AI assistant
BEGA CHEESE LIMITED — M&A Activity 2011
Nov 16, 2011
64516_rns_2011-11-16_57dfdac5-d449-4333-bc77-62d3b0e5ec8f.pdf
M&A Activity
Open in viewerOpens in your device viewer
Scheme booklet
Tatura Milk Industries Limited ABN 66 006 603 970
A proposal to merge 100% of Tatura Milk Industries Limited with Bega Cheese Limited
Your Dairy Farmer Supplier Directors unanimously recommend that you vote in favour of the proposed Merger in the absence of a superior proposal
Please read this scheme booklet in its entirety, consider your decision carefully and cast your vote
Table of contents
| Important notices ........................................................................................................................ 1 |
|---|
| Detailed information ................................................................................................................. 10 |
| 1. Introduction ..................................................................................................................... 10 |
| 2. Advantages, disadvantages and alternatives.................................................................... 15 |
| 3. What the Merger means for Tatura Milk RP Shareholders ............................................. 20 |
| 4. Industry developments..................................................................................................... 23 |
| 5. Information on Tatura Milk ............................................................................................. 28 |
| 6. Information on Bega Cheese ........................................................................................... 42 |
| 7. An explanation of the process ......................................................................................... 76 |
| 8. Summary of the constitution of Bega Cheese ................................................................. 84 |
| 9. Additional information .................................................................................................... 87 |
| 10. Glossary ......................................................................................................................... 101 |
| 11. Statements by directors.................................................................................................. 104 |
| Independent expert report ....................................................................................................... 105 |
| Taxation report ........................................................................................................................ 178 |
| Scheme of arrangement deed .................................................................................................. 181 |
| Notice of general meeting ....................................................................................................... 192 |
| Notice of Scheme meeting ...................................................................................................... 195 |
| Corporate directory ................................................................................................................. 197 |
Important notices
This scheme booklet encompasses the explanatory statement required to be sent to Tatura Milk RP Shareholders in relation to the Scheme under section 412 of the Corporations Act and is dated 17 November 2011.
On that date a copy of this scheme booklet was lodged with ASIC for registration, and was registered by ASIC for the purpose of section 412(6) of the Corporations Act. ASIC and its officers take no responsibility for the contents of this scheme booklet. However, under section 412(8) of the Corporations Act ASIC must not register a copy of this document unless it appears to comply with the Corporations Act and ASIC is of the opinion that the document does not contain any matter that is false in a material particular or materially misleading in the form or context in which it appears.
IMPORTANT NOTICE ASSOCIATED WITH COURT ORDER UNDER SECTION 411(1) OF CORPORATIONS ACT
The fact that under section 411(1) of the Corporations Act the Court has ordered that a meeting of Tatura Milk RP Shareholders be convened to consider the proposed Scheme and has approved the explanatory statement required to accompany the notices of the meeting (as contained in this scheme booklet), does not mean that the Court:
-
(a) has formed any view as to the merits of the proposed Scheme or as to how Tatura Milk RP Shareholders should vote (on this matter Tatura Milk RP Shareholders must reach their own decision); or
-
(b) has prepared, or is responsible for the content of, the explanatory statement.
Tatura Milk RP Shareholders are encouraged to read this scheme booklet and the accompanying material in its entirety before making a decision on how to vote in relation to the proposed Merger. This scheme booklet does not take into account the individual investment objectives, financial situation and particular needs of each Tatura Milk RP Shareholder. You are encouraged to seek independent legal, financial and taxation advice before making a decision as to whether or not to vote in favour of the proposed Merger and whether Bega Cheese shares are an appropriate investment for you.
A proxy form for the general meeting and a proxy form for the Scheme meeting accompany this scheme booklet.
The forward looking statements contained in this scheme booklet have been based on expectations at the date of preparation of this scheme booklet about future events. They are, therefore, subject to risks, uncertainties and assumptions that could cause actual results to differ materially from the expectations. These factors include matters not yet known to Tatura Milk or Bega Cheese or not currently considered material by Tatura Milk or Bega Cheese. While Tatura Milk or Bega Cheese (as the case may be) believe there is a reasonable basis for making the forward looking statements contained in this scheme booklet, none of Tatura Milk, Bega Cheese, the officers and employees of Tatura Milk or Bega Cheese and the persons engaged by
Scheme booklet │ Page 1
Tatura Milk or Bega Cheese in the preparation of this scheme booklet, makes any representation or warranty (express or implied) as to the accuracy or likelihood of fulfilment of any forward looking statement, except to the extent required by law. You are therefore cautioned not to place undue reliance on any such forward looking statements.
Defined terms
A number of terms used in this scheme booklet are defined in section 10.
Important dates
| Event | Date |
|---|---|
| Latest time for lodgement of the proxy forms for | 11:00 am Melbourne time on Monday |
| the Tatura Milk general meeting and Scheme | 12 December 2011 |
| meeting. | |
| General meeting of Tatura Milk, to be followed | 11:00 am Melbourne time on |
| immediately by the Scheme meeting, both to be | Wednesday 14 December 2011 |
| held at the Sir Ian McLennan Centre, Echuca | |
| Road, Mooroopna, Victoria to consider the | |
| Merger. | |
| Supreme Court hearingto approve Scheme. | Friday16 December 2011 |
| Implementation of Scheme and Merger. | Friday23 December 2011 |
Tatura Milk reserves the right to change the above dates and times. If Tatura Milk decides to change the date or time for holding the meetings, it will notify shareholders accordingly. Tatura Milk will advertise the date of the Court hearing for approval of the Scheme at least 5 days before the hearing in The Australian and The Age newspapers. If Tatura Milk decides to change the date of the Court hearing, the revised date will be advertised. The date for implementation of the Scheme and Merger may change depending on when the Court approves the Scheme and when an office copy of the Court order approving the Scheme is lodged with ASIC. Implementation must occur on the 4[th] Business Day after lodgement of the order, although this may be changed by agreement between Tatura Milk and Bega Cheese and with the permission of the Court.
Privacy
The proxy forms that accompany this scheme booklet require you to provide information that may be personal information for the purposes of the Privacy Act 1988 (Cth). This information, and other information you may provide to Tatura Milk, may include your name, contact details and the name of a person appointed to act as your proxy, corporate representative or attorney. Tatura Milk and Bega Cheese may collect, hold and use that personal information in the process of implementing the Merger. The primary purpose of the collection of personal information is to assist Tatura Milk to conduct the general meeting and Scheme meeting and for Tatura Milk and Bega Cheese to implement the Merger and administer any applicable shareholdings for you. Personal information may be disclosed to external advisers, consultants and other service providers, who may assist Tatura Milk with responding to general enquiries about the meetings, the conduct of the meetings and who may undertake the role of returning officer at those meetings. Personal information may also be disclosed to print and mail service providers and personnel of Tatura Milk and other members of the Bega Cheese Group.
Page 2 │ Scheme booklet
You have certain rights to access personal information that has been collected from you. You should contact the Tatura Milk privacy liaison officer, Jason Wells, on (03) 5824 6200 in the first instance if you wish to access your personal information.
If you appoint a named person to act as your proxy, corporate representative or attorney, you should ensure that you inform that person of these matters.
Scheme booklet │ Page 3
Letter from the deputy chairman
Dear shareholders
On 4 October 2011, I wrote to let you know that Tatura Milk had entered into a Merger Implementation Agreement with Bega Cheese for the acquisition of your Tatura Milk A class redeemable preference shares ( Tatura Milk RP Shares ).
Bega Cheese’s offer to buy the 30% (approximately) of Tatura Milk it does not own, allows us as holders of Tatura Milk RP Shares ( Tatura Milk RP Shareholders ) to become shareholders in Bega Cheese which is listed on ASX.
Bega Cheese has offered to acquire all of the Tatura Milk RP Shares pursuant to a Court approved scheme of arrangement for the consideration of 2 Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares for every 1 Tatura Milk RP Share.
The Bega Cheese Group already owns approximately 70% of Tatura Milk through its ownership of all of the Tatura Milk Ordinary Shares. The Tatura Milk RP Shares, which represent the remaining 30% (approximately), are all held by Tatura Milk Suppliers.
Bega Cheese acquired its 70% shareholding in 2007 when Tatura Milk was financially vulnerable, the result of a high debt load in the middle of one of Australia’s worst droughts. Since then, debt is substantially reduced, profitability is substantially up, and Tatura Milk is well positioned for the future.
The Tatura Milk RP Shareholders are beneficiaries of this turnaround. This is evidenced by Bega Cheese offering Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares with a value of approximately $40.8 million for the remaining 30% of Tatura Milk (based on a Bega Cheese Ordinary Share price of $1.70), whereas it paid $38.8 million for the initial 70% stake. Certainly it has been to Tatura Milk RP Shareholders’ benefit to have held the remaining 30% and to now be able to get the reward for the financial turnaround of Tatura Milk.
The Dairy Farmer Supplier Directors believe the consideration offered by Bega Cheese is fair and reasonable. We believe the consideration is consistent with how Bega Cheese and other food companies are valued by the stock market notwithstanding Tatura Milk is not listed on ASX. The Bega Cheese offer price is significantly above the $1 sum for which each Tatura Milk RP Share may be redeemed. Furthermore, the independent expert, Value Adviser Associates Pty Ltd, who was appointed by Tatura Milk to provide you with an opinion on the Scheme, has concluded that the proposed Scheme is in the best interests of Tatura Milk RP Shareholders and has placed a value on Tatura Milk RP Shares of between $3.05 and $3.78. This range should be compared with the offer of 2 Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares, together valued at $3.40 based on the volume weighted average price of Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares sold on ASX over the period from the date the Merger was announced (4 October 2011) to the day before the date of this scheme booklet.
In addition to the value of the Bega Cheese offer, your Dairy Farmer Supplier Directors support the Merger for the reasons outlined in this scheme booklet, but in particular because:
Page 4 │ Scheme booklet
-
(a) The Merger provides Tatura Milk RP Shareholders with an opportunity to realise value for their Tatura Milk RP Shares reflecting the financial turnaround and a premium for control.
-
(b) Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares are quoted on ASX and Bega Cheese operates a number of diversified businesses in the dairy industry and food processing industry. In consequence, Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares provide greater liquidity and investment diversification than Tatura Milk RP Shares on their own.
-
(c) Bega Cheese has stated that it is committed to the ongoing investment and development of the Tatura Milk site and business.
-
(d) Bega Cheese has stated that it is committed to the ongoing maintenance and growth of Tatura Milk’s dairy farmer supply base.
While the Dairy Farmer Supplier Directors unanimously endorse the Merger proposal, and the independent expert says it is in your best interests, the final decision on the Merger is in the hands of you and the other Tatura Milk RP Shareholders and the Court.
A general meeting of Tatura Milk and a Scheme meeting of Tatura Milk RP Shareholders have been convened to consider a number of resolutions to implement the Merger. The meetings are to be held at the Sir Ian McLennan Centre, Echuca Road, Mooroopna, Victoria on Wednesday 14 December 2011 starting at 11:00 am.
This scheme booklet contains important information regarding the Scheme, including the report of the independent expert. You are encouraged to read this information carefully and, if required, seek your own investment or other professional advice before voting on the Merger.
Your Dairy Farmer Supplier Directors encourage you to vote at the general meeting and the Scheme meeting, and I look forward to seeing as many of you as possible at those meetings.
Yours faithfully
==> picture [145 x 63] intentionally omitted <==
Rick Cross Deputy chairman Tatura Milk Industries Limited
Scheme booklet │ Page 5
Important questions
| Important questions | |
|---|---|
| **Question ** | **Answer ** |
| What is the Scheme? | The Scheme, once approved by Tatura Milk RP Shareholders and |
| the Court, will bind all Tatura Milk RP Shareholders on and from | |
| the Effective Date, even those who vote against it. If the Scheme is | |
| approved and all other conditions of the Scheme and Merger are | |
| satisfied or waived, Bega Cheese will acquire all Tatura Milk RP | |
| Shares held by you at9:00am on the Implementation Date. | |
| What will I receive if the | You will receive 2 Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares for every 1 of |
| Scheme is approved and | your Tatura Milk RP Shares. |
| implemented? | |
| Who is Bega Cheese? | Bega Cheese is an Australian company that recently listed on ASX. |
| It has an approximate 70% stake in Tatura Milk and operates a | |
| number of diversified businesses in the dairy industry and food | |
| processingindustry. | |
| When will I receive the | You will be issued the Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares to which you |
| consideration? | are entitled under the Scheme on the Implementation Date. On the |
| basis of the current proposed timetable for the Scheme, the | |
| Implementation Date is expected to be Friday23 December 2011. | |
| Will I have to pay | No brokerage fees or stamp duty will be payable on the sale or |
| brokerage fees or stamp | transfer of your Tatura Milk RP Shares or the issue of Bega Cheese |
| duty? | OrdinaryShares in exchange under the Scheme. |
| When and where will the | The general meeting of Tatura Milk, to be followed immediately by |
| meetings be held? | the Scheme meeting, will be held at the Sir Ian McLennan Centre, |
| Echuca Road, Mooroopna, Victoria on Wednesday 14 December | |
| 2011 startingat 11:00 am Melbourne time. | |
| Am I entitled to vote? | If you are registered as a Tatura Milk RP Shareholder at 7:00 pm |
| Melbourne time on Monday 12 December 2011 you will be entitled | |
| to vote at the meetings. You may vote in person or by duly | |
| appointed proxy or attorney, or in the case of a body corporate, | |
| corporate representative. | |
| What do the Dairy Farmer | The Dairy Farmer Supplier Directors believe that the Scheme is in |
| Supplier Directors | the best interests of Tatura Milk RP Shareholders and unanimously |
| recommend? | recommend that Tatura Milk RP Shareholders vote in favour of the |
| Scheme,in the absence of a superiorproposal. | |
| How do the Dairy Farmer | All of the Dairy Farmer Supplier Directors who own Tatura Milk |
| Supplier Directors intend to | RP Shares either directly or through a controlled entity intend to |
| vote? | vote in favour of the Scheme in the absence of a superiorproposal. |
| What is the opinion of the | The independent expert has concluded that the proposed Scheme is |
| independent expert? | in the best interests of Tatura Milk RP Shareholders – see the |
| independent expert report startingonpage 105. |
Page 6 │ Scheme booklet
Question Answer What majority is required The Scheme must be approved at the Scheme meeting by 2 for implementation of the majorities. The resolution approving the Scheme must be passed Merger? by a majority in number of the Tatura Milk RP Shareholders present and voting (either in person or by proxy, attorney or corporate representative) at the meeting and by at least 75% of the votes cast on the resolution.
The proposed special resolution modifying the constitution of Tatura Milk must be passed at the earlier general meeting by at least 75% of the votes cast by shareholders present and voting (either in person or by proxy, attorney or corporate representative) at the meeting, including any votes cast by Bega Cheese as holder of all of the Tatura Milk Ordinary Shares.
Should I vote? You do not have to vote. However, the Dairy Farmer Supplier Directors believe that the Scheme is important to all Tatura Milk RP Shareholders and encourage you to vote or to appoint a proxy to vote on your behalf. Where do I send my proxy Just follow the instructions on the proxy forms which accompany forms? this scheme booklet. What happens if I do If the Scheme is approved by the Court and all other conditions of nothing or vote against the the Scheme and Merger are satisfied or waived, and you are a Scheme? Tatura Milk RP Shareholder at 9:00 am on the Implementation Date, your Tatura Milk RP Shares will be transferred pursuant to the Scheme and you will be entitled to receive Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares as consideration for your Tatura Milk RP Shares. If the Scheme is not approved, you will remain a Tatura Milk RP Shareholder.
Why is a 100% merger of The Merger will enable Tatura Milk RP Shareholders to convert Tatura Milk with Bega their Tatura Milk RP Shares into Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares, Cheese being proposed? which can be traded on ASX at a market price. This will put Tatura Milk RP Shareholders into a position where they can make an individual investment decision as to whether to sell or retain their Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares. From a business perspective, the Merger will enable a more complete integration of the businesses of Tatura Milk and Bega Cheese.
How do I assess whether This scheme booklet is designed to provide you with all relevant the consideration I will information you may need to assess the Merger. Tatura Milk has receive is fair? engaged an independent expert, Value Adviser Associates Pty Ltd, to assess whether the Merger is in the best interests of Tatura Milk RP Shareholders. Part of this task is to assess whether the consideration provided under the Merger is fair. Value Adviser Associates Pty Ltd has concluded that the Merger is fair and reasonable and in the best interests of Tatura Milk RP Shareholders. The independent expert’s conclusions are set out in the independent expert report starting on page 105 of this scheme booklet. You should read this report carefully.
Scheme booklet │ Page 7
Question
What is an ASX listed share?
What things will impact on the value of Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares?
How do I trade Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares?
Answer
The fact that Bega Cheese is listed on ASX means that its shares may be traded on the stock market operated by ASX.
The price at which Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares trade at any time on ASX is determined by market forces including the number of buyers and sellers and the price they are willing to pay or receive having regard to, among other things, the risks, financial position and financial performance of the Merged Group as well as external factors such as the domestic and international economy and the industry in which the Merged Group will operate.
You can trade Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares through a stock broker (brokerage fees will apply). You may already have an account with a stock broker. However, Bega Cheese will also arrange for a stock broker to make its services available to Tatura Milk RP Shareholders – see section 3.8.
Will I be able to participate Once you become a shareholder in Bega Cheese you will be in the Bega Cheese entitled to participate in the dividend reinvestment plan on the same dividend reinvestment plan? basis as all other shareholders – see section 6.11.
What is the tax effect of the Merger on a Tatura Milk RP Shareholder?
The exchange of Tatura Milk RP Shares for Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares under the Merger may give rise to taxable capital gains or other tax consequences. However, you may qualify for capital gains tax rollover relief and the exchange of shares under the Merger may not result in any immediate taxation liability. Further details of some of the taxation consequences of the Merger are set out in the taxation report beginning on page 178. You should seek your own tax advice as to the tax effect of the Merger on your individual circumstances.
What will be my ongoing It is Bega Cheese’s stated intention that Tatura Milk RP relationship with Tatura Shareholders will continue to be able to sell their milk to Tatura Milk? Milk in accordance with the same arrangements that currently exist. There will be a seamless continuity in the present milk supply practices and policies, except that Tatura Milk shareholders who are Dairy Farmer Suppliers will cease to be entitled to dividends based on their milk supplies to Tatura Milk.
How will the Merger affect my current and future milk price?
Bega Cheese recognises that Tatura Milk requires a substantial and reliable supply of milk in its business and, accordingly, is committed to maintaining a base of dairy farmer milk suppliers to Tatura Milk in Northern Victoria. In order to ensure that this milk supply base remains in place, Bega Cheese recognises that Tatura Milk will need to continue to pay a leading manufacturing price for milk supplied to it by farmer suppliers.
Will I need to hold Bega No. The decision as to whether you retain or sell the Bega Cheese Cheese Ordinary Shares in Ordinary Shares you receive upon implementation of the Merger is order to supply milk to an investment decision for you to make personally. Tatura Milk?
Page 8 │ Scheme booklet
Question
What impact will the Merger have on Tatura Milk’s operations?
What representation will Dairy Farmer Suppliers have on the Bega Cheese board of directors?
How does Bega Cheese intend to maintain the relationship with Dairy Farmer Suppliers?
Answer
Bega Cheese has stated that it intends to continue to conduct the key business operations of Tatura Milk from the company’s facilities at Tatura, Victoria.
The Bega Cheese constitution provides that 2 positions on the Bega Cheese board of directors will be made available for Tatura Milk Dairy Farmer Suppliers for a period of 2 years after the implementation of the Merger. The 2 initial directors to be appointed to these positions will be selected from the existing Dairy Farmer Supplier Directors by Tatura Milk RP Shareholders in conjunction with their approval of the Merger. The Bega Cheese constitution also provides for the board to include a minimum of 4 Bega Cheese Dairy Farmer Suppliers, and all Tatura Milk Dairy Farmer Suppliers will qualify for election to these positions. Accordingly, even after the conclusion of the 2 year period following the implementation of the Merger, there will be scope for ongoing participation by Tatura Milk Dairy Farmer Suppliers as Bega Cheese directors.
The Bega Cheese Group, including Tatura Milk, understands the need to retain a reliable supply of milk for the production of its dairy products. The listing of Bega Cheese on ASX has not altered this and Bega Cheese recognises that the combination of leading regional manufacturing milk prices and innovative farm extension programs are the key to attracting and retaining milk suppliers.
Scheme booklet │ Page 9
Detailed information
1. Introduction
1.1 Purpose of this scheme booklet
The purpose of this scheme booklet is to explain to Tatura Milk RP Shareholders the proposal to merge Tatura Milk with Bega Cheese and for Tatura Milk RP Shareholders to become shareholders of Bega Cheese.
This scheme booklet explains the process involved to effect the Merger and provides information to Tatura Milk RP Shareholders to help them decide whether or not to approve the Merger.
This scheme booklet is being sent through the post to Tatura Milk RP Shareholders and includes notices of a general meeting and Scheme meeting to be held on Wednesday 14 December 2011 where Tatura Milk RP Shareholders will be requested to vote on the Merger and the Scheme. Information about Bega Cheese is provided in section 6 of this scheme booklet.
The booklet is also being sent to Bega Cheese as holder of all of the Tatura Milk Ordinary Shares, for the purpose of convening the general meeting.
1.2 Overview of the proposed Merger
If the Merger with Bega Cheese is implemented, Bega Cheese will acquire all of your Tatura Milk RP Shares.
The consideration for this acquisition is 2 Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares for every 1 Tatura Milk RP Share that you hold.
Bega Cheese was admitted to the official list of ASX on 16 August 2011 and Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares commenced trading on ASX on 19 August 2011. The volume weighted average price of Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares sold on ASX over the period from the date the Merger was announced (4 October 2011) to the day before the date of this scheme booklet was $1.70.
Based on this volume weighted average price, the consideration for each of your Tatura Milk RP Shares represents approximately $3.40 (though of course no guarantee can be given as to the market price of Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares at the time of implementation of the Scheme or any time in the future).
The Merger is proposed to be effected by a scheme of arrangement between Tatura Milk and the Tatura Milk RP Shareholders. A scheme of arrangement involves both Court approval and approval by resolution of Tatura Milk RP Shareholders voting at a meeting convened by the Court to consider the Scheme. The resolution must be passed by both a majority in number of the Tatura Milk RP Shareholders voting at the Scheme meeting and also by at least 75% of the votes cast on the resolution. The Scheme meeting is a separate class meeting of Tatura Milk RP Shareholders only. No member of the Bega Cheese Group will be permitted to vote at this meeting.
Page 10 │ Scheme booklet
In addition, because the constitution of Tatura Milk contains a 5% limit on the ownership of Tatura Milk RP Shares and prohibits the transfer of Tatura Milk RP Shares to anyone other than a Supplier, a special resolution modifying the constitution is also required to remove these restrictions and to make other consequential changes so that Bega Cheese can acquire all of the Tatura Milk RP Shares as proposed. This special resolution is to be considered at a general meeting of Tatura Milk convened by the board of directors of Tatura Milk. The general meeting is to be held on the same day as, and before, the Scheme meeting. The special resolution must be passed at the general meeting by at least 75% of the votes cast by shareholders entitled to vote on the resolution. All shareholders of Tatura Milk, including Bega Cheese as holder of the Tatura Milk Ordinary Shares, who would normally be entitled to attend and vote at a general meeting of Tatura Milk, will be entitled to attend the general meeting and vote on the special resolution. Bega Cheese is obliged under the terms of the Merger Implementation Agreement to vote in favour of the special resolution to modify the constitution.
In simple terms, the Merger would result from the completion of the following remaining steps:
-
(a) Tatura Milk shareholders voting to modify the constitution of Tatura Milk at the general meeting;
-
(b) Tatura Milk RP Shareholders voting to approve the Scheme at the Scheme meeting;
-
(c) the Court approving the Scheme and a copy of the Court’s order being lodged with ASIC; and
-
(d) with effect on the Implementation Date, pursuant to the terms of the Scheme of Arrangement Deed:
-
(1) all Tatura Milk RP Shares held by Tatura Milk RP Shareholders being transferred to Bega Cheese;
-
(2) Bega Cheese issuing to each Tatura Milk RP Shareholder 2 Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares for every 1 Tatura Milk RP Share held by the Tatura Milk RP Shareholder at 9:00 am on the Implementation Date; and
-
(3) thereby, Tatura Milk becoming a wholly-owned subsidiary of Bega Cheese and Tatura Milk RP Shareholders becoming the holders of approximately 24 million Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares which immediately after the issue of those shares would represent approximately 15.9% of the expanded share capital (and rights convertible in share capital) of Bega Cheese (assuming no other Bega Cheese securities are issued after the date of this scheme booklet).
1.3 Reason for Merger
The Merger represents the fulfilment of the relationship between Bega Cheese and Tatura Milk, which began with Bega Cheese’s investment in Tatura Milk in 2007. At that time, Tatura Milk found itself facing challenging issues such as high debt levels, pressure on earnings, decreased milk supply due to drought and the rationalisation of other dairy industry participants. In response to these difficult circumstances, the directors and shareholders of Tatura Milk endorsed the acquisition by Bega Cheese of a 70%
Scheme booklet │ Page 11
shareholding in the company, on the basis that Bega Cheese’s investment would enable Tatura Milk:
-
(a) to make substantial distributions to Tatura Milk RP Shareholders;
-
(b) to access the financial and dairy industry expertise of Bega Cheese as the company’s new majority shareholder; and
-
(c) to develop synergies from working with Bega Cheese, including benefits flowing from increased management depth and business development opportunities.
Since the commencement of their relationship in 2007, the businesses of both Tatura Milk and Bega Cheese have strengthened and developed. Tatura Milk has regained its reputation as a significant and respected participant in the dairy industry. This has been achieved through the establishment of a sound strategic plan, which has resulted in improved customer engagement, more stable revenues and margins and a strengthened management team. Bega Cheese has grown substantially during that same period, culminating with its ASX listing in August 2011, to become Australia’s largest ASX listed dairy company.
The Merger will enable Tatura Milk RP Shareholders to convert their A class redeemable preference shares in Tatura Milk to ordinary shares in Bega Cheese, which will be tradable on ASX. This will allow the Tatura Milk RP Shareholders to participate in the growth and dividends of the Bega Cheese Group and provide them with the individual opportunity either to sell or hold their Bega Cheese shares or to buy more shares in Bega Cheese, depending on their personal investment goals. As milk suppliers, Tatura Milk RP Shareholders will continue to be able to sell their milk to Tatura Milk, and Bega Cheese has stated that it will continue to support Tatura Milk, endeavouring to pay a leading manufacturing price for milk in order to maintain a sustainable and reliable supply of milk from dairy farmers in Northern Victoria.
From a business perspective, the Merger will enable a more complete integration of the businesses of Tatura Milk and Bega Cheese. This will allow a fuller combination of the strengths of both companies, to produce an even stronger consolidated Bega Cheese Group.
1.4 Dividends
No further dividends may be paid in respect of your Tatura Milk RP Shares before the Implementation Date without the approval of Bega Cheese (which is not expected).
If the Merger is effected before 31 January 2012 as planned, as the holder of Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares issued to you under the Scheme, you will be entitled to participate in any dividend on the Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares that is declared or paid after that date in respect of the financial performance of Bega Cheese for the second half of 2011.
However, if implementation of the Merger is delayed until after 31 January 2012, and the Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares under the Scheme are not issued to you until after the record date for a Bega Cheese dividend, you will have no right to participate in the dividend.
Page 12 │ Scheme booklet
1.5 Independent expert report
Tatura Milk has engaged an independent expert, Value Adviser Associates Pty Ltd, to prepare a report on the proposed Scheme. A copy of the report is set out in this scheme booklet starting at page 105. The independent expert has concluded that the proposed Scheme is in the best interests of Tatura Milk RP Shareholders.
It is worth noting that the independent expert has valued a Tatura Milk RP Share at between $3.05 and $3.78 and 2 Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares at between $3.40 and $3.58. Accordingly, the consideration under the proposed Scheme of 2 Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares for every 1 Tatura Milk RP Share is within this valuation range.
1.6 Directors’ recommendations
Your Dairy Farmer Supplier Directors
Having considered the terms of the Scheme and the other aspects of the Merger, and having considered the limited alternatives to the proposal (see section 2.3 of this scheme booklet), each of your Dairy Farmer Supplier Directors desires to make and considers himself justified in making a recommendation in relation to the Merger.
Each of your Dairy Farmer Supplier Directors:
-
(a) considers that the Merger is in the best interests of the Tatura Milk RP Shareholders;
-
(b) recommends acceptance of the Scheme; and
-
(c) recommends that Tatura Milk RP Shareholders vote in favour of all resolutions to approve the Scheme or otherwise to facilitate the Merger;
in the absence of a superior proposal.
The reasons of your Dairy Farmer Supplier Directors for so recommending are set out in this scheme booklet – in particular see the letter from the deputy chairman starting on page 4 and section 1.3 for more details.
Bega Cheese Nominees
Each other director of Tatura Milk is a Bega Cheese Nominee and was appointed by Bega Cheese in accordance with the constitution of Tatura Milk. Each Bega Cheese Nominee is also a director or senior executive of Bega Cheese. In view of this conflict of interest, each Bega Cheese Nominee does not consider it appropriate for him to make a recommendation in relation to acceptance of the Merger and does not do so.
Personal voting intentions
The interests of the directors of Tatura Milk in relation to the Merger are set out in section 9.3 of this scheme booklet.
Scheme booklet │ Page 13
All of your Tatura Milk directors who own or otherwise have a relevant interest in Tatura Milk RP Shares themselves, intend to vote, or procure the relevant Tatura Milk RP Shareholder to vote, in favour of the Scheme, in the absence of a superior proposal.
Page 14 │ Scheme booklet
2. Advantages, disadvantages and alternatives
2.1 Advantages of the Merger
The following are reasons why you may choose to vote in favour of the Merger.
- (a) Your Dairy Farmer Supplier Directors and the independent expert believe that the Merger is in the best interests of Tatura Milk RP Shareholders
The Merger consideration of 2 Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares for 1 Tatura Milk RP Share is considered to reflect a premium for control.
The volume weighted average price of Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares sold on ASX over the period from the date the Merger was announced (4 October 2011) to the day before the date of this scheme booklet was $1.70. Based on this volume weighted average price, the Scheme consideration of 2 Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares for 1 Tatura Milk RP Share values the Tatura Milk RP Shares at $3.40 each. This is a significant uplift on the amount that would be payable were the shares redeemed, namely $1 for each share, and is around the middle of the independent expert’s valuation range for a Tatura Milk RP Share of $3.05 to $3.78 – see the independent expert report starting on page 105.
- (b) The Merger provides Tatura Milk RP Shareholders with an opportunity to realise market value for their Tatura Milk RP Shares.
The Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares that Tatura Milk RP Shareholders will receive under the Merger will be quoted on ASX and therefore tradeable (subject to demand and supply) with an established market value, and will be generally free of any restrictions on sale. In contrast, it is difficult for Tatura Milk RP Shareholders to access the market value of their Tatura Milk RP Shares under the present capital structure of Tatura Milk, given that Tatura Milk RP Shares are not quoted on any stock exchange, they may only be sold to other Suppliers and they may be redeemed for the amount paid up on the shares (i.e. $1 each) if the holder ceases to supply milk to Tatura Milk. Accordingly, Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares should provide a more liquid investment than your Tatura Milk RP Shares by being more readily saleable at a price reflecting market value.
If you become a shareholder in Bega Cheese, you will be able to identify the market value of your investment in the Bega Cheese Group. You will also be in a position to make your own individual decisions as to whether to retain your Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares, utilise them as security for borrowings, sell some or all of them or buy additional shares.
- (c) Investment in the broader Bega Cheese Group
Bega Cheese is a substantial Australian dairy company and an investment in Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares will allow you to participate in the future growth of the broader Bega Cheese Group. Your Dairy Farmer Supplier Directors believe that further consolidation and corporate activity is likely to occur in the Australian dairy industry and that Bega Cheese appears to be well placed to take advantage of any appropriate investment or rationalisation opportunities that arise.
Scheme booklet │ Page 15
- (d) Continuation of milk supply arrangements
The Merger will not interrupt the relationship between Tatura Milk and Tatura Milk RP Shareholders as milk suppliers to Tatura Milk. There will be a seamless continuity of the current practices and policies in relation to milk acquisition and farm services.
- (e) Milk pricing
The Bega Cheese Group relies on ongoing milk supply from its farmer suppliers. The price paid to farmer suppliers for their milk is a key factor in being able to attract and retain supply. Bega Cheese recognises that the Tatura Milk business requires a substantial and reliable supply of milk and accordingly, has stated that it is committed to maintaining a base of dairy milk farmer suppliers to Tatura Milk in Northern Victoria. In order to ensure that the milk supply base remains in place, Bega Cheese recognises that Tatura Milk will need to continue to pay a leading manufacturing price for milk supplied to it by farmer suppliers in accordance with the Bega Cheese Group milk price policy – see page 48.
Following the Merger, Tatura Milk RP Shareholders will cease to be entitled to any dividends based on their milk supplies to Tatura Milk. However, it is expected that the total price paid for Dairy Farmer Suppliers’ milk supplied to Tatura Milk under their milk supply arrangements will take account of any milk supply dividend that they would otherwise have received as Tatura Milk RP Shareholders.
- (f) No redemption if you cease to be a Supplier
Tatura Milk RP Shareholders will no longer need to remain a Supplier in order to retain their investment. Currently, only Suppliers can hold Tatura Milk RP Shares and the Tatura Milk board has the right to redeem your Tatura Milk RP Shares for $1 each if you cease to be a Supplier. However whether you remain a Supplier will not impact your ability to hold Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares. This may give some Tatura Milk RP Shareholders more flexibility in their dairy farm succession planning.
- (g) Tatura Milk RP Shareholders aggregate holding in Bega Cheese
Upon the successful implementation of the Merger, Tatura Milk RP Shareholders will be issued with Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares representing approximately 15.9% in aggregate of the expanded share capital (and rights convertible into share capital) of Bega Cheese. Therefore, at least initially, Tatura Milk RP Shareholders will have a significant, aggregate holding in Bega Cheese.
- (h) Impact of the consolidated Bega Cheese Group
An investment in Tatura Milk RP Shares is limited to the rights and benefits that result from Tatura Milk’s operations. An investment in Bega Cheese allows for greater diversification into the dairy and food processing industries. This could have a positive impact on the return on your investment if the non-Tatura Milk business of the Bega Cheese Group outperforms the Tatura Milk business.
Page 16 │ Scheme booklet
- (i) Commitment to maintain Tatura Milk operations in Tatura
Bega Cheese has stated that it intends to continue to conduct the key business operations of Tatura Milk from the facilities at Tatura and to support and foster the success of the Tatura Milk business and the use of the Tatura brand in that business.
- (j) Tatura Milk supplier representation on Bega Cheese board
Under the terms of the Bega Cheese constitution, for the first 2 years after the Merger, the board of directors of Bega Cheese must include 2 representatives of Tatura Milk Dairy Farmer Suppliers. To initially meet this requirement, Bega Cheese has agreed to appoint 2 of the Dairy Farmer Supplier Directors to the Bega Cheese board upon implementation of the Merger – refer to sections 3.7 and 7.7.
In addition, even after the first 2 years following the Merger, dairy farmers who supply milk to Tatura Milk will be eligible for election to the 4 positions on the Bega Cheese board reserved for Bega Cheese Dairy Farmer Suppliers.
- (k) Additional synergies to the Bega Cheese Group
Although a number of strategy, personnel and corporate activities have already been integrated between Tatura Milk and Bega Cheese since Bega Cheese acquired its controlling stake in Tatura Milk in 2007, the Merger is likely to result in full integration of the Tatura Milk operations with that of Bega Cheese and accordingly, should result in additional synergy benefits to the Bega Cheese Group, thereby benefiting all shareholders of Bega Cheese.
2.2 Disadvantages of the Merger
The following are reasons why you may choose to vote against the Merger.
- (a) Not all Bega Cheese shareholders are milk suppliers
Ownership of Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares is not limited to milk suppliers. You may consider that this move away from the co-operative style business, as was the historical position for both Bega Cheese and Tatura Milk, could result in a focus on shareholder returns to the detriment of the interests of Dairy Farmer Suppliers and/or Industrial Suppliers.
- (b) Impact on milk pricing and regional focus
As there will be no change in contractual milk supply arrangements between Tatura Milk and its Suppliers in consequence of the Merger (including the way in which Tatura Milk sets its milk pricing), the Merger does not, in itself, represent an opportunity for Suppliers to obtain a higher price for their milk supply.
On the other hand, despite the stated intention of Bega Cheese to continue to pay leading regional milk prices to its milk suppliers and to maintain a base in Tatura, the Merger may have the impact of diluting the influence of Tatura Suppliers on the Tatura Milk business (even though Dairy Farmer Suppliers will have continued representation rights at the Bega Cheese board level for some time following the
Scheme booklet │ Page 17
Merger) and may result in a reduced focus by the Bega Cheese Group on regional issues specific to Northern Victoria.
It is also possible that new or changed circumstances could occur in the future that result in Bega Cheese changing its stated intentions in relation to milk pricing or continuing the conduct of the key business operations at Tatura Milk to the detriment of Dairy Farmer Suppliers and/or Industrial Suppliers.
- (c) The share price of Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares is subject to market factors
Under the Merger you will receive Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares. Those shares are not redeemable and your ability to realise the market value of Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares is largely dependent on the price at which these shares are traded on ASX. As with all investments in securities, there is no guarantee as to the future performance of Bega Cheese or the Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares.
Further, although Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares are quoted on ASX and are generally free of any restrictions on sale, under Bega Cheese’s constitution there is a shareholding limit of 5% for the first 2 years from the date Bega Cheese listed on ASX, increasing to 10% for the following 3 years. The shareholding limit may also be renewed for another 5 years at 15% – see section 8.7 for more details. The existence of a shareholding limit is unusual for a listed company and may adversely affect the value ascribed to Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares. The full value of the Bega Cheese Group may also not be reflected in the prevailing market price of Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares due to other external market factors.
In addition, Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares have had limited trading history on ASX. Although to date there has been some trading volumes, it is possible that over the long term, the value of a Bega Cheese Ordinary Share may decline due to insufficient volumes of shares traded on ASX.
- (d) You will no longer be a Tatura Milk RP Shareholder
You will no longer have a direct investment in Tatura Milk or have a right to vote at meetings of shareholders of Tatura Milk. Tatura Milk RP Shareholders will therefore cease to have the degree of direct influence over the affairs of Tatura Milk that they currently have as holders of Tatura Milk RP Shares, and will no longer be able to have their Tatura Milk RP Shares redeemed for $1 each.
Further, as a holder of Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares, you will no longer have the special milk supply dividend right and other entitlements that attach to your Tatura Milk RP Shares – see section 3.2 for more details.
- (e) Impact of the consolidated Bega Cheese Group
As your investment will be in the broader Bega Cheese Group, your investment is more diversified across the Bega Cheese Group businesses. This could have a negative impact on the return on your investment if the non-Tatura Milk business of the Bega Cheese Group underperforms as compared to the Tatura Milk business and this may impact future dividends.
Page 18 │ Scheme booklet
- (f) Change to the Bega Cheese constitution
Although the Bega Cheese constitution currently provides for Tatura Milk Dairy Farmer Supplier representation on the Bega Cheese board for 2 years after the Merger and that dairy farmers who supply milk to Tatura Milk will be eligible for election to the 4 positions on the Bega Cheese board reserved for Bega Cheese Dairy Farmer Suppliers, it is possible that the Bega Cheese constitution may be modified (by special resolution passed by Bega Cheese shareholders) to remove this representation right.
2.3 Alternative courses of action for Tatura Milk
Your Dairy Farmer Supplier Directors consider that as far as the interests of Tatura Milk RP Shareholders are concerned, the proposed Merger is superior to any other possible alternatives that Tatura Milk could pursue:
- (a) Alternative merger proposals
The Merger Implementation Agreement between Bega Cheese and Tatura Milk does not prevent a third party from making an alternative proposal or Tatura Milk sourcing other options or offers. However the proposed Merger has been widely publicised since the issue of the Bega Cheese Prospectus in July 2011 and no alternative proposal has emerged.
Given the time period that has elapsed since Bega Cheese publicised its intention to seek the Merger in the Bega Cheese Prospectus and the fact that Bega Cheese currently holds approximately 70% of Tatura Milk shares, it is the view of the Dairy Farmer Supplier Directors that an alternative proposal is unlikely to emerge or be feasible.
- (b) Continue the present business operations of Tatura Milk
The Dairy Farmer Supplier Directors consider that maintaining the status quo remains in the short term a viable option. However, as the business needs grow and in particular, funding of major capital expenditure requirements comes up for consideration, it is likely that there will be a need for a mixture of debt and equity. Accordingly, over the long term it is the Dairy Farmer Supplier Directors’ opinion that these capital expenditure demands will necessitate a strategy for fund raising in the future. Accordingly, it is unlikely that the current ownership structure of Tatura Milk will be viable in the long term.
(c) Other corporate activity
Given that Bega Cheese already owns approximately 70% of Tatura Milk and the level of contribution that Tatura Milk makes to the Bega Cheese Group profits, a listing, sale or winding up of Tatura Milk is considered to be a highly unlikely option.
Scheme booklet │ Page 19
3. What the Merger means for Tatura Milk RP Shareholders
3.1 Consideration
If the Merger is implemented, you will receive 2 Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares for every 1 of your Tatura Milk RP Shares that you hold at 9:00 am on the Implementation Date.
The Merger consideration and all other terms of the Merger were negotiated with Bega Cheese by your Dairy Farmer Supplier Directors on behalf of Tatura Milk with the benefit of financial and legal advice.
The independent expert has also made an assessment of the Merger consideration, and the respective value of a Tatura Milk RP Share and Bega Cheese Ordinary Share for this purpose, and has concluded that the exchange ratio of 2 Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares for 1 Tatura Milk RP Share is fair and reasonable from the perspective of Tatura Milk RP Shareholders – see the independent expert report starting on page 105.
3.2 Becoming a Bega Cheese shareholder
If the Merger is implemented, Tatura Milk RP Shareholders would cease to be shareholders of Tatura Milk and would become shareholders of Bega Cheese. As a consequence, Tatura Milk RP Shareholders would cease to enjoy their current rights as such shareholders which include:
-
(a) the right to attend, speak and vote at general meetings of Tatura Milk and thereby have a say in the appointment of Dairy Farmer Supplier Directors and other governance arrangements concerning Tatura Milk;
-
(b) the right to dividends from Tatura Milk either according to the number of Tatura Milk RP Shares held or the quantity of milk supplied to Tatura Milk;
-
(c) the right to have their Tatura Milk RP Shares redeemed; and
-
(d) in the case of Dairy Farmer Suppliers, the right to subscribe for additional Tatura Milk RP Shares under the Tatura Milk subscription scheme based on their milk supplies to Tatura Milk.
See section 5.7 of this scheme booklet for further details of these benefits.
By becoming a shareholder of Bega Cheese, Tatura Milk RP Shareholders would acquire rights as the holders of Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares with respect to Bega Cheese under its constitution. They would not, however, be entitled to receive dividends or to subscribe for additional Bega Cheese shares based on their milk supplies or to have their shares redeemed. Further details regarding the rights of holders of Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares under Bega Cheese’s constitution are set out in section 8.
3.3 Contractual and other supply arrangements
There would be no change to the contractual arrangements between Tatura Milk RP Shareholders and Tatura Milk for the supply of milk and other dairy commodities, in consequence of the Merger.
Page 20 │ Scheme booklet
In fact, subject to regulatory requirements and good business practice, Bega Cheese does not expect any material changes to occur regarding how Tatura Milk RP Shareholders as suppliers currently interact with Tatura Milk and how they would interact with Tatura Milk as a wholly-owned subsidiary of Bega Cheese after the Merger.
3.4 Milk pricing
Bega Cheese recognises that the Tatura Milk business requires a substantial and reliable supply of milk and, accordingly, is committed to maintaining a base of dairy farmer milk suppliers to Tatura Milk in Northern Victoria. Bega Cheese recognises that, in order to ensure that this milk supply base remains in place following the Merger, Tatura Milk will have to continue to pay a leading manufacturing price for milk supplied to it by dairy farmers in Northern Victoria.
3.5 Location of Tatura Milk business
Following the Merger, Bega Cheese intends to continue the key business operations of Tatura Milk from the company’s facilities at Tatura, Victoria. Bega Cheese also intends to continue to support and foster the success of the Tatura Milk business and the use of the Tatura brand in that business.
3.6 Dairy Farmer Supplier Directors will cease to hold office
If the Merger is implemented, all of your Dairy Farmer Supplier Directors will cease as directors of Tatura Milk. As a consequence, the Tatura Milk board would be comprised of the Bega Cheese Nominees (and/or any other directors appointed by Bega Cheese, who are expected to be from the directors and executives of the Bega Cheese Group).
3.7 Representation on the Bega Cheese board
Bega Cheese has agreed that it will use its best endeavours to ensure that 2 individuals who are, or represent bodies corporate that are, Tatura Milk Dairy Farmer Suppliers are on the Bega Cheese board for 2 years from the Implementation Date. In accordance with this commitment, Bega Cheese intends to appoint 2 of your Dairy Farmer Supplier Directors as directors of Bega Cheese by the Implementation Date.
All 4 of the Dairy Farmer Supplier Directors have nominated for these 2 board positions, and have agreed to have a ballot for the selection of 2 of them to be voted on by Tatura Milk RP Shareholders only. This ballot is planned to be conducted at the general meeting of Tatura Milk to be held on the same day as the Scheme meeting.
3.8 Sale facility for Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares
Bega Cheese has agreed to use its best endeavours to establish an arrangement with a stock broker to enable Tatura Milk RP Shareholders to trade in the Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares issued to them under the Scheme on market at prevailing market prices within a period of 3 months following the Implementation Date. Once the Merger is implemented, Bega Cheese will write to each Tatura Milk RP Shareholder who acquires Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares under the Scheme with further details of this arrangement.
Scheme booklet │ Page 21
3.9 Otherwise business as usual
As Tatura Milk has been operating as a 70% controlled subsidiary of Bega Cheese since 2007, the companies have already combined those functions involved in setting overall planning and control of their respective businesses and operations, with a view to eliminating duplication of tasks, and reducing cost. Both companies’ structures and operations have also been regularly reviewed with a view to identifying the business units which may be combined, improved, further developed or disposed of, and where appropriate, operations have been rationalised or other review outcomes have been implemented.
In the circumstances, other than set out in this section 3, it is the present intention of the directors of Bega Cheese and those Tatura Milk directors who would continue as directors of Tatura Milk or become a director of Bega Cheese:
-
(a) to continue, grow and improve the business of Tatura Milk;
-
(b) not to make any major change to the nature of the business of Tatura Milk, including any redeployment of the fixed assets of Tatura Milk; and
-
(c) to continue the employment of the present employees of Tatura Milk.
-
All directors of Tatura Milk support these intentions.
Page 22 │ Scheme booklet
4. Industry developments
4.1 Overview
This section 4 has been prepared by Bega Cheese by reference to its own information as well as to information and statistics provided by Dairy Australia in its publications, specifically ‘Dairy 2011 (September) – Situation and Outlook’ and ‘Australian Dairy Industry In Focus 2010’. Extracts that have been drawn from Dairy Australia publications relate to the Australian dairy industry as a whole and not specifically to the Bega Cheese Group. Tatura Milk, which operates in the same industry as Bega Cheese, agrees with Bega Cheese’s comments and observations on the industry as outlined in this section 4. This section should be read in conjunction with sections 5.11 and 6.17, which include various industry and company specific risk factors relevant to Tatura Milk and Bega Cheese respectively.
The dairy industry encompasses businesses ranging from dairy farms through to food manufacturers. Cow’s milk consists of solids (milk fat, protein, lactose and minerals) in water, with water making up about 87% of the volume.
Milk produced by farmers is processed into products including fresh milk, cheese, butter, cream, yoghurts, custards and milk powders. In addition, certain products comprise the nutritional components of milk such as lactoferrin and colostrum or by-products such as whey and permeate.
In general, the industry tends to be categorised into two sectors. The first is the ‘market’ or ‘liquid’ milk sector that produces fresh drinking milk for immediate domestic consumption. The second is the ‘manufacturing’ milk sector which further processes the milk into various dairy commodities and value-added products including cheese, butter, yoghurt and milk powders. The importance of this distinction is that the price paid for market milk, particularly in NSW and Queensland, is based on local demand for drinking milk on a year round basis, while the price paid for manufacturing milk tends to be based on returns from international dairy commodity prices (translated into Australian dollars). This reflects the fact that products such as cheese, milk powders and butter are global commodity items and prices received are based on international prices.
Bega Cheese and Tatura Milk are primarily manufacturing milk entities, although Bega Cheese has a minor involvement in the liquid milk market through its 25% interest in Capitol Chilled Foods (Australia) Pty Limited.
Australia
The overall product output of the Australian dairy industry is as follows:
Scheme booklet │ Page 23
Australia’s dairy industry is one of its three most important domestic rural industries ranking behind the beef and wheat industries. The estimated farm gate value of the dairy industry in 2009/10 was $3.4 billion.
Features of the Australian dairy industry include the following:
-
(a) In FY2011, 1.6 million cows on just over 7,500 farms produced 9.1 billion litres of milk, an increase of around 1% on milk production in FY2010.
-
(b) Recent low volumes and intense competition at both the supply and retail level has resulted in ongoing rationalisation in the number of dairy processors and manufacturers.
-
(c) 64% of Australia’s milk is produced in Victoria.
-
(d) 45% of milk production is now converted into products that are exported overseas as opposed to 31% in 1990. Australia’s major export destinations by value in 2009/2010 included Japan (19%), China (10%), Singapore (9%) and Indonesia (6%).
-
(e) The Australian dairy manufacturing sector is diverse including farmer-owned cooperatives as well as public, private and multinational companies. Industry estimates are that six major milk buyers acquire circa 90% of all milk production. The Bega Cheese Group’s total milk intake in FY2011 was 591.3 million litres which equates to approximately 6% of the total Australian milk production.
-
(f) Per capita consumption of dairy products has remained relatively stable over the past decade.
The Bega Cheese Group’s business model is focused on both conversion of milk into value added dairy products and the value adding of dairy ingredients. While the Bega Cheese group manages a relatively small percentage of Australia’s raw milk, it is a significant packager and value adder of cheese and other dairy products in Australia.
Page 24 │ Scheme booklet
Global
The international dairy trade is of considerable importance to the Australian dairy industry. Dairy product exports account for nearly half of total milk production. The price of milk received by farmers in the domestic market is linked to export returns and the relative value of the Australian dollar to the US dollar.
Features of the global dairy industry include:
-
(a) Most countries in the world have a local milk production capacity. In many countries, including large Australian dairy export destinations such as the Middle East and Asia, dairy production falls significantly short of demand. These countries supplement their local production with imported dairy products.
-
(b) The European Union and USA account for 26% and 16% respectively of world cows’ milk output, compared to Australia which produces 2%.
-
(c) Most dairy products are consumed in the country in which they are produced, with less than 8% of global production traded on international markets.
-
(d) Global dairy exports are dominated by New Zealand (35% of all export sales), the European Union (32% of all export sales) and Australia (10% of all export sales).
-
(e) Significant trade barriers exist in many countries.
-
(f) Milk production has been relatively stable in Western countries but has increased steadily in Asia and Central and South America.
-
(g) Consumption of dairy products in Western countries is relatively stable while dairy consumption in Asia and Central and South America is increasing rapidly. Infant formula is an important part of this demand.
4.2 Government regulation of the dairy industry
Australia
Major changes to the structure of the dairy industry occurred in July 2000 with the removal of all production and sale quantity price regulation, including official distinctions between market milk and manufacturing milk. As a result, Australian dairy farmers now operate in a deregulated and open market with the main government involvement being the administration of food standards and food safety assurance systems. Deregulation has resulted in intense competition between processors in the market milk sector.
Domestic and international market circumstances combined with regional milk supply availability are now the only drivers for the price received by farmers for their milk. Manufacturers and processors of dairy foods now derive their earnings from revenue generated by the sale of their products without any government support or payments.
Scheme booklet │ Page 25
Global
The international trade in dairy produce is distorted by tariff and non-tariff protection by the major producing and consuming countries including the USA, Japan and countries within the European Union.
Some significant trade barriers include:
-
(a) USA – direct bilateral quota arrangements restrict Australian imports
-
(b) European Union – direct bilateral quota arrangements restrict Australian imports
-
(c) Japan – quotas on Australian cheese and skim milk powder
-
(d) China – tariffs exist but there are no quotas
Australia does apply some tariffs on imports of dairy products.
4.3 Current market conditions
The decade commencing January 2000 has been heavily influenced by drought conditions throughout Australia which has resulted in lower cattle numbers and a reduction in milk supply.
In FY2008, market conditions (especially prices for commodity products) improved dramatically as a result of strong global demand. However, FY2009 was impacted by the world wide downturn associated with the global financial crisis. FY2010 saw a significantly improved turn around in operating conditions for the Australian dairy industry. Strengthening global economic conditions following the global financial crisis underpinned demand growth in key markets, while reduced international supplies saw dairy commodity prices rise in US dollar terms throughout 2010 and into early 2011. More recently, international dairy commodity prices have softened with increasing supplies from Latin America and New Zealand and production growth in the United States and the European Union. This downward trend may continue if the current global economic instability resulting from Eurozone sovereign debt issues deteriorates further.
On-farm milk production in late 2010 and early 2011 was impacted by wet conditions and in some regions substantial floods. While this had a short term impact on milk production, generally the improved water supplies facilitated a reasonable finish to the FY2011 milk season especially in the south-eastern regions. Milk production in the first quarter of FY2012 has started slowly due to very wet conditions in Southern Victoria, farms continuing to recover from floods in Queensland and continued drought in Western Australia. Production is anticipated to increase throughout the year as a result of solid home-grown feedbases and guaranteed access to water.
The high Australian dollar continues to constrain returns to exporters but strong global demand for dairy products continues, particularly from China, Asia and the Middle East China’s total volume of dairy product imported in 2010 was estimated at US$30 billion, up 61% from the prior year.
Page 26 │ Scheme booklet
==> picture [431 x 207] intentionally omitted <==
----- Start of picture text -----
Historical dairy commodity prices June 1991 - May 2011
7,000
6,000
5,000
4,000 Butter
$A/t Cheddar
3,000
Skim milk powder
Whole milk powder
2,000
1,000
-
Jan-90Oct-90Jul-91Apr-92Jan-93Oct-93Jul-94Apr-95Jan-96Oct-96Jul-97Apr-98Jan-99Oct-99Jul-00Apr-01Jan-02Oct-02Jul-03Apr-04Jan-05Oct-05Jul-06Apr-07Jan-08Oct-08Jul-09Apr-10Jan-11
----- End of picture text -----
Domestically the recent action by major retailers to cut the retail selling price of private label milk, butter and cream as part of a wider strategic market play has received substantial media attention and resulted in an enquiry by the Australian Parliament. There is no immediate material impact on Bega Cheese (or Tatura Milk) or farmer suppliers as a result of this action. The medium to long term implications however are still not clear.
4.4 Industry outlook
Industry fundamentals remain sound at present, with advantageous climatic conditions, particularly in Southern Australia, leading to a favourable seasonal outlook. However, downside risks exist particularly around continued instability in the global economy. Longer term, there are a number of unknowns which may affect the industry, including:
-
(a) short term currency volatility
-
(b) impact of food price inflation in China and India
-
(c) political unrest in the Middle East
-
(d) USA Farm Bill that provides assistance to US farmers is due for renewal in 2012
-
(e) recovery of regional areas form the impact of recent droughts and floods
Milk production is expected to increase approximately 1.5% to around 9.25 billion litres in 2012 and global demand is predicted to remain strong, underpinned by the Chinese economy continuing to grow rapidly. Global dairy commodity prices are stabilising after recently falling from their peaks.
The late 2008 acquisition of Dairy Farmers by Lion Nathan National Foods a member of the Kirin Group, was the most recent significant corporate consolidation in the Australian dairy sector. In November 2010, Bega Cheese acquired a 15% interest in WCB. Fonterra sold its Brownes business to a private equity company in early 2011. Lion Nathan National Foods has also announced a rationalisation of its Australian cheese making facilities.
Scheme booklet │ Page 27
5. Information on Tatura Milk
5.1 Overview
Tatura Milk conducts a successful dairy products business with a long history of operating in Victoria’s Goulburn Valley.
The company is located at Tatura, Victoria and manufactures dairy products such as milk powder and cream cheese and nutritional food products such as infant formula. The products are sold locally and exported internationally.
Tatura Milk is currently supplied with milk from approximately 270 professional dairy farms. The majority of these dairy farms are located within a 60 kilometre radius of the Tatura factory. Tatura Milk currently processes approximately 350 to 400 million litres of milk each year that produces approximately 62,000 to 72,000 tonnes of manufactured products each year.
5.2 History
Tatura Milk traces its origins to Tatura Butter Factory and Farmers Produce Company Ltd which was established in 1907. Significant events in the history of the company are noted below:
| Year | Milestone |
|---|---|
| 1907 | Tatura Butter Factory and Farmers Produce Company Ltd is founded |
| 1952 | Merchandise store opens to cater for rural supply needs |
| 1980 | Tatura Cheese Industries Pty Ltd established to produce 2,000 tonnes of |
| cream cheese per annum for the domestic and export markets | |
| 1986 | Corporate reorganisation resulting in Tatura Milk owning and |
| controlling all of the group’s operations | |
| 1991 | Technology exchange contract signed with Snow Brand Australia |
| 1993 | Snow Brand Australia, a customer of Tatura Milk, builds a $25 million |
| infant formula canning plant adjacent to the company’s factory | |
| 1996 | $20 million plant expansion, including the installation of a new dryer |
| and evaporator capable of producing 5 tonnes of powder per hour as | |
| well as a new 12 tonne per hour packer | |
| 2001 | New drying plant commissioned at a cost of $34 million with the |
| capacity to produce 30,000 metric tonnes (mt) each year of fortified and | |
| high fat powders | |
| 2003 | New lactoferrin plant built at a cost of $8.5 million with the capacity to |
| produce 12 mt of lactoferrin each year. |
Page 28 │ Scheme booklet
Year Milestone
2005 Construction of milk protein concentrate plant in conjunction with Ingredia
2007 Bega Cheese acquires a 70% shareholding in Tatura Milk
5.3 Current operations
Tatura Milk principally conducts its business from its manufacturing facility at Tatura, Victoria. The business has two divisions – core dairy products manufacturing and nutritional food products manufacturing.
Core dairy products manufacturing
Tatura Milk is a business-to-business dairy food manufacturer, that is, it supplies dairy products to other food companies on a wholesale basis. Milk is converted into a range of core dairy products, including cream cheese, high fat frozen cream, whole milk powder, skim milk powder, milk protein isolate and butter. Tatura Milk conducts a sales and marketing operation separate from Bega Cheese and has been active for many years in the Asian markets.
The cream cheese and high fat dairy products produced at Tatura Milk are used in the production of cheesecakes and other food and drink products in Asia. Some of Tatura Milk’s customers are major international food, dairy product and trading companies. Over 65% of Tatura Milk FY2011 revenue was from exports, primarily to Asian markets.
Milk protein isolate is produced as a spray-dried powder containing 85% milk protein and is used as a dairy ingredient in desserts, baked goods, toppings, low-fat spreads, dairy based mixes, beverages and processed cheese products. It is produced by Tatura Milk in one of its driers which incorporates plant and know-how provided under lease and licence arrangements by a French company, Ingredia SA. Ingredia SA is also Tatura Milk’s largest customer for milk protein isolate and its relationship with Tatura Milk is documented in a series of agreements relating to the manufacture, supply and sale of milk protein isolate products.
In addition, Tatura Milk produces approximately 20,000 tonnes a year of commodity type milk powders. The majority of this production is exported to Asian markets.
Nutritional food products manufacturing
Infant formula
Tatura Milk produces high value nutritional products such as formula for infants and children, and lactoferrin. While milk is sourced locally, the production of infant and other formula products is not substantially dependent on local milk supply.
Tatura Milk has been manufacturing infant and other formula products for customers since 1993 and has developed supply arrangements with companies in Australia, Japan, China, Korea and Taiwan. Some of the formulations that have been developed in
Scheme booklet │ Page 29
conjunction with these companies are complex and manufactured to very tight quality specifications.
Tatura Milk operates within a strict quality environment monitoring and evaluating the quality of product from the farm through to the final product delivered to customers. Raw materials are sourced from a number of suppliers and blended to exacting specifications. Australian product has a high reputation in the Asian markets for its quality and safe use for infants.
Products currently manufactured include:
-
(a) infant formula – stage 1 for 0-6 month old infants
-
(b) follow-on formula – stage 2 for 6-12 month old infants
-
(c) growing-up milk powder – stage 3 for 12-24 month old toddlers
Tatura Milk’s current production capability comprises wet-mix dry ingredient addition and two multi-stage driers. In FY2010, Tatura Milk produced nearly 20,000 tonnes of infant and other formula product. Tatura Milk supplies these products in bags ranging from 25kg up to bulk bags of approximately 800kg. Tatura Milk can also arrange for formula products to be supplied in retail-ready cans through third party canning service providers.
An important part of Tatura Milk’s production of nutritional formula products takes place under a long term agreement with Mead Johnson, a global leader in infant and children’s nutrition. Under this agreement, Tatura Milk allocates one of its two multi-stage driers and provides the staff and site services required to enable Mead Johnson to produce nutritional powder.
Lactoferrin
Lactoferrin is a significant milk biologic product that brings to food markets unique health and nutritional features of milk.
Lactoferrin is a freeze-dried protein purified directly from premium quality milk. As well as being necessary for normal growth of intestinal cells, lactoferrin functions as an antioxidant in iron mediated oxidation reactions and as an anti-inflammatory agent. Tatura Milk uses advanced ion-exchange technology producing lactoferrin that is of the highest purity. Lactoferrin is used in a range of applications including infant formulas, adult nutritional powders and drinks, yoghurts and sports formulations.
5.4 Board of directors
As at the date of this scheme booklet, the Tatura Milk board comprises:
| Name | Status |
|---|---|
| BarryIrvin AM | Chairman and Bega Cheese Nominee |
| Richard Parbery | Bega Cheese Nominee |
Page 30 │ Scheme booklet
| Name | Status |
|---|---|
| Colin Griffin | Bega Cheese Nominee |
| Aidan Coleman | Bega Cheese Nominee |
| Rick Cross | Deputychairman and DairyFarmer Supplier Director |
| Ken Wood | DairyFarmer Supplier Director |
| Fred De Cicco | DairyFarmer Supplier Director |
| Jeff Odgers | DairyFarmer Supplier Director |
The constitution of Tatura Milk specifies that there are to be up to 4 directors appointed by Bega Cheese, 2 Dairy Farmer Supplier Directors and up to 2 other directors as determined by the board. Currently, there are 4 Dairy Farmer Supplier Directors with the additional 2 positions having been allocated to Dairy Farmer Supplier Directors. All of the Dairy Farmer Supplier Directors are elected by the shareholders.
If the Merger is implemented, all of your Dairy Farmer Supplier Directors will cease as directors of Tatura Milk. As a consequence, the Tatura Milk board would be comprised of the Bega Cheese Nominees (and/or any other directors appointed by Bega Cheese, who are expected to be from the directors and executives of the Bega Cheese Group). All of the Bega Cheese Nominees are currently directors or senior executives of Bega Cheese and their profiles are set out in sections 6.5 and 6.6.
A summary of the relevant experience of your Dairy Farmer Supplier Directors is set out below.
Rick Cross, B.Ag Sci (Hon), AAICD Deputy chairman
Mr Cross has been a director of Tatura Milk since 2003, having spent the previous 2 years as an associate director.
Mr Cross is currently the deputy chairman of Tatura Milk and previously held that position from 2005 to 2007. During that earlier period he was heavily involved in negotiating the subscription by Bega Cheese of its 70% shareholding in Tatura Milk.
Mr Cross has represented dairy farmers at various levels within the United Dairyfarmers of Victoria and also sits on the Innovation Selection Committee for the Gardiner Foundation. In 2002, he completed the residential program run by the Australian Institute of Company Directors.
Mr Cross is an active dairy farmer and his current responsibilities at Tatura Milk include:
-
(a) Director of Tatura Milk since 2003;
-
(b) Deputy chairman from 2005 to 2007, and from 2009 onwards;
Scheme booklet │ Page 31
- (c) Member of the Tatura Milk finance committee
Ken Wood
Mr Wood has been a shareholder-supplier of Tatura Milk since 1972. He has been heavily involved in water issues in northern Victoria since 2004.
He is an active dairy farmer and his involvement in the dairy industry includes:
-
(d) Director of Tatura Milk since 2005;
-
(e) Former UDV District Councillor;
-
(f) Inaugural member of Northern Victorian Irrigators;
-
(g) Former member of Goulburn-Murray Water Services Committee;
-
(h) Current member of Northern Victorian Irrigation Renewal Project Modernisation Committee;
-
(i) Tatura Milk’s representative on National Irrigators Council.
Mr Wood has served in various community organisations and is a member and pastpresident of the Rotary Club of Tatura.
Fred De Cicco
Mr De Cicco has been a director of Tatura Milk since 27 October 2005. Prior to this appointment, he was an associate director from 1 August 2003 for a 12 month period. In addition to the above, he has served as a member of Tatura Milk’s finance committee since January 2008.
Since 1981, Mr De Cicco has been farming and is also a stud breeder. Holstein Australia awarded him Master Breeder of the Year for 2010.
Jeff Odgers, B Bus (Ag Mgt)
Mr Odgers has been strongly involved in dairy industry roles for the past 12 years, and actively managing farming businesses for over 20 years.
Mr Odgers served as chairman of Bonlac Foods Tasmanian Supplier Representative Scheme from 1999 to 2001, developing a broad understanding of dairy supply chain dynamics.
Following a relocation of business interests to Victoria, Mr Odgers became involved in local irrigator representation as a member of Central Goulburn Water Services Committee from 2004 to 2007. Currently Mr Odgers is a member of the Australian Dairy Industry Council’s ‘Water Taskforce’ which seeks to achieve balanced outcomes from the Murray Darling Basin Plan.
In 2006, Mr Odgers was appointed a director of Murray Dairy Inc and has been board chairman since August 2008. Murray Dairy works closely with numerous organisations
Page 32 │ Scheme booklet
on research, extension and industry development that is regionally focused.
Since November 2009 Mr Odgers has served as a director of Tatura Milk.
Mr Odgers’ formal qualifications include an Associate Diploma of Farm Management (1987) and a Bachelor of Business (2005). In 2008 he completed the residential program run by the Australian Institute of Company Directors.
5.5 Management
Tatura Milk’s business is supervised by the board which has delegated day to day management to an experienced team based at its production facility at Tatura, Victoria. The team is led by Tatura Milk’s Executive General Manager, Paul van Heerwaarden, and supported by the senior executives. This executive team reports to the board of directors of Tatura Milk. A summary of the experience and capabilities of Tatura Milk’s management team is provided below.
Paul van Heerwaarden, CPA, MBA, BBus (Acct) (Tatura Milk Executive General Manager)
In May 2011 Paul was appointed Tatura Milk Executive General Manager after two years as Chief Financial Officer. Previously Paul worked in senior financial and management positions with a number of Australian and international agribusinesses.
He has an MBA from the Melbourne Business School, a Bachelor of Business (Accounting), RMIT and is a CPA.
Tony Kilmartin
(Tatura Milk General Manager Sales)
Tony commenced employment at Tatura Milk in December 1975. He was sponsored by Tatura Milk to undertake tertiary study in dairy manufacture technology at Gilbert Chandler Institute in 1977-78. After graduating, Tony’s roles have included Laboratory Manager and R&D Manager before becoming Cream Cheese Manager and then Planning & Logistics Manager. He moved to his current role of General Manager Sales in 2003.
Frank Baldi, Dip App Science (Dairy) (Tatura Milk General Manager Operations)
Frank has been with Tatura Milk for 15 years and he has held several managerial roles during that period. Frank’s current responsibility is the overall operations at Tatura Milk. He completed a Diploma of Applied Science in dairy at Gilbert Chandler College in 1999/2000.
Scheme booklet │ Page 33
Stuart Brown, B. Agr Science (Hons) (Tatura Milk General Manager Milk Supplier Services)
Stuart joined Tatura Milk in April 2004 following some 25 years’ experience in Northern Victoria as a private farm management consultant (Farmanco Pty Ltd), Goulburn Broken catchment salinity program coordinator and dairy extension officer with the Department of Agriculture. Stuart manages field services and the farmer production/shareholder interface with Tatura Milk and brings a wealth of experience to his role.
Jason Wells, CPA, BBus (Acct) (Tatura Milk Financial Controller/Company Secretary)
Jason joined Tatura Milk in March 2000 after three years as financial accountant at Goulburn Valley Water and previous accounting experience with SPC/Ardmona. With 11 years’ experience, Jason leads the finance team and is responsible for company secretarial duties for Tatura Milk.
He has a Bachelor of Business (Accounting) from Charles Sturt University and is a CPA.
5.6 Corporate governance
Tatura Milk operates under its own corporate governance arrangements that are appropriate for its operation as a 70% owned subsidiary of Bega Cheese. These include its own board committees and management structure. Where appropriate, code of conduct type polices have been made consistent with Bega Cheese policies. Appropriate rationalisation of policies will occur following the completion of the Merger.
5.7 Share capital structure
Tatura Milk has two classes of shares on issue, Tatura Milk Ordinary Shares and Tatura Milk RP Shares.
Tatura Milk Ordinary Shares
At the date of this scheme booklet, there are 28,413,511 Tatura Milk Ordinary Shares on issue, all of which are held by Bega Cheese, and represent approximately 70% of the total number of issued Tatura Milk shares.
Under Tatura Milk’s constitution, 35 million shares is the maximum number of Tatura Milk Ordinary Shares that may be held at any time by or on behalf of one person.
Tatura Milk RP Shares
At the date of this scheme booklet, there are 12,009,408 Tatura Milk RP Shares on issue.
The Tatura Milk RP Shares are widely held by Suppliers i.e. people who supply milk and other dairy commodities to Tatura Milk. The Suppliers comprise Dairy Farmer Suppliers (dairy farmers who supply commercial quantities of milk to Tatura Milk on a regular basis) and Industrial Suppliers (organisations and others who trade in milk or other dairy commodities and supply significant quantities to Tatura Milk).
Page 34 │ Scheme booklet
At the date of this scheme booklet, there are 313 Dairy Farmer Suppliers and 5 Industrial Suppliers holding all of the issued Tatura Milk RP Shares.
The rights and restrictions applying to the Tatura Milk RP Shares under Tatura Milk’s constitution are substantially the same as those applying to the Tatura Milk Ordinary Shares, except in the following key respects:
-
(a) The maximum number of Tatura Milk RP Shares that may be held at any time by or on behalf of one person is 5% of the issued Tatura Milk RP Shares.
-
(b) Tatura Milk RP Shares may only be issued to Suppliers.
-
(c) Unless the Tatura Milk directors determine otherwise, the number of Tatura Milk RP Shares that may be issued to a new Supplier is 100.
-
(d) Tatura Milk RP Shares are redeemable at the option of Tatura Milk if the holder ceases to be a Supplier or requests redemption.
-
(e) The amount payable on redemption is the amount paid up on the share together with any dividend declared but not paid.
-
(f) Tatura Milk RP Shares may only be transferred to another Supplier.
-
(g) Tatura Milk RP Shareholders are entitled to dividends according to the quantity of milk supplied by shareholders to Tatura Milk over a period determined by the Tatura Milk directors, as well as according to the number of Tatura Milk RP Shares held at the same rate per share as that payable on the Tatura Milk Ordinary Shares.
In addition, the Tatura Milk board has, in the past, established and implemented a share subscription scheme under which Tatura Milk RP Shareholders who are Dairy Farmer Suppliers have been given the opportunity to subscribe for additional Tatura Milk RP Shares each year on a basis determined by the directors. The scheme has provided a means by which the total number of Tatura Milk RP Shares on issue can represent 30% (or close to 30%) of the total number of issued Tatura Milk shares. Tatura Milk RP Shareholders who are Industrial Suppliers do not participate in the scheme.
Tatura Milk RP Shareholders who are Industrial Suppliers also have not participated in dividends paid according to milk supplied because they do not supply milk on a daily basis, which is the basis on which those dividends have been determined. However, they do participate in dividends paid according to the number of shares held, on the same basis as all other shareholders.
At the date of this scheme booklet the aggregate number of Tatura Milk RP Shares represents 29.71% of the total number of issued shares in Tatura Milk. There is no intention to offer further Tatura Milk RP Shares under the share subscription scheme prior to the implementation of the Merger.
Scheme booklet │ Page 35
5.8 Dividend policy and payment history
Shares
All Tatura Milk shareholders are entitled to dividends based on cents per share. The timing and the amount of dividends paid depends upon the profits of Tatura Milk, its financial and taxation position, funds retained for capital expenditure and the Tatura Milk directors’ views of the appropriate payout ratio at the time. In respect of FY2011, the directors of Tatura Milk declared a dividend of 4 cents per share (totalling $1,545,693.24). This dividend was paid in December 2010.
Milk
Tatura Milk RP Shareholders are also entitled to dividends based on milk supply. Tatura Milk is committed to delivering an attractive return to its Dairy Farmer Suppliers who hold Tatura Milk RP Shares and has a number of ways it can use to pay Dairy Farmer Suppliers who hold Tatura Milk RP Shares for their milk supply. For example, in the past Tatura Milk has paid dividends to Dairy Farmer Suppliers based on premium and choice milk solids supplied during particular periods. The total dividend determined to be paid to Dairy Farmer Suppliers holding Tatura Milk RP Shares based on milk supplied during FY2011 was $2,711,544.74. Following implementation of the Merger, Tatura Milk RP Shareholders will cease to be entitled to be paid dividends by Tatura Milk based on milk supply.
5.9 Historical financial performance
The historical financial information below has been extracted from Tatura Milk’s audited financial statements for FY2011. The information relates to Tatura Milk only and therefore does not reflect the impact of the Scheme.
The information is a summary only and does not contain the disclosures provided in annual financial reports in accordance with the Corporations Act.
Tatura Milk’s 2011 annual report was mailed to Tatura Milk RP Shareholders on 25 October 2011. Tatura Milk RP Shareholders can request an additional copy of this report by contacting Tatura Milk’s registered office on (03) 5824 6200.
Page 36 │ Scheme booklet
Consolidated statement of financial position
| $’000 | Actual 2011 Actual 2010 |
|---|---|
| Current assets | |
| Cash and cash equivalents | 1,780 8,915 |
| Trade and other receivables | 41,071 41,369 |
| Derivatives | 1,854 - |
| Inventories | 33,118 54,646 |
| Total current assets | 77,824 104,929 |
| Non-current assets | |
| Other financial assets | 153 153 |
| Property, plant and equipment | 69,903 65,303 |
| Deferred tax assets | 14,847 14,280 |
| Intangible assets | 190 376 |
| Total non-current assets | 85,092 80,111 |
| Total assets | 162,916 185,040 |
| Current liabilities | |
| Trade and other payables | 40,379 55,340 |
| Derivatives | - 2,222 |
| Borrowings | 12,726 26,873 |
| Provisions | 6,059 5,293 |
| Total current liabilities | 59,163 89,728 |
| Non-current liabilities | |
| Trade and other payables | - 150 |
| Borrowings | - 6,659 |
| Provisions | 330 421 |
| Total non-current liabilities | 330 7,230 |
| Total liabilities | 59,493 96,958 |
| Net assets | 103,423 88,082 |
| Equity | |
| Contributed equity | 48,846 47,020 |
| Reserves | 17,952 15,808 |
| Retainedprofits | 36,625 25,254 |
| Total equity | 103,423 88,082 |
Scheme booklet │ Page 37
Consolidated income statement
| $’000 | Actual 2011 |
Actual 2010 |
|---|---|---|
| Revenue 312,316 271,241 |
||
| Changes in inventories of finished goods and work in progress (21,527) 19,183 |
||
| Raw materials and consumables used (211,237) (209,447) |
||
| Employee benefits expense (35,648) (32,490) |
||
| Depreciation and amortisation expense (7,174) (7,149) |
||
| Other expenses (13,557) (15,284) |
||
| Warehousing and distribution expenses (7,271) (10,296) |
||
| Finance costs (2,064) (3,034) |
||
| Profit before income tax 13,838 12,724 |
||
| Income tax (expense)/benefit 1,790 4,088 |
||
| Profit for the year 15,628 16,812 |
||
| Profit attributable to | ||
| Equity holders of Tatura Milk 15,628 16,812 |
5.10 Material changes to financial position since balance date
To the knowledge of the directors of Tatura Milk, there has been no material change to the financial position of Tatura Milk since 30 June 2011.
5.11 Risks
This section 5.11 identifies what Tatura Milk regards as the key risks which could adversely impact Tatura Milk’s financial performance and cause that performance to differ from statements of forecast performance contained in this scheme booklet. It also identifies the key risk factors associated with an investment in Tatura Milk RP Shares. You should read the whole of this scheme booklet in order to fully appreciate those risks.
These risks have been identified having regard to the likelihood of them occurring, their potential impact on Tatura Milk and their relevance to Tatura Milk RP Shareholders. They ought not to be taken as an exhaustive statement of the risks faced by Tatura Milk or investors in Tatura Milk. Those risk factors, and others not specifically referred to below, may in the future materially affect the financial performance of Tatura Milk and the value of Tatura Milk RP Shares.
Business specific risks
Business specific risks that may impact significantly on Tatura Milk, its performance and price of Tatura Milk RP Shares include the risks described below.
International dairy commodity prices and foreign exchange risk
Dairy commodity prices fluctuate in accordance with global supply and demand. The market value of core products of Tatura Milk such as milk powders are all affected by the global commodities market to some extent, even those products not exported but traded within the domestic market are similarly affected. There is a risk that a decline in commodity prices may reduce the prices at which Tatura Milk is able to sell its products,
Page 38 │ Scheme booklet
thereby adversely impacting its earnings unless input prices for raw materials, including milk, can be adjusted to reflect this change.
Where dairy commodities are sold into export markets the main currency is the US dollar. Fluctuations in the Australian dollar as compared to foreign currencies have the potential to adversely impact the revenue and returns of Tatura Milk.
Reliance on major customers and exports
Tatura Milk’s business relies on its ongoing commercial relationships with the major customers for which it manufactures and supplies products, such as Mead Johnson and Ingredia. However, while these major customer relationships represent a strength, the loss of a major customer could result in significant adverse financial consequences, as it is likely to take some time to replace a major customer.
As about 65% of the Tatura Milk sales are exports, any imposition of trade barriers, regulatory requirements or other matters that would affect world trade may impact Tatura Milk Group’s business.
Environmental risk
Tatura Milk, as with other dairy food manufacturers, generates noise, odour, waste and air emissions in the course of food production. These emissions are regulated by statute, licence and agreement that Tatura Milk has to comply with.
Liquid waste at the Tatura facility is disposed of through facilities operated by Victorian water authorities. In this respect, Tatura Milk has an agreement with Goulburn Valley Regional Water Corporation for the disposal of waste water from the Tatura Milk facility. This agreement requires the control of chemical and physical qualities as well as the volume of waste water discharged into the water authority’s systems.
Tatura Milk has formulated a program of improvements to its facilities to address its management of waste water and ensure that Tatura Milk is able to comply with all aspects of its agreement with Goulburn Valley Regional Water Corporation. The anticipated costs associated with these proposed improvements total $3 million, which is budgeted to be spent in FY2012 and FY2013.
In addition to liquid waste, Tatura Milk has to ensure that air emissions from its powder facilities, storm water run-off and noise from general factory operations are controlled in a manner consistent with its environmental licences. Tatura Milk has a number of ongoing projects directed to environmental compliance.
Supply of nutritional formula products
Tatura Milk has a number of major customers who are required to provide nutritional formula raw materials for processing. If for any reason major customers were unable to source adequate quantities of raw materials, this may impact the returns to Tatura Milk from its nutritionals operations. It should be noted that these customers are either major manufacturers of dairy products or have global procurement networks to ensure supply.
Scheme booklet │ Page 39
Commercial, operational and product risk
Tatura Milk may be subject to general commercial and operational risks including product defects, changes to market competition and events that interrupt production. Such events could adversely affect Tatura Milk’s financial performance. Tatura Milk depends on the ongoing and efficient operation of its business systems, infrastructure and supply chain. It faces inherent risks including failure of machinery, energy suppliers and computer equipment, industrial action and natural disasters. It maintains appropriate insurance policies in respect of most insurable risks in accordance with normal commercial practices.
Tatura Milk’s ability to remain productive, profitable, competitive and to effect its planned growth initiatives depends on its ability to attract and retain workers. Tightening of the labour market in key regions due to a shortage of suitably skilled workers may inhibit the Tatura Milk Group’s ability to hire and retain employees. Tatura Milk is also subject to occupational health and safety regulations. If it is not able to maintain its working conditions to meet those regulations, this may impact its operations and ability to attract and retain workers and also result in contravention of those regulations, which may give rise to potential criminal and civil liability and also damage Tatura Milk’s reputation.
As with all dairy food processors, Tatura Milk is exposed to the risk of product contamination and product recalls. It manages this risk by:
-
(a) testing and monitoring milk intake continually during and on completion of the production process;
-
(b) quality review procedures during manufacturing;
-
(c) external audit of operations systems by Dairy Food Safety Victoria, Australian Quarantine and Inspection Service, SAI Global and some customers; and
-
(d) maintaining insurance cover against any third party claim where appropriate and cost effective to do so.
Interest paying debt
Tatura Milk has debt facilities with Westpac Banking Corporation of up to circa $45 million. Equitable mortgages and floating charges over all the assets and undertakings of Tatura Milk have been provided as security for the facilities. A condition of these facilities is to comply with various covenants in respect of the financial position and performance of Tatura Milk.
Based on current cash flows, Tatura Milk has sufficient facilities to finance its operations. Where debt facilities are drawn down, the term and use of the loans is taken into account in deciding what proportion of the loan, if any, should be protected from interest rate movements. The underlying interest rate payable on borrowings is driven largely by factors outside the control of the group. All borrowings are denominated in Australian dollars.
The working capital facility is generally negotiated with 12 to 18 month terms and renewed towards the end of each term or otherwise as required. Currently all facilities are due to expire in December 2012. Tatura Milk currently complies with all the financial covenants associated with its facilities. While Tatura Milk has no reason to expect that it
Page 40 │ Scheme booklet
will not be able to renew its facilities there is a risk of non-renewal or that terms and conditions of renewal may be less favourable than they are currently.
General risks
General risks that may impact significantly on Tatura Milk, its performance and the price or value of Tatura Milk RP Shares include the following.
General economic conditions
The operating and financial performance of Tatura Milk is influenced by a variety of general domestic and world economic and business conditions, inflation, interest rates, exchange rates, access to debt and equity capital markets, and government fiscal, monetary and regulatory policies. A prolonged deterioration in any of the above factors may have a material adverse effect on the financial performance, financial position, cash flows, distributions and growth prospects of Tatura Milk.
Force majeure events
Events such as acts of terrorism, an outbreak of international hostilities or natural disasters may occur within or outside Australia and may have an impact on the Tatura Milk business. Any such force majeure events may have a negative impact on the value of an investment in Tatura Milk.
Scheme booklet │ Page 41
6. Information on Bega Cheese
6.1 Overview
Bega Cheese has a long history as a successful supplier co-operative business. The Bega brand is Australia’s number one cheese brand with 60 million Bega branded products sold throughout the country each year.
The Bega Cheese Group undertakes dairy manufacturing, processing, cutting and packing operations through 5 specialised facilities, 2 in New South Wales (NSW) and 3 in Victoria (including the Tatura Milk facilities).
The growth of Bega Cheese from its origins as the Bega Co-operative Creamery Company has occurred both organically and through acquisitions, resulting in an expanded business with a diversified product mix and increased production volumes. A landmark acquisition occurred in April 2007, when Bega Cheese acquired its 70% controlling interest in Tatura Milk.
Although it changed its structure in 2008 from a co-operative to an unlisted public company, and on 16 August 2011 was admitted to the official list of ASX, its constitution retains a number of features reflecting the co-operative background of Bega Cheese, namely the requirement that the board will include at least 4 directors who are or represent Bega Cheese Dairy Farmer Suppliers and maximum limits on individual shareholdings in Bega Cheese for a defined period.
Key business drivers for Bega Cheese include ensuring that investment and capital expenditure decisions generate appropriate returns for shareholders, commercial and strategic activities reflect the competitive environment the business operates in and milk pricing secures reliable milk supply from farmers.
6.2 History
Bega Cheese started business over 110 years ago as The Bega Co-operative Creamery Company. Its major milestones are as follows:
| Year | Milestone |
|---|---|
| 1899 | The Bega Co-operative Creamery Company formed |
| 1900 | Original butter factory opened |
| 1924 | Butter factory built on present Lagoon Street site |
| 1944 | Name changed to The Bega Co-operative Society Ltd |
| 1983 | Bonlac1commences marketing Bega branded natural and processed |
1 In 1983 the Bega Cheese brand was licensed to Amalgamated Co-operative Marketers (Australia) Limited (which became Bonlac Foods Limited). Bonlac Foods Limited was subsequently acquired by Fonterra Brands (Australia) Pty Limited’s parent company.
Page 42 │ Scheme booklet
Year Milestone
cheese products outside NSW and the ACT
-
1994 Commenced exporting cheese to a number of countries
-
1997 Commenced Capitol Chilled Foods (Australia) joint venture
-
1998 Commissioned the cheese cutting, packaging and processing facility at Ridge Street, Bega
-
2001 The Bega brand licensed to Fonterra for use in Australia on cheese and butter, in conjunction with a long term product supply agreement and a major upgrade of the Ridge Street facility
-
2007 Acquired 70% of Tatura Milk
-
2008 Corporate structure changed from a co-operative to an unlisted public company
-
2008 Acquired Coburg cheese plant
2009 Acquired Kraft Foods’ Strathmerton packaging and cheese plant 2010 Acquired 15% of WCB 2011 Listed on ASX
6.3 Current operations
The Bega Cheese Group operates 5 dairy manufacturing sites across NSW and Victoria (including the Tatura Milk facilities), manufacturing and value adding approximately 186,000 tonnes of dairy products in FY2011. Bulk cheddar cheese, string cheese and whey powder are produced at Lagoon Street, Bega and bulk cheddar and mozzarella cheese at Coburg, Victoria. Milk powders, cream cheese and nutritionals are produced at Tatura. The Ridge Street, Bega and Strathmerton, Victoria facilities are dedicated to the cutting, packaging and processing of bulk cheese products into retail and food service packs.
The Bega Cheese Group’s business can be categorised as follows:
Core dairy products manufacturing (which include Tatura Milk’s operations)
(a) cheddar, cream and mozzarella cheeses, milk powders, butter and cream
Fast Moving Consumer Goods (FMCG) business focused on cheese packaging and processing, including products under the Bega brand
-
(a) cutting, packaging and processing of cheese products into retails packs for customers including Fonterra, Kraft Foods and ALDI Stores
-
(b) receiving a royalty from Fonterra for the exclusive right to use the Bega brand
Scheme booklet │ Page 43
trade marks in Australia on natural and processed cheddar cheese, string cheese and butter products
(c) direct marketing and sales of Bega products internationally
Nutritional food products manufacturing (principally undertaken by Tatura Milk)
-
(a) infant formula
-
(b) milk biologics such as lactoferrin and colostrum
Bega Cheese also has several assets and interests that could be defined as strategic investments outside of its core manufacturing businesses. These assets and interests include an investment of approximately 16.5% in WCB and 25% interest in Capitol Chilled Foods (Australia).
The following table summarises the recent production levels and the Bega Cheese Group’s assessment of reasonable capacity levels in tonnes per annum (assuming traditional product mix). One of the potential growth areas is the Bega Cheese Group’s investment in capacity and the ability to benefit from higher utilisation of its existing facilities.
| Facility | Production FY2010 Production FY2011 Capacity |
|---|---|
| Tonnes Tonnes Tonnes |
|
| Lagoon St Coburg Ridge St Strathmerton Tatura Total |
23,349 24,683 42,000 5,799 4,750 10,000 61,626 60,528 75,000 29,422 33,864 100,000 66,896 62,398 94,000 |
| 187,092 186,223 321,000 |
The following table provides a schematic overview from the receipt of milk and other raw materials and the processing by the Bega Cheese business.
Page 44 │ Scheme booklet
==> picture [431 x 270] intentionally omitted <==
The size of boxes and arrows in the above chart does not reflect the relative size of each business.
Based on FY2011 numbers, the split of revenue by business units and by destination is as depicted in the following pie charts.
==> picture [426 x 243] intentionally omitted <==
----- Start of picture text -----
Bega Cheese Group 2011 revenue by business
unit
9%
32% Core dairy manufacturing
Value add packaging FMCG
Nutritional products
59%
----- End of picture text -----
Scheme booklet │ Page 45
6.4 Milk supply and pricing
The annual milk intake by the Bega Cheese Group is approximately 600 million litres, which is about 6% of total Australian milk production.
The Bega Cheese Group receives milk from about 500 farmer suppliers (including the Tatura Milk suppliers). The largest single farmer supplier represents just over 1% of milk delivered. Traditionally, farmer suppliers do not have written, long term contracts relating to the supply of their milk, but effectively commit to a buyer on an annual basis.
The Bega Cheese Group also acquires milk from third party suppliers as and when required and available.
Milk pricing is traditionally set on a July to June financial year or ‘season’ basis.
Milk pay rates applying to NSW dairy farmers are influenced by domestic drinking milk demands as the majority of NSW milk goes into that market. Therefore pay rates are set by processing companies at the commencement of the year and they only change in exceptional circumstances. This system provides these dairy farmers with certainty as to what price they will receive for their milk and provides an incentive for them to continue to produce milk throughout the year.
Page 46 │ Scheme booklet
Milk pay rates applying to Victorian dairy farmers consist of opening pay rates together with deferred ‘loyalty’ payments announced to farmer suppliers during the year. The loyalty payments depend on the operating performance of the business. This pricing system enables Victorian based manufacturers to manage the risk of setting the pay rates too high at the beginning of the year, without knowing all of the variables that will affect the selling price of the products to be manufactured during the year. This is because a significant amount of Victorian milk is processed and exported and returns are dependent on a range of factors that can vary during the year.
In both Victoria and NSW, the milk pay rates for the Bega Cheese Group’s farmer suppliers (those dairy farmers who actively supply milk to a member of the Bega Cheese Group) vary by season. Generally higher pay rates are paid in the winter months when costs to the farmers to produce milk are higher and lower pay rates are paid in spring when costs to the farmers to produce milk are lower. These seasonal milk pay rates are designed to incentivise year-round milk production, and smooth out the seasonal milk production peak.
Milk prices are also adjusted to reflect the quality of the milk received at the factory and are set based on the composition of milk solids supplied (i.e. butterfat and protein).
Milk prices are set in a highly competitive environment. In NSW the major competitors for milk are dairy companies selling milk to satisfy demand in the liquid milk market. In Victoria the competitors for milk are mostly entities processing milk into cheese and other dairy products primarily for export markets. Prices therefore reflect global commodity prices and competition for product. Bega Cheese intends to continue its history of paying leading manufacturing milk prices. This is important to ensure security of supply in an environment where in recent years the number of dairy farms and herd numbers has contracted and milk pools have reduced.
Currently milk price decisions are made by the respective Bega Cheese and Tatura Milk boards based on recommendations by management. Bega Cheese believes that it is in the interests of shareholders that all Bega Cheese board members (including those who are farmer suppliers) are involved in milk pricing decisions due to its critical importance.
To ensure that the milk price paid by the Bega Cheese Group is appropriate, the Bega Cheese board has adopted a new milk price policy effective from 1 July 2011. Under the new milk pricing policy, farmer suppliers who actively supply milk to a member of the
Scheme booklet │ Page 47
Bega Cheese Group will receive a price determined in accordance with that policy, and will only participate in future distributions of profit if they are a shareholder of Bega Cheese (and on the same basis as all shareholders).
Bega Cheese Group Milk Price Policy – effective 1 July 2011
1. Introduction
A cornerstone of the development of the Bega Cheese business has been the organisation’s understanding of, and focus on, retaining and growing milk supply.
The careful management and recognition of the changing environment dairy farmers operate in has seen Bega Cheese develop a close association with its suppliers. The organisation’s capacity to respond to supplier concerns, deliver appropriate market signals and provide support on key issues will remain a core competency for Bega Cheese.
A long term, sustainable supply of milk ensures Bega Cheese’s manufacturing facilities operate efficiently and competitively to meet the short and long term needs of its customers.
2. Milk Price Policy and Milk Prices in Various Regions
Bega Cheese will consider the following issues in relation to the milk prices set for the various supply regions:
-
(a) place of origin – the significance of the place of origin of the milk used in manufacture of particular dairy products (for example, milk used in the manufacture of Bega branded cheese);
-
(b) financial returns from dairy products – the financial return expected to be earned from dairy products manufactured using milk supplied by the relevant farmers;
-
(c) sustainability of supply base – Bega Cheese will endeavour to ensure the long term sustainability of dairy farming in the relevant region;
-
(d) competitive circumstances – the competitive farm gate milk prices in each region.
3. Company of Choice
Bega Cheese endeavours to be the preferred company choice of dairy farmers in South Eastern Australia for the sale of their milk. The combination of a leading manufacturing milk price and innovative farm extension programs will be the key to attracting and retaining milk supply and keeping our farmer suppliers viable.
6.5 Board of directors
The board of Bega Cheese brings relevant experience and skills including relating to fast moving consumer goods, financial management and corporate governance. As at the date of this scheme booklet, the Bega Cheese board comprises:
| Name | Status |
|---|---|
| Barry Irvin AM | Executive chairman who also is (or is the |
| representative of a body corporate that is) a Bega | |
| Cheese DairyFarmer Supplier | |
| Max Roberts | Non-executive director who also is (or is the |
| representative of a body corporate that is) a Bega | |
| Cheese DairyFarmer Supplier |
Page 48 │ Scheme booklet
| Name | Status |
|---|---|
| Richard Parbery | Non-executive director who also is (or is the |
| representative of a body corporate that is) a Bega | |
| Cheese DairyFarmer Supplier | |
| Tom D’Arcy | Non-executive director who also is (or is the |
| representative of a body corporate that is) a Bega | |
| Cheese DairyFarmer Supplier | |
| Richard Platts | Non-executive director who also is (or is the |
| representative of a body corporate that is) a Bega | |
| Cheese DairyFarmer Supplier | |
| Peter Margin | Independent non-executive director |
| JoyLinton | Independent non-executive director |
If the Merger is implemented as proposed, Bega Cheese has agreed for two of the Tatura Milk Dairy Farmer Supplier Directors, as voted on by you, to join the Bega Cheese board. These directors would be, or represent, Tatura Milk Dairy Farmer Suppliers, and would be in addition to the above directors.
A summary of the relevant experience of the directors of Bega Cheese is set out below.
Barry Irvin, AM Executive chairman
Mr Irvin has been chairman of Bega Cheese since 2000 and executive chairman since 2008. Mr Irvin has led the Bega Cheese executive teams in the implementation of strategies, initiatives and acquisitions that have driven Bega Cheese’s success and growth.
Mr Irvin is recognised globally for his extensive knowledge of the Australian dairy industry and speaks regularly at international conferences. He was recently awarded the Rabobank 2011 Leadership Award for his outstanding contribution to the food and agribusiness industries and was the NAB Agribusiness leader of the year in 2009. He was appointed a Member of the Order of Australia for service to the dairy industry and to children with disabilities and their families in 2008. Mr Irvin continues to have involvement in his family’s dairy farming business and, as such, has a thorough knowledge of the dairy industry supply chain from production, through to manufacture and sales.
Following Aidan Coleman’s May 2011 appointment as CEO of Bega Cheese, Mr Irvin has continued as executive chairman providing direction for the CEO and the Bega Cheese Group to ensure that it meets its long term strategies including financial, organisational and cultural goals. The executive chairman will be pivotal in leading key strategic business activities centred on the evolving Bega Cheese Group structure, public and stakeholder relations and stewarding major customer and alliance relationships.
Scheme booklet │ Page 49
Mr Irvin is also:
-
(a) director and deputy chairman of Capitol Chilled Foods (Australia);
-
(b) director and chairman of Tatura Milk;
-
(c) director of WCB;
-
(d) director of the Gardiner Foundation, a Victorian dairy industry group that invests in projects that have positive impact on the dairy industry and the wider community;
-
(e) director and chairman of Giant Steps Sydney Limited, an educational and therapy centre for children with autism.
Max Roberts
Mr Roberts has been involved in the dairy industry for many years, including agripolitical, board representation and direct dairy farming activities. Moving from an initial career in journalism, Mr Roberts was a director of Milk Marketing NSW Pty Ltd, chairman of NSW Farmers Inc dairy section and vice president of Australian Dairy Farmers Federation. Mr Roberts is currently chairman of Dairy Australia Limited.
Mr Roberts is an active dairy farmer and his responsibilities in serving Bega Cheese include:
-
(a) director since 1983;
-
(b) deputy chairman from 2000 to 2011.
Richard Parbery, FCPA
Mr Parbery is a managing partner of a successful regional accounting practice, is a fellow of the Australian Society of Certified Practicing Accountants, a registered company auditor, registered tax agent and a justice of the peace NSW. Mr Parbery is experienced in servicing many agricultural and general business clients.
Mr Parbery is also heavily involved in a number of family businesses and investments, including a major dairying business. His responsibilities in serving Bega Cheese include:
-
(a) director since 1988;
-
(b) deputy chairman from 2000 to 2011;
-
(c) member of the Audit and Risk Committee.
Mr Parbery is also:
-
(a) director of Tatura Milk since April 2007;
-
(b) chairman of the Tatura Milk Finance Committee.
Page 50 │ Scheme booklet
Tom D’Arcy, Dip . App. Sc (Dairy Tech), Dip Ag, GAICD
Mr D’Arcy has a Diploma in Dairy Technology and Agriculture and is a member of the Australian Institute of Company Directors. Following graduation Mr D’Arcy worked in quality control at Bega Cheese and ultimately became responsible for management of quality systems until he left in 1977. Mr D’Arcy extended his knowledge of international dairy practices by working for the International Agricultural Exchange in Alberta, Canada before returning to Australia to manage his family’s farming business.
Mr D’Arcy has actively represented farmers on many state and federal committees designed to address key and emerging issues in the Australian dairy industry.
Mr D’Arcy is an active dairy farmer and his responsibilities in serving Bega Cheese include:
(a) director since 1998;
(b) member of the Audit and Risk Committee.
Richard Platts, Adv Dip Agr; GAICD
Mr Platts has been representing farmers for over twenty years, through various roles in the NSW Dairy Farmers Association, Dairy Industry Development Corporation and Dairy Farmers Co-operative.
Mr Platts has a background in agriculture, has an Advanced Diploma in Agriculture and is a member of the Australian Institute of Company Directors.
Mr Platts is an active dairy farmer and has been a director of Bega Cheese since 2000.
Peter Margin, BSc (Hons), MBA
Mr Margin joined the Bega Cheese board on 27 June 2011. He has many years of leadership experience in major Australian and international food companies.
His most recent position was the CEO of ASX-listed food group Goodman Fielder Ltd from 2005 until April 2011.
Prior to that appointment he was the CEO and Chief Operating Officer of National Foods Ltd and has had prior experience at Heinz , Birds Eye Foods and Plumrose.
Mr Margin is also a non-executive director of ASX-listed Nufarm Limited.
Joy Linton, BComm, Grad Dip AFI, GAICD
Ms Linton is currently Chief Financial Officer at Bupa Australia, one of Australia’s leading healthcare companies. Ms Linton has 20 years of experience in strategic and financial roles with companies such as Ford Motor Company, Pacific Dunlop Food Group and National Foods Limited. She held the role of CFO of National Foods from 2007 to 2010 and prior to that was General Manager Commercial for the Dairy Foods Group.
Scheme booklet │ Page 51
Over recent years, Ms Linton has been instrumental in the acquisition and integration of the Dairy Farmers, Lactos, Berri and King Island businesses respectively into National Foods, and was a key member of the National Foods business takeover defence team in 2004 when National Foods was listed on the ASX.
Ms Linton has a Bachelor of Commerce from the University of Melbourne, a Graduate Diploma of Applied Finance and Investment from the Securities Institute of Australia, and is a Graduate of the Australian Institute of Company Directors.
6.6 Senior management
Bega Cheese has an experienced team of executives leading the business. A summary of the experience and capabilities of the CEO and members of the senior executive team are provided below.
Aidan Coleman, BA, BBS, GAICD (Chief Executive Officer)
Aidan was appointed CEO effective 10 May 2011. He has 27 years of experience in the international marketing and manufacturing of consumer dairy products and dairy ingredients primarily in Australia, New Zealand, China, Japan, South East Asia, Latin America and the Indian sub-continent.
Aidan has held positions including Manager Director–Fonterra Brands Australia, CEO of Bonland Dairies-Australia, and Managing Director of New Zealand Milk in Sri Lanka and was General Manager of the Consumer Foods business of Tatura Dairy Cooperative in New Zealand. In 2008 he was appointed CEO of Tatura Milk and has been part of the Bega Cheese executive group since that time.
He holds a Bachelor of Arts in economics and psychology from Auckland University and a Business Degree in marketing from Massey University in New Zealand, as well as being a graduate of the Australian Institute of Company Directors. Since 2009, Aidan has been a director of Dairy Innovation Australia Limited, an industry funded research/innovation organisation.
Maurice Van Ryn, B.Bus. (Acc.) (General Manager – Sales and Marketing)
Maurice joined the Bega Cheese Group in 1986 initially as group accountant and company secretary and has 25 years of experience with the company. He was the CEO from 1990 to 2005. He then took responsibility for sales and marketing including the export activities of Bega Cheese and apart from a brief secondment to be CEO of Tatura Milk between 2007 – 2008 has continued in that role.
At present, he is the longest serving senior executive within the Bega Cheese Group and has a wide ranging experience across all facets of the Bega business.
Maurice holds non-executive board positions in two small listed ASX companies. However, his time is substantially dedicated to his role at Bega Cheese.
Page 52 │ Scheme booklet
Colin Griffin, CA, BA in Accounting
(Chief Financial Officer/Company Secretary/Bega Brand Franchise Manager)
Born in Bega, Colin completed a BA (Accounting) in 1985 and obtained his Chartered Accountant membership in 1988. With a background in auditing and corporate advisory at KPMG, Colin joined the Bega Cheese team as Finance Manager and Company Secretary in 1993.
With 18 years experience, Colin has led the finance team and is responsible for corporate development, mergers and acquisitions and legal affairs for both Bega and Tatura Milk. He is a director of Tatura Milk and Capitol Chilled Foods (Australia).
In addition he is responsible for the stewardship of the Bega brand franchise agreement and is the relationship manager for Fonterra.
Sean Moran, Dip. App. Sc. (Dairy) (General Manager – Processing and Packaging)
Sean started his career in the dairy industry in New Zealand in 1984. He moved to Australia where he joined Tatura Milk in 1988 and had several senior management roles in manufacturing and logistics.
Sean joined Bega Cheese in July 2005. His current role is the responsibility for the operations at the process and packaging facilities at both the Ridge St and Strathmerton sites.
Grattan Smith, B.Bus.
(General Manager – Supply Chain)
Grattan joined Bega Cheese in December 1997. He has over 25 years of industry experience in logistics and supply chain including retail, manufacturing and contract warehousing and distribution. Grattan’s various roles have encompassed all aspects of the supply chain including inventory management, purchasing, planning, import/export/transport and warehouse management.
He is currently responsible for all supply chain (non-milk) activities across the Bega company sites.
Matthew Fanning, B Ec (General Manager – Human Resources)
Matt joined Bega Cheese in January 2000. He currently holds responsibility for all human resources activities at Bega, Strathmerton and Coburg. Prior to joining the company he worked with a number of large organisations in human resources and industrial relations roles.
He has a Bachelor of Economics from Monash University and has undertaken postgraduate studies in human resources related areas.
Scheme booklet │ Page 53
John Hicks, GAICD
(General Manager – Manufacturing and New Business Development)
John joined Bega Cheese in January 2001 as a Project Manager, after five years experience with a major UK dairy company. In 2002 he became the Site Manager Dairy Products Unit and in 2008 was appointed as GM Operations Tatura Milk Industries.
He was appointed to his current position in 2009 and currently has responsibility for the Lagoon St and Coburg Facilities, in addition to ongoing development of new business opportunities. John is a graduate of the Australian Institute of Company Directors.
Michael Hampson, CA, BBus (Acct) (General Manager – Commercial)
Michael joined Bega Cheese in April 2003 as Manager, PPU Finance. He assumed the Commercial Procurement function in December 2005 as Manager, Commercial Finance. He was seconded to Tatura Milk in April 2007 as CFO/General Manager – Commercial assuming all finance, IT, procurement, supply chain and major commercial negotiations responsibilities. He returned to Bega Cheese in May 2009 as General Manager – Commercial.
Michael’s current activities are financial management of the FMCG business, including financial responsibility of the Strathmerton Facility, procurement across the Group, and relationship manager to Kraft Foods.
He has a Bachelor of Business (Accounting), Charles Sturt University and is a Chartered Accountant.
Paul van Heerwaarden, CPA, MBA, BBus (Acct) (Tatura Milk Executive General Manager)
See section 5.5.
6.7 Corporate governance
The board of Bega Cheese is committed to maximising performance, generating appropriate levels of shareholder value and financial return and sustaining the growth and success of the Bega Cheese business and the Bega brand.
In conducting business with these objectives, the board will ensure that Bega Cheese is properly managed to protect and enhance shareholder interest, and that Bega Cheese, its directors, officers and employees operate in an appropriate environment of corporate governance. Accordingly, the board has adopted corporate governance policies and practices designed to promote the responsible management of Bega Cheese.
Through the Bega Cheese initial public offering, new investors who are not Bega Cheese Dairy Farmer Suppliers became shareholders. The Bega Cheese board will act in accordance with its board charter and the Corporations Act to enhance value for all shareholders. The board also recognises that maintaining a secure supply of milk is important for the company, therefore it will continue to endeavour to pay a leading manufacturing price for its milk in accordance with its milk pricing policy.
Page 54 │ Scheme booklet
ASX Corporate Governance Council’s Corporate Governance Principles and Recommendations defines an ‘independent director’ as a non-executive director who is not a member of management and who is free of any business or other relationship that could materially interfere with – or be perceived to materially interfere with – the independence of their judgment. Although some directors are also suppliers of milk to Bega Cheese, they do so on the same terms as all other milk suppliers in the same region and the company’s procedures and systems ensure that milk prices are set according to the commercial interests and needs of the company. Nonetheless, the Bega Cheese board recognises that there may be a perception that the milk supply relationship between directors who are or represent Bega Cheese Dairy Farmer Suppliers and Bega Cheese may influence the decision making of those directors. Accordingly, those supplier directors have not been characterised as independent within the terms of ASX Corporate Governance Principles and Recommendations.
This means that the board of Bega Cheese does not comply with ASX Corporate Governance Recommendation 2.1, which provides that a majority of the board should be independent directors, or ASX Corporate Governance Recommendation 2.2, which provides that the chairperson of the board should be an independent director. The board appointed one new external, independent director, Peter Margin, prior to listing and recently appointed a second external, independent director, Joy Linton. With these additions, the Bega Cheese board believes it will be well placed to oversee the Bega Cheese Group’s business and its future development. The board believes that Barry Irvin is the right person to continue to perform the role of chairperson, even though he is not classified as independent according to ASX Corporate Governance Principles and Recommendations. As the constitution of Bega Cheese provides for a board of up to 8 directors with a minimum of 4 who are or represent Bega Cheese Dairy Farmer Suppliers, the shareholders will be in a position to determine the composition of the Bega Cheese board in the future.
Details of Bega Cheese’s key policies and practices and the charters for the Bega Cheese board and each of its committees are available at www.begacheese.com.au.
6.8 Share capital structure
Bega Cheese has one class of shares on issue, Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares. At the date of the scheme booklet, there are 126,709,903 issued Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares.
Bega Cheese has established employee share plans under which Bega Cheese shares, or rights to receive Bega Cheese shares, may be issued to employees of the Bega Cheese Group. At the time Bega Cheese was listed on ASX, a number of shares and rights were issued to employees of Bega Cheese for no monetary payment. At the date of this scheme booklet, 362,500 Bega Cheese Employee Rights have been granted to senior executives of the Bega Cheese Group, each of which entitles the holder to one Bega Cheese Ordinary Share for no monetary payment upon certain conditions being satisfied.
If the Merger is implemented Bega Cheese intends to offer Bega Cheese shares or rights on a similar basis to employees of Tatura Milk. While the details of participation by the Tatura Milk employees in the employee share plans are yet to be finalised by the Bega Cheese board, it is anticipated that no amount will be payable by the employees for the shares or rights and that the maximum number of shares or rights will not exceed
Scheme booklet │ Page 55
$500,000 in value (based on the market value of the shares or underlying shares that are issued or agreed to be issued).
The Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares to be issued as consideration for your Tatura Milk RP Shares will be of the same class and will rank equally with the existing Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares on issue.
The principal rights attaching to Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares are summarised in section 8.
6.9 Top 20 shareholders
As at 17 October 2011 the top 20 holders of Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares were as follows:
| Name | Number of shares | Percentage of total shares on issue |
|---|---|---|
| KD & JL Kimber | 5,014,984 | 3.96 |
| RBC Dexia Investor Services | ||
| Australia Nominees Pty Ltd | 4,916,781 | 3.88 |
| (Pipooled a/c) | ||
| Paewai PtyLtd | 4,194,364 | 3.31 |
| Richard Ellwyn Platts | 3,537,956 | 2.79 |
| Aljo Pastoral PtyLtd | 3,004,984 | 2.37 |
| CB & MA Moffitt | 2,850,564 | 2.25 |
| R & R Apps PtyLtd | 2,823,972 | 2.23 |
| JerangPtyLtd | 2,664,012 | 2.10 |
| Telstar Holsteins PtyLtd | 2,442,564 | 1.93 |
| BR Game and MC & CL Beresford |
2,179,288 | 1.72 |
| WF RN & BJ Taylor | 1,925,136 | 1.52 |
| NG & NG Pearce | 1,876,388 | 1.48 |
| G & NE Lucas | 1,779,996 | 1.42 |
| Peter Shearer | 1,781,408 | 1.41 |
| JelgowryPtyLtd | 1,692,852 | 1.34 |
| Max & Sue Roberts | 1,675,000 | 1.32 |
Page 56 │ Scheme booklet
| Name | Number of shares | Percentage of total shares on issue |
|---|---|---|
| BJ & CA Cochrane | 1,652,264 | 1.30 |
| RBC Dexia Investor Services | ||
| Australia Nominees Pty Ltd | 1,620,163 | 1.28 |
| (bkcust a/c) | ||
| Stephen & MaryGuthrey | 1,612,156 | 1.27 |
| Kameruka Estates Limited | 1,584,200 | 1.25 |
| Total | 50,849,032 | 40.13 |
6.10 Dividend policy and payment history
Subject to available profits and the financial position of the Bega Cheese Group, it is the intention of the directors of Bega Cheese to pay up to 50% of the net profit after tax applicable to the members of Bega Cheese as a dividend for FY2012.
No guarantee can be given about future dividends, or the level of franking or imputation of such dividends, as these matters will depend upon the future profits of the Bega Cheese Group, its financial and taxation position, the need to retain funds for capital expenditure and the directors’ views of the appropriate payout ratio at the time.
In respect of the financial year ended 30 June 2011, the directors of Bega Cheese declared a fully franked dividend for shareholders on the register as at 9 June 2011 of 1.25 cents per share. This dividend was paid on 15 June 2011.
Sections 6.12 and 6.13 provide more detail on the financial position of the Bega Cheese Group.
6.11 Dividend reinvestment plan
Bega Cheese has adopted a dividend reinvestment plan ( DRP ) which will provide its shareholders with the choice of reinvesting dividends paid by Bega Cheese by applying all or part of those dividends to acquire additional shares, rather than receiving the dividends in cash.
Participation in the DRP is optional and open to all Bega Cheese shareholders holding fully paid Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares, other than those whose registered addresses are in jurisdictions outside of Australia. Shareholders can elect to participate in the DRP by completing and returning the application form provided by the Bega Cheese share registry in respect of all or some of their shares. No action is required by a shareholder who wishes to receive cash dividends.
The rules of the DRP are typical of a dividend reinvestment plan operated by an ASX listed company, including the ability for the Bega Cheese board to vary, suspend or terminate the plan at any time, and can be found on the Bega Cheese website at www.begacheese.com.au.
Scheme booklet │ Page 57
6.12 Historical financial performance
The historical financial information below has been extracted from Bega Cheese’s audited financial statements for the financial year ended 30 June 2011. The information relates to the consolidated Bega Cheese Group and does not reflect the impact of the Scheme.
The information is a summary only and does not contain the disclosures provided in annual financial reports in accordance with the Corporations Act.
Bega Cheese’s 2011 annual report was lodged with ASX on 28 September 2011. A copy of this report, which includes notes to the accounts, can be downloaded from the Bega Cheese website at www.begacheese.com.au or from the ASX website at www.asx.com.au. A hard copy can be requested by contacting Bega Cheese (see section 6.19).
Page 58 │ Scheme booklet
Consolidated statement of financial position
| $’000 | Actual 2011 |
Actual 2010 |
|---|---|---|
| Current assets | ||
| Cash and cash equivalents | 20,587 18,169 |
|
| Trade and other receivables | 83,341 89,580 |
|
| Other financial assets | 2,489 819 |
|
| Inventories | 104,595 122,531 |
|
| Assets held for sale | 9 27 |
|
| Total current assets | 211,021 231,126 |
|
| Non-current assets | ||
| Other financial assets | 37,010 199 |
|
| Property, plant and equipment | 197,866 193,796 |
|
| Deferred tax assets | 14,400 17,212 |
|
| Intangible assets | 1,788 2,170 |
|
| Total non-current assets | 251,064 213,377 |
|
| Total Assets | 462,085 444,503 |
|
| Current liabilities | ||
| Trade and other payables | 117,764 112,465 |
|
| Borrowings | 22,006 63,953 |
|
| Current tax liabilities | 1,904 2,717 |
|
| Provisions | 18,872 16,745 |
|
| Total current liabilities | 160,546 195,880 |
|
| Non-current liabilities | ||
| Trade and other payables | 148 704 |
|
| Borrowings | 94,300 68,659 |
|
| Provisions | 1,616 1,644 |
|
| Total non-current liabilities | 96,064 71,007 |
|
| Total Liabilities | 256,610 266,887 |
|
| Net Assets | 205,475 177,616 |
|
| Equity | ||
| Contributed equity | 27,169 27,163 |
|
| Reserves | 46,057 31,907 |
|
| Retained earnings | 106,633 92,888 |
|
| Capital and reserves attributable to owners of Bega Cheese Limited | 179,859 151,958 |
|
| Non-controllinginterests | 25,616 25,658 |
|
| Total equity | 205,475 177,616 |
Scheme booklet │ Page 59
Consolidated statement of income
| $’000 | Actual 2011 Actual 2010 |
|---|---|
| Revenue | 931,690 829,029 |
| Cost of sales | (837,145) (743,750) |
| Gross profit | 94,545 85,279 |
| Other income | 7,533 8,106 |
| Distribution expense | (25,343) (24,016) |
| Marketing Expense | (10,765) (8,085) |
| Occupancy expense | (2,634) (2,358) |
| Administration expense | (31,741) (27,007) |
| Finance costs | (9,505) (10,120) |
| Profit before income tax | 22,090 21,799 |
| Income tax(expense)/benefit | (397) 1,468 |
| **Profit for the year ** | 21,693 23,267 |
| Other comprehensive income: | |
| Cash flow hedges | 3,442 (3,300) |
| Change in the fair value of other financial assets | 10,474 98 |
| Total other comprehensive income | 13,916 (3,202) |
| Total comprehensive income for theyear | 35,609 20,065 |
| Profit attributable to | |
| Equity holders of Bega Cheese Limited | 17,005 18,223 |
| Non-controllinginterests | 4,688 5,044 |
| 21,693 23,267 |
|
| Total Comprehensive income for the year is attributable to: | |
| Equity holders of Bega Cheese Limited | 30,065 15,909 |
| Non-controllinginterests | 5,544 4,156 |
| 35,609 20,065 |
Page 60 │ Scheme booklet
Consolidated statement of cash flows
| $’000 | Actual 2011 |
Actual 2010 |
|---|---|---|
| Cash flows from operating activities | ||
| Receipts from customers inclusive of goods and services tax | 980,246 863,366 |
|
| Payments to suppliers and employees inclusive of goods and services tax | (893,851) (797,736) |
|
| Interest and other costs of financing paid | (8,934) (11,000) |
|
| Income taxespaid | (3,582) (1,412) |
|
| Net cash inflow from operating activities | 73,879 53,218 |
|
| Cash flows from investing activities | ||
| Interest received | 456 438 |
|
| Dividend received | 327 - |
|
| Payments for property, plant and equipment | (24,817) (20,741) |
|
| Payments for shares in listed companies | (22,235) (1,211) |
|
| Proceeds from sale of property, plant and equipment | 42 622 |
|
| Proceeds from sale of shares in listed companies | - 1,423 |
|
| Proceeds from sale of shares in unlisted companies | - 112 |
|
| Net cash (outflow) from investing activities | (46,227) (19,357) |
|
| Cash flows from financing activities | ||
| Proceeds from borrowings | 20,000 - |
|
| Repayment of borrowings | (35,000) (33,367) |
|
| Repayment of leases | (1,394) (514) |
|
| Loans made to non-controlling interests | (2,753) (3,228) |
|
| Share capital subscribed by members | 8 2,353 |
|
| Share capital purchased back from members | (2) - |
|
| Share capital subscribed by non-controlling interests | 2,058 1,340 |
|
| Share capital purchased back from non-controlling interests | (232) (1,194) |
|
| Dividends paid to members | (3,260) (1,737) |
|
| Dividendspaid to non-controllinginterests | (4,659) (1,308) |
|
| Net cash (outflow) from financing activities | (25,234) (37,655) |
|
| Net increase/(decrease) in cash and cash equivalents | 2,418 (3,794) |
|
| Cash and cash equivalents at the beginningof theyear | 18,169 21,963 |
|
| Cash and cash equivalents at the end of the year | 20,587 18,169 |
6.13 Material changes to financial position since balance date
To the knowledge of the directors of Bega Cheese, there has been no material change to the financial position of Bega Cheese or to the consolidated financial position of the Bega Cheese Group since 30 June 2011 except as noted below:
Bega Cheese initial public offering
On 18 July 2011, as part of its IPO, Bega Cheese issued the Bega Cheese Prospectus inviting certain categories of the public (including Tatura Milk RP Shareholders) and employees of Bega Cheese to subscribe for new Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares. Under the offer 17,500,000 Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares were issued at an issue price of $2.00 each. In addition, 532,975 Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares were issued to staff of Bega Cheese under the Bega Cheese employee loyalty offer for no consideration. In total, 18,032,975 Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares were issued for consideration totalling $35,000,000, with the Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares being issued and the cash proceeds from the issue of Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares being received in August 2011. A further 362,500 Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares are to be issued in August 2012 under the retention award portion of the Bega Cheese employee loyalty offer.
Scheme booklet │ Page 61
Pro-forma consolidated statement of financial position
The table below sets out the historical consolidated statement of financial position of the Bega Cheese Group as at 30 June 2011 as well as normalisation adjustments to reflect the impact of the IPO and Bega Cheese operating as a listed entity. The adjustments assume the IPO was completed and the Bega Cheese Group had been operating as a listed entity for the full year ending 30 June 2011.
| $’000 | Actual 30 June 2011 |
Pro-forma adjustments Impact of IPO |
Pro-forma 30 June 2011 IPO |
|---|---|---|---|
| Current assets | |||
| Cash and cash equivalents | 20,587 4,729 25,316 |
||
| Trade and other receivables | 83,341 (2,152) 81,189 |
||
| Other financial assets | 2,489 - 2,489 |
||
| Inventories | 104,595 - 104,595 |
||
| Assets held for sale | 9 - 9 |
||
| Total current assets | 211,021 2,577 213,598 |
||
| Non-current assets | |||
| Other financial assets | 37,010 - 37,010 |
||
| Property, plant and equipment | 197,866 - 197,866 |
||
| Deferred tax assets | 14,400 - 14,400 |
||
| Intangible assets | 1,788 - 1,788 |
||
| Total non-current assets | 251,064 - 251,064 |
||
| Total Assets | 462,085 2,577 464,662 |
||
| Current liabilities | |||
| Trade and other payables | 117,764 (1,175) 116,589 |
||
| Borrowings | 22,006 - 22,006 |
||
| Current tax liabilities | 1,904 90 1,994 |
||
| Provisions | 18,872 - 18,872 |
||
| Total current liabilities | 160,546 (1,085) 159,461 |
||
| Non-current liabilities | |||
| Trade and other payables | 148 - 148 |
||
| Borrowings | 94,300 (31,500) 62,800 |
||
| Provisions | 1,616 - 1,616 |
||
| Total non-current liabilities | 96,064 (31,500) 64,564 |
||
| Total Liabilities | 256,610 (32,585) 224,025 |
||
| Net Assets | 205,475 35,162 240,637 |
||
| Equity | |||
| Contributed equity | 27,169 33,441 60,610 |
||
| Reserves | 46,057 (1,080) 44,977 |
||
| Retained earnings | 106,633 2,801 109,434 |
||
| Capital and reserves attributable to owners of Bega Cheese Limited |
179,859 35,162 215,021 |
||
| Non-controllinginterests | 25,616 - 25,616 |
||
| Total equity | 205,475 35,162 240,637 |
The FY2011 consolidated statement of financial position shown in the table above has been extracted from the Bega Cheese Group 2011 financial statements as reviewed by the
Page 62 │ Scheme booklet
company’s auditors and adjusted to reflect the assumptions set out below and in more detail in section 6.16:
-
(a) Balance sheet effect of one-off items and other normalisation adjustments associated with the IPO as detailed in the reconciliation to statutory financial statements below.
-
(b) 17.5 million Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares were issued as part of the IPO for gross proceeds of $35 million.
-
(c) $31.5 million of the gross proceeds was used to repay existing debt facilities.
-
(d) Residual $3.5 million of gross proceeds was used to fund the fees and expenses of the IPO of which $2.6 million was offset against share capital raised and $0.875 million was expensed in 2011.
-
(e) 532,975 Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares were issued to existing employees for nil consideration under the employee share scheme. This was accounted for in the consolidated 30 June 2011 Bega Cheese Group financial statements as a cost during the year and credited to the share based payment reserve. The value of the issued Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares was then transferred to share capital on issue.
Reconciliation to statutory financial statements
In the table below the statutory profit before tax has been extracted from Bega Cheese’s audited 2011 consolidated financial statements and adjusted to reflect the impact of oneoff items and other normalisation adjustments associated with the IPO and Bega Cheese operating as a publicly listed entity.
Pro-forma adjustments to statutory consolidated income statement
| $’000 | Actual 2011 |
Actual 2010 |
|---|---|---|
| Statutory profit before income tax | 22,090 21,799 |
|
| Adjustments per Bega Cheese Prospectus (excluding tax effect) | ||
| 1 Add back total RMPP |
6,497 6,605 |
|
| 2 Deduct the expense component of RMPP |
(4,240) (3,963) |
|
| 3 Incremental public company expenses |
(1,338) - |
|
| 4 Adjust interest expense for IPO capital raising |
1,868 - |
|
| 5 Employee loyalty offer expense |
1,080 - |
|
| 6 IPO related expenses |
875 - |
|
| Total adjustments as per prospectus | 4,742 2,642 |
|
| Additional adjustments to reflect IPO (excluding tax effect) | ||
| 7 IPO related expenses (actual) |
(875) - |
|
| 8 Issue of Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares under employee share scheme |
(1,066) - |
|
| Total pro-forma adjustments to statutory consolidated statement of income | 3,867 2,642 |
|
| Pro-forma profit before income tax | 25,957 24,441 |
Scheme booklet │ Page 63
Notes to adjustments:
-
Bega Cheese made payments to its dairy farmer suppliers in these periods described as regional milk price premiums (RMPP). This item comprised separately identified payments to Bega Cheese Dairy Farmer Suppliers for actual milk delivered in excess of the estimated average price of milk paid to dairy farmers of other entities and in some years it also included a specific drought relief payment. Whilst it was effectively a distribution to dairy farmer suppliers paid based on milk delivered (rather than shares) it was treated as a separate expense line in the calculation of reported profit before tax.
-
With effect from 1 July 2011, Bega Cheese adopted a new milk payments policy which will no longer recognise RMPP separately. Accordingly, the board and management reviewed previous payments to determine that the results reflect consistent outcomes based on how they intend to implement the new milk pricing policy going forward. Accordingly, line 1 adds back all of the actual RMPP and line 2 shows that part of the RMPP that the Bega Cheese board has assessed should be treated as an expense to cost of goods manufactured, consistent with the new milk pricing policy. The difference between lines 1 and 2 is effectively the distribution primarily paid to dairy farmer suppliers.
-
Reflects the incremental expenses associated with being a public company. These have been included on a pro-forma basis to FY2011 only.
-
Reflects an estimate of interest expense savings expected from the capital raised through the IPO being applied (after applicable fees) to the repayment of debt. These have been included on a proforma basis to FY2011 only.
-
Reflects the FY2011 expense associated with the Bega Cheese employee loyalty offer. This was accounted for in the consolidated 30 June 2011 Bega Cheese Group financial statements as an expense during the year and credited to the share based payments reserve. The value of the issued Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares was then transferred to share capital on issue.
-
Reflects the reversal of accrued IPO expenses associated with the IPO.
-
Reflects the expense of issuing Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares under the IPO.
-
Reflects the expense of issuing 532,975 Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares under the employee share scheme on listing.
6.14 Forecast financial performance
This scheme booklet does not include an earnings forecast for Bega Cheese. The Bega Cheese board does not believe that it has a reasonable basis to provide a meaningful and reliable forecast of Bega Cheese’s earnings due to the uncertainty of such matters as future milk prices, exchange rates and international dairy commodity prices.
6.15 Effect of Merger on Bega Cheese
If the Merger is successful and, as a consequence, Bega Cheese acquires 100% of the Tatura Milk RP Shares, the principal effect of the Merger on the consolidated Bega Cheese Group will be to its equity structure.
Share capital structure
The effect of the Merger on the share capital structure of Bega Cheese will be as follows (assuming no Bega Cheese shares or rights are issued after the date of this scheme booklet until after the Implementation Date other than the Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares to be issued as consideration for the Tatura Milk RP Shares under the Scheme):
Page 64 │ Scheme booklet
| Shares | Number | Percentage of total after |
|---|---|---|
| Merger takes effect | ||
| Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares on | 127,072,403 | 84.1% |
| issue, including the underlying | ||
| Bega Cheese Employee Rights on | ||
| issue, at the date of this scheme | ||
| booklet | ||
| Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares to be | 24,018,816 | 15.9% |
| issued in exchange for Tatura Milk | ||
| RP Shares | ||
| Total | 151,091,219 | 100% |
Pro-forma consolidated statement of financial position
To illustrate the expected effect of the Merger on the Bega Cheese Group, a pro-forma consolidated statement of financial position is set out below which has been prepared using Bega Cheese’s pro-forma consolidated statement of financial position including the effect of the IPO included in section 6.13 of this scheme booklet. As Tatura Milk is currently part of the consolidated Bega Cheese Group, the impact of the Merger is therefore internal to the reserves and equity of Bega Cheese and has no impact on net assets or retained earnings.
Scheme booklet │ Page 65
| $’000 | Pro-forma 30 June 2011 IPO |
Pro-forma adjustments Impact of Merger |
Pro-forma 30 June 2011 Merged Group |
|---|---|---|---|
| Current assets | |||
| Cash and cash equivalents | 25,316 - 25,316 |
||
| Trade and other receivables | 81,189 - 81,189 |
||
| Other financial assets | 2,489 - 2,489 |
||
| Inventories | 104,595 - 104,595 |
||
| Assets held for sale | 9 - 9 |
||
| Total current assets | 213,598 - 213,598 |
||
| Non-current assets | |||
| Other financial assets | 37,010 - 37,010 |
||
| Property, plant and equipment | 197,866 - 197,866 |
||
| Deferred tax assets | 14,400 - 14,400 |
||
| Intangible assets | 1,788 - 1,788 |
||
| Total non-current assets | 251,064 - 251,064 |
||
| Total Assets | 464,662 - 464,662 |
||
| Current liabilities | |||
| Trade and other payables | 116,589 - 116,589 |
||
| Borrowings | 22,006 - 22,006 |
||
| Current tax liabilities | 1,994 - 1,994 |
||
| Provisions | 18,872 - 18,872 |
||
| Total current liabilities | 159,461 - 159,461 |
||
| Non-current liabilities | |||
| Trade and other payables | 148 - 148 |
||
| Borrowings | 62,800 - 62,800 |
||
| Provisions | 1,616 - 1,616 |
||
| Total non-current liabilities | 64,564 - 64,564 |
||
| Total Liabilities | 224,025 - 224,025 |
||
| Net Assets | 240,637 - 240,637 |
||
| Equity | |||
| Contributed equity | 60,610 40,832 101,442 |
||
| Reserves | 44,977 (15,216) 29,761 |
||
| Retained earnings | 109,434 - 109,434 |
||
| Capital and reserves attributable to owners of Bega Cheese Limited |
215,021 25,616 240,637 |
||
| Non-controllinginterests | 25,616 (25,616) - |
||
| Total equity | 240,637 - 240,637 |
6.16 Pro-forma financial information
Financial profile of the Merged Group
The pro-forma historical information of the Merged Group comprises the consolidated statement of financial position of Tatura Milk and Bega Cheese as at 30 June 2011 which has been prepared using:
- (a) the Bega Cheese consolidated statement of financial position as at 30 June 2011, as extracted from the audited consolidated financial statements at that date;
Page 66 │ Scheme booklet
-
(b) normalising adjustments contained in the Bega Cheese Prospectus. In addition, the adjustments show the effect of material events since the balance sheet date, being the issue of additional share capital pursuant to the Bega Cheese Prospectus on or about 15 August 2011 as if it had taken place at 30 June 2011;
-
(c) relevant acquisition and other adjustments required to present the pro-forma consolidated statement of financial position for the Merged Group as if the Merger had been implemented on 30 June 2011.
Basis of preparation
The Merged Group pro-forma historical financial information is provided for illustrative purposes and is prepared using assumptions to adjust the financial statements as prepared at 30 June 2011.
The pro-forma consolidated statement of financial position of the Bega Cheese Group is based on the Bega Cheese consolidated financial position as at 30 June 2011, which was prepared in accordance with Australian Accounting Standards and audited by PricewaterhouseCoopers. This is contained in the 2011 annual report which can be found on the Bega Cheese website at www.begacheese.com.au.
Normalising adjustments have been incorporated into the consolidated statement of financial position to reflect the balance sheet effect of the pro-forma adjustments to profit before income tax described above. The effect of these is summarised as:
| Description of normalising adjustments | Impact on pro-forma consolidated statement of financialposition |
Impact on pro-forma consolidated statement of financialposition |
Impact on pro-forma consolidated statement of financialposition |
|---|---|---|---|
| Net assets $’000 |
Retained earnings $’000 |
Equity and Reserves $’000 |
|
| Add back total RMPP | 6,497 | 6,497 | - |
| Deduct the expense component of RMPP | (4,240) | (4,240) | - |
| Incrementalpublic companycosts | (1,338) | (1,338) | - |
| Adjust interest expense for IPO capital raising | 1,868 | 1,868 | - |
| Employee loyaltyoffer expense | - | 1,080 | (1,080) |
| IPO related costs | 875 | 875 | - |
| Total of adjustmentsper Bega Cheese Prospectus | 3,662 | 4,742 | (1,080) |
No account is taken of the tax effect of these adjustments. The pro-forma financial information does not incorporate any actual transactions that have occurred subsequent to 30 June 2011, except the impact of the IPO as detailed in section 6.13. The issuing of share capital has been reflected in the pro-forma consolidated statement of financial position as follows:
| Impact onpro-forma consolidated statement of financialposition | Impact onpro-forma consolidated statement of financialposition | Impact onpro-forma consolidated statement of financialposition | Impact onpro-forma consolidated statement of financialposition |
|---|---|---|---|
| Net assets $’000 |
Retained earnings $’000 |
Equity and Reserves $’000 |
|
| Issue of 17.5 million Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares to thepublic at$2.00 each |
35,000 | - | 35,000 |
| Issue of 0.533 million Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares to employees at nil consideration |
- | (1,066) | (1,066) |
| Costs associated with the raisingof new capital | (2,625) | - | (2,625) |
| Other costs associated with the offer | (875) | (875) | - |
| Total | 31,500 | (1,941) | 33,441 |
Scheme booklet │ Page 67
The above adjustments have been reflected in the pro-forma statement of financial position to match the accounting treatment as at 30 June 2011. The $31.5 million net proceeds of the offer were used to decrease long term debt, which is also reflected in the pro-forma statement of financial position.
In addition to the impact of the normalising adjustments and effect of the issue of shares, the pro-forma shows the impact of the proposed Merger by accounting for the proposed transaction as outlined in this scheme booklet.
Merger consideration
Consideration for the acquisition of the 12,009,408 Tatura Milk RP Shares held by Tatura Milk RP Shareholders will be the issue of 2 Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares for every 1 Tatura Milk RP Share held. The pro-forma information reflects the issue of the new Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares at a value of $1.70 each, which equates to a value of $3.40 for each Tatura Milk RP Share and represents total consideration of $40.8 million. This amount has been shown as an increase in share capital.
The actual value of this consideration will fluctuate as the Bega Cheese Ordinary Share price fluctuates during the period through to the Implementation Date.
The potential transaction costs of the Bega Cheese Group of $1,090,000 have not been reflected in the pro-forma adjustments and transactions set out above. If the transaction had occurred at 30 June 2011, the transaction costs would decrease each of cash and cash equivalents and equity of the Merged Group by $1,090,000 before tax.
Accounting for the Merger
The pro-forma financial information assumes that the Merger is accounted for as a transaction with non-controlling interests in accordance with AASB 127 Consolidated and Separate Financial Statements. AASB 127 outlines that change in a parent entity’s ownership that does not result in a change of control is accounted for as an equity transaction.
In applying AASB 127, the following treatment has been adopted:
-
(a) the value of the consideration is $40.8 million;
-
(b) this has been used to offset amounts in respect of the non-controlling interests of $25.6 million, reducing the figure to zero. This demonstrates that on the implementation of the Merger, the shareholders in Bega Cheese will own all the interests of the subsidiaries of Bega Cheese;
-
(c) the balance of $15.2 million is debited to a new reserve – Transactions with Noncontrolling Interests.
Page 68 │ Scheme booklet
This can be summarised as shown below:
| his can be summarised as shown below: | his can be summarised as shown below: | his can be summarised as shown below: | his can be summarised as shown below: |
|---|---|---|---|
| Impact onpro-forma consolidated statement of financialposition | |||
| Description of impact of the Merger | Net assets $’000 |
Retained earnings $’000 |
Equity and Reserves $’000 |
| Issue of new share capital | - | - | 40,832 |
| Removal of non-controllinginterest | - | - | (25,616) |
| Creation of new reserve – Transactions with Non- controllingInterests |
- | - | (15,216) |
| Total | - | - | - |
The Merger is therefore internal to the reserves and equity section of the pro-forma statement of financial position and has no impact on net assets or retained earnings.
The Merger is not expected to have any material tax consequences on the Merged Group. The tax base of the shares purchased by the Bega Cheese Group has been assumed to be equal to the consideration paid and therefore no taxable gain or loss is due on the transaction by the Bega Cheese Group. The impact of tax on the Tatura Milk RP Shareholders is detailed in the taxation report starting on page 178 of this scheme booklet.
6.17 Risks
This section 6.17 identifies what Bega Cheese regards as the key risks which could adversely impact Bega Cheese’s financial performance and cause that performance to differ from any statements of forecast performance contained in this scheme booklet. It also identifies the key risk factors associated with an investment in Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares. You should read the whole of this scheme booklet in order to fully appreciate those risks.
These risks have been identified having regard to the likelihood of them occurring, their potential impact on the Bega Cheese Group and their relevance to Tatura Milk RP Shareholders. They ought not to be taken as an exhaustive statement of the risks faced by Bega Cheese or investors in Bega Cheese. Those risk factors, and others not specifically referred to below, may in the future materially affect the financial performance of Bega Cheese and the value of Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares.
Business specific risks
Business specific risks that may impact significantly on Bega Cheese, its performance and price of Bega Cheese Ordinary include the risks described below.
Background as a co-operative styled business
Bega Cheese has a long history as a successful supplier co-operative business. Although it changed its structure in 2008 from a co-operative to an unlisted public company, and on 16 August 2011 was admitted to the official list of ASX, its constitution retains a number of features reflecting the co-operative background of Bega Cheese, namely the requirement that the board will include at least 4 directors who are or represent Bega Cheese Dairy Farmer Suppliers (out of a maximum of 8) and maximum limits on individual shareholdings in Bega Cheese. There are currently 5 ‘supplier’ directors on the board (see section 6.5 for further details of the directors).
Scheme booklet │ Page 69
As noted in section 6.7, the directors who are or represent Bega Cheese Dairy Farmer Suppliers are not classified as independent directors within the terms of ASX Corporate Governance Principles and Recommendations and accordingly, Bega Cheese does not comply with ASX Corporate Governance Recommendation 2.1, which provides that a majority of directors should be independent directors, or ASX Corporate Governance Recommendation 2.2, which provides that the chairperson of the board of directors should be an independent director.
The constitution of Bega Cheese sets a maximum shareholding limit of 5% for the first 2 years after the listing of Bega Cheese, increasing to 10% from the end of the second year until the end of the fifth year, when the limit must be voted on by shareholders. If shareholders approve the continuation of the shareholding limit, it will be 15% from the end of year 5 until the end of year 10, at which time it will cease to apply. The purpose of the shareholding limit is to provide shareholder stability for the company for a minimum period following its listing on ASX and ensure that a significant stake can only be acquired if the constitution is modified which would require the approval of a special resolution (75% vote) of Bega Cheese shareholders. However, the existence of a shareholding limit is unusual for a listed company and may adversely affect the value ascribed to Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares. As noted in section 8.7, if a person acquires Bega Cheese shares in excess of the limit, the right to vote and receive dividends in respect of the excess shares will be suspended. Further the constitution contains provisions that allow the directors of Bega Cheese to require the sale of the excess shares.
Tatura Milk RP Shareholders should also be aware that if the Merger is effected they will be in minority compared with the existing shareholders of Bega Cheese. As most of the existing Bega Cheese shareholders are current or former NSW-based dairy farmer suppliers to Bega Cheese and the other shareholders are non-dairy farmer investors, it is possible that they may take a different view to Tatura Milk RP Shareholders as to what is in the best interests of Bega Cheese and/or as to the composition of the Bega Cheese board of directors. A table of the current major shareholders of Bega Cheese is set out in section 6.9, and a table of the Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares expected to be on issue after the Merger is implemented is set out in section 6.15.
Milk supply and pricing
The Bega Cheese Group relies upon ongoing milk supply from its farmer suppliers. In turn, the farmer suppliers need suitable climatic conditions in order to produce pastures and source grain and hay/fibre to feed their dairy herds. Farmer suppliers are not under long term supply contracts, and milk prices are usually set and communicated to farmer suppliers on an annual basis.
Farmer suppliers are free to supply alternative buyers if they so wish. The price paid to farmer suppliers for their milk is a key factor in being able to attract and retain supply. Milk prices paid are a function of the returns that the Bega Cheese Group can achieve for its dairy products. If the Bega Cheese Group cannot achieve a return that enables it to be competitive, it may lose supply of milk from its farmer suppliers.
To ensure that the milk price paid by the Bega Cheese Group is appropriate, the board has adopted a new milk price policy effective from 1 July 2011. Under its previous structure Bega Cheese made additional distributions to farmer suppliers in the form of payments based on milk supplied to Bega Cheese. Bega Cheese confirms that under the new milk pricing policy, farmer suppliers will receive a price determined in accordance with that
Page 70 │ Scheme booklet
policy and will participate in future distributions of profits on the same basis as all shareholders.
International dairy commodity prices and foreign exchange risk
Dairy commodity prices fluctuate in accordance with global supply and demand. The market value of core products of the Bega Cheese Group such as cheddar cheese, whey powder, milk powders and butter are all affected by the global commodities market to some extent even those products not exported but traded within the domestic market are similarly affected. There is a risk that a decline in commodity prices may reduce the prices at which the Bega Cheese Group is able to sell its products, thereby adversely impacting Bega Cheese Group earnings unless input prices for raw materials, including milk, can be adjusted to reflect this change.
Where dairy commodities are sold into export markets the main currency is the US dollar. Fluctuations in the Australian dollar as compared to foreign currencies have the potential to adversely impact the revenue and returns of the Bega Cheese Group.
Reliance on major customers and exports
The businesses of both Bega Cheese and Tatura Milk rely on their ongoing commercial relationships with the major customers for which they manufacture and supply products. The scale of the Bega Cheese and Tatura Milk capabilities has enabled them to satisfy the substantial product requirements of large customers, such as Fonterra and Kraft Foods. However, while these major customer relationships represent a strength, the loss of a major customer could result in significant adverse financial consequences, as it is likely to take some time to replace a major customer.
Bega Cheese and its major customer Fonterra have been reviewing various aspects of their agreement for some time and have reached in principle agreement on certain changes to that document. While the parties intend to reflect their in principle agreement in a more detailed, legally binding document to be signed in the near future, there is a risk that this will not be achieved. While the existing agreement between the parties would continue to apply in those circumstances, Fonterra is only obliged to source Bega branded products and could potentially reduce the volume of other products that it sources from Bega Cheese.
As about 34% of the Bega Cheese Group sales are exports, any imposition of trade barriers, regulatory requirements or other matters that would affect world trade may impact the Group’s business.
Environmental risk
Bega Cheese Group, as with other dairy food manufacturers, generates noise, odour, waste and air emissions in the course of food production. These emissions are regulated by statute, licence and agreement that the Bega Cheese Group has to comply with. While the Bega Cheese Group has undertaken major investments to address emission issues and has implemented strategies to deal with some by-products and emissions, it may be required to take further action. Further expense will be incurred in the future to meet commitments to minimise adverse impact on the environment or comply with future requirements from environmental authorities and to changes to environmental regulations.
Scheme booklet │ Page 71
There is a risk that production events could breach environmental/discharge licences or arrangements that the Group holds.
The Bega Cheese Group is also a major energy user and is subject to legislation that requires it to review and seek to reduce its energy usage. Bega Cheese is currently assessing the impact of the new carbon tax legislation. Preliminary analysis by Bega Cheese indicates that the new tax is likely to impact across the supply chain with some costs being passed through to customers and some impact on raw material suppliers. Bega Cheese’s view is that at this early stage of implementation, it is difficult to quantify the impact but it is unlikely to be materially adverse to the Bega Cheese Group’s earnings.
Supply of bulk cheese and nutritional formula products
The Bega Cheese Group has a number of major customers who are required to provide bulk cheese and nutritional formula raw materials for processing. If for any reason major customers were unable to source adequate quantities of raw materials, this may impact the returns to Bega Cheese from its FMCG and nutritionals operations. It should be noted that these customers are either major manufacturers of dairy products or have global procurement networks to ensure supply.
Commercial, operational and product risk
The Bega Cheese Group may be subject to general commercial and operational risks including product defects, changes to market competition and events that interrupt production. Such events could adversely affect the Bega Cheese Group’s financial performance. Like many businesses, the Bega Cheese Group depends on the ongoing and efficient operation of its business systems, infrastructure and supply chain. The Group faces inherent risks including failure of machinery, energy suppliers and computer equipment, industrial action and natural disasters. The group maintains appropriate insurance policies in respect of most insurable risks in accordance with normal commercial practices.
Bega Cheese is the largest retail cheese processor and packer in Australia. It is possible that a new or existing dairy or food processor may build a new facility, acquire an existing operation or otherwise enter the markets in which the Bega Cheese group sells it products and seek to aggressively reduce the group’s existing market share. In addition, retailers may increase their direct import of foreign dairy products. Bega Cheese and some of its customers provide products to Australian supermarkets. Supply arrangements with supermarkets are subject to change with product margin pressure and the de-listing of stock lines having potential to impact the performance of Bega Cheese.
The Bega Cheese Group’s ability to remain productive, profitable, competitive and to effect its planned growth initiatives depends on its ability to attract and retain workers. Tightening of the labour market in key regions due to a shortage of suitably skilled workers may inhibit the group’s ability to hire and retain employees. The group is also subject to occupational health and safety regulations. If the group is not able to maintain its working conditions to meet occupational health and safety regulations it may impact its operations and ability to attract and retain workers and also result in contravention of those regulations, which may give rise to potential criminal and civil liability and also damage the Bega Cheese Group’s reputation.
Page 72 │ Scheme booklet
As with all dairy food processors, the Bega Cheese Group is exposed to the risk of product contamination and product recalls. The group manages this risk by:
-
(a) testing and monitoring milk intake continually during and on completion of the production process;
-
(b) quality review procedures during manufacturing;
-
(c) external audit of operations systems by NSW Food Authority, Dairy Food Safety Victoria, Australian Quarantine and Inspection Service and some customers; and
-
(d) maintaining insurance cover against any third party claim where appropriate and cost effective to do so.
Key personnel
The Bega Cheese Group’s success depends to a significant extent on its key personnel, in particular the senior management team described in section 6.6. These individuals have extensive experience in and knowledge of the Australian dairy industry and the Bega Cheese Group business. Changes that adversely affect the Bega Cheese Group’s ability to retain key personnel or an inability to recruit or retain suitable replacement or additional personnel could material impact Bega Cheese Group’s business, operational performance and financial results.
Credit risk
The Bega Cheese Group conducts business with its domestic and international customers on normal commercial terms. These terms include trade credit for varying periods from payment up front to settlement up to 90 days after despatch of goods.
The group has policies and procedures in place to manage credit risk, including risk assessments and/or credit checks on its customers. For some trade receivables the group may also obtain security in the form of letters of credit. In addition, the group obtains insurance over export debtors and Australian customers where appropriate and cost effective.
Regulatory risk
Bega Cheese is required to comply with a range of laws and regulations, including laws and regulations specific to the dairy industry, competition, environmental, occupational health and safety, customs and tariff and taxation laws. Future changes to laws and regulations or accounting standards which apply to Bega Cheese could materially adversely affect Bega Cheese’s future financial performance.
Interest paying debt
Bega Cheese and Tatura Milk have debt facilities with 2 separate financial institutions of circa $155 million. The facilities are stand-alone and are not subject to cross charges or cross guarantees. Separate mortgages and floating charges over all the assets and undertakings of the respective entities have been provided. A condition of these facilities is to comply with various covenants in respect of the financial position and performance of the respective entities.
Scheme booklet │ Page 73
Based on current cash flows, Bega Cheese and Tatura Milk have sufficient facilities to finance their respective operations. Where debt facilities are drawn down, the term and use of the loans is taken into account in deciding what proportion of the loan, if any, should be protected from interest rate movements by using interest swap arrangements. The underlying interest rate payable on borrowings is driven largely by factors outside the control of the group. The group generally maintains between 30 and 60 percent of its borrowings at a fixed rate using interest rate swaps and other arrangements. All borrowings are denominated in Australian dollars.
The working capital facilities ($70 million) are generally negotiated with 12 to 18 month terms and renewed towards the end of each term or otherwise as required. Currently the working capital facilities are due to expire in December 2012 and the term loan facilities in mid-2014. The group currently complies with all the financial covenants associated with its facilities. While the group has no reason to expect that it will not be able to renew its facilities there is a risk of non-renewal or that terms and conditions of renewal may be less favourable than they are currently.
General risks
General risks that may impact significantly on the Bega Cheese Group, its performance and the price or value of Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares include the following.
General economic conditions
The operating and financial performance of Bega Cheese is influenced by a variety of general domestic and world economic and business conditions, inflation, interest rates, exchange rates, access to debt and equity capital markets, and government fiscal, monetary and regulatory policies. A prolonged deterioration in any of the above factors may have a material adverse effect on the financial performance, financial position, cash flows, distributions, growth prospects and share price of Bega Cheese.
No guarantee of dividends
There is no guarantee that dividends will be paid on Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares in the future as this is a matter that depends on the financial performance of the Bega Cheese Group.
Stock market risks
Potential investors should recognise that there are risks associated with any investment in shares. The price at which Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares may trade on ASX may vary depending on the financial performance of the Bega Cheese Group and various external factors. In particular there is a risk that the price at which Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares trade on ASX may be less than the market price for Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares as at the date of this scheme booklet. Further, there is no guarantee that an active, liquid market in the Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares will develop or continue.
Force majeure events
Events such as acts of terrorism, an outbreak of international hostilities or natural disasters may occur within or outside Australia and may have an impact on the Bega Cheese Group’s business. Any such force majeure events may have a negative impact on the value of an investment in Bega Cheese shares.
Page 74 │ Scheme booklet
6.18 Bega Cheese Prospectus
Bega Cheese was admitted to the official list of ASX on 16 August 2011 following its initial public offering of 18,350,000 Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares to raise total proceeds of up to $35,000,000. The offer was made under the Bega Cheese Prospectus dated 18 July 2011 and closed a week early over subscribed.
The Bega Cheese Prospectus contains detailed information about the Bega Cheese Group as at the date of its issue, including its prospects and the potential risks and rewards of investing in Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares. If you would like to review a copy of the Bega Cheese Prospectus it can be obtained by you from Bega Cheese, free of charge, by calling Bega Cheese’s company secretary, Brett Kelly, on (02) 6491 7777 or by downloading a copy from the Bega Cheese website at www.begacheese.com.au.
6.19 Continuous disclosure statement
Bega Cheese, as a disclosing entity under the Corporations Act, is subject to regular reporting and disclosure obligations. These obligations include requiring Bega Cheese to notify ASX of information about specified events and matters as they arise for the purposes of ASX making that information available to the stock market conducted by ASX. In particular Bega Cheese has an obligation under the ASX Listing Rules (subject to certain limited exceptions) to notify ASX immediately of any information of which it becomes aware which a reasonable person would expect to have a material effect on the price or value of the Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares.
Copies of documents lodged with ASIC in relation to Bega Cheese may be obtained from, or inspected at, an ASIC office.
Bega Cheese will provide a copy of any of the following documents, free of charge, to any person who asks for it on or before the Implementation Date:
-
(a) The annual financial report of Bega Cheese for the year ended 30 June 2011.
-
(b) All continuous disclosure notices given by Bega Cheese to ASX to notify ASX of information relating to Bega Cheese under the provisions of the ASX Listing Rules referred to in section 674(1) of the Corporations Act after lodgement of the 30 June 2011 annual financial report and before the lodgement of the copy of this scheme booklet with ASIC.
6.20 ASX quotation
Application for quotation on ASX of the new Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares to be issued under the Scheme has been made to ASX by Bega Cheese, or will be made within 7 days after the date of this scheme booklet.
6.21 Expiry date
No Bega Cheese securities will be issued on the basis of this scheme booklet after 16 December 2012.
Scheme booklet │ Page 75
7. An explanation of the process
7.1 Outline and effect of the proposed Merger
-
(a) The Merger involves you selling your Tatura Milk RP Shares to Bega Cheese in exchange for Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares. As a result, Tatura Milk will become a wholly-owned subsidiary of Bega Cheese.
-
(b) To achieve this it is proposed that pursuant to the Scheme (which only becomes effective if it is approved by Tatura Milk RP Shareholders and the Supreme Court) as set out in the Scheme of Arrangement Deed:
-
(1) Tatura Milk RP Shareholders sell and transfer all their Tatura Milk RP Shares held at 9:00 am on the Implementation Date to Bega Cheese; and
-
(2) Bega Cheese issue to each Tatura Milk RP Shareholder 2 Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares for every 1 Tatura Milk RP Share held by the Tatura Milk RP Shareholder at 9:00 am on the Implementation Date.
This is to happen on the Implementation Date.
-
(c) On the Merger taking effect:
-
(1) Bega Cheese will become the only shareholder of Tatura Milk, holding all of the Tatura Milk RP Shares and Tatura Milk Ordinary Shares;
-
(2) you will become a shareholder of Bega Cheese holding Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares in the ratio of 2 Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares for every 1 Tatura Milk RP Share held by you at 9:00 am on the Implementation Date; and
-
(3) Tatura Milk RP Shareholders will hold in aggregate approximately 24 million Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares which immediately after the issue of those shares would represent approximately 15.9% of the total number of issued Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares and Bega Cheese Employee Rights (assuming no other Bega Cheese securities are issued after the date of this scheme booklet).
-
(d) The Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares issued to you will rank pari passu with all other Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares then on issue. This will include the right to participate in any interim or final dividend payable in respect of Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares, the record date for which is on or after the Implementation Date.
-
(e) Bega Cheese has agreed that the record date for determining entitlements to any dividend on the Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares in respect of the financial performance of Bega Cheese for the 6 months ending 31 December 2011 will be after 31 January 2012. Accordingly, if the Implementation Date occurs before 31 January 2012 as planned, as the holder of Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares issued to you under the Scheme, you will be entitled to participate in any such dividend. However, if implementation of the Merger is delayed until after 31 January 2012, and the Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares under the Scheme are not issued to you until after the record date for a Bega Cheese dividend, you will have no right to participate in the dividend.
Page 76 │ Scheme booklet
-
(f) Bega Cheese must seek ASX quotation of the Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares, and must use its reasonable endeavours to ensure that they are listed for quotation on and from the Business Day after they are issued to you.
-
(g) The terms of the Scheme and Merger are embodied in the Scheme of Arrangement Deed. A copy of the Scheme of Arrangement Deed is set out in this scheme booklet starting on page 181.
7.2 Modifications to the constitution of Tatura Milk
-
(a) Under Tatura Milk’s constitution:
-
(1) the maximum number of Tatura Milk RP Shares which may at any time be held by or on behalf of one person is 5% of the issued Tatura Milk RP Shares (article 4(2));
-
(2) a transfer of Tatura Milk RP Shares must not be registered unless the instrument of transfer is executed by the transferor and transferee and the transfer is to a Supplier (article 25(1));
-
(3) the board of directors of Tatura Milk must include 2 Dairy Farmer Suppliers (article 65(5)); and
-
(4) the number of directors that the ‘Majority Shareholder’ may appoint by written notice is limited to 4 (article 66(1)).
The Majority Shareholder is the person holding more than 50% of the issued shares in Tatura Milk, which is currently Bega Cheese,
-
(b) These and other articles are proposed to be modified to allow Bega Cheese to acquire 100% of the issued Tatura Milk RP Shares under the Scheme as proposed, and to ensure that only Bega Cheese nominees can be directors of Tatura Milk and there is no limit on number, after the Merger takes effect.
-
(c) In particular, it is proposed:
-
(1) to insert at the end of article 4(2) a new paragraph which:
-
(A) would make the acquisition of Tatura Milk RP Shares by Bega Cheese under the Scheme an exception to the limit; and
-
(B) would result in the article ceasing to apply after Tatura Milk becomes a wholly-owned subsidiary of Bega Cheese upon the Merger taking effect;
-
-
(2) to modify article 25(1) to allow the transfer of Tatura Milk RP Shares to Bega Cheese under the Scheme, and to any subsequent transferee after the Merger takes effect;
-
(3) to modify article 65(5) to remove the requirement following the Merger taking effect that there be 2 directors who are Dairy Farmer Suppliers;
Scheme booklet │ Page 77
-
(4) to modify article 66(1) to remove the limit on the number of directors that the Majority Shareholder may appoint following the Merger taking effect; and
-
(5) to modify article 72(1) so that the Dairy Farmer Supplier Directors automatically vacate office upon the Merger taking effect.
-
(d) These proposed modifications are contained in the notice of the general meeting which is set out on page 192.
7.3 Voting by Tatura Milk RP Shareholders
-
(a) The Merger requires three levels of shareholder approval.
-
(b) As noted, Tatura Milk’s constitution will need to be modified to allow Bega Cheese to acquire 100% of the issued Tatura Milk RP Shares under the Scheme as proposed. Tatura Milk may modify its constitution by special resolution. A special resolution must be passed by at least 75% of the votes cast by Tatura Milk shareholders (either in person or by proxy, attorney or representative) who are entitled to vote on the resolution.
-
(c) The special resolution to modify the constitution is to be considered at a general meeting of Tatura Milk convened by the board of directors of Tatura Milk. All shareholders of Tatura Milk, including Bega Cheese as holder of the Tatura Milk Ordinary Shares, will be entitled to attend the general meeting and vote on the special resolution, unless disqualified from doing so under Tatura Milk’s constitution because of outstanding indebtedness owed to Tatura Milk – see paragraph (i) below. Bega Cheese is obliged under the terms of the Merger Implementation Agreement to vote in favour of the special resolution to modify the constitution.
-
(d) The Scheme under which the Merger is to be effected must be approved at a meeting of Tatura Milk RP Shareholders convened in accordance with an order of the Court by a resolution:
-
(1) passed by a majority in number of the Tatura Milk RP Shareholders present and voting (either in person or by proxy, attorney or representative); and
-
(2) passed by at least 75% of the votes cast on the resolution.
-
(e) On an application by Tatura Milk, the Supreme Court ordered Tatura Milk to convene a meeting of Tatura Milk RP Shareholders for the purpose of considering the Scheme. This meeting is a separate class meeting of Tatura Milk RP Shareholders only, excluding Bega Cheese or a subsidiary of Bega Cheese (if any of them are Tatura Milk RP Shareholders). Accordingly, no member of the Bega Cheese Group will be permitted to vote at this meeting. As at the date of this scheme booklet, no member of the Bega Cheese Group is a Tatura Milk RP Shareholder.
-
(f) The general meeting of Tatura Milk at which the special resolution to modify the constitution is to be considered has been convened by the board of directors of Tatura Milk to be held at the Sir Ian McLennan Centre, Echuca Road, Mooroopna, Victoria on Wednesday 14 December 2011 at 11:00 am. The separate class meeting of Tatura Milk RP Shareholders to consider the resolution to approve the Scheme
Page 78 │ Scheme booklet
has been convened in accordance with the order of the Court to be held immediately following the conclusion or adjournment of the general meeting.
-
(g) Notice of the general meeting and notice of the Scheme meeting are included in this scheme booklet on pages 192 and 195.
-
(h) The general meeting will be conducted in accordance with the provisions of Tatura Milk’s constitution applicable to general meetings of Tatura Milk, including the provisions relating to shareholders’ eligibility to vote. The Scheme meeting will also be conducted in accordance with those provisions so far as they are capable of application (and with all necessary changes).
-
(i) Where money due and payable to Tatura Milk in respect of any Tatura Milk shares has not been paid, the holder of those shares is not entitled to attend or vote at a meeting by virtue of that shareholding.
-
(j) Those persons who are registered as the holders of Tatura Milk shares on Monday 12 December 2011 at 7:00 pm ( Determination Time ) will be taken to be the holders of those shares for the purposes of determining voting entitlements at the general meeting and the Scheme meeting. Accordingly, unless disqualified from attending and voting due to outstanding indebtedness owed to Tatura Milk:
-
(1) Bega Cheese, assuming it continues to be the holder of all of the Tatura Milk Ordinary Shares at the Determination Time, will be entitled to attend the general meeting and vote on the special resolution to be considered at that meeting; and
-
(2) if you hold Tatura Milk RP Shares at the Determination Time, you will be entitled to attend both the general meeting and the Scheme meeting and to vote on all resolutions to be considered at those meetings.
-
(k) Each Tatura Milk shareholder entitled to vote on a resolution has one vote on a show of hands and, on a poll, has one vote for each share held.
-
(l) Voting on all resolutions to be considered at the general meeting and Scheme meeting will be by a poll.
-
(m) A shareholder entitled to attend and vote at a meeting is entitled to appoint a proxy, attorney or representative to attend the meeting and vote on the shareholder’s behalf. A shareholder may appoint up to 2 proxies and may specify the proportion or number of votes each proxy may exercise on a poll, but neither proxy is entitled to vote on a show of hands. A person may be appointed proxy, attorney or representative for more than one shareholder, in which case he or she has the voting entitlement of each shareholder he or she represents.
-
(n) In the case of joint holders of a share, anyone of them may vote at a meeting in person or by proxy, attorney or representative in respect of that share as if solely entitled to it, but if more than one joint holder is present (in person or by proxy, attorney or representative) only the joint holder whose name stands first in Tatura Milk’s register of shareholders in respect of the share is entitled to vote in respect of the share.
Scheme booklet │ Page 79
- (o) The quorum required for a meeting is 5 shareholders present at the meeting in person or by proxy, attorney or representative. Where within 15 minutes after the time appointed for the meeting a quorum is not present, the meeting stands adjourned to the same day in the next week at the same time and place or to such other day, time and place as notified to shareholders and others entitled to notice of the meeting. At the adjourned meeting 2 persons each being a shareholder, or proxy, attorney or representative of a shareholder, will constitute a quorum.
7.4 Conditions of Scheme becoming effective
-
(a) The Scheme is conditional on an order of the Court approving the Scheme being made under section 411(4)(b) of the Corporations Act on or before 29 February 2012 or such other date as Bega Cheese and Tatura Milk may agree. It is anticipated that Court approval will be sought on Friday 16 December 2011 and the Implementation Date will be Friday 23 December 2011.
-
(b) The Scheme is also conditional on the Merger Implementation Agreement between Tatura Milk and Bega Cheese not being terminated. Termination could occur because of a number conditions not being satisfied, such as the occurrence of a ‘material adverse change’ or ‘prescribed occurrence’ in relation to Tatura Milk or Bega Cheese, subject to the rights of each of them to waive the non-satisfaction of certain conditions.
-
(c) A more detailed summary of these conditions is set out in section 9.8, and a copy of the Merger Implementation Agreement is available for inspection by Tatura Milk RP Shareholders:
-
(1) free of charge during normal business hours at the registered office of Tatura Milk at 236 Hogan Street, Tatura, Victoria; or
-
(2) from Bega Cheese’s announcements on the ASX website at www.asx.com.au. A summary of relevant provisions of the Merger Implementation Agreement is also contained in section 9.8.
7.5 Becoming a shareholder of Bega Cheese
-
(a) On the Implementation Date of the Scheme, you will be issued Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares and, if you are not then already a shareholder of Bega Cheese, you will have agreed to become a member of Bega Cheese and authorised your name and address as it appears in the register of shareholders of Tatura Milk to be entered into the register of shareholders of Bega Cheese. Bega Cheese will include these details in its register of shareholders as they appear in the register of shareholders of Tatura Milk, subject to the requirements of Bega Cheese’s share registrar. While you are a shareholder of Bega Cheese you agree to be bound by the constitution of Bega Cheese.
-
(b) Your rights as a shareholder of Bega Cheese are set out in Bega Cheese’s constitution, which is summarised in section 8.
Page 80 │ Scheme booklet
7.6 Dealings in Tatura Milk RP Shares before and after Implementation Date
-
(a) If the Court makes an order approving the Scheme under section 411(4)(b) of the Corporations Act, Tatura Milk will close its register of shareholders at 5:00 pm on the date an office copy of the order is lodged with ASIC. That is expected to happen on the next Business Day after the Court approval.
-
(b) Tatura Milk will ensure that all registrable transfers and transmission applications in respect of Tatura Milk RP Shares which are:
-
(1) received by Tatura Milk (or its share registrar) before closure of the register; and
-
(2) not refused for registration in accordance with Tatura Milk’s constitution;
are registered as soon as reasonably practicable after receipt and, where registration occurs after closure of the register, with effect at that time.
-
(c) A Tatura Milk RP Shareholder (and any person claiming through that Tatura Milk RP Shareholder) must not dispose of or purport to agree to dispose of any Tatura Milk RP Shares or any interest in them after the time of closure of the register.
-
(d) Tatura Milk will not register any transfer or transmission application in respect of Tatura Milk RP Shares received after the time of closure of the register, until all the transfers of Tatura Milk RP Shares to Bega Cheese under the Scheme are registered.
7.7 Your Dairy Farmer Supplier Directors to be appointed to the Bega Cheese board
Under the Scheme of Arrangement Deed, Bega Cheese has agreed that:
-
(a) by the Implementation Date 2 of your Dairy Farmer Supplier Directors who are in office at the Effective Date and are selected by or in accordance with an agreement between them will be appointed to the board of Bega Cheese; and
-
(b) Bega Cheese will use its best endeavours to ensure that 2 individuals who are Tatura Milk Dairy Farmer Suppliers (or the representative of a body corporate that is a Tatura Milk Dairy Farmer Supplier) are on the Bega Cheese board for 2 years from the Implementation Date.
All 4 of your Dairy Farmer Supplier Directors have nominated for these 2 board positions, and have agreed to have a ballot for the selection of 2 of them to be voted on by Tatura Milk RP Shareholders only. This ballot is planned to be conducted at the general meeting of Tatura Milk to be held on the same day as the Scheme meeting. Tatura Milk RP Shareholders (or their proxies or other representatives) at the meeting will be asked to cast their vote in favour of just 2 of the candidates and the 2 Dairy Farmer Supplier Directors who receive the most votes will be selected for appointment to the Bega Cheese board. Voting will be by a poll.
7.8 Amendment of Scheme of Arrangement Deed
From the date of this scheme booklet until the Implementation Date, the Scheme of Arrangement Deed may be amended or repealed and replaced by a supplementary deed
Scheme booklet │ Page 81
between Tatura Milk and Bega Cheese but only if the Court approves the amendment or replacement.
7.9 Court approval – when Scheme becomes effective and who is bound by the Scheme
-
(a) On application by Tatura Milk, the Supreme Court has ordered Tatura Milk to convene the Scheme meeting at which Tatura Milk RP Shareholders can consider the resolution to approve the Scheme, to be held immediately after the closure or adjournment of the general meeting on Wednesday 14 December 2011.
-
(b) If the resolution is passed at the Scheme meeting, and the special resolution to modify Tatura Milk’s constitution is also passed at the earlier general meeting, Tatura Milk will apply to the Court for the Court’s approval of the Scheme.
-
(c) If the Scheme is approved by the Court and all other conditions of the Scheme and Merger are satisfied or waived, the Scheme and Merger will become effective whereby all Tatura Milk RP Shares on issue at 9:00 am on the Implementation Date will be transferred to Bega Cheese and Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares will be issued to Tatura Milk RP Shareholders.
-
(d) That will happen on the Implementation Date which will be the 4[th] Business Day after the Effective Date. The Effective Date is the date an office copy of the Court order approving the Scheme is lodged with ASIC or such other effective date of the Scheme and Merger as Tatura Milk and Bega Cheese may, with the consent of the Court, agree. The Scheme, and the Scheme of Arrangement Deed, is binding on Tatura Milk and Bega Cheese and will become binding on all persons who are Tatura Milk RP Shareholders on and from the Effective Date.
-
(e) It is anticipated that Court approval of the Scheme will be sought on Friday 16 December 2011 and the Implementation Date will be Friday 23 December 2011.
7.10 Taxation considerations
Tatura Milk has engaged MB+M Business Solutions to prepare a report on the general Australian taxation implications of disposing of Tatura Milk RP Shares and acquiring Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares as consideration for that disposal under the Scheme. A copy of the report is set out in this scheme booklet starting at page 178. The taxation report is not intended to be comprehensive, and is based on the income tax legislation in force at the date of the report. The report focuses on the situation of Australian resident shareholders holding Tatura Milk RP Shares on capital account. It does not address the tax considerations applicable to Tatura Milk RP Shareholders that may be subject to special rules, such as shares held by non-residents, shares held as trading stock and shares held on revenue account.
You should not rely on the taxation report as advice in relation to your own affairs. The taxation laws are complex and there could be implications in addition to those generally described in the report. It is recommended that you consult your own tax adviser for advice applicable to your individual needs and circumstances. No responsibility is accepted for the tax implications of disposing of your Tatura Milk RP Shares in exchange for Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares under the Scheme. The taxation report is not exhaustive of all possible Australian income tax considerations that could apply and, in particular, does not address the tax considerations applicable to shareholders that may be
Page 82 │ Scheme booklet
subject to special tax rules, nor does it address any foreign tax law ramifications resulting from the Scheme.
Scheme booklet │ Page 83
8. Summary of the constitution of Bega Cheese
8.1 Inspection
Your rights and obligations as a shareholder of Bega Cheese on the Merger taking effect, will be largely contained in Bega Cheese’s constitution, the material provisions of which are summarised below. If further information is required, the constitution should be consulted, a copy of which can be obtained by calling Bega Cheese’s company secretary, Brett Kelly, on (02) 6491 7777 or by downloading a copy from the Bega Cheese website at www.begacheese.com.au. The Corporations Act, ASX Listing Rules and general law also govern the rights of shareholders of Bega Cheese.
8.2 Shares
Subject to the Corporations Act, ASX Listing Rules and the constitution of Bega Cheese, the directors of Bega Cheese may issue, or grant options in respect of, shares in Bega Cheese to such persons, on such conditions and with such rights and restrictions as the directors think fit. At present the only shares in Bega Cheese on issue are Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares.
As the Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares to be issued as consideration for your Tatura Milk Ordinary Shares will, on issue, be fully paid, they are not subject to any calls for money by the directors and will therefore not become liable for forfeiture.
8.3 Voting rights
At a general meeting, every shareholder present in person or by proxy, attorney or representative has one vote on a show of hands and one vote for each Bega Cheese Ordinary Share on a poll.
A poll may be demanded by the chairperson of the meeting, at least 5 shareholders entitled to vote on the resolution or shareholders with at least 5% of the total number of shares in Bega Cheese.
8.4 Dividend rights
Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares participate in all dividends that have a record date after their issue. Dividends are determined by the directors at their discretion and, subject to any special rights (at present there are none), are payable on all Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares in proportion to the amount of the issue price paid up on those shares.
8.5 Rights on winding up
On a winding up of Bega Cheese, all shareholders are entitled to participate in the distribution of surplus property in proportion to the Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares held by them.
8.6 Transfers of shares
Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares are transferable, subject to the requirements of the constitution (including the shareholding limit) and the ASX Listing Rules.
Page 84 │ Scheme booklet
8.7 Shareholding limit
-
(a) No person, together with his or her associates, may hold or have a relevant interest in a number of shares in Bega Cheese that exceeds the shareholding limit. The shareholding limit is 5% of the total number of shares in Bega Cheese on issue for the first 2 years from date of the ASX listing of Bega Cheese (16 August 2011) and 10% of the total shares on issue from the end of that 2 year period (16 August 2013) and to the anniversary of the fifth year of listing (16 August 2016). The shareholding limit must be put to shareholders for renewal for another 5 years by way of ordinary resolution by no later than the fifth anniversary of the listing. If the shareholding limit is not renewed, it will automatically cease. If the shareholding limit is renewed, the shareholding limit will increase to 15% of the total shares on issue and will automatically cease at the tenth anniversary (16 August 2021).
-
(b) The shareholding limit will cease to have effect at an earlier time if Bega Cheese’s constitution is amended by special resolution of shareholders to remove the shareholding limit.
-
(c) If a person acquires shares in excess of the shareholding limit, the right to vote and be paid dividends in relation to the shares held in excess of the shareholding limit will be suspended. Further the directors may require the disposal of the shares held in excess of the shareholding limit. If that disposal is not made within the period set out in the constitution, the directors may proceed to sell those shares and distribute the proceeds of the sale, after paying relevant costs and expenses, to the holder.
8.8 Directors
-
(a) The board of directors of Bega Cheese will comprise up to 8 directors of whom 4 must be, or be the representative of a body corporate that is, a Bega Cheese Dairy Farmer Supplier. This includes a Tatura Milk Dairy Farmer Supplier or any other person who conducts a dairy farming business and supplies milk to Tatura Milk (or any other member of the Bega Cheese Group).
-
(b) Further, during the 2 years after the successful implementation of the Merger, 2 of the directors must be, or be the representative of a body corporate that is, a Tatura Milk Dairy Farmer Supplier.
-
(c) Subject to the Corporations Act and the requirement for a minimum number of 4 directors who are or represent Bega Cheese Dairy Farmer Suppliers, the board may increase or reduce the number of directors comprising the board from time to time. The board must not reduce the size of the board to less than the number of directors in office at the time the reduction takes effect.
8.9 Remuneration of directors
The directors are entitled to be remunerated for their services as directors. The total annual remuneration must not exceed $900,000 or such other amount approved by shareholders. The total annual remuneration amount is divided between the directors in the manner agreed or in default of agreement, equally. Refer sections 9.3(l) and 9.4(j) for further details.
Scheme booklet │ Page 85
8.10 Liquidation rights
All Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares, rank equally in the event of liquidation. Once all the liabilities of Bega Cheese are satisfied, a liquidator may, with the authority of a special resolution of shareholders, divide among the shareholders at the time the whole or any part of the remaining assets of Bega Cheese.
8.11 Indemnity
Bega Cheese must indemnify, on a full indemnity basis and to the fullest extent permitted by law, each director of Bega Cheese for all losses or liabilities incurred by the director as a director. The directors of Bega Cheese may extend this indemnity to other officers, or an auditor, of the Bega Cheese Group.
8.12 Alteration of constitution
The constitution can only be amended by a special resolution passed by at least 75% of the votes cast by shareholders entitled to vote on the resolution.
Page 86 │ Scheme booklet
9. Additional information
9.1 Marketable securities of Tatura Milk – recent sale prices
-
(a) At the date of this scheme booklet, the only marketable securities of Tatura Milk on issue are 28,413,511 Tatura Milk Ordinary Shares and 12,009,408 Tatura Milk RP Shares.
-
(b) As far as Tatura Milk is aware, no Tatura Milk Ordinary Shares have been sold in the 6 months immediately before the date of this scheme booklet.
-
(c) Set out below is all the information that Tatura Milk has as to the sales of Tatura Milk RP Shares in the above-mentioned 6 month period:
| This number of | ...were sold on or | ...for this price | ...totalling this |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tatura Milk RP | about this date... | for each share... | amount... |
| Shares... | |||
| 126,069 | 22 June 2011 | $1 | $126,069 |
| 187,939 | 27 July2011 | $1 | $187,939 |
| 9,585 | 24 August 2011 | $1 | $9,585 |
| 277,773 | 21 September 2011 | $1 | $277,773 |
9.2 Marketable securities of Bega Cheese – recent sale prices
-
(a) At the date of this scheme booklet, the only marketable securities of Bega Cheese on issue are 126,709,903 Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares and 362,500 Bega Cheese Employee Rights.
-
(b) Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares are granted official quotation on ASX, having commenced quotation on 19 August 2011.
-
(c) The latest ASX recorded sale price of a Bega Cheese Ordinary Share before the date of this scheme booklet was $1.72 on 16 November 2011.
-
(d) The highest and lowest ASX recorded sale prices of a Bega Cheese Ordinary Share during the 3 months immediately before the date of this scheme booklet were $1.91 on 8 September 2011 and $1.60 on 7 November 2011 respectively.
-
(e) On 9 March 2011 (before the listing of Bega Cheese) a public announcement about the Scheme and Merger was issued by Tatura Milk and Bega Cheese. On 4 October 2011 a further public announcement about the Scheme and Merger was issued by Tatura Milk and Bega Cheese. The latest ASX recorded sale price of a Bega Cheese Ordinary Share immediately before this further public announcement was $1.77.
Scheme booklet │ Page 87
-
(f) The volume weighted average price of Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares sold on ASX over the period from the commencement of trading of Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares on ASX (19 August 2011) to the day before the date of this scheme booklet was $1.76.
-
(g) The volume weighted average price of Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares sold on ASX over the period from the date the Merger was announced (4 October 2011) to the day before the date of this scheme booklet was $1.70.
9.3 Directors of Tatura Milk and their interests
-
(a) Under Tatura Milk’s constitution, the board of directors of Tatura Milk must comprise up to 4 Bega Cheese Nominees, 2 Dairy Farmer Supplier Directors and up to 2 other directors.
-
(b) The directors of Tatura Milk holding office at the date of this scheme booklet are:
| Name | Status |
|---|---|
| BarryIrvin AM | Chairman and Bega Cheese Nominee |
| Richard Parbery | Bega Cheese Nominee |
| Colin Griffin | Bega Cheese Nominee |
| Aidan Coleman | Bega Cheese Nominee |
| Rick Cross | Deputy chairman and Dairy Farmer |
| Supplier Director | |
| Ken Wood | DairyFarmer Supplier Director |
| Fred De Cicco | DairyFarmer Supplier Director |
| Jeff Odgers | DairyFarmer Supplier Director |
- (c) At the date of this scheme booklet, the directors of Tatura Milk own legally or beneficially or otherwise have a relevant interest in the following marketable securities of Tatura Milk:
| This director… | …has a relevant interest in these |
|---|---|
| Tatura Milk marketable securities… | |
| BarryIrvin AM | Nil |
| Richard Parbery | Nil |
| Colin Griffin | Nil |
| Aidan Coleman | Nil |
Page 88 │ Scheme booklet
| This director… | …has a relevant interest in these |
|---|---|
| Tatura Milk marketable securities… | |
| Rick Cross | 136,585 Tatura Milk RP Shares |
| Ken Wood | 154,927 Tatura Milk RP Shares |
| Fred De Cicco | 135,314 Tatura Milk RP Shares |
| Jeff Odgers | 81,587 Tatura Milk RP Shares |
-
(d) No director of Tatura Milk has acquired or disposed of a relevant interest in Tatura Milk marketable securities in the 4 month period ended on the day immediately before the date of this scheme booklet.
-
(e) Each director who has a relevant interest in Tatura Milk RP Shares will be entitled to participate in the Scheme on the same basis as all other Tatura Milk RP Shareholders and, accordingly, if the Scheme becomes effective, will as a consequence of the Scheme acquire an equivalent relevant interest in 2 Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares for every 1 Tatura Milk RP Share in which the director has a relevant interest at 9:00 am on the Implementation Date.
-
(f) All of your Tatura Milk directors who own or otherwise have a relevant interest in Tatura Milk RP Shares themselves, intend to vote, or procure to the extent they can the relevant Tatura Milk RP Shareholder to vote, in favour of the Scheme and Merger and all related resolutions (including the special resolution to amend Tatura Milk’s constitution to be considered at the general meeting of Tatura Milk to be held before the Scheme meeting).
-
(g) At the date of this scheme booklet, the directors of Tatura Milk own legally or beneficially or otherwise have a relevant interest in the following marketable securities of Bega Cheese:
| This director… | …has a relevant interest in these Bega |
|---|---|
| Cheese marketable securities… | |
| BarryIrvin AM | 3,004,984 Bega Cheese OrdinaryShares |
| Richard Parbery | 2,664,012 Bega Cheese OrdinaryShares |
| Colin Griffin | 120,000 Bega Cheese OrdinaryShares |
| Aidan Coleman | 82,512 Bega Cheese OrdinaryShares |
| Rick Cross | 15,300 Bega Cheese OrdinaryShares |
| Ken Wood | 15,500 Bega Cheese OrdinaryShares |
| Fred De Cicco | 5,250 Bega Cheese OrdinaryShares |
Scheme booklet │ Page 89
| This director… | …has a relevant interest in these Bega |
|---|---|
| Cheese marketable securities… | |
| Jeff Odgers | Nil |
-
(h) No director of Tatura Milk has acquired or disposed of a relevant interest in any Bega Cheese marketable securities in the 4 month period ended on the day immediately before the date of this scheme booklet except as follows:
-
(1) Aidan Coleman has acquired a relevant interest in the following Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares – 82,512 under the Bega Cheese Prospectus by issue on 15 August 2011 at an issue price of $2 each.
-
(2) Rick Cross has acquired a relevant interest in the following Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares – 10,000 under the Bega Cheese Prospectus by issue on 15 August 2011 at an issue price of $2 each; 2,500 by purchase on ASX on 19 August 2011 at a sale price of $1.77 each; 2,800 by purchase on ASX on 23 August 2011 at a sale price of $1.83 each.
-
(3) Ken Wood has acquired a relevant interest in the following Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares – 10,000 under the Bega Cheese Prospectus by issue on 15 August 2011 at an issue price of $2 each; 5,500 by purchase on ASX on 13 September 2011 at a sale price of $1.77 each.
-
(4) Fred De Cicco has acquired a relevant interest in the following Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares – 5,250 under the Bega Cheese Prospectus by issue on 15 August 2011 at an issue price of $2 each.
-
(5) Colin Griffin has acquired a relevant interest in the following Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares – 120,000 under the Bega Cheese Prospectus by issue on 15 August 2011 at an issue price of $2 each.
-
(i) There is no agreement or arrangement made between any director of Tatura Milk and another person in connection with or conditional on the outcome of the Scheme or Merger except as described elsewhere in this scheme booklet.
-
(j) No director of Tatura Milk has any interest in any contract entered into by Bega Cheese (or Tatura Milk or any other member of the Bega Cheese Group) except as described below or elsewhere in this scheme booklet:
-
(1) Barry Irvin and Richard Parbery are Bega Cheese Dairy Farmer Suppliers (or they represent bodies corporate that are Bega Cheese Dairy Farmer Suppliers). In the 2011 financial year, collectively they delivered approximately 2.7% of all milk acquired by Bega Cheese. The terms (including pricing) on which they (or the body corporate they represent) supply their milk, are exactly the same as for other Bega Cheese Dairy Farmer Suppliers in the region in which these directors operate their dairy farms.
-
(2) Each Dairy Farmer Supplier Director, or a body corporate he represents, supplies milk to Tatura Milk. Collectively this amounts to approximately 2.3% of milk acquired by Tatura Milk. The terms (including pricing) on which Dairy Farmer Supplier Directors (or the bodies corporate they
Page 90 │ Scheme booklet
represent) provide their milk are exactly the same as for other Tatura Milk Dairy Farmer Suppliers in the region in which the Dairy Farmer Supplier Directors operate their dairy farms.
-
(3) Each of Barry Irvin, Aidan Coleman and Colin Griffin receive remuneration for their performance of executive duties for Bega Cheese, as detailed in section 9.3(l)(2) below.
-
(k) None of the directors of Tatura Milk has any material interests (whether as a director, shareholder or creditor of Tatura Milk or otherwise):
-
(1) in the Scheme or otherwise in the Merger; or
-
(2) where the effect of the Scheme on those interests is or will be different from the effect on the like interests of other persons;
other than as stated in this section 9 or elsewhere in this scheme booklet.
-
(l) Set out below is a summary of the additional material personal interests of the directors of Tatura Milk in transactions and other arrangements with Tatura Milk (or any other member of the Bega Cheese Group) which are current or occurred since 30 June 2011:
-
(1) Rick Cross is entitled to director fees for his services as a director and deputy chairman of the board of directors of Tatura Milk at the annual rate of $30,000 plus a 9% superannuation contribution and each other Dairy Farmer Supplier Director is entitled to director fees for his services as a director of Tatura Milk at the annual rate of $20,000 plus a 9% superannuation contribution. In addition each Dairy Farmer Supplier Director is entitled to remuneration for performing extra duties (such as working on the Merger) at the daily rate of $625. To the date of this scheme booklet, the Dairy Farmer Supplier Directors have received or are entitled to receive additional remuneration of approximately $20,000 in the aggregate for extra duties relating to the Merger.
-
(2) Each Bega Cheese Nominee is also a director or senior executive of Bega Cheese and is entitled to the following remuneration for his services as such:
-
(A) As executive chairman, Barry Irvin receives a set base salary which is adjusted down for any fees he may earn from his role as director with related organisations and dairy industry entities. Currently that annual amount is $425,000 which includes an annual incentive amount (inclusive of superannuation) of $100,000, less any amounts received by Barry Irvin in his position as a director of the boards of WCB, Tatura Milk and the Gardiner Foundation (estimated currently to be $135,000).
-
(B) Richard Parbery is entitled to director fees for his services as a director of Bega Cheese at the annual rate of $70,000 (inclusive of superannuation).
-
(C) Under his service contract with Bega Cheese as CEO, from 1 July 2011, Aidan Coleman will receive a set base annual salary of $700,000, an at
-
Scheme booklet │ Page 91
risk short term incentive amount subject to the achievement of agreed outcomes of up to $300,000 and a long term incentive scheme linked to the market price of Bega Cheese shares.
-
(D) Under his service contract with Bega Cheese as CFO, Colin Griffin receives a base annual salary and an at risk short term incentive amount subject to the achievement of agreed outcomes as agreed from time to time. In FY2011, Colin Griffin’s total remuneration was $420,689 (inclusive of superannuation).
-
(3) No Bega Cheese Nominee receives, separately, any director fees for his services as a director of Tatura Milk other than:
-
(A) Barry Irvin, who is paid a director’s fee and chairman’s allowance totalling $40,000 per annum (plus a 9% superannuation contribution) by Tatura Milk for his role as chairman; and
-
(B) Richard Parbery, who is paid a director’s fee of $30,000 per annum (plus a 9% superannuation contribution) by Tatura Milk for his role as a director.
9.4 Directors of Bega Cheese and their interests
-
(a) The constitution of Bega Cheese requires that at least 4 out of 8 directors must be (or be the representative of a body corporate that is) a Bega Cheese Dairy Farmer Supplier, and for 2 years following the Merger, 2 of those Bega Cheese Dairy Farmer Supplier directors must be or represent Tatura Milk Dairy Farmer Suppliers.
-
(b) The directors of Bega Cheese holding office at the date of this scheme booklet are:
| Name | Status |
|---|---|
| Barry Irvin AM | Executive chairman who also is (or is the |
| representative of a body corporate that is) a | |
| Bega Cheese DairyFarmer Supplier | |
| Max Roberts | Non-executive director who also is (or is |
| the representative of a body corporate that | |
| is)a Bega Cheese DairyFarmer Supplier | |
| Richard Parbery | Non-executive director who also is (or is |
| the representative of a body corporate that | |
| is)a Bega Cheese DairyFarmer Supplier | |
| Tom D’Arcy | Non-executive director who also is (or is |
| the representative of a body corporate that | |
| is)a Bega Cheese DairyFarmer Supplier | |
| Richard Platts | Non-executive director who also is (or is |
| the representative of a body corporate that | |
| is)a Bega Cheese DairyFarmer Supplier |
Page 92 │ Scheme booklet
| Name | Status |
|---|---|
| Peter Margin | Independent non-executive director |
| JoyLinton | Independent non-executive director |
-
(c) At the date of this scheme booklet, no director of Bega Cheese owns legally or beneficially or otherwise has a relevant interest in any marketable securities of Tatura Milk.
-
(d) No director of Bega Cheese has acquired or disposed of a relevant interest in Tatura Milk marketable securities in the 4 month period ended on the day immediately before the date of this scheme booklet.
-
(e) At the date of this scheme booklet, the directors of Bega Cheese own legally or beneficially or otherwise have a relevant interest in the following marketable securities of Bega Cheese:
| This director… | …has a relevant interest in these Bega |
|---|---|
| Cheese marketable securities… | |
| BarryIrvin AM | 3,004,984 Bega Cheese OrdinaryShares |
| Richard Parbery | 2,664,012 Bega Cheese OrdinaryShares |
| Max Roberts | 1,755,000 Bega Cheese OrdinaryShares |
| Tom D’Arcy | 1,290,276 Bega Cheese OrdinaryShares |
| Richard Platts | 3,616,586 Bega Cheese OrdinaryShares |
| Peter Margin | 2,500 Bega Cheese OrdinaryShares |
| JoyLinton | 20,000 Bega Cheese OrdinaryShares |
-
(f) No director of Bega Cheese has acquired or disposed of a relevant interest in any Bega Cheese marketable securities in the 4 month period ended on the day immediately before the date of this scheme booklet except as follows:
-
(1) Max Roberts has acquired a relevant interest in the following Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares – 80,000 under the Bega Cheese Prospectus by issue on 15 August 2011 at an issue price of $2 each.
-
(2) Tom D’Arcy has acquired a relevant interest in the following Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares – 10,000 under the Bega Cheese Prospectus by issue on 15 August 2011 at an issue price of $2 each.
-
(3) Richard Platts has acquired a relevant interest in the following Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares – 31,000 under the Bega Cheese Prospectus by issue on 15
Scheme booklet │ Page 93
August 2011 at an issue price of $2 each; 47,630 by purchase on ASX on 7 September 2011 at a sale price of $1.89.
-
(4) Peter Margin has acquired a relevant interest in the following Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares – 2,500 under the Bega Cheese Prospectus by issue on 15 August 2011 at an issue price of $2 each.
-
(5) Joy Linton has acquired a relevant interest in the following Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares – 20,000 under the Bega Cheese Prospectus by issue on 15 August 2011 at an issue price of $2 each.
-
(g) There is no agreement or arrangement made between any director of Bega Cheese and another person in connection with or conditional on the outcome of the Scheme or Merger except as described elsewhere in this scheme booklet.
-
(h) No director of Bega Cheese has any interest in any contract entered into by Tatura Milk (or any other member of the Bega Cheese Group) except as described in this section 9 or elsewhere in this scheme booklet.
-
(i) None of the directors of Bega Cheese has any material interests:
-
(1) in the Scheme or otherwise in the Merger; or
-
(2) where the effect of the Scheme on those interests is or will be different from the effect on the like interests of other persons;
other than as stated in this section 9 or elsewhere in this scheme booklet.
-
(j) Set out below is a summary of the additional material personal interests of the directors of Bega Cheese in transactions and other arrangements with Tatura Milk (or any other member of the Bega Cheese Group) which are current or occurred since 30 June 2011:
-
(1) Each non-executive director is entitled to director fees for his or her services as a director of Bega Cheese at the annual rate of $70,000 (inclusive of superannuation).
-
(k) Other than as set out below or elsewhere in this scheme booklet, no director of Bega Cheese has had any interest in the last 2 years in the formation or promotion of Bega Cheese, or in property acquired or proposed to be acquired by Bega Cheese in connection with its formation or promotion or the offer of Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares under the Merger or in the offer itself, and no amount has been paid or agreed to be paid and no benefit has been given or agreed to be given to any director to induce the director to become, or to qualify as, a director of Bega Cheese, or for services provided by the director in connection with the formation or promotion of Bega Cheese or the offer of Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares under the Merger:
-
(1) Directors’ fees payable to the non-executive directors of Bega Cheese on commercial market terms. In the last 2 financial years these have totalled $362,315.
Page 94 │ Scheme booklet
- (2) Executive salary and other remuneration payable to Barry Irvin as an executive director of Bega Cheese as described in section 9.3.
9.5 Retirement benefits
As a result of or in connection with the Scheme or any other aspect of the Merger, no payment or other benefit has been, or is proposed to be, made or given:
-
(a) to any director, secretary or executive officer of Tatura Milk as compensation for loss of, or as consideration for or in connection with his or her retirement from, office in Tatura Milk or another member of the Bega Cheese Group;
-
(b) to any director, secretary or executive officer of a member of the Bega Cheese Group other than Tatura Milk as compensation for the loss of, or as consideration for or in connection with his or her retirement from, office in that entity or in Tatura Milk; or
-
(c) to any person in connection with the retirement of a person from a board or managerial office in Tatura Milk or a related body corporate.
9.6 Bega Cheese’s interests in Tatura Milk
-
(a) At the date of this scheme booklet, Bega Cheese had a relevant interest in 28,413,511 Tatura Milk Ordinary Shares, and had no relevant interest in any Tatura Milk RP Shares.
-
(b) At the date of this scheme booklet, Bega Cheese’s voting power in Tatura Milk was 70.29%.
-
(c) Neither Bega Cheese nor an associate of Bega Cheese has provided, or agreed to provide, consideration for any Tatura Milk marketable securities under a purchase or agreement during the 4 month period ended on the day immediately before the date of this scheme booklet.
-
(d) Neither Bega Cheese nor an associate of Bega Cheese has acquired or disposed of a relevant interest in Tatura Milk marketable securities in the 4 month period ended on the day immediately before the date of this scheme booklet.
-
(e) During the period of 4 months ended on the day immediately before the date of this scheme booklet, neither Bega Cheese nor an associate of Bega Cheese gave, or offered to give or agreed to give a benefit to another person which was likely to induce the other person, or an associate of the other person, to:
-
(1) vote in favour of the Scheme; or
-
(2) dispose of Tatura Milk RP Shares;
and which is not offered or provided to all Tatura Milk RP Shareholders under the Scheme.
- (f) Neither Bega Cheese nor an associate of Bega Cheese has entered into any escalation agreement that would be prohibited by section 622 of the Corporations
Scheme booklet │ Page 95
Act if Bega Cheese had offered to acquire all of the Tatura Milk RP Shares pursuant to takeover bid for those securities made or proposed at the date of this scheme booklet.
9.7 Voting intentions of Bega Cheese
-
(a) Bega Cheese currently holds all of the Tatura Milk Ordinary Shares.
-
(b) Bega Cheese is obligated under the terms of the Merger Implementation Agreement to, and intends to, vote all of its Tatura Milk Ordinary Shares in favour of the special resolution to modify the constitution of Tatura Milk to remove the 5% limit on the ownership of Tatura Milk RP Shares to allow Bega Cheese to acquire 100% of them under the Scheme as proposed, and to make other consequential changes.
9.8 Merger Implementation Agreement
- (a) On 4 October 2011, Tatura Milk and Bega Cheese entered into the Merger Implementation Agreement. The Merger Implementation Agreement sets out the process for Tatura Milk and Bega Cheese preparing for and implementing the Merger and proposing the Merger to the Tatura Milk RP Shareholders. Relevant extant provisions of the Merger Implementation Agreement are summarised below.
Pre-conditions to the Merger
-
(b) Implementation of the Merger is subject to the satisfaction or waiver of a number of pre-conditions. These include:
-
(1) all necessary regulatory approvals being obtained;
-
(2) the Scheme being approved by the Tatura Milk RP Shareholders;
-
(3) the special resolution to modify the constitution of Tatura Milk being passed;
-
(4) there being no temporary restraining order, preliminary or permanent injunction or other order or decision by any court of competent jurisdiction or any regulatory authority which prevents the Merger from proceeding and there being no other legal restraint or prohibition preventing the consummation of any aspect of the Merger on the Implementation Date;
-
(5) no material adverse change event occurring on or before the Implementation Date;
-
(6) no prescribed occurrence occurring on or before the Implementation Date; and
-
(7) the representations and warranties given by a party under the Merger Implementation Agreement being true and correct in all material respects up to the Implementation Date.
-
(c) A material adverse change event will occur if:
-
(1) any one or more events or circumstances happens which individually, or when aggregated, will result in, or be reasonably likely to result in, the earnings
Page 96 │ Scheme booklet
before interest, tax, depreciation and amortisation ( EBITDA ) of Bega Cheese or Tatura Milk for the financial year ended on 30 June 2010 or any later financial year being $10 million or more less than the EBITDA of that entity disclosed (or based on the results disclosed) in its annual audited financial statements for the financial year ended 30 June 2010 lodged with ASIC;
-
(2) the arithmetic average of the daily volume weighted average price at which Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares are sold in the ordinary course of trading on ASX over any 5 consecutive trading days falls below $1.55; or
-
(3) a change in law (including a change to a regulatory approval held by Bega Cheese or Tatura Milk) occurs which prohibits or materially restricts the Merger.
-
(d) A prescribed occurrence will occur if:
-
(1) a party converts all or any of its securities into a larger or smaller number of securities;
-
(2) a party resolves to reduce its capital in any way or reclassifies, combines, splits or redeems or repurchases directly or indirectly any of its securities;
-
(3) a party enters into a buy-back agreement or resolves to approve the terms of a buy-back agreement under the Corporations Act;
-
(4) a party declares or pays a dividend or makes any other distribution to its shareholders;
-
(5) a party issues securities or other instruments convertible into securities, or grants an option over its securities, or agrees to make such an issue or grant such an option;
-
(6) a party makes any change or amendment to its constitution; or
-
(7) an insolvency event occurs in relation to a party;
unless required or permitted to be done or procured by the party pursuant to the Merger Implementation Agreement or the Scheme or approved by the other party. For instance, the issue and redemption of Tatura Milk RP Shares that is approved by the board of directors of Tatura Milk, the issue of Bega Cheese securities to employees of Tatura Milk or any other member of the Bega Cheese Group and the declaration of a dividend by Bega Cheese after 31 January 2012 in respect of the financial performance of Bega Cheese for the 6 months ending 31 December 2011 are permitted under the Merger Implementation Agreement.
Current status of pre-conditions
- (e) At the date of this scheme booklet, the status of each of the pre-conditions is as follows:
Scheme booklet │ Page 97
-
(1) ASIC/ASX approvals –
-
(A) before the Court hearing at which an order to convene the Scheme meeting was sought, ASIC issued a letter stating that it did not propose to make submissions to the Court, or to intervene to oppose the Scheme, at that hearing; as noted on page 1 of this scheme booklet, ASIC has registered this scheme booklet; before the Court hearing for approval of the Scheme, Tatura Milk will request a letter from ASIC stating that ASIC has no objection to the Scheme;
-
(B) Bega Cheese is making arrangements to apply to ASX for quotation of the Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares to be issued to Tatura Milk RP Shareholders under the Scheme and Bega Cheese is not aware of any reason why ASX will not approve the quotation of those shares;
-
(2) obtaining all other regulatory approvals – none is required;
-
(3) obtaining shareholder approval of the Scheme and modification of article 4(2) – this condition cannot be satisfied until the general meeting and Scheme meeting are held;
-
(4) there being no restraining order, material adverse change, prescribed occurrence or breach of warranty – neither Tatura Milk nor Bega Cheese is aware that any such event or circumstance has occurred in relation to it, the occurrence of which has not been waived.
Superior proposal
-
(f) Nothing in the Merger Implementation Agreement restricts Tatura Milk or your Dairy Farmer Supplier Directors from responding to or undertaking another act with respect to a proposed bona fide takeover bid, scheme of arrangement, amalgamation, merger or other business combination involving any member of the Tatura Milk Group and any other person in circumstances where the Dairy Farmer Supplier Directors have determined in good faith and acting reasonably that:
-
(1) the proposal, if recommended by the directors of Tatura Milk and completed substantially as proposed, would result in a transaction materially more favourable to Tatura Milk and its shareholders as a whole than the Merger, after receiving written advice from Tatura Milk’s financial adviser in relation to the matter; and
-
(2) failing to respond in any way to the proposal would be likely to cause the Dairy Farmer Supplier Directors (or the directors of Tatura Milk) to breach their fiduciary or other legal duties, after receiving written advice from Tatura Milk’s external lawyers in relation to the matter;
and Tatura Milk notifies Bega Cheese of this determination in writing (including providing to Bega Cheese the advice from Tatura Milk’s financial adviser and external lawyers).
Page 98 │ Scheme booklet
Termination
-
(g) The Merger Implementation Agreement will terminate if the Scheme is not approved by the Tatura Milk RP Shareholders at the Scheme meeting or the special resolution to modify the constitution of Tatura Milk is not passed at the general meeting, and may be terminated by a party if any other pre-condition to the Merger is not satisfied or waived or resolved by the parties in accordance with the Merger Implementation Agreement.
-
(h) A party may also terminate the Merger Implementation Agreement in a number of other circumstances, including:
-
(1) if the Scheme is not approved by the Court on or before 29 February 2012 or such other date as Bega Cheese and Tatura Milk may agree;
-
(2) due to the material default of the other party; or
-
(3) where the Dairy Farmer Supplier Directors determine that another proposal is superior to the Merger in the circumstances noted above.
-
(i) Bega Cheese may also terminate the Merger Implementation Agreement if a Dairy Farmer Supplier Director withdraws his recommendation that Tatura Milk RP Shareholders vote in favour of the Scheme or makes a public statement indicating that he no longer supports the Scheme.
9.9 Interests and fees of certain people involved in the Merger
Other than as set out below or elsewhere in this scheme booklet, no person named in this scheme booklet as performing a function in a professional, advisory or other capacity in connection with the preparation or distribution of the scheme booklet has had any interest in the last 2 years in the formation or promotion of Bega Cheese, or in property acquired or proposed to be acquired by Bega Cheese in connection with its formation or promotion or the offer of Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares under the Merger or in the offer itself, and no amount has been paid or agreed to be paid and no benefit has been given or agreed to be given for services provided by any such person in connection with the formation or promotion of Bega Cheese or the offer of Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares under the Merger:
-
(a) Value Adviser Associates Pty Ltd has prepared the independent expert report set out in this scheme booklet starting on page 105 and will receive fees at the firm’s usual rates for this work, which will be approximately $70,000 plus GST in total. No statement in this scheme booklet is made by Value Adviser Associates Pty Ltd or is based on a statement made by Value Adviser Associates Pty Ltd, except for the independent expert report, or a reference to that report or a conclusion or other information contained in that report.
-
(b) MB+M Business Solutions has prepared the taxation report set out in this scheme booklet starting on page 178 and will receive fees at the firm’s usual rates for this work, which will be $1,850 plus GST in total. No statement in this scheme booklet is made by MB+M Business Solutions or is based on a statement made by MB+M Business Solutions, except for the taxation report, or a reference to that report or a conclusion or other information contained in that report.
Scheme booklet │ Page 99
-
(c) Lawler Corporate Finance Pty Ltd has acted as corporate adviser for Tatura Milk in connection with the Merger and will receive fees at the firm’s usual rates for this work. In connection with the preparation of this scheme booklet, these fees will be approximately $13,000 plus GST. No statement in this scheme booklet is made by Lawler Corporate Finance Pty Ltd or is based on a statement made by Lawler Corporate Finance Pty Ltd.
-
(d) Norton Gledhill has acted as lawyers for Tatura Milk in connection with the Merger and will receive fees at the firm’s usual rates for this work. In connection with the preparation of this scheme booklet, these fees will be approximately $85,000 plus GST. No statement in this scheme booklet is made by Norton Gledhill or is based on a statement made by Norton Gledhill.
9.10 Consents
-
(a) Every director of Tatura Milk and Bega Cheese has consented to the lodgement of this scheme booklet with ASIC, and its despatch to the shareholders of Tatura Milk.
-
(b) Value Adviser Associates Pty Ltd has consented to the independent expert report set out in the scheme booklet starting on page 105 being included in this scheme booklet in the form and context in which it is included, and has not withdrawn its consent before lodgement of this booklet with ASIC.
-
(c) MB+M Business Solutions has consented to the taxation report set out in the scheme booklet starting on page 178 being included in this scheme booklet in the form and context in which it is included, and has not withdrawn its consent before lodgement of this booklet with ASIC.
Page 100 │ Scheme booklet
10. Glossary
In this scheme booklet, unless the context otherwise requires, the following definitions apply:
ASIC
Australian Securities and Investments Commission
ASX
ASX Limited or the Australian Securities Exchange operated by ASX Limited, as the context requires
ASX Listing Rules Listing rules of ASX Bega Cheese Bega Cheese Limited ABN 81 008 358 503 Bega Cheese Dairy A person who conducts a dairy farming business and supplies Farmer Supplier milk to Bega Cheese or any of its related bodies corporate (which includes Tatura Milk)
Bega Cheese A right granted to a senior executive of the Bega Cheese Employee Right Group to acquire a Bega Cheese Ordinary Share for no monetary payment under an employee share plan established by the board of directors of Bega Cheese called the ‘Incremental Plan’
Bega Cheese Group Bega Cheese and its subsidiaries (which includes Tatura Milk) Bega Cheese A director of Tatura Milk appointed by Bega Cheese Nominee Bega Cheese An ordinary share in Bega Cheese which is, or on issue will Ordinary Share be, fully paid or credited as fully paid
Bega Cheese The prospectus dated 18 July 2011 issued by Bega Cheese for Prospectus its initial public offering of Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares preparatory to its listing on ASX
Business Day A day which is not a Saturday, Sunday, bank holiday or public holiday in Melbourne or Sydney Corporations Act Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) Court or Supreme Supreme Court of Victoria Court
Dairy Farmer A person who conducts a dairy farming business and supplies Supplier or Tatura milk to Tatura Milk (or whom the directors are satisfied will Milk Dairy Farmer do so or deem to be a supplier). After the Merger, to qualify as Supplier a Tatura Milk Dairy Farmer Supplier for the purposes of Bega Cheese’s constitution, the supply of milk must be collected from the person’s farm and delivered directly to Tatura Milk’s milk processing facility at Tatura, Victoria
Scheme booklet │ Page 101
Dairy Farmer Supplier Director
A director of Tatura Milk who is a Dairy Farmer Supplier
Effective Date
The date an office copy of the Court order approving the Scheme under section 411(4)(b) of the Corporations Act is lodged with ASIC or such other effective date of the Scheme and Merger as Tatura Milk and Bega Cheese may, with the consent of the Court, agree
FY
12 months ended or ending 30 June of any year (e.g. FY2010 is the 12 months ended 30 June 2010)
Implementation Date
The 4[th] Business Day after the Effective Date
Industrial Supplier
A person who trades in milk or other dairy commodities and supplies significant quantities to Tatura Milk, and who is not a Dairy Farmer Supplier
IPO
The initial public offer of Bega Cheese Ordinary Shares which resulted in Bega Cheese being admitted to the official list of the ASX on 16 August 2011
Merged Group
The Bega Cheese Group following implementation of the Scheme
Merger
Merger between Tatura Milk and Bega Cheese whereby Tatura Milk RP Shareholders become shareholders of Bega Cheese and Tatura Milk becomes a wholly-owned subsidiary of Bega Cheese in accordance with the Scheme as set out in the Scheme of Arrangement Deed, as proposed or effected
Merger Merger implementation agreement dated 4 October 2011 Implementation between Tatura Milk and Bega Cheese, as amended Agreement
Scheme Scheme of arrangement between Tatura Milk and the Tatura Milk RP Shareholders under part 5.1 of the Corporations Act the terms of which are embodied in the Scheme of Arrangement Deed, as proposed or effected Scheme of Scheme of arrangement deed dated 9 November 2011 between Arrangement Deed Tatura Milk and Bega Cheese Supplier Dairy Farmer Supplier or Industrial Supplier Tatura Milk Tatura Milk Industries Limited ABN 66 006 603 970 Tatura Milk Group Tatura Milk and its dormant controlled entity Tatura Milk An ordinary share in Tatura Milk Ordinary Share
Page 102 │ Scheme booklet
Tatura Milk RP An A class redeemable preference share in Tatura Milk Share Tatura Milk RP A person who is the registered holder of Tatura Milk RP Shareholder Shares other than Bega Cheese or a subsidiary of Bega Cheese WCB Warrnambool Cheese and Butter Factory Company Holdings Limited ACN 071 945 232 you The reader of this document, if you are a Tatura Milk RP Shareholder
Scheme booklet │ Page 103
11. Statements by directors
11.1 Statement by directors of Tatura Milk
This scheme booklet has been approved by each director of Tatura Milk for despatch to the shareholders of Tatura Milk.
The information in this scheme booklet has been prepared by Tatura Milk partly from information provided by Bega Cheese. Tatura Milk has assumed for the purpose of preparing this scheme booklet that the information in sections 3.3 to 3.5, 3.7 to 3.9, 4, 6, 8, 9.2, 9.4, 9.5(b), 9.6, 9.7 and 11.2, in statements attributed or relating to Bega Cheese or its directors and other information provided to Tatura Milk by Bega Cheese ( Bega Cheese Statements ) is correct.
The information concerning Tatura Milk contained in this scheme booklet other than the independent expert report, the taxation report and the Bega Cheese Statements, is the responsibility of Tatura Milk. None of Tatura Milk, its officers and employees and persons engaged by Tatura Milk in the preparation of this scheme booklet takes any responsibility for anything in the Bega Cheese Statements or anything else prepared or distributed by Bega Cheese, except to the extent required by law.
There is no information material to the making of a decision in relation to the Merger (including a decision by a Tatura Milk RP Shareholder whether or not to agree to the Scheme), being information that is within the knowledge of any director of Tatura Milk or of its dormant subsidiary and that has not previously been disclosed to the Tatura Milk RP Shareholders, other than the information set out in this scheme booklet.
11.2 Statement by directors of Bega Cheese
Each director of Bega Cheese agrees with the Bega Cheese Statements, and has approved their despatch to the shareholders of Tatura Milk as contained in this scheme booklet.
The Bega Cheese Statements are the responsibility of Bega Cheese. None of Bega Cheese, its officers and employees and persons engaged by Bega Cheese in the preparation of the Bega Cheese Statements takes any responsibility for any other part of this scheme booklet or anything else prepared or distributed by Tatura Milk, except to the extent required by law.
There is no information material to the making of a decision in relation to the Merger (including a decision by a Tatura Milk RP Shareholder whether or not to agree to the Scheme), being information that is within the knowledge of any director of Bega Cheese or of any wholly-owned subsidiary of Bega Cheese and that has not previously been disclosed to the Tatura Milk RP Shareholders, other than the information set out in this scheme booklet.
Page 104 │ Scheme booklet
Independent expert report
==> picture [454 x 641] intentionally omitted <==
Scheme booklet │ Page 105
==> picture [463 x 653] intentionally omitted <==
Page 106 │ Scheme booklet
==> picture [463 x 656] intentionally omitted <==
Scheme booklet │ Page 107
==> picture [463 x 655] intentionally omitted <==
Page 108 │ Scheme booklet
==> picture [463 x 655] intentionally omitted <==
Scheme booklet │ Page 109
==> picture [463 x 654] intentionally omitted <==
Page 110 │ Scheme booklet
==> picture [463 x 653] intentionally omitted <==
Scheme booklet │ Page 111
==> picture [463 x 655] intentionally omitted <==
Page 112 │ Scheme booklet
==> picture [463 x 655] intentionally omitted <==
Scheme booklet │ Page 113
==> picture [463 x 655] intentionally omitted <==
Page 114 │ Scheme booklet
==> picture [463 x 654] intentionally omitted <==
Scheme booklet │ Page 115
==> picture [463 x 652] intentionally omitted <==
Page 116 │ Scheme booklet
==> picture [463 x 655] intentionally omitted <==
Scheme booklet │ Page 117
==> picture [463 x 655] intentionally omitted <==
Page 118 │ Scheme booklet
==> picture [463 x 654] intentionally omitted <==
Scheme booklet │ Page 119
==> picture [463 x 654] intentionally omitted <==
Page 120 │ Scheme booklet
==> picture [463 x 655] intentionally omitted <==
Scheme booklet │ Page 121
==> picture [463 x 654] intentionally omitted <==
Page 122 │ Scheme booklet
==> picture [463 x 655] intentionally omitted <==
Scheme booklet │ Page 123
==> picture [463 x 654] intentionally omitted <==
Page 124 │ Scheme booklet
==> picture [463 x 656] intentionally omitted <==
Scheme booklet │ Page 125
==> picture [463 x 654] intentionally omitted <==
Page 126 │ Scheme booklet
==> picture [463 x 654] intentionally omitted <==
Scheme booklet │ Page 127
==> picture [463 x 655] intentionally omitted <==
Page 128 │ Scheme booklet
==> picture [463 x 655] intentionally omitted <==
Scheme booklet │ Page 129
==> picture [463 x 654] intentionally omitted <==
Page 130 │ Scheme booklet
==> picture [463 x 652] intentionally omitted <==
Scheme booklet │ Page 131
==> picture [463 x 654] intentionally omitted <==
Page 132 │ Scheme booklet
==> picture [463 x 654] intentionally omitted <==
Scheme booklet │ Page 133
==> picture [463 x 654] intentionally omitted <==
Page 134 │ Scheme booklet
==> picture [463 x 655] intentionally omitted <==
Scheme booklet │ Page 135
==> picture [463 x 654] intentionally omitted <==
Page 136 │ Scheme booklet
==> picture [463 x 654] intentionally omitted <==
Scheme booklet │ Page 137
==> picture [463 x 654] intentionally omitted <==
Page 138 │ Scheme booklet
==> picture [463 x 656] intentionally omitted <==
Scheme booklet │ Page 139
==> picture [463 x 654] intentionally omitted <==
Page 140 │ Scheme booklet
==> picture [463 x 654] intentionally omitted <==
Scheme booklet │ Page 141
==> picture [463 x 654] intentionally omitted <==
Page 142 │ Scheme booklet
==> picture [463 x 654] intentionally omitted <==
Scheme booklet │ Page 143
==> picture [463 x 654] intentionally omitted <==
Page 144 │ Scheme booklet
==> picture [463 x 654] intentionally omitted <==
Scheme booklet │ Page 145
==> picture [463 x 655] intentionally omitted <==
Page 146 │ Scheme booklet
==> picture [463 x 654] intentionally omitted <==
Scheme booklet │ Page 147
==> picture [463 x 652] intentionally omitted <==
Page 148 │ Scheme booklet
==> picture [463 x 656] intentionally omitted <==
Scheme booklet │ Page 149
==> picture [463 x 653] intentionally omitted <==
Page 150 │ Scheme booklet
==> picture [463 x 654] intentionally omitted <==
Scheme booklet │ Page 151
==> picture [463 x 656] intentionally omitted <==
Page 152 │ Scheme booklet
==> picture [463 x 654] intentionally omitted <==
Scheme booklet │ Page 153
==> picture [463 x 654] intentionally omitted <==
Page 154 │ Scheme booklet
==> picture [463 x 654] intentionally omitted <==
Scheme booklet │ Page 155
==> picture [463 x 655] intentionally omitted <==
Page 156 │ Scheme booklet
==> picture [463 x 654] intentionally omitted <==
Scheme booklet │ Page 157
==> picture [463 x 654] intentionally omitted <==
Page 158 │ Scheme booklet
==> picture [463 x 654] intentionally omitted <==
Scheme booklet │ Page 159
==> picture [463 x 655] intentionally omitted <==
Page 160 │ Scheme booklet
==> picture [463 x 655] intentionally omitted <==
Scheme booklet │ Page 161
==> picture [463 x 654] intentionally omitted <==
Page 162 │ Scheme booklet
==> picture [463 x 654] intentionally omitted <==
Scheme booklet │ Page 163
==> picture [463 x 653] intentionally omitted <==
Page 164 │ Scheme booklet
==> picture [463 x 654] intentionally omitted <==
Scheme booklet │ Page 165
==> picture [463 x 654] intentionally omitted <==
Page 166 │ Scheme booklet
==> picture [463 x 654] intentionally omitted <==
Scheme booklet │ Page 167
==> picture [463 x 654] intentionally omitted <==
Page 168 │ Scheme booklet
==> picture [463 x 654] intentionally omitted <==
Scheme booklet │ Page 169
==> picture [463 x 653] intentionally omitted <==
Page 170 │ Scheme booklet
==> picture [463 x 654] intentionally omitted <==
Scheme booklet │ Page 171
==> picture [463 x 654] intentionally omitted <==
Page 172 │ Scheme booklet
==> picture [463 x 654] intentionally omitted <==
Scheme booklet │ Page 173
==> picture [463 x 654] intentionally omitted <==
Page 174 │ Scheme booklet
==> picture [463 x 655] intentionally omitted <==
Scheme booklet │ Page 175
==> picture [463 x 654] intentionally omitted <==
Page 176 │ Scheme booklet
==> picture [463 x 654] intentionally omitted <==
Scheme booklet │ Page 177
Taxation report
==> picture [451 x 637] intentionally omitted <==
Page 178 │ Scheme booklet
==> picture [466 x 659] intentionally omitted <==
Scheme booklet │ Page 179
==> picture [466 x 659] intentionally omitted <==
Page 180 │ Scheme booklet
Scheme of arrangement deed
==> picture [460 x 649] intentionally omitted <==
Scheme booklet │ Page 181
==> picture [466 x 659] intentionally omitted <==
Page 182 │ Scheme booklet
==> picture [466 x 659] intentionally omitted <==
Scheme booklet │ Page 183
==> picture [466 x 659] intentionally omitted <==
Page 184 │ Scheme booklet
==> picture [466 x 659] intentionally omitted <==
Scheme booklet │ Page 185
==> picture [466 x 659] intentionally omitted <==
Page 186 │ Scheme booklet
==> picture [466 x 659] intentionally omitted <==
Scheme booklet │ Page 187
==> picture [466 x 659] intentionally omitted <==
Page 188 │ Scheme booklet
==> picture [466 x 659] intentionally omitted <==
Scheme booklet │ Page 189
==> picture [466 x 659] intentionally omitted <==
Page 190 │ Scheme booklet
==> picture [466 x 75] intentionally omitted <==
==> picture [466 x 74] intentionally omitted <==
==> picture [466 x 74] intentionally omitted <==
==> picture [466 x 74] intentionally omitted <==
==> picture [466 x 74] intentionally omitted <==
==> picture [466 x 74] intentionally omitted <==
==> picture [466 x 74] intentionally omitted <==
==> picture [466 x 74] intentionally omitted <==
==> picture [466 x 74] intentionally omitted <==
Scheme booklet │ Page 191
Notice of general meeting
Tatura Milk Industries Limited ACN 006 603 970
Notice of general meeting
Notice is given that a meeting of members of Tatura Milk Industries Limited ( Tatura Milk ) will be held at the Sir Ian McLennan Centre, Echuca Road, Mooroopna, Victoria on Wednesday 14 December 2011 at 11:00 am (Melbourne time).
Item 1 — Modification of constitution
To consider and if thought fit pass the following resolution as a special resolution :
That the constitution of Tatura Milk be modified as follows:
- Insert the following new definition in alphabetical order in article 1(1):
‘“Scheme” means the scheme of arrangement between the Company and the holders of A class shares under part 5.1 of the Act the terms of which are embodied in the scheme of arrangement deed dated 9 November 2011 between the Company and Bega Cheese Limited, as proposed or effected;’
-
Insert the following new paragraph at the end of article 4(2):
‘Article 4(2)(b) does not apply to Bega Cheese Limited in circumstances where it becomes the holder of A class shares due to the acquisition of A class shares under the Scheme. Further, this article 4 shall cease to apply and to have any effect after the Company becomes a wholly-owned subsidiary of Bega Cheese Limited upon the Scheme taking effect.’
-
Insert the following words after the ‘statute’ at the end of article 25(1)(a):
‘or, in the case of the transfer to Bega Cheese Limited under the Scheme, there has been delivered to the Company the scheme of arrangement deed which embodies the terms of the Scheme or such other proper instrument of transfer, duly stamped if necessary’
- Insert the following after the word ‘Supplier’ at the end of article 25(1)(c):
‘, or the transfer is to Bega Cheese Limited of A class shares acquired by Bega Cheese Limited under the Scheme. This article 25(1)(c) shall cease to apply and to have any effect after the Company becomes a wholly-owned subsidiary of Bega Cheese Limited upon the Scheme taking effect’
- Insert the following new paragraph at the end of article 65(5):
Page 192 │ Scheme booklet
‘Article 65(5)(b) shall cease to apply and to have any effect after the Company becomes a wholly-owned subsidiary of Bega Cheese Limited upon the Scheme taking effect.’
- Insert the following words after the word ‘Directors’ at the end of article 66(1)(a):
‘or after the Company becomes a wholly-owned subsidiary of Bega Cheese Limited upon the Scheme taking effect, up to the maximum number of Directors’
-
Insert the following new paragraph (g) in article 72(1):
‘is a Director other than a Majority Shareholder Director and the Company becomes a wholly-owned subsidiary of Bega Cheese Limited upon the Scheme taking effect; or’
and relabel the existing paragraph (g) of article 72(1) as paragraph (h).
Item 2 — selection of 2 Dairy Farmer Supplier Directors to be appointed to Bega Cheese board
To conduct a ballot for the selection of 2 of the Dairy Farmer Supplier Directors (Rick Cross, Ken Wood, Fred De Cicco and Jeff Odgers) that are to be appointed as directors of Bega Cheese Limited in connection with the merger of 100% of Tatura Milk with Bega Cheese Limited.
Dated: 17 November 2011
By order of the board
==> picture [154 x 50] intentionally omitted <==
..........................................
Paul van Heerwaarden Company Secretary
Notes:
-
A member entitled to attend and vote at this meeting is entitled to appoint one proxy or, if the member is entitled to cast two or more votes at the meeting, two proxies to attend and vote on behalf and instead of the member.
-
Where two proxies are appointed, each proxy must be appointed to represent a specified proportion or number of the member’s votes. If the appointment does not specify the proportion or number of the member’s votes each proxy may exercise, each proxy may exercise half of the votes.
-
A proxy need not be a member.
-
A proxy form accompanies this notice. To be valid it must be received together with the power of attorney or other authority (if any) under which the form is signed, or a certified copy of that power or authority, not less than 48 hours before the time for holding the meeting, namely by 11:00 am (Melbourne time) on Monday 12 December 2011 at Tatura Milk’s registered office at 236 Hogan Street, Tatura, Victoria, 3616 by hand delivery or post or fax (fax no: (03) 5824 2534).
Scheme booklet │ Page 193
- Regulation 7.11.37 determination: A determination has been made by the board of directors of Tatura Milk under regulation 7.11.37 of the Corporations Regulations 2001 (Cth) that those persons who are registered as the holders of shares in Tatura Milk as at 7:00 pm (Melbourne time) on Monday 12 December 2011 will be taken to be the holders of shares for the purposes of determining voting entitlements at the meeting.
Voting exclusion
Tatura Milk will disregard any votes cast in the ballot under item 2 by Bega Cheese Limited or any subsidiary of Bega Cheese Limited.
Defined terms
A word or term defined in section 10 of the scheme booklet of which this notice forms part, has the same meaning in this notice, unless the context otherwise requires.
Page 194 │ Scheme booklet
Notice of Scheme meeting
Tatura Milk Industries Limited ACN 006 603 970
Notice of scheme meeting
Notice is given, in accordance with an order of the Supreme Court of Victoria on 17 November 2011, under section 411(1) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), that a meeting of members of Tatura Milk Industries Limited ( Tatura Milk ) who hold A class redeemable preference shares in Tatura Milk will be held at the Sir Ian McLennan Centre, Echuca Road, Mooroopna, Victoria on Wednesday 14 December 2011, immediately following the conclusion of the general meeting of Tatura Milk (which is to be held at the same place on that date commencing at 11:00 am (Melbourne time)).
Resolution — Scheme of arrangement
To consider and if thought fit pass the following resolution:
That the scheme of arrangement proposed to be made between Tatura Milk and its members holding A class redeemable preference shares pursuant to the scheme of arrangement deed between Tatura Milk and Bega Cheese Limited, a copy of which has been tabled at the meeting and signed by the chairman for the purposes of identification, be approved.
Dated: 17 November 2011
By order of the board
==> picture [154 x 50] intentionally omitted <==
..........................................
Paul van Heerwaarden Company Secretary
Notes:
-
A member entitled to attend and vote at this meeting is entitled to appoint one proxy or, if the member is entitled to cast two or more votes at the meeting, two proxies to attend and vote on behalf and instead of the member.
-
Where two proxies are appointed, each proxy must be appointed to represent a specified proportion or number of the member’s votes. If the appointment does not specify the proportion or number of the member’s votes each proxy may exercise, each proxy may exercise half of the votes.
-
A proxy need not be a member.
Scheme booklet │ Page 195
-
A proxy form accompanies this notice. To be valid it must be received together with the power of attorney or other authority (if any) under which the form is signed, or a certified copy of that power or authority, by 11:00 am (Melbourne time) on Monday 12 December 2011 at Tatura Milk’s registered office at 236 Hogan Street, Tatura, Victoria, 3616 by hand delivery or post or fax (fax no: (03) 5824 2534).
-
Regulation 7.11.37 determination: A determination has been made by the board of directors of Tatura Milk under regulation 7.11.37 of the Corporations Regulations 2001 (Cth) that those persons who are registered as the holders of A class redeemable preference shares in Tatura Milk as at 7:00pm (Melbourne time) on Monday 12 December 2011, excluding Bega Cheese Limited or any subsidiary of Bega Cheese Limited, will be taken to be the holders of those A class redeemable preference shares for the purposes of determining voting entitlements at the scheme meeting.
Eligibility to attend and vote
This scheme meeting is a meeting of the members of Tatura Milk who hold A class redeemable preference shares in Tatura Milk, excluding Bega Cheese Limited or any subsidiary of Bega Cheese Limited. Only those members are entitled to attend and vote at the scheme meeting.
Convening of this meeting
The Supreme Court of Victoria has ordered the convening of the scheme meeting to consider the proposed scheme of arrangement between Tatura Milk and its members who hold A class redeemable preference shares. The court has directed that Richard Cross or, if he is unable or unwilling to act, Fred De Cicco to act as chair of the scheme meeting and has also directed the chair to report the result of the meeting to the court to the extent it relates to the scheme of arrangement. The scheme of arrangement, if approved by members, will be subject to the subsequent approval of the court. This notice should be read in conjunction with the scheme booklet of which this notice forms part. The scheme booklet contains, among other things, a copy of the scheme of arrangement as contained in the scheme of arrangement deed between Tatura Milk and Bega Cheese Limited. The scheme booklet also provides information about the scheme of arrangement and should be read in its entirety.
Defined terms
A word or term defined in section 10 of the scheme booklet of which this notice forms part, has the same meaning in this notice, unless the context otherwise requires.
Page 196 │ Scheme booklet
Corporate directory
Tatura Milk Industries Limited ABN 66 006 603 970
Registered office
236 Hogan Street Tatura VIC 3616
Directors
Barry Irvin AM Richard Parbery Colin Griffin Aidan Coleman Rick Cross Ken Wood Fred De Cicco Jeff Odgers
Executive general manager
Paul van Heerwaarden
Company secretaries
Colin Griffin Paul van Heerwaarden Jason Wells
Corporate adviser
Lawler Corporate Finance Pty Ltd Level 9, 1 O’Connell Street Sydney NSW 2000
Independent expert
Value Adviser Associates Pty Ltd Level 2 65 Southbank Boulevard Southbank VIC 3006
Lawyers
Norton Gledhill Commercial Lawyers Level 23, 459 Collins Street Melbourne VIC 3000
Taxation adviser MB+M Business Solutions Chartered Accountants 23 Nixon Street Shepparton VIC 3630
Merger inquiry contact details
Stuart Brown Tatura Milk (03) 5824 6200
Scheme booklet │ Page 197