Annual Report • Nov 24, 2024
Annual Report
Open in ViewerOpens in native device viewer
ARGO Properties N.V.
Company address: Argo Properties N.V. Stroombaan 6-8 1181VX Amstelveen The Netherlands Chamber of Commerce No. 70252750
Argo Properties N.V. (hereinafter: "the Company" and together with its subsidiaries hereinafter: "the Group") hereby submits the Board of Directors' report for a period of twelve months ending on December 31, 2023 (hereinafter: "the Reported Period" or "the Report Period".
These financial statements have been prepared for statutory purposes in the Netherlands. The Company has issued shares (ISIN NL0015000D84) which are traded on the Tel Aviv Stock Exchange in Israel.
These financial statements do not constitute an offer to subscribe for, buy or sell the securities mentioned herein. It cannot be used or relied on for purposes of making any investment decision with respect to any securities.
For more current information regarding Argo Properties NV, please consult the press releases, annual reports, regulatory filings, presentations and other documents available at www.tase.co.il and www.argo-nv.com.
The financial statements attached in this report are presented according to IFRS as adopted by the European Union and with Part 9 of Book 2 of the Dutch Civil Code.
In this report: "The report date" or "the date of the report" refers to December 31, 2023 and "the signing date" or "the date of signing the report" refers to November 21st, 2024.
The Group is engaged, via a local team of 60 people, in the acquisition (mainly from private sellers) and value enhancement of high-quality residential properties (renewal of high-quality residential properties in Germany) in the center of the cities of Leipzig, Dresden, Magdeburg and Hanover (the Group has approximately 3,932 residential units, mainly in the cities of Leipzig and Dresden, with a leasable area of 263 thousand square meters). The rapid value enhancement enables the Group to generate higher cash flows and the equity turnover via refinancing of the value enhanced properties is at a leverage level of 50%. In addition, the Group has a project for the conversion and development of office spaces in Berlin in an area of approximately 21 thousand square meters. The Company's management has extensive experience of 20 years in this segment. The Group's intension is to double the number of residential units under its ownership until 2030.
1 According to the Company's estimate.
2 Net debt (debt deducted of cash and restricted deposits) divided to total real estate assets.
3 See Note 5(g)(c) of the financial statements.
• Energetic efficiency: approximately 99% of the Group's residential property areas comply with the energetic ranking regulations, which are expected to be applied in the year of 2030. According to a European Union's research, about 30% of the residential buildings in Germany do not comply with these regulations.





As of December 31, 2023, the Group owns 361 residential buildings comprise of 3,773 rental units (97% residential) with a rentable area of approximately 252.3 thousand square meters (with additional 737 parking spaces) generating an annual rental income of approximately EUR 25.4 million (at full occupancy). The book value of this asset portfolio amounts to approximately EUR 645 million.
The following is a geographical breakdown of the multifamily residential rental properties of the Group:
| Location | No. of Units |
Net Rentable Area (sqm) |
Annual Rental Income46 (TEUR) |
Average Monthly Rental Income per sqm56 |
Rental Yield67 |
Book Value psqm )EUR( |
Annual ERV7 9 Income )TEUR( |
Monthly ERV psqm |
ERV Yield81 0 |
ERV Upside |
Occ. rate in the Group's assets |
Occ. rate in the operating city |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Leipzig | 2,031 | 133,426 | 13,103 | 7.87 | 3.78% | 2,597 | 19,468 | 12.07 | 5.62% | 53% | 96% | 97% |
| Dresden | 1,197 | 81,604 | 8,639 | 8.40 | 3.76% | 2,816 | 12,098 | 12.18 | 5.27% | 45% | 95% | 98% |
| Magdeburg | 509 | 35,562 | 3,531 | 7.87 | 5.40% | 1,837 | 4,208 | 9.58 | 6.44% | 22% | 94% | 95% |
| Hanover | 36 | 1,672 | 167 | 8.34 | 5.19% | 1,929 | 276 | 13.75 | 8.55% | 65% | 100% | 98% |
| Total | 3,773 | 252,264 | 25,440 | 8.04 | 3.95% | 2,556 | 36,050 | 11.77 | 5.59% | 46% | 95% | 97% |
4 Annual rental income generated from 12 months of operations based on actual leases and under the assumption of full occupancy (assuming that the vacant spaces will be leased at an average rental income per sq.m in the existing leases)/occupancy rate, as the case may be, as of December 31, 2023.
5 Average rental income per sq.m in existing leases of the Company's assets in the same city in residential areas.
6 Annual rental income divided by the book value of the assets.
7 The expected annual rental income assuming all properties are leased at full occupancy and at the prevailing market rental prices. The market rentalprices were mostly calculated based on actual new rentals the Company has performed during the fourth quarter of 2023 and in part were calculated on the basis of market information held by the Company.
8 Annual rental income at market prices divided by the book value of the assets.
Location - in well-established and central residential neighborhoods in the cities of Leipzig, Dresden, Magdeburg and Hanover (all are federal capital cities/the largest city in the federal state) close to public transportation, educational institutions and shopping centers. All of the Group's assets are designated for the middle-high class. The Group does not have assets in peripheral locations/satellite towns/neighborhoods characterized by low socio-economic status.
Physical condition - most of the properties are buildings for preservation that have undergone extensive renovation (apartments, facades, stairwells, replacement of electrical infrastructures, heating and plumbing infrastructures, roofs, and basements). The other buildings were constructed using modern architecture.
Significant potential for rental income increase - all structures, without exception, are subject only to general regulation of rental income increase prescribed by law and are not subject to specific rental income restrictions. The current rental income level in the properties embodies a potential rental income increase of approximately 47%, based on new rentals the Group is performing.
During 2023 the Group has performed 515 new rentals (grossing up to an annual rate of approximately 15% of the average19 2 inventory of apartments for rental owned by the Group in 2023).
19 At the end of 2022, the company owned 3,304 residential units and at the end of March 2024 3,718 residential units, thus on average the Company owned 3,580 residential units during the first quarter of 2024.
Below is the rental income development in new rentals (ERV) and rental income growth in identical assets over the quarters:
| Q1 2022 |
Q2 2022 |
Q3 2022 |
Q4 2022 |
Q1 2023 |
Q2 2023 |
Q3 2023 |
Q4 2023 |
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Number of new rentals |
95 | 116 | 116 | 120 | 124 | 111 | 155 | 125 |
| Average rental income per sq.m18 2 based on new rentals |
€ 10.47 | € 10.59 | € 10.77 | € 10.92 | € 11.04 | € 11.17 | € 11.54 | € 11.78 |
| Rental income growth rate L-F-L (on an annual basis) |
8.0% | 8.2% | 8.5% | 8.9% | 9.5% | 9.4% | 9.9% | 9.0% |
L-F-L rental income growth potential: the growth rate of rental income per square meter in identical assets in the fourth quarter of 2023 has amounted to approximately 9.0% on an annual basis.
Rental income growth in new rentals (ERV): during the fourth quarter of 2023, the average rental income per sq.m in new rentals performed by the Group has improved by approximately 7.9% (ERV) on an annual basis (Q4/2022 vs. Q4/2023).
18 Weighted at their percentage rate out of the total amount of apartments (regarding the type/size of the apartments, the borough and the city).
Below are details regarding the cumulative value enhancement that was carried out in rental income in the multifamily assets held by the Group for more than two years and the remaining value enhancement potential (rental income data is presented in thousands of EUR on an annual basis):
| Rental income upon acquisition |
Rental income as of December 31, 2023 |
Rate of cumulative change* |
Rate of annual change* |
Rental income according to market prices at full occupancy |
Remaining value enhancement potential |
Total upside potential versus acquisition |
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| In assets acquired in 2018 |
2,289 | 3,533 | 54 % | 9.1% | 5,073 | 44% | 122% |
| In assets acquired in 2019 |
2,736 | 3,931 | 44 % | 8.7% | 5,775 | 47% | 111% |
| In assets acquired in 2020 |
2,514 | 3,472 | 38 % | 9.5% | 5,220 | 50% | 108% |
| In assets acquired in 2021 |
3,771 | 4,778 | 27% | 8.9% | 7,414 | 55% | 97% |
| Total | 11,310 | 15,714 | 39% | 9.1% | 23,482 | 49% | 108% |
* For sake of simplicity, the rates of change were calculated with a conservative assumption that the assets were acquired at the beginning of the calendar year; for example, the rate of change in rental income in assets purchased in 2018 was calculated as follows: the cumulative rate of change is divided by 6 years.
High profitability potential from conversion of apartments for rent into apartments for sale (R2C) According to the Company's management estimates, the types of buildings and their location embody a significant future profit potential from the sale of apartments to end users in the cities in which ownership rates are low (10%-20%) compared to the average rate prevailing in Germany (about 50%), and are expected to increase, among others, due to the continued rental income increase and the growth in rental income burden (approximately 20% of disposable income in the Group's operating cities) on the tenants, along with the expected continued trend in positive migration of financially strong population into the Group's operating cities' centers.
Grossed up value potential in R2C activity: the Group's assets are revalued as income generating asset and therefore the value potential from selling the apartments as condo is not reflected in the Group's Asset Appraisal Reports and its financial statements (except as a part of the value of construction rights that as of the report date amounted to approximately EUR 13.1 million and are included under the section of Investment Property - Construction Rights).
20 Under German law, anyone purchasing an apartment for its own use may terminate the lease agreement with the existing tenant in the same apartment by providing a notice of 3 months for its eviction, provided that the apartment was registered in the land registryas a separate unit in a condominium, before the tenant took possession.
Out of the 3,673 residential units identified by the Company's management as having potential for R2C,
The apartments with R2C potential, as of the report date, are located in areas which are not subject to subdivision and condominium registration restrictions by the local authority, thus the tenant eviction restriction upon selling the apartment to a third party is according to the law for a period of 3 years only for a tenant residing in the apartment at the time of the execution of the sub-division (a tenant occupying the apartment after sub-division completion is not entitled to such protection).
| R2C potential | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Leipzig Dresden Magdeburg Total |
||||||||
| Net Rentable area (square meters) | 136,188 | 81,997 | 29,158 | 247,343 | ||||
| Number of buildings | 197 | 120 | 37 | 354 | ||||
| Number of units | 2,061 | 1,201 | 411 | 3,673 | ||||
| Number of units per building | 10.5 | 10.0 | 11.1 | 10.4 | ||||
| % of total number of units | 96% | 98% | 79% | 93% |
The information described in this section above in regards to potential from R2C is "forwardlooking information" as defined in the Israeli Securities Law, 1968 (hereinafter: "the Securities Law"), which is not under the full control of the Group and its actual realization, in whole or in part, is uncertain. The information is based on information available in the Group as of the report date, regarding: (1) the extremely low ownership rate in the Group's operating cities compared to the average in German cities; (2) the rental income increase trend and the increase of rental income burden on the tenants; (3) the Company's management forecasts regarding the continued upward trend of residential real estate prices in these cities; and includes additional estimates made by the Group.
Even when the Group decides to commence this activity, change in circumstances (including without derogating from the foregoing – increase in the supply of such apartments, increase in interest rates and a reduction in credit sources), partial sale of apartments in a condo building (in a way that may lead to additional expenses and even to impaired ability to sell them with a profit over time), the creation of special conditions under the circumstances of the case and/or the existence of one or more of the risk, may significantly change the Group's estimates abovementioned and materially affect the profitability forecast from this activity.
The Group has a land complex with an area of approximately 11,800 sq.m. which is centrally located in the borough of Friedrichshain/Prenzlauerberg in the city of Berlin in an area of mixed commercial and residential uses and enjoys excellent transportation access as well as proximity to commercial areas and parks. In this complex, there are three buildings with a leasable area of approximately 3,600 sq.m., most of which are currently leased to commercial tenants, and a land with an area of approximately 7,800 thousand sq.m. which is used for open parking.
The Group is in the process of planning to convert these buildings into office buildings (permitted use under existing urban building scheme) and adding areas by putting into use the Mezzanine floor that is not in use today such that the leasable area after conversion is expected to increase to approximately 6,000 sq.m, net for rental, and is operating to promote a new plan with the local authority aiming to allow the development (in lieu of the use of parking) of two "Landmark" modernized office buildings in a total net rentable area of approximately 15.3 thousand sq.m. It should be emphasized that since the land is part of a site for conservation and is subject to the supervision and approval of the building conservation department and in view of the complexity of the project, there is a high degree of uncertainty regarding the scope of the construction rights to be actually approved as well as there may also be significant changes to the current concept.
The buildings currently generate an annual rental income of approximately EUR 442 thousand, and as of December 31, 2023, the total value of the complex is approximately EUR 16.9 million, of which EUR 15.6 million are attributed to the value of the existing buildings (and the construction rights in the Mezzanine floor) based inter alia on a discount rate of 4.4% and a representative rental income of approximately EUR 25.5 per square meter per month. The value attributed to that land used for parking is approximately EUR 1.3 million.
In addition, the Group has an additional property in this segment of activity which its value as of December 31, 2023, amounted to approximately EUR 4.8 million. The said property is rented under a long-term lease therefore the Group currently has no concrete plans for the development of additional areas in this property.
The Group consistently works to maximize the risk-return profile for its shareholders by means, inter alia, of optimization of the capital structure, both on the property level and on the corporate level.
21 The information described in regards to the Company's development projects and in regards to the rezoning of said residential properties (including the expected completion dates, expected square meters, expected profit) is forward looking information that is not under the full control of the Company and the actual realization of such rezoning, in whole or in part, is uncertain. It should be noted that the Company has not yet decided regarding the development of any of such said land complexes and regarding the use of the land division in Eldenaer 42-43, including the development of the land complex and/or zoning (office or residential). The decision to develop any of such land complexes is subject to the completion of the relevant UBP approval procedures, the market conditions prevailing at the completion date of the UBP, the ability to obtain financing for the development of a project, availability of capital resources required to realize such development plan, meeting financial rations and more. There is no assurance whether a value enhancement process will be carried out and/or will be completed, if at all, since its completion is subject to the planning and construction processes required by German law, the completion of which is not under the Company's control.
The Group, on an ongoing basis, is examining and acquiring single properties in Leipzig, Dresden, Magdeburg and Hanover. The acquisition process is comprised of the following:
Desktop analysis➔site visit & technical DD ➔LOI ➔legal DD & legal preparation ➔notarization➔ closing.
| Acquisitions of residential rental properties from January 1, 2023 until December 31, 2023 |
|||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Location | # of properties |
# of units |
Net rentable area (sqm) |
NRI (p.a.) at full occupancy |
Total Acquisition costs |
||||
| Leipzig | 24 | 275 | 19,730 | € 1,604,361 | € 40,547,854 | ||||
| Transactions | Dresden | 7 | 71 | 5,305 | € 476,660 | € 12,203,499 | |||
| completed as of | Magdeburg | 7 | 75 | 5,356 | € 467,960 | € 7,458,750 | |||
| December 31, 2023 | Hanover | 5 | 36 | 1,672 | € 156,354 | € 3,239,056 | |||
| Total | 43 | 457 | 32,063 | € 2,705,335 | € 63,449,159 | ||||
| Leipzig | 3 | 31 | 2,231 | € 196,230 | € 4,623,363 | ||||
| Transactions in a process of |
Dresden | 2 | 16 | 1,332 | € 133,593 | € 3,132,771 | |||
| acquisition as of | Magdeburg | 0 | 0 | 0 | € 0 | € 0 | |||
| December 31, 2023 | Hanover | 1 | 8 | 487 | € 40,836 | € 922,384 | |||
| Total | 6 | 55 | 4,050 | € 370,659 | € 8,678,518 | ||||
| Total | 49 | 512 | 36,113 | € 3,075,994 | € 72,127,677 |
Below is the distribution of assets according to the transaction status:
During 2023, the Group has completed the acquisition of 457 residential units at a total amount of approximately EUR 63.4 million (including transaction costs; including transactions of which exclusivity agreements were signed during the last quarter of 2022), generating an annual rental income of approximately EUR 2.7 million. During this period, the Group has entered into 6 separate transactions (including notarized agreements and exclusivity agreements) that have not yet been completed as of the report date, for the acquisition of 55 residential units at a total amount of approximately EUR 8.7 million (including transaction costs), generating an annual rental income of approximately EUR 371 thousand.
The Current Loans bear a fixed (weighted) annual interest rate of approximately 0.99% and their final repayment date is due in the years of 2025 – 2027, and are secured by first-ranking liens on the full rights of the subsidiaries in 81 buildings which comprise of 878 units (with a total area of 56,462 square meters) in the cities of Leipzig, Dresden and Magdeburg in Germany, which their cumulative book value is approximately EUR 167.2 million (as of the loans' underwriting due date in October 2022) (hereinafter and respectively only in this subsection: the "Asset Companies" and the "Assets", as the case may be).
The refinancing process is enabled due to a value enhancement of approximately 30% of the rental income generated from these assets, which were purchased and financed for the first time by the aforementioned Banks during the second half of 2019 and the first half of 2020 – from an annual rental income of approximately EUR 3.9 million at the time of drawing of the Current Loans to an amount of approximately EUR 5.1 million, as of the New Loans' underwriting due date in October 2022. It is clarified that the refinancing process was carried out by drawing New Loans in addition to the Current Loans without any change in their terms ("Top up"). As a result:
from operating activities during the period) and thus is due to value enhancement of about 59% in the rental income of these properties during the last four years.
The New Loan: is for a period of 5 years (until January 31,2029) and will bear a variable interest rate with an additional margin of 1.3% above the basic interest rate. The Company is entitled to hedge the interest rate at any convenient time. The new loan is secured by firstranking liens on the full rights of the asset companies in the said properties.
The free cash flow that will derive to the Group due to the refinancing subject of the new loan will sum up (after deducting expenses) at the amount of approximately EUR 11.9 million and will be used by the Group for financing new acquisitions and for its operating activities.
The Current Loans: an amount of EUR 6.5 million out of the current loans bearing a variable interest rate was drawn down at the time of executing the refinancing. The remaining balance of the current loans at an amount of approximately EUR 20 million bearing a fixed interest rate of between 0.94% to 1.1% and is to repaid in July and December 2026. The Company achieved a commercial understanding from the bank that provided the current loans, that the remaining balance of the current loans bearing a fixed interest rate and their terms would be maintained and would be used for the purpose of:
a. Financing at an amount of approximately EUR 15.5 million for the acquisition of new assets upon which the Company's sub-subsidiaries entered into notary purchase agreements.
b. Refinancing at a manner of "Top Up" at an amount of approximately EUR 3.2 million as an addition to other current loans that the bank had provided to the Company's subsubsidiaries. And repayment of bank loan of other bank with balance of EUR 1.3 million.
The said engagement with the bank was signed during 2024.
During the third quarter of 2023, the Company's sub-subsidiaries entered into an agreement with a German banking corporation regarding refinancing of a current loan, which its original due date was set for December 31, 2023, in order to finance the Group's assets within the operating segment of real estate for development for additional 5 years. The remaining balance of the current loans as of the refinancing date was at the amount of approximately EUR 6.8 million, and the refinancing increased the said balance to an amount of approximately EUR 7.5 million. The new loans bear a fixed interest rate of 4.65%. The drawing down of the loans was carried out on December 31,2023.
b. Financing for the acquisition of new assets-
During 2023, the Company's Board of Directors approved option plans for the allocation of options to employees and officers in the Group and the remuneration committee, the Company's Board of Directors and the general meeting of the Company's shareholders (respectively and as the case may be) approved the allocation of options in virtue of the said plans for the joint CEOs as well as for additional officers. Below are the main terms of the said plans:
| ESOP 2 | ESOP1A in regards to the |
ESOP1A in regards to the officers who |
||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| joint CEOs | are not CEOs | |||||||
| Date of the approval of allocations | In regards of the joint CEOs – January | August 31, 2023 (the remuneration | ||||||
| (name of the approving organ) | 19, 2023 (the remuneration committee | committee); | ||||||
| and the Company's Board of directors) | September 7, 2023 (the Company's Board | |||||||
| and March 9, 2023 (the general meeting | of Directors); | |||||||
| of the Company's shareholders); | September 16, 2023 (the general meeting of | |||||||
| In regards of other senior officers – | the Company's shareholders); | |||||||
| August 23, 2023 (the audit committee | ||||||||
| and the Company's Board of Directors); | ||||||||
| Number of allocated options | 2,048,904 | 1,331,277 | 839,283 | |||||
| Date of actual allocation | 1,309,169 options were allocated on July | October 16, 2023 | ||||||
| 2, 2023 to the joint CEOs; | ||||||||
| 739,735 options were allocated to other | ||||||||
| senior officers on August 23, 2023. | ||||||||
| Exercise price (NIS) The method of the options exercise |
77.13 65 59.33 |
|||||||
| Cashless only with accordance to the average share price in the period of 30 days prior to the exercise notice (*) |
||||||||
| Vesting periods and dates | 3 vesting periods of one, two and three | One vesting date on December 31, 2024 | ||||||
| years, starting from July 1, 2023 | ||||||||
| Final date for exercise | June 30, 2027 | June 30, 2026 | ||||||
| Fair value of the total amount of | NIS 12,492 thousand | NIS 4,960 thousand | NIS 4,580 thousand | |||||
| granted options as determined by | ||||||||
| an external independent appraiser | ||||||||
| Main parameters that were used for the valuation of the options | ||||||||
| Valuation Model | Black and Scholes | Black and Sholes | Black and Sholes | |||||
| and Monte Carlo | ||||||||
| Closing price of the share (NIS) on | 54.03 and 50.95, with accordance to the | 47.51, with accordance to the date the | ||||||
| the date of valuation | date the options were granted | options were granted on October 16, 2023 | ||||||
| respectively: March 9, 2023 with regards | ||||||||
| to 1,309,169 options and August 23, | ||||||||
| 2023 with regards to 737,735 options. | ||||||||
| Annual standard deviation | 29%-31% | 31% | ||||||
| Option expected term (based on | Between 3.2. and 2.9 years, with | Two years, with accordance to the date the | ||||||
| "Simplified method") | accordance to the date the options were | options were granted. | ||||||
| granted. | ||||||||
| Risk-free interest rate | 3.96%-4.26% | 3.89% | ||||||
| Maximum dilution factor | Up to 6% | Up to 7% |
*With regards to 636,286 options which were granted to Mr. Tenenbaum (joint CEO), it was determined as for the net exercise mechanism, that in spite of the calculation based only on the average closing prices, the calculation will be determined by the lower of: (i) average closing share prices; and (ii) the EPRA NTA per share value234 , as specified in the Company's Board of Directors Report (hereinafter: the "Exercise Cap").
23 In NIS currency according to the exchange rate on the date of exercising the options. For further details regarding the calculation method of the abovementioned Index – see Section 4 of Chapter 4 in this report.
The sharp rise in the inflation rate in the Eurozone in 2022 has led to a monetary contraction by the European Central Bank during which the interest rate was increased to a level of 4.0% in September 2023.
Due to the decrease in the inflation rate in the EU zone, the European Central Bank have reduced the interest rate with 25 basis point in June 2024 with further decreases accrued in September and October down to level of 3.25% today. In addition, the nominal interest rate curve increased when Germany's 10-year bond yield increased by approximately 250 basis points from the beginning of 2022 to a level of about 2.37% today.
The real interest rate has increased in a more moderate manner during this period - the yield of 10-year CPI linked government bond is currently approximately 0.47%.

Consequently, there has been a decrease in the scope of real estate transactions, in the prices of assets (which has also been reflected in the increase of the discount rates that are used for the estimate of the value of the Group's assets) and in the commencement of new construction projects alongside a significant increase in construction costs.
The demand for rental residential in Germany (where about 50% of the households live in rented properties), being is a basic consumer product, is inelastic relatively to a negative economic cycle. This fact has been tested during the financial crisis of the years 2008-2009 and during the Corona period, when on average, occupancy rates in the rental residential sector in Germany have not been changed throughout the crisis at all. This conclusion is also strengthened in view of the fact that the rent burden (the cost of rent out of the household's disposable income) in the Group's operating cities is only about 20% to 24%, a significantly lower rate than is common in other major cities in Western Europe in general and in Germany in particular (in Berlin for example, the rent burden of the disposable income is above 30%).
24 World Urbanization Prospects - Population Division - United Nations
25 Source: Bertelsmann population report, Morgan Stanley Research, German residential chartbook January 24, 2023
26 Sanierungen: In zwei Städten müssen Eigentümer bis 2030 am meisten machen - FOCUS online
thousands of immigrants with free professions/academic education will mainly concentrate in the large cities. In 2022, the immigration contributed to an increase of 1.1 million inhabitants to the number of inhabitants in Germany274 . The previous wave of migration from southern European countries to Germany that began in 2010 (due to the debt crisis in Greece/Italy/Spain) has led to a continuous wave of strong price increase in residential real estate prices in Germany285.
The excess structural demand compared to the slowing down supply of condo apartments for the upper deciles in high-quality buildings and in central residential locations "generates" an investment asset that is in chronic shortage, and as such has a high potential for long-term capital appreciation surpassing the inflation rate.
(b) Tax benefits encourage the diversion of funds for investment in residential apartments–
In Germany, investing in residential apartments qualifies for a capital gain exemption on sale after 10 years, as opposed to 25% tax on other types of capital gains. This tax benefit encourages a significant portion of households to divert their savings towards investing in residential apartments.
(c) A margin of 3.65% between the residential real estate yield and the inflation-linked bond yield of the German government–
In spite of the increase in inflation rate and despite of an increase of 250 basis points on the yield of 10-year nominal government bond from the beginning of 2022, the real interest rate for 10 years in Germany is still significantly low at a rate of 0.3%. As a result, the margin between the yield on residential real estate (owned by the Group) and the CPI linked government bond is 3.65%.
(d) In historic perspective (according to OECD publications) condo apartments have proven themselves as a real asset which maintains its value during periods of inflation–
During the 1970s, residential rental income in Germany increased significantly above the annual inflation rate. Similarly, a Deutsche Bank research report has shown that during periods of high inflation, residential apartment prices in Germany rose at a higher rate than the inflation rate and provided investors with a hedge against inflation. Thus, during a decade of high inflation between the years 1970-1980, the prices of residential apartments in Germany increased by approximately 85%, while the inflation rate in Germany increased by only 64%. Similarly, in the period of reunification during the years 1989-1994 when a high accumulated inflation rate of approximately 20% was recorded, the prices of residential apartments in Germany increased by approximately 30%, whereas throughout the entire period from 1970 to 2022 residential apartment prices in Germany increased by more than 400% while the inflation in the said period accumulated below 300%296 .
On the other hand, according to the Group's estimate, structural failures that delay the market forces from catching the demand create a structural gap (that is constantly growing) between demand and supply:
(1) Acute "historic" cumulative shortage of the supply of residential apartments in the centers of the largest cities - low volumes of residential construction in the centers of the largest cities in Germany during the last 15 years due to the prolonging of the construction processes, acute shortage of lands designated for residential housing in the attractive locations and limitations on construction of higher
27 According to a research by Morgan Stanley as of January 23, 2024.
28 Source: DeStatis, Eurostat, Morgan Stanley Research., German residential chartbook January 24, 2023.
29 https://www.dbresearch.com/PROD/RPS\_EN-ROD/PROD0000000000526925/German\_housing\_market%3A\_History\_suggests\_it\_is\_an\_i.xhtml?rwnode=RPS\_EN-PROD\$IMMO
buildings, have led to generating a "deficit" in the supply of residential apartments versus the demand. A research recently published by the German Property Federation307 presents that as for the end of 2023, the said deficit is estimated to reflect a shortage of about 400,000 new residential units in whole of Germany and is expected to reach a shortage of 700,000 new residential units at the end of 2025. At the same time, in Leipzig and Dresden a shortage of about 60,000 new residential units is expected by the end of 2030 (about 19% and 17% respectively of the total current inventory of residential units, where during the last 7 years alone, a cumulative shortage of 23,000 new residential units has been created in Leipzig (excess demand over supply which was added to a cumulative gap from previous years).318
(2) Slowdown in supply as a result of a sharp increase in construction costs of new apartments which led to a sharp decrease in executing new projects for residential construction - the sharp rise in commodity prices was also reflected in a significant increase in construction costs in Germany during 2021 and 2022 at a rate of approximately 20% cumulatively, while during 2023 there has been a moderation in the growth rate of construction costs in Germany. The significant increase of the construction costs is expected to cause a delay in the commencement of new apartment construction projects at the current construction price level. Thus, for instance, in 2022, a decrease in construction commencements to a level of below 300,000 residential units has been noted, while the forecast for 2023 and 2024 is only 220,000 and 180,000 respectively, versus a governmental objective of building 400,000 residential units per annum432. In addition, since September 2022 a continued monthly decrease in construction permits has been noted which as of December 2023 decreased by 26% compared to December 2022433 .
The ability to raise rental fees above the inflation rate, tax benefits, high margin of 3.65% above CPI linked government bond and the expectation for Long Term Capital Appreciation as condo apartments in central locations are an investment product in chronic shortage, will continue to support according to the Group's estimate the prices of residential condo apartments in Germany in the mid-long term as an asset generating real yield at low risk.
Therefore, and according to the Group's estimate, the effect of the increase of the discount rate is of short-term characteristics which is influenced by the cyclicity in the markets and is expected to impact negatively the real estate prices in the short term. In the event of an additional increase of the interest rates and the discount rates, a negative impact is expected on the value of assets as aforesaid.
On the other hand, the structural supply and demand gaps have a long-term impact and support a continued and significant increase of residential rental income in the centers of cities where the Group operates and as a result - an increase of the value of the assets in the mid/long term.
It should be noted that the defense/political status in Israel has no effect on the Group's operations except an effect on the exchange rate exposure in regards with the loan denominated in NIS that the Group had taken from an institutional entity.
The information described above in regards with the continued growth trend in rental income, low vitality in the short term and the increase in the value of residential properties for rental in Germany is "forward-looking information" as defined in the Securities Law, which is not under the full control of the Group and its actual materialization, in whole or in part, is uncertain. The information is based on information available in the Group as of the date of the report, regarding: (1) the expected increase in rental demand curve; (2) the high strength of German households; (3) the low rental burden in the Group's operating cities; (4) the low unemployment rate in Germany due to high fiscal flexibility of the German government; (5) the lack of harm to residential income
33 destatis
30 From Vonovia's Investors Presentation for the third quarter of 2023.
31 BNP Paribas Real Estate, Residential Report Germany, March 2023
32 destatis/ 1 GDW (2023) and Macroeconomic Policy Institute (IMK) (2024)
or the continued long-term growth trend of residential rental income in previous periods of crisis and recession in Germany; (6) The Group's assessments regarding the diversion of investments between cash and real assets; (7) future developments in the inflation rates, yields and yields margins between the yield of a risk-free asset and real assets and liabilities that are related to these assets; (8) market information and also includes additional estimates by the Group.
Change of circumstances (including without derogating from the generality of the foregoing material adverse change in the state of the economy in Germany, increase of interest rates and crisis in the real estate market in Europe in general and Germany in particular), the creation of special conditions under the circumstances, may significantly change the Group's assessments set forth above and materially affect its aforesaid forecasts.
| December 31, | December 31, | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| Assets | 2023 | 2022 | Additional explanation |
| 000' EUR | 000' EUR | ||
| Current assets | |||
| Cash and cash equivalents | 11,562 | 27,352 | See cash flow statement |
| Restricted bank deposits and liquidated investments |
11,622 | 15,058 (*) | (*) reclassified |
| Financial assets | 1,219 | 2,111 | |
| Accounts receivable | 2,455 | 912 (*) | (*) reclassified |
| Total current assets | 26,858 | 45,433 | |
| Non-current assets: | |||
| Investment property | 666,410 | 654,683 | Combined effect of increase due to the purchase of new assets and decrease due to changes in value. |
| Investment property – construction |
13,116 | 8,897 | |
| Accounts receivable | 403 | 2,518 | |
| Deferred taxes | 513 | - | |
| Total non-current assets | 680,442 | 666,098 | |
| Total assets | 707,300 | 711,531 | |
| December 31, | December 31, | ||
| Liabilities | 2023 | 2022 | Additional explanation |
| 000' EUR | 000' EUR | ||
| Current liabilities: | |||
| Current maturities of loans from banks |
6,618 | 12,398 | * |
| Accounts payable | 8,856 | 6,794 | |
| Total current liabilities | 15,474 | 19,192 | |
| Non-current liabilities: | |||
| Loans from banks and others and financial institutions |
341,909 | 294,344 | Increase derives from new loans for the purchase of assets and refinancing |
| Deferred taxes | 19,674 | 26,708 | |
| Total noncurrent liabilities | 361,583 | 321,052 | |
| Equity attributable to Company shareholders |
330,243 | 371,287 | |
| Total liabilities and equity | 707,300 | 711,531 |
* The decrease derives from refinancing of a loan that was executed in 2023 for a loan that was classified as a current maturity in 2022 in accordance with the loan original settlement schedule.
| Year ended December 31, 2023 |
Year ended December 31, 2022 |
Year ended December 31, 2021 |
Additional explanation |
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 000' EUR | 000' EUR | 000' EUR | ||
| Revenues from rental of properties |
21,386 | 16,600 | 11,328 | |
| Revenues from property management and others |
7,998 | 6,095 | 3,596 | Purchase of new assets and increase in rental income |
| Property management expenses |
)7,998( | )6,095( | )3,596( | from identical assets |
| Cost of maintenance of rental properties |
)3,793( | )3,261( | )2,041( | |
| Gross profit | 17,593 | 13,339 | 9,287 | |
| General and administrative expenses |
)6,437( | )5,653( | )4,209( | |
| Operating profit (before changes in fair value of investment property, |
11,156 | 7,686 | 5,078 | |
| net) Change in fair value of investment property, net |
)45,352( | 27,022 | 63,744 | |
| Changes in fair value of investment property, due to a one-time change of Real estate Transfer Tax |
)11,471( | - | - | |
| Operating profit (loss) |
)45,667( | 34,708 | 68,822 | |
| Financing expenses | )7,636( | )5,523( | )2,080( | Increase in bank financing for the purchase of new assets and refinancing |
| Change in fair value of financial assets and exchange rate differences, net |
2,400 | 3,215 | 2,335 | |
| Income (loss) before taxes on income |
)50,903( | 32,400 | 69,077 | |
| Taxes on income | 7,408 | )5,125( | )10,245( | |
| Net income (loss) | )43,495( | 27,275 | 58,832 |
| Year ended December 31, 2023 |
Year ended December 31, 2022 |
Year ended December 31, 2021 |
Additional Explanation |
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 000' EUR | 000' EUR | 000' EUR | ||
| Cash flows derived from operating activities |
12,900 | 8,842 | 7,447 | For further details see the statement of cash flows |
| Cash flows used in investing activities |
)65,936( | )155,469( | )121,688( | For further details see the statement of cash flows |
| Cash flows derived from/used for financing activities (excluding refinancing) |
19,648 | 119,296 | 110,261 | For further details see the statement of cash flows |
| Cash flows from refinancing activities |
17,568 | 19,999 | 995 | For further details see the statement of cash flows |
Access to financing sources – the Group evaluates its accessibility to sources of financing as very high in light of its financial strength, the stability of core activity, and the vast good long-term relationships it has created with the banks financing real-estate projects in Germany.
For the period of twelve months that ended on December 31, 2023, the Company in its Company-only financial statements (but not in the consolidated reports), had a negative cash flow from operating activities that amounted to EUR 0.5 million. The Company's board of directors determined, based on an examination it carried out, that this was a purely technical matter and it is not deemed to indicate a liquidity problem in the Company, since as of the date of signing the report, the cash, the value of cash and liquidity balances in the Company (Company-only) amount to approximately EUR 81 million, compared to current liabilities in the Company (Company-only) in the amount of approximately EUR 1 million, so that in the Company (Companyonly), as of the date of signing the report, there is an excess in the working capital amounting to approximately EUR 80 million, consisting of cash and liquidity balances. As a result, in light of the high liquidity balances held by the Company (Company-only), the Company chose not to receive management fees (other than small amounts for administrative purposes) or withdraw dividends from its wholly owned subsidiaries, such that led to the negative cash flows from the Company's operating activities at the "Company-only" level, whereas according to the Company's consolidated financial statements the cash flow from the Group's operating activities was positive and amounted to approximately EUR 12.9 million in 2023. For further details, see the Company-only financial statements of the Company as of December 31, 2023.
| NTA 000' EUR |
|
|---|---|
| Equity attributed to the Company's shareholders |
330,243 |
| Plus deferred taxes due to EPRA adjustments |
23,349 |
| Plus Real estate Transfer Tax (RETT) and other transaction costs |
- |
| Fair value of nominal liabilities bearing fixed interest, net3750 |
- |
| Early liquidation and related repayment costs |
- |
| Total | 353,592 |
| Per share (in EUR) | 19.53 |
Below is a calculation of the EPRA metrics as of December 31, 2023:
The FFO index is calculated as the net profit (loss) attributed to the Company's shareholders from the income-generating activity only, in accordance with the Securities Authority's guidelines and certain adjustments in respect of non-operating items, which are affected by fair value revaluation of assets and liabilities. The adjustments involved are mainly investment property fair value adjustments, various capital gains and losses, various amortizations, adjustment of expenses for management and planning of the Group's office project in Berlin, change in fair value recognized in respect of financial instruments and deferred taxes.
In addition, since the Group has acquired and is acquiring assets at an accelerated rate in each of the years of operation since its establishment and the business operating results of these assets were only partially reflected in the annual net profit of each period (acquired during the year and yielded a partial return). Therefore, as part of the FFO calculation, adjustment was carried out for full annual income generation in respect of the operating results for the last quarter of each reported period of operation and adjustment to full annual income generation in respect of the operating results of assets under notarized purchase agreements and exclusivity agreements that have not yet been consolidated in the year of operation.
37 The value is based on calculating the present value of the projected cash flows according to loan agreements at an interest reflecting market interest as of the report date following a deduction of deferred taxes.
| FFO (Funds from Operations) | Year ended December 31, 2023 |
Year ended December 31, 2022 |
|
|---|---|---|---|
| € in thousands, consolidated (unaudited) | |||
| Net income (loss) for the year attributed to the Company's | |||
| holders of capital rights | )43,495( | 27,275 | |
| Adjustments in accordance with the provisions of the Fourth Addendum to the Securities Regulations (Details of the |
|||
| Prospectus and the Draft Prospectus - Structure and Form), | |||
| -1969 (hereinafter: "Prospectus Details Regulations") | |||
| 1. Changes in fair value of investment properties |
56,823 | )27,022( | |
| 6. Changes in fair value of financial instruments measured at fair value through profit or loss |
)2,400( | )3,215( | |
| 8. Deferred taxes due to adjustments |
)7,408( | 5,146 | |
| Nominal FFO (Funds From Operations) pursuant to the provisions of the Fourth Addendum to Prospectus Details Regulations* |
3,520 | 2,184 | |
| Adjustment to full income generation in respect of the operating results for the assets and liabilities that were consolidated for the first time during the reported period385 |
381 | 3 | |
| Adjustment to full income generation in respect of the operating liabilities results of assets and under notarized purchase agreements and exclusivity agreements that have not yet been consolidated in the reported period39502 |
635 | 1,756 | |
| Additional adjustments for non- cash items: | |||
| Cost of share based payment | 2,451 | 1,987 | |
| Euro-NIS interest rates gap/Embedded interest in SWAP currency hedge transactions |
784 | 240 | |
| Deferred financing costs | 612 | 805 | |
| Adjustment of administrative and general expenses in respect of entrepreneurial activity and business development |
821 | 586 | |
| Depreciation, donations, professional services and one-off adjustments |
373 | 1,190 | |
| FFO according to management approach for the period | 9,577 | 8,751 |
According to the Company's management opinion, at this stage of the "Company's life", the FFO index does not represent a suitable indicator for examining the Group's performance, since it does not properly reflect the Group's asset value enhancement oriented business model.
38 Operating results (including financing expenses) of assets that were consolidated for the first time during the reported period presented in the table above were adjusted such that the results represent full periods of operations.
39 Assets whose ownership has passed to the Company after the reported period in the table and have not yet been consolidated in the Company's financial statements, and assets, which at the time of signing the statements of each period presented in the table, were under notarized purchase agreements and exclusivity agreements – the operating results (including financing expenses) thereof were adjusted to a full period of operation.
According to the Group's estimate, the activity of the Group in its areas of activity is exposed to the following principal risk factors:
(e) Property and liability risks - the Group insures the real estate property in insurance policies, and also purchases policies to insure the customary risks to which the Group is exposed. In the event of an insurance event, the Group may have monetary exposure at the rate of the difference between the total insurance coverage and the monetary scope of the claim or the damage to the property. It is emphasized that according to the Company's management estimate it is not underinsured.
(a) Legislation and regulation in the real estate sector in Germany - the activity of the Group is subject to German regulation in general and in the cities of operation in particular, whereby a change in the regulatory environment (inter alia, changes in the provisions of law regulating the activity of renovations of buildings owned by the Group, provisions concerning energy efficiency requirements, legislation impacting the local rental laws and legislation concerning conversion of buildings to condominiums), may impact the Group's activity and its operating results.
In addition, the Group's activity in Germany is subject to the provisions of law concerning local privacy laws adopted during 2018, which obligate stringent compliance with requirements concerning storage and use of personal information. Noncompliance with these provisions of law may lead to the imposition of fines in scopes calculated from the income cash flow of the Group. It should be noted that the Group entered into an agreement with an expert in the field of privacy laws during 2022 and implemented procedures following her recommendations in order to meet the requirements of the law.
The Company took a loan from an institutional entity denominated in NIS. Since the Group's activity is in EURO, the Company has exposure to changes in exchange rates. For further details regarding the Group's hedging policy see the Company's board report.
| Measure of impact of risk factor on | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| the area of activity | |||
| High | Medium | Low | |
| Macro risks | |||
| State of the economy in Germany | + | ||
| Recession in credit market, downturn in capital markets in Israel and worldwide and insolvency of European countries |
+ | ||
| Interest risks | + | ||
| Business environment | + | ||
| Sectorial risks – income-generating real estate |
|||
| Decrease in demand for rental space | + | ||
| Decrease in occupancy rates in apartments in the Group's properties |
+ | ||
| Decrease in payment ability of tenants | + | ||
| Value of Group properties | + | ||
| Apartment sale activity (condo) | + | ||
| Acquisition risks and liabilities | + | ||
| Decrease in demand for office space in Berlin | + | ||
| Increased supply of available land and/or projects under construction for offices in Berlin |
+ | ||
| Increase of construction costs and/or contract performance costs | + | ||
| Increase of interest rates in the Eurozone | + | ||
| Legislation and regulation in the real estate sector in Germany | + | ||
| Liability for environmental damages | + | ||
| Cyber risks | + | ||
| Unique risks to the Group | |||
| Slowdown in the residential real estate markets in Leipzig, Dresden, Magdeburg and Hanover |
+ | ||
| The state of the office real estate market in Berlin | + | ||
| Appreciation of NIS vs. EURO | + |
The assessment of the Group regarding the risk factors above, including the measure of the impacts of the risk factors on the Group, is based upon information in the possession of the Group as of the date of the report and includes assessments and intentions of the Group. The Group may be exposed in the future to additional risk factors and the impact of every risk factor, if materializes, may be different than the assessment of the Group.
Currency rate effects - as of the report date, the Group's currency exposure rate deriving from taking an institutional loan denominated in NIS, amounts to approximately 7.6% of the Group's total balance sheet. As of the report date and as of the report signing date, the Group has no open hedging transactions against this exposure.
As of the report date, most of the Group's financial instruments are presented at their fair value.
Below are sensitivity tests for changes in the fair value of the Group's primary financial instruments, due to changes in the interest rates (in EUR thousands):
The basic interest rate is 3-months Euribor.
December 31, 2023
| 10% | 5% | Fair Value |
-5% | -10% | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fixed-interest rate loan | 2,790 | 1,594 | )268,013( | )1,594( | )2,790( |
| Total | 2,790 | 1,594 | )268,013( | )1,594( | )2,790( |
In addition, negative change in the fair value of fixed interest rate agreements (CAP) is limited to their value as of the report date (EUR 2,383 thousand).
| 10% | 5% | Fair | -5% | -10% | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Value | |||||
| Fixed-interest rate loan | 2,087 | 1,041 | )230,393( | )1,035( | )2,065( |
| Interest rate SWAP transactions which are not recognized as an accounting hedging |
8 | 4 | 126 | (4) | (8) |
| Total | 2,095 | 1,045 | )230,267( | )1,039( | )2,073( |
Below are sensitivity tests for changes in the fair value of the Group's primary financial instruments, due to changes in the exchange rates (in EUR thousands):
Change in EUR exchange rate compared to NIS.
| 10% | 5% | Fair Value |
-5% | -10% | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fixed-interest rate loan | )5,359( | )2,680( | )53,594( | 2,680 | 5,359 |
| Cash held in NIS | 10 | 5 | 104 | )5( | )10( |
| Total | )5,349( | )2,675( | )53,490( | 2,675 | 5,349 |
December 31, 2022
| 10% | 5% | Fair Value |
-5% | -10% | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fixed-interest rate loan | 5,969 | 2,848 | )56,966( | )2,848( | )5,696( |
| Cash held in NIS | 72 | )36( | 721 | 36 | 72 |
| Currency hedging transaction | )2,700( | )1,350( | 96 | 1,350 | 2,700 |
| Total | 3,341 | 1,462 | )56,149( | )1,462( | )2,924( |
The fair value of the investment real-estate properties is also affected by changes in the interest rates in the market. A permanent increase/decrease (increase/decrease observed by the market as such which is not temporary, but rather characterizes a medium/long-term trend) in market interest rates will lead to changes in the requested yields on real-estate properties (although there is no full correlation between the change in the market interest rates level and the change in yields on properties), and to a decrease/increase in their fair value, respectively.
The Company is a Dutch company incorporated in the Netherlands in January 2018 as a public limited company (NV)405 in accordance with the Dutch Law. According to the Dutch Companies Law, the shares of a Dutch company of NV type can be issued to the public and traded on the stock exchange, in contrast to a Dutch company of BV type (Besloten vennootschap) whose shares cannot be issued to the public. Therefore, the Dutch Companies Law defines an NV type as a public company even if its shares have not yet been issued to the public.
Pursuant to section 39A (a) of the Israeli Securities Law, 1968 (hereinafter: "the Securities Law" and "Section 39A" respectively), the provisions of the Companies Law – 1999 (hereinafter: "the Corporates Law") and the Regulations under the Securities Law, shall apply to a company which incorporated outside Israel and offered its shares or liability certificates to the public in Israel, all in accordance with the provisions described in Part A of the Fourth Addendum to the Securities Law, however, the Securities Authority may exempt such company from the provisions and regulations set forth in said addendum, in whole or in part, if it has found that the law outside Israel which is applicable to the Company sufficiently ensures the interests of the Israeli investors public.
Since the Company's shares were initially offered to the public in Israel and were listed for trading on the Tel Aviv Stock Exchange Ltd. (hereinafter: "the Stock Exchange") in accordance with the Israeli Law, the provisions of Section 39A , as abovementioned, will apply to the Company and, as a result, various provisions of the Corporates Law as set forth in Part A of the Fourth Addendum of the Securities Law (hereinafter: "Part A of the Fourth Addendum") will apply to the Company, where such provisions apply in addition to the provisions of the Dutch Law415 . For further details, see Chapter 5 of the prospectus.
Without derogating from the responsibility of each of the members of the Board of Directors (who approved the Board of Directors report) to the information as stated in this report above and below, it is clarified that three Messrs. (Peter Bodis, Monique van Dijken Eeuwijk and Bert van den Heuvel) out of the five members of the Board of Directors, do not speak Hebrew. Regarding this issue, it is noted that Monique van Dijken Eeuwijk, Bert van den Heuvel and Peter Bodis who participated on the Board of Directors meeting for the discussion and approval of the Company's report and approved this report, notified the Company that they approved this report based on the report's translation to English and not based on its original version in Hebrew. The said directors stated that they are aware of that the binding version of the Board of Directors report is its original version in the Hebrew language.
No policy on donations was determined.
40 N.V. is a legal entity under the Dutch law, with a registered capital divided into transferable shares. Shareholders are not personally liable for actions taken on behalf of N.V., and are not liable for losses beyond the amount they must repay in respect of the shares in their possession. N.V Shares can be traded on a stock exchange.
41 The Company's articles of association, include the application of the full sections of the Corporates Law applicable to the Company by virtue of section 39A and the Fourth Addendum (Part A) to the Securities Law, except for sections 256 (c), 256 (d), 280 (b) and 281 of the Corporates Law (which contradict the Dutch law), which the Company requested the Authority for an exemption from their application. The Company's articles of association do not contradict mandatory provisions of the Dutch law.
Below are details regarding the Company's internal auditor (Regulation 10 (b) (11) and the Fourth Addendum to the Israeli Reporting Regulations):
| The auditor's name: | Amir Lavi, CPA |
|---|---|
| Tenure commencement | 27.07.2021 |
| date: | |
| Compliance with the provisions of the law: |
The internal auditor meets the conditions set forth in Section 3 (a) of the Internal Audit Law, -1992 ("the Internal Audit Law"). To the best knowledge of the Company and as was informed by the internal auditor, the internal auditor meets the provisions of Section 146(b) of the Companies' Law the provisions of section 8 of the Internal Audit Law. |
| Holding of the Comapny's securities: |
The internal auditor, according to his announcement, does not hold securities of the company or of an entity related to the company, as defined in the Fourth Addendum of the Reporting Regulations. |
| Material/business relations with the Company: |
The internal auditor does not have material business relations or other material relations with the Company or with an entity related to the Company, as defined the Fourth Addendum to the Reporting Regulations. The internal auditor will provide internal audit services as an external service provider. The internal auditor is not an interested party in the company, does not hold an office in the company and is not a relative of any of these. The internal auditor does not perform a position outside the company that creates or may create a conflict of interest with his position as the internal auditor of the company and his only position in the company is internal auditor of the company. The internal auditor is a partner in the firm of PKF Amit Halfon. |
| Appointment of internal auditor: |
On July 27, 2021, at the proposal of the Company's audit committee, the Company's Board of Directors approved the appointment of Mr. Amir Lavi as the Company's internal auditor. The Company's organs determined, after examining his many years of education and experience and after examining Mr. Amir Lavi's skills, taking into account, among other things, the type of company, its size, scope of activity and complexity that Mr. Amir Lavi is the most suitable candidate for the company's internal auditor. |
| The organizational supervisor of the auditor: |
The person in charge of the internal auditor is the chairman of the board. |
| The audit plan: | In 2023, the audit plan included an audit of insurance, fraud and embezzlement. |
| Scope of employment: | The scope of employment in 2023 was approximately 400 hours. |
| Professional standards: | The internal auditor, according to his statement, conducts the audit in accordance with IIA's professional international standards, including the professional guidelines of IIA Israel - the Association of Internal Auditors in Israel. In the opinion of the Company's Board of Directors, based on the statements of the Internal Auditor and his extensive experience, the internal audit work is conducted in accordance with generally accepted professional standards for internal auditing. |
| Access to information: | The internal auditor is given free access to the company's documents, information and information systems, including financial data and everything for the purpose of fulfilling his task and in accordance with the provisions of Section 9 of the Internal Audit Law. |
| Internal auditor's report: |
On November 16, 2023 and February 1, 2024, the internal auditor presented to the audit committee the internal audit reports in accordance with the abovementioned internal audit plan. |
| Remuneration : | Professional fees for the internal audit services were set at NIS 105 thousand plus VAT. In the opinion of the audit committee and the Board of Directors, the remuneration of the internal auditor is reasonable and does not affect the exercise of the auditor's professional judgment in conducting the audit. |
The auditor is Deloitte Brightman Zohar Almagor & Co. The scope of professional fees for audit and review services amounted to approximately NIS 430 thousand for 2023 and approximately NIS 360 thousand for 2022. In addition, the Company engaged with the Risk Management Department in Deloitte office for conducting a market comparison report – Benchmark (Benchmark report) of senior executives salaries and this is in accordance with section 8.3 in the remuneration policy of the Company; the scope of professional fees for these services amounted to approximately NIS 40 thousand and approximately NIS 18 thousand in the years of 2023 and 2022, respectively.
(6) Details regarding the statutory auditor in the Netherlands (IUS)
The statutory auditor of the company is IUS Statutory Audits Cooperatie U.A.. The scope of professional fees for audit services amount to approximately EUR 70.000 for 2023 which has been the first year of their appointment.
(7) Details regarding the Dutch Corporate Governance Code For details regarding the information to be provided regarding compliance with the Dutch Corporate Governance, please see the Company's website argo-nv.com
Regarding critical accounting estimates see note 2 to the annual audited consolidated financial statements of the Company.
Disclosure regarding material and highly material valuations and highly material appraisers
Highly material appraisers of the Group's assets are Jones Lang Lassale SE and BNP Paribas. The rate of assets assessed by them represents approximately 55%, and 42%, respectively, of the value of the Group's assets as of December 31, 2023. The appraisers are not dependent on the Company.
For details regarding the contact details with the appraisers, in accordance with section 2 of the Third Addendum to the Reports' Regulations, see below:
Jones Lang LaSALLE
| The identity of the company that ordered the valuations and the identity of the organ in said company that decided on entering into agreement with the appraiser; |
Argo Properties N.V. By Mr. Fred Ganea VP of Strategy, Transactions and Financing |
|---|---|
| The agreement date between the party ordering the valuations and the appraiser; |
In regards with 66 residential assets, March 29, 2023; In regards with 86 residential assets, July 5, 2023; In regards with 65 residential assets, September 28, 2023; In regards with 86 residential assets, January 9, 2024. |
| The reasons for ordering the valuations by the company; | Investment property value update |
| The name of the appraiser and the date of signing the | Jones Lang LaSalle |
|---|---|
| agreement; | March 29, 2023; July 5, 2023; September 28, |
| 2023; January 9, 2024. | |
| Details of the appraisers providing the valuations; | ppa. Roman Heidrich, ppa Stefan Wieser, i.A |
| Marlit Juette | |
| Details of the appraisers' education; | Appraisers hold academic degrees (some of |
| them hold master's degree), in economics and/or | |
| real estate | |
| Stipulations, if any, regarding the fee to which the | No |
| appraiser is entitled; Also, the extent of the effect that | |
| such stipulations have on the results of the valuation; | |
| Consent, if any, to indemnification of the appraiser for | No |
| his work; If there was such consent, the terms of the | |
| indemnification and the identity of the party providing | |
| the indemnification will be specified; | |
| Details regarding the experience of the appraisers in | Each of the appraisers has over 10 years of |
| performing valuations in similar volumes to those of the | experience in valuations of similar volumes. |
| current valuations or in higher volumes; |
| The identity of the company that ordered the valuations and the identity of the organ in said company that decided on entering into agreement with the appraiser; |
Argo Properties N.V. By Mr. Fred Ganea, VP of Strategy, Transactions and Financing |
|---|---|
| The agreement date between the party ordering the valuations and the appraiser; |
In regards with 44 residential assets, February 26, 2023; In regards with 60 residential assets, June 20, 2023; In regards with 47 residential assets, September 30, 2023; In regards with 77 residential assets and 2 commercial assets for development, January 15, |
| The reasons for ordering the valuations by the company; |
2024. Investment property value update |
| The name of the appraiser and the date of signing the agreement; |
BNP Paribas February 26, 2023; June 20, 2023; September 13, 2023; January 15, 2024. |
| Details of the appraisers providing the valuations; | Manuel Westphal FRICS; ppa. Anne Tonscheidt MRICS |
| Details of the appraisers' education; | Appraisers hold academic degrees (some of them hold master's degree) in economics and/or real estate |
| Stipulations, if any, regarding the fee to which the appraiser is entitled; Also, the extent of the effect that such stipulations have on the results of the valuation; |
No |
| Consent, if any, to indemnification of the appraiser for his work; If there was such consent, the terms of the indemnification and the identity of the party providing the indemnification will be specified; |
No |
| Details regarding the experience of the appraisers in performing valuations in similar volumes to those of the current valuations or in higher volumes; |
Each of the appraisers has over 10 years of experience in valuations of similar volumes. |
Amsterdam, November 21st 2024
| Name | Position | Signature |
|---|---|---|
| Ron Tira | Chairman of the Board of | |
| Directors | ||
| Nir Ilani | Executive Director | |
| Bert van den Heuvel | External Director | |
| Monique van Dijken Eeuwijk | External Director | |
| Peter Bodis | Non External director |
Below are data regarding the compliance of the Company and sub-subsidiaries with the financial covenants determined in material loans. The calculation of the financial covenants is made according to the definitions in the relevant loan agreements and does not necessarily comply with the accepted accounting principles.
| Loan grant date |
Original loan |
Principal balance as of December 31, 2023 |
Financial liabilities |
Net debt to CAP net | Value of a single asset | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| amount | EUR in thousands | |||||
| EUR in | ||||||
| thousands | 42 | |||||
| 1 | 18/1/2022 | 60,000 | 53,5946 | Net financial |
As of December 31, 202347 |
As of December 31, 2023 |
| 43 to debt6 |
6 50.5% |
2.5% | ||||
| 44 CAP net6 |
As of the signing date of the report | As of the signing date of the report | ||||
| will not | 43.9% | 2.3% | ||||
| exceed 75% | ||||||
| at any time; | ||||||
| Value of a | ||||||
| single 45 of the asset6 |
||||||
| Group's | ||||||
| assets will | ||||||
| not exceed | ||||||
| 15% of the | ||||||
| Group's total | ||||||
| real estate 46; assets6 |
||||||
| Loan grant | Original | Principal balance as of | Financial | LTV ratio | Debt to yield ratio | |
| date | loan | December 31, 2023 | liabilities | |||
| amount | EUR in thousands | |||||
| EUR in | ||||||
| thousands | ||||||
| 2 | 15/02/2022 | 40,000 | 38,499496 | Maximum LTV ratio of |
As of December 31, 2023 |
As of December 31, 2023 |
| 75%; debt to | 54.7 % | 5.5 % | ||||
| yield | As of the signing date | As of the signing date | ||||
| ratio506 above 3.5%; |
51.4% | 6.1% | ||||
| Loan grant | Original | Principal balance as of | Financial | LTV ratio | Minimal rental fees | |
| date | loan | December 31, 2023 | liabilities | |||
| amount | EUR in thousands | |||||
| EUR in | ||||||
| thousands | 6 | |||||
| 3 | 19/02/2024 | 39,000 | - | Maximum LTV |
As of December 31, 2023 |
As of December 31, 2023 |
42 Loan agreement was signed on January 18, 2022 and drawing down the loan was carried out on January 25, 2022. The difference between the original loan amount and the loan amount as of the report date derives from exchange rates differences; see sensitivity analysis as part of Chapter B of this report.
| Loan grant date |
Original loan amount EUR in thousands |
Principal balance as of December 31, 2023 EUR in thousands |
Financial liabilities |
Net debt to CAP net | Value of a single asset |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| ratio51 6of |
N.R | N.R | |||
| 66.5%; rate | As of the signing date of the report | As of the signing date of the report | |||
| of minimal | 59 % | EUR 2.28 million | |||
| rental fees | |||||
| of the | |||||
| pledged | |||||
| assets | |||||
| against the | |||||
| loan EUR | |||||
| 2.12 million |
It should be noted that in addition, as of the date of the report, the Company's sub-subsidiaries have immaterial bank loans (against real estate collateral) that are subject to financial covenants in a total amount of approximately EUR 68.6 million and an average LTV ratio of approximately 42% and immaterial bank loans (against real estate collateral) excluding financial covenants in a total amount of approximately EUR 190.1 million and with an average LTV ratio of approximately 39%.
51 According to the value of assets by the appraisal conducted by the bank.
(IN THOUSANDS OF EUROS)
| December 31, | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2023 | 2022 | |||
| Euros in | Euros in | |||
| Note | thousands | thousands | ||
| CURRENT ASSETS: | ||||
| Cash and cash equivalents | 3 | 11,562 | 27,352 | |
| Restricted deposits and |
liquidated investments | 4 | 11,622 | )*( 15,058 |
| Financial assets | 12a | 1,219 | 2,111 | |
| Accounts receivable | 4 | 2,455 | ) *( 912 |
|
| 26,858 | 45,433 | |||
| NON-CURRENT ASSETS: | ||||
| Investment property | 5 | 666,410 | 654,683 | |
| Investment property – | construction rights | 5 | 13,116 | 8,897 |
| Accounts receivable Deferred taxes |
9 | 403 513 |
2,518 - |
|
| 680,442 | 666,098 | |||
| 707,300 | 711,531 | |||
| CURRENT LIABILITIES: | ||||
| Current maturities of loans from banks | 7 | 6,618 | 12,398 | |
| Accounts payable | 6 | 8,856 | 6,794 | |
| 15,474 | 19,192 | |||
| NON-CURRENT LIABILITIES: | ||||
| Loans from banks and financial institutions | 7 | 341,909 | 294,344 | |
| Deferred taxes | 9 | 19,674 | 26,708 | |
| 361,583 | 321,052 | |||
| EQUITY ATTRIBUTABLE TO SHAREHOLDERS OF | ||||
| THE COMPANY: | ||||
| Share capital | 11 | 181 | 181 | |
| Share premium | 225,628 | 221,012 | ||
| Statutory capital reserve | 11d | 83,400 | 131,727 | |
| Share based payment capital reserve | 11c | 1,472 | 3,637 | |
| Retained earnings | 19,562 | 14,730 | ||
| Total equity attributable to shareholders | of the Company | 330,243 | 371,287 | |
| 707,300 | 711,531 | |||
| (*)reclassified | ||||
| st 21 November 2024 |
||||
| Date of approval of the | Ron Tira | |||
| financial statements | Ofir Rahamim Joint CEO |
Guy Priel CFO |
Chairman of the Board of Directors |
| Note | Year ended December 31, 2023 Euros in thousands |
Year ended December 31, 2022 Euros in thousands |
Year ended December 31 2021 Euros in thousands |
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Revenues from rental of properties Revenues from property management and others Property management expenses Cost of maintenance of rental properties |
21,386 7,998 )7,998( )3,793( |
16,600 6,095 )6,095( )3,261( |
11,328 3,596 )3,596( )2,041( |
|
| Profit from property rental | 17,593 | 13,339 | 9,287 | |
| General and administrative expenses | 13 | )6,437( | )5,653( | )4,209( |
| Operating income before changes in fair value of investment property, net Changes in fair value of investment property, net Changes in fair value of investment property due to one time update in the Real estate Transfer Tax |
5 | 11,156 )45,352( )11,471( |
7,686 27,022 - |
5,078 63,744 - |
| Operating (loss) income | )45,667( | 34,708 | 68,822 | |
| Finance expenses, net Change in fair value of financial assets and exchange rate differences |
13 | )7,636( 2,400 |
)5,523( 3,215 |
)2,080( 2,335 |
| (Loss) income before taxes on income | )50,903( | 32,400 | 69,077 | |
| Taxes on income | 9 | 7,408 | )5,125( | )10,245( |
| Total net and comprehensive (loss) income attributable to shareholders of the Company |
)43,495( | 27,275 | 58,832 | |
| Basic (loss) earnings per share | 17 | (2.40) | 1.51 | 3.46 |
| Diluted (loss) earnings per share |
(2.40) | 1.47 | 3.15 |
| Share capital |
Share premium |
Statutory capital reserve |
Share based payment capital reserve |
Retained earnings |
Total equity attributable to shareholders of the Company |
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Euros in thousands | ||||||
| Balance as of January 1, 2023 | 181 | 221,012 | 131,727 | 3,637 | 14,730 | 371,287 |
| Expiration of options deriving from share based payment Total net and comprehensive |
- | 4,616 | - | )4,616( | - | - |
| income (loss) |
- | - | - | - | )43,495( | )43,495( |
| Classification in accordance with Dutch law Cost of share based payment |
- - |
- - |
)48,327( - |
- 2,451 |
48,327 - |
- 2,451 |
| Balance as of December 31, 2023 |
181 | 225,628 | 83,400 | 1,472 | 19,562 | 330,243 |
| Share capital |
Share premium |
Statutory capital reserve |
Share based payment capital reserve |
Retained earnings |
Total equity attributable to shareholders of the Company |
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Euros in thousands | ||||||
| Balance as of January 1, 2022 | 181 | 221,012 | 110,652 | 1,650 | 8,530 | 342,025 |
| Total net and comprehensive income Classification in accordance |
- | - | - | - | 27,275 | 27,275 |
| with Dutch law Cost of share based payment |
- - |
- - |
21,075 - |
- 1,987 |
)21,075( - |
- 1,987 |
| Balance as of December 31, 2022 |
181 | 221,012 | 131,727 | 3,637 | 14,730 | 371,287 |
| Share capital |
Share premium |
Statutory capital reserve (1) |
Share based payment capital reserve |
Retained earnings |
Total attributable equity shareholders of the Company |
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Euros in thousands | ||||||
| Balance as of January 1, 2021 | 151 | 171,076 | 55,602 | 263 | 4,748 | 231,840 |
| Issuances of share capital, net Total net and comprehensive |
30 | 49,936 | - | - | - | 49,966 |
| income | - | - | - | - | 58,832 | 58,832 |
| Classification in accordance with Dutch law Cost of share based payment |
- - |
- - |
55,050 - |
- 1,387 |
)55,050( - |
- 1,387 |
| Balance as of December 31, 2021 |
181 | 221,012 | 110,652 | 1,650 | 8,530 | 342,025 |
| Year ended December 31, |
Year ended December 31, |
Year ended December 31 |
|
|---|---|---|---|
| 2023 | 2022 | 2021 | |
| Euros in thousands |
Euros in thousands |
Euros in thousands |
|
| Cash flows from operating activities: | |||
| Net (loss) income | )43,495( | 27,275 | 58,832 |
| Adjustments required to present net cash from operating activities: |
|||
| Adjustments to profit or loss: | |||
| Finance expenses, net | 5,392 | 2,308 | )265( |
| Changes in fair value of investment property, net | 56,823 | )27,022( | )63,744( |
| Cost of share based payment | 2,451 | 1,987 | 1,387 |
| Deferred taxes, net | )7,547( | 5,146 | 10,460 |
| Cash flows from operating activities before changes in asset and liability items |
13,624 | 9,694 | 6,670 |
| Changes in operating asset and liability items: | |||
| Other receivables |
)288( | )1,098( | 910 |
| Increase in accounts payable | )436( | 246 | )133( |
| Net cash derived from operating activities |
12,900 | 8,842 | 7,447 |
| Cash flows from investing activities: | |||
| Purchase of investment property | )64,329( | )143,371( | )117,591( |
| Additions in respect of investment property (including planning costs) |
)5,350( | )3,714( | )2,991( |
| Loans to employees | - | - | 366 |
| Realization of financial assets | - | 1,850 | 1,640 |
| Depositing restricted deposits and prepaid transaction costs, net |
3,716 | )10,234( | )3,112( |
| Net cash used in investing activities | )65,963( | )155,469( | )121,688( |
| Cash flows from financing activities: | |||
| Interest paid | )7,111( | )4,762( | )1,762( |
| Receipt of long-term loans, net | 33,877 | 130,657 | 64,675 |
| Repayment of long-term loans | )6,633( | )4,871( | (3,523) |
| Receipt of long-term loans under refinancing | 24,250 | 45,000 | 2,700 |
| Repayment of long-term loans under refinancing | )6,682( | )25,001( | (1,705) |
| Purchase of interest cap fixing transactions (CAP) | )485( | )1,728( | - |
| Issuance of shares, net | - | - | 50,871 |
| Net cash derived from financing activities |
37,216 | 139,295 | 111,256 |
| Year ended December 31, 2023 Euros in |
Year ended December 31, 2022 Euros in |
Year ended December 31 2021 Euros in |
|
|---|---|---|---|
| thousands | thousands | thousands | |
| Change in cash and cash equivalents | )15,847( | )7,332( | )2,985( |
| Effect of changes in exchange rates | 57 | )392( | 1,770 |
| Balance of cash and cash equivalents at the beginning of the year |
27,352 | 35,076 | 36,291 |
| Balance of cash and cash equivalents at the end of the year |
11,562 | 27,352 | 35,076 |
| (a) Non cash activities |
|||
| Purchase of real estate (*) |
876 | 362 | 1,690 |
| Payables in respect of investing activities | )2,474( | )3,902( | 4,369 |
(*) see Note 6.
a. General description of the Company and its activity
ARGO Properties N.V. (hereinafter: "the Company") and its subsidiaries (hereinafter: "the Group") was incorporated in January 2018 and commenced its operations in July 2018 and is a Dutch-based real estate company engaging via subsidiaries in value enhancement and acquisition of investment properties in Germany in the area of income-generating residential real estate and income-generating real estate for development.
Regarding the Company's operating segments, see Note 17.
b. Definitions
In these financial statements -
| Interested parties - |
Stake holders which holds more than 5% from the capital voting rights or the Company's Equity. Director or CEO of the Company or someone that has sole right to nominate them. |
|---|---|
| The report date or the date of the report - |
December 31, 2023 |
| The signing date or the date of signing the report - |
November 21, 2024 |
The Company has elected to present its statement of comprehensive income according to the operations attribute method.
The consolidated financial statements of the Group have been compiled in accordance with International Financial Reporting Standards (hereinafter: "IFRS") as adopted by the European Union (hereinafter: "EU-IFRS") and with Book 2 Title 9 of the Dutch Civil Code and interpretations thereof issued by the International Accounting Standards Board (IASB). The main principles of the accounting policies which are detailed below have been applied consistently in regards to all reporting periods presented in these consolidated financial statements, except for changes in the accounting policies that derived from the application of standards, amendments to standards and interpretations which have been effective as of the reporting date of the financial statements as specified in Note 3 below.
The financial statements were authorized for issue by the Company's Board of Directors on November 21st , 2024.
During the preparation of the financial statements, the management is required to make estimates and assumptions that have an effect on the application of the accounting policies and on the reported amounts of assets, liabilities, revenues and expenses. These estimates and underlying assumptions are reviewed regularly. Changes in accounting estimates are reported in the period of the change in estimate.
The key assumptions made in the financial statements concerning uncertainties at the end of the reporting period and the critical estimates calculated by the Group that may result in a material adjustment to the carrying amounts of assets and liabilities within the next consecutive financial year are discussed below.
Investment property that can be reliably measured is presented at fair value at the end of the reporting period. Changes in their fair value are recognized in profit or loss. Fair value is determined by independent valuation experts using economic valuations that involve valuation techniques and assumptions as to estimates of projected future cash flows from the property and estimate of the suitable discount
rate for these cash flows.
The fair value measurement of investment property requires valuation experts and the Company's management to use certain assumptions regarding rates of return on the Group's assets, future lease prices, occupancy rates, contract renewal terms, the probability of leasing vacant areas, asset operating expenses, the tenants' financial stability and the implications of any investments made for future development purposes in order to assess the future expected cash flows from the assets. In determining the fair value of lands and potential rights, the duration of establishing the project and establishment costs are taken into account, if relevant. Any change in the assumptions used to measure the investment property may affect fair value.
See note 5d for sensitivity tests.
c. Consolidated financial statements:
The consolidated financial statements comprise the financial statements of companies that are controlled by the Company (subsidiaries). Control is achieved when the Company is exposed, or has rights, to variable returns from its involvement with the investee and has the ability to affect those returns through its power over the investee. Potential voting rights are considered when assessing whether an entity has control. The Company legally holds of specific entities at a rate of 89.9% and earns a yield imputation of 100% in accordance with the essence and the mechanism that was defined in the profit sharing agreement (see Note 10(b)(1)).
d. Functional currency and presentation currency:
The presentation currency of the financial statements is the Euro.
The Group determines the functional currency of each Group entity. The vast majority of the group companies operate in Euro.
Cash equivalents are considered as highly liquid investments, including unrestricted shortterm bank deposits with an original maturity of three months or less from the date of acquisition or with a maturity of more than three months, but which are redeemable on demand without penalty and which form part of the Group's cash management.
The operating cycle is one year.
g. Financial instruments:
The financial liabilities that are not measured at fair value through profit or loss are initially recognized at fair value after reduction of transaction costs. After initial recognition date, these financial liabilities are measured at amortized cost using the effective interest method.
The effective interest method is a method of calculating the amortized cost of a financial liability and the allocation of interest expense over the relevant credit period. The effective interest rate is the rate that accurately discounts the forecasted flow cash flows over the expected life of the financial liability to book value, or where appropriate, for a shorter period.
The Group derecognizes a financial liability when and only when the financial liability is repaid, canceled or expires. The difference between the carrying amount of the financial liability settled and the consideration paid is recognized in profit or loss.
An investment property is property (land or a building or both) held by the owner (lessor under an operating lease) or by the lessee under a finance lease to earn rentals or for capital appreciation or both rather than for use in the production or supply of goods or services, for administrative purposes or for sale in the ordinary course of business.
Investment property is measured initially at cost, including costs directly attributable to the acquisition. After initial recognition, investment property is measured at fair value which reflects market conditions at the end of the reporting period. Gains or losses arising from changes in the fair values of investment property are included in profit or loss when incurred. Investment property is not systematically depreciated.
Investment property is derecognized on disposal or when the investment property ceases to be used and no future economic benefits are expected from its disposal. The difference between the net disposal proceeds and the carrying amount of the asset in the financial statements is recognized in profit or loss in the period of the disposal.
The Group determines the fair value of investment property on the basis of valuations by independent appraisers who hold recognized and relevant professional qualifications and the necessary knowledge and experience.
Current or deferred taxes are recognized in the statement of profit or loss except to the extent that the tax arises from items which are recognized in other comprehensive income or in equity.
The current tax liability is measured using the tax rates and tax laws that have been enacted or substantively enacted by the end of reporting period as well as adjustments required in connection with the tax liability in respect of previous years.
Deferred taxes are computed in respect of temporary differences between the carrying amounts in the financial statements and the amounts attributed for tax purposes.
The Group does not create deferred taxes for temporary differences arising from initial recognition of the asset or liability in a non-business combination transaction, when, at the date of the transaction, the initial recognition of the asset or liability does not affect accounting income and taxable income (loss for tax purposes), see Note 9.
Deferred taxes are measured at the tax rates that are expected to apply to the period when the taxes are reversed in profit or loss, comprehensive income or equity, based on tax laws that have been enacted or substantively enacted by the end of the reporting period.
The calculation of deferred taxes does not take into account the taxes that would apply in the event of the realization of investments in investees. In addition, deferred taxes were not taken into account for the distribution of profits by subsidiaries as dividends, since the realization of investments in investee companies and dividend distribution does not involve additional tax liability.
Revenue from contracts with customers is recognized according to the fair value of the consideration that was received or the consideration that the Group is entitled to receive in regards with revenue from rendering of services in the normal course of business. Revenue is measured according to the fair value of the consideration that was received or the consideration that the Group is entitled to receive in regards with revenue from rendering of services in the normal course of business.
The specific criteria for revenue recognition for the following types of revenues are:
Revenue from rendering of services is recognized over time, during the period the customer simultaneously receives and consumes the benefits provided by the Group's performance. Revenues are recognized according to reporting periods in which the services were provided. The Group charges its customers based on payment terms agreed upon in specific agreements when payments are made before or after the service is performed, the Group recognizes the resulting contract asset or liability.
Where the contract outcome cannot be measured reliably, revenue is recognized only to the extent that the expenses incurred are recoverable.
Rental income is recognized on a straight-line basis over the lease term. Where there is a fixed increase in rent over the term of the contract, the aggregate amount of the increase is recognized as revenues on a straight-line basis over the lease period.
In cases where the Group acts as an agent or as a broker without being exposed to the risks and rewards associated with the transaction, its revenues are presented on a net basis. However, in cases where the Group operates as a principal supplier and is exposed to risks and rewards associated with the transaction, its revenues are presented on a gross basis.
According to the Group's activity, it bears the risks stemming from revenues from property management and therefore, the Group recognizes its revenues on a gross basis.
Fair value of investment property is the price that would be received to sell an asset or paid to transfer a liability in an orderly transaction between market participants at the measurement date.
The fair value of of investment property is measured using the assumptions that market participants would use when pricing the asset or liability, assuming that market participants act in their economic best interest.
Fair value measurement of a non-financial asset takes into account a market participant's ability to generate economic benefits by using the asset in its highest and best use or by selling it to another market participant that would use the asset in its highest and best use. Best use is met when it is physically possible, legally allowed and financially feasible.
The Group uses valuation techniques that are appropriate in the circumstances and for which sufficient data are available to measure fair value, maximizing the use of relevant observable inputs and minimizing the use of unobservable inputs.
The Group classifies cash flows for interest and dividends received as cash flows from investing activities, as well as cash flows for interest paid as cash flows used in financing activity. Cash flows for income taxes are generally classified as cash flows used in current operations, except those that are easily identifiable with cash flows used in investing or financing activities. Dividends paid by the Group are classified as cash flows from financing activities.
The amendment replaces the term "significant accounting policies" with "material information regarding accounting policies". Information about accounting policies is material if, when considered together with other information included in an entity's financial statements, it can reasonably be expected to influence the decisions that the primary users of the financial statements make for general purposes on the basis of those financial statements.
In addition, the amendment clarifies that information regarding accounting policies that refer to transactions, events or other conditions that are not material, is not material and does not need to be disclosed. Information about accounting policies may be material because of the nature of the transactions, events or other conditions related to it, even if the amounts are immaterial. However, not all information regarding the accounting policies relating to material transactions, events or other conditions is in itself material.
▪ Amendment to IAS 8, "Accounting Policies, Changes to Accounting Estimates and Errors" (regarding the definition of accounting estimates)"
The definition of "change in accounting estimate" was replaced by the definition of "accounting estimates". Accounting estimates according to the new definition are "monetary amounts in financial statements that are subject to measurement uncertainty".
The amendment clarifies that a change in an accounting estimate resulting from new information or new developments is not a correction of an error. In addition, the effects of a change in a figure or measurement technique used to develop an accounting estimate constitute a change in accounting estimates if those changes do not result from the correction of errors in a prior period.
There was no material impact on the company's financial statements.
In 2020, the IASB issued an amendment to IAS 1regarding the classification of liabilities as current or non-current (hereinafter: Amendment 2020). The amendment clarifies that the classification of liabilities as current or non-current is based on the rights that exist at the end of the reporting period and is not affected by the entity's expectation of exercising this right.
The amendment removed the reference to existence of an unconditional right and clarified that if the right to defer extinguishment is conditional upon compliance with financial criteria, the right exists if the entity meets the criteria that were determined for the end of the reporting period, even if compliance with the criteria is performed by the lender at a later date.
In addition, as part of the amendment, a definition was added to the term "extinguishment" in order to clarify that extinguishment may be the transfer of cash, goods and services or equity instruments of the entity itself to the counter party. In this regard, it was clarified that if under the terms of the liability, the counter party has an option to demand extinguishment of the entity's equity instruments, this condition does not affect the classification of the liability as current or non-current if the option is classified as a separate equity component in accordance with IAS 32 "Financial Instruments: Presentation".
The amendment only affects the classification of liabilities as current or non-current in the statement of financial position and not the amount or timing of recognition of those liabilities or the associated income and expenses.
In October 2022, another amendment was published regarding the classification of liabilities with financial covenants (hereinafter: Amendment 2022) which clarified that only financial covenants which the entity is required to meet at the end of the reporting period or before it, affect the entity's right to postpone the settlement of a liability for at least 12 months after a period of the report, even if compliance with them is actually examined after the reporting period.
Amendment 2022 states that if the entity's right to postpone the settlement of the liability is subject to the entity meeting financial covenants within 12 months after the reporting period, the entity is required to provide a disclosure that will allow the users of the financial statements to understand the risk inherent therein.
The other amendments published as part of 2020 Amendment remain in force. The application date of Amendment 2020 and Amendment 2022 is set for annual reporting periods beginning on or after January 1, 2024. Early application is permitted provided that both amendments are carried out at the same time.
| December 31, | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| 2023 | 2022 | ||
| Euros in thousands |
Euros in thousands |
||
| Cash on hand | 5,345 | 14,765 | |
| Short-term deposits (1) |
6,217 | 12,587 | |
| 11,562 | 27,352 |
(1) As of December 31, 2023, includes deposits of approximately € 6,186 thousand bearing an annual average weighted interest of approximately 4.46% and a deposit of € 31 thousand denominated in NIS bearing an annual weighted interest rate of approximately 1.5% .
| December 31, | ||
|---|---|---|
| 2023 | 2022 | |
| Euros in thousands |
Euros in thousands |
|
| Restricted bank accounts | 9,084 | 15,058 |
| Liquidated investments | 2,538 | - |
| Tenants, net | 755 | 306 |
| Prepaid expenses | 1,459 | 342 |
| Accounts receivable and debit balances | 241 | 264 |
| 14,077 | 15,970 |
| Year ended December 31, | ||
|---|---|---|
| 2023 | 2022 | |
| Euros in |
Euros in |
|
| thousands | thousands | |
| Income generating residential real estate – level 3: |
||
| Balance at the beginning of the year | 634,680 | 460,191 |
| Purchases and additions during the year | 71,800 | 142,912 |
| Increase in fair value | 7,356 | 39,412 |
| Decrease in fair value | )56,010( | )7,835( |
| Balance at the end of the year (*) | 657,826 | 634,680 |
| Income generating commercial real estate – level 3: |
||
| Balance at the beginning of the year | 28,900 | 33,100 |
| Purchases and additions during the year Increase in fair value |
349 - |
267 - |
| Decrease in fair value | )7,549( | )4,467( |
| Balance at the end of the year | 21,700 | 28,900 |
| 679,526 | 663,580 |
(*) As of December 31, 2023, the Group has 12,03 square meters of construction rights reflecting an average value of € 982 per meter.
Investment property is stated at fair value, as determined in valuations generally performed by independent outside appraisers who hold recognized and relevant professional qualifications and who have extensive experience in the location and category of the property being valued. The fair value was determined based on estimated future cash flows from the property. In estimating cash flows, their inherent risks and limitations of rental fees are taken into account where they are capitalized at a rate of return that reflects the risks embodied in the cash flows, which is determined taking into account the market rate of return, whilst adapting it to the specific characteristics of the property and the level of risk of the revenues expected from it.
c. Significant assumptions (based on weighted averages) that were used in valuation estimates are as follows:
| December 31, | ||
|---|---|---|
| 2023 | 2022 | |
| Income-generating residential real estate: | ||
| Discount rate (%) (*) | 4.78% | 4.14% |
| Growth rate for the first 10 years | 1.78% | 1.79% |
| Long-term growth rate (*) |
1.21% | 1.06% |
| Long-term vacancy rate (%) |
1.58% | 1.63% |
| Representative monthly rental fees per sq. m. (in | ||
| Euros) | 10.77 | 10.2 |
| Income-generating real estate under development: (**) |
||
| Monthly rental fees for offices (EUR) per sq. m upon | ||
| project completion | 25.45 | 25.45 |
| Construction cost per sq.m (EUR) | 2,612 | 2,508 |
| Unrecoverable costs upon completion | 5.29% | 6.29% |
| Cap Rate | 4.4% | 3.8% |
| Developer's profit, transaction costs and others | 33% | 35% |
d. The following table presents the sensitivity of the valuation to the changes in the most material assumptions underlying the valuation of investment property:
| December 31, | ||
|---|---|---|
| 2023 | 2022 | |
| Euros in |
Euros in |
|
| thousands | thousands | |
| Increase of 25 basis points at the discount rate of investment property relating to income-generating residential real estate/ at CAP RATE relating to |
||
| income-generating real estate under development | )41,413( | )38,917( |
| Decrease of 25 basis points at the discount rate of investment property relating to income-generating residential real estate/ at CAP RATE relating to income generating real estate under development |
||
| 47,278 | 44,001 | |
| Increase of 5% in representative rental fees per square meter |
||
| 33,431 | 33,753 | |
| Decrease of 5% in representative rental fees per square meter |
||
| )33,431( | )33,753( |
e. Regarding charges: see Note 10.
The Group owns income generating residential real estate where all of its lease agreements are shorter than one year.
As of December 31, 2023, the Group has lease agreements in the residential segment reflecting, based on the current occupancy rate, an annual rental income at the amount of approximately EUR 23.5 million.
In addition, the Group owns income generating commercial real estate consisting of assets leased to third parties generating annual rental income at the amount of approximately EUR 0.7 million.
The future minimum rental fees receivable from existing tenants in the income generating commercial real estate are as follows:
| As of December 31: | Euros in thousands 2023 |
Euros in thousands 2022 |
|---|---|---|
| First year | 704 | 700 |
| Second year | 662 | 658 |
| Third year | 624 | 634 |
| Fourth year | 396 | 628 |
| Fifth year | 258 | 391 |
| Sixth year and thereafter | 2,219 | 1,221 |
| 4,863 | 4,232 |
During 2022, the Company entered through several sub-subsidiaries into non-recourse loan agreements with several German banking corporations (for periods of 5-6 years according to the following terms:
Refinancing as a result of property value enhancement:
The Current Loans bear a fixed (weighted) annual interest rate of approximately 0.99% and their final repayment date is due in 2025 – 2027 and are secured by firstranking liens on the full rights of the subsidiaries in 81 buildings which comprise of 878 units (with a total area of 56,462 square meters) in the cities of Leipzig, Dresden and Magdeburg in Germany, which their aggregate book value is about EUR 168.9 million (as of the loans' underwriting date – September 2022) (hereinafter: the "Asset Companies" and the "Assets", respectively).
The refinancing process is enabled due to a value enhancement of these assets on the initial financing date by the abovementioned Banks, close to the date of their acquisition during the second half of 2019 and in the first half of 2020 - as of the loans' underwriting date. It is clarified that the refinancing process was carried out by drawing New Loans in addition to the Current Loans without any change in their terms ("Top Up").
The Company attributes the exchange rate differences to the profit or loss.
Fixed annual interest rate of 3.69% per annum ("the basic interest rate"). The basic interest rate will be increased with 1% per annum if the loan is not repaid on December 31, 2028, and 0.5% per annum at each additional exit date / early repayment date if the loan is not fully repaid by that date.
The loan is subject to the following financial covenants: net debt ratio to CAP net (as defined in the loan agreement) is lower than 75% (43.9% as of the signing date of the report) and the value of a single asset is lower than 15% of the value of the Group's consolidated real estate assets (2.3% as of the signing date of the report). The loan is secured by a negative lien on its assets (other than real estate), a change of control stipulation, various powers and structure. In addition, interest rate adjustment mechanisms and grounds for early repayment have been established as acceptable in such loans. The loan was fully drawn down on January 20, 2022.
h. Purchases of investment property and entering into financing agreements during 2023 (Cont.):
Refinancing as a result of property value enhancement:
The New Loan: is for a period of 5 years (until January 31,2029) and will bear a variable interest rate with an additional margin of 1.3% above the interest rate that will be determined. The Company is entitled to hedge the interest rate at any convenient time. The New Loan is secured by first-ranking liens on the full rights of the asset companies in the said properties.
The free cash flow that will derive from the refinancing subject of the New Loan will sum up (after deducting expenses) at the amount of approximately EUR 11.9 million and will be used by the Group for financing new acquisitions and for its operating activities.
The current loans: An amount of EUR 6.5 million out of the current loans which is at a variable interest rate which is expected to be drawn down at the time of executing the refinancing. The remaining balance of the current loans at the amount of approximately EUR 20 million bears a fixed interest rate of between 0.94% to 1.1% and is to repaid in the months of July and December 2026. The Company obtained a commercial understanding with the bank that granted the current loans, that (subject to the approval of credit committee and signing legal documents) the remaining
h. Purchases of investment property and entering into financing agreements during 2023 (Cont.):
balance of the current loans bearing a fixed interest rate and their terms would be maintained and would be used for the purpose of:
a. Financing at an amount of approximately EUR 15.5 million for the acquisition of new assets upon which the Company's sub-subsidiaries entered into notary purchase agreements.
b. Refinancing at a manner of "Top Up" at an amount of approximately EUR 3.2 million as an addition to other current loans that the bank had provided to the Company's sub-subsidiaries. And repayment of bank loan of other bank with balance of EUR 1.3 million.
The said engagement with the bank was signed during 2024.
| December 31, | ||
|---|---|---|
| 2023 | 2022 | |
| Euros in | Euros in | |
| thousands | thousands | |
| Expenses payable |
3,823 | 1,950 |
| Agreement with a partner (**) | 333 | 326 |
| Interest payable |
115 | 289 |
| Trade payables | 436 | 836 |
| Deposits from tenants | 3,076 | 2,506 |
| Provision for vacation and sick leave | 1,073 | 887 |
| 8,856 | 6,794 | |
| (**) see Note 10b(1). |
| Weighted interest rate (*) as of December 31, 2023 |
December 31, 2023 |
December 31, 2022 |
|
|---|---|---|---|
| % | Euros in thousands |
Euros in thousands |
|
| Non-current loans from banks | |||
| and others : | |||
| Variable interest rates based on | |||
| 3 or 6 months Euribor rate (**) | 3.94% | 63,250 | 50,172 |
| Fixed interest rates | 1.82% | 233,972 | 201,238 |
| Fixed interest rate from institutional entity |
|||
| denominated in NIS (***) | 3.84% | 53,594 | 57,287 |
| Deferred finance costs | )2,289( | )2,000( | |
| Total loans from banks and others, net of deferred finance |
|||
| costs | 348,527 | 306,742 | |
| Less - current maturities | )6,618( | )12,398( | |
| 341,909 | 294,344 | ||
| Maturity dates (excluding the | |||
| deduction of deferred finance costs): |
|||
| First year | 6,618 | 12,398 | |
| Second year | 35,647 | 5,360 | |
| Third year | 85,328 | 34,472 | |
| Fourth year | 128,816 | 80,110 | |
| Fifth year and beyond | 95,497 | 176,402 | |
| 351,906 | 308,742 |
(* ( The weighted interest rate is taking into account the interest rate cap in accordance with agreements to fix the Euribor rate cap (CAP) the companies entered into.
(**) The values of the loans at variable interest rate do not include a loan the balance of which as of December 31, 2023 amounted to EUR 7,500 thousand that was fixed by SWAP agreement and is presented by weighing the SWAP agreement under loans bearing fixed interest rate.
(***) For further details see Note 5(g)(c).
(1) Under the loan agreement the balance of which as of December 31, 2023 amounts to EUR 38,499 thousand, the Company's subsidiaries have committed to meet a number of financial covenants, as specified in Note 5(g)(b). In addition, the Company has other loans from banks the balance of which as of December 31, 2023 amounted to EUR 48,884 thousand in which the Company committed to meet at a debt coverage ratio of 1.2. All bank loans are without a right of recourse to the borrower (Non-Recourse).
The balance of the bank loans does not include a commitment to meet financial covenants. Regarding covenants determined as part of a loan from an institutional entity see Note 5(g)(c). As of December 31, 2023, the Group meets all covenants that were set.
Financial liabilities in regards of interest SWAP transactions as of December 31, 2023 and 2022 are in the amount of approximately EUR 0 thousand and approximately EUR 24 thousand, respectively (level 2). As of December 31, 2023 and 2022, the fixed interest rates (without margin) were set at 2.72% and 0.17%, respectively. (See also Note 12f).
Subsidiaries in Germany that own investment properties took loans and signed interest rate SWAP agreements. In these agreements, the subsidiary hedges its exposure to future changes in variable interest rates on cash flows, by swapping it for a fixed interest rate. As of December 31, 2023, the loan balance amounted to € 7,500 thousand. The Group did not treat these transactions as accounting hedging. The change in the fair value of the instrument was recognized in profit or loss statements.
| % | |
|---|---|
| State | |
| The Netherlands | 25 |
| Germany | 15.825 |
Some of the Company's subsidiaries are German companies, which are generally also subject to local business tax rates ranging from 14% to 17%. The tax law provides for exceptions and exemptions that are relevant to the Company's operations in these companies.
The Company and its Dutch subsidiaries were incorporated during 2018 and the tax assessments for previous years are not final. With respect to German companies and Luxembourgian companies acquired by the Company in the framework of share purchase transactions, the Company received indemnification from the companies' sellers in relation to tax assessments prior to the purchase period, to some German companies final tax assessments until 2018, and some were not yet issued tax assessments from their incorporation date.
The Group has business losses for tax purposes carried forward for tax purposes on the coming years and temporary differences that do derive from investment property, amounting as of December 31, 2023 to approximately € 20,846 thousand. In regards of these losses, deferred tax assets have been recognized in the financial statements in the amount of approximately € 4,188 thousand.
In addition, the Group has business losses, which were accumulated in asset companies the Company acquired during the period prior to the acquisition of the companies, for tax purposes carried forward to future years, amounting as of December 31, 2023 to approximately € 304 thousand, for which no deferred tax assets were recognized.
In addition, the Group has temporary differences, which were created at the time of acquisition of asset companies in non-business combinations and that at the time of the transaction did not affect the accounting profit or the taxable income, between the tax base of real estate for tax purposes and the cost of its acquisition which amounted as of December 31, 2023 and 2022 to approximately EUR 21,413 thousand, for which no deferred tax liabilities were recognized.
| December 31, | |
|---|---|
| 2022 | |
| Euros in thousands |
|
| )23,349( )28,822( |
|
| 4,188 2,114 |
|
| )19,161( )26,708( |
|
| 513 - |
|
| )26,708( | |
| )26,708( | |
| )19,674( )19,161( |
| Year ended December 31, | ||
|---|---|---|
| 2023 | 2022 | |
| Euros in thousands |
Euros in thousands |
|
| Balance at the beginning of the period/year | )26,708( | )21,562( |
| Investment property Revaluation of financial derivatives |
5,473 | )4,693( - |
| Creation (utilization) of losses carried forward for tax purposes |
2,074 | )453( |
| Balance at the end of the period/year | )19,161( | )26,708( |
(*) The deferred taxes are computed at an average tax rate of 15.825% based on the tax rates expected to apply upon asset realization in the Company's sub-subsidiaries. Deferred taxes in regards of carryforward tax losses in the Netherlands are calculated at a tax rate the Company expects that these losses will be utilized.
| Year ended December 31, | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| 2023 | 2022 | 2021 | |
| Euros in thousands |
Euros in thousands |
Euros in thousands |
|
| Deferred taxes Current taxes and taxes in |
7,547 | )5,146( | )10,460( |
| regards of previous years |
)139( | 21 | 215 |
| Tax expenses | 7,408 | )5,125( | )10,245( |
The following is the reconciliation between the tax expense, assuming that all revenues and expenses, profits and losses in the statement of profit or loss had been taxed at the statutory tax rate in the Netherlands and the amount of taxes on income charged in the statement of profit or loss:
| Year ended December 31, | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| 2023 | 2022 | 2021 | |
| Euros in thousands |
Euros in thousands |
Euros in thousands |
|
| Income (loss) before taxes on income | )45,667( | 32,400 | 69,077 |
| Statutory tax rate in the Netherlands |
25% | 25% | 25% |
| Tax calculated using statutory tax rate | 11,417 | )8,100( | )17,269( |
| Deferred tax assets created in other tax rate (see section d. above) |
)4,009( | 2,975 | 7,024 |
| Taxes on income | 7,408 | )5,125( | )10,245( |
(1) To secure loans from banking corporations that have no right of recourse to the borrower (Non-recourse), charges have been recorded on investment property as well as on bank accounts where rents are received, rights in respect of insurance policies, charge on shares of the Company the owner of the property, etc. Each property is owned by a subsidiary (SPV). For some of the properties, there is a cross guarantee to secure credit facilities taken to finance the acquisition of the properties.
Some of the loan agreements contain "negative lien" provisions stipulating that the borrowers were prohibited from creating additional charges on the charged properties and income, without an explicit approval of the lender.
(2) The balance of the secured liabilities is as follows:
| December 31, | ||
|---|---|---|
| 2023 | 2022 | |
| Euros in thousands |
Euros in thousands |
|
| Non-current liabilities (including current maturities) see Note 7 |
351,816 | 306,742 |
(1) The Company has entered into an agreement with a partner holding 10.1% in a number of subsidiaries, according to which the Company has provided the partner with loans of approximately € 3,035 thousand. The loans are without a right of recourse to the borrower (non-recourse) secured by the shares of the subsidiaries, bearing interest at a rate of 10% and repayable in 2029. The partner assigned to the Company rights for any payment to be paid by the subsidiaries until the full repayment of the loan.
In addition, the Company has an option to acquire the partner's rights in the subsidiaries after 10 years from the agreement date in exchange for an amount equal to the partner's share in the net assets of the subsidiaries less certain reductions in accordance with the mechanism defined in the agreement.
Under said loan agreement, an annual amount for the above option to which the partner is entitled under the option agreement as well as additional amounts to which the partner is entitled for a dividend from the subsidiaries will be deducted against the annual interest amounts in respect of the loans granted to the partner as mentioned above. For further details see Note 6.
(2) Regarding commitments for the purchase of real estate purchase - see Note 5g above.
a. Composition of share capital:
| December 31, 2022 and 2021 | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| Authorized | Issued and outstanding |
||
| Ordinary shares of EUR Cent 1 par value each (1) |
30,000,000 | 18,101,534 |
The Company works to ensure a capital structure that will enable the Company to support its business and to maximize value for its shareholders. The Company manages its capital structure and makes changes according to changes in the environment in which the Company operates.
b. Employee stock options:
During 2023, the Company's Board of Directors approved plans for the allocation of options to employees and officers in the Group and the remuneration committee, the Company's Board of Directors and the general meeting of the Company's shareholders (respectively and as the case may be) approved the allocation of options in virtue of the said plans for the joint CEOs as well as for additional senior officers. Below are the main terms of the said plans:
| ESOP 2 | ESOP1A in | ESOP1A in | |
|---|---|---|---|
| regards to the | regards to the | ||
| joint CEOs | officers who are | ||
| not CEOs | |||
| Date of the approval of allocations | January 19, 2023 –In regards of the joint CEOs | August 31, 2023 (the remuneration | |
| (name of the approving organ) | (the remuneration committee and the Company's | committee); | |
| Board of directors) and March 9, 2023 (the general | September 7, 2023 (the Company's Board | ||
| meeting of the Company's shareholders); | of Directors); | ||
| August 23, –In regards of other senior officers | September 16, 2023 (the general meeting | ||
| 2023 (the audit committee and the Company's | of the Company's shareholders); | ||
| Board of Directors); | |||
| Number of allocated options | 2,048,904 | 1,331,277 | 839,283 |
| Date of actual allocation | 1,309,169 options were allocated on July 2, 2023 | October 16, 2023 | |
| to the joint CEOs; | |||
| 739,735 options were allocated to other senior | |||
| officers on August 23, 2023. | |||
| Exercise price (NIS) | 77.13 | 65 | 59.33 |
| The method of the options exercise | Cashless only with accordance to the average share price in the period of 30 days prior to the | ||
| exercise notice (*) | |||
| Vesting periods and dates | 3 vesting periods of one, two and three years, | One vesting date on December 31, 2024 | |
| starting from July 1, 2023 | |||
| Final date for exercise | June 30, 2027 | June 30, 2026 | |
| Fair value of the total amount of | NIS 12,492 thousand | NIS 4,960 thousand | NIS 4,580 thousand |
| granted options as determined by | |||
| an external independent appraiser | |||
| Main parameters that were used for the valuation of the options | |||
| Valuation Model | Black and Scholes | Black and Scholes | Black and Sholes |
| and Monte Carlo | |||
| Closing price of the share (NIS) on | 54.03 and 50.95, with accordance to the date the | 47.51, with accordance to the date the | |
| the date of valuation | options were granted respectively: March 9, 2023 | options were granted on October 16, 2023 | |
| with regards to 1,309,169 options and August 23, | |||
| 2023 with regards to 737,735 options. | |||
| Annual standard deviation | 29%-31% | 31% | |
| Option expected term (based on | Between 3.2. and 2.9 years, with accordance to the | Two years, with accordance to the date the | |
| "Simplified method") | date the options were granted. | options were granted. | |
| Risk-free interest rate | 3.96%-4.26% | 3.89% | |
| Maximum dilution factor | Up to 6% | Up to 7% |
* With regards to 636,286 options which were granted to Mr. Tenenbaum (joint CEO), it was determined as for the net exercise mechanism, that in spite of the calculation based only on the average closing prices, the calculation will be determined by the lower of: (i) average closing share prices; and (ii) the EPRA NTA per share value (in NIS currency according to the exchange rate on the date of exercising the options).
In accordance with the Company's founders agreement, if the Company's shares are issued in the stock exchange the investors included in the founders' agreement of July 2018 will be entitled to options for additional 20% of shares than they had on the founders' agreement signing date (fully diluted) at a price higher by 25% than the price per share of the shares to be issued in the stock exchange (if issued) subject to 4 year vesting period from the IPO date.
In accordance with the foregoing, on May 10, 2021, the Company's board of the directors approved the allocation of 2,069,785 non-marketable options (Initial Investors' Option Warrants) exercisable to 2,069,785 shares of the Company to the Company's founders and other investors in the Company's first fundraising round according to the terms specified in the founders' agreement as of the Company's establishment date, the Company accounts for such grant of options as a share based payment for services rendered by the Company's founders.
In accordance with Dutch law applicable to the Company, the Company's profits from adjustments to fair value that have not been realized cannot be distributed as dividends.
In addition, profits of subsidiaries are not distributable as dividends unless distributed by the subsidiaries themselves.
However, according to Dutch law, these profits can only be distributed after being converted into share capital and the reduction of capital as a result of the dividend distribution.
In the reported year, the Company classified the distributable earnings from the statutory capital reserve.
Accordingly, the balance of distributable earnings as of December 31, 2023 is approximately € 19,562 thousand.
On September 17, 2024 the Company held a tender for classified investors for the issuance of the Company's shares and on September 19, 2024, a public tender was held for the issuance of the Company's shares. According to the Company's shelf offering report and the results of the tenders, the Company issued 2,458,100 shares at a price of NIS 89.70 per share and a total amount of NIS 220,492 thousand (gross) received in cash.
| December 31, | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| 2023 | 2022 | ||
| Euros in thousands |
Euros in thousands |
||
| Cash, loans and receivables at amortized cost : |
|||
| Cash and cash equivalents | 11,562 | 27,352 | |
| Restricted deposits and liquidated investments |
11,622 | 15,058 | |
| Financial assets | 1,219 | 2,111 | |
| Accounts receivable | 1,056 | 570 | |
| 25,459 | 45,091 | ||
| Other financial liabilities at amortized cost : | |||
| Credit from banks and others | 351,816 | 306,742 | |
| Other accounts payable (1) | 4,707 | 3,401 | |
| 356,523 | 310,143 | ||
The Group is exposed to risk resulting from changes in cash flows of loans bearing variable interest rates because of changes in interest rates.
The Group hedges most of its financial liabilities by taking loans at fixed interest rate or by entering into interest SWAP agreements or CAP agreements.
The interest swap contract conditions are suited to the base loans. As of the report date, 97% of the Group's loans are at fixed interest or hedged. See Note 7 regarding the Group's loans at fixed and variable interest.
The Group, whose operating currency is EURO, is exposed to risk due to changes in exchange rates for a loan from an institutional body that it took out in NIS the balance of which as of December 31, 2023 amounted to EUR 53,594 thousand.
The Group is considering hedging its exposure to exchange rates, through forward transactions and natural hedging (by holding cash in NIS), mainly in light of market conditions, financial flexibility and liquidity considerations.
As of December 31, 2023, the exposure to changes in exchange rates is not hedged.
Credit risk could arise from cash and cash equivalents, derivatives and deposits with banking corporations and financial institutions, as well as from receivables, including tenants' debit balances.
Management has a credit policy and exposure to credit risk is examined on a regular basis. In principle, the Group does not provide credit to tenants. In cases in which tenants request credit, the Group carries out a credit assessment for those customers. The Group holds all or part of the tenants' deposits that are refundable until the tenants will settle their payments or in other cases of breach of contract.
The Group estimates the need for making an allowance for doubtful accounts according to the management's estimate of the balance's nature based on the cumulative experience in managing the asset.
Credit risk could also arise from an engagement by a number of financial instruments with a single entity. The Group holds cash and cash equivalents, short-term investments and other financial instruments in various financial institutions with high credit ratings. The Group's policy is to spread its investments among the various institutions.
As of the report date, there were no significant concentrations of credit risk. According to management estimate, the balance in the financial statements of each of the financial assets represents the maximum exposure to credit risk.
Liquidity risk is the risk that the Group will have difficulty meeting obligations in respect of financial liabilities. Financial liabilities to banking corporations regarding interest payments are guaranteed through rental payments regularly deposited in designated accounts/collection accounts.
The Group's goal is to maintain a balance between the receipt of financing and the flexibility in the use of bank loans.
As of December 31, 2023, 1.9% of the Group's debt to banks and others will be redeemed within under a year (See also Note 7).
The following table sets out the maturity dates of the Group's financial liabilities in accordance with the contractual conditions in non-discounted sums (including interest payments):
| First year |
Second year |
Third year |
Forth year |
Fifth year onwards |
Total | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Euros in thousands | ||||||
| Accounts payable Loans from banking corporations and |
4,707 | - | - | - | - | 4,707 |
| others (1) | 6,618 | 35,647 | 85,328 | 128,407 | 95,407 | 351,816 |
| 11,325 | 36,647 | 85,328 | 128,407 | 95,407 | 356,523 |
(1) The balance of loans from banking corporations and others include interest payments and other financial liabilities.
Management estimated that the balance of cash and cash equivalents, short term deposits, trade receivables, trade payables, overdrafts, and other current liabilities and bank loans that bear a variable interest rate and are presented at amortized cost matches or approximates their fair value.
The fair value of loans from banks as of December 31, 2023 that bear a fixed interest rate and are presented at amortized cost is lower by approximately EUR 19.4 million than their balance in the financial statements.
The fair value of financial instruments that are not quoted on an active market is determined using valuation techniques. Valuation tools specific to financial instruments include:
The following describes unobservable material data that are used in valuation:
| Valuation technique |
unobservable material datal |
Range weighted( )average |
Fair value sensitivity to change in data which shall effect the profit or loss |
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Interest swap transactions (SWAP) |
DCF | Payment curve |
Euribor curve for transaction period |
2% increase/decrease in Euribor curve will result in increase/decrease in fair value up to € 0.6 million |
A decrease in fair value of the interest rate cap agreements (CAP) is limited to the positive value of the assets (EUR 1,151 thousand as of the date of the report).
As of December 31, 2023, the Group has interest rate swap agreements (SWAP) in the sum of € 7,500 thousand according to which the Group pays a fixed interest rate of 2.72% and receives a variable interest rate at a rate equal to three months Euribor rate.
As of December 31, 2023, the Group has CAP agreements on the 3 and 6 months Euribor rate on reserves in a total amount of EUR 53,031 thousand to fix caps of the Euribor rates at a range between 2% to 3%.
| December 31, | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2023 | 2022 | |||
| Euros in thousands |
Euros in thousands |
|||
| Sensitivity test to changes in interest rates : | ||||
| Effect on profit or loss: |
||||
| For loans (*) |
||||
| Interest increase of 200 basis points |
)5,112( | )5,234( | ||
| Interest decrease of 200 basis points |
5,112 | 5,234 | ||
| For SWAP transactions | ||||
| Interest increase of 200 basis points |
680 | 139 | ||
| Interest decrease of 200 basis points |
)680( | )126( | ||
| For CAP transactions (*) |
||||
| Interest increase of 200 basis points |
||||
| Interest decrease of 200 basis points |
4,380 | 4,137 | ||
| )1,151( | )1,889( | |||
| For FORWARD transactions | ||||
| Increase of 2% in the EUR/NIS exchange rate | - | )540( | ||
| Decrease of 2% in the EUR/NIS exchange rate | - | 540 |
(*) sensitivity analysis is presented according to projected cash flows from agreements according to their terms in nominal values.
The fluctuations chosen in the relevant risk variables were set in accordance with acceptable practice in regards to options for SWAP transactions. The results of the change are presented only in the expected effect on the internal value of the option.
The Group has performed sensitivity tests of principal market risk factors that are liable to affect its reported operating results or financial position. The sensitivity tests present the profit or loss and/or the comprehensive income with respect to each financial instrument for the relevant risk variable chosen for that instrument as of each reporting date. The test of risk factors was determined based on the materiality of the exposure of the operating results or financial condition of each risk with reference to the functional currency and assuming that all the other variables are constant.
In long-term loans at fixed interest ,the Group is not exposed to changes in profit/loss due to interest risk. In non-current variable-interest loans, the sensitivity test for interest rate risk was only performed on the variable component of interest.
| Year ended December 31, | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| 2021 | |||
| Euros in |
|||
| thousands | thousands | thousands | |
| )1,300( | |||
| )817( | |||
| )1,387( | |||
| )787( | )895( | )705( | |
| )6,437( | )5,653( | )4,209( | |
| - | |||
| )1,640( | |||
| )637( | )722( | )440( | |
| )2,080( | |||
| 2023 Euros in )1,481( )1,718( )2,451( 689 )7,688( )7,636( |
2022 Euros in )1,518( )1,253( )1,987( 32 )4,833( )5,523( |
| No. of people |
Amount - Euros in thousands |
|
|---|---|---|
| Short-term employee benefits (* ( | 6 | 4,247 |
| Cost of share based payment (** ( | 6 | 2,450 |
| No. of people |
Amount - Euros in thousands |
|
|---|---|---|
| Short-term employee benefits | 6 | 2,065 |
| Cost of share based payment (** ( | 6 | 1,987 |
| No. of people |
Amount - Euros in thousands |
|
|---|---|---|
| Short-term employee benefits | 6 | 1,208 |
| Cost of share based payment (** ( | 6 | 1,387 |
(*( The amount of short term employees benefit for this period does not include EUR 193 thousand for provision for vacation and sick leave.
(** ( The cost of share based payment in 2021, 2022 and an amount of EUR 978 thousand from the cost of share based payment in 2023 were recognized due to ESOP1 option plan that was expired valueless on September 30, 2023.
b. Compensation and benefits granted to interested parties and related parties:
| Year ended December 31, | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2021 | ||||
| Euros in thousands |
Euros in thousands |
Euros in thousands |
||
| 1,300 | ||||
| 2 | 2 | 2 | ||
| 365 | 267 | 137 | ||
| 5 | 5 | 5 | ||
| 2023 2,341 |
2022 2,164 |
The monthly employment cost of each of the joint CEOs until May 31, 2021 was EUR 12 thousand per month. Effective this date the cost was updated to NIS 90 thousand per months and from December 2022 was updated to NIS 110 thousand per month. The employment cost includes their salary, car maintenance and social security contributions as customary. In addition, the Company provides to them a mobile phone, laptop and bears their maintenance expenses and pays for fuel expenses and other expenses as well (flights, hotels, office expenses) that he spends for the purpose of fulfilling his position. Their employment period is not limited in time and each party may announce its termination with prior written notice of 6 months in advance. In addition, the joint CEOs are entitled to retirement grant upon termination of their employment in the amount of 6 monthly salaries or 12 monthly salaries (employer's cost) if employed by the Company for a period exceeding 5 or 10 years, respectively. Total payroll and related costs in regards of the joint CEOs for 2023 does not include provision for vacation and sick leave.
The table below lists the changes in the Group's liabilities arising from financing activities, including both changes arising from cash flows and non - cash changes. Liabilities arising from financing activities are liabilities in respect of which cash flows have been classified, or future cash flows will be classified in the statement of cash flows as cash flows from financing activities.
| Balance as of January 1, 2023 |
Cash flows from financing activities, net (a) |
Cash flows used in investing activities |
cash flows from operating activities (b) |
Balance as of December 31, 2023 |
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Loans from banks | 306,742 | 44,812 | - | )3,297( | 348,257 |
| Balance as of January 1, 2022 |
Cash flows from financing activities, net (a) |
Cash flows used in investing activities |
cash flows from operating activities (b) |
Balance as of December 31, 2022 |
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Loans from banks | 161,888 | 145,785 | - | (931) | 306,742 |
The Company's Board of Directors functions as the chief operational decisions maker of the Group. Operating segments have been determined based on information reviewed by the Chief Operational Decision Maker (CODM) for the purpose of making decisions with regard to resource allocation and performance assessment. Accordingly, for management purposes, the Group consists of operating segments of business units and has two operating segments, as follows:
| Income generating residential real estate |
- | Value enhancement and leasing of residential real estate. |
|---|---|---|
| Income generating real estate for development |
- | Development of real estate for offices and asset for commercial use. |
The operating segments data are based on the Company's accounting policy.
Segment revenues include rental revenues and revenues from property management.
The segment results reported to the operational decision maker include items that relate directly to the segment. Items not allocated include mainly general and administrative expenses, financing costs, financing income, adjustment to fair value of financial instruments and taxes on income, which are managed on a Group basis.
In each of the areas of activity, the Company's CEO reviews the data for each project on its own and each project is defined as operating segment. For each of the above areas of activity, the Company grouped for financial reporting all projects to one reportable operating segment such that the Company has two reportable operating segments in the financial statements according to its areas of activity.
The following are the management's considerations when grouping operating segments:
The Company's management examined each of its reported segments that all segments that were grouped are in a similar economic environment, since all segments are in Germany and the functional currency of all of them is in Euro and that long-term economic performance is similar in each of the operating segments. Also, all segments in each area of activity are similar in all of the following characteristics:
Based on the considerations outlined above, the Group's management believes that the grouping to segments is in accordance with IFRS 8.
| Income generating residential real |
Income generating real estate for |
Total | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| estate development Euros in thousands |
||||||
| Year ended December 31, 2023 | ||||||
| Revenues from property rental Revenues from property management and |
20,689 | 697 | 21,386 | |||
| others | 7,920 | 78 | 7,998 | |||
| Property management expenses | )7,920( | )78( | )7,998( | |||
| Rental property maintenance expenses | )3,679( | )114( | )3,793( | |||
| Profit from property rental General and administrative expenses |
17,010 | 583 | 17,593 )6,437( |
|||
| Changes in fair value of investment property, net |
)49,274( | )7,549( | )56,823( | |||
| Financial expenses, net | )5,236( | |||||
| )Loss) before taxes on income |
)50,903( |
| Income generating residential real |
Income generating real estate for |
||
|---|---|---|---|
| estate | development | Total | |
| Euros in thousands | |||
| Year ended December 31, 2022 | |||
| Revenues from property rental | 15,919 | 681 | 16,600 |
| Revenues from property management and | |||
| others | 6,013 | 82 | 6,095 |
| Property management expenses | )6,013( | )82( | )6,095( |
| Rental property maintenance expenses | )3,163( | )98( | )3,261( |
| Profit from property rental | 12,756 | 583 | 13,339 |
| General and administrative expenses | )5,653( | ||
| Changes in fair value of investment | |||
| property, net | 31,489 | )4,467( | 27,022 |
| Financial expenses, net | )2,308( | ||
| Income before taxes on income | 32,400 |
| Total |
|---|
| 11,328 |
| 3,596 |
| )3,596( |
| )2,041( |
| 9,287 |
| )4,209( |
| 63,744 |
| 255 |
| 69,077 |
| Income generating residential real estate |
Income generating real estate for development |
Total | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Euros in thousands | |||
| Capital investments and acquisitions (*) | 71,804 | 349 | 72,153 |
| * of which an amount of approximately EUR 5 million were invested in renovation of the Group's assets in the income generating residential real estate segment. |
| Segment assets | 657,826 | 21,700 | 679,526 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Unallocated assets | 27,774 | ||
| Segment liabilities | )289,772( | )7,500( | )297,272( |
| Unallocated liabilities | )79,785( |
| Income generating residential real estate |
Income generating real estate for development |
Total | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Euros in thousands | |||
| Capital investments and acquisitions (*) | 142,919 | 267 | 143,186 |
| * of which an amount of approximately EUR 3.5 million were invested in renovation of the Group's assets in the income-generating residential real estate segment. |
|||
| As of December 31, 2022 | |||
| Segment assets | 634,680 | 28,900 | 663,580 |
| Unallocated assets | 47,951 | ||
| Segment liabilities | )244,444( | )6,966( | )251,410( |
| Unallocated liabilities | )88,834( |
| Year ended December 31, | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| 2023 | 2022 | 2021 | |
| Euros in thousands |
Euros in thousands |
Euros in thousands |
|
| (loss) income for the year attributed to the | |||
| holders of the parent company | )43,495( | 27,275 | 58,832 |
| (loss) income used for calculating basic earnings per share |
)43,495( | 27,275 | 58,832 |
| Weighted average number of ordinary shares used to calculate basic earnings |
|||
| per share | 18,101,534 | 18,101,534 | 16,986,948 |
| Year ended December 31, | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2023 | 2022 | 1202 | ||
| Euros in |
Euros in |
Euros in | ||
| thousands | thousands | thousands | ||
| Income (loss) used for calculating basic earnings per share Income (loss) used for calculating diluted |
)43,495( | 27,275 | 58,832 | |
| earnings per share | )43,495( | 27,275 | 58,832 | |
| Weighted average number of ordinary shares used to calculate basic earnings per share |
18,101,534 | 18,101,534 | 16,986,948 | |
| Adjustments | ||||
| Warrants issued as part of the founders agreement (*) |
- | - | - | |
| Warrants to employees issued as part of share based payment arrangements |
194,224 | 500,960 | 1,707,702 | |
| Weighted average number of ordinary shares used to calculate diluted earnings |
||||
| per share | 18,295,758 | 18,602,494 | 18,694,650 |
(*) warrants issued as part of the founders agreement were not included in the calculation of diluted earnings per share since their effect is anti-dilutive.
Regarding events after the report date see Note 5(h), 7(b)3 and note 11(e).
| Name of entity | Country of | December 31, 2023 |
|
|---|---|---|---|
| incorporation | |||
| % in equity |
|||
| ARGO Properties N.V. | The Netherlands | 100% | |
| GRT B.V. | The Netherlands | 100% | |
| GRT Finco B.V. | The Netherlands | 100% | |
| ARGO Residential GmbH & Co. KG | Germany | 100% | |
| Dresden Zinshaus B.V. | The Netherlands | 100% | |
| Leipzig Zinshaus B.V. | The Netherlands | 100% | |
| Dresden Zinshaus II B.V. | The Netherlands | 100% | |
| Leipzig Zinshaus II B.V. | The Netherlands | 100% | |
| Dresden Zinshaus III B.V. | The Netherlands | 100% | |
| Leipzig Zinshaus III B.V. |
The Netherlands | 100% | |
| Hannover Zinshaus B.V | The Netherlands | 100% | |
| ART Leipzig GmbH | Germany | 100% | |
| DGRA B.V. | The Netherlands | 100% | |
| ARGO Residential Management GmbH | Germany | 100% | |
| Gama A.G.A.F Consulting Ltd. | Israel | 100% | |
| Crown Residential GmbH | Germany | )*( 89.9% | |
| Crown Black Estate GmbH | Germany | )*( 89.9% | |
| Crown Blue Estate GmbH | Germany | )*( 89.9% | |
| Crown CapitalInvest Dresden I GmbH | Germany | )*( 89.9% | |
| Crown Donathstr. 7-13 GmbH | Germany | )*( 89.9% | |
| Crown Green Estate GmbH | Germany | )*( 89.9% | |
| Crown Magenta Estate GmbH | Germany | )*( 89.9% | |
| Crown Orange Estate GmbH | Germany | )*( 89.9% | |
| Crown Pink Estate GmbH | Germany | )*( 89.9% | |
| Crown Purple Estate GmbH | Germany | )*( 89.9% | |
| Crown Red Estate GmbH | Germany | )*( 89.9% | |
| Crown Silver Estate GmbH | Germany | )*( 89.9% | |
| Crown Grey Estate GmbH | Germany | )*( 89.9% | |
| Crown Capitalinvest Dresden II GmbH | Germany | )*( 89.9% | |
| Eldenaer Holding B.V. | The Netherlands | 100% | |
| Eldenaer Investment GmbH | Germany | )*( 89.9% | |
| Schönow Investment GmbH | Germany | )*( 89.9% | |
| Ladius Investment GmbH | Germany | 100% |
(*) The rights of the Company and the partner for profit sharing are in accordance with the mechanism set out in the founders agreements of the subsidiaries – see Note 10b(1).
(IN THOUSANDS OF EUROS)
| Note | December 31, | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2023 | 2022 | |||
| Euros in thousands | ||||
| CURRENT ASSETS: | ||||
| Cash and cash equivalents | 3 | 5,518 | 14,993 | |
| Cash in trust | 5,043 | 11,359 | ||
| Restricted deposits and liquidated investments |
2,538 | )*( 11,150 |
||
| Other receivables | 65 | )*( 10 |
||
| Financial assets | - | 96 | ||
| (*) reclassified | 13,164 | 37,608 | ||
| NON-CURRENT ASSETS: | ||||
| Investment in investees | 6 | 371,812 | 392,217 | |
| Deferred taxes | - | - | ||
| 371,812 | 392,217 | |||
| Total assets | 384,976 | 429,825 | ||
| CURRENT LIABILITIES: | ||||
| Accounts payable | 938 | 1,034 | ||
| NON-CURRENT LIABILITIES: Loans from financial institutions |
53,594 | 56,966 | ||
| Deferred taxes | 201 | 538 | ||
| 53,795 | 57,504 | |||
| EQUITY: | ||||
| Share Capital | 181 | 181 | ||
| Share Premium |
225,628 | 221,012 | ||
| Share-based payment capital reserve | 1,472 | 3,637 | ||
| Statutory capital reserve | 83,400 | 131,727 | ||
| Retained earnings | 19,562 | 14,730 | ||
| 330,243 | 371,287 | |||
| Total equity and liabilities |
384,976 | 429,825 | ||
| August 13th 2024 |
||||
| Date of approval of the Ofir Rahamim Joint |
Guy Priel | Ron Tira | ||
| financial statements CEO |
CFO | Chairman of the Board of Directors |
| Year ended December 31, 2023 Euros in thousands |
Year ended December 31, 2022 Euros in thousands |
Year ended December 31 2021 Euros in thousands |
||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| General and administrative expenses net of |
||||
| intercompany charges | )3,521( | )1,253( | )1,206( | |
| Financial income (expenses), net | 2,018 | 2,301 | 2,350 | |
| Taxes on income | 337 | )611( | )517( | |
| Equity in earnings (losses) of investees | )42,329( | 26,838 | 58,205 | |
| Net and comprehensive (loss) income |
)43,495( | 27,275 | 58,832 |
| Share capital |
Share premium |
Statutory capital reserve |
Share based payment capital reserve |
Retained earnings |
Total equity attributable to shareholders of the Company |
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Euros in thousands | ||||||
| Balance as of January 1, 2023 | 181 | 221,012 | 131,727 | 3,637 | 14,730 | 371,287 |
| Expiration of options deriving from share based payment Total net and comprehensive |
- | 4,616 | - | )4,616( | - | - |
| income (loss) | - | - | - | - | )43,495( | )43,495( |
| Classification in accordance with Dutch law Cost of share based payment |
- - |
- - |
)48,327( - |
- 2,451 |
48,327 - |
- 2,451 |
| Balance as of December 31, 2023 |
181 | 225,628 | 83,400 | 1,472 | 19,562 | 330,243 |
Year ended December 31, 2022 Equity attributable to shareholders of the Company
| Share capital |
Share premium |
Statutory capital reserve |
Share based payment capital reserve Euros in thousands |
Retained earnings |
Total equity attributable to shareholders of the Company |
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Balance as of January 1, 2022 | 181 | 221,012 | 110,652 | 1,650 | 8,530 | 342,025 |
| Total net and comprehensive income |
- | - | - | - | 27,275 | 27,275 |
| Classification in accordance with Dutch law Cost of share based payment |
- - |
- - |
21,075 - |
- 1,987 |
)21,075( - |
- 1,987 |
| Balance as of December 31, 2022 |
181 | 221,012 | 131,727 | 3,637 | 14,730 | 371,287 |
| Share capital |
Share premium |
Statutory capital reserve (1) |
Share based payment capital reserve |
Retained earnings |
Total attributable equity shareholders of the Company |
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Euros in thousands | ||||||
| Balance as of January 1, 2021 | 151 | 171,076 | 55,602 | 263 | 4,748 | 231,840 |
| Issuances of share capital, net Total net and comprehensive |
30 | 49,936 | - | - | - | 49,966 |
| income | - | - | - | - | 58,832 | 58,832 |
| Classification in accordance with Dutch law Cost of share based payment |
- - |
- - |
55,050 - |
- 1,387 |
)55,050( - |
- 1,387 |
| Balance as of December 31, 2021 |
181 | 221,012 | 110,652 | 1,650 | 8,530 | 342,025 |
| Year ended December 31, 2023 Euros in thousands |
Year ended December 31, 2022 Euros in thousands |
Year ended December 31, 2021 Euros in thousands |
|
|---|---|---|---|
| Cash flows to operating activities of the Company |
|||
| Net income (loss) attributable to the Company's shareholders |
)43,495( | 27,275 | 58,832 |
| Adjustments required to present net cash to operating activities of the Company: |
|||
| Adjustments to profit or loss items of the Company: |
|||
| Financial expenses Cost of share-based payment Deferred taxes Equity in earnings (losses) of investees |
)1,511( 2,451 )337( 42,329 |
)2,300( 1,987 611 )26,838( |
)2,557( 1,387 517 )58,205( |
| Changes in operating asset and liabilities items of the Company: |
|||
| Increase in other receivables Increase (decrease) in accounts payable |
)55( 165 |
138 )228( |
)131( 244 |
| Net cash derived from operating activities of the Company |
)453( | 645 | 87 |
| Cash Flows from investing activities of the Company |
|||
| Movement in restricted deposits and liquidated investments |
8,612 | )11,150( | - |
| Investment in investees and prepaid expenses (Purchase) realization of financial derivatives |
)21,923( - |
)56,394( 1,850 |
)52,486( 1,640 |
| Net cash used in investing activities of the Company |
)13,311( | )65,694( | )50,846( |
| Year ended December 31, 2023 Euros in thousands |
Year ended December 31, 2022 Euros in thousands |
Year ended December 31 2021 Euros in thousands |
|
|---|---|---|---|
| Cash flows from financing activities of the Company |
|||
| Interest paid Receipt of long-term loans, net Issuance of shares, net |
)2,084( - - |
)1,963( 59,680 - |
50,871 |
| Net cash derived from financing activities of the Company |
)2,084( | 57,717 | 50,871 |
| Change in cash and cash equivalents | )15,848( | )7,332( | 112 |
| Effect of changes in exchange rates | 57 | )392( | 1,770 |
| Balance of cash and cash equivalents at the beginning of the year |
26,352 | 34,076 | 32,194 |
| Balance of cash and cash equivalents at the end of the year |
10,561 | 26,352 | 34,076 |
Argo Properties N.V. (hereinafter - "the Company") was incorporated in January 2018 and commenced its operations in July 2018 and is a Dutch-based real estate company engaging via subsidiaries in acquisition, mainly from private sellers, and value enhancement of investment properties in Germany, in the area of income-generating residential real estate and income-generating real estate for development.
The Company's separate financial information is prepared in accordance with accounting policies set forth in Note 2 to the Company's consolidated financial statements.
The Company prepared its Company-Only financial statements in accordance with the International Financial Reporting Standards ('IFRS') as adopted by the European Union (EU-IFRS) and with Part 9 of Book 2 of the Dutch Civil Code. In case no other policies are mentioned, refer to the accounting policies as described in the accounting policies in the consolidated financial statements. For an appropriate interpretation, the company-only financial statements of Argo Properties N.V. should be read in conjunction with the consolidated financial statements. The company-only financial statements are presented in Euros and all values are rounded to the nearest thousand (€ in thousands) except when otherwise indicated.
With regard to the company-only income statement, the company applies the exemption of article 2:402 BW.
If there is no further explanation provided to the items in the company-only statement of financial positions and the company-only income statement, please refer to the notes in the consolidated statement of financial position and statement of income.
The principles for the valuation of assets and liabilities and the determination of the result are the same as those applied to the consolidated statement of income.
Subsidiaries are accounted for at fair value in accordance with IAS 27. Management has estimated that the net asset value of its subsidiaries is a reliable indicator of the fair value.
Cash equivalents are considered as highly liquid investments, which include unrestricted short-term bank deposits with an original maturity of three months or less from the date of acquisition or with a maturity of more than three months, but which are redeemable on demand without penalty and which form part of the Group's cash management.
During the first quarter of 2020, the Company signed a trust agreement with subsidiaries held by the Company by indirect holding (hereinafter in this note: "the Subsidiaries"). Under said agreement, cash balances and cash equivalents in the subsidiaries in excess of € 50 thousand shall be held for the sole purpose of holding and managing cash balances in trust for the Company. The Company has the exclusive and unlimited ability to use the cash balances and cash equivalents held in the accounts in the names of the subsidiaries in trust for the Company at its discretion and considers these balances as cash balances that are used and available to the Company at any time.
For information regarding the Company's taxation environment, see Note 9a to the Company's consolidated financial statements.
Regarding material events with regards to the Company's loans and equity see Notes 5(g) and 11 to the consolidated financial statements.
As at 31 December 2023 the company has 1 direct 100% subsidiaries: GRT B.V. (The Netherlands)
Movements in the investment accounts in the period:
GRT BV, Amsterdam, The Netherlands (100% held by the Company)
| In €'000 | |
|---|---|
| Balance as of January 1, 2022 | 308,985 |
| Result for the period | 26,838 |
| Investment | 56,394 |
| Balance as of January 1, 2023 | 392,217 |
| Result for the period | (42,329) |
| Invetsments | 21,923 |
| Otehrs | 1 |
| Balance as of December 31, 2023 | 371,812 |
Argo Properties N.V. forms a fiscal unity with GRT B.V. and GRT Finco BV for the corporate income tax in the Netherlands.
| Total remuneration of the directors in 2023 |
|
|---|---|
| EUR in thousands | |
| Ron Tira | 52 |
| Nir Ilani | 54 |
| Bert van den Heuvel | 69 |
| Monique van Dijken Eeuwijk | 69 |
| Peter Bodis | 48 |
| Accruals | 73 |
| 365 |
| IUS Statutory Audits |
Other auditors Euros in thousands |
Total | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Audit and assurance services | 66 | 115 | 181 |
| Others | - | 10 | 10 |
| 66 | 125 | 191 |
The Company's offices are located in Amstelveen. The Company also has other offices throughout Germany from which the Property Management Company manages the properties.
The Group's employees and service providers as of December 31, 2023 and December 31, 2022 are as follows:
| Number of employees | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| As at December | As at December 31, | ||
| Employing company | Position in the employing company | 31, 2023 | 2022 |
| VP Business Development | 1 | 1 | |
| The Company | Bookkeeping and office manager | 2 | 3 |
| CFO | 1 | 1 | |
| Gama | Co-CEO | 2 | 2 |
| VP Strategy, Transactions, and Finance |
1 | 1 | |
| Director of Regulation | - | 1 | |
| COO | 1 | 1 | |
| The Property Management |
Accounting | 6 | 6 |
| Company | Head of Hanover operations | 1 | 1 |
| Property management/ marketing/ technical |
41 | 41 | |
| Total | 56 | 58 |
| Name | Position | Signature |
|---|---|---|
| Ron Tira | Chairman of the Board of | |
| Directors | ||
| Nir Ilani | Executive Director | |
| Bert van den Heuvel | External Director | |
| Monique van Dijken Eeuwijk | External Director | |
| Peter Bodis | Non External director |
The Articles of Association of the Company provide that the appropriation of the net result for the year is decided upon at the Annual General Meeting of Shareholders.

To: the shareholders and Board of Directors of Argo Properties N.V.
We have audited the financial statements 2023 of Argo Properties N.V. based in Amsterdam, the Netherlands.
In our opinion, the accompanying financial statements give a true and fair view of the financial position of Argo Properties N.V. ('the Company') as at 31 December 2023 and of its result and its cash flows for 2023 in accordance with International Financial Reporting Standards as adopted by the European Union (EU-IFRS) and with Part 9 of Book 2 of the Dutch Civil Code.
The financial statements comprise:
We conducted our audit in accordance with Dutch law, including the Dutch Standards on Auditing. Our responsibilities under those standards are further described in the 'Our responsibilities for the audit of the financial statements' section of our report.
We are independent of Argo Properties N.V. in accordance with the Wet toezicht accountantsorganisaties (Wta, Audit firms supervision act), the Verordening inzake de onafhankelijkheid van accountants bij assurance-opdrachten (ViO, Code of Ethics for Professional Accountants, a regulation with respect to independence) and other relevant independence regulations in the Netherlands. Furthermore we have complied with the Verordening gedrags- en beroepsregels accountants (VGBA, Dutch Code of Ethics).
We believe the audit evidence we have obtained is sufficient and appropriate to provide a basis for our opinion.
We designed our audit procedures in the context of our audit of the financial statements as a whole and in forming our opinion thereon. The following information in support of our opinion was addressed in this context, and we do not provide a separate opinion or conclusion on these matters.
Based on our professional judgement we determined the materiality for the financial statements as a whole at EUR 10.7 mln. The materiality is based on approximately 3.2% of total assets. We have also taken into account misstatements and/or possible misstatements that in our opinion are material for the users of the financial statements for qualitative reasons.
We agreed with the board of directors that misstatements in excess of EUR 530.000, which are identified during the audit, would be reported to them, as well as smaller misstatements that in our view must be reported on qualitative grounds.
Argo Properties N.V. is at the head of a group of entities. The financial information of this group is included in the consolidated financial statements of Argo Properties N.V.
Because we are ultimately responsible for the opinion, we are also responsible for directing, supervising and performing the group audit. In this respect we have determined the nature and extent of the audit procedures to be carried out for group entities. The group audit had a centralized audit approach on all group entities being that we consider all activities (regardless of the legal subsidiaries in which transactions are recorded) to be part of one component, which is the financial information presented in the consolidated financial statements (for the group as a whole). We have used the work of other auditors i.e. of a component audit team who performed the audit work for all group entities. We provided detailed written instructions to the component audit team, which, in addition to communicating our requirements of the component audit team, among others also included detailed significant audit areas, including awareness for significant risks and fraud risks. Furthermore, we performed procedures for overseeing the component audit team which included (virtual) meetings with the component audit team and working paper reviews as well as review of component audit team deliverables to gain a sufficient understanding of the work performed based on our instructions.
By adopting this approach and performing the procedures mentioned above, together with additional procedures at group level, we have been able to obtain sufficient and appropriate audit evidence about the group's financial information to provide an opinion on the consolidated financial statements.
Within the framework of our audit of the financial statements we were alert for the risk of fraud specifically relating to so called management override of internal controls including manual journal entries with the aim to manipulate the financial statements and relating to fraudulent revenue recognition.
We executed a mainly substantive audit approach which amongst others included evaluating design and implementation of internal controls that mitigate fraud risks, analytical procedures, reconciliation procedures, sampling, balance detail testing, visiting a sample of company's properties and examination of actual occupancy, data analysis and sampling of manual journal entries for unusual transactions and evaluating estimates for management bias. We performed inquiries with management in respect of fraud and compliance with laws and regulations and reviewed legal arrangements and material contracts.
For the audit of the figures, we cooperated with a component audit team in line with Dutch Standard 600. We were involved in their planning and completion procedures and reviewed their audit file. The component audit team had no findings in relation to the identified fraud risks.
Also management confirmed to us that they are not aware of any instances of actual or suspected fraud or noncompliance with laws and regulations including corruption.
Our audit procedures did not lead to specific indications of fraud or suspicions of fraud and/or noncompliance with laws and regulations that are material for our audit.
Management and the Board of Directors prepared the financial statements on a going concern basis. When preparing the financial statements management and the Board of Directors made a specific assessment of the company's ability to continue as a going concern and to continue its operations for the foreseeable future (i.e. at least twelve months from the date of the preparation of the financial statements).
Our procedures to evaluate the management and Board of Directors' going concern assessment included amongst others:
Based on our audit procedures performed we conclude that the management and Board of Directors' use of the going concern basis of accounting is appropriate.
Key audit matters are those matters that, in our professional judgement, were of most significance in our audit of the financial statements. We have communicated the key audit matters to the board of directors. The key audit matters are not a comprehensive reflection of all matters discussed.
We identified the following key audit matter(s):
As mentioned in notes 2B, 2H and 5, to the consolidated financial statements, as of 31 December 2023, the company has investment properties. As per the accounting policy described in note 2, investment property is measured at their fair values as of the balance sheet date with changes in fair value recognized in profit or loss. The fair value of all the investment property of the company (including investment property development rights) as of 31 December 2023, amounts to a total of EUR 679,526 thousand, and in 2023 the company recorded a decrease in fair value in the amount of EUR 56,823 thousand (of which a total of approx. EUR 11,471 thousand is due to a onetime effect update of purchase tax rates).
As mentioned in note 2B to the consolidated financial statements, the measurement of the fair value of investment property is a critical estimate, involving uncertainties and subjective assessments. The measurement and determination of fair value is based on valuations, which include assumptions, some of which are subjective considering the circumstances and the best information as of 31 December 2023, and which were conducted with the assistance of external real estate appraisers. These assumptions mainly include the rate of return, the projected net operating income (NOI) of the assets and market prices for relevant comparison units. These basic assumptions, as well as the determination of the fair value estimate as a whole of the company's investment property, including the selection of an appropriate valuation approach, are the result of subjective conclusions in an environment of uncertainty, sometimes particularly significant. Changes in the aforementioned basic assumptions may result in changes in the fair value of the investment property, sometimes substantially, and therefore also affect the company's financial position as of 31 December 2023 and the results of its operations for that year, as detailed in Note 5.
Due to the above, and in particular that the fair value of investment property is a critical estimate, involving uncertainties and is based on valuations, which include assumptions, some of which are subjective, we determined, according to our professional judgment, that the examination of the fair value of investment property, with an emphasis on the reasonableness of the rates of return used in its estimation, is a key matter in the audit.
The following are the main procedures we performed to address this key matter in our audit, with an emphasis on examining the reasonableness of the rates of return used in the valuations of the assets:
The financial statements 2022 and 2021 have not been audited. Consequently, the corresponding figures included in the consolidated and company-only statements of profit or loss and other comprehensive income, changes in equity and cash flows and in the related notes are unaudited.
The annual report contains other information, in addition to the financial statements and our auditor's report thereon.
The other information consists of:
Based on the following procedures performed, we conclude that the other information:
We have read the other information. Based on our knowledge and understanding obtained through our audit of the financial statements or otherwise, we have considered whether the other information contains material misstatements.
By performing these procedures, we comply with the requirements of Part 9 of Book 2 of the Dutch Civil Code and the Dutch Standard 720. The scope of the procedures performed is substantially less than the scope of those performed in our audit of the financial statements.
Management is responsible for the preparation of the Board of Directors' report in accordance with Part 9 of Book 2 of the Dutch Civil Code and other information as required by Part 9 of Book 2 of the Dutch Civil Code.
We were engaged by the board of directors as auditor of Argo Properties N.V. on 14 September 2023, as of the audit for the year 2023 and have operated as statutory auditor since that financial year.
Management is responsible for the preparation and fair presentation of the financial statements in accordance with EU-IFRS and with Part 9 of Book 2 of the Dutch Civil Code. Furthermore, management is responsible for such internal control as management determines is necessary to enable the preparation of the financial statements that are free from material misstatement, whether due to fraud or error.
As part of the preparation of the financial statements, management is responsible for assessing the company's ability to continue as a going concern. Based on the financial reporting frameworks mentioned, management should prepare the financial statements using the going concern basis of accounting, unless management either intends to liquidate the company or to cease operations, or has no realistic alternative but to do so. Management should disclose events and circumstances that may cast significant doubt on the company's ability to continue as a going concern in the financial statements.
The Board of Directors is responsible for overseeing the company's financial reporting process.
Our objective is to plan and perform the audit engagement in a manner that allows us to obtain sufficient and appropriate audit evidence for our opinion.
Our audit has been performed with a high, but not absolute, level of assurance, which means we may not detect all material errors and fraud during our audit.
Misstatements can arise from fraud or error and are considered material if, individually or in the aggregate, they could reasonably be expected to influence the economic decisions of users taken on the basis of these financial statements. The materiality affects the nature, timing and extent of our audit procedures and the evaluation of the effect of identified misstatements on our opinion.
We have exercised professional judgement and have maintained professional scepticism throughout the audit, in accordance with Dutch Standards on Auditing, ethical requirements and independence requirements. Our audit included among others:
We communicate with the Board of Directors regarding, among other matters, the planned scope and timing of the audit and significant audit findings, including any significant findings in internal control that we identify during our audit.
We provide the Board of Directors with a statement that we have complied with relevant ethical requirements regarding independence, and to communicate with them all relationships and other matters that may reasonably be thought to bear on our independence, and where applicable, related safeguards.
From the matters communicated with the Board of Directors, we determine the key audit matters: those matters that were of most significance in the audit of the financial statements. We describe these matters in our auditor's report unless law or regulation precludes public disclosure about the matter or when, in extremely rare circumstances, not communicating the matter is in the public interest.
Amstelveen, 21 November 2024
Original signed by J.C. Schächter RA
Ref: IUS-ARGO-JS-WC-JR23-21/11/2024


Argo Properties N.V. (the 'Company') has a one-tier board. Management is executed by the executive director and delegated to the managing directors. Supervision is executed by the non-executive directors. The Dutch Corporate Governance Code (the "Code") provides that the company must explicitly state in a separate chapter of the management report or a publication on the company's website the extent to which the company complies with the principles and best practice provisions of the Code and, where it does not comply, why and to what extent it deviates from these. The Code recognizes that a one-size fits all approach does not work for a company's governance structure by definition and deviations can be justified. The Code departs from the main concept that the company has a management board and a supervisory board. It, however, also acknowledges the concept of a one-tier board. Responsibilities attributed in the Code to the chairperson of the supervisory board in a two-tier structure, are attributed to the chair of the board in a one-tier structure. The comply-or-explain principle stresses that the boards are responsible for the company's governance structure and compliance with the Code and must provide a clear explanation of a deviation. The Code clarifies what companies should at least include in such explanation.
The explanation of any deviations must in any event include the following elements:

of the company.
Comply-or-explain manual
The below overview serves as a manual for the company to assess the compliance with the principles and best practices of the Code. In the second column, for each principle and best practice the "comply", "deviate" or "N/A" (not applicable) box can be ticked. An explanation can be included in the third column, which for a deviation should in any event cover the elements outlined under (i) through (iv) above.
Only the explanation in respect of deviations from the Code's principles and best practices needs to be included in a separate chapter of the management report or a publication on the company's website; the explanation about principles and best practices the company has complied with, or which are not applicable can be used for internal purposes. Nevertheless, a company may want to elaborate on its compliance with the Code in the management report in more general terms or make public a full overview of compliance and non-compliance with the Code, extending to all principles and best practices.

| Ref 1 |
Principle or best practice LONG-TERM VALUE CREATION |
Comply, deviate or non-applicable |
Explanation of compliance, deviation or non- applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1.1 | Long-term value creation (principle) The management board is responsible for the continuity of the company and its affiliated enterprise and for sustainable long-term value creation by the company and its affiliated enterprise. The management board considers the impact the actions of the company and its affiliated enterprise have on people and the environment and to that end weighs the stakeholder interests that are relevant in this context. The supervisory board monitors the management board in this. |
✓ Comply |
Board Regulations: General, article v; Tasks of Executive Director, Article 3), 5), 8) Since the Company has a one-tier Board, the Non Executive Board Members are already involved in these subjects. The Company does not require specific approval from the Non-Executive Board Members. |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or non-applicable |
Explanation of compliance, deviation or non- applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1.1.1 | Long-term value creation strategy (best practice) The management board should develop a view on sustainable long-term value creation by the company and its affiliated enterprise and formulate a strategy in line with this. The management board should formulate specific objectives in this regard. Depending on market dynamics, it may be necessary to make short-term adjustments to the strategy. When developing the strategy, attention should in any event be paid to the following: the strategy's implementation and feasibility. i. the business model applied by the company and the ii. market in which the company and its affiliated enterprise operate. opportunities and risks for the company. iii. the company's operational and financial goals and their iv. impact on its future position in relevant markets. the interests of the stakeholders; v. the impact of the company and its affiliated enterprise vi. in the field of sustainability, including the effects on people and the environment; paying a fair share of tax to the countries in which the vii. company operates; and |
✓ Comply |
Board Regulations: General, article v; Tasks of Executive Director, Article 3), 5), 8) |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or non-applicable |
Explanation of compliance, deviation or non- applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| the impact of new technologies and changing business viii. models. |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or non-applicable |
Explanation of compliance, deviation or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1.1.2 | Involvement of the supervisory board (best practice) The management board should engage the supervisory board early on in formulating the strategy for realizing sustainable long term value creation. The management board account to the supervisory board for the strategy and the explanatory notes to that strategy. |
✓ Comply |
Board Regulations: General, article v; Tasks of Executive Director, Article 3), 5), 8) Since the Company has a one-tier Board, the Non Executive Board Members are already involved in these subjects. The Company does not require specific approval from the Non-Executive Board Members. |
| 1.1.3 | Role of the supervisory board (best practice) The supervisory board should supervise the manner in which the management board implements the s t r a t e g y f o r s u s t a i n a b l e long-term value creation strategy. The supervisory board should regularly discuss the strategy, the implementation of the strategy and the principal risks associated with it. In the report drawn up by the supervisory board, an account is given of its involvement in the establishment of the strategy, and the way in which it monitors its implementation. |
✓ Comply |
Board Regulations: General, article v; Tasks of Executive Director, Article 3), 5), 8) Since the Company has a one-tier Board, the Non Executive Board Members are already involved in these subjects. The Company does not require specific approval from the Non-Executive Board Members. |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or non-applicable |
Explanation of compliance, deviation or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1.1.4 | Accountability of the management board (best practice) In the management report, the management board should provide a more detailed explanation of its view on sustainable long-term value creation and the strategy to realize this and describe the contributions made to sustainable long-term value creation in the past financial year. In addition, it describes the formulated objectives, what effects the company's products, services and activities have had on people and the environment, how the interests of stakeholders have been considered, what action has been taken in that context and the extent to which the set objectives have been attained. The management board should report on both the short-term and long-term developments. The second sentence of this best practice provision is not applicable if the company reports in accordance with the requirements laid down in Dutch legislation pursuant to the Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive1 (CSRD) or comparable standards applicable to the company in respect of its listing outside the Netherland |
✓ Comply |
This topic is covered in the annual report. |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or non-applicable |
Explanation of compliance, deviation or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1.1.5 | Dialogue with stakeholder To ensure that the interests of the relevant stakeholders of the company are considered when the sustainability aspects of the strategy are determined; the company should draw up an outline policy for effective dialogue with those stakeholders. The relevant stakeholders and the company should be prepared to engage in a dialogue. The company should facilitate this dialogue unless, in the opinion of the management board, this is not in the interests of the company and its affiliated enterprise. The company should publish the policy on its website |
✓ | |
| 1.2 | Risk management (principle) The company should have adequate internal risk management and control systems in place. The management board is responsible for identifying and managing the risks associated with the company's strategy and activities. |
✓ Comply |
Board Regulations: Tasks of Non-Executive Directors and Executive Directors article 7), Tasks of the Executive Director: Article 5), 7) AC Charter: Article 4. -ll chapter Article 5– d Article 10 - e, f, i Article 11– c, i, p, |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or non-applicable |
Explanation of compliance, deviation or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| Article 12 – c, d, g Article 14 |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or non-applicable |
Explanation of compliance, deviation or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1.2.1 | Risk assessment (best practice) The management board should identify and analyze the risks associated with the strategy and activities of the company and its affiliated enterprise. The identification and analysis should cover in any case the strategic, operational, compliance and reporting risks. The management board responsible for establishing the risk appetite, and also the measures that are put in place in order to counter the risks being taken. |
✓ Comply |
AC Charter: Article 4. -ll chapter Article 5– d Article 10 - e, f, i Article 11– c, i, p, Article 12 – c, d, g Article 14 |
| 1.2.2 | Implementation (best practice) Based on the risk assessment, as referred to in best practice provision 1.2.1, the management board should design, implement and maintain adequate internal risk management and control systems. To the extent relevant, these systems should be integrated into the work processes within the company and its affiliated enterprise, and should be familiar to those whose work to which they are relevant. |
✓ Comply |
AC Charter: Article 4. -ll chapter |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or non-applicable |
Explanation of compliance, deviation or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1.2.3 | Monitoring of effectiveness (best practice) The management board should monitor the design and operation of the internal risk management and control systems and should carry out a systematic assessment of their design and operation at least once a year. Attention should be paid to observed weaknesses, instances of misconduct and irregularities, indications from whistleblowers, lessons learned and findings from the internal audit function and the external Auditor Where necessary, improvements should be made to internal risk management and control systems. |
✓ Comply |
AC Charter: Article 14– |
| 1.3 | Internal audit function (principle) The task of the internal audit function is to assess the design and the operation of the internal risk management and control systems. The management board is responsible for the internal audit function. The supervisory board oversees the internal audit function and maintains regular contact with the person fulfilling this function. |
✓ Comply |
AoA Art. 22.1 Board Regulations: Art. 13,14 (p.19) – i) AC Charter: Article 10 - e, f, i |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or non-applicable |
Explanation of compliance, deviation or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1.3.1 | Appointment and dismissal (best practice) The management board both appoints and dismisses the senior internal auditor. Both the appointment and the dismissal of the senior internal auditor should be submitted to the supervisory board for approval, along with the recommendation of the audit committee. |
✓ Comply |
AC Charter: Article 4. -ll chapter Article 5– d Article 10 - e, f, i Article 11– c, i, p, * "Since the Company has a one-tier Board, the Non Executive Board Members are already involved in these subjects. The Company does not require specific approval from the Non-Executive Board Members." |
| 1.3.2 | Assessment of the internal audit function (best practice) The management board should assess annually the way in which the internal audit function fulfils its responsibility, after consultation with the audit committee. An independent third party should assess the performance of the internal audit function at least every five years. |
✓ Comply |
AoA article 21.5(e ) AC Charter: Article 4. -ll chapter Article 5– d Article 10 - e, f, i Article 11– c, i, p, |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or non-applicable |
Explanation of compliance, deviation or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1.3.3 | Internal audit plan (best practice) The internal audit function should draw up an audit plan for consultation with the management board, the audit committee and the external auditor. The audit plan should be submitted to the management board and then to the supervisory board for approval. In the internal audit plan, attention should be paid to interaction with the external auditor. |
✓ Comply |
AoA articles 22.4 and 21.5(d) AC Charter: Article 4. -ll chapter Article 5– d Article 10 - e, f, i Article 11– c, i, p, Article 12 – c, d, g Article 14 * "Since the Company has a one-tier Board, the Non-Executive Board Members are already involved in these subjects. The Company does not require specific approval from the Non-Executive Board Members |
| 1.3.4 | Performance of work (best practice) The internal audit function should have sufficient resources to execute the internal audit plan and have access to information that is important for the performance of its work. The internal audit function should have direct access to the audit committee and the external auditor. Records should be kept of how the audit committee is informed by the internal audit function. |
✓ Comply |
AoA articles 22.2(e), 22.2(f), 22.2(g) and 21.5(e) AC Charter: Article 4. -ll chapter Article 5– d Article 10 - e, f, i Article 11– c, i, p, Article 12 – c, d, g Article 14 |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or non-applicable |
Explanation of compliance, deviation or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1.3.5 | Reports of findings (best practice) |
✓ Comply |
AoA article 22.7 |
| The internal audit function should report its audit results to |
|||
| the management board and the audit committee, |
AC Charter: |
||
| Article 4. -ll chapter | |||
| Article 5– d |
|||
| Article 10 - e, f, i |
|||
| Article 11– c, i, p, |
|||
| Article 12 – c, d, g |
|||
| Article 14 |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or non-applicable |
Explanation of compliance, deviation or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| and inform the external auditor. The findings of the internal audit function should, at least, include the following: any flaws in the effectiveness of the internal risk i. management and control systems. any findings and observations with a material impact on ii. the risk profile of the company and its affiliated enterprise; and any failings in the follow-up of recommendations made iii. by the internal audit function. The internal audit function should report hierarchically to a member of the management board, preferably to the CEO. |
|||
| 1.3.6 | Absence of an internal audit department (best practice) If there is no separate department for the internal audit function, the supervisory board will assess annually whether adequate alternative measures have been taken, partly on the basis of a recommendation issued by the audit committee and will consider whether it is necessary to establish an internal audit department. The supervisory board should include the conclusions, along with any resulting recommendations and |
✓ Comply |
Board Regulations: Art. 13,14 (p.19) – i) AC Charter: Article 10 - e, f, i |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or non-applicable |
Explanation of compliance, deviation or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| alternative measures, in the report of the supervisory board. |
|||
| 1.4 | Risk management accountability (principle) The management board should render account of the effectiveness of the design and the operation of the internal risk management and control systems. |
✓ Comply |
Board Regulations |
| 1.4.1 | Accountability to the supervisory board (best practice) The management board should discuss the effectiveness of the design and operation of the internal risk management and control systems referred to in best practice provisions 1.2.1 to 1.2.3 inclusive with the audit committee, and render account of this to the supervisory board. |
✓ Comply |
See paragraph 1.2(c) of Schedule 6 of the Board Regulations. |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or non-applicable |
Explanation of compliance, deviation or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1.4.2 | Accountability in the management report (best practice) |
✓ Comply |
This is covered in the annual report. |
| In the management report, the management board should render account of: the execution of the risk assessment, with a description of i. |
|||
| the principal risks facing the company in relation to its risk appetite, as referred to in best practice provision 1.2.1.; |
|||
| the design and operation of the internal risk management ii. and control systems during the past financial year; |
|||
| any major failings in the internal risk management and iii. control systems which have been observed in the financial year, any significant changes made to these systems and any major improvements planned, along with a confirmation that these issues have been discussed with the audit committee and the supervisory board; and |
|||
| the sensitivity of the results of the company to material iv. |
|||
| changes | |||
| in external factors. |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or non-applicable |
Explanation of compliance, deviation or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1.4.3 | Statement by the management board (best practice) |
✓ Comply |
|
| The management board should state in the management report, with clear substantiation, that: the report provides sufficient insights into any failings in i. the effectiveness of the internal risk management and control systems with regard to the risks as referred to in best practice provision 1.2.1; the aforementioned systems provide reasonable ii. assurance that the financial reporting does not contain any material inaccuracies; |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or |
Explanation of compliance, deviation or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| non-applicable | |||
| based on the current state of affairs, it is justified that the iii. |
|||
| financial reporting is prepared on a going concern basis; | |||
| and | |||
| the report states those material risks, as referred to in iv. |
|||
| best practice provision 1.2.1, and t he uncertainties, to the |
|||
| extent that t h ey are |
|||
| relevant to the expectation of the company's continuity |
|||
| for the period of twelve months after the preparation of |
|||
| the report. | |||
| 1.5 | Role of the supervisory board (principle) |
✓ Comply |
st Board Regulations – 1 Chapter – General |
| The supervisory board should supervise the policies carried out | |||
| by the management board and the general affairs of the | |||
| company and its affiliated enterprise. In so doing, the supervisory |
|||
| board should also focus on the effectiveness of the company's |
|||
| internal risk management and |
|||
| control systems and the integrity and quality of the financial |
|||
| sustainability reporting. |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or non-applicable |
Explanation of compliance, deviation or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1.5.1 | Duties and responsibilities of the AC (best practice) The audit |
✓ Comply |
Article 21.5 of the AOA |
| committee undertakes preparatory work for the supervisory |
|||
| board's decision-making regarding the supervision of the |
|||
| integrity and quality of the company's financial and sustainability |
AC Charter – full Procedure, Tasks and |
||
| reporting and the effectiveness of the company's internal risk |
Responsibilities Chapter | ||
| management and control systems, as referred to in best practice |
|||
| provisions 1.2.1 to 1.2.3 inclusive. It focuses among other things |
|||
| on the supervision of the management board with regard to: | |||
| relations with, and compliance with recommendations i. |
|||
| and follow up of comments by, the internal and external | |||
| auditors and any other external party involved in auditing |
|||
| the sustainability reporting. | |||
| the funding of the company. ii. |
|||
| the company's tax policy. iii. |
|||
| 1.5.2 | Attendance of the management board, internal auditor and | ✓ Comply |
Article 21.3, 21.4 and 21.9 of the AOA |
| external auditor at AC consultations (best practice) |
|||
| The chief financial officer, the internal auditor and the external |
Board Regulations: meeting of the Board (p.22) | ||
| auditor should attend the audit committee meetings, unless the |
and AC Charter Chapter 6 art. Committee's |
||
| audit committee | meetings | ||
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or non-applicable |
Explanation of compliance, deviation or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| determines otherwise. The audit committee should decide whether and, if so, when the chairperson of the management board should attend its meetings. |
|||
| 1.5.3 | Audit committee report (best practice) The AC should report to the supervisory board on its deliberations and findings. This report must, at least, include the following information: the methods used to assess the effectiveness of the i. design and operation of the internal risk management and control systems referred to in best practice provisions 1.2.1 to 1.2.3, inclusive; the methods used to assess the effectiveness of the ii. internal and external audit processes; material considerations concerning financial and iii. sustainability reporting; and the way in which the material risks and uncertainties, iv. referred to in best practice provision 1.4.2 and 1.4.3, have been analyzed and discussed, along with a description of the most important findings of the audit committee. |
✓ Comply |
AC Charter Chapter 8 - Reporting to the Board |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or non-applicable |
Explanation of compliance, deviation or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1.5.4 | Supervisory board (best practice) The supervisory board should discuss the items reported on by the audit committee as per of best practice provision 1.5.3. |
✓ Comply |
Board minutes, Board Regulations P. 27 – AC Reports to the Board |
| 1.6 | Appointment and assessment of the functioning of the external auditor (principle) The supervisory board should submit the nomination for the appointment of the external auditor to the general meeting and should supervise the external auditor's functioning. |
✓ Comply |
Articles 1.1(b), 18.6 and 23.1(g) of the AOA Board Regulations Tasks of the Non-Executive Directors p. 9 art. 12, 13 and AC Charter |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or non-applicable |
Explanation of compliance, deviation or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1.6.1 | Functioning and appointment (best practice) The AC should report annually to the supervisory board on the functioning of, and the developments in, the relationship with the external auditor. The AC should advise the supervisory board regarding the external auditor's nomination for appointment/reappointment or dismissal and should prepare the selection of the external auditor. The AC should g i v e d u e c o n s i d e r a t i o n t o t h e m a n a g e m e n t b o a r d ' s o b s e r v a t i o n s d u r i n g the aforementioned work. Also on this basis, the supervisory board should determine its nomination for the appointment of the external auditor to the general meeting. |
✓ Comply |
Board Regulations Tasks of the Non-Executive Directors p. 9 art. 12-13, p. 19 art.e, i , |
| 1.6.2 | Informing the external auditor about their functioning (best practice) The supervisory board should give the external auditor a general idea of the content of the reports relating to their functioning. |
✓ Comply |
Board Regulations P. 27 – AC Reports to the Board |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or non-applicable |
Explanation of compliance, deviation or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1.6.3 | Engagement (best practice) |
✓ Comply |
Article 21.5(f) of the AOA |
| The AC should submit a proposal to the supervisory board for the external auditor's engagement to audit the annual accounts . The management board should play a facilitating role in this process. In formulating the terms of engagement, attention should be paid to the scope of the audit, the materiality to be applied and remuneration for the audit. The supervisory board should resolve on the engagement. |
AC Charter , chapter 11 |
||
| 1.6.4 | Accountability (best practice) |
✓ Comply |
Board Regulations , The powers and duties of the |
| The main conclusions of the supervisory board regarding the external auditor's nomination and the outcomes of the external |
Board of Directors areas, p. 7 | ||
| auditor selection process should be communicated to the general meeting. |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or |
Explanation of compliance, deviation or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| non-applicable | |||
| 1.6.5 | Departure of the external auditor (best practice) |
✓ Comply |
|
| The company should publish a press release in the event of the early termination of the relationship with the external audit firm. The press release should explain the reasons for this early termination. |
|||
| 1.7 | Performance of the external auditor's work (principle) |
✓ Comply |
AC Charter , chapter 11 |
| The AC and the external auditor should discuss the audit plan, and the findings of the external auditor based on the work the external auditor has undertaken. The management board and the supervisory board should maintain regular contact with the external auditor. |
|||
| 1.7.1 | Provision of information to the external auditor (best practice) |
✓ Comply |
Board Regulations p. 19 , e), i) |
| The management board should ensure that the external auditor will receive all information that is necessary for the performance of his work in a timely fashion. The management board should give the external auditor the opportunity to respond to the information that has been provided. |
| ✓ 1.7.2 Audit plan and external auditor's findings (best practice) Comply Board Regulations p. 9 art. 13 AC charter chapter 10 Internal auditor The external auditor should discuss the draft audit plan with the management board before presenting it to the AC. The AC should discuss annually with the external auditor: the scope and materiality of the audit plan and the i. |
Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or non-applicable |
Explanation of compliance, deviation or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| external auditor in the audit plan; and based also on the documents from which the audit plan ii. was developed, the findings and outcomes of the audit work on the annual accounts and the management letter. |
principal risks of the annual reporting identified by the |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or non-applicable |
Explanation of compliance, deviation or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1.7.3 | Publication of financial reports (best practice) |
✓ Comply |
AC charter p 12 Communication, functioning and |
| The AC should determine whether and, if so, how the external |
reporting | ||
| auditor should be involved in the content and publication of | |||
| financial reports other than the annual accounts | ✓ | ||
| 1.7.4 | Consultations with the external auditor outside the management board's presence (best practice) |
Comply | AC charter p 12 Communication, functioning and reporting |
| The AC should meet with the external auditor as often as it |
|||
| considers necessary, but at least once per year, without the |
|||
| presence of | |||
| the management board. |
|||
| 1.7.5 | Examination of discussion points arising between the external | ✓ Comply |
AC charter p 12 Communication, functioning and |
| auditor and the management board (best practice) | reporting | ||
| The supervisory board should be permitted to examine the most | |||
| important points of discussion arising between the external | |||
| auditor and the management board based on the draft |
|||
| management letter or the draft |
|||
| audit report. |
|||
| 1.7.6 | External auditor's attendance of supervisory board meetings (best | ✓ Comply |
Article 21.4 of the AOA |
| practice) | |||
| The external auditor should in any event attend the meeting |
AC charter p 12 Communication, functioning and | ||
| of the |
reporting |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or non-applicable |
Explanation of compliance, deviation or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| supervisory board at which the report of the external auditor on the audit of the annual accounts is discussed. |
|||
| 2 | EFFECTIVE MANAGEMENT AND SUPERVISION |
||
| 2.1 | Composition and size (principle) The management board, the supervisory board and the executive committee (if any) should be composed in such a way as to ensure a degree of diversity appropriate to the company with regard to expertise, experience, competencies, other personal qualities, sex or gender identify, age nationality and cultural or other background. |
✓ Comply |
Board Regulations |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or non-applicable |
Explanation of compliance, deviation or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2.1.1 | Profile (best practice) The supervisory board should prepare a profile, taking account of the nature and the activities of the enterprise affiliated with the company. The profile should address: |
N/A | It is addressed in the Board regulations, p. 9 art. 16, p. 20 "Board Profile". The Board members are appointed in accordance with the AoA, Art. 12, regarding, among other |
| the desired expertise and background of the supervisory i. board members; the desired diverse composition of the supervisory ii. board, referred to in best practice provision 2.1.5; the size of the supervisory board; and iii. the independence of the supervisory board members. iv. The profile should be posted on the company's website. |
things, independence and qualifications. |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or |
Explanation of compliance, deviation or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| non-applicable | |||
| 2.1.2 | Personal information (best practice) |
✓ Comply |
This information is covered in the annual report. |
| The following information about each supervisory board member should be included in the report of the supervisory board: |
|||
| gender; i. |
|||
| age; ii. |
|||
| nationality; iii. |
|||
| principal position (if appropriate); iv. |
|||
| other positions, insofar as they are relevant to the v. performance of the duties of the supervisory board member; |
|||
| date of initial appointment; and vi. |
|||
| current term of office. vii. |
|||
| 2.1.3 | Executive committee (best practice) |
N/A | There is no executive committee. |
| If the management board works with an executive committee, the management board should take account of the checks and balances that |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or non-applicable |
Explanation of compliance, deviation or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| are part of the two-tier system. This means, among other things, that the management board's expertise and responsibilities are safeguarded, and the supervisory board is informed adequately. The supervisory board should supervise this whilst paying specific attention to the dynamics and the relationship between the management board and the executive committee. In the management report, account should be rendered of: the choice to work with an executive committee; i. the role, duty and composition of the executive ii. committee; and how the contacts between the supervisory board and the iii. executive committee have been given shape. |
|||
| 2.1.4 | Expertise (best practice) Each supervisory board member and each management board member should have the specific expertise required for the fulfilment of his duties. Each supervisory board member should be capable of assessing the broad outline of the overall management. |
✓ Comply |
Board members appointment statements and documentation reflect compliance |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or non-applicable |
Explanation of compliance, deviation or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2.1.5 | Policy on diversity and Inclusion (D&I policy) The company should have a D&I policy for the enterprise. The D&I policy should in any case set specific appropriate and ambitious targets in order to achieve a good balance in gender diversity and the other D&I aspects of relevance to the company with regard to the composition of the management board, the supervisory board, the executive committee (if any) and a category of employees in managerial positions ("senior management") to be determined by the management board. The supervisory board adopt the D&I policy for the composition of the management board and the supervisory board. The management board should adopt the D&I policy for the executive committee (if applicable), the senior management and for the rest of the workforce with the prior approval of the supervisory board. background. [?] |
N/A | Implementing a diversity policy in the income – producing real estate industry may face significant challenges due to the industry's specific hiring requirements. In fields such as construction and engineering, there is a strong demand for specialized expertise and experience which cannot be compromised. These requirements often include professional qualifications, extensive industry experience, and adherence to legal standards. As a result, the pool of eligible candidates is limited to those who meet these stringent criteria, which can restrict the ability to implement a diversity policy effectively. In other words, the need for highly specialized skills and qualifications can overshadow efforts to promote diversity, making it difficult to balance industry specific demands with broader diversity goals. |
| 2.1.6 | Accountability about diversity (best practice) The corporate governance statement should explain the D&I policy and the way in which it is implemented in practice. This includes the following information: i. the goals of the D&I policy; |
Deviate | As mentioned in Art. 2.1.5, the company is committed to diversity and inclusion, which are integral values in its culture. However, the professional requirements in construction and engineering pose challenges to effectively implementing a diversity policy. It is imperative to |
| Ref | Principle | or best practice |
Comply, deviate or non-applicable |
Explanation of compliance, deviation or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| ii. iii. iv. |
the plan to achieve the goals of the D&I policy; the results of the D&I policy in the past financial year and – where relevant and applicable – insight into the info, progression and retention of employees; and the gender composition of the management board, the supervisory board, the executive committee (if any) and senior management at the end of the past financial year. If one or more goals for the composition of the management board, the supervisory board, the executive committee (if any) and/or senior management are not achieved, an explanation of the reasons should be included in the corporate governance statement, along with an explanation as to which measures are being taken to attain the goals, and by when this is likely to be achieved. |
hire employees with specialized expertise and experience and as a result it can limit the pool of candidates and make it difficult to meet diversity goals. In other words, the imperative need for highly specialized skills and qualifications can sometimes overshadow efforts to promote diversity. Despite these challenges, the company remains dedicated to achieving a diverse and inclusive workforce within these constraints. |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or non-applicable |
Explanation of compliance, deviation or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or non-applicable |
Explanation of compliance, deviation or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2.1.7 | Independence of the supervisory board (best practice) The composition of the supervisory board is such that the members are able to operate independently and critically vis-à vis one another, the management board, and any particular interests involved. In order to safeguard its independence, the supervisory board is composed in accordance with the following criteria: any one of the criteria referred to in best practice i. provision 2.1.8, sections i. to v. inclusive should be applicable to at most one supervisory board member; the total number of supervisory board members to whom ii. the criteria referred to in best practice provision 2.1.8 are applicable should account for less than half of the total number of supervisory board members; and for each shareholder, or group of affiliated shareholders iii. directly or indirectly hold more than ten percent of the shares in the company, there is at most one supervisory board member who can be considered to be affiliated with or representing them as stipulated in best practice provision 2.1.8, sections vi. and vii. |
✓ Comply |
Board Regulations p. 20, The Chairperson, Board Profile. |
| non-applicable | |
|---|---|
| ✓ 2.1.8 Independence of supervisory board members (best practice) Comply Article 12.2 of the AOA |
|
| supervisory board members are not independent if they or their Board Regulations p. 20, The Chairperson, Board spouse, registered partner or life companion, foster child or Profile. relative by blood or marriage up to the second degree: has been an employee or member of the management i. board of the company as referred to in Section 5:48 of the Financial Supervision Act (Wet op het financial toezicht, Wf) in the five years prior to the appointment;; receives personal financial compensation from the ii. company, or an entity associated with it, other than the compensation received for the work performed as a supervisory board member and insofar as this is not in keeping with the normal course of business; has had an important business relationship with the iii. company or an entity associated with it in the year prior to the appointment. This includes in any event the case where the supervisory board member, or the firm of which he is a shareholder, partner, associate or adviser, has acted as adviser to the company (consultant, external auditor, civil notary or lawyer) and the case where the supervisory board member has been a management |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or non-applicable |
Explanation of compliance, deviation or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| board member or an employee of a bank with which the company has a lasting and significant relationship; is a member of the management board of a company in iv. which a member of the management board of the company which he supervises is a supervisory board member; |
| Ref | Principle | or best practice |
Comply, deviate or |
Explanation of compliance, deviation or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| non-applicable | ||||
| v. | has temporarily performed management duties during | |||
| the previous twelve months in the absence or incapacity |
||||
| of management board members; | ||||
| vi. | has a shareholding in the company of at least ten percent, | |||
| considering the shareholding of natural persons or legal |
||||
| entities collaborating with him on the basis of an express | ||||
| or tacit, verbal or written agreement; | ||||
| vii. | is a member of the management board or supervisory | |||
| board – or is a representative in some other way – of a |
||||
| legal entity which directly or indirectly holds at least ten |
||||
| percent of the shares in the company, unless |
||||
| the entity is a group company. |
||||
| 2.1.9 | Independence | of the chairman of the supervisory board |
✓ Comply |
Article 12.2 of the AOA |
| (best practice) | ||||
| The chairman of the supervisory board should not be a former | Board Regulations p. 20, The Chairperson, Board | |||
| member of the management board of the company and should be |
Profile. | |||
| independent | within | |||
| the meaning |
of best practice provision 2.1.8. |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or non-applicable |
Explanation of compliance, deviation or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2.1.10 | Accountability regarding supervisory board member independence (best practice) The report of the supervisory board should state that, in the opinion of the supervisory board, the independence requirements referred to in best practice provisions 2.1.7 to 2.1.9 inclusive have been fulfilled and, if applicable, should also state which supervisory board member(s), if any, it does not consider to be independent. |
✓ Comply |
Article 12.2 of the AOA As required from a one-tier Board, Board Regulations p. 20, The Chairperson, Board Profile. |
| 2.2 | Appointment, succession and evaluation (principle) The supervisory board should ensure that a formal and transparent procedure is in place for the appointment and reappointment of management board and supervisory board members, in accordance with the D&I policy. The functioning of the management board and the supervisory board as a collective and the functioning of individual members should be evaluated on a regular basis |
✓ Comply |
The Board has approved a Remuneration, Selection & Nomination Committee (RSNC) Charter, chapter 2.2 (Chapter B) reflects the compliance with this requirement |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or non-applicable |
Explanation of compliance, deviation or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2.2.1 | Appointment and reappointment periods – management board members (best practice) A management board member is appointed for a maximum period of four years. A member may be reappointed for a term of not more than four years at a time, which reappointment should be prepared in a timely fashion. The diversity objectives from best practice provision 2.1.5 should be considered in the preparation of the appointment or reappointment. |
N/A | Articles 12 and 13.1 of the AoA address the appointment of ARGO's directors. |
| 2.2.2 | Appointment and reappointment periods – supervisory board members (best practice) A supervisory board member is appointed for a period of four years and may then be reappointed once for another four-year period. The supervisory board member may then be reappointed again for a period of two years, which appointment may be extended by at most two years. In the event of a reappointment after an eight-year period, reasons should be given in the report of the supervisory board. At any appointment or reappointment, |
N/A | Articles 12 and 13.1 of the AoA address the appointment of ARGO's directors |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or non-applicable |
Explanation of compliance, deviation or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| the profile referred to in best practice provision 2.1.1 should be observed. |
|||
| 2.2.3 | Early retirement (best practice) A member of the supervisory board or the management board should retire early in the event of inadequate performance, structural incompatibility of interests, and in other instances in which this is deemed necessary by the supervisory board. In the event of the early retirement of a member of the management board or the supervisory board, the |
✓ Comply |
Articles 13.10 and/or 13.11 as applicable Board Regulations p. 20 – retirement schedule |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or |
Explanation of compliance, deviation or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| non-applicable | |||
| company should issue a press release mentioning the reasons |
|||
| for the departure. |
|||
| 2.2.4 | Succession (best practice) |
✓ N/A |
Retirement, appointment and succession are all |
| The supervisory board should ensure that the company has a | addressed by article 12 of the AoA |
||
| sound plan in place for the succession of management board and | |||
| supervisory board members that is aimed at retaining the | |||
| balance in the requisite expertise, experience and diversity. Due | |||
| regard should be given to the profile referred to in best practice |
|||
| provision 2.1.1 in drawing up the plan for supervisory board | |||
| members. The supervisory board should also draw up a |
|||
| retirement schedule in order to avoid, as much as possible, | |||
| supervisory board members retiring simultaneously. The |
|||
| retirement schedule should |
|||
| be published on the company's website. |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or |
Explanation of compliance, deviation or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| non-applicable | |||
| 2.2.5 | Duties of the selection and appointment committee (best | ✓ Comply |
Remuneration, Selection & Nomination |
| practice) The selection and appointment committee should | Committee (RSNC) Charter | ||
| prepare the supervisory board's decision-making and report to |
|||
| the supervisory board on its deliberations and findings. |
Board Regulations p. 21, 22 art. 21, 30, p. 26 |
||
| The selection and appointment committee should in any event |
chapter "board Committees" - full chapter |
||
| focus on: |
|||
| drawing up selection criteria and appointment i. procedures for management board members and supervisory board members; periodically assessing the size and composition of the ii. management board and the supervisory board, and making a proposal for a composition profile of the supervisory board; periodically assessing the functioning of individual iii. management board members and supervisory board members, and reporting on this to the supervisory board; |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or non-applicable |
Explanation of compliance, deviation or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| drawing up a plan for the succession of management iv. board members and supervisory board members; making proposals for appointments and reappointments; v. and supervising the policy of the management board vi. regarding the selection criteria and appointment Regulations for senior management. |
|||
| 2.2.6 | Evaluation by the supervisory board (best practice) At least once per year, outside the presence of the management board, the supervisory board should evaluate its own functioning, the functioning of the various committees of the supervisory board and that of the individual supervisory board members and should discuss the conclusions that are attached to the evaluation. In doing so, attention should be paid to: substantive aspects, c o n d u c t a n d c u l t u r e , the i. mutual interaction and collaboration, and the interaction with the management board; events that occurred in practice from which lessons ii. may be learned; and the desired profile, composition, competencies and iii. |
✓ Comply |
Board Regulations p.10, art. 21, 25, 26 |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or non-applicable |
Explanation of compliance, deviation or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| expertise of |
|||
| the supervisory board. |
|||
| 2.2.7 | Evaluation of the management board (best practice) |
✓ Comply |
Board Regulations p.10, art. 21, 25, 26 |
| At least once per year, outside the presence of the management | |||
| board, the supervisory board should evaluate both the |
|||
| functioning of the management board as a whole and that of the | |||
| individual management board members, and should discuss the | |||
| conclusions that must be attached to the evaluation, such |
|||
| also in light of the succession of |
|||
| management board members. At least once annually, the |
|||
| management |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or non-applicable |
Explanation of compliance, deviation or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| board, too, should evaluate its own functioning as a whole and that of the individual management board members. |
|||
| 2.2.8 | Evaluation accountability (best practice) The supervisory board's report should state: how the evaluation of the supervisory board, the various i. committees and the individual supervisory board members has been carried out; how the evaluation of the management board and the ii. individual management board members has been carried out; the main findings and conclusions of the evaluations; and iii. what has been or will be done with the conclusions from iv. the evaluations. |
N/A | |
| 2.3 | Organization of the supervisory board and reports (principle) The supervisory board should ensure that it functions effectively. The supervisory board should establish committees to prepare the supervisory board's decision-making. The foregoing does not affect the responsibility of the supervisory board as an organ and of the individual members of the supervisory board for |
✓ Comply |
Board Regulations p. 8 "Dividing of Duties and Powers among the Directors" |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or |
Explanation of compliance, deviation or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2.3.1 | obtaining information and forming an independent opinion. Supervisory board's terms of reference (best practice) The division of duties within the supervisory board and the procedures of the supervisory board should be laid down in terms of reference. The supervisory board's terms of reference should include a paragraph dealing with its relations with the management board, the general meeting, the employee participation body (if any) and the executive committee (if any). The terms of reference should be posted on the |
non-applicable ✓ Comply |
Board Regulations p. 7 "The powers and duties of the Board of Directors areas" |
| company's website. |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or non-applicable |
Explanation of compliance, deviation or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2.3.2 | Establishment of committees (best practice) If the supervisory board consists of more than four members, it should appoint from among its members an AC, a remuneration committee and a selection and appointment committee. Without prejudice to the collegiate responsibility of the supervisory board, the duty of these committees is to prepare the decision making of the supervisory board. If the supervisory board decides not to establish an AC, a remuneration committee or a selection and appointment committee, the best practice provisions applicable to such committees) should apply to the entire supervisory board. |
✓ Comply |
AoA art 21 – Audit Committee, art. 34 – Remuneration Committee, Board Regulations p. 26 "powers of the Committees", Committee charters – Audit Committee Charter, Remuneration, Selection and Nomination Committee Charter |
| 2.3.3 | Committees' terms of reference (best practice) The supervisory board should draw up terms of reference for the AC, the remuneration committee and the selection and appointment committee. The terms of reference should indicate the role and responsibility of the committee concerned, its composition and the manner in which it discharges its duties. The terms of reference should be posted on the company's website. |
✓ Comply |
AoA art 21 – Audit Committee, art. 34 – Remuneration Committee, Board Regulations p. 26 "powers of the Committees", Committee charters – Audit Committee Charter, Remuneration, Selection and Nomination Committee Charter |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or non-applicable |
Explanation of compliance, deviation or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2.3.4 | Composition of the committees (best practice) The AC and the remuneration committee should not be chaired by the chairperson of the supervisory board or by a former member of the management board of the company. More than half of the members of the committees should be independent within the meaning of best practice provision 2.1.8. |
✓ Comply |
Committee charters – Audit Committee Charter p. 5 chapter 5. Remuneration, Selection and Nomination Committee Charter p. 6 Composition and Organization |
| 2.3.5 | Committee reports (best practice) The supervisory board should receive from each of the committees a report of their deliberations and findings. In the report of the supervisory board, it should comment on how the duties of the committees were |
✓ Comply |
Audit Committee Charter p. 8 chapter 8. Remuneration, Selection and Nomination Committee Charter p. 8, chapter 6 |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or non-applicable |
Explanation of compliance, deviation or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| conducted in the financial year. In this report, the composition of the committees, the number of committee meetings and the main |
|||
| items discussed at the meetings should be mentioned. |
| Ref | Principle | or best practice |
Comply, deviate or |
Explanation of compliance, deviation or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2.3.6 | Chairperson The that: i. ii. iii. iv. v. vi. vii. viii. |
of the supervisory board (best practice) chairman of the supervisory board should in any case ensure the supervisory board has proper contact with the management board, the employee participation body (if any) and the general meeting; the supervisory board elects a vice-chairman; there is sufficient time for deliberation and decision making by the supervisory board; the supervisory board members receive all information that is necessary for the proper performance of their duties in a timely fashion; the supervisory board and its committees function properly; the functioning of individual management board members and supervisory board members is assessed at least annually; the supervisory board members and management board members follow their induction programme; the supervisory board members and management |
non-applicable ✓ Comply |
Board Regulations p. 8 '" Dividing of Duties and Powers among the Directors" art. 3), p. 19, p. 20 "the Chairperson"" |
| ix. | board members follow their education or training programme; the management board performs activities in respect of |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or non-applicable |
Explanation of compliance, deviation or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| culture; the supervisory board recognizes signs from the x. enterprise affiliated with the company and ensures that any actual or suspected ) material misconduct and irregularities are reported to the supervisory board without delay; the general meeting proceeds in an orderly and efficient xi. manner; |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or non-applicable |
Explanation of compliance, deviation or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| effective communication with shareholders is assured; xii. and The supervisory board is involved closely, and at an early xiii. stage, in any merger or takeover processes. The chairman of the supervisory board should consult regularly with the chairman of |
|||
| 2.3.7 | the management board. Vice-chairman of the supervisory board (best practice) The vice-chairman of the supervisory board should deputize for the chairman when the occasion arises. |
✓ Comply |
Ad-hoc nomination in BoD meetings |
| 2.3.8 | Delegated supervisory board member (best practice) A delegated supervisory board member is a supervisory board member who has a special duty. The delegation must not extend beyond the duties of the supervisory board itself and must not include the management of the company. Its purpose is more intensive supervision and advice and more regular consultation with the management board. The delegation should be only of a temporary nature. The delegation must not detract from the duties and powers of the supervisory board. The delegated supervisory board member continues to be a member of the |
N/A |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or non-applicable |
Explanation of compliance, deviation or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| supervisory board and should report regularly on the execution of hisspecial duty to the plenary supervisory board. |
|||
| 2.3.9 | Temporary management board function of a supervisory board member (best practice) A supervisory board member who temporarily takes on the management of the company, where the management board members are absent or unable to fulfil their duties, should resign from the supervisory board. |
N/A |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or non-applicable |
Explanation of compliance, deviation or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2.3.10 | Company secretary (best practice) |
✓ Comply |
Board Regulations p.19 - Company Secretary |
| The supervisory board should be supported by the company secretary; The secretary: should ensure that the proper procedures are followed i. and that the statutory obligations and obligations under the articles of association are complied with; should facilitate the provision of information of the ii. management board and the supervisory board; and should support the chairman of the supervisory board in iii. the organization of the affairs of the supervisory board, including the provision of information, meeting agendas, evaluations and training programs. |
|||
| The company secretary should, either on the initiative of the | |||
| supervisory board or otherwise, be appointed and dismissed by | |||
| the management board, after the approval of the supervisory board has been obtained. |
|||
| If the secretary also undertakes work for the management board | |||
| and notes that the interests of the management board and the |
|||
| supervisory board diverge, as a result of which it is unclear which | |||
| interests the secretary should represent, the secretary should |
|||
| report this to the chairperson of the supervisory board. |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or non-applicable |
Explanation of compliance, deviation or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2.3.11 | Report of the supervisory board (best practice) |
✓ Comply |
This topic is covered in the annual report. |
| The annual statements of the company include a report by |
|||
| the supervisory board. In this report, the supervisory board | |||
| should render account of the supervision conducted in the past | |||
| financial year, reporting in any event on the items referred to in |
|||
| best practice provisions 1.1.3, 2.1.2, 2.1.10, 2.2.8, 2.3.5 and 2.4.4 |
|||
| and, if applicable, the items referred |
|||
| to in best practice provisions 1.3.6 and 2.2.2. |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or non-applicable |
Explanation of compliance, deviation or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2.4 | Decision-making and functioning (principle) The management board and the supervisory board should ensure that decisions are made in a balanced and effective manner whilst taking account of the interests of stakeholders. The management board should ensure that information is provided in a timely and sound manner. The management board and the supervisory board should keep their knowledge and skills up to date and devote sufficient time on their duties and responsibilities. They should ensure that, in performing their duties, they have the information that is required for effective |
✓ Comply |
Board Regulations p. 6 "Role, responsibilities and tasks of the Board and its members" |
| 2.4.1 | decision-making. Stimulating openness and accountability (best practice) The management board and the supervisory board are each responsible for stimulating openness and accountability within the body of which they form part, and between the different bodies within the company. |
✓ Comply |
Board Regulations p. 6 "Role, responsibilities and tasks of the Board and its members" art. xiv. |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or non-applicable |
Explanation of compliance, deviation or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2.4.2 | Other positions (best practice) Management board members and supervisory board members should report any other positions they may hold to the supervisory board in advance and, at least annually, the other positions should be discussed at the supervisory board meeting. The acceptance of membership of a supervisory board by a management board member requires the approval of the supervisory board. |
✓ Comply |
Board Regulations p. 26 "Other Positions" |
| 2.4.3 | Point of contact for the functioning of supervisory board and management board members (best practice) The chairman of the supervisory board should act on behalf of the supervisory board as the main contact for the management board, supervisory board members and shareholders regarding the functioning of management board members and supervisory board members. The vice-chairman should function as contact for individual supervisory board |
✓ Comply |
Board regulations p. 18 "Tasks and Responsibilities Executive Director and the Secretary of the Board", p. 19, p. 20 "the Chairperson"" |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or non-applicable |
Explanation of compliance, deviation or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| members and management board members regarding the functioning of the chairman. |
|||
| 2.4.4 | Attendance at supervisory board meetings (best practice) Supervisory board members should attend supervisory board meetings and the meetings of the committees of which they are a part. If supervisory board members are frequently absent from these meetings, they should be held to account for this. The report of the supervisory board should state the absenteeism rate from supervisory board and committee meetings of each supervisory board member. |
✓ Comply |
Board Regulations p. 21 and onward: "Board Operation: Invitation, Convening, Voting and Minutes". |
| 2.4.5 | Induction programme for supervisory board members (best practice) All supervisory board members should follow an induction programme geared to their role. The induction programme should in any event cover general financial, social and legal affairs, financial and sustainability reporting by the company, any specific aspects that are unique to the relevant company and its business activities, the company culture and the relationship with the employee participation body (if any), and the responsibilities of a |
✓ Comply |
New members are covered by an On-boarding personal process with the Head of Corporate Governance of the company |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or non-applicable |
Explanation of compliance, deviation or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| supervisory board member. |
|||
| 2.4.6 | Development (best practice) The management board and the supervisory board should each conduct an annual review for their own body to identify any aspects regarding which the supervisory board members and management board members require training or education. |
✓ Comply |
Board Regulations p. 10 art. 21, 25 and 26 |
| 2.4.7 | Information safeguards (best practice) The management board should ensure that internal procedures are established and maintained which safeguard that all relevant information is known to the management board and the supervisory board in a timely |
✓ Comply |
Board regulations p. 9 art. 11, The Board members approved the Board Regulations and the Committees charters, they have access to a shared file containing the company's internal regulations |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or non-applicable |
Explanation of compliance, deviation or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| fashion. The supervisory board should supervise the establishment and implementation of these procedures. |
|||
| 2.4.8 | Supervisory board members' responsibility for obtaining information (best practice) The supervisory board and each individual supervisory board member have their own responsibility for obtaining the information from the management board, the internal audit function, the external auditor and the employee participation body (if any) that the supervisory board needs in order to be able to perform its duties as a supervisory organ properly. |
✓ Comply |
Board Regulations p. 9 art. 11, p. 12 art. 12, 13 |
| 2.4.9 | Obtaining information from officers and external parties (best practice) If the supervisory board considers it necessary, it may obtain information from officers and external advisers of the company. The company should provide the necessary means to this end. The supervisory board may require that certain officers and external advisers attend its meetings. |
✓ Comply |
Board Regulations p. 9 art. 11, p. 12 art. 12, 13 |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or non-applicable |
Explanation of compliance, deviation or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2.5 | Culture (principle) The management board is responsible for creating a culture aimed at long-term value creation for the company and its affiliated enterprise. The supervisory board should supervise the activities of the management board in this regard. |
✓ Comply |
Board Regulations p. 6 sec. V, p. 11 art. 3), 5), 8) |
| 2.5.1 | Management board's responsibility for culture (best practice) The management board should adopt values for the company and its affiliated enterprise that contribute to a culture focused on long-term value creation and discuss these with the supervisory board. The management board is responsible for the incorporation and maintenance of the values within the company and its affiliated enterprise. The management board should encourage behaviour that is in keeping with the values and propagate these values through leading by example. Attention must be paid to the following, among other things: |
✓ Comply |
Board Regulations p. 6 sec. V, p. 11 art. 3), 5), 8) |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or non-applicable |
Explanation of compliance, deviation or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| the strategy and the business model; i. the environment in which the enterprise operates; and ii. the existing culture within the enterprise, and iii. whether it is desirable to implement any changes in this the social safety within the enterprise and the ability to iv. discuss and report actual or suspected misconduct or irregularities. |
|||
| 2.5.2 | Code of Conduct (best practice) The management board should draw up a code of conduct and monitor its effectiveness and compliance with this code, both on the part of both it and of the employees of the company. The management board should inform the supervisory board of its findings and observations with regard to the effectiveness of, and compliance with, the code. The code of conduct will be published on the company's website. |
✓ Comply |
See website - Code of Conduct |
| 2.5.3 | Employee participation (best practice) If the company has established an employee participation body, the following should also be discussed in the consultations between the management board, the supervisory board and such |
N/A |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or non-applicable |
Explanation of compliance, deviation or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| employee participation body: i. the conduct and culture in the company and its affiliated enterprise; |
|||
| ii. the values adopted by the management board on the basis of best practice provision 2.5.1, and |
|||
| iii. iii. the company's D&I policy |
|||
| 2.5.4 | Reporting on culture (best practice) In the management report, the management board should provide explanatory notes on: the culture within the enterprise, and whether it is i. desirable to implement any changes in this; how the culture, the underlying values and conduct ii. promoted within the enterprise contribute to sustainable long-term value creation and, if it is considered desirable to amend these, which initiatives are taken to further increase this contribution; and the effectiveness of, and compliance with, the code of iii. conduct. |
✓ Comply |
This topic is covered in the management report. |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or non-applicable |
Explanation of compliance, deviation or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2.6 | Misconduct and irregularities (principle) The management board and the supervisory board should be alert to indications of actual or suspected misconduct or irregularities. The management board should establish a procedure for reporting actual or |
✓ Comply |
The company's Internal Enforcement Program and Regulations for investigating were approved by the Board. |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or |
Explanation of compliance, deviation or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| non-applicable | |||
| suspicion of misconduct or irregularities and take appropriate |
|||
| follow-up action on the basis of these reports. The supervisory | |||
| board monitors the management board in this. | |||
| 2.6.1 | Regulations for reporting actual or suspicion of misconduct or |
✓ Comply |
Policies are in place |
| irregularities (best practice) | |||
| The management board should establish a procedure for | |||
| reporting actual or suspected irregularities within the company | |||
| and its affiliated enterprise. The procedure should be published | |||
| on the company's website. The management board should |
|||
| ensure that employees have the opportunity |
|||
| to file a report without jeopardizing their legal position. |
|||
| 2.6.2 | Informing the chairperson of the supervisory board (best |
✓ Comply |
Board Regulations p. 10, Internal Enforcement |
| practice) The management board should inform the chairman |
Program p. 10 Reporting and Notification |
||
| of the supervisory board without delay of any signs of actual |
|||
| or suspected material misconduct or irregularities within the |
|||
| company and its affiliated enterprise. If the actual or |
|||
| suspected misconduct or irregularity pertains to the functioning |
|||
| of a management board member, employees can report |
|||
| this directly to the chairman of the supervisory board. |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or non-applicable |
Explanation of compliance, deviation or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2.6.3 | Notification by the external auditor (best practice) The external auditor should inform the chairperson of the AC without delay if, during the performance of his duties, he discovers or suspects an instance of misconduct or irregularity. If the actual or suspected misconduct or irregularity pertains to the functioning of one or more management board members, the external auditor should report this directly to the chairperson of the supervisory board. |
✓ Comply |
AC charter p. 7 art 4), p. 10 chapter 11 ''external Auditor'' |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or non-applicable |
Explanation of compliance, deviation, or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2.6.4 | Oversight by the supervisory board (best practice) The supervisory board monitors the operation of the procedure for reporting actual or suspected misconduct or irregularities, appropriate and independent investigations into signs of misconduct or irregularities, and, if an instance of misconduct or irregularity has been discovered, an adequate follow-up of any recommendations for remedial actions. In order to safeguard the independence of the investigation in cases where the management board itself is involved; the supervisory board should have the option of initiating its own investigation into any irregularities that have been discovered and to coordinate this investigation. |
✓ Comply |
Internal Enforcement Program p. 10 Reporting and Notification |
| 2.7 | Preventing conflicts of interest (principle) Any form of conflict of interest between the company and the members of its management board or supervisory board should be prevented. To avoid conflicts of interest, adequate measures should be taken. The supervisory board is responsible for the decision-making on dealing with conflicts of interest regarding management board members, supervisory board members and majority shareholders in relation to the company. |
✓ Comply |
Articles 12.10 and 20.15 of the AOA Board Regulations p. 24 chapter "conflicts of interests", Code of Conduct p. 6 "Conflict of Interest Policies" |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or non-applicable |
Explanation of compliance, deviation, or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2.7.1 | Preventing conflicts of interest (best practice) Management board members and supervisory board members are alert to conflicts of interest and should in any case refrain from the following: competing with the company; i. demanding or accepting substantial gifts from the ii. company for themselves or their spouse, registered partner or other life companion, foster child or relative by blood or marriage up to the second degree; providing unjustified advantages to third parties at the iii. company's expense; |
✓ Comply |
Article 20.15 of the AOA Board Regulations p. 24 chapter "conflicts of interests", Code of Conduct p. 6 "Conflict of Interest Policies" |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or non-applicable |
Explanation of compliance, deviation, or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2.7.2 | iv. taking advantage of business opportunities to which the company is entitled for themselves or for their spouse, registered partner or other life companion, foster child or relative by blood or marriage up to the second degree. Terms of reference (best practice) |
✓ Comply |
Articles 12.10 and 20 of the AOA |
| The terms of reference of the supervisory board should contain rules on dealing with conflicts of interest, including conflicting interests between management board members and supervisory board members on the one hand and the company on the other. The terms of reference should also stipulate which transactions require the approval of the supervisory board. The company should draw up regulations governing ownership of, and transactions in, securities by management or supervisory board members, other than securities issued, by the company. |
Board Regulations p. 24 chapter "conflicts of interests", Code of Conduct p. 6 "Conflict of Interest Policies" * "Since the Company has a one-tier Board, the Non Executive Board Members are already involved in these subjects. The Company does not require specific approval from the Non-Executive Board Members." |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or non-applicable |
Explanation of compliance, deviation, or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2.7.3 | Reporting (best practice) A conflict of interest may exist if the company intends to enter into a transaction with a legal entity: in which a member of the management board or the i. supervisory board personally has a material financial interest; or which has a member of the management board or the ii. supervisory board who is related under family law to a member of the management board or the supervisory board of the company. A management board member should report any potential |
✓ Comply |
Articles 1(nn) and 20.13 of the AOA Board Regulations p. 24 chapter "conflicts of interests", Code of Conduct p. 6 "Conflict of Interest Policies" |
| conflict of interest in a transaction that is of material significance to the company and/or to such management board member to the chairman of the |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or non-applicable |
Explanation of compliance, deviation, or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| supervisory board and to the other members of the management | |||
| board without delay. The management board member should |
|||
| provide all relevant information on this subject,, including the |
|||
| information relevant to the situation concerning his spouse, |
|||
| registered partner or other life companion, foster child and | |||
| relatives by blood or marriage up to the second degree. |
|||
| A supervisory board member should report any conflict of | |||
| interest or potential conflict of interest in a transaction that is of | |||
| material significance to the company and/or to such supervisory | |||
| board member to the chairman of the supervisory board without |
|||
| delay and should provide all relevant information on this subject, | |||
| including the information relevant to the situation regarding his |
|||
| spouse, registered partner or other life companion, foster child | |||
| or relatives by blood or marriage up to the second degree. | |||
| . If the chairman of the supervisory board has a potential conflict | |||
| of interest, he must report this to the vice-chairman of the | |||
| supervisory board without delay. The supervisory board should | |||
| decide, outside the presence of the management board member | |||
| or supervisory board member concerned, whether there is a | |||
| conflict of interest. |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or non-applicable |
Explanation of compliance, deviation, or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2.7.4 | Accountability regarding transactions: management board and supervisory board members (best practice) All transactions in which there are conflicts of interest with management board members or supervisory board members should be agreed on terms that are customary in the market. Decisions to enter into transactions in which there are conflicts of interest with management board members or supervisory board members that are of material significance to the company and/or to the relevant management board members or supervisory board members should require the approval of the supervisory board. Such transactions should be published in the management report, together with a statement of the conflict of interest and a declaration that best practice provisions 2.7.3 and 2.7.4 have been complied with. |
✓ Comply |
Article 20 of the AOA Board Regulations p. 24 chapter "conflicts of interests", Code of Conduct p. 6 "Conflict of Interest Policies" [ * "Since the Company has a one-tier Board, the Non-Executive Board Members are already involved in these subjects. The Company does not require specific approval from the Non-Executive Board Members." |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or non-applicable |
Explanation of compliance, deviation, or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2.7.5 | Accountability regarding transactions: majority shareholders (best practice) All transactions between the company and legal or natural persons who hold at least ten percent of the shares in the company should be agreed on terms that are customary in the market. Decisions to enter into transactions with such persons that are of material significance to the company and/or to such persons should require the approval of the supervisory board. Such transactions should be published in the management report, together with a declaration that best practice provision 2.7.5 has been complied with. |
✓ Comply |
Board Regulations p. 24 chapter "conflicts of interests", Code of Conduct p. 6 "Conflict of Interest Policies" * "Since the Company has a one-tier Board, the Non Executive Board Members are already involved in these subjects. The Company does not require specific approval from the Non-Executive Board Members." |
| 2.7.6 | Personal loans (best practice) The company should not grant its management board members and supervisory board members any personal loans, guarantees or the like unless in the normal course of business and on terms applicable to the personnel as a whole, and after approval of |
✓ Comply |
Article 20 of the AOA Board Regulations p. 25 "Loans and Guarantees" |
| the supervisory board. No |
* "Since the Company has a one-tier Board, the Non- |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or non-applicable |
Explanation of compliance, deviation, or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| remission of loans should be forgiven. |
Executive Board Members are already involved in these subjects. The Company does not require specific approval from the Non-Executive Board Members." |
||
| 2.8 | Takeover situations (principle) In the event of a takeover bid for the company's shares, or for the depositary receipts for the company's shares, if it concerns a private bid for a business unit or a participating interest, where the value of the bid exceeds the threshold referred to in Article 2:107a(1)(c) of the Dutch Civil Code, and/or involves other substantial changes in the structure of the company, both the management board and the supervisory board should ensure that the stakeholder interests concerned are carefully weighed and any conflict of interest for supervisory board members or management board members is avoided. The management board and the supervisory board should be guided in their actions by the interests of the company and its affiliated enterprise. |
✓ Comply |
Board Regulations p. 24 chapter "conflicts of interests", Code of Conduct p. 6 "Conflict of Interest Policies" |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or non-applicable |
Explanation of compliance, deviation or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2.8.1 | Supervisory board involvement (best practice) When a takeover bid for the company's shares or for the depositary receipts for the company's shares is being prepared, in the event of a private bid for a business unit or a participating interest, where the value of the bid exceeds the threshold referred to in Section 2:107a(1)(c) of the Dutch Civil Code, and/or in the event of other substantial changes in the structure of the company, the management board should ensure that the supervisory board is involved in the takeover process and/or the change in the structure closely and in a timely fashion. |
✓ Comply |
Board Regulations p. 24 chapter "conflicts of interests", Code of Conduct p. 6 "Conflict of Interest Policies" |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or non-applicable |
Explanation of compliance, deviation or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2.8.2 | Informing the supervisory board about request for inspection by competing bidder (best practice) If a takeover bid has been announced for the shares, or depositary receipts for shares, in the company, and the management board receives a request from a competing bidder to inspect the company's records, the management board should discuss this request with the supervisory board without delay. |
✓ Comply |
Board Regulations p. 24 chapter "conflicts of interests", Code of Conduct p. 6 "Conflict of Interest Policies" |
| 2.8.3 | Management board's position on a private bid (best practice) If a private bid for a business unit or a participating interest has been made public, where the value of the bid exceeds the threshold referred to in Section 2:107a (1)(c) of the Dutch Civil Code, the management board |
✓ Comply |
Board Regulations p. 24 chapter "conflicts of interests", Code of Conduct p. 6 "Conflict of Interest Policies" |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or non-applicable |
Explanation of compliance, deviation or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| of the company should as soon as possible make public its position on the bid and the reasons for this position. |
AoA art. 20.8 | ||
| 3 | REMUNERATION | ||
| 3.1 | Remuneration policy – management board (principle) The remuneration policy applicable to management board members should be clear and understandable, should focus on long-term value creation for the company and its affiliated enterprise, and consider the internal pay ratios within the enterprise. The remuneration policy should not encourage management board members to act in their own interest, nor to take risks that are not in keeping with the strategy formulated and the risk appetite that has been established. The supervisory board is responsible for formulating the remuneration policy and its implementation. |
✓ Comply |
Board Regulations p. 26 The Board Committees. The remuneration policy is being reviewed, updated and published as required. |
| 3.1.1 | Remuneration policy proposal (best practice) The remuneration committee should submit a clear and understandable proposal to the supervisory board concerning the remuneration policy to be pursued with regard to the management board. The supervisory board |
✓ Comply |
RC Charter P. 3 art. 2.1 "The Remuneration Proposal to the Board" |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or |
Explanation of compliance, deviation or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| should present the policy to the general meeting for adoption. |
non-applicable | ||
| 3.1.2 | Remuneration policy (best practice) The following aspects should in any event be taken into consideration when formulating the remuneration policy: the objectives for the strategy for the implementation of i. long-term value creation within the meaning of best practice provision 1.1.1; the scenario analyses carried out in advance; ii. the pay ratios within the company and its affiliated iii. enterprise; the development of the market price of the shares; iv. |
✓ Comply |
According to RC charter p.3, the remuneration policy covers in any event the remuneration structure (fixed and variable components), performance criteria, scenario analyses and pay ratios within the company. Aspects vi and vii are not applicable. Remuneration Policy. |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or |
Explanation of compliance, deviation or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| an appropriate ratio between the variable and fixed v. remuneration components. The variable remuneration component is linked to measurable performance criteria determined in advance, which are long-term in character; If shares are being awarded, the terms and conditions vi. govern this. Shares should be held for at least five years after they are awarded; and If share options are being awarded, the terms and vii. conditions governing this and the terms and conditions subject to which the share options can be exercised. I n a n y c a s e , share options cannot be exercised during the first three years after they are awarded. |
non-applicable | ||
| 3.1.3 | Remuneration – executive committee (best practice) If the management board has an executive committee, the management board should inform the supervisory board about the remuneration of the members of the executive committee who are not management board members. The management board should discuss this remuneration with the supervisory board annually. |
N/A |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or non-applicable |
Explanation of compliance, deviation or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| 3.2 | Determination of management board remuneration (principle) The supervisory board should determine the remuneration of the individual members of the management board, within the limits of the remuneration policy adopted by the general meeting. The remuneration committee should prepare the supervisory board's decision-making regarding the determination of remuneration. The inadequate performance of duties should not be rewarded. |
✓ Comply |
Remuneration Policy, Remuneration Proposal according to the RC Charter Chapter 2.1 |
| 3.2.1 | Remuneration committee's proposal (best practice) The remuneration committee should submit a proposal to the supervisory board concerning the remuneration of individual members of the |
✓ Comply |
RC Charter P. 3 art. 2.1 "The Remuneration Proposal to the Board" |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or non-applicable |
Explanation of compliance, deviation or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| management board. The proposal is drawn up in accordance with | |||
| the remuneration policy that has been established and will, in |
|||
| any event, cover the remuneration structure, the amount of the | |||
| fixed and variable remuneration components, the performance | |||
| criteria used, the scenario analyses that are conducted and the |
|||
| pay ratios within the company and |
|||
| its affiliated enterprise. |
|||
| 3.2.2 | Management board members' views on their own remuneration | ✓ Comply |
RC Charter p. 5 art. j |
| (best practice) | |||
| When drafting the proposal for the remuneration of |
|||
| management board members, the remuneration committee | |||
| should take note of individual management board members' | |||
| views with regard to the amount and structure of their own | |||
| remuneration. The remuneration committee should ask the |
|||
| members of the management board to pay attention to the |
|||
| aspects referred to in best practice provision 3.1.2. |
|||
| 3.2.3 | Severance payments (best practice) |
✓ Comply |
RC Charter p. 5 art. K |
| The remuneration in the event of dismissal should not exceed | |||
| one year's salary (the 'fixed' remuneration component). | |||
| Severance pays will not be awarded if the agreement is |
|||
| terminated early at the initiative of the management board |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or |
Explanation of compliance, deviation or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| member, or in the event of seriously culpable or negligent behavior on the part of the management board member. |
non-applicable | ||
| 3.3 | Remuneration – supervisory board (principle) The supervisory board should submit a clear and understandable proposal for its own appropriate remuneration to the general meeting. The remuneration of supervisory board members should promote an adequate performance of their role and should not be dependent on the results of the company. |
✓ Comply |
RC Charter P. 3 art. 2.1 "The Remuneration Proposal to the Board" |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or |
Explanation of compliance, deviation or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| non-applicable | |||
| 3.3.1 | Time spent and responsibility (best practice) |
✓ Comply |
AoA art. 35 Remuneration Policy; RC Charter p. 2 |
| The remuneration of the supervisory board members should |
chapter 3 tasks and Responsibilities | ||
| reflect the time spent and the responsibilities of their role. |
|||
| 3.3.2 | Remuneration of supervisory board members (best practice) | ✓ Comply |
AoA art. 35 Remuneration Policy |
| Supervisory board members must not be awarded |
|||
| remuneration in the form of shares and/or rights to shares. |
|||
| 3.3.3 | Share ownership (best practice) |
N/A | |
| Shares held by a supervisory board member in the company on |
|||
| whose supervisory board they serve should be long-term | |||
| investments. | |||
| 3.4 | Accountability for implementation of remuneration policy | ✓ Comply |
See BoD report, annual report. |
| (principle) In the remuneration report, the supervisory board | |||
| should render account of the implementation of the |
|||
| remuneration policy in a transparent manner. The report should | |||
| be published on the company's website. |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or non-applicable |
Explanation of compliance, deviation or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| 3.4.1 | Remuneration report (best practice) |
✓ Comply |
RC Charter Chapter 2 Tasks and Responsibilities |
| The remuneration committee should prepare the remuneration report. This report should in any event describe, in a transparent manner, in addition to the matters required by law: how the remuneration policy has been implemented in i. the past financial year. How the implementation of the remuneration policy ii. contributes to long-term value creation. that scenario analyses have been taken into consideration; iii. |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or non-applicable |
Explanation of compliance, deviation or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| the pay ratios within the company and its affiliated iv. enterprise and, if applicable, any changes in these ratios in comparison with the previous financial year; if a management board member receives variable v. remuneration, how this remuneration contributes to long-term value creation, the measurable performance criteria determined in advance upon which the variable remuneration depends, and the relationship between the remuneration and performance; and if a current or former management board member vi. receives a severance payment, the reason for this payment. |
|||
| 3.4.2 | Agreement of management board member (best practice) The main elements of the agreement of a management board member with the company should be published on the company's website in a transparent overview after the agreement has been concluded, and in any event no later than the date of the notice calling the general meeting where the appointment of the management board member will be proposed. |
✓ Comply |
This is covered in C h a p t e r D ( A d d i t i o n a l D e t a i l s " ) o f t h e A n n u a l report , published on the website. The financial Statements are published in English, and the full report is published in Hebrew. |
| 4 | THE GENERAL MEETING |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or non-applicable |
Explanation of compliance, deviation or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| 4.1 | The general meeting (principle) The general meeting should be able to exert such influence on the policies of the management board and the supervisory board of the company that it plays a fully-fledged role in the system of checks and balances in the company. Good corporate governance requires the fully- fledged participation of shareholders in the decision-making in the general meeting. |
✓ Comply |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or non-applicable |
Explanation of compliance, deviation or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| 4.1.1 | Supervisory board supervision (best practice) |
✓ Comply |
Board Regulations p. 3 Background and Applicable |
| The supervisory board's supervision of the management board |
Legislation | ||
| should include the supervision of relations with shareholders. | |||
| 4.1.2 | Proper conduct of business at meetings (best practice) |
✓ Comply |
|
| The chairman of the general meeting is responsible for ensuring | |||
| the proper conduct of business at meetings to promote a |
|||
| meaningful discussion at the meeting. |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or non-applicable |
Explanation of compliance, deviation or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| 4.1.3 | Agenda (best practice) The agenda of the general meeting should list which items are up for discussion and which items are to be voted on. The following items should be dealt with as separate agenda items: material changes to the articles of association; i. proposals relating to the appointment of management ii. board and supervisory board members; the policy of the company on additions to reserves and on iii. dividends (the level and purpose of the addition to reserves, the amount of the dividend and the type of dividend); any proposal to pay out dividend; iv. resolutions to approve the management conducted by v. the management board (discharge of management board members from liability); resolutions t o approve the supervision exercised by vi. the supervisory board (discharge of supervisory board members from liability); |
✓ Comply |
AoA article 26 Board regulations p. 7 ''The powers and duties of the Board of Directors areas'' art. ix, xi, xiv, xv, p. 23 "Approval of resolutions of the Board of Directors'' p. 26 General Meeting |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or |
Explanation of compliance, deviation or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| non-applicable | |||
| any substantial change in the corporate governance vii. structure of the company and in the compliance with this Code; and |
|||
| 4.1.4 | the appointment of the external auditor. viii. Proposal for approval or authorization (best practice) A proposal for approval or authorization by the general meeting should be explained in writing. In its explanation the management board should deal with all facts and circumstances relevant to the approval or authorization to be granted. The notes to the agenda should be posted on the company's website. |
✓ Comply |
Board regulations p. 7 ''The powers and duties of the Board of Directors areas'' art. ix, xi, xiv, xv, p. 23 "Approval of resolutions of the Board of Directors'' p. 26 general Meeting |
| 4.1.5 | Shareholder's explanation when exercising the right to put items on the agenda (best practice) If a shareholder has arranged for an item to be put on the agenda, he should explain this at the meeting and, if necessary, answer questions about it. |
✓ Comply |
Articles of Association Article 24 |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or non-applicable |
Explanation of compliance, deviation or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| 4.1.6 | Placing of items on the agenda by shareholders (best practice) A shareholder should only exercise the right to put items on the agenda after having consulted with the management board on this. If one or more shareholders intend to request that an item be put on the agenda that may result in a change in the company's strategy, for example as a result of the dismissal of one or several management board or supervisory board members, the management board should be given the opportunity to stipulate a reasonable period in which to respond (the response time). The opportunity to stipulate the response time should also apply to an intention as referred to above for judicial leave to call a general meeting pursuant to Article 2:110 of the Dutch Civil Code. The relevant shareholder should respect the response time stipulated by the management board, within the meaning of best practice provision 4.1.7. |
✓ Comply |
Article 24 and Article 26.3 to AoA |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or |
Explanation of compliance, deviation or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| non-applicable | |||
| 4.1.7 | Stipulation of the response time (best practice) |
✓ Comply |
|
| If the management board stipulates a response time, this should | |||
| be a reasonable period that does not exceed 180 days from the | |||
| moment the management board is informed by one or more | |||
| shareholders of their intention to put an item on the agenda to |
|||
| the day of the general meeting at which the item is to be dealt |
|||
| with. The management board should use the response time for |
|||
| further deliberation and constructive consultation, in any event |
|||
| with the relevant shareholder(s) and should explore the |
|||
| alternatives. At the end of the response time, the management | |||
| board should report on this consultation and the exploration to | |||
| the general meeting. This should be monitored by the | |||
| supervisory board. | |||
| The response time may be stipulated only once for any given | |||
| general meeting and should not apply to an item in respect of | |||
| which a response time or a statutory refection period as referred | |||
| to in Article 2:114b of the Dutch Civil Code has already been | |||
| stipulated, or to meetings where a shareholder holds at least | |||
| three-quarters of the issued capital as a consequence of a | |||
| successful public bid. |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or non-applicable |
Explanation of compliance, deviation or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| 4.1.8 | Attendance of members nominated for the management board or supervisory board (best practice) Management board and supervisory board members nominated for appointment should attend the general meeting at which votes will be cast on their nomination. |
✓ Comply |
|
| 4.1.9 | External auditor's attendance (best practice) The external auditor may be questioned by the general meeting in relation to his report on the fairness of the financial statements. The external auditor should a t t e n d a n d b e e n t i t l e d t o a d d r e s s t h e m e e t i n g f o r t h i s p u r p o s e . |
✓ comply |
AoA p. 54 |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or non-applicable |
Explanation of compliance, deviation or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| 4.1.10 | General meeting's report (best practice) The report of the general meeting should be made available, on request, to the shareholders no later than three months after the end of the meeting, after which shareholders should have the opportunity to react to the report in the following three |
✓ Comply |
AoA Art. 27, reporting is a requirement by Israeli Securities Law and regulations |
| months. The report should then be adopted in the manner provided for in the articles of association. |
|||
| 4.2 | Provision of information (principle) The management board and the supervisory board should ensure that the general meeting is adequately provided with information. |
✓ Comply |
Board Regulations p. 26 'general Meeting'. |
| 4.2.1 | Substantiation of invocation of overriding interest (best practice) If the management board and the supervisory board do not provide the general meeting with all information desired with the invocation of an overriding interest on the part of the company, they must give reasons for this. |
✓ Comply |
Board Regulations p. 26 'general Meeting'. |
| 4.2.2 | Policy on bilateral contacts with shareholders (best practice) The company should formulate an outline policy on bilateral contacts with the shareholders and should post this policy on its website. Shareholders and the company should be prepared to enter into a dialogue, where appropriate and at their own |
Deviate | This is not deemed necessary due to frequent, steady bilateral contact with shareholders and the market. |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or non-applicable |
Explanation of compliance, deviation or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| 4.2.3 | discretion. The company is expected to facilitate the dialogue unless, in the opinion of the management board, this is not in the interests of the company and its affiliated enterprise. Shareholders are expected to be prepared to enter into a constructive dialogue with the company. If a shareholder enters into a dialogue with the company outside the context of a general meeting, the shareholder shall disclose his full share position (long and short and through derivatives) at the request of the company. Meetings and presentations (best practice) Analyst meetings, analyst presentations, presentations to institutional or other investors and press conferences should be announced in advance on the company's website and by means of press releases. Analysts' meetings and presentations to investors should not take place shortly before the publication of the regular financial information. All shareholders should be able to follow these meetings and presentations in real time, by means of webcasting, telephone or otherwise. After the meetings, the presentations should be posted on the company's website. |
☐ ✓ comply ☐ |
Presentations are posted on TASE website before the meetings ] |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or |
Explanation of compliance, deviation or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| non-applicable | |||
| 4.2.4 | Posting information in a separate section of the website (best | ✓ Comply |
See under 'Investor Relations' on the website. |
| practice) | |||
| The company should post and update information which is | |||
| relevant to the shareholders and which it is required to publish | |||
| or submit pursuant to the provisions of company law and |
|||
| securities law applicable to it in a separate |
|||
| section of the company's website. |
|||
| 4.2.5 | Management board contacts with press and analysts (best | ✓ Comply |
|
| practice) The contacts between the management board on the | |||
| one hand and the press and financial analysts on the other should | |||
| be managed and structured carefully and with due observance |
|||
| of the applicable laws and regulations. The company should not |
|||
| do anything that might compromise |
|||
| the independence of analysts in relation to the company and vice |
|||
| versa. | |||
| 4.2.6 | Outline of anti-takeover measures (best practice) |
N/A | |
| The management board should outline all existing or potential | |||
| anti- takeover measures in the management report and should |
|||
| also indicate in what circumstances and by whom these | |||
| measures may be used. |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or |
Explanation of compliance, deviation or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| non-applicable | |||
| 4.3 | Casting votes (principle) |
✓ Comply |
Art. 28.7 of AoA |
| Participation of as many shareholders as possible in the |
|||
| general meeting's decision-making is in the interest of the | |||
| company's checks and balances. The company should, as far as | |||
| possible, give shareholders the opportunity to vote by proxy |
|||
| and to communicate with all other |
|||
| shareholders. | |||
| 4.3.1 | Voting as deemed fit (best practice) |
N/A | |
| shareholders, including institutional investors (pension funds, | |||
| insurance companies, investment institutions and asset |
|||
| managers), should exercise their voting rights on an informed | |||
| basis and as they deem ft. Institutional investors that use the | |||
| services of proxy advisors (i) should encourage those proxy | |||
| advisors to be prepared to enter into a dialogue with the | |||
| company regarding their voting policy, voting guidelines and | |||
| voting recommendations, and (ii) ensure that their votes are cast | |||
| in line with their own voting policy |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or non-applicable |
Explanation of compliance, deviation or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| 4.3.2 | Providing voting proxies or voting instructions (best practice) |
✓ Comply |
Art. 29 of AoA p. |
| The company should give shareholders and other persons | |||
| entitled to vote the possibility of issuing voting proxies or voting | |||
| instructions, to an independent third party prior to the general meeting. |
|||
| 4.3.3 | Cancelling the binding nature of a nomination or dismissal (best practice) |
✓ Comply |
AoA, art. 12.6 |
| The general meeting of shareholders of a company not having | |||
| statutory two-tier status (structuurregime) may adopt a |
|||
| resolution to cancel the binding nature of a nomination for the |
|||
| appointment of a member of the management board or of the | |||
| supervisory board and/or a resolution to dismiss a member of the management board or of the supervisory board by an absolute |
|||
| majority of the votes cast. It may be provided that this majority | |||
| should represent a given proportion of the issued capital, which | |||
| proportion must not be set higher than one-third. If this |
|||
| proportion of the capital is not represented at the meeting, but |
|||
| an absolute majority of the votes cast is in favor of a resolution |
|||
| to cancel the binding nature of a nomination, or to dismiss a |
|||
| board member, a new meeting may be convened at which the |
|||
| resolution may be passed by an absolute majority of the votes |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or non-applicable |
Explanation of compliance, deviation or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| cast, | |||
| regardless of the proportion of the capital represented at the |
|||
| meeting. | |||
| 4.3.4 | Voting right on financing preference shares (best practice) |
N/A | Not applicable, there are no preference shares. |
| The voting right attaching to financing preference shares should | |||
| be based on the fair value of the capital contribution. | |||
| 4.3.5 | Publication of institutional investors' voting policy (best practice) | N/A | |
| Institutional investors should implement principle 4.4 when | |||
| drawing up their engagement policy. Institutional investors | |||
| should publish their engagement policy on their website. |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or non-applicable |
Explanation of compliance, deviation or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| 4.3.6 | Report on the implementation of institutional investors' voting policy (best practice) Institutional investors should report annually on their website on how they implemented their engagement policy. The report should provide in any case a general description on their voting behavior as well as an explanation of the most significant votes and the use of the services of proxy advisors. "Most significant votes" should be understood in any event to mean: i. votes on matters that have received substantive media attention or votes on items that are regarded by institutional investors as a priority in of the run-up to the general meeting season; ii. ii. votes on a resolution on the agenda of a general meeting (a) that are of strategic importance, or (b) where the institutional investor disagrees with the resolution of the company's management board; or |
N/A | |
| iii. iii. votes in general meetings of companies in which the institutional investor has a large holding compared to the institutional investor's holding in other investee companies. |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or non-applicable |
Explanation of compliance, deviation or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| In addition, institutional investors should report on their website at least once per quarter on whether and, if so, how they have voted as shareholders for each company and voting item. In the report, institutional investors should disclose the key points of the dialogues they have conducted with companies. If an institutional investor votes against a resolution of the management board or abstains from voting on a resolution of the management board, the institutional investor should explain the reasons for its voting behaviour to the management board either pro-actively or at the company's request |
|||
| 4.3.7 | Abstaining from voting in the event of a larger short position than long position. Shareholders will abstain from voting if their short position in the company is larger than their long position. |
N/A |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or non-applicable |
Explanation of compliance, deviation or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| 4.3.8 | Share lending Shareholders should recall their lent shares before the voting record date for a general meeting of the company if the agenda for that meeting includes one or more significant matters. The shareholder should determine what is regarded as a significant matter, but this will include, in any event, resolutions on the agenda of a general meeting: i. that is of strategic importance; ii. where the shareholder disagrees with the resolution of the management board. |
N/A | |
| 4.4 | Recognizing the importance of company strategy Shareholders, including institutional investors, recognize the importance of a strategy focused on sustainable long-term value creation for the company and its affiliated enterprise. |
N/A |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or non-applicable |
applicability | Explanation of compliance, deviation or non | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 4.5 | Issuing depositary receipts for shares Depositary receipts for shares can be a means of preventing a majority (including a chance majority) of shareholders from controlling the decision-making process as a result of absenteeism at a general meeting. Depositary receipts for shares should not be issued as an anti-takeover protective measure. The board of the trust office should issue voting proxies under all circumstances and without limitations to all depositary receipt holders who request this. The holders of depositary receipts so authorized can exercise the voting right at their discretion. The board of the trust |
N/A | ||||
| office should have the confidence of the holders of depositary receipts. Depositary receipt holders should have the possibility of recommending candidates for the board of the trust office. The company should not disclose to the trust office information which has not been made public. |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or non-applicable |
Explanation of compliance, deviation or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| 4.5.1 | Trust office board The board of the trust office should have the confidence of the holders of depositary receipts and operate independently of the company that has issued the depositary receipts. The trust conditions should specify in what cases and subject to what conditions holders of depositary receipts may request the trust office to call a meeting of holders of depositary receipts |
N/A | |
| 4.5.2 | Appointment of board members The board members of the trust office should be appointed by the board of the trust office, after the vacancy has been announced on the website of the trust office. The meeting of holders of depositary receipts may make recommendations to the board of the trust office for the appointment of persons to the position of board member. No management board members or former management board members, supervisory board members or former supervisory board members, employees or permanent advisors of the company should be a member of the board of the |
N/A |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or |
Explanation of compliance, deviation or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| non-applicable | |||
| trust office. | |||
| 4.5.3 | Board appointment period | N/A | |
| A person may be appointed to the board of the trust office for a |
|||
| maximum of two four-year terms, followed by a maximum of two | |||
| two-year terms. In the event of a reappointment after an eight |
|||
| year period, reasons should be given in the report of the board of | |||
| the trust office. | |||
| 4.5.4 | Attendance of the general meeting | N/A | |
| The board of the trust office should attend the general meeting |
|||
| and should, if desired, make a statement about how it proposes | |||
| to vote at the meeting. |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or non-applicable |
Explanation of compliance, deviation or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| 4.5.5 | Exercise of voting rights | N/A | |
| In exercising its voting rights, the trust office should be guided |
|||
| primarily by the interests of the depositary receipt holders, taking | |||
| the interests of the company and the enterprise affiliated with it |
|||
| into account. | |||
| 4.5.6 | Periodic reports The trust office should report periodically, but at least once i. per year, on its activities. The report should be posted on the company's website |
N/A | |
| 4.5.7 | Contents of the reports | N/A | |
| The report referred to in best practice provision 4.5.6 should in any event set out: |
|||
| i. the number of shares for which depositary receipts have been issued and an explanation of changes to this number; |
|||
| ii. the work carried out in the financial year; |
|||
| iii. the voting behaviour in the general meetings held in the financial year; |
|||
| iv. the percentage of votes represented by the trust office |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or |
Explanation of compliance, deviation or non applicability |
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| non-applicable | ||||
| during the meetings referred to in section iii; | ||||
| v. | the remuneration of the members of the board of the | |||
| trust office; | ||||
| vi. | the number of meetings held by the board and the main | |||
| items dealt with in them; | ||||
| vii. | the costs of the activities of the trust office; | |||
| viii. | any external advice obtained by the trust office; | |||
| ix. | the positions or ancillary positions held by the board | |||
| members of the trust office; and | ||||
| x. | the contact details of the trust office. |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or non-applicable |
Explanation of compliance, deviation or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| 4.5.8 | Voting proxies The board of the trust office should issue voting proxies under all circumstances and without limitations to all depositary receipt holders who request this. Each depositary receipt holder may also issue binding voting instructions to the trust office in respect of the shares which the trust office holds on his behalf. |
||
| 5 | ONE-TIER GOVERNANCE STRUCTURE |
||
| 5.1 | One-tier governance structure (principle) The composition and functioning of a board of directors comprising both executive and non-executive directors must be such that the supervision by non-executive directors can be properly carried out and independent supervision is assured., |
✓ Comply |
Board regulations p.2 Background and Applicable Legislation |
| 5.1.1 | Composition of the management board (best practice) The majority of the board of directors is made up of non executive directors. The requirements for independence stipulated in best practice provisions 2.1.7 and 2.1.8 apply to the non-executive directors. |
✓ Comply |
Board regulations p.3 Background and Applicable Legislation; Definitions 'Board', 'management Board', "Non Executive Director", "External Director", "Non External Director", "Independent Director". P. 14 composition of the Board |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or non-applicable |
Explanation of compliance, deviation or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| 5.1.2 | Chairman of the management board (best practice) |
✓ Comply |
Board Regulations p. 20 The Chairperson |
| The chairman of the board of directors chairs the meetings of the board. The chairman of the board of directors should ensure that the board collectively and its committees have a balanced composition and function properly. |
|||
| 5.1.3 | Independence of the chairman of the board of directors (best practice) The chairman of the board of directors should not be an executive director or former executive director of the company and should be independent within the meaning of best practice provision 2.1.8. |
✓ Comply |
Board Regulations p. 20 The Chairperson |
| 5.1.4 | Composition of committees (best practice) The committees referred to in best practice p r o v i s i o n 2.3.2 should c o m p r i s e exclusively of non-executive directors. Neither the AC nor the remuneration committee can be chaired by the chairman of the board of directors or by a former executive director of the company. |
✓ Comply |
Board Regulations p. 26 The Board Committees |
| Ref | Principle or best practice |
Comply, deviate or |
Explanation of compliance, deviation or non applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| non-applicable | |||
| N/A | |||
| 5.1.5 | Accountability for supervision by non-executive directors (best practice) The non-executive directors render account of the supervision exercised in the past financial year. They should, as a minimum, report on the items referred to in best practice provisions 1.1.3, 2.1.2, 2.1.10, 2.2.8, 2.3.5 and 2.4.4 and, if applicable, the items referred to in best practice provisions 1.3.6 and 2.2.2. |
✓ Comply |
Board Regulations p. 6 The powers and duties of the Board of Directors; p. 8 Tasks of Non-Executive Directors and Executive Directors |
Building tools?
Free accounts include 100 API calls/year for testing.
Have a question? We'll get back to you promptly.