Management Reports • Apr 19, 2024
Management Reports
Open in ViewerOpens in native device viewer

Limited Liability Company (Naamloze Vennootschap) Zinkstraat 1, 2490 Balen (Belgium) Company number VAT BE 0888.728.945 RPR/RPM Turnhout
Pursuant to articles 3:5 and 3:6 of the Belgian Code of Companies and Associations, we are hereby reporting to you on the operations of Nyrstar NV (the "Company") with respect to the financial year as from 1 January 2023 until 31 December 2023. This report comprises also the corporate governance statement and remuneration report in accordance with article 3:6 §2 and §3 of the Belgian Code of Companies and Associations as attached to this report in annex C and D respectively.
The Company has its registered office at Zinkstraat 1, Balen, Belgium. The Company has been listed on Euronext Brussels since 29 October 2007.
Until 31 July 2019, the Company was the holding company of the Nyrstar Group (consisting of Nyrstar NV and its subsidiaries). In addition, until 31 July 2019, the Company delivered a number of support services to the Nyrstar Group, such as, but not limited to, regional purchasing, IT, environment, innovation and development, continuous improvement and legal support services. Following the completion of the restructuring of the Nyrstar group at 31 July 2019 (described in more detail in section 2 below), the Company intended to continue trading as an investment company, holding 2% of the equity in NN2 NewCo Limited ("NN2") for the benefit of the Company's shareholders.
At 9 December 2019, the Extraordinary General Meeting ("EGM") of the Company was held to deliberate on the continuation of the Company's activities and a proposed capital decrease. The shareholders rejected the continuation of the Company's activities. As such, the 31 December 2023 financial statements of the Company are prepared on a discontinuity basis. As the result of an order of 26 June 2020 of the President of the Antwerp Enterprise Court (Antwerp division), at the request of a group of shareholders, the Company was prohibited from holding a general meeting with the dissolution of the Company on the agenda until three months after a final decision on the appointment of a college of experts (see below, under section 8.3) would have obtained res judicata effect. As announced on 14 February 2023 and as set out below under section 8.3, in light of the announcement in the press that certain shareholders of the Company would file a Supreme Court appeal against the judgment of the Antwerp Court of Appeal dated 17 November 2022 with respect to the claim for the appointment of a panel of experts (which appeal has meanwhile been lodged and on the date of this report is still pending), the Company is of the opinion that it is not opportune to carry out its obligation to place the dissolution on the agenda pending the Supreme Court appeal. The Company thus announced that it will not take steps to convene a general meeting with dissolution as an agenda item (or take preparatory actions to that effect) until the Supreme Court has rendered a judgment in the aforementioned proceedings, and it will update the market by then.
Under article 3:23 of the Belgian Code of Companies and Associations, a parent company that controls one or more subsidiaries is required to prepare consolidated financial statements, unless such subsidiaries are, in view of the consolidated assets, financial position or the consolidated results, individually and together, only of a negligible significance. Given that, as at 31 December 2023, Nyrstar NV did not control any significant subsidiary, the Company was not required to prepare consolidated financial statements for the year ended 31 December 2023. In accordance with article 12, §3, final paragraph, of the Royal Decree of 14 November 2007, the Company has prepared the 31 December 2023 standalone statutory financial statements in accordance with Belgian GAAP.
In October 2018, the former Nyrstar group initiated a review of its capital structure (the "Capital Structure Review") in response to the challenging financial and operating conditions being faced by the Nyrstar group. The Capital Structure Review identified a very substantial additional funding requirement that the Nyrstar group was unable to meet without a material reduction of the Nyrstar group's indebtedness. As a consequence, the Capital Structure Review necessitated negotiations between the Nyrstar group's financial creditors that ultimately resulted in the restructuring of the Nyrstar group, which became effective on 31 July 2019 (the "Restructuring"). As a result of the Restructuring, Trafigura Group Pte. Ltd., via its indirect 98% ownership of the new holding company NN2 Newco Limited ("NN2"), became the ultimate parent company of the former (direct and indirect) subsidiaries of the Company (the "Operating Group"), with the remaining 2% stake in NN2 (and thereby the Operating Group) being owned by the Company.
The agreements to which the Company is currently a party are discussed in further detail below.
The lock-up agreement ("Lock-Up Agreement") entered into on 14 April 2019 between, among others, the Company and representatives of its key financial creditor groups, envisaged that the Company, Trafigura Pte Ltd ("Trafigura") and Nyrstar Holdings Limited ("Nyrstar Holdings", a Trafigura special-purpose vehicle incorporated, amongst other things, for the purpose of implementing the Restructuring, now known as Nyrstar Holdings Plc) would enter into a deed confirming their agreement in respect of (i) certain steps necessary for the implementation of the restructuring as envisaged in the Lock-Up Agreement and (ii) the terms of the ongoing relationship between the Company and the Trafigura group (the "NNV-Trafigura Deed"). The NNV-Trafigura Deed was duly executed on 19 June 2019.
Certain key terms of the NNV-Trafigura Deed namely those governing the distributions policy, drag / tag rights and change of control in respect of NN2, have previously been described in the Company's related party disclosures. However, following the exercise of the Put Option (as defined below and on which, see 2.2 below for more details) and the Company ceasing to be a shareholder of NN2, these provisions of the NNV-Trafigura Deed are no longer relevant / no longer apply.
Under the provisions of the NNV-Trafigura Deed that continue notwithstanding the exercise of the Put Option and the Company ceasing to be a shareholder of NN2, the Company continues to benefit from a right (subject to compliance with applicable law and any relevant confidentiality obligations) to make reasonable requests of Trafigura to procure that the Company is provided with financial or other information in relation to the Operating Group (or any member of it).
Pursuant to the NNV-Trafigura Deed, the Company and Trafigura also agreed that Trafigura shall grant to the Company an option to require a Trafigura entity to purchase the Company's entire interest in NN2. The terms of this option are set out in a separate deed, dated 25 June 2019, between the Company, Trafigura and Nyrstar Holdings (the "Put Option Deed"). Under the terms of the Put Option Deed, the Company could put all (but not only a part) of its 2% holding in NN2 to Trafigura at a price equal to EUR 20 million (the "Put Option").
On 18 November 2021, the Company announced that it had appointed Moore Corporate Finance to prepare an independent expert's opinion for the independent directors of the Company ("Committee of Independent Directors"), in the framework of Article 7:97 of the Belgian Code of Companies and Associations. The independent expert's opinion was to advise the Committee of Independent Directors in examining the benefit to the Company, taking all relevant circumstances into account, of the exercise or non-exercise of the Put Option that the Company had in relation to its entire 2% investment in NN2.
On 28 July 2022, the Company publicly announced that the Board had completed its detailed review process in respect of the decision whether or not to exercise the Put Option related to its entire 2% shareholding in NN2. Considering the independent expert report prepared by Moore Corporate Finance, which valued the 2% shareholding in NN2 in a range of EUR 0 million to EUR 3.4 million, the opinion of the independent directors of the Company, questions and comments raised by certain minority shareholders and other information made available to it, the Board decided that it was in the corporate benefit of the Company to exercise the Put Option. On 28 July 2022, the Company duly gave notice to Nyrstar Holdings Plc and to Trafigura Pte Ltd. that it exercised the Put Option in accordance with the terms of the Put Option Deed. The Company received the proceeds from the exercise of the Put Option on 29 July 2022.
Documentation in respect of the Company's decision to exercise the Put Option was published on the Company's website nyrstarnv.be on 28 July 2022. In addition, a memo of Moore Law was published on 17 November 2022 on the Company's website, at the request of several shareholders. These documents remain available there as at the date of this report.
We refer in this respect to the related party disclosures included in the annual accounts for the financial year ended 31 December 2023 in respect of the mandatory prepayment obligations and limited recourse provisions under the Limited Recourse Loan Facility (as defined below) that apply to the proceeds of the Put Option.
As stated above, prior to the effective date of the Restructuring which was 31 July 2019 (the "Restructuring Effective Date"), the Company was the ultimate parent company of the Nyrstar group, and had previously issued various parent company guarantees (the "PCGs") in respect of the obligations of its subsidiaries, including, but not limited to, two parent company guarantees (the "Trafigura PCGs") granted in respect of the primary financial obligations of the Company's indirect subsidiary at that time, Nyrstar Sales & Marketing AG ("NSM"), to Trafigura, namely under the USD 650 million Trade Finance Framework Agreement ("TFFA") and the USD 250 million Bridge Finance Facility Agreement ("BFFA"). The Trafigura PCGs as well as all other security and / or guarantees provided to Trafigura by the Operating Group in respect of the TFFA and BFFA, were released in full on the Restructuring Effective Date.
Prior to, and as part of the implementation of, the Restructuring, the Company entered into an agreement for the sale and transfer by the Company of substantially all of its assets including 100% of its shareholding in Nyrstar Netherlands (Holdings) BV and also its holdings (direct and indirect) in its subsidiaries, but excluding its shares in NN1 NewCo Limited ("NN1"), to NN2 (the "NNV-NN2 SPA"). Under the NNV-NN2 SPA, the Company benefits from contractual agreements with NN2 and Trafigura in respect of its release from, or indemnification for, liabilities for existing financial indebtedness and obligations owed to third parties in respect of financial, commercial or other obligations of the then current members of the Operating Group (the "PCGs"), such that those third parties should no longer have recourse to the Company. The release and / or indemnification obligations of NN2 from which the Company benefits can be summarised as follows.
or (iii) to the extent that the Company has sufficient funds available (excluding any dividends or sale proceeds in respect of the Company's (now sold) direct 2% shareholding in NN2).
On 23 July 2019, the Company entered into a EUR 13.5 million committed, limited recourse, loan facility (the "Limited Recourse Loan Facility") provided to it by NN2 (as "Lender"). The key terms of the Limited Recourse Loan Facility are described below. The Limited Recourse Loan Facility is made available in two separate tranches: (i) up to EUR 8.5 million to be applied towards the Company's ongoing ordinary course operating activities ("Facility A"); and (ii) up to EUR 5 million intended for the payment of certain costs related to litigation defense ("Facility B"). No security, collateral or guarantees have been granted in respect of the Company's obligations under the Limited Recourse Loan Facility.
As at 31 December 2023, the Company owed EUR 6.3 million (2022: EUR 6.2 million) under Facility A. Facility A can be used by the Company to cover day-to-day operating costs, including, without limitation, reasonable director and employee costs, D&O insurance premium (to the extent not paid prior to the Restructuring Effective Date), audit fees, legal costs (except those relating to litigation or other actual or threatened proceedings against the Company, which should be funded from Facility B (defined below)), listing fees and investor relations costs. The funding under Facility A is provided to the Company based on the quarterly cash flow forecast prepared by the Company and provided to Trafigura as a condition of the funding. The total quantum of funds to be made available under Facility A was agreed based on the Company's forecast operating costs for a five year period following the completion of the Restructuring, taking into account the ongoing operational services provided to the Company by NN2, as agreed in the NNV-NN2 SPA, for a period of approximately three years from the Restructuring Effective Date (the "Ongoing Services"). The Ongoing Services provided by NN2 to the Company included finance, tax, corporate counsel, IT and administration services. The provision of the Ongoing Services to the Company was intended to reduce the Company's operating costs in the period following the Restructuring Effective Date.
As at 31 December 2023, the Company had drawn EUR 3.7 million (2022: EUR 3.7 million) under Facility B. Subject to the restrictions detailed below, Facility B can be applied by the Company towards payment or reimbursement of costs in respect of any litigation, proceeding, action or claims (including tax claims) made, asserted or threatened against the Company, NN1 Newco Limited ("NN1") or any of their current or former directors or officers (each being a "Claim").
Under Facility A, the Company could borrow up to EUR 7.3 million before 31 July 2023 and then up to a further EUR 1.2 million annually until 2024. Funding under Facility B can be drawn based on costs incurred in respect of any Claim (subject to the restrictions detailed below, and on the delivery of an invoice for such costs). Utilisation of each Facility is limited to a maximum of three drawings per financial quarter per Facility (excluding any PIK Loans (defined below)). As at the date of this report, the Company has drawn EUR 6.4 million under Facility A and EUR 3.8 million under Facility B.
As a result of the exercise of the Put Option and the Company ceasing to be a shareholder of NN2, the "NNV Exit Date" (as defined in the Limited Recourse Loan Facility) has occurred. The NNV Exit Date is specified as an Event of Default (as defined) under the Limited Recourse Loan Facility, which gives NN2 (as Lender) the right to cancel (by notice to the Company) the whole or any part of the Lenders' remaining commitments under the Limited Recourse Loan Facility. As at the date of this report, NN2 has not exercised such right.
However, each utilisation request under the Limited Recourse Loan Facility must (unless otherwise agreed by the Lender) be accompanied by a certificate signed by a director stating, among other things, that (in short) the Company's "Available Cash" (as defined therein) is not sufficient to meet the anticipated costs and liabilities for which the relevant utilisation is intended. Given the Company's receipt of EUR 20 million from the exercise of the Put Option in July 2022, it is not currently envisaged that the Company would be able to make any further valid utilisation requests under the Limited Recourse Loan Facility.
The rate of interest on amounts outstanding under the Limited Recourse Loan Facility is the aggregate of EURIBOR plus a margin of 0.5% per annum. It shall be payable within 10 business days of the anniversary of the date on which such amount was made available, provided that such interest will be capitalised if it has accrued for a period of one year or more and the Company has given a notice in the form prescribed by the Limited Recourse Loan Facility. Any interest which is capitalised shall be treated as a new loan (a "PIK Loan") under the relevant Facility. Any PIK Loan shall itself accrue interest, and that interest may also be capitalised. No payments of interest have been made by the Company as all payable interest until 31 December 2023 of EUR 327k (2022: 107k) has been capitalised into a new PIK Loan. The interest charges on the Limited Recourse Loan Facility expensed in the Profit and Loss Account in the year ended 31 December 2023 were EUR 368k.
The Company must not use any amount borrowed under either Facility A or Facility B for funding (directly or indirectly) any of the costs related to asserting or bringing or assisting in the pursuit of claims (including any counterclaim or defense) against Trafigura, other members of the Trafigura group, NN2 and / or any Replacement Holdco, and / or any other member of the Operating Group), against any of such entities' current or former directors, officers, or advisers, against any creditor in respect of such entities (other than with the consent of NN2, such consent not to be unreasonably withheld or delayed) or in connection with any challenge to the Restructuring, including in relation to the TFFA and the BFFA or any other document contemplated by the Restructuring implementation deed.
The provisions of the Limited Recourse Loan Facility that relate to mandatory prepayment out of "Excess Cash", and which were described in previous versions of this reports by the Company, have ceased to apply as a result of the Company ceasing to be a shareholder of NN2 and having received the proceeds of the exercise of the Put Option (such proceeds constituting "Disposal Proceeds" for the purposes of the Limited Recourse Loan Facility).
Immediately upon receipt of any Disposal Proceeds, and subject to the limited recourse provisions described below (see in particular at 2.5.5, the Company shall procure that these shall be applied first to prepay any amount outstanding under Facility B (being the litigation tranche), and secondly, if (i) any Disposal Proceeds remain after any required prepayment of Facility B, and (ii) the aggregate amount of all amounts outstanding under Facility A (being the operational costs tranche) exceeds EUR 5 million, to prepay such Facility Amounts to or towards an aggregate amount of EUR 5 million.
The Company shall ensure that, if any distribution is paid to the Company's shareholders on or after the Company Exit Date, an amount equal to that distribution is applied to repay or prepay amount outstanding under Facility A before or simultaneously with such distribution.
The Company has also agreed that, if it receives any amounts from costs awards, damages awards and / or any other recovery from any counterparty to a Claim (such amounts constituting "Claim Proceeds"), then such Claim Proceeds must be used immediately to repay or prepay any amounts outstanding under Facility B.
Additionally, there are customary provisions that require mandatory prepayment of amounts outstanding under either or both Facility A and B in the case of certain events of default that allow for acceleration by the Lender.
However, in accordance with the limited recourse provisions of the Limited Recourse Loan Facility (as detailed further at 2.5.5. below), NN2's recourse to the Company in respect of repayment of funds drawn or any other obligation thereunder is limited to the Company's net assets, if any.
As mentioned above, the recourse of NN2 as Lender under the Limited Recourse Loan Facility in respect of repayment thereof or any other obligation of the Company thereunder is limited to the "Company Net Assets", being the assets (including all present and future properties, revenues and rights of every description) of the Company (other than assets held or received on trust for a person which is not a member of Nyrstar or its subsidiaries) having satisfied or provided for its "Liabilities" (meaning all present or future liabilities and obligations, both actual and contingent and whether incurred solely or jointly or as principal or surety or in any other capacity), except for Liabilities of the Company under the Limited Recourse Loan Facility and related finance documents which shall be disregarded for this purpose.
Further, to the extent that the Company Net Assets are insufficient to discharge the Company's obligations under the Limited Recourse Loan Facility, such obligations shall be deemed to be limited to the amount of the Company Net Assets, and the Lender shall not be entitled to make a claim and shall have no further recourse against the Company and the Company shall have no liability to pay or otherwise.
All actual, contingent and prospective liabilities would need to be factored in when calculating the Company Net Asset position. The Company determined at the time of the exercise of the Put Option on 28 July 2022 and as at 31 December 2023, that it is in the corporate benefit of the Company that, for the purposes of the mandatory prepayment, these liabilities are calculated on a worst-case scenario basis, and not (i) in accordance with IFRS or Belgian GAAP, nor (ii) based upon the Company's assessment of the likelihood of such contingent or prospective liabilities eventually materialising. Based on the Company's estimates, the Company has determined that the Company Net Assets (as defined under the Limited Recourse Loan Facility) are negative even taking into account the receipt of the proceeds of the Put Option, and that currently no repayments of the Limited Recourse Loan Facility are necessary. The Company will, however, continue to monitor the development of its Company Net Asset position until the completion of the liquidation process, to consider whether any repayment of the Limited Recourse Loan Facility needs to be made.
However, this limitation on NN2's recourse against the Company shall not apply to the extent that the value of the Company Net Assets is impaired, or NN2 suffers loss as a result of any breach by the Company of any provision of the Limited Recourse Loan Facility (or any related finance document) other than the repeating representations / warranties thereunder or the provisions requiring payment of interest / fees or repayment / prepayment of principal thereunder.
So long as any amount is outstanding under the Limited Recourse Loan Facility or the Lender's commitment thereunder is still in force, if any Claim arises as a result of which the Company reasonably anticipates that it may make a utilisation under Facility B, the Company must must give notice to the Lender and Trafigura of the Claim. The Company shall:
The Company must also consult with Trafigura prior to taking any action relating to insolvency or bankruptcy proceedings, including under Book XX of the Belgian Code of Economic Law.
The Company is also obliged to provide NN2 with certain financial information, including quarterly cashflow forecasts (and any revisions thereto required under the terms of the Limited Recourse Loan Facility), half-yearly financial statements and audited annual financial statements, drawn up on a consolidated basis (to the extent the Company has subsidiaries) and in accordance with the accounting principles agreed under the terms of the Limited Recourse Loan Facility.
At the completion of the Restructuring at 31 July 2019, the "Relationship Agreement" between Trafigura Group Pte Ltd and the Company (dated 9 November 2015) was terminated. The Relationship Agreement governed the relationship between the Company (and the broader Nyrstar Group) and Trafigura Group Pte. Ltd. and its affiliated persons between its execution on 9 November 2015 and the completion of the Restructuring on 31 July 2019.
As at 31 December 2023, based on the information available to the Company, the Company has been fully released from all contingent liabilities previously provided or irrevocably promised by the Company for debts and commitments of third parties that were yet to be transferred to the Trafigura group for which the Company has been indemnified. The Company is fully indemnified in relation to any liability that may arise in this respect (see "Related party disclosures"). For more details, refer to the parent company guarantees disclosures in note C 6.14 and C 6.20.
Before 28 July 2022, the Company had, in its current investments, a 2% investment in NN2 at the cost of EUR 15,395,000. The investment in NN2 of EUR 15,395,000 was carried at the lower of cost and fair value, taking into consideration that the Company had a Put Option (as defined above) that enabled it to sell all (but not part only) of its 2% holding in NN2 to Trafigura at a price equal to EUR 20 million in aggregate payable to the Company.
On 18 November 2021, the Company announced that it had appointed Moore Corporate Finance, to prepare an independent expert's opinion for the independent directors of the Company ("Committee of Independent Directors"), in the framework of Article 7:97 of the Belgian Code of Companies and Associations. The independent expert's opinion is to advise the Committee of Independent Directors in examining the benefit to the Company, taking all relevant circumstances into account, of the exercise or non-exercise of the Put Option that the Company has in relation to its (entire) 2% investment in NN2.
On 28 July 2022, the Company publicly announced that the Board had completed its detailed review process in respect of the decision whether or not to exercise the Put Option related to its entire 2% shareholding in NN2. Considering the independent expert report prepared by Moore Corporate Finance, which valued the 2% shareholding in NN2 in a range of EUR 0 million to EUR 3.4 million, the opinion of the independent directors of the Company, questions and comments raised by certain minority shareholders and other information made available to it, the Board decided that it was in the corporate benefit of the Company to exercise the Put Option. On 28 July 2022, the Company duly gave notice to Nyrstar Holdings Plc and to Trafigura Pte Ltd. that it exercised the Put Option in accordance with the terms of the Put Option Deed. The Company received the proceeds from the exercise of the Put Option on 29 July 2022.
Documentation in respect of the Company's decision to exercise the Put Option was published on the Company's website nyrstarnv.be on 28 July 2022. In addition, a memo of Moore Law was published on 17 November 2022 on the Company's website, at the request of several shareholders. These documents remain available there as at the date of this report.
At 9 December 2019, an EGM was held to deliberate on the continuation of the Company's activities and a proposed capital decrease. The shareholders rejected the continuation of the Company's activities. The shareholders also rejected the proposed capital reduction, as a result of which it was not carried out.
As explained above, the Board of Directors of the Company convened a new EGM to formally decide on the dissolution of the Company, and if approved, appoint a liquidator. However, as a result of an order of 26 June 2020 of the President of the Antwerp Enterprise Court (Antwerp division), at the request of a group of shareholders, the Company was prohibited from holding a general meeting with the dissolution of the Company on the agenda until three months after a final decision on the appointment of a college of experts (see below, under section 8.3) would have obtained res judicata effect. As announced on 14 February 2023 and as set out below under section 8.3, in light of the announcement in the press that certain shareholders of the Company would file a Supreme Court appeal against the judgment of the Antwerp Court of Appeal dated 17 November 2022 with respect to the claim for the appointment of a panel of experts (which appeal has meanwhile been lodged and on the date of this report is still pending), the Company is of the opinion that it is not opportune to carry out its obligation to place the dissolution on the agenda pending the Supreme Court appeal. The Company thus announced that it will not take steps to convene a general meeting with dissolution as an agenda item (or take preparatory actions to that effect) until the Supreme Court has rendered a judgment in the aforementioned proceedings, and it will update the market by then.
These comments are based on the balance sheet and the proposed allocation of results and are therefore subject to the approval of the proposed allocation of results by the shareholders of the Company. The statutory financial statements were prepared in accordance with Belgian accounting laws.
During the last financial year, the Company generated a net loss of EUR 1,464k and has a balance sheet total as at 31 December 2023 of EUR 16,212k.
The operating result shows a loss of EUR 1,476k. This result derives from an operating income amounting to EUR 3,584k and the operating charges of EUR 5,060k.
The operating income is primarily related to the refunds of the various legal costs by the Directors and Officers's insurers of the Company and by the decrease of the provision for discontinuation of EUR 1,443k.
The operating costs mainly relate to services and other goods for EUR 5,071k, mainly related to audit fees, legal and advisory fees, directors fees and other administrative services.
The financial result mainly relates to:
There has been no income tax expense incurred during 2023.
The current assets at 31 December 2023 consist of:
The equity as at 31 December 2023 amounted to negative EUR 3,961k.
The changes in equity for the financial year 2023 relate to the loss of EUR 1,464k.
The liabilities as at 31 December 2023 mainly relate to:
The Board of Directors proposes to allocate the current year loss of EUR 1,464k to the losses carried forward.
The Company has invested the majority of the proceeds received from the exercise of the Put Option into the short-term deposits while maintaining sufficient day-to-day liquidity.
For information on the Company's risk management and management of uncertainties and information regarding the use by the Company of financial instruments, please refer to the Corporate Governance Statement of the Company.
As a consequence of the Restructuring and the outcomes of the 9 December 2019 EGM, where the shareholders rejected the continuation of the Company's activities, the 31 December 2023 financial statements of the Company are prepared on a discontinuity basis.
At the date of authorisation of the 31 December 2023 financial statements, the Company has assessed that, taking into account its available cash, cash equivalents and its cash flow projections for the next 12 months from the authorisation by the Board of Directors of the 31 December 2023 financial statements, it has sufficient liquidity to meet its present obligations and cover working capital needs. The forecast available liquidity of the Company includes cash and cash term deposits of EUR 14.9 million as of 31 December 2023 and is dependent on various matters including the possible appointment of a liquidator and his next steps, the existence and extent of the legal claims against the Company which could require funding of these legal proceedings and other matters not currently foreseen as described in section d) of the valuation rules above. If the appointment of the liquidator is further delayed or not approved by the shareholders or if the costs are higher than currently expected, the Company may need to secure additional funding. There is a risk that such additional funding may not be available to the Company or may not be available at acceptable conditions. Reference is also made to the related party disclosures in respect of the mandatory prepayment obligations and limited recourse provisions under the Limited Recourse Loan Facility (to the extent that these apply following the receipt of the proceeds of the exercise of the Put Option (see also at 2.2, 2.5.4 and 2.5.5 above)).
There have been no significant events which occurred after the end of the financial year except those included in section 8 below.
As described above, at 9 December 2019, an EGM was held to deliberate on the continuation of the Company's activities and a proposed capital decrease. The shareholders' meeting rejected the continuation of the Company's activities. The shareholders' meeting also rejected the proposed capital reduction, as a result of which it was not carried out. The Board of Directors of the Company had taken the necessary measures to prepare the necessary reports with its statutory auditor and had convened a new EGM to formally consider a proposal for liquidation. Such EGM was first scheduled to be held on 25 March 2020 but had to be postponed due to the Covid-19 outbreak and corresponding restrictions that had been introduced in Europe. The Company re-convened such EGM on 30 April 2020 for 2 June 2020 and, if the required attendance quorum would not be met, 30 June 2020.
Certain shareholders initiated summary proceedings before the court of Antwerp to request the court to order that the decision on the dissolution of the Company, following the 9 December 2019 EGM, be postponed (i) until three months after a final report will have been issued by a panel of experts whose appointment is requested in separate proceedings before the court, or, alternatively (ii) until three months after a final decision will have been rendered in the aforementioned proceedings regarding the appointment of a panel of experts. On 26 June 2020, the court of Antwerp dismissed the minority shareholders' claim for a postponement until three months after a final report will have been issued by a panel of experts whose appointment is requested. However, the court did accept their claim for a postponement of the decision on the dissolution of the Company until three months after a final decision (i.e. a decision that will have obtained "res judicata effect") will have been rendered in the proceedings regarding the appointment of a panel of experts. Consequently, in compliance with the 26 June 2020 court order, the (second) EGM planned for 30 June 2020 having the resolutions regarding the proposal for dissolution of the Company on the agenda was postponed. As announced on 14 February 2023, in light of the announcement in the press that certain shareholders of the Company would file a Supreme Court appeal against the judgment of the Antwerp Court of Appeal dated 17 November 2022 with respect to the claim for the appointment of a panel of experts (which appeal has meanwhile been lodged and on the date of this report is still pending), the Company is of the opinion that it is not opportune to carry out its obligation to place the dissolution on the agenda pending the Supreme Court appeal. The Company thus announced that it will not take steps to convene a general meeting with dissolution as an agenda item (or take preparatory actions to that effect) until the Supreme Court has rendered a judgment in the aforementioned proceedings, and it will update the market by then.
The delayed decision on the proposal for dissolution of the Company and the appointment of a liquidator may negatively impact the Company's liquidity position as the Company continues to incur running costs and costs in respect of the legal proceedings mentioned above and below. If the appointment of the liquidator is further delayed beyond what is currently expected or not approved by the shareholders' meeting or if the costs are higher than currently expected, the Company may need to secure additional funding. There is a risk that such additional funding may not be available to the Company or may not be available at acceptable conditions.
The management committee of the Belgian Financial Services and Markets Authority ("FSMA") decided in September 2019 to investigate the Company's policy regarding disclosure of information to the market. Initially, this investigation focused on the information disclosed on the commercial relationship of the Company with Trafigura.
In a press release dated 29 May 2020, the FSMA announced that the investigation would be expanded so as to also include information on the expected profit contribution and total costs for the Port Pirie smelter redevelopment in Australia and on the solvency and liquidity position of the Company at the end of 2018.
In a press release dated 25 July 2022, the FSMA outlined the state of affairs in the investigation. The FSMA announced that the investigations officer had drafted a provisional report covering the three elements of the investigation.
In a press release dated 30 September 2022, the FSMA announced that, after deliberating on the Investigations Officer's final report, the management committee of the FSMA had decided to initiate proceedings against Nyrstar that may result in the imposition of an administrative fine, as well as that it had forwarded the notification of the grievances to the chairman of the sanctions committee. The FSMA further reports that the management committee had also forwarded this notification to the public prosecutor of the Antwerp district. Finally, according to the press release, the management committee had asked the Investigations Officer for an additional report on the possible application of an administrative fine to each of the directors (or the permanent representatives of the directors) of Nyrstar who were in office at the time of the facts.
Nyrstar confirms that, on 30 September 2022, the management committee of the FSMA notified it of the grievances and provided it with the investigations officer's final investigation report. The Company believes that it has at all times disclosed the required information in accordance with the relevant financial regulations and laws and defends that position in the proceedings before the Sanctions Committee.
Nyrstar further learned in the press that the public prosecutor of the Antwerp district would have initiated an investigation in the autumn of 2022 following the notification by the FSMA. Besides what appears in the press, Nyrstar is not aware of the status of this investigation. Nyrstar will refrain from addressing the content of these ongoing sanction proceedings any further, given their confidential nature.
On 27 April 2020, a group of shareholders summoned the Company in summary proceedings before the President of the Antwerp Enterprise Court (Antwerp division). The claim of plaintiffs aimed at having a panel of experts appointed in accordance with Article 7:160 of the Belgian Companies and Associations Code. This procedure was initiated on 5 May 2020. The court hearing took place on 15 September 2020.
On 30 October 2020, the President of the Antwerp Enterprise Court (Antwerp division) issued an order in which she upheld the shareholders' claim. The court order included, but was not limited to, the following elements:
The Company reviewed the court order together with its legal advisors and decided that lodging an appeal with the Antwerp Court of Appeal was appropriate and required in light of the Company's corporate interest. The Company has filed the application for appeal on 15 December 2020. On 3 March 2021, the original plaintiff shareholders summoned Trafigura PTE Ltd. and Trafigura Group PTE Ltd. to forcefully intervene in this appeal. In particular, they asked that the judgment to be delivered by the Court of Appeal be declared enforceable against and applicable to Trafigura PTE Ltd. and Trafigura Group PTE Ltd. Both the appeal by the Company and the forced intervention of Trafigura PTE Ltd. and Trafigura Group PTE Ltd. were heard at the hearing of 3 June 2021. On 2 September 2021, the court ordered the reopening of the debates to allow the parties to comment on (i) the third-party application order dated 2 July 2021 (infra), (ii) the memo and evidence submitted by the original plaintiff shareholders on 2 August 2021 in execution of the aforementioned third-party application order, (iii) the order of the President of the Antwerp Enterprise Court (Antwerp Division) of 29 June 2021 by which, in accordance with Article 973 of the Belgian Judicial Code, a number of incidents in relation to the expert investigation are settled, (iv) the documents relating to the general meeting of the Company held on 29 June 2021, and (v) the request for voluntary intervention in the third-party application proceedings of 22 other shareholders of the Company. On 29 October 2021, those same 22 other shareholders of the Company submitted a request for voluntary intervention in these appeal proceedings.
On 4 February 2021, Trafigura PTE Ltd. and Trafigura Group PTE Ltd. filed a third-party application against the aforementioned decision of 30 October 2020. The Company and the original plaintiff shareholders were also involved in these proceedings. In this third-party application, Trafigura PTE Ltd. and Trafigura Group PTE Ltd. requested that the President of the Antwerp Enterprise Court (Antwerp division) revoke its decision of 30 October 2020 with immediate effect and terminate the expert investigation, also vis-à-vis the Company and the original plaintiffs. The third-party application was introduced in court on 26 March 2021, and was dealt with a first time at the hearing of 15 June 2021. In response, an interim judgment was issued on 2 July 2021. In this interim judgment, the President of the Antwerp Enterprise Court (Antwerp division) ordered the original plaintiff shareholders to produce to the court a full overview of their respective transactions in the Company's shares. Further, the President ordered that the aforementioned expert investigation be suspended until the verdict that would follow the hearing scheduled for 28 September 2021 in respect of the new evidence submitted. The suspension of the expert investigation aimed to give the plaintiff shareholders time to produce documentary proof of their shareholdings and transactions in the Company's shares and provided the parties, including the Company, the opportunity to debate the legal consequences of the new evidence, after which the court would take a decision. On 19 August 2021, 22 other shareholders of Nyrstar submitted a petition to voluntarily intervene in these third-party application proceedings. As mentioned, a second hearing in this procedure took place on 28 September 2021. On 9 November 2021, the President of the Antwerp Enterprise Court (Antwerp division) rendered a second judgment in these third-party application proceedings. In this decision, the President declared the thirdparty application proceedings of Trafigura PTE Ltd. and Trafigura Group PTE Ltd. well-founded and revoked the previous judgment of 30 October 2020 vis-à-vis Trafigura PTE Ltd., Trafigura Group PTE Ltd., the Company and the original claimant shareholders, thus revoking the appointment of the experts and halting the expert investigation. The costs to that date of the expert investigation were put by the President with the party that had borne them to date in accordance with that previous judgment, i.e. the Company. On 23 December 2021, the original plaintiff shareholders and the newly intervening shareholders lodged appeal against the aforementioned judgments of 2 July and 9 November 2021.
Both appeals (i.e. the appeal against the decision of 30 October 2020 and the appeal against the decisions of 2 July and 9 November 2021) were dealt with at the court hearing of 6 October 2022.
On 17 November 2022, the Antwerp court of appeals issued its judgment in these appeals. In this judgment, the court of appeals declared the appeal proceedings lodged by the claimant shareholders ill-founded and confirmed the judgment of 9 November 2021, thus ordering that the appointment of the panel of corporate law experts be revoked and the expert investigation halted. The court of appeals found that there were no indications that the interests of the Company would be seriously threatened, and hence that an expert investigation was not justified. The court of appeals also joined the proceedings regarding the Company's appeal against the judgment of 30 October 2020 and confirmed that such appeal no longer had any subject matter given the 17 November 2022 judgment. Finally, the court of appeals ordered the parties to bear their own costs, and ordered the claimant shareholders to repay 50% of the costs incurred by Nyrstar in the expert investigation.
On 10 February 2023, Nyrstar learnt through the press that the claimant shareholders would lodge an appeal with the Supreme Court against the aforementioned 17 November 2022 judgment. On 28 March 2023, the Supreme Court petition was served on Nyrstar. The case is currently pending before the Supreme Court and is scheduled to be dealt with at the hearing of 2 May 2024, unless any new procedural actions are introduced.
On 9 February 2021, Trafigura PTE Ltd. and Trafigura Group PTE Ltd. had submitted a request for suspension of the 30 October 2020 decision to the Attachment Judge of the Antwerp Court of First Instance (Antwerp Division). The Company and the original plaintiff shareholders were again involved in this procedure. Trafigura PTE Ltd. and Trafigura Group PTE Ltd. specifically requested that the execution of the aforementioned decision be immediately suspended until the delivery of a final judgment in the third-party application proceedings mentioned earlier. The suspension request was introduced in court on 1 April 2021, and was dealt with at the hearing of 24 June 2021. In a decision of 15 July 2021, the Attachment Judge ruled that a re-opening of the debates was required in light of the aforementioned judgment of the President of the Antwerp Enterprise Court (Antwerp division) of 2 July 2021 (in the third-party application proceedings). As a result, the suspension request was dealt with at the hearing of 28 October 2021, where it was again adjourned until the hearing of 2 December 2021. During said 2 December 2021 hearing, the case was put on hold for an indefinite period of time, given the aforementioned 9 November 2021 judgment by the President of the Antwerp Enterprise Court (Antwerp division) in the third-party application proceedings.
On Friday 29 May 2020, a group of shareholders of the Company summoned the Company, various directors and the Company's (former) statutory auditor, Deloitte Bedrijfsrevisoren CV ("Deloitte"), before the Antwerp Enterprise Court (Turnhout division). This writ of summons followed a notice of default received on 17 March 2020 by the directors and certain senior managers of the Company.
On Monday 9 November 2020, this group of shareholders issued a corrective writ of summons against the Company, various directors and Deloitte, which amended the writ of summons dated 29 May 2020 on certain points.
The plaintiffs in this procedure are making the following claims:
i. a minority claim on account of the Company against (amongst others) the current directors of the Company for alleged shortcomings in their management and breaches of the Belgian Companies Code and the Company's articles of association. This minority claim is a derivative claim, meaning that the proceeds will be paid to the Company (not the plaintiff shareholders). In particular, the plaintiffs request that the defendants are jointly and severally ordered to pay damages to the Company. The damages are estimated in the (corrective) writ of summons at a minimum of EUR 1.2 billion. Nyrstar has understood from other proceedings that the plaintiff shareholders currently estimate the alleged damages to be at least 2 EUR billion, but has not received a formal confirmation thereof;
These proceedings were introduced in the court on 18 November 2020; however, they were sent to the docket at the introductory hearing (at the request of plaintiffs) pending the report of the panel of experts appointed by order of 30 October 2020 of the President of the Antwerp Enterprise Court (Antwerp division) (see above under "Summary proceedings relating to the appointment of a panel of experts").
The Company formally contests the claims in the writ of summons and notes that it will firmly defend itself against the claims raised within the framework of these proceedings.
In addition, the Company learned that the same group of plaintiff shareholders has brought similar liability claims against certain former directors of the Company as well as certain companies of the Trafigura group. Initially, neither the Company nor its current directors were party to these proceedings. However, the Company has learned that the Antwerp Enterprise Court (Turnhout Division) has, by decision of 26 July 2022, joined the proceedings against the companies of the Trafigura group with the proceedings against the Company and its directors.
On Monday 27 February 2023, 13 new plaintiffs submitted a petition for voluntary intervention in these proceedings.
On 22 January 2024, Deloitte submitted a trial brief in these proceedings. In this brief, Deloitte demands that:
No procedural timetable or hearing date has yet been determined.
On 11 March 2024, the plaintiff shareholders filed a petition for interim measures in the framework of these proceedings. They request the court to grant the following interim measures:
• an order against, among others, the Company to produce a series of documents within a period of 48 hours from the verdict to be rendered, on a penalty fine of EUR 25.000 per day of delay.
In subordinate order, the plaintiff shareholders request the appointment of an ad hoc trustee in the Company with a specific mandate for a period of 12 months with possibility of extension, at least until a decision with res judicata effect is rendered in the proceedings on the merits.
The plaintiff shareholders also demand that the Company be ordered to advance the costs of the provisional administrator or ad hoc trustee.
The plaintiff shareholders request the court to refer the remainder of the case back to the docket.
The Company contests the allegations of the plaintiff shareholders and will defend its position in the court proceedings.
On 3 January 2023, a group of shareholders summoned the Company in summary proceedings before the President of the Antwerp Enterprise Court (Antwerp division). They requested (among others) (i) a prohibition for the Company to hold a general meeting with the dissolution of the Company on the agenda, (ii) the appointment of a provisional administrator or an ad hoc trustee and (iii) to order Nyrstar to join several claims brought by the plaintiff shareholders against Trafigura and/or associated persons in the proceedings on the merits (and to, at the very least as a precautionary measure, lodge these claims). By decision of 12 May 2023, the President dismissed the claims of the plaintiff shareholders. To date, this group of shareholders has not taken any further steps regarding these proceedings.
The Company learned that criminal complaints have been filed by shareholders. The Company shall cooperate with the judicial investigation.
The Company has no branches.
Until 31 July 2019, the Group undertook research and development through a number of activities at various production sites of the Group. This research and development was primarily concentrated on the production of various high margin noncommodity grade alloy products and by-products in Nyrstar's Metals Processing operations. Following the completion of the Restructuring at 31 July 2019, the Company does not undertake any research or development.
The Company held no Company's shares as at 31 December 2023 and 2022.
| Issued shares | 2023 | 2022 |
|---|---|---|
| Shares outstanding | 109,873,001 | 109,873,001 |
| Treasury shares As at 31 Dec |
- 109,873,001 |
- 109,873,001 |
| Movement in shares outstanding | 2023 | 2022 |
|---|---|---|
| As at 1 Jan | 109,873,001 | 109,873,001 |
| Capital increase | - | - |
| Employee shared based payment plan | - | - |
| As at 31 Dec | 109,873,001 | 109,873,001 |
Directors are expected to arrange their personal and business affairs so as to avoid conflicts of interest with the Company. Any director with a conflicting financial interest (as contemplated by article 7:96 of the Belgian Code of Companies and Associations) on any matter before the Board of Directors must bring it to the attention of both the statutory auditor and fellow directors, and take no part in any deliberations or voting related thereto. Section 1.4 of the Corporate Governance Charter sets out the procedure for transactions between Nyrstar and the directors which are not covered by the legal provisions on conflicts of interest.
To the knowledge of the Board of Directors, there are, in the period covered by this report, no potential conflicts of interests between any duties to the Company of the directors and their private interests and/or other duties.
There has therefore not been any non-compliance with article 7:96 of the Belgian Code of Companies and Associations.
When decisions or transactions are taken by the Company involving its related parties within the meaning of IAS 24, such decisions and transactions are subject to the decision-making procedure set out in article 7:97 of the Belgian Code of Companies and Associations.
No decisions or transactions have taken place during the financial year ending on 31 December 2023 that fell within the scope of article 7:97 of the Belgian Code of Companies and Associations.
On 18 November 2021, the Company announced that it had appointed Moore Corporate Finance to prepare an independent expert's opinion for the independent directors of the Company ("Committee of Independent Directors"), in the framework of Article 7:97 of the Belgian Code of Companies and Associations. The independent expert's opinion was to advise the Committee of Independent Directors in examining the benefit to the Company, taking all relevant circumstances into account, of the exercise or non-exercise of the Put Option that the Company had in relation to its entire 2% investment in NN2.
On 28 July 2022, the Company publicly announced that the Board had completed its detailed review process in respect of the decision whether or not to exercise the Put Option related to its entire 2% shareholding in NN2. Considering the independent expert report prepared by Moore Corporate Finance, which valued the 2% shareholding in NN2 in a range of EUR 0 million to EUR 3.4 million, the opinion of the independent directors of the Company, questions and comments raised by certain minority shareholders and other information made available to it, the Board decided that it was in the corporate benefit of the Company to exercise the Put Option. On 28 July 2022, the Company duly gave notice to Nyrstar Holdings Plc and to Trafigura Pte Ltd. that it exercised the Put Option in accordance with the terms of the Put Option Deed. The Company received the proceeds from the exercise of the Put Option on 29 July 2022.
The opinion of the Committee of Independent Directors read as follows:
On the basis of the considerations set out above, including the Expert Report, the information provided [by management] in Annex 2 as well as the comments made by minority shareholders, the Committee is of the opinion that the decision to exercise the Put Option is not such as to imply a disadvantage to the Company that, in light of its current policies, would be manifestly illegitimate.
Furthermore, the Committee is of the opinion that it is unlikely that the decision to exercise the Put Option would lead to disadvantages for the Company which will not be outweighed by the benefits for the Company of such a decision.
The Company's statutory auditor, BDO, has reviewed the Expert Report, the report by the Committee and the minutes of the Board of Directors of the Company on 27 July 2022 in accordance with article 7:97 BCCA and its assessment was as follows.
Based on our review, nothing has come to our attention that causes us to believe that the financial and accounting data reported in the advice of the committee of independent directors dated 27 July 2022 and in the minutes of the administrative body dated 27 July 2022, which justify the proposed transaction, are not consistent, in all material respects, compared to the information we have in the context of our assignment as statutory auditor of Nyrstar NV.
Our assignment is solely executed for the purposes described in article 7:97 of the Code of Companies and Associations and therefore our report is not to be used for any other purpose.
Reference is made to the press release of the Company which was published on the Company's website on 28 July 2022: https://otp.tools.investis.com/clients/fi/nyrstar1/omx/omx-story.aspx?cid=250&newsid=74701&culture=en-US.
Documentation, including the report of the independent expert, the report of the Committee of Independent Directors and BDO's report, are all available on the Company's website: https://www.nyrstarnv.be/en/investors/results-reportsand-presentations/2022.
The elements that need to be provided in accordance with article 34 of the Royal Decree dated 14 November 2007 to the extent that these elements could have consequences in the event of a public takeover bid are discussed in detail in the corporate governance statement as attached to this report as annex B.
The Audit Committee consists of at least three directors. All members of the Audit Committee are non-executive directors. According to the Belgian Code of Companies and Associations, all members of the Audit Committee must be non-executive directors, and at least one member must be independent within the meaning of the Belgian Code on Corporate Governance. The members of the Audit Committee at 31 December 2023 were Anne Fahy (Chairman), Jane Moriarty, Carole Cable and Marc Taeymans. The current composition of the Audit Committee complies with the Belgian Code of Companies and Associations. For the justification of the independence and accounting and audit expertise of the members of the Audit Committee, reference is made to the Corporate Governance Statement of the Company.
The members of the Audit Committee must have a collective competence in the business activities of the Company as well as accounting, auditing and finance. The current Chair of the Audit Committee is competent in accounting and auditing as evidenced by her previous role as Chief Financial Officer of BP's Aviation Fuels business. According to the Board of Directors, the other members of the Audit Committee also satisfy this requirement, as evidenced by the different senior management and director mandates that they have held in the past and currently hold (see also "—Other mandates" in the Corporate Governance Statement).
The assignments of the Audit Committee can vary according to the circumstances. However, the Audit Committee mainly has the following duties (article 7:99 §4 BCCA):
The Audit Committee regularly reports to the Board of Directors on the exercise of its missions, including when preparing the annual accounts.
In principle, the Audit Committee meets as frequently as necessary for the efficiency of the operation of the Audit Committee, but at least two times a year.
The Board of Directors requests the shareholders of the Company to approve the statutory financial statements attached hereto and to grant discharge to the directors of the Company and to the statutory auditor for the exercise of their mandate during this financial year of the Company.
* * *
Brussels, 18 April 2024.
On behalf of the Board of Directors,
Martyn Konig Director
___________________________ ___________________________
Anne Fahy Director
Annex A: Statutory financial statements of Nyrstar NV for the year ended 31 December 2023
Annex B: Statement of responsibility of Nyrstar NV for the year ended 31 December 2023
Annex C: Corporate governance statement in accordance with article 3:6 §2 of Belgian Code of Companies and Associations
Annex D: Remuneration Report in accordance with article 3:6 §3 of Belgian Code of Companies and Associations
[Separate document]
The undersigned, Martyn Konig, Chairman of the Board of Directors, and Anne Fahy, Director, declare that, to the best of their knowledge:
Brussels, 18 April 2024
Martyn Konig Anne Fahy Chairman of the Board of Directors Director
Corporate governance statement in accordance with article 3:6 §2 of Belgian Code of Companies and Associations
[Separate document]
Remuneration Report in accordance with article 3:6 §3 of Belgian Code of Companies and Associations
[Separate document]
| N°. | 1 | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Town: Balen |
||||
| 0888728945 | ||||
| 4 | 25/06/2024 | |||
| 1/01/2023 | to | 31/12/2023 | ||
| 1/01/2022 | to | 31/12/2022 | ||
| 5 are / are not |
||||
| 44 | ||||
| Register of legal persons - commercial court: 10/07/2020 the ANNUAL ACCOUNTS in the OTHER DOCUMENTS The amounts for the preceding period Total number of pages filed: because they serve no useful purpose: |
IDENTIFICATION DETAILS (at the filing date) Public limited liability company EURO (2 decimals) the financial year covering the period from the preceding period of the annual accounts from |
CODE Antwerpen, Division Turnhout the deed of incorporation and of the deed of amendment of the articles of association. 6.5.2, 6.17, 6.18.2, 7, 8, 9, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15 |
ANNUAL ACCOUNTS AND OTHER DOCUMENTS TO BE FILED IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE BELGIAN COMPANIES AND ASSOCIATIONS Company registration number of filing the most recent document mentioning the date of publication of approved by the general meeting of identical to the ones previously published. Numbers of the sections of the standard model form not filed 6.1, 6.2.1, 6.2.2, 6.2.3, 6.2.4, 6.2.5, 6.3.1, 6.3.2, 6.3.3, 6.3.4, 6.3.5, 6.3.6, 6.4.1, 6.4.2, 6.4.3, 6.5.1, |
Signature (name and position) Martyn Konig Director
Signature (name and position) Anne Fahy Director
F-cap 1
Where appropriate, "in liquidation" is stated after the legal form. 1
Optional mention. 2
3 Tick the appropriate box(es).
If necessary, change to currency in which the amounts are expressed. 4
5 Strike out what does not apply.
COMPLETE LIST with surname, first names, profession, place of residence (address, number, postal code and town) and position within the company
Zinkstraat 1, 2490 Balen, Belgium
Mandate: Director, start: 29/06/2020, end: 25/06/2024
Cable Carole Zinkstraat 1, 2490 Balen, Belgium
Mandate: Director, start: 29/06/2021, end: 24/06/2025
Zinkstraat 1, 2490 Balen, Belgium
Mandate: Director, start: 27/06/2023, end: 29/06/2027
Zinkstraat 1, 2490 Balen, Belgium
Mandate: President of the board of directors, start: 27/06/2023, end: 29/06/2027
Zinkstraat 1, 2490 Balen, Belgium
Mandate: Director, start: 27/06/2023, end: 29/06/2027
Membership number: B00023 Vincilaan 9, box E.6, 1930 Zaventem, Belgium Mandate: Auditor, start: 27/06/2023, end: 30/06/2026 Represented by:
The managing board declares that not a single audit or correction assignment has been given to a person not authorized to do so by law, pursuant to article 5 of the law of 17 March 2019 concerning the professions of accountant and tax advisor.
The annual accounts were / were not * audited or corrected by a certified accountant or by a company auditor who is not the statutory auditor.
If affirmative, should be mentioned hereafter: surname, first names, profession and address of each certified accountant or company auditor and their membership number at their Institute, as well as the nature of their assignment:
If the tasks mentioned under A or B are executed by accountants or fiscal accountants, the following information can be mentioned hereafter: surname, first names, profession and address of each accountant or fiscal accountant and their membership number at the Institute of Accountants and Tax advisors, as well as the nature of their assignment.
| Surname, first names, profession and address | Membership number | Nature of the assignment (A, B, C and/or D) |
|---|---|---|
* Strike out what does not apply.
** Optional mention.
| Notes | Codes | Period | Preceding period | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| ASSETS | ||||
| FORMATION EXPENSES | 6.1 | 20 | ||
| FIXED ASSETS | 21/28 | |||
| Intangible fixed assets | 6.2 | 21 | ||
| Tangible fixed assets | 6.3 | 22/27 | ||
| Land and buildings | 22 | |||
| Plant, machinery and equipment | 23 | |||
| Furniture and vehicles | 24 | |||
| Leasing and other similar rights | 25 | |||
| Other tangible fixed assets | 26 | |||
| Assets under construction and advance payments | 27 | |||
| Financial fixed assets | 6.4 / 6.5.1 |
28 | ||
| Affiliated Companies | 6.15 | 280/1 | ||
| Participating interests | 280 | |||
| Amounts receivable | 281 | |||
| Other companies linked by participating interests | 6.15 | 282/3 | ||
| Participating interests | 282 | |||
| Amounts receivable | 283 | |||
| Other financial fixed assets | 284/8 | |||
| Shares | 284 | |||
| Amounts receivable and cash guarantees | 285/8 | |||
| Notes | Codes | Period | Preceding period | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| CURRENT ASSETS | 29/58 | 16.211.966,96 | 18.781.961,52 | |
| Amounts receivable after more than one year | 29 | |||
| Trade debtors | 290 | |||
| Other amounts receivable | 291 | |||
| Stocks and contracts in progress | 3 | |||
| Stocks | 30/36 | |||
| Raw materials and consumables | 30/31 | |||
| Work in progress | 32 | |||
| Finished goods | 33 | |||
| Goods purchased for resale | 34 | |||
| Immovable property intended for sale | 35 | |||
| Advance payments | 36 | |||
| Contracts in progress | 37 | |||
| Amounts receivable within one year | 40/41 | 321.505,95 | 332.430,02 | |
| Trade debtors | 40 | |||
| Other amounts receivable | 41 | 321.505,95 | 332.430,02 | |
| Current investments | 6.5.1 / 6.6 |
50/53 | 13.000.000,00 | 15.000.000,00 |
| Own shares | 50 | |||
| Other investments | 51/53 | 13.000.000,00 | 15.000.000,00 | |
| Cash at bank and in hand | 54/58 | 1.915.376,70 | 2.827.946,03 | |
| Accruals and deferred income | 6.6 | 490/1 | 975.084,31 | 621.585,47 |
| TOTAL ASSETS | 20/58 | 16.211.966,96 | 18.781.961,52 |
| Notes | Codes | Period | Preceding period | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| EQUITY AND LIABILITIES | ||||
| EQUITY | 10/15 | -3.960.901,78 | -2.497.336,69 | |
| Contributions | 6.7.1 | 10/11 | 1.330.530.636,44 | 1.330.530.636,44 |
| Capital | 10 | 114.134.760,97 | 114.134.760,97 | |
| Issued capital | 100 | 114.134.760,97 | 114.134.760,97 | |
| 6 Uncalled capital |
101 | |||
| Beyond capital | 11 | 1.216.395.875,47 | 1.216.395.875,47 | |
| Share premium account | 1100/10 | 1.216.395.875,47 | 1.216.395.875,47 | |
| Other | 1109/19 | |||
| Revaluation surpluses | 12 | |||
| Reserves | 13 | 16.257.028,06 | 16.257.028,06 | |
| Reserves not available | 130/1 | 16.257.028,06 | 16.257.028,06 | |
| Legal reserve | 130 | 16.257.028,06 | 16.257.028,06 | |
| Reserves not available statutorily | 1311 | |||
| Purchase of own shares | 1312 | |||
| Financial support | 1313 | |||
| Other | 1319 | |||
| Untaxed reserves | 132 | |||
| Available reserves | 133 | |||
| Accumulated profits (losses) | (+)/(-) | 14 | -1.350.748.566,28 | -1.349.285.001,19 |
| Capital subsidies | 15 | |||
| Advance to shareholders on the distribution of net 7 assets |
19 | |||
| PROVISIONS AND DEFERRED TAXES | 16 | 9.396.097,76 | 10.851.065,44 | |
| Provisions for liabilities and charges | 160/5 | 9.396.097,76 | 10.851.065,44 | |
| Pensions and similar obligations | 160 | |||
| Taxes | 161 | |||
| Major repairs and maintenance | 162 | |||
| Environmental obligations | 163 | |||
| Other liabilities and charges | 6.8 | 164/5 | 9.396.097,76 | 10.851.065,44 |
| Deferred taxes | 168 |
Amount to be deducted from the issued capital. 6
Amount to be deducted from the other components of equity. 7
| Notes | Codes | Period | Preceding period | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| AMOUNTS PAYABLE | 17/49 | 10.776.770,98 | 10.428.232,77 | |
| Amounts payable after more than one year | 6.9 | 17 | ||
| Financial debts | 170/4 | |||
| Subordinated loans | 170 | |||
| Unsubordinated debentures | 171 | |||
| Leasing and other similar obligations | 172 | |||
| Credit institutions | 173 | |||
| Other loans | 174 | |||
| Trade debts | 175 | |||
| Suppliers | 1750 | |||
| Bills of exchange payable | 1751 | |||
| Advance payments on contracts in progress | 176 | |||
| Other amounts payable | 178/9 | |||
| Amounts payable within one year | 6.9 | 42/48 | 10.598.442,27 | 10.378.942,43 |
| Current portion of amounts payable after more than one year falling due within one year |
42 | |||
| Financial debts | 43 | 10.059.138,49 | 9.820.478,16 | |
| Credit institutions | 430/8 | |||
| Other loans | 439 | 10.059.138,49 | 9.820.478,16 | |
| Trade debts | 44 | 500.974,31 | 540.505,57 | |
| Suppliers | 440/4 | 500.974,31 | 540.505,57 | |
| Bills of exchange payable | 441 | |||
| Advance payments on contracts in progress | 46 | |||
| Taxes, remuneration and social security | 6.9 | 45 | 38.329,47 | 17.958,70 |
| Taxes | 450/3 | 16.316,83 | ||
| Remuneration and social security | 454/9 | 22.012,64 | 17.958,70 | |
| Other amounts payable | 47/48 | |||
| Accruals and deferred income | 6.9 | 492/3 | 178.328,71 | 49.290,34 |
| TOTAL LIABILITIES | 10/49 | 16.211.966,96 | 18.781.961,52 |
| Notes | Codes | Period | Preceding period | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Operating income | 70/76A | 3.584.339,22 | 502.245,54 | ||
| Turnover | 6.10 | 70 | |||
| Stocks of finished goods and work and contracts in progress: increase (decrease) |
(+)/(-) | 71 | |||
| Produced fixed assets | 72 | ||||
| Other operating income | 6.10 | 74 | 33.025,32 | 97.333,86 | |
| Non-recurring operating income | 6.12 | 76A | 3.551.313,90 | 404.911,68 | |
| Operating charges | 60/66A | 5.060.102,39 | 5.903.726,01 | ||
| Goods for resale, raw materials and consumables | 60 | ||||
| Purchases | 600/8 | ||||
| Stocks: decrease (increase) | (+)/(-) | 609 | |||
| Services and other goods | 61 | 5.070.617,88 | 4.109.020,49 | ||
| Remuneration, social security and pensions | (+)/(-) | 6.10 | 62 | ||
| Amortisations of and other amounts written down on formation expenses, intangible and tangible fixed assets |
630 | ||||
| Amounts written down on stocks, contracts in progress and trade debtors: additions (write-backs) |
(+)/(-) | 6.10 | 631/4 | ||
| Provisions for liabilities and charges: appropriations (uses and write-backs) |
(+)/(-) | 6.10 | 635/8 | -11.767,68 | -6.864,48 |
| Other operating charges | 6.10 | 640/8 | 1.252,19 | 970,00 | |
| Operating charges reported as assets under restructuring costs |
(-) | 649 | |||
| Non-recurring operating charges | 6.12 | 66A | 1.800.600,00 | ||
| Operating profit (loss) | (+)/(-) | 9901 | -1.475.763,17 | -5.401.480,47 |
| Notes | Codes | Period | Preceding period | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Financial income | 75/76B | 386.635,76 | 4.639.017,90 | ||
| Recurring financial income | 75 | 386.635,76 | 34.017,90 | ||
| Income from financial fixed assets | 750 | ||||
| Income from current assets | 751 | 386.510,00 | 33.833,33 | ||
| Other financial income | 6.11 | 752/9 | 125,76 | 184,57 | |
| Non-recurring financial income | 6.12 | 76B | 4.605.000,00 | ||
| Financial charges | 6.11 | 65/66B | 374.437,68 | 85.831,58 | |
| Recurring financial charges | 65 | 374.437,68 | 85.831,58 | ||
| Debt charges | 650 | 367.698,70 | 77.214,82 | ||
| Amounts written down on current assets other than stocks, contracts in progress and trade debtors: additions (write-backs) |
(+)/(-) | 651 | |||
| Other financial charges | 652/9 | 6.738,98 | 8.616,76 | ||
| Non-recurring financial charges | 6.12 | 66B | |||
| Profit (Loss) for the period before taxes | (+)/(-) | 9903 | -1.463.565,09 | -848.294,15 | |
| Transfer from deferred taxes | 780 | ||||
| Transfer to deferred taxes | 680 | ||||
| Income taxes on the result | (+)/(-) | 6.13 | 67/77 | ||
| Taxes | 670/3 | ||||
| Adjustment of income taxes and write-back of tax provisions |
77 | ||||
| Profit (Loss) of the period | (+)/(-) | 9904 | -1.463.565,09 | -848.294,15 | |
| Transfer from untaxed reserves | 789 | ||||
| Transfer to untaxed reserves | 689 | ||||
| Profit (Loss) of the period available for appropriation | (+)/(-) | 9905 | -1.463.565,09 | -848.294,15 |
| Codes | Period | Preceding period | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Profit (Loss) to be appropriated | (+)/(-) | 9906 | -1.350.748.566,28 | -1.349.285.001,19 |
| Profit (Loss) of the period available for appropriation | (+)/(-) | (9905) | -1.463.565,09 | -848.294,15 |
| Profit (Loss) of the preceding period brought forward | (+)/(-) | 14P | -1.349.285.001,19 | -1.348.436.707,04 |
| Transfers from equity | 791/2 | |||
| from contributions | 791 | |||
| from reserves | 792 | |||
| Appropriations to equity | 691/2 | |||
| to contributions | 691 | |||
| to legal reserve | 6920 | |||
| to other reserves | 6921 | |||
| Profit (loss) to be carried forward | (+)/(-) | (14) | -1.350.748.566,28 | -1.349.285.001,19 |
| Shareholders' contribution in respect of losses | 794 | |||
| Profit to be distributed | 694/7 | |||
| Compensation for contributions | 694 | |||
| Directors or managers | 695 | |||
| Employees | 696 | |||
| Other beneficiaries | 697 |
| Preceding period | ||
|---|---|---|
| 51 | ||
| 8681 | ||
| 8682 | ||
| 8683 | ||
| 52 | ||
| 8684 | ||
| 53 | 13.000.000,00 | 15.000.000,00 |
| 8686 | ||
| 8687 | 13.000.000,00 | 15.000.000,00 |
| 8688 | ||
| 8689 | ||
| Codes | Period |
Insurance fees 133.193,95 External services - consultants 237,85 Telephone/communication 15.357,01 Lawyers' and related fees reimbursed by insurance 696.928,01 Membership deductible 2.083,32 Interest income 46.334,17 Audit fees BDO 60.950,00
Period
Issued capital at the end of the period Issued capital at the end of the period
Modifications during the period
Composition of the capital Share types
Registered shares
Shares dematerialized
| Codes | Period | Preceding period |
|---|---|---|
| 100P | XXXXXXXXXXXXXX | 114.134.760,97 |
| (100) | 114.134.760,97 |
| Codes | Period | Number of shares | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Modifications during the period | |||
| Composition of the capital | |||
| Ordinary shares without par value | 114.134.760,97 | 109.873.001 | |
| Registered shares | 8702 | XXXXXXXXXXXXXX | 7.429.434 |
| Shares dematerialized | 8703 | XXXXXXXXXXXXXX | 102.443.567 |
| Codes | Uncalled amount | Called up amount, unpaid | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Unpaid capital | |||
| Uncalled capital | (101) | XXXXXXXXXXXXXX | |
| Called up capital, unpaid | 8712 | XXXXXXXXXXXXXX | |
| Shareholders that still need to pay up in full | |||
| Codes | Period | |
|---|---|---|
| Own shares | ||
| Held by the company itself | ||
| Amount of capital held | 8721 | |
| Number of shares | 8722 | |
| Held by a subsidiary | ||
| Amount of capital held | 8731 | |
| Number of shares | 8732 | |
| Commitments to issuing shares | ||
| Owing to the exercise of conversion rights | ||
| Amount of outstanding convertible loans | 8740 | |
| Amount of capital to be subscribed | 8741 | |
| Corresponding maximum number of shares to be issued | 8742 | |
| Owing to the exercise of subscription rights | ||
| Number of outstanding subscription rights | 8745 | |
| Amount of capital to be subscribed | 8746 | |
| Corresponding maximum number of shares to be issued | 8747 | |
| Authorised capital not issued |
| 0888728945 N°. |
F-cap 6.7.1 | |
|---|---|---|
| Codes | Period | |
| Shares issued, non-representing capital | ||
| Distribution | ||
| Number of shares | 8761 | |
| Number of voting rights attached thereto | 8762 | |
| Allocation by shareholder |
8771 8781
Period
Number of shares held by the company itself
Number of shares held by its subsidiaries
ADDITIONAL NOTES REGARDING CONTRIBUTIONS (INCLUDING CONTRIBUTIONS IN THE FORM OF SERVICES OR KNOW-HOW)
As reflected in the notifications received by the company pursuant to article 7:225 of the Belgian Companies and Associations Code, article 14 fourth paragraph of the law of 2 May 2007 on the publication of major holdings and article 5 of the Royal Decree of 21 August 2008 on further rules for certain multilateral trading facilities.
15/44
Provision for discontinuation 9.379.100,00 Other provisions 16.997,76
| Codes | Period | |
|---|---|---|
| BREAKDOWN OF AMOUNTS PAYABLE WITH AN ORIGINAL TERM OF MORE THAN ONE YEAR, ACCORDING TO THEIR RESIDUAL MATURITY |
||
| Current portion of amounts payable after more than one year falling due within one year | ||
| Financial debts | 8801 | |
| Subordinated loans | 8811 | |
| Unsubordinated debentures | 8821 | |
| Leasing and other similar obligations | 8831 | |
| Credit institutions | 8841 | |
| Other loans | 8851 | |
| Trade debts | 8861 | |
| Suppliers | 8871 | |
| Bills of exchange payable | 8881 | |
| Advance payments on contracts in progress | 8891 | |
| Other amounts payable | 8901 | |
| Total current portion of amounts payable after more than one year falling due within one year | (42) | |
| Amounts payable with a remaining term of more than one year, yet less than 5 years | ||
| Financial debts | 8802 | |
| Subordinated loans | 8812 | |
| Unsubordinated debentures | 8822 | |
| Leasing and other similar obligations | 8832 | |
| Credit institutions | 8842 | |
| Other loans | 8852 | |
| Trade debts | 8862 | |
| Suppliers | 8872 | |
| Bills of exchange payable | 8882 | |
| Advance payments on contracts in progress | 8892 | |
| Other amounts payable | 8902 | |
| Total amounts payable with a remaining term of more than one year, yet less than 5 years | 8912 | |
| Amounts payable with a remaining term of more than 5 years | ||
| Financial debts | 8803 | |
| Subordinated loans | 8813 | |
| Unsubordinated debentures | 8823 | |
| Leasing and other similar obligations | 8833 | |
| Credit institutions | 8843 | |
| Other loans | 8853 | |
| Trade debts | 8863 | |
| Suppliers | 8873 | |
| Bills of exchange payable | 8883 | |
| Advance payments on contracts in progress | 8893 | |
| Other amounts payable | 8903 | |
| Amounts payable with a remaining term of more than 5 years | 8913 |
| Codes | Period | |
|---|---|---|
| AMOUNTS PAYABLE GUARANTEED (included in accounts 17 and 42/48 of liabilities) |
||
| Amounts payable guaranteed by the Belgian government agencies | ||
| Financial debts | 8921 | |
| Subordinated loans | 8931 | |
| Unsubordinated debentures | 8941 | |
| Leasing and other similar obligations | 8951 | |
| Credit institutions | 8961 | |
| Other loans | 8971 | |
| Trade debts | 8981 | |
| Suppliers | 8991 | |
| Bills of exchange payable | 9001 | |
| Advance payments on contracts in progress | 9011 | |
| Remuneration and social security | 9021 | |
| Other amounts payable | 9051 | |
| Total of the amounts payable guaranteed by the Belgian government agencies | 9061 | |
| Amounts payable guaranteed by real securities given or irrevocably promised by the company on its own assets |
||
| Financial debts | 8922 | |
| Subordinated loans | 8932 | |
| Unsubordinated debentures | 8942 | |
| Leasing and other similar obligations | 8952 | |
| Credit institutions | 8962 | |
| Other loans | 8972 | |
| Trade debts | 8982 | |
| Suppliers | 8992 | |
| Bills of exchange payable | 9002 | |
| Advance payments on contracts in progress | 9012 | |
| Taxes, remuneration and social security | 9022 | |
| Taxes | 9032 | |
| Remuneration and social security | 9042 | |
| Other amounts payable | 9052 | |
| Total amounts payable guaranteed by real securities given or irrevocably promised by the company on its own assets |
9062 |
| Codes | Period | |
|---|---|---|
| TAXES, REMUNERATION AND SOCIAL SECURITY | ||
| (headings 450/3 and 178/9 of liabilities) Taxes |
||
| Outstanding tax debts | 9072 | |
| Accruing taxes payable | 9073 | 16.316,83 |
| Estimated taxes payable | 450 | |
| Remuneration and social security (headings 454/9 and 178/9 of liabilities) | ||
| Amounts due to the National Social Security Office | 9076 | |
| Other amounts payable in respect of remuneration and social security | 9077 | 22.012,64 |
TR accrued intrest payable 178.328,71
Period
| OPERATING RESULTS | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| Codes | Period | Preceding period | |
|---|---|---|---|
| OPERATING INCOME | |||
| Net turnover | |||
| Allocation by categories of activity | |||
| Allocation by geographical market | |||
| Other operating income | |||
| Operating subsidies and compensatory amounts received from public authorities |
740 | ||
| OPERATING CHARGES | |||
| Employees for whom the company submitted a DIMONA declaration or who are recorded in the general personnel register |
|||
| Total number at the closing date | 9086 | ||
| Average number of employees calculated in full-time equivalents | 9087 | ||
| Number of actual hours worked | 9088 | ||
| Personnel costs | |||
| Remuneration and direct social benefits | 620 | ||
| Employers' contribution for social security | 621 | ||
| Employers' premiums for extra statutory insurance | 622 | ||
| Other personnel costs | 623 | ||
| Retirement and survivors' pensions | 624 | ||
| Codes | Period | Preceding period |
| Provisions for pensions and similar obligations | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Appropriations (uses and write-backs) | (+)/(-) | 635 | ||
| Depreciations | ||||
| On stock and contracts in progress | ||||
| Recorded | 9110 | |||
| Written back | 9111 | |||
| On trade debtors | ||||
| Recorded | 9112 | |||
| Written back | 9113 | |||
| Provisions for liabilities and charges | ||||
| Appropriations | 9115 | |||
| Uses and write-backs | 9116 | 11.767,68 | 6.864,48 | |
| Other operating charges | ||||
| Taxes related to operation | 640 | 283,93 | 102,00 | |
| Other | 641/8 | 968,26 | 868,00 | |
| Hired temporary staff and personnel placed at the company's disposal |
||||
| Total number at the closing date | 9096 | |||
| Average number calculated in full-time equivalents | 9097 | |||
| Number of actual hours worked | 9098 | |||
| Costs to the company | 617 | |||
| Codes | Period | Preceding period | |
|---|---|---|---|
| RECURRING FINANCIAL INCOME | |||
| Other financial income | |||
| Subsidies paid by public authorities, added to the profit and loss account | |||
| Capital subsidies | 9125 | ||
| Interest subsidies | 9126 | ||
| Allocation of other financial income | |||
| Exchange differences realized | 754 | ||
| Other | |||
| positive foreign exchange differences | 125,76 | 184,57 | |
| RECURRING FINANCIAL CHARGES | |||
| Depreciation of loan issue expenses | 6501 | ||
| Capitalised interests | 6502 | ||
| Depreciations on current assets | |||
| Recorded | 6510 | ||
| Written back | 6511 | ||
| Other financial charges | |||
| Amount of the discount borne by the company, as a result of negotiating amounts receivable |
653 | ||
| Provisions of a financial nature | |||
| Appropriations | 6560 | ||
| Uses and write-backs | 6561 | ||
| Allocation of other financial costs | |||
| Exchange differences realized | 654 | ||
| Results from the conversion of foreign currencies | 655 | ||
| Other | |||
| Negative foreign exchange differences | 4.112,27 | 3.830,89 |
| Codes | Period | Preceding period | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| NON-RECURRING INCOME | 76 | 3.551.313,90 | 5.009.911,68 | |
| Non-recurring operating income | (76A) | 3.551.313,90 | 404.911,68 | |
| Write-back of depreciation and of amounts written off intangible and tangible fixed assets |
760 | |||
| Write-back of provisions for extraordinary operating liabilities and charges |
7620 | 1.443.200,00 | ||
| Capital profits on disposal of intangible and tangible fixed assets | 7630 | |||
| Other non-recurring operating income | 764/8 | 2.108.113,90 | 404.911,68 | |
| Non-recurring financial income | (76B) | 4.605.000,00 | ||
| Write-back of amounts written down financial fixed assets | 761 | |||
| Write-back of provisions for extraordinary financial liabilities and charges |
7621 | |||
| Capital profits on disposal of financial fixed assets | 7631 | |||
| Other non-recurring financial income | 769 | 4.605.000,00 | ||
| NON-RECURRING CHARGES | 66 | 1.800.600,00 | ||
| Non-recurring operating charges | (66A) | 1.800.600,00 | ||
| Non-recurring depreciation of and amounts written off formation expenses, intangible and tangible fixed assets |
660 | |||
| Provisions for extraordinary operating liabilities and charges: appropriations (uses) |
(+)/(-) | 6620 | 1.800.600,00 | |
| Capital losses on disposal of intangible and tangible fixed assets | 6630 | |||
| Other non-recurring operating charges | 664/7 | |||
| Non-recurring operating charges carried to assets as restructuring costs |
(-) | 6690 | ||
| Non-recurring financial charges | (66B) | |||
| Amounts written off financial fixed assets | 661 | |||
| Provisions for extraordinary financial liabilities and charges - appropriations (uses) |
(+)/(-) | 6621 | ||
| Capital losses on disposal of financial fixed assets | 6631 | |||
| Other non-recurring financial charges | 668 | |||
| Non-recurring financial charges carried to assets as restructuring costs |
(-) | 6691 |
Period
| Codes | Period | |
|---|---|---|
| INCOME TAXES | ||
| Income taxes on the result of the period | 9134 | |
| Income taxes paid and withholding taxes due or paid | 9135 | 115.952,99 |
| Excess of income tax prepayments and withholding taxes paid recorded under assets | 9136 | 115.952,99 |
| Estimated additional taxes | 9137 | |
| Income taxes on the result of prior periods | 9138 | |
| Additional income taxes due or paid | 9139 | |
| Additional income taxes estimated or provided for | 9140 | |
| Major reasons for the differences between pre-tax profit, as it results from the annual accounts, and estimated taxable profit |
Influence of non-recurring results on income taxes on the result of the period
| Codes | Period | |
|---|---|---|
| Sources of deferred taxes | ||
| Deferred taxes representing assets | 9141 | 329.875.907,01 |
| Accumulated tax losses deductible from future taxable profits | 9142 | 225.779.089,12 |
| Other deferred taxes representing assets | ||
| DBI | 104.096.817,89 | |
| Deferred taxes representing liabilities | 9144 | |
| Allocation of deferred taxes representing liabilities |
To the company (deductible)
By the company
Payroll withholding taxes
Withholding taxes on investment income
| Codes | Period | Preceding period | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 9145 | 863.420,75 | 664.400,73 | ||
| 9146 | 229.957,40 | 200.323,99 | ||
| 9147 | ||||
| 9148 | ||||
| Codes | Period | |
|---|---|---|
| PERSONAL GUARANTEES PROVIDED OR IRREVOCABLY PROMISED BY THE COMPANY AS SECURITY FOR DEBTS AND COMMITMENTS OF THIRD PARTIES |
9149 | |
| Of which | ||
| Bills of exchange in circulation endorsed by the company | 9150 | |
| Bills of exchange in circulation drawn or guaranteed by the company | 9151 | |
| Maximum amount for which other debts or commitments of third parties are guaranteed by the company |
9153 | |
| REAL GUARANTEES | ||
| Real guarantees provided or irrevocably promised by the company on its own assets as security of debts and commitments of the company |
||
| Mortgages | ||
| Book value of the immovable properties mortgaged | 91611 | |
| Amount of registration | 91621 | |
| For irrevocable mortgage mandates, the amount for which the agent can take registration |
91631 | |
| Pledging of goodwill | ||
| Maximum amount up to which the debt is secured and which is the subject of registration |
91711 | |
| For irrevocable mandates to pledge goodwill, the amount for which the agent can take the inscription |
91721 | |
| Pledging of other assets or irrevocable mandates to pledge other assets | ||
| Book value of the immovable properties mortgaged | 91811 | |
| Maximum amount up to which the debt is secured | 91821 | |
| Guarantees provided or irrevocably promised on future assets | ||
| Amount of assets in question | 91911 | |
| Maximum amount up to which the debt is secured | 91921 | |
| Vendor's privilege | ||
| Book value of sold goods | 92011 | |
| Amount of the unpaid price | 92021 |
| Codes | Period | |
|---|---|---|
| Real guarantees provided or irrevocably promised by the company on its own assets as security of debts and commitments of third parties |
||
| Mortgages | ||
| Book value of the immovable properties mortgaged | 91612 | |
| Amount of registration | 91622 | |
| For irrevocable mortgage mandates, the amount for which the agent can take registration |
91632 | |
| Pledging of goodwill | ||
| Maximum amount up to which the debt is secured and which is the subject of registration | 91712 | |
| For irrevocable mandates to pledge goodwill, the amount for which the agent can take the inscription |
91722 | |
| Pledging of other assets or irrevocable mandates to pledge other assets | ||
| Book value of the immovable properties mortgaged | 91812 | |
| Maximum amount up to which the debt is secured | 91822 | |
| Guarantees provided or irrevocably promised on future assets | ||
| Amount of assets in question | 91912 | |
| Maximum amount up to which the debt is secured | 91922 | |
| Vendor's privilege | ||
| Book value of sold goods | 92012 | |
| Amount of the unpaid price | 92022 | |
| Codes | Period |
SUBSTANTIAL COMMITMENTS TO ACQUIRE FIXED ASSETS
SUBSTANTIAL COMMITMENTS TO DISPOSE OF FIXED ASSETS
FORWARD TRANSACTIONS
Goods purchased (to be received) Goods sold (to be delivered) 9214 Currencies purchased (to be received) 9215 Currencies sold (to be delivered) 9216
COMMITMENTS RELATING TO TECHNICAL GUARANTEES IN RESPECT OF SALES OR SERVICES

Period
9213
AMOUNT, NATURE AND FORM CONCERNING LITIGATION AND OTHER IMPORTANT COMMITMENTS
Brief description
Measures taken to cover the related charges
| Code | Period | |
|---|---|---|
| PENSIONS FUNDED BY THE COMPANY ITSELF | ||
| Estimated amount of the commitments resulting from past services | 9220 | |
| Methods of estimation | ||
| Period | ||
| NATURE AND FINANCIAL IMPACT OF SIGNIFICANT EVENTS AFTER THE CLOSING DATE not reflected in the balance sheet or income statement |
||
| Refer to VOL 6.20 | ||
| Period | ||
| COMMITMENTS TO PURCHASE OR SALE AVAILABLE TO THE COMPANY AS ISSUER OF OPTIONS FOR | ||
| SALE OR PURCHASE | ||
| Period | ||
| NATURE, COMMERCIAL OBJECTIVE AND FINANCIAL CONSEQUENCES OF TRANSACTIONS NOT REFLECTED IN THE BALANCE SHEET |
||
| If the risks and benefits resulting from such transactions are of any meaning and if publishing such risks and benefits is necessary to appreciate the financial situation of the company |
||
| Refer to VOL 6.20 | ||
| Period | ||
| OTHER RIGHTS AND COMMITMENTS NOT REFLECTED IN THE BALANCE SHEET (including those that cannot be calculated) |
||
| Until 31 July 2019, the Company was the holding company of the Nyrstar group (consisting of the Company and its former subsidiaries). At 31 July 2019, when the Restructuring of the Nyrstar group was finalised, the |
||
| Company was released of liabilities for existing financial indebtedness and obligations owed under parent company guarantees of commercial or other obligations of the current members of the Operating Group |
||
| (all former subsidiaries of the Nyrstar group excluding NN1) (or indemnified by NN2 to the extent such garantuee liabilities are not released). As at 31 December 2023, based on information available to the |
||
| Company, the Company has been fully released from all contingent liabiliteis previously provided or | ||
| irrevocably promised by the Company debts and commitments of third parties. The Company is fully indemnified in relation to any liability that may arise in this respect see "Related party disclosures"). |
||
| Codes | Period | Preceding period | |
|---|---|---|---|
| AFFILIATED COMPANIES | |||
| Financial fixed assets | (280/1) | ||
| Participating interests | (280) | ||
| Subordinated amounts receivable | 9271 | ||
| Other amounts receivable | 9281 | ||
| Amounts receivable | 9291 | ||
| Over one year | 9301 | ||
| Within one year | 9311 | ||
| Current investments | 9321 | ||
| Shares | 9331 | ||
| Amounts receivable | 9341 | ||
| Amounts payable | 9351 | ||
| Over one year | 9361 | ||
| Within one year | 9371 | ||
| Personal and real guarantees | |||
| Provided or irrevocably promised by the company as security for debts or commitments of affiliated companies |
9381 | ||
| Provided or irrevocably promised by affiliated companies as security for debts or commitments of the company |
9391 | ||
| Other significant financial commitments | 9401 | ||
| Financial results | |||
| Income from financial fixed assets | 9421 | ||
| Income from current assets | 9431 | ||
| Other financial income | 9441 | ||
| Debt charges | 9461 | ||
| Other financial charges | 9471 | ||
| Disposal of fixed assets | |||
| Capital profits realised | 9481 | ||
| Capital losses realised | 9491 | ||
| Codes | Period | Preceding period | |
|---|---|---|---|
| ASSOCIATED COMPANIES | |||
| Financial fixed assets | 9253 | ||
| Participating interests | 9263 | ||
| Subordinated amounts receivable | 9273 | ||
| Other amounts receivable | 9283 | ||
| Amounts receivable | 9293 | ||
| Over one year | 9303 | ||
| Within one year | 9313 | ||
| Amounts payable | 9353 | ||
| Over one year | 9363 | ||
| Within one year | 9373 | ||
| Personal and real guarantees | |||
| Provided or irrevocably promised by the company as security for debts or commitments of affiliated companies |
9383 | ||
| Provided or irrevocably promised by affiliated companies as security for debts or commitments of the company |
9393 | ||
| Other significant financial commitments | 9403 | ||
| COMPANIES LINKED BY PARTICIPATING INTERESTS | |||
| Financial fixed assets | 9252 | ||
| Participating interests | 9262 | ||
| Subordinated amounts receivable | 9272 | ||
| Other amounts receivable | 9282 | ||
| Amounts receivable | 9292 | ||
| Over one year | 9302 | ||
| Within one year | 9312 | ||
| Amounts payable | 9352 | ||
| Over one year | 9362 | ||
| Within one year | 9372 | ||
TRANSACTIONS WITH AFFILIATED PARTIES BEYOND NORMAL MARKET CONDITIONS
Mention of these transactions if they are significant, including the amount of the transactions, the nature of the link, and all information about the transactions that should be necessary to get a better understanding of the financial situation of the company
The relationship with Trafigura, including the outstanding balances as at 31 December 2023 and the interest charges on the LRLF incurred during the year ended on 31 December 2023 are further disclosed in C 6.20.
| Period | |
|---|---|
| Codes | Period | |
|---|---|---|
| DIRECTORS AND MANAGERS, INDIVIDUALS OR LEGAL PERSONS WHO CONTROL THE COMPANY DIRECTLY OR INDIRECTLY WITHOUT BEING ASSOCIATED THEREWITH, OR OTHER COMPANIES CONTROLLED DIRECTLY OR INDIRECTLY BY THESE PERSONS |
||
| Amounts receivable from these persons | 9500 | |
| Principal conditions regarding amounts receivable, rate of interest, duration, any amounts repaid, cancelled or written off |
||
| Guarantees provided in their favour | 9501 | |
| Other significant commitments undertaken in their favour | 9502 | |
| Amount of direct and indirect remunerations and pensions, reflected in the income statement, as long as this disclosure does not concern exclusively or mainly, the situation of a single identifiable person |
||
| To directors and managers | 9503 | 517.839,30 |
| To former directors and former managers | 9504 |
| Codes | Period | |
|---|---|---|
| THE AUDITOR(S) AND THE PERSONS WHOM HE (THEY) IS (ARE) COLLABORATING WITH |
||
| Auditors' fees | 9505 | 145.000,00 |
| Fees for exceptional services or special assignments executed within the company by the auditor | ||
| Other audit assignments | 95061 | |
| Tax consultancy assignments | 95062 | |
| Other assignments beyondthe audit | 95063 | |
| Fees for exceptional services or special assignments executed within the company by people the auditor(s) is (are collaborating with |
||
| Other audit assignments | 95081 | |
| Tax consultancy assignments | 95082 | |
| Other assignments beyond the audit | 95083 | |
Mentions related to article 3:64, § 2 and § 4 of the Belgian Companies and Associations Code
The company has prepared and published consolidated annual accounts and a consolidated annual report*
The company has not prepared consolidated annual accounts and a consolidated annual report, because of an exemption for the following reason(s)*
The company and its subsidiaries exceed, on a consolidated basis, not more than one of the criteria mentioned in article 1:26 of the Belgian Companies and Associations Code*
The company only has subsidiaries that, considering the evaluation of the consolidated capital, the consolidated financial position or the consolidated result, individually or together, are of negligible interestError! Bookmark not defined. (article 3:23 of the Belgian Companies and Associations Code)
The company itself is a subsidiary of a parent company that prepares and publishes consolidated annual accounts, in which the annual accounts are integrated by consolidation*
Name, full address of the registered office and, if it concerns companies under Belgian law, the company registration number of the parent company(ies) and the indication if this (these) parent company(ies) prepares (prepare) and publishes (publish) consolidated annual accounts, in which the annual accounts are included by means of consolidation**:
If the parent company(ies) is (are) (a) company(ies) governed by foreign law, the location where the abovementioned annual accounts are available**:
* Strike out what does not apply.
** Where the annual accounts of the company are consolidated at different levels, the information should be given, on the one hand at the highest and on the other at the lowest level of companies of which the company is a subsidiary and for which consolidated accounts are prepared and published.
Valuation rules Nyrstar NV (hereafter "the Company")
General:
The valuation rules are drafted in accordance with the statements of the Royal Decree dd. 29 April 2019 implementing the Belgian Code of Companies and Associations, relating to valuation rules. As a consequence of the Restructuring (as defined below) and the outcomes of the 9 December 2019 Extraordinary Shareholders Meeting ("EGM"), where the shareholders' meeting rejected the continuation of the Company's activities, the 31 December 2023 financial statements of the Company are prepared on a discontinuity basis. For further information on the outcomes of the Restructuring, please refer to "Related party disclosures".
Valuation rules applied to the Company's balance sheet prepared on a discontinuity basis include:
I.Financial fixed assets Participations are accounted for at the lower of realisation values and historical purchase cost.
Current assets, which include input VAT on ongoing expenses for which the Company either received or expects to receive refund from the relevant authorities, and current liabilities are recognised at their realisation values. At 31 December 2023, the realization values equal nominal values. Current assets and liabilities denominated in foreign currencies are valued at the closing rates on the end of the financial year. The negative (unrealized) exchange rate differences are accounted for in the income statement. Based on the principle of prudence, the positive, unrealized exchange rate differences at balance sheet date are accounted for as deferred income on the balance sheet.
A provision is recognized to reflect liabilities and charges, resulting from a past event for which the nature is clearly defined, is considered probable or certain at balance sheet date, but for which the amount is uncertain. Provisions resulting from prior accounting years are regularly reviewed and are reversed if they are no longer required or the risks and charges are realized.
The income statement reflects all revenue realized and expenses incurred during the accounting period on an accrual basis, regardless of the date on which these expenses and income are paid or collected.
Adjustments recorded with respect to the valuation and the classification of certain balance sheet items as a result of the Company applying the discontinuity basis for the preparation of the 31 December 2023 financial statements:
a)The formation expenses were fully depreciated as required by Article 3:6 of the Royal Decree d.d. 29 April 2019 implementing the Belgian Code of Companies and Associations.
b)Explanation on determination of expected probable realization value in accordance with Article 3:6 of the Royal Decree d.d. 29 April 2019 implementing the Belgian Code of Companies and Associations.
Before 28 July 2022, the Company had, in its current investments, a 2% equity stake in NN2 NewCo Limited ("NN2") as a consequence of the issuance by NN2 of a 2% equity stake in NN2 to the Company with the remaining 98% equity stake issued to Nyrstar Holdings Plc (a holding company within the Trafigura corporate group, formerly known as Nyrstar Holdings Limited). The Company also had a Put Option (as defined below) enabling it to sell all (but not a part only) of its 2% stake in NN2 to a Trafigura entity at a price equal to EUR 20 million in aggregate payable to the Company. As announced by the Company on 28 July 2022, this Put Option was exercised by the Company on 28 July 2022 (see Related Party disclosures - 1.2 below) and on 29 July 2022, the Company duly received the EUR 20 million Put Option price following such exercise. Reference is made in this respect to the related party disclosures in respect of the mandatory prepayment obligations and limited recourse provisions under the Limited Recourse Loan Facility (to the extent that these apply following the receipt of the proceeds of the exercise of the Put Option (see 1.5.4. and 1.5.5. below)).
c)The decision of the 9 December 2019 EGM not to continue the Company's activities resulted in the requirement for the Company to recognize a provision for discontinuation representing the estimated costs that the Company expects to incur before the completion of the liquidation. At 31 December 2023 the Company recognised a provision for discontinuation of EUR 9.4 million (31 December 2022: EUR 10.8 million) representing the estimated costs that the Company expects to incur before the completion of a liquidation process that is assumed to be finalised before the end of 2030 (31 December 2022: before the end of Q2 2029). Potential additional litigation may result in a further delay of this assumed date of completion of a liquidation process; the Company has at current no indication thereof.
The following legal and regulatory actions have been considered when determining the amount of the provision as at 31 December 2023. The EGM of 9 December 2019 and the order of the President of the Antwerp Enterprise Court of 26 June 2020 As described above, at 9 December 2019, an EGM was held to deliberate on the continuation of the Company's activities and a proposed capital decrease. The shareholders' meeting rejected the continuation of the Company's activities. The shareholders' meeting also rejected the proposed capital reduction, as a result of which it was not carried out. The Board of Directors of the Company had taken the necessary measures to prepare the necessary reports with its statutory auditor and had convened a new EGM to formally consider a proposal for liquidation. Such EGM was first scheduled to be held on 25 March 2020 but had to be postponed due to the Covid-19 outbreak and corresponding restrictions that had been introduced in Europe. The Company re-convened such EGM on 30 April 2020 for 2 June 2020 and, if the required attendance quorum would not be met, 30 June 2020.
Certain shareholders initiated summary proceedings before the court of Antwerp to request the court to order that the decision on the dissolution of the Company, following the 9 December 2019 EGM, be postponed (i) until three months after a final report will have been issued by a panel of experts whose appointment is requested in separate proceedings before the court, or, alternatively (ii) until three months after a final decision will have been rendered in the aforementioned proceedings regarding the appointment of a panel of experts. On 26 June 2020, the court of Antwerp dismissed the minority shareholders' claim for a postponement until three months after a final report will have been issued by a panel of experts whose appointment is requested. However, the court did accept their claim for a postponement of the decision on the dissolution of the Company until three months after a final decision (i.e. a decision that will have obtained "res judicata effect") will have been rendered in the proceedings regarding the appointment of a panel of experts. Consequently, in compliance with the 26 June 2020 court order, the (second) EGM planned for 30 June 2020 having the resolutions regarding the proposal for dissolution of the Company on the agenda was postponed. As announced on 14 February 2023, in light of the announcement in the press that certain shareholders of the Company would file a Supreme Court appeal against the judgment of the Antwerp Court of Appeal dated 17 November 2022 with respect to the claim for the appointment of a panel of experts (which appeal has meanwhile been
lodged and on the date of this report is still pending), the Company is of the opinion that it is not opportune to carry out its obligation to place the dissolution on the agenda pending the Supreme Court appeal. The Company thus announced that it will not take steps to convene a general meeting with dissolution as an agenda item (or take preparatory actions to that effect) until the Supreme Court has rendered a judgment in the aforementioned proceedings, and it will update the market by then.
The delayed decision on the proposal for dissolution of the Company and the appointment of a liquidator may negatively impact the Company's liquidity position as the Company continues to incur running costs and costs in respect of the legal proceedings mentioned above and below. If the appointment of the liquidator is further delayed beyond what is currently expected or not approved by the shareholders' meeting or if the costs are higher than currently expected, the Company may need to secure additional funding. There is a risk that such additional funding may not be available to the Company or may not be available at acceptable conditions.
Investigation by the FSMA
The management committee of the Belgian Financial Services and Markets Authority ("FSMA") decided in September 2019 to investigate the Company's policy regarding disclosure of information to the market. Initially, this investigation focused on the information disclosed on the commercial relationship of the Company with Trafigura.
In a press release dated 29 May 2020, the FSMA announced that the investigation would be expanded so as to also include information on the expected profit contribution and total costs for the Port Pirie smelter redevelopment in Australia and on the solvency and liquidity position of the Company at the end of 2018.
In a press release dated 25 July 2022, the FSMA outlined the state of affairs in the investigation. The FSMA announced that the investigations officer had drafted a provisional report covering the three elements of the investigation.
In a press release dated 30 September 2022, the FSMA announced that, after deliberating on the Investigations Officer's final report, the management committee of the FSMA had decided to initiate proceedings against Nyrstar that may result in the imposition of an administrative fine, as well as that it had forwarded the notification of the grievances to the chairman of the sanctions committee. The FSMA further reports that the management committee had also forwarded this notification to the public prosecutor of the Antwerp district. Finally, according to the press release, the management committee had asked the Investigations Officer for an additional report on the possible application of an administrative fine to each of the directors (or the permanent representatives of the directors) of Nyrstar who were in office at the time of the facts.
Nyrstar confirms that, on 30 September 2022, the management committee of the FSMA notified it of the grievances and provided it with the investigations officer's final investigation report. The Company believes that it has at all times disclosed the required information in accordance with the relevant financial regulations and laws and defends that position in the proceedings before the Sanctions Committee.
Nyrstar further learned in the press that the public prosecutor of the Antwerp district would have initiated an investigation in the autumn of 2022 following the notification by the FSMA. Besides what appears in the press, Nyrstar is not aware of the status of this investigation. Nyrstar will refrain from addressing the content of these ongoing sanction proceedings any further, given their confidential nature.
Summary proceedings relating to the appointment of a panel of experts
On 27 April 2020, a group of shareholders summoned the Company in summary proceedings before the President of the Antwerp Enterprise Court (Antwerp division). The claim of plaintiffs aimed at having a panel of experts appointed in accordance with Article 7:160 of the Belgian Companies and Associations Code. This procedure was initiated on 5 May 2020. The court hearing took place on 15 September 2020.
On 30 October 2020, the President of the Antwerp Enterprise Court (Antwerp division) issued an order in which she upheld the shareholders' claim. The court order included, but was not limited to, the following elements:
A panel of three experts was appointed to examine:
i.whether the transactions between the former Nyrstar Group and the Trafigura Group on and after 9 November 2015 were concluded in accordance with the "at arm's length" principle and at normal commercial conditions and, if not, to assess the direct and indirect damage suffered by Nyrstar as a result of violations of this principle;
ii.whether the conditions for the transfer of all rights under the agreements between Talvivaara Mining Company group and Nyrstar, from Nyrstar to Terrafame, Winttal Oy Ltd. and subsequently to Terrafame Mining, were market-conform and, if not, to assess the direct and indirect damage suffered by Nyrstar as a result of that transfer; and
iii.what caused the liquidity crisis, as well as whether it was necessary to conclude the binding term sheet, the TFFA and the Lock-up agreement, as well as to advise whether the terms and conditions of the aforementioned agreements were market-conform and, if not, to assess the damage suffered by Nyrstar by entering into those agreements.
The Company was condemned to advance the costs of the panel of experts.
The Company reviewed the court order together with its legal advisors and decided that lodging an appeal with the Antwerp Court of Appeal was appropriate and required in light of the Company's corporate interest. The Company has filed the application for appeal on 15 December 2020. On 3 March 2021, the original plaintiff shareholders summoned Trafigura PTE Ltd. and Trafigura Group PTE Ltd. to forcefully intervene in this appeal. In particular, they asked that the judgment to be delivered by the Court of Appeal be declared enforceable against and applicable to Trafigura PTE Ltd. and Trafigura Group PTE Ltd. Both the appeal by the Company and the forced intervention of Trafigura PTE Ltd. and Trafigura Group PTE Ltd. were heard at the hearing of 3 June 2021. On 2 September 2021, the court ordered the reopening of the debates to allow the parties to comment on (i) the third-party application order dated 2 July 2021 (infra), (ii) the memo and evidence submitted by the original plaintiff shareholders on 2 August 2021 in execution of the aforementioned third-party application order, (iii) the order of the President of the Antwerp Enterprise Court (Antwerp Division) of 29 June 2021 by which, in accordance with Article 973 of the Belgian Judicial Code, a number of incidents in relation to the expert investigation are settled, (iv) the documents relating to the general meeting of the Company held on 29 June 2021, and (v) the request for voluntary intervention in the
third-party application proceedings of 22 other shareholders of the Company. On 29 October 2021, those same 22 other shareholders of the Company submitted a request for voluntary intervention in these appeal proceedings.
On 4 February 2021, Trafigura PTE Ltd. and Trafigura Group PTE Ltd. filed a third-party application against the aforementioned decision of 30 October 2020. The Company and the original plaintiff shareholders were also involved in these proceedings. In this third-party application, Trafigura PTE Ltd. and Trafigura Group PTE Ltd. requested that the President of the Antwerp Enterprise Court (Antwerp division) revoke its decision of 30 October 2020 with immediate effect and terminate the expert investigation, also vis-à-vis the Company and the original plaintiffs. The third-party application was introduced in court on 26 March 2021, and was dealt with a first time at the hearing of 15 June 2021. In response, an interim judgment was issued on 2 July 2021. In this interim judgment, the President of the Antwerp Enterprise Court (Antwerp division) ordered the original plaintiff shareholders to produce to the court a full overview of their respective transactions in the Company's shares. Further, the President ordered that the aforementioned expert investigation be suspended until the verdict that would follow the hearing scheduled for 28 September 2021 in respect of the new evidence submitted. The suspension of the expert investigation aimed to give the plaintiff shareholders time to produce documentary proof of their shareholdings and transactions in the Company's shares and provided the parties, including the Company, the opportunity to debate the legal consequences of the new evidence, after which the court would take a decision. On 19 August 2021, 22 other shareholders of Nyrstar submitted a petition to voluntarily intervene in these third-party application proceedings. As mentioned, a second hearing in this procedure took place on 28 September 2021. On 9 November 2021, the President of the Antwerp Enterprise Court (Antwerp division) rendered a second judgment in these third-party application proceedings. In this decision, the President declared the third-party application proceedings of Trafigura PTE Ltd. and Trafigura Group PTE Ltd. well-founded and revoked the previous judgment of 30 October 2020 vis-à-vis Trafigura PTE Ltd., Trafigura Group PTE Ltd., the Company and the original claimant shareholders, thus revoking the appointment of the experts and halting the expert investigation. The costs to that date of the expert investigation were put by the President with the party that had borne them to date in accordance with that previous judgment, i.e. the Company. On 23 December 2021, the original plaintiff shareholders and the newly intervening shareholders lodged appeal against the aforementioned judgments of 2 July and 9 November 2021.
Both appeals (i.e. the appeal against the decision of 30 October 2020 and the appeal against the decisions of 2 July and 9 November 2021) were dealt with at the court hearing of 6 October 2022.
On 17 November 2022, the Antwerp court of appeals issued its judgment in these appeals. In this judgment, the court of appeals declared the appeal proceedings lodged by the claimant shareholders ill-founded and confirmed the judgment of 9 November 2021, thus ordering that the appointment of the panel of corporate law experts be revoked and the expert investigation halted. The court of appeals found that there were no indications that the interests of the Company would be seriously threatened, and hence that an expert investigation was not justified. The court of appeals also joined the proceedings regarding the Company's appeal against the judgment of 30 October 2020 and confirmed that such appeal no longer had any subject matter given the 17 November 2022 judgment. Finally, the court of appeals ordered the parties to bear their own costs, and ordered the claimant shareholders to repay 50% of the costs incurred by Nyrstar in the expert investigation.
On 10 February 2023, Nyrstar learnt through the press that the claimant shareholders would lodge an appeal with the Supreme Court against the aforementioned 17 November 2022 judgment. On 28 March 2023, the Supreme Court petition was served on Nyrstar. The case is currently pending before the Supreme Court and is scheduled to be dealt with at the hearing of 2 May 2024, unless any new procedural actions are introduced.
On 9 February 2021, Trafigura PTE Ltd. and Trafigura Group PTE Ltd. had submitted a request for suspension of the 30 October 2020 decision to the Attachment Judge of the Antwerp Court of First Instance (Antwerp Division). The Company and the original plaintiff shareholders were again involved in this procedure. Trafigura PTE Ltd. and Trafigura Group PTE Ltd. specifically requested that the execution of the aforementioned decision be immediately suspended until the delivery of a final judgment in the third-party application proceedings mentioned earlier. The suspension request was introduced in court on 1 April 2021, and was dealt with at the hearing of 24 June 2021. In a decision of 15 July 2021, the Attachment Judge ruled that a re-opening of the debates was required in light of the aforementioned judgment of the President of the Antwerp Enterprise Court (Antwerp division) of 2 July 2021 (in the third-party application proceedings). As a result, the suspension request was dealt with at the hearing of 28 October 2021, where it was again adjourned until the hearing of 2 December 2021. During said 2 December 2021 hearing, the case was put on hold for an indefinite period of time, given the aforementioned 9 November 2021 judgment by the President of the Antwerp Enterprise Court (Antwerp division) in the third-party application proceedings.
Proceedings on the merits against (amongst others) the Company and its directors
On Friday 29 May 2020, a group of shareholders of the Company summoned the Company, various directors and the Company's (former) statutory auditor, Deloitte Bedrijfsrevisoren CV ("Deloitte"), before the Antwerp Enterprise Court (Turnhout division). This writ of summons followed a notice of default received on 17 March 2020 by the directors and certain senior managers of the Company.
On Monday 9 November 2020, this group of shareholders issued a corrective writ of summons against the Company, various directors and Deloitte, which amended the writ of summons dated 29 May 2020 on certain points.
1.a minority claim on account of the Company against (amongst others) the current directors of the Company for alleged shortcomings in their management and breaches of the Belgian Companies Code and the Company's articles of association. This minority claim is a derivative claim, meaning that the proceeds will be paid to the Company (not the plaintiff shareholders). In particular, the plaintiffs request that the defendants are jointly and severally ordered to pay damages to the Company. The damages are estimated in the (corrective) writ of summons at a minimum of EUR 1.2 billion. Nyrstar has understood from other proceedings that the plaintiff shareholders currently estimate the alleged damages to be at least 2 EUR billion, but has not received a formal confirmation thereof;
2.a direct liability claim against, among others, the current directors of the Company for errors which (allegedly) caused individual damages to the plaintiffs. On this basis, the plaintiffs claim personal damages provisionally estimated at EUR 1;
3.a claim against the Company to reimburse any costs incurred by the plaintiffs which are not reimbursed by the other defendants. These proceedings were introduced in the court on 18 November 2020; however, they were sent to the docket at the introductory hearing (at the request of plaintiffs) pending the report of the panel of experts appointed by order of 30 October 2020 of the President of the
Antwerp Enterprise Court (Antwerp division) (see above under "Summary proceedings relating to the appointment of a panel of experts").
The Company formally contests the claims in the writ of summons and notes that it will firmly defend itself against the claims raised within the framework of these proceedings.
In addition, the Company learned that the same group of plaintiff shareholders has brought similar liability claims against certain former directors of the Company as well as certain companies of the Trafigura group. Initially, neither the Company nor its current directors were party to these proceedings. However, the Company has learned that the Antwerp Enterprise Court (Turnhout Division) has, by decision of 26 July 2022, joined the proceedings against the companies of the Trafigura group with the proceedings against the Company and its directors.
On Monday 27 February 2023, 13 new plaintiffs submitted a petition for voluntary intervention in these proceedings.
On 22 January 2024, Deloitte submitted a trial brief in these proceedings. In this brief, Deloitte demands that:
(i)the claims of all plaintiff shareholders are dismissed as inadmissible and at least ill-founded;
(ii)the plaintiff shareholders are condemned to pay the legal costs; and
(iii)in subordinate order: Nyrstar and its (current and former) directors involved in these proceedings are jointly and severally, in solidum or one in the absence of the other ordered to indemnify Deloitte for any convictions (including interests and costs) it would incur against the plaintiff shareholders.
No procedural timetable or hearing date has yet been determined.
On 11 March 2024, the plaintiff shareholders filed a petition for interim measures in the framework of these proceedings. They request the court to grant the following interim measures:
"the appointment of a provisional administrator in the Company, for a period of 12 months with the possibility of extension, at least until a decision with res judicata effect is rendered in the proceedings on the merits, with the assignment to provisionally take over all tasks of management and administration in the broadest sense;
"the suspension ex nunc of the enforceability of all, at least part of the obligations under the Limited Recourse Loan Facility concluded between the Company and NN2 Newco Limited, until a decision with res judicata effect is rendered in the proceedings on the merits and at least for the entire duration of the mandate of the provisional administrator or ad hoc trustee (see below);
"an order against, among others, the Company to produce a series of documents within a period of 48 hours from the verdict to be rendered, on a penalty fine of EUR 25.000 per day of delay.
In subordinate order, the plaintiff shareholders request the appointment of an ad hoc trustee in the Company with a specific mandate for a period of 12 months with possibility of extension, at least until a decision with res judicata effect is rendered in the proceedings on the merits.
The plaintiff shareholders also demand that the Company be ordered to advance the costs of the provisional administrator or ad hoc trustee.
The plaintiff shareholders request the court to refer the remainder of the case back to the docket.
The Company contests the allegations of the plaintiff shareholders and will defend its position in the court proceedings.
On 3 January 2023, a group of shareholders summoned the Company in summary proceedings before the President of the Antwerp Enterprise Court (Antwerp division). They requested (among others) (i) a prohibition for the Company to hold a general meeting with the dissolution of the Company on the agenda, (ii) the appointment of a provisional administrator or an ad hoc trustee and (iii) to order Nyrstar to join several claims brought by the plaintiff shareholders against Trafigura and/or associated persons in the proceedings on the merits (and to, at the very least as a precautionary measure, lodge these claims). By decision of 12 May 2023, the President dismissed the claims of the plaintiff shareholders. To date, this group of shareholders has not taken any further steps regarding these proceedings.
The Company learned that criminal complaints have been filed by shareholders. The Company shall cooperate with the judicial investigation.
In estimating the provision for discontinuation of EUR 9.4 million recognised at 31 December 2023 and taking into account the (pending) legal proceedings referred to above (and on the basis of a reasonable expectation as to the timing of Belgian court proceedings), in calculating the provision for discontinuation, the Company assumes the liquidation process to complete approximately by the end of 2030, i.e. within approximately six and half years after the release of the 31 December 2023 financial statements. The amount of the provision is based on the estimated operating costs to be incurred before and during the liquidation process. These costs include costs of the liquidator, legal, accounting and audit costs, listing fees and other operating costs. As at 31 December 2023 (and as at 31 December 2022), the Company has excluded from the calculation of the provision the EUR 2.4 million estimated costs of the panel of experts appointed by the President of the Antwerp Enterprise Court, that were previously included in the calculation of the provision, given that this expert investigation has been revoked and halted as a consequence of the judgment of 9 November 2021 of the President of the Antwerp Enterprise Court (Antwerp division) and the appeal by the claimant shareholders was found ill-founded by the Antwerp court of appeals on 17 November 2022. The Company does not expect that these costs will be incurred by the Company even though the claimant shareholders can, and have, appealed the verdict of the Antwerp court of appeals with the Belgian Supreme Court. The estimated amount of the provision assumes a stable run-rate of the cost of the liquidator and other costs to be incurred by the Company over the period until the completion of the liquidation process.
The estimated amount of the provision excludes any costs that the Company may incur in relation to the defense in the legal proceedings
referred to above for which the Company's Directors & Officers ("D&O") insurer has at current confirmed to indemnify the Company for its fees, costs and expenses incurred. The D&O insurer has at current only confirmed to indemnify the Company for its fees, costs and expenses incurred in respect of:
(i)its counsel for assisting with the response to the notice of default dated 17 March 2020, and representing the Company in the proceedings issued on 29 May 2020;
(ii)its counsel for representing the Company in the interlocutory (expert) proceedings issued on 27 April 2020, as well as the appeal lodged by the Company on 15 December 2020 against the 30 October 2020 court order appointing an expert panel in the sense of Article 7:160 BCCA (and not, for the avoidance of doubt, the third party application initiated by Trafigura PTE Ltd and Trafigura Group PTE Ltd against the 30 October 2020 court order and the appeal against the court orders of 2 July and 9 November 2021), and the Supreme Court appeal; (iii)its counsel for representing the Company in the (now halted) expert investigation ordered by the aforementioned 30 October 2020 court order;
(iv)the party-appointed experts the Company has retained in order to research the claims made in the proceedings mentioned above as well as to assist the Company in the expert investigation mentioned above; and
(v)its counsel for representing the Company regarding the FSMA investigation and the experts retained by the Company in respect of its defense, for up to 80% of the work done as of 6 October 2022;
(vi)its counsel for representing the Company in the summary proceedings for interim measures initiated by certain shareholders on 3 January 2023.
However, the D&O insurer has refused coverage of the fees, costs and expenses of the court-appointed experts (as referred to above) and, based on the court order of 30 October 2020 (against which the Company lodged appeal and against which Trafigura PTE Ltd. and Trafigura Group PTE Ltd. lodged a third-party application, and which was as a result of the latter application revoked by the judgment of 9 November 2021 of the President of the Antwerp Enterprise Court (Antwerp division)), which need to be covered by the Company. The actual amount of these fees, costs and expenses depends on whether a court of appeal will decide to re-open the expert investigation (e.g., as a possible result of the appeal with the Supreme Court), the length of the ordered investigation, the length of the legal proceedings referred to above, the level of involvement of the Company and any other elements.
Should the liquidation process take longer than expected, the estimated costs to be incurred by the Company before the completion of the liquidation would be higher. Assuming the liquidation is in that case completed by the end of 2032, the Company estimates the costs incurred during the liquidation process would increase to EUR 11.7 million. These additional costs in excess of the provision of EUR 9.4 million recognised at 31 December 2023 would further decrease the equity of the Company subsequent to 31 December 2023. If there are any additional costs or if the costs related to one or more legal proceedings noted above would not be covered by the Company's D&O insurance, it may require the Company to obtain additional funding. In case the Company is unable to obtain such additional funding, the liquidation may not be a solvent liquidation.
The Company has recognised the ongoing operating costs that it incurred during the year ended 31 December 2023 as Services and other goods (Code 61). During the year ended 31 December 2023, the Company has utilised the provision for discontinuation of EUR 3,022,718, primarily to offset the ongoing operating costs. The utilisation of the provision is recognised in Non-recurring operating income (Code 76A) net of the additions to the provision for discontinuation of EUR 1,579,518.
d)As at 31 December 2023, based on the information available to the Company, the Company has been fully released from all contingent liabilities previously provided or irrevocably promised by the Company for debts and commitments of third parties. The Company is fully indemnified in relation to any liability that may arise in this respect (see "Related party disclosures").
The Company has assessed the potential impact of the war in Ukraine on the recognition and measurement of the Company's assets and liabilities as at 31 December 2023. Following the exercise of the Put Option and the receipt of the proceeds of the exercise of the Put Option, the Company's main assets are cash and cash term deposits. In the Company's view, there are no potential significant impacts of the war in Ukraine on the measurement of the Company's assets and liabilities at 31 December 2023.
At 9 December 2019, an EGM of the Company was held to deliberate on the continuation of the Company's activities and a proposed capital decrease. The shareholders' meeting rejected the continuation of the Company's activities. As the result of a decision of 26 June 2020 of the President of the Antwerp Enterprise Court (Antwerp division), given at the request of a group of shareholders, the Company was prohibited from holding a general meeting with the dissolution of the Company on the agenda until three months after a final decision on the appointment of a panel of experts would have obtained res judicata effect. As set out above, as announced on 14 February 2023, in light of the announcement in the press that certain shareholders of the Company would file a Supreme Court appeal against the judgment of the Antwerp Court of Appeal dated 17 November 2022 with respect to the claim for the appointment of a panel of experts (which appeal has meanwhile been lodged and on the date of this report is still pending), the Company is of the opinion that it is not opportune to carry out its obligation to place the dissolution on the agenda pending the Supreme Court appeal. The Company thus announced that it will not take steps to convene a general meeting with dissolution as an agenda item (or take preparatory actions to that effect) until the Supreme Court has rendered a judgment in the aforementioned proceedings, and it will update the market by then. As such, these 31 December 2023 financial statements of the Company have been prepared on a discontinuity basis.
Under article 3:23 of the Belgian Code of Companies and Associations, a parent company that controls one or more subsidiaries is required to prepare consolidated financial statements, unless such subsidiaries are, in view of the consolidated assets, the consolidated financial position or the consolidated results, individually and together, only of a negligible significance. Given that, as at 31 December 2023, the Company did not control any significant subsidiary, the Company was not required to prepare consolidated financial statements for the year ended 31 December 2023. In accordance with article 12, §3, final paragraph, of the Royal Decree of 14 November 2007, the Company has prepared the 31 December 2023 standalone financial statements in accordance with Belgian GAAP.
At the date of authorisation of the 31 December 2023 financial statements, the Company has assessed that, taking into account its available cash, cash equivalents and its cash flow projections for the next 12 months from the authorisation by the Board of Directors of the 31 December 2023 financial statements, it has sufficient liquidity to meet its present obligations and cover working capital needs. The forecast available liquidity of the Company comprises cash and cash term deposits of EUR 14.9 million as of 31 December 2023 and is dependent on various matters including the possible appointment of a liquidator and his next steps, the existence and extent of the legal claims against the Company which could require funding of these legal proceedings and other matters not currently foreseen as described in section d) of the valuation rules above. As stated above, if the appointment of the liquidator is further delayed or not approved by the shareholders' meeting or if the costs are higher than currently expected, the Company may need to secure additional funding. There is a risk that such additional funding may not be available to the Company or may not be available at acceptable conditions. Reference is also made to the related party disclosures in respect of the mandatory prepayment obligations and limited recourse provisions under the Limited Recourse Loan Facility (to the extent that these apply following the receipt of the proceeds of the exercise of the Put Option (see 1.5.4. and 1.5.5. below)).
In October 2018, the former Nyrstar group initiated a review of its capital structure (the "Capital Structure Review") in response to the challenging financial and operating conditions being faced by the Nyrstar group. The Capital Structure Review identified a very substantial additional funding requirement that the Nyrstar group was unable to meet without a material reduction of its indebtedness. As a consequence, the Capital Structure Review necessitated negotiations between the Nyrstar group's financial creditors that ultimately resulted in the restructuring of the Nyrstar group, which became effective on 31 July 2019 (the "Restructuring"). As a result of the Restructuring, Trafigura Group Pte. Ltd., via its indirect 98% ownership of the new holding company of NN2, became the ultimate parent company of the former (direct and indirect) subsidiaries of the Company (the "Operating Group"), with the remaining 2% stake in NN2 (and thereby the Operating Group) then being owned by the Company (though see 1.2 below for details of the exercise of the Put Option by the Company on 28 July 2022).
The agreements with Trafigura to which the Company is currently a party are discussed in further detail below.
The lock-up agreement ("Lock Up Agreement") entered into on 14 April 2019 between, among others, the Company and representatives of its key financial creditor groups, envisaged that the Company, Trafigura Pte Ltd ("Trafigura") and Nyrstar Holdings Plc (formerly known as Nyrstar Holdings Limited, "Nyrstar Holdings"), a Trafigura special-purpose vehicle incorporated, amongst other things, for the purpose of implementing the Restructuring) would enter into a deed confirming their agreement in respect of (i) certain steps necessary for the implementation of the restructuring as envisaged in the Lock Up Agreement and (ii) the terms of the ongoing relationship between the Company and the Trafigura group (the "NNV-Trafigura Deed"). The NNV-Trafigura Deed was duly executed on 19 June 2019.
Certain key terms of the NNV-Trafigura Deed, namely those governing the distributions policy, drag / tag rights and change of control in respect of NN2, have previously been described in the Company's related party disclosures. However, following the exercise of the Put Option (on which, see 1.2 below for more details) and the Company ceasing to be a shareholder of NN2, these provisions of the NNV-Trafigura Deed are no longer relevant / no longer apply.
Under the provisions of the NNV-Trafigura Deed that do continue notwithstanding the exercise of the Put Option and the Company ceasing to be a shareholder of NN2, the Company continues to benefit from a right (subject to compliance with applicable law and any relevant confidentiality obligations) to make reasonable requests of Trafigura to procure that the Company is provided with financial or other information in relation to the Operating Group (or any member of it).
Pursuant to the NNV-Trafigura Deed, the Company and Trafigura also agreed that Trafigura would grant to the Company an option to require a Trafigura entity to purchase the Company's entire interest in NN2. The terms of this option are set out in a separate deed, dated 25 June 2019, between the Company, Trafigura and Nyrstar Holdings (the "Put Option Deed"). Under the terms of the Put Option Deed, the Company could put all (but not only a part) of its 2% holding in NN2 to a Trafigura entity at a price equal to EUR 20 million (the "Put
Option"). Reference is made in this respect to the related party disclosures in respect of the mandatory prepayment obligations and limited recourse provisions under the Limited Recourse Loan Facility (to the extent that these apply following the receipt of the proceeds of the exercise of the Put Option (see 1.5.4. and 1.5.5. below)). The Put Option was exercisable by the Company until 31 July 2022, subject to limited triggers which would have allowed earlier termination of the Put Option before 31 July 2022.
On 18 November 2021, the Company announced that it had appointed Moore Corporate Finance to prepare an independent expert's opinion for the independent directors of the Company ("Committee of Independent Directors"), in the framework of Article 7:97 of the Belgian Code of Companies and Associations. The independent expert's opinion was to advise the Committee of Independent Directors in examining the benefit to the Company, taking all relevant circumstances into account, of the exercise or non-exercise of the Put Option that the Company had in relation to its entire 2% investment in NN2.
On 28 July 2022, the Company publicly announced that the Board had completed its detailed review process in respect of the decision whether or not to exercise the Put Option related to its entire 2% shareholding in NN2. Considering the independent expert report prepared by Moore Corporate Finance, which valued the 2% shareholding in NN2 in a range of EUR 0 million to EUR 3.4 million, the opinion of the independent directors of the Company, questions and comments raised by certain minority shareholders and other information made available to it, the Board decided that it was in the corporate benefit of the Company to exercise the Put Option. On 28 July 2022, the Company duly gave notice to Nyrstar Holdings Plc and to Trafigura Pte Ltd. that it exercised the Put Option in accordance with the terms of the Put Option Deed. The Company received the proceeds from the exercise of the Put Option on 29 July 2022. Documentation in respect of the Company's decision to exercise the Put Option was published on the Company's website nyrstarnv.be on 28 July 2022 and remains available there as at the date of this report.
As stated above, prior to the effective date of the Restructuring which was 31 July 2019 (the "Restructuring Effective Date"), the Company was the ultimate parent company of the Nyrstar group, and had previously issued various parent company guarantees (the "PCGs") in respect of the obligations of its subsidiaries, including, but not limited to, two PCGs granted in respect of the primary financial obligations of the Company's indirect subsidiary at that time, Nyrstar Sales & Marketing AG ("NSM"), to Trafigura, namely under the USD 650 million Trade Finance Framework Agreement ("TFFA") and the USD 250 million Bridge Finance Facility Agreement ("BFFA") (the "Trafigura PCGs"). The Trafigura PCGs, as well as all other security and / or guarantees provided to Trafigura by the Operating Group in respect of the TFFA and BFFA, were released in full on the Restructuring Effective Date.
1.4. The Company's release from parent company guarantees in favour of third-parties and the Company's rights to indemnification by NN2 under the NNV-NN2 SPA
Prior to, and as part of the implementation of, the Restructuring, the Company entered into an agreement for the sale and transfer by the Company of substantially all of its assets including 100% of its shareholding in Nyrstar Netherlands (Holdings) BV and also its holdings (direct and indirect) in its subsidiaries, but excluding its shares in NN1, to NN2 (the "NNV-NN2 SPA"). Under the NNV-NN2 SPA, the Company benefits from contractual agreements with NN2 and Trafigura in respect of its release from, or indemnification for, liabilities for existing financial indebtedness and obligations owed to third parties in respect of financial, commercial or other obligations of the then current members of the Operating Group (the "PCGs"), such that those third parties should no longer have recourse to the Company. The release and / or indemnification obligations of NN2 from which the Company benefits can be summarised as follows.
-Release of PCGs and general indemnity: The NNV-NN2 SPA includes a commitment by NN2 to use reasonable endeavors to procure the release of obligations owed by the Company under third-party PCGs. This obligation is combined with an obligation on NN2 to indemnify the Company, to the extent such PCGs are not released, for any and all liabilities in relation to such PCGs in respect of the failure by the applicable member of the Operating Group to comply fully with its principal obligations.
-Indemnity for specified historic liabilities: Further, the NNV-NN2 SPA also contains an obligation on NN2 to indemnify the Company, to the extent not covered by the release and/or indemnification of PCGs mentioned above, in respect of certain specified liabilities, including certain liabilities arising in relation to certain historic disposals by the former Nyrstar group and/or from certain historic mine closures, which are specified in a schedule to the NNV-NN2 SPA.
-Limitation on recourse to the Company of former subsidiaries: To limit and release further any financial obligations on the Company, the NNV-NN2 SPA obliges NN2 to procure that, and the NNV-Trafigura Deed obliges Trafigura to procure that no former subsidiaries of the Company will make any demands for payment from the Company except (i) under the Limited Recourse Loan Facility (as defined below), (ii) as otherwise agreed following the completion of the Restructuring; or (iii) to the extent that the Company has sufficient funds available (excluding any dividends or sale proceeds in respect of the Company's (now sold) direct 2% shareholding in NN2).
On 23 July 2019, the Company entered into a EUR 13.5 million committed, limited recourse, loan facility (the "Limited Recourse Loan Facility") provided to it by NN2 (as "Lender"). The key terms of the Limited Recourse Loan Facility are described below. The Limited Recourse Loan Facility is made available in two separate tranches: (i) up to EUR 8.5 million to be applied towards the Company's ongoing ordinary course operating activities ("Facility A"); and (ii) up to EUR 5 million intended for the payment of certain costs related to litigation defense ("Facility B"). No security, collateral or guarantees have been granted in respect of the Company's obligations under the Limited Recourse Loan Facility.
As at 31 December 2023, the Company owed EUR 6.3 million (31 December 2022: EUR 6.2 million) under Facility A. Facility A can be used by the Company to cover day-to-day operating costs, including, without limitation, reasonable director and employee costs, D&O insurance premium (to the extent not paid prior to the Restructuring Effective Date), audit fees, legal costs (except those relating to litigation or other actual or threatened proceedings against the Company, which should be funded from Facility B (defined below)), listing fees and investor relations costs. The funding under Facility A is provided to the Company based on the quarterly cash flow forecast prepared by the Company and provided to Trafigura as a condition of the funding. The total quantum of funds to be made available under Facility A was agreed based on the Company's forecast operating costs for a five-year period following the completion of the Restructuring, taking into account the ongoing operational services provided to the Company by NN2, as agreed in the NNV-NN2 SPA, for a period of approximately three years from the Restructuring Effective Date (the "Ongoing Services").
The Ongoing Services to be provided by NN2 to the Company include finance, tax, corporate counsel, IT and administration services. The provision of the Ongoing Services to the Company was intended to reduce the Company's operating costs in the period following the Restructuring Effective Date. It is noted here that, in accordance with the terms of the NNV-NN2 SPA, the period for the provision of the
Ongoing Services to the Company expired upon the Company's receipt of the proceeds from the exercise of the Put Option.
As at 31 December 2023, the Company had drawn EUR 3.7 million (31 December 2022: EUR 3.7 million) under Facility B. Subject to the restrictions detailed below, Facility B can be applied by the Company towards payment or reimbursement of costs in respect of any litigation, proceeding, action or claims (including tax claims) made, asserted or threatened against the Company, NN1 or any of their current or former directors or officers (each being a "Claim").
Under Facility A, subject to the terms of utilisation (on which see more below), the Company could borrow up to EUR 7.3 million before 31 July 2023 and thereafter can borrow up to a further EUR 1.2 million annually until 2024. Funding under Facility B can be drawn based on costs incurred in respect of any litigation, proceeding, action or claims (subject to the terms of utilisation and other restrictions detailed below, and on the delivery of an invoice for such costs). Utilisation of each Facility is subject to various conditions (on which see below), and is limited to a maximum of three drawings per financial quarter per Facility (excluding any PIK Loans (defined below)). As at the date of this report, the Company has drawn EUR 6.4 million under Facility A and EUR 3.8 million under Facility B.
As a result of the exercise of the Put Option and the Company ceasing to be a shareholder of NN2, the "NNV Exit Date" (as defined in the Limited Recourse Loan Facility) has occurred. The NNV Exit Date is specified as an Event of Default (as defined) under the Limited Recourse Loan Facility, which gives the NN2 (as Lender) the right to cancel (by notice to the Company) the whole or any part of the Lenders' remaining commitments under the Limited Recourse Loan Facility. As at the date of this report, NN2 has not exercised such right.
However, each utilisation request under the Limited Recourse Loan Facility must (unless otherwise agreed by the Lender) be accompanied by a certificate signed by a director stating, among other things, that (in short) the Company's "Available Cash" (as defined therein) is not sufficient to meet the anticipated costs and liabilities for which the relevant utilisation is intended. Given the Company's receipt of EUR 20 million from the exercise of the Put Option in July 2022, it is not currently envisaged that the Company would be able to make any further valid utilisation requests under the Limited Recourse Loan Facility.
The rate of interest on amounts outstanding under the Limited Recourse Loan Facility is the aggregate of EURIBOR plus a margin of 0.5% per annum. It shall be payable within 10 business days of the anniversary of the date on which such amount was made available, provided that such interest will be capitalised if it has accrued for a period of one year or more and the Company has given a notice in the form prescribed by the Limited Recourse Loan Facility. Any interest which is capitalised shall be treated as a new loan (a "PIK Loan") under the relevant Facility. Any PIK Loan shall itself accrue interest, and that interest may also be capitalised. No payments of interest have been made by the Company as all payable interest until 31 December 2023 of EUR 327k has been capitalised into a new PIK Loan. The interest charges on the Limited Recourse Loan Facility expensed in the Profit and Loss Account in the year ended 31 December 2023 were EUR 368k.
The Company must not use any amount borrowed under either Facility A or Facility B for funding (directly or indirectly) any of the costs related to asserting or bringing or assisting in the pursuit of claims (including any counterclaim or defense) against Trafigura, other members of the Trafigura group, NN2 and / or any Replacement Holdco, and / or any other member of the Operating Group), against any of such entities' current or former directors, officers, or advisers, against any creditor in respect of such entities (other than with the consent of NN2, such consent not to be unreasonably withheld or delayed) or in connection with any challenge to the Restructuring, including in relation to the TFFA and the BFFA or any other document contemplated by the Restructuring Implementation Deed.
Excess Cash: the provisions of the Limited Recourse Loan Facility that relate to mandatory prepayment out of "Excess Cash", and which were described in the version of this disclosure contained in previous such reports by the Company, have ceased to apply as a result of the Company ceasing to be a shareholder of NN2 and having received the proceeds of the exercise of the Put Option (such proceeds constituting "Disposal Proceeds" for the purposes of the Limited Recourse Loan Facility).
Disposals: Immediately upon receipt of any Disposal Proceeds, and subject to the limited recourse provisions described below (see in particular at 1.5.5.), the Company shall procure that these shall be applied first to prepay any amount outstanding under Facility B (being the litigation tranche), and secondly, if (i) any Disposal Proceeds remain after any required prepayment of Facility B, and (ii) the aggregate amount of all amounts outstanding under Facility A (being the operational costs tranche) exceeds EUR 5 million, to prepay such Facility A amounts to or towards an aggregate amount of EUR 5 million.
Distributions: The Company shall ensure that, if any distribution is paid to the Company's shareholders on or after the NNV Exit Date, an amount equal to that distribution is applied to repay or prepay the amount outstanding under Facility A before or simultaneously with such distribution.
The Company has also agreed that, if it receives any amounts from costs awards, damages awards and / or any other recovery from any counterparty to a Claim (as defined above) (such amounts constituting "Claim Proceeds"), then such Claim Proceeds must be used immediately to repay or prepay any amounts outstanding under Facility B.
Additionally, there are customary provisions that require mandatory prepayment of amounts outstanding under either or both Facility A and B in the case of certain events of default that allow for acceleration by the Lender.
However, in accordance with "limited recourse" provisions of the Limited Recourse Loan Facility (as detailed further at 1.5.5. below), NN2's recourse to the Company in respect of repayment of funds drawn or any other obligation thereunder is limited to the Company's Net Assets (as defined in the Limited Recourse Loan Facility, and as described below), if any.
As mentioned above, the recourse of NN2 as Lender under the Limited Recourse Loan Facility in respect of repayment thereof or any other obligation of the Company thereunder is limited to the "Company Net Assets", being the assets (including all present and future properties, revenues and rights of every description) of the Company (other than assets held or received on trust for a person which is not a member of the Company or its subsidiaries) having satisfied or provided for its "Liabilities" (meaning all present or future liabilities and
obligations, both actual and contingent and whether incurred solely or jointly or as principal or surety or in any other capacity), except for Liabilities of the Company under the Limited Recourse Loan Facility and related finance documents, which shall be disregarded for this purpose.
Further, to the extent that the Company Net Assets are insufficient to discharge the Company's obligations under the Limited Recourse Loan Facility, such obligations shall be deemed to be limited to the amount of the Company Net Assets, and the Lender shall not be entitled to make a claim and shall have no further recourse against the Company and the Company shall have no liability to pay or otherwise.
All actual, contingent and prospective liabilities would need to be factored in when calculating the Company Net Asset position. The Company determined at the time of the exercise of the Put Option on 28 July 2022 and as at 31 December 2023, that it is in the corporate benefit of the Company that, for the purposes of the mandatory prepayment, these liabilities are calculated on a worst-case scenario basis, and not (i) in accordance with IFRS or Belgian GAAP, nor (ii) based upon the Company's assessment of the likelihood of such contingent or prospective liabilities eventually materialising. Based on the Company's estimates, the Company has determined that the Company Net Assets (as defined under the Limited Recourse Loan Facility) are negative even taking into account the receipt of the proceeds of the Put Option, and that currently no repayments of the LRLF are necessary. The Company will, however, continue to monitor the development of its Company Net Asset position until the completion of the liquidation process, to consider whether any repayment of the LRLF needs to be made.
However, this limitation on NN2's recourse against the Company shall not apply to the extent that the value of the Company Net Assets is impaired, or NN2 suffers loss as a result of any breach by the Company of any provision of the Limited Recourse Loan Facility (or any related finance document) other than the repeating representations / warranties thereunder or the provisions requiring payment of interest / fees or repayment / prepayment of principal thereunder.
1.5.6. Information, consultation and litigation strategy undertakings
So long as any amount is outstanding under the Limited Recourse Loan Facility or the Lender's commitment thereunder is still in force, if any Claim arises as a result of which the Company reasonably anticipates that it may make a utilisation under Facility B, the Company must give notice to the Lender and Trafigura of the Claim. The Company shall:
-promptly notify NN2 and Trafigura of the Claim;
-subject to compliance with applicable law or confidentiality obligations to third parties, make available to NN2 and Trafigura all information in its possession and control as reasonably requested by NN2 or Trafigura in connection with assessing, contesting, disputing, defending, appealing or compromising the Claim, provided that NN2 and Trafigura shall maintain confidentiality and/or privilege with regard to such information;
-keep NN2 and Trafigura informed of the progress / developments in respect of the Claim, and promptly provide any correspondence or other information received in connection with the Claim;
-consult and take into account the views of NN2 and Trafigura as to the applicable legal advisors that will represent the Company, NN1, or the applicable directors or officers. NNV shall also procure that such legal advisors provide fee estimates as requested by NN2 or Trafigura;
-consult with and take into account the views of NN2 and Trafigura in relation to the conduct of the defense / negotiations / settlements in respect of the Claim; and
-whilst any amount is outstanding under Facility B in relation to a civil Claim, not make any admission of Liability, agreement, settlement or compromise in relation to that Claim without the prior written approval of Trafigura.
The Company must also consult with Trafigura prior to taking any action relating to insolvency or bankruptcy proceedings, including under Book XX of the Belgian Code of Economic Law.
The Company is also obliged to provide NN2 with certain financial information, including quarterly cashflow forecasts (and any revisions thereto required under the terms of the Limited Recourse Loan Facility), half-yearly financial statements and audited annual financial statements, drawn up on a consolidated basis (to the extent the Company has subsidiaries) and in accordance with the accounting principles agreed under the terms of the Limited Recourse Loan Facility.
At the completion of the Restructuring at 31 July 2019, the "Relationship Agreement" between Trafigura Group Pte Ltd and the Company (dated 9 November 2015) was terminated. The Relationship Agreement governed the relationship between the Company (and the broader Nyrstar group) and Trafigura Group Pte. Ltd. and its affiliated persons between its execution on 9 November 2015 and the completion of the Restructuring on 31 July 2019.
Other than as described in these disclosures, the Company has not entered into any commercial or other transactions with Trafigura in the year ended 31 December 2023.
Until 31 July 2019, the Company was the holding company of the Nyrstar group (consisting of the Company and its former subsidiaries). At 31 July 2019, when the Restructuring of the Nyrstar group was finalised, the Company was released of liabilities for existing financial indebtedness and obligations owed under parent company guarantees of commercial or other obligations of the current members of the Operating Group (all former subsidiaries of the Nyrstar group excluding NN1) (or indemnified by NN2 to the extent such guarantee liabilities are not released). As at 31 December 2023, based on the information available to the Company, the Company has been fully released from all contingent liabilities previously provided or irrevocably promised by the Company for debts and commitments of third parties. The Company is fully indemnified in relation to any liability that may arise in this respect (see "Related party disclosures").
In addition to the legal and regulatory claims and proceedings disclosed above, the Company is subject to risks related to tax matters as
the possible tax audits of certain fiscal years are not yet complete. Although the Company cannot estimate the risk related to these possible tax audits as remote, it currently does not consider it probable that the outcome of these possible tax audits will have significant impact on the financial position of the Company.
The Company has concluded that no additional provision is required at this time in relation to pending or potential tax reviews and that it is currently unable to quantify the potential risks, but it continues to monitor and assess the situation.
Numbers of the joint industrial committees competent for the company: 224
| During the period | Codes | Total | 1. Men | 2. Women |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Average number of employees | ||||
| Full-time | 1001 | |||
| Part-time | 1002 | |||
| Total in full-time equivalents (FTE) | 1003 | |||
| Number of actual hours worked | ||||
| Full-time | 1011 | |||
| Part-time | 1012 | |||
| Total | 1013 | |||
| Personnel costs | ||||
| Full-time | 1021 | |||
| Part-time | 1022 | |||
| Total | 1023 | |||
| Benefits in addition to wages | 1033 |
| During the preceding period | Codes | P. Total | 1P. Men | 2P. Women |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Average number of employees in FTE | 1003 | |||
| Number of actual hours worked | 1013 | |||
| Personnel costs | 1023 | |||
| Benefits in addition to wages | 1033 | |||
| Codes | 1. Full-time | 2. Part-time | 3. Total in full-time equivalents |
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| At the closing date of the period | ||||
| Number of employees | 105 | |||
| By nature of the employment contract | ||||
| Contract for an indefinite period | 110 | |||
| Contract for a definite period | 111 | |||
| Contract for the execution of a specifically assigned work | 112 | |||
| Replacement contract | 113 | |||
| According to gender and study level | ||||
| Men | 120 | |||
| primary education | 1200 | |||
| secondary education | 1201 | |||
| higher non-university education | 1202 | |||
| university education | 1203 | |||
| Women | 121 | |||
| primary education | 1210 | |||
| secondary education | 1211 | |||
| higher non-university education | 1212 | |||
| university education | 1213 | |||
| By professional category | ||||
| Management staff | 130 | |||
| Salaried employees | 134 | |||
| Hourly employees | 132 | |||
| Other | 133 |
| During the period | ||
|---|---|---|
| ------------------- | -- | -- |
Average number of persons employed Number of actual hours worked Costs to the company
| Codes | 1. Hired temporary staff |
2. Hired temporary staff and personnel placed at the company's disposal |
|---|---|---|
| 150 | ||
| 151 | ||
| 152 |
| By nature of the employment contract | ||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Contract for an indefinite period | ||||||
| Contract for a definite period | ||||||
| Contract for the execution of a specifically assigned work | ||||||
| Replacement contract | ||||||
| By reason of termination of contract | ||||||
| Retirement | ||||||
| Unemployment with extra allowance from enterprise | ||||||
| Dismissal | ||||||
| Other reason | ||||||
| Of which: | the number of persons who continue to render services to the company at least half-time on a self-employment basis |
general personnel register during the period
| 211 212 213 |
||
|---|---|---|
| equivalents | ||
| 305 | ||
| 310 | ||
| 311 | ||
| 312 | ||
| 313 | ||
| 340 | ||
| 341 | ||
| 342 | ||
| 343 | ||
| 350 |
| Total of initiatives of formal professional training at the expense of the employer |
Men | Codes | Women | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Number of employees involved | 5811 | |||
| Number of actual training hours | 5812 | |||
| Net costs for the company | 5813 | |||
| of which gross costs directly linked to training | 58131 | |||
| of which contributions paid and payments to collective funds | 58132 | |||
| of which grants and other financial advantages received (to deduct) | 58133 | |||
| Total of initiatives of less formal or informal professional training at the expense of the employer |
||||
| Number of employees involved | 5831 | |||
| Number of actual training hours | 5832 | |||
| Net costs for the company | 5833 | |||
| Total of initial initiatives of professional training at the expense of the employer |
||||
| Number of employees involved | 5841 | 5851 | ||
| Number of actual training hours | 5842 | 5852 | ||
| Net costs for the company | 5843 | 5853 |

T : +32 (0)2 778 01 00 www.bdo.be
The Corporate Village - Elsinore Building Da Vincilaan 9, box E6 B-1935 Zaventem
NYRSTAR NV
Statutory auditor's report to the general meeting for the year ended 31 December 2023
Free translation
In the context of the statutory audit of the annual accounts of Nyrstar NV ("the Company"), we hereby present our statutory auditor's report. It includes our report of the annual accounts and the other legal and regulatory requirements. This report is an integrated whole and is indivisible.
We have been appointed as statutory auditor by the general meeting of 27 June 2023, following the proposal formulated by the administrative body issued upon recommendation of the Audit Committee. Our statutory auditor's mandate expires on the date of the general meeting deliberating on the annual accounts closed on 31 December 2025. We have performed the statutory audit of the annual accounts of the Company for four consecutive years.
We have audited the annual accounts of the Company, which comprise the balance sheet as at 31 December 2023, the profit and loss account for the year then ended and the notes to the annual accounts, characterised by a balance sheet total of 16.211.967 EUR and a profit and loss account showing a loss for the year of 1.463.565 EUR.
In our opinion, the annual accounts give a true and fair view of the Company's net equity and financial position as at 31 December 2023, as well as of its results for the year then ended, in accordance with the financial reporting framework applicable in Belgium.
We conducted our audit in accordance with International Standards on Auditing (ISAs) as applicable in Belgium. Our responsibilities under those standards are further described in the 'Statutory auditor's responsibilities for the audit of the annual accounts' section in this report. We have complied with all the ethical requirements that are relevant to the audit of annual accounts in Belgium, including those concerning independence.
We have obtained from the administrative body and the officials of the Company the explanations and information necessary for performing our audit.
We believe that the audit evidence we have obtained is sufficient and appropriate to provide a basis for our opinion.
BDO Bedrijfsrevisoren - BDO Réviseurs d'Entreprises BV/SRL, a company under Belgian law in the form of a private limited liability company, is a member of BDO International Limited, a UK company limited by guarantee, and forms part of the international BDO network of independent member firms.
BDO is the brand name for the BDO network and for each of the BDO Member Firms.

Without modifying our opinion, we draw attention to F-cap 6.20 (section "Discontinuity") of the annual accounts, where the Company discloses that the annual accounts have been prepared on a discontinuity basis and provides information on its liquidity position.
Without modifying our opinion, we draw attention to note F-cap 6.19 and F-cap 6.20 of the annual accounts, which include a detailed description of significant ongoing legal proceedings and a procedure with the regulator (FSMA) in which the Company and some of its directors are involved.
Key audit matters are those matters that, in our professional judgment, were of most significance in our audit of the annual accounts of the current year. These matters were addressed in the context of our audit of the annual accounts as a whole, and in forming our opinion thereon, and we do not provide a separate opinion on these matters.
Following the decision of the 9 December 2019 extraordinary shareholders' meeting to reject the continuation of the company's activities, the Company recognized a provision representing the estimated costs that the company expects to incur until the end of the liquidation period, amounting to 9,4 million EUR (10,8 million EUR as per 31 December 2022). We consider this provision as a key audit
matter since it requires significant judgment and estimates of the Company, both with respect to the expected future costs as well as the expected duration of the liquidation period.
Our audit procedures related to the provision for liquidation included among other things, the following:
NYRSTAR NV:

Completeness and accuracy of disclosures
As disclosed in F-cap 6.19 and 6.20, the company has off-balance rights, commitments and contingencies. The rights and commitments are mainly related to ongoing contracts resulting from the restructuring of the company. Furthermore significant contingencies exist considering the several legal proceedings and a procedure with the regulator (FSMA) in which the company and some of its directors are involved.
We consider these disclosures as a key audit matter, because they are essential for a good understanding of the financial position of the company, the uncertainties and risks of the company, and they required significant audit effort to be checked for accuracy and completeness.
Our audit procedures related to the disclosures included among other things, the following:
The administrative body is responsible for the preparation of annual accounts that give a true and fair view in accordance with the financial reporting framework applicable in Belgium, and for such internal control as the administrative body determines is necessary to enable the preparation of annual accounts that are free from material misstatement, whether due to fraud or error.
In preparing the annual accounts, the administrative body is responsible for assessing the Company's ability to continue as a going concern, disclosing, as applicable, matters related to going concern and using the going concern basis of accounting unless the administrative body either intends to liquidate the Company or to cease operations, or has no realistic alternative but to do so.
Our objectives are to obtain reasonable assurance about whether the annual accounts as a whole are free from material misstatement, whether due to fraud or error, and to issue a statutory auditor's report that includes our opinion. Reasonable assurance is a high level of assurance, but is not a guarantee that an audit conducted in accordance with ISAs will always detect a material misstatement when it exists.
Misstatements can arise from fraud or error and are considered material if, individually or in the aggregate, they could reasonably be expected to influence the economic decisions of users taken on the basis of these annual accounts.

When executing our audit, we respect the legal, regulatory and normative framework applicable for the audit of annual accounts in Belgium. However, a statutory audit does not guarantee the future viability of the Company, neither the efficiency and effectiveness of the management of the Company by the administrative body. Our responsibilities with respect to the administrative body's use of discontinuity basis of accounting are described below.
As part of an audit in accordance with ISAs, we exercise professional judgment and maintain professional skepticism throughout the audit. We also:
considering the decision of the extraordinary meeting of shareholders of 9 December 2019 to reject the continuation of the Company's activities;
• Evaluate the overall presentation, structure and content of the annual accounts and whether the annual accounts represent the underlying transactions and events in a manner that achieves fair presentation.
We communicate with the Audit Committee regarding, among other matters, the planned scope and timing of the audit and significant audit findings, including any significant deficiencies in internal control that we identified during our audit.
We also provide the Audit Committee with a statement that we have complied with relevant ethical requirements regarding independence, and to communicate with them all relationships and other matters that may reasonably be thought to bear on our independence and, where applicable, related safeguards.
From the matters communicated with the Audit Committee, we determine those matters that were of most significance in the audit of the financial statements of the current year, and are therefore the key audit matters. We describe these matters in our statutory auditor's report, unless law or regulation precludes public disclosure about the matter.

The administrative body is responsible for the preparation and the content of the director's report and for the documents to be deposited in accordance with the legal and regulatory requirements, as well as for the compliance with the legal and regulatory requirements regarding bookkeeping, with the Code of companies and associations and with the Company's by-laws.
In the context of our mission and in accordance with the Belgian standard (version revised 2020) which is complementary to the International Standards on Auditing (ISAs) as applicable in Belgium, it is our responsibility to verify, in all material aspects, the director's report, certain documents to be deposited in accordance with the legal and regulatory requirements, and compliance with certain provisions of the Code of companies and associations and of the Company's by-laws, as well as to report on these elements.
In our opinion, after having performed specific procedures in relation to the director's report, the director's report is consistent with the annual accounts for the same financial year, and it is prepared in accordance with articles 3:5 and 3:6 of the Code of companies and associations.
In the context of our audit of the annual accounts, we are also responsible for considering, in particular based on the knowledge we have obtained during the
audit, whether the director's report contains any material misstatement, i.e. any information which is inadequately disclosed or otherwise misleading. Based on the procedures we have performed, there are no material misstatements we have to report to you.
Our audit firm and our network did not provide services which are incompatible with the statutory audit of annual accounts and our audit firm remained independent of the Company during the terms of our mandate.
In accordance with the draft standard of the Institute of Réviseurs d'Entreprises concerning the standard on auditing the conformity of financial statements with the European Single Electronic Format (hereinafter "ESEF"), we also audited the conformity of the ESEF format with the regulatory technical standards established by Commission Delegated Regulation (EU) 2019/815 of 17 December 2018 (hereinafter: "Delegated Regulation").
The administrative body is responsible for preparing, in accordance with ESEF requirements, the financial statements in the form of an electronic file in ESEF format (hereinafter "digital financial statements") included in the annual financial report.
It is our responsibility to obtain sufficient and appropriate supporting information to conclude that the format of the digital financial statements complies in all material aspects with the ESEF requirements under the Delegated Regulation.
NYRSTAR NV:

Based on our work, we believe that the format of the official Dutch version of the digital financial statements included in the annual financial report of Nyrstar NV as at 31 December 2023 complies in all material aspects with the ESEF requirements under the Delegated Regulation.
Zaventem , 18 April 2024

BDO Réviseurs d'Entreprises SRL Statutory auditor Represented by Gert Claes* Auditor *Acting for a company
Building tools?
Free accounts include 100 API calls/year for testing.
Have a question? We'll get back to you promptly.