Q3 2017 Results
Investor presentation Oslo, 27.10.2017
Our DNA
Vision
The Challenger
Business Idea
This will happen through unique relationships, best in class decision-making and cost effective solutions
Main targets
Cost and quality leadership Profitable growth
Top 3
Values Credible
Open Bold Committed
Values tested in Grenfell Tower situation …walk the talk or…
Grenfell Tower – a human tragedy
As the insurance provider for Royal Borough of Kensington and Chelsea, Protector Forsikring ASA is involved in the tragic fire in Grenfell Tower which occurred 14th of June, 2017.
Our thoughts go out to the people who lived in the building, their families and everyone directly or indirectly involved with this terrible event.
Grenfell Tower Fire Claims Handling – The moment of truth
- Manage claim and client
- Keep legal costs at decent level
- Process is key
- Allign with reinsurance companies
• Proactive and professional communication to involved parties and other stakeholders (brokers)
Grenfell Tower Fire
Status - Property
- London Resilience Team (LRT) and Gold Command (GC) in control of the site
- Building unlikely to be released to RBKC/Protector until April 2018
- All information is secondary or rumors
- LRT has so far focused on stabilizing the building, securing and remove human remains and facilitate the investigations
- The damaged building will be sheeted this autumn, to enable instigations during the winter
- Protector in regular communication with LRT and GC and prepared to handle the site when released
Grenfell Tower Fire Status - Liability
- Victims from the fire have suffered, several with personal injuries and many have lost most of their belongings
- It will take a long time to establish the liability
- RBKC and Protector don't want to wait months or years, victims in focus
- RBKC and Protector working together on schemes to assist and help the victims
- Tenants' contents scheme is ongoing
- Received positive feed back from claimants and their lawyers
- Victim rehabilitation scheme special medical needs
- Corpore and The Grove (PTSD-treatment), acknowledged suppliers
Grenfell Tower Fire
Risk Mangement/Underwriting
- Protector tower block exposure analysed
- Identified 604 high rise buildings
- Working closely with our clients
- 210 properties flagged for further inspection
- 54 with high priority
- 96% of high priority inspections completed
- 5 buildings (9 %) had ACM cladding
- 52 % had non-combustible cladding and 39 % had no cladding
- We are advising clients with tower block exposure on fire safety
- Medium to low priority inspections on-going
- Preliminary post Grenfell Risk Management report will be completed ultimo 2017
Inspection examples
Grenfell Tower Fire
Risk Mangement/Underwriting
- RBKC UW walk through UW well done
- UW/RM credibility has been rebuild with reinsurers and brokers
- UW improvements post Grenfell Tower tragedy
- Technical training provided to UWs by Risk Engineers
- Good and bad RM of tower blocks what to avoid
- Introduced tower block evaluations in our UW procedures
- Street view of all high rises, first hand inspections on flagged properties, exposure benchmark model
- Created a new set of pre-quote questions
- To fully understand any tower block exposure
- Compiled all our high rise properties into one document and created a risk management matrix
| No. Tower |
No. Units |
Avg. No. |
Total |
Average |
Maximum |
Total Sums |
Flagged for |
No. |
$\boldsymbol{\kappa}$ |
% High |
% Med |
% Low |
|
Street |
| Blocks |
|
of Units |
Storeys |
Storeys |
Storeys |
Insured |
Inspection Inspected |
|
Inspected |
Inspected |
|
|
Inspected Inspected StreetViewed |
Viewed % |
| 115 |
6,087 |
53 |
991 |
9 |
22 |
437,999,096 |
51 |
24 |
47% |
100% |
40% |
0% |
115 |
100% |
| 131 |
3.140 |
24 |
1.265 |
10 |
27 |
985.729.757 |
45 |
9 |
20% |
90% |
0% |
0% |
131 |
100% |
| 26 |
1.815 |
70 |
278 |
11 |
13 |
321.164.454 |
11 |
11 |
100% |
100% |
N/A |
N/A |
26 |
100% |
| 184 |
7,680 |
42 |
1.496 |
8 |
22 |
1.360.827.445 |
48 |
3 |
6% |
100% |
0% |
O 3 |
184 |
100% |
| 50 |
3,215 |
64 |
484 |
10 |
19 |
432,765,367 |
22 |
٥ |
0% |
N/A |
0% |
O 2 |
50 |
100% |
| 7 |
548 |
78 |
81 |
12 |
17 |
89,796,697 |
|
2 |
100% |
100% |
N/A |
N/A |
7 |
100% |
|
603 |
86 |
119 |
17 |
22 |
61,548,237 |
|
|
20% |
100% |
0% |
0% |
|
100% |
| Δ |
229 |
57 |
68 |
17 |
17 |
24.208.910 |
|
|
100% |
100% |
N/A |
N/A |
|
100% |
|
|
|
|
|
٠ |
|
|
|
|
N/A |
N/A |
N/A |
|
N/A |
| 17 |
1,041 |
61 |
298 |
18 |
32 |
210,869,021 |
|
n |
0% |
N/A |
N/A |
O 2 |
17 |
100% |
| 15 |
1.305 |
87 |
250 |
17 |
25 |
199,964,035 |
11 |
|
45% |
100% |
0% |
0% |
15 |
100% |
| 12 |
861 |
72 |
204 |
17 |
23 |
107.338.030 |
9 |
|
78% |
88% |
0% |
N/A |
12 |
100% |
|
484 |
121 |
24 |
6 |
6 |
83,730,146 |
|
|
|
N/A |
N/A |
N/A |
|
100% |
|
685 |
98 |
89 |
13 |
13 |
52,801,000 |
|
|
|
N/A |
N/A |
N/A |
|
100% |
|
259 |
86 |
40 |
13 |
14 |
29,075,000 |
|
|
|
N/A |
N/A |
N/A |
|
100% |
|
50 |
50 |
7 |
7 |
7 |
4,005,670 |
|
|
|
N/A |
N/A |
N/A |
|
100% |
| 21 |
1.060 |
50 |
228 |
11 |
17 |
92.498.000 |
|
|
|
N/A |
N/A |
N/A |
21 |
100% |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| 604 |
29,062 |
48 |
5,922 |
10 |
32 |
4,494,320,863 |
210 |
66 |
31% |
96% |
11% |
0% |
604 |
100% |
| 604 |
29,062 |
48 |
5,922 |
10 |
32 |
4,494,320,863 |
210 |
66 |
31% |
96% |
11% |
0% |
604 |
100% |
|
|
. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
. |
|
|
|
|
|
Protector's High Rise Exposure Overview Matrix, names anonymized
Grenfell Tower Fire Reinsurance
- Claims handling involvement and support
- Align reinsurance with Risk Management, UW and renewal season
- UK Casualty Reinsurance contract renewal completed acceptable terms
- Challenging process also because "Ogden returned with a potential change in discount rate"
- 8 out 10 reinsurers in the casualty panel still on board
- Good dialogue and involvement from Reinsurers
- Our credibility amongst reinsurers are strong
Grenfell Tower Fire Media/Communication
• Reactive and open
- On the spot and credible
- No media advisor all requests handled internally
- We are in the periphery
- Focus on the claims handling process
- Presentations held in Oslo, Copenhagen, Stockholm and Helsinki
- Good reception in broker society
- Sverre Bjerkeli Keynote speaker at Post Claims summit in London
- Claims handling and Grenfell in focus
- 120 Claim handlers present
UK Summary Ahead of schedule, more expertise on board
Q3 2017 Results
Investor presentation Oslo, 27.10.2017
Highlights Q3 2017 results
56,3 % growth – Combined ratio on track
- Grenfell Tower gross reserves increased to £75m
- GWP growth of 56,3% (57,0 % local currency)
- Gross cost ratio 7,3% (9,1%)
- Net Combined ratio 93,3% (97,1%)
- Operating profit before tax of NOK 149,1m (NOK 170,5m)
- Investment return NOK 114,9m or 1,2 %
- Solvency ratio of 192,5 %, prepared for growth in 2018-2020
- Protector assigned BBB+ rating from A.M. Best
- UK Casualty Reinsurance contract renewal completed acceptable terms
Guiding unchanged since CMD 22.08.2017
Guiding unchanged since CMD 22.08.2017 Net combined ratio 92% Volume growth 22% (24% local) Cost ratio <7%
Gross written premiums Q3 2017 YTD growth 18,9 %
- GWP total NOK 645,1m up 56,3%
- Strong growth in Norway ex COI and Sweden (NOK 144,6m)
- Largest client ever on board 01.07.2017
- Growth in UK materializing
- On schedule to 22 % growth in 2017
| Business unit |
Q3 17 NOK m |
Q3 16 NOK m |
YTD 17 NOK m |
YTD 16 NOK m |
Q3 NOK % growth |
YTD NOK % growth |
| Norway Commercial & Public sector |
232,6 |
149,0 |
1.328,4 |
1.252,8 |
56,1 % |
6,0 % |
Change of Ownership (COI) |
158,9 |
137,7 |
434,8 |
411,6 |
15,4 % |
5,7 % |
| Sweden |
165,7 |
104,7 |
939,3 |
737,1 |
58,2 % |
27,4 % |
| Denmark |
41,0 |
19,4 |
668,0 |
609,0 |
111,1 % |
9,7 % |
| UK |
41,2 |
3,2 |
198,3 |
13,2 |
1184,6 % |
1404,2 % |
| Finland |
5,6 |
-1,3 |
54,1 |
23,1 |
-514,8 % |
134,2 % |
| Group |
645,1 |
412,8 |
3.623,0 |
3.046,7 |
56,3 % |
18,9 % |
Claims development Q3 2017
Grenfell Tower reserves increased
- Grenfell Tower reserves adjusted to £75m up from £50m
- Gross claims ratio 108,3%, up from 93,9%
- Net claims ratio 86,2%, down from 89,4%
- Net impact of Grenfell Tower reserve adjustment is 0
- Q3 run-off losses f.o.a amounted to NOK 29,9m or 4,0%
-
YTD run-off gains f.o.a. NOK 5,6m or 0,3 %
-
GDPR Compliance in focus prepare in due time
-
Inception date GDPR 25.05.2018
-
Gross cost ratio 7,3%, down from 9,1%
- Net cost ratio 7,1%, down from 7,7%
- Cost on a normal, very low level
- Volume in UK & FI gradually kicking in, will lead to scalability and cost improvements
• Full-time employees 294 up from 269
Commercial and Public sector Norway Excellent volume growth - Largest client ever on board July 1st
- Volume up 56,1 %
- Good hit ratio both on volume and number of wins
- Renewal rate of 97 %
- Higher price increases than last three years will be implemented 01.01.2018
- Continued rate pressure for a long time reduces profitability
- Strong team ready for "hunting season"
- One large affinity renewal confirmed, January 1st inception
Change of ownership insurance (COI)
Real estate prices cooling down
- Number of open claims historically low again
- OK volume development
- Court results slightly improved in Q3
- 45 % 16 % 39 % (win, draw, losses)
- Very strong recourse results
- ProTakst (iPad-app) for technical surveys launched in H1
- Market penetration is difficult but…
- …very good feedback from users
- … and new technical company "on board" from Q4
- Winner of Cultural Lead 2017
- Internal award for living our DNA; The Challenger
Management Training & Cultural Development
Cultural development
Culture eats strategy for breakfast
Vision
The Challenger
Business Idea
solutions
Main targets
Cost and quality leadership
Profitable growth
Top 3
Values
Merete C. Bernau Director of Change of Ownership insurance & Head of HR
Committed
Protector Profile
Medarb Qx 1x
Leder Qx 1x
18 months management training program
Tools, mangement training and cultural development
|
|
2017 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
2018 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Jan |
Feb |
Mar |
Apr |
May |
Jun |
Jul |
Aug |
Sep |
Oct |
Nov |
Dec |
Jan |
Feb |
Mar |
Apr |
May |
Jun |
Jul |
Aug |
Sep |
Oct |
Comment |
Next Level Events Next Level - Track 2 |
|
Lysebu |
3/2-5/2 |
|
|
7/6 Oslo 8/6 |
|
|
|
|
24/10 Oslo |
|
|
25/1-26/1 Oslo |
|
|
|
|
14/6 (TBD) |
|
17/8-19/8 (TBD) |
|
Central (orange) & Local (blue) events |
Local follow ups (all) |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| UK Mgmt. training |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Dates and scope TBD |
22
Next level themes
Q3 2017 results continued
Sweden Another good quarter
- Volume up 58,2 % (57,6 % LCY)
- Very good hit-ratio (43%)
- Gross combined ratio of 85,9 % (81,5 % )
- Gross combined YTD 95,0 %
- Net combined ratio of 88,8 % (86,5 %)
- Net combined YTD 86,0 %
- Good momentum in all teams and all personnel contribute to create results
Denmark Good volume development in a small quarter
- Volume up 111,1 % (116,7 % LCY)
- Renewal rate 92 %
- New volume both from Commercial and Public sector
- Gross combined ratio of 90,8 % (151,3 % )
- Gross combined YTD 99,6 %
- Net combined ratio of 97,9 % (146,3 %)
- Net combined YTD 101,7 %
- Claims Ratio Workers comp. still too high and above 100%
- Other lines performing well
- Poor volume start on Q1 2018
Finland Small quarter, insignificant figures
Profit & loss Q3 2017 Profitable growth continues
| [1.000.000 NOK] |
|
Q3 2017 |
Q3 2016 |
YTD 2017 |
YTD 2016 |
FY 2016 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| Gross premiums written |
|
645,1 |
412,8 |
3.623,0 |
3.046,7 |
3.439,0 |
Q3 growth 56,3 %, YTD 18,9 % |
| Gross premiums earned |
|
1.022,2 |
825,9 |
2.808,1 |
2.481,8 |
3.250,4 |
|
| Gross claims incurred |
|
(1.106,6) |
(775,5) |
(3.152,9) |
(2.264,7) |
(3.005,0) |
|
| Earned premiums, net of reinsurance |
|
749,6 |
692,3 |
2.217,6 |
2.044,3 |
2.669,0 |
|
| Claims incurred, net of reinsurance |
|
(646,0) |
(618,8) |
(1.980,0) |
(1.907,8) |
(2.540,4) |
|
| Net commission income |
|
2,3 |
8,6 |
122,1 |
128,2 |
118,5 |
|
| Operating expenses |
|
(55,7) |
(62,0) |
(146,9) |
(125,9) |
(167,0) |
|
| Other income/costs |
|
(15,9) |
(10,3) |
(44,3) |
(17,4) |
(38,3) |
|
| Net financial income |
|
114,9 |
160,7 |
257,5 |
349,3 |
499,3 |
Q3 ROI 1,2 % , YTD 3% |
| Profit before tax |
|
149,1 |
170,5 |
426,0 |
470,6 |
541,1 |
|
| Tax |
|
(23,1) |
(27,3) |
(83,6) |
(87,0) |
(88,4) |
|
| Profit before components of comprehensive income |
|
126,0 |
143,2 |
342,4 |
383,6 |
452,7 |
|
| Comprehensive income incl. tax |
|
(13,4) |
(9,6) |
16,2 |
(17,6) |
(3,4) |
|
| Profit for the period |
|
112,6 |
133,6 |
358,6 |
366,0 |
449,3 |
|
Claims ratio, net of ceded business Expense ratio, net of ceded |
(1) |
86,2% |
89,4 % |
89,3% |
93,3 % |
95,2 % |
|
| business |
(2) |
7,1% |
7,7 % |
1,1% |
-0,1 % |
1,8 % |
|
| Combined ratio, net of ceded |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| business |
(3) |
93,3% |
97,1 % |
90,4% |
93,2 % |
97,0 % |
|
| Gross claims ratio |
(4) |
108,3% |
93,9 % |
112,3% |
91,3 % |
92,5 % |
|
| Gross expense ratio |
(5) |
7,3% |
9,1 % |
7,3% |
6,7 % |
6,8 % |
World leading cost ratio |
| Gross combined ratio |
(6) |
115,5% |
103,0 % |
119,6% |
98,0 % |
99,2 % |
|
| Retention rate |
(7) |
73,3% |
83,8 % |
79,0% |
82,4 % |
82,1 % |
|
| Earnings per share |
(8) |
1,46 |
1,66 |
3,97 |
4,45 |
5,25 |
|
Balance sheet Q3 2017
SCR 192,5 % based on standard formula
| [1.000.000 NOK] |
30.09.2017 |
30.09.2016 |
31.12.2016 |
| Owner-occupied property |
13,6 |
13,6 |
13,7 |
| Financial assets |
9.298,4 |
7.568,0 |
7.547,0 |
| Derivatives |
6,0 |
20,0 |
1,3 |
| Bank deposits |
268,1 |
127,0 |
204,3 |
| Other assets |
2.776,9 |
1.167,0 |
1.091,7 |
| Total assets |
12.362,9 |
8.895,6 |
8.858,0 |
| Total equity |
2.433,3 |
2.184,9 |
2.268,2 |
| Subordinated loan capital |
1.243,3 |
645,9 |
645,9 |
| Total reserves |
7.364,9 |
5.360,0 |
5.148,0 |
| Derivatives |
6,1 |
0,2 |
2,9 |
| Other liabilities |
1.315,3 |
704,6 |
793,1 |
| Total equity and liabilities |
12.362,9 |
8.895,6 |
8.858,0 |
- SCR coverage ratio 192,5% pr. 30.09
- SCR fully covered by Tier 1 capital only
- Full Tier 2 utilization; some Tier 1 restricted capacity
- As stated at CMD, the board will most likely not propose distribution of dividends for the fiscal year
2017 to the general meeting, to further strengthen the balance sheet and support growth in the UK
Solvency II
Composition of SCR:
- Net insurance risk 51%
- Net market risk 38%
- Other risks 11%
Available SII capital:
- Assumed no dividend
- Guarantee provision subtracted from own
funds
Available SII capital
Core Business -Investments
Investments Net financial assets will pass 10 bn. in January 2018
Equity portfolio statistics
| Key Figures |
In-house Managed Portfolio |
OSEBX |
| Performance |
129,5 % |
37,2 % |
| Dividend yield |
2,4 % |
3,7 % |
| P/E NTM* |
15,9 |
16,4 |
3 yr sales CAGR |
23,2 % |
4,3 % |
3 yr EPS CAGR |
32,9 % |
-5,7 % |
*Factset estimates except for one company not listed where own estimates are used
- Extreme outperformance in period
- Comfortable with periods of underperformance as long as underlying performance is good
- Goal to beat market over time
Performance – In-house managed equity portfolio vs. benchmarks (08.10.2014 – 30.09.2017)
In-House bond portfolio statistics
| Portfolio data 30.09.2017 |
|
| Size NOK m |
6 635 |
| Yield |
2,2% |
| Duration |
0,4 |
| Credit duration |
3,2 |
Average rating |
A 1 |
1Average rating based on official and Protector rating
- Navigating in a low yielding market
- Noteworthy risk reduction in 2017
- Lower risk than crossover bond funds avg.
- Similar risk to avg. BBB+ rating bond funds
- Significant outperformance in the period
- Goal to beat benchmark over time
Performance – In-house managed bond portfolio vs. benchmark (31.03.2015 – 30.09.2017)1,2,3
1Crossover fund benchmark consist of: Storebrand Rente +, Arctic Return Class I, Carnegie Corp. Bond, Handelsbanken Høyrente, Holberg Kreditt, Pareto Høyrente, Alfred Berg Income, Eika Kreditt, Landkreditt Høyrente
2BBB+ rating benchmark consist of: Storebrand Rente +, Arctic Return Class I, Carnegie Corp. Bond, Handelsbanken Høyrente, Pareto Høyrente, Alfred Berg Income, Nordea OMF likviditet
3 Protector graph adjusted for the difference between NIBOR, STIBOR and CIBOR from February and March '17 when portfolios were created in Sweden and Denmark, respectively
Q3 investment results
Continued risk reduction in fixed income portfolio
Shareholder's matters
Per 30.09.2017
| Shareholder |
No. Shares |
Percent |
| STENSHAGEN INVEST AS |
6.550.000 |
7,6 % |
| ODIN NORDEN |
4.485.857 |
5,2 % |
| SWEDBANK ROBUR SMABOLAGSFOND |
3.963.756 |
4,6 % |
| OJADA AS |
3.563.116 |
4,1 % |
| HVALER INVEST AS* |
3.186.809 |
3,7 % |
| STATE STREET BANK AND TRUST COMP |
2.459.967 |
2,9 % |
| ARTEL AS |
1.873.451 |
2,2 % |
| SWEDBANK ROBUR NORDENFON |
1.800.000 |
2,1 % |
| VEVLEN GÅRD AS |
1.650.000 |
1,9 % |
| FROGNES AS |
1.649.916 |
1,9 % |
| VERDIPAPIRFONDET DNB NORGE (IV) |
1.624.461 |
1,9 % |
| JOHAN VINJE AS |
1.437.841 |
1,7 % |
| SKANDINAVISKA ENSKILDA BANKEN AB |
1.430.000 |
1,7 % |
| GENERALI PANEUROPE LTD -GP11940006 |
1.413.350 |
1,6 % |
| BNP PARIBAS SECURITIES SERVICES |
1.372.405 |
1,6 % |
| AVANZA BANK AB |
1.315.207 |
1,5 % |
| NORDNET BANK AB |
1.290.522 |
1,5 % |
| PETROSERVICE AS |
1.283.815 |
1,5 % |
| MP PENSJON PK |
1.245.379 |
1,4 % |
| AWILHELMSEN SPECIAL OPPORTUNITIES |
1.152.000 |
1,3 % |
| 20 LARGEST |
44.747.852 |
51,9 % |
| OTHERS |
41.407.753 |
48,1 % |
| TOTAL SHARES |
86155605 |
100,0 % |
*CEO, Sverre Bjerkeli
Related parties shareholding
- Management's direct and indirect shareholding totals 3,5m shares or 4,0% of current outstanding shares
- Board members directly own a total of 11,1m shares or 12,9% of current outstanding shares
- Protector owns a total of 1303 own shares
¹ Share price adjusted for dividends, no reinvestment of dividends Data pr. 30.06.2017
Summary Q3 2017 56,3 % growth – Combined ratio on track
- GWP growth of 56,3% (57,0 % local currency)
- On track 22 % growth
- Net Combined ratio 93,3% (97,1%)
- YTD combined 90,4 %
- Solvency ratio of 192,5 %, prepared for growth in 2018-2020
Guiding unchanged since CMD 22.08.2017
| Net combined ratio |
92% |
| Volume growth |
22% (24% local) |
| Cost ratio |
<7% |
- UK Casualty Reinsurance contract renewal completed acceptable terms
- Strong volume growth expected in Q4
Q3 2017 Results
Q&A
Key ratio description
Ratio
- (1) Claims ratio, net of ceded business
- (2) Expense ratio, net of ceded business
- (3) Combined ratio, net of ceded business
- (4) Gross claims ratio
- (5) Gross expense ratio
- (6) Gross combined ratio
- (7) Retention rate
- (8) Earnings per share
- (9) Return on Equity (ROE)
- (10) Return on Solvency Capital
Ratio calculation
- (1) Claims incurred, net of reinsurance in % of earned premiums, net of reinsurance
- (2) Operating expenses in % of earned premiums, net of reinsurance
- (3) Net claims ratio + net expense ratio
- (4) Gross claims incurred in % of gross premiums earned
- (5) Sales and administration costs in % of gross premiums earned
- (6) Gross claims ratio + gross expense ratio
- (7) Earned premiums, net of reinsurance in % of gross earned premiums
- (8) Profit before other comprehensive income divided by weighted number of shares
- (9) Profit before other comprehensive income divided by average shareholder's equity
- (10) Profit before changes in security provisions less tax divided by sum of average shareholder's equity and security reserves