Skip to main content

AI assistant

Sign in to chat with this filing

The assistant answers questions, extracts KPIs, and summarises risk factors directly from the filing text.

AXA Interim / Quarterly Report 2009

May 7, 2009

1135_10-q_2009-05-07_222a2d0e-3c4e-46b0-931b-d7a1ed7504c4.pdf

Interim / Quarterly Report

Open in viewer

Opens in your device viewer

1Q 2009 Activity Indicators

Resilient revenues

Total revenues were down 2% to €27,598 million

On a comparable basis, revenues were down 5%:

  • Life & Savings down 7% to €16,453 million
  • Property & Casualty up 1% to €9,113 million

P&C: +296,0001 net new personal contracts

• Asset Management down 34% to €762 million

Positive insurance net inflows

Asset Management: €-17.4 billion

Life & Savings: € +3.3 billion

Enhanced Solvency2

March 31, 2009 Solvency I ratio slightly above 2008 year-end level of 127%

Chairman's statement

"First quarter total revenues were slightly down, in line with trends observed in 4Q08", said Henri de Castries, Chairman of AXA's Management Board.

"Life & Savings revenues continued to be impacted by a negative market environment, notably for the Unit-Linked business. We believe, however, that long-term savings (including variable annuities) and protection products remain well adapted to customers' needs, and that the continued product redesign across the board will allow us to continue our successful long-term development in a profitable way. Moreover it is pleasing to see sustained positive Life & Savings net inflows."

"Asset Management revenues declined mostly as a result of lower assets under management. However, improved 1Q09 investment performance makes us confident in the capacity of our Asset Management business to recover."

"Property & Casualty business continued to grow in most business lines and countries, with positive net new personal contracts."

"As anticipated, our Solvency I ratio proved resilient in this turbulent environment and will allow us to absorb further possible market shocks.

We expect the environment to remain difficult throughout 2009, but we remain convinced that AXA has the business model, flexibility and strength to face the current global economic recession."

Investor Relations +33 1 40 75 46 85

Media Relations +33 1 40 75 71 81

Individual Shareholder Relations +33 1 40 75 48 43

Contents:
Key Highlights………………….…2
Life & Savings……………………….…3
Property & Casualty……………6
Asset Management….…………7
International Insurance…………7
Notes & Other information…8
Appendices……………….…………9
Revenues : Key figures
Change
Euro million, except when otherwise
noted
1Q08 1Q09 Change on a
reported basis
Comp.(a) basis Scope &
Other
FX
impact(b)
Life & Savings revenues 16,877 16,453 -2.5% -7.4% +0.7pt +4.2pts
Net inflows (Euro billion) 4.0 3.3
APE3 (Group share) 1,939 1,604 -17.3% -18.5% +0.1pt +1.2pts
NBV4 (Group share) 277 206 -25.7% -30.0%
NBV to APE margin (Group share) 14.3% 12.8% -1.5pts -2.0pts
Property & Casualty revenues 8,885 9,113 +2.6% +1.1% +2.9pts -1.4pts
International Insurance revenues 1,136 1,179 +3.8% +3.3% +0.9pt -0.4pt
Asset Management revenues 1,071 762 -28.9% -34.3% +0.1pt +5.3pts
Net inflows (Euro billion) 3.5 -17.4
Total revenues 28,066 27,598 -1.7% -5.2% +1.3pts +2.2pts

(a) Change on a comparable basis was calculated at constant FX and scope.

(b) Mainly due to appreciation of USD and JPY against Euro partly offset by the depreciation of the GBP.

Numbers herein have not been audited. APE and NBV are both in line with the Group's EEV disclosure. They are non-GAAP measures, which Management uses as key indicators of performance in assessing AXA's Life & Savings business and believes to provide useful and important information to shareholders and investors.

All comments are on a comparable basis (constant Forex, scope and methodology)

Revenues and net inflows

  • Total Revenues were resilient, down 5% to Euro 27,598 million.
  • Life & Savings revenues were down 7% to Euro 16,453 million, in line with trends observed in 4Q08 (down 8%), due to continued adverse market conditions.

Net inflows were positive (Euro +3.3 billion) with strong positive contributions across the board driven by increased client retention.

New Business Volume (APE3) was down 18% to Euro 1,604 million, with unitlinked share down from 46% to 40%.

New business margin was down 2.0 pts to 12.8%, mostly as a result of (i) lower interest rates impacting "Variable Annuity" Accumulator products, (ii) higher unit costs across the board due to lower volumes, partly offset by (iii) favorable business mix mainly driven by the US (progressive development of new redesigned Accumulator products), as well as Japan and the UK.

  • Property & Casualty revenues increased by 1% to Euro 9,113 million, driven by higher volumes both in Personal and Commercial lines. Net new personal contracts amounted to +296,000.
  • Asset Management revenues were down 34% to Euro 762 million, in line with trends observed in 4Q08 (down 32%), due to lower management fees (-37%) mainly driven by lower average assets under management (-27%) and unfavorable change in product mix (-10%), as well as a reduced contribution from distribution fees. Net outflows amounted to Euro -17.4 billion (mainly at AllianceBernstein).

Solvency

• AXA's European consolidated Solvency I ratio on March 31, 2009 is estimated2 to be slightly above Dec 31, 2008 level of 127%. Moreover, the solvency of our local entities remained resilient, including in the US where 1Q09 IFRS earnings5 are expected to be positive with no negative contribution from Variable Annuity hedging results.

Life & Savings

Negative new business momentum but positive net inflows • Life & Savings revenues were down 7% to Euro 16,453 million, in line with trends observed in 4Q08 (down 8%), due to continued adverse market conditions.

Net inflows were positive (Euro +3.3 billion). The evolution versus 1Q08 was due to lower inflows (Euro -2.2 billion) partly offset by higher client retention (Euro +1.8 billion) with an adverse Forex and scope impact (Euro -0.4 billion).

Net Inflows by country/region
Euro billion 1Q08 1Q09
United States 0.8 0.6
France 0.7 1.0
United Kingdom(a) -0.3 -0.4
NORCEE6 2.3 1.5
Asia Pacific7 0.5 0.4
MedLA8 0.0 0.2
Total L&S Net Inflows 4.0 3.3

(a) UK Net Inflows, excluding with-profit funds, stood at Euro -0.1 billion in 1Q09

  • New Business Volume (APE3) was down 18% (or down 3% sequentially, ie. versus 4Q08) to Euro 1,604 million, mainly due to:
  • (i) Adverse financial environment:
    • Decline in individual investments & savings sales mainly in the US, Australia, the UK and Belgium, notably due to financial market turmoil
    • Decrease in group life sales in Switzerland as a result of limited client turnover in the market
  • (ii) Negative impact from one-off events, mainly in Japan (bankruptcy of a major independent agent) and Germany (non recurring 2008 Riester incentive measures)
  • (iii) Partly offset by a solid performance in France, with successful developments in group business.

The unit-linked share was down from 46% to 40%, notably impacted by the decrease in Variable Annuity type products' APE, down 20% to Euro 290 million (US down 22%, Rest of World down 9%).

Annual Premium Equivalent by country/region
Euro million 1Q08 1Q09 Change on a
reported
basis
Change on a
comparable
basis
United States 418 327 -21.8% -31.9%
France 357 387 +8.5% +8.5%
United Kingdom 333 228 -31.5% -17.8%
NORCEE6 433 335 -22.7% -24.5%
Asia Pacific7 299 227 -24.3% -27.8%
MedLA8 99 101 +1.9% -10.0%
Total Life & Savings APE 1,939 1,604 -17.3% -18.5%

New business margin was down 2.0 pts to 12.8%, mostly as a result of (i) lower interest rates impacting Accumulator products, (ii) higher unit costs across the board due to lower volumes, partly offset by (iii) favorable business mix mainly driven by the US (progressive development of new redesigned Accumulator products), as well as Japan and the UK.

Note: Actuarial and financial assumptions are not updated on a quarterly basis, except for interest rates which are hedged at point of sale for Variable Annuity products

Detail by country:

The United States

New business APE decreased 32% to Euro 327 million, in line with trends observed in 4Q08, driven by (i) lower Variable Annuity sales (-22%) mainly in the wholesale channel due to difficult equity market conditions and redesigned products with lower benefits, (ii) lower mutual funds sales through proprietary channels (-52%), and (iii) lower Life sales (-38%), mainly in the wholesale channel, following Universal Life product redesign in 1Q08.

NBV margin was down 6.2 points to -1.0%, primarily as a result of lower interest rates negatively impacting the Variable Annuity profitability and higher unit costs (due to lower volumes), partly offset by the improved business mix following progressive development of new redesigned Accumulator products (November 2008 and February 2009). A new version with lower roll-up rate will be launched in June 2009 to further restore profitability in line with our long-term targets.

France

New business APE was up 8% to Euro 387 million, driven by Group business (+82%), boosted by both retirement and protection sales, partly offset by Individual lines (-14%) impacted by the decrease in unit-linked products sales.

NBV margin was down 1.4 points to 3.4% mainly due to lower share of individual unit-linked products.

The United Kingdom

New business APE was down 18% to Euro 228 million, mainly as a result of lower offshore and onshore bonds' sales due to lower consumer confidence stemming from the challenging financial environment, as well as lower individual pension sales, partly offset by Protection.

NBV margin was up 0.9 point to 9.1% due to a favorable shift from savings towards higher margin protection business, partly offset by higher unit costs.

Northern Central & Eastern Europe

• Germany new business APE was down 13% to Euro 132 million mainly as a result of non recurring 2008 Riester incentive measures and decreasing Twinstar variable annuity product sales, partly offset by a one-off increase in the Health business before legal changes later in 2009.

NBV margin was down 4.1 points to 14.5% primarily due to negative investment experience on Twinstar products as a result of lower interest rate.

• Switzerland new business APE was down 26% to Euro 123 million mainly due to limited new business opportunities in Group Life (-30%) as a result of limited client turnover in the market due to adverse financial environment, combined with a stable individual business.

NBV margin was down 2.1 points at 29.7% due to a slight deterioration in the individual business mix.

• Belgium new business APE was down 46% to Euro 52 million due to a decrease in Individual Investment & Savings sales (-45%) for both unit-linked and non unitlinked products. However, at the same time, AXA Bank registered a strong growth in short term savings product sales.

NBV margin was down 3.9 points to 5.9% mainly driven by higher unit costs as a consequence of lower volumes.

• Central & Eastern Europe new business APE was down 8% to Euro 28 million, mainly driven by Poland (suspension of tax wrapper commercialization partly offset by growth in pension funds).

NBV margin was up 2.6 points to 22.0% driven by decreased contribution from lower margin tax wrapper products.

Asia Pacific

• Japan new business APE decreased by 21% to Euro 126 million, mainly driven by the bankruptcy of a large independent agent (LINA). Excluding this one-off event, APE decreased by 4% as a result of lower sales of Term products.

NBV margin was up 0.6 point to 54.7% mainly driven by a more favorable business mix following the end of LINA's low margin product sales.

• Australia/New Zealand new business APE was down 42% to Euro 56 million, mainly due to a drop in mutual fund sales as a result of negative financial market conditions, partly offset by higher traditional savings and Accumulator products.

NBV margin was up 2.3 points to 9.3% mainly driven by decreasing sales of lower margin mutual funds.

• Hong Kong new business APE was down 7% to Euro 30 million, mainly due to a decrease in unit-linked sales given adverse financial market conditions, partially offset by higher traditional life sales.

NBV margin remained stable at 64.0%.

• South East Asia & China new business APE was down 21% to Euro 15 million mainly driven by Indonesia with a drop in single premium unit-linked sales as a result of negative financial market conditions, while Thailand and China continued to increase.

NBV margin was down 0.8 point to 31.6%.

Mediterranean and Latin American Region (MedLA)

  • New business APE decreased by 10% to Euro 101 million, driven by Spain (lower contribution of traditional savings products and non recurrence of a large 1Q08 contract) and AXA Italy (lower index-linked product sales), partly offset by AXA's Italian JV with BMPS (increased General Account sales).
  • NBV margin was down 0.9 point to 11.8%, as a result of lower unit-linked share (down from 40% to 14%).

PROPERTY & CASUALTY /

Continued growth across the board

Property & Casualty

Property & Casualty revenues increased by 1% to Euro 9,113 million, driven by higher volumes both in Personal and Commercial lines. Net new contracts amounted to +296,000:

Property & Casualty : IFRS revenues by country
In Euro million 1Q08 1Q09 Change on a
reported
basis
Change on a
comparable
basis
NORCEE6 3,932 4,108 +4.5% +1.6%
of which Germany 1,602 1,619 +1.1% +1.1%
of which Belgium 637 648 +1.6% +1.6%
of which Switzerland 1,652 1,795 +8.6% +1.6%
France 1,821 1,864 +2.3% +2.3%
United Kingdom & Ireland 1,152 968 -16.0% -0.6%
MedLA8 1,547 1,725 +11.5% -1.6%
Other countries 432 449 +4.0% +8.3%
Total P&C revenues 8,885 9,113 +2.6% +1.1%

• Personal Motor revenues (35% of total P&C revenues) were up 0.6% mainly driven by Direct business (in the UK and France), Canada and Asia, partly offset by Germany, in a context of competitive pressure and lower volumes, as well as Spain due to the drop in new car sales and Turkey.

Net new contracts increased by +249,000.

• Personal Non-Motor revenues (22% of total P&C revenues) increased by 0.5% with overall positive price effect across the board, partially offset by a decrease in UK travel and health.

Net new contracts increased by +47,000.

  • Commercial Motor revenues (8% of total P&C revenues) down 0.8% with contrasted contribution across the board (positive mainly in the Gulf, Belgium and Germany, negative mainly in Spain, the UK and France) in a context of mixed pricing trends.
  • Commercial Non-Motor revenues (35% of total P&C revenues) were up 1.4%, with positive contribution driven by France (notably property and liability businesses) and Switzerland (notably health business), partially offset by flat sales in the Mediterranean and Latin American Region and a decrease in Canada.

Revenues driven by lower average Assets Under management

Asset Management

  • Asset Management revenues were down 34% to Euro 762 million, in line with trends observed in 4Q08 (down 32%), due to 37% lower management fees mainly driven by lower average assets under management (-27%) and unfavorable changes in product mix (-10%), as well as a reduced contribution from distribution fees.
  • Assets Under Management were down Euro 29 billion versus Dec 31, 2008 to Euro 787 billion at March 31, 2009, as a result of :
  • Net inflows: Euro -17 billion, in line with 4Q08 trends, mainly due to AllianceBernstein Institutional client segment
  • Market impact: Euro -33 billion mainly at AllianceBernstein due to adverse financial market conditions.
  • Forex impact: Euro +21 billion mainly as a result of the appreciation of USD versus Euro.
  • AllianceBernstein new developments:
  • Encouraging investment performance during 1Q09 (solid performance versus benchmark and peers' average across all services, especially in Growth Equity and Fixed Income).
  • Mandate won with the US Treasury to provide asset management services on securities held as part of the Capital Purchase Program.
Assets Under Management Roll-forward
In Euro billion Alliance
Bernstein
AXA IM Total
AUM at December 31, 2008 331 485 816
Net inflows -15 -2 -17
Market impact -24 -9 -33
Scope & other impacts 0 0 0
Forex impact +19 +3 +21
AUM at March 31, 2008 310 477 787
Average AUM over the period 325 474 799
Change of average AUM YoY on a reported basis -36% -11% -23%
Change of average AUM YoY on a comparable
basis
-44% -10% -27%

International Insurance

International Insurance revenues were up 3% to Euro 1,179 million, with (i) AXA Corporate Solutions Assurance up 1%, driven mainly by Marine (+11%) with positive portfolio developments, partly offset by lower volumes in Property (-7%) as well as (ii) AXA Assistance up 14%.

International Insurance IFRS revenues
In Euro million 1Q08 1Q09 Change on a
reported
basis
Change on a
comparable basis
AXA Corporate Solutions Assurance 889 900 +1.2% +1.3%
AXA Assistance 177 194 +9.9% +14.1%
AXA Cessions 53 55 +3.4% +3.4%
Other International activities 17 30 +74.8% -1.5%
Total International Insurance 1,136 1,179 +3.8% +3.3%

Notes

1 Motor and household personal contracts

2 This estimate has not been reviewed or approved by AXA's French insurance supervisor « Autorité de Contrôle des Assurances et des Mutuelles »

3 Annual Premium equivalent (APE) represents 100% of new business regular premiums + 10% of new business single premiums. APE is Group share

4 New Business Value

5 Estimate, unaudited

6 Northern Central and Eastern Europe: Germany, Belgium, Switzerland, Central & Eastern Europe and Luxemburg 7 Japan, Australia/New-Zealand, Hong-Kong, South East Asia & China

8 Mediterranean and Latin American Region: Italy, Spain, Portugal, Turkey, Mexico, Greece and Morocco (and Gulf region for Property & Casualty).

About AXA

AXA Group is a worldwide leader in Financial Protection. AXA's operations are diverse geographically, with major operations in Europe, North America and the Asia/Pacific area. For full year 2008, IFRS revenues amounted to Euro 91.2 billion and IFRS underlying earnings to Euro 4.0 billion. AXA had Euro 981 billion in assets under management as of December 31, 2008. The AXA ordinary share is listed on compartment A of Euronext Paris under the ticker symbol CS (ISIN FR0000120628 – Bloomberg: CS FP – Reuters: AXAF.PA). The American Depository Share is also listed on the NYSE under the ticker symbol AXA.

This press release is available on the AXA Group website: www.axa.com

AXA Investor Relations: AXA Media Relations:

Etienne Bouas-Laurent : +33.1.40.75.46.85 Emmanuel Touzeau: +33.1.40.75.46.74
Marie-Elodie Bazy: +33.1.40.75.97.24 Laurent Sécheret: +33.1.40.75.48.17
Gilbert Chahine: +33.1.40.75.56.07 Armelle Vercken: +33.1.40.75.46.42
Paul-Antoine Cristofari: +33.1.40.75.73.60 Chris Winans +1.212.314.55.19
Sylvie Gleises: +33.1.40.75.49.05
George Guerrero: +1.212.314.28.68
Etienne Bouas-Laurent : +33.1.40.75.46.85 Emmanuel Touzeau: +33.1.40.75.46.74
Marie-Elodie Bazy: +33.1.40.75.97.24 Laurent Sécheret: +33.1.40.75.48.17
Gilbert Chahine: +33.1.40.75.56.07 Armelle Vercken: +33.1.40.75.46.42
Paul-Antoine Cristofari: +33.1.40.75.73.60 Chris Winans +1.212.314.55.19

AXA Individual shareholders Relations: +33.1.40.75.48.43

IMPORTANT LEGAL INFORMATION AND CAUTIONARY STATEMENTS CONCERNING FORWARD-LOOKING STATEMENTS

Certain statements contained herein are forward-looking statements including, but not limited to, statements that are predictions of or indicate future events, trends, plans or objectives. Undue reliance should not be placed on such statements because, by their nature, they are subject to known and unknown risks and uncertainties. Please refer to AXA's Annual Report on Form 20-F and AXA's Document de Référence for the year ended December 31, 2008, for a description of certain important factors, risks and uncertainties that may affect AXA's business. In particular, please refer to the section "Special Note Regarding Forward-Looking Statements" in AXA's Annual Report on Form 20-F. AXA undertakes no obligation to publicly update or revise any of these forwardlooking statements, whether to reflect new information, future events or circumstances or otherwise.

APPENDIX 1: AXA Group IFRS revenues – 1Q09 vs. 1Q08 /

AXA Group IFRS revenues – contributions & growth by segment and country/region
In Euro million 1Q08 1Q09 IFRS revenues change
IFRS IFRS Reported Comp. basis
United States 3,439 3,214 -6.6% -18.6%
France 3,976 4,012 +0.9% +0.9%
NORCEE 5,310 4,984 -6.1% -9.3%
of which Germany 1,477 1,516 +2.7% +2.7%
of which Switzerland 2,714 2,798 +3.1% -3.5%
of which Belgium 989 534 -46.0% -46.0%
of which Central & Eastern Europe 113 115 +2.1% +13.1%
United Kingdom 935 612 -34.5% -21.4%
Asia Pacific 1,897 2,188 +15.3% -0.9%
of which Japan 1,132 1,377 +21.7% -7.7%
of which Australia/New-Zealand 424 468 +10.4% +25.9%
of which Hong Kong 276 314 +13.6% -1.0%
of which South East Asia 66 30 -54.6% -54.8%
MedLA 1,291 1,417 +9.8% +4.8%
Other countries 29 28 -4.4% +3.3%
Life & Savings 16,877 16,453 -2.5% -7.4%
NORCEE 2,932 4,108 +4.5% +1.6%
of which Germany 1,602 1,619 +1.1% +1.1%
of which Belgium 637 648 +1.6% +1.6%
of which Switzerland 1,652 1,795 +8.6% +1.6%
France 1,821 1,864 +2.3% +2.3%
Mediterranean Region 1,547 1,725 +11.5% -1.6%
United Kingdom & Ireland 1,152 968 -16.0% -0.6%
Canada 232 237 +2.2% +10.4%
Asia 200 212 +6.0% +5.9%
Property & Casualty 8,885 9,113 +2.6% +1.1%
AXA Corporate Solutions Assurance 889 900 +1.2% +1.3%
Others 247 279 +13.0% +10.5%
International Insurance(a) 1,136 1,179 +3.8% +3.3%
AllianceBernstein 697 467 -33.0% -41.6%
AXA Investment Managers 374 295 -21.2% -20.6%
Asset Management 1,071 762 -28.9% -34.3%
Banking 96 90 -6.3% -4.7%
Total 28,066 27,598 -1.7% -5.2%

Page 9/14

f
1
2 m
Bre
k
do
A
P
E –
in
tr
ies
ion
d m
de
l
le
d
bu
ine
g
a
wn
o
a
co
un
, re
s a
n
o
s
ss
es
Gr
ha
ou
p
s
re
1
Q
0
9
A
P
E
%
U
L
(
l. m
utu
ex
c
in
A
P
E
fun
l
ds
)
a
U
L c
ha
ng
e o
n
in
Eu
i
l
l
ion
ro
m
U
L
No
U
L
n-
Mu
l Fu
tua
ds
n
1
Q
0
8
1
Q
0
9
b
le
ba
is
co
mp
ara
s
Fra
nc
e
5
7
3
3
0
- 1
5
%
1
5
%
+5
%
Un
ite
d
Sta
tes
2
2
3
5
2
5
2
8
2
%
8
1
%
-2
6
%
Un
ite
d
K
ing
do
m
1
9
8
2
9
1 9
0
%
8
7
%
-2
1
%
O
C
N
R
E
E
Ge
rm
an
y
3
7
9
5
- 3
9
%
2
8
%
-3
6
%
Sw
itze
lan
d
r
6 1
1
7
- 3
%
5
%
+2
6
%
Be
lg
ium
2 5
0
- 8
%
4
%
-7
6
%
Ce
l
&
Ea
Eu
ntr
ste
a
rn
rop
e
2
0
8 1 6
6
%
7
2
%
+2
%
A
S
I
A
P
A
C
I
F
I
C
Ja
p
an
2
7
9
9
- 1
7
%
2
1
%
-1
1
%
Au
str
l
ia
/
Ne
Ze
lan
d
a
w-
a
2 1
7
3
7
2
4
%
9
%
0
%
-5
Ho
Ko
ng
ng
1
1
1
9
- 0
5
%
3
8
%
-3
1
%
So
h
Ea
As
ia
&
C
h
ina
ut
st
6 8 1 6
3
%
4
3
%
-5
3
%
Me
d
L
A
1
3
8
5
3 4
0
%
1
4
%
-6
7
%
To
l
ta
6
0
0
9
0
8
9
5
4
6
%
4
0
%
-2
5
%

Page 10/14

APPENDIX 3: AXA Group IFRS Revenues in local currency – Discrete quarters /

(
In
i
l
l
ion
loc
l c
Ja
t
m
a
urr
en
cy
ex
ce
p
p
an
in
b
i
l
l
ion
)
1
Q
0
8
2
Q
0
8
3
Q
0
8
4
Q
0
8
1
Q
0
9
L
i
fe
&
Sa
ing
v
s
Un
ite
d
Sta
tes
5,
1
5
7
5,
1
4
9
5,
1
4
9
4,
7
7
4
4,
1
9
7
Fra
nc
e
3,
9
7
6
3,
4
6
5
3,
2
1
5
3,
6
1
5
4,
0
1
2
O
C
N
R
E
E
f w
Ge
h
ic
h
o
rm
an
y
1,
4
7
7
1,
4
8
7
1,
4
6
8
1,
8
1
0
1,
1
6
5
f w
h
ic
h
Sw
itz
lan
d
o
er
4,
3
4
2
9
1
5
8
4
3
1,
0
1
0
4,
1
8
8
f w
h
ic
h
Be
lg
ium
o
9
8
9
6
1
1
4
1
9
5
4
1
5
3
4
f w
h
ic
h
Ce
l
&
Ea
Eu
ntr
ste
o
a
rn
rop
e
1
1
3
1
1
6
1
2
1
1
1
5
1
1
5
Un
ite
d
K
ing
do
m
7
0
8
7
6
5
6
8
0
6
7
6
5
5
6
f
As
ia
Pa
i
ic
c
f w
h
ic
h
Ja
o
p
an
1
8
5
1
9
3
2
0
7
1
6
3
1
4
7
f w
h
ic
h
Au
l
ia
/
Ne
Ze
lan
d
str
o
a
w-
a
7
0
1
6
2
5
7
4
8
9
2
4
9
1
8
f w
h
ic
h
Ho
Ko
ng
ng
o
3,
2
1
2
3,
1
4
5
3,
3
9
3
3,
1
4
6
3,
1
7
8
Me
d
L
A
1,
2
9
1
1,
4
9
7
9
2
0
1,
1
0
4
1,
4
1
7
&
Ca
Pro
ert
lty
p
y
su
a
N
O
R
C
E
E
f w
h
ic
h
Ge
o
rm
an
y
1,
6
0
2
5
9
7
7
0
9
6
2
1
1,
6
1
9
f w
h
ic
h
Sw
itz
lan
d
o
er
2,
6
4
3
2
5
6
1
5
9
1
4
2
2,
6
8
6
f w
h
ic
h
Be
lg
ium
o
6
3
7
5
1
7
5
0
7
4
7
7
6
4
8
Fra
nc
e
1,
8
2
1
1,
2
0
0
1,
3
6
2
1,
2
1
2
1,
8
6
4
Me
d
L
A
1,
4
5
7
1,
4
3
6
1,
2
1
5
2,
2
1
5
1,
2
7
5
Un
ite
d
K
ing
do
&
Ire
lan
d
m
8
7
3
9
7
9
9
0
1
7
7
0
8
8
1
As
ia
2
0
0
1
7
6
1
8
7
1
8
5
2
1
2
Ca
da
na
3
4
9
4
6
3
4
3
7
4
2
3
3
8
5
Int
at
ion
l
Ins
ern
a
ura
nc
e
Co
So
A
X
A
te
lut
ion
As
rp
ora
s
su
ran
ce
8
8
9
3
3
1
3
4
5
3
8
0
9
0
0
Ot
he
inc
lu
d
ing
A
X
A
R
E
rs,
2
4
7
2
0
5
2
0
3
2
3
2
2
7
9
As
Ma
t
t
g
se
na
em
en
A
l
l
ian
Be
in
te
ce
rns
1,
0
4
5
1,
0
0
6
9
3
1
7
1
1
6
1
0
A
X
A
Inv
Ma
tm
t
g
ers
es
en
na
3
7
4
3
8
8
3
3
7
3
3
7
2
9
5
Ba
k
ing
&
Ho
l
d
ing
n
s
8
7
8
9
8
2
1
1
0
7
8

Page 11/14

Pro
&
Ca
lty
ert
p
su
a
re
ve
nu
y
i
bu
ion
&
ntr
t
es
co
h
by
bu
ine
t
g
row
s
l
ine
ss
Pe
rso
l
Mo
tor
na
Pe
l
rso
na
No
Mo
tor
n-
ia
l
Mo
tor
erc
Co
ia
mm
erc
l
No
Mo
tor
n-
in
%
Gr
%
os
s r
ev
en
ue
s
C
ha
ng
p. ba
e o
n c
om
is
s
Gr
%
os
s r
ev
en
ue
s
C
ha
ng
p. ba
e o
n c
om
is
s
Gr
%
os
s r
ev
en
ue
s
C
ha
ng
p. ba
e o
n c
om
is
s
Gr
%
os
s r
ev
en
ue
s
C
ha
ng
p. ba
e o
n c
om
is
s
Fra
nc
e
2
7
%
+2
8
%
2
6
%
+3
0
%
9
%
-2.
3
%
3
8
%
+2
7
%
Un
ite
d
K
ing
do
(a)
m
1
8
%
+1
6.
2
%
3
4
%
-7.
2
%
6
%
-8.
2
%
3
9
%
+1
5
%
N
O
R
C
E
E
of
wh
ich
Ge
rm
any
of
wh
ich
Be
lg
ium
of
wh
ich
Sw
itze
rla
nd
3
8
%
37
%
30
%
42
%
-1.
1
%
-3.
5%
-0.
1%
+0
.2%
1
8
%
26
%
27
%
9%
+1
6
%
+1
.3%
+1
.5%
+2
.3%
6
%
7%
8%
5%
+3
5
%
+2
.6%
+8
.4%
+0
.7%
3
5
%
25
%
33
%
45
%
+1
9
%
+0
.9%
+2
.2%
+2
.2%
Me
d
L
A
Ca
da
na
As
ia
4
1
%
3
5
%
7
1
%
-3.
9
%
+1
9.
8
%
+6
1
%
1
9
%
1
6
%
5
%
+3
2
%
+1
6.
9
%
+5
1
%
1
0
%
7
%
4
%
-3.
1
%
+3
5
%
+2
1.
2
%
2
7
%
4
2
%
2
0
%
+0
2
%
-8.
1
%
+2
2
%
To
ta
l
3
5
%
+0
6
%
2
2
%
+0
5
%
8
%
-0.
8
%
3
5
%
+1
4
%

(a) Including Ireland.

Page 12/14

in
Eu
i
l
l
ion
ro
m
1
Q
0
8
A
P
E
1
Q
0
9
A
P
E
C
ha
ng
e o
n a
b
le
ba
is
co
mp
ara
s
1
Q
0
8
N
B
V
1
Q
0
9
N
B
V
C
ha
ng
e o
n a
b
le
ba
is
co
mp
ara
s
1
Q
0
9
N
B
V
/
A
P
E
in
rg
ma
C
ha
ng
e o
n a
b
le
co
mp
ara
ba
is
s
Sta
Un
ite
d
tes
4
1
8
3
2
7
-3
1.
9
%
2
2
-3 -1
1
2.
9
%
-1.
0
%
-6.
2p
ts
Fra
nc
e
3
5
7
3
8
7
+8
5
%
1
7
1
3
-2
2.
5
%
3.
4
%
-1.
4p
ts
Un
ite
d
K
ing
do
m
3
3
3
2
2
8
-1
7.
8
%
2
7
2
1
-8.
9
%
9.
1
%
+0
9p
t
O
C
N
R
E
E
4
3
3
3
3
5
-2
4.
5
%
9
3
6
5
-3
2.
3
%
1
9.
4
%
-2.
2p
ts
Ge
rm
an
y
1
4
6
1
3
2
-1
2.
7
%
2
7
1
9
-3
1.
7
%
1
4.
5
%
-4.
1p
ts
Sw
itze
lan
d
r
1
5
7
1
2
3
-2
6.
4
%
5
0
3
7
-3
1.
3
%
2
9.
7
%
-2.
1p
ts
Be
lg
ium
9
6
2
5
-4
6.
2
%
9 3 -6
%
7.
5
9
%
5.
-3.
9p
ts
Ce
l
&
Ea
Eu
ntr
ste
a
rn
rop
e
3
4
2
8
-7.
8
%
7 6 +4
6
%
2
2.
0
%
+2
6p
ts
A
S
I
A
P
A
C
I
F
I
C
2
9
9
2
2
7
-2
7.
8
%
1
0
4
9
8
-1
8.
6
%
4
3.
2
%
+4
5p
ts
Ja
p
an
1
3
3
1
2
6
-2
1.
3
%
6
7
6
9
-2
0.
4
%
4.
5
7
%
+0
6p
t
Au
l
ia
/
Ne
Ze
lan
d
str
a
w-
a
1
0
9
5
6
-4
1.
7
%
9 5 -2
4.
9
%
9.
3
%
+2
3p
ts
Ho
Ko
ng
ng
2
8
3
0
-7.
3
%
1
8
1
9
-7.
5
%
6
4.
0
%
-0.
1p
t
So
&
C
ut
h
Ea
st
As
ia
h
ina
2
9
1
5
-2
1.
1
%
1
0
5 -2
3.
1
%
3
1.
6
%
-0.
8p
t
Me
d
L
A
9
9
1
0
1
-1
0.
0
%
1
4
1
2
-1
6.
4
%
1
1.
8
%
-0.
9p
t
T
O
T
A
L
1,
9
3
9
1,
6
0
4
-1
8.
5
%
2
7
7
2
0
6
-3
0.
0
%
1
2.
8
%
-2.
0p
ts

Page 13/14

  • •02/19/2009 Full Year 2008 Earnings - Resilient operating performance in a challenging environment
  • •03/17/2009 AXA to subscribe to AXA Asia Pacific Holdings' capital increase: no impact on the Group's Solvency, non material impact on liquidity
  • •03/24/2009 First year results of the AXA Research Fund: Over Euro 13 million allocated for research in 2008
  • •03/27/2009 Filing of AXA's Form 20-F with the SEC
  • •04/08/2009 AXA opens its first Campus in the Japan Asia-Pacific region in Singapore
  • •04/30/2009 AXA Shareholders' Meeting – Approval of all resolutions submitted to a vote of shareholders

Please refer to the following web site address for further details: http://www.axa.com/en/press/pr/

APPENDIX 7: 1Q09 operations on AXA shareholders' equity and debt /

Shareholders' Equity

No significant operations.

Debt

No significant operations.

Page 14/14