AI Terminal

MODULE: AI_ANALYST
Interactive Q&A, Risk Assessment, Summarization
MODULE: DATA_EXTRACT
Excel Export, XBRL Parsing, Table Digitization
MODULE: PEER_COMP
Sector Benchmarking, Sentiment Analysis
SYSTEM ACCESS LOCKED
Authenticate / Register Log In

Fondul Proprietatea

Legal Proceedings Report Mar 30, 2016

2288_rns_2016-03-30_3f9dd873-3b15-4c09-9bf5-482a1e0e9980.pdf

Legal Proceedings Report

Open in Viewer

Opens in native device viewer

To: Bucharest Stock Exchange Financial Supervisory Authority London Stock Exchange

Current report according to Article 113 point A, paragraph (1) letter j) of the Romanian National Securities Commission Regulation no. 1/2006 regarding the issuers and the operations with securities, as subsequently amended and completed, as well as the provisions of Article 99 of the Code of the Bucharest Stock Exchange, Title II, Issuers and Financial Instruments.

Important events to be reported:

Update on all litigations between a litigant and Fondul Proprietatea SA

Franklin Templeton Investment Management Ltd. United Kingdom Bucharest Branch ("the Fund Manager"), in its capacity as sole director and fund manager of Fondul Proprietatea SA ("the Fund"), would like to update shareholders and investors on all ongoing cases between Ioana Sfiraiala (the "Litigant") and the Fund, as set out in the table enclosed as Annex 1 to this report. The Fund Manager notes that, of the four ongoing litigations described in Annex 1, only two pertain to the annulment of shareholders' resolutions and these are in the final appeal phase, having been won in the first instance by the Fund.

In particular, the Fund Manager would like to note that the Bucharest Court announced on 29 March 2016 that it has rejected the Litigant's claim in file no. 16453/3/2013 (retrial phase). The said Litigant's claim targeted the annulment of the shareholders' resolution described in Annex 2 herein. The court's decision is not final, being subject to appeal.

The updated table of all pending files, as well as all closed files with the same Litigant, is available on the Fund's webpage at http://www.fondulproprietatea.ro/sites/default/files/list\of\_pending\ and\_closed\_cases\_with\_is\_29\_march\_2016.pdf.

Franklin Templeton Investment Management Ltd. United Kingdom Bucharest Branch, in its capacity of Sole Director of FONDUL PROPRIETATEA S.A.

Oana Valentina Truța Legal Representative

Report date: 30 March 2016

Name of the issuing entity: Fondul Proprietatea S.A.

Registered office: 78-80 Buzesti St., 7 th floor, district 1, Bucharest, postal code 011017

Phone/fax number: Tel.: + 40 21 200 9600 Fax: + 40 21 200 9631

Sole Registration Code with the Trade Register Office: 18253260

Order number in the Trade Register: J40/21901/2005

Subscribed share capital: RON 9,869,265,720.90

Paid-up share capital: RON 9,541,834,605.90

Number of shares in issue: 10,965,850,801

Number of paid shares: 10,602,038,451

Regulated market on which the issued securities are traded: Shares on Bucharest Stock Exchange

GDRs on London Stock Exchange

FONDUL PROPRIETATEA S.A., a closed-end investment company administrated under a unitary system • Headquarters at: 78-80 Buzesti Street, 7th floor, Bucharest 1st district, postal code 011017, Romania. • Fiscal Identification Code (CIF): 18253260, registered with the Trade Registry under no: J40/21901/2005 • Register on Data Protection Notification Register under number 18668 • Subscribed share capital RON 9,869,265,720.90, Paid-up Share Capital: RON 9,541,834,605.90 • Tel.: + 40 21 200 9600; Fax: +40 21 200 9631; Email: [email protected]; Internet: www.fondulproprietatea.ro

_________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Crt. File number Court The object of the court file Status ANNEX
1
Next hearing
1. File no. 16425/3/2013 Bucharest Court of
Appeal
The file is formed as a result of the legal
action in court initiated by the Fund against
the Litigant, for the recovery of the
damages incurred by the Fund as a result
of the Litigant's actions which delayed
significantly the implementation of the
second buy-back programme approved by
the Shareholders as of 25 April 2012
(please refer to the description of the file
no. 15964/3/2012).
Appeal. Initial decision in favour of
the Fund. The first hearing has
been set for 25 September 2013.
Following the hearing on 25
September 2013 the Court rejected
the suspension request and set a
new hearing for 18 October 2013.
On 18 October 2013, the Court
postponed the hearing for 6
November 2013. On 6 November
2013, the Court postponed the
hearing for 20 November 2013 due
to procedural reasons. On 20
November 2013, the Court decided
to postpone the hearing for 18
December 2013. On 18 December
2013, The Court postponed the
hearing due to procedural reasons.
On 15 January 2014, the Court
postponed the hearing for 12
February 2014. On 12 February
2014 the Court postponed the
hearing for 26 February 2014. On
26 February 2014, the Court
postponed the hearing for 26 March
2014. On 26 March 2014 the Court
postponed the hearing for 7 May
2014. On 7 May 2014 the Court
postponed the hearing for 4 June
2014. On 18 June 2014 was the
last hearing and a decision is
expected on 2 July 2014. On 2 July
2014 the Court ruled partially in
favour of the Fund:
the Court
ascertained that the abuse of
procedural rights performed by the
Litigant against the Fund is a three
folded one characterized by the
following:
13 April 2016

FONDUL PROPRIETATEA S.A., a closed-end investment company administrated under a unitary system • Headquarters at: 78-80 Buzesti Street, 7th floor, Bucharest 1st district, postal code 011017, Romania. • Fiscal Identification Code (CIF): 18253260, registered with the Trade Registry under no: J40/21901/2005 • Register on Data Protection Notification Register under number 18668 • Subscribed share capital RON 9,869,265,720.90, Paid-up Share Capital: RON 9,541,834,605.90 • Tel.: + 40 21 200 9600; Fax: +40 21 200 9631; Email: [email protected]; Internet: www.fondulproprietatea.ro

_____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

-
The Litigant has filled
various claims with the same
subject and only selectively choose
which ones to continue in court
afterwards;
-
The Litigant has filled
repeated claims within ongoing files
which
were
obviously
not
grounded;
-
The Litigant has filled
repeated
claims
for
engaging
judges' liability without fulfilling
procedural
obligations
(e.g.
payment of stamp duties).
It is to be noted that the Court ruled
also that the abuse in the forms
above
mentioned
to
stop
immediately and that such future
abusive actions to be denied. The
Litigant appealed the decision, as
well as the Fund (in this case for
awarding the claimed damages
denied in first instance)
__________________
2. File no. 17692/3/2013 Bucharest Court of
Appeal
Challenging
EGM
Resolution
no.
2/04.04.2012 for amending the Constitutive
Act and EGM Resolution no. 3/25.04.2012
for subscribed share capital decrease and a
request for de-registration with Trade
Registry of these resolutions.
Ongoing (retrial). Initial
decision in
favour
of
the
Fund;
second
decision, first stage also in favour
of the Fund. The first hearing has
been set for 13 June 2013, hearing
when
the
court
rejected
the
Litigant's re-examination request.
The file has been rendered for the
judgment to
continue. The next
hearing has been set for 3 October
2013 when the Court postponed
the hearing due to procedural
reasons for 31 October 2013. On
31 October 2013,
the Court
admitted the intervention request
filed in this file. On 28 November
2013,
the
Court
decided
to
postpone for 5 December 2013 the
decision regarding the objection
raised by the Fund regarding the
right of the Litigant to start such a
case. On 5 December 2013, the
Court rejected the Litigant's request
arguing that the Litigant had no
right to start such a case. The
Litigant filed an appeal and the
Bucharest Court of Appeal set the
first hearing on 27 May 2014. On
30 September 2014 the Court
admitted the appeal and sent the
file for a retrial with the Bucharest
Court. The first hearing in this stage
has been set for 26 February 2015.
On 23 October 2015 the court
announced that it has rejected the
Litigant's claim as ungrounded.
The Litigant filed an appeal and a
hearing in this phase is to be set.
Hearing to be set
__________________
3. File no. 17107/3/2014 Bucharest Court
of
Appeal
Annulment action against:
-
OGM 2/28 April 2014 for the
renewal/extension
of
FTIML
Bucharest Branch mandate;
-
OGM 7/28 April 2014 for the
ratification of OGM Resolutions;
-
EGM 4/28 April 2014 for the
amendment of Article 19 (1) of the
Constitutive Act;
-
EGM 6/28 April 2014 for the
approval of the secondary listing
on London Stock Exchange;
-
EGM 10/28 April 2014 for the
ratification of EGM Resolutions.
Decision in favour of the Fund. First
hearing has been set for 19
September 2014.
On 19 September
2014 the Court postponed the
hearing for 14 November 2014. The
next hearing has been set for 26
January 2015. Next hearing has
been set for 23 February 2015. On
23 February 2015 the Court
postponed the hearing for 9 March
2015. On 9 March 2015 it was the
last hearing in this file and the
Court announced afterwards that it
has rejected the Litigant's claim.
The Litigant filed an appeal. A
hearing is to be set.
Hearing to be set
__________________
4. File no. 692/299/2014 st
1
District Court
House
Legal action filed by the Fund against the
Litigant and her husband for the annulment of
certain legal deeds concluded between them
with an aim of separating the assets between
them; this legal case in relation to the forced
execution initiated by the Fund
against the
Litigant for the recovery of legal fees.
After first procedural hearings, the
next hearing has been set for 10
December 2014. Next hearing has
been set for 28 January 2015. On 28
January
2015
the
Court
has
postponed the hearing for 11 March
2015. On 11 March 2015 the Court
set a new hearing for 22 April 2015. A
new hearing has been set for 17 June
2015. On 17 June 2015 the Court
postponed
the
hearing
for
16
September 2015. Litigant filed a
recusal claim, which was dismissed.
On the last hearing on 23 March
2016, the judge declared that she
abstains. This claim is to be solved
and a new hearing is to be set.
set Next hearing to be

The shareholders' resolution challenged by the Litigant

Annex 2

  • EGM Resolution no. 4/25 April 2012 regarding the approval of the buy-back programme;
  • EGM Resolution no. 5/25 April 2012 regarding the ratification of EGM Resolutions no. 1 and 2 of 6 September 2010;
  • EGM Resolution no. 6/25 April 2012 regarding the approval of EGM Resolutions no. 1 and 2 of 6 September 2010;
  • EGM Resolution no. 7/25 April 2012 regarding the ratification of EGM Resolutions;
  • EGM Resolution no. 8/25 April 2012 regarding the approval of EGM Resolution;
  • EGM Resolution no. 9/25 April 2012 regarding the ratification of the Articles of Association in the form approved through EGM Resolution no. 1/6 September 2010;
  • EGM Resolution no. 10/25 April 2012 regarding the approval of the Articles of Association in the form approved through EGM Resolution no. 1/6 September 2010;
  • OGM Resolution no. 9/25 April 2012 regarding the approval of the annual report;
  • OGM Resolution no. 11/25 April 2012 regarding the ratification of OGM Resolutions no. 8 and 9 of 6 September;
  • OGM Resolution no. 12/25 April 2012 regarding the approval of OGM Resolutions no. 8 and 9 of 6 September;
  • OGM Resolution no. 13/25 April 2012 regarding the ratification of OGM Resolutions;
  • OGM Resolution no. 14/25 April 2012 regarding the approval of OGM resolutions;
  • OGM Resolution no. 15/25 April 2012 regarding the ratification of the Investment Management Agreement;
  • OGM Resolution no. 16/25 April 2012 regarding the approval of the Investment Management Agreement;
  • OGM Resolution no. 17/25 April 2012 regarding the ratification of all the legal acts of the Fund Manager;
  • OGM Resolution no. 18/25 April 2012 regarding the approval of all the legal acts of the Fund Manager.

_____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ FONDUL PROPRIETATEA S.A., a closed-end investment company administrated under a unitary system • Headquarters at: 78-80 Buzesti Street, 7th floor, Bucharest 1st district, postal code 011017, Romania. • Fiscal Identification Code (CIF): 18253260, registered with the Trade Registry under no: J40/21901/2005 • Register on Data Protection Notification Register under number 18668 • Subscribed share capital RON 9,869,265,720.90, Paid-up Share Capital: RON 9,541,834,605.90 • Tel.: + 40 21 200 9600; Fax: +40 21 200 9631; Email: [email protected]; Internet: www.fondulproprietatea.ro

Talk to a Data Expert

Have a question? We'll get back to you promptly.