Share Issue/Capital Change • Mar 24, 2025
Share Issue/Capital Change
Open in ViewerOpens in native device viewer
Report On Realization And Evaluation of the Assumptions Used in Determining the IPO Price January 1 – December 31, 2024
This report has been prepared pursuant to the Capital Markets Board Communiqué on Shares No. VII‐128.1 article 29/5.
March 24, 2025
Pursuant to the Capital Markets Board Communiqué on Shares No. VII/128.1 article 29/5, the Audit Committee has prepared this report on "Realization and Evaluation of the Assumptions used in Determining the IPO Price", which includes evaluations on whether the assumptions used in determining the initial public offering price of Kaleseramik, Çanakkale Kalebodur Seramik Sanayi A.Ş.. ("Kaleseramik" or "Company") have been realized.
According to the Price Determination Report, prepared on June 14, 2023 by Yapı Kredi Yatırım Menkul Değerler A.Ş. ("Yapı Kredi Yatırım"), the intermediary facilitating the IPO of the company shares together with Ak Yatırım Menkul Değerler A.Ş., and published on the Public Disclosure Platform on July 17, 2023, the company's market value and the initial public offering price have been determined based on the following assumptions.
The equity value of the Company was calculated as a result of EV/EBITDA and P/E analyses, and the equity value was calculated as a result of Market Multipliers Analysis by giving equal weight to the values calculated as a result of the analysis.
The company's enterprise value was calculated separately using foreign peers EV/EBITDA multiple and domestic peers EV/EBITDA multiple method. The final equity value was determined based on two multiple analysis by deducting the net debt position as of March 31, 2023 from the calculated enterprise values, and the equity value was calculated according to the Company's EV/EBITDA multiple analysis by giving equal weight to each calculated equity value.
Multiples of peers were obtained from the "Bloomberg" platform as of the closing of June 9, 2023 for foreign companies, and from the Rasyonet platform as of the closing of June 9, 2023 for domestic companies.
EV/EBITDA multiple was calculated by dividing the current enterprise values of peer public companies by the EBITDA values of the relevant companies as of the 12-month period ending on March 31, 2023.
The median EV/EBITDA multiple of foreign peers is calculated as 8.6X. According to this multiple value, the company's enterprise value and equity value are calculated in the table below.
| Foreign Peers EV/EBITDA | 8,6x | |
|---|---|---|
| EBITDA* | TL | 809.929.512 |
| Enterprise Value | TL | 6.933.804.520 |
| Net Debt | TL | 1.730.710.526 |
| Equity Value according to Foreign Peers EV/EBITDA Multiple | TL | 5.203.093.994 |
*Excluding other operating income/expense
The median EV/EBITDA multiple of domestic peers is calculated as 10.4x. According to this multiple value, the company's enterprise value and equity value are calculated in the table below.
| Domestic Peers EV/EBITDA | 10,4x | |
|---|---|---|
| EBITDA* | TL | 809.929.512 |
| Enterprise Value | TL | 8.440.915.504 |
| Net Debt | TL | 1.730.710.526 |
| Equity Value according to Domestic Peers EV/EBITDA Multiple | TL | 6.710.204.978 |
| Table 2: Equity Value Calculation According to Domestic Peers EV/EBITDA Multiple |
|---|
| ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
* Excluding other operating income/expense
By giving equal weight to the equity values calculated, using the EV/EBITDA multiples of foreign and domestic peers, an equity value of TL 5,956,649,486 was reached as a result of the EV/EBITDA multiple analysis.
| Table 3: Average Equity Value According to EV/EBITDA Multiple Analysis | ||
|---|---|---|
| Equity Value according to foreign peers EV/EBITDA Multiple | TL | 5.203.093.994 |
|---|---|---|
| Equity Value according to domestic peers EV/EBITDA Multiple | TL | 6.710.204.978 |
| Equity Value according to EV/EBITDA Multiple | TL | 5.956.649.486 |
The equity value of the Company was calculated separately using the foreign and domestic peers P/E multiples, and by giving equal weight to the calculated equity values.
Multiples of peers were obtained from the "Bloomberg" platform as of the closing of June 9, 2023 for foreign companies, and from the Rasyonet platform as of the closing of June 9, 2023 for domestic companies.
P/E multiple is calculated by dividing the current equity values of peer public companies by the net profit values of the relevant companies as of the 12-month period ending on March 31, 2023.
The median P/E multiple of foreign peers is calculated as 13.4X. According to this multiple, the Company's equity value is calculated in the table below.
| Table 4: Equity Value Calculation According to Foreign Peers P/E Multiple | ||
|---|---|---|
| --------------------------------------------------------------------------- | -- | -- |
| Foreing Peers P/E | 13,4x | |
|---|---|---|
| Net Profit | TL | 1.474.351.806 |
| Equity Value according to P/E Multiple | TL | 19.779.974.412 |
The median P/E multiple of domestic peers is calculated as 10.0X. According to this multiple, the Company's equity value is calculated in the table below.
| Domestic Peers P/E | 10,0x | |
|---|---|---|
| Net Profit | TL | 1.474.351.806 |
| Equity Value according to P/E Multiple | TL | 14.767.658.582 |
By giving equal weight to the equity values calculated, using the P/E multiples of foreign and domestic peers, an equity value of TL 17.273.816.497 was reached as a result of the P/E multiple analysis.
Tablo 6: Average Equity Value According to P/E Multiple Analysis
| Equity Value according to foreign peers P/E Multiple | TL | 19.779.974.412 |
|---|---|---|
| Equity Value according to domestic peers P/E Multiple | TL | 14.767.658.582 |
| Equity Value according to P/E Multiple | 17.273.816.497 |
Of the two methods, equal weight is given to the EV/EBITDA multiple and 50% to the P/E multiple. As a result of the multiple analysis, the Company's equity value was calculated as TL 11,615,232,992.
| Evaluation Methodology | Calculated Equity Value (TL) |
Weight | Calculated Equity (TL) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Peers EV/EBITDA Multiple | 5.956.649.486 | 50% | 2.978.324.743 |
| Peers P/E Multiple | 17.273.816.497 | 50% | 8.636.908.249 |
| Equity Value | 11.615.232.992 |
According to the valuation study, the discounted cash flow method and multiple analysis method were weighted by 50% and 50%, respectively. In the market multiple analysis method, EV/EBITDA and P/E multiples are also weighed equally at 50%.
The equity values calculated by discounted cash flow analysis and market multiple analysis are listed below.
| Table 8: Results of Valuation Methods | |
|---|---|
| --------------------------------------- | -- |
| Valuation Method | Equity Value (TL) | Weight | Contribution to Final Calculated Equity |
|---|---|---|---|
| Discounted Cash Flow Analysis | 12.342.654.936 | 50% | 6.171.327.468 |
| Market Multiple Analysis | 11.615.232.992 | 50% | 5.807.616.496 |
| Weighted Equity Value | 11.978.943.964 |
With 50%-50% weight, the company's average pre-public offering equity value is calculated as TL 11,978,943,964.
The public offering price is calculated as TL 25.00 per share by applying a 15.4% pre-public offering discount rate, based on the equity value calculated by valuation methods.
| Equity Value (TL) | |
|---|---|
| Nominal Capital Value | 405.388.196 |
| Pre-IPO Equity Value based on valuation methods | 11.978.943.964 |
| IPO Discount | %15,4 |
| Public Offering Discounted Market Value | 10.134.704.888 |
| IPO Price (TL/per share) | 25,00 |
Since the projection data in the Price Determination Report (PDR) published by Yapı Kredi Investment on July 17, 2023, was prepared prior to the decision to implement the IAS 29 standard, the inflation accounting method was not applied in the report.
As the Company's published financials dated December 31, 2024 were prepared in accordance with IAS-29 principles, the annual assumptions in the PDR were compared with 2024 financials, which are not adjusted by IAS-29 and not independently audited.
| (TL mio.) | 2024 12 M (Actual) - IAS 29 not applied |
2024 12 M (PDR Forecast) - IAS 29 not applied |
Realization |
|---|---|---|---|
| Net Sales | 8.520,4 | 14.870,4 | %57 |
| Cost of Goods Sold | 6.987,0 | 10.560,1 | %66 |
| Gross Profit | 1.533,4 | 4.310,3 | %36 |
| Operating Expenses* | 2.040,7 | 2.170,4 | %94 |
| Amortization adj. | 283,0 | 252,7 | %120 |
| EBITDA** | -224,3 | 2.392,6 | - |
* Operating Expenses = Marketing, Sales & Distribution Expenses + General Administrative Expenses + R&D Expenses
** EBITDA = Gross Profit – Operating Expenses + Amortization
In 2024, 57% of the revenue projected for the whole of 2024 was reached in the Price Determination Report (FTR) prepared by Yapı Kredi Investment.
The shrinkage in the construction sector in Europe, which is our main export market as a country, and the anti-dumping duty imposed by the EU against Turkish manufacturers continue to put pressure on the country's exports.
According to IMSAD data, the contraction in 2023 in Turkiye's exports of ceramic coating materials and ceramic sanitary ware, were 38% and 8%, respectively. Despite the high decrease in 2023, the increase in export of ceramic coating materials in 2024 remained limited to 8%, while the export of ceramic sanitary ware decreased further by 19%.
In the domestic market, the pressure created by high interest rates on housing demand played a negative role on sales. According to TurkStat data, housing sales, which decreased by 17.5% in 2023, fell by 3.7% in the first half of 2024, but increased by 21% in the whole of 2024 thanks to the momentum achieved in the second half of the year.
Although total sales increased, mortgage sales fell to a historical low of approximately 158 thousand units due to rising credit costs. (Its share in total sales was 11%)
On the other hand, only 33% of housing sales in 2024 consisted of first-hand sales. In 2013- 18, when the construction sector performed strong, this rate was around 47%.
Building occupancy permits, which show newly completed, ready-to-live houses, increased by 10% to 586 thousand units in 2024 after the lowest level of the last 13 years (535 thousand) in 2023, but are still 19% below their 2013 level.
Although the construction sector grew by 9.3% in 2024, the production increase in the construction material industry was just 1.4% annually. The growth in the construction sector was not reflected in the production of construction materials. The domestic demand created by the growth in the construction sector was largely met from inventory. Sales channels, dealers and manufacturers used their stocks.
According to the February 2025 report of the Turkish Construction Material Manufacturers' Association (IMSAD), production in 11 sub-sectors increased in 2024 compared to 2023, while production decreased in 11 sub-sectors. While the production of construction glass increased by 13.0% and the production of iron and steel construction products increased by 12.4%, the production of ceramic coating materials decreased by 22.1% and the production of ceramic sanitary ware decreased by 25.6%.
Our company's production of ceramic coating materials decreased by 20.0% to 27.7 million m², while the production of ceramic sanitary ware decreased by 10.4% to 691.8 thousand units.
Our gross profit and EBITDA margins were adversely affected due to the decreasing sales volume in domestic and foreign markets, falling production quantities and capacity utilization rates, as well as the increase in personnel expenses, which have a significant share in production costs. As a result, 36% of the gross profit projected in PDR was reached in 2024, while a loss was realized at the EBITDA level.
Regards,
Audit Committee
Fahri Okan BÖKE Arzu ERDEM Member Member
Building tools?
Free accounts include 100 API calls/year for testing.
Have a question? We'll get back to you promptly.