flexibility in when, and where, they work, they can strike the perfect balance between 'love, work and play'.
Playing is allowed at Mobistar, provided you follow the rules of the game. The customers, the products and the job in hand are what matter. Mobistar celebrates achievements and emphatically encourages team spirit.
INTERVIEW WITH ANNE CAMBIER
Since 1 October 2012, Anne Cambier, Chief People Officer, headed up the revamped HR department, with the ambition to constantly improve team member satisfaction, as indeed, a happy team member, full of positive energy, makes for a happy customer, which is at the very heart of our strategy. We tracked her down to find out whether she is on course.
"Our employees enjoy working at Mobistar and clearly want to stay. Our values - respect, dynamism, sincerity and responsibility and corporate culture are key assets which we try to improve upon every day. All the team members form part of a great business, and we want them to take pride in working for us. Careers spanning 10 to 15 years are not uncommon here. This is also because we set great store by the work-life balance, which we continue to develop. At Mobistar, flexible working hours and teleworking are not empty words, something which is greatly appreciated.
Likewise, in 2012, we launched a mentoring scheme, whereby we asked our senior members of staff to mentor our junior staff. This programme not only proved useful for junior staff, senior staff also got a lot out of it. We therefore expect the mentoring scheme to burst at the seams in 2013. And, of course, we also carried on the successful Leadership Programme from 2011. Thanks to this programme, we have a clear overview of the strengths and weaknesses of the different teams within Mobistar. The big challenge for our department for 2013 will be to build on the different competences, but I have every confidence that we can do this."
" A happy team member makes for a happy customer."
Mobistar in society
Mobistar sets the bar high when it comes to doing business in a socially responsible manner. Its commitment to society might be considered ambitious. The key to success? A step-by-step approach. It allowed us to make much headway in 2012. In this report Mobistar tells you everything about the progress of its projects.
Corporate social responsibility
Contributing to a better society
The involvement of all employees is essential in order to allow CSR to penetrate the very core of our organisation. A new management-level CSR committee provided a powerful framework for sustainable development. This guarantees the resources and support needed to allow CSR to develop within each department.
Mobistar does not just want to integrate CSR within departments, but also in all its areas of activity. The four pillars - employees, customers, society and the environment –thus form the basis of our CSR strategy. The achievements made within each of these pillars are presented in the following pages.
CSR as a fundamental part of our business strategy
In 2011, Jean-Marc Harion became Mobistar's new CEO. His arrival brought about some changes. The number of 'sponsors' on the Management Board was reduced from two to one. Similarly, whereas there were previously two CSR officers, this was reduced to one who will be known as the 'CSR manager' from now on.
own CSR committee. The CEO, Secretary General, Chief Marketing Officer, Chief People Officer and Chief Technology Officer are all part of this committee.
This does not mean that the old CSR committee will dissolve. The team of approximately 20 employees will continue to manage social and environmental projects. Yet it is important to avoid any confusion in the names, which is why this group will be referred to as the 'task force' from now on. In 2012, the two groups—the CSR committee and the task force met at every fourth session to examine the evolution of the CSR action plan.
New
Mobistar Advisory Board
In 2013, Mobistar will be establishing an 'Advisory Board' consisting of professionals from outside the company. Their mission is to inform Mobistar of any innovations in the field of sustainable development and make suggestions on improving its CSR strategy.
Mobistar thought it was also important to give CSR more weight within the management board. This is why the management board now has its
Launching the stakeholder dialogue
An action plan for sustainable development like this is not just some random document which will not have any impact. Several actors are influenced by it, or have an influence on Mobistar's activities. This is why it is interesting to listen to their needs. What do those parties—Mobistar's stakeholders expect in terms of CSR? And are those expectations consistent with the existing CSR strategy? Mobistar answered these questions in 2012 with a new initiative: the stakeholder dialogue—in other
interview with Paul-Marie Dessart, Secretary General
"In 2012, Mobistar took major steps in terms of corporate social responsibility." says Paul-Marie Dessart.
"We created an advisory group last year for discussing our role in society with our stakeholders. This turned out to be an extremely successful and instructive project. Alongside this, we also strengthened support for CSR at the management level. As of now, a top level CSR platform establishes guidelines in collaboration with the company's CSR ambassadors.
Yet social responsibility is not just a matter concerning management at Mobistar. For example: it was at our staff's request that we increased our volunteer projects in 2012. So there is certainly plenty of enthusiasm for the idea... This is why we are confident that all departments and employees will do their best to succeed in our CSR challenges for 2013."
" Social responsibility is not just a matter concerning management at Mobistar"
words, a series of interviews with internal and external stakeholders. Employees from 15 different teams within the company were interviewed. Mobistar also invited professionals from the political, social and financial world for an interview.
The results show that the majority of stakeholders most value customer service, transparency, fair prices and high-quality networks. According to them, telecom companies should focus in the first place on their core business. According to the stakeholders, other important topics are the safe and responsible use of products and
services as well as Mobistar's contribution to local economic development.
The stakeholder dialogue allowed us to identify stakeholders' expectations. Mobistar is now aware of the issues that are important to them. This helps the company to set the 2013 CSR strategy. As a consequence, Mobistar will focus on customer experience, transparency and accountability by supporting local ecosystems in the next action plan.
Corporate social responsibility
On the right road to sustainable development
It is encouraging to receive recognition for the CSR activities it has already implemented. For example, last year, the organisation was awarded both the Ecodynamic label and Top Employer België - Belgique 2012 certificate. That does not mean that Mobistar can rest on its laurels, because there is still a lot of work to do. Both awards are primarily a motivation to keep working on CSR.
Ecodynamic label
In 2012, Mobistar launched the procedure required to obtain the 'Eco-dynamic Enterprise' label, an official award given by the Brussels Institute for Environmental Management.
One, two or three stars are awarded, depending on the environmental performance of the company in question. These are allocated by a panel of representatives from government agencies, environmental and consumer associations, business federations and universities.
Mobistar received the Brussels Institute for Environmental Management label, as well as the maximum of three stars. Even though this is the best result possible, Mobistar has not put its commitment to the environment on a back burner. On the contrary, these are long-term efforts and are implemented with a view to continuous improvement.
Top Employer België – Belgique 2012
Mobistar is one of 54 companies who received a certificate for 'Top Employer België - Belgique 2012' this year. This label is only awarded to organisations that have achieved the highest level required in HR; in other words: the best Belgian employers to work for. The independent analysis was carried out by the CRF Institute, a centre for expertise in international research into Primary and Secondary Benefits and Working Conditions, Training and Development, Career Opportunities and Organisational Culture. The institute awarded top points to Mobistar for its excellent working conditions and very good organisational culture.
You can't manage what you don't measure
CSR is a continuous improvement process. This does not just require feedback from stakeholders, but also a thorough evaluation of the results.
In 2012, Mobistar continued to improve its reporting on its CSR policy. An internal audit had already been conducted in 2011 covering forty CSR indicators in social and environmental areas. This audit was repeated for the 2012 results.
New findings indicate a good overall management of the indicators. However, the indicators for 'waste' need to be clarified and strengthened. This is why Mobistar is planning to improve the management and monitoring of these indicators in 2013.
CSR-indicators 2012
Environment
| GRI Code | Indicators | Units | 2010 | 2011 | 2012 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| EN3 | Volume of fuel (all building, all uses) | m3 | 414 | 464 | 322 |
| EN3 | Volume of natural gas | m3 | 229.206 | 144.729 | 238.140 |
| EN4 | CO2 emissions due to use of fuel |
tonnes CO2 | 1.110 | 1.244 | 862 |
| EN4 | CO2 emissions due to use of natural gas |
tonnes CO2 | 442 | 279 | 460 |
| EN4 | CO2 emissions due to the combustion of all fuels in our establishments (excluding vehicles) |
tonnes CO2 | 1.552 | 1.523 | 1.322 |
| EN4 | Total amount of electricity used | GWh | 83 | 108 | 110 |
| EN16 | CO2 emissions related to the use of electricity |
tonnes CO2 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| EN3 | Volume of diesel used for the vehicles | liter | 1.818.498 | 1.888.664 | 1.862.598 |
| EN5 | CO2 emissions as a result of vehicles |
tonnes CO2 | 5.001 | 5.194 | 5.122 |
| EN29 | Distance travelled by airplane | km | 1.179.835 | 1.253.189 | 1.169.243 |
| EN16 | CO2 emissions related to travel by airplane |
tonnes CO2 | 212 | 226 | 210 |
| EN29 | Distance travelled by train | km | - | 866.188 | 1.353.461 |
| EN16 | emissions related to travel by train CO2 |
tonnes CO2 | 13,5 | 42 | 66 |
| EN | Amount of renewable energy used | GWh | 83 | 108 | 110 |
| EN | Total CO2 emissions saved by using green energy |
tonnes CO2 | 21.630 | 26.787 | 23.888 |
| EN22 | Mobile terminals collected from customers and valorised |
amouth | - | - | 34.924 |
CSR-indicators 2012
employees
| GRI Code | Indicators | 2010 | 2011 | 2012 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| LA1 | Total number of employees | 1.635 | 1.771 | 1.787 |
| LA1 | Total number of fixed-term contracts | 7 | 8 | 14 |
| LA13 | Number of male managers | 441 | 459 | 467 |
| LA13 | Number of female managers | 149 | 171 | 174 |
| LA1 | Average age of personnel | 37,1 | 37,2 | 37,7 |
| LA2 | Number of redundancies | 70 | 77 | 101 |
| LA2 | Number of external recruitments | 213 | 342 | 239 |
| LA2 | Number of resignations | 54 | 105 | 104 |
| LA1 | Total number of employees previous year | 1.418 | 1.628 | 1.763 |
| LA2 | Number of departed male employees | 81 | 153 | 153 |
| LA2 | Number of departed female employees | 43 | 35 | 58 |
| LA2 | Number of departed employees < 30 years old | 37 | 82 | 77 |
| LA2 | Number of departed employees between 30 and 50 years old |
83 | 101 | 127 |
| LA2 | Number of departed employees > 50 years old | 4 | 5 | 7 |
| LA10 | Total number of trained employees | 1.369 | 1.692 | 1.992 |
| LA10 | Training hours | 40.849 | 60.261 | 57.987 |
Corporate social responsibility
Employees
Telecommuting
It is clear that Mobistar believes in telecommuting. It has numerous advantages. Employees spend less time sitting in traffic. They also have a quiet workspace, flexible hours create a better balance between work and private life, the company can save on transport costs and Mobistar's ecological footprint is reduced. Everybody wins from working from home: the employees, our planet and Mobistar itself.
Achievements in 2012
- Mobistar's efforts to encourage working from home have paid off once again. This year, 1000 employees started telecommuting at least one day a week. That's 80 more employees working from home compared to last year.
- Last autumn, Mobistar participated in the National Homeworking Day for the second time. This is an initiative that promotes working remotely. More than 350 Mobistar employees worked from home on 22 November. This is a significant increase compared with 2011 when 293 employees took part.
Working environment
In 2010, Mobistar took over the Sirius building, where the 'flex desk' principle was applied. In order to have a quiet and stimulating working environment the office set-up was improved in 2012.
Achievements in 2012
Mobistar wants to give its employees the opportunity to work in both 'serene' and 'stimulating' areas. In 2011, several pilot areas were created, including areas for meetings, speaking on the telephone or working in silence. Last year, Mobistar applied this layout throughout the whole Sirius building. The company also put elements in place to make the various zones more easily distinguishable from each other.
Health and well-being at work
Mobistar believes that it has a responsibility to provide certain health services.
Diversity
Mobistar puts a lot of time and effort into diversity through its CSR policy, with a special focus on gender and age. Equality also remains one of our top priorities. We continue to aim for 35% women and 65% men employed at every level.
Achievements in 2012
- Last year, 292 employees were vaccinated to protect them against flu.
- In 2012, Mobistar offered employees the opportunity to follow Allen Carr's training programme aimed at helping people to quit smoking. In total, six employees managed to give up cigarettes permanently.
- The health and eyesight of 288 employees was tested this year.
- Regular exercise helps reduce stress. This is why Mobistar employees were given the opportunity to participate in activities such as Tai Chi, Pilates, relaxation therapy, Zumba and Rhythm Dance in 2012. The initiative was successful with 665 participants attending these classes.
- Mobikids, the project that takes care of employees' children during the school holidays, has become increasingly successful. In 2012, 173 children took part in the activities compared to 148 in 2011.
6
employees stopped smoking
Achievements in 2012
- Mobistar believes strongly in supporting research on diversity in the workplace. This is why the company entered into a partnership with the University of Liège and SEIN, an interdisciplinary research centre at the University of Hasselt in April. A shared chair of 'Diversity and social innovation' was established for a period of four years.
- This year, Anne Cambier, Chief People Officer at Mobistar, sat on the jury of the 'AXA Wo_Men@ Work Award'. This prize rewards managers who are personally committed to achieving a gender balance within their company's management team.
- In December, a working group was established which will contribute to an employment plan for employees of different ages. The group will set up initiatives for older employees and also attempt to attract younger workers.
Employee health and well-being in 2012
medical visits
anti-flu vaccines
665 participants in tai-chi, Pilates, sophrology, Zumba and rhythmic dance
participants in Mobikids
Corporate social responsibility
Customers
Data protection
As a telecom operator, Mobistar provides new digital services every day. This means that is has an increasing amount of customer data in its possession. Because this information is very confidential and may be very sensitive, Mobistar has to gain the trust of its customers. Customers need to know that their data is in safe hands with Mobistar. Communicating openly about what is being done with the data and emphasising the fact that the customer is always in control of it, is thus essential.
Achievements in 2012
- In early 2012, Mobistar launched a poster campaign in its offices. The aim was clear: to ensure that all employees understand that they must handle the information that they use on a daily basis, carefully and discreetly. This kind of communication was repeated regularly to ensure that new employees were also aware of it.
- Different aspects of data protection are relevant to those working in marketing as opposed to customer service employees. This is why specific information sessions were held for the various departments.
- Some effort was put into procedures surrounding incident management last year. If someone is trying to get hold of certain information without authorisation, Mobistar must be in a position to follow up on such incidents effectively. In addition to this, codes of conduct were established, such as a policy on cookies.
- Mobistar carried out a thorough analysis of all possible external and internal threats in 2012. This allowed any vulnerabilities to be identified, while establishing the best ways to tackle them. This means that Mobistar will soon be able to start renewing its security infrastructure.
Corporate social responsibility
Society
Participate!
The project Participate! for people with autism is Mobistar's most important social project. Since 2006, it has brought together specialists in the field of autism along with parents and Mobistar for the attainment of one general objective: to improve the quality of life of those with autism and their friends and families.
Achievements in 2012
- The interactive Participate! website provides highquality and accessible information to parents whose children have recently been diagnosed with autism. The site contains three main sections. The first section contains theoretical information as well as videos that illustrate the theory by presenting concrete cases. The second section provides tips on education and everyday life. The third section is a practical guide which was completed in 2012. Three psychologists produced the contents under the supervision of a scientific committee made up of specialists and parents. This section also contains 'De Wegwijzer' ('The signpost)', a handy tool that parents can use to share information about their child with those around them.
- Throughout 2012, Participate! stepped up its campaign to raise awareness about autism. Various training courses on using the website were also held.
Voluntary work
Mobistar encourages its employees to be engaged with society. It has been noted that the interest in doing voluntary work has increased.
Achievements in 2012
At Mobistar, June was the month of 'Mobicents', an initiative in which colleagues were able to get rid of their euro cent coins for a good cause. The result was 80 kilos of copper, worth about 1080 euros. The money was used by a group of Mobistar volunteers for 'Operation Thermos' in which 600 free hot meals were distributed to the homeless at Brussels Central Station.
Solidarity initiatives
Mobistar has been involved in several solidarity initiatives for many years—and 2012 was no exception.
Achievements in 2012
- Along with other Belgian operators, Mobistar has run various fundraising initiatives by text message. No charges are made for messages sent as part of such initiatives. The cost of sending the text is passed on in full to a charitable cause. To qualify for this, the initiatives should be linked to a natural disaster, or a national or regional action. Last year, Mobistar participated as usual in Cap 48, the solidarity campaign run by RTBF and various campaigns run by VRT and Q-Music. Mobistar also participated in the campaign 'Een Sms voor een Dakloze' ('A text message for a homeless person') run by the Brusselsbased organisation Samu Social.
- Since 2004, Mobistar has donated used IT equipment to the non-profit organisation, Close the Gap. This organisation recycles the devices and uses them for educational projects in developing countries. In 2012, Mobistar donated 733 devices, including fax machines, laptops, PCs and printers.
- As in other years, Mobistar ran two blood drives in 2012, in cooperation with the Red Cross. A total of 171 employees donated blood.
Mobistar's commitment to society is not limited to just a few people, but is widely supported by various departments. And this has had great results.
'Operation Thermos'
4 evenings 1 2 3 4
90 Mobistar volunteers
600 meals
171 blood donations
733 Close the gap donations
Corporate social responsibility
Environment
CO2 balance
Mobistar's objective is to reduce the company's CO2 emissions by 50% by 2020.
Achievements in 2012
- In 2012, Mobistar called once more on the assistance of CO2logic, a company specialising in calculating, reducing and offsetting CO2 emissions. The calculations were made on the basis of consumption levels recorded in 2011.
- In 2011, Mobistar had a carbon footprint of 8,691 tonnes of CO2 in the audited areas which was a decrease of 11% compared to 2010.
-
The C02 emissions resulting from employee travel decreased by 22%. This is mainly due to the intensive promotion of teleworking and the use of public transport.
-
Thanks to a centralised printing system and the introduction of electronic invoicing, Mobistar managed to reduce its paper usage by 50%.
- More people took the train instead of flying. This resulted in a reduction in emissions of 62% in this area.
- With environmentally-friendly office buildings, photovoltaic solar panels and the use of green energy, Mobistar decreased its CO2 - emission by 25,800 tons in 2011.
Interview Jan Janssen, CO2logic
The use of green energy does not mean that Mobistar has discarded its aim of using less energy. However, it does ensure that Mobistar's ecological footprint is now mainly created by lorries. This is why the company continues to make efforts to reduce this impact through the introduction of videoconferencing, eco-driving courses, new cars with an average emission of 121g C02 /km and electric cars.
"At CO2logic, we are all too aware that companies do not make the transition to low carbon intensity operations automatically. We therefore appreciate all the more the commitment and perseverance of those companies that are attempting to overcome the inertia of the status quo."
In the telecom sector — where you always have to keep up with the latest technology — it is very difficult to reduce absolute energy consumption. However, Mobistar still actively seeks to implement creative measures for improving energy efficiency and has been using green energy for many years. Mobistar also has a strong policy in the field of mobility and the company is undoubtedly one of the vanguards in this area. Every year, the most diverse and innovative activities have been added to the ambitious list of measures aimed at reduction.
" It is impressive to see how a team of dedicated people at Mobistar have put every effort into keeping their impact on the climate to a minimum."
2015 target already achieved
Mobistar's aim for 2012 was to emit no more than 120 grams of CO2 for each newly ordered car. This objective was achieved comfortably. Average emissions last year were less than 112 grams — the target objective for 2015. That's no reason to slow down: the targets will be revised to reflect this achievement.
Mobility
In 2012, Mobistar made considerable efforts to reduce car usage and encourage alternative modes of transport and working from home.
Achievements in 2012
- In 2012, Mobistar made five electric pool cars available to its employees. Those who wanted to were able to test out the electric cars when driving to an appointment with a client, for example. 30,000 km were driven in total, which reduced CO2 emissions by an estimated 3.5 tonnes.
- Alongside its usual car list, Mobistar developed a separate list last year which only consisted of electric and hybrid cars. It is the first company in Belgium to do this.
- Carpooling had not had much success within Mobistar in previous years. The company has been working with Djengo since September with a view to breathing new life into the idea of sharing car journeys. This new web platform makes carpooling more accessible, with features such as a carpooling schedule and software that matches employees' journeys.
- A fleet of approximately ten shared bicycles was also introduced. Mobistar encourages everyone to travel short distances by bike.
- Following a successful test in 2011, 'eco-driving' classes were included as a training course in the 2012 course catalogue. Around forty employees enrolled and consequently reduced their fuel consumption by an average of 8%.
- Last year, Mobistar also won the Green Fleet Award 2012, an award for businesses who consciously work to maintain an environmentally-friendly fleet policy.
- Employees were offered a free Railease subscription as a means to encourage them to use public transport in addition to their own vehicles. This allowed them to travel by train to Sirius one day a week for the whole year.
Energy
Mobistar intends to reduce its consumption of electricity, gas and diesel by enrolling in a process of rational energy use, with a preference for renewable energy. Since 2008 Mobistar has used only green energy from certified 100% renewable sources, permitting a reduction in CO2 emissions of 28,000 tonnes per year.
The 5 main areas of energy consumption in order are: the GSM network, the fixed network and internet, the central telecom sites and the data centres, the offices, and Mobistar Centers.
Achievements in 2012
- Together, the 2012 actions have resulted in savings of 735,000 euros.
- At the end of 2011 the new energy director provided a detailed report of consumption in each area in order to initiate actions in the best places, at the best times.
- Measuring devices with Mobistar M2M cards were installed to allow 'smart metering' (remote, real-time monitoring of consumption at each point).
- Several initiatives were undertaken in the technical centres:
- replacement of technical equipment with more efficient equipment without greenhouse gas emissions.
- installation and use of 'free-chilling' (using cool outside air to cool the building).
- increasing the set temperature of core sites to reduce the use of air conditioning.
- The existing features of the Sirius building have been optimised, including presence detectors for lighting, solar energy installation, maximum building insulation and automated temperature management.
- A major programme of rationalisation, virtualisation and consolidation of the IT server infrastructure has been achieved, greatly reducing consumption.
- Several actions have been taken in stores, including the installation of air conditioning timers.
Waste
Mobistar has been running campaigns throughout the year to reduce waste and encourage recycling. Any remaining waste has been separated as much as possible.
Achievements in 2012
- Employees were encouraged to minimise their waste generation by reusing items such as cups and scrap paper.
- Separate collection points were created for used writing materials and plastic lids. All of the proceeds earned from selling these to a recycling company were donated to the Belgian Centre for Guide Dogs.
- The European Week for Waste Reduction which Mobistar also participated in this year was the ideal time to launch new initiatives and to place existing activities in the limelight.
- Mobistar aims to make maximum use of recyclable office supplies wherever possible. This is why an internal catalogue of green products was launched in 2012, in cooperation with supplier Lyreco.
Plans for 2013
In 2013, the France Télécom group plans to evaluate waste management at its subsidiary, Mobistar. In order to improve the relevant processes, it will analyse how Mobistar's offices, stores and network infrastructure deal with waste.
| PILL AR |
CO MMITMENT |
||
|---|---|---|---|
| EMPLO YEE S |
Enable employees to work in a stimulating |
WORKING ENVIRON MENT |
Create a working environment which stimulates creativity, promotes an appropriate collaboration between the employees and creates a serene mentality |
| environment, recognise their contributions and develop |
TRAINING AND PER SONAL DEVELOP MENT |
Enable employees to develop their potential | |
| their potential | HEALTH AND WELLBE ING AT WORK |
Guarantee a good balance between private life and work and combat stress |
|
| WORKING FRO M HOME |
Make flexibility and mobility possible for the employees (organisation of working time + reduction in CO2 emissions) |
||
| DIVERSITY | Promote diversity and equity amongst the employees | ||
| lients | A quality service, offering safety |
PROTECT ION OF MINOR S |
Ensure the protection of children and young people as regards their access to unsuitable content |
| and transparency | DATA PROTECT ION |
Respect for the legal framework and for private life | |
| DIALOGUE WITH THE CUSTOMERS |
Listen actively to the customers and be able to provide favourable follow up in accordance with their expectations |
||
| Society | Promote social and digital |
THE PARTICIPATE! ASSOCIATION |
Promote the quality of life of autistic people and their families by means of the development and dissemination |
| integration | of instruments for a better integration and increased independence for these people |
||
| VOLUNT ARY WORK |
Give employees the opportunity to get socially involved in voluntary work |
||
| SOLIDARITY CAMPAIGNS | For those who need it, place infrastructures and equipment at their disposal, more specifically computer equipment |
||
| ETHICS | Guarantee an ethical and responsible running of our purchasing procedures and our relations with the suppliers |
||
| Environment | Reduce our impact on the |
CO2 BALANCE |
Reduce our CO2 emissions |
| environment | ENER GY |
Limit gas and electricity consumption and use green and renewable energy |
|
| MOBILITY | Reduce the impact of employees' home-work traffic on the environment |
||
| WASTE | Reduce our impact on the environment by usual reuse and the recycling of waste |
||
| PAPER | Reduce the use of paper, optimise recycling and use FSC labelled paper |
||
| REC YCLING OF MOBILE PHONE S |
Collecting old mobile phones, recycling and where appropriate making them useable again |
||
| MACHINE-TO-MACHINE | Reduce the negative impact on the environment by promoting the remote management of machines (in this way travel and transport can be economised) |
54
OBJECTIVE PROGRESS IN 2012
| Be recognised as one of the best employers of Belgium by 2015 | Modifications and improvements to 'Flex desk' principle in the entire Sirius building. |
|---|---|
| By 2015 100% of the employees are given 2 days of training per year |
57,987 hours of training followed by the employees |
| Be recognised as one of the best employers in Belgium by 2015 |
292 employees were vaccinated against the flu, 288 medical examinations were carried out, 665 participants in sports and relaxing activities, 173 employees' children at Mobikids during the holidays |
| By 2015: 100% of employees (who don't come into contact with clients) telecommuting |
1000 employees worked from home. Over 350 participants in the National Homeworking Day. |
| By 2015: proportion of 35% women and 65% men on all the hierarchical levels |
Establishment of a Chair on diversity in collaboration with the Université de Liège and the Universiteit Hasselt. The 'Top Employer 2012' label was obtained. |
| Every year choose 3 concrete points, to work upon | Signature of the "E-safety" charter |
| Ensure the confidentiality of information relating to clients, suppliers and employees |
Internal campaign based around data protection, specific information sessions for the different departments, improved incident management procedures, thorough analysis of external and internal threats |
| Offer customers the possibility of getting in touch with Mobistar when and how they want |
Introduction of simple 'animal tariffs', improvement in the Net Promoter Score (NPS) and the establishment of the Customer Test Center for customer feedback. |
| Reach 100% of Belgian families affected by autism | Completion of the third module of the Participate! website and increase in the number of awareness-raising campaigns surrounding autism |
| Provide associations with 50 days voluntary work in 2012 | Collection of 80 kilos of copper cents for 'Operation Thermos' and 90 volunteers provided 600 homeless people with a meal |
| Give 100% of old computers to the association "Close the Gap" | 733 used IT apparatus donated to Close the Gap |
| Raise awareness of 100% of the employees and provide training relating to that |
Installation of 2 training and e-learning modules which should be followed by all employees |
| Reduce our carbon footprint by 50% by 2020 | The firm C02logic has calculated that in 2011 we reduced our C02 emissions by 11% in relation to 2010 |
| Reduce our energy consumption by 15% by 2020 | Energy conscious interventions mean 735,000 euro was economised in 2012 |
| By 2015, the maximum emission of any vehicles ordered will be 115g CO2 /km. 400 people will be travelling by public transport by the end of 2013 |
The objective for 2015 has already been attained: new vehicles emit on average 112g C02 /km, 370 employees used public transport |
| Obtain the "Ecodynamic Enterprise" label | The Ecodynamic label has been obtained, with the maximum of three stars for our environmental services |
| Organise a paper-free working environment | 30% of the invoices are electronic |
| Recycle 30% of the mobile phones sold in the Mobistar Centers by 2015 |
34,925 mobile phones collected |
| 1 million cards activated in 2012 | Partnership agreements for a total of 4.5 million M2M SIM cards in circulation |
Activity report
Management report for the 2012 financial year
consolidated and non-consolidated
1. Corporate Governance Statement
1.1 Introduction
Mobistar attaches significant importance to a proper governance and confirms its willingness to comply with the Belgian Corporate Governance Code of 12 March 2009 which it has adopted as its reference code.
This code is available online and can be consulted at the following internet address: http://www.corporategovernancecommittee.be. It has also been published in the Belgian Official Gazette (Belgisch Staatsblad / Moniteur belge) as an annex to the Royal Decree of 6 June 2010 regarding the designation of the Corporate Governance Code to be complied with by listed companies.
In 2012, the Board of Directors has drawn up, in collaboration with the Governance Supervisory Committee, a new Corporate Governance Charter which has been approved by the Board of Directors on 19 October 2012. This eighth version of the Corporate Governance Charter has entered into force on 15 November 2012. The Charter is available on the Mobistar website (http://corporate.mobistar.be/go/ en/financial_information/corporate_governance.cf) and may be obtained on request from the Investor Relations Department.
The company considers that its Corporate Governance Charter as well as this Corporate Governance Statement reflect not only the spirit but also the provisions of the Belgian Corporate Governance Code and the relevant provisions of the Belgian Companies Code.
1.2 Description of the five components of the internal control environment
> Control environment
Through its vision, its mission and its values, Mobistar defines its corporate culture and promotes ethical values that are reflected in all of its activities. There is a charter of professional ethics at the company level, and there are also specific ethical charters that supplement it and which also apply, in particular with respect to purchasing and auditing. A section of the company's intranet, accessible to all employees, is dedicated to ethics and to the company culture in general. An annual report is drawn up and presented to the audit committee.
The human resources management and the social responsibility of the company are described in the first part of the annual report, as are the management and control of the company. The functioning of the management bodies is detailed in the declaration of corporate governance contained in the second part of the annual report as well as in the company's articles of association. This corporate governance covers in particular the responsibilities of these bodies, their internal regulations as well as the main rules to be respected in the management of the company.
In addition, an internal control system has been deployed since several years at Mobistar and is regularly reviewed. It covers aspects such as governance, the delegations of powers and signatures, ethics, fraud, controls on data and tools, controls on processes and financial information, the human resources policies, etc. This internal control system participates to the conformity with the Sarbanes-Oxley requirements that must be complied with at the level of the France Télécom group.
> Risk management process
The company has formalised a risk management charter. The "Mobistar Risk Management Charter" is validated by the entire Executive Committee and approved by the Audit Committee. In essence, this document develops the framework and the process of risk management, as well as the organisation and the responsibilities relating to it. The "Area Risk Managers", who are key players in the different departments, are responsible for the identification, analysis, evaluation and treatment of the risks per area. A "corporate" layer is responsible, at the company scale, for designing and monitoring the framework, the deployment of common tools and techniques as well as communication. Bottom-up information on the risk management is assured via the "Risk Management Committee", which comprises the members of the Executive Committee pursuant to the aforementioned charter. This information is also given to the Audit Committee.
> Control activities
Mobistar is ISO 9001-certified. All of its major processes and the controls that they encompass are formalised and published on the company´s intranet. As a result of belonging to the France Télécom group, Mobistar Governance and Mobistar Financial Reporting are subject to the American Sarbanes-Oxley legislation. The control activities are carried out in the first place by the functional or operational managers under the supervision of their superiors. On top, the Sarbanes-Oxley framework is used for documenting the Financial Internal control of the most financially impacting activities. The whole documentation, including the Segregation of Duties matrices, is regularly reviewed and duly updated. Specific functions of assurance (i.e. "Fraud & Revenue Assurance"), compliance and audit (i.e. "Internal Audit") have also been set up and the budget control covers not only the budget aspects, but also key performance indicators. Indeed, in order to ensure adequate financial planning and follow-up, a financial planning procedure describing the planning, the quantification, the implementation and the review of the budget in alignment with the periodical forecasts, is closely followed. This process consists of the following 6 steps:
-
- Budget instructions: the budget instructions provide the operational translation of the strategic guidelines in budgets and objectives for the upcoming year.
-
- Quantification operational plan: translate the operational plans (budgets, revenues, throughput time) in one master planning.
-
- Budget validation: validation of the master budget by the Executive Management and the shareholders.
-
- Budget implementation and communication: communication of the validated budget to the different market units and departments.
-
- Budget review: review hypotheses and expectations used at budget development (from a cost and revenue perspective) and set objectives to outperform budget.
-
- Communicate forecast to shareholders: bi-annual communication to shareholders of revenue and cost actuals as well as forecasts.
The Audit Committee monitors and controls the reporting process of the financial information disclosed by the company and its reporting methods.
To this effect, the Audit Committee discusses all financial information with the Executive Management and with the external auditor and if required, examines specific issues with respect to this information.
At least once a year, the Audit Committee reviews with the Executive Management the effectiveness of the internal control and risk management systems set up by the Executive Management. It must ensure that the principal risks are properly identified, managed and disclosed in accordance with the framework which was approved by the Board of Directors. The Audit Committee and its Chairman also monitor the risk coverage, the risk management, the quality of the internal control, the compliance with the rules and audits and the follow-up of (corrective) action plans.
For more detailed information regarding these procedures and controls, reference is made to Appendix III, Title III of the Corporate Governance Charter.
> Information and communication
The company maintains transparent communication vis-àvis its employees, in conformity with its values and based on a multiple system integrating in particular its intranet and the periodical presentations of the Executive Management at different levels (i.e. "Leaders Day" and "Learn Together").
An advanced electronic data processing and control processes (as described in the paragraph "Control activities" here above) make it possible to circulate reliable information in due course, in particular for the production of the financial reporting. The "Mobistar Advanced Reporting System" gives, via the intranet, personalised access to the relevant operational and management data.
The system for information concerning risks is described in the paragraph "Risk management process" here above.
Within the framework of promoting ethical values, a professional warning system allows for reporting confidential information intended to strengthen the control environment. In addition, as far as communication and information to the Group are concerned, conformity with the rules of governance is controlled by a specific procedure and verified by the Audit Committee.
Mobistar aspires to be open and transparent in its disclosure to the public, customers, employees and other stakeholders. The Company publishes detailed quarterly financial reports providing a comprehensive set of key performance indicators and financial statements for each business segment (mobile and non-mobile operations in Belgium and in Luxembourg), accompanied by a breakdown of direct and indirect costs. These results are made available to the press four times a year and during two meetings and two conference calls/webcasts with the analysts. The provided information is accessible to all and available on the company's website (http://corporate. mobistar.be) in advance of the meetings.
Mobistar's communication efforts are rewarded as 24 brokerage firms are actively publishing equity research notes on the company. This analyst base shows a good mix of a local (33 % from the Benelux) and international analyst coverage (respectively 50 %, 13 % and 4 % from the United Kingdom, France and Italy). Mobistar keeps also regular contacts with current and potential shareholders by organising each year roadshows in the main European and American financial centers. In December 2012, Siddy Jobe was appointed Director Investor Relations & Corporate Finance at Mobistar. In 2013 Mobistar plans to hold an Analyst & Investor Day, which will give the financial community the opportunity to gain more inside in the company's strategy and ambition for the coming years. In addition the Investor Relations' team is always available for questions and investor teachings.
> Monitoring
As indicated in the paragraph "Risk management process" here above, in addition to the front-line control activities, specific functions of assurance, compliance and audit are in place in order to ensure a constant evaluation of the internal control system. The segregation of duties receives specific attention, in particular within the framework of compliance with the Sarbanes-Oxley provisions.
The Audit Committee receives the conclusions of all internal audits. It also receives periodical reports from the "Fraud & Revenue Assurance", "Risk Management", "Ethics" and "Legal" functions.
1.3 Relevant information as foreseen by the law of 2 May 2007 and the Royal Decree of 14 November 2007
On 31 December 2012, the shareholders' structure of the company was composed as follows:
| Mobistar shareholders |
Number of shares |
Capital percentage |
|---|---|---|
| Atlas Services Belgium S.A. | 31,753,100 | 52.91 % |
| Free float | 28,261,314 | 47.09 % |
| Total number of shares | 60,014,414 | 100 % |
The company's majority shareholder is Atlas Services Belgium S.A., which currently holds 52.91 % of the company's shares. Atlas Services Belgium S.A. is an indirect wholly owned subsidiary of France Télécom S.A.
In compliance with the transparency rules (article 15 of the law of 2 May 2007) on notifying the shareholders of companies listed on a regulated market, Mobistar maintains the notification thresholds of 3 %, 5 % and multiples of 5 %. During 2012 none of the Mobistar shareholders passed the threshold of 3 %.
A study of Mobistar's global shareholdership at 31 December 2012 identified that next to the 52.91 % ownership of the company by France Télécom S.A., through its subsidiary Atlas Services Belgium S.A., 8.85 % of the shares of the company are held by identified institutional investors (256). The bulk of the identified institutional investors is located in France, United States, Canada, Belgium and the Netherlands. The most prevailing investment style that is categorizing the identified institutional investors is the 'Value Approach'.
For more detailed information on the main shareholders, reference is made to Appendix VII, Title I of the Corporate Governance Charter.
All the shares issued by the company are ordinary shares. There are no specific categories of shares and all shares are provided with the same rights. There are no exceptions to this rule.
The articles of association provide that the company's shares are registered or dematerialised. A transitional provision is in place in relation to the existing bearer shares. All bearer shares will be converted into registered or dematerialised shares by 1 January 2014 at the latest.
There is no legal or statutory limitation to the exercise of the voting rights attached to the shares of the company.
The directors are appointed and replaced in accordance with the relevant articles of the Belgian Companies Code. More detailed information in this respect can be found in Appendix I, Title II of the Corporate Governance Charter.
The articles of association of the company may be modified in accordance with the relevant provisions of the Belgian Companies Code.
The Board of Directors is not empowered to issue new shares as the company does not make use of the procedure of the authorised capital.
At the General Meeting held on 6 May 2009, the shareholders authorised the Board of Directors to acquire (by purchase or exchange) the company's shares, up to a maximum of 20 % of the number of shares issued by the company. This authorisation is valid for a period of five years as from the above mentioned date of the General Meeting. The acquisition price of the shares must not be higher than 110 % and must not be lower than 90 % of the average closing price of the shares during the five working days preceding the acquisition. This authorisation shall also be valid for the acquisition of shares in the company by a direct subsidiary pursuant to article 627 of the Belgian Companies Code. The shareholders have authorised the Board of Directors to cancel the shares acquired by the company, to record this cancellation in a notarised deed and to amend and coordinate the articles of association in order to bring them in line with the relevant decisions.
1.4 Composition and operation mode of the Board of Directors and the committees
The composition of the Board of Directors is determined on the basis of diverse and complementary competencies, experience and knowledge, as well as on the basis of gender diversity and diversity in general. The Board of Directors must consist of a reasonable number of directors allowing its effective operation while taking into account the specificities of the company.
On 31 December 2012, the Board of Directors consisted of twelve members of which one executive director and eleven non-executive directors (of which four independent directors). No age limit has been fixed within the Board of Directors.
| Name | Function | Main function | Age | Nationality | End of mandate |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jan Steyaert | Chairman | Director of companies | 67 | Belgian | 2014 |
| Jean Marc Harion (1) (2) | Executive director | CEO Mobistar | 51 | French | 2014 |
| Conseils Gestion Organisation (3) (4) Independent director | Director of companies | NA | Belgian | 2014 | |
| Eric Dekeuleneer (3) | Independent director | CEO Credibe | 60 | Belgian | 2014 |
| CEO University Foundation | |||||
| Johan Deschuyffeler (3) | Independent director | Vice-president HP Technology Services | 55 | Belgian | 2014 |
| Société en Gestion, Conseil et Stratégie d'Entreprise (3) (6) |
Independent director | Director of companies | NA | Belgian | 2014 |
| Geneviève André-Berliat (1) | Director | VP Governance & Performance (FT) | 57 | French | 2014 |
| Benoit Scheen (1) | Director | EVP Europe (FT) | 46 | Belgian | 2014 |
| Brigitte Bourgoin (1) | Director | Group Chief Compliance Officer (FT) | 59 | French | 2014 |
| Bertrand du Boucher (1) | Director | VP Finance (FT) | 59 | French | 2014 |
| Gérard Ries (1) | Director | Directeur des Participations Internationales (FT) | 58 | French | 2014 |
| Wirefree Services Belgium (1) (5) | Director | NA | Belgian | 2014 |
The Board of Directors meets at least four times a year. In 2012, the Board of Directors mainly discussed the following subjects:
- the company's strategy and structure;
- the budget and financing of the company;
- the operational and financial situation;
- the follow-up of the strategic projects;
- the functioning and resolutions of the committees set up by the Board of Directors;
- the evolution of the regulatory framework.
The management of the company systematically provides to the directors, before each meeting, a file containing all necessary information with a view on the deliberation of the subjects mentioned in the agenda (of which the most relevant subjects have been enumerated herein above).
The articles of association stipulate that the resolutions of the Board of Directors are taken by the majority of the votes cast.
- (3) The independent directors have signed a declaration stating they comply with the criteria of independence mentioned in the Belgian Companies Code.
- (4) The company Conseils Gestion Organisation is represented by Mr. Philippe Delaunois.
- (5) The company Wirefree Services Belgium S.A. is a wholly owned subsidiary of France Télécom S.A. and is represented by Mr. Aldo Cardoso.
(1) Directors who represent the majority shareholder (Atlas Services Belgium).
(2) Director in charge of the daily management since 1 December 2011.
(6) The company Société en Gestion, Conseil et Stratégie d'Entreprise (SOGESTRA) is represented by Mrs. Nadine Lemaître-Rozencweig.
| Directors | 07/02 | 23/03 | 25/04 | 20/07 | 19/10 | 11/12 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jan Steyaert | P | P | P | P | P | P |
| Brigitte Bourgoin | P | P | P | P | P | P |
| WSB | P | P | P | P | P | R |
| Eric Dekeuleneer | P | R | P | P | P | P |
| Conseils Gestion Organisation | P | P | P | P | P | P |
| Bertrand du Boucher | P | P | P | P | P | P |
| Gérard Ries | P | P | E | P | P | R |
| Benoit Scheen | P | P | P | P | P | P |
| Johan Deschuyffeleer | P | P | P | P | P | P |
| SOGESTRA | P | P | P | P | P | P |
| Jean Marc Harion | P | P | P | P | P | P |
| Geneviève André-Berliat | P | P | P | P | P | P |
Presence of the directors at the meetings of the Board of Directors:
The Board of Directors has set up three statutory committees (the Audit Committee, the Remuneration and Nomination Committee and the Strategic Committee) as well as an extra-statutory committee (the Governance Supervisory Committee).
> The Audit Committee
In 2012, the Audit Committee consisted of five directors: Mr. Eric Dekeuleneer (Chairman), the companies Conseils Gestion Organisation (represented by Mr. Philippe Delaunois) and Société en Gestion, Conseil et Stratégie d'Entreprise (SOGESTRA represented by Mrs. Nadine Lemaître-Rozencweig), and Messrs. Bertrand du Boucher and Gérard Ries.
The Audit Committee's mission is to assist the Board of Directors, among others, in its responsibilities with respect to the monitoring of the reporting process of the financial information disclosed by the company, the monitoring of the effectiveness of the internal control and risk management systems of the company, the monitoring of the internal audit and its effectiveness, the monitoring of the statutory audit of the financial reports, the review and the monitoring of the independence of the external auditor, the review of the budget proposals presented by the management and the monitoring of the financial relations between the company and its shareholders. The Audit Committee met six times in 2012.
Presence of the members at the meetings of the Audit Committee:
| Directors | 06/02 | 24/04 | 19/07 | 18/10 | 21/11 | 10/12 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Eric Dekeuleneer | P | P | P | P | p | P |
| SOGESTRA | P | P | P | P | P | P |
| Conseils Gestion Organisation | P | P | P | P | E | P |
| Bertrand du Boucher | P | P | P | P | P | P |
| Gérard Ries | P | E | P | P | E | E |
P: present E: excused
The principal subjects which have been discussed within the Audit Committee in 2012 are the following:
- the periodical financial, budget and activity reports;
- the internal control, including the quality aspects;
- the internal audit (plan, activities and conclusions);
- the evaluation of the external audit and report of the statutory auditor;
- the risk management (cartography and important risks and events);
- the annual report concerning fraud prevention and "revenue assurance";
- the annual report concerning ethics;
- the annual report concerning the main disputes.
The Audit Committee also did a yearly review of its working processes and informed the Board of Directors about this review.
> The Remuneration and Nomination Committee
In 2012, the Remuneration and Nomination Committee consisted of five directors: Messrs. Benoit Scheen (Chairman), Eric Dekeuleneer and Jan Steyaert, and the companies Conseils Gestion Organisation (represented by Mr. Philippe Delaunois) and Société en Gestion, Conseil et Stratégie d'Entreprise (SOGESTRA represented by Mrs. Nadine Lemaître-Rozencweig).
The Remuneration and Nomination Committee has the mission, among others, to assist the Board of Directors in setting the remuneration of the members of the management of the company and also to assist the Board of Directors with the proposal of members of the Board of Directors for nominations or re-elections.
In 2012, the Remuneration and Nomination Committee met twice.
Presence of the members at the meetings of the Remuneration and Nomination Committee:
| Directors | 07/02 | 20/07 | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Benoit Scheen | P | P | |||
| Jan Steyaert | P | P | |||
| Eric Dekeuleneer | P | P | |||
| SOGESTRA | P | P | |||
| Conseils Gestion Organisation | P | P |
P: present
In 2012, the Remuneration and Nomination Committee examined, among others, the remuneration of the members of the Executive Management and the remuneration policy of the company. The Remuneration and Nomination Committee has also drafted the company's remuneration report and presented it to the Board of Directors.
> The Strategic Committee
The role of the Strategic Committee consists of assisting the Board of Directors in the setting and assessment of the company's strategy.
In 2012, the Strategic Committee consisted of eight directors: the company Conseils Gestion Organisation (represented by Mr. Philippe Delaunois) (Chairman), Mrs. Brigitte Bourgoin, Mrs. Geneviève André-Berliat, Messrs. Johan Deschuyffeleer, Jan Steyaert, Gérard Ries, Benoit Scheen and Bertrand du Boucher.
In 2012, the Strategic Committee met seven times.
| Presence of the members at the meetings of the Strategic Committee: | ||
|---|---|---|
| -- | -- | --------------------------------------------------------------------- |
| Directors | 11/03 | 06/02 | 02/05 | 25/07 | 28/09 | 09/10 | 21/12 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Conseils Gestion Organisation | P | P | P | P | P | P | P |
| Brigitte Bourgoin | P | E | P | P | P | E | P |
| Jan Steyaert | P | P | P | P | P | P | P |
| Bertrand du Boucher | P | P | P | P | P | P | P |
| Gérard Ries | E | P | P | P | E | P | P |
| Benoit Scheen | P | R | P | P | P | P | P |
| Johan Deschuyffeleer | P | P | E | P | P | P | P |
| Geneviève André-Berliat | P | P | P | P | P | P | P |
P: present E: excused R: represented
In 2012, the Strategic Committee mainly dealt with the following subjects:
- the results of the company;
- the development and prospects of the company;
- the renewal of the IT systems;
- the convergence and new technologies;
- the new investments;
- the strategy with regard to fixed lines;
- the trends of the market and the strategic positioning of the company;
- the strategy regarding MVNO.
> The Governance Supervisory Committee
The Governance Supervisory Committee is an ad hoc committee which was set up on 14 December 2004, after the publication of the (first) Corporate Governance Code, with a view to follow the evolutions regarding Corporate Governance and ensuring its application within the company.
In 2012, the Governance Supervisory Committee consisted of five directors: Messrs. Eric Dekeuleneer (Chairman) and Jan Steyaert, Mrs. Geneviève André-Berliat and the companies Wirefree Services Belgium (represented by Mr. Aldo Cardoso) and Conseils Gestion Organisation (represented by Mr. Philippe Delaunois).
In 2012, the Governance Supervisory Committee met twice.
Presence of the members at the meetings of the Governance Supervisory Committee:
| Directors | 24/04 | 19/07 |
|---|---|---|
| Eric Dekeuleneer | P | P |
| WSB | P | P |
| Jan Steyaert | P | P |
| Conseils Gestion Organisation | P | P |
| Geneviève André-Berliat | p | P |
P: present
The subjects dealt with in 2012 were, among others, the update of the Corporate Governance Charter, the evaluation of the committees, as well as the follow-up of the decisions taken by the Board of Directors.
1.5 Efforts undertaken to ensure that at least onethird of the members are of a different gender than the other
When replacing directors, one attempts as much as possible to appoint female candidates. In 2012 no director has been replaced. The cooptation of Mrs. Geneviève André-Berliat has been confirmed during the General Assembly of 2 May 2012.
The Board of Directors has currently three female directors out of a total of 12. These efforts will continue for future appointments in order to reach the desired quota (onethird female directors) as soon as possible. Mobistar is striving to attain the objective long before the legally-imposed deadline (2019).
1.6 Composition and operation of the Executive Management
Mr. Jean Marc Harion exercises the position of CEO since 1 December 2011.
During the meeting of 24 July 2003, the Board of Directors resolved not to make use of the legal and statutory possibility of delegating specific powers to a management committee.
In order to assist the CEO in its responsibilities regarding the daily management, a committee (the "Executive Management") meets, in principle, on a weekly basis. Every member of the Executive Management, except the CEO, is at the head of a department of the organization.
The Executive Management is composed of the following persons:
- Jean Marc Harion (Chief Executive Officer)
- Stéphane Beauduin (Chief Business Unit B2B Officer) new position since 1 April 2012
- Paul-Marie Dessart (Secretary General)
- Werner De Laet (Chief Financial Officer)
- Olivier Ysewijn (Chief Strategy Officer)
- Anne Cambier (Chief People Officer) new position since 1 October 2012
- Cristina Zanchi (Chief Customer Relationship Officer)
- Bart De Groote (Chief Consumer Marketing Officer B2C) since 1 April 2012
- Erick Cuvelier (Chief Information Officer) since 1 June 2012
- Sven Bols (Chief Sales & Distribution Officer) since 22 October 2012
- Gabriel Flichy (Chief Network Officer) since 15 November 2012
Gabriel Flichy, Chief Network Officer
Management
Sven Bols, Chief Sales & Distribution Officer Cristina Zanchi, Chief Customer Relationship Officer
Paul-Marie Dessart, Secretary General
Xavier Fortemps, Director Procurement & Efficiency
Stéphane Beauduin Chief BU B2B Officer
Erick Cuvelier, Chief Information Officer
Bart De Groote, Chief Consumer Marketing Officer B2C
Werner De Laet, Chief Financial Officer
Jean-Marc Harion, Chief Executive Officer
Anne Cambier, Chief People Officer
Olivier Ysewijn, Chief Strategy Officer
1.7 Contractual relations with directors, managers and companies of the Group
Every contract and every transaction between a director or a member of the Executive Management and the company is subject to the prior approval of the Board of Directors, after informing and consulting with the Audit Committee in that respect. Such contracts or transactions should be concluded at commercial conditions, in accordance with the prevailing market circumstances. The prior approval of the Board of Directors is required, even if articles 523 and 524 of the Belgian Companies Code are not applicable to the said transaction or the said contract. However, services delivered by the company in its normal course of business and at normal market conditions (i.e. a normal "customer relationship") are not subject to such prior approval requirement.
Between several companies of the France Télécom group and the company, there are agreements and/or invoices regarding the performances of the staff members and/or delivery of services or goods. These contracts and invoices are reviewed by the Audit Committee of the company.
1.8 Evaluation procedure of the Board of Directors, the committees and each director
The Board of Directors is in charge of a periodical evaluation of its own effectiveness and of the periodical evaluation of the different committees.
In this respect, at least every two to three years, the Board of Directors, under the lead of its chairman, carries out an assessment as to the size, composition and performances of the Board of Directors and the different committees. This assessment has four objectives:
- assessing the operation;
- checking that the important issues are thoroughly prepared and discussed;
- evaluating the actual contribution of each director to the work of the Board of Directors and the committees, his/ her attendance at the Board of Directors and committee meetings and his/her constructive involvement in discussions and decision-making process;
- checking the current composition of the Board of Directors and the committees against its desired composition.
In order to enable periodic individual evaluations, the directors must give their full assistance to the chairman of the Board of Directors, the Remuneration and Nomination Committee and any other persons, whether internal or external to the company, entrusted with the evaluation of the directors. The chairman of the Board of Directors, and the performance of his/her duties within the Board of Directors, must also be carefully evaluated.
The non-executive directors must assess, on an annual basis, their interaction with the Executive Management and, if necessary, make proposals to the chairman of the Board of Directors with a view to facilitating improvements.
For more information, reference is made to Title II, 1.3 and 2.1 of the Corporate Governance Charter.
1.9 Information regarding the remuneration connected to shares
In 2012, no remuneration was paid out in the form of shares, options or other rights to acquire shares of the company. No proposal in this respect shall be made at the 2013 Annual Shareholders' meeting.
In the course of 2012, the company has been informed of a transaction on the company's shares by a member of the Executive Management. The FSMA has been informed on this matter and published it on its website: Mr Werner De Laet (CFO) bought on 2 May 2012 1,000 shares of the company on Euronext Brussels for a total amount of € 28,725.
1.10 Remuneration report
> Remuneration policy for the members of the Executive Management
The remuneration policy of the company is based on the performance of the company and the individual performance of the members of the Executive Management.
The recommended level of remuneration within the company must suffice to attract, maintain and motivate the members of the Executive Management.
A benchmark is used as basis to determine the level of remuneration, the elements of which it is composed as well as the level of these elements.
The wage surveys used for this benchmark are chosen depending on the companies (IT, telecom) which participate to it and with which the company can best be compared. The company systematically works with two wage surveys. The analysis of the annual reports of the companies of the BEL 20 is only used as an indication.
The possible adaptations of the remuneration following the benchmark are discussed within the Remuneration and Nomination Committee that submits its propositions for approval to the Board of Directors.
The Remuneration and Nomination Committee does not foresee major changes with regard to salary policy during the next two years.
> Components of the remuneration of the members of the Executive Management
All the members of the Executive Management have the statute of employees of the company; some of them are remunerated directors in Luxembourg; others have the statute of part-time employees in Luxembourg depending on their local activity. The detailed remuneration, as reported in the present remuneration report, comprises the totality of these elements.
No particular notice conditions have been agreed between the company and the members of the Executive Management.
The remuneration of the members of the Executive Management consists of the following elements:
-
- Yearly basis remuneration
-
- Variable remuneration
- a. Short-term variable remuneration called "performance bonus"
- b. Strategic Letter
- c. LTR 2011-2013
The General Assembly of May 2011 decided to apply the exception provided for in article 520ter of the Belgian Companies Code (combined with article 525) to take account of the competitive and constantly developing context that is intrinsic to the telecommunications sector. Thus the same remuneration policy as that of the previous years was applied for the members of the Executive Management concerning the short-term variable part ("performance bonus"), the Strategic Letter and the LTR.
-
- Other elements of the remuneration
- a. Group insurance consisting of four parts: life death – invalidity and exemption of premiums
- b. Hospital insurance
- c. Employee participation plan
- d. Availability of /Disposal over a vehicle
- e. Meal vouchers
The wage elements requiring additional explanation are described below.
1. The yearly basis remuneration
The yearly basis remuneration is intended to remunerate the nature and the extent of the individual responsibilities.
It is based on the benchmark while taking into consideration the respect of the internal equity within the company.
2.a. The variable short-term part – performance bonus
The short-term variable remuneration is a key element in the remuneration policy of the company.
The level of the target variable contractual remuneration lies between 35 % and 50 % of the yearly basis remuneration depending on the type of position.
The calculation methodology, for the collective as well as for the individual part, is set out in an internal code.
The variable remuneration comprises two parts:
- An individual part based on the evaluation of the relevant and neutral targets. An important part is based on the management qualities as well as on the personal implication in the transformation of the company.
- The collective part which is based in 2012 on the following financial indicators:
-
- The consolidated turnover
-
- The EBITDA (Earnings before Interest, Taxes, Depreciation and Amortization)
-
- The Net Promoter Score (NPS = percentage of customers who are promoters - percentage of customers who are detractors)
The result of the collective part is submitted for review to the Remuneration and Nomination Committee each semester prior to it being granted.
In case of non-achievement of the financial targets, the collective part can be brought back to 0 %.
In case of insufficient personal performance, the financial individual part can also be reduced and even annulled.
The individual performance of the CEO is determined by the Remuneration and Nomination Committee; the individual performance of the other members of the Executive Management is proposed by the CEO to the Remuneration and Nomination Committee. The Board of Directors resolves to accept the propositions or, as the case may be, rejects them.
The variable part is evaluated and fixed every semester.
The results of the first semester are established in September of the current year; the results of the second semester are established in March of the year following the end of the financial year.
The performance bonus is granted in cash or in options on shares which are not connected to the company.
2.b. The Strategic Letter
The "Strategic Letter" is an exceptional bonus of which the eligibility and the grant are proposed and evaluated by the Remuneration and Nomination Committee in a discretionary manner and are approved by the Board of Directors.
In 2012, a 'Strategic Letter' has been granted to all the members of the Executive Management. The CEO benefits from a contractual 'Strategic Letter'.
The measured KPI's are the following:
- Operating Cash-flow
- Churn postpaid
- Customer NPS improvement
2.c. LTR 2011-2013
The "LTR 2011-2013" is a withheld long-term bonus granted in 2011 in order to ensure the stability within the members of the Executive Management for a period of three years.
It is linked to a condition of presence in March 2013 and shall be granted at that moment under the form of options on shares which are not linked to the company.
These options shall be blocked during one year.
It is based on a percentage applicable to four performance bonus periods as well as on the same financial KPI's and this for the two semesters of 2011 and the two semesters of 2012.
As the CEO started working for the company at the end of 2011, he does not participate to this plan.
3.a. Group insurance - additional pension plan
The additional pension plan is a plan with predefined contributions.
The acquired reserve consists of employers' and personal contributions.
3.c. Employee participation plan
In accordance with the law of 22 May 2001, a Collective Labour Agreement has been executed in order to share 1 % of the net profit under certain circumstances with the members of the personnel including the members of the Executive Management.
In case the conditions are not fulfilled, the participation in the profit is not granted.
The amount granted to each employee, herein included the members of the Executive Management, is identical no matter which position is held.
> The detailed remuneration of the members of the Executive Management
| CEO | 2011 | 2012 | |
|---|---|---|---|
| B. Scheen | JM. Harion | ||
| - gross basis remuneration: | € 266,080 | € 23,333 | € 298,945 |
| - gross variable remuneration in cash and/or options which are not connected to the company: | € 534,835 | € 76,240 | |
| - other components of the remuneration (excluding employers' contributions to the pension plan): | € 12,491 | € 291 | € 37,134 |
| - risk insurance: | € 7,622 | € 9,866 | |
| - other components: | € 4,869 | € 291 | € 27,268 |
| - employers' contributions to the pension plan: | € 47,764 | € 6,604 | € 70,961 |
| Total | € 861,170 | € 30,228 | € 483,280 |
| Executive Management (except the CEO) | 2011 | 2012 | |
| - gross basis remuneration: | € 1,721,246 | € 1,951,232 | |
| - gross variable remuneration in cash and/or options which are not connected to the company: | € 1,107,543 | € 885,465 | |
| - other components of the remuneration (excluding employers' contributions to the pension plan): | € 133,765 | € 177,152 | |
| - risk insurance: | € 43,663 | € 47,766 | |
| - other components: | € 90,102 | € 129,385 | |
| - employers' contributions to the pension plan: | € 264,023 | € 287,614 | |
| Total | € 3,226,577 | € 3,301,463 | |
| Global total | € 4,117,975 | € 3,784,743 |
All the amounts are reported on the basis of a gross amount, excluding the social security of the employer and all taxes due by the employer, notably on the insurance premiums.
The variable remuneration taken into account is the variable remuneration which has been actually paid out over the period concerned or, in the case of options which are not linked to the company, the options that were actually granted over the period concerned. The "Black & Scholes" formula is used for the valuation of the options.
In 2012, the Executive Management (except the CEO) was composed of 9.4 full-time equivalents. In 2011, it was composed of 8.5 full-time equivalents. The members of the Executive Management who were not in service all year long are taken into account pro rata temporis.
All the remuneration amounts mentioned here below relate to the Belgian and Luxembourg activities. A redundancy payment corresponding to 8 months remuneration has been paid to Mr. Pascal Koster in 2012.
In 2012, the variable remuneration amount for the CEO represents only the variable remuneration for half a year due to the shift in time of the actual bonus payment and only one month of activity of the new CEO. In 2011, the variable remuneration amount for the CEO is linked to the anticipated payment of various bonuses due to his nomination in the France Télécom group in the course of 2011.
The amount "other components of the remuneration" for the CEO and the Executive Management includes the housing costs of the CEO and of some members of the Executive Management.
No share, option or any other right to acquire shares of the company have been granted, exercised or have expired in 2012.
> The remuneration policy for the directors
For 2012, the independent directors will receive a fixed annual remuneration of € 33,000 as well as an additional remuneration of € 2,200 per meeting of a statutory or ad hoc committee they have attended. These amounts have been determined on the basis of a benchmark realized on the BEL 20 companies. This remuneration will be paid (if necessary, pro rata) after the Annual General Meeting that approves the annual accounts of the financial year in question.
These directors are:
- Eric Dekeuleneer
- Conseils Gestion Organisation (represented by Mr. Philippe Delaunois)
- SOGESTRA (represented by Mrs. Nadine Lemaître-Rozencweig)
- Johan Deschuyffeleer
For 2012, the chairman of the Board of Directors, Mr. Jan Steyaert, will receive a fixed annual remuneration of € 66,000 as well as an additional remuneration of € 2,200 per meeting of a Board of Directors' committee of which he is a member. As for the independent directors, these amounts have been determined on the basis of a benchmark realized on the BEL 20 companies. This remuneration will be paid (if necessary, pro rata) after the Annual General Meeting that approves the annual accounts of the financial year in question.
The following directors fulfil their mandate without remuneration:
- Jean Marc Harion (1)
- Brigitte Bourgoin
- Bertrand du Boucher
- Gérard Ries
- Wirefree Services Belgium
- (represented by Mr Aldo Cardoso)
- Geneviève André-Berliat
- Benoit Scheen
> The detailed remuneration of the directors
| Directors | Fixed yearly remuneration |
Audit Committee |
Remuneration and Nomination Committee |
Strategic Committee |
Governance Supervisory Committee |
Total |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jan Steyaert (chairman of the Board of Directors) | € 66,000 | € 0 | € 4,400 | € 15,400 | € 4,400 | € 90,200 |
| Conseils Gestion Organisation (represented by Mr Philippe Delaunois) (independent director) |
€ 33,000 | € 11,000 | € 4,400 | € 15,400 | € 4,400 | € 68,200 |
| Eric Dekeuleneer (independent director) | € 33,000 | € 13,200 | € 4,400 | € 0 | € 4,400 | € 55,000 |
| SOGESTRA (represented by Mrs Nadine Lemaître Rozencweig) (independent director) |
€ 33,000 | € 13,200 | € 4,400 | € 0 | € 0 | € 50,600 |
| Johan Deschuyffeleer (independent director) | € 33,000 | € 0 | € 0 | € 13,200 | € 0 | € 46,200 |
| Total | € 198,000 | € 37,400 | € 17,600 | € 44,000 | € 13,200 | € 310,200 |
(1) Mr. Jean Marc Harion (CEO) is remunerated under his statute of employee (see above).
2. Key events 2012
2.1 Market developments
Market competition further intensified in 2012, with all operators seeking to acquire and retain customers in a context of market saturation. According to Mobistar's estimates, the number of active SIM cards on the Belgian market has reached 114 % of the population by the end of 2012.
Mobistar ended the year with 4,321.6 thousand active mobile customers (including mobile broadband and MVNO's, excluding Luxembourg), which represents a 5.3 % increase year on year. Mobistar has maintained its position on the Belgian market, with a market share of 34.0 %. These figures do not include the growth of "Machine-to-Machine" cards, which increased from 417.0 thousand at the end of 2011 to 518.1 thousand end of 2012.
The number of postpaid customers has reached 68.1 % of the total customer base at the end of 2012 (MVNO's excluded), as compared to 66.3 % in 2011.
The segmentation approach via MVNOs and partnerships remains for Mobistar the best strategy for conquering market share in specific segments where Mobistar itself is not active. In this way, Mobistar can surf on the success of its partners. The number of MVNO customers rose by 50.8 % in one year, from 589,830 active customers at the end of December 2011 to 889,540 active customers one year later. The growth comes from both full and light MVNO partners.
2.2 Evolution of offers and services
The consequences of the new telecom law were well anticipated by the launch in April 2012 of the new 'Animals' subscriptions (Squirrel, Kangaroo, Dolphin and Panther), which can be concluded without a contract.
Mobistar also reacted to the intense competition and the increasing demand for mobile internet by lowering the price of the ´Kangaroo -´ and ´Panther unlimited´ subscriptions, and increasing the volume of mobile data included in the ´Dolphin´ subscriptions.
The changes made to the subscription formulas and the lower prices were well received by the consumers and at the end of December 2012, 43 % of the residential postpaid customers opted for an 'Animal' subscription.
For a more detailed view of our offers and services, we refer you to the 'Customer at the center' section (page 18) of this annual report.
2.3 Distribution
Mobistar continues to deploy a distribution strategy based on three main pillars:
- Emphasis on exclusive distribution (Mobistar centers, telesales, web sales, …).
- Presence via complementary channels, partnerships and regional implantations.
- Promotion of the Mobistar sales share in the open distribution.
End 2012, the chain of Mobistar centers included 161 shops. Forty-five of these points of sale are owned stores. The Mobistar chain continued to extend its focus on customer service and loyalty, alongside the traditional commercial objectives.
2.4 Mobistar Enterprise Services S.A.
Mobistar Enterprise Services S.A. (MES) is part of the Mobistar group since 1st April 2010. The synergies between both entities are obvious, especially in the professional market (consolidate the portfolio as a convergent telecom player) and in the network domain (internalize and reduce cash out to other market players).
On the fix voice market, MES continued to migrate the high value customers to Mobistar convergent solutions (mobile, fix and internet). All fix voice migrations should be finalized in 2013. Concerning fix data business, MES data portfolio is still increasingly cross-sold to existing Mobistar customers.
On the network side, 255 dark fibers replace Mobistar outsourced links by MES links. As such, Mobistar can send national traffic via MES' network, while MES international traffic is conveyed via Mobistar, in both cases at lower termination rates than before.
MES also continues to provide wholesale services to KPN Group Belgium for fix voice and internet products and services to their residential customers.
2.5 Orange Communications Luxembourg S.A.
Mobile market shares have remained stable in 2012. The incumbent operator (EPT-Luxgsm) represents 48.2 %, the other 51.8 % are shared between Tango (37.2 %) and Orange Communications Luxembourg S.A. (14.6 %).
At the end of December 2012, Orange Communications Luxembourg S.A. had 105,805 active mobile telephony customers, 6.6 % more than the year before. In the last quarter of 2012, the Luxembourg subsidiary of Mobistar was able to attract 2,626 new customers. Orange Communications Luxembourg S.A. closed its financial year 2012 with service revenues of 65.5 million euros, compared to 60.6 million euros at the end of December 2011, an increase of 8.1 %. The total turnover for the financial year 2012 amounted to 75.5 million euros, an increase of 14.9 % compared to 65.7 million euros one year earlier, thanks to the successful sale of mobile telephones. The turnover of mobile telephones doubled in the fourth quarter of 2012 compared to the same period a year earlier, from 5.0 million euros in 2011 to 9.9 million euros in 2012. The average revenue per user for the full year 2012 amounted to 51.88 euros/month/ active customer, compared to 50.76 euros/month/active customer for the year 2011.
Orange Communications Luxembourg S.A. maintained its commercial footprint on the market with a total of 18 shops at the end of 2012.
On the network side, 254 GSM 2G sites, and 196 UMTS 3G sites are on air. In 2012, the company started the deployment of its LTE 4G network and end 2012, the company already counted 98 LTE 4G sites on air, covering 66.4 % of the population. As from October 2012, the company launched its first LTE offers (unlimited internet for € 39 per month).
The mobile termination rates (MTR) have remained unchanged in 2012. The Luxembourgian Regulator (ILR) has fixed MTR prices for the period from 2006 to 2008. They remained unchanged since then.
2.6 Evolution of the Mobistar share price
Mobistar's share price started the year 2012 on a downward trend that began after France Télécom finished its strategic review of its international assets portfolio in 2011. Pricing pressure stemming from both regulation and the fierce competition between the main telecom players has compounded this trend.
Up to February 2012, with the publication of the 2011 results, Mobistar's share price performance kept largely pace with the Dow Jones EURO STOXX Telecom index. Despite the 2011 results that were largely in line with the provided forecast, it was the 2012 outlook that disappointed the market. Mobistar referred to the new telecom law and aggressive fix-to-mobile offers of the incumbent operator to explain the provided wide forecast range. The general analyst feeling after Mobistar gave its 2012 EBITDA guidance back in February 2012 was that it seemed rather conservative.
In April 2012, Mobistar developed a new segmentation associated with user profiles that are represented by animals. These new offers enable the customers to keep control of their consumption and their usage, and to choose a subscription that really suits their needs. Backed by the launch of the Animals segmentation the share price performance won back some lost ground.
However with the publication of the first quarter results at the end of April 2012, it became clear for the investors community that the forecast provided in February 2012 was more realistic than they previously assumed. As of that moment Mobistar's share performance drifted away of the overall sector index. The renewal of the Full MVNO contract with Telenet early May 2012 was not a real share price mover.
In July 2012 Mobistar reported results in line with its forecast and reiterated its guidance for the full year 2012, however the inclusion of a positive one-off reversal of provision was seen by the market as an earnings downgrade of the underlying results forecast. Since August 2012, the relative underperformance versus the Dow Jones EURO STOXX Telecom index remained rather stable, but as the sector index was pressured, this also pressured the performance of the Mobistar share, making 2012 the worst year for Mobistar in terms of share price performance in the last 14 years.
2.7 Subsequent events
No adjusting events arose between the balance sheet date and the date at which the financial statements have been authorized for issue by the Board of Directors.
3. Comments on the consolidated accounts prepared according to IFRS standards
The scope of consolidation includes Mobistar S.A., Mobistar Enterprise Services S.A. (hereafter MES), the Luxembourgian company Orange Communications Luxembourg S.A. (hereafter OLU), 50 % of the temporary joint venture 'Irisnet' and as from 1 November 2012, 28.16 % of IRISnet S.C.R.L. (hereafter IRISnet).
OLU, a company organised and existing under the laws of Luxembourg, has been acquired as of 2 July 2007 by Mobistar S.A. The purchase concerned 90 % of the shares of OLU. The remaining 10 % of shares have been acquired on 12 November 2008. The company has consolidated the results of OLU for 100 % as of 2 July 2007.
MES, a company organised and existing under the laws of Belgium, has been acquired as of 31 March 2010 by Mobistar S.A. The purchase concerned 100 % of the shares of affiliated company. The company has consolidated the results of MES for 100 % as of 1 April 2010.
The temporary association Irisnet is a joint venture between France Télécom S.A. and Belgacom S.A. (the initial partner Telindus S.A. is since January 2010 an integral part of Belgacom S.A.). As such, Mobistar does not own directly or indirectly any voting power in Irisnet. However, in application of SIC 12, Mobistar concluded that Irisnet is actually controlled by Mobistar and its partner Belgacom. In addition, it is concluded that the risks and rewards are not born by France Télécom but by Mobistar.
At the beginning of November 2012, the temporary association Irisnet stopped its activities. The activities of Irisnet have been taken over by a newly created company named IRISnet S.C.R.L. Irisnet will just continue to collect its outstanding receivable balances open as of 31 October 2012 and complete the legal liquidation of the temporary association.
Based on the fact that the temporary association stopped its activities, Mobistar decided to include in the 2012 closing all necessary provisions regarding the legal liquidation of the temporary association. This review has allowed the Group to record € 9.8 million of additional income in the fourth quarter of 2012.
IRISnet has been constituted in July 2012 in order to take over the activities performed by the temporary association Irisnet. The take-over of the activities took place on 1 November 2012. In this new legal structure, Mobistar has contributed in cash for € 3,450,000 representing 345,000 shares out of the 1,225,000 shares issued by the company. Due to the deal structure, IRISnet will be integrated in the consolidated accounts using the equity method. Given the limited impact of the results generated in 2012, no impact has been included in the 2012 consolidated results.
3.1 Income statement
In 2012, the Group recorded a consolidated net profit of € 185.7 million, a decrease of 16.0 % on the figure of € 221.0 million recorded in the previous year.
Consolidated turnover decreased by 0.4 % from € 1,657.6 million in 2011 to € 1,650.5 million in 2012. Service revenues decreased from € 1,505.8 million in 2011 to € 1,450.0 million in 2012. Revenue from the sale of equipment, in particular handsets, showed an increase of 32.1 % to € 200.5 million against € 151.8 million in 2011.
In 2012, the total consolidated customer base of the Mobistar group grew by 5.3 % to reach 4,427,405 customers, for a consolidated turnover of € 1,650.5 million (-0.4 % vs. 2011).
At the end of 2012, the number of active customers for mobile telephony (excluding MVNO's and OLU) reached 3,432,060 which is a decrease of 2.4 % compared to the 3,515,593 active customers one year earlier. Mainly postpaid customers opted for Mobistar, so the share of subscribers in the customer base rose to 68.1 % at the end of 2012, compared to 66.3 % at the end of 2011.
The number of MVNO customers grew by 50.8 %, from
589,830 active customers at the end of December 2011 to 889,540 active customers at the end of December 2012 as a result of the success of Mobistar's MVNO partners.
The demand for mobile internet, driven by the use of smartphones and tablets, increased sharply in 2012. More and more Belgian consumers want to have access - everywhere and at all times - to the internet, Facebook and Twitter, as well as to be able to send and receive e-mails. Around 80 % of the ´Animals' subscriptions sold include mobile data, and consumers are also buying more smartphones. In the Mobistar centers, the share of smartphones in the sale of mobile telephones rose to 50 % in 2012. The number of customers with a smartphone on our network increased by 52 % in a single year, from 19 % in January 2012 to 26 % at the end of the year. The great success of the iPhone 5, the combined offer with the Samsung Galaxy S3 and the Samsung ´Gio´ action, a limited edition subsidised offer in the fourth quarter 2012, confirm this trend. The strongest increase in mobile data traffic was registered in the fourth quarter of 2012: it rose by 70 % compared to the third quarter of 2012. At the end of December 2012, the share of mobile data in the service revenues of Mobistar amounted to 41.4 %, compared to 37.1 % a year earlier.
In 2012, the revenues of the Mobistar group were once again negatively influenced by the reduction of the MTR rates in January 2012 and of the roaming rates in July 2011 and 2012. The impact of these reductions on the turnover amounted respectively to € 29.6 million and € 28.9 million for the year 2012.
Other operating revenue totalled € 52.0 million in 2012, compared with € 42.0 million in 2011. This revenue comes predominantly from the cross-charging of services provided to the France Télécom group and from information supplied to the judicial authorities.
At the beginning of November 2012, the temporary association Irisnet stopped its activities. The activities of Irisnet have been taken over by a newly created company named IRISnet S.C.R.L. Irisnet will just continue to collect its outstanding receivable balances open as of 31st of October 2012 and complete the legal liquidation of the temporary association. Based on the fact that the temporary association stopped its activities, Mobistar has decided to include in the 2012 closing all necessary provisions regarding the legal liquidation of the temporary association. This review has allowed the Group to record € 9.8 million of additional income in the fourth quarter of 2012.
Rigorous policy on expense control remained a focus for the Group in 2012. This has allowed the Group to maintain a controlled level of increase in the total operating expenses. These ones have been mainly influenced by the cost of equipment and goods sold (following the continued increase of handsets sales), payroll costs (related to the investments made in the sales department and the customer service in order to improve the customer relationship) and the depreciation (increased by the fact that the IT renewal and the network swap have generated an increase of the depreciation of fixed assets due to changes in useful life, and by the accelerated depreciations on software development due to IT strategy review). Finally compared to previous year, some important claims needed to be accrued in 2012. These elements resulted in an increase of the Group's operating expenses which went from € 1,359.9 million to € 1,425.6 million at the end of 2012.
Interconnection costs slightly decreased.
Costs of equipment and goods sold recorded an increase as a result of the growth in revenue from equipment sales, especially in the area of smartphones (€ 49.7 million).
The cost of services and other goods decreased by € 15.7 million reaching € 281.8 million. An important positive impact is related to the review of the provision for universal service compensation for € 17.5 million. In light of the Court decision taken last year and the evolution of the regulation, Mobistar has reviewed its approach on the calculation of the provision from a 'loss of revenue' basis to a 'net charges' basis. Professional fees, which include IT consultants and outsourced activities, have increased over the year by € 8.8 million, although commercial expenses have been reduced by € 7.8 million as well as the commissions paid by € 4.1 million.
The company is not involved in 'Research & Development' activities so that no expenses have been registered.
The payroll costs have increased in line with the variance of team members and the salaries indexation recorded beginning of 2012 for 3.47 %. The average full-time equivalent number of employees increased from 1,859.3 in 2011 to 1,896.0 in 2012. The increase has been focused on the sales force and on the customer service in order to largely improve the customer experience.
Depreciations and amortizations on intangible and tangible assets increased by 14.1 %, from € 190.3 million at the end of 2011 to € 217.2 million in 2012. Due to important projects related to technical swap of technology, the useful life of the assets related has been reviewed and shortened in order to consider the expected decommissioning dates. This change has resulted in an increase of the depreciation for a total amount of € 14.1 million in 2012. An exceptional accelerated depreciation has also been recorded on software development in order to reflect the impact of the change in the IT strategy. The cost for the company has reached € 15.5 million.
Bad debt provision increase is largely impacting this header as it increased by € 14.6 million. This increase is partially due to the fact that in 2012 a lower amount of write-offs was acted compared to 2011 and consequently the reverse of the provision has been lower (€ -10.4 million). The increase is also the consequence of the continued slowdown in cash collection due to economic circumstances (impacting Mobistar SA by € 5.0 million). Orange Communication Luxembourg S.A. had also to increase its bad debt provision in 2012 (€ 1.6 million) due to issues with its billing system that has generated a high level of contestations and risks on collectability of its receivables.
Other operating charges decreased by € 1.5 million.
In 2012, financial income amounted to € 0.5 million, a small decrease of € 0.4 million compared to the € 0.9 million recorded in 2011. Financial costs amounted to € 11.2 million in 2012, a small decrease compared to 2011 (€ 0.6 million). The main drivers of the financial expenses are the interests paid on borrowings which have been slightly lower than in 2011.
For the year 2012, the operator posted a net profit of € 185.7 million, a decrease of 16.0 % after a tax expense of € 80.5 million. The basic earnings per share as well as the diluted earnings per share decreased by 16.0 % to reach € 3.09.
The General Shareholders' Meeting held on 2 May 2012 endorsed the proposal made by the Board of Directors to distribute a gross ordinary dividend of € 2.90 per ordinary share and a gross extraordinary dividend of € 0.80 per ordinary share on the results of the year 2011.
For the 2012 financial year, the Board of Directors will propose at the General Shareholders' Meeting to be held on 2 May 2013 the distribution of a gross ordinary dividend of € 1.80 per ordinary share.
3.2 Balance sheet
The consolidated balance sheet total was € 1,347.0 million at the end of 2012 which represents a decrease of € 34.5 million compared with € 1,381.5 million recorded at the end of the previous financial year.
Non-current assets amounted to € 1,045.8 million at the end of 2012 compared with € 1,070.3 million at the end of 2011 and consisted of the following items:
- Goodwill of € 80.1 million, resulting from:
- o the acquisition of Mobistar Affiliate S.A. (€ 10.6 million) in 2001;
- o the acquisition of OLU (€ 70.9 million) in 2007, adjusted by € 2.2 million (decrease) after the acquisition of the remaining shares of OLU in 2008;
- o the acquisition of MES in 2010 (€ 0.8 million).
- The goodwill's have been reviewed for impairment during
the year. As the recoverable values exceeded the carrying amount at the end of the year, no impairment loss was recorded.
• Intangible assets, posting a net value of € 286.6 million at the end of 2012 compared with € 312.0 million at the end of 2011. Values related to the licences are as follows (respectively acquisition value, net book value at the end of the period, remaining amortization period):
o 2G (extension): € 74.4 million, € 43.5 million, 35 months;
o 3G: € 149.0 million, € 77.2 million, 99 months;
o 4G (2.6 Ghz): € 20.0 million, € 20.0 million, as from technical readiness up to end of June 2027.
An accelerated depreciation of € 15.5 million has been recorded on IT developments to consider the change in the IT strategy.
- Tangible assets of € 665.0 million at the end of the 2012 financial year to be compared with € 666.0 million recorded at the end of the 2011 financial year. During 2012, accelerated depreciation due to a change in useful life on tangible and intangible assets has been recognised for an amount of € 14.5 million (€ 12.4 million in 2011) and shown as expense on the line 'Depreciation, amortisation and impairment' in the income statement. The changes recognised during the year have been determined on individual asset basis in order to consider technology and IT evolution. Obsolescence, dismantling or losses are also considered in the exercise.
- In 2012, the Group invested in a new Belgian company (IRISnet S.C.R.L.) for an amount of € 3.5 million corresponding to 28.16 % of the equity. This company will be treated as an associated company. IRISnet started its activities on 1 November 2012. Given the limited impact of the results generated in 2012, no impact has been included in the 2012 consolidated results.
- Other non-current assets decreased from € 5.8 million at the end of 2011 to € 4.0 million at the end of 2012. The decrease is mainly due to the transfer to 'Other current assets' of the maturing part of the long-term loans to specific partners.
- Net deferred tax assets, relating essentially to investments tax credits, to the temporary differences resulting from the consideration of borrowing costs and the development costs for intranet sites, to the income related to the free minutes of traffic granted to subscribed customers and to the dismantling assets depreciation, as well as the integration of losses carried forward from OLU and from MES, amounted to € 6.7 million at the end of 2012.
Current assets decreased year to year, going from a total of € 311.2 million at the end of 2011 to € 301.2 million at the end of 2012. They consist of the following items:
• Inventories of goods, amounting to € 20.6 million at the end of 2012, compared to € 16.5 million at the end of 2011. The increase of the inventory level is partially due to the implementation of the bundle offers (combination of service plan and handset), which has postponed the de-recognition of the inventory transferred to the distribution channels from the transfer date to the distributor to the end customer received date (€ 2.8 million).
- Trade receivables, amounting to € 230.2 million at the end of 2012, compared with € 225.3 million at the end of 2011. The small increase results from a compensation of a small decrease in the 'Service Revenue' receivable, which is influenced by the reduction of service revenue itself, over compensated by the increase on receivable related to distributors, influenced by the very high level of handsets sales in the last quarter of the year. The slowdown in cash collection noted at the end of 2011 has been stabilized in the residential segment but required a small increase in the provision for bad debt (up to 2.1 %) again in 2012. Some more difficulties have been noted in the 'small and medium enterprises' segment, resulting in an increase of the bad debt provision related to this segment. The Group is not dependent from major customers' situation, none representing more than 10 % of the company's turnover. The customers risk is spread over more than 4 million customers.
- Other current assets and accrued revenues, decreasing from € 62.3 million at the end of 2011 to € 38.2 million at the end of 2012. This variance is mainly due to the change in the VAT situation at the end of 2012 compared to 2011 (switch from a receivable balance of € 5.5 million to a payable balance), the decrease in the service revenues cut-off entries (€ -4.6 million) and the impact of the new telecom law that has accelerated the reversal of gratuity related to previous years contracts (€ -8.2 million).
- Cash and cash equivalents amounting to € 12.3 million at the end of 2012, an increase of € 5.2 million since the end of the 2011 financial year. The cash flow statement gives details of the flows that gave rise to this trend.
Equity decreased by € 36.2 million during the 2012 financial year, from € 394.0 million to € 357.8 million:
- The share capital remained at € 131.7 million.
- The legal reserve corresponds to 10 % of the share capital.
- The evolution of retained earnings, decreasing from € 249.1 million to € 212.9 million, is the result of the net profit of the period (€ 185.7 million), payment of the 2011 dividend (€ 222.1 million) and costs of equity transactions and other equity transactions (€ -0.2 million).
Non-current liabilities consist of:
- loans payable after more than one year (€ 383.7 million in 2012 against € 293.2 in 2011); these amounts correspond to the use of the credit facility granted by the France Télécom group. The company signed in 2010 a new long-term credit facility for an amount of € 450 million for a period of 5 years at Euribor + 65 Bps margin + 20 Bps utilization fee;
- long-term provisions intended to cover litigations (€ 14.9
million in 2012 against € 14.2 million in 2011) mainly impacted by the release of provision for onerous contracts set up in 2010 and 2011 for which costs have been incurred in the 2012 operations;
- costs of dismantling network sites and refurbishing of rented buildings (€ 52.2 million in 2012 against € 47.4 million in 2011). The increase is due to the unwinding effect and the change in discount rate;
- amount payable over one year related to the renewal of the 2G licence, as the company has opted for the deferred payment approach (€ 28.3 million end 2011, € 13.4 million end 2012);
- deferred taxes liabilities decreasing by € 1.2 million; therefore there are no deferred taxes liabilities outstanding at the end of 2012.
Current liabilities decreased by € 78.5 million, going from € 603.2 million at the end of 2011 to € 524.7 million at the end of 2012:
- Short-term borrowing increased by € 4.1 million to € 22.6 million at the end of 2012.
- Outstanding trade payables remained stable at € 344.6 million.
- Liabilities resulting from employee benefits increased by € 1.5 million, going from € 32.9 million at the end of 2011 to € 34.4 million at the end of 2012.
- Variation of corporate tax payable is due to the fact that the tax bills 2010 and 2011 have been paid during 2012 (for a total of € 105.0 million). Prepayments of taxes for 2012 have been slightly lower than in 2011 due to the lower level of pre-tax result.
- Deferred income relates to the portion of the upfront payments made under some tariff plans not used at closing date and to the amount of prepaid cards issued but not used. Decrease comes essentially from the change in the tariff plans' structure in the portfolio. Indeed the 'Animals' tariff plans do not include anymore a roll-over period of the unused part of the fixed part billed, which resulted in the decrease of the deferred income. The decrease in prepaid customers has also resulted in a decrease in deferred revenues. Both evolution in preand postpaid have had an impact of € -11.7 million.
3.3 Financial instruments, financial risk management objectives and policy
Mobistar's principal financial instruments comprise bank and inter-company loans, overdrafts, cash at bank and short-term bank and inter-company deposits. The main purpose of these financial instruments is to raise finance for Mobistar's operations. Mobistar has also various other financial assets and liabilities such as trade receivables and trade payables, which arise directly from its operations.
It is to be noted that Mobistar's policy does not allow trading in financial instruments.
- Interest rate risk: As a result of the exceptionally high distribution to its shareholders paid-out in 2008 (nearly € 600 million), the Company showed a debt amounting to € 407.6 million on 31 December 2012. The Company didn't hedge the interest rate risk on the debt that bears interests based on Euribor + 65 Bps margin + 20 Bps utilization fee. The company decided not to hedge the long-term interest rate risk linked to its long-term debt in the light of the currently low interest rates levels and the amount's fluctuations of the said long-term debt.
- Foreign currency risk: The Company is not subject to significant foreign currency risks.
- Credit risk: Mobistar trades only with recognised, creditworthy third-parties. It is Mobistar's policy that all customers who wish to trade on credit terms are subject to credit verification procedures. In addition, trade receivable balances are monitored on an ongoing basis. Allowance for doubtful debtors is calculated on the basis of different criteria depending on the type of customers. Hardware customers allowance is based on individual evaluation of the customer financial reliability on a case by case basis. In some circumstances, payment terms are defined as cash on delivery. For Airtime customers, allowance is based on a percentage of turnover generated combined with ageing of the open items. Percentages are defined based on customer segmentation, previous years recovery experience. Yearly review is made of all the indicators.
- Liquidity risk: Mobistar's objective is to maintain a balance between continuity of funding and flexibility through the use of bank overdrafts, bank loans and intercompany loans. We refer to the table summarizing the maturity profile of the financial assets and liabilities.
4. Comments on Mobistar S.A.'s 2012 annual accounts prepared according to Belgian accounting standards
4.1 Income statement
Turnover for the year 2012 reached € 1,533.1 million, an increase of 0.6 % on the figure of € 1,524.5 million recorded in the previous year.
Produced fixed assets, including IT development costs and research and design costs for the new sites required for network deployment, have slightly increased to € 4.8 million.
Other operating income reached € 54.9 million, compared to the € 54.4 million posted in 2011. This income mainly comes from the revenues from the cross-charging of services provided to the France Télécom group, from the revenues from the cross-charging of sites shared with other operators and from the revenues generated from information supplied to the judicial authorities.
Operating charges have increased. These reached € 1,310.5 million, an increase of 5.9 % compared with the figure of € 1,238.0 million recorded in 2011, and can be broken down as follows:
- Purchases and supplies totalled € 687.9 million, mainly consisting of interconnection costs (50.8 % of the total, compared with 52.6 % in 2011). The balance mainly consists of the costs associated with the operation of the technical network, leased lines and the cost of GSM and SIM cards sales. This year, the increase is also largely due to the purchase of handsets for € 50.6 million. The business of handsets sales has indeed increased by 28 % in 2012 compared to 2011.
- The cost of services and other goods slightly decreased by € 15.9 million reaching € 267.8 million. An important positive impact is related to the review of the provision for universal service compensation for € 17.5 million. In light of the Court decision taken last year and the evolution of the regulation, Mobistar has reviewed its approach on the calculation of the provision from a 'loss of revenue' basis to a 'net charges' basis. Professional fees, which include IT consultants and outsourced activities, have increased over the year by € 3.7 million, although commercial expenses have been reduced by € 5.1 million as well as commissions paid by € 3.2 million.
- Remuneration, social security costs and pensions collectively totalled € 151.5 million compared with € 142.7 million in the previous year. Employee costs are influenced by the evolution of the number of employees and a 3.47 % salary increase as from 1 January 2012, following a wage indexation and a sector understanding. The comparison between 2011 and 2012 is also largely influenced by the efforts started during the second half of 2011 and continued in 2012 to reinforce sales and customer support teams. Despite these negative impacts, the increase of employee benefits cost has been limited to 6.2 %.
- Depreciation of and impairment on formation expenses, on intangible and tangible fixed assets, amounted to € 175.8 million for the 2012 year compared with € 161.4 million in 2011. The useful lives of intangible and tangible assets remained unchanged in 2012. Due to important projects related to technical swap of technology, the useful life of the assets related has been reviewed and shortened in order to consider the expected decommissioning dates. This change has resulted in an increase of the depreciation for a total amount of € 14.4 million in 2012.
- Provision for write-off on stocks and trade receivables increased to € 17.5 million in 2012, mainly as a consequence of the net increase of the bad debt provision related to trade receivables. This evolution has to be combined with the decrease in 'other operating charges'. In 2011, an amount of € 14.3 million of trade receivables has
been written off, generating an usage of the provision. In 2012, write-offs for an amount of € 4.0 million have been booked.
- Provisions for liabilities and charges in relation to various disputes totalled € 0.1 million, compared with € 1.8 million in 2011. No major claims have been recorded in 2012, only small evolutions of the claims open at the end of 2011 were noted.
- Other operating charges totalled € 9.9 million in 2012, compared with € 15.1 million in 2011, a change mainly due to the write-off of trade receivables for which allowances for doubtful debts had been made in previous financial years. It is also to be noted that a correction of the building taxes 2010 has had a negative impact of € 0.9 million.
Operating profit for the financial year was € 282.3 million, a decrease of 18.1 % on the figure of € 344.6 million recorded in 2011.
Financial income generated during the year amounted to € 0.6 million, lower compared to previous year due to the reduction of the financial discounts obtained in 2012 compared to the one's received in 2011 and lower interest rates.
Financial expenses for the year amounted to € 10.8 million, a decrease compared to the financial charges (€ 12.7 million) recorded during the previous financial year. This decrease is mainly due to the interest level evolution.
In 2012, an exceptional write-off has been recorded on software development in order to reflect the impact of the change in the IT strategy. The cost for the company has reached € 15.5 million. The € 12.0 million extraordinary income booked in 2011 was related to the revaluation of a financial receivable on OLU.
At the end of the year, Mobistar S.A. declared a profit for the period before taxes of € 256.6 million, a decrease of 25.7 % compared with the figure of € 345.5 million recorded in 2011. The estimated income tax expenses for the year 2012 and the adjustments of previous years' taxes totalled € 81.9 million, of which € 50.1 million had been paid through advance payments of tax for the year 2012.
Mobistar S.A. posted an after-tax profit for the period of € 174.7 million for the 2012 financial year compared with € 236.3 million for the previous year.
The Board of Directors will recommend to the General Shareholders' Meeting that the profit be appropriated as follows:
| € million | |
|---|---|
| • P rofit for the period available for appropriation |
174.7 |
| • P rior year profit carried forward |
33.3 |
| • P rofit to be appropriated |
208.0 |
| • Ordinary dividend 2012 - € 1.80 per share | 108.0 |
| • Employee profit sharing plan | 1.9 |
| • P rofit to be carried forward |
98.1 |
4.2 Balance sheet
The company's balance sheet total was € 1,272.2 million compared with € 1,290.5 million recorded in the 2011 financial year.
The capital expenditure in intangible and tangible assets, made during the year, amounts to € 170.1 million, after having invested a net amount of € 189.9 million in 2011. The acquisition of the 4G licence has been recorded in 2011 for € 20.0 million while no licence has been acquired in 2012. The invested amount in 2012 corresponds to the continued update and deployment of the radio equipment and the other network technologies.
Intangible and tangible fixed assets are broken down as follows:
- Intangible fixed assets represented a total of € 281.2 million. These relate essentially to GSM, UMTS and 4G licences and the related IT developments, and to the net value of goodwill fully amortized at the end of 2012 but which is broken down as follows:
- o Goodwill of € 60.1 million resulting from the acquisition, in 2003, of all of the assets of Mobistar Corporate Solutions S.A., amortized over 5 years. This goodwill has been totally amortized at the end of 2008.
- o Merger goodwill of € 1.4 million accounted for in accordance with Article 78, § 7 a of the Royal Decree of 30 January 2001 following the merger by absorption into Mobistar S.A. of its subsidiary Mobistar Affiliate S.A. on 4 May 2005, with retroactive effect from 1 January 2005. This goodwill has been totally amortized at the end of 2009.
- Tangible fixed assets represented a total of € 547.6 million. These relate to network infrastructures, telephony equipment and added-value services.
Financial fixed assets totalling € 167.6 million consist of investments in affiliated enterprises. The financial fixed assets have evolved during the year 2012 due to the participation to the creation of IRISnet S.C.R.L., the company that has taken over the activities of the joint venture Irisnet, for an amount of € 3.5 million. At the end of 2012 the open amount was made of:
| - OLU (100 %) | € 87.0 million |
|---|---|
| - MES (100 %) | € 77.0 million |
| - IRISnet (28.16 %) | € 3.5 million |
Current assets increased by € 1.1 million to stand at € 274.4 million at the end of the 2012 financial year. This result is essentially due to an increase in trade receivables (€ 9.0 million) resulting from a continued slowdown in cash collection, and in the level of stocks of goods (€ 3.9 million), and to a decrease in other receivables (€ -10.8 million) due to the intercompany loans granted to OLU and a switch to a VAT payable in the current year from a VAT receivable last year. Cash and cash equivalents increased by € 6.9 million and deferred charges and accrued incomes decreased by € 7.0 million.
As far as equity is concerned, the capital remained at € 131.7 million and the legal reserve at € 13.2 million.
At the end of 2012, equity totalled € 243.1 million and was made up of:
- issued capital of € 131.7 million,
- legal reserve of € 13.2 million,
- profit carried forward of € 98.1 million,
- investment grants of € 0.1 million.
Provisions and liabilities at the end of 2012 amounted to € 1,029.0 million and are broken down as follows:
- Provisions for liabilities and charges remained stable at € 6.1 million. No major evolution in the claims has been noted in 2012.
- Long-term liabilities recorded for € 398.4 million in 2012 consist of € 385.0 million of financial debt and € 13.4 million of long-term trade payable. The amount of € 13.4 million of other long-term debt corresponds to the amount payable over one year related to the renewal of the 2G licence.
- Short-term liabilities amounting to € 559.8 million compared with € 711.3 million in 2011, broken down as follows:
- o long-term debt maturing in 2013 for 14.9 million, related to the renewal of the 2G licence,
- o short-term interest-bearing borrowing for € 43.8 million,
- o trade debts: € 316.2 million compared with € 302.9 million in 2011,
- o taxes, remuneration and social security contributions: € 72.0 million compared with € 140.5 million in 2011, largely influenced by the fact that tax payments were higher in 2012 than in 2011 as the remaining tax payable amount of 2010 and 2011 was paid during 2012 for a total of € 105.0 million,
- o other liabilities: € 112.9 million (out of which € 108.0 million of dividend 2012) compared with € 227.0 million in 2011 (out of which € 222.1 million of dividends 2011).
- Accrued charges and deferred income totalling € 64.7 million.
4.3 Disputes
Masts: Since 1997, certain municipalities and three provinces have adopted local taxes, on an annual basis, on pylons, masts and antennas erected within their boundaries. These taxes are currently being contested before the Civil Courts (Courts of First Instance - Tax Chamber and Courts of Appeal).
Pursuant to a preliminary question raised by the Council of State to the European Court of Justice, the latter ruled in its decree dated 8 September 2005 that such taxes are not inconsistent with European law, provided they do not alter the conditions of competition between the historical operator and new operators on the market.
The Council of State decided since 20 November 2007 in several arrests that a tax regulation violates the principle of equality if the motive appearing in the preamble of this tax regulation results from the financial situation of the municipality. In fact, such a motive does not explain at all the differentiation made between the mobile telephone network operators (which are taxed on the basis of this tax regulation) and the operators of other similar networks (which are not taxed on the basis of this same tax regulation). It is therefore not established that the difference in treatment is based on a criterion that can be objectively and logically justified.
The Constitutional Court decided in its judgment of 15 December 2011 that article 98 §2 of the Act of 21 March 1991 reforming certain public companies doesn't prohibit the municipalities from taxing the economic activity of the telecom operators which is achieved in the territory of the municipality by the presence (whether on the public or private domain) of mobile phone masts, pylons or antennas dedicated to this activity, for budgetary or other reasons. According to the Constitutional Court, this interpretation of article 98 §2 is not inconsistent with article 170 § 4 of the Constitution.
The Supreme Court has confirmed in its judgments of 30 March 2012 the interpretation of the Constitutional Court of article 98 of the Act of 21 March 1991.
The total receivable amount of taxes charged, plus default interest calculated at the legal rate, amounts to € 57.3 million and is subject to a bad debt provision for the whole amount, of which € 7.6 million correspond to the financial year 2012.
MTR tariffs: In its decision of 29 June 2010, the BIPT concluded to impose new MTR tariffs based on a pure long run incremental cost model (LRIC). Tariffs will go down according to a glide to reach a symmetrical level of 1.08 c€/ min (before indexation) as of 1st January 2013. KPN Group Belgium and Mobistar have filed an appeal in suspension and in annulment against this decision. On 15 February 2011, the suspension has been rejected. On 16 May 2012, the Court of appeal issued an interim decision in which it rejected the grounds for annulation and referred the matter on a procedural aspect to the Constitutional Court. Although the final decision has not yet been issued, the case on the merits has been definitively decided.
Abuse of dominant position by the Belgacom group: In May 2007, the Commercial Court of Brussels handed down a judgment confirming the dominant position of Belgacom Mobile between 1999 and 2004, and appointing experts with an assignment to determine any abuses and to calculate the loss sustained by Mobistar and KPN Group Belgium. A second intermediary report issued in December 2010 confirmed the abuses and increased the estimated damages to € 1.84 billion for Mobistar and KPN Group Belgium together. In 2011, Belgacom launched expert dismissal proceedings which led to the replacement of the experts in March 2012. New experts must be appointed. Furthermore, the replacement decision has been attacked before the Court of appeal by the dismissed experts and before the Supreme Court by Mobistar. Additionally, in January 2012, Belgacom has filed an appeal against the initial judgment of the Commercial Court. The appeal process is ongoing. The pleadings will take place in 2014.
In another case for abuse of dominant position identified during the years 2004 and 2005, the Competition Council fined Belgacom Mobile € 66 million in May 2009. The decision was appealed by Mobistar requesting the court to include additional abuses (loyalty discounts and on-net/offnet discrimination) to the one withheld. The case has been reactivated in March 2012 and pleadings will take place in Q1 2013 regarding the access of Mobistar and KPN Group Belgium to the administrative file. Mobistar also referred the matter to the Commercial Court, seeking damages for the prejudice sustained. The damage claim proceedings before the Commercial Court are on hold until the adoption of a final decision on the abuses in appeal.
Finally, Mobistar, acting jointly with KPN Group Belgium, filed a complaint with the European Commission against Belgacom for abuse of dominant position on the broadband market in April 2009. In the course of 2010 this complaint was withdrawn and introduced instead before the Belgian Competition Council. The investigation is ongoing.
Portability cost: The three mobile network operators active in Belgium have challenged the BIPT's 2003 decision concerning the portability cost for mobile numbers. Mobistar maintains that the price required for transferring several numbers is too high. The matter was referred to the European Court of Justice as an interlocutory question. The European Court of Justice decided in July 2006 that the regulator can set maximum prices on the basis of a theoretical cost model provided that these prices are set based on actual costs and that consumers are not dissuaded from using the portability feature. The litigation before the Court of Appeal is still pending.
Universal service: Mobistar is involved, together with other alternative operators, in a number of legal actions regarding the planned financial compensation system in relation to the provision of social tariffs. These actions can be regarded as concluded. On 26 January 2013, Mobistar and KPN Group Belgium attacked the law transposing the Telecom Directives before the Constitutional Court regarding the compensation system put in place and the retroactive effect relating to social tariffs.
Renewal of the 2G licence and licence renewal fee: The Mobistar 2G licence was renewed for 5 years and it now runs until end 2015. By a new law dated 15 March 2010, the possibility to ask a licence renewal fee for the 2G licence was introduced. The fee would amount to approximately € 15 million per year for a 5 years period. Belgacom Mobile, KPN Group Belgium and Mobistar challenged this law before the Constitutional Court, which submitted in June 2011 a number of questions to the European Court of Justice. In its opinion of 25 October 2012 the Advocate General supports the Belgian State. The European Court of Justice should decide in 2013.
Regulation of broadband and cable: Mid-2011 the 4 media regulators (BIPT, CSA, Medienrat and VRM) decided to impose access and resale obligations on the cable operators (in particular the resale of analogue TV and the access to the digital TV platform). In addition, they must offer a resalebroadband service, but only in combination with a TV service. The cable operators are seeking the suspension and cancellation of the decisions relating to them. Mobistar, as an interested party, is intervening in the proceeding. The suspension requests of the cable operators have been rejected in September and November 2012. The proceedings on the merits are pursued in 2013.
Emissions/health: In the Brussels Capital Region, at the end of 2009 the Brussels government has issued two orders implementing the ordinance of March 2007, which sets a maximum cumulative standard of 3 volts/meter for all emission sources, except for radio and television signals. In 2012, Mobistar has fulfilled its first obligation by submitting to the administration the environment permit files for all outdoor sites.
KPN Mobile International B.V. / Mobistar S.A. Share Purchase Agreement: On 10 November 2010, KPN Mobile International B.V. (KPN) filed a request for arbitration with the Cepani against Mobistar for a dispute regarding their Share Purchase Agreement (SPA) dated 24 November 2009.
In its request, KPN asked the arbitral tribunal to rule that no adjustment to the financial statements should be allowed. In other words, that the independent accountant cannot decide on the items in dispute that were previously submitted to him by the parties in accordance with the SPA and that Mobistar should consequently be condemned to pay an amount of € 6.3 million to KPN instead of receiving between € 0.3 million and € 2.2 million based upon the independent accountant's report. Mobistar asked the tribunal to dismiss all the claims of KPN and to confirm the independent accountant's mission. The arbitration has been rendered on 5 July 2012 and confirms the scope of the mission of the expert but states that the independent expert's report contains manifest errors. As the Court is not competent to engage into further examination of the disputed items, it proposes that both parties would choose a new independent expert to review the disputed items. Mobistar started an annulment procedure against the arbitration award.
Agency agreement: A former agent has initiated a procedure before the Brussels Commercial Court to obtain compensation for the termination of his agency agreement. The agent claims damages for an amount of around € 16.9 million. Mobistar is convinced that the claim is, at least for the major part, unfounded. Mobistar has filed a counterclaim for a value of around € 14.6 million. The procedure has been initiated in July 2011. The hearing took place in January 2013. Mobistar is awaiting the judgment.
5. Trends
In order to anticipate the opportunities that will be presenting themselves on the Belgian market as of 2015, in particular the maturity in the 4G market and the regulation of the cable infrastructure, Mobistar decided to accelerate its investments in its four strategic programmes:
Strengthening its leadership in the mobile activities market:
• In order to preserve its commercial leadership in the mobile activities market, Mobistar today announces its ´SuperMobile 2013-2015´ investment programme. Along with the planned investments in the 3G/4G network, Mobistar will in the coming 3 years invest € 150 million so as to terminate the accelerated roll-out of its superfast mobile data network. In 2013 Mobistar will more rapidly convert its 2G/3G network in order to meet the current needs of its customers. Driven by the increasing demand for mobile internet, Mobistar wishes to join the leading group of operators, which will more quickly roll out a 4G network in 1800 MHz or some other spectrum that is available in the future. Mobistar's objective is to provide 80 % of the population with 4G by 2015, even in Brussels if the emission standard is made less restrictive, and to offer its customers the best 4G network in the country.
Developing services that are available everywhere and at all times:
• In 2013 Mobistar will continue to offer fixed-line products in combination with mobile products and services. In the coming 12 to 24 months Mobistar will prepare itself in order to market offers via the regulated cable offer and to exploit all the new possibilities deriving from an accelerated roll-out of the 4G network.
• Mobistar will also invest in the development of services that permit the residential customers to be connected everywhere and at all times, whether it be to watch TV via the PC, tablets or smartphones, or to get access to 'cloud' services, for example. In the business market, Mobistar will make use of its growth in the 'machineto-machine' sector and the company fleets, as well as its strategic partners in order to offer 'connectivity 3.0' services to companies that offer their employees the possibility of using their own mobile telephones at work and of having access to professional cloud services.
Offering the best customer experience on the market:
• Customer satisfaction remains a top priority in 2013 as well. In order to maintain this commitment to the customer, Mobistar is accelerating the investments in its online distribution and its stores, loyalty programmes and its customer test center. Mobistar continues to strive for the best customer experience on the market and wants to become the preferred telecommunications brand in Belgium.
Managing the costs of the company as efficiently as possible:
• Finally, Mobistar wishes to be a pioneer in terms of cost control of the company via its ACE programme (Agility – Cost – Efficiency). The preparations for the ACE programme began in the second half of 2012 and will achieve additional gross savings of at least € 100 million between 2013 and 2015. The first part of the ACE programme, aimed at tactical efficiency improvements, already generated major cost savings in 2012. The more strategic improvements that begin in January 2013 will deliver results in 2014-2015.
The impact of the roaming regulation is the result of the retail price reduction for voice, data and SMS traffic on 1st July 2012 and the future reduction on 1st July 2013. As of 2014 the national regulator will be focusing more on the fixed network operators, and Mobistar expects no further reduction in the MTR rates beside the decrease of 1st January 2013.
Based on the business strategy for 2013-2015, the Mobistar group foresees for the full financial year 2013:
- a reduction of the total turnover between -4 % and -6 %;
- an EBITDA between € 380 and 420 million;
- an operating cash-flow between € 175 and 215 million.
The forecasts of the Mobistar group for 2013 take account of the negative impact of the regulatory measures for around € 57 million on the turnover and € 32 million on the EBITDA for the financial year 2013.
The hypotheses are based on the current figures on the evolution of the Belgian economic situation. They could be modified as a function of the impact of the price adjustments on the customer base resulting from the competitive pressure and the economic situation in Belgium.
6. Justification of the application of the going concern accounting principles
In view of Mobistar's financial results in the course of the financial year which closed on 31 December 2012, the company is not subject to the application of article 96 (6°) of the Company Code relating to provision of evidence of the application of the going concern accounting rules.
7. Application of article 524 of the Company Code during the 2012 financial year
The procedure foreseen in article 524 of the Company Code has not been applied during the 2012 financial year.
Nevertheless, the Board of Directors entrusted the independent directors asking them to track inter-group transactions in which Mobistar is involved.
8. Application of Article 96, 9° of the Company Code
As foreseen by the article 96, 9° of the Company code, the company justifies of the independence and the accounting and audit expertise of at least one member of the Audit Committee as follows: Mr Eric Dekeuleneer, Chairman of the Audit Committee, is an independent director since 18 November 2004.
He has been appointed by the General Assembly and meets the independence criteria as described in the article 524 of the Company code.
His expertise in accounting and auditing is justified as well by his education than by his position as member or Chairman of various Audit Committees, and as teacher in Finance and Regulation at the 'Université Libre' of Brussels (Solvay Brussels School). During his career, he has also collaborated to and managed various private and public banks.
9. Law on takeover bids
On 24 August 2009, Mobistar has received notification from its ultimate shareholder France Télécom S.A. on the basis of article 74 § 8 of the law of 1st April 2007 concerning takeover bids.
This notification detailed France Télécom S.A.'s participation in Mobistar S.A. As at 24 August 2009, France Télécom S.A. held indirectly 31,753,000 shares of Mobistar S.A. as per below ownership chain:
No change occurred in 2012.
10. Information concerning the tasks entrusted to the auditors
In the course of the 2012 financial year, the statutory auditor and linked companies provided services at a total cost of € 411.9 thousand broken down as follows:
| • audit services | € 406.9 thousand |
|---|---|
| • other audit services | € 5.0 thousand |
Annual accounts Mobistar S.A.
- Annual accounts p. 86
- Accounting principles p. 102
- Report of the Statutory Auditor p. 105
Balance sheet after appropriation
Assets
| 2012 in thousand € |
2011 in thousand € |
|
|---|---|---|
| FIXED ASSETS | 997 794 | 1 017 279 |
| Formation expenses (Note 5.1) | 1 350 | 1 800 |
| Intangible fixed assets (Note 5.2) | 281 196 | 305 088 |
| Tangible fixed assets (Note 5.3) | 547 641 | 546 242 |
| Land and buildings | 301 262 | 294 895 |
| Plant, machinery and equipment | 217 347 | 219 607 |
| Furniture and vehicles | 19 015 | 21 488 |
| Other tangible fixed assets | 10 017 | 10 252 |
| Financial fixed assets (Notes 5.4/5.5.1) | 167 607 | 164 149 |
| Affiliated enterprises (Note 5.14) | 164 077 | 164 077 |
| Participating interests | 164 077 | 164 077 |
| Other enterprises linked by participating interests (Note 5.14) | 3 450 | |
| Participating interests | 3 450 | |
| Other financial assets | 80 | 72 |
| Amounts receivable and cash guarantees | 80 | 72 |
| CURRENT ASSETS | 274 390 | 273 253 |
|---|---|---|
| Amounts receivable after more than one year | 3 722 | 5 556 |
| Other amounts receivable | 3 722 | 5 556 |
| Stocks and contracts in progress | 18 484 | 14 622 |
| Stocks | 18 484 | 14 622 |
| Goods purchased for resale | 18 484 | 14 622 |
| Amounts receivable within one year | 213 940 | 215 693 |
| Trade debtors | 205 358 | 196 329 |
| Other amounts receivable | 8 582 | 19 364 |
| Current investments (Notes 5.5.1/5.6) | 2 460 | 1 518 |
| Other investments and deposits | 2 460 | 1 518 |
| Cash at bank and in hand | 8 340 | 1 416 |
| Deferred charges and accrued income (Note 5.6) | 27 444 | 34 448 |
Equity and liabilities
| 2012 | 2011 | |
|---|---|---|
| in thousand € | in thousand € | |
| Equity | 243 135 | 178 343 |
| Capital (Note 5.7) | 131 721 | 131 721 |
| Issued capital | 131 721 | 131 721 |
| Reserves | 13 172 | 13 172 |
| Legal reserve | 13 172 | 13 172 |
| Accumulated profits (losses) (+) (-) | 98 144 | 33 327 |
| Investment grants | 98 | 123 |
| PROVISIONS AND DEFERRED TAXES | 6 127 | 6 075 |
|---|---|---|
| Provisions for liabilities and charges | 6 127 | 6 075 |
| Pensions and similar obligations | 247 | |
| Other liabilities and charges (Note 5.8) | 5 880 | 6 075 |
| AMOUNTS PAYABLE | 1 022 922 | 1 106 114 |
|---|---|---|
| Amounts payable after more than one year (Note 5.9) | 398 447 | 323 321 |
| Financial debts | 385 000 | 295 000 |
| Other loans | 385 000 | 295 000 |
| Trade debts | 13 447 | 28 321 |
| Suppliers | 13 447 | 28 321 |
| Amounts payable within one year | 559 821 | 711 342 |
| Current portion of amounts payable after more than | ||
| one year falling due within one year (Note 5.9) | 14 873 | 14 873 |
| Financial debts | 43 811 | 26 069 |
| Other loans | 43 811 | 26 069 |
| Trade debts | 316 206 | 302 915 |
| Suppliers | 316 206 | 302 915 |
| Taxes, remuneration and social security (Note 5.9) | 72 013 | 140 486 |
| Taxes | 41 346 | 111 999 |
| Remuneration and social security | 30 667 | 28 487 |
| Other amounts payable | 112 918 | 226 999 |
| Accrued charges and deferred income (Note 5.9) | 64 654 | 71 451 |
TOTAL EQUITY AND LIABILITIES 1 272 184 1 290 532
Income statement
| 2012 | 2011 | |
|---|---|---|
| in thousand € | in thousand € | |
| Operating income | 1 592 852 | 1 582 664 |
| Turnover (Note 5.10) | 1 533 122 | 1 524 493 |
| Own construction capitalised | 4 803 | 3 757 |
| Other operating income (Note 5.10) | 54 927 | 54 414 |
| Operating charges | 1 310 547 | 1 238 091 |
| Raw materials, consumables | 687 884 | 626 594 |
| Purchases | 691 428 | 633 948 |
| Stocks: decrease (increase) (+) (-) | -3 544 | -7 354 |
| Services and other goods | 267 839 | 283 731 |
| Remuneration, social security costs and pensions (+) (-) (Note 5.10) | 151 478 | 142 743 |
| Depreciation of and amounts written off formation expenses, | ||
| intangible and tangible fixed assets | 175 843 | 161 354 |
| Amounts written down stocks, contracts in progress and trade | ||
| debtors - Appropriations (write-backs) (+) (-) (Note 5.10) | 17 532 | 6 760 |
| Provisions for risks and charges - Appropriations (uses and | ||
| write-backs) (+) (-) (Note 5.10) | 52 | 1 784 |
| Other operating charges (Note 5.10) | 9 919 | 15 125 |
| Operating profit (loss) (+) (-) | 282 305 | 344 573 |
| Financial income | 601 | 1 583 |
| Income from current assets | 383 | 842 |
| Other financial income (Note 5.11) | 218 | 741 |
| Financial charges (Note 5.11) | 10 842 | 12 711 |
| Debt charges | 7 851 | 9 634 |
| Other financial charges | 2 991 | 3 077 |
| Gain (loss) on ordinary activities before taxes (+) (-) | 272 064 | 333 445 |
| Extraordinary income | 12 060 | |
| Write-back of amounts written down financial fixed assets | 12 060 | |
| Extraordinary charges | 15 457 | |
| Extraordinary depreciation of and extraordinary amounts written | ||
| off formation expenses, intangible and tangible fixed assets | 15 457 | |
| Profit (loss) for the period before taxes (+) (-) | 256 607 | 345 505 |
| Income taxes (+) (-) (Note 5.12) | 81 907 | 109 199 |
| Income taxes | 89 010 | 119 017 |
| Adjustment of income taxes and write-back of tax provisions | 7 103 | 9 818 |
| Profit (loss) for the period (+) (-) | 174 700 | 236 306 |
| Profit (loss) for the period available for appropriation (+) (-) | 174 700 | 236 306 |
| 2012 | 2011 | |
|---|---|---|
| in thousand € | in thousand € | |
| APPROPRIATIONS AND WITHDRAWINGS | ||
| Profit (loss) to be appropriated (+) (-) | 208 027 | 257 590 |
| Profit (loss) to be appropriated (+) (-) | 174 700 | 236 306 |
| Profit (loss) to be carried forward (+) (-) | 33 327 | 21 284 |
| Profit (loss) to be carried forward (+) (-) | 98 144 | 33 327 |
| Profit to be distributed | 109 883 | 224 263 |
| Dividends | 108 026 | 222 053 |
| Other beneficiaries | 1 857 | 2 210 |
Notes
| 2012 in thousand € |
2011 in thousand € |
||
|---|---|---|---|
| STATEMENT OF FORMATION EXPENSES | |||
| 5.1 | Net book value at the end of the period | 1 800 | |
| Movements during the period | |||
| Other (+) (-) | -450 | ||
| Net book value at the end of the period | 1 350 | ||
| Of which: restructuring costs | 1 350 | ||
| STATEMENT OF INTANGIBLE FIXED ASSETS | |||
| 5.2.2 | Concessions, patents, licences, knowhow, brands and similar rights |
||
| Acquisition value at the end of the period | 1 045 178 | ||
| Movements during the period | |||
| Acquisitions, including produced fixed assets | 64 949 | ||
| Sales and disposals | 45 851 | ||
| Acquisition value at the end of the period | 1 064 276 | ||
| Depreciation and amounts written down at the end of the period | 740 090 | ||
| Movements during the period | |||
| Recorded | 86 655 | ||
| Cancelled owing to sales and disposals | 43 665 | ||
| Depreciation and amounts written down at the end of the period | 783 080 | ||
| Net book value at the end of the period | 281 196 | ||
| 5.2.3 | Goodwill | ||
| Acquisition value at the end of the period | 61 519 | ||
| Acquisition value at the end of the period | 61 519 | ||
| Depreciation and amounts written down at the end of the period | 61 519 | ||
| Depreciation and amounts written down at the end of the period | 61 519 | ||
| Net book value at the end of the period | 0 | ||
| STATEMENT OF TANGIBLE FIXED ASSETS | |||
| 5.3.1 Land and buildings | |||
| 2012 in thousand € |
2011 in thousand € |
|
|---|---|---|
| Depreciation and amounts written down at the end of the period Movements during the period |
259 857 | |
| Recorded | 22 667 | |
| Cancelled owing to sales and disposals | 10 557 | |
| Depreciation and amounts written down at the end of the period | 271 967 | |
| Net book value at the end of the period | 301 262 | |
| 5.3.2 Plant, machinery and equipment |
||
| Acquisition value at the end of the period | 623 080 | |
| Movements during the period | ||
| Acquisitions, including produced fixed assets | 70 765 | |
| Sales and disposals | 87 164 | |
| Acquisition value at the end of the period | 606 681 | |
| Depreciation and amounts written down at the end of the period | 403 473 | |
| Movements during the period | ||
| Recorded | 73 025 | |
| Cancelled owing to sales and disposals | 87 164 | |
| Depreciation and amounts written down at the end of the period | 389 334 | |
| Net book value at the end of the period | 217 347 | |
| 5.3.3 Furniture and vehicles |
||
| Acquisition value at the end of the period | 126 625 | |
| Movements during the period | ||
| Acquisitions, including produced fixed assets | 5 403 | |
| Sales and disposals | 5 001 | |
| Acquisition value at the end of the period | 127 027 | |
| Depreciation and amounts written down at the end of the period | ||
| Movements during the period | ||
| Recorded | 7 876 | |
| Cancelled owing to sales and disposals | 5 001 | |
| Depreciation and amounts written down at the end of the period | 108 012 | |
| Net book value at the end of the period | 19 015 | |
| 5.3.5 Other tangible fixed assets |
||
| Acquisition value at the end of the period | 14 444 | |
| Movements during the period | ||
| Acquisitions, including produced fixed assets | 844 | |
| Sales and disposals | 1 204 | |
| Acquisition value at the end of the period | 14 084 | |
| Depreciation and amounts written down at the end of the period | ||
| Movements during the period | ||
| Recorded | 1 079 | |
| Cancelled owing to sales and disposals | 1 204 | |
| Depreciation and amounts written down at the end of the period | 4 067 | |
| Net book value at the end of the period | 10 017 | |
| 2012 in thousand € |
2011 in thousand € |
||
|---|---|---|---|
| STATEMENT OF FINANCIAL FIXED ASSETS | |||
| 5.4.1 | Affiliated enterprises - participating interests and shares | ||
| Acquisition value at the end of the period | 164 077 | ||
| Acquisition value at the end of the period | 164 077 | ||
| Net book value at the end of the period | 164 077 | ||
| 5.4.2 | Other enterprises linked by participating interests - | ||
| participating interests and shares | |||
| Acquisition value at the end of the period | 0 | ||
| Movements during the period | |||
| Acquisitions, including produced fixed assets | 3 450 | ||
| Acquisition value at the end of the period | 3 450 | ||
| Net book value at the end of the period | 3 450 | ||
| 5.4.3 | Other enterprises - amounts receivable | ||
| Net book value at the end of the period | 72 | ||
| Movements during the period | |||
| Additions | 8 | ||
| Net book value at the end of the period | 80 |
INFORMATION RELATING TO THE SHARE IN CAPITAL
5.5.1 Share in capital and other rights in other companies
| Name, full address of the registered office and for the enterprise governed by Belgian law, the company |
Shares held by | Information from the most recent period for which annual accounts are available |
||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| number | Number | % | Primary financial statement |
Monetary unit |
Capital and reserves in thousand € |
Net result in thousand € |
| Orange Communications Luxembourg S.A. | ||||||
| Rue des Mérovingiens 8 | ||||||
| 8070 Bertrange Luxembourg |
||||||
| 19749504 | ||||||
| Registered shares | 1 506 350 | 100.00 | 31/12/11 | EUR | 17 052 | -762 |
| Mobistar Enterprise Services S.A. | ||||||
| Avenue du Bourget 3 | ||||||
| 1140 Evere | ||||||
| Belgium | ||||||
| 0459 623 216 | ||||||
| Registered shares | 2 950 | 100.00 | 31/12/11 | EUR | 76 196 | 1 713 |
| IRISnet S.C.R.L. | ||||||
| Avenue des Arts 21 | ||||||
| 1000 Brussels | ||||||
| Belgium | ||||||
| 0847 220 467 | ||||||
| Registered shares | 345 000 | 28.16 |
| 2012 in thousand € |
2011 in thousand € |
||
|---|---|---|---|
| OTHER INVESTMENTS AND DEPOSITS, DEFERRED CHARGES AND ACCRUED INCOME (ASSETS) |
|||
| 5.6 | Investments: other investments and deposits | ||
| Other investments not yet shown separately | 2 460 | 1 518 | |
| Deferred charges and accrued income | |||
| Allocation of heading 490/1 of assets if the amount is significant | |||
| Accrued income | 15 626 | ||
| Deferred charges | 11 753 | ||
| Financial income | 65 | ||
| STATEMENT OF CAPITAL AND STRUCTURE OF SHAREHOLDINGS | |||
| 5.7 | Statement of capital Social capital |
||
| Issued capital at the end of the period | 131 721 | ||
| Issued capital at the end of the period | 131 721 | ||
| 2012 | |||
| Structure of the capital | in thousand € | number of shares | |
| Different categories of shares | |||
| Ordinary shares | 131 721 | 60 014 414 | |
| Registered shares | 31 753 214 | ||
| Bearer shares and/of dematerialized shares | 28 261 200 | ||
| Shareholders' structure of the company as at 31/12/2012 | |||
| Atlas Services Belgium | 31 753 100 | ||
| Others (free float) | 28 261 314 | ||
| Total shares | 60 014 414 | ||
| PROVISIONS FOR OTHER LIABILITIES AND CHARGES | |||
| 5.8 | Allocation of heading 163/5 of liabilities if the amount is |
| considerable | |
|---|---|
| Repayment guarantee to the amount of 50 % for a bank credit line | |
| granted for the temporary association IRISNET | 2 475 |
| Provisions for litigations | 3 405 |
STATEMENT OF AMOUNTS PAYABLE, ACCRUED CHARGES AND DEFERRED INCOME
| 5.9 | Analysis by current portions of amounts initially payable after more than one year |
||
|---|---|---|---|
| Amounts payable after more than one year, not more than one year |
|||
| Trade debts | 14 873 | ||
| Suppliers | 14 873 | ||
| Total amounts payable after more than one year, not more than one year |
14 873 | ||
| Amounts payable after more than one year, between one | |||
| and five years | |||
| Financial debts | 385 000 | ||
| Other loans | 385 000 | ||
| Trade debts | 13 447 | ||
| Suppliers | 13 447 | ||
| Total amounts payable after more than one year, between | |||
| one and five years | 398 447 | ||
| Amounts payable for taxes, remuneration and social security | |||
| Taxes (heading 450/3 of the liabilities) | |||
| Non expired taxes payable | 2 470 | ||
| Estimated taxes payable | 38 876 | ||
| Remuneration and social security (heading 454/9 of the liabilities) | |||
| Other amounts payable relating to remuneration and social security | 30 667 | ||
| Accrued charges and deferred income | |||
| Allocation of heading 492/3 of liabilities if the amount is | |||
| considerable | |||
| Deferred income | 64 271 | ||
| Accrued charges | 383 | ||
| 2012 | 2011 | ||
| in thousand € | in thousand € | ||
| OPERATING RESULTS | |||
| 5.10 | Operating income | ||
| Net turnover | |||
| Broken down by categories of activity | |||
| Mobile activity | 1 451 339 | 1 466 702 | |
| Fix voice and data | 81 783 | 57 791 | |
| Operating costs | |||
| Employees for whom the company has submitted a Dimona | |||
| declaration or are recorded in the general personnel register | |||
| Total number at the closing date (in units) | 1 735 | 1 724 | |
| Average number of employees calculated in full-time equivalents | |||
| (in units) | 1 690.8 | 1 645.5 | |
| Number of actual worked hours (in units) | 2 866 051 | 2 802 659 |
| 2012 | 2011 | |
|---|---|---|
| in thousand € | in thousand € | |
| Personnel costs | ||
| Remuneration and direct social benefits | 107 045 | 101 484 |
| Employers' social security contributions | 30 866 | 29 489 |
| Employers' premiums for extra statutory insurances | 5 556 | 4 565 |
| Other personnel costs | 8 011 | 7 205 |
| Provisions for pensions | ||
| Additions (uses and write-back) (+) (-) | 247 | |
| Amounts written off | ||
| Stocks and contracts in progress | ||
| Recorded | 540 | |
| Written back | 317 | |
| Trade debtors | ||
| Recorded | 17 849 | 6 220 |
| Provisions for risks and charges | ||
| Additions | 559 | 2 432 |
| Uses and write-back | 507 | 648 |
| Other operating charges | ||
| Taxes related to operation | 2 912 | 715 |
| Other charges | 7 007 | 14 410 |
| Hired temporary staff and persons placed at the enterprise's | ||
| disposal | ||
| Total number at the closing date (in units) | 120 | 100 |
| Average number calculated as full-time equivalents (in units) | 87.5 | 89.3 |
| Number of actual worked hours (in units) | 176 400 | 179 495 |
| Charges to the enterprise | 6 819 | 7 320 |
FINANCIAL AND EXTRAORDINARY RESULTS
| Financial results | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Other financial income | |||||
| Amount of subsidies granted by public authorities, credited | |||||
| to income for the period | |||||
| Capital subsidies | 26 | 26 | |||
| Allocation of other financial income | |||||
| Other financial income | 40 | 562 | |||
| Exchange gains | 152 | 152 | |||
| Other financial charges | |||||
| Amount of the discount borne by the enterprise, as a result | |||||
| of negociating amounts receivable | 1 126 | 1 331 | |||
| Allocation of other financial charges | |||||
| Bank charges | 1 251 | 1 348 | |||
| Exchange losses | 581 | 318 | |||
| Other financial charges | 33 | 79 | |||
| 2012 | 2011 |
|---|---|
| in thousand € | in thousand € |
INCOME TAXES AND OTHER TAXES
| 5.12 | Income taxes | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| Income taxes on the result of the current period | 89 010 | ||
| Income taxes paid and withholding taxes due or paid | 50 134 | ||
| Estimated additional taxes | 38 876 | ||
| In so far as income taxes of the current period are materially | |||
| affected by differences between the profit before taxes, as stated | |||
| in the annual accounts, and the estimated taxable profit | |||
| Disallowed expenses | 6 935 | ||
| Deductions for investments | -943 | ||
| Notional interests | -360 | ||
| Non taxable donations | -300 | ||
| Status of deferred taxes | |||
| Deferred taxes representing assets | |||
| Other deferred taxes representing assets | |||
| Deductions for investments | 1 921 | ||
| Total amount of value added tax and taxes borne by third parties | |||
| Total amount of value added tax charged | |||
| To the enterprise (deductible) | 157 804 | 148 494 | |
| By the enterprise | 318 516 | 312 819 | |
| Amounts retained on behalf of third parties for | |||
| Payroll withholding taxes | 31 488 | 29 402 | |
| Withholding taxes on investment income | 5 967 | 14 193 |
RIGHTS AND COMMITMENTS NOT REFLECTED IN THE BALANCE SHEET
| 5.13 | Substantial commitments to acquire fixed assets | |
|---|---|---|
| Commitments to acquire fixed assets | 232 935 |
Information concerning important litigation and other commitments Commitments
-
- Bank guarantees issued on behalf of the company: 8.7 million euros.
-
- Obligations related to the rent of offices and the lease of the company cars: 417.0 million euros.
-
- Obligations related to the purchase of equipment and services: 116.9 million euros.
-
- Since 1997, certain municipalities and three provinces have adopted local taxes, on an annual basis, on pylons, masts and antennas erected within their boundaries. These taxes are currently being contested before the Civil Courts (Courts of First Instance - Tax Chamber and Courts of Appeal).
Pursuant to a preliminary question raised by the Council of State to the European Court of Justice, the latter ruled in its decree dated 8 September 2005 that such taxes are not inconsistent with European law, provided they do not alter the conditions of competition between the historical operator and new operators on the market.
The Council of State decided since 20 November 2007 in several arrests that a tax regulation violates the principle of equality if the motive appearing in the preamble of this tax regulation results from the financial situation of the municipality. In fact, such a motive does not explain at all the differentiation made between the mobile telephone network operators (which are taxed on the basis of this tax regulation) and the operators of other similar networks (which are not taxed on the basis of this same tax regulation). It is therefore not established that the difference in treatment is based on a criterion that can be objectively and logically justified.
| 2012 | 2011 |
|---|---|
| in thousand € | in thousand € |
The Constitutional Court decided in its judgment of 15 December 2011 that article 98 §2 of the Act of 21 March 1991 reforming certain public companies doesn't prohibit the municipalities from taxing the economic activity of the telecom operators which is achieved in the territory of the municipality by the presence (whether on the public or private domain) of mobile phone masts, pylons or antennas dedicated to this activity, for budgetary or other reasons. According to the Constitutional Court, this interpretation of article 98 §2 is not inconsistent with article 170 § 4 of the Constitution.
The Supreme Court has confirmed in its judgments of 30 March 2012 the interpretation of the Constitutional Court of article 98 of the Act of 21 March 1991.
The total receivable amount of taxes charged, plus default interest calculated at the legal rate, amounts to 57.3 million euros and is subject to a bad debt provision for the whole amount, of which 7.6 million euros correspond to the financial year 2012.
Brief description of the supplementary retirement or survivors' pension plan in favour of the personnel or the executives of the enterprise and of the measures taken by the enterprise to cover the resulting charges
The company runs a retirement pension scheme based on a set contribution that provides a supplement to the statutory pension for employees. This pension scheme is covered and financed by an insurance company as required by the Belgian law.
RELATIONSHIPS WITH AFFILIATED ENTERPRISES AND ENTERPRISES LINKED BY PARTICIPATING INTERESTS
| 5.14 | Affiliated enterprises | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| Financial fixed assets | 164 077 | 164 077 | |
| Investments | 164 077 | 164 077 | |
| Amounts receivable | 16 919 | 28 191 | |
| Within one year | 16 919 | 28 191 | |
| Amounts payable | 442 204 | 333 768 | |
| After one year | 385 000 | 295 000 | |
| Within one year | 57 204 | 38 768 | |
| Financial results | |||
| Income from current assets | 156 | 350 | |
| Debts charges | 6 102 | 7 407 | |
| Enterprises linked by participating interests | |||
| Financial fixed assets | 3 450 | ||
| Investments | 3 450 | ||
| Transactions with related parties outside normal market conditions |
|||
| Mention of such operations if they are material, stating the amount of these transactions, the nature of the relationship with the related party and other information about the transactions necessary for the understanding of the financial position of the |
Additional information
Due to the nature of its activities, the company carries out a number of transactions with subsidiaries in areas such as roaming, interconnection and delivery of services and goods. However, in the absence of legal criteria to inventory transactions with related parties, which would be made on terms other than market conditions, no transaction is included in the state XVIIIbis.
company Nihil
FINANCIAL RELATIONSHIPS WITH
5.15 Directors and managers
6, place d'Alleray 75505 Paris Cedex 15
France
| Amount of direct and indirect remunerations and pensions, included in the income statement, as long as this disclosure does not concern exclusively or mainly the situation of a single identifiable person |
|
|---|---|
| To directors and managers | 802 |
| Auditors or people they are linked to Auditor's fees Fees for exceptional services or special missions executed in |
288 |
| the company by the auditor Other attestation missions |
5 |
INFORMATION RELATING TO CONSOLIDATED ACCOUNTS
5.17 Information that must be provided by each company that is subject to the provisions of Company Law on the consolidated annual accounts of enterprises The enterprise has drawn up and published a consolidated annual statement of accounts and a management report. Information to disclose by the reporting enterprise being a subsidiary or a joint subsidiary Parent company France Télécom 6, place d'Alleray 75505 Paris Cedex 15 France draws up consolidated annual accounts for the major part of the enterprise. The consolidated accounts can be obtained at the following address: France Télécom
Social report
STATEMENT OF THE PERSONS EMPLOYED
Employees for whom the company has submitted a Dimona declaration or are recorded in the general pesonnel register
| Total | Men | Women | |
|---|---|---|---|
| During the period | |||
| Average number of employees | |||
| Full-time | 1 557.3 | 1 079.0 | 478.3 |
| Part-time | 171.5 | 37.7 | 133.8 |
| Total in full-time equivalents (FTE) | 1 690.8 | 1 108.0 | 582.8 |
| Number of hours actually worked | |||
| Full-time | 2 644 797 | 1 875 183 | 769 614 |
| Part-time | 221 254 | 49 001 | 172 253 |
| Total | 2 866 051 | 1 924 184 | 941 867 |
| Personnel costs (in thousand €) | |||
| Full-time | 139 792 | 104 508 | 35 283 |
| Part-time | 11 687 | 3 999 | 7 688 |
| Total | 151 478 | 108 507 | 42 971 |
| Advantages in addition to wages (in thousand €) | 2 068 | 1 380 | 688 |
| During the previous period | |||
| Average number of employees in full-time equivalents (FTE) | 1 645.5 | 1 078.3 | 567.2 |
| Number of hours actually worked | 2 802 659 | 1 881 624 | 921 035 |
| Personnel costs (in thousand €) | 142 743 | 102 250 | 40 493 |
| Advantages in addition to wages (in thousand €) | 2 028 | 1 353 | 675 |
| Total in | |||
| Full-time | Part-time | full-time | |
| At the closing date of the period | equivalents | ||
| Number of employees | 1 566 | 169 | 1 697.5 |
| By nature of the employment contract | |||
| Contract for an indefinite period | 1 561 | 168 | 1 691.7 |
| Contract for a definite period | 5 | 1 | 5.8 |
| According to the gender and by level of education | |||
| Male | 1 078 | 37 | 1 106.6 |
| primary education | 2 | 2.0 | |
| secondary education | 263 | 17 | 276.1 |
| higher education (non-university) | 459 | 9 | 466.0 |
| university education | 354 | 11 | 362.5 |
| Female | 488 | 132 | 590.9 |
| secondary education | 142 | 36 | 170.1 |
| higher education (non-university) | 191 | 63 | 240.1 |
| university education | 155 | 33 | 180.7 |
| By professional category | |||
| Employees | 1 566 | 169 | 1 697.5 |
Hired temporary staff and personnel placed at the enterprise's disposal
| Temporary staff |
Personnel placed at the enterprise's disposal |
|
|---|---|---|
| During the period | ||
| Average number of employees | 73.7 | 13.8 |
| Number of hours actually worked | 148 579 | 27 821 |
| Charges of the enterprise (in thousand €) | 5 549 | 1 270 |
TABLE OF PERSONNEL CHANGES DURING THE PERIOD
| Full-time | Part-time | Total in full-time equivalents |
|
|---|---|---|---|
| Entries | |||
| Number of employees for whom the company has submitted a Dimona declaration or are recorded in the general personnel |
|||
| register during the financial year | 220 | 1 | 220.8 |
| By nature of the employment contract | |||
| Contract for an indefinite period | 217 | 1 | 217.8 |
| Contract for a definite period | 3 | 3.0 | |
| Departures | |||
| Number of employees with a in the Dimona declaration indicated | |||
| or in the general personnel register listed date of termination of | |||
| the contract during the financial year | 200 | 10 | 207.3 |
| By nature of the employment contract | |||
| Contract for an indefinite period | 195 | 10 | 202.3 |
| Contract for a definite period | 5 | 5.0 | |
| According to the reason for termination of the employment contract | |||
| Unemployment with company allowance | 2 | 2.0 | |
| Dismissal | 91 | 3 | 93.4 |
| Other reason | 107 | 7 | 111.9 |
INFORMATION WITH REGARD TO TRAINING RECEIVED BY EMPLOYEES at company expense during the period
| Male | Female | |
|---|---|---|
| Total number of official advanced professional training projects | ||
| at company expense | ||
| Number of participating employees | 1 143 | 628 |
| Number of training hours | 39 403 | 21 217 |
| Costs for the company (in thousand €) | 4 283 | 2 543 |
| of which gross costs directly linked to the training | 4 249 | 2 475 |
| of which paid contributions and deposits in collective funds | 207 | 114 |
| of which received subsidies (to be deducted) | 173 | 46 |
| Total number of less official and unofficial advanced professional | ||
| training projects at company expense | ||
| Number of participating employees | 48 | 22 |
| Number of training hours | 444 | 148 |
| Costs for the company (in thousand €) | 38 | 9 |
| Total number of initial professional training projects at company expense |
||
| Number of participating employees | 1 | 1 |
| Number of training hours | 2 088 | 1 008 |
| Costs for the company (in thousand €) | 12 | 4 |
Accounting principles
Formation costs
The first formation costs are capitalised on the balance sheet at cost and amortised over five years on a linear basis, starting from the date of payment. The costs related to increases in the issued capital are expensed as incurred from the initial public offer in 1998 onwards. Since 2010, the formation costs include the costs related to the negociation of a long-term credit facility. These costs are amortised over the validity period of the credit facility, i.e. 5 years as from 31 December 2010.
Intangible assets
The intangible assets are booked at cost value and are essentially comprised of the following capitalised costs and expenditures, including, if applicable, the fixed assets produced for use by the company: acquisition of the GSM network licence, acquisition of the UMTS licence, cost of the design and development of the network in execution of the GSM and UMTS licences, permits, software licences and related development cost and goodwill. In 2011, the acquisition cost of the 4G licence has been added in this section.
The GSM network licence has been granted for a duration of 15 years, and is amortised on a linear basis. The renewal of this licence has been granted in 2010 for a duration of 5 years, and is amortised on a linear basis over this period.
The UMTS licence has a duration of 20 years and is amortised on a linear basis over 16 years as from April 2005, when the first geographical area has been technically declared able to work.
The 4G licence acquired in 2011 will be depreciated as from the start of use up to the end of the right granted, which means over the period included between the launch date and the 1st July 2027. As the commercial launch has not yet been performed, the depreciation has not started yet.
The other intangible assets are amortised on a linear basis over a period of 4 to 5 years.
Tangible assets
The tangible assets are entered at cost value and are
amortised on a linear basis pro rata temporis using the rates defined in the current Belgian tax law, which correspond to the life span of the assets concerned, as follows:
| Buildings and constructions on sites | 20 years |
|---|---|
| Optical fiber | 15 years |
| Mobile telephone equipment | 7-8 years |
| Messaging equipment | 5 years |
| Computer hardware | 4 and 5 years |
| Other tangible equipment | 5 to 10 years |
The amortisation period and amortisation method for assets with a finite useful life are reviewed at least at each financial year-end. Any change in the useful life or in the expected pattern of consumption of the future economic benefits embodied in the asset, is accounted for prospectively as a change in an accounting estimate.
The costs of regular maintenance and repairs are booked as expenses during the period in which they are incurred. Improvements to property are capitalised. The loan costs relating to the purchase of fixed assets, if any, are activated and amortised according to the same pattern as the fixed assets in question.
Financial assets
Shareholdings, stocks and shares are recorded at their acquisition value. Receivables are valued at their nominal value. Reductions in value on shareholdings, stocks and shares are booked in the case of long-term losses in value or depreciations. Receivables are reduced in value if their payment when due is wholly or partly uncertain or compromised.
Receivables
Receivables are recorded at their nominal value. Reductions in value on doubtful receivables are assessed taking into account the potential risk of non-recovery.
Stocks
Stocks include goods purchased for resale. Stock movements are recorded using the FIFO (First In – First Out) method. Inventories are recorded at the "lower of cost or market" value.
Accounting principles Impairment The company assesses at each reporting date whether there is an indication that an asset may be impaired. If any such indication exists, or when annual impairment testing for an asset is required, Mobistar makes an estimate of the asset's recoverable amount. An asset's recoverable amount is the higher of an asset's or cash-generating unit's fair value less costs to sell and its value in use and is determined for an individual asset, unless the asset does not generate cash inflows that are largely independent of those from other assets or groups of assets. Where the carrying amount of an asset exceeds its recoverable amount, the asset is considered impaired and is written down to its recoverable amount. In assessing value in use, the estimated future cash flows are discounted to their present value using a post-tax discount rate that reflects current market assessments of the time value of money and the risks specific to the asset. Impairment losses are recognised in the income statement in the operating expenses under the heading 'Depreciation, amortisation and impairment'.
For impaired assets, an assessment is made at each reporting date as to whether there is any indication that previously recognised impairment losses may no longer exist or may have decreased. If such indication exists, the company estimates the asset's or cash-generating unit's recoverable amount. A previously recognised impairment loss is reversed only if there has been a change in the assumptions used to determine the asset's recoverable amount since the last impairment loss was recognised. The reversal is limited so that the carrying amount of the asset does not exceed its recoverable amount, nor exceed the carrying amount that would have been determined, net of depreciation, had no impairment loss been recognised for the asset in prior years. Such reversal is recognised in the income statement.
Cash (and cash equivalents)
Liquid assets and equivalents include cash deposits and fixed deposits of less than three months. They are booked at their nominal value. Foreign currencies are converted at the closing rate and profits and losses are recorded as operating income and expenses.
Deferred charges and accrued income
The deferred charges for assets include the expenses to be carried forward and the accrued income. The deferred charges for liabilities include accrued expenses and income to be carried forward.
Pensions
The company runs a retirement pension scheme based on a set contribution that provides a supplement to the statutory pension for employees. This pension scheme is covered and financed by an insurance company as required by Belgian law.
Provisions
Provisions are recognised when the company has a present obligation (legal or constructive) as a result of a past event, it is probable that an outflow of resources embodying economic benefits will be required to settle the obligation and a reliable estimate can be made of the amount of the obligation.
Where the company expects some or all of the provision to be reimbursed, the reimbursement is recognised as a separate asset but only when the reimbursement is virtually certain. The expense relating to any provision is presented in the income statement net of any reimbursement.
Acknowledgement of income and expenses
Income and expenses are registered at the moment they are generated, regardless of their payment or collection.
Income derived from services is declared when it is acquired. Invoices for these services are issued on a monthly basis throughout the entire month. Revenues not invoiced at the end of the month are estimated on the basis of traffic and recorded at the end of the month. Payments received in advance are carried forward and included on the balance sheet under deferred income.
Taxes on income
The company is subject to corporation tax in accordance with Belgian legislation governing income tax. Beneficial deferred taxes, which are the result of temporary differences in the declaration of income and expenses, are not acknowledged.
Foreign currency transactions
Foreign currency transactions are converted into euros at the rates in force at the time of the transaction. Receivables and debts booked in foreign currencies on the date of the balance sheet are adjusted in order to reflect the exchange rates effective at this time. These adjustments are acknowledged in the profit and loss account to the extent that Belgian accounting laws permit.
Judgments, estimates and assumptions
In the process of applying the accounting policies, management has not made any significant judgments, estimates and assumptions concerning the future and other key sources of estimating uncertainty at the balance sheet date, that have a significant risk of causing a material adjustment to the carrying amounts of assets and liabilities within the next financial year, except for 'Operating lease commitment – as a lessee'. The company has entered into property leases, network and cars leases. It has determined, based on an evaluation of the terms and conditions of the arrangements, that the lessor retains all the significant risks and rewards of ownership of these properties and accounts for the contracts as operating leases.
Social report
Regarding the breakdown between men and women in the statement of the persons employed during the previous period, the ratios used are the same as those used for the current period. As this section is new, the social secretariat could only deliver data for the current year.
Statutory auditor's report
to the Shareholders' Meeting on the annual accounts for the year ended 31 December 2012
To the shareholders
As required by law and the company's articles of association, we report to you on the performance of our mandate of statutory auditor. This report includes our report on the annual accounts as defined below together with our report on other legal and regulatory requirements.
Report on the annual accounts – Unqualified opinion
We have audited the annual accounts of Mobistar S.A. ("the company") for the year ended 31 December 2012 prepared in accordance with the financial reporting framework applicable in Belgium, which show total assets of 1,272,184 (000) EUR and a profit for the year of 174,700 (000) EUR.
Responsibility of the Board of Directors for the preparation of the annual accounts
The Board of Directors is responsible for the preparation and fair presentation of annual accounts in accordance with the financial reporting framework applicable in Belgium, and for such internal control as the Board of Directors determines is necessary to enable the preparation of annual accounts that are free from material misstatement, whether due to fraud or error.
Statutory auditor's responsibility
Our responsibility is to express an opinion on these annual accounts based on our audit. We conducted our audit in accordance with International Standards on Auditing. Those standards require that we comply with ethical requirements and plan and perform the audit to obtain reasonable assurance about whether the annual accounts are free from material misstatement.
An audit involves performing procedures to obtain audit evidence about the amounts and disclosures in the annual accounts. The procedures selected depend on the statutory auditor's judgment, including the assessment of the risks of material misstatement of the annual accounts, whether due to fraud or error. In making those risk assessments, the auditor considers internal control relevant to the company's preparation and fair presentation of the annual accounts in order to design audit procedures that are appropriate in the circumstances, but not for the purpose of expressing an opinion on the effectiveness of the company's internal control. An audit also includes evaluating the appropriateness of accounting policies used and the reasonableness of accounting estimates made by the Board of Directors, as well as evaluating the overall presentation of the annual accounts. We have obtained from the company's officials and the Board of Directors the explanations and information necessary for performing our audit.
We believe that the audit evidence we have obtained is sufficient and appropriate to provide a basis for our opinion.
Unqualified opinion
In our opinion, the annual accounts of Mobistar S.A. give a true and fair view of the company's net equity and financial position as of 31 December 2012 and of its financial performance for the year then ended, in accordance with the financial reporting framework applicable in Belgium.
Report on other legal and regulatory requirements
The Board of Directors is responsible for the preparation and the content of the directors' report on the annual accounts, maintaining the company's accounting records in compliance with the legal and regulatory requirements applicable in Belgium and for the company's compliance with the Companies Code and the company's articles of association.
In the framework of our mandate, our responsibility is to verify, for all significant aspects, the compliance with some legal and regulatory requirements. On this basis, we provide the following additional comments which do not modify the scope of our opinion on the annual accounts:
- The directors' report includes the information required by law, is, for all significant aspects, in agreement with the annual accounts and is not in obvious contradiction with any information obtained in the performance of our mandate.
- Without prejudice to certain formal aspects of minor importance, the accounting records are maintained in
accordance with the legal and regulatory requirements applicable in Belgium.
- The appropriation of the results proposed to the general meeting is in accordance with the requirements of the law and the company's articles of association.
- No transactions have been undertaken or decisions taken in violation of the company's articles of association or the Companies Code such as we would be obliged to report to you.
Diegem, 22 March 2013
The statutory auditor DELOITTE Bedrijfsrevisoren / Reviseurs d'Entreprises BV o.v.v.e. CVBA / SC s.f.d. SCRL Represented by Rik Neckebroeck
IFRS consolidated financial statements
- Consolidated statement of comprehensive income p. 108
- Consolidated balance sheet p. 109
- Consolidated cash flow statement p. 110
- Consolidated statement of changes in equity p. 111
- Corporate information p. 112
- Accounting policies p. 113
- Notes to the consolidated financial statements p. 123
- Statutory auditor's report p. 151
Consolidated statement of comprehensive income
| 2012 in thousand € |
2011 in thousand € |
||
|---|---|---|---|
| Note | |||
| Revenue | |||
| Service revenue | 1 450 027 | 1 505 846 | |
| Handsets sales | 200 448 | 151 734 | |
| 17 | Total turnover | 1 650 475 | 1 657 580 |
| 17 | Other operating revenue | 51 962 | 42 027 |
| Total revenue | 1 702 437 | 1 699 607 | |
| Operating expenses | |||
| Interconnection costs | -390 494 | -393 327 | |
| 17 | Costs of equipment and goods sold | -352 944 | -300 105 |
| 17 | Services and other goods | -281 828 | -297 498 |
| 17 | Employee benefits expenses | -156 083 | -150 027 |
| 2,3 | Depreciation, amortisation and impairment | -217 214 | -190 339 |
| Amounts written down stocks, contracts in progress and trade | |||
| debtors | -20 420 | -7 680 | |
| Provisions for risks and charges | 2 561 | -4 931 | |
| 17 | Other operating charges | -9 176 | -15 955 |
| Total operating expenses | -1 425 598 | -1 359 862 | |
| Result of operating activities | 276 839 | 339 745 | |
| 17 | Finance income | 497 | 914 |
| 17 | Finance costs | -11 186 | -11 786 |
| Result of operating activities after net finance costs | 266 150 | 328 873 | |
| 6 | Tax expense | -80 465 | -107 852 |
| Net profit of the period (*) | 185 685 | 221 021 | |
| Profit or loss attributable to equity holders of the parent | 185 685 | 221 021 | |
| Consolidated statement of comprehensive | |||
| income | |||
| Net profit for the period | 185 685 | 221 021 | |
| Other comprehensive income | 0 | 0 | |
| Total comprehensive income for the period | 185 685 | 221 021 | |
| Part of the total comprehensive income attribuable to equity | |||
| holders of the parent | 185 685 | 221 021 | |
| 11 | Basic earnings per share (in €) | 3,09 | 3,68 |
| Weighted average number of ordinary shares | 60 014 414 | 60 014 414 | |
| 11 | Diluted earnings per share (in €) | 3,09 | 3,68 |
| Diluted weighted average number of ordinary shares | 60 014 414 | 60 014 414 | |
* Since there are no discontinued operations, the profit or loss of the period corresponds to the result of continued operations.
Consolidated balance sheet
| 31.12.2012 in thousand € |
31.12.2011 in thousand € |
||
|---|---|---|---|
| Note | |||
| ASSETS | |||
| Non-current assets | |||
| 1, 2 Goodwill | 80 080 | 80 080 | |
| 2 | Intangible assets | 286 595 | 312 026 |
| 3 | Tangible assets | 665 010 | 666 000 |
| 4 | Interests in associates | 3 450 | |
| 5 | Other non-current assets | 3 965 | 5 818 |
| 6 | Deferred taxes | 6 669 | 6 401 |
| Total non-current assets | 1 045 769 | 1 070 325 | |
| Current assets | |||
| 7 | Inventories | 20 594 | 16 501 |
| 8 | Trade receivables | 230 168 | 225 250 |
| 9 | Accrued revenue | 19 039 | 31 812 |
| 9 | Other current assets | 19 160 | 30 496 |
| 10 | Cash and cash equivalents | 12 266 | 7 119 |
| Total current assets | 301 226 | 311 178 | |
| Total assets | 1 346 995 | 1 381 503 | |
| EQ UITY AND LIABILITIES Equity |
|||
| 12 | Share capital | 131 721 | 131 721 |
| 12 | Legal reserve | 13 173 | 13 173 |
| 12 | Retained earnings | 212 905 | 249 078 |
| Total equity | 357 799 | 393 972 | |
| Non-current liabilities | |||
| 14 | Long-term interests-bearing borrowings | 383 650 | 293 200 |
| 15 | Long-term trade payables | 13 447 | 28 321 |
| 13 | Long-term provisions | 67 375 | 61 595 |
| 6 | Deferred taxes | 0 | 1 176 |
| Total non-current liabilities | 464 472 | 384 292 | |
| Current liabilities | |||
| 14 | Short-term interests-bearing borrowings | 22 580 | 18 444 |
| 16 | Trade payables | 344 563 | 347 635 |
| 16 | Employee benefits related liabilities | 34 385 | 32 855 |
| 16 | Current taxes payable | 42 709 | 113 737 |
| 16 | Deferred income | 77 451 | 87 833 |
| 16 | Other payables | 3 035 | 2 736 |
| Total current liabilities | 524 723 | 603 240 | |
| Total liabilities | 989 196 | 987 532 | |
| Total equity and liabilities | 1 346 995 | 1 381 503 |
Consolidated cash flow statement
| 2012 in thousand € |
2011 in thousand € |
||
|---|---|---|---|
| Note | |||
| Cash flows from operating activities | |||
| Profit before taxes | 266 150 | 328 873 | |
| Non-cash adjustments for: | |||
| 2,3 | Depreciation, amortisation and impairment of fixed assets | 217 214 | 190 339 |
| Changes in long-term provisions | 649 | 5 287 | |
| Changes in provision for bad debt | 13 320 | -1 311 | |
| Other non-cash expenses | 1 108 | ||
| Interest income | -247 | -871 | |
| Interest charges | 7 331 | 9 902 | |
| Adjusted result of operating activities before net finance costs | 505 525 | 532 219 | |
| 6 | Inventories | -4 092 | -6 202 |
| 15 | Trade and other receivables | 5 219 | -25 736 |
| Trade and other payables | -33 885 | 23 928 | |
| Net changes in working capital | -32 758 | -8 010 | |
| 5 | Tax paid | -154 893 | -79 397 |
| Interests paid | -6 790 | -9 793 | |
| Interests received | 396 | 980 | |
| Net cash from operating activities | 311 480 | 435 998 | |
| Cash flows from investing activities | |||
| 3 | Purchase of intangible and tangible assets | -188 242 | -203 739 |
| Debt associated to purchase of assets (increase +, decrease -) | 7 985 | 9 970 | |
| 1 | Acquisition of subsidiary net of cash acquired | -3 450 | 0 |
| 2,3 | Proceeds from sale of equipment | 2 186 | 0 |
| 4 | Reimbursement long-term loans granted | 1 907 | 1 008 |
| Net cash used in investing activities | -179 614 | -192 761 | |
| Organic Cash Flow | 133 198 | 242 260 | |
| Cash flows from financing activities | |||
| 14 | Short-term borrowings - net | 4 137 | -14 519 |
| 14 | Long-term borrowings - proceeds | 135 000 | 180 000 |
| 14 | Long-term borrowings - repayments | -45 000 | -155 161 |
| 11 | Transactions costs paid for long-term credit facility | 450 | 450 |
| 11 | Others | 942 | -1 629 |
| Equity transactions costs | 195 | -157 | |
| 11 | Dividends paid | -222 443 | -258 062 |
| Net cash used in financing activities | -126 719 | -249 078 | |
| Net increase (+), decrease (-) in cash and cash equivalents | 5 147 | -5 841 | |
| Cash and cash equivalents at beginning of period | 7 119 | 12 959 | |
| Cash and cash equivalents at end of period | 12 266 | 7 119 |
Consolidated statement of changes in equity
| in thousand € | ||
|---|---|---|
| Share | Legal | Retained | Total | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| capital | reserve | earnings | equity | |
| Balance as at 1 January 2012 | 131 721 | 13 173 | 249 078 | 393 972 |
| Net profit for the period | 185 685 | 185 685 | ||
| Total comprehensive income for the period | 185 685 | 185 685 | ||
| Dividends | -222 053 | -222 053 | ||
| Equity transaction costs | 195 | 195 | ||
| Balance as at 31 December 2012 | 131 721 | 13 173 | 212 905 | 357 799 |
| Share | Legal | Retained | Total | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| capital | reserve | earnings | equity | |
| Balance as at 1 January 2011 | 131 721 | 13 173 | 286 276 | 431 170 |
| Net profit for the period | 221 021 | 221 021 | ||
| Total comprehensive income for the period | 221 021 | 221 021 | ||
| Dividends | -258 062 | -258 062 | ||
| Equity transaction costs | -157 | -157 | ||
| Balance as at 31 December 2011 | 131 721 | 13 173 | 249 078 | 393 972 |
Corporate information
Companies in the perimeter of consolidation
The following parent company, subsidiaries and joint venture are included in the perimeter of consolidation:
Mobistar S.A. Parent company, incorporated under Belgian law Limited company with publicly traded shares Avenue du Bourget 3 B - 1140 Brussels Belgium Company identification number: BE 0456 810 810
Joint venture France Télécom - Belgacom, denominated 'Irisnet' Consolidated at 50 %, incorporated under Belgian law Avenue du Bourget 3 B - 1140 Brussels Belgium Company identification number: BE 0545 698 541
IRISnet S.C.R.L. Accounted for by equity method Avenue des Arts 21 B – 1000 Brussels Belgium Company identification number BE 0847 220 467
Mobistar Enterprise Services S.A. (hereafter MES) 100 % of the shares held by Mobistar S.A. Avenue du Bourget 3 B - 1140 Brussels Belgium Company identification number: BE 0459 623 216
Orange Communications Luxembourg S.A. (formerly Orange S.A.) 100 % of the shares held by Mobistar S.A. 8, rue des Mérovingiens L - 8070 Bertrange Luxembourg Company identification number: LU 19749504
The principal activities of the Group are described in note 20 (segment information).
Date of authorisation for issue of the financial statements
On 21 March 2013, the Board of Directors of Mobistar S.A. reviewed the 2012 consolidated financial statements and authorised them for issue.
The 2012 consolidated financial statements will be approved on 2 May 2013 by the General Assembly of shareholders which has still the power to amend the financial statements after issue.
Corporate information Accounting policies
1. Basis of preparation
The consolidated financial statements are presented in 000 Euros except when otherwise indicated. The Group's functional and presentation currency is Euro. Each entity in the Group applies this functional currency for its financial statements.
Statement of compliance
The consolidated financial statements of Mobistar S.A. and all its subsidiaries have been prepared in accordance with the International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS), as adopted by the European Union.
Basis for consolidation
The consolidated financial statements include the financial statements of Mobistar S.A. and its subsidiaries as at 31 December each year. The financial statements of the subsidiaries are prepared for the same reporting period as the parent company, using consistent accounting policies.
Subsidiaries are fully consolidated from the date of acquisition, being the date on which the Group obtains control, and continue to be consolidated until the date such control ceases.
The following entities are consolidated as at 31 December 2012 by using the following consolidation method:
| Mobistar S.A.: | 100 % full consolidation |
|---|---|
| Orange Communications | |
| Luxembourg S.A.: | 100 % full consolidation |
| Mobistar Enterprise Services S.A.: | 100 % full consolidation |
| Temporary association Irisnet: 50 % proportional consolidation | |
| IRISnet S.C.R.L: | 28.16 % equity method |
• Orange Communications Luxembourg S.A., a company organised and existing under the laws of Luxembourg, has been acquired as of 2 July 2007 by Mobistar S.A. The purchase concerned 90 % of the shares of Orange Communications Luxembourg S.A. The remaining 10 % of shares have been acquired on November 12, 2008. The company has consolidated the results of Orange Communications Luxembourg S.A. for 100 %, as of 2 July 2007.
- Mobistar Enterprise Services S.A., a company organised and existing under the laws of Belgium, has been acquired as of 31 March 2010 by Mobistar S.A. The purchase concerned 100 % of the shares of affiliated company. The company has consolidated the results of Mobistar Enterprise Services S.A. for 100 %, as of 1 April 2010.
- The temporary association Irisnet is a joint venture between France Télécom S.A. and Belgacom S.A. (the initial partner Telindus S.A. is since January 2010 an integral part of Belgacom S.A.). As such, Mobistar does not own directly or indirectly any voting power in Irisnet. However, in application of SIC 12, Mobistar concluded that Irisnet is actually controlled by Mobistar and its partner Belgacom. In addition, it is concluded that the risks and rewards are not born by France Télécom but by Mobistar. On 1st November 2012, the activities of the temporary association have been transferred to IRISnet S.C.R.L. Assets of the temporary association have been sold to the new company. Irisnet will just continue to collect its outstanding receivables balances open as of 31st October 2012 and complete the legal liquidation of the temporary association. Based on the fact that the temporary association stopped its activities, Mobistar has decided to include in the 2012 closing all necessary provisions regarding the legal liquidation of the temporary association.
- IRISnet S.C.R.L. is a company constituted in July 2012 in collaboration with the Brussels authorities in order to take over the activities performed by the temporary association Irisnet. The take-over of the activities took place on 1st November 2012. In this new legal structure, Mobistar has contributed in cash for 3,450,000 euros equivalent to 345,000 shares out of the 1,225,000 shares issued by the company. Due to the deal structure, IRISnet S.C.R.L. will be accounted for in the accounts using the equity method.
All intra-group balances, transactions, income and expenses and profits and losses resulting from intra-group transactions are eliminated in full.
2. Changes in accounting policy and disclosures
The accounting policies and methods of computation adopted in the preparation of the consolidated financial statements are consistent with those followed in the preparation of the consolidated financial statements for the year ended 31 December 2011, except for the following element:
• Universal Service provision: following the evolution of the regulation, Mobistar has reviewed its approach on the calculation of the provision from a 'loss of revenue' basis to a 'net charges' basis. This change has had a positive impact of 17.1 million euros recorded in the first half year 2012.
Although there has been no impact on the operations performed by the Group, following new amendments to IFRS have been considered in the preparation of the annual consolidated accounts:
- Amendment to IFRS 1 First-Time Adoption of International Financial Reporting Standards – Severe Hyperinflation and Removal of Fixed Dates for First-Time Adopters (applicable for annual periods beginning on or after 1 July 2011)
- Amendment to IFRS 7 Financial Instruments: Disclosures – Derecognition (applicable for annual periods beginning on or after 1 July 2011)
- Amendment to IAS 1 Presentation of Financial Statements - Presentation of Items of Other Comprehensive Income (applicable for annual periods beginning on or after 1 July 2012)
- Amendment to IAS 12 Income Taxes Deferred Tax: Recovery of Underlying Assets (applicable for annual periods beginning on or after 1 January 2012)
3. Significant accounting judgments, estimates and assumptions
The preparation of the Group's financial statements in conformity with IFRS requires that management makes certain judgments, estimates and assumptions that affect the amounts reported in the financial statements and accompanying notes.
Estimates that have been made at each reporting date reflect conditions that existed at those dates (e.g. market prices, interest rates and foreign exchange rates). Although these estimates are based on management's best knowledge of current events and actions that Mobistar may undertake, actual results may differ from those estimates.
Judgments, estimates and assumptions
In the process of applying the Group's accounting policies,
management has not made any significant judgments, estimates and assumptions concerning the future and other key sources of estimating uncertainty at the balance sheet date, that have a significant risk of causing a material adjustment to the carrying amounts of assets and liabilities within the next financial year, except for:
Operating lease commitment – Group as a lessee
The Group has entered into property leases, network and cars leases. It has determined, based on an evaluation of the terms and conditions of the arrangements, that the lessor retains all the significant risks and rewards of ownership of these properties and accounts for the contracts as operating leases. Details are given in note 19.
Impairment of non-financial assets
The Group's impairment test for goodwill is based on value in use calculations that use a discounted cash flow model. The cash flows are derived from the budget for the next five years and do not include restructuring activities that the Group is not yet committed to or significant future investments that will enhance the asset base of the cash generating unit being tested. The recoverable amount is most sensitive to the discount rate used for the discounted cash flow model as well as the expected future cash-inflows and the growth rate used for extrapolation purposes. The key assumptions used to determine the recoverable amount for the different cash generating units are further explained in note 2.
Deferred tax assets
Deferred tax assets are recognised for all unused tax losses to the extent that it is probable that taxable profit will be available against which the losses can be utilised. Significant management judgment is required to determine the amount of deferred tax assets that can be recognised, based upon the likely timing and level of future taxable profits together with future tax planning strategies. Details on deferred tax assets are given in note 6.
Provision for dismantling network sites
The Group has recognised a provision for dismantling network sites obligations as for the rented building situated at Avenue du Bourget and the various antennas sites. In determining the amount of the provision, assumptions and estimates are required in relation to discount rates and the expected cost to dismantle and remove all plants from the sites. See note 13.
Universal service
Mobistar is involved, together with other alternative operators, in a number of legal actions regarding the planned financial compensation system in relation to the provision of social tariffs. Significant management judgment and assumptions have been required in order to assess the potential impact of the evolution of the regulation in that matter.
4. Summary of significant accounting policies
4.1. Transactions in foreign currencies
On initial recognition in the functional currency, a foreign currency transaction is recorded by applying the spot exchange rate between the functional currency and the foreign currency at the date of the transaction. At each balance sheet date, foreign monetary assets and liabilities are translated using the closing rate.
Exchange gains and losses are recognised as operational income and expenses when they are related to the operational activities. Exchange gains and losses are recognised as financial income and expenses only when they are related to the financing activities.
4.2. Business combinations and Goodwill
Goodwill acquired in a business combination is initially measured at cost, being the excess of the cost of the business combination over the Group's share in the net fair value of the acquiree's identifiable assets, liabilities and contingent liabilities.
After initial recognition, goodwill is measured at cost less any accumulated impairment losses.
Impairment is determined by assessing the recoverable amount of the cash-generating unit to which the goodwill relates. This goodwill is tested for impairment at the end of each financial year (31 December), or more frequently if events or change in circumstances indicate that its carrying amount may be impaired, by comparing the carrying amount of the cash-generating units with their fair value less costs to sell or with their value in use. When the recoverable amount of the cash-generating unit is less than their carrying amount, an impairment loss is recognized and cannot be reversed in future periods.
Estimating the fair value less costs to sell requires taking into account the Mobistar's share price as quoted on the stock exchange. Alternatively, an estimation of the value in use of the mobile activity cash-generating unit could be made. This method requires to make an estimate of the future cash flows from the mobile cash-generating unit and to choose a suitable discount rate to calculate the present value of those cash flows.
4.3. Intangible assets
Are included under this asset category, the intangible assets with a finite useful life such as the cost of the GSM, UMTS and 4G licences, the cost of network design and development, the cost of purchased and internally generated software.
Intangible assets are measured on initial recognition at cost. The cost includes the purchase price, import duties, non-refundable purchase taxes, after deduction of trade discounts and rebates, and any directly attributable costs of preparing the asset for its intended use, i.e. costs of employee benefits, professional fees and testing costs.
After initial recognition, intangible assets are carried at cost less any accumulated amortisation and impairment losses.
The residual value of intangible assets is assumed to be zero unless the conditions provided for by IAS 38 are met.
Intangible assets are amortised over the useful life and assessed for impairment whenever there is an indication that the intangible asset may be impaired.
The depreciable amount of an intangible asset with a finite useful life is allocated on a linear basis over its useful life.
The depreciation of the mobile licences starts when they are ready to operate.
The GSM and UMTS licences have been granted for a period of 15 years (originally) and 20 years respectively. However, the depreciation period is limited to 14 and 16 years, representing the remaining licence terms at the date of availability for use. The extension of the GSM licence, acquired in 2010, is amortized over a period of 5 years which corresponds to the licence term.
The 4G licence, acquired in 2011, has been granted for a period of 15 years, till the 1st of July 2027. Depreciation of the licence should start when the asset is available for use, i.e. when it is in the location and technical condition necessary for it to be capable of operating in the manner intended by the management, even if the asset is actually not being used. The licence will be available for use when the first geographical zone will be declared "ready to launch" by the technical team. The full amount will be depreciated on a straight line basis over its remaining useful life of that date.
The useful life of acquired and internally generated software is 5 years (network software) or 4 years (non-network software) and their depreciation starts when the software has been ready for use.
The amortisation period and amortisation method for an intangible asset with a finite useful life are reviewed at least at each financial year-end. Any change in the useful life or in the expected pattern of consumption of the future economic benefits embodied in the asset, is accounted for prospectively as a change in an accounting estimate.
Amortisation and impairment losses are recorded in the income statement under the heading 'Depreciation, amortisation and impairment'.
Research costs are expenses as incurred. Development expenditure on an individual project is recognized as an intangible asset when the Group can demonstrate the technical feasibility of completing the intangible asset so that it will be available for use or sale, its intention to complete and its ability to use or sell the asset, how the asset will generate future economic benefits, the availability of resources to complete the asset and the liability to measure reliably the expenditure during development.
Following initial recognition of the development expenditure as an asset, the cost model is applied requiring the asset to be carried at cost less any accumulated amortisation and accumulated impairment losses. Amortisation of the asset begins when development is complete and the asset is available for use. It is amortized over the period of expected future benefit. During the period of development, the asset is tested for impairment annually.
4.4. Tangible assets
The following items of property, plant and equipment are classified under the tangible assets category: building, network infrastructure and equipment, IT servers and personal computers, office furniture, leasehold improvements, equipment leased to customers.
Upon recognition, tangible assets are measured at cost. The cost includes the purchase price, import duties and non-refundable purchase taxes, after deduction of trade discounts and rebates, and any costs directly attributable to bringing the asset to the location and condition for it to be capable of operating in the expected manner. The cost of replacing part of an item of property, plant and equipment is recognised as an asset when incurred and if the recognition criteria are met. All other repair and maintenance costs are recognised in profit or loss as incurred. The cost includes also the estimated cost to dismantle the network sites and to refurbish the rented premises when such obligation exists.
After initial recognition, tangible assets are measured at cost less any accumulated depreciation and impairment losses.
The depreciable amount of a tangible asset is allocated on a systematic and linear basis over its useful life. The depreciation of a tangible asset starts when it is ready to operate as intended.
The useful life of each category of tangible assets has been determined as follows:
| Building | 20 years |
|---|---|
| Pylons and network constructions | 20 years |
| Optical fibre | 15 years |
| Network equipment | 7-8 years |
| Messaging equipment | 5 years |
| IT servers | 5 years |
| Personal computers | 4 years |
| Office furniture | 5 - 10 years |
| Leasehold improvements | 9 years or rental period if shorter |
The residual value and the useful life of a tangible asset are reviewed at least at each financial year-end and, if expectations differ from previous estimates, the changes are accounted for prospectively as a change in an accounting estimate.
Depreciation and impairment losses are recorded in the income statement under the heading 'Depreciation, amortisation and impairment'.
An item of property, plant and equipment is derecognised upon disposal or when no future economic benefits are expected from its use or disposal. Any gain or loss arising on derecognition of the asset is included in the income statement in the year the asset is derecognised.
The asset retirement obligation relating to the network sites is measured based on the known term of sites rental contracts, assuming a high probability of renewal upon each renewal date, and considering that the entire sites park will be dismantled in the future. The dismantling asset is measured by using appropriate inflation and discount rates.
4.5. Impairment of non-financial assets
The Group assesses at each balance sheet date whether there is an indication that an asset may be impaired. If any such indication exists, or when annual impairment testing for an asset is required, Mobistar makes an estimate of the asset's recoverable amount. An asset's recoverable amount is the higher of an asset's or cash-generating unit's fair value less costs to sell and its value in use and is determined for an individual asset, unless the asset does not generate cash inflows that are largely independent of those from other assets or groups of assets. Where the carrying amount of an asset exceeds its recoverable amount, the asset is considered impaired and is written down to its recoverable amount. In assessing value in use, the estimated future cash flows are discounted to their present value using a post-tax discount rate that reflects current market assessments of the time value of money and the risks specific to the asset. Impairment losses are recognised in the income statement in the operating expenses under the heading 'Depreciation, amortisation and impairment'.
For assets excluding goodwill, an assessment is made at each reporting date as to whether there is any indication that previously recognised impairment losses may no longer exist or may have decreased. If such indication exists, the Group estimates the asset's or cash-generating unit's recoverable amount. A previously recognised impairment loss is reversed only if there has been a change in the assumptions used to determine the asset's recoverable amount since the last impairment loss was recognised. The reversal is limited so that the carrying amount of the asset does not exceed its recoverable amount, nor exceed the carrying amount that would have been determined, net of depreciation, had no impairment loss been recognised for the asset in prior years. Such reversal is recognised in the income statement unless the asset is carried at revalued amount, in which case the reversal is treated as a revaluation increase.
4.6. Borrowing costs
Borrowing costs are capitalized after 1 January 2009. Evaluation of the need to capitalize borrowing costs is made at project level. Up to end of 2008, borrowing costs were recognised as an expense in the period in which they occurred.
4.7. Government grants
A government grant is recognised when there is a reasonable assurance that the grant will be received and the conditions attached to them are complied with.
When the grant relates to an expense item, it is recognised as income over the period necessary to match on a systematic basis to the costs that it is intended to compensate.
Where the grant relates to an asset, the fair value is credited to the carrying amount of the asset and is released to the income statement over the expected useful life of the relevant asset by equal annual instalments.
4.8. Taxes
Current income taxes
Current income tax assets and liabilities for the current and prior periods are measured at the amount expected to be recovered from or paid to the taxation authorities. The tax rates and tax laws used to compute the amount are those that are enacted or substantively enacted by the balance sheet date.
Deferred income tax
Deferred income tax is provided using the liability method on temporary differences at the balance sheet date between the tax basis of assets and liabilities and their carrying amounts for financial reporting purposes.
Deferred income tax liabilities are recognised for all taxable temporary differences, except:
- where the deferred income tax liability arises from the initial recognition of goodwill or of an asset or liability in a transaction that is not a business combination and, at the time of the transaction, affects neither the accounting profit nor taxable profit or loss; and
- in respect of taxable temporary differences associated with investments in subsidiaries, associates and interests in joint ventures, where the timing of the reversal of the temporary differences can be controlled and it is probable that the temporary differences will not reverse in the foreseeable future.
Deferred tax assets are recognised for all deductible temporary differences, carry forward of unused tax credits and unused tax losses, to the extent that it is probable that taxable profit will be available against which the deductible temporary differences, and the carry forward of unused tax credits and unused tax losses can be utilised except:
- where the deferred income tax asset relating to the deductible temporary difference arises from the initial recognition of an asset or liability in a transaction that is not a business combination and, at the time of the transaction, affects neither the accounting profit nor taxable profit or loss; and
- in respect of deductible temporary differences associated with investments in subsidiaries, associates and interests in joint ventures, deferred income tax assets are recognised only to the extent that it is probable that the temporary differences will reverse in the foreseeable future and taxable profit will be available against which the temporary differences can be utilised.
The carrying amount of deferred income tax assets is reviewed at each balance sheet date and reduced to the extent that it is no longer probable that sufficient taxable profit will be available to allow all or part of the deferred income tax asset to be utilised. Unrecognised deferred income tax assets are reassessed at each balance sheet date and are recognised to the extent that it has become probable that future taxable profit will allow the deferred tax asset to be recovered.
Deferred income tax assets and liabilities are measured at the tax rates that are expected to apply to the year when the asset is realised or the liability is settled, based on tax rates (and tax laws) that have been enacted or substantively enacted at the balance sheet date.
Deferred income tax assets and deferred income tax liabilities are offset, if a legally enforceable right exists to set off current tax assets against current income tax liabilities and the deferred income taxes relate to the same taxable entity and the same taxation authority.
Sales tax
Revenues, expenses and assets are recognised net of the amount of sales tax except:
- where the sales tax incurred on a purchase of assets or services is not recoverable from the taxation authority, in which case the sales tax is recognised as part of the acquisition cost of the asset or as part of the expense item as applicable; and
- receivables and payables that are stated with the amount of sales tax included.
The net amount of sales tax recoverable from, or payable to, the taxation authority is included as part of receivables or payables in the balance sheet.
4.9. Inventories
Inventories are assets held for sale in the ordinary course of business, i.e. handsets and SIM cards.
Inventories are measured at the lower of cost and net realisable value. The cost of inventories comprises all costs of purchase, cost of conversion and other costs incurred in bringing the inventories to their present location and condition. Costs of inventories are assigned by using the first-in, first-out (FIFO) cost formula. Net realisable value is the estimated selling price in the ordinary course of business, less estimated costs of completion and the estimated costs necessary to make the sale.
4.10. Treasury shares
Own equity instruments which are reacquired (treasury shares) are deducted from equity.
No gain or loss is recognised in profit or loss on the purchase, sale, issue or cancellation of own equity instruments.
4.11. Cash and cash equivalents
Cash and cash equivalents include cash on hand and cash deposits with a maximum term of 3 months. Cash and cash equivalents held with financial institutions are measured at nominal value. Banks and intercompany cash pooling overdrafts are classified as short-term financial liabilities.
4.12. Financial instruments
Recognition and derecognition
A financial asset or a financial liability is recognised on the balance sheet at settlement date when the Group becomes a party to the contractual provisions of the financial instrument.
A financial asset will be derecognised when the contractual rights to the cash flows from the financial asset expire.
A financial liability will be derecognised when the contractual obligation is discharged or cancelled or expires.
Financial assets
Financial assets are classified as either financial assets at fair value through profit or loss, or loans and receivables.
The Company has no held-to-maturity investments or available for sale financial assets.
Upon initial recognition, financial assets are measured at fair value, plus directly attributable transaction costs in case investments are not recognised at fair value through profit and loss accounts. The Group determines the classification of its financial assets on initial recognition and, where allowed and appropriate, re-evaluates the designation at each financial year-end.
Financial assets at fair value through profit or loss
Financial assets classified as held for trading and financial assets designated upon initial recognition as at fair value through profit or loss are classified under this category.
Loans and receivables
Loans and receivables are non-derivative financial assets with fixed or determinable payments that are not quoted in an active market. Such assets are carried at amortised cost using the effective interest method. Gains and losses are recognised in income statement when the loans and receivables are derecognised or impaired, as well as through the amortisation process.
Trade and other short-term receivables with no stated interest rate are measured at the original invoice or nominal amount when the effect of discounting is immaterial. An impairment loss on trade and other short-term receivables is recognised in the profit and loss statement when their carrying amount is lower than the present value of estimated future cash flows. Impairment is valuated on an individual basis or on a segmented category basis when individual impairment cannot be evaluated. Trade and other shortterm receivables are presented on the face of the balance sheet net of any accumulated impairment losses.
Impairment of financial assets
The Group assesses at each balance sheet date whether a financial asset or group of financial assets has to be impaired.
Assets carried at amortised cost
If there is objective evidence that an impairment loss on assets carried at amortised cost has been incurred, the amount of the loss is measured as the difference between the asset's carrying amount and the present value of future cash flows (excluding future expected credit losses that have not been incurred) discounted at the financial asset's original effective interest rate (i.e. the effective interest rate computed at initial recognition). The carrying amount of the asset is reduced through use of an allowance account. The amount of the loss shall be recognised in profit or loss.
If, in a subsequent period, the amount of the impairment loss decreases and the decrease can be related objectively to an event occurring after the impairment was recognised, the previously recognised impairment loss is reversed, to the extent that the carrying value of the asset does not exceed its amortised cost at the reversal date. Any subsequent reversal of an impairment loss is recognised in profit or loss.
In relation to trade receivables, a bad debt accrual is made when there is objective evidence (such as the probability of insolvency or significant financial difficulties of the debtor) that the Group will not be able to collect all of the amounts due under the original terms of the invoice. The carrying amount of the receivable is reduced through use of an allowance account. Impaired debts are derecognised when they are assessed as uncollectible.
Financial liabilities
Interest-bearing loans and borrowings
Loans and borrowings are initially recognised at the fair value of the consideration received less directly attributable transaction costs.
After initial recognition, interest-bearing loans and borrowings are subsequently measured at amortised cost using the effective interest method.
Gains and losses are recognised in income when the liabilities are derecognised as well as through the amortisation process.
Trade and other short-term payables
Trade and other short-term payables with no stated interest rate are measured at the original invoice or nominal amount when the effect of discounting is immaterial.
Offsetting a financial asset and a financial liability
Trade receivables and payables are offset and the net amount is presented on the face of the balance sheet when such amounts may legally be offset and a clear intention to settle them on a net basis exists.
4.13. Share-based payment
Employees of Mobistar may receive remuneration in the form of share-based payment transactions, whereby employees render services as consideration for equity instruments.
The cost of any equity-settled transactions with employees is measured by reference to the fair value of the equity instruments at the date on which they are granted. The fair value of such equity-settled transactions will be measured based on market prices if available, taking into account the terms and conditions upon which those equity instruments were granted. If market prices are not available, appropriate pricing model will be used. In valuing equity-settled transactions, no account is taken of any performance conditions, other than conditions linked to the price of the shares, if applicable.
The cost of equity-settled transactions is recognised, together with a corresponding increase in equity, over the period in which the performance and/or service conditions are fulfilled, ending on the date on which employees become fully entitled to the award (vesting date).
No expense is recognized for awards that do not ultimately vest, except for awards where vesting is conditional upon a market condition, which are treated as vesting irrespective of whether or not the market condition satisfies, provided that all other performance and/or service conditions are met.
The cumulative expense recognised for equity-settled transactions at each reporting date until the vesting date reflects the extent to which the vesting period has expired and the best estimate of equity instruments that will ultimately vest.
4.14. Long-term provisions
Provisions are recognised when Mobistar has a present obligation (legal or constructive) as a result of a past event, it is probable that an outflow of resources embodying economic benefits will be required to settle the obligation and a reliable estimate can be made of the amount of the obligation.
Where Mobistar expects some or all of the provision to be reimbursed, the reimbursement is recognised as a separate asset but only when the reimbursement is virtually certain. The expense relating to any provision is presented in the income statement net of any reimbursement.
If the effect of the time value of money is material, provisions are discounted using a current pre-tax rate that reflects, where appropriate, the risks specific to the liability. Where discounting is used, the increase in the provision due to the passage of time is recognised as a borrowing cost.
The estimate of the dismantling costs regarding the network sites and of the refurbishment costs related to the rented premises is recognised as an item of tangible asset. This estimate is also recognised as a provision that is measured by using appropriate inflation and discount rates.
4.15. Employee benefits
Short-term employee benefits, such as wages, salaries, social security contributions, paid annual leave, profit-sharing and bonuses, medical care, company cars and others are recognised during the period in which the service has been rendered by the employee.
Short-term employee benefits are shown as liabilities as a result of a legal or constructive present obligation and when a reliable estimate of such liabilities can be made.
Post-employment benefit plan is classified as defined contribution plan since the minimum return imposed by law is guaranteed by the current terms and conditions of the group insurance contract without additional cost for Mobistar.
4.16. Revenue
Revenue is recognised to the extent that it is probable that the economic benefits will flow to Mobistar and the revenue can be measured reliably. Revenue is measured at the fair value of the consideration received, excluding discounts, rebates, and other sales taxes or duty.
Sale of goods is recognised as revenue when most of the risks and rewards of ownership of the goods and the control on them have been transferred to the buyer.
Revenue arising from rendering of services is recognised by reference to the stage of completion of the transaction at the balance sheet date. Revenue is measured at the fair value of the consideration received or receivable. Different indicators are used to define the completion of the transaction depending on the service rendered. For prepaid services, revenues are recorded based on usage information (minutes used, sms issued). For postpaid services, revenues are recorded based either on usage (billed or accrued) or on percentages of estimated consumptions (for advanced billed services).
Specific revenue streams and related recognition criteria are as follows:
Sales of equipment
Sales of equipment to the distribution channels and to the final customers are recognised in revenue upon delivery. Consignment sales are recognised in revenue upon sale to the final customer.
Revenue from subscription contracts
Traffic revenue is recognised upon usage and non-used traffic rights are deferred when such right of deferral exists. Prepaid subscription amount is recognised over the subscription period on a linear basis.
Separable components of bundled offers
As from the last weeks of the year 2012, some service offers of the Group include two components: an equipment component (e.g. a mobile handset) and a service component (e.g. a talk plan).
For the sale of multiple products or services, the Group evaluates all deliverables in the arrangement to determine whether they represent separate units of accounting. A delivered item is considered a separate unit of accounting if (i) it has value to the customer on a stand-alone basis and (ii) there is objective and reliable evidence of the fair value of the undelivered item(s). The total fixed or determinable amount of the arrangement is allocated to the separate units of accounting based on its relative fair value. However, when an amount allocated to a delivered item is contingent upon the delivery of additional items or meeting specified performance conditions, the amount allocated to that delivered item is limited to the non-contingent amount. This case arises in the mobile business for sales of bundled offers including a handset and a telecommunications service contract. The handset is considered to have value on a stand-alone basis to the customer, and there is objective and reliable evidence of fair value for the telecommunications service to be delivered. As the amount allocable to the handset generally exceeds the amount received from the customer at the date the handset is delivered, revenue recognized for the handset sale is generally limited to the amount of the arrangement that is not contingent upon the rendering of telecommunication services, i.e. the amount paid by the customer for the handset.
Revenue from the sale of prepaid cards
Sales of prepaid cards are recognised at facial value as deferred income at the time of sale and released in the profit and loss statement as revenue upon usage.
Interconnection revenue
Traffic revenue paid by other telecommunication operators for use of our network is recognized upon usage.
Revenue sharing
Revenue arising from contracts with third-party content providers is recognized after deduction of the fees paid to them in remuneration of the product or service delivered.
Revenue deferred until payment
Revenue of which the collectability is not reasonably assured at the point of sale is deferred until the payment has been received.
Site sharing rental income
Regarding the agreements whereas Mobistar has the entire responsibility to respect the terms and conditions of sites rental contracts, the rental costs are shown in expenses. Revenue arising from sites sub-letting agreements entered with other operators is shown as revenue.
4.17. Leases
A lease whereby all the risks and rewards incidental to ownership are not substantially transferred to the lessee is an operating lease and lease payments are recognised as an expense on a straight-line basis over the lease term.
Determining whether an arrangement is or contains a lease requires assessment of whether the arrangement is dependent on the use of a specific asset and the arrangement conveys a right to use the asset.
4.18. Loyalty commissions
Loyalty commissions earned by the distribution channels on postpaid contracts are recognised upfront upon contract subscription.
4.19. Financial discounts
Financial discounts granted to customers or received from suppliers for early payments are deducted from revenue and costs of sales as incurred.
4.20. Dividend
A dividend declared by the General Assembly of the shareholders after the balance sheet date is not recognised as a liability at that date.
4.21. Loyalty programs
Loyalty programs are based on points granted to customers in function of their behaviour. These points are considered as a separate part of the services invoiced but still to be delivered. Part of the revenues invoiced is thus allocated to these points and deferred up to the moment the points are transformed in advantage by the customers. The amount allocated to the points is based on the fair value of the equivalent advantage proposed (sales value) combined with an estimated usage rate of these points.
5. Future changes in accounting policies
New or amended standards and interpretations issued up to the date of issuance of the Group's financial statements, but not yet effective for 2012 financial statements, are listed below. The Group has elected not to adopt any Standards or Interpretations in advance of their effective dates.
- IFRS 9 Financial Instruments, effective 1 January 2015. The standard is the first part of the three-part project that will supersede IAS 39 Financial Instruments: Recognition and Measurement. This first part deals with the classification and the measurement of financial instruments. The effects of its application cannot be analyzed separately from the two other parts not yet published and which should retrospectively address the impairment methodology for financial assets and hedge accounting.
- IFRS 10 Consolidated Financial Statements (applicable for annual periods beginning on or after 1 January 2013). IFRS 10 supersedes SIC-12 and IAS 27 for the part relating to the consolidated financial statements. This standard deals with the consolidation of subsidiaries and structured entities, and redefines control which is the basis of consolidation. Based on the current reading of the standard's provisions, the retrospective application of this standard on the Group's consolidation scope has no effect on the Group's financial statements.
-
IFRS 11 Joint Arrangements (applicable for annual periods beginning on or after 1 January 2013). IFRS 11 supersedes IAS 31 and SIC-13. This standard deals with the accounting for joint arrangements. The definition of joint control is based on the existence of an arrangement and the unanimous consent of the parties which share the control. There are two types of joint arrangements:
-
joint ventures: the joint venturer has rights to the net assets of the entity to be accounted for using the equity method, which is the method already applied by the Group, and
- joint operations: the parties to joint operations have direct rights to the assets and direct obligations for the liabilities of the entities which should be accounted for as arising from the arrangement.
The IFRS 11 application will have no significant effect on the Group's financial statements' presentation.
- IFRS 12 Disclosures of Interests in Other Entities (applicable for annual periods beginning on or after 1 January 2013). IFRS 12 supersedes disclosures previously included in IAS 27, IAS 28 and IAS 31. This standard groups and develops all the disclosures related to subsidiaries, joint ventures, associates, consolidated and unconsolidated structured entities. The implementation of this standard should not substantially change the disclosures provided by the Group.
- IFRS 13 Fair Value Measurement (applicable for annual periods beginning on or after 1 January 2013). IFRS 13 is a single source of fair value measurement and disclosure requirements for use across IFRSs. It:
- o defines fair value;
- o sets out a framework for measuring fair value; and
- o requires disclosures about fair value measurements, including the fair value hierarchy already set out in IFRS 7.
This standard is applicable prospectively and has no effect on the fair value scope. The clarifications provided by the standard has no effect on the measurement at fair value.
• Amendments to IAS 28 Investments in Associates and Joint Ventures (applicable for annual periods beginning on or after 1 January 2013). This standard relates to the accounting for joint ventures and associates under the equity method. Some clarifications have been included with respect to the accounting for changes in ownership interests (with or without loss of control) whereas disclosures are now covered by IFRS 12. This revision has no consequence on the Group's financial statements.
The following new Amendments and Standards are not applicable in view of the current operations performed by the Group:
- Improvements to IFRS (2009-2011) (normally applicable for annual periods beginning on or after 1 January 2013)
- Amendments to IFRS 1 First Time Adoption of International Financial Reporting Standards – Severe Hyperinflation and Removal of Fixed Dates for First-time Adopters (applicable for annual periods beginning on or after 1 January 2013)
- Amendments to IFRS 1 First Time Adoption of International Financial Reporting Standards – Government Loans (applicable for annual periods beginning on or after 1 January 2013)
- Amendments to IFRS 7 Financial Instruments: Disclosures – Offsetting Financial Assets and Financial Liabilities (applicable for annual periods beginning on or after 1 January 2013)
- Amendments to IFRS 10, IFRS 11 and IFRS 12 Consolidated Financial Statements, Joint Arrangements and Disclosure of Interests in Other Entities: Transition Guidance (applicable for annual periods beginning on or after 1 January 2014)
- Amendments to IFRS 10, IFRS 12 and IAS 27 Consolidated Financial Statements and Disclosure of Interests in Other Entities: Investment Entities (applicable for annual periods beginning on or after 1 January 2014)
- Amendments to IAS 1 Presentation of Financial Statements - Presentation of Items of Other Comprehensive Income (applicable for annual periods beginning on or after 1 July 2012)
- Amendments to IAS 12 Income Taxes Deferred Tax: Recovery of Underlying Assets (applicable for annual periods beginning on or after 1 January 2013)
- Amendments to IAS 19 Employee Benefits (applicable for annual periods beginning on or after 1 January 2013)
- Amendments to IAS 27 Separate Financial Statements (applicable for annual periods beginning on or after 1 January 2014)
- Amendments to IAS 28 Investments in Associates and Joint Ventures (applicable for annual periods beginning on or after 1 January 2014)
- Amendments to IAS 32 Financial Instruments: Presentation – Offsetting Financial Assets and Financial Liabilities (applicable for annual periods beginning on or after 1 January 2014)
- IFRIC 20 Stripping Costs in the Production Phase of a Surface Mine (applicable for annual periods beginning on or after 1 January 2013)
Notes to the consolidated financial statements
1. Business combinations (in 000 euros)
Changes in 2012
No acquisition has been realised in 2012.
However, as mentioned in the annual reports 2010 and 2011, the share purchase agreement between Mobistar and KPN foresees an adjustment of the purchase consideration based on the net debt and working capital as of 28 February 2010. The final purchase price is still under review between Mobistar and the seller and the case has been submitted to an expert review. The outcome of the expert's report, i.e. that KPN should pay Mobistar an amount between 0.3 and 2.2 million euros, is disputed by KPN which states that this is not in agreement with the scope of the expert's mission. Therefore KPN has launched an arbitrage case regarding the expert's mission. On 5 July 2012, the Belgian Constitutional Court issued a ruling in which the scope of the expert´s mission was confirmed, but which also finds that the report of the independent expert contains manifest errors. Because the Court is not competent to engage in further examination of the disputed points, it proposes that the two parties choose a new independent expert to review the disputed points. Mobistar initiated a proceeding with a view to having this decision annulled.
Changes in 2011
At the end of December 2010, the fair value of the identified assets and liabilities was provisional in relation to the following assets and liabilities as no sufficient information was available for the determination of:
- 1) Deferred tax assets on losses carried forward
- 2) Fair value of onerous contracts
- 3) Final adjustment of the purchase price
Further analysis performed during the first quarter of 2011 led to two adjustments of the fair values of Deferred tax assets on losses carried forward for an amount of 3.9 million euros and of onerous contracts for an amount of 3.9 million euros. These entries have slightly modified the goodwill resulting from the transaction, but for which rounded value remains at 0.8 million euros.
The values related to the Purchase Price Accounting are shown in the below table:
| Final fair value recognized on acquisition as at 31.03.2011 |
Preliminary fair value recognized on acquisition as at 31.12.2010 |
MES contribution as at 31.12.2010 (before intercompany elimination) |
|
|---|---|---|---|
| ASSETS | |||
| Non-current assets | |||
| Goodwill | 0 | 0 | 843 |
| Intangible assets | 2 257 | 2 257 | 2 072 |
| Tangible assets | 75 544 | 75 544 | 68 695 |
| Financial assets | 4 | 4 | 4 |
| Other non-current assets | 202 | 202 | 0 |
| Deferred taxes | 3 916 | 0 | 0 |
| Total non-current assets | 81 923 | 78 007 | 71 614 |
| Current assets | |||
| Inventories | 1 340 | 1 340 | 1 095 |
| Trade receivables | 17 046 | 17 046 | 22 058 |
| Other current assets and deferred expenses | 3 734 | 3 734 | 2 450 |
| Short-term loans intercompany | 0 | 0 | 2 300 |
| Cash and cash equivalents | 1 922 | 1 922 | 732 |
| Total current assets | 24 042 | 24 042 | 28 635 |
| Total assets | 105 965 | 102 049 | 100 249 |
| EQ UITY and LIABILITIES |
|||
| Equity | |||
| Retained earnings | 0 | 0 | -1 638 |
| Total equity | 0 | 0 | -1 638 |
| Non-current liabilities | |||
| Long-term provisions | 9 033 | 5 168 | 5 228 |
| Deferred taxes | 1 090 | 1 090 | 984 |
| Total non-current liabilities | 10 123 | 6 258 | 6 212 |
| Current liabilities | |||
| Financial lease | 262 | 262 | 161 |
| Trade payables | 23 484 | 23 484 | 23 841 |
| Employee benefits related liabilities | 2 127 | 2 127 | 735 |
| Current taxes payables | 0 | 0 | 362 |
| Deferred income | 5 762 | 5 762 | 5 505 |
| Other payables | 0 | 0 | 71 |
| Total current liabilities | 31 635 | 31 635 | 30 675 |
| Total liabilities | 41 758 | 37 893 | 36 887 |
| Total equity and liabilities | 41 758 | 37 893 | 35 249 |
| Total identifiable net assets at fair value | 64 207 | 64 156 | 65 000 |
| Goodwill arising on acquisition | 793 | 844 | |
| Purchase consideration transferred | 65 000 | 65 000 | |
| Net cash outflows (purchase consideration | |||
| transferred less cash acquired) | 63 078 | 63 078 |
2. Intangible assets and goodwill (in 000 euros)
2012 Goodwill GSM and UMTS licences Internally generated software development costs Other intangible assets Total intangible assets Acquisition value As at 1 January 2012 80 080 467 228 44 371 552 403 1 064 002 Movements during the period: Acquisitions and consolidation differences 3 784 63 227 67 011 Sales and disposals -1 193 -47 527 -48 720 As at 31 December 2012 80 080 467 228 46 962 568 103 1 082 293 Amortisation and impairment As at 1 January 2012 0 302 143 39 377 410 456 751 976 Movements during the period: Additions 24 283 2 761 63 219 90 263 Sales and disposals -1 139 -45 401 -46 540 As at 31 December 2012 0 326 426 40 999 428 273 795 698 Net carrying amount as at 31 December 2012 80 080 140 802 5 963 139 830 286 595
| 2011 | Goodwill | GSM and UMTS licences |
Internally generated software development costs |
Other intangible assets |
Total intangible assets |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Acquisition value | |||||
| As at 1 January 2011 | 80 131 | 447 208 | 41 559 | 526 412 | 1 015 179 |
| Movements during the period: | |||||
| Acquisitions and consolidation differences | -51 | 20 020 | 2 812 | 65 087 | 87 919 |
| Sales and disposals | -39 096 | -39 096 | |||
| As at 31 December 2011 | 80 080 | 467 228 | 44 371 | 552 403 | 1 064 002 |
| Amortisation and impairment | |||||
| As at 1 January 2011 | 0 | 277 860 | 36 136 | 406 404 | 720 400 |
| Movements during the period: | |||||
| Additions | 24 283 | 3 241 | 43 141 | 70 665 | |
| Sales and disposals | -39 089 | -39 089 | |||
| As at 31 December 2011 | 0 | 302 143 | 39 377 | 410 456 | 751 976 |
| Net carrying amount as at 31 December 2011 | 80 080 | 165 085 | 4 994 | 141 947 | 312 026 |
Goodwill
The Goodwill end 2012 consists of:
| Goodwill Mobistar Affiliate S.A. | 10 558 |
|---|---|
| Goodwill Mobistar Enterprise Services S.A. | 793 |
| Goodwill Orange Communications Luxembourg S.A. | 68 729 |
| Total | 80 080 |
| The Goodwill end 2011 consists of: | |
| Goodwill Mobistar Affiliate S.A. | 10 558 |
| Goodwill Mobistar Enterprise Services S.A. | 793 |
| Goodwill Orange Communications Luxembourg S.A. | 68 729 |
| Total | 80 080 |
Mobistar Affiliate S.A.
The acquisition of Mobistar Affiliate S.A. was achieved in two phases: initial purchase of 20 % shares in April 1999 and purchase of the remaining 80 % shares in May 2001.
The reported goodwill is fully allocated to the segment 'Belgium' (see note 20).
Mobistar Enterprise Services S.A.
The goodwill resulting from the acquisition of MES was recorded in two steps. First allocation on 1st April 2010 for 844 thousand euros, adjusted on 31st March 2011 for a final result of 793 thousand euros.
The reported goodwill is fully allocated to the segment 'Belgium' (see note 20).
Impairment test on the goodwill allocated to the segment 'Belgium' is performed at least at the end of each financial year to assess as to whether its carrying amount does not exceed its recoverable amount. Estimating the fair value less costs to sell will take into account Mobistar's share price as quoted on the stock exchange.
Concerning the goodwill of the segment 'Belgium', when considering the relationship between the market capitalization and the net assets of the Group as at 31 December 2012, the market capitalization was significantly higher than the net book value.
Orange Communications Luxembourg S.A.
The acquisition of Orange Communications Luxembourg S.A. has been achieved in two phases. 90 % of the shares were acquired on 2 July 2007. The remaining 10 % have been acquired on 12 November 2008.
The reported goodwill is fully allocated to the segment 'Luxembourg'.
Impairment test on this goodwill is performed at least at the end of each financial year to assess as to whether its carrying amount does not exceed its recoverable amount.
The recoverable amount of this cash-generating unit has been estimated using a discounted cash flow method.
For 2012, same methodology has been used as in previous years. Cash flows have been estimated on a five years business plan (2013 to 2017) approved by the local management. This estimate includes the impact of the reinforcement on the market by extending the sales channels in both residential and business segments and the integration of a strong impact of the regulation in the next two years (MTR and roaming). As Luxembourg population will continue to grow in the future, management assumes a long-term annual growth rate of 2 % for the years after 2017. Cash flows have been actualised at 8.5 % (post tax). In line with previous years, management uses a discount rate of 8.5 % which is based upon Mobistar weighted average cost of capital (WACC) increased with a risk premium relating to the relatively small size of the Luxembourg operations. Sensitivity analysis of these parameters has been performed, using a growth rate varying from 1 to 3 % and a discount rate varying from 7.5 to 9.5 %, and this even if the extremes are considered as very theoretical. The worst case scenario, based on a growth rate of 1 % and a WACC of 9.5 % would result in head room available amounting to 5.2 million euros. Best case scenario envisaged in the sensitivity analysis would result in a positive amount of 89.8 million euros. Selected rate assumptions result in 34.1 million euros.
For 2011, cash flows have been estimated on a five years business plan (2012 to 2016) approved by the local management. For the following years, figures have been extrapolated based on a growth rate estimated at 2 % (estimated growth rate on the Luxembourgian market adjusted to consider Orange Communications Luxembourg S.A. strategy deployment). Cash flows have been actualised. The discount rate applied to cash flow projections has been estimated at 8.5 % (post tax). Sensitivity analysis of these parameters has been performed. The worst case scenario, based on a growth rate of 1 % and a WACC of 9.5 % would result in head room available amounting to 9.9 million euros. Best case scenario envisaged in the sensitivity analysis would result in a positive amount of 98.4 million euros. Selected rate assumptions resulted in 40.5 million euros.
As the recoverable amount of the segment 'Luxembourg', including goodwill, exceeds its carrying value, no impairment loss has to be recognised.
Intangible assets
The UMTS licence has been depreciated from April 2005 onwards when the 3G network has been technically declared ready to operate in the region of Antwerp. The UMTS licence is depreciated over 16 years on a linear basis and the depreciation cost amounts to 9,364 thousand euros on a full year basis. The 2G licence has been renewed at the end of 2010. The costs of this licence, 74,367 thousand euros, is amortized over a period of five years which corresponds to the duration of the licence. The amortization expense for the years 2011 and 2012 amounts to 14,920 thousand euros. The acquisition of the 4G licence (2.6 MHz) has been recorded in December 2011 for an amount of 20,020 thousand euros. The 4G licence will be depreciated as from the technical readiness up to the end of the right granted (at the end of June 2027). Currently the start date of the depreciation is not defined.
Internally generated intangible assets include software development and software licence costs. The useful lives of intangible assets applied in 2012 remain comparable to the one's used in 2011.
Other intangible assets are mainly related to software acquired or developed by external suppliers. They are mainly used for the network applications or for administrative purpose.
An important renewal program started in 2010 that aimed to review applications managing provisioning, mediation, billing and CRM for prepaid and postpaid activities. Due to the evolution of the IT strategy, an accelerated depreciation of 15.5 million euros has been recorded in the year 2012.
Some intangible assets are fully amortized however still in use. The main one is the original GSM licence that has been fully amortized at the end of 2011. Investments related to original software acquisition may be fully amortized as well but upgrades of these softwares, still in use, are not fully amortized. The same applies to original site's research costs.
3. Property, plant and equipment (in 000 euros)
| 2012 | Land and buildings |
Network infra structure |
Plant, machinery, equipment |
Furniture and vehicles |
Other intangible assets |
Total intangible assets |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Acquisition value | ||||||
| As at 1 January 2012 | 1 966 | 611 629 | 719 720 | 127 148 | 19 191 1 479 654 | |
| Movements during the period: | ||||||
| Acquisitions, including self-constructed fixed assets | 29 071 | 84 361 | 5 437 | 2 632 | 121 502 | |
| Dismantling asset | 3 968 | 3 968 | ||||
| Sales and disposals | -10 956 | -97 199 | -5 225 | -1 398 | -114 778 | |
| As at 31 December 2012 | 1 966 | 633 712 | 706 882 | 127 361 | 20 425 1 490 345 | |
| Depreciation and impairment | ||||||
| As at 1 January 2012 | 211 | 268 217 | 434 560 | 105 399 | 5 267 | 813 654 |
| Movements during the period: | ||||||
| Additions | 47 | 25 940 | 88 126 | 8 114 | 1 392 | 123 618 |
| Dismantling asset | 3 332 | 3 332 | ||||
| Sales and disposals | -11 454 | -97 249 | -5 226 | -1 339 | -115 269 | |
| As at 31 December 2012 | 258 | 286 034 | 425 436 | 108 287 | 5 320 | 825 335 |
| Net carrying amount as at 31 December 2012 | 1 708 | 347 677 | 281 446 | 19 074 | 15 105 | 665 010 |
| 2011 | Land and buildings |
Network infra structure |
Plant, machinery, equipment |
Furniture and vehicles |
Other intangible assets |
Total intangible assets |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Acquisition value | ||||||
| As at 1 January 2011 | 1 966 | 553 625 | 723 803 | 125 715 | 17 231 1 422 340 | |
| Movements during the period: | ||||||
| Acquisitions, including self-constructed fixed assets | 31 888 | 75 734 | 7 327 | 1 980 | 116 929 | |
| Dismantling asset | 32 562 | 32 562 | ||||
| Sales and disposals | -6 446 | -79 816 | -5 894 | -21 | -92 177 | |
| As at 31 December 2011 | 1 966 | 611 629 | 719 720 | 127 148 | 19 191 1 479 654 | |
| Depreciation and impairment | ||||||
| As at 1 January 2011 | 164 | 248 170 | 432 211 | 101 452 | 4 416 | 786 413 |
| Movements during the period: | ||||||
| Additions | 47 | 22 899 | 81 837 | 9 841 | 872 | 115 496 |
| Dismantling asset | 4 178 | 4 178 | ||||
| Sales and disposals | -7 031 | -79 487 | -5 894 | -21 | -92 433 | |
| As at 31 December 2011 | 211 | 268 217 | 434 560 | 105 399 | 5 267 | 813 654 |
| Net carrying amount as at 31 December 2011 | 1 755 | 343 412 | 285 160 | 21 749 | 13 924 | 666 000 |
"Land, buildings and network infrastructure" is mainly constituted of the network equipment and site installation costs. Own land and buildings related amounts are very limited.
Capital expenditure
During the 2012 financial year, Mobistar invested 188.5 million euros (67.0 million euros in intangible assets and 121.5 million euros in tangible assets), which represents 13.0 % of service revenues. The investments, which are in line with the investment programme foreseen for the financial year 2012, focused on IT projects and on extending the capacity and increasing the speed of the mobile data network. During the year 2012, Mobistar thus strove to replace its 2G equipment, which had arrived at the end of its service life, with more modern and higher-performance 2G/3G equipment, and deployed a first 4G mobile test network in the city of Antwerp. By the end of December 2012, the 3G/HSDPA coverage reached 97 % of the population. The Mobistar network had 5,762 sites at the end of December 2012, of which 730 are shared with other operators.
Change in useful life and impairment on intangible and tangible assets
The changes recognised during the year have been determined on individual asset basis in order to consider technology and IT evolution. Obsolescence, dismantling or losses are also considered in the exercise.
During 2012, change in useful life on both tangible and intangible assets has been recognised for an amount of 37.6 million euros (2011: 12.4 million euros) and shown as expense on the line 'Depreciation, amortisation and impairment' in the income statement.
Impact can be split as such:
- Software: 15.5 million euros resulting from the write-off related to the change in IT strategy
- Network and other equipment: 22.1 million euros including the change in useful life of the network material currently covered by the swap of technology (14.1 million euros), and impairment resulting from assets inventory procedures (6.3 million euros).
Fair value less costs to sell of both software applications and the obsolete network equipment is nil.
Government grant
A capital grant amounting to 3,148 thousand euros was received in 1997 from the government of the Walloon Region in order to contribute to the investment in an office building and its equipment.
The capital grants are deducted from the acquisition value of the related assets.
All the conditions and contingencies attached to the capital grant received are met.
| 2012 | 2011 | |
|---|---|---|
| Net carrying amount as at 1 January | 123 | 149 |
| Released to the income statement | -26 | -26 |
| Net carrying amount as at 31 December | 97 | 123 |
4. Interests in associates (in 000 euros)
| 2012 | ||
|---|---|---|
| Interests in associates |
Result in associated companies |
|
| Net carrying amount as at 1 January 2012 | 0 | |
| Acquisition | 3 450 | |
| Result of the year | 0 | 0 |
| Net carrying amount as at 31 December 2012 | 3 450 | 0 |
In July 2012, the Group participated to the constitution of the company IRISnet S.C.R.L. The objective of this new company is the takeover of the activities of the joint venture Irisnet. The activity of IRISnet S.C.R.L. started on 1st November 2012.
The share of the Group in the equity of IRISnet S.C.R.L. is 28.16 %. The Group is represented in the Board of Directors for 2 out of 7 seats. Therefore this company will be accounted for via the equity method.
IRISnet S.C.R.L. has taken over the activities of the joint venture Irisnet (a temporary association between Mobistar and Belgacom - formerly Telindus) as of November 2012. Given the limited impact of the results generated in 2012, no impact has been included in the 2012 consolidated results.
5. Other non-current assets (in 000 euros)
| Cash guarantees | Long-term receivables | Total |
|---|---|---|
| 262 | 5 556 | 5 818 |
| 8 | 0 | 8 |
| -27 | -1 834 | -1 861 |
| 243 | 3 722 | 3 965 |
| 2011 | Cash guarantees | Long-term receivables | Total |
|---|---|---|---|
| Net carrying amount as at 1 January 2011 | 162 | 7 339 | 7 501 |
| Additions | 100 | 0 | 100 |
| Reimbursements | 0 | -1 783 | -1 783 |
| Net carrying amount as at 31 December 2011 | 262 | 5 556 | 5 818 |
The decrease in other non-current receivables in 2012 is mainly due to the transfer to 'other current assets' of the maturing part of the long-term loans to specific partners (1,834 thousand euros).
Since the end of 2009, a pledge collateral has been issued in favour of Mobistar on the assets of one of its partners in order to hedge the loan receivable toward this partner (short- and long-term parts).
6. Current and deferred taxes (in 000 euros)
| Deferred tax assets and liabilities | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Balance sheet | Income statement | |||
| 31.12.2012 | 31.12.2011 | 31.12.2012 | 31.12.2011 | |
| Deferred tax assets | ||||
| Related to Orange Communications Services S.A. operations | ||||
| Carried forward tax losses beginning of the year | 4 398 | 3 265 | 1 133 | |
| Carried forward tax losses of the year | -664 | 1 133 | -1 797 | 1 133 |
| DTA on Purchase Price Allocation Orange Communications Services S.A. | -496 | -1 035 | 539 | 580 |
| Related to MES S.A. | ||||
| DTA on wholesale's agreement on MES Purchase Price Allocation | 3 918 | 3 918 | ||
| Transfer from deferred tax liabilities | -1 115 | -984 | ||
| Deferred tax liabilities on MES Purchase Price Allocation | 103 | -217 | -217 | |
| Deferred tax liabilities MES of the year | 321 | 321 | ||
| Carried forward tax losses of the year | -1 830 | -1 830 | ||
| Total deferred tax assets from activities | 4 314 | 6 401 | -1 955 | 1 817 |
| Deferred tax liabilities | ||||
| Related to Mobistar S.A. operations | ||||
| Investment tax credit | 662 | 961 | -299 | -321 |
| Revenue recognition for free airtime minutes | -1 160 | -3 944 | 2 784 | -1 529 |
| Borrowing costs expensed as incurred | 24 | -24 | -129 | |
| Website development costs expensed as incurred | 205 | 277 | -72 | |
| Assets dismantling obligations on sites | 2 648 | 1 506 | 1 142 | 1 506 |
| Other items | 3 | |||
| Related to MES S.A. operations | ||||
| Deferred tax liabilities on MES Purchase Price Allocation | -1 181 | -963 | -218 | |
| Deferred tax liabilities MES of the year | 66 | -21 | 87 | |
| Transfer in deferred tax assets | 1 115 | 984 | ||
| Total deferred tax liabilities from activities | 2 355 | -1 176 | 3 400 | -470 |
| Total net deferred tax assets | 6 669 | 5 225 | 1 445 | 1 347 |
Major components of tax expense
| 31.12.2012 | 31.12.2011 | |
|---|---|---|
| Current income tax | 89 010 | 119 017 |
| Current income tax of prior periods | -7 103 | -9 818 |
| Deferred tax expense | -1 442 | -1 347 |
| Tax expense | 80 465 | 107 852 |
Orange Communications Luxembourg S.A.
The main component is related to the carried forward losses for 3,238 thousand euros and to temporary differences between LUX GAAP and IFRS.
Mobistar Enterprise Services S.A.
In 2011, following the finalization of the Purchase Price Accounting related to MES acquisition, a deferred tax asset has been recognized on MES tax losses. At the end of March 2011, the recoverable tax loss of MES amounted to 29,978 thousand euros. Due to the estimate of the future taxable profits together with the tax planning expected, the deferred tax amounts were capped on a tax loss of 11,510 thousand euros or an amount of deferred tax asset of 3,918 thousand euros.
In 2012, in line with the taxable result of MES, an amount of 1,115 thousand euros of deferred tax assets has been used. However MES results perspectives do not allow to increase the level of deferred tax assets up to the amount of taxes calculated based on the total carried forward losses.
Mobistar S.A.
Deferred taxes recorded on Mobistar's operations are essentially related to investments tax credits and to the temporary differences resulting from the consideration of borrowing costs and the development costs for intranet sites, to the income related to the free minutes of traffic granted to subscribed customers and to the dismantling assets depreciation.
Due to carried forward losses, Orange Communications Luxembourg S.A. and Mobistar Enterprise Services S.A. have no current tax recorded.
Relationship between tax expense and accounting profit
| 31.12.2012 | 31.12.2011 | |
|---|---|---|
| Consolidated accounting profit before taxes | 266 150 | 328 873 |
| Tax at the applicable rate of 33.99% | 90 464 | 111 784 |
| Tax effect of permanent differences: | ||
| * Expenses that are not deductible in | ||
| determining taxable profit | 2 958 | 3 096 |
| * Tax on debt waiver reevaluation | 0 | 4 099 |
| * Tax on Irisnet result not considered | -3 217 | 81 |
| Tax credit on investment | -21 | -321 |
| Tax deductible risk capital | -122 | -153 |
| Tax credits on business combination | -2 494 | -916 |
| Adjustment on prior years | -7 103 | -9 818 |
| Current year tax expense | 80 465 | 107 852 |
| Effective tax rate | 30.23% | 32.79% |
7. Inventories (in 000 euros)
| . | ||
|---|---|---|
| 31.12.2012 | 31.12.2011 | |
|---|---|---|
| Finished goods (i.e. handsets and SIM cards) | ||
| Inventories - Gross amount | 22 467 | 18 820 |
| Reserve for obsolete and slow moving items | -1 873 | -2 319 |
| Inventories - Net carrying amount | 20 594 | 16 501 |
| Inventories - Cost recognised as an expense during the period | 225 290 | 179 327 |
The level of inventories recorded at the end of 2011 was lower compared to 2012. Increase of the inventory level is partially due to the implementation of the bundle offers (combination of service plan and handset), which has postponed the de-recognition of the inventory transferred to the distribution channels from the transfer date to the distributor to the end customer received date. The impact at year-end is 2.8 million euros.
The amount of reserve for obsolete and slow moving items related to inventories has generated a decrease of expense amounting to 448 thousand euros, which is recognised in 'Costs of equipment and goods sold'.
8. Trade receivables (in 000 euros)
| 31.12.2012 | 31.12.2011 | |
|---|---|---|
| Trade receivables - Gross value | 293 314 | 275 359 |
| Allowance for doubtful debtors | -63 146 | -50 109 |
| Trade receivables - Net carrying amount | 230 168 | 225 251 |
For terms and conditions relating to related parties receivables, refer to note 18.
Trade receivables are non-interest bearing and are generally paid via direct debits (60 percent of the service revenues are collected by direct debit). Trade receivables which are not paid via direct debits bear mainly a payment term of 30 days end of month.
Trade receivables amount to 230.2 million euros at the end of 2012, compared with 225.3 million euros at the end of 2011. The small evolution results from a compensation of a small decrease in the 'Service Revenue' receivable, which is influenced by the reduction of Service Revenue itself, over compensated by the increase on receivable related to distributors, influenced by the very high level of handset sales in the last quarter of 2012.
Trade receivables: Allowance for doubtful debtor's reconciliation
| Balance sheet | Income statement | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 31.12.2012 | Accrual | Reversal | 31.12.2011 | 31.12.2012 | |
| Hardware customers | -3 817 | -3 494 | 323 | ||
| Airtime customers | -59 329 | -46 615 | 12 714 | ||
| Total allowance for doubtful debtors | -63 146 | -18 068 | 5 031 | -50 109 | 13 037 |
| 31.12.2011 | Accrual | Reversal | 31.12.2010 | 31.12.2011 | |
| Hardware customers | -3 494 | -5 875 | -2 381 | ||
| Airtime customers | -46 615 | -45 575 | 1 040 | ||
| Total allowance for doubtful debtors | -50 109 | -14 382 | 15 724 | -51 450 | -1 342 |
Trade receivables: Ageing balance
| Trade receivables - Net carrying amount |
Not past due | Less than 180 days |
Between 180 days and 360 days |
More than 360 days |
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2012 | 230 168 | 172 111 | 22 699 | 17 191 | 18 167 |
| 2011 | 225 251 | 171 947 | 30 192 | 13 982 | 9 130 |
Due to the evolution of the market conditions and the increasing difficulty of recovering the receivables, the percentage of bad debt provisions has been raised in 2011 from 1.8 % to 2.0 % of the average billing for the residential market. The slowdown in cash collection noted at the end of 2011 has been stabilized in the residential segment but required a small increase in the provision for bad debt (up to 2.1 %) again in 2012. Some more difficulties have been noted in the 'small and medium enterprises' segment, resulting in an increase of the bad debt provision related to this segment and an expense of 924 thousand euros.
The decrease of the allowance for doubtful debtors in 2011 was related to the write-offs performed during that year on old receivables. These write-offs were related to uncollectible amounts for which fiscal attests have been received. Impact on non-accrued losses has been immaterial. In 2012 a lower volume of write-offs has been recorded resulting in a net increase of the provision.
9. Other current assets and accrued revenues (in 000 euros)
| 31.12.2012 | 31.12.2011 | |
|---|---|---|
| Local and regional taxes on pylons | 57 332 | 49 741 |
| Impairment on taxes on pylons | -57 332 | -49 741 |
| Prepayments | 13 690 | 14 026 |
| VAT to be recovered | 0 | 5 453 |
| Other current assets | 5 470 | 11 017 |
| Total other current assets | 19 160 | 30 496 |
| Accrued revenues | 19 039 | 31 812 |
| Total | 38 199 | 62 308 |
Local and regional taxes on GSM pylons, masts and antennas
Since 1997, certain municipalities and three provinces have adopted local taxes, on an annual basis, on pylons, masts and antennas erected within their boundaries. These taxes are currently being contested before the Civil Courts (Courts of First Instance - Tax Chamber and Courts of Appeal).
Pursuant to a preliminary question raised by the Council of State to the European Court of Justice, the latter ruled in its decree dated 8 September 2005 that such taxes are not inconsistent with European law, provided they do not alter the conditions of competition between the historical operator and new operators on the market.
The Council of State decided since 20 November 2007 in several arrests that a tax regulation violates the principle of equality if the motive appearing in the preamble of this tax regulation results from the financial situation of the municipality. In fact, such a motive does not explain at all the differentiation made between the mobile telephone network operators (which are taxed on the basis of this tax regulation) and the operators of other similar networks (which are not taxed on the basis of this same tax regulation). It is therefore not established that the difference in treatment is based on a criterion that can be objectively and logically justified.
The Constitutional Court decided in its judgment of 15 December 2011 that article 98 §2 of the Act of 21 March 1991 reforming certain public companies doesn't prohibit the municipalities from taxing the economic activity of the telecom operators which is achieved in the territory of the municipality by the presence (whether on the public or private domain) of mobile phone masts, pylons or antennas dedicated to this activity, for budgetary or other reasons. According to the Constitutional Court, this interpretation of article 98 §2 is not inconsistent with article 170 § 4 of the Constitution.
The Supreme Court has confirmed in its judgments of 30 March 2012 the interpretation of the Constitutional Court of article 98 of the Act of 21 March 1991.
The total receivable amount of taxes charged, plus default interest calculated at the legal rate, amounts to 57.3 million euros and is subject to a bad debt provision for the whole amount, of which 7.6 million euros correspond to the financial year 2012. The provision is recorded under the 'Other operating charges' heading in the profit and loss account.
Prepayments
Prepayments have decreased due to seasonality effect.
VAT to be recovered
Other current assets have decreased due to the VAT situation of Mobistar S.A. at the end of the year that shows a payable balance of 3,689 thousand euros in 2012 against a 5,453 thousand euros receivable balance end of 2011.
Other current assets
Variation of the other current assets is partially driven by the reinvoicing of costs incurred in the past by the joint venture Irisnet to IRISnet S.C.R.L. for 5,264 thousand euros.
Accrued revenues
Accrued revenues are made of two types of items: estimated amounts of revenues not billed and adjustments to revenues considered in context of some tariff plans including free advantages for which the allocation period is different from the loyalty period (for example). These accrued revenues have decreased essentially due to the second type of operations as the introduction of the new telecom law has accelerated the release of the amounts linked to gratuity related to previous plans. The introduction of the 'Animals' had also an impact on the level of deferred revenues as the possibility of carrying over unused part of the bundle has been removed from these new tariff models.
10. Cash and cash equivalents (in 000 euros)
| 31.12.2012 | 31.12.2011 | |
|---|---|---|
| Total cash and cash equivalents | 12 266 | 7 119 |
Short-term deposits with France Télécom have a maturity of 1 month and bear interests according to the market conditions.
Cash at bank earns interest at floating rates based on daily bank deposit rates. The fair value of cash, short-term deposits and cash equivalents is 12,266 thousand euros at the end of 2012.
11. Earnings per share (in 000 euros)
Basic earnings per share are calculated by dividing the net profit for the year attributable to ordinary equity holders of the parent by the weighted average number of ordinary shares outstanding during the year.
Diluted earnings per share are calculated by dividing the net profit for the year attributable to ordinary equity holders of the parent by the weighted average number of ordinary shares outstanding during the year plus the weighted average number of ordinary shares that would be issued on the conversion of all the dilutive potential ordinary shares into ordinary shares.
| 31.12.2012 | 31.12.2011 | |
|---|---|---|
| Net profit attributable to ordinary equity holders of the parent | 185 685 | 221 021 |
| Weighted average number of ordinary shares for basic earnings per share | 60 014 414 | 60 014 414 |
| Effect of dilution | NA | NA |
| Weighted average number of ordinary shares adjusted for the effect of dilution | 60 014 414 | 60 014 414 |
No transaction involving ordinary shares or potential ordinary shares has occurred after the balance sheet date which would have changed significantly the number of ordinary shares or potential ordinary shares outstanding at the end of the financial year if those transactions had occurred before the end of the financial year.
12. Equity (in 000 euros)
Share capital
Changes during 2012
No changes have been performed during the year 2012.
| Share capital |
Number of ordinary shares |
|
|---|---|---|
| As at end December 2011 | 131 721 | 60 014 414 |
| As at 1 January 2012 | 131 721 | 60 014 414 |
| As at 31 December 2012 | 131 721 | 60 014 414 |
All ordinary shares are fully paid and have a par value of 2.195 euros. As no changes occurred during 2012, the par value is the same for 2012 and 2011.
Legal reserve
In accordance with the Belgian accounting law, 5 % of the annual net after tax profit of Mobistar S.A. must be allocated to the legal reserve until it represents 10 % of the share capital. The current level of legal reserve has reached the 10 % required in the past.
No changes have occurred in 2012.
| 2012 | 2011 | |
|---|---|---|
| As at 1 January | 13 173 | 13 173 |
| As at 31 December | 13 173 | 13 173 |
Retained earnings
| 2012 | 2011 | |
|---|---|---|
| As at 1 January | 249 078 | 286 276 |
| Current year profit after taxes | 185 685 | 221 021 |
| Dividend paid | -222 053 | -258 062 |
| Equity transaction costs | 195 | -157 |
| As at 31 December | 212 905 | 249 078 |
Shareholders' remuneration
At the Annual General Assembly of shareholders to take place on 2 May 2013, the Board of Directors will propose to approve the following shareholders' remuneration scheme:
Dividend 2012
The number of shares receiving a dividend based on the distribution of the result 2012 amounts to 60,014,414 shares.
| Number of ordinary shares as at the date of dividend payment | 60 014 414 |
|---|---|
| Gross ordinary dividend per ordinary share, in euros | 1.80 |
| Total ordinary dividend 2012 (000 euros) | 108 026 |
The dividend relating to the financial year 2012 has not been recognised as a liability at the balance sheet date as the approval of the Annual General Assembly of shareholders will take place after the balance sheet date.
Capital management
The primary objective of the Group's capital management is to ensure that it maintains a strong credit rating in order to support its business and maximise shareholders' value.
The Group manages its capital structure and makes adjustments to it, in light of changes in economic conditions. In order to maintain or adjust its capital structure, the Group may adjust the dividend payment to its shareholders, return capital to its shareholders, buy back shares or issue new shares. As a consequence, for 2013, concomitant with the accelerated investments in the 4G network and the provision of customer services, instead of implementing the usual shareholders' remuneration policy (pay-out ratio close to 100 % of the net result), the Board of Directors of the company decided to adapt its dividend policy in order to preserve a sound balance sheet.
In line with the usual remuneration scheme, Mobistar distributed 222.1 million euros to its shareholders during the 2012 financial year. This distribution took the form of an ordinary dividend of 2.90 euros per ordinary share and an extraordinary dividend of 0.80 euro per ordinary share.
External funding is negotiated on the market at maturity dates of the credit lines. Conditions of this external funding are described in note 14.
2012 01.01.2012 Additions Utilisations Reversal Unwinding effect 31.12.2012 Outstanding litigations 14 206 3 513 -2 787 -76 14 856 Network sites dismantling costs 44 807 4 677 -571 -100 1 001 49 814 Office refurbishment costs 2 582 16 107 2 705 Total 61 595 8 206 -3 358 -176 1 108 67 375 2011 01.01.2011 Additions Utilisations Reversal Unwinding effect 31.12.2011 Outstanding litigations 5 054 9 809 -198 -459 14 206 Network sites dismantling costs 11 327 34 617 -175 -1 206 244 44 807 Office refurbishment costs 2 192 411 -90 69 2 582
13. Long-term provisions (in 000 euros)
Outstanding litigations
Mobistar is engaged in various judicial procedures whereby third-party individuals or entities are claiming repair of damages they pretend to have incurred. Each litigation is evaluated on an individual basis in order to assess as to whether it is more likely than not that an outflow of resources will be necessary to settle the litigation and to ensure that the assumptions taken to measure the provisions are valid.
Total 18 573 44 837 -463 -1 665 313 61 595
The outstanding claims are built up during the previous years and it can be reasonably assumed that they will be subject to a Court decision or solved by means of a common agreement within the following years.
Since the consolidation of MES in 2010, the outstanding litigations include a liability relating to VAT claims and a provision for onerous contracts.
Variance of the provision is mainly due to new provisions for specific risks booked in Mobistar and MES for 3,513 thousand euros. Provision for onerous contracts booked in MES in the previous years for 7,122 thousand euros has been used for 2,558 thousand euros, as losses have been incurred.
Network sites dismantling provision
The key assumptions used to measure the network sites dismantling provision are as follows:
| 31.12.2012 | 31.12.2011 | |
|---|---|---|
| Number of network sites Orange Communications Luxembourg S.A. incl. (in units) | 4 436 | 4 373 |
| Average dismantling cost per network site | 11 | 11 |
| Inflation rate | 2.0% | 2.0% |
| Discount rate | 2.29% | 2.98% |
Although size and installation on site may slightly vary from site to site, the provision is calculated on an average dismantling cost which is based on the actual costs incurred in the past for similar activities. For sites of a bigger size, like MSC's (Mobile Switching Centre), the provision is calculated on the surface area of the sites rented and an average dismantling cost per m² based on past similar experience.
Although it is rather not practicable to estimate the timing of the cash outflows, it is assumed that all the network sites will be dismantled in the future. In 2011, the duration of the rental contracts has been capped to 15 years, which is considered to be equivalent to a dismantling plan spread over a period close to 30 years. Before that change, the longest period considered was 99 years. The same approach was maintained to evaluate the provision in 2012, leading to a net variation of the provision for 4,006 thousand euros. Unwinding effect has increased the provision for 1,001 thousand euros.
Network sites dismantling provision will also be adjusted when there is sufficient objective evidence that future change in technology or in legislation will have an impact on the amount of the provision.
Office refurbishment costs
Office refurbishment provision arises from office rental contracts and is measured at the level of costs incurred in the past on similar transactions.
The increase in 2012 of the provision amounted to 123 thousand euros. This can be split as such:
| - changes with impact in fixed assets | 16 000 |
|---|---|
| - changes with impact in Profit and Loss (financial expenses) | 107 000 |
Waste Electrical and Electronic Equipment
According to the European Directive issued on that subject and to the IFRIC 6 interpretation, Mobistar is responsible for the treatment and disposal for any wasted electrical and electronic equipment (i.e. network equipment, IT hardware, ...) acquired on or before 13 August 2005.
Mobistar is currently selling its waste electrical and electronic equipment to a WEEE certified third-party supplier at a net selling price which includes all the European Directive obligations. The agreement with this supplier also includes the obligations of Mobistar for the period before 13 August 2005. No provision has to be recognised in this respect in the Mobistar financial statements.
14. Financial instruments (in 000 euros)
Financial risk management objectives and policies
Mobistar's principal financial instruments comprise bank and inter-company loans, overdrafts, cash at bank and shortterm bank and inter-company deposits. The main purpose of these financial instruments is to raise finance for Mobistar's operations. Mobistar has also various other financial assets and liabilities such as trade receivables and trade payables, which arise directly from its operations.
It is to be noted that Mobistar's policy does not allow trading in financial instruments.
Interest rate risk
As a result of the exceptionally high distribution to its shareholders paid-out in 2008 (nearly 600 million euros), the Company showed a debt amounting to 407.6 million euros on 31 December 2012. The Company didn't hedge the interest rate risk on the debt that bears interests based on Euribor + 65 Bps margin + 20 Bps utilization fee.
The company decided not to hedge the long-term interest rate risk linked to its long-term debt in the light of the current low interest rates levels and the amount's fluctuations of the said long-term debt.
Foreign currency risk
The Company is not subject to significant foreign currency risks.
Credit risk
Mobistar trades only with recognised, creditworthy third-parties. It is Mobistar's policy that all customers who wish to trade on credit terms are subject to credit verification procedures. In addition, trade receivable balances are monitored on an ongoing basis. See notes 8 & 9.
Allowance for doubtful debtors is calculated based on different criteria depending on the type of customers. Hardware customers allowance is based on individual evaluation of the customer financial reliability on a case by case basis. In some circumstances, payment terms are defined as cash on delivery. For Airtime customers, allowance is based on a percentage of turnover generated combined with ageing of the open items. Percentages are defined based on customer segmentation, previous years recovery experience. Yearly review is made of all the indicators.
Liquidity risk
Mobistar's objective is to maintain a balance between continuity of funding and flexibility through the use of bank overdrafts, bank loans and intercompany loans. We refer to the table summarizing the maturity profile of the financial assets and liabilities.
Interest-bearing loans and borrowings
| Nominal amount end 2012 |
Interest rate |
Maturity | 31.12.2012 | 31.12.2011 | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Unsecured revolving credit facility agreement | |||||
| with Atlas Services Belgium | 450 000 | Euribor + 0.65 | 31.12.2015 | 385 000 | 295 000 |
| Transaction costs on long-term loan | -1 350 | -1 800 | |||
| Total long-term loans and borrowings | 383 650 | 293 200 | |||
| Cash-pool related credit facility with France | |||||
| Télécom | 50 000 | EONIA + 0.65 | on demand | 22 580 | 16 234 |
| Uncommitted credit lines with various banks | 43 500 | determined upon withdrawal |
on demand | 0 | 0 |
| Share of a joint venture loan (Irisnet) | 2 727 maximum |
determined upon withdrawal |
on demand | 0 | 2 210 |
| Total short-term loans and borrowings | 22 580 | 18 444 |
Fair values
| Carrying amount | Fair value | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 31.12.2012 | 31.12.2011 | 31.12.2012 | 31.12.2011 | |
| Financial assets | ||||
| Cash and cash equivalent | 12 266 | 7 119 | 12 266 | 7 119 |
| Other financial assets (non-current) | 3 450 | 0 | 3 450 | 0 |
| Short-term receivables(1) | 2 658 | 2 583 | 2 526 ** | 2 265 * |
| Long-term receivables (non-current)(1) | 3 722 | 5 556 | 3 694 ** | 5 461 * |
| Trade receivable(1) | 230 168 | 225 251 | 230 168 | 225 251 |
| Other current assets(1) | 16 502 | 27 913 | 16 502 | 27 913 |
| Financial liabilities | ||||
| Long-term borrowing | 385 000 | 295 000 | 383 207 ** | 290 502* |
| Long-term trade payable | 13 447 | 28 321 | 13 404 ** | 28 092 * |
| Short-term borrowing | 22 580 | 16 234 | 22 580 | 16 234 |
| Share of a joint venture loan (Irisnet) | 0 | 2 210 | 0 | 2 210 |
| Trade payables | 344 563 | 347 635 | 344 563 | 347 635 |
| Other payables | 3 035 | 2 736 | 3 035 | 2 736 |
* Discount rates (assumption) have been considered on the estimated period of repayment (1 year: 0.367%, 2 years: 1.3111%, 3 years: 1.3803%, 4 years: 1.5483%, 5 years: 1.7443%) ** Discount rates (assumption) have been considered on the estimated period of repayment (1 year: 0.3224%, 2 years: 0.376%, 3 years: 0.4678%, 4 years: 0.6012%, 5 years: 0.7688%)
(1) See note 4.12 related to the accounting principles (loans and receivables).
As at 31 December 2012, the Group held no significant financial instruments measured at fair value.
The carrying amount of cash and cash equivalent, trade receivables and other assets, trade payables and other payables is deemed to represent their fair value considering the associated short-term maturity. Other non-current financial assets are measured at amortised costs which are deemed to represent their fair value.
Maturity
| Year ended December 2012 | Amount | Within 1 year |
Within 2-5 years |
More than 5 years |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Financial assets | ||||
| Cash and cash equivalent | 12 266 | 12 266 | ||
| Long-term receivables (non-current) | 6 380 | 2 658 | 3 722 | |
| Financial liabilities | ||||
| Long-term borrowing | 385 000 | 385 000 | ||
| Short-term borrowing | 22 580 | 22 580 | ||
| Share of a joint venture loan (Irisnet) | 0 | |||
| Year ended December 2011 | Amount | Within 1 year |
Within 2-5 years |
More than 5 years |
| Financial assets | ||||
| Cash and cash equivalent | 7 119 | 7 119 | ||
| Long-term receivables (non-current) | 8 139 | 2 583 | 5 556 | |
| Financial liabilities | ||||
| Long-term borrowing | 295 000 | 295 000 | ||
| Short-term borrowing | 18 444 | 18 444 | ||
| Share of a joint venture loan (Irisnet) | 2 210 | 2 210 |
Sensitivity
As indicated above, the main risk area related to external variable elements is the cost of borrowing. Considering an average long-term indebtedness of 359 million euros for 2012, a variation of floating rate of 0.5 % would have meant an impact on financing costs of 1.8 million euros.
15. Long-term trade payable (in 000 euros)
| 31.12.2012 | 31.12.2011 | |
|---|---|---|
| Payable on licence acquisition over 1 year | 13 447 | 28 321 |
| Total long-term trade payable | 13 447 | 28 321 |
This amount represents the part payable over more than one year relating to the renewal of the 2G licence. The company has indeed opted for the deferred payment approach over 5 years. At the end of 2012, 2 installments remain to pay, out of which 1 over one year. Interests on this payable have been paid in advance for the year 2013 in December 2012. These interests have been calculated based on a provisional rate of 4.25 %.
16. Trade payables and other current liabilities (in 000 euros)
| 31.12.2012 | 31.12.2011 | |
|---|---|---|
| Trade payables | 344 563 | 347 635 |
| Salaries and termination pay | 2 258 | 3 848 |
| Social security contributions | 880 | 1 087 |
| Holiday pay | 18 744 | 18 335 |
| Performance and Profit Sharing bonus | 9 431 | 7 884 |
| Other | 3 072 | 1 701 |
| Total employee benefits related liabilities | 34 385 | 32 855 |
| Corporate taxes - 2010 | 51 009 | |
| Corporate taxes - 2011 | 14 | 61 001 |
| Corporate taxes - 2012 | 39 006 | |
| Value added tax & other taxes | 3 689 | 1 727 |
| Total current taxes payable | 42 709 | 113 737 |
| Deferred income | 77 451 | 87 833 |
| Dividend 2004 | 29 | 36 |
| Dividend 2005 | 47 | 67 |
| Dividend 2006 | 39 | 66 |
| Dividend 2007 | 26 | 45 |
| Reimbursement share capital 2008 | 51 | 93 |
| Dividend 2008 | 78 | 132 |
| Dividend 2009 | 46 | 146 |
| Dividend 2010 | 52 | 224 |
| Dividend 2011 | 52 | |
| Other liabilities | 2 615 | 1 927 |
| Total other payables | 3 035 | 2 736 |
Except for the short-term payable related to the 2G licence renewal, trade payables are non-interest bearing and are normally settled on 30 to 60-days terms.
Variation of trade payable of -3,072 thousand euros is mainly due to the combination of two main operations: the reversal of the amount related to universal service provision (-17,085 thousand euros) compensated by the increase of operational and fixed assets trade payable at the end of the year (14,395 thousand euros).
Variation of the employee benefits related liabilities is partially due to employee number increase and a higher global performance rate influencing the bonus level and the higher outstanding amount for group insurance to pay linked to different payment patterns at the end of each year.
Variation of corporate tax payable is due to the payment of the tax bills for the accounting years 2010 and 2011 for respectively 51 and 54 million euros and the adjustment of 2011 tax provision. Prepayments of taxes for 2012 have been slightly lower than in 2011 due to the lower level of pre-tax result.
Deferred income relates to the portion of the upfront payments made under some tariff plans not used at closing date and to the amount of prepaid cards issued but not used. Decrease comes essentially from the change in the tariff plans' structure in the portfolio. Indeed the 'Animals' tariff plans do not include anymore a roll-over period of the unused part of the fixed part billed, which resulted in the decrease of the deferred income. The decrease in prepaid customers has also resulted in a decrease in deferred revenues. Both evolutions in pre- and postpaid have had an impact of -11.7 million euros.
17. Consolidated income statement (in 000 euros)
Turnover
| 2012 | 2011 | |
|---|---|---|
| Revenue from subscription contracts | 913 808 | 963 185 |
| Revenue from prepaid subscription cards | 144 908 | 159 418 |
| Interconnection revenue | 315 527 | 311 451 |
| Site sharing rental income | 3 018 | 2 807 |
| Other services | 72 766 | 68 985 |
| Total service revenue | 1 450 027 | 1 505 846 |
| Sale of equipment | 200 448 | 151 734 |
| Total | 1 650 475 | 1 657 580 |
In 2012, the revenues of the Mobistar group were once again negatively influenced by the reduction of the MTR rates in January 2012 and of the roaming rates in July 2011 and 2012. The impact of these reductions on the turnover amounted to respectively 29.6 million euros and 28.9 million euros for the year 2012. Without regulatory impact, the consolidated service revenues would have been stable compared to last year (+0.2 %). The results were also negatively affected by a decrease in the revenues coming from voice traffic and roaming, as a result of price decreases.
Finally, the traffic revenues related to SMS abundance offers continued to increase (+33.3 million euros compared to 2011).
Driven by the success of smartphones, sales of mobile telephones rose from 151.8 million euros at the end of 2011 to 200.5 million euros at the end of 2012, a 32.1 % increase. The increase was primarily noticeable in the fourth quarter when the turnover from the handsets sales increased by 30 million euros compared to the average of the first 3 quarters of the year.
Other operating revenue
| 2012 | 2011 | |
|---|---|---|
| Expenses recharged to France Télécom group entities | 8 988 | 8 378 |
| Administrative costs recharged to customers and third-parties | 19 183 | 23 351 |
| Services rendered to judicial authorities | 3 389 | 4 659 |
| Other operating revenue | 20 403 | 5 639 |
| Total | 51 962 | 42 027 |
Other operating revenue totaled 51,962 thousand euros in 2012, compared with 42,027 thousand euros in 2011. This revenue comes predominantly from the cross-charging of services provided to the France Télécom group and from information supplied to the judicial authorities. At the beginning of November 2012, the temporary association Irisnet stopped its activities. The activities of Irisnet have been taken over by a newly created company (IRISnet S.C.R.L.). Irisnet will just continue to collect its outstanding receivables balances open as of 31st of October 2012 and complete the legal liquidation of the temporary association. Based on the fact that the temporary association stopped its activities, Mobistar has decided to include in the 2012 closing all necessary provisions regarding the legal liquidation of the temporary association. This review has allowed the Group to record 9.8 million euros of additional income in the fourth quarter of 2012.
Interconnection costs
Interconnection costs have slightly decreased by 0.7 % at 390,494 thousand euros.
Costs of equipment and goods sold
| 2012 | 2011 | |
|---|---|---|
| Purchase of goods | 234 754 | 185 000 |
| Purchase of services | 118 190 | 112 081 |
| Total | 352 944 | 297 081 |
Costs of equipment and goods sold recorded an increase as a result of the growth in revenue from equipment sales, especially in the area of smartphones (49,754 thousand euros). Other service costs are related to leased lines and sites costs that have slightly increased.
Services and other goods
| 2012 | 2011 | |
|---|---|---|
| Rental costs | 26 630 | 27 375 |
| Maintenance | 17 493 | 19 347 |
| Professional fees | 78 203 | 69 413 |
| Administration costs | 19 874 | 20 475 |
| Commissions | 105 832 | 109 950 |
| Universal service | -17 040 | -7 519 |
| Advertising and promotions | 37 730 | 45 539 |
| Other | 13 106 | 12 918 |
| Total | 281 828 | 297 498 |
The cost of services and other goods has decreased by 15.7 million euros reaching 281.8 million euros. An important positive impact is related to the review of the provision for universal service compensation for 17.5 million euros. In light of the Court decision taken last year and the evolution of the regulation, Mobistar has reviewed its approach on the calculation of the provision from a 'loss of revenue' basis to a 'net charges' basis. Professional fees, including IT consultants and outsourced activities, have increased over the year by 8.8 million euros, although commercial expenses have been reduced by 7.8 million euros as well as commissions paid by 4.1 million euros.
Employee benefits expenses
| 2012 | 2011 | |
|---|---|---|
| Short-term employee benefits | 116 468 | 112 424 |
| Social Security contributions | 32 642 | 31 553 |
| Group insurance and medical care | 4 919 | 4 426 |
| Other personnel costs | 2 054 | 1 624 |
| Total | 156 083 | 150 027 |
Short-term employee benefits are presented net of employee benefits expenses internally capitalised as intangible and tangible assets totalling 6,463 thousand euros in 2012 and 5,877 thousand euros in 2011.
The average full-time equivalent number of employees increased from 1,859.3 in 2011 to 1,896.0 in 2012.
The amount paid as expenses related to the defined contribution pension plan and included in the 'Group insurance' amounted to 5,099 thousand euros for 2012 compared to 4,769 thousand euros for 2011.
Depreciations
Depreciations and amortizations on intangible and tangible assets increased by 14.1 %, from 190.3 million euros at the
end of 2011 to 217.2 million euros in 2012. Due to important projects related to technical swap of technology, the useful life of the assets related has been reviewed and shortened in order to consider the expected decommissioning dates. This change has resulted in an increase of the depreciation for a total amount of 14.1 million euros in 2012. In 2012 an exceptional accelerated depreciation has been recorded on software development in order to reflect the impact of the change in the IT strategy. The cost for the company has reached 15.5 million euros.
Amounts written down stocks, contracts in progress and trade debtors
Bad debt provision increase is largely impacting this header as it increased by 14.6 million euros. This increase is partially due to the fact that in 2012 a lower amount of write-offs was acted compared to 2011 and consequently the reverse of the provision has been lower (-10.4 million euros). The increase is also the consequence of the continued slowdown in cash collection due to economic circumstances (impacting Mobistar S.A. by 5.0 million euros). Orange Communications Luxembourg S.A. had also to increase its bad debt provision in 2012 (1.6 million euros) due to issues with its billing system that have generated a high level of contestations and risks on collectability of its receivables.
Other operating charges
| 2012 | 2011 | |
|---|---|---|
| Inventories - obsolete and slow moving items | 249 | 571 |
| Trade receivables - realized losses | 13 037 | 15 724 |
| Trade receivables - Accrual variation | 5 031 | -1 342 |
| Impairment on local taxes on GSM antennas and pylons | 7 591 | 7 804 |
| Property taxes | 2 912 | 860 |
| Long-term provisions | -2 561 | 4 931 |
| Loss on sales of assets | 130 | 0 |
| Other operating charges | 646 | 18 |
| Total | 27 035 | 28 566 |
As described in the note related to the trade receivables, the amount of write-offs related to previous years' invoices has been lower in 2012 compared to 2011.
Local taxes on GSM masts and antennas impairment remained at the same level.
Long-term provisions were positive in 2012 mainly due to the reversal of a part of the provision for onerous contracts booked in MES. In 2011, the Group has recorded new claims for an amount of 4.8 million euros including a risk for onerous contracts of 3.2 million euros in MES.
Note that a reclass has been made between the lines "Other operating charges" and "Impairment on local taxes on GSM antennas and pylons" due to the fine tuning of the cost allocation.
Financial result
| 2012 | 2011 |
|---|---|
| Financial income | |
| Interest on deposits and current bank accounts 308 |
708 |
| Other financial income 189 |
206 |
| Total 497 |
914 |
| Financial costs | |
| Interest on financial debts 7 872 |
9 902 |
| Other financial charges 3 314 |
1 884 |
| Total 11 186 |
11 786 |
| Total net financial costs -10 689 |
-10 872 |
Net financial income is mainly influenced by the general evolution of the interest level, which has been favourable to the Group in 2012.
Tax expense
The tax burden for the year amounts to 80.5 million euros. A positive previous year impact on the taxable year 2011 was recorded in December 2012 for an amount of 7.0 million euros resulting from the confirmation of the investment deductibility, versus 9.6 million euros recorded in 2011.
18. Relationships with related parties (in 000 euros)
Relationships with affiliated enterprises
Balance sheet and income statement
| 31.12.2012 | 31.12.2011 |
|---|---|
| Assets and liabilities | |
| Short-term trade receivables 10 798 |
15 005 |
| Liabilities | |
| Short-term interest-bearing loan 22 580 |
16 234 |
| Long-term interest-bearing loan 383 200 |
293 200 |
| Short-term trade payables 9 036 |
9 670 |
| Income and charges | |
| Sales 38 961 |
42 542 |
| Purchases 38 137 |
43 516 |
The consolidated financial statements include the financial statements of Mobistar S.A., 100 % of Orange Communications Luxembourg S.A., 100 % of Mobistar Enterprise Services S.A. and 50 % of the interests held by France Télécom in the joint venture Irisnet, since Mobistar is actually controlling the joint venture with its partner Belgacom (formerly Telindus) and is assuming the risks and rewards relating to this activity instead of France Télécom.
The ultimate parent entity of Mobistar S.A. is France Télécom S.A., place d'Alleray 6, 75505 Paris Cedex 15, France.
Related party - 2012 transactions
| Sales to related parties |
Purchases from related parties |
Amounts owed by related parties |
Amounts owed to related parties |
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ultimate parent company | ||||
| France Télécom - Traffic and services | 28 337 | 26 254 | 6 136 | 6 815 |
| France Télécom - Cash pooling | 50 | 22 580 | ||
| France Télécom subsidiaries | ||||
| Airtime traffic and services | 10 574 | 5 818 | 4 662 | 2 221 |
| Atlas Services Belgium - Borrowing | 6 065 | 383 200 | ||
| Total | 38 961 | 38 137 | 10 798 | 414 816 |
Related party - 2011 transactions
| Sales to related parties |
Purchases from related parties |
Amounts owed by related parties |
Amounts owed to related parties |
|---|---|---|---|
| 31 452 | 30 664 | 8 289 | 7 605 |
| 176 | 14 | 16 234 | |
| 10 914 | 5 491 | 6 716 | 2 064 |
| 7 347 | 293 200 | ||
| 42 542 | 43 516 | 15 005 | 319 103 |
Terms and conditions of transactions with related parties
The terms and conditions applied to sales and purchases of traffic and services, to the centralised treasury management agreement and to the revolving credit facility agreement are determined at arm's length basis according to the normal market prices and conditions.
There is no outstanding guarantee provided to or received from any related parties at the balance sheet date. No allowance for doubtful debtors on amounts owed by related parties is outstanding at the balance sheet date.
Relationships with Board of Directors members and senior management
The total employee benefits and compensation, including employer social security contributions, attributed to the members of the Executive Committee of Mobistar, and recognized as an expense during the period, are as follows:
| 2012 | 2011 | |
|---|---|---|
| Basic remuneration (gross annual salary) | 2 250 | 2 011 |
| Variable remuneration | 962 | 1 642 |
| Other elements of remuneration | 214 | 147 |
| Post employment benefits (defined contribution pension plan) | 359 | 318 |
| Total employee benefits | 3 785 | 4 118 |
The total remuneration attributed to the Board of Directors (excluding the normal compensation of the CEO which is included in the table above) is as follows:
| 2012 | 2011 | |
|---|---|---|
| Total remuneration | 319 | 242 |
19. Commitments and contingencies (in 000 euros)
| Purchases | |
|---|---|
| -- | ----------- |
| Commitments end of | < 1 year | 1-3 years | 3-5 years | > 5 years | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2011 | 2012 | |||||
| Intangible assets | 5 249 | 14 089 | 14 089 | |||
| Tangible assets | 208 662 | 220 305 | 128 011 | 62 176 | 30 118 | |
| Inventories | 81 740 | 74 871 | 74 554 | 317 | ||
| Other services | 62 791 | 42 861 | 27 954 | 13 967 | 376 | 564 |
| Operational leases costs | ||||||
| Commitments end of | < 1 year | 1-3 years | 3-5 years | > 5 years | ||
| 2011 | 2012 | |||||
| Offices | 70 117 | 65 101 | 5 108 | 10 260 | 10 601 | 39 132 |
| Network sites | 362 609 | 361 775 | 29 302 | 55 379 | 39 722 | 237 372 |
| Cars | 13 930 | 14 194 | 1 268 | 7 330 | 5 596 |
Operating leases for offices have a duration up to 15 years with renewal options. Operating leases for network sites have a duration from 1 to 99 years. The amounts indicated in the table represent the minimum rental payments.
Total 446 656 441 069 35 678 72 969 55 919 276 504
Guarantees received
| Commitments end of | < 1 year | 1-3 years | 3-5 years | > 5 years | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2011 | 2012 | |||||
| Total | 155 000 | 50 000 | 50 000 |
Guarantees granted
| Commitments end of | < 1 year | 1-3 years | 3-5 years | > 5 years | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2011 | 2012 | |||||
| Total | 8 275 | 9 580 | 141 | 1 202 | 777 | 7 460 |
Guarantees granted are related to various lease agreements (1,875.4 thousand euros in 2012) and to network performance commitment granted to some corporate customers (6,877.6 thousand euros in 2012). No other security (mortgage, pledge or other) has been granted on Mobistar assets as at 31 December 2012.
Purchase agreement
No purchase agreement has been signed in 2012.
Events after the balance sheet date
No adjusting events arose between the balance sheet date and the date at which the financial statements have been authorised for issue.
20. Operating segment information (in 000 euros)
Segment information is structured by country. For the main countries, segmentation per business segment will be maintained. Countries involved are Belgium, country covered by Mobistar S.A., Irisnet operations and Mobistar Enterprise Services S.A., and Luxembourg for the operations of Orange Communications Luxembourg S.A.
The segment Belgium continues to be split between two operating units:
- Mobile segment: delivers mobile phone equipment and services to residential and corporate customers.
- Non-mobile segment: provides fix voice, data and Internet services to residential and corporate customers.
Management monitors the operating results of its operating units separately for the purpose of making decisions about resource allocation and performance assessment. Segment performance is evaluated based on operating profit & loss in the consolidated financial statements. No operating segment has been aggregated to form the above reportable segments.
As far as balance sheet allocation is considered, unallocated amounts in the Belgian segment mainly correspond to the investments in affiliated companies, deferred tax assets and loan to Orange Communications Luxembourg S.A. for the assets and to financial loans, deferred and current taxes and amounts payables for dividend and equity transactions for the liabilities. Indeed, these various elements are managed at Group level.
The presentation of the operating segment information has been refined in 2012 essentially in terms of fixed assets allocation to the different segments. The new allocation is based on the assets (and only to these assets) that are specifically needed in order to run the non-mobile segment: dedicated infrastructure, end customer specific connection or material,… In the past part of the assets that were used by the two segments, like transmission, MES backbone, were partially allocated to the non-mobile. In consequence of the revision of the allocation, figures presented in 2011 have been restated including the depreciation expenses (which are aligned to the assets allocated).
In February 2013, Mobistar's Board of Directors approved the 'SuperMobile' strategy. This strategy will increase the company's investment in its mobile network while significantly improving the profitability in its fix activities, preparing the company to have access to a regulated cable offer in 2014.
| 2012 | 31.12.2012 Belgium |
31.12.2012 Luxembourg |
Interco elimination |
Mobistar Group |
||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mobile | Non-Mobile | Total | Total | Total | Total | |
| Operating revenues | ||||||
| Network & other operating revenues (service revenues) | 1 240 052 | 160 303 | 1 400 355 | 65 453 | -15 780 | 1 450 027 |
| Handsets sales | 204 954 | 0 | 204 954 | 10 009 | -14 515 | 200 448 |
| Total turnover | 1 445 006 | 160 303 | 1 605 309 | 75 461 | -30 295 | 1 650 475 |
| Other | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| Total operating revenues | 1 445 006 | 160 303 | 1 605 309 | 75 461 | -30 295 | 1 650 475 |
| Operating charges | ||||||
| Direct costs excl. direct commercial costs | -533 994 | -84 200 | -618 194 | -39 000 | 23 695 | -633 494 |
| Direct commercial costs | -120 500 | -3 100 | -123 600 | -1 200 | 0 | -124 800 |
| Direct costs | -654 494 | -87 300 | -741 794 | -40 200 | 23 695 | -758 294 |
| Direct margin | 790 512 | 73 003 | 863 515 | 35 261 | -6 600 | 892 176 |
| % Operating revenues | 63.8% | 45.5% | 61.7% | 53.9% | 41.8% | 61.5% |
| Indirect production costs | -109 000 | -37 342 | -146 342 | -8 782 | 6 600 | -148 524 |
| Information technology | -41 700 | -3 700 | -45 400 | -600 | 0 | -46 000 |
| Communication, Marketing & Product development | -29 000 | -13 000 | -42 000 | -3 200 | 0 | -45 200 |
| Indirect customer facing costs | -87 700 | -24 300 | -112 000 | -7 900 | 0 | -119 900 |
| General and administration costs | -30 800 | -4 400 | -35 200 | -3 300 | 0 | -38 500 |
| Indirect costs | -298 200 | -82 742 | -380 942 | -23 782 | 6 600 | -398 124 |
| EBITDA | 492 312 | -9 739 | 482 573 | 11 480 | 0 | 494 053 |
| % EBITDA on operating revenues | 34.5% | 17.6% | -0.2% | 34.1% | ||
| Depreciations | -193 889 | -15 438 | -209 327 | -7 886 | 0 | -217 214 |
| EBIT | 298 423 | -25 177 | 273 246 | 3 593 | 0 | 276 839 |
| Financial income | 584 | 18 | -105 | 497 | ||
| Financial costs | -10 974 | -317 | 105 | -11 186 | ||
| Profit before taxes | 262 856 | 3 294 | 0 | 266 150 | ||
| Tax expense | -80 339 | -126 | 0 | -80 465 | ||
| Net profit of the period (*) | 182 517 | 3 168 | 0 | 185 685 | ||
| Profit attributable to equity holders of the parent | 182 517 | 3 168 | 0 | 185 685 |
(*) Since there are no discontinued operations, the profit of the period corresponds to the result of continued operations.
| 2011 | 31.12.2011 Belgium |
31.12.2011 Luxembourg |
Interco elimination |
Mobistar Group |
||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mobile | Non-Mobile | Total | Total | Total | Total | |
| Operating revenues | ||||||
| Network & other operating revenues (service revenues) | 1 288 096 | 168 319 | 1 456 416 | 60 660 | -11 229 | 1 505 846 |
| Handsets sales | 154 626 | 0 | 154 626 | 5 064 | -7 956 | 151 734 |
| Total turnover | 1 442 722 | 168 319 | 1 611 042 | 65 724 | -19 186 | 1 657 580 |
| Other | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| Total operating revenues | 1 442 722 | 168 319 | 1 611 042 | 65 724 | -19 186 | 1 657 580 |
| Operating charges | ||||||
| Direct costs excl. direct commercial costs | -480 623 | -90 070 | -570 693 | -39 306 | 19 186 | -590 813 |
| Direct commercial costs | -115 300 | -10 000 | -125 300 | 0 | 0 | -125 300 |
| Direct costs | -595 923 | -100 070 | -695 993 | -39 306 | 19 186 | -716 113 |
| Direct margin | 846 799 | 68 249 | 915 048 | 26 419 | 0 | 941 467 |
| % Operating revenues | 65.7% | 40.5% | 62.8% | 43.6% | 0.0% | 62.5% |
| Indirect production costs | -106 299 | -41 900 | -148 199 | -6 573 | 0 | -154 772 |
| Information technology | -35 400 | -3 800 | -39 200 | -2 177 | 0 | -41 377 |
| Communication, Marketing & Product development | -28 400 | -13 200 | -41 600 | -1 747 | 0 | -43 347 |
| Indirect customer facing costs | -88 300 | -27 300 | -115 600 | -5 431 | 0 | -121 031 |
| General and administration costs | -42 400 | -6 399 | -48 799 | -2 058 | 0 | -50 857 |
| Indirect costs | -300 799 | -92 599 | -393 398 | -17 985 | 0 | -411 383 |
| EBITDA | 546 000 | -24 350 | 521 650 | 8 434 | 0 | 530 084 |
| % EBITDA on operating revenues | 35.8% | 14.0% | -0.4% | 35.2% | ||
| Depreciations | -168 784 | -11 173 | -179 957 | -10 382 | 0 | -190 339 |
| EBIT | 377 216 | -35 523 | 341 693 | -1 948 | 0 | 339 745 |
| Financial income | 1 077 | 8 | -172 | 914 | ||
| Financial costs | -11 553 | -405 | 172 | -11 786 | ||
| Profit before taxes | 331 217 | -2 345 | 0 | 328 873 | ||
| Tax expense | -109 565 | 1 713 | 0 | -107 852 | ||
| Net profit of the period (*) | 221 652 | -631 | 0 | 221 021 | ||
| Profit attributable to equity holders of the parent | 221 652 | -631 | 0 | 221 021 |
(*) Since there are no discontinued operations, the profit of the period corresponds to the result of continued operations.
| 31.12.2012 2012 Belgium |
31.12.2012 Luxembourg |
Interco elimination |
Mobistar Group |
||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mobile | Fix | Unallocated | Total | Total | |||
| Goodwill | 11 351 | 11 351 | 68 574 | 155 | 80 080 | ||
| Intangible and tangible assets | 887 855 | 38 389 | 926 244 | 25 361 | 951 605 | ||
| Financial assets | 87 017 | 87 017 | -87 017 | 0 | |||
| Interests in associates | 3 450 | 3 450 | 3 450 | ||||
| Deferred taxes assets | 3 431 | 3 431 | 3 238 | 6 669 | |||
| Other non-current assets | 3 722 | 84 | 3 806 | 159 | 3 965 | ||
| Inventories | 17 472 | 1 324 | 18 796 | 1 798 | 20 594 | ||
| Trade receivable | 174 270 | 43 810 | 218 080 | 14 564 | -2 475 | 230 168 | |
| Other current assets | 30 708 | 5 529 | 6 330 | 42 567 | 764 | -5 132 | 38 199 |
| Cash and cash equivalent | 10 900 | 10 900 | 1 366 | 12 266 | |||
| Segment assets | 1 136 277 | 89 051 | 100 313 | 1 325 641 | 115 823 | -94 470 | 1 346 995 |
| Long-term interests-bearing borrowings | 383 650 | 383 650 | 383 650 | ||||
| Long-term provisions | 53 196 | 11 223 | 64 419 | 2 956 | 67 375 | ||
| Long-term payable | 13 447 | 13 447 | 13 447 | ||||
| Financial liabilities | 22 580 | 22 580 | 5 112 | -5 112 | 22 580 | ||
| Trade payables | 287 657 | 47 957 | 335 614 | 11 424 | -2 475 | 344 563 | |
| Taxes | 2 508 | 215 | 39 020 | 41 742 | 967 | 42 709 | |
| Salaries and social security | 29 084 | 4 620 | 33 705 | 680 | 34 385 | ||
| Deferred income | 68 365 | 7 618 | 205 | 76 188 | 1 283 | -20 | 77 451 |
| Other current liabilities | 3 | 3 032 | 3 035 | 3 035 | |||
| Segment liabilities | 454 260 | 71 633 | 448 487 | 974 381 | 22 423 | -7 608 | 989 196 |
| Capital expenditure | 168 456 | 14 138 | 182 594 | 5 648 | 188 242 | ||
| Depreciation and amortisation | 156 363 | 15 438 | 171 801 | 7 886 | 179 688 | ||
| Impairment losses recognised in profit or loss | 37 526 | 37 526 | 37 526 |
| 2011 | 31.12.2011 Belgium |
31.12.2011 Luxembourg |
Interco elimination |
Mobistar Group |
|||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mobile | Fix | Unallocated | Total | Total | |||
| Goodwill | 11 351 | 11 351 | 68 574 | 155 | 80 080 | ||
| Intangible and tangible assets | 911 168 | 39 412 | 950 580 | 27 445 | 978 026 | ||
| Financial assets | 87 017 | 87 017 | -87 017 | 0 | |||
| Deferred taxes assets | 3 038 | 3 038 | 3 363 | 6 401 | |||
| Other non-current assets | 5 556 | 83 | 5 640 | 178 | 5 818 | ||
| Inventories | 12 595 | 2 243 | 14 838 | 1 663 | 16 501 | ||
| Trade receivable | 160 412 | 50 348 | 210 760 | 16 967 | -2 477 | 225 251 | |
| Other current assets | 49 242 | 10 897 | 12 999 | 73 138 | 433 | -11 263 | 62 308 |
| Cash and cash equivalent | 3 825 | 3 825 | 3 294 | 7 119 | |||
| Segment assets | 1 154 149 | 102 900 | 103 137 | 1 360 186 | 121 918 | -100 602 | 1 381 503 |
| Long-term interests-bearing borrowings | 293 200 | 293 200 | 293 200 | ||||
| Long-term provisions | 46 343 | 12 668 | 59 011 | 2 584 | 61 595 | ||
| Long-term payable | 28 321 | 28 321 | 28 321 | ||||
| Deferred taxes | 1 176 | 1 176 | 1 176 | ||||
| Financial liabilities | 18 444 | 18 444 | 11 233 | -11 233 | 18 444 | ||
| Trade payables | 268 384 | 66 880 | 335 263 | 14 848 | -2 477 | 347 635 | |
| Taxes | 7 | 807 | 111 999 | 112 813 | 924 | 113 737 | |
| Salaries and social security | 26 910 | 4 967 | 31 877 | 978 | 32 855 | ||
| Deferred income | 77 518 | 8 874 | 352 | 86 744 | 1 120 | -30 | 87 833 |
| Other current liabilities | 253 | 2 482 | 2 736 | 2 736 | |||
| Segment liabilities | 447 735 | 94 196 | 427 653 | 969 584 | 31 687 | -13 740 | 987 532 |
| Capital expenditure | 175 021 | 22 326 | 197 347 | 6 392 | 203 739 | ||
| Depreciation and amortisation | 156 347 | 11 173 | 167 520 | 10 382 | 177 902 | ||
| Impairment losses recognised in profit or loss | 12 437 | 12 437 | 12 437 |
21. Interests in the joint venture 'Irisnet' (in 000 euros)
The interests in the joint venture 'Irisnet' have been recognised using the line-by-line reporting format in the proportionate consolidation method up to 31 December 2012 in the consolidated statement of comprehensive income.
At the beginning of November 2012, the temporary association Irisnet stopped its activities. The activities of Irisnet have been taken over by a newly created company (IRISnet S.C.R.L.). Irisnet will just continue to collect its outstanding receivables balances open as of 31st of October 2012 and complete the legal liquidation of the temporary association. Based on the fact that the temporary association stopped its activities, Mobistar has decided to include in the 2012 closing all necessary provisions regarding the legal liquidation of the temporary association. This review has allowed the Group to record 9.8 million euros of additional income in the fourth quarter of 2012.
Aggregate amounts, including intercompany transactions, related to the interests held in the joint venture are detailed as follows:
| 31.12.2012 | 31.12.2011 | |
|---|---|---|
| Non-current assets | 8 | |
| Current assets | 7 371 | |
| Total assets | 0 | 7 379 |
| Equity | -11 941 | |
| Current liabilities | 19 320 | |
| Total equity and liabilities | 0 | 7 379 |
| Income | 5 018 | |
| Expenses | 5 214 |
Related party relationships between Mobistar and the joint venture have been recognised in the financial statements as follows:
| 31.12.2012 | 31.12.2011 | |
|---|---|---|
| Assets and liabilities | ||
| Current assets - trade receivables | 20 280 | |
| Current liabilities - trade payables | 7 719 | |
| Current liabilities - deferred income | 12 561 | |
| Income and charges | ||
| Sales | 5 123 | |
| Purchases | 5 123 |
Statutory auditor's report
to the Shareholders' Meeting on the consolidated financial statements for the year ended 31 December 2012
To the shareholders
As required by law, we report to you on the performance of our mandate of statutory auditor. This report includes our report on the consolidated financial statements as defined below together with our report on other legal and regulatory requirements.
Report on the consolidated financial statements – Unqualified opinion
We have audited the accompanying consolidated financial statements of Mobistar S.A. ("the company") and its subsidiaries (jointly "the Group"), prepared in accordance with International Financial Reporting Standards as adopted by the European Union and with the legal and regulatory requirements applicable in Belgium. These consolidated financial statements comprise the consolidated balance sheet as at 31 December 2012, the consolidated statement of comprehensive income, the consolidated statement of change in equity and the consolidated cash flow statement for the year then ended, as well as the summary of significant accounting policies and other explanatory notes. The consolidated financial statements show total assets of 1,346,995 (000) EUR and the consolidated statement of comprehensive income shows a consolidated profit (Group share) for the year then ended of 185,685 (000) EUR.
Responsibility of the Board of Directors for the preparation of the consolidated financial statements
The Board of Directors is responsible for the preparation and fair presentation of consolidated financial statements in accordance with International Financial Reporting Standards as adopted by the European Union and with the legal and regulatory requirements applicable in Belgium, and for such internal control as the Board of Directors determines is necessary to enable the preparation of consolidated financial statements that are free from material misstatement, whether due to fraud or error.
Statutory auditor's responsibility
Our responsibility is to express an opinion on these consolidated financial statements based on our audit. We conducted our audit in accordance with International Standards on Auditing. Those standards require that we comply with ethical requirements and plan and perform the audit to obtain reasonable assurance about whether the consolidated financial statements are free from material misstatement.
An audit involves performing procedures to obtain audit evidence about the amounts and disclosures in the consolidated financial statements. The procedures selected depend on the statutory auditor's judgment, including the assessment of the risks of material misstatement of the consolidated financial statements, whether due to fraud or error. In making those risk assessments, the auditor considers internal control relevant to the Group's preparation and fair presentation of the consolidated financial statements in order to design audit procedures that are appropriate in the circumstances, but not for the purpose of expressing an opinion on the effectiveness of the Group's internal control. An audit also includes evaluating the appropriateness of accounting policies used and the reasonableness of accounting estimates made by the Board of Directors, as well as evaluating the overall presentation of the consolidated financial statements. We have obtained from the company's officials and the Board of Directors the explanations and information necessary for performing our audit.
We believe that the audit evidence we have obtained is sufficient and appropriate to provide a basis for our opinion.
Unqualified opinion
In our opinion, the consolidated financial statements of Mobistar S.A. give a true and fair view of the Group's net equity and financial position as of 31 December 2012, and of its results and its cash flows for the year then ended, in accordance with International Financial Reporting Standards as adopted by the European Union and with the legal and regulatory requirements applicable in Belgium.
Report on other legal and regulatory requirements
The Board of Directors is responsible for the preparation and the content of the directors' report on the consolidated financial statements.
In the framework of our mandate, our responsibility is to verify, for all significant aspects, the compliance with some legal and regulatory requirements. On this basis, we provide the following additional comment which does not modify the scope of our audit opinion on the consolidated financial statements:
• The directors' report on the consolidated financial statements includes the information required by law, is, for all significant aspects, in agreement with the consolidated financial statements and is not in obvious contradiction with any information obtained in the performance of our mandate.
Diegem, 22 March 2013
The statutory auditor DELOITTE Bedrijfsrevisoren / Reviseurs d'Entreprises BV o.v.v.e. CVBA / SC s.f.d. SCRL Represented by Rik Neckebroeck
Declaration by the responsible persons
153
Declaration by the responsible persons
We, the undersigned, Jean Marc Harion, CEO, and Werner De Laet, CFO, declare that to our knowledge:
a) the financial statements drawn up in accordance with the prevailing accounting standards, give a true and fair view of the company's assets, liabilities, financial position and results of the issuer and the companies included within its consolidation;
b) the management report contains an accurate overview of the business activities evolution, the results and the financial situation of the issuer and the companies included within its consolidation, and a description of the main risks and uncertainties they are confronted to.
Jean Marc Harion Werner De Laet CEO CFO
Notes
FOR MORE INFORMATION,
PLEASE CONTACT: Siddy Jobe For the shareholders and analysts e-mail: [email protected]
Patti Verdoodt Mathieu Van Overstraeten For the press e-mail: [email protected]
FINANCIAL DIRECTOR Werner De Laet
RESPONSIBLE EDITOR Olivier Ysewijn
COORDINATION
Marco Demerling Sabine Desmette Nathalie Kervyn Anne-Catherine Scufl aire CONCEPT & LAYOUT Cypres
PRINTING Drukkerij Daneels bvba
PICTURES Mobistar, Karel Duerinckx
MOBISTAR S.A.
Avenue du Bourget 3 Be-1140 Brussels Belgium
Tel. +32 2 745 71 11 Fax +32 2 745 70 00 www.mobistar.be
RCB 599 402 VAT Be 0456 810 810 Ce rapport annuel est également disponible en français. Dit jaarverslag is ook verkrijgbaar in het Nederlands. C006748
Mobistar • Avenue du Bourget 3 • BE 1140 Bruxelles • Tel.: +32 2 745 71 11 [email protected] • www.mobistar.be • business.mobistar.be corporate.mobistar.be
© 2013, Mobistar, all rights reserved. Mobistar is a registered trademark. The trademarks of commercial products mentioned in this document are registered and are the property of their various manufacturers. The characteristics of the products and services mentioned in this document may be changed at any time without notice. Mobistar cannot be held liable for printing errors in this document. The products of other manufacturers are mentioned for information. The manufacturers are solely liable for any and all warranties concerning their products. Mobistar cannot be held liable under any circumstances for data transmission services, nor for the content, legality or accessibility of these services, nor for the use made of them by the customer, whether these services are provided by third parties or by Mobistar.