AI assistant
Nova Ltd. — Regulatory Filings 2005
Dec 1, 2005
6955_rns_2005-12-01_de0e8c35-17df-495f-a1a8-443c849db5c2.zip
Regulatory Filings
Open in viewerOpens in your device viewer
CORRESP 1 filename1.htm Created by EDGAR Ease Plus (EDGAR Ease+) Project: \Backup\office\EDGAR Filing\Nova Measuring Istruments Ltd\52026\a52026.eep Control Number: 52026 Rev Number: 1 Client Name: Nova Measuring Istruments Ltd Project Name: CORRESP Firm Name: Zadok-Keinan Ltd CORRESP MARKER FORMAT-SHEET="Scotch Rule Top-TNR" FSL="Workstation"
December 1, 2005
Ms. Angela Crane Branch Chief United States Securities and Exchange Commission Division of Corporation Finance 450 Fifth Street, NW Mail Stop 6010 Washington, D.C. 20549 Fax: 212-551-3640
MARKER FORMAT-SHEET="Para Hang Lv 2-TNR" FSL="Workstation"
Re: Nova Measuring Instruments Ltd. (the Company) Form 20-F for the year ended December 31, 2004 Filed June 28, 2005 File No. 0-030668
MARKER FORMAT-SHEET="Head Left-TNR" FSL="Workstation"
Dear Ms. Crane,
MARKER FORMAT-SHEET="Para Flush Lv 0-TNR" FSL="Workstation"
Following you will find the Companys responses to your letter dated August 2, 2005, including references to the comments detailed in the letter:
MARKER FORMAT-SHEET="Head Left-TNR" FSL="Workstation"
Form 20-F for the year ended December 31, 2004
MARKER FORMAT-SHEET="Head Left-TNR" FSL="Workstation"
Item 3. Key Information, page 2
MARKER FORMAT-SHEET="Head Left-TNR" FSL="Workstation"
Selected Financial Data, page 2
MARKER FORMAT-SHEET="Para (List) Hang LV 1-TNR" FSL="Default"
- We note that you named your accounting firm, Brightman, Almagor & Co. in the opening paragraph prior to your table. If you elect to make such a reference, please note that you will be required to identify the auditing firm under Experts and include their consent in your registration statement. We will not object if you wish to indicate only that your financial statements have been audited by an independent registered public accounting firm. Please revise in future filings.
MARKER FORMAT-SHEET="Para Flush Lv 2-TNR" FSL="Workstation"
Response: The Company will revise its disclosure accordingly in future filings.
MARKER FORMAT-SHEET="Head Left-TNR" FSL="Workstation"
Financial Statements
MARKER FORMAT-SHEET="Head Left-TNR" FSL="Workstation"
Statements of Cash Flows, page F-5
MARKER FORMAT-SHEET="Para (List) Hang LV 1-TNR" FSL="Workstation"
- In future filings please revise your statement of cash flows to show the increase and decrease in short-term and long-term held to maturity securities on a gross basis. Refer to paragraph 11 of SFAS 95.
MARKER FORMAT-SHEET="Para Flush Lv 2-TNR" FSL="Workstation"
Response: The Company will revise the presentation of its statement of cash flows accordingly in future filings.
MARKER FORMAT-SHEET="Head Left-TNR" FSL="Workstation"
Note 2 Significant Accounting Policies, page F-7
MARKER FORMAT-SHEET="Head Left-TNR" FSL="Workstation"
Revenue Recognition, page F-9
MARKER FORMAT-SHEET="Para (List) Hang LV 1-TNR" FSL="Workstation"
- Your disclosure regarding revenue recognition is too vague. Expand future filings to describe your revenue recognition policy in greater detail. To the extent that policy differs among significant product lines, please make your disclosure product line specific. Details should be provided to the extent that policy differs among the various marketing venues used by the company, i.e. distributors and direct sales force. Provide details of discounts, return policies, post shipment obligations, customer acceptance, warranties, credits, rebates, and price protection or similar privileges and how these impact revenue recognition. Also provide an analysis that explains your revenue recognition practices and demonstrates that your policies are SAB 104 and SFAS 48 compliant.
MARKER FORMAT-SHEET="Para Flush Lv 2-TNR" FSL="Workstation"
Response: The Company will expand, as applicable, its disclosures relating to revenue recognition in future filings.
MARKER FORMAT-SHEET="Para (List) Hang LV 1-TNR" FSL="Workstation"
- Based on your disclosures, it appears that you provide services and application support to customers. Tell us and expand your disclosures in future filings to describe your revenue recognition policies related to services provided.
MARKER FORMAT-SHEET="Para Flush Lv 2-TNR" FSL="Workstation"
Response: According to the Companys revenue recognition policy (as approved by the companys audit committee):
MARKER FORMAT-SHEET="Para Hang Lv 3-TNR" FSL="Workstation"
Service Contracts Revenue : service contracts (which sometimes include application support) generally specify fixed payment amounts for periods longer than one month, and are recognized on a straight line basis over the term of the contract.
MARKER FORMAT-SHEET="Para Hang Lv 3-TNR" FSL="Workstation"
Spare Parts Revenue: Usually recognized upon shipment of the parts.
MARKER FORMAT-SHEET="Para Hang Lv 3-TNR" FSL="Workstation"
Other Service Revenue (Training, Time & Material, etc.): Revenue is recognized upon completion of work in the field.
MARKER FORMAT-SHEET="Para Flush Lv 2-TNR" FSL="Workstation"
It should also be noted that other revenue recognition criteria (as specified in SAB 101 and SAB 104) must be met in order to recognize revenue.
MARKER FORMAT-SHEET="Para Flush Lv 2-TNR" FSL="Workstation"
These criteria are:
MARKER FORMAT-SHEET="Para Hang Lv 3-TNR" FSL="Workstation"
- Persuasive evidence that an arrangement exists;
MARKER FORMAT-SHEET="Para Hang Lv 3-TNR" FSL="Workstation"
- The sellers price is fixed or determinable, and;
MARKER FORMAT-SHEET="Para Hang Lv 3-TNR" FSL="Workstation"
- Collectability is reasonably assured.
MARKER FORMAT-SHEET="Para Flush Lv 2-TNR" FSL="Workstation"
The Company will disclose in future filings its revenue recognition policies related to services provided.
MARKER FORMAT-SHEET="Head Left-TNR" FSL="Workstation"
Note 7 Commitments and Contingent Liabilities, page F-15
MARKER FORMAT-SHEET="Para (List) Hang LV 1-TNR" FSL="Workstation"
- We note that you canceled a liability recorded in prior years and recognized $2.2 million as other income in the current period, related to OCS grants. Explain your accounting in greater detail and demonstrate how it complies with U.S. GAAP.
MARKER FORMAT-SHEET="Para Flush Lv 2-TNR" FSL="Workstation"
Response: As detailed in Note 7 to the Companys 2004 financial statements, the Company is obligated to pay royalties to the OCS (Office of Chief Scientist). The royalties are calculated as a percentage of the net sales of products developed directly or indirectly from projects partially funded by grants from the OCS. Therefore, repayment of OCS grants is contingent on future sales and the Company has no obligation to refund grants if sufficient sales are not generated.
MARKER FORMAT-SHEET="Para Flush Lv 2-TNR" FSL="Workstation"
Generally, the obligation for the payment of royalties to the OCS is satisfied only when all grants from the OCS have been fully repaid. As a result, and until the end of 2003, the Company accrued and paid royalties to the OCS on the basis of its total net sales. During 2003, however, the Company applied to the OCS to have grants totaling $2.2 million allocated to a specific technology project and to permit the Company to repay those grants through royalties only on net sales of products related to this specific technology project. The Company based its request on the fact that the product developed in the project is based on a different technology than the products developed under other OCS arrangements, among other factors. The Company had already accrued the full $2.2 million as a contingent liability by the end of the Companys third quarter of 2003, based on the then existing arrangements with the OCS.
MARKER FORMAT-SHEET="Para Flush Lv 2-TNR" FSL="Workstation"
In December 2003, the OCS approved the Companys request to allocate the $2.2 million in grants to the specific technology project and to have those grants be repaid through royalties only on net sales of products related to this specific technology project. As a result, the Company is obligated to repay the $2.2 million in grants only through royalties on net sales of products related to this specific technology project. Based on this approval and due to the fact that up to the date of the approval from the OCS, the Company had not sold any products related to this specific technology project (and there have been no sales to date), the probability for payment of these royalties changed from probable to remote (as specified in FASB 5). Therefore, the Company cancelled the royalty provision that was made with respect to the $2.2 million in OCS grants relating to this specific technology project. Due to the materiality of the cancellation and the fact that substantially all of the $2.2 million was already accrued prior to 2003, the Company decided to reflect the cancellation as a separate line item in its 2003 annual financial statements.
MARKER FORMAT-SHEET="Para Flush Lv 0-TNR" FSL="Default"
Upon your request, the Company acknowledges that:
MARKER FORMAT-SHEET="Para Hang Lv 1-TNR" FSL="Workstation"
The Company is responsible for the adequacy and accuracy of the disclosure in the filings;
MARKER FORMAT-SHEET="Para Hang Lv 1-TNR" FSL="Workstation"
Staff comments or changes to disclosure in response to staff do not foreclose the Commission from taking any action with respect to the filing; and
MARKER FORMAT-SHEET="Para Hang Lv 1-TNR" FSL="Workstation"
The Company may not assert staff comments as a defense in any proceeding initiated by the Commission or any person under the federal securities laws of United States.
MARKER FORMAT-SHEET="Para Flush Lv 0-TNR" FSL="Workstation"
The Company believes that the above fully responds to your questions and comments. If you have additional questions or comments, please do not hesitate to contact Mrs. Orly Davidian, Company Secretary, at +972-8-9387505 or by email at [email protected].
MARKER FORMAT-SHEET="Signature (Single)" FSL="Workstation"
Sincerely, /s/ Dror david Dror David Chief Financial Officer