Regulatory Filings • Sep 16, 2016
Preview not available for this file type.
Download Source FileCORRESP 1 filename1.htm
Proskauer Rose LLP 2049 Century Park East, 32nd Floor Los Angeles, CA 90067-3206
September 16, 2016 Monica J. Shilling Member of the Firm d 310.284.4544 f 310.557.2193 [email protected] www.proskauer.com
VIA EDGAR
United States Securities and Exchange Commission Division of Investment Management 100 F Street, N.E. Washington, D.C. 20549 Attention: John Ganley
Re: Ares Capital Corporation Registration Statement on Form N-14 Filed July 20, 2016 (File No. 333-212604)
Dear Mr. Ganley:
In a telephone conversation on August 23, 2016, you provided us with verbal comments on the registration statement on Form N-14 (the Registration Statement) filed by Ares Capital Corporation (the Fund) on July 20, 2016. We have revised the Registration Statement to respond to the comments you provided during the telephone conversation and today filed Amendment No. 1 (Amendment No. 1) to the Registration Statement. We are concurrently filing this letter via EDGAR as a correspondence filing.
Set forth below are the comments of the staff of the Securities and Exchange Commission (the Staff) verbally provided by you and immediately below each comment is the response with respect thereto and, where applicable, the first location in the relevant filing of the requested disclosure. Comments described with respect to one section (and the responses thereto) are applicable to other sections of the Registration Statement that contain similar disclosure. Capitalized terms used but not defined herein shall have the meanings set forth in the Registration Statement.
**Letter to Ares Capital Stockholders****
The Fund has made the requested revision.
The Fund has made the requested revision on the first page of the letter.
Beijing | Boca Raton | Boston | Chicago | Hong Kong | London | Los Angeles | New Orleans | New York | Newark | Paris | São Paulo | Washington, DC
SEQ.=1,FOLIO='',FILE='C:\JMS\105568\16-14761-3\task8102588\14761-3-bc-01.htm',USER='105568',CD='Sep 17 00:08 2016'
U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission
September 16, 2016
Page 2
The Fund has made the requested revisions on the first page of the letter.
The Fund has made the requested revision on the second page of the letter.
The Fund has made the requested revision on the second page of the letter.
**Letter to American Capital Stockholders****
The Fund has made the requested revision.
The Fund has made the requested revision on the first page of the letter.
The Fund has made the requested revisions on the first page of the letter.
The Fund has made the requested revision on the first page of the letter.
SEQ.=1,FOLIO='Page 2',FILE='C:\JMS\105568\16-14761-3\task8102588\14761-3-bc-01.htm',USER='105568',CD='Sep 17 00:08 2016'
U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission
September 16, 2016
Page 3
The Fund has made the requested revision on the first page of the letter.
The Fund has made the requested revision on the first page of the letter.
The Fund has made the requested revision on the second page of the letter.
**Table of Contents****
The Fund has made the requested revision in the table of contents.
The Fund has made the requested revision on page 1.
The Fund has made the requested revision.
**Questions and Answers****
The Fund has made the requested revision in this section, where applicable.
SEQ.=1,FOLIO='Page 3',FILE='C:\JMS\105568\16-14761-3\task8102588\14761-3-bc-01.htm',USER='105568',CD='Sep 17 00:08 2016'
U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission
September 16, 2016
Page 4
The Fund has addressed this comment by revising certain questions to provide separate answers targeted at Ares Capital stockholders or American Capital stockholders, as applicable.
The Fund has made the requested revision on page 5.
Replace the language in the first paragraph of this answer with a table or chart that describes the components of the merger consideration and simplify the disclosure regarding additional consideration to be received upon the declaration of certain dividends by providing examples with numbers.
The Fund has made the requested revisions on page 6.
In the second paragraph of this answer, add disclosure regarding the expected percentage ownership of Ares Capital stockholders and American Capital stockholders in the combined company following the completion of the Transactions.
The Fund has made the requested revisions on page 7.
Replace the language in the third and fourth paragraphs of this answer with a table or chart that shows the market value of the merger consideration and add information regarding the last reported net asset value of Ares Capital and American Capital for the same time periods presented.
The Fund made the requested revisions on page 8.
The Fund has revised the disclosure on page 8 to provide the percentage of the total merger consideration that is estimated to be paid to holders of American Capital stock options.
SEQ.=1,FOLIO='Page 4',FILE='C:\JMS\105568\16-14761-3\task8102588\14761-3-bc-01.htm',USER='105568',CD='Sep 17 00:08 2016'
U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission
September 16, 2016
Page 5
The Fund has made the requested revision on page 9.
The Fund has made the requested revision on page 11.
The Fund has made the requested revision on page 12.
The Fund has made the requested revision on page 10.
The Fund has made the requested revision on page 15.
The Fund has made the requested revision on page 18.
The Fund has made the requested revision on page 19.
SEQ.=1,FOLIO='Page 5',FILE='C:\JMS\105568\16-14761-3\task8102588\14761-3-bc-01.htm',USER='105568',CD='Sep 17 00:08 2016'
U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission
September 16, 2016
Page 6
The Fund has made the requested revision on page 20.
The Fund has made the requested revision on page 22.
The Fund has made the requested revision on page 15.
**Summary****
The Fund has made the requested revision on page 27.
The Fund has made the requested revision on page 29.
SEQ.=1,FOLIO='Page 6',FILE='C:\JMS\105568\16-14761-3\task8102588\14761-3-bc-01.htm',USER='105568',CD='Sep 17 00:08 2016'
U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission
September 16, 2016
Page 7
The Fund has made the requested revision on page 31.
The Fund has made the requested revision on page 33.
The Fund has made the requested revisions on page 33.
The Fund has made the requested revisions on page 34.
The Fund has made the requested revision on page 38.
The Fund has made the requested revision on page 37.
The Fund has made the requested revision on page 38.
The Fund has made the requested revision on page 39.
SEQ.=1,FOLIO='Page 7',FILE='C:\JMS\rcheney\16-14761-3\task8102858\14761-3-bc-03.htm',USER='rcheney',CD='Sep 16 16:02 2016'
U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission
September 16, 2016
Page 8
The Fund has made the requested revision on page 40.
The Fund has made the requested revision on page 40.
The Fund has made the requested revision on page 45.
The Fund has made the requested revision on page 44.
**Comparative Fees and Expenses****
*Acquired Funds Fees and Expenses*
Item 3(a) of Form N-14 requires that the Fund include a table showing the current fees for the Fund, American Capital and pro forma fees, if different, for the Fund after giving effect to the Transactions using the format prescribed in Item 3 of Form N-2. Item 3 of Form N-2 defines an Acquired Fund as any company in which the Registrant invests or intends to invest (A) that is an investment company or (B) that would be an investment company under section 3(a) of the 1940 Act (15 U.S.C. 80a-3(a)) but for the exceptions to that definition provided for in sections 3(c)(1) and 3(c)(7) of the 1940 Act (15 U.S.C. 80a3(c)(1) and 80a-3(c)(7)).
SEQ.=1,FOLIO='Page 8',FILE='C:\JMS\rcheney\16-14761-3\task8102858\14761-3-bc-03.htm',USER='rcheney',CD='Sep 16 16:02 2016'
U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission
September 16, 2016
Page 9
The SDLP (as defined below) relies on section 3(c)(7) of the Investment Company Act for its exception from the definition of investment company. Accordingly, the Fund confirms that the expenses of the SDLP are included in the Acquired Funds Fees and Expenses line item of the fee table.
As described in further detail below, the Senior Secured Loan Program (the SSLP) is not an Acquired Fund because it is exempt from the definition of investment company pursuant to Rule 3a-7 promulgated under the Investment Company Act. The SSLP does not rely on the exceptions set forth in section 3(c)(1) or 3(c)(7) of the Investment Company Act. Accordingly, the SSLPs expenses are not included in the Acquired Funds Fees and Expenses line item of the fee table.
*Investment Company Status of the SSLP*
The SSLP was formed by Allied Capital Corporation (Allied) and General Electric Capital Corporation and GE Global Sponsor Finance LLC (collectively, GE) in December 2007 to extend stretch senior and unitranche loans (loans that combine both senior and subordinated debt, generally in a first lien position) to middle-market companies. In connection therewith, the SSLP issued, in each case pursuant to an indenture (the Indenture), senior notes and subordinated certificates to the Fund and GE as well as certain limited liability company interests pursuant to the SSLP limited liability company agreement (the LLCA). The Fund owns 87.5% of the limited liability company interests of the SSLP, which are stapled to its 87.5% of the subordinated certificates in the SSLP, and GE owns the remaining amounts of stapled subordinated certificates and limited liability company interests. In addition, GE owns all of the SSLPs senior notes.
Rule 3a-7 (Rule 3a-7) under the Investment Company Act provides an exception from the Investment Company Act definition of investment company for any issuer who is engaged in the business of purchasing, or otherwise acquiring, and holding eligible assets (and in activities related or incidental thereto) and who does not issue redeemable securities. The issuer must issue fixed-income securities or other securities which entitle their holders to receive payments that depend primarily on the cash flow from eligible assets. Rule 3a-7 further specifies eligible purchasers for different classes of the issuers securities and when and how the issuer may acquire and dispose of eligible assets. In addition, unless the issuer issues only certain short-term commercial paper securities, Rule 3a-7 generally requires an issuer to appoint an independent trustee who has certain rights with respect to the eligible assets and obligations to the holders of the fixed income securities of the issuer. The SSLPs ability to rely on Rule 3a-7 is discussed below.
In addition, the Fund notes that: (i) the SSLP has no line of credit or other arrangements to borrow from banks or other financial institutions; (ii) the Fund is not liable for any obligations of the SSLP; and (iii) the Fund has not sold or otherwise transferred any of its assets to the SSLP.
SEQ.=1,FOLIO='Page 9',FILE='C:\JMS\rcheney\16-14761-3\task8102858\14761-3-bc-03.htm',USER='rcheney',CD='Sep 16 16:02 2016'
U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission
September 16, 2016
Page 10
The following is a description of how the SSLP meets each of Rule 3a-7s requirements (as described in more detail below) as well as the provisions of the Indenture, which restrict the SSLP from taking actions that would cause it not to comply with Rule 3a-7.
Rule 3a-7(a)(1) and Rule 3a-7(b) The SSLP invests only in eligible assets, the cash flow of which funds payments in respect of fixed income and other securities of the SSLP.
Under subsection (a)(1) of Rule 3a-7, an issuer must issue non-redeemable fixed income securities or other securities that entitle their holders to receive payments that depend primarily on the cash flow from eligible assets.
Fixed-Income and Other Securities
The term fixed-income securities is defined in subsection (b)(2) of Rule 3a-7 to mean any securities that entitle the holder to receive: (i) a stated principal amount; (ii) interest on a principal amount calculated by reference to a fixed rate or to a standard or formula that does not reference any change in the market value or fair value of eligible assets; (iii) interest on a principal amount calculated by reference to auctions among holders and prospective holders or through remarketing of the security; (iv) an amount equal to specified fixed or variable portions of the interest received on the assets held by the issuer; or (v) any combination of these foregoing amounts. Substantially all of the payments to which the holders of fixed-income securities are entitled must consist of these foregoing amounts.
The SSLP has two primary classes of outstanding fixed income securities, the senior notes and subordinated certificates. Both the SSLPs senior notes and subordinated certificates are fixed-income securities within the meaning of Rule 3a-7 because they entitle the holders to receive interest on a principal amount calculated by reference to a standard or formula that does not reference any change in the market value or fair value of eligible assets. Under the Indenture, the senior notes and subordinated certificates have stated principal amounts, which the holders are entitled to receive. Additional amounts calculated in reference to LIBOR (and, in the case of the subordinated certificates, excess cash flow from interest on the SSLPs eligible assets) are also distributed in respect of the SSLPs securities. As a result, the senior notes fall within clauses (i) and (ii) and the subordinated certificates fall within clauses (i), (ii) and (iv) of the definition of fixed-income securities set forth above. Importantly, substantially all of the payments to which the holders of senior notes and subordinated certificates are entitled under the Indenture consist of these foregoing amounts.
In this regard, the Indenture provides for the payment of the stated principal amount of the senior notes at their stated maturity and the payment of all remaining amounts to the subordinated certificates in accordance with the terms of the Indenture as a return of capital thereof or a distribution (once no outstanding capital remains). In addition, Senior Note Interest Rate, which relates to the interest rate payable on the senior notes, is defined in the Indenture by reference to the weighted average LIBOR in effect for the applicable interest period plus the Base Senior Note Interest Rate Margin, which in turn is defined by reference to: (i) the average
SEQ.=1,FOLIO='Page 10',FILE='C:\JMS\rcheney\16-14761-3\task8102858\14761-3-bc-03.htm',USER='rcheney',CD='Sep 16 16:02 2016'
U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission
September 16, 2016
Page 11
outstanding principal amounts of all senior secured term loans made by the SSLP (the Senior Loans); and (ii) for each Senior Loan, a margin that is designated with reference to LIBOR. Furthermore, the holders of the subordinated certificates are entitled to receive (i) interest thereon based on the sum of LIBOR plus a base rate margin (i.e., the Subordinated Certificate Margin as defined in the Indenture, which in turn is defined by reference to the average outstanding principal amounts of all Senior Loans) and (ii) excess cash flow on interest proceeds on the eligible assets held by the SSLP. As a result, the senior notes and subordinated certificates are fixed-income securities for purposes of Rule 3a-7.
The fixed-income securities and other securities of an issuer relying on Rule 3a-7 may not be redeemable. Under Section 2(a)(32) of the Investment Company Act (Section 2(a)(32)), a security is redeemable only if it is redeemable at the option of the holder, upon its presentation to the issuer, [and] entitles [the holder] to receive approximately his proportionate share of the issuers current net assets, or cash equivalent thereof; a security is not a redeemable security if it is redeemable solely at the option of the issuer. Under the Indenture, the SSLPs senior notes are redeemable only at the option of the issuer, and the subordinated certificates may be redeemed at the direction of the majority of the aggregate outstanding amount of the subordinated certificates, but only on any date on or after the date on which all senior notes are retired or redeemed. Because the senior notes are only redeemable at the option of the issuer, and the redemption of the subordinated certificates depends on the retiring or redemption of the senior notes, the senior notes and subordinated certificates are not redeemable securities under Section 2(a)(32).
Eligible Assets
Subsection (a)(1) of Rule 3a-7 requires that the issuer be engaged in purchasing, or otherwise acquiring, and holding eligible assets. The term eligible assets is defined in subsection (b)(1) of Rule 3a-7 as financial assets, either fixed or revolving, that by their terms convert into cash within a finite time period plus any rights or other assets designed to assure servicing or timely distribution of proceeds to the security holders. This definition encompasses any self-liquidating asset which by its terms converts into one or more cash payments within a finite period of time. Consequently, virtually all assets that produce cash flows of the type that may be statistically analyzed by rating agencies and investors will meet the definition of eligible assets. Eligible assets also include credit and liquidity arrangements that support the payment of the securities and the underlying assets, and ancillary or incidental assets that are necessary in the course of servicing the underlying assets or to assure the distribution of cash flow and/or proceeds to security holders.
Under the Indenture, the SSLP is generally not permitted to engage in any business or activity other than issuing and selling its senior notes and subordinated certificates and investing in Senior Loans and other collateral in connection therewith. Under the terms of the Indenture, a Senior Loan must, in addition to a number of other requirements, provide for a fixed amount of principal on scheduled payment dates and/or at maturity and not by its terms provide for earlier amortization or prepayment at a price of less than par; and must also provide for periodic payments of interest thereon in cash at least quarterly. In addition, the Indenture
SEQ.=1,FOLIO='Page 11',FILE='C:\JMS\rcheney\16-14761-3\task8102858\14761-3-bc-03.htm',USER='rcheney',CD='Sep 16 16:02 2016'
U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission
September 16, 2016
Page 12
includes a number of provisions designed to assure servicing or timely distribution of proceeds to the holders of the SSLPs senior notes and subordinated certificates. Finally, the Indenture only permits the SSLP to make Senior Loans that satisfy certain criteria, including: (i) the Senior Loan must be a financial asset, either fixed or revolving, that by its terms converts into cash within a finite time period and (ii) the date of commitment and the date of the funding of the Senior Loan both must occur prior to the end of the investment period agreed to by the parties pursuant to the LLCA.
As a result, Senior Loans are eligible assets as defined in Rule 3a-7 because they are financial assets that by their terms convert into cash within a finite time and include rights designed to assure the servicing or timely distribution of proceeds to the holders of the SSLPs senior notes and subordinated certificates.
Payments in Respect of Fixed Income Securities
Under subsection (a)(1) of Rule 3a-7, payments to the holders of the fixed-income securities and other securities issued by the issuer must depend primarily on the cash flow from eligible assets.
The SSLPs revenue, and therefore the payments it makes to the holders of senior notes and subordinated certificates are primarily dependent on the cash flow generated from the Senior Loans held by the SSLP (which are eligible assets), which as of June 30, 2016 consisted of loans to 32 separate borrowers. As a result, the amounts distributable under the Indenture to holders of senior notes and subordinated certificates meet the requirements of Rule 3a-7. The SSLP may also receive revenue from fees associated with the Senior Loans, which is consistent with the Staffs position in Citicorp that commitment fees generated by incidental or related activities are allowable under Rule 3a-7.
As a result, the SSLP satisfies the conditions contained in subsection (a)(1) of Rule 3a-7 because it issue[d] fixed income securities or other securities that entitle their holders to receive payments that depend primarily on the cash flow from eligible assets.
Rule 3a-7(a)(2) The SSLPs fixed income and other securities have been sold only to Qualified Institutional Buyers.
Under subsection (a)(2) of Rule 3a-7, securities sold to the public must be fixed-income securities that are rated, at the time of initial sale, in one of the four highest long-term debt categories or an equivalent short-term category by at least one nationally recognized statistical rating organization. Fixed-income securities not so rated may only be sold to institutional accredited investors, qualified institutional buyers or QIBs (as defined in Rule 144A of the Securities Act), and to persons involved in the organization or operation of the issuer and their affiliates. All other securities, such as residual interests, can only be sold to QIBs and to persons involved in the organization or operation of the issuer and their affiliates.
All securities sold by the SSLP have been sold to QIBs.
SEQ.=1,FOLIO='Page 12',FILE='C:\JMS\rcheney\16-14761-3\task8102858\14761-3-bc-03.htm',USER='rcheney',CD='Sep 16 16:02 2016'
U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission
September 16, 2016
Page 13
Rule 3a-7(a)(3) The SSLP has acquired and disposed of eligible assets in the manner set forth in such subsection.
Under subsection (a)(3) of Rule 3a-7, an issuer can acquire eligible assets or dispose of eligible assets only if: (i) the eligible assets are acquired or disposed of in accordance with the terms and conditions set forth in the agreements, indentures, or other instruments pursuant to which the issuers securities are issued; (ii) the acquisition or disposition of the eligible assets does not result in a downgrading in the rating (if any) of the issuers outstanding fixed-income securities; and (iii) the eligible assets are not acquired or disposed of for the primary purpose of recognizing gains or decreasing losses resulting from market value changes. Issuers are permitted to retain any profits obtained through the disposition of assets, provided the assets were not sold for the primary purpose of obtaining that profit.
The SEC noted in Rule 3a-7s adopting release that the intent of the subsection was to prevent the underlying asset pool from being managed to the same extent as an investment company, while allowing financings to operate without undue impediments. The release noted that [t]he paragraph provides virtually all structured financings, including those that require a significant degree of asset acquisitions and dispositions, the flexibility to engage in current practices without raising concerns that they could engage in portfolio management practices resembling those employed by mutual funds.
The Indenture governs how the assets of the SSLP may be acquired and disposed of. Specifically, the Indenture provides that the SSLP may only make a Senior Loan to the extent that the making of such Senior Loan satisfies the Portfolio Acquisition and Sale Requirements. Likewise, the Indenture specifies that the SSLP may only sell a Senior Loan if such sale satisfies the Portfolio Acquisition and Sale Requirements. The term Portfolio Acquisition and Sale Requirements is specifically defined so that Senior Loans (i.e., the eligible assets) can only be made, acquired, or disposed of in accordance with the terms and conditions of the Indenture. In addition, the Portfolio Acquisition and Sale Requirements specifically prohibit a Senior Loan from being made, acquired, or disposed of for the primary purpose of recognizing gains or decreasing losses resulting from market value changes, and that, if any of the senior notes issued by the SSLP are rated, such making, acquisition, or sale of a Senior Loan cannot result in the downgrading of any such rating.
In addition to the Portfolio Acquisition and Sale Requirements, the SSLP may only make a Senior Loan under certain circumstances where no acceleration of the SSLPs senior notes has occurred as a result of an event of default and where the making of such Senior Loan satisfies certain criteria, including: (i) the Senior Loan must be a financial asset, either fixed or revolving, that by its terms converts into cash within a finite time period and (ii) the date of commitment and the date of the funding of the Senior Loan both must occur prior to the end of the investment period agreed to by the parties pursuant to the LLCA.
SEQ.=1,FOLIO='Page 13',FILE='C:\JMS\rcheney\16-14761-3\task8102858\14761-3-bc-03.htm',USER='rcheney',CD='Sep 16 16:02 2016'
U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission
September 16, 2016
Page 14
A Senior Loan can be sold pursuant to the Indenture only if such sale satisfies the Portfolio Acquisition and Sale Requirements, as described above. To date, all repayments of Senior Loans in the SSLP have been as a result of a third party event (i.e., a restructuring, refinancing or change of control of the borrower). There have been no other dispositions of Senior Loans to date, other than the SSLPs distribution of its entire Senior Loan investment in Instituto de Banca y Comercio, Inc. to the Fund in October 2015.
Rule 3a-7(a)(4) A trustee meeting the requirements of Rule 3a-7(a)(4) has been appointed under the Indenture.
Independent Trustee
Subsection (a)(4)(i) of Rule 3a-7 requires the appointment of an independent trustee under an indenture if the issuer issues any securities other than securities exempted from the Securities Act by Section 3(a)(3) of the Securities Act. In addition, under subsection (a)(4)(i) of Rule 3a-7, the trustee must execute an agreement stating that it will not resign until the issuer has been completely liquidated and the proceeds of the liquidation have been distributed to holders or until a qualifying successor trustee has been designated and has accepted such trusteeship.
State Street Bank and Trust Company (State Street) has been appointed as the Trustee under the Indenture and under the terms of the Indenture, State Street has agreed not to resign until a successor trustee has been appointed. State Street has no affiliation with and is not owned or controlled by the SSLP, the Fund or GE and does not provide credit or credit enhancement to the SSLP. State Street therefore meets the requirements of subsection (a)(4)(i) of Rule 3a-7.
Trustees Perfected Security Interest
Subsection (a)(4)(ii) of Rule 3a-7 further requires that the issuer take reasonable steps for the trustee to have a perfected security interest or ownership interest in the eligible assets. The granting clauses of the Indenture grant the Trustee all of the SSLPs right, title and interest in all its property, including all Senior Loans made by the SSLP. Also, the SSLP is prohibited from making a loan under the Indenture unless the issuer of such loan has granted to the Trustee a first priority perfected security interest (subject to certain exceptions with respect to senior revolving debt, to which the Trustee has a subordinated security interest) in the loan. The Indenture also describes in detail the mechanisms by which each Senior Loan is to be transferred to the Trustee and by which the Trustees security interest will be perfected.
Segregated Cash Flows
Finally, subsection (a)(4)(iii) of Rule 3a-7 provides that the issuer must take actions necessary so that cash flows from the eligible assets are periodically deposited into a segregated account that is maintained or controlled by the trustee consistent with the rating of the outstanding fixed-income securities. The Indenture requires the Trustee to segregate and hold all money and other property
SEQ.=1,FOLIO='Page 14',FILE='C:\JMS\rcheney\16-14761-3\task8102858\14761-3-bc-03.htm',USER='rcheney',CD='Sep 16 16:02 2016'
U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission
September 16, 2016
Page 15
payable to or receivable by the Trustee pursuant to the Indenture, and further requires that each of the SSLPs accounts be established and maintained in a segregated trust account established by the Trustee. In addition, prior to the initial issuance of the SSLPs senior notes and subordinated certificates, two single, segregated trust accounts were established in accordance with the terms of the Indenture. The Trustee deposits all collections, including any interest or principal payments, including prepayments, received on the eligible assets, into these accounts.
Conclusion
Given the SSLPs compliance with the requirements of Rule 3a-7 set forth herein, the Fund respectfully submits that the SSLP falls within such exception from the definition of investment company.
**American Capital and Ares Capital Proposal #1****
The Fund has made the requested revisions on page 296.
The Fund has added new sections for each of (i) Ares Capital Proposal #1, (ii) Ares Capital Proposal #2 and (iii) American Capital Proposal #1 on pages 296, 297 and 298, respectively, such that the stock issuance proposals and the adoption of the merger agreement proposal are clearly presented and easily reached once an Ares Capital or American Capital stockholder reads these sections.
**American Capital Proposal #2****
The Fund has made the requested revisions on page 299.
SEQ.=1,FOLIO='Page 15',FILE='C:\JMS\107899\16-14761-3\task8102696\14761-3-bc-05.htm',USER='107899',CD='Sep 17 00:50 2016'
U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission
September 16, 2016
Page 16
**American Capital Executive Compensation****
The Fund has made the requested revisions on page 333.
**Business of American Capital****
The Fund has added the requested disclosure on page 485.
*Other Comments*
Separately, in a telephone conversation on July 22, 2016, you provided us with verbal comments on the registration statement on Form N-2 (the Shelf Registration Statement) filed by the Fund on June 21, 2016. We have revised the Registration Statement to respond to the comments the Staff provided during the telephone conversations that are applicable to both the Shelf Registration Statement and the Registration Statement.
Set forth below are the comments of the Staff to the Shelf Registration Statement, provided verbally by the Staff, that are also applicable to the Registration Statement, and immediately below each comment is the response with respect thereto and, where applicable, the location in the relevant filing of the requested disclosure.
The Fund advises the Staff on a supplemental basis that the Fund has determined that it should not consolidate the joint venture with Varagon Capital Partners, L.P. (Varagon), the Senior Direct Lending Program (the SDLP), on the Funds consolidated financial statements because the Fund does not have a controlling financial interest in the SDLP and the SDLP does not satisfy any of the other criteria under GAAP for consolidation.
*Regulation S-X Consolidation Analysis*
Rule 3A-02 of Regulation S-X (Rule 3A-02) provides support for the Funds position not to consolidate the SDLP. Specifically, the Fund does not have a controlling financial interest (as such term is used in Rule 3A-02) in the SDLP by virtue of the SDLPs governance structure. Rule 3A-02 generally requires consolidation of entities that are majority owned. However, the
SEQ.=1,FOLIO='Page 16',FILE='C:\JMS\107899\16-14761-3\task8102696\14761-3-bc-05.htm',USER='107899',CD='Sep 17 00:50 2016'
U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission
September 16, 2016
Page 17
rule recognizes that the determination of majority ownership requires a careful analysis of the facts and circumstances of the particular relationship among the entities. Rule 3A-02 states that, consolidation of a majority owned subsidiary may not result in a fair presentation, because the registrant, in substance, does not have a controlling financial interest. The Fund owns 87.5% of the limited liability company interests of the SDLP, which are stapled to 87.5% of its subordinated certificates in the SDLP, and Varagon and its clients own the remaining amounts of subordinated certificates and limited liability company interests. However, these percentages do not have any bearing on the governance of the SDLP or the question of whether the Fund has a controlling financial interest in the SDLP. Said differently, the 87.5% economic interest through the subordinate certificates only provides the Fund the ability to a 50% vote on matters of governance that are most important to the performance of the SDLP. For instance, as a contractual matter, the SDLP is capitalized as transactions are completed and all portfolio decisions and generally all other decisions in respect of the SDLP are required to be approved by the SDLPs investment committee (the SDLP Investment Committee), which consists of two representatives appointed by Varagon and two representatives appointed by the Fund. Decisions requiring approval of the SDLP Investment Committee include those relating to all investments in SDLP loans, sales of the SDLPs loans, substantive changes to existing portfolio investments (including reductions in interest rates or fees, changes in maturity dates or amortization payments, and any other changes that would reasonably be expected to impact the creditworthiness of an investment), consent to the direct or indirect transfers of the senior notes in the SDLP, the subordinated certificates in the SDLP, the limited liability company interests of the SDLP and the securities issued by special-purpose vehicles controlled by Varagon, the approval of substitute members and the target advance rates.
Under certain circumstances (generally where the Fund and Varagon cannot agree), a tie-breaker representative not affiliated with either the Fund or Varagon would be appointed to the SDLP Investment Committee and may be required to cast a tie-breaking vote on certain issues, including a limited number of SDLP governance issues such as initiating or settling certain litigation and initiating bankruptcy proceedings of the SDLP. As a result, particularly given its inability to act unilaterally to approve portfolio decisions or generally any other actions by the SDLP, the Fund does not have the ability to assert the level of control normally associated with a controlling financial interest or majority ownership position in an entity that would ordinarily trigger consolidation under Rule 3A-02.
*GAAP Consolidation Analysis*
While Regulation S-X is the highest level of authority under GAAP, the Fund further analyzed other guidance under GAAP and concluded that the consolidation analysis for the SDLP under such other guidance is similar to the analysis under Regulation S-X discussed above. Financial Accounting Standards Board Accounting Standards Codification Section 810-10-25 (ASC 810) provides that,
[c]onsolidation is appropriate if a reporting entity has a controlling financial interest in another entity and a specific
SEQ.=1,FOLIO='Page 17',FILE='C:\JMS\107899\16-14761-3\task8102696\14761-3-bc-05.htm',USER='107899',CD='Sep 17 00:50 2016'
U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission
September 16, 2016
Page 18
scope exception does not apply (see Section 810-10-15). The usual condition for a controlling financial interest is ownership of a majority voting interest, but in some circumstances control does not rest with the majority owner.
As discussed above, the Fund does not hold a controlling interest in the SDLP. Therefore, the SDLP is not subject to consolidation by the Fund under ASC 810.
In conclusion, the Fund does not have a controlling financial interest in the SDLP and the SDLP does not satisfy any of the other criteria under GAAP for consolidation. In addition, the Funds registered independent public accounting firm, KPMG LLP, concurs with the Funds conclusions.
The Fund confirms to the Staff that it performs (i) an annual analysis as to whether the financial statement and information requirements of Rules 3-09 or 4-08(g) of Regulation S-X are triggered for any of its unconsolidated subsidiaries, and (ii) a quarterly analysis as to whether the financial information requirements of Rule 10-01(b)(1) of Regulation S-X are triggered for any of its unconsolidated subsidiaries.
The Fund does not hold any equity interests in CLOs, but may hold equity interests in CLOs after the completion of the mergers.
The Fund has included the requested disclosure with respect to applicable expiration dates of warrants held by the Fund in the financial statements included in its most recently filed quarterly report on Form 10-Q and the interim financial statements included in this Registration Statement. The Fund will also disclose any applicable expiration dates of warrants held by the Fund in future financial statements.
The Fund has included the requested disclosure in the interim financial statements included in the Registration Statement. The Fund
SEQ.=1,FOLIO='Page 18',FILE='C:\JMS\107899\16-14761-3\task8102696\14761-3-bc-05.htm',USER='107899',CD='Sep 17 00:50 2016'
U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission
September 16, 2016
Page 19
will also include disclosure in future financial statements that the financial statements of the SSLP are attached as an exhibit to the Form 10-K, if applicable.
The Fund has included the requested disclosure in the financial statements included in its most recently filed quarterly report on Form 10-Q and the interim financial statements included in the Registration Statement. The Fund will also disclose the counterparty to the foreign currency forward contracts in future financial statements, if applicable.
We look forward to discussing with you any additional questions you may have regarding the Registration Statement. Please do not hesitate to call me at (310) 284-4544.
| /S/ MONICA J. SHILLING | |
| Monica J. Shilling | |
| cc: | Penni Roll, Chief Financial Officer of Ares Capital Corporation |
| Joshua M. Bloomstein, General Counsel of Ares Capital Corporation | |
| M. Adel Aslani-Far, Latham & Watkins LLP | |
| James C. Gorton, Latham & Watkins LLP | |
| Paul F. Kukish, Latham & Watkins LLP | |
| David J. Goldschmidt, Skadden, Arps, Slate, Meagher & Flom LLP | |
| Michael K. Hoffman, Skadden, Arps, Slate, Meagher & Flom LLP |
SEQ.=1,FOLIO='Page 19',FILE='C:\JMS\107899\16-14761-3\task8102696\14761-3-bc-05.htm',USER='107899',CD='Sep 17 00:50 2016'
Building tools?
Free accounts include 100 API calls/year for testing.
Have a question? We'll get back to you promptly.