Governance Information • Mar 27, 2020
Governance Information
Open in ViewerOpens in native device viewer
Report on corporate governance and ownership structures

Document approved by the Board of Directors on 12 March 2020
Banca IFIS S.p.A.- Registered office in Via Terraglio 63, 30174 Mestre, Venice - Registration number in the Companies Registered of Venice and Tax Code 02505630109 – VAT number 04570150278 – REA (Administrative Economic Index) number: VE – 0247118 – Fully paid-up share capital Euro 53.811.095 – Registry of Banks no. 5508 – Parent Company of the Banca IFIS Banking Group S.p.A., enrolled in the registry Banking Groups – Member of the Interbank Deposit Protection Fund, of the Italian Banking Association, of the Italian Factoring Association, of Factors Chain International. Member of the National Compensation Fund.
| Glossary | 3 |
|---|---|
| 1. Profile of the Issuer |
4 |
| Profile and structure | 4 |
| Shareholders | 6 |
| Corporate governance model | 6 |
| Shareholders' Meeting | 7 |
| Board of Directors | 8 |
| Board committees | 8 |
| Board of Statutory Auditors | 9 |
| 2. Information on ownership interests as at 31st December 2019 |
10 |
| 2.1 Structure of the share capital | 10 |
| 2.2 Restrictions on the transfer of titles | 10 |
| 2.3 Relevant equity investments | 10 |
| 2.4 Titles that confer special rights | 11 |
| 2.5 Employee ownership scheme: a mechanism for the exercise of voting rights | 11 |
| 2.6 Restrictions to voting rights | 11 |
| 2.7 Agreements between shareholders | 11 |
| 2.8 Change of control clauses and takeover-related provisions of the Articles of Association | 11 |
| 2.9 Proxies for increase of the share capital and authorisations for the acquisition of treasury shares | 11 |
| 2.10 Management and administration activities | 11 |
| 3. Compliance |
12 |
| 4. Board of Directors |
12 |
| 4.1 Appointment and replacement | 12 |
| Succession plans | 14 |
| 4.2 Composition | 14 |
| Diversity criteria and policies | 20 |
| Maximum number of posts held in other companies | 21 |
| Induction Programme | 24 |
| 4.3 Role of the Board of Directors | 25 |
| Meetings and operation | 25 |
| Tasks | 26 |
| Self-assessment | 28 |
| 4.4. Delegated bodies | 29 |
| Chief Executive Officers | 29 |
| President of the Board of Directors | 32 |
| Information to the Board | 32 |
|---|---|
| 4.5. Other Executive Directors | 33 |
| 4.6. Independent Directors | 33 |
| 4.7. Lead Independent Director | 34 |
| 5. Processing corporate information | 34 |
| 6. Internal Board Committees | 34 |
| 7. Appointments Committee | 35 |
| Composition and role of the Appointments Committee | 36 |
| Duties of the Appointments Committee | 36 |
| 8. Remuneration Committee | 37 |
| 9. Directors' Remuneration | 37 |
| 10. Risk Management and Internal Control Committee | 37 |
| Composition | 38 |
| Duties of the Risk Management and Internal Control Committee | 38 |
| 11. Risk management and internal control system | 40 |
| a. Key characteristics of the current risk management and internal control systems in relation to the financial reporting process |
42 |
| a.1. Introduction | 42 |
| a.2. Description of key characteristics of the current risk management and internal control systems in relation to the financial reporting process (the "System") |
43 |
| a.2.1 Phases of the risk management process regarding inaccurate financial reporting | 43 |
| a.2.2 Roles and Departments involved | 44 |
| 11.1. Director in charge of the risk management and internal control system | 45 |
| 11.2. Head of the Internal Audit Department | 45 |
| 11.3. Organisational Model ex-(It.) Legislative Decree no. 231/2001 | 47 |
| 11.4. External Auditor | 49 |
| 11.5. Financial Reporting Officer responsible for preparing company accounts and other roles and company functions | 49 |
| 11.6. Coordination between individuals involved in the risk management and internal control system | 50 |
| 12. Directors' interests and related-party transactions | 52 |
| 13. Appointment of Statutory Auditors | 53 |
| 14. Composition and role of the Board of Statutory Auditors | 54 |
| Diversity criteria and policies | 58 |
| 15. Relations with shareholders | 60 |
| 16. Shareholders' Meetings | 61 |
| 17. Further corporate governance practices | 62 |
| 18. Changes since the end of the reference financial year | 63 |
| 19. Considerations on the letter dated 19th December 2019 from the President of the Corporate Governance Committee | 63 |
Code/Corporate Governance Code: the "Corporate Governance Code for Listed Companies", version applicable as of July 2018, approved by the Corporate Governance Committee and promoted by Borsa Italiana S.p.A., ABI [Italian Banking Association], ANIA [Italian National Association of Insurance Companies], Assogestioni [National Association of Asset Management Companies], Assonime [Association for Italian Public Limited Companies] and Confindustria [Italian Manufacturing Companies Association].
Civil Code/C.C.: the (It.) Civil Code.
Board: the Issuer's Board of Directors.
Issuer: the issuer of securities to which the Report refers.
Financial Year: the corporate financial year to which the Report refers.
CONSOB Issuer Regulation: the Regulation issued by CONSOB [Italian Securities and Exchange Commission] with decision no. 11971 of 1999 (as subsequently amended) on issuers.
CONSOB Market Regulation: the Regulation issued by CONSOB with decision no. 20249 of 2017 on markets.
CONSOB Related Parties Regulation: the Regulation issued by CONSOB with decision no. 17221 of 12th March 2010 (as subsequently amended) on transactions with related parties.
Report: the report on corporate governance and company shareholding structure that companies are obliged to prepare pursuant to Article 123-bis of the Consolidated Law on Finance.
Consolidated Law on Finance (TUF): (It.) Legislative Decree of 24th February 1998, no. 58, as subsequently amended.
Consolidated Law on Banking (TUB): (It.) Legislative Decree of 1st September 1993, no. 385, as subsequently amended.
Banca IFIS is subject to the provisions contained in the Supervisory Provisions issued by the Bank of Italy (Circular no. 285/2013) and, in particular, with regard to the matter of corporate governance pursuant to the provisions contained in the aforementioned Circular in Part I, Heading IV, Chapter 1. It is qualified as a bank of larger size or operational complexity, as it is listed and included in the Less Significant Institutions that are supervised directly by the Bank of Italy. Banca IFIS does not fall under the definition of SME, pursuant to Article 1, paragraph 1, letter w-quarter. 1) of the TUF and Article 2-ter of the CONSOB Issuer Regulation.
Since 2001, the company has adopted the Corporate Governance Code, of which the current "applicable" version is that of July 2018. The Code is accessible to the public on the website of the Corporate Governance Committee (http://www.borsaitaliana.it/comitatocorporate-governance/codice/2018clean.pdf).
The Code indicates the corporate governance standards and best practices recommended to Italian listed companies by the Corporate Governance Committee, to be applied in accordance with the "comply or explain" principle, which requires companies to explain in their corporate governance report the reasons for a possible failure to comply with one or more recommendations contained in the principles or the application criteria.
The Committee drafts, annually, a Report on the Code's application, accompanied by a letter by the President of the Corporate Governance Committee, which indicates the possible areas of improvement with regard to the governance of listed companies.
The principal areas identified in 2019, which become "Recommendations of the Committee for 2020" are:
sustainability, understood as general and strategic profile for business activity;
the quality of the information provided to the Board of Directors;
the quality of the independence assessments, understood as a fundamental element for the efficient operation of the corporate governance system outlined by the Code;
the suitability of the remuneration of Non Executive Directors and of the members of the Supervisory Board, also in light of a comparative analysis.
The letter of the President of the Committee and the annual report formed the subject of a specific information notice by the Vice-President of the Board of Directors (meeting of 13th January 2020).
Banca IFIS drafts, once a year, the Report on Corporate Governance and Shareholding Structure; this document was approved by the Board of Directors in the meeting of 12th March 2020 and was published, at the same time as the Management Report, on the company's website.
Unless otherwise specified, the information contained in the Report refers to the date of its approval.
Banca IFIS is the parent company of Banca IFIS Banking Group, an active player in specialty finance. Its core businesses are the offer of lending services and solutions to undertakings, and acquiring/servicing non-performing loan portfolios.
The increasing ability to provide financial support to small and medium enterprises and to transform insolvent individuals into solvent debtors and potential receivers of new credit, as well as the continuous increase of the number of its employees, complete the Group's ability to meet the expectations of its stakeholders.
Banca IFIS is a company that, since 2003, has been listed in the Milan Stock Exchange (STAR segment); aside from banking, it manages and coordinates the financial and related companies that belong to Banca IFIS Group and are controlled, directly and indirectly, by the bank.

As at 31/12/2019, the following companies are also members of the Banking Group:
Furthermore, Banca IFIS S.p.A. controls IFIS Rental Services S.r.l., an unregulated company specialising in the operating lease segment, not included in the Banking Group. In this context, please note that, on 26th June 2019, the entire
investment in the company Two Solar Park 2008 S.r.l., which operates in the sector of energy generation from renewable sources, was sold to third parties.
As at 31st December 2019, the share capital of Banca IFIS is represented by 53,811,095 ordinary shares of a par value of €1, issued in book-entry form, indivisible and freely transferable.
Banca IFIS adopts the traditional model of administration and control, believing it to be the most suitable for its business to ensure efficient administration and effective control.
For Banca IFIS, the traditional model of administration and control has so far yielded good results in terms of creating value for shareholders, strengthening capital and ensuring financial balance. The stability of the Bank and the Group, which is also evident from the comprehensive and fruitful dialogue with the Supervisory Authorities, has, in turn, confirmed the choice of the traditional model.
The traditional model appears, including from a future viewpoint, to be the most suitable to secure a harmonious and orderly development for the Group, in that it places strategic supervision, administration and control skills within a structure that has so far proved to be effective and efficient, facilitating a clear definition of responsibilities, a streamlined decision-making process and effective dialogue between the bodies themselves.
Under the model adopted by Banca IFIS:

The Shareholders' Meeting is a decision-making collective body composed of the shareholders of the Bank and/or their representatives; its decisions, adopted in accordance with the Law and the Articles of Association, are binding for all shareholders, even if they are absent or of a different opinion. The Shareholders' Meeting is ordinary and extraordinary pursuant to the Law and may be convoked also outside the company's registered office, as long as it is held in the country.
The ordinary Shareholders' Meeting is convoked at least once a year, within 120 days from the end of the financial year, to deliberate on the matters under its purview, as per the regulatory framework in force and the Bank's Articles of Association.
In particular, the ordinary Shareholders' Meeting:
applicable legal and regulatory provisions pro tempore (currently equal to 200%, a ratio of 2:1). The proposal may be deemed to have been approved validly with the majority envisaged by the regulatory framework that applies at any given time.
The extraordinary Shareholders' Meeting deliberates on amendments to the Articles of Association and on other matters under its purview in accordance with the Articles of Association or the law.
The Shareholders' Meeting is, usually, chaired by the President of the Board of Directors; the Shareholders' Meeting may hear shareholders with voting rights who have sent to the Company, by the end of the third business day before that fixed for the first-call Shareholders' Meeting, the communication of the authorised intermediary, attesting their legitimation.
The Company is managed by a Board of Directors made up of five to fifteen members, elected by the Shareholders' Meeting. On 12th March 2020, the number of directors elected by the Shareholders' Meeting of 19th April 2019 stood at 12; their mandate will expire on the date of the Shareholders' Meeting convoked for the approval of the 2021 financial statements.
The appointment of the members is based on lists presented by the shareholders; candidates are listed in sequential order and their number must not exceed the maximum number of Members established by the Articles of Association. Only shareholders who, alone or together with others, own at least 1% of ordinary shares at the time of submission have the right to submit lists.
The Articles of Association set forth that: at least one quarter of the members must fulfil the requirements of independence and such members must be placed, on the list, among the first four posts of the sequential order; at least one third of candidates must belong to the least represented gender, an exception being made for lists that present fewer than three candidates; one director must be taken from the second list by number of votes.
The Board elects a President and may elect a Vice-President; in addition, it appoints a Chief Executive Officer, tasked with performing the company's operations with the aim of following the lead and achieving the strategic corporate objectives decided by the Board of Directors, and establishes their management powers.
Also in compliance with the provision of the Corporate Governance Code, three committees have been established within the Board of Directors; these committees, which have powers of investigation, consultation and proposal, allow the body tasked with strategic supervision to adopt its decisions with a better knowledge of the facts:
The composition, operation and powers of the Board Committees are regulated by the Regulation of each individual Committee and the General Regulation.
The Board of Statutory Auditors is composed of three standing and two alternate auditors. They are appointed based on lists presented by the shareholders, in which the candidates are listed in sequential order; their number may not exceed that of the members of the body to be elected. Each list is made up of two sections, one for candidates for the standing auditor post and one for candidates for the alternate auditor post. The mandate of the Statutory Auditors will expire on the date of the Shareholders' Meeting convoked to approve the 2021 financial statements.
The Articles of Association envisage that two standing auditors and one alternate will be elected from the list that obtained the majority of votes; one standing auditor and one alternate will be elected from the second list in number of votes. The standing auditor elected from the minority list shall be declared President of the Board of Statutory Auditors.
The means of operation and the powers of the Board of Statutory Auditors are regulated by the Articles of Association and the General Regulation.
On 31st December 2019, the capital subscribed and paid up amounted to €53,811,095.00, subdivided in 53,811,095 ordinary shares of a par value of €1, as shown in Table 1 below:
Table 1
| STRUCTURE OF THE SHARE CAPITAL | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Number of shares |
% with regard to the share capital |
Listed (market) unlisted |
Rights and obligations |
|
| Ordinary shares | 53,811,095 | 100% | Listed (MTA) | Each ordinary share grants the right to one vote |
As at 31st December 2019, no other financial instruments that attribute the right to subscribe newly-issued shares had been issued.
For own shares to be attributed as variable remuneration to the Chief Executive Officer and the General Manager and, possibly, to other employees on the list of "Key Personnel", please see the Report on remuneration, drafted pursuant to Article 123-ter of the TUF, and the Document of information on compensation plans based on financial instruments drafted pursuant to Article 114 bis of the TUF and 84 bis of the CONSOB Issuer Regulation; the documents are available on the website www.bancaifis.it under "Shareholders' Meeting" and "Remuneration" and implement the amendments decided by the extraordinary Shareholders' Meeting of 19/12/2019.
There are no restrictions on the transfer of shares, save the retention periods foreseen for the shares to be allocated as variable pay to the C.E.O.,to the General Manager and to any other employees considered "Key Personnel". For details on the shares to be assigned to such company personnel, please see the Report on remuneration drafted pursuant to Article 123-ter of the TUF.
Based on the communications made pursuant to article 120 of the TUF, and on the communications made by Key Personnel pursuant to Article 152-octies of the CONSOB Issuer Regulation, Table 2 below shows the persons who, as at 31st December 2019, directly or indirectly own shares with voting rights exceeding 3% of the share capital.
Table 2
| Declarant | Direct shareholder | Share % on ordinary capital |
Share % on voting capital |
|---|---|---|---|
| FÜRSTENBERG SEBASTIEN EGON | La Scogliera S.p.A. | 50.400% | 50.400% |
| Fürstenberg Sebastien Egon | 0.009% | 0.009% |
We believe that it is worth pointing out that:
No titles that confer special controlling rights have been issued.
Any employees holding shares of the Company exercise their shareholder rights in the same way as other shareholders.
On the approval date of the Report, the company did not have restrictions to voting rights.
No agreements between the company's shareholders exist at the Board of Directors of Banca IFIS S.p.A., pursuant to Article 122 of the TUF. Conversely, the Bank has stipulated, on acquisition, shareholder agreements with the minority shareholders of Credifarma.
Banca IFIS knows of no significant agreements between its shareholders that take effect, are modified or cease in the event of a change in control of its contracting company.
However, with reference to restrictions on the transfer of shares, please note that the agreements stipulated between Banca IFIS and Federfarma on acquisition of control of Credifarma S.p.A. by the Bank set forth that the two shareholders may not transfer, in whole or in part, the Credifarma shares they hold at any given time until expiry of the 5th year following the date on which the agreement was stipulated; one of the Parties may transfer shares to companies it controls.
The Articles of Association of Banca IFIS S.p.A. do not contain derogations from the provisions on the passivity rule of Article 104 paragraphs 1 and 1-bis of the TUF, nor do they envisage the application of the neutralisation rules set forth by Article 104 bis, paragraphs 2 and 3 of the TUF.
As at 31st December 2019, no proxies for the increase of the share capital pursuant to Article 2443 of the (It.) Civil Code or for the issue of equity financial instruments had been conferred to the Board.
The Shareholders' Meeting did not authorise the acquisition of treasury shares, pursuant to Articles 2357 et seq. of the (It.) Civil Code and Article 132 of (It.) Legislative Decree 58/98.
La Scogliera S.p.A., despite being a majority shareholder, does not manage and coordinate Banca IFIS S.p.A. In this regard, as mentioned above, please note that the corporate object of La Scogliera S.p.A. expressly excludes the activities of management and administration of the financial companies and banks in which it participates.
Please note that:
Banca IFIS is the Parent Company of the Banking Group and controls, other than the companies that belong to said group, also other companies that form part of the so-called Economic Group.
Pursuant to the TUB, it manages and coordinates the companies that belong to the Banking Group and issues them with the directives necessary for the transposition of the decisions of the Parent Company in the controlled companies.
In addition and pursuant to Articles 2497 et seq. of the (It.) Civil Code, it manages and coordinates the companies that belong to the Economic Group.
Banca IFIS S.p.A. has adopted the Corporate Governance Code for Listed Companies, as indicated under point 1.0, Issuer Profile.
The Corporate Governance structure of Banca IFIS is not influenced by the provisions of non-Italian laws.
IFIS Finance Sp. z o.o., a factoring company 100% owned by the Issuer, is a Polish legal entity and is therefore subject to Polish legislation. However, this in no way affects Banca IFIS S.p.A.'s Corporate Governance structure because of the subsidiary's limited size in relation to the Parent Company.
Strategic supervision is performed by the Board of Directors, which, pursuant to the Provisions, is called upon to decide on the strategic guidance of the bank and to continuously check that it is implemented.
The Articles of Association envisage that the Directors are appointed based on the mechanism of voting lists by the Shareholders' Meeting, in compliance with the applicable legal and regulatory provisions (professionalism and authoritativeness) and in compliance with the composition criteria that relate to the presence of minority and independent directors, with respect for gender balance.
In order to encourage that the best candidates are put forward for the renewal of the Administrative Body, in support of the Shareholders and in compliance with the Vigilance Provisions for banks in matters of Corporate Governance, the Board of Directors identifies preventively what is deemed its optimal qualitative-quantitative composition, identified and justifying the theoretical profile of candidates. The analyses performed are reported in the document "Optimal qualitative-quantitative composition of the Board of Directors of Banca IFIS", approved by the Board of Directors on 11th February 2019 and published on the bank's website, together with the documentation concerning the Shareholders' Meeting of 8th March 2019, so that the assessments made by the outgoing BoD could reach the Shareholders, leaving them time to present the lists.
The bank's organisational and governance structures must guarantee conditions of healthy and prudent management, the objective of the regulation, of the supervisory bodies and of all stakeholders; therefore, the composition of the administrative body is of paramount importance for the efficient performance of the tasks entrusted thereto by law, by the supervision provisions and by the Articles of Association.
The candidates are listed in sequential order and their number may not, in any case, exceed the maximum number of members set forth by the Articles of Association (fifteen). The right to present a list is only granted to shareholders who, at the time of delivery of the list, own, alone or jointly, a stake of at least 1% of ordinary shares or other minimum ownership threshold that - pursuant to the applicable regulatory framework - must be indicated in the notice of convocation of the Shareholders' Meeting which is called upon to deliberate on the appointment of the members of the Board of Directors.
A shareholder may not present or vote more than one lists, even through a third party or a trust company. Shareholders belonging to the same group and shareholders who have stipulated a shareholder agreement related to shares of the Company may not present or vote more than one lists, even through a third party or a trust company. A candidate may only be present on one list, on pain of ineligibility.
The lists are deposited at the registered office of the Company by the twenty-fifth day before the date of the first-call Shareholders' Meeting and are made available to the pubic at the registered office of the company, on the Company's website and by the other means set forth by the applicable regulatory framework, at least twenty days before the date of the first-call Shareholders' Meeting.
In order to prove the ownership of the number of shares necessary to present the lists, the shareholders may produce the related certificate even after the deposit, on the condition that this is done within the deadline foreseen for the publication of the lists by the Company.
The lists must be accompanied:
Candidates who do not meet the requirements of integrity, professionalism and independence established by Article 26 of (It.) Legislative Decree no. 385/1993 cannot be included on lists. It should be noted that the legislation implementing Article 26 of the Italian Consolidated Banking Act (TUB) – for which definitive approval is awaited – is also based on the contents of the ECB's Fit and Proper Assessment Guidelines, proposing the introduction of new parameters for the suitability of corporate officers, including: the criteria of fairness, experience, independence of mind and independence from members of management bodies, as well as integrity and professionalism.
Each list must also indicate:
Members of the Board of Directors are elected as follows:
Should this selection criteria fail to ensure proper gender balance to the extent established on a case by case basis by Italian Law, a sliding mechanism is applied to the selection from the list which obtained, during the Shareholders' Meeting, the highest number of votes based on the sequential order in which the candidates are indicated. This mechanism excludes the candidate or candidates of the most represented gender and selects the candidate or candidates of the unrepresented gender.
If just one list of candidates is submitted, the names indicated on that list will be elected as Members of the Board of Directors, up to the number of Directors to be elected less one, who shall be elected by the Shareholders' Meeting there and then, based on a simple majority but excluding from the vote the shareholders who submitted the single list, and based on the proposal of the shareholders not excluded from the right to vote.
If, during the year, less than a quarter of the Directors are found to meet such requirements, the Board will resolve to terminate the role of one or two of its Members who have ceased to meet such requirements, based on a criterion of shorter tenure, or, in the case of equal tenure, lower age, and will co-opt one or two independent members.
The laws in force, without the involvement of list voting, shall govern any replacement of Directors, except in the event that all Directors cease their roles.
To guarantee the presence of the director selected from the list that did not obtain the majority vote, in case they cease their role, the Board will first check the continued availability of the candidates included on the list, according to the its sequential order, and will co-opt members based on this criterion of preference.
If a Director belonging to the least represented gender ceases, the co-opted Director shall be of the same gender.
The Appointments Committee has launched the drafting of an organic succession plan for top management following the presentation of the 2020-2022 Industrial Plan. To delineate the succession plans, the Board has deemed it useful to perform an internal reorganisation, identifying the activity sectors and the business areas that are believed to be strategic interest to the Group's future.
In accordance with the Company's Articles of Association, the Board of Directors is composed of a minimum of five up to a maximum of fifteen members, elected by the Shareholders' Meeting.
The ordinary Shareholders' Meeting of the Shareholders of 19th April 2019 set the composition of the Board of Directors to 12 and fixed the duration of the mandate to three financial years (2019-2021); the mandate will expire on the date of the Shareholders' Meeting convoked for the approval of the financial statements for the financial year 2021.
Four lists were deposited and published within the deadlines and in the manner laid down by the applicable provisions and by the Articles of Association for the election of the Board of Directors at the Shareholders' Meeting of 19th April 2019:
As well as the lists, the following documents were also deposited and published:
Table 4 shows the list of candidates, the list of those elected and the percentage of votes obtained compared to the voting capital:
| LIST | LIST OF CANDIDATES | LIST OF CANDIDATES ELECTED | PERCENTAGE OF VOTES OBTAINED |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Simona Arduini Antonella Malinconico Beatrice Colleoni Monica Billio Sebastien Egon Fürstenberg Ernesto Fürstenberg Fassio l uciano Colombini Alessandro Csillaghy de Pacser I uca I o Giudice Daniele Umberto Santosuosso Divo Gronchi Ferruccio Di Lenardo |
Simona Arduini Antonella Malinconico Beatrice Colleoni Monica Billio Sebastien Egon Fürstenberg Ernesto Fürstenberg Fassio Luciano Colombini Alessandro Csillaghy de Pacser I uca I o Giudice Daniele Umberto Santosuosso Divo Gronchi |
69,55% |
| 2 | Giuseppe Benini Renato Giovannini |
10,83% | |
| 3 | Roberto Diacetti Alessandra Giuseppina Barzaghi |
Roberto Diacetti | 16,25% |
| 4 | Riccardo Preve Giovanni Angioni |
3,18% |
Table 4
The composition of the Board was found to agree with the composition identified in advance as optimal in the document "Optimal qualitative-quantitative composition of the Board of Directors of Banca IFIS"; the declarations provided on the requirements of professionalism, integrity and independence, and on the limit of accumulation of offices were found to have been complied with.
All directors declared their ability to dedicate sufficient time to the proper performance of their mandate and all the areas of competence identified in the self-assessment process of 2018 were found to be well represented in the Board (Banking Business and activities and banking and financial products (7); Dynamics of the economic/financial system (5); Industry regulations (5); Internal control systems and systems for the methodology of risk management and control (9); Risk management and control methodology (6); Corporate governance (8); Corporate management processes (8); Knowledge of the organisational structure and IT systems (2); Accounting and financial information statement (9)).
Below please see how the members of the Board of Directors are distributed in terms of gender and age groups, as at 31st December 2019:


Table 5 provides information relating to the Board of Directors for the financial year 2019.
| Table 5 |
|---|
| --------- |
| In office | First | |||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Role | Components | from to |
appointment | List (M/m)* |
Exec. | Non Exec. | Indep. Code |
Indep. TUF |
% particip. BoD meetings ** |
|
| President | Sebastien Egon Fürstenberg | 19/04/2019 | Approval of 2021 financial statements |
date 1983 |
M | X | 75 | |||
| Vice-President | Ernesto Fürstenberg Fassio | 19/04/2019 | Approval of 2021 financial statements |
2019 | M | × | 100 | |||
| Chief Executive Officer | Luciano Colombini | 19/04/2019 | Approval of 2021 financial statements |
2019 | M | X | 100 | |||
| Director | Alessandro Csillaghy de Pacser | 19/04/2019 | Approval of 2021 financial statements |
1995 | M | × | ਰੇਟ | |||
| Director | Daniele Umberto Santosuosso | 19/04/2019 | Approval of 2021 financial statements |
2013 | M | X | X | × | 100 | |
| Director (LID) | Simona Arduini | 19/04/2019 | Approval of 2021 financial statements |
2019 | M | × | × | × | 100 | |
| Director | Monica Billio | 19/04/2019 | Approval of 2021 financial statements |
2019 | M | X | X | × | 93.33 | |
| Director | Antonella Malinconico | 19/04/2019 | Approval of 2021 financial statements |
2016 | M | X | X | X | 100 | |
| Director | Roberto Diacetti | 19/04/2019 | Approval of 2021 financial statements |
2019 | m | X | X | X | 100 | |
| Director | Divo Gronchi | 19/04/2019 | Approval of 2021 financial statements |
2019 | M | × | × | × | 100 | |
| Director | Beatrice Colleoni | 19/04/2019 | Approval of 2021 financial statements |
2019 | M | x | × | × | 93.33 | |
| Director | Luca Lo Giudice | 19/04/2019 | Approval of 2021 financial statements |
2019 | M | X | 100 | |||
| Directors who have ceased to hold office during the Financial Year 2019 | ||||||||||
| Chief Executive Officer | Giovanni Bossi | 2016 | Approval of 2018 financial statements |
ਰਰੇਤ | M | X | 100 | |||
| Director (LID) | Giuseppe Benini | 2016 | Approval of 2018 financial statements |
2013 | M | X | × | × | 100 | |
| Director | Marina Salamon | 2016 | Approval of 2018 financial statements |
2005 | M | X | 100 | |||
| Director | Francesca Maderna | 2016 | Approval of 2018 financial statements |
2010 | M | × | × | × | 100 | |
| Director | Riccardo Preve | 2016 | Approval of 2018 financial statements |
2005 | M | X | 100 | |||
| Quorum required for the presentation of the election of one or more members (ex.Article 147-ter of the TUF): 1% | ||||||||||
| No. of meetings held during the financial year of reference: 20 | ||||||||||
| Notes: This column indicates the list from which each director was selected ("M": majority list, "m"; minority list). * No. of presences/no. of meetings held during the effective time in office of the subject during the Financial Year. |
Information relating to the personal and professional characteristics of each director in office on the date of approval of this report may be found below:
Sebastien Egon Furstenberg has operated in the factoring sector for more than 30 years; in 1983 he founded the company I.Fi.S. S.p.A. – Istituto di Finanziamento e Sconto (now Banca IFIS S.p.A.).
He is currently the Chief Executive Officer and the Chairman of the Board of Directors of La Scogliera S.p.A., a company whose objective is the acquisition, management and divestment of participations in banks and financial companies, and which holds the majority of the capital of Banca IFIS S.p.A.
Vice-President - Ernesto Fürstenberg Fassio
He graduated in Law from the University of Padua; he is currently studying towards the MA in Accounting and Control at Bocconi University. In 2009, he joined the Board of Directors of La Scogliera S.p.A., the financial holding company that controls Banca IFIS, where he has been Chief Executive Officer since 2018. He is in charge of the implementation of the company's operational and management and control processes, as well as the promotion of its image.
He graduated in Law and started his professional career at the Banco di Roma; in 1984, he joined Banca Popolare di Vicenza where for twenty years he took on positions of increasing responsibility culminating in his appointment as General Manager in 2005. In October 2007, he left the Banca Popolare di Vicenza and, in subsequent years, was General Manager for various banks (Banca Popolare di Verona San Geminiano and San Prospero - Banca Popolare Group, Unipol Banca - Unipol Group, and Banca Desio e Brianza Group); in July 2016 he was appointed Chief Executive Officer of Banca Finint Group.
Since April 2019 he has been Chief Executive Officer of Banca IFIS S.p.A.; within the Group he holds the positions of Chief Executive Officer of IFIS NPL S.p.A. and FBS S.p.A.
Alessandro Csillaghy de Pacser has been active in the factoring sector for over 30 years; from 1996 until April 2019 he held the post of Vice President of the Bank. He contributes to the development of the Bank's presence abroad, through contacts with local Institutions and with foreign entrepreneurs, the purpose of which is to facilitate the activity of Banca IFIS abroad.
In particular, he has established representative offices in Central Europe, specifically in Romania and Hungary, and, for a while, worked at the Bank's office in Paris, France. Since 2011, he has been responsible for organising and developing the activities of
the subsidiary company IFIS Finance Sp. z o.o., a Polish factoring company, as part of his role as President of the Board of Directors. He is currently responsible for the delegation in Bucharest.
Having graduated in Commercial Law, he pursued an academic path as honorary fellow and visiting fellow in various foreign universities, and then researcher, associate professor of Commercial Law at the University "La Sapienza" of Rome and, lastly, professor pro tempore and then full professor at the department of Commercial Law at the same university. He has authored numerous notes, articles, essays and books; he has also contributed to certain scientific journals and collaborates with Il Sole 24 Ore, as well as being the founder and director responsible for the "Rivista di diritto societario" [Journal of Corporate Law]. He has been enrolled in the Italian Register of Lawyers since 1992, has his own law firm and has held various institutional and corporate management posts (including as a Member of the Government Commission for the reform of company law in 2003 and the Government Commission for the reform of the law on distressed businesses – the so-called "Rordorf Reform") and corporate management offices.
She is a professor in the scientific disciplinary sector of Corporate Economy at the Department of the same name of the Roma Tre University. In 2016-2019 she was the Chair of the School of Economy and Corporate Studies. She teaches Financial Statements, and Business Valuation. She is a member of the Board of Statutory Auditors of Rentokil Initial Italia S.p.A. and of Officine NPL S.p.A.;in 2019, she was appointed by Mibac [Ministry of Cultural Heritage and Activities and Tourism] to the Board of Auditors of Rome's Special Superintendency for Archaeology, the Arts and the Landscape, and she has been a member of the Supervisory Committee of Veneto Banca S.p.A. in L.C.A. since April 2018. She was a member of the Board of Statutory Auditors of Nuova Cassa di Risparmio di Ferrara S.p.A. and of Poste Vita S.p.A. She was a member of the supervisory committee of various administrative liquidation and extraordinary administration procedures of banks and financial entities. She has performed expert assessment of the economic capital for leading Italian companies. She has been a consultant at the Civil Court of Rome since 1999.
She graduated in Economy and Commerce from the Università Ca' Foscari Venezia and was awarded a PhD in Applied Mathematics from the Université Paris IX Dauphine (France).
Since 2006, she has been full professor of Econometrics at the Università Ca' Foscari and is currently Director of the Department of Economy and member of the Academic Senate. She has published numerous articles in internationally recognised econometrics and finance journals, with applications to the measurement and management of financial risks, the analysis of the financial system's and the financial cycle's stability.
She participates in numerous research projects financed by the European Commission, Eurostat and the Italian Ministry of Universities and Research. She is currently a member of the Board of Directors of the European Financial Management Association (EFMA) and a member of the scientific committee of the Associazione Italiana Financial Industry Risk Managers (AIFIRM).
She was an independent member of the Board of Directors of Banco delle Tre Venezie S.p.A. and member of the Board of Directors of Contarina S.p.A.
She graduated in Economy and Commerce from the Università Federico II of Naples and was awarded, from the same university, a PhD in Financial Science for Companies. She is currently full professor of the Economy of financial intermediaries at the Università degli Studi del Sannio. She has authored numerous studies and publications on subjects such as Risk Management in banks, Management of Non Performing Loans, Prudential Vigilance, Relationship between Banks and Undertakings.
She has been a licensed Accountant since 1995 and is a consultant on financial matters for numerous banking institutions, where she also provides training. Over the years she has held various professional posts, among which the post of member of the Board of the Bank of Italy (Naples branch) from 2009 until she was co-opted in the Board of Directors of Banca Antonio Capasso S.p.A., of which she was a member from 2014 to 2016.
Since 2016, she has been a member of the Board of Directors of Banca IFIS S.p.A., as non executive independent director, as well as a member of the Risk Management and Internal Control Committee.
Since 2018, she has been a member of the Board of Directors of IFIS NPL S.p.A.
He graduated in Law from the Università LUISS-Guido Carli of Rome. He has accumulated significant managerial experience in the public and private sector. Over the years he has been Chief Executive Officer of Resources for Roma Spa and ATAC Spa, President of EUR Spa and Roma Convention Group Spa. He was also Director of Banca Centro Lazio and a member of the Supervisory Board of Igea Banca. He was Vice-President of World Food Programme Italia and Visiting Lecturer in Planning and Control at the Università degli Studi di Cassino for over ten years. He is currently General Manager of Fondazione Enpaia.
He graduated in Economy and Commerce and started his banking career in 1958 at Banca Toscana, the Parent Company of Monte dei Paschi di Siena, where he was appointed General Manager from 1996 until June 2000 and, thereafter, director: he resigned in December 2000. He was then appointed General Director of the Banca Popolare di Vicenza; later, he was appointed General Manager and then Chief Executive Officer of the Banca Popolare Italiana, until its merger with the Banco Popolare, where he held the office of President of the Management Board. He resigned in December 2007 to take up the office of General Manager and then Chief Executive Officer at the Banca Popolare di Vicenza until October 2011. He is the General Manager, Chief Executive Officer and President of the Cassa di Risparmio di S. Miniato until its incorporation into Credit Agricole in June 2018. Throughout his banking career he has held numerous posts with various roles in banking and other companies.
He has been awarded the honorific titles of Cavaliere di Gran Croce and Maestro del Lavoro.
She graduated in Economy and Commerce from the Università Cattolica del Sacro Cuore of Milan; since 2020 she has been an accountant, mainly busy with corporate, administrative and strategic consultancy, national and international taxation, drafting of financial statements, extraordinary operations, organisation of labour.
During her career, she collaborated with the firms IBI Consulting Srl and Andersen Legal and, since 2002, she has been working for Gruppo Colleoni, also holding the post of member of the Boards of Directors of certain companies.
He graduated in Law from the Università Cattolica del Sacro Cuore of Milan in 1996; he has been practising law since 1999 and has been a Supreme Court attorney since 2011.
A legal consultant with over 20 years of experience in corporate, banking and insurance issues regarding corporations, insurance companies, banks and investment funds both on a permanent basis and in the context of operations of corporate reorganisation, securitisation and restructuring of financial debt. In certain outstanding cases, he held the office of director, on the instruction of the main national credit institutions.
The Board of Directors, when its mandate was renewed, invited Shareholders to consider, for the purposes of submitting lists of candidates, the Board's needs in terms of professionalism and skills (including managerial skills) deemed to be necessary to ensure that the composition of the Strategic Supervisory Body is optimal, as shown in the report on "Optimal Qualitative and Quantitative Composition of Banca IFIS's Board of Directors" approved by the Board of Directors on 11th February 2019 and made available at the company's registered office, "Borsa Italiana S.p.A." and the authorised storage mechanism , as well as the Company's website. This document will be updated annually to support the selfassessment carried out by the Directors.
The process of selecting Board members ensures that the Board is diverse, guaranteeing that the Body has an adequate degree of diversification in terms of abilities, which must be extensive and diversified from both a managerial and technical perspective (in terms of legal, accounting, tax, financial, risk management and control, corporate governance, IT process, business organisation and human resources knowledge).
In order to guarantee a fruitful internal dialogue and to contribute to the adoption of decisions that align with the Bank's interests, the Board of Directors must ensure that its members have significant and consolidated experience in the management, administration, control activities of banks and/or undertakings.
As a matter of fact, performance of the functions assigned to the strategic supervision body requires the presence of persons who:
• are fully aware of the powers and obligations inherent to the roles they are each called upon to carry out (executive and non-executive duties, independent members, etc.);
These skills are monitored annually through the self-assessment process, which requires each Director to judge their own level of technical-regulatory competences in relation to the Bank's business and any other subjects deemed necessary considering the Bank's activities.
The Bank is also aware that an appropriate degree of diversification in terms of age, gender and geographic origin gives a plurality of approaches and perspectives in analysing problems and taking decisions, avoiding the risk of behaviour that aligns with a dominant position, within or outside the Bank. Objectives regarding diversity in the composition of the Board must be pursued considering the skills and professionalism requirements which all directors must possess.
To this end, the adopted Board member selection process protects and promotes their diversity right from the nomination phase, as the list vote mechanism governed by the Articles of Association ensures that at least one Director is chosen from minority shareholdings and that the regulatory provisions on the number of candidates belonging to the least represented gender are complied with; As already mentioned, at least a third of the Board of Directors must be made up of the least represented gender.
As a result, the Bank does not consider it necessary to adopt additional specific diversity policies relating to the composition of the strategic supervisory body.
***
Banca IFIS has also adopted measures to promote equal opportunity and treatment of gender within the entire business organisation. The Group firmly condemns any discrimination against employees or applicants based on gender, age, religious or political beliefs and trade union affiliation, as well any form of nepotism and preferential treatment.
As the Code of Ethics—the Group's main reference for standards of conduct and ethics—clearly states, all Group employees shall maintain the highest standard of conduct, respecting the dignity and moral personality of everyone. These rules apply also to Collaborators.
It is possible to report any conduct contrary to these principles, with the guarantee that the personal data of the complainant and the alleged offender will remain confidential, through the Whistleblowing mechanism, which is available to employees as well as collaborators and independent contractors working with the Group on a regular basis. No incidents of discrimination were reported in 2019.
As for the composition of staff, we van see that, as at 31st December 2019, 52.13% of the employees of Banca IFIS are women; specifically, approximately 40.35% of management personnel (Senior and Middle Managers) are women.
The differences in base remuneration between men and women range from 0.78% to 12.33% in favour of men, in accordance with grade.
The "Regulation on the maximum number of posts held in other companies by company officers" was approved by the Shareholders' Meeting of 30th June 2009.
This Regulation first of all establishes that:
"The Officers of Banca IFIS S.p.A. accept their post and hold it insofar as they believe themselves able to dedicate the necessary time to the diligent performance of their tasks, taking into account both the number and the quality of posts held in the administration and control bodies of other companies and the commitment required of them by their other professional activities and by associated posts held".
To calculate the limits on the maximum number of posts in other companies as governed by the "Regulation", the following are considered significant:
Offices held within the Banca IFIS Group or in companies other than those listed above, are not considered significant.
In the Regulation, the term "executive posts" refers to the following posts:
The terms "Non-executive Director or controlling posts" refer to the following posts:
In addition to the post held at the Bank, an Executive Director:
In addition to the office held at the Bank, a Non-executive Director cannot hold more than ten posts as Director or Statutory Auditor in other companies identified, in terms of type or size, as significant per the Regulation, of which not more than two can be Executive posts.
Candidates for appointment as Director or Statutory Auditor of Banca IFIS S.p.A. must provide the Bank with an updated statement of the administration, management and control posts held by each of them.
Following their appointment, the Company's Directors and Statutory Auditors must promptly notify the Banca IFIS S.p.A.'s Corporate Affairs Department of any changes regarding the posts held by them in the administration and control bodies of other companies.
Banca IFIS S.p.A.'s Board of Directors has the authority to grant exceptions, including temporary ones, to the maximum limit set out in the Regulation. As of the date of this Report, no such exceptions have been granted.
When appointment lists were submitted by the Shareholders' Meeting on 19th April 2019, all candidates declared – when accepting their candidacy and possible appointment – to have read the "Regulation" and to have declared that they do not hold a number of posts in other companies that exceed the prescribed limits.
Table 6 below shows the number and type of posts held by the Directors of Banca IFIS on the date this Report was drafted, based on information provided thereby. In addition, in order to comply with the requirements of Bank of Italy Circular no. 285/2013 (Section VII, Chapter 1, Heading IV, Part One), evidence was also provided of the posts held in the companies that are not considered significant for the purposes of the "Regulation on the maximum number of posts held in other companies by company officers".
| Table 6 | |
|---|---|
| --------- | -- |
| POSTS HELD BY THE MEMBERS OF THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS IN OTHER COMPANIES | |||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| POSTS IN THE BANKING GROUP |
COMPANY POSTS RELEVANT FOR THE PURPOSES OF THE REGULATION ON LIMITS ON THE NUMBER OF POSTS HELD BY |
THE DIRECTORS | COMPANY POSTS NOT RELEVANT FOR THE PURPOSES OF THE REGULATION ON LIMITS ON THE NUMBER OF POSTS HELD BY THE DIRECTORS |
TOTAL | |||||||
| Companies listed in regulated markets, also abroad |
Financial, banking, insurance corporations |
Companies of relevant size |
|||||||||
| E. | N.E. | E. | N.E. | E. | N.E. | E. | N.E. | E. | N.E. | ||
| Sebastien Egon Fürstenberg | 1 | 2 | 3 | ||||||||
| Ernesto Fürstenberg Fassio | 1 | 1 | 2 | ||||||||
| Luciano Colombini | 2 | 2 | |||||||||
| Alessandro Csillaghy de Pacser | 1 | 1 | |||||||||
| Daniele Umberto Santosuosso | 1 | 1 | 2 | ||||||||
| Simona Arduini | 7 | 7 | |||||||||
| Monica Billio | 0 | ||||||||||
| Antonella Malinconico | 1 | 1 | |||||||||
| Roberto Diacetti | 1 | 1 | |||||||||
| Divo Gronchi | 1 | 1 | |||||||||
| Beatrice Colleoni | 1 | 1 | 2 | ||||||||
| Luca Lo Giudice | 1 | 5 | 6 |
Table 7 shows details of the offices held by the Directors in other companies.
Table 7
| Undertakings belonging to the Banca IFIS Group |
|||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| List of posts | NO | Banking Group |
Non-banking Group |
||
| President of the Board of Directors of La Scogliera S.p.A. | X | ||||
| Sebastien Egon Fürstenberg President |
Chief Executive Officer of La Scogliera S.p.A. | X | |||
| Limited partner in AB.CO. S.a.s. di Rivolta Gianmario e c. | × | ||||
| Ernesto Fürstenberg Fassio | Chief Executive Officer of La Scogliera S.p.A. | X | |||
| Vice-President | President of the Board of Directors of FBS S.p.A. | × | |||
| Luciano Colombini | Chief Executive Officer of IFIS IMPLS.p.A. | X | |||
| Chief Executive Officer | Chief Executive Officer of FBS S.p.A. | X | |||
| Alessandro Csillaghy de Pacser Director |
President of the Board of Directors of IFIS Finance Sp. Z.o.o. | × | |||
| Daniele Umberto Santosuosso Director of Lottomatica Holding | × | ||||
| Director | Legal liquidator of Santa Passera II S.r.l. | X | |||
| Member of the Supervisory Committee of Veneto Banca S.p.A. in I.c.a. | X | ||||
| Member of the Supervisory Committee of Orconsult Capital Management Italia S.p.A. in I.c.a. | X | ||||
| Simona Arduini | Member of the Supervisory Committee of Europeenne de Gestion Privee S.A. filiale italiana in I.c.a. | X | |||
| Director (LID) | Member of the Supervisory Committee of Province Calabre s.c.p.a. in I.c.a. | X | |||
| Member of the Board of Statutory Auditors of Officine INIPL S.p.A. | X | ||||
| Member of the Board of Statutory Auditors of Rentokil Initial Italia S.p.A. | X | ||||
| Member of the Board of Statutory Auditors of Initial Italia S.p.A. | X | ||||
| Monica Billio | |||||
| Director | |||||
| Antonella Malinconico Director |
Director of IFIS IMPLS.p.A. | X | |||
| Roberto Diacetti Director |
Vice-President of the Board of Directors of FBS S.p.A. | X |
| Undertakings belonging to the Banca IFIS Group |
|||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| List of posts | NO | Banking Group |
Non-banking Group |
||
| Divo Gronchi Director | Director of IFIS NPLS.p.A. | × | |||
| Beatrice Colleoni Director | Sole Administrator of C. Holding S.p.A. | x | |||
| Director of T2D S.r.l. | X | ||||
| President of the Board of Directors of CISFI S.p.A. | × | ||||
| Director of INTERPORTO CAMPANO S.P.A. | X | ||||
| Director of FRECCIA ROSSA S.P.A. | X | ||||
| Luca Lo Giudice Director | Director of CALVI HOLDING S.p.A. | x | |||
| Director of FBS S.p.A. | × | ||||
| President of the Board of Directors of FBS RE S.p.A. | × |
The Directors must also take into account the provisions of Article 36 of (It.) Legislative Decree 201/2011 ("prohibition of interlocking"), converted with amendments by (It.) Law 214/2011, which forbids persons holding posts in the management,
supervisory and control bodies and the executives of undertakings or groups of undertakings operating in the credit, insurance and financial markets from assuming or exercising similar posts in competing undertakings or groups of undertakings.
Given the renewal of the structure of Directors elected by the Shareholders' Meeting of 19th April 2019, the company considered carrying out the assessment process shortly before the expiry of the first year of the mandate; however, as the skills and professionalism of the candidates were made known and assessed on the occasion of their nomination, the company decided to allow an adequate period of time to the directors so that they become familiar with the particularities of the company.
On assuming their office, the Directors received a wide range of documentation aiming to facilitate the integration of the new members.
As no gaps in the skills of the Board were identified, it was decided to provide its members with access to the Advanced Training for the Board of Directors of the Italian Banking Association (ABI), while an articulated and balanced Training Plan was being formulated.
The Board of Directors defines the strategic guidelines and continuously checks their implementation, guaranteeing healthy and prudent management. Its composition, manner of operation, the powers and duties assigned to the Board of Directors are set forth by the law and the Bank's Articles of Association.
A total of 20 meetings, 5 of which were of the outgoing Board of Directors and 15 of the Board elected by the Shareholders' Meeting of 19th April 2019, were held in 2019; the average duration of the meetings was 4 hours and 52 minutes. The presence percentages are shown in Table 5, on page 15.
Since the start of 2020 and until the date of approval of this document, the Board has held 4 meetings, including the one during the "Report" was approved. We foresee that the number of Board of Directors meetings in 2020 will be in line with that of the previous financial year.
To meet the obligations established for listed issuers by Article 2.6.2 of the Market Regulations of Borsa Italiana S.p.A., the Board of Directors annually approves the Corporate Events Calendar, to be notified to Borsa Italiana for disclosure to the public, within 30 days of the end of the previous financial year.
The Transparency Directive II (2013/50/EU), implemented in Italy by Italian Legislative Decree no. 25 of 15th February 2016, removed the obligation to publish interim management reports but retains the right to reintroduce periodic information in addition to financial and six-monthly reports, albeit only under certain conditions and subject to regulatory impact analysis and to cost/benefit analysis. This provision has been integrated into the CONSOB Issuer Regulations through the inclusion of the new Article 82-ter, in view of which Banca IFIS has announced its choice to continue preparing and publishing quarterly information, in accordance with previous practice, in accordance with the Borsa Italiana regulations for the STAR segment and in order to ensure continuity and regularity of information made available to the financial community.
Therefore, the dates fixed for the Shareholders' Meeting to consider the financial statement and the Board of Directors meetings to approve the draft financial statement and the quarterly/half-yearly financial reports have been included on the Calendar.
The "Regulation on the convoking and functioning of Board of Directors Meetings", last updated on 18th October 2018, states that:
The methods and time limits for sending the documentation to the Board as described above were normally complied with during the financial year 2019. The situation whereby the President deemed it appropriate to provide documents directly during a meeting almost never arose. This occurred in negligible percentage terms compared with the total number of issues addressed by the Board, mainly to provide more accurate versions of communications on periodic financial notices, and as regards negotiations concerning potential extraordinary transactions discussed within Banca IFIS during the year.
In accordance with the Articles of Association, Board meetings are attended by the General Manager in a consulting role. The Board in office until the April Shareholders' Meeting chose the Corporate Affairs as the corporate structure tasked with performing the tasks that the Articles of Association entrust to the Secretary for minute keeping; in July, pursuant to Article 12 of the Articles of Association, the Head of the Legal Department was appointed as Secretary of the Board of Directors and the Head of Corporate Affairs was nominated as his alternate. In addition, pursuant to the aforementioned "Regulation", the President and/or the Chief Executive Officer may invite to the meetings of the Board of Directors managers or other Company employees or other subjects or external consultants, whose presence is deemed useful with regard to the subject to be discussed.
During 2019, the Head of the Legal Department and some Corporate Affairs organisational unit staff attended the meetings.
Participants also included:
The Head of Internal Audit, the Chief Risk Officer and the Heads of Compliance and Anti-Money Laundering explain directly to the directors their reports and their policies in compliance with the applicable vigilance regulatory framework issued by the Bank of Italy.
Lastly, since April 2019, Giuseppe Rumi, attorney-at-law with the Bonelli Erede Legal Firm has participated in his capacity of external legal consultant of the Bank.
Pursuant to Article 14 of the Articles of Association, besides the duties that cannot be delegated by law, the matters deemed to be the exclusive prerogative of the Board of Directors include:
Based on the Board of Directors' strategic indications, as well as size objectives and additional qualitative-quantitative elements set out in the Strategic Plan, the Risk Appetite Framework, the ICAAP and ILAAP Reports are drawn up and approved annually by the Board of Directors. In accordance with the requirements of the Supervisory Provisions for banks, as defined by Bank of Italy Circular no. 285, the ICT Strategic Plan is also approved.
As in previous years, in 2019, the Board of Directors approved some documents that are part of the review process of organisational and informational structures.
The Board will assess the general management performance when analysing the Financial Report required by Article 154-ter of the TUF, the comparison between the plan objectives and the results achieved (this analysis is forecast to occur after the half-yearly report is approved), and other documents required by the strategic planning process.
The Board also continually assesses, as part of its responsibilities, the suitability of the Bank's general organisational, administration and accounting structure.
The suitability of the organisational, administration and general accounting structure of the Bank's subsidiaries is assessed by the Board of Directors by using corporate governance and control tools, identified in the Group Regulations which define the roles of the Parent Company and its Subsidiary Companies, as well as the management/administration activities as part of strategic management and technical-operational control activities.
When negotiating regarding the acquisition of new companies, the Bank's Board of Directors has all the tools required to assess the future subsidiary's structures and whether they are in line with the system adopted by the Bank. These reflections lead the Board to issue a special directive, following acquisition, to adapt the new subsidiary's structures and internal control systems to those of the Banking Group.
A description of the organisational model characteristics of the Group's internal control system and of the activities carried out by the Group's control units (that is, as part of the Parent Company's management and administration activities over its Subsidiary Companies) is contained in the "Group internal control system guidelines" and in the regulations governing control organisational units.
In accordance with the provisions of the Articles of Association highlighted earlier, the Board has the power to review and give prior approval for the Issuer's transactions and those of its Subsidiary Companies, when these transactions are of significant strategic, economic, capital or financial importance. In this case, the Board of Directors will be convoked by the President at the start of negotiations with the selling counterparty and/or liaison with the Supervisory Authority, thus being able to guide negotiations until they are concluded, until necessary authorisations are obtained and until closing.
The Board has not established general criteria to identify transactions of significant strategic, economic, capital or financial importance for the Bank, since these operations can only be approved by the Board itself, as part of the planning process or, as has occurred so far, as part of the key points that modify the strategic objectives and risk appetite that have already been approved.
In contrast, the general criteria to identify transactions with associated persons that have a significant impact on the Bank's strategic, economic, capital or financial positions are set out in the "Procedures for transactions with associated persons" which has been updated, together with the Policies to control risk assets and conflicts of interest in relation to associated persons, at its meeting of 29th June 2018, following the favourable opinion of the Financial Reporting Officer, the Board of Statutory Auditors and the Risk Management and of the independent directors of the Risk Management and Internal Control Committee. A small update to the Procedures was approved by the General Manager on 9th October 2018.
Under these Procedures, the following are considered to be significant:
In any case, the Board of Directors, based on appropriate considerations, has the right to classify which transactions carried out by the Bank or its Subsidiary Companies are significant.
Significant Transactions are divided into:
As previously stated, the Board of Directors, at its meeting of 18th January 2019, and also in light of the provisions and instructions provided by the Bank of Italy, concluded its annual assessment of the functioning of the Board and its committees as well as on their size and composition. This assessment was carried out by means of distributing a questionnaire, in the weeks prior, which varied according to the role of the person due to complete it (e.g. the President of the Board of Directors, Members of Internal Committees, etc.).
This assessment was carried out taking into account the usual elements, such as Board members' professional characteristics and experience, both managerial and general, as well as their seniority in office, including with a view to preparing the opinions to be expressed to shareholders on those people whose presence on the Board is deemed to be appropriate.
With regards to the assessment methods used, first of all the President chose the Bank's internal staff to take part in the selfassessment process, taking into account the criteria set by the Bank in its Self-Assessment Process Regulations. During the self-assessment process, the designated individual (Head of Corporate Affairs) was assisted by an external professional, Ferdinando Parente, from the company Parente & Partners S.r.l., who formerly carried out technical assistance and consultancy roles to ensure that the Bank complies with its obligations. This consultancy was terminated on approval by the Board of the results of the self-assessment.
The means of performance adopted for the self-assessment, the main positive outcomes and the points on which attention should be paid or which should be improved may be found in the Report drafted for the year 2018.
Please note that the activity described in the previous Report related to the Board in office until the Shareholders' Meeting of 19th April 2019 and that the current Board launched, in February 2020, almost one year after its installation, its own selfassessment; it will be carried out in accordance with the procedure of the previous year, except from the fact that, for this financial year, the Board has decided not to use the services of an external consultant.
The Shareholders' Meeting did not authorise derogations from the prohibition of competition set forth by Article 2390 of the (It.) Civil Code.
In the model adopted by Banca IFIS:
Management powers cover the following main areas:
Management powers are distributed at a decreasing rate in accordance with the management level, from the Board of Directors down to operating units.
The most significant limits, in terms of value and subject, applied to the Chief Executive Officer's powers are summarised below, notwithstanding the fact that systematic information flows are required concerning the exercise of powers at any given time, and related quantitative limits must be observed:
| ASSUMPTION OF THE CREDIT RISK | Limits of the power | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Credits Trade Corpor Financ Granting and ate operations |
overdrafts e |
on | factoring | Up to 30m per overdraft, with and without recourse |
| Financing of risk category 1 operations (Opening credit in current account; Amortising/bullet loans; Loans on signature; Direct reimbursement of non notification factoring with non-channelled payment; Minibonds) |
Up to 10m | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Financing of risk category 2 operations (Medium/long-term loans assisted by a guarantee fund; Advance on Contract with assignment; Non-notification factoring with channelled payment; Infra-group factoring; Advances on future receivables under maturation; Leasing - Equipment Finance; High-risk non-notification tax receivables) |
Up to 20m | |||||
| Financing of risk category 3 operations (Notified factoring of ordinary loans; Leasing - Transportation; Tax receivables at high risk with notification; Tax credits at low risk non-notification) |
Up to 40m | |||||
| Financing of risk category 4 operations (PA recognised and/or certified factoring; Tax receivables at low risk with notification) |
Up to 60m | |||||
| Structured finance transactions | Up to 20m | |||||
| Acquisition and disposal of shareholdings | up to €5m per acquisition/disposal of non-qualified shareholdings and €7.5m for qualified shareholdings as part of the business managed by the Equity Investment BU |
|||||
| Special Situation | Up to 5m | |||||
| Problem Loans | Up to 20m | |||||
| granted the following powers: | As part of risk positions falling within the scope of or assumed by the Board of Directors, the Chief Executive Officer is also | |||||
| • • |
to suspend, revoke and resume operations; to change the amount of risk, convert its technical form and change its operational characteristics without |
| MANAGEMENT OF THE CREDIT RISK | Limits of the power | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Trade receivables | Negative balances and/or temporary unplanned overdrafts | Max 20% of the overdraft | ||||
| (Euros) | ||||||
| Waiving of credit for principal, interest and/or fees | Up to 500 thousand | |||||
| Suspension/restoration of credit lines, unloading management, management of blocked positions and | ||||||
| reassignment and/or release of debtors |
| Repositioning maturity dates and/or defining repayment plans (with obligation to report to the direct manager) up to | |||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 4m and for a maximum term of 12 months | |||||||
| Repositioning maturity dates and/or defining repayment plans (with obligation to report to the direct manager) |
Up to 10m | ||||||
| Large Public Administration clients | Waiving of credit for principal resulting from out-of-court activity |
up to 100% of the nominal value of the credit provided that it is within the carrying amount estimated on a case by case basis |
|||||
| Waiving of credit for default interest and/or extension calculated using the rate set out in (It.) Legislative Decree 231/2002 |
up to 100% | ||||||
| Pharma | Waiving of credit for default interest resulting from out-of court activity, and waiving of credit for default interest for which legal action has begun as part of the business financing operations managed by the Pharma BU |
no limit | |||||
| Corporate Finance |
Waiving of credit | Up to 500,000 | |||||
| Tax receivables | Transactions with no predefined limits and, in any case, with a maximum loss (in relation to the greater between the amortised cost and the price paid) of €500,000 |
||||||
| Waiving of credit for principal, interest and/or fees: | Up to 500,000 | ||||||
| Repositioning maturity dates and/or defining repayment plans | Maximum amount 4,000,000 | ||||||
| (with obligation to report to the direct manager) | Maximum term 60 months with single signature | ||||||
| Unlimited minimum extension rate | |||||||
| Temporary concession of credit on loans granted as part of the business financing operations to undertakings managed by the Problem Credits BU |
Up to a maximum of 20% of the overdraft granted | ||||||
| Suspension of/abstention from legal action | Up to 10m | ||||||
| Acceptance of a creditors arrangement, filing proof of claim | Up to 4m | ||||||
| and Structured Finance) | Standstill (with reference to Special Situation Transactions | Up to 10m | |||||
| Problem credits | Suspension/restoration of credit lines, unloading management, management of blocked positions and reassignment and/or release of debtors |
| Financing granted to employees, in derogation from the Regulations governing the concession of loans to Banca IFIS Group employees, requires the joint signature of the Head of Human Resources and the Chief Executive Officer |
|||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| CAPITAL MARKETS | |||||||
| PROPERTY PORTFOLIO: Increase up to €2.5bn of the maximum investable Liquidity POSITIONS IN FOREIGN CURRENCIES: Exceeding the individual imbalance limit up to a maximum of 2% of the Total Own Funds at consolidated level |
|||||||
| STAFF MANAGEMENT | |||||||
| Decisions concerning the start, management and cessation of managers' employment contracts, subject to the authority maintained by the Board for the contracts of key managers and/or those who are on staff on the Board and notwithstanding the fact that the Board retains prerogatives regarding managers of control functions established by the supervisory provisions for Banks. |
|||||||
| DELEGATED POWERS REGARDING THE PURCHASE AND SALE OF GOODS AND SERVICES | |||||||
| Authorisation of all types of expenditure up to €1,000,000 (only for suppliers who are not associated persons) Decisions regarding lease assets and liabilities, whose annual fee is up to €200,000 Disposal of goods whose original cost is up to €150,000 Appointing external auditors for activities whose costs are lower than €50,000 |
|||||||
| INVESTMENTS IN SHAREHOLDINGS | |||||||
| NON-QUALIFIED | QUALIFIED | ||||||
| Performing non-financial businesses | ≤ 5 ml € | ≤ 7.5 ml € | |||||
| Intermediary organisations | ≤ 5 ml € | ≤ 7.5 ml € |
The President of the Board, majority shareholder of the issuer, was not granted managerial powers and does not play a specific role in the preparation of corporate strategies.
The Chief Executive Officer, pursuant to Article 15 of the Articles of Association, in emergencies may adopt decisions regarding any business or transaction that does not fall under the exclusive purview of the Board of Directors, immediately notifying the President of such decisions and announcing them to the Board at the first subsequent meeting.
In all remaining cases, the Chief Executive Officer reports to the Board on their activity with the frequency summarised below:
| Report on liquidity status monthly |
||||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Composition of investment securities portfolio | monthly | |||
| Credit-granting activity monthly |
||||
| Report on use of spending powers | quarterly | |||
| Report on use of Human Resources management powers | half-yearly | |||
| Incentive system (report on criteria adopted by Senior Management) | annual |
There are no other directors considered to be Executive Directors because they hold:
The Board carries out its own assessments of the requirements established by the Corporate Governance Code for directors classified as independent at the first meeting after appointment by the Shareholders' Meeting. It also periodically assesses the directors' level of independence. On 19th April 2019, following its appointment, the Board ascertained that seven of its members (Simona Arduini, Antonella Malinconico, Beatrice Colleoni, Monica Bilio, Daniele Umberto Santosuosso, Divo Gronchi and Roberto Diacetti) met the independence requirements as set out in the Corporate Governance Code for Listed Companies, and paragraph 3 of Article 148 of the TUF.
The independence requirements were checked taking into consideration, inter alia, the information concerning the existence of relationships (credit, commercial/professional and employment, as well as relevant offices held) directly or indirectly between the Directors and (i) the Bank, (ii) the Parent Company and/or group company, and (iii) the President of the Board of Directors, the Executive Directors and the Managers with strategic responsibilities of the companies under points (i) and (ii) above.
The Company deemed it appropriate to adopt specific criteria for checking the independence requirements, since such check requires a more extensive assessment that takes into account subjective and objective factors.
The criteria identified for this purpose and established also taking into account best practice included: (i) the nature and characteristics of the relationship; (ii) the amount, in absolute and relative terms, of the transactions; and (iii) the subjective profile of the relationship.
In particular, in assessing the importance of the relationship, the following information was taken into account, if available: 1) for credit relationships, the amount in absolute value of the credit granted, its percentage weight compared to the total value of the borrower's debt and, where appropriate, the economic/financial situation of the latter; 2) for professional/commercial relationships, the characteristics of the transaction/relationship, the amount of the consideration and, where appropriate, the economic/financial situation of the counterparty; 3) for employment relationships, the terms and characteristics of the related relationship and the remuneration envisaged; 4) for posts held at group companies and/or at the parent company, the total amount of the related remuneration and its percentage weight compared to the total economic/assets situation of the director concerned; as well as any other payment and/or remuneration received on any grounds, in the last three financial years, from (i) Banca IFIS, (ii) the parent company and/or the group companies, including any additional remuneration (compared to the "fixed" emoluments of non-executive director and the fee for participation in the committees), also in the form of participation in incentive plans linked to corporate performance, also in the form of shares.
In addition, the Board of Statutory Auditors, in accordance with the application criterion 3.C.5 of the Corporate Governance Code checked, on the same date, the application of the ascertainment criteria and procedures adopted by the Board of Directors to assess the independence of its members, deeming it compliant with the instructions provided by the Corporate Governance Code.
The outcome of the assessments performed was announced by means of a communication to the market issued on the same date, i.e. on 19th April 2019.
In addition, the Board of Directors checks, on an annual basis, that the independent directors still meet the independence requirements laid down by the Corporate Governance Code and by Article148, paragraph 3 of the TUF. The next check will be carried out during the Board meeting of 26th March 2020.
In compliance with the application criterion 3.C.6 of the Code, on 19th December 2019 the independent directors met in the absence of the other directors; the self-assessment process and the discussion of subjects pertaining to corporate governance took place during said meeting.
In line with the guidelines established by the Corporate Governance Code for Listed Companies (application criterion 2.C.4), as the President of the Board of Directors is also the majority shareholder of La Scogliera S.p.A. and thus controls Banca IFIS, the Board of Directors has designated an independent director as Lead Independent Director.
The Lead Independent Director is the point of reference and coordination for (non-executive and, particularly, independent) Directors' requests and contributions and for cooperation with the President of the Board of Directors towards ensuring that information flows between directors are constant and effective.
The Lead Independent Director has the power to convoke, when deeming it appropriate or at the request of other Directors, specific meetings solely for independent Directors for significant matters relating to Board operations and/or to company management in general.
On 19th April 2019, the Board of Directors appointed Professor Simona Arduini as Lead Independent Director for the three years 2019/2021.
The Bank has adopted the "Policy for Managing Inside Information", last updated in September 2019 to reflect a reorganisation of certain stages of the process, pursuant to application criterion 1.C.1., letter j of the Corporate Governance Code.
The Policy governs in detail the identification, internal management and external communication of inside information. In addition, it establishes the duties and responsibilities of the Bank's representatives in the context of the meetings with the financial community.
The policy requires the creation of an inside information register (RIL) with the aim of mapping in advance the types of inside information which may affect the Bank or its Subsidiary Companies in order to make subsequent continuous identification easier. For each type of significant information, the map indicates the organisational roles who ordinarily have access to it for the purposes of facilitating the compilation of the register of persons who have access to inside information.
In future, information regarding Banca IFIS or a Subsidiary Company will be checked to see if it is significant information and, if so, if it can be classed as inside information.
Three committees have been established within the Board of Directors; these committees, which have powers of investigation, consultation and proposal, allow the body tasked with strategic supervision to adopt its decisions with a better knowledge of the facts:
The composition, operation and powers of the Board Committees are governed by the Regulation of each individual Committee and by the General Regulation; the information is reported in the various reporting meetings held by each Committee.
No function has been distributed other than per the recommendations of the Code or reserved for the entire Board.
In line with the provisions of the Corporate Governance Code, on the occasion of the extraordinary Shareholders' Meeting held on 19th December 2019, the new Article 12-bis was introduced, which governs, at Articles of Association level, the Board committees.
Table 8 shows information on the composition of the Committees and the actual participation in meetings of each member.
| Risk Management and Internal Control Committee |
Appointments Committee |
Remuneration Committee |
||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Components | Exec. | Non Exec. |
Indep. Code |
Indep. TUF |
Post held | % particip. meetings ** |
Post held | % particip. meetings ** |
Post held | % particip. meetings ** |
| Sebastien Egon Fürstenberg | X | |||||||||
| Ernesto Fürstenberg Fassio | X | |||||||||
| Luciano Colombini | X | |||||||||
| Alessandro Csillaghy de Pacser | X | |||||||||
| Daniele Umberto Santosuosso | X | X | X | P | 100% | * p |
100% | M* | 100% | |
| Simona Arduini | X | X | X | M | 100% | P | 100% | |||
| Monica Billio | X | X | X | M | 88.23% | |||||
| Antonella Malinconico | X | X | X | M | 87.50% | |||||
| Roberto Diacetti | X | X | X | M** | 75% | M | 66.66% | |||
| Divo Gronchi | X | X | X | P | 100% | |||||
| Beatrice Colleoni | X | X | x | M | 66.66% | M | 90.91% | |||
| Luca Lo Giudice | X | M | 100% | |||||||
| Members who ceased to hold office during the Financial Year 2019 | ||||||||||
| Giovanni Bossi | × | |||||||||
| Giuseppe Benini | X | X | X | P | 100% | M | 100% | |||
| Marina Salamon | X | |||||||||
| Francesca Maderna | X | X | X | M | 100% | P | 100% | |||
| Riccardo Preve | x | M | 100% | M | 100% | |||||
Table 8
The Regulation of the Appointments Committee sets forth that it is composed of at least 3 members chosen from among the non-executive members of the Board of Directors, the majority of whom must be independent; the members must possess skills useful for the performance of their tasks. The Committee's President must be chosen from among the independent directors.
The Committee currently in office is composed of the independent directors Divo Gronchi, as President, Roberto Diacetti and Beatrice Colleoni.
The Regulation envisages that the President of the Board of Statutory Auditors, or another Standing Auditor delegated by them on a case by case basis, may attend Committee meetings. The Committee's meetings may also be attended by the other members of the Board of Statutory Directors. The Chief Executive Officer and the General Manager may also attend, where no matters that concern them are discussed.
The Committee may avail itself and/or request the presence of:
Summary minutes of the Committee's meetings are kept, to be signed by the members, which are notified to the Board by the President of the Committee at the first available meeting.
During the financial year 2019, the Appointments Committee met 5 times, of which two were joint meetings with the other Committees and, on the occasion of one of these meetings, also jointly with the Board of Statutory Auditors. The meetings lasted 47 minutes on average.
The two meetings held before the April Shareholders' Meeting were attended, on the invitation of the Committee and for single items on the agenda, by Ferdinando Parente and an associate of the consultancy firm Parente & Partner srl; the meetings are usually attended by Corporate Affairs staff to assist the Committee in drafting minutes, and, since last April, by the Bank's external legal advisor.
On the date of approval of this Report, the Appointments Committee met once to launch the process of self-assessment of the Board of Directors and of the Committees and the process for checking the requirements of professionalism, integrity and independence. Four meetings have been planned for the financial year 2020.
The Committee assists the Board of Directors and other corporate bodies in the following processes:
• defining succession plans for senior management positions (Chief Executive Officer and General Manager) due to expiry of mandates or for any other reason, in order to ensure business continuity and to avoid economic and reputational damage.
Furthermore, the Committee:
During 2019, the Committee discussed matters related to the self-assessment of corporate executives, to the description of the optimal qualitative-quantitative composition of the Board of Directors, the determination of the criteria for verifying the requirements of corporate executives, verifying the requirements, verifying of the correspondence between the optimal qualitative-quantitative composition and that resulting from the appointment process. The appointment of the Head of Internal Audit and of the Head of Risk Management were discussed in joint meetings.
The Committee may access all company information deemed relevant for the performance of its tasks and may have autonomous use of a set of financial resources to the limit of €60,000 per year established by the Board by virtue of decision dated 3rd February 2015 and with the requirement of reporting on the use of funds, at least once a year, usually during the review of the Report on Corporate Governance and Shareholding Structures.
Please refer to the relevant parts of the Remuneration Report published pursuant to Article 123-ter of the TUF.
Please refer to the relevant parts of the Remuneration Report published pursuant to Article 123-ter of the TUF.
The Risk Management and Internal Control Committee is responsible for supporting the Board of Directors in making assessments and decisions concerning the internal control and risk management system and concerning the approval of the periodic financial reports based on preliminary analyses.
It is composed of members of the Board of Directors chosen from among the non-executive directors, the majority of whom must be independent, in possession of knowledge, skills and experience such as to allow them to fully comprehend and monitor the bank's risk-related strategies and guidelines.
At least one member of the Committee must possess sufficient experience in accounting and financial matters or in risk management, to be assessed by the Board of Directors on their appointment. The President of the Committee is chosen from among the independent directors and must possess sufficient experience in accounting and financial matters or in risk management.
On the date of publication of this Report, and in compliance with Principle 7.P.4., the Committee is composed of 5 Independent and Non-Executive Directors: Daniele Umberto Santosuosso (holding the office of President), Simona Arduini, Monica Billio, Antonella Malinconico and Roberto Diacetti (appointed on 19th September 2019).
The work of the Committee is coordinated by the President; minutes of the meetings are kept regularly and the President of the Committee is responsible for informing the Board at the first available meeting.
During 2019, the Committee met 24 times, six of which were joint meetings with the Board of Statutory Auditors, one was a joint meeting with the Appointments Committee, the Remuneration Committee and the Board of Statutory Auditors, and one a joint meeting with just the Appointments Committee and the Remuneration Committee, with meetings lasting an average of two hour and thirty-seven minutes.
Since the start of the year 2020 and up to the date of approval of this document, the Committee has met six times, of which two were joint meetings with the Board of Statutory Auditors; 21 meetings have been planned for 2020, 6 of which have already been held as of the time of writing this Report.
The President of the Board of Statutory Auditors - or another auditor designated by the President on a case-by-case basis assists the work of the Committee. Whenever deemed appropriate with regard to the matters to be discussed, the Risk Management and Internal Control Committee and the Board of Statutory Auditors hold joint meetings.
In addition to holding joint meetings with the control body, during its meetings, the Committee also interacted, to address individual subjects, with the Chief Executive Officer, the General Manager, the Financial Reporting Officer (and the Chief Financial Officer), the Heads of Compliance and Anti-Money Laundering, the external auditing firm and the Chief Risk Officer. It systematically interacted with the Head of Internal Audit, who normally attends the Committee's meetings with a view to achieving synergy between the various stakeholders in the internal control system. The Committee also met, to analyse the Board's work, with the Head of Problem Credits, the Head of Accounting, the Head of Monitoring and Control of Financial Information and the Head of Regulatory Reporting, the Head of Operations, the Head of Privacy and Security Management, the Head of Complaints, and the Head of Validation.
The Head and/or other employees of Corporate Affairs are normally invited to Committee meetings.
The Committee provides its preliminary opinion to the Board of Directors on:
The Risk Management and Internal Control Committee is required to provide its favourable opinion (which is binding) regarding the appointment and dismissal of the Head of the Internal Audit and the allocation of adequate resources by the Board so that the Head of Internal Audit can carry out his or her duties.
When assisting the Board of Directors, the Risk Management and Internal Control Committee:
With particular reference to the tasks relating to managing and controlling risks, the Committee acts as support to the body with strategic supervisory function:
Without prejudice to the powers of the Remuneration Committee, the Risk Management and Internal Control Committee certifies that the incentives underlying the Bank's remuneration and incentive system are in line with the RAF.
The President of the Risk Management and Internal Control Committee reports to the Board of Directors at its next available meeting, on the activities carried out, whether it used any of the finances allocated to it, as well as on the suitability of the internal audit and risk management system. The President of the Committee, where necessary, assesses whether further forms of reporting are appropriate.
On the subject of transactions with related parties and/or associated persons, the Risk Management and Internal Control Committee also performs the roles assigned to it by the Board of Directors, as governed by the current "Procedures".
During 2019, the Committee's activity concerned the following key guidelines:
The Committee has also actively participated in the process which led the Board of Directors to express a positive assessment on the fact that the internal control system and the business organisation are aligned with the principles laid down in Part I, Heading IV, Chapter 3 of Bank of Italy circular no. 285/2013 as amended and that company control functions meet the requirements and comply with the provisions of Section III of the above Supervisory Regulations.
The Committee may access all company information deemed relevant for the performance of its tasks and may have autonomous use of a set of financial resources to the limit of €60,000 per year established by the Board and with the requirement of reporting on the use of funds.
The internal control system plays a central role in the organisation of Banca IFIS, represents a fundamental element for monitoring corporate risks and their inter-relations; in addition, it encourages the dissemination of a proper culture of risks, lawfulness and corporate values.
The Banca IFIS Group's internal control system consists of rules, procedures and organisational structures aimed at ensuring, among other things, monitoring of the strategic risk, the effectiveness and efficiency of processes, and compliance of operations with the law, supervisory regulations, and the policies, procedures and codes of conduct adopted by the Group.
All business operations are subject to audits: by the functions or business Areas that own the various processes and operations (line controls or first line of defence), second line of defence functions (Risk Management, Compliance and Anti-Money Laundering), and third line of defence functions (Internal Audit).
In defining the strategic plan, the Board of Directors has defined the nature and level of risk compatible with the Bank's strategic objectives, including in its assessments all risks that may have an impact on medium/long-term sustainability.
In the document "Group guidelines on the Internal Control system", last updated in September 2018, the Board of Directors defined the guidelines at Group level:
Risk Management is required to identify the risks the Parent and the Group companies are exposed to and measures and monitors them on a regular basis through specific risk indicators, planning potential actions to mitigate material risks. The goal is to provide a holistic and comprehensive view of the risks the Group is exposed to, ensuring an adequate reporting to governance bodies. Risk Management regularly reports to corporate bodies on its operations through the Dashboard-as well as, if required, to the Bank of Italy and CONSOB.
The Group's overall risk governance and management structure is governed by the Risk Appetite Framework and the relevant documents, which are constantly updated based on the evolution of the Group's strategic framework. Concerning the changes in the Group's scope, Banca IFIS promptly aligns and integrates risk governance and management methods while taking into account the peculiarities of each business.
Specifically, Banca IFIS has prepared a Taxonomy of Risks describing how it identifies the existing and/or potential risks the Group could be exposed to in pursuing its strategic goals as well as the tools for preventing and mitigating each type of risk.
The Parent carries out an initial identification of risks based on the list of the minimum risks laid down by supervisory regulations, adding any additional material risks emerged during the analysis of the business model and reference markets in which the Group's companies operate, the strategic outlook, operational methods, and the characteristics of loans and funding sources.
Identifying risks and regularly updating the relevant taxonomy is the result of the joint work of second line of defence functions (Risk Management, Compliance, Anti-Money Laundering) and third line of defence functions (Internal Audit), which meet once a year to discuss whether to introduce new risk events and/or review the assessment of potential risks based on the risk management outcomes of the previous year.
The Supervisory Board is tasked with suitably identifying and monitoring the risks as per (It.) Legislative Decree 231/2001 that are or may be assumed with regard to actual corporate processes, constantly updating the Organisational Model by mapping risk areas and "sensitive processes".
The Risk Management and Internal Control Committee is responsible for supporting the Board of Directors in making assessments and decisions concerning the internal control and risk management system.
The audit work performed by Compliance (systematic audits and inspections) is based on the plans approved by the Board of Directors and seeks to evaluate the effectiveness of the required, proposed or implemented organisational measures intended to manage the risk of non-compliance. The audits' outcomes are formalised in reports that are shared with the competent corporate functions, which are requested to provide feedback on the remedial actions identified and on the schedule of their implementation. These obligations are subject to the monitoring of the department and to periodic reporting to the corporate bodies, through the Dashboard and, where envisaged, to the Bank of Italy and CONSOB.
Concerning the regulations for which there is specialised supervision (e.g.: occupational safety or personal data processing), the responsibilities of Compliance can be adjusted, for instance by making the organisational unit responsible for coordinating methods, so that it can provide the Corporate Bodies with a comprehensive view of the exposure to the risk of noncompliance. In any case, Compliance, at a minimum and together with the relevant specialised structures, is responsible for defining non-compliance risk assessment methods, identifying the relevant procedures, and reviewing whether these are adequate.
Compliance operates using two types of approaches:
It continuously monitors the evolution of the regulatory framework and performs impact assessments, provides advice and support to business on new projects and on the correct management of the risk, carries out compliance checks on processes and products, monitors the effectiveness of internal processes.
In addition, when starting a major project (such as acquisitions or the launch of new products or operations), the Compliance function actively participates by providing operational and other recommendations on how to properly manage the risk of non-compliance, for instance in terms of precautions and controls to be implemented, regulations impacted, and monitoring actions to be taken.
To promote a culture of respect for the law at all organisational levels, in 2019 the Group provided refresher courses and training programmes to employees to make sure they acquire and develop the knowledge necessary to comply with the law, internal rules, and industry regulations. Compliance informs the structures concerned of any regulatory changes deemed significant, and either provides training or encourages more comprehensive training initiatives by involving Human Resources.
Anti-Money Laundering performs systematic second line of defence audits concerning the risk of money-laundering and financing of terrorism to ensure the relevant procedures are properly applied to operational processes, and develops Key Risk Indicators representing the most significant risk factors to be monitored. The function shares the audit findings and the action plan with the relevant Management. These audits and indicators are also displayed in the Dashboard on a quarterly basis and reported to the Board of Directors as well as, if required, to the Bank of Italy. Anti-Money Laundering also monitors the evolution of the regulatory framework on matters under its purview, notifying the structures affected and taking action for the necessary adjustments. To guarantee the effective application of the anti-money laundering regulatory framework, the function also ensures the implementation of staff training programmes that guarantee full awareness of the corporate purposes, principles, obligations and responsibilities in matters of the fight against money laundering.
The audit work performed by Internal Audit concerns all processes and consists in regularly monitoring the application of all the Bank's operational policies, procedures and practices to identify potential areas of improvement of the corporate processes, violations of internal and external rules as well as evaluate the effectiveness of the internal control system as a whole.
Internal Audit operates based on the plans approved by the Board of Directors, which, for 2019, were discussed in the meeting of 18th July 2019, and conducts unplanned audits if required. Audit findings are shared with the relevant organisational unit as well as second line of defence functions, which are involved because of either their expertise or their responsibilities on a case-by-case basis, and submitted to the Board of Statutory Auditors and shared with the Risk Management and Internal Control Committee during quarterly reporting. Internal Audit reports to the Corporate Bodies, specifically by presenting specific reports (Annual reports and Quarterly Dashboards) that, if required, are also submitted to the Bank of Italy or CONSOB.
The overall risk management and internal control system was the subject of a positive evaluation by the Board of Directors and by the Board of Statutory Auditors at the meeting held on 28th March 2019.
***
a.1. Introduction
In relation to the financial reporting process, the risk management and internal control system are components of the same overall "System", which is designed, among other things, to ensure the credibility, accuracy, reliability and timeliness of financial reporting.
To ensure appropriate safeguards and correct mitigation against the risk of inaccurate financial reporting, Banca IFIS has a specific analysis framework that crosses the various business processes and aims to identify and control the main risks that the Company is exposed to in carrying out significant transactions that generate the information contained in the financial statements and any other report of a financial nature.
The application of the framework is designed to ensure accuracy, reliability and timeliness of financial reporting, working towards integration with the overall risk management and internal control system.
The provisions in the Articles of Association concerning the Financial Reporting Officer, the appointment of the current Financial Reporting Officer, the Group's Risk Management Policy Regarding Inaccurate Financial Reporting, the updated "Financial Reporting Officer's Scope of Activity" and the "Financial Reporting Officer's Regulations and the Monitoring and Control of Financial Reporting", approved by the Board of Directors, comprise, together with the overall set of administrative and accounting procedures, the collection of measures adopted by the Bank to cover the risk of inaccurate financial reporting.
The framework is made up of several levels of analysis that, together, define adequate Group administrative and accounting procedures. It is inspired by the principles and guidelines defined by the Internal Control - Integrated Framework issued by the Committee of Sponsoring Organisations of the Treadway Commission (known as CoSO) and by the Control Objectives for Information and related Technology (known as CobiT), considered as reference models accepted internationally.
The framework analysis levels are as follows:
The process of managing the risk of inaccurate financial reporting and the methods of collaboration and coordination between the Monitoring and Control of Financial Reporting department, the Accounting and Financial Statement department and the Bank's other departments and bodies are defined within the Group Policy to manage the risk of inaccurate financial reporting, approved by the Board of Directors. The Accounting and Financial Statement department is required to perform administrative and accounting tasks, as well as producing financial reports with the contribution of the Financial Reporting Officer and certified by the latter pursuant to Article 154-bis of the TUF.
The operational approach that characterises the overall process of risk management of inaccurate financial reporting is divided, in line with the Bank's risk management process phases, into the following sub-processes:
• Identification: the Monitoring and Control of Financial Reporting department, with operational support from the Accounting and Financial Statement section, identifies entities to be included in the scope of verification activities. The significance of Subsidiary Companies is assessed annually on the basis of the criteria adopted.
In light of the significant responsibilities entrusted to them, the Financial Reporting Officer is attributed appropriate powers and resources to perform their duties, as detailed in the last paragraph, number 11.5. The Financial Reporting Officer receives all cooperation necessary from all of the Bank's organisational units to carry out the activities of the role, having guaranteed free access to all areas, information, accounting records and documents relating to the role's activities. In addition, if necessary, they may require information or documents held by external suppliers, through the relevant contact point for the outsourced activity. Lastly, the Financial Reporting Officer may agree with each organisational unit involved in the process on the procedures for transmitting the information flows necessary to carry out their duties.
The Financial Reporting Officer, in performing their activities, has access to the Monitoring and Control of Financial Reporting organisational unit. This OU assesses the completeness, suitability, functionality and reliability of the internal control system, focusing on producing financial reports and managing the risk of their potential inaccuracy.
The Monitoring and Control of Financial Reporting section works closely with the Finance, Organisation and Operations organisational units, each in relation to its own activities.
Internal Audit assesses the completeness, suitability, functionality and reliability of the process to manage the risk of inaccurate financial reporting.
As part of the management and administration activities exercised by the Parent Company over Group Companies, the Parent Company's Finance Department issues administrative and accounting guidance by which the organisational units of the Group Companies must abide when carrying out the activities under their responsibility.
In view of the fact that the Group's configuration includes entities considered as significant in defining the scope of the Financial Reporting Officer's activities (the so-called identification phase), Banca IFIS, as part of the management and administration activities it exercises over Subsidiary Companies, requires the following to be carried out, via the Parent Company's Financial Reporting Officer:
The Board of Directors, appointed by the shareholders at the Shareholders' Meeting of 19th April 2019, has confirmed that the Chief Executive Officer is the director in charge of overseeing the functionality of the risk management and internal control system.
In his managing role, he constantly reported back to the Board of Directors on all aspects of business management, including verification of the overall suitability, effectiveness and efficiency of the risk management and internal control system.
The Chief Executive Officer also:
Since 1st June 2019, Angelo Ferracchiati has replaced Ruggero Miceli, accountant, who went on pension, as Head of Internal Audit.
Ferracchiati was appointed on proposal of the director tasked with overseeing the functionality of the risk management and internal control system, in the Board meeting of 30th May 2019, with the favourable opinion of the Risk Management and Internal Control Committee and after consulting with the Board of Statutory Auditors.
On his appointment, the Board, on proposal formulated by the Remuneration Committee, requested the Chief Executive Officer, the General Manager and the Head of Human Resources to define his remuneration.
The unit is a staff department of the Board of Directors and it is not responsible for any operational area; from time to time it is provided with resources that are adequate to carry out its own activities.
The positioning of the Internal Audit in the organisational chart as a staff department of the Board of Directors, in addition to assuring its independence – in line with the Bank of Italy's guidance and with sector best practice – facilitates the appropriate exchange of information with the Risk Management and Internal Control Committee, with the Board of Statutory Auditors and, in general, with company bodies and management.
The mission assigned to the Internal Audit by the related regulation, approved by the Board of Directors, includes verifying that the risk management and internal control system is complete, suitable, functional and reliable.
***
The Group's Internal Auditing Regulations require the Parent Company's Internal Audit department to define a plan of activities that is based on a structured process of analysis and prioritisation of the main risks and takes into account the different levels of risk involved in the various activities and structures of the Parent Company and its Subsidiary Companies. Specifically with regard to the companies of the Banca IFIS Group, a contact point of the Internal Audit Department was appointed, that each Subsidiary has outsourced to the Bank; the contact point reports hierarchically to the Head of the Bank's Auditing Department, but functionally to the Subsidiaries' Administrative and Control Bodies.
The Audit Plan lists the controls planned for a three-year period (multi-year plan) and contains a separate and detailed presentation of the activities planned for the first 18 months. A specific section of the Audit Plan is dedicated to ICT auditing.
Subject to the administration of and cooperation with other control functions, taking into account the importance of the activities programmed by second-level control functions, the Audit Plan is not usually submitted until the Parent Company's Risk Management, Compliance and Anti-Money Laundering control units have submitted their own activity programmes to management.
The Audit Plan is forwarded simultaneously to the Board of Statutory Auditors, to the Risk Management and Internal Control Committee, to the President of the Board of Directors, to the director in charge of the risk management and internal control system (who is also the Chief Executive Officer) as well as to the Parent Company's General Manager for subsequent review by the Board of Directors. The Audit Plan is updated as and when it is deemed necessary, upon request from management and/or when proposed by the Head of Internal Audit.
During the financial year 2019, the Board, with the favourable opinion of the Risk Management and Internal Control Committee, approved a new "Audit Plan for 2019-2021". The activities foreseen for 2019 were developed mainly in two directions: a planning direction, for the development of the Department, and one aiming to guarantee continuity in the internal audit of the Group's main processes.
During 2019, the Head of Internal Audit inter alia:
The main activities carried out by the Head of Internal Audit during 2019 were based on the above Audit Plan and concerned, to varying degrees in accordance with the level of risk, the Parent Company (Banca IFIS S.p.A.) and its Subsidiary Companies.
Audit activities regarding the Polish subsidiary, IFIS Finance, were conducted by Internal Audit, either directly or with the cooperation of BDO Sp. z o.o.
The auditing of Group companies mainly referred to the NPL segment with particular attention paid to the main processes of the two Group companies that operated in the sector (IFIS NPL and FBS), the Bank's commercial segment and, specifically: the leasing and factoring business units, the pharmacy segment, important outsourced operating functions, and management of business liquidity. Audit activities were also carried out on the IT system, the second-level control units and certain transversal corporate processes not directly and uniquely related to specific business areas, in particular, with reference to the process of management of operational continuity, to the compliance of remuneration practices with the regulatory framework.
Alongside the quarterly reports (Dashboard) and the Annual Report on the work carried out, in compliance with the supervisory bodies' provisions, the Head of Internal Audit also prepared specific reports concerning:
lastly, Internal Audit liaised with second-level control units regarding the areas of risk they cover, constantly promoting coordination and sharing meetings.
Banca IFIS Group, sensitive to the need to ensure conditions of transparency and fairness in conducting its business, in order to safeguard the image of the individual companies that belong to the Group, the expectations of shareholders and of those who work for and with the Group's companies, has deemed it consistent with its corporate policies to implement the Organisational and Management Model provided for by (It.) Legislative Decree 231/2001.
This initiative was also launched in the belief that applying the Organisational Model is a sound means of informing those who work for the Bank, spurring them to act fairly and consistently when carrying out their activities, in order to limit the risk of the crimes set out in (It.) Legislative Decree no. 231/2001 being committed.
The Banca IFIS Group condemns behaviour that is contrary to current legislation and the ethics principles set out in the Bank's Code of Ethics. In this context, the application and effective implementation of the Model improve the Bank's Corporate Governance, limiting the risk of the crimes set out in (It.) Legislative Decree no. 231/2001 being committed.
On 26th October 2004, the Board of Directors appointed a Supervisory Board with the autonomous powers of initiative and control as per (It.) Legislative Decree 231/2001; in the meeting of 19th April 2019, it confirmed the decision, already adopted by the previous directors, not to entrust the tasks of the Supervisory Board to the Board of Statutory Auditors. The Supervisory Board is composed of an Auditor, by the Heads of the Internal Audit and Compliance Departments, and by two independent directors, one of whom holds the office of President.
In preparing its Organisational Model, updated on 11th February 2019, Banca IFIS used the ABI's (Italian Banking Association) "Guidelines for the adoption of organisational models regarding a bank's administrative liability". These provide guidance on the interpretation and analysis of the legal and organisational implications resulting from the introduction of (It.) Legislative Decree no. 231/2001.
In preparing its Model, Banca IFIS considered its existing and widely implemented procedures and control systems, in that they are suitable as measures to prevent crimes and to control processes. The Model is part of a broader control system that consists mainly of the Internal Control Systems required by the Bank of Italy and by the Corporate Governance rules that apply to the company.
In addition, viewing its organisational and management model as a key company policy tool, Banca IFIS extends the organisational instruments that form part of the Organisational Model adopted by the Bank to its subsidiaries as applicable.
The "Banca IFIS Organisational Model" is currently made up of the following organisational tools:
The Supervisory Board's Regulations are available on the Bank's website, in the section "Corporate Governance – The Value of Ethics".
At present, the rules in question refer to the following types of crime:
The Supervisory Board's mandate is for three years; it meets at least quarterly. Regular minutes are kept at the meetings, recorded in the Minutes Book. The President of the Supervisory Board, or other member as designated on a case by case basis by the President, reports to the Board of Directors, at its first available meeting, on the activities already carried out and, where this is the case, the activities being carried out and/or planned and whether any of its autonomous budget has been used.
The Board has autonomous powers of initiative and control, pursuant to (It.) Legislative Decree no. 231/2001 "Governance of administrative liability of legal persons, companies and associations including without legal status".
The Shareholders' Meeting of 17th April 2014 appointed EY S.p.A. to audit the Company's annual financial statement and the Group's consolidated financial statement as well as the limited auditing of Banca IFIS's half-yearly interim report, for each of the nine financial years with closing dates from 31st December 2014 until 31st December 2022.
EY S.p.A. have also been tasked, by means of separate formalised agreements, with auditing the controlling company's financial statement and those of Banca IFIS's Subsidiary Companies.
On 12th April 2016, the Board of Directors appointed Mariacristina Taormina as Financial Reporting Officer with effect from 18th April 2016.
Pursuant to Article 19 of the Articles of Association:
The Board of Directors gives the Financial Reporting Officer autonomous spending powers, in accordance with the programmed plan of activities they intend to implement. The Financial Reporting Officer must report periodically to the Board of Directors on the exercise of their spending powers.
The Financial Reporting Officer also has the right to:
***
The names of the Heads of the other company functions who have been assigned specific tasks on risk management and internal control are shown below:
The Heads of Internal Audit, Risk Management, Compliance and of the Anti-Money Laundering Unit:
The duties and responsibilities of the above second- and third-level control functions are in line with the supervisory provisions on internal control systems.
As part of the Group's internal control system, the Parent Company is responsible for creating a unitary system at Group level that enables the effective control of both the Group's strategic choices as a whole and the balanced management of its individual components.
The correct functioning of the internal control system is based on successful interaction whilst carrying out of tasks (guidance, implementation, verification, assessment) between management, any committees formed within management bodies, external auditors and control functions.
For this reason, in line with what is required by the Corporate Governance Code, the Board of Directors, appointed by the Ordinary Shareholders' Meeting of 19th April 2019, has confirmed that the Chief Executive Officer is the director in charge of overseeing the functionality of the risk management and internal control system.
In addition, fruitful interaction and coordination between the top management involved in the risk management and internal control system is facilitated by cross-membership mechanisms and by a balanced composition of committees and bodies; in particular, the Risk Management and Internal Control System Committee and the Board of Statutory Auditors interact frequently during their meetings, and, whenever necessary, with the Chief Executive Officer, with the Financial Reporting Officer responsible for preparing company accounts, with the External Auditor, with the Chief Risk Officer, with the Head of Compliance and the Head of Anti-Money Laundering. They also systematically interact with the Head of Internal Audit who, usually, attends the meetings of both bodies.
The Supervisory Board ex (It.) Legislative Decree 231/2001 benefits of the same cross-membership mechanisms and similar systematic interaction with the other staff of the risk management and internal control system.
The Heads of the control organisational units liaise with each other, coordinating and collaborating, to avoid overlapping, to develop synergies and to optimise partnership.
At least quarterly, normally initiated by the Head of Internal Audit, the Heads of organisational units who manage the Parent Company's control functions1 take part in the control functions' coordination meetings convoked at certain times to discuss and exchange views on the following issues:
Meetings are subject to appropriate tracking and, in relation to the specific matters to be discussed, representatives of other organisational units may be invited to participate.
Meeting minutes and other documentation of common interest are:
1 Invitations to these meetings may be extended to contacts or Heads of Group Company control functions, where established, if deemed to be appropriate by the Parent Company.
In June 2018, the Board of Directors approved – following favourable opinion from the Board of Statutory Auditors, the Risk Management and Internal Control Committee (composed of only independent directors) and the Financial Reporting Officer – an update to the "Policy to control risk assets and conflicts of interest in dealings with associated persons" and the "Procedure to manage related-party transactions" (a definition which includes, in accordance with the Bank of Italy's supervisory provisions, "related parties" and persons "associated" with them). A minor update to the Procedure was approved by the General Manager on 9th October 2018.
The Policy, which outlines the Bank's approach to achieve effective management of risks associated with conflicts of interest in transactions with related parties and associated persons, and the Procedure, which describes, among other things, the criteria for identifying transactions that must be approved by the Board after receiving opinion from (or involving) the Risk Management and Internal Control Committee, is available on the website www.bancaifis.it (under "Corporate Governance – Corporate Documents – Related Parties and Associated Persons").
The Board has adopted further appropriate operational solutions to identify and adequately manage situations in which a director holds an interest in their own name or on behalf of a third-party. These are the Policy on Personal Transactions (last updated in July 2019) and the Policy on transactions carried out by Key Personnel and by people closely associated with them regarding shares, negotiable instruments and associated financial instruments issued by Banca IFIS (last updated in October 2018).
The Policy on Personal Transactions governs the obligations related to the identification of Key Personnel and to the information that the Bank must provide thereto; the rules with which Key Personnel must comply to report to the Bank Personal Transactions Subject to Notification made on Financial Instruments; the means of maintaining the Key Personnel Register, of the Third Issuer Register, and of the Personal Transactions.
In fact, the Policy on Personal Transactions governs trading in a financial instrument carried out by or on behalf of a key member of personnel (including the members of the Board of Directors), provided at least one of the following conditions is met:
This document is available on we website www.bancaifis.it (under the "Corporate Governance - Internal Dealing").
The appointment of members of the Board of Statutory Auditors is regulated by Article 21 of the Articles of Association and is based on lists presented by shareholders on which candidates are listed in sequential order and with a number of candidates not exceeding the number of members to be elected. Each list consists of two sections: one for candidates for the office of Standing Auditor, and the other for candidates for the office of Alternate Auditor.
A list can be presented by the shareholder or shareholders who, at the time of submission, own an equity interest equal to at least 1% of ordinary shares, or to another lower ownership threshold that – pursuant to current legislation and regulatory provisions – must be indicated in the notice convoking the Shareholders' Meeting called to pass a resolution to appoint Statutory Auditors.
A shareholder may not present or vote more than one lists, even through a third party or a trust company. Shareholders belonging to the same group and shareholders who have stipulated a shareholder agreement related to shares of the Company may not present or vote more than one lists, even through a third party or a trust company. A candidate may only be present on one list, on pain of ineligibility.
Two Standing Auditors and one Alternate Auditor are elected from the list that obtained the highest number of votes, based on the sequential order in which they appear on the list. The candidate who is in first position of the relevant section of the list that obtained the highest number of votes among the lists submitted and voted upon by shareholders who are not associated with the reference shareholders pursuant to Article 148, paragraph 2 of (It.) Legislative Decree no. 58/1998, is elected as Standing Auditor. The candidate who is in first position of the relevant section of that same list is elected as Alternate Auditor.
In the case of a tie between two or more lists, the oldest candidates will be elected as Statutory Auditors.
If the selection criteria do not ensure election of at least one Standing Auditor and one Alternate Auditor belonging to the least represented gender, a sliding mechanism is applied to the selection from the list obtaining, during the Shareholders' Meeting, the highest number of votes based on the sequential order in which the candidates are indicated. This mechanism excludes the candidate or candidates of the most represented gender and selects the candidate or candidates of the missing gender.
The Standing Auditor elected from the minority list mentioned above is appointed as President of the Board of Statutory Auditors.
Outgoing Statutory Auditors can be re-elected, for no more than three mandates, in compliance with the regulatory provisions and the Corporate Governance Code.
If, despite the provisions of the Articles of Association and what is set out above, only one list is presented or only one list receives votes, three Standing and two Alternate Auditors will be elected – on condition that the list in question receives the majority of the votes represented at the Shareholders' Meeting – in the order in which they are indicated on that list for the respective post. The Standing Auditor candidate indicated in first place on the list will be appointed President of the Board of Statutory Auditors.
If a Standing Auditor is to be replaced, their post will go to the Alternate Auditor belonging to the same list as the Auditor who has ceased to hold office.
If it is necessary to appoint Standing and/or Alternate Auditors to supplement the Board of Statutory Auditors following early termination of the auditors in office, the Shareholders' Meeting will act as follows: if auditors elected from the majority list must be replaced, the auditor(s) are appointed by majority vote, without list constraints. If, however, it is necessary to replace a Statutory Auditor designated from the minority list, the Shareholders' Meeting will replace them by relative majority vote, choosing the candidate from among the candidates on the list from which the auditor to be replaced was elected. These candidates will have confirmed their candidacy at least 25 days before the date set for the first-call Shareholders' Meeting, together with statements confirming that no reasons for ineligibility or incompatibility exist, and that they possess the requirements needed to hold the post.
Lists must be submitted to the Company's registered office at least twenty-five days prior to the date set for the first-call Shareholders' Meeting, and are made available to the public at the registered office, on the Company's website and through the other methods provided for by current legislation and regulatory provisions at least twenty-one days prior to the date of the first-call Shareholders' Meeting.
Ownership of the minimum number of shares needed to submit a list is determined by taking into account the shares recorded in the name of the individual shareholder or multiple joint-shareholders on the day lists are submitted to the Company. In order to prove the ownership of the number of shares necessary to present the lists, the shareholders may produce the related certificate even after the deposit, on the condition that this is done within the deadline foreseen for the publication of the lists by the Company.
The lists must be accompanied:
Candidates who already hold the post of auditor in five other listed companies or who do not possess the integrity, professionalism and independence requirements as set out in applicable regulations or that fall within the cases referred to in Article 148, para. 3 of (It.) Legislative Decree no. 58/1998, may not be included in candidate lists. It should be noted that (It.) Legislative Decree no. 72/2015 initiated a comprehensive reform to the requirements of corporate officers, aimed at integrating the objective requirements of integrity and professionalism with skills and correctness criteria that will be incorporated in secondary legislation to be issued by the Ministry of Economy and Finance. As of the date of this Report, the new legislation has not been defined by the Ministry.
Each list must contain at least one candidate for the post of Standing Auditor and at least one candidate for the post of Alternate Auditor belonging to the least represented gender. This requirement does not apply to lists with fewer than three candidates.
The composition of the Board of Statutory Auditors in post as at the close of the 2019 financial year is as follows:
The present Board of Statutory Auditors was elected at the Ordinary Shareholders' Meeting of 19th March 2019 for the 2019, 2020 and 2021 financial years and its mandate will expire on the date on which the Shareholders' Meeting is convoked to approve the 2021 Annual Financial Statements.
Three lists of candidates were presented, deposited and published within the deadlines and in the manner laid down by the applicable provisions and by the Articles of Association for the election of the Board of Statutory Auditors at the Shareholders' Meeting of 19th April 2019; specifically:
As well as the lists, the following documents were also deposited and published:
Table 9 shows the list of candidates, the list of those elected and the percentage of votes obtained with regard to voting capital, while Table 10 provides various information on the Board of Statutory Auditors for the financial year 2019.
| LIST | LIST OF CANDIDATES | LIST OF CANDIDATES ELECTED | PERCENTAGE OF VOTES OBTAINED |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Standing Auditors: Franco Olivetti Marinella Monterumisi Alternate Auditors: Anna Maria Salvador Alessandro Carducci Artenisio |
Standing Auditors: Franco Olivetti Marinella Monterumisi Alternate Auditors: Alessandro Carducci Artenisio |
67.04% |
| 2 | Standing Auditors: Giacomo Bugna Alternate Auditors: Giuseppina Manzo |
President: Giacomo Bugna Alternate Auditors: Giuseppina Manzo |
22.58% |
| 3 | Standing Auditors: Paolo Bifulco Alternate Auditors: Giorgio Stefano Marcolongo |
5.70% |
| Components | In office | First | List | Indep. | % particip. BSA | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Role | from | to | appointment date |
(M/m)* | Code | meetings ** | |
| President | Giacomo Bugna | 19/04/2019 | Approval of 2021 financial statements |
2013 | m | X | 100 |
| Standing Auditor | Franco Olivetti | 19/04/2019 | Approval of 2021 financial statements |
2019 | M | X | 100 |
| Standing Auditor | Marinella Monterumisi | 19/04/2019 | Approval of 2021 financial statements |
2019 | M | X | 100 |
| Alternate Auditor | Giuseppina Manzo | 19/04/2019 | Approval of 2021 financial statements |
2019 | m | X | |
| Alternate Auditor | Alessandro Carducci Artenisio | 19/04/2019 | Approval of 2021 financial statements |
2019 | M | × | |
| Auditors who ceased to hold office during the Financial Year 2019 | |||||||
| Standing Auditor | Massimo Miani | 2016 | Approval of 2018 financial statements |
2016 | M | X | 87.5 |
| Standing Auditor | Giovanna Ciriotto | 2016 | Approval of 2018 financial statements |
2013 | M | × | 87.5 |
| Alternate Auditor | Valentina Martina | 2016 | Approval of 2018 financial statements |
2016 | M | X | |
| Alternate Auditor | Guido Gasparini Berlingieri | 2016 | Approval of 2018 financial statements |
2016 | M | X | |
| Quorum required for the presentation of the lists by minorities for the election of one or more members (ex Article 147-ter of the TUF): 1% | |||||||
| No. of meetings held during the financial year of reference: 28 | |||||||
| Notes: r |
The members of the Board of Statutory Auditors were found to meet the requirements set forth by the applicable regulations, the requirements of integrity, fairness, professionalism and skill, independence and interlocking restriction were checked, on the occasion of the renewal of the body, with notification to the Board of Directors on 9th May 2019.
Other than what is laid down by Article 148, paragraph 3 of the TUF and the Code, the assessment of the requirements of all corporate executive includes the verification of the requirements based on the Applicable Regulatory Framework in relation to Requirements of Article 26 of the TUB, also checking the absence of any critical elements related to the criteria set forth by the Draft Decree on the requirements of integrity, fairness, professionalism, skill, independence and independence of judgement.
The personal and professional characteristics of each auditor (pursuant to Article 144-decies of the CONSOB Issuer Regulation), based on the statements provided by each of them and attached to the lists, and on any subsequent updates notified by those concerned, are summarised below.
He acquired his experience at a leading auditing firm, providing both auditing and advisory services for financial institutions.
In 1997-1998, he was responsible for introducing the certification of financial statements at the Bank of Italy. From 2011, and until April 2014, he was a Member of the Board of the "Fédération des Experts-comptables Européens" (Federation of European Expert Accountants), which groups together the professional associations of the 27 EU Member States.
Born in Venice on 6th May 1974, Qualified Auditor and Public Accountant, a member of the Order of Chartered Accountants and Expert Accountants of Venice since 2006, he is the proprietor of the Professional Firm Lex-Tax, with registered office in Treviso. A member of the Board of Directors, Auditor and Standing Statutory Auditors in corporations, financial companies and IPAB [Public Welfare Institutions], he performs his professional activities by providing consultancy on corporate and taxation matters, with skills and experience in the economic/financial restructuring and reorganisation of companies and in assignments for admissions to collective procedures.
Qualified Auditor and Public Accountant in Rimini, she has been a member of the Order of Chartered Accountants and Expert Accountants of the province of Rimini since 1978.
Since that date, she has performing her professional activities through her own firm, providing consultancy on corporate and taxation matters, with specific skills in the industrial and manufacturing sector. She acts as Independent Technical Consultant and Party-Appointed Expert in arbitration procedures. She is a member of the Board of Directors of companies listed in the STAR segment, S.G. of Credit Institutions and corporations. Auditor and Standing Statutory Auditor in corporations, AIM listed companies, Public Bodies - Municipalities - Municipal Undertakings and Credit Institutions, she audits and controls the approach to taxation with regard to direct and indirect taxes, audit of accounts and financial statements in accordance with the instructions of the Italian Board of Professional Accountants and Auditors.
She graduated summa cum laude with a degree in Economy from the Università Bocconi and then went on to obtain the Executive Master in Corporate Finance & Banking from SDA Bocconi. Since 2006, she has worked for Partners S.p.A. where she consolidated her experience in professional consultancy on matters of financial statements and extraordinary finance, in particular handling audits of companies and shareholdings, providing her opinion on the financial statements and the application of accounting standards (OIC and IAS/IFRS), extraordinary transactions, technical consultancy. She is a Qualified Auditor and Public Accountant. Currently she holds the office of statutory auditor in companies of the industrial and service sectors.
An accountant in Milan, he specialises in extraordinary finance and crisis solutions. He is an associate professor at the LIUC University of Castellanza, giving courses on private Equity in cooperation with the AIFI [Italian Private Equity Venture Capital Association]. He was the founding partner of Teca Consulting, a Milan-based company that has been active for over twenty years.
He often golds office in bodies active in the financial sector on behalf of the Bank of Italy.
***
Below please find the division of the current members of the Board of Statutory Auditors by age group and gender.


During the financial year 2019, the Board of Statutory Auditors met 28 times (6 of which were joint meetings with the Risk Management and Internal Control Committee and 2 joint meetings with all three Board Committees); the meetings lasted for 2 hours and 40 minutes on average. On the date of approval of this Report 7 meetings had been held, of which 2 were joint meetings with the Risk Management and Internal Control Committee, out of 22 meetings planned for 2020.
The aims of the self-assessment process that the Board of Auditors undergoes on the assignment of its duties include that of checking the correct and effective functioning of the Body and its suitability in terms of composition, skills and professionalism.
The qualitative composition for average age and gender is good, including with regard to the statutory provision which states that at least one standing auditor and one alternate must belong to the least represented gender.
The self-assessment process also highlighted the suitability of professional skills and characteristics, as well as noting that the spread and diversification of skills are in line with the Bank's complexity and its activities.
The diversification of skills and professionalism enables Auditors to make an appropriate contribution to the activities of the Board of Statutory Auditors and promotes multiple approaches and perspectives to analysing problems and making decisions on which actions to carry out.
In this sense, the diversification of Board members' skills was believed to be mostly appropriate in relation to the their main activities, which include:
During checks on whether the Auditors possess the professionalism, integrity and independence required of Directors and Auditors, differentiation of expertise was noted; it should also be noted that the independence requirement is subject to the obligation for individuals who perform control functions to be entered in the Register of Auditors (Article 3 of (It.) Ministerial Decree no. 161/98).
In any case, the Bank, aware of the need for members of administration and control bodies to have the technical skills to enable them to properly fulfil their roles, invited members of the Board of Auditors to take part in the course "Advanced training for the Board of Directors" of the Italian Banking Association, as well as in additional courses indicated by the auditors.
Taking all this into account, the Bank is not considering the adoption of additional and specific policies in relation to the diversity of the composition of the supervision body.
The criteria adopted correspond to the independence requirements set forth by the Corporate Governance Code and Article 148, paragraph 3 of the TUF; the positive results were notified to the Board of Directors, which informed the public by means of a communication to the market disseminated on the same date, i.e. on 19th April 2019.
***
The check of the continued presence of the independence requirements took place on 11th March 2020; the results of the check were notified to the Board on 12th March 2020 and, aside from the criteria mentioned above, all the criteria set forth by the Code with reference to directors' independence were applied.
The members of the Board of Statutory Auditors must meet the requirements of integrity and professionalism laid down by the Regulation adopted by decree of the (It.) Minister of Justice no. 162 of 30th March 2000, as well as the independence requirements set forth by (It.) Legislative Decree 58/1998 (TUF) and the Corporate Governance Code (Article 8).
In addition, the Board periodically checks the ability of its members to perform the functions of control body with professionalism, availability of time, and independence, as well as the Board's suitability in terms of powers, roles and composition, taking into account the size and complexity of the activities of Banca IFIS.
The remuneration of the Statutory Auditors is in line with the effort requested of them, with the importance of their role and with the company's size and structure.
In line with the provisions of the Corporate Governance Code and also pursuant to the provisions of Article 136, paragraph 1 of the TUB ("Obligations of banking officers"), if a Statutory Auditor, either directly or on behalf of a third party, has an interest in a particular transaction of the Issuer, they must inform the other Statutory Auditors and the President of the Board of Directors promptly and exhaustively about the nature, terms, origin and extent of their interest. The Statutory Auditors also fall within the scope of the "Procedure to manage related-party transactions" outlined in Section 12.
To coordinate with the other stakeholders of the risk management and internal control system, the Board of Statutory Auditors liaised mostly, as set out by the Corporate Governance Code, with Internal Audit, whose Head normally attends the Board of Statutory Auditors meetings, as well as with the Appointments Committee – whose meetings are normally attended by the President of the Board of Statutory Auditors – and the Risk Management and Internal Control Committee and the Remuneration Committee.
In compliance with the requirements of Circular no. 285/2013 of the Bank of Italy (Section VII, Chapter 1, Heading IV, Part One), Table 11 shows the number and type of the assignments of the standing members of the Board of Statutory Auditors of Banca IFIS on the date this Report was presented, based on the information provided by them.
Table 11
| POSTS HELD BY THE MEMBERS OF THE BOARD OF STATUTORY AUDITORS IN OTHER COMPANIES | ||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Management and control posts in the companies of Book V, Heading V, Chapters V, VI and VII of the (It.) Civil Code |
Other posts | TOTAL | ||||
| BANKING GROUP | Others | |||||
| E. | N.E. | E | N.E. | E | N.E. | |
| 3 | 2* | 5 | ||||
| 3** | এ | |||||
| 8 1 4 |
13 | |||||
Table 12 shows details of the offices held by the Auditors in other companies.
| Undertakings belonging to the Banca IFIS Group | ||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| List of posts | NO | Banking Group | Non-banking Group |
|||
| President of the Board of Statutory Auditors of IFIS NPLS.p.A. | × | |||||
| President of the Board of Statutory Auditors of Capitalfin S.p.A. | X | |||||
| Giacomo Bugna President of the Board |
President of the Board of Statutory Auditors of IFIS Rental Services s.r.l. | X | ||||
| Auditor of FBS S.p.A. | X | |||||
| Auditor of FBS Real Estate S.p.A. | X | |||||
| Auditor of La Scogliera S.p.A. | x | |||||
| Franco Olivetti | Auditor of FBS Real Estate S.p.A. | × | ||||
| Standing Auditor | Auditor of Istituti di soggiorno per anziani San Gregorio (IPAB) | × | ||||
| Sole member of the BSA/auditor of Atesina San Marco srl | X | |||||
| Director of MARR S.p.A. | X | |||||
| President of the Board of Statutory Auditors of NEODECORTECH S.p.A. | x | |||||
| Liquidator of Costruzioni ed Impianti S.p.A. | X | |||||
| President of the Board of Statutory Auditors of Finanziaria Valentini S.p.a. | X | |||||
| President of the Board of Statutory Auditors of Industrie Valentini S.p.A. | X | |||||
| President of the Board of Statutory Auditors of Promozione Alberghiera Soc. Coop. | X | |||||
| Marinella Monterumisi | Sole auditor of Rimini welcome - destination management company società consortile a r.l. | × | ||||
| Standing Auditor | Liquidator of Immobiliare Appia S.a.s. di Bernhard Daniel | X | ||||
| Auditor of Società Agricola Le Cicogne S.r.l. | X | |||||
| Auditor of Lugo Immobiliare S.r.l. - In liquidation | X | |||||
| Co-liquidator of Gestioni Cinematografiche - GE.Cl di De Sarno Pignano Renato, Succi Massimo, Berti Ferruccio, Berti Flavio - S.n.c. (inactive company) |
x | |||||
| Auditor of Rimini Reservation S.r.l. | X | |||||
| Partner of Team Work di Miria e Marinella Monterumisi S.n.c. | x | |||||
The Bank has created some easily identifiable and accessible sections on its website, which make important information available to shareholders, in order to enable them to exercise their rights in an informed manner. In particular, it is possible to find the related material under Corporate Governance and Investor Relations.
On 29th November 2018, the Board of Directors ratified the appointment of Andrea Martino Da Rio as Head of Bank IFIS's Investor Relations department.
Since 2010, for the annual financial statements Banca IFIS has also created an interactive website, to make it possible for the public to use the economic/financial documentation. The sharing of financial subjects also foresees the sharing of the main performance indexes on the publication of the results of the financial year and of the quarterly results on the social network pages and profiles of Banca IFIS.
The "Shareholders' Meeting Regulations", the current version of which was approved by the Shareholders' Meeting on 30th April 2013, governs the manner in which meetings are called and held.
The "Regulations", which specify the maximum duration of individual contributions by attendees, their order, the voting procedure, the contributions of Directors and Statutory Auditors, and also the powers to settle and prevent the occurrence of conflicts of interest during Shareholders' Meetings, is available on the website www.bancaifis.it (in the section "Shareholders' Meetings").
The Shareholders' Meeting is, usually, chaired by the President of the Board of Directors; the Shareholders' Meeting may hear shareholders with voting rights who have sent to the Company, by the end of the third business day before that fixed by the first-call Shareholders' Meeting, the communication of the authorised intermediary, attesting their legitimation. The communication is made based on the evidence at the end of the seventh accounting day of open trading before the day set for the first-call Shareholders' Meeting.
This is subject to legitimate attendance and the exercising of the right to vote if such communication is received by the Company after the established deadline, providing this is before the start of the first-call Shareholders' Meeting works.
Anyone entitled to vote may be represented at the Shareholders' Meeting, pursuant to the law, by means of written proxy or proxy granted by electronic means.
Electronic notification of proxy may be made using the special form available on the Company website.
For each Shareholders' Meeting, as indicated in the convocation notice, the Company designates one or more individuals to whom the holders of voting rights can grant, following the methods established by applicable legislation and regulatory provisions, a proxy with voting instructions on all or some of the subjects on the agenda. The proxy is valid only with regard to the subjects for which voting instructions have been provided.
Majorities for the validity of resolutions and the drafting of the minutes are those established by legislation, applicable regulations, the Articles of Association and the Shareholders' Meeting Regulations.
All those who attend have the right to speak on each of the topics discussed. Those with rights may ask questions on the items on the agenda before the Shareholders' Meeting takes place, within the terms set out by current legislation and regulatory provisions and indicated in the convocation notice. Questions received before the deadline indicated in the notice will be answered, at the latest, during the Meeting. A single answer may be given to questions with the same content. Those who intend to speak must ask the President, by written request containing an indication of the topic to which the question refers, after the President has read out the agenda items and until the moment the President declares discussion of the related topic closed. As a rule, the President gives permission to speak according to the chronological order in which requests are submitted. If two or more requests are submitted simultaneously, the President gives permission to speak according to the alphabetical order of the requesters' surnames. The President can authorise the submission of requests to speak by a show of hands. In this case, the President gives permission to speak according to the alphabetical order of requesters' surnames. Members of the Board of Directors, the Board of Statutory Auditors and the Bank's general management, or that of other Group companies, as well as the representatives from the External Auditors and Company and Group personnel may all ask to join the discussion when the President deems it useful in connection with the topic to be discussed.
***
During the Ordinary Shareholders' Meeting held on 19th April 2019, all members of the Board of Directors were present. All members of the Board of Statutory Auditors were also present.
During the ordinary and extraordinary Shareholders' Meeting held on 19th December 2019, eight members of the Board of Directors and all members of the Board of Statutory Auditors were present.
During the Shareholders' Meetings, the Chief Executive Officer, on behalf of the Board of Directors, makes himself available to report on the activity performed and planned by the Board, while observing the rules on inside information. The Board, including through reports made available to shareholders under the terms established by the TUF and through ongoing finetuning of the organisation of institutional communication via the website, is committed to ensuring that shareholders receive sufficient information on agenda items to enable them to take informed decisions on the resolutions proposed at Shareholders' Meetings.
***
During the Shareholders' Meetings held on 19th April and 19th December 2019, the shareholders received information on the means by which the Committee performs its functions in the context of the Report on remuneration.
***
No changes to the control structure of Banca IFIS S.p.A. were made during the financial year.
The market capitalisation of shares recorded the following values at the beginning and end of the period:
| Date | share price | no. of shares making up the share capital |
capitalisation |
|---|---|---|---|
| Friday 28th December 2018 | 15.44 | 53.811.095 | 830,843,306.8 |
| Monday 30th December 2019 | 14.00 | 53.811.095 | 753,355,330.0 |
The effects on capitalisation reflect the trends observed regarding Banca IFIS shares. There were no resulting assessments on the prerogatives intended to protect minority shareholders, who can designate the President of the Board of Statutory Auditors and one director and exercise company rights based on the large amount of information made available to investors and market operators.
No further committees have been appointed other than those described in the previous sections. Adoption of the Organisational Model pursuant to (It.) Legislative Decree no. 231/2001 is described in the third paragraph of Section 11.
In order to promote a corporate culture of lawfulness, characterised by correct behaviours founded on dignity and respect, the Bank has an internal system whereby employees can report any irregularities or infringements of relevant legislation and regulatory provisions and internal procedures (whistleblowing systems), which guarantees a specific and confidential information channel and the anonymity of the person making the report.
The analysis and processing by the competent corporate structures protect confidentiality to prevent reprisals and the discrimination of the person making the report.
In compliance with the provisions of the regulations on personal data protection, the person responsible for the internal reporting systems drafts an annual report on the correct operation of the internal reporting systems, which contains aggregated information on the results of the activities performed subsequently to the reports received, which is approved by the corporate bodies and made available to the Bank's personnel. This system is also accessible from the "Corporate Governance" "The Value of Ethics" section of the Banca IFIS website.
On the date of approval of this Report, there have been no changes in the corporate governance structure.
The President's letter and the annual Report on the application of the Corporate Governance Code were brought to the attention of the Board of Directors and of the Board of Statutory Auditors on 20th December 2019.
The subjects was discussed subsequently to the meeting of the Board of 13th January 2020, so that it may be duly taken into account in the preparation of the Report on Corporate Governance and Shareholding Structure.
The recommendations formulated in the letter were duly taken into account also in the preparation of the document pertaining to self-assessment and will be examined in a future meeting of just the independent directors.
Table 13 below summarises the contents on the main improvement areas identified in 2019.
Table 13
| Areas for improvement identified in 2019 | Considerations |
|---|---|
| The Committee invites the Boards of Directors to assess the sustainability of business activities in the definition of strategies and remuneration policies, also based on an analysis of the importance of factors that may impact the generation of value in the long term. |
The Board endorsed the integration of business activity sustainability in the definition of strategies (industrial plan 2020- 2022) and in the remuneration policies (Shareholders' Meeting of 19/12/19) with a view to generating value in the long term. |
| The Committee recommends that the company ensure, also in a possible regulation of the Board's work, an adequate management The "Regulation on the means of convocation of of the information flows to the Board of Directors, guaranteeing - I ast updated on 18th October 2018, takes that the confidentiality requirements are protected without compromising the completeness, usability and promptness of the information flows. information. |
into consideration the instructions regarding the management of |
| Areas for improvement identified in 2019 | Considerations |
|---|---|
| The Committee invites the administrative bodies to apply the independence criteria defined by the Code with greater rigour, and the control bodies to oversee the correct application of these criteria. The Committee underlines that any non- application of these criteria must be exceptional and justified on a case-by-case basis, especially, be the subject of deeper assessment at individual level, with reference to the situations on 19th April 2019 during the assessment of independence in which individual directors find themselves, and invites the issuers to pay more attention to the assessment of the importance of the relationships being assessed. For this purpose, the Committee invites the administrative bodies to define in advance the quantitative and/or qualitative criteria for the assessment of the importance of the relationships being examined. These criteria should pertain to the total position, not limited to solely economic benefits, of the director whose independence is assessed, and be suitably and transparently communicated to the market in the report on corporate governance. |
The administrative bodies of Banca IFIS applied these criteria in taking up their office. In addition, a more in-depth review was carried out while checking the requirements of integrity, professionalism and skill at the meeting of 9th March 2019. The definition and formalisation in advance of such criteria will be the subject of assessment during the first revision of the internal documents. |
| Also in light of the comparative analysis, the Committee recommends that the administrative bodies - and the committees competent on matters of remuneration - verify that the remuneration paid to the non-executive directors and to the members of the control body be suited to the skills, professionalism and effort required by their tasks. For this purpose, reference to the remuneration practices in the sectors of reference and for companies of similar size could be of help, possibly also taking into account comparable experiences abroad. |
The remuneration of directors and auditors was subjected to thorough analysis and re-evaluation in previous years, and the remuneration was commensurate with the skill, professionalism and effort required by the tasks. The suggestion to compare the remuneration practices in the sectors of companies of similar size will be evaluated. |
Building tools?
Free accounts include 100 API calls/year for testing.
Have a question? We'll get back to you promptly.