Business and Financial Review • May 20, 2024
Business and Financial Review
Open in ViewerOpens in native device viewer

Prepared in accordance with Article 29/5 of the Capital Markets Board's Equity Communiqué No. VII-128.1. May 20, 2024
Trade Name: Çates Elektrik Üretim Anonim Şirketi
Head Office: Şahinler Mahallesi Şahinler (Küme Evler) Yatağan Termik Santrali Sitesi No: 259/1 Yatağan/Muğla
Corporate Website: www.cates.com.tr
Traded on Stock Exchange: Borsa Istanbul A.Ş. Registered Capital Ceiling : TRY 300.000.000 Issued Capital : TRY 165.200.000 Trade Registry No.: 8907 Tax Office : Yatağan Tax Office - Muğla Tax No: 1650297639
This report, which includes assessments regarding the realization of the assumptions taken as basis in determining the public offering price of Çates Elektrik Üretim Anonim Şirketi ("Çates" or "Company"), has been prepared by the Audit Committee in accordance with Article 29/5 of the Capital Markets Board's Equity Communiqué No. VII-128.1.
According to Article 29, Paragraph 5 of the Capital Markets Board's Communiqué on Shares No. VII-128.1, "It is obligatory for the corporation, whose shares are offered to public for the first time, to prepare a report within ten business days following the public disclosure of its financial statements for two years following the commencement of trading of its shares on the stock exchange, including assessments on whether the assumptions taken as basis in determining the public offering price have been realized or not, and if not, the reason thereof, and to publish the said report on the corporation's website and PDP. This obligation is fulfilled by the audit committee within the company. For the companies that are not obliged to establish an audit committee, this obligation is fulfilled by the board of directors." Pursuant to this provision, this report is prepared and disclosed to the public.
Within the scope of the public offering brokerage agreement signed on August 9, 2023 and revised on September 21, 2023 between İnfo Yatırım Menkul Değerler A.Ş. (İnfo Yatırım), the intermediary for the public offering of the Company's shares, and Çates Elektrik Üretim Anonim Şirketi (Company), this report has been prepared to determine the value that will constitute the basis of the price in the public offering of the Company's shares in accordance with the International Valuation Standards in accordance with the Capital Markets Board's "Communiqué on Valuation Standards in Capital Markets" numbered III.62-1. On November 24, 2023, the valuation date of the price determination report published on PDP is September 6, 2023 and the report date is September 11, 2023. Company value and public offering price have been determined asfollows.
In order to determine the value per share of Çates Elektrik Üretim Anonim Şirketi, the following valuation methods were analyzed.
Discounted Cash Flow Analysis (DCF) is a valuation method based on discounting the cash flows that companies are likely to generate over the period of their operations. The ICA method focuses on finding the intrinsic value of a company's operations based on a number of assumptions, reflects its long-term potential and incorporates company-specific risks within a certain framework. Although the sensitivity of this method to assumptions may seem like a disadvantage, it is more suitable for non-static business models.
Market multiples analysis is a valuation method based on comparing the current price levels of similar companies traded on stock exchanges with the ratios of certain data in their publicly disclosed financial statements. It is one of the most frequently used valuation methods because it is easy to apply and relatively objective. The disadvantages are that companies similar to the company subject to valuation cannot always be found and only the financial data of these companies for a certain period can be used as a basis for comparison. In addition, since it is very sensitive to current market pricing, valuations are volatile depending on the changing market risk appetite in different periods. It is not easy to capture the future prospects of companies exactly with market multiples. In addition, reducing dynamic business models to a static multiplier involvesrisks.
In this valuation method, the Firm Value/EBITDA (FD/EBITDA) multiplier, which is frequently used in the Company's sector, was used and the market value of the Company was calculated based on the EBITDA realized for the last 12 months (30.06.2022-30.06.2023).
Market Multiplier Analysis is a reasonable method as it reflects the current market values of similar companies. One of the most important reasons for this isthe significant levels of foreign currency denominated debt of energy companies and the significant levels of one-time financing income and expenses arising from exchange rate increases due to the currency hedged deposit mechanism. This situation prevents normalization of profits and prevents the formation of healthy F/S multiples. For these reasons, the valuation is based on FD/EBITDA multiplier only. In the EBITDA calculation, foreign exchange gains and losses arising from trading activities are also taken into account and included in the EBITDA calculation. Therefore, EBITDA including FX gains and losses arising from trading activities are used to determine FD/EBITDA multiples. While calculating the value from foreign multiples, since Bloomberg provides dollar-based multiples in the sample, the value was found with the Company's dollar-based data and the market value was determined at the USD/TL exchange rate on the valuation date.
In the final value, 60% weight was given to İNA as it is considered to better reflect the company dynamics, while 40% weight was given to market multiples in order to take into account the market behavior model in the value. In addition to the international multiples, a value was found from the Çan Termik multiplier, which is exactly similar to the Company, and a certain weight was given to the multiplier value from the BIST-Termik sample in which the Company will be included. While INA received the highest weighting as it most accurately reflects the dynamics of the company, the value of Çan Termik, which is exactly similar to the Company, was given 0% weight due to the fact that it is a single sample. Due to the fact that they are subject to different country risks, foreign peers are given 10% weight, while the BIST Termik sample is given 30% weight. While determining the share value according to traditional valuation methodologies, a 20% IPO discount was applied to the valueobtained.
| Değerleme Özeti | Değer (m\$) | Ağırlık | Pay Başı Değer (TL) | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Metodolojiler | ||||
| İNA | 309,1 | 60,0% | 59,02 | |
| Çan2 | 440,0 | 0,0% | 84,01 | |
| Yurtışı Çarpanlar | 553,5 | 10,0% | 105,69 | |
| BİST Termik | 444,4 | 30,0% | 84,85 | |
| Halka Arz Piyasa Değeri (TL) | 374,1 | 100% | 71,44 | |
| Halka Arz İskontosu | -20% | |||
| Nihai Değer | 299,3 | 57,15 | ||
| Değer Çarpanları | 2023/06 | 2023T | ||
| EV/EBITDA | 5,5 | 6,6 | ||
| F/K | 11,7 | m.d. | ||
| EV/Net Satış | 1,9 | m.d. | ||
| PD/DD | 2,1 | m.d. |
| Public Offering Price (TRY/share) | 57,15 |
|---|---|
| Market Capitalization Before IPO Prices (m USD) | 374,1 |
| Pre-IPO Market Value Calculated by Valuation Methods (m USD) | 299,3 |
| Pre-IPO Discount Rates | %20 |
The public offering price was determined as TRY 57.15 by applying a 20% public offering discount to the value calculated by valuation methods.
The estimated data for 2023 in the price determination report and the actual data for the same period are calculated as follows.
| (Million TRY) | Price Determination Report 2023 End of Year Estimated |
Realized - Except TAS 29 |
Realization Rate (%)- Excluding TAS 29 |
Realized - Including TAS 29 |
Realization Rate (%)- Including TAS 29 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Total Revenues | 4.269 | 4.140 | 97% | 5.296 | 124% |
| Electricity Sales Revenues | 4.245 | 4.110 | 97% | 5.259 | 124% |
| Other Income | 24 | 30 | 126% | 37 | 154% |
| Cost of Sales + Operational Expenses (*) |
(2.853) | (2.837) | 99% | (3.618) | 127% |
| EBITDA | 1.416 | 1.303 | 92% | 1.678 | 118% |
(*) Calculated net of other operating income and expenses, excluding depreciation and amortization expenses and net foreign exchange gains on trading transactions.
The 2023 targeted production volumes, production revenues and EBITDA generated were analyzed in line with the annual targets and the annual deviation shares were evaluated.
Revenue and profitability figures for generation plants on an annual basis;
The Company's team of experts, supported by high quality equipment and well-established maintenance processes, ensures that the Company's portfolio achieves high levels of availability and capacity at low cost.


As of the end of the period 01.01.2023-31.12.2023, according to the tables containing the calculations made after the application of TAS 29 inflation accounting, the Company has outperformed the income statement projection stated in the Price Determination Report and framed during the public offering and has significantly met the expectations in the estimates according to the tables containing the calculations made with the TAS 29 non-inflation accounting.
Sincerely,
Hamdi ALP Mehmet Akif GÜL President Member (The originals have signatures.) (The originals have signatures.)
Engin KAVAS Emirhan KARAYAY Member Member (The originals have signatures.) (The originals have signatures.)
Rıdvan Edip AKDENİZ Member (The originals have signatures.)
Building tools?
Free accounts include 100 API calls/year for testing.
Have a question? We'll get back to you promptly.