Annual Report • Dec 6, 2023
Annual Report
Open in ViewerOpens in native device viewer
FOR THE YEAR ENDED 30 SEPTEMBER 2023
Foresight Sustainable Forestry Company Plc ("FSF") is the first and only UK listed investment trust focused on UK forestry, afforestation and natural capital. FSF was awarded the London Stock Exchange's Green Economy Mark at IPO.
In December 2022, FSF became the first fund to be accredited with the London Stock Exchange's Voluntary Carbon Market designation.
COVER IMAGE: Frongoch, Wales
Highly Winner Winner
OVERVIEW STRATEGIC REPORT GOVERNANCE FINANCIAL Strategy Performance
| About us | IFC |
|---|---|
| Highlights | 2 |
| Investment case | 3 |
| Business model | 4 |
| Geographic footprint | 5 |
| Chair's statement | 6 |
| The Investment Manager | 10 |
|---|---|
| Key performance indicators | 11 |
| Stakeholder engagement (Section 172) | 13 |
| Our markets | 17 |
| Investment Manager's report | 22 |
| Operational review | 24 |
| Sustainability and ESG | 33 |
| TCFD and emissions reporting | 38 |
| Risk and risk management | 39 |
| Financial review | 46 |
| Alternative performance measures ("APMs") 50 |
| Board of Directors | 52 |
|---|---|
| Board leadership and company purpose | 53 |
| Division of responsibilities | 55 |
| Report of the Audit and Risk Committee | 56 |
| Report of the Management Engagement Committee |
60 |
| Report of the Sustainability and ESG Committee |
62 |
| Report of the Nomination and Remuneration Committee |
64 |
| Directors' remuneration report | 68 |
| Directors' report | 71 |
| Directors' responsibilities statement | 79 |
| Independent auditor's report | 81 |
|---|---|
| Statement of comprehensive income | 88 |
| Statement of financial position | 89 |
| Statement of changes in equity | 90 |
| Statement of cash flows | 91 |
| Notes to the audited financial statements 92 | |
| Company summary | 107 |
| Advisers | 108 |
| Glossary of terms | 109 |
| Appendix one | 111 |
Chair's statement 6 Business model 4
NET ASSET VALUE ("NAV")1 (30 September 2022: £180.6m)
NAV PER SHARE1 (30 September 2022: 105.0p)
TOTAL NAV RETURN FROM IPO1 (30 September 2022: 7.0%)2
IN THE PORTFOLIO (30 September 2022: 9,618 hectares)
TIMBER ANTICIPATED TO BE HARVESTED IN 2024 PROGRAMME (30 September 2022: c.26,000 tonnes)
LAND NEWLY PLANTED OR IN AFFORESTATION DEVELOPMENT (30 September 2022: 3,917 hectares3)
TOTAL TREES PLANTED SINCE IPO
£2.7 million VALUE ASCRIBED TOWARDS CREATION OF CARBON CREDITS4
(30 September 2022: £0.6m)
1. Alternative performance measures ("APMs") have been included to better reflect the Group's underlying activities. Whilst appreciating that APMs are not considered to be a substitute for, or superior to, IFRS measures, the Company believes their selected use may provide stakeholders with additional information, which will assist in their understanding of the business. Further information is available on page 50.
OVERVIEW STRATEGIC REPORT GOVERNANCE FINANCIAL
Strategy Performance
| The Company invests in a portfolio of UK afforestation (woodland creation) and forestry assets to increase the UK's |
Growing real assets |
Attractive asset class |
Portfolio diversification |
Inflation protection |
Fight against climate change |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| sustainable timber supply. The Company targets the generation of attractive risk-adjusted total returns through land capital appreciation, sustainable timber and carbon credits sales. |
Trees continue to grow and appreciate in value regardless of macroeconomic conditions. |
UK commercial forestry has historically outperformed the Consumer Price Index ("CPI") on a long-term basis. Until FSF, it has had high barriers to entry. |
UK forestry is uncorrelated to traditional and alternative assets (including UK power prices) underpinned by biological tree growth which occurs regardless of the economic cycle. |
Underpinned by a global shortage of sustainable timber, amplified in the UK as one of Europe's least forested countries. |
The Company will make a direct contribution to the twin fights against climate change and biodiversity loss. |
| The Company's newly planted trees additionally and permanently remove carbon dioxide from the atmosphere, making a |
36 sites with development phase afforestation projects, covering 4,503 hectares |
First UK-listed investment trust focused on natural capital |
Uncorrelated to equities and bonds |
UK commercial forestry has strong inflation-protection characteristics over the long term |
63,954 tCO2e carbon sequestered by the portfolio since IPO |
| direct contribution to the fight against climate change. Additionally, the Company has a stated objective to protect and enhance biodiversity across its portfolio. |
c.1.4m trees planted since IPO |
85% increase in the value of six afforestation properties developed |
12 545 , hectares managed |
CPI +5% target per annum over a rolling five-year basis |
843 hectares in the portfolio which is long-term, mixed broadleaf woodland |
| Read more about the Company's business model on page 4. Statistics as at 30 September 2023. |
Read more about risk management on pages 39 to 45. prevention and air purification.
Read more about governance on pages 51 to 79.
OVERVIEW STRATEGIC REPORT GOVERNANCE FINANCIAL Strategy Performance
Fordie Estate
Located in Perthshire, Scotland, Fordie
5
Richard Davidson Chair
deployed into 18 properties
1.4m trees planted (since inception) 35,081 tCO₂e sequestration
For year ended 30 September 2023 unless stated
On behalf of the Board, I am pleased to present the Company's audited Annual Report and Financial Statements for the year ended 30 September 2023. FSF's two-year journey since IPO has been full of positive milestones and I am pleased that the Company has weathered a challenging period while building our forestry and afforestation portfolio and establishing FSF as a genuine pioneer in the sustainable investment space.
During the year, financial markets have grappled with issues ranging from inflation and higher interest rates to uncertainty and widening discounts in the investment trust sector. Against this backdrop, we have seen volatility in our share price and Net Asset Value ("NAV") as described below in this statement but we have continued to invest in our portfolio, plant trees, harvest sustainable timber and sequester carbon.
I would like to take this opportunity to reiterate the goals of FSF. Forestry is a long-term business where cycles are measured in decades rather than quarters.
Our purpose is to generate financial returns for our Shareholders through investing in a diversified portfolio of UK afforestation and forestry properties. Operating across the UK, our actions are guided by our commitment to long-term value creation and sustainability.
Over our 2022/23 year, FSF has added 18 new properties to its portfolio, a total of 2,929 hectares. Our current planting pipeline is material in a national context and is equivalent, once planted, to one-third of the total amount of tree planting that the entire UK achieved in the year to March 2023. We have already acquired six sites which are due for planting in 2025 adding to our material 2023 and 2024 planting plans.
FSF invests for the long term. However, the Board is currently acutely aware that the Company's shares have fallen and moved to a discount to NAV over the last six months. The share price move during the period aligns with the broader pattern in the real assets investment trust sector, which has shown a notable sensitivity to higher interest rates.
Our share price, at the time of writing, stands at a low since our IPO of 59.8 pence. Having traded in a 100-110 pence range for most of the year, our stock moved down sharply from June onwards (despite a positive first half NAV announcement) as the dam burst on many investment trust share prices, especially real assets.
The share price is, of course, not controlled by the Board and over the long term we believe it will return to levels that reflect the development of the Company's NAV and the Company's outlook and prospects more generally in its core markets of land, natural capital, timber and voluntary carbon.
I would like to emphasise a few points:
FSF is invested for the long term and doing what it set out to do at IPO.
Our 2022/23 financial year has been the clichéd game of two halves. In the six months to 31 March 2023, we delivered a NAV gain of 3.3%, particularly helped by completion of planting at four afforestation properties and an upward revaluation (by Savills, our independent valuer) to our planting land portfolio. The second half to 30 September 2023 saw a downwards move in our NAV by 9.3% as the number of transactions in, and prices for, forestry and planting land slowed significantly.
The combination of these different environments means that in the full year to 30 September 2023, the Company generated a total NAV loss of 6.3% (30 September 2022: +7.0%) and a NAV decrease of £11.4 million to £169.2 million (30 September 2022: £180.6 million).
NAV per Ordinary Share fell to 98.4 pence (30 September 2022: 105.0 pence). Within this overall NAV number I would highlight the split between the progression of valuations in established forestry and our planting portfolio. Whilst afforestation values (excluding carbon) decreased by 11.2% during the year, established forestry values were relatively resilient, decreasing by a lesser figure of 6.5%, which means the opportunity for FSF to secure development value through a disciplined purchasing strategy has actually improved. The combination of increasing inflation and interest rates along with the phased withdrawal of the Basic Payment Scheme ("BPS"), the main farming subsidy regime, has led to a weakening of the planting land investment market over the last six months.
The Company has continued to acquire afforestation land during the period to take advantage of the softer land prices.
Furthermore, voluntary carbon is becoming an increasingly material part of FSF's NAV, increasing by £2.1 million to £2.7 million during the year. Our intention is to retain the carbon credits that we generate as a long-term source of future income and/or potentially distribute them to those Shareholders who elect to receive them in-specie.
Since the last Annual Report, the Company has deployed a further c.£38.41 million into 18 properties, mainly in Scotland. Of the properties acquired, 15 have afforestation potential and the remainder are established forestry. In many cases, properties are acquired with some assets that we regard as non-core, such as farm buildings. In the period, five sales of non-core assets took place. A full description of our investment activity is provided in the Investment Manager's report.
As our equity funds were fully invested by the spring of 2023, the final acquisitions to complete our 2025 planting portfolio have been funded through the utilisation of the Company's £30 million Revolving Credit Facility ("RCF") which is now £10.4 million drawn. The current acquisition programme is now substantially complete and servicing/repayment of the RCF will be made through a combination of timber harvesting and the planned disposal of non-core or other assets.
It has remained a busy and productive period for operations across the portfolio. I am pleased to report that within the year we planted 472 hectares across four properties. This has brought the total area of the portfolio categorised as Establishment Stage Afforestation to 1,024 hectares, with c.1.4 million trees planted since FSF's inception.
Furthermore, we are currently gearing up for the 2024/2025 planting seasons, in which we plan to deliver a total of 9 million trees planted over an area of c.4,000 hectares. The planting programme is expected to create 1.0-1.2 million voluntary carbon credits.
Despite significant government targets for tree planting in the nations of the UK, delivery has fallen short with only 12,960 hectares of new woodland created in 2022/23. Disappointingly, UK planting actually decreased by 7% year-on-year and the combined nations' target was missed by approximately 17,000 hectares. FSF is committed to narrowing this gap and our planting programme will be one of the largest, if not the largest, planting operations across the UK in 2024.
As a sustainable investing leader we have watched the emergence of concerns around greenwashing. The travails of those companies who have over-inflated their environmental, social and governance ("ESG") credentials has cast a wider shadow over many other companies, good and bad. By investing in and growing trees, FSF is dedicated to actions that make a positive environmental outcome, and offers a transparent and leading approach to sustainability.
Last year, we published our first Sustainability and ESG ("S&ESG") report, which introduced our three key S&ESG objectives and outlined our positive progress against them and many of our KPIs. Notably, the Company's growing portfolio achieved 35,081 tCO2e sequestration from the atmosphere over the period (30 September 2022: 28,873 tCO2e).
Our 2024 planting programme is expected to create around 700 rural jobs and we have now rolled out our Forestry Skills Training programme from Wales into Scotland.
All Shareholders are invited to attend the Company's second Annual General Meeting ("AGM") on 21 February 2024. Details of how Shareholders may participate will be published in the circular accompanying this report, dated 6 December 2023.
Afforestation development is the engine room of the Company's returns and sustainable impact. Our investment policy allows FSF to invest up to 50% of Gross Asset Value into afforestation land and projects. The Board would like to increase the Company's flexibility to invest in new afforestation assets whilst keeping aggregate exposure to development risk within the agreed tolerable threshold.
To make this possible, a proposed amendment to the Company's investment policy will be put to the AGM, such that planted and establishing afforestation schemes are changed from being considered afforestation assets to being considered forestry assets for the purposes of our investment policy.
The change, which acknowledges that afforestation assets become materially de-risked once planting has been achieved, will enable the Company to pursue a fuller rolling programme of afforestation development, and the associated returns and positive impact this affords.
I would like to point Shareholders towards the regulatory news service ("RNS") announcement that will be released at the same time as this Annual Report and Financial Statements which will provide details of the AGM resolutions, including the proposed amendment to the investment policy and an accompanying Circular which provides the rationale for the proposed adjustment.
I would like to thank the Fund Managers, advisers, Shareholders and other members of the Board for contributing to another very busy year. The Board is very aware of the disconnect between our share price and NAV and has been discussing with Shareholders and advisers the potential to close this gap within our commitment to long-term value creation. As Shareholders you should be reassured that no matter what happens to the stock market or the base rate each year, your trees will have grown.
Chair
5 December 2023
FORESIGHT SUSTAINABLE FORESTRY COMPANY PLC Annual Report and Financial Statements 2023 9 ADDITIONAL
OVERVIEW STRATEGIC REPORT GOVERNANCE FINANCIAL Strategy Performance
STATEMENTS
INFORMATION
| STRATEGY | PERFORMANCE | |
|---|---|---|
| THE INVESTMENT MANAGER | 10 | |
| KEY PERFORMANCE INDICATORS | 11 | |
| STAKEHOLDER ENGAGEMENT | ||
| (SECTION 172) | 13 | |
| OUR MARKETS | 17 | |
| PERFORMANCE | |
|---|---|
| INVESTMENT MANAGER'S REPORT | 22 |
| OPERATIONAL REVIEW | 24 |
| SUSTAINABILITY AND ESG | 33 |
| TCFD AND EMISSIONS REPORTING | 38 |
| RISK AND RISK MANAGEMENT | 39 |
| FINANCIAL REVIEW | 46 |
| ALTERNATIVE PERFORMANCE | |
| MEASURES ("APMS") | 50 |
FSF is managed by Foresight Group LLP ("Foresight", "Foresight Group" or "Investment Manager"), an experienced team of investment, forestry and asset management professionals that can draw on the depth and breadth of Foresight Group's networks and resources, managing the day-to-day activities. With a long-established focus on ESG and sustainability-led strategies, it aims to provide attractive returns in hard to access private markets to institutional and private investors.
Foresight Group was founded in 1984 and is a leading listed infrastructure and private equity investment manager. With a long-established focus on ESG and sustainability-led strategies, it aims to provide attractive returns to its institutional and private investors from hard-to-access private markets. Foresight manages over 400 infrastructure assets with a focus on solar and onshore wind assets, bioenergy and waste, as well as renewable energy enabling projects, energy efficiency management solutions, social and core infrastructure projects and sustainable forestry assets. Foresight operates in eight countries across Europe, Australia and the United States with AUM of £12.1 billion1 . Foresight Group Holdings Limited listed on the Main Market of the London Stock Exchange in February 2021 and is a constituent of the FTSE 250 index.
Fund management
Robert Guest Co-Lead, Foresight Sustainable Forestry Company
Richard Kelly Co-Lead, Foresight Sustainable Forestry Company
Julian Elsworth Portfolio Director
Helge Hansen Forestry Portfolio Manager
Murray Aitchison Forestry Portfolio Associate
Christian Tingsgaard Lassen Investment Analyst
OVERVIEW STRATEGIC REPORT GOVERNANCE FINANCIAL Strategy Performance
To invest funds to provide sustainable, risk-adjusted financial returns to our investors.
To deliver and increase the supply of home-grown UK timber to reduce the country's reliance on imports, blending the commercial aspects of forestry (planting, harvesting and the sale
To demonstrate the capital appreciation of afforestation sites once development milestones are met, through carefully considered portfolio construction and management of afforestation development schemes.
To facilitate the flow of capital to climate change mitigation projects and provide our investors with exposure to high-integrity and independently verified carbon credits that can be used for science-based carbon offsetting.
To mobilise our investors' capital into projects that play a key role in tackling climate change, protecting the natural environment and delivering positive impacts for communities
of sustainable timber).
• NAV and NAV per share declined in the 12-month period by 6.3%.
and society.
NAV/NAV per share
(2022: £180.6m/105.0p)
£169.2m/98.4p
12,545 (2022: 9,618)
• Disposal of some non-core assets and re-allocation within the core portfolio to maximise the afforestation development opportunity. Grow portfolio if equity market conditions enable fundraising.
• Lack of future funding impacts the Company's ability to purchase more land (see risk 4 – equity in the principal risk register on page 43).
Real returns and capital appreciation
Access to voluntary carbon credits
| Tonnes of timber in annual harvesting programme c.118,000 (2022: c.26,000) |
Performance in 2022/23 • Softening of timber prices seen since the end of 2022. • Ongoing harvesting at five sites. • Harvesting at several of the highest yielding sites has been postponed until timber prices are considered to have returned to a premium. |
Objectives for 2023/24 • Selective harvesting in 2024 where it results in NAV accretion or there is a good silvicultural reason to pursue the harvesting or to provide cash flow to the Company. |
Principal risks • See risk 7 – demand for timber in the principal risk register on page 44. • The risk that a reduction in demand from the purchasers of timber would negatively impact the Company's profitability. See risk 7 in the principal risk register on page 44. |
|---|---|---|---|
| Total hectares of land in afforestation development 6,455 (2022: 3,917) |
Performance in 2022/23 • Focus on increasing FSF's exposure to afforestation assets over the year. • Overall percentage of the portfolio dedicated to afforestation has risen from 40% to 45% (by value). |
Objectives for 2023/24 • Afforestation development will remain a focus for the Company as a driver of higher valuation and creation of associated carbon credits. |
Principal risks • The risk that there is resistance to change of land use from the public, see risk 9 – reputational in the principal risk register on page 45. |
| Trees planted in the year c.950,000 (2022: c.514,000) |
Performance in 2022/23 • c.1.4 million trees planted since FSF's inception. |
Objectives for 2023/24 • Targeting planting 9 million trees over an area of c.4,000 hectares during the 2024 and 2025 planting seasons. |
Principal risks • Risk that extreme weather events impact trees planted in the year. |
| Value ascribed to progress towards creation of carbon credits £2.7m (2022: £0.6m) |
Performance in 2022/23 • In the period, four afforestation schemes completed planting and FSF has recognised an additional £2.1 million of value ascribed to the creation of carbon credits. |
Objectives for 2023/24 • Targeting to create 1.0-1.2 million PIU carbon credits that are associated with the completion of the planting of 9 million trees over the 2024 and 2025 planting seasons. |
Principal risks • The risk that demand or volume leads to a reduction in demand from the users of carbon credits, see risk 6 – demand for carbon credits in the principal risk register on page 44. |
| Real returns and Link to Fund |
Combat climate change Access to voluntary |
objectives:
capital appreciation
and biodiversity loss
carbon credits
OVERVIEW STRATEGIC REPORT GOVERNANCE FINANCIAL Strategy Performance
The Board is committed to promoting the long-term sustainable success of the Company whilst conducting business in a fair, ethical and transparent manner
The Directors consider that in conducting the business of the Company over the course of the year they have complied with Section 172(1) of the Companies Act 2006 (the "Act") by fulfilling their duty to promote the success of the Company and to act in the way they consider, in good faith, would be most likely to promote the success of the Company for the benefit of the members as a whole, whilst also considering the broad range of stakeholders who interact with and are impacted by the Company's business, especially with regard to major decisions.
The purpose of the Company is to act as an investment company to provide financial returns to its Shareholders taking a long-term view. Investment companies are generally active in the long term and are typically externally managed, have no employees and are overseen by an independent board of Non-Executive Directors. The role of the Investment Manager is particularly important in engaging with stakeholders on behalf of the Company and reporting on developments to the Board and relationships with all service providers are considered in detail at the annual Management Engagement Committee meeting.
The Board recognises that the Company should be run for the benefit of Shareholders, but that the long-term success of a business is dependent on maintaining relationships with stakeholders and considering the external impact of the Company's activities. The Board, with the assistance of the Management Engagement Committee, works closely with the Investment Manager and the Company Secretary in reviewing how stakeholder issues are handled, ensuring good governance and responsibility in managing the Company's affairs, as well as openness in how these are conducted. Through measures such as these the Board embeds a strong culture of governance.
As the Company is externally managed and has no employees, the Board considers the key stakeholders to be Shareholders, local communities closely linked to the portfolio, service providers and lenders, and agents of the Company including the Investment Manager. The Board is acutely aware of its responsibilities to all the stakeholders in the Company and has considered:
Shareholders are the Company's primary stakeholders, and all key Board decisions are carefully considered with their long-term interests in mind. As a public company listed on the LSE, the Company is subject to the Listing Rules and the Disclosure Guidance and Transparency Rules. The Listing Rules include a principle that a listed company must ensure that it treats all holders of the same class of shares that are in the same position equally in respect of the rights attached to such shares. With the assistance of regular discussions with, and formal advice from, the Company's legal adviser, Company Secretary and corporate broker, the Board is kept appraised of developments in corporate governance guidance, reporting standards and other non-statutory provisions and does its best to comply or explain why it does not comply.
The Investment Manager has developed relationships with key Shareholders and prospective investors. During the year, the Investment Manager and the Company's broker held multiple direct engagement sessions with major Shareholders and prospective investors.
OVERVIEW STRATEGIC REPORT GOVERNANCE FINANCIAL
Strategy Performance
The Chair has also met with several Shareholders alongside the Investment Manager. During discussions, Shareholders often ask for additional information pertaining to certain aspects of the Company, such as the factors influencing the Company's NAV, as well as the methodology implemented in calculating it. There has also been interest from Shareholders in visiting sites within the portfolio.
Over the course of the year the Company has hosted several investor site visits and will continue to expand this programme in 2024 (please see page 15 for more details).
The Company, supported by its Investment Manager, communicates with Shareholders through a variety of means and always welcomes their views. This includes the publication of interim and annual accounts, the AGM and regulatory news and bi-annual NAV updates, all published on the Company's website. The Board encourages Shareholders to vote on the resolutions to be proposed at the AGM to be held on 21 February 2024. Investors holding shares through platforms should contact their investment platform directly for guidance on how to cast their vote. An increase in the number of investors who exercise their right to vote will help the Company reflect the views of its Shareholder base.
The Investment Manager is responsible for the implementation of the investment strategy and the day-to-day investment and management decisions, including identifying assets for acquisition. The Board engages constructively with the Investment Manager to ensure the expectations of Shareholders are being met and that it is aware of the challenges being faced, including meeting the long-term objectives for the Company's growth. This ensures that the Company and the Investment Manager have aligned interests to
safeguard the Company's position and to try and ensure the future success of the Company.
The Board regularly reviews the Company's performance against its investment objectives and undertakes an annual strategy review meeting to ensure that the Company is well positioned for the future delivery of its objectives for its Shareholders.
The Board receives presentations from the Investment Manager at every Board meeting to help it to exercise effective oversight of the Company's strategy and the performance of the Investment Manager. The Board, through the Management Engagement Committee, reviews formally the performance of the Investment Manager at least annually.
The Company has a Revolving Credit Facility with Virgin Money (formerly Clydesdale Bank Plc). This facility is subject to covenants and lender consent may be required on certain business decisions. The Investment Manager is in regular contact with Virgin Money to keep it appraised of ongoing portfolio matters and general market updates so that they have a full understanding of the Company and how it is performing.
The Board seeks to maintain constructive relationships with the Company's service providers, which include its corporate broker, legal adviser and its Public Relations agency. This occurs either directly or through the Investment Manager, with regular communications and meetings. The Management Engagement Committee conducts an annual review of the performance and terms and conditions of the Company's main service providers to ensure that they are performing their responsibilities in line with Board expectations and providing value for money.
The Board has placed Sustainability and ESG factors at the heart of its investment objectives to guide the way it operates. The Company's proactive approach to community engagement is applied across the Company's afforestation projects as well as its established forestry and woodland assets. A case study is provided on page 16 that provides further details. Aiming to maximise the Company's societal impact, in partnership with Tilhill Forestry Limited, the Company launched a Forestry Skills Training Programme in Wales last year. Expanding its scope to Scotland in 2023, and likely England in the future, this initiative equips local rural communities with essential skills, qualifications and opportunities for employment within the forestry sector, aligning with the Company's commitment to both community development and sustainable practices underpinning afforestation-related land use change. Completing participants are also offered paid work on the Company's afforestation and forestry properties.
In response to the AIC's call for ESG disclosures, the Company shared its strategy on the AIC
website in 2021. Notably, receiving the LSE's Green Economy Mark at IPO affirmed the Company's dedication to environmental and climate-related objectives. More details on the Company's approach and impact are provided in the S&ESG section of this report on pages 33 to 36.
FSF's LSE Green Economy Mark and Voluntary Carbon Market designations recognise the ongoing environmental stewardship role that FSF has and continues to contribute towards positive environmental objectives including, but not limited to, contributions to mitigating climate change and biodiversity loss.
INFORMATION
FSF hosted its second Investor Day at Fordie Estate in Scotland on 20 September 2023, following a successful event in April 2023. This Investor Day offered Shareholders a comprehensive insight into the Company's forestry and natural capital initiatives. Spanning 2,150 hectares, the mixed afforestation and forestry property at Fordie Estate, a significant asset in FSF's portfolio, served as a showcase of the Company's diverse business model.
Located near Comrie, Scotland, Fordie Estate features various habitats and land uses, supporting diverse ecosystems, biodiversity, socio-economic contributions and commercial timber production.
The event provided attendees with a deeper understanding of FSF's role in promoting sustainable land management.
Investors interacted with key members of the Foresight management team, the Fordie Estate team, and advisory personnel, exchanging perspectives on the Company's practices. This event highlighted FSF's commitment to environmental stewardship and responsible forestry.
Join us for our next investor site visit. Follow this link or visit our website to find out more.
https://www.eventbrite.co.uk/e/foresight-sustainableforestry-company-plc-investor-day-2024-tickets-744438925867?aff=oddtdtcreator
| Date | Event | Fund lead |
|---|---|---|
| 2-Nov | NCIA Policy, Industry and Governance Workstream |
Richard Kelly |
| 10-Nov | Designing the Future – Developing the market for woodland Carbon in the UK |
Robert Guest |
| 10-Nov | AIC Event | Robert Guest |
| 17-Nov | Nature of Scotland Awards | Robert Guest |
| 22-Nov | The UK Forest Market Report |
Richard Kelly, Robert Guest |
| 05-Dec | LSE VCM Launch and Market Open |
Robert Guest and Richard Kelly |
| 17-Mar | LSE Annual Funds Conference |
Robert Guest |
| 16-17 May | Foresight Sustainability Forum |
Josephine Bush (S&ESG Committee Chair), Robert Guest |
| 20-23 June | Royal Highland Show | Robert Guest |
| 26-Sep | UK Investor Virtual Conference |
Richard Kelly |
| 02-Oct | UUET Agreement and meeting |
Robert Guest |
| 03-Oct | Carbon Credits Demystified – Stifel |
Richard Kelly |
| 03-Oct | Fordie Site Visit | Robert Guest |
| 19-Oct | VCM Market Infrastructure Roundtable |
Richard Kelly |
FINANCIAL STATEMENTS INFORMATION
Community engagement has been a key focus of the period with the continual development of the afforestation pipeline.
A townhall meeting either has or will be held for each of FSF's woodland creation schemes, giving local residents the opportunity to view plans and offer comments on the schemes. At Fordie Estate, a community engagement meeting was held in April with representatives of the estate, Foresight and trusted advisers hosting the meeting which was well attended by the community.
A number of open days were held at the estate to allow locals to walk the ground of the planting scheme and gain a better understanding of how the plans sit within the landscape. Many of the comments raised across these sessions have been incorporated into the latest scheme design.
The James Hutton Institute has conducted research into the community impact of green investments in Scotland and Fordie Estate has been a key case study for this work. FSF engaged with the institute to provide their views on land use and change and they also engaged with members of the community directly.
The Upper Urr Environmental Trust was interested in developing a volunteer-led woodland planting and habitat restoration project. FSF has made an agreement with the trust covering 95 hectares, with a formal lease over a portion of the land for this purpose.
Two parcels of land at Frongoch have been sold to the benefit of the local community. One parcel was sold to the local church to extend the community graveyard and the other was sold to Natural Resources Wales, allowing access to harvest an area of diseased trees, removing an eyesore from the picturesque valley.
The establishment of mountain bike trails at Banc Farm has commenced and continues to progress.
The Investment Manager strives to sensitively deal with any objections or concerns that arise in relation to its woodland creation schemes. The regular scheduling of townhall meetings and open days around the planning phase of these schemes aims to inform the local communities of its plans and also to provide a forum for objections to be made. When concerns or issues are raised, the Investment Manager will seek to proactively address these concerns through further education, engagement and, where possible, adaptations to the scheme design.
The UK timber market continues to rely heavily on imports, which account for c.80% of all timber consumed. Further, the UK is the third largest timber importer globally, behind only China and the USA. Total imports for the first seven months of 2023 were 5% less than over the same period in 2022.
Sources: Based on Foresight analysis of market data and Forest Research data (sourced from the UK governmental forest statistic institution). 'Blended Total' comes from Foresight's harvest estimates of each category, which is 58% sawlog, 24% pallet and fencing, 18% chipwood, based on market analysis and thus reflects the real price per tonne.
Top diameter is a measurement dimension that expresses the diameter of a log at its thinnest point, furthest from the butt.
Based on the Investment Manager's estimates of market data.
Timber outputs are divided into the following three categories depending on the top diameter1 .
The last year has seen mixed price signals. UK sawlog prices in Q3 2023 declined by c.7.5% compared to Q3 2022, while fencing prices declined by c.1.4%. Meanwhile, chipwood prices increased by 13.1%. The overall picture shows the blended price for timber has decreased by -4.1% during the year2.
Of the publicly available timber indexes, the Softwood Standing Price Spruce ("SSPI") / All Conifers Index published quarterly by Forest Research is the most comparable to the sawlog price index that is used by the Investment Manager. From Q2 2022 a material deviation between the prices reported in both indexes is observed, which has continued to widen. When analysed, the public SSPI pricing suggests prices have been skewed by the significantly higher volumes of Storm Arwen damaged timber, which has transacted at increasingly discounted prices. Pricing of high quality and undamaged sawlog, as represented in the Investment Manager's index, has demonstrated more resilience.
The UK's economic output has remained subdued during the year. The aftermath of the UK Government's Mini Budget, rising debt costs and a cost-of-living crisis have contributed to reduced demand for UK timber. The CPA forecasts that construction output, a key driver of timber demand, is expected to fall by 7% in 2023 but to grow by 0.3% in 2024. The Investment Manager's view is that domestic demand for sawlog and roundwood will likely remain relatively subdued during the rest of 2023 and 2024. In the Board's and Investment Manager's opinion, we believe there is growing preference towards home-grown timber.
INFORMATION
On the domestic supply side, most of the excess storm damaged timber from Storm Arwen in 2021, representing c.20% of the UK's annual harvest (and c.4% of UK annual demand, given that the country imports c.80% of its needs), is understood to have been processed through the timber supply chain. UK originated timber supply and inventory levels are therefore gradually readjusting to normal levels. The latest UK Forest Market Report on UK commercial timber markets was released on 21 November 2023 and the Investment Manager will utilise this data for future supply market forecasting.
Chipwood prices remained more stable during the year, increasing by 13.1% according to the Investment Manager's Chipwood Price Index. A main factor influencing European markets during the year has been the ongoing conflict in Eastern Europe and the ensuing energy crisis which has driven a surge in both European and UK woodchip demand.
Bioenergy use in the EU increased by over 150% since 2000 and a further increase between 70-150% by 2050 is predicted. Policy developments such as the UK Government's Biomass Strategy seek to generate more bioenergy using sustainable chipwood as fuel, ensuring incentives for sustainable biomass energy. The Investment Manager believes that chipwood demand will remain resilient and has a robust long-term outlook. However, prices will also be influenced by Europe's longer-term ability to secure supplies of liquefied natural gas.
Overall, European supply of softwood is forecast to decline in 2024 which when combined with steady forecast demand is expected to create a slight material supply deficit in Europe. This situation is expected to place slow but steady upward pricing pressure on European timber through the coming year. Key drivers of this movement include the ongoing bark beetle1 crisis (with current damage considered to be nearly 10x larger compared to pre-2000 levels), climate change, and EU legislation. Key contributors to European timber supply such as Germany and Latvia, and countries such as the US, have proved susceptible to such factors.
2023 has been a year where extreme weather patterns have influenced the worldwide timber market. Timber supply disruptions observed in Canada and Germany, for example, have been closely linked to climate change and are expected to materially impact the market. The bark beetle outbreak addressed previously in this report is closely linked with the droughts brought on by climate change. As global temperatures change, new emerging risks for key timber geographies will require due attention by managers.
Positively, UK forestry has been assessed as relatively climate resilient, with a climactically wetter and cooler climate. Looking at wildfire and drought risk, this is viewed to be significantly lower in the UK than in much of mainland Europe, especially in Scotland, which is marked with the lowest fire risk indication. The Investment Manager believes that the UK's timber supply will benefit positively from its climate resilient characteristic; however, to mitigate potential climate-related risks, the Investment Manager has followed a series of initiatives to create more climate resilient forests within the portfolio (which will be detailed in full in the Company's 2023 S&ESG report due to be published in early 2024).
The outlook for American construction looks particularly positive, following the Inflation Reduction Act and the additional timber-related demand this will likely generate. With the debt ceiling increase signed in June 2023 and the US Government thereby avoiding default, growth in US construction has seemed to continue undisturbed during the year. The latest report from the US Census Bureau shows that during the first eight months of this year, construction spending amounted to \$1,284.7 billion, 4.2% above the \$1,233.4 billion for the same period in 2022.
Due to China's lifting of strict zero-COVID-19 policies and the introduction of a 21-point plan to aid property developers with financing and debt extensions worth up to \$67 billion, the outlook for Chinese timber demand has been positive during the period. Following the announcement of stimulus measures, China's timber market has since picked up, which is reflected in the country's Global Timber Index registering 53.0% in July, indicating growth in the sector. The Chinese construction industry was expected to grow by 8.0% in 2023.
Last year, the top three largest global importers of timber were China, the UK and the US. With global demands unlikely to decline, more European timber is expected to reach Chinese and US markets in future years. In our view, this could drive upward pressure on domestic UK timber prices where the availability of, typically steady, European imports
is reduced. 1. Bark beetle is a forestry pest which can cause significant damage to the trees if left uncontrolled.
Source: SBTi Database and Trove Research1 .
Voluntary carbon credits recognise the additional and permanent capture or avoidance of carbon dioxide from the atmosphere. Carbon credits can be retired by companies with net zero pledges to offset unabatable emissions created within their businesses or indirectly within their supply chains. During the year, the number of companies setting, or committing to set, Science Based Target Initiative ("SBTi") net zero pledges has continued to accelerate, with an all-time yearly high of 3,120 companies committing to SBTi between Q4 2022 and Q3 2023, effectively doubling the total to 6,048.
Examples of firms making new SBTi commitments last quarter include Heineken and Rolls-Royce. The total market capitalisation of all the companies with SBTi targets in Q3 2023 is above \$35 trillion. Companies' continued acceleration of net zero pledges bolsters the long-term demand outlook for voluntary carbon credits. In our view, these companies will likely require carbon credits to offset up to 5-10% of their emissions, considered unabatable, in line with SBTi rules.
Weighted average price per Woodland Carbon Code ("WCC") carbon credit (tCO2e)1
The Woodland Carbon Code ("WCC") has, for the first time, published a price index of their voluntary carbon credits in collaboration with Ecosystem Marketplace, summarised in the above chart. Over 99% of units contributing to the index were Pending Issuance Units ("PIUs"), that have yet to mature into Verified Carbon Units ("VCUs"), that are capable of being used for offsetting, with less than 1% of the units contributing to the index being VCUs. The Investment Manager therefore sees this as the best publicly available index yet, and provides a good proxy for its own voluntary carbon credit portfolio, which currently consists of 100% PIUs. The new index captures transactions totalling more than half a million PIUs (since January 2021). FSF is expecting to create 1.0-1.2 million PIUs with its current afforestation portfolio and planting programme (based on c.4,000 hectares planted). During the 2.5 years that the WCC index covers, the price of WCC carbon credits has grown by 69.9%.
Source: Trove Intelligence database. Graph based on approximation.
Following a Guardian article that exposed the low-integrity nature of many avoided deforestation ("REDD+") voluntary carbon credits, we have observed a significant shift in buyer preferences towards higher-integrity nature-based carbon removal credits of the sort which FSF creates with its afforestation schemes. Globally, nature restoration voluntary carbon credits, which include the WCC credits that FSF creates with its afforestation schemes, have increased by 63% from Q1 2023 to Q2 2023. During the same period, demand for carbon avoidance based REDD+ voluntary carbon credits has diminished, which has been reflected in prices falling by 17% from Q1 2023 to Q2 2023.
The Investment Manager has been encouraged by the progress made within voluntary carbon markets this year. The combination of a near doubling of corporate climate SBTi pledges, which further bolsters the long-term demand outlook, combined with a material shift in buyer preferences towards scarcer, higher-integrity, nature-based carbon removals credits of the sort which FSF creates, currently suggests that over the medium to long term, there will be sustained upward pressure on pricing.
FSF's afforestation carbon credits are to be issued, validated and independently verified using the WCC's UK Standard. The WCC is well recognised as being of high integrity and has secured International Carbon Reduction and Offsetting Accreditation ("ICROA"). ICROA is a non-profit organisation that promotes best practices across the voluntary carbon market. ICROA certification is an existing badge demarking WCC's high-integrity standards.
Trove Research published a paper in September 2023, which shows that investment into carbon credit projects between 2012 and 2022 totalled \$36 billion. Half of this occurred in the last three years. There is also a further \$3 billion in future investment already committed. This wave of investment facilitates more than a thousand new carbon reduction projects. More than \$18 billion of funding came from carbon credit funds during the last two and a half years alone. Over 80% of this funding is targeted towards nature-based projects such as FSF's afforestation projects and others such as improved forest management and reducing emissions from deforestation and forest degradation. The nature-based projects cover c.30 million hectares.
The Integrity Council for Voluntary Carbon Markets ("ICVCM"), an independent governance body, was specifically established with the aim of setting and maintaining global standards for quality within the voluntary carbon market. To assist with this, the ICVCM, in March 2023, launched the Core Carbon Principles ("CCPs"), which are intended to establish fundamental principles for high-quality carbon credits that create a verifiable climate impact, based on the latest science and best practice. Buyers and users of voluntary carbon credits that are certified as aligning with the CCPs can be assured of the high integrity of the underlying carbon credit. CCP labels for carbon credit methodologies are expected to start being issued in late 2023. The Investment Manager believes WCC could receive confirmation of CCP alignment during 2024 along with potentially a Carbon Offsetting Reduction Scheme for International Aviation ("CORSIA") approval.
During the period, as already mentioned, REDD+ has come under scrutiny. The press articles exposed integrity issues with some avoided deforestation voluntary carbon credits issued by Verra's REDD+ methodology. REDD+ and other avoidance credits improve the relative balance of carbon in the atmosphere by conserving nature and avoiding deforestation. The additionality case for REDD+ rests on the concept that without protection and conservation large areas of natural forest (which acts as a valuable rotational natural storage system for carbon) will be felled to make way for agriculture and development (usually intensive livestock farming).
However, proving the additionality case for REDD+ has proved challenging as quantifying the level of threat of natural forest destruction for specific projects/sites is quite variable and subjective. With afforestation projects, proving additionality and permanence, and therefore high levels of integrity of credits, is relatively clearer and simpler as newly planted trees draw down additional carbon from the atmosphere. In the view of the Investment Manager, this may explain the apparent shift in buyer preference that has been observed during the year.
On the demand side (i.e. companies seeking to make climate-related claims), the Voluntary Carbon Markets Integrity Initiative, whose ambition is to set the standard for high integrity use of carbon credits in organisations' climate strategies, issued their provisional Claims Code of Practice. This outlines clear guidance on how companies can make transparent and credible claims regarding carbon offsetting. Leveraging the newly developed frameworks, Bloomberg and other media outlets have criticised some corporate "carbon neutral" claims, that are not science-based and where there is no obligation to decarbonise (as up to 100% of emissions can be offset), as "junk carbon neutral claims" enabled by "junk carbon offsets" such as avoidance-based carbon credits. Unlike carbon removals-based credits, avoidance-based carbon credits are not compatible with a SBTi net zero claim.
It has also been encouraging to see regulators increasingly pursue legal action against companies which exaggerate their climate and environmental credentials, with several large companies abandoning carbon neutral claims, to instead focus on decarbonising first and only offsetting the balance. The Investment Manager is encouraged by these developments. It provides further evidence towards a high integrity market for voluntary carbon credits establishing and scaling.
Whilst the nuances of how carbon credits can be used to support a science-based climate claim have been in focus, a recent Trove Research report finds that firms that use carbon credits, of any type and quality, reduced their emissions twice as fast compared to companies that do not use carbon credits at all. Further, companies that used higher-integrity carbon credits are decarbonising faster still.
The Company remains fully committed to investment in projects that yield carbon credits that are compatible with internationally recognised high integrity standards (such as ICROA and the CCPs) that can be used by companies with a high integrity SBTi net zero claim that adheres to the Claims Code of Practice.
OVERVIEW STRATEGIC REPORT GOVERNANCE FINANCIAL Strategy Performance
INFORMATION
In its second year, FSF made solid progress on several fronts, in the face of a challenging market and macroeconomic headwinds. During the year, FSF has further demonstrated that successfully developing and planting new forests (afforestation) remains the reliable engine room of value creation. The year saw four new forests planted, taking the total since FSF's inception to c.1.4 million trees planted across six properties. Since IPO, the value of these six properties has increased by 85% versus acquisition costs, based on their carrying value of £18.9 million as at 30 September 2023. During the year, strong progress was made in the development of a further 37 properties with afforestation potential in the portfolio. Many of these will be planted in the current planting season, which runs from November to May. Once fully planted, FSF's afforestation portfolio is expected to create 1.0-1.2 million carbon credits and representing a material upside opportunity for investors.
During the year, the Woodland Carbon Code ("WCC") published new financial additionality test rules for afforestation schemes. Whilst good for carbon credit integrity levels, the Company has reduced the level of grant taken in order for commercial forestry projects to pass. The Investment Manager holds a seat on the WCC Advisory Board and has led an industry group to provide feedback to the WCC on how the test could be improved. Through a combination of engagement with the WCC and optimising afforestation designs we are confident that the Company's position can be improved overall whilst maintaining the high integrity levels of the carbon credits.
In the year, the NAV declined by £11.4 million overall. FSF delivered NAV per share gains in the first half of the year, mostly relating to the outperformance of its afforestation portfolio, in an otherwise flat market. The second half of the year has seen FSF's NAV decline by £17.4 million since the 31 March 2023 valuation. These NAV losses primarily relate to the relatively less buoyant UK forestry and agricultural land investment market, rather than any material changes to the physical condition of FSF's forestry assets or their long-term outlook. The Company's portfolio valuation is dictated by the property specialist, Savills, in their capacity as independent valuer using the Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors ("RICS") Red Book approach. The approach incorporates comparable market transaction evidence and the valuer's view of market sentiment and is reflective of current conditions.
In the face of persistently high inflation and interest rates, the value of UK forestry assets sold in the first nine-month period of 2023 (to 30 September) represents 12% of the annual average of the value of assets sold in 2021 and 2022. Prices for land with afforestation potential declined significantly during the year, when compared to market declines for established forestry properties.
OVERVIEW STRATEGIC REPORT GOVERNANCE FINANCIAL Strategy Performance
INFORMATION
Whilst this has impacted FSF's NAV in the short term, it is FSF's intention to change the land use of its afforestation properties and only exit the property once it has been established as a new forest. Further, acquiring land with afforestation potential at lower entry prices increases the total return prospects that can be achieved by successfully developing it. Carbon credit prices relating to nature restoration have remained highly resilient throughout the year, driven by a significant shift in corporate demand towards higher-integrity carbon credits of the sort FSF creates. We have been pleased to add afforestation properties to the portfolio throughout the year, which have enhanced capital appreciation prospects.
Established forestry values proved to be more resilient versus afforestation values, but were still down on the year. Forest asset prices' relative resilience is underpinned by the fact that trees continue to grow and add timber value regardless of macroeconomic conditions. Their values are driven more by investors' long-term views on future timber prices, than they are from spot timber prices. Whilst UK forestry is well recognised for its resilient and inflation-beating qualities over the long term, it is not completely immune to current market conditions (elevated base rates and constrained capital supply) in the short term. Overall, whilst it is disappointing to see a subdued forestry investment market in the second half of the year having a negative impact on the portfolio valuation, we are pleased by the operational achievements and opportunistic acquisitions we have made in the period. We are excited about the year ahead with a particular focus on successfully planting many millions of trees and establishing multiple new forests.
At the beginning of the financial year FSF had approximately £30.0 million of cash available for further acquisitions which remained from the £45.0 million equity placing that took place in June 2022. In January 2023, FSF had successfully acquired 12 properties, which saw the June 2022 equity proceeds fully deployed, ahead of the committed six-month target. The Company bought six more properties during the period. These acquisitions have substantially completed FSF's acquisition of land in preparation for its 2024/25 planting programme and there are no material additions expected in the near term. The acquisitions completed in September 2023 were funded by the RCF and repayment of the borrowings will occur through a combination of timber harvesting and the planned disposal of non-core or other assets.
The majority of acquisitions in the year were directly originated off-market and bilateral opportunities, where we continue to see better value. These opportunities are sourced from a combination of Foresight's proprietary market-mapping deal procurement approach and by leveraging our extensive network of contacts. We are also increasingly enjoying inbound approaches from vendors who recognise FSF's strong track record as a reliable, all-cash counterparty that operates a highly efficient transaction process. Immediate mark-to-market gains on new acquisitions have been underpinned in many instances through the realisation of marriage value with existing properties in the portfolio. The Company has continued to acquire properties that are either directly adjacent, or in close proximity, to existing FSF properties, which can result in scale economies that are reflected in uplifted valuations when combined.
Foresight sources deals and acquisition opportunities via selling agents, on-market bids, bilateral deals, direct origination and inbound direct approaches. Approximately 4,500 specific properties (c.900,000 hectares) which are highly suitable for afforestation have been identified by the Investment Manager.
Co-Lead, Foresight Sustainable Forestry Company Co-Lead 5 December 2023
Co-Lead, Foresight Sustainable Forestry Company Co-Lead 5 December 2023
As at 30 September 2023, the Company's portfolio comprised 68 properties covering a total area of 12,545 hectares. An overview of the portfolio is provided on page 5 as well as the split of hectares by country and by property type. The portfolio's allocation continues to be weighted towards Scotland (85% of FSF's portfolio by land area), which is the most forested of the UK's nations and the least far behind in achieving its tree planting targets.
During the year, FSF updated the categorisation of afforestation properties into three separate categories to help stakeholders to more clearly follow the progression of portfolio development. Properties are now classified as Development Stage, Planting Stage and Establishment Stage, with full definitions provided below.
| Forest Area1 30 September |
Other land area 30 September |
Total area 30 September |
Forest Area at time of writing report 17 November |
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Hectares | 2023 | 20232 | 2023 | 2023 |
| Development Stage Afforestation | 4,446 | 721 | 5,167 | 4,226 |
| Planting Stage Afforestation | 93 | — | 93 | 373 |
| Establishment Stage Afforestation | 937 | 98 | 1,035 | 937 |
| Established Stage Forestry | 5,184 | 1,067 | 6,251 | 5,184 |
| Total | 10,660 | 1,886 | 12,545 | 10,720 |
Includes commercial stocked/stockable; broadleaf stocked/stockable; designed open ground; natural forest/woodland regeneration zones; and other land considered part of the forest area.
Includes areas of land that sit outside the forest area; this includes, but is not limited to, land leased for grazing; regenerative grazing land; peatland/wetland; hill ground; non-core land considered for disposal; non-core land not considered for disposal; house/farm curtilage.
| Category | Definition |
|---|---|
| (1) Development Stage Afforestation Area | Land prior to the securing of planning permission and grant application. |
| (2) Planting Stage Afforestation Area | Planning permission and grant application completed but initial planting of trees not yet completed. |
| (3) Establishment Stage Afforestation Area | Initial planting of site completed but trees establishing (typically three to five years). |
| (4) Established Stage Forestry Area | Trees established. |
A particular area of interest for stakeholders will be the progression from the Development Stage Afforestation to Planting Stage Afforestation, as this will be the signal of the amount of land which has received all permissions and grants and is ready to commence their respective planting programmes. It can be considered an early indication of expected capital appreciation of this area, which is recognised by FSF's valuer at the point of planting completion and the entering of the Establishment Stage.
| Total hectares (Forest Area) | At year end 30 September 2023 |
At time of writing report 17 November 2023 |
|---|---|---|
| Survey and design stage | 2,701 | 2,671 |
| Initial public consultation stage | 1,416 | 469 |
| Admitted to public register stage | 329 | 1,086 |
| Total | 4,446 | 4,226 |
The Investment Manager and their contractors and advisers continue to hold public consultations and progress the projects through to getting onto the public register for review and further comments by the public and statutory consultees. If the consultation with communities and statutory consultees is well run and done in advance, it can take circa one to two months from point of going on the register to receiving permission and grant contract, after which point the Planting Stage can commence.
| Total hectares (Forest Area) | At year end 30 September 2023 |
At time of writing report 17 November 2023 |
|---|---|---|
| Development Stage Afforestation | 4,446 | 4,226 |
| Planting Stage Afforestation | 93 | 373 |
| Establishment Stage Afforestation | 937 | 937 |
| Total | 5,476 | 5,536 |
It is anticipated that approximately 19 sites covering 2,700 hectares of Forest Area will have completed the Development and Planting Stages and entered the Establishment Stage by the next valuation cycle, with the vast majority of the balance of Development Stage and Planting Stage Afforestation entering the Establishment Stage either in April/ early May 2024 or in the subsequent planting season between November 2024 and May 2025.
An afforestation progress to date and development outlook summary is provided below.
Overall, FSF has planted six woodland creation schemes since IPO. All six planted schemes continue to establish well. A breakdown of FSF's Establishment Stage Afforestation assets can be found below:
| Newly planted Establishment Stage Afforestation (1 October 2022 – 30 September 2023) |
Total Establishment Stage Afforestation |
|
|---|---|---|
| Properties (number) | 4 | 6 |
| Total Establishment Stage Afforestation creation (hectares) |
702 | 937 |
| Commercially stocked afforestation (%) | 44% | 50% |
| Non-commercially stocked afforestation (%) | 15% | 14% |
| Designed open ground (%) and other land considered part of the forest area |
41% | 36% |
| Number of carbon credits awaiting validation (exclusive of 20% buffer) |
107,592 | 143,707 |
| Anticipated tonnes of sustainable timber to be produced from the first rotation |
190,500 | 283,150 |
FORESIGHT SUSTAINABLE FORESTRY COMPANY PLC OVERVIEW Annual Report and Financial Statements 2023 27
STRATEGIC REPORT GOVERNANCE Strategy Performance
FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
ADDITIONAL INFORMATION
Surveys were undertaken and the scheme was drawn up by Scottish Woodlands, the appointed Forest Manager ("FM"), with asset and portfolio management oversight from EJD Forestry and Foresight's portfolio management team respectively.
The community has been at the heart of this development process and several key initiatives were presented to a variety of community groups for feedback.
Planning approval and a woodland creation grant contract were obtained.
| Tree species type | Native broadleaves, mixed conifers (Sitka Spruce, Norway Spruce, Noble Fir, Pacific Silver Fir, Scots Pine) |
|---|---|
| Total trees planted | 288,299 |
| Gross area planted | 151.7 hectares |
| Jobs provided | 1,460 hours (0.5 FTE) |
| Location | Dumfries & Galloway, Scotland | |
|---|---|---|
| Size | 344 hectares | |
| Land designated for afforestation | 151.7 hectares | |
| Date of acquisition | March 2022 |
Employment continued throughout the summer, bringing the total hours worked for the year to 2,070 hours or 0.99 FTE. There have been no issues with the establishment of the crops and minimal tree loss is anticipated.
Recognition of the successful planting at the property delivered an 83% valuation uplift to the acquisition price paid for the property.
Upper Barr has been registered with the Woodland Carbon Code and is due to benefit from carbon credits associated with the sequestration achieved by the new planting. A total of c.40,000 Pending Issuance Units are expected to be registered following a confirmatory inspection by the Soil Association.
FSF has designed a portfolio that should supply a steady stream of potential harvesting over the coming years. The table below gives an overview of the quantity of standing timber in each category within the FSF portfolio. Where gaps are present, FSF will, over time, look to infill and generate the ability to harvest to provide the Company with cash flow each year should it be required.
The above chart excludes afforestation assets at any stage.
There has been ongoing harvesting at five sites during the year. Largely, these harvesting operations have focused on either continued clear up of windblow or addressing Statutory Plant Health Notifications ("SPHNs"). An SPHN is issued by either the Forestry Commission, Scottish Forestry or Natural Resources Wales where infected plants have been identified. In the cases seen within the FSF portfolio, these are Larch crops at low volumes and this is not considered by the Investment Manager to represent a material issue for the Company or to be out of keeping with standard woodland management practice in UK forestry. Income is still generated by this harvesting. During the year a total of 17,000 tonnes of timber was harvested generating net income of £750,000.
STATEMENTS
Timber prices are yet to recover from the softening seen towards the end of 2022 and the harvesting plan has been adjusted accordingly. Harvesting is being included in the shortterm programme where it results in NAV accretion or there is a good silvicultural reason to pursue the harvesting. It is not currently the intention to harvest all the available timber within the portfolio. The Investment Manager will continue to monitor prices closely, commencing harvesting activities at the optimal time giving consideration to timber market conditions and Company cash revenue requirements.
Across all planned harvesting activities expected in the next 12 months, a total of 118,000 tonnes are anticipated to be harvested.
In addition to the short-term view, FSF has reviewed the long-term harvesting plan. Harvesting does not need to be undertaken immediately and can be delayed. Making use of the additional biological growth, it is useful to forecast what timber will be available over the coming years. The chart below is illustrative only and is subject to variation depending on the Company's strategy and requirements.
A number of upside opportunities continue to be developed across the portfolio.
Knock Fell – Peatland restoration with the potential to create up to 20,000 peatland carbon credits.
Drumelzie – Full planning application for a three turbine wind farm development has been submitted by a developer for this site. Negotiations regarding felling requirements are ongoing.
Fordie Estate – A glamping project continues to be developed. This would see eight glamping pods being constructed at Fordie in 2024.
As at 30 September 2023, FSF has maintained compliance with its Prospectus commitment to dual certify all forests within 12 months of either acquisition or planting completion.
| Number of projects | As a % | |
|---|---|---|
| Projects certified | 34 | 50% |
| Projects requiring certification | 5 | 7% |
| Projects yet to require certification | 29 | 43% |
The importance of obtaining the correct certification for timber ahead of selling continues to increase. The largest sawmilling companies are placing ever-more stringent restrictions on uncertified timber. Specifically, James Jones have recently announced that they will only process dual certified timber. Therefore, there continues to be a premium associated with certified timber.
ISO 9001 sets the requirements for a company's Quality Management System ("QMS") and ISO 14001 is the equivalent standard for an Environmental Management System ("EMS"). To date a review has been completed in relation to the two ISO standards to assess the current level of accreditation across the companies of the portfolio, where gaps in this exist and where the standards should be implemented.
FSF's focus at present is on its suppliers to attain ISO accreditation to provide an initial layer of ISO accreditation. further details will be provided in the Company's 2023 S&ESG report.
A biodiversity monitoring tool called Biodiversity HAB-CON Alpha has been developed by experienced ecology consultants in collaboration with the Investment Manager. This tool is based on the UK Habitat Classification System and condition assessment and has the following notable key features:
Biodiversity value is ascribed to the transitional habitats that both commercial softwood conifer forests and long-term broadleaf woodland provide during the cyclical forest process (i.e. trees grow in establishment stage, canopy closure occurs, natural/planned thinning occurs, trees are harvested or naturally perish, trees are re-stocked or naturally re-generate).
Time frames have been extended from 30-years to 60-years to recognise the long-term nature of forestry management and enable managed woodlands additional time to reach target condition (e.g. moderate or good condition).
Biodiversity HAB-CON Alpha is being pilot-tested across six FSF pilot sites. After the pilot phase, the measurement and monitoring tool will be rolled out over thirty FSF properties as part of the next stage. FSF is seeking to deliver an overall biodiversity uplift across the portfolio, using the tool to monitor the environmental status of the Company's assets and drive nature positive management decisions within the portfolio in the future.
More information on this will be included in the Company's 2023 S&ESG report.
Health and safety ("H&S") is a focus for the Company's Board and the Investment Manager's portfolio management team. The target of the portfolio management team is to position FSF as a market leader for forestry H&S best practices. Regular reporting on notifiable incidents is provided to the Company's Directors to ensure Board oversight on H&S matters.
| Health and safety event | Number during the period |
|---|---|
| Reporting of Injuries, Diseases and Dangerous Occurrences Regulations | |
| ("RIDDOR") | 0 |
| Near miss events | 7 |
RIDDOR events are serious and must be reported to the Health and Safety Executive, which is administered by the UK Government. The Company is pleased to report that no RIDDORs occurred during the period.
"Near miss" events are categorised as all H&S incidents that are not reportable under the RIDDOR framework. There were only seven events throughout the year, which is considered low. Near miss reporting is embedded in day-to-day forest management and the portfolio management team continually reviews measures that can further improve the quality of reporting. For the period these include:
INFORMATION
Valuation bridge
As at 30 September 2023, the forestry portfolio, excluding additional carbon credits held through SPVs as described on page 47, was valued at £172.2 million. Since 30 September 2022, 18 assets valued at £38.4 million (inclusive of tax and transaction costs) were acquired and the property revaluation in the portfolio delivered a gain of £2.7 million, representing a weighted average (across the three investment categories) valuation loss of 5.8%.
Afforestation properties observed unrealised losses of £2.3 million, representing a 7.5% decrease in that category, despite observing mark-to-market gains and recognition of the successful completion of planting at four properties (Auchensoul, Redding Farm, Upper Barr and Frongoch). Forestry properties observed unrealised losses of £3.2 million, representing a 4.8% decrease in that category. Mixed afforestation and forestry properties delivered unrealised losses of £1.0 million, representing a 4.9% decrease in that category.
During the year to 30 September 2023, four afforestation schemes completed planting and FSF has recognised an additional £2.1 million of value ascribed to the creation of carbon credits, bringing the overall portfolio value to £2.7 million. This estimate takes into consideration the verifier's 20% buffer to ensure that the number of units offset or traded is conservative versus the amount of carbon that will be sequestered. The four properties are estimated to create c.108,000 voluntary carbon credits (net of the 20% buffer) and are part of a wider afforestation programme that is expected to see the creation of 1.0-1.2 million voluntary carbon credits in total from the current portfolio. The methodology and treatment of the additional value added at 30 September 2023 has remained consistent with the audited financial statements as at 30 September 2022. The unit pricing of voluntary carbon has increased from £17.50 at 30 September 2022 to £19.00 at 30 September 2023.
Savills Advisory Services Limited ("Savills") was engaged by the Company to provide a fair value valuation of the portfolio in accordance with the Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors ("RICS") Valuation – Global Standards July 2017 (the "Red Book").
The Red Book valuation falls within the International Financial Reporting Standards ("IFRS"), as part of the International Valuation Standards which requires investment properties to be considered on the basis of fair value at the balance sheet date. IFRS 13 outlines the principles for fair value measurement which Savills' valuation is consistent with. The Red Book valuations are undertaken on a property-by-property basis and are completed semi-annually.
The fair value assessment of the properties has been completed by Savills on a comparable basis by looking at transactions of similar properties. Development Stage and Planting Stage Afforestation property comparables include the rights to future potential voluntary carbon credit creation. Establishment Stage Afforestation and Established Forest property comparables exclude any value ascribed to any associated voluntary carbon credits that have been created.
In addition to the fair value, the Red Book methodology considers a number of additional factors impacting the valuation. A reasonable view of the potential for afforestation properties' value uplift over time is considered rather than valuing the land in its current state. Savills also considers the stage of each property within the forestry grant application process and may make reassessments as to the value of properties when a new developmental milestone occurs. Additionally, as the properties under ownership are located across the UK (Scotland, Northern England and Wales), the external valuer accounts for the potential differences in market interest and demand at the different locations.
The value associated with the carbon credits attached with the Establishment Stage Afforestation properties is excluded from the RICS Red Book valuation of these properties. Value recognition for carbon credits is ascribed separately using the Investment Manager's assessment based on a range of recent comparable voluntary carbon credit transactions that occurred in the period and observed by leading third-party carbon credit consultants and brokers. When establishing the value of carbon credits, a 25% risk discount is applied to the average observed unit price of a validated carbon credit. The risk discount accounts for the Woodland Carbon Code validation process not having fully completed.
FORESIGHT SUSTAINABLE FORESTRY COMPANY PLC Annual Report and Financial Statements 2023 33 ADDITIONAL
OVERVIEW STRATEGIC REPORT GOVERNANCE FINANCIAL Strategy Performance
INFORMATION
Sustainability and strong governance are fundamental to FSF's business model, as captured in the Company's three key Sustainability and ESG objectives
| Key objective 1: timber | |
|---|---|
| supply |
To deliver and increase the supply of home-grown UK timber to reduce the country's reliance on imports.
To do so in a way that combines sustainable financial returns with carbon sequestration, biodiversity protection and other positive environmental and social impacts.
To be a sustainability leader in the UK forestry industry whilst delivering both traditional commercial timber products and innovative natural capital services.
Expansion of the Forestry Skills Training Programme to Scotland, with
placements awarded across Scotland and Wales
35,081
tCO2e Sequestered
10
FSF's vision and management of its assets, with a focus on its key S&ESG objectives, are closely aligned with five of the UN Sustainable Development Goals ("SDGs"). The SDGs represent a key consideration of the Company's investment activities and, in the following pages, we demonstrate the progress made by the Company in each of these core areas for the period 1 October 2022 to 30 September 2023.
12,545
Total hectarage of portfolio (inc. forests and open ground)
publication of the Company's dedicated S&ESG Report1
Schoolchildren from Carreg Hirfaen School to play a part in the planting at Frongoch
£2.1 million
Additional value ascribed towards creation of carbon credits with 143,707 PIUs held on balance (as at 30 September 2023)
https://media.umbraco.io/foresight/ar0gzg2h/sustainability-and-esg-report-2022.pdf
UN SDG 12 (Responsible Consumption and Production) is most closely aligned with FSF's Key S&ESG Objective 1 (Timber Supply). There is also strong overlap with Objective 2 (Sustainable Returns) and Objective 3 (Progressive Industry Leadership). Timber in the UK is used in a variety of ways; from a construction material as an alternative to concrete and steel, through to biomass to produce renewable power and heat. FSF's timber plays a role in meeting these demands.
UN SDG 3 (Good Health and Wellbeing) is most closely aligned with FSF's Key S&ESG Objective 2 (Sustainable Returns), specifically the delivery of "other positive environmental and social impacts". Aside from sequestering carbon, our trees help to actively remove pollutants from the air.
| Goal | SDG target | Contribution | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Goal | SDG target 12.2 Achieve the sustainable management and efficient use of natural resources. |
Contribution Number of m3 of sustainably grown, standing timber. Percentage of commercial forestry projects that are dual certified within 12 months of acquisition. |
3.9 Substantially reduce the number of deaths and illnesses from hazardous chemicals and air, water and soil pollution and contamination. |
Number of tonnes of pollutants1 removed from the atmosphere, including: NO2 (Nitrous Oxide), SO2 (Sulphur Dioxide), PM10 (μm10 Particulate Matter), PM2.5 (μm2.5 Particulate Matter), Ground-level Ozone, NH3 (Ammonia). |
|
| m3 1,200 1,000 800 |
50,104 163,684 866,349 |
1,062,325 0 (17,813) |
Key: Ground-level Ozone PM10 PM2.5 |
NH3 SO2 NO2 |
|
| 600 400 200 |
366.3 tonnes of Ground-level Ozone |
25.5 tonnes of PM10 (μm10 Particulate Matter) |
|||
| 0 Opening balance |
0 tonnes New Biological acquisitions growth (in year) |
Harvested Other Closing loss |
of NH3 (Ammonia) | 16.3 tonnes | 11.7 tonnes of SO2 (Sulphur Dioxide) |
| 1,062,325 m3 of standing commercial timber |
100% existing forestry dual FSC and PEFC certified, in line with commitment to dual certify within 12 months |
21.6 tonnes of PM2.5 (μm2.5 Particulate Matter) |
5.2 tonnes of NO2 (Nitrous Oxide) |
||
| 1. Office for National Statistics, woodland natural capital accounts, UK 2020. Note: 1m3 of standing timber on average equates to 0.81 green tonnes of softwood |
446.6 tonnes of pollutants removed from the atmosphere |
Note: 1m3 of standing timber on average equates to 0.81 green tonnes of softwood
UN SDG 6 (Clean Water and Sanitation), specifically the delivery of "biodiversity protection and other positive environmental and social impacts", is most closely aligned with FSF's Key S&ESG Objective 2 (Sustainable Returns). Greater focus is being placed on the interconnectedness of our ecosystems. Watercourses and peatlands within and around FSF's portfolio provide habitats for wildlife and support biodiversity and drainage.
| Goal | SDG target | Contribution |
|---|---|---|
| 6.6 Protect and restore water-related ecosystems, including mountains, forests, wetlands, rivers, aquifers and lakes. |
Number of kilometres of sustainably managed watercourses. |
3491 kilometres of sustainably managed watercourses
UN SDG 13 (Climate Action) is most closely aligned with FSF's Key S&ESG Objective 2 (Sustainable Returns), specifically the delivery of "carbon sequestration". As FSF's operations grow, the overall benefit here is twofold: carbon sequestration is increased and simultaneously timber production is increased.
| Goal | SDG target | Contribution |
|---|---|---|
| 13.3 Strengthen resilience and adaptive capacity to climate-related hazards and natural disasters in all countries. |
Total annual portfolio sequestration (tCO2e/annum). Average annual sequestration per stocked |
|
| ha (tCO2e/stocked ha). Average annual sequestration per gross ha. |
arboreal sequestration achieved over the reporting period within the portfolio
2.80 tCO2e/ha average arboreal sequestration per
gross hectare
average arboreal sequestration on a per stocked hectare basis (commercial + non-commercial)
UN SDG 15 (Life on Land), specifically the delivery of "biodiversity protection", is most closely aligned with FSF's Key S&ESG Objective 2 (Sustainable Returns). As a natural capital fund, we believe that, when managed responsibly, forestry and afforestation can provide a wide-ranging flow of ecosystem services which are valuable to society in which biodiversity plays a vital role.
| Goal | SDG target | Contribution |
|---|---|---|
| 15.2 By 2020, promote the implementation of sustainable management of all types of forests, halt deforestation, restore degraded forests and substantially increase afforestation and reforestation globally. |
Number of hectares of sustainably managed forests. Of which: • Number of hectares that are long-term, mixed broadleaf carbon sinks. • Number of hectares that are SSSI1 /SAC2. |
769 ha of which is SSSI1 /SAC2 7,884 ha of open ground and land awaiting approval for afforestation
3,819 ha of which is sustainably managed commercial forest (excludes open ground)
of which is long-term, mixed broadleaf woodland (excludes open ground)
| Carbon credits generated: | |
|---|---|
| PIUs awaiting validation held on balance | 143,707 |
| PIUs held on balance | — |
| PIUs sold | — |
| PIUs pipeline | 897,427 |
| WCUs held on balance | — |
| WCUs sold | — |
| Total carbon credits held on balance | 143,707 |
| Total carbon credits sold | — |
INFORMATION
One of the major issues that faces rural communities throughout the UK is a shortage of skills. There are fewer individuals with the necessary skills to undertake a variety of roles. The Forestry Skills Training Programme, sponsored by FSF and administered by Tilhill, aims at redressing the balance of skills within the community.
In May of this year, FSF announced that following the success of the pilot of the Forestry Skills Training Programme launched in 2022, it will repeat and significantly expand the initiative for 2023.
Fully funded three-week programme that provides candidates with the skills and equipment needed to commence a career in forestry. The programme focuses on three key areas:
Richard Kelly, Co-lead Manager of FSF, with three of the four successful FSF Forestry Skills Training Programme graduates at a community tree planting day at Frongoch, Wales, in March 2023
| Scope of programme in 2022 |
Scope of programme in 2023 |
|
|---|---|---|
| Geographic area covered | Wales | Scotland and Wales |
| Number of candidates | 4 | 10 |
| Number of candidates going onto receive paid forestry work at an FSF afforestation property |
4 | TBC |
FSF has closely followed candidates from the pilot and has been proud of the positive professional and personal impact that has had on the individuals involved.
The Company's 2022 S&ESG report, published in April 20231 , provides a comprehensive response to all 11 of the TCFD recommended disclosures and can be found on the Company's website. For the period to 30 September 2023, the Company will be publishing its 2023 report in the new year. However, for the year ended 30 September 2023, the below reports on the Company's emissions profile, using Scope 1, 2 and 3 emissions data and the TCFD Core Metrics, calculated in accordance with the TCFD recommended methodologies2.
| Scope 1 emissions | 349.8 tCO e 2 |
|---|---|
| Scope 2 emissions | 0 tCO e 2 |
| Scope 3 emissions | 863.5 tCO e 2 |
Weighted average carbon intensity (tCO2e/£m revenue)
Portfolio's exposure to carbon-intensive assets, expressed in tonnes CO2e/£m revenue.
Total carbon emissions (tCO2e)
The absolute greenhouse gas emissions associated with the portfolio, expressed in tonnes CO2e.
349.8
Carbon footprint (tCO2e/£m invested)
Total carbon emissions for a portfolio normalised by the market value of the portfolio, expressed in tonnes CO2e/£m invested
2.0
Volume of carbon emissions per million pounds of revenue (carbon efficiency of a portfolio), expressed in tonnes CO2e/£m revenue
183.9
The amount or percentage of carbon-related assets in the portfolio, expressed in £m or percentage of the current portfolio value
0
As part of the Company's disclosures under TCFD, the S&ESG report1 demonstrated the approach it has taken to conducting robust scenario analysis using S&P Global's Climanomics platform. This integrated not only physical and transition risks, but also climate-related opportunities, providing a single output reflecting the resilience of the portfolio under different climate futures. The Company does not intend to repeat this test for future years.
SFDR is a framework designed to increase transparency on sustainability reporting with a view to facilitating sustainable investment practices and to aid the understanding of the sustainability credentials as published by funds and/or companies.
The Company is classified as an Article 9 fund, meeting the necessary disclosure requirements as stipulated in the Level 2 Regulatory Technical Standards under SFDR. FSF updated its pre-contractual and website disclosures, both of which can be found on the Company's website and are summarised below:
The Company's investment objective stipulates the targeted sustainable impact it aims to achieve through predominantly investment in sustainably managed forestry assets (including standing forests and afforestation assets).
FSF has a climate change mitigation objective, seeking to make a direct contribution in the fight against climate change through its forestry and afforestation carbon sequestration initiatives.
The indicators for the portfolio are reported in the SDG tables on pages 34 to 36.
FSF's Annex III Pre-Contractual Disclosure, RTS Website Disclosure and Article V Periodic Disclosure are all available on the Company's website1 . For the purposes of periodic disclosure updates, the Company will be aligning its reference period with its annual reporting period, namely 1 October to 30 September.
1. Available on the Company's website here: https://fsfc.foresightgroup.eu/shareholder-centre.
2. TCFD recommended methodologies for calculation of the Common Carbon Footprinting and Exposure Metrics https://www.fsb-tcfd.org/recommendations/
OVERVIEW STRATEGIC REPORT GOVERNANCE FINANCIAL Strategy Performance
INFORMATION
Risk is the potential for events to occur that may result in damage, liability or loss. Such occurrences could adversely impact the Company's business model, reputation or financial standing. Alternatively, under a well-formed risk management framework, potential risks can be identified in advance and can either be mitigated or possibly converted into opportunities. Pages 41 to 45 of this report detail the risks that the Directors consider are the top ten risks to the Company.
Risks are monitored by the Audit and Risk Committee, comprising the full Board, which is responsible for overseeing the current and potential risk exposures of the Company, with particular focus on the principal and emerging risks, being those with the greatest potential to influence Shareholders' economic decisions, and the controls in place to mitigate those risks.
The identification, assessment and management of risk are integral aspects of the Investment Manager's work in managing the portfolio on a day-to-day basis.
Mitigation actions have been developed with respect to each risk so as first to reduce the likelihood of such risk occurring and secondly to minimise the severity of its impact in the case that it does occur.
The risk register is reviewed and updated regularly by the Investment Manager and the Audit and Risk Committee as new risks emerge and existing risks change. The portfolio managers maintain strong relationships between counterparties, contractors, third-party asset managers and other stakeholders. This ensures effective management of potential risks.
The Audit and Risk Committee regularly seek assurances as to the resilience of the reporting and control systems in place for both the management of the portfolio and for the Company's investment activities. The Committee will continue to evaluate and challenge the resilience of all key agents to the Company.
The Board undertook a robust assessment of the Company's emerging and principal risks during the year. More information can be found in the Governance section on page 54.
The following represent the most relevant emerging risks as viewed by the Board and the Investment Manager:
The UK economy has seen significant fluctuations in growth over the last two years, predominantly due to rising debt costs, high inflation and Russia's invasion of Ukraine. However, the Company is in a relatively strong position to withstand changes in the macroeconomic environment as it is invested in real assets, principally freeholds of UK land and forest stock. The forest stock enjoys biological growth regardless of occurrences in financial markets. UK freeholds, real assets and the value of commodities, such as timber, have a strong track record of good performance during periods of inflation and instability of equity markets. In the view of the Investment Manager, the continued global supply and demand imbalance in timber markets, which is accentuated in the UK as a net timber importer and during a period where GBP is weak versus EUR and USD, leaves the Company well positioned to deliver real-term value growth for Shareholders. Moreover, FSF is in a position to mitigate the impact of any intra-quarter or intra-year falls in timber prices by postponing parts of its harvesting programme, and allowing the trees to continue to grow until the underlying imbalance between supply and demand begins to be reflected in market prices again.
In order to achieve its growth ambitions and to ensure the Company is able to take full advantage of the opportunities in its pipeline, additional financing will be required in the short to medium term. The Company's borrowing policy enables the Directors to use gearing for liquidity and working capital purposes, or to finance acquisition of investments subject to following a prudent approach and maintaining a conservative level of aggregate borrowings that will not exceed 30% of Gross Asset Value, calculated at the time of drawdown. The Company has a £30 million Revolving Credit Facility, that at the end of the period was partially drawn by £10.4 million. The equity levels of the Company are closely monitored by the Board and the Investment Manager on a regular basis. The Company continues to work closely with its broker and the Investment Manager's in-house Retail Sales team will conduct market research ahead of any future funding rounds to gauge demand from existing and new investors.
Timber prices can be volatile periodically. However, demand over the medium to long term has historically created real-term pricing growth. In the context of global under-supply and increasing demand, this reduces market risk for the sale of the Company's key products and revenue streams. Should timber prices be less attractive at the point of felling, the Investment Manager also has the option to delay felling, allowing trees to continue to grow and provide time for a recovery from short-term pricing volatility.
The development of afforestation assets in rural areas is sensitive for local residents and, if managed unsatisfactorily, could result in poor relationships developing between the Company and local communities. This in turn could impact both its ability to obtain the necessary planning consent for planting to commence and potentially the Company's reputation. The Investment Manager selectively commissions an independent community risk assessment and only pursues opportunities where the risk of not obtaining planning consent, including for reasons relating to objections raised by the local community, is assessed to be low.
Once afforestation properties are acquired, the Investment Manager runs a co-ordinated programme of community engagement and seeks to respond and, wherever possible, adapt the scheme design to meet concerns raised by community members. In addition, in the event that planting was unable to go ahead, the acquired land would still have inherent agricultural value. Therefore, whilst the return generated from this would be lower, an income stream would still be available to the Company. The Company is also working closely with industry bodies such as Confor and Timber Development UK to promote the merits of increased sustainable UK timber supply. For more information on the Company's community engagement initiatives, please see the community engagement case study on page 16.
The Company is exposed to a number of risks that have the potential to materially affect the Company's valuation, reputation and financial or operational performance. The nature and levels of risk are identified according to the Company's investment objectives and existing policies, with the levels of risk tolerance ultimately defined by the Board.
The Company's risk register covers seven main areas of risk: financial, market, forestry, legal and regulatory, operational, economic and investment, although not all of these risks will fall into the top ten risk category.
Forestry as an asset class has its own set of unique risks which are considered and managed by the Investment Manager's dedicated team and external advisers. After mitigations are taken into account, most of these risks have a low residual risk score and those that do not are covered in more detail in the top ten risks section of this report.
Climate-specific risks are also monitored by the Board and the Investment Manager and an extensive climate change scenario analysis has been undertaken. The Investment Manager uses the S&P Global Climanomics platform to undertake this work and their findings are included in the Company's most recent Sustainability and ESG Report. After mitigations are taken into account, physical climate risks have a low residual risk score while some transition risks feature in the Company's top ten risks.
The Company's top ten risks are summarised on pages 41 to 45, followed by a detailed discussion of the mitigating factors.
OVERVIEW STRATEGIC REPORT GOVERNANCE FINANCIAL Strategy Performance
INFORMATION
This risk map shows our assessment of each area of principal risk after mitigation.
Residual risk
The risk that there will be changes in the interest expense for debt, or interest received on deposits, as measured in the currency of that debt, due to movements in market interest rates. Higher interest rates could also effectively increase the risk-free rate and reduce the valuation of longdated forestry assets. There is a risk that rising interest rates could result in a higher cost of debt than on the associated projects' return on equity, which would be NAV destructive over time.
The risk that inflation remains at persistently high levels and this increases future costs of developing and operating the portfolio. High inflation could also erode the valuation of the existing portfolio.
Changes in economic, technological, political or regulatory environment and market sentiment can impact the returns expected from the assets in the Company's portfolio.
Agricultural land with afforestation potential is less sensitive to inflationary pressures, therefore the strategy of the Investment Manager is to increase the amount of afforestation investment within the portfolio
Diversity of revenue streams is targeted where possible, preventing over-concentration to specific risks
The risk that the Company is unable to access sufficient funding to complete its operations.
5 Valuation
The risk that valuations are prepared incorrectly by either the Investment Manager or the valuer, leading to a publicly stated NAV that is not representative of the value of the portfolio. There is a risk that there are an insufficient number of comparable transactions used to inform the RICS Red Book valuation which is less representative of FSF's actual value. This could reduce investor confidence in the Company and could result in investors selling FSF's shares.
6 Demand for carbon credits
8 Cost to transition to lower emissions technology
The risk that demand or volume leads to a reduction in demand from the users of carbon credits that negatively impacts profitability.
The risk that a reduction in demand from the purchasers of timber would negatively impact the Company's profitability.
The risk that timber sawmills/processors could face increased energy supply costs e.g. if biomass energy is phased out, or if the supply chain have increased costs with mitigating their GHG emissions. Costs could be passed onto FSF, in the form of lower prices paid for FSF's timber and in higher prices charged for downstream timber products leading to reduced timber demand.
Due to no regular dividend yield commitments to Shareholders, the Investment Manager will be able to postpone harvesting programmes during periods of short-term timber pricing volatility
FSF is in a strong position where its product has a very low carbon intensity and a long time horizon (notably only processing and delivery costs with product going to mills approximately every 40 years)
The risk that there is resistance to change of land use from the public generating negative PR.
Negative press and media coverage could negatively impact investor sentiment, ultimately impacting the ability to raise more capital.
The risk that the UK Government changes its net zero strategy, leading to less support for sustainable forestry and climate action; timber regulation changes in favour of only broadleaf afforestation schemes to achieve net zero action; fewer grants; commercial timber falling out of favour; WCC changing the Carbon Credit Policy; and convoluted policy developments.
The financial statements of the Company for the year ended 30 September 2023 are set out on pages 88 to 106.
The Company prepared the audited financial statements for the year to 30 September 2023 in accordance with the UK adopted International Accounting Standards as applicable to companies reporting under those standards. The Company applies IFRS 10 and Investment Entities: Amendments to IFRS 10, IFRS 12 and measures all their subsidiaries that are themselves investment entities at fair value. The Company accounts for its interest in its wholly owned direct subsidiary FSFC Holdings Limited as an investment at fair value through profit or loss in accordance with IFRS 13 Fair Value Measurement.
The primary impact of this application, in comparison to consolidating subsidiaries, is that the cash balances, the working capital balances and borrowings in the intermediate holding companies and project companies are presented as part of the Company's fair value of investments.
The Company, its subsidiaries FSFC Holdings Limited and FSFC Holdings 2 Limited (together the "Group"), hold investments in 68 portfolio properties held within five special purpose vehicles which intend to make distributions in the form of interest on loans and dividends on equity as well as loan repayments and equity redemptions.
For more information on the basis of accounting and Company structure, please refer to the notes to the financial statements on pages 92 to 106.
| All amounts presented in £million (except as noted) | As at 30 September 2023 |
As at 30 September 2022 |
|---|---|---|
| Gross Asset Value ("GAV")1 | 179.6 | 180.6 |
| Market capitalisation | 140.2 | 182.4 |
| Net Asset Value ("NAV")2 | 169.2 | 180.6 |
| NAV per share (pence) | 98.4 | 105.0 |
| Total return on investment | (8.7) | 11.0 |
| Profit/(loss) before tax | (11.3) | 8.8 |
| Earnings/(losses) per share (pence) | (6.6) | 6.2 |
Calculated as the sum of the NAV and total outstanding debt on page 47.
Total equity as per the statement of financial position on page 89.
Net assets decreased 6.3% from £180.6 million at 30 September 2022 to £169.2 million at 30 September 2023.
The net assets of £169.2 million comprise £172.2 million of forestry and afforestation assets, with an additional £2.7 million carbon credit valuation and cash balances of £1.2 million in the Company and £2.7 million in the project companies. Offset by the drawn Revolving Credit Facility ("RCF") balance of £10.4 million, £2.0 million of other assets in the Company and £1.2 million of other liabilities in the project companies.
At 30 September 2023, £10.4 million of the Group's £30 million RCF had been drawn. The GAV is equal to the sum of the NAV of £169.2 million and the outstanding debt of £10.4 million as described in the alternative measures table on page 50. The GAV as at 30 September 2023 was £179.6 million.
| As at | As at | |
|---|---|---|
| 30 September | 30 September | |
| All amounts presented in £million (except as noted) | 2023 | 2022 |
| Red Book valuation1 | 172.2 | 144.2 |
| Carbon credits valuation2 | 2.7 | 0.6 |
| Portfolio value | 174.9 | 144.8 |
| Project companies' cash | 2.7 | 2.0 |
| Project companies' other net liabilities | (1.2) | (0.5) |
| Revolving Credit Facility | (10.4) | — |
| Investments at fair value through profit or loss | 166.0 | 146.3 |
| Company's cash | 1.2 | 34.3 |
| Company's other net assets | 2.0 | — |
| Net Asset Value | 169.2 | 180.6 |
| Number of shares | 172,056,075 | 172,056,075 |
| Net Asset Value per share (pence) | 98.4 | 105.0 |
Classified as the fair value of the underlying forestry assets held through the SPVs.
The carbon credit valuation noted is based on value ascribed to progress towards creation of carbon credits.
As at 30 September 2023, the Company had used £10.4 million of its RCF with £19.6 million remaining undrawn. The total outstanding £10.4 million RCF balance represented 5.8% of GAV (30 September 2022: 0%).
Details of the debt arrangements:
| Borrower | Provider | Facility type | Outstanding | Maturity | Applicable rate1 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| FSFC | Clydesdale | Revolving | SONIA + | ||
| Holdings 2 | Bank PLC | credit | £10.40m | July 2025 | (2.00%-2.20%) |
The Net Asset Value at 30 September 2023 was £169.2 million, compared to £180.6 million at 30 September 2022. The decrease of £11.4 million is the net impact of a reduction of the fair value of the existing afforestation and forestry assets by £6.5 million, acquisition costs of £2.0 million, fund operational expenditure of £3.4 million, asset-level operational expenditure of £1.9 million and £1.3 million of capital expenditure, offset by grant and timber income of £1.7 million and an additional £2.1 million for 107,591 carbon credits attributed to four underlying afforestation assets where planting has been completed during the year.
The Company's loss before tax for the year to 30 September 2023 was £11.3 million, generating negative earnings of (6.6) pence per share.
For the period to 30 September 2023, the total return on investments was £(8.7) million, which relates to £2.6 million of interest on the FSFC Holdings loan notes and £11.3 million net losses on investments at fair value. The interest income is from the Company's Shareholder loan to FSFC Holdings Limited. The net loss on investment is generated by the net fair value movement on the Company's investment in FSFC Holdings Limited.
Operating expenses included in the income statement for the period were £2.7 million, in line with expectations. These comprise investment management fees of £1.6 million and £1.1 million of operating expenses. The details on how the investment management fees are charged are set out in note 5 to the financial statements.
| Period from | ||
|---|---|---|
| Year to | 31 August 2022 | |
| 30 September | to 30 September | |
| All amounts presented in £million (except as noted) | 2023 | 2022 |
| Interest received on FSFC Holdings loan notes | 2.6 | 0.9 |
| Net (losses)/gains on investments at fair value | (11.3) | 10.1 |
| Total return on investment | (8.7) | 11.0 |
| Operating expenses | (2.6) | (2.2) |
| Profit before tax | (11.3) | 8.8 |
| Earnings per share (pence) | (6.6) | 6.2 |
The ongoing charges ratio is an indicator of the costs incurred in the day-to-day management of the Fund. FSF uses the Association of Investment Companies ("AIC") recommended methodology for calculating this ratio, which is an annual figure.
The ongoing charges ratio for the year to 30 September 2023 was 1.46% (30 September 2022: 1.43%). The ongoing charges have been calculated, in accordance with AIC guidance, as annualised ongoing charges (i.e. excluding acquisition costs and other non-recurring items) divided by the average published unaudited Net Asset Value in the period. The ongoing charges percentage has been calculated on the consolidated basis and therefore takes into consideration the expenses of the Company, FSFC Holdings Limited and FSFC Holdings 2 Limited.
The Investment Manager believed this to be competitive for the market in which FSF operates and the stage of development and size of the Fund, demonstrating that management of the Fund is efficient with minimal expense incurred in its ordinary operation.
| Ongoing charges | |
|---|---|
| Ongoing charges ratio | 1.46% | |
|---|---|---|
| Total | 2.61 | |
| Other ongoing fees | 0.19 | 0.13 |
| Other legal and professional fees | 0.33 | |
| Audit fees | 0.15 | |
| Administration fees | 0.15 | |
| Directors' fees | 0.10 | |
| Investment management fees | 1.56 | |
| All amounts presented in £million (except as noted) | FSFC | FSFC H2 |
| Average | 177.9 |
|---|---|
| 30 September 2023 | 169.2 |
| 31 March 2023 | 186.6 |
| NAV | |
The Company held cash balances at 30 September 2023 of £1.2 million. This amount excludes cash held in subsidiaries. The breakdown of the movements in cash during the year is shown below.
| Year to | 31 August 2021 | |
|---|---|---|
| 30 September | to 30 September | |
| 2023 | 2022 | |
| Opening cash balance | 34.3 | — |
| Gross proceeds from IPO and fundraising | — | 175.0 |
| IPO and share issuance costs | — | (3.2) |
| Investment in FSFC Holdings Limited | ||
| (equity and loan notes) | (31.0) | (136.2) |
| Loan interest receipts | 0.4 | — |
| Group movements in working capital | 0.2 | 0.9 |
| Directors' fees and expenses | (0.2) | (0.1) |
| Investment management fees | (1.5) | (1.1) |
| Administrative expenses | (1.0) | (1.0) |
| Company's closing cash balance | 1.2 | 34.3 |
Combined asset-level income analysis
| Total asset-level revenue | 2.1 | |
|---|---|---|
| Other income | 0.2 | Includes sporting and hospitality rental income |
| Hydro power | 0.1 | Hydro electricity sales at Fordie |
| Livestock sales and agricultural rent | 0.2 | Includes livestock sales and land rental for livestock |
| Timber income | 0.7 | 16,755 tonnes of harvesting |
| Grant income | 0.9 | 472 hectares of planting |
| Asset-level revenue type | Revenue (£m) | Details |
The underlying investments generate revenue from grants, timber harvesting and a number of isolated activities across a number of sites. Details of the combined income
The Group is defined as the Company and its two intermediate holding companies. The cash flows for the Group of £1.2 million include £0.01 million in FSFC Holdings 2 Limited.
| APM purpose | Calculation | APM value | Reconciliation to IFRS |
|---|---|---|---|
| Net Asset Value ("NAV") A measure of the value of the Company's total assets. |
The sum of net assets of the Company as shown on the statement of financial position. |
£169.2 million | The calculation uses the Net Asset Value as per the statement of financial position on page 89. |
| Gross Asset Value ("GAV") A measure of the value of the Company's total assets. Gross Asset Value on investment basis including debt. |
The sum of total assets of the Company as shown on the statement of financial position and the total debt of the Group. |
£179.6 million | The calculation uses the Net Asset Value as per the statement of financial position on page 89 and total outstanding debt on page 47. |
| Net Asset Value per share Allows investors to gauge whether shares are trading at a premium or a discount by comparing the Net Asset Value per share with the share price. |
The net assets divided by the number of Ordinary Shares in issuance. |
98.4 pence | As per the closing Net Asset Value per the statement of financial position on page 89 and the closing number of Ordinary Shares as per note 13 of the financial statements on page 100. |
| Total NAV return since IPO A measure of financial performance, indicating the movement of the value of the Fund since IPO and expressed as a percentage. |
Closing NAV per share as at 30 September 2023 plus all dividends since IPO assumed reinvested, divided by the NAV at IPO, expressed as a percentage. |
0.3% | The calculation uses the Net Asset Value as per the statement of financial position on page 89 and cash dividends as per the statement of cash flows on page 91. |
| Market capitalisation Provides an indication of the size of the Company. |
Closing share price as at 30 September 2023 multiplied by the closing number of Ordinary Shares in issuance. |
£140.2 million | The calculation uses the closing share price as per the key investment metric table on page 44 and the closing number of Ordinary Shares as per note 13 of the financial statements on page 100. |
| Ongoing charges A measure, expressed as a percentage of average net assets, of the regular, recurring annual costs of running the Company. |
Calculated and disclosed in accordance with the AIC methodology. Annualised expenses divided by average NAV. |
1.46% | Ongoing charges are detailed on page 48. |
| Gearing A measure of financial risk on the balance sheet of the Group. |
Total debt of the Group and underlying investments as shown on page 47 as a percentage of GAV. |
5.8% | The calculation uses the total debt on page 47 and the Net Asset Value as per the statement of financial position on page 89. |
51
FORESIGHT SUSTAINABLE FORESTRY COMPANY PLC Annual Report and Financial Statements 2023
OVERVIEW STRATEGIC REPORT GOVERNANCE FINANCIAL Strategy Performance
ADDITIONAL INFORMATION
| BOARD OF DIRECTORS | 52 |
|---|---|
| BOARD LEADERSHIP AND COMPANY PURPOSE |
53 |
| DIVISION OF RESPONSIBILITIES | 55 |
| REPORT OF THE AUDIT AND RISK COMMITTEE |
56 |
| REPORT OF THE MANAGEMENT ENGAGEMENT COMMITTEE |
60 |
REPORT OF THE SUSTAINABILITY AND ESG COMMITTEE 62
| REPORT OF THE NOMINATION AND | |
|---|---|
| REMUNERATION COMMITTEE | 64 |
| DIRECTORS' REMUNERATION | |
| REPORT | 68 |
| DIRECTORS' REPORT | 71 |
| DIRECTORS' RESPONSIBILITIES |
STATEMENT 79
Richard Davidson Chair of the Board, Management Engagement Committee Chair
Richard has a 20-year track record of investing in UK forestry and has been heavily involved in the management of his own Scottish forestry investments, including the planning and design of several new planting projects. He was previously the chair of the investment committee of Gresham House Forestry.
Richard was formerly a Managing Director and Investment Strategist at Morgan Stanley. He was also previously a partner of Lansdowne Partners, running the macro fund. Richard chairs the University of Edinburgh investment committee, overseeing the university's endowment.
Aberforth Smaller Companies Trust Plc
MIGO Opportunities Trust Plc
Sarika Patel Non-Executive Director, Audit and Risk Committee Chair, Senior Independent Director
Sarika has nearly 30 years' experience in a mixture of public and private organisations. She is a chartered accountant and a chartered marketer. Sarika is also currently Chair of Action for Children and is a Board Member of the Office for Nuclear Regulation where she chairs the Audit, Risk and Assurance Committee.
abrdn Equity Investment Trust Plc SDCL Energy Efficiency Income Trust Plc Office for Nuclear Regulation Action for Children
London General Surgery Ltd
Josephine Bush Non-Executive Director, Sustainability and ESG Committee Chair
Josephine was a senior partner at EY for 14 years, specialising in the renewable energy sector. She is a qualified solicitor and chartered tax adviser, as well as earning the CFA ESG investing qualification and a sustainable finance certification. She is a fellow of the Royal Geographic Society.
JRB Consulting Limited Vulcan Energy Resources Sustineri Strategy Ltd NextEnergy Solar Fund Plc
Christopher Sutton Non-Executive Director, Nomination and Remuneration Committee Chair
Christopher was a director of James Latham plc, one of the UK's largest independent trade distributors of timber, panels and decorative surfaces, for 14 years. He is currently the Chair of Timber Development UK, a Non-Executive Commercial Director of UNWASTED and an ambassador for the National Forest Company.
Timber Development UK Limited CDS Consultants Limited UNWASTED Group Plc
Nomination and Remuneration Committee
Sustainability and ESG Committee
Management Engagement Committee
Chair
Shareholders and stakeholders
The role of the Board is to collectively promote the long-term success of the Company. The Board shapes the Company's strategy, having regard to all stakeholders within a framework of effective controls. The "Matters Reserved for the Board" is available to view on the Company's website or by writing to the Company Secretary at the registered office.
| Section 172 statement | Pages 13 and 14 |
|---|---|
| Principal risks | Pages 41 to 45 |
The Board has established four Committees to focus on the specific activities of the Company, under the chairmanship of different members of the Board, and ultimately all reporting to the full Board.
The day-to-day management of the Company and in particular the management of its forestry and afforestation portfolio.
The Company's stakeholders play an important role in monitoring and safeguarding its governance. The Board ensures that its highly experienced third-party advisers, such as its corporate broker and legal adviser, are consulted on appropriate matters. Pages 13 and 14
Pages 13 and 14
Shareholders
Nomination and Remuneration Committee Ensures the Board and its Committees Pages 64 to 67
Oversees financial reporting, maintains a constructive relationship with the external auditor and monitors the effectiveness of the Company's risk management systems.
have the appropriate balance of skills, knowledge, diversity, experience and independence. Establishes a remuneration policy and ensures there is a clear link between performance and remuneration.
Pages 62 and 63
Pages 60 and 61
Pages 56 to 59
Audit and Risk Committee
Provides oversight in relation to its Sustainability and ESG strategy.
Reviews the performance of the Investment Manager, Fund Administrator, Company Secretary and key external service providers.
OVERVIEW STRATEGIC REPORT GOVERNANCE FINANCIAL
Strategy Performance
INFORMATION
CORPORATE GOVERNANCE REPORT
The Company has a clear and consistent purpose, which forms the foundation of its strategic objectives. The Company's Board embeds a strong culture of governance, informed by a number of factors including its focus on long-term net total return through targeting sustainable impact investments and openness and transparency with stakeholders. This approach is at the heart of how the Directors fulfil their duty under Section 172 of the Companies Act 2006 and the Board feels strongly that its policies, practices and behaviours contribute effectively to the success of the Company and its stakeholders.
The Board meets formally on a quarterly basis and, in addition, also meets to review and discuss the Company's strategy annually. The Board also holds ad hoc meetings for matters such as to approve the half-yearly Net Asset Value, receive trading updates and other general corporate matters. The Company Secretary attends all scheduled meetings, whilst representatives of the Investment Manager, the external auditor and other advisers are invited to attend as required.
In addition to the scheduled Board and Committee meetings for FY23, there were a further seven Board meetings held during the period. Attendance at all scheduled meetings can be seen in the table below.
| Richard | Sarika | Josephine | Christopher | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Davidson | Patel | Bush | Sutton | |
| Quarterly Board meetings | 4/4 | 4/4 | 4/4 | 4/4 |
| Audit and Risk Committee meetings | 2/2 | 2/2 | 2/2 | 2/2 |
| Nomination and Remuneration Committee meetings |
1/1 | 1/1 | 1/1 | 1/1 |
| Management Engagement Committee meetings | 1/1 | 1/1 | 1/1 | 1/1 |
| Sustainability and ESG Committee meetings | 0/1 | 1/1 | 1/1 | 1/1 |
The Company has complied throughout the accounting period ended 30 September 2023 with the Provisions set out in Sections 5 to 9 of the AIC Code.
The Board has considered the need for an internal audit function and, as all the day-to-day operations of the Company are outsourced, this was not deemed necessary at this time. Due to the size of the Board and the nature of the Company's business, the Board considers it appropriate for the entire Board, including the Chair, to fulfil the role of the Audit and Risk Committee.
Under the AIC Code, the Board needs to consider whether it is appropriate to adopt the going concern basis of accounting in preparing the financial statements. The Board continues to adopt the going concern basis and the detailed consideration is contained on page 77.
The viability statement, under which the Directors assess the prospects of the Company over a longer period, is contained on page 77 and 78.
The Board undertook a robust assessment of the Company's emerging and principal risks during the year. Particular focus was given to the liquidity of the Company's assets and subsidiaries. Further details can be found on page 93.
| Board | Role overview |
|---|---|
| Chair | • Sets the agenda for Board meetings • Works with the Company Secretary to manage the meeting timetable • Facilitates open and constructive dialogue amongst Directors during meetings • Ensures timely flow of accurate and reliable information within the Board |
| Non-Executive Directors |
• Work closely with the Chair and Foresight in monitoring the Company's delivery of strategy • Ensure internal controls are robust and that an external audit is carried out • Provide constructive input to the development of the Company's strategy • Serve on the Board's Committees |
| Role overview | |
| Investment Manager | • Provides portfolio and risk management services • Ensures compliance with the Company's investment policy and the requirements of the AIFM Directive, pursuant to the Investment Management Agreement ("IMA") • Fulfils the duties set out in the IMA, which sets out the matters over which the Investment Manager has authority • Works alongside the Board on corporate strategy, risk management and corporate governance procedures • Provides full information on the Company's investment performance, assets, liabilities, projected cash flow and other relevant information to the Board at its quarterly meetings |
| Administrator | • Maintains the Company's books and records • Prepares the management and financial accounts • Calculates, in conjunction with the Investment Manager and Savills, the Company's NAV |
| Company Secretary | • Ensures regulatory compliance • Supports the Board's corporate governance processes and continuing obligations • General secretarial functions required by the Companies Act 2006 • Provides support to the Chair in ensuring timely and accurate information flows to the Board |
Sarika Patel Chair of the Audit and Risk Committee
The Audit and Risk Committee comprises the full Board and is chaired by Sarika Patel. Due to the size of the Board and the independent, non-executive nature of the Directors, the Board considers it appropriate for all of the Directors to be members of the Committee. The Committee's terms of reference were reviewed during the year and are available on the Company's website.
The Board is satisfied that, in line with the recommendations of the AIC Code, at least one member of the Audit and Risk Committee has recent and relevant financial experience, and that the Committee as a whole has experience relevant to the sector in which the Company operates. As the Chair of the Board was independent on appointment, it is considered appropriate for him to be a member of the Audit and Risk Committee and to bring his considerable experience in the forestry sector to bear on its activities.
The role of the Audit and Risk Committee is to ensure that the financial and other reporting of the Company is accurate, complete, and appropriately audited and reported thereon. The Committee reviews internal procedures of its advisers and agents to ensure that the Company's significant risks have been identified and that suitable steps have been taken to ensure that the controls in place appropriately mitigate these risks.
The duties of the Audit and Risk Committee are, inter alia:
• To review the Company's internal financial controls and review the adequacy and effectiveness of the Company's internal control and risk management systems and monitor the proposed implementation of such controls
STATEMENTS
In March 2023, the Committee undertook a detailed review of the Company's risk register and emerging risks. The risk register was updated to reflect, amongst other things, increased inflation and interest rates and the general macroeconomic challenges in the market.
During the year, the Audit and Risk Committee has sought assurances as to the resilience of the reporting and control systems in place for both the management of the portfolio and for the Company's investment activities. The Committee will continue to evaluate and challenge the resilience of all key agents to the Company.
Although the Board has overall responsibility for preparing the Annual Report and Financial Statements, the Audit and Risk Committee considers the form and content of the Annual Report and Financial Statements and any significant areas of complexity, judgement and estimation that have been applied in the preparation of the financial statements. These areas of judgement and estimation were discussed with the Investment Manager, Administrator and auditor during the year and the Audit and Risk Committee reviewed and agreed the auditor's audit plan and audit findings report following the conclusion of its year-end audit.
The Committee formally met twice during the year and attendance is set out on page 54. The meetings allowed sufficient time to enable the Committee to consider all the matters of importance and the Committee was satisfied that it received full information in a timely manner to allow it to fulfil its obligations. The formal Audit and Risk Committee meetings were also attended by representatives of the Investment Manager, Administrator and Company Secretary.
The Board has ultimate responsibility for the effective management of risk for the Company including determining its risk appetite and identifying key strategic and emerging risks. The Audit and Risk Committee serves as a governance body to oversee, review and challenge the risk management processes. The Committee has conducted a robust assessment of the principal risks faced by the Company and was satisfied on the adequacy and effectiveness of the Company's risk management systems with appropriate operational and assurance reporting from third parties. A description of these risks, including procedures employed to manage or mitigate them, is included in the strategic report on pages 41 to 45.
The Board is responsible for the internal financial control systems of the Company and for reviewing their effectiveness. It has contractually delegated these services to third parties, but the Directors annually review the internal control framework established by the Investment Manager and Administrator to satisfy itself on the effectiveness of internal financial control.
The Directors receive and consider quarterly reports from the Investment Manager, giving full details of the portfolio and of all aspects of the financial position of the Company. Additional ad hoc reports are received as required and Directors have access at all times to the advice and services of the Company Secretary, which is responsible for ensuring that Board procedures are followed, and that applicable rules and regulations are complied with.
The Board has reviewed the need for an internal audit function. It has decided that the systems and procedures adopted by the Investment Manager, Administrator, the Audit and Risk Committee and other third-party advisers provide sufficient assurance that a sound system of internal control, which safeguards Shareholders' investments and the Company's assets, is maintained. In addition, the Company's financial statements are audited by external auditors. The Board has therefore concluded that it is not necessary to establish an internal audit function at present but this approach will be kept under review.
INFORMATION
As part of the review of auditor independence and effectiveness, Ernst & Young LLP ("EY") has confirmed that they are independent of the Company and have complied with the relevant auditing standards. In evaluation of EY's performance, the Audit and Risk Committee has taken into consideration the skills and experience of the firm and of the audit team.
The Committee assessed the effectiveness of the audit process through the quality of the audit planning reports it received from EY, together with the contribution which EY made to the discussion of any matters raised in these reports or by Committee members. The Committee also took into account any relevant observations made by the Investment Manager and Company Secretary. The Committee is satisfied that EY provides an effective independent challenge in carrying out its responsibilities.
EY was appointed as the Company's auditor upon its IPO in November 2021. Having considered the effectiveness of the audit, including reviewing the Audit Quality Inspection Reports in relation to EY published by the Financial Reporting Council, the Audit and Risk Committee has recommended the continuing appointment of EY to the Board. EY's performance will continue to be reviewed annually, taking into account all relevant guidance and best practice.
All non-audit work to be carried out by EY must be approved in advance by the Audit and Risk Committee to avoid compromising the independence of EY as auditor. No non-audit fees were incurred during the financial year to 30 September 2023.
| Service provided (excluding VAT) |
2023 fee | 2022 fee |
|---|---|---|
| Audit services | £143,775 | £118,250 |
| Non-audit services | £0 | £0 |
| Total | £143,775 | £118,250 |
The key areas of risk identified and considered by the Committee in relation to the business activities and financial statements of the Company for the year ended 30 September 2023 were as follows:
Although valued by an independent firm of valuers, Savills, the valuation of the Company's portfolio is inherently subjective, requiring significant judgement by the valuers. Errors in the valuation could have a material impact on the Company's NAV. Further information about the portfolio and inputs to the valuations are set out in note 10 to the financial statements.
As the sale of carbon credits is a relatively new area, support for the pricing and valuations prepared by the Company is more limited than its forestry and afforestation assets. As carbon credits now make up a larger area of the portfolio than the previous year, errors or an overly conservative approach to the valuation have the potential to impact the Company's NAV in a material way.
Verification of the ESG metrics contained on pages 34 to 36 does not form part of the scope of the external audit. Incomplete or inaccurate data contributing to these metrics could lead to errors in reporting the Company's significant ESG considerations to Shareholders.
The Directors are required to prepare the financial statements on a going concern basis unless they intend to liquidate the Company or have no alternative but to do so.
The Investment Manager liaises with the valuers on a regular basis to ensure they have up-to-date management information to value the portfolio. The Board reviewed the results of the valuation procedure at each half-year and discussed in detail the process of producing each valuation with the Investment Manager.
The Investment Manager discussed with the auditor the work performed to confirm the valuation and existence of the assets in the portfolio. The 30 September valuation was also discussed in detail with Savills to ensure that the Board understood the assumptions underlying the valuation and sensitivities inherent in the valuation and any significant area of judgement.
The Investment Manager and the valuer worked closely together to consider the process for the valuation of the Company's carbon credits. Details of the methodology and assumptions applied can be found on page 32. The valuers also reported directly to the Board at its strategy day in August 2023, in relation to both the forestry and afforestation market and the outlook for carbon credit valuations.
The Board reviewed the results of the valuation procedure at each half-year and discussed in detail the process of producing each valuation with the Investment Manager.
The Audit and Risk Committee worked closely with the Sustainability and ESG Committee and the Investment Manager to ensure that this data is reliable, accurate and being sufficiently tested. Further detail on how these metrics have been produced can be found in the Sustainability and ESG Committee report on pages 62 and 63.
In assessing the Company's going concern, the Committee has taken into consideration the current economic situation, the principal risks facing the Company, its loan arrangements and liquidity position. The Company's going concern statement can be found on page 93.
The Audit and Risk Committee has concluded that the Annual Report and Financial Statements for the year ended 30 September 2023, taken as a whole, are fair, balanced and understandable and provide the information necessary for Shareholders to assess the Company's business model, strategy and performance.
This conclusion was reached through knowledge of the Company and its activities, a detailed review of this Annual Report and enquiries of the various parties involved in the preparation of the Annual Report and Financial Statements. The Audit and Risk Committee has reported to, and agreed its conclusions with, the Board.
A detailed and rigorous evaluation of the Committee was undertaken as part of the Board's annual performance evaluation. The skills and experience of the members, including recent and relevant financial experience and industry experience, were found to be appropriate. The Committee was found to be functioning effectively and all Committee members were satisfied with the overall workings of the Committee. Through the Nomination and Remuneration Committee, there was also consideration of succession planning and the continued independence of all the members of the Committee.
Chair of the Audit and Risk Committee 5 December 2023
OVERVIEW STRATEGIC REPORT GOVERNANCE FINANCIAL
Strategy Performance
Richard Davidson Chair of the Management Engagement Committee
The Management Engagement Committee comprises the full Board with Richard Davidson as Chair. The Committee's terms of reference were reviewed during the year and are available on the Company's website.
The duty of the Management Engagement Committee is to review the terms of appointment of, and the performance by, the Investment Manager, the Administrator and the other key service providers appointed by the Company and to decide whether it is in the best interests of Shareholders for those appointments to continue.
The Company's auditor is not included in this review as their appointment falls under the remit of the Audit and Risk Committee.
The following are considered particular areas of focus for the Committee:
To regularly review the composition and performance of the key personnel performing the services on behalf of the Investment Manager and consider whether the continuing appointment of the Investment Manager, on the terms of the Investment Management Agreement, is in the interests of Shareholders as a whole, and make recommendations to the Board thereon together with a statement of the reasons for this view
To consider and review the level and method of remuneration of the Investment Manager pursuant to the terms of the Investment Management Agreement, including the methodology of calculation of the annual fee and any performance fee
In addition to the Committee members drawing upon their own experiences of working with the service providers, the Committee also had Foresight Group complete assessments of the performance of the other service providers. This feedback was carefully reviewed and discussed by the Committee.
OVERVIEW STRATEGIC REPORT GOVERNANCE FINANCIAL
Strategy Performance
INFORMATION
The day-to-day management of the Company, and in particular the management of its forestry and afforestation portfolio, is delegated to the Investment Manager. The Committee carried out a robust assessment of the Investment Manager during the year, including fee levels. The feedback was positive. The Board requested a breakdown of the investment management fees, including fees paid to EJD Forestry for asset management services, and these were presented and discussed at the annual strategy day. It was concluded that, despite the rate of acquisitions in the 2023 financial year being lower than the previous year, the development of the Company's afforestation portfolio required a considerable time commitment. The Investment Manager also employed a portfolio manager during the year to assist with the implementation of the Company's considerable planting programme in spring 2024. The increased resource within the portfolio management team at Foresight is expected to allow Robert Guest and Richard Kelly additional time to focus on the overall strategy of the portfolio and seeking prospects for improved performance and growth. The Board also reviewed an Investment Manager prepared fee benchmarking exercise, comparing the Investment Manager's fees to other equivalent forestry investment funds and alternative investment trusts. The Board was satisfied that the investment management fees represented good value for the Company. Therefore, no fee changes were recommended to the Board by the Committee for this financial year.
The Committee remains firmly of the view that the Investment Manager demonstrates the skills and commitment to perform its role. The Committee recommended the Investment Manager's continued appointment to the Board, and it was unanimously agreed that this is in the best interests of Shareholders.
Foresight Group LLP has served as Administrator and Company Secretary to the Company since its IPO in November 2021.
Under the terms of the Investment Management Agreement, Foresight Group is entitled to an annual fee in respect of administration and company secretarial services which is calculated and payable monthly in arrears as the greater of: (i) 0.07 per cent. of the Net Asset Value per annum; and (ii) £120,000. The Investment Manager is also entitled to reimbursement of all out-of-pocket costs, expenses and charges reasonably and properly incurred on behalf of the Company in connection with these services. No additional fees were paid to the Administrator and Company Secretary during the period.
Following the Committee's recommendation, the Board agreed that the continued appointment of the Administrator and Company Secretary is in the best interests of the Company and its Shareholders.
During the year, the Management Engagement Committee conducted a review of the Company's other key service providers, as listed at the back of this Annual Report. The Committee reviewed the performance as well as the fees charged by each service provider and instructed the Investment Manager to provide feedback to those providers where it was deemed appropriate. As a result of this review and following the departure of the Company's main corporate broker contact, who had been instrumental in the Company's IPO, the Company undertook a formal and rigorous tender process to select a new corporate broker. A decision was made after the year end to appoint Stifel Nicolaus Europe Limited as the new corporate broker to the Company.
The Company appointed a new PR Adviser, SEC Newgate, during the year and has been pleased with the results produced to date.
Following a robust review of the Committee as part of the Company's annual performance evaluation, the experience of the Committee's members was found to be appropriate. Committee meetings were considered effective and efficient, and all members contributed appropriately.
Chair of the Management Engagement Committee 5 December 2023
Josephine Bush Chair of the Sustainability and ESG Committee
The Sustainability and ESG Committee comprises the full Board and is chaired by Josephine Bush. It is considered appropriate that all Directors are members of the Committee due to the central focus on sustainability of the Company and the importance of all Board members remaining up to date with sustainability and ESG matters.
The Sustainability and ESG Committee is responsible for reviewing the Company's ESG strategy and ensuring this is in line with the aims and objectives agreed by the Board and the Investment Manager. The Committee's terms of reference were reviewed during the year and are available on the Company's website.
The duties of the Sustainability and ESG Committee are, inter alia:
The Sustainability and ESG Committee met once during the year to oversee, guide and discuss the Company's approach to sustainability and ESG strategy, review progress against KPIs, and to assess the disclosures to make in this report and the separate Sustainability and ESG report. The Sustainability and ESG Committee Chair also met with representatives of the Investment Manager throughout the year to progress and evolve the approach to sustainability, and oversee the finalisation of the standalone Sustainability and ESG report, which was published in April 2023. The Company Secretary attends the meetings as Secretary to the Committee. In addition, representatives of the Investment Manager are also invited to attend.
OVERVIEW STRATEGIC REPORT GOVERNANCE FINANCIAL
Strategy Performance
The Company has categorised its ESG commitments into a series of sustainable business initiatives, measures and targets, with the core aim of generating "natural capital alpha" (as defined within the standalone Sustainability and ESG report) through sustainable forestry management practice. This strategy is set out on page 33 of this report and in the standalone Sustainability and ESG report published on 18 April 2023.
In recognition of the increasing importance of Sustainability and ESG credentials to Shareholders, the Board prepared and published a separate Sustainability and ESG report on 18 April 2023, following the publication of the 2022 Annual Report and Financial Statements. The Sustainability and ESG report aimed to provide additional detail on the narrative surrounding the statistics set out on pages 62 and 63.
Following positive engagement and feedback on the content of the report, the Committee has taken the decision to prepare an updated version for the 2023 financial year, which will build on the Company's sustainability strategy, climate-related risk management, metrics and targets.
The Committee has considered the ISSB's first sustainability-related reporting standards, S1 and S2, released in June 2023 (the "Standards"), and is aware that the Standards are open for voluntary adoption for annual reporting periods commencing on or after 1 January 2024, with reporting to commence in 2025. It is the view of the Board and the Investment Manager that the Standards adopt a wider approach to sustainability and the Company has a strong baseline to support a move towards the ISSB recommendations. Therefore, the Company will continue to report against TCFD for the 2024 financial year with a view to moving to the voluntary adoption of the ISSB Standards for the 2025 financial year.
An evaluation of the Committee was undertaken as part of the Board's annual performance evaluation. The Committee was found to be functioning well and that its approach to Sustainability and ESG was appropriate for the Company.
Chair of the Sustainability and ESG Committee
5 December 2023
OVERVIEW STRATEGIC REPORT GOVERNANCE FINANCIAL
Strategy Performance
NOMINATION AND REMUNERATION COMMITTEE REPORT
Christopher Sutton Chair of the Nomination and Remuneration Committee
The Nomination and Remuneration Committee comprises the full Board and is chaired by Christopher Sutton. The Board considers that, given its size, it would be unnecessarily burdensome to establish a Nomination and/or Remuneration Committee which did not include the entire Board and believes that this enables all Directors to be kept fully informed of any issues that arise on the Board. The Committee's terms of reference were reviewed during the year and these are available on the Company's website.
The role of the Nomination and Remuneration Committee is to ensure that there is a rigorous, formal and transparent procedure for appointments to the Board and to determine Director remuneration levels. The Committee assists the Board in ensuring that its composition is optimal for Board effectiveness and that it is able to operate in the best interests of Shareholders.
The Committee has various functions, the most important of which are:
The Nomination and Remuneration Committee meets formally at least once a year. At this meeting, the Committee discusses succession planning, Board composition and also reviews the results of the annual evaluation of the effectiveness of the Board and its Committees. The Company Secretary attends the meetings as Secretary to the Committee and representatives of the Investment Manager are invited to attend as required.
STATEMENTS
NOMINATION AND REMUNERATION COMMITTEE REPORT
The Committee has adopted a policy for succession planning and Board tenure, and this was reviewed during the year. Each Director has indicated their preference and intentions with regard to their length of service on the Board, with consideration being given to the AIC Code's recommendation of a maximum term of nine years. In acknowledgement of all Directors having the same appointment date, in the event that all current Directors are still in place within the next few years, the Board will agree provisional timings for the recruitment of new Board members. Any new Board members who will replace the Chair of the Board or the Chair of the Audit and Risk Committee will be appointed prior to the existing Director's resignation to ensure an effective handover is delivered. There are no expected Board changes for the year ending 30 September 2024.
The Board consists solely of Non-Executive Directors under the chairmanship of Richard Davidson. All the Directors are considered by the Board to be independent of the Investment Manager.
Richard Davidson was independent on appointment and is still considered to be independent. The Company is subject to the AIC Code and therefore there is no requirement to limit the Chair's tenure. The Directors' feedback during the 2023 Board evaluation process showed that the Chair effectively promoted a culture of openness and debate, facilitated constructive Board dynamics and ensured all Board members contributed effectively.
The Board supports the recommendations issued by the FTSE Women Leaders Review, the Parker Review and the Listing Rule requirement introduced in April 2022 for listed companies to target at least 40% female Board representation and at least one member of the Board from an ethnic minority background by December 2024. This information is set out in the tables below.
| Number of Board members |
Percentage of the Board |
Number of senior positions on the Board |
|
|---|---|---|---|
| Men | 2 | 50% | N/A1 |
| Women | 2 | 50% | N/A1 |
| Other categories | None | None | N/A1 |
| Number of Board members |
Percentage of the Board |
Number of senior positions on the Board |
|
|---|---|---|---|
| White British or other White (including minority white groups) |
3 | 75% | N/A1 |
| Mixed/multiple ethnic groups | None | None | N/A1 |
| Asian/Asian British | 1 | 25% | N/A1 |
| Black/African/Caribbean/Black British | None | None | N/A1 |
| Other ethnic group | None | None | N/A1 |
All current Board members have been drawn from diverse working and social experience with no prior connections between the individual Board members.
NOMINATION AND REMUNERATION COMMITTEE REPORT
During the year, a formal and rigorous evaluation of the performance of the Board, its Committees and the individual Directors was carried out through an assessment process led by the Nomination and Remuneration Committee Chair and the Company Secretary. Areas of particular strength included the balance of skills on the Board and the level of engagement and commitment shown by all members. The Board's close working relationship with the Investment Manager and detailed knowledge of the Company's strategy and the issues the Company faces were also noted.
| Key recommendations | Actions agreed |
|---|---|
| Legal and corporate governance | |
| • Increase the Board's understanding of the views and desires of the Company's Shareholders and stakeholders |
• Increased feedback from the Fund Managers regarding interactions with Shareholders • Encourage all Shareholders to attend the Company's second AGM in February 2024 • All Board members to remain open to discussions with Shareholders at any time |
| Meetings and communication | |
| • Feedback from the Board to the Investment Manager on timeliness of information and time frames for Board approval |
• The Committee felt that these issues had largely been resolved during the second half of the year and the upward trajectory should continue |
| Training and induction | |
| • Acknowledgement of the need for continued professional |
• Periodic training, increased attendance at site visits and the |
The Company Secretary considers the content of the review questionnaire, ensuring that this is tailored to suit the nature of the Company and the requirements of the AIC Code
The Company Secretary and the Nomination and Remuneration Committee Chair agree a timetable for the review to take place and the content of the questionnaire to be sent to Directors
Each Director provides their feedback to the Company Secretary through the questionnaire
development on the Board
and Remuneration Committee Chair
The full responses are provided to the Nomination
Results Reporting Feedback
An anonymised version of the consolidated scores and comments is included in the Nomination and Remuneration Committee meeting pack and a discussion lead by the Nomination and Remuneration Committee Chair
maintenance of a training log to be implemented
Any specific feedback relevant to an individual Director is provided to them privately by the Nomination and Remuneration Committee Chair
OVERVIEW STRATEGIC REPORT GOVERNANCE FINANCIAL
Strategy Performance
NOMINATION AND REMUNERATION COMMITTEE REPORT
The Committee acknowledges the AIC Code's recommendation for an independent Board evaluation to be carried out every three years. As the Company has only been operating for two years and no significant concerns were raised during the Board evaluation process, it is the Board's view that an external evaluation is not currently required. However, this will be kept under review throughout the upcoming year.
The Company's remuneration policy can be found in the Directors' remuneration report on pages 68 to 70. The remuneration policy was last put to a vote at the Company's first AGM in February 2023 and will be re-tabled every three years hereafter.
A detailed review of Board emolument levels was undertaken by the Committee during the year. This was supported by a peer group and fee analysis and taking into account the general macroeconomic environment and inflation levels. During this evaluation in the 2022 financial year, the Board's fees were found to be c.£10k below market rate for an investment trust of this size. Therefore, in addition to the increases implemented as at 1 October 2022, the Board decided to increase its base remuneration by a further £3,000 in order to more accurately reflect the current market and time commitment required of the Directors. Further, an additional fee of £1,000 per annum was awarded to Sarika Patel for her new role of Senior Independent Director. Both increases became effective on 1 October 2023. Additional fees for the roles of Chair of the Board and Committee Chairs remain unchanged. Full Director salary details can be found in the Directors' remuneration report on pages 68 to 70.
An evaluation of the Committee was undertaken as part of the Board's annual performance evaluation. The Committee was found to be functioning well and the diversity of skills and experience of its members were considered appropriate and sufficient to ensure informed debate and constructive challenge.
Chair of the Nomination and Remuneration Committee
5 December 2023
Christopher Sutton Nomination and Remuneration Committee Chair
The Board considers annually the level of fees paid to each Director. Whilst the Board has final determination of the level of Directors' fees, the Nomination and Remuneration Committee is responsible for assessing whether the current fee levels are appropriate. This review takes into account the individual responsibilities of each Board member under the Committee structure, anticipated input required to oversee the Company's activities in the future and how Board remuneration is structured for the Company's peers.
The Company's policy is that the remuneration of Directors should be determined with due regard to the experience of the Board as a whole, the time commitment required and to be fair and comparable to that of other Non-Executive Directors of similar companies. The Company may also periodically choose to benchmark Directors' fees with an independent review to ensure they remain competitive, fair and reasonable.
The fees for the Directors are determined within the limits set out in the Company's Articles of Association which states that the Directors' remuneration for their services in the office of director shall, in the aggregate, not exceed £300,000 per annum or such higher figure as the Company, by ordinary resolution, determines. The Directors may elect to apply the cash amount equal to their annual fee to subscribe for or to purchase Ordinary Shares. Directors' fees will be reviewed at least annually.
The Directors are entitled only to their annual fee and to be reimbursed for any expenses properly and reasonably incurred by them in and about the business of the Company or in the discharge of his or her duties as a Director.
Any Director who performs services which in the opinion of the Directors are outside the scope of the ordinary duties of a Director, may be paid such reasonable additional remuneration to be determined by the Directors or any committee appointed by the Directors and such additional remuneration shall be in addition to any remuneration provided for by way of their annual fee and their reasonable expenses.
STATEMENTS
No element of the Directors' remuneration is performance related, nor does any Director have any entitlement to pensions, share options or any long-term incentive plans from the Company.
The Directors hold their office in accordance with the Articles of Association and their appointment letters. No Director has a service contract with the Company, nor is any such contract proposed. The Directors' appointments can be terminated in accordance with the Articles of Association and their appointment letters and without compensation.
STATEMENTS
The Directors who served during the year received the following emoluments (excluding employers' National Insurance contributions) in the form of fees:
| Taxable | Basic | Committee | Additional | Total | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| benefits | fees | Chair fee | fees1 | fees | |
| 2023 | 2023 | 2023 | 2023 | 2023 | |
| Richard Davidson (Chair) |
— | £48,000 | — | £2,500 | £50,500 |
| Sarika Patel | £357 | £33,000 | £7,500 | £2,500 | £43,000 |
| Josephine Bush | £1,617 | £33,000 | £3,000 | £2,500 | £38,500 |
| Christopher Sutton |
£362 | £33,000 | £2,500 | £2,500 | £38,000 |
| Total | £2,336 | £147,000 | £13,000 | £10,000 | £170,000 |
30 September 2022, but paid in December 2022, in acknowledgement of the time commitment required of Board members surrounding the placing programme undertaken in June 2022.
Note – members of the Board were reimbursed for travel and accommodation expenses incurred in connection with their duties for the Company, which in aggregate amounted to £2,336.
As detailed in the Nomination and Remuneration Committee report, the Board has elected to increase Directors' fees by £3,000 per annum, plus an additional fee of £1,000 for Sarika Patel for her role as Senior Independent Director, effective 1 October 2023. Based on this, and the Directors appointed as at the date of this report, Board remuneration for the year ending 30 September 2024 is expected to be as follows:
| Total | £159,000 | £13,000 | £1,000 | £173,000 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Christopher Sutton | £36,000 | £2,500 | — | £38,500 |
| Josephine Bush | £36,000 | £3,000 | — | £39,000 |
| Sarika Patel | £36,000 | £7,500 | £1,000¹ | £44,500 |
| Richard Davidson (Chair) | £51,000 | — | — | £51,000 |
| Basic fees 2024 |
Committee Chair fee 2024 |
Additional fees 2024 |
Total fees 2024 |
The table below shows the actual expenditure during the year in relation to Directors' remuneration and Shareholder distributions in the financial year:
| Total 2023 |
|
|---|---|
| Aggregate Directors' remuneration | £170,000 |
| Aggregate dividends paid to Shareholders | — |
The Directors who held office at the year end and their interests in the Ordinary Shares of the Company as at 6 December 2023 and 30 September 2023 were as follows:
| 6 December 2023 |
30 September 2023 |
|
|---|---|---|
| Richard Davidson (Chair) | 100,000 | 100,000 |
| Sarika Patel | 24,000 | 24,000 |
| Josephine Bush | 19,000 | 19,000 |
| Christopher Sutton | 25,000 | 25,000 |
| Total | 168,000 | 168,000 |
INFORMATION
Although not forming part of this report, it is also noted that the senior personnel of the Investment Manager held in aggregate 78,804 Ordinary Shares of the Company as at 30 September 2023. As at 6 December 2023, these aggregate holdings were 78,804 Ordinary Shares.
In addition, 51,003,762 (29.64%) of the Company's shares are held by Blackmead Infrastructure Limited, an investee company of the Foresight Inheritance Tax Fund, which is also managed by the Investment Manager.
An ordinary resolution for the approval of the Directors' remuneration policy is proposed every three years and will therefore be put to Shareholders next at the AGM to be held in February 2026. An ordinary resolution for the approval of this Directors' remuneration report will be put to Shareholders at the forthcoming AGM in February 2024.
On behalf of the Board
Nomination and Remuneration Committee Chair
5 December 2023
The Directors present their report and financial statements of the Company for the year ended 30 September 2023. The corporate governance statement on page 86 forms part of their report.
Information required to be part of this Directors' report can be found elsewhere in the Annual Report as indicated below and is incorporated into this report by reference:
| Key performance indicators | Pages 11 and 12 |
|---|---|
| Principal risks and risk management | Pages 41 to 45 |
| Board of Directors | Page 52 |
| Report of the Audit and | |
| Risk Committee | Pages 56 to 59 |
| Report of the Nomination | |
| and Remuneration Committee | Pages 64 to 67 |
| Report of the Management | |
| Engagement Committee | Pages 60 and 61 |
| Report of the Sustainability | |
| and ESG Committee | Pages 62 and 63 |
| Remuneration report | Pages 68 to 70 |
Foresight Sustainable Forestry Company Plc (the "Company") is registered as a public limited company in terms of the Companies Act 2006 (number: 13594181). It is an investment company as defined by Section 833 of the Companies Act 2006.
The Company was incorporated on 31 August 2021 and listed on the premium segment of the Official List for trading on the London Stock Exchange's Main Market on 24 November 2021. The Company has a single share class of Ordinary Shares in issue.
The Company is a member of the Association of Investment Companies ("AIC"), Timber Development UK and Scottish Land & Estates.
The Company invests in forestry assets with cash flow typically reinvested for further accretive growth.
The Company intends to pay dividends in order to satisfy the ongoing requirements under the Investment Trust (Approved Company) (Tax) Regulations 2011 save that, in the medium term, the Company's forestry assets may also generate free cash flow which the Company may decide not to reinvest. In such case(s), the Company currently intends to distribute these amounts to Shareholders.
Distributions made by the Company may take either the form of dividend income or may be designated as interest distributions for UK tax purposes. The UK tax treatment of the Company's distributions may vary for a Shareholder depending on the classification of such distributions. In accordance with regulation 19 of the Investment Trust (Approved Company) (Tax) Regulations 2011, the Company will not (except to the extent permitted by those regulations) retain more than 15% of its income (as calculated for UK tax purposes) in respect of an accounting period.
In addition, the Company intends to explore the possible distribution of carbon credits "in specie" to Shareholders in the future.
Investors should note that references in this paragraph to "dividends" and "distributions" are intended to cover both dividend income and income which is designated as an interest distribution for UK tax purposes and therefore subject to the interest streaming regime applicable to investment trusts.
In accordance with the above policy, there have been no dividends paid to Shareholders during the year and the Directors are not recommending a final dividend.
The Company will seek to generate an attractive net total return for Shareholders over the longer term, comprising capital growth and aperiodic dividends, targeting sustainable impact through investment predominantly in sustainably managed forestry assets (including standing forests and afforestation assets). The Company will seek to make a direct contribution in the fight against climate change through forestry and afforestation carbon sequestration initiatives. The Company will seek to preserve and proactively enhance natural capital and biodiversity across its portfolio. It is expected that the Company will achieve, and aim to exceed, the requirements of compliance with the EU Green Taxonomy and Article 9 of the Sustainable Finance Disclosure Regulation ("SFDR").
The Company's investment policy was updated during the year following approval at a General Meeting of the members held on 21 December 2022. The amended policy is set out below.
The Company intends to achieve its investment objective by predominantly investing in a diversified portfolio of sustainable Forestry Assets, predominantly located in the UK.
STATEMENTS
"Forestry Assets" are land assets where stands of trees have a canopy cover of at least 20% of land area ("Standing Forests"), or have the potential to achieve this through new planting ("Afforestation") initiatives. These Forestry Assets may be used for planting, maintaining and growing trees for commercial production of timber or other forest products ("Commercial Forestry") or for non-commercial purposes ("Non-Commercial Forestry") and in both cases may include areas where a community of naturally occurring tree species regenerate by natural (i.e. without intervention) means ("native woodland") and areas that are left unplanted with trees ("open ground").
The Group will seek to acquire a mixture of cash flow generating sustainable Forestry Assets representing a mixture of Standing Forests (of varying age classes) together with land suitable for Afforestation projects (representing both Commercial Forestry projects and Non-Commercial Forestry projects) to achieve a balanced portfolio with an optimal harvesting and capital growth profile.
Diversification within the Group's portfolio will be achieved by:
Although the Group's revenues will primarily be generated by the sale of harvested timber and, in due course, the sale of carbon credits, where appropriate and practicable, the Group will also seek to generate ancillary non-core revenue streams from its Forestry Assets, including, but not limited to, the leasing or licensing of land to third parties for agricultural, sporting and tourism activities, the leasing of land to third parties for renewable energy and/or energy storage and/or telecommunications development projects (such as the erection of wind turbines or mobile telecommunications towers) and, if a future market develops, the sale of biodiversity credits.
The Company will gain exposure to Forestry Assets indirectly through its holding of equity interests in underlying asset holding companies. The Company will invest via equity or debt interests in such asset holding companies. The asset holding companies will use the funds received by the Company to acquire Forestry Assets directly or indirectly through intermediate holding companies.
Returns generated by the asset holding companies (either from the sale of harvested timber, the sale of carbon credits or from ancillary non-core revenue sources) will either be retained by the relevant asset holding companies and reinvested or paid to the Company in the form of dividends, distributions or the payment of interest on intra-group debt.
The Group may acquire freehold or leasehold interests in Forestry Assets or may acquire the shares in corporate entities holding such Forestry Assets.
Investments in Forestry Assets will typically entail 100% ownership by the Group. The Group may, however, enter into joint venture arrangements alongside one or more co-investors where the Investment Manager, in consultation with the Board, believes it is in the Group's best interests to do so (such as where an investment opportunity is too large for the resources of the Group on its own, to share risk or where a joint venture arrangement will optimise returns for the Group). In the case of such co-investments, the Group will target retaining a control position, where this is possible, or, where this is not possible, will have strong minority investor protections and governance rights.
In addition, as part of a transaction to acquire Forestry Assets, the Group may end up owning ancillary non-forestry related assets, including, but not limited to, residential land and buildings, vehicles, equipment, agricultural outbuildings and small-scale renewable energy assets (together "Non-Core Assets"). Where appropriate and beneficial to the overall strategy, the Group will look to realise the value of any Non-Core Assets over time for the benefit of Shareholders.
The Investment Manager will have overall responsibility for asset managing the Group's Forestry Assets (including any ancillary non-core revenue streams) and Non-Core Assets. The Group will also appoint appropriate specialist third-party forestry management companies who will be responsible for the day-to-day physical management of the Group's Forestry Assets, including harvesting and planting activity.
The Group's Forestry Assets will, where commercially appropriate, be operated with a view to generating carbon credits. Save where the sale of carbon credits is required to meet the working capital needs of the Group, the Company intends to realise the value of carbon credits for the direct benefit of Shareholders. Generally, the Company intends, when appropriate, to sell carbon credits and make aperiodic distributions to Shareholders of the net proceeds of such sales. As an alternative to receiving a cash distribution, the Company intends, where practicable, to offer Shareholders the option to elect to receive distributions "in kind" of carbon credits. The method and process for the distribution of any carbon credits "in kind" will be determined by the Board from time to time. The Company currently does not intend to retire carbon credits on behalf of Shareholders. The Company may, in the future, if considered appropriate, retire certain carbon credits generated from the Group's Forestry Assets for the purposes of meeting the Group's own net zero targets.
The Company will invest and manage its assets with the objective of spreading risk and, in doing so, will maintain the following investment restrictions:
No more than 10% of Gross Asset Value may be invested in Forestry Assets located in EEA countries
The maximum exposure to Afforestation projects will not exceed, in aggregate, 50% of Gross Asset Value
In accordance with the requirements of the Listing Rules, the Company will not undertake any trading activity which is material in the context of the Company as a whole.
Compliance with the above investment limits is measured at the time of investment and non-compliance resulting from changes in the price or value of assets following investment will not be considered as a breach of the investment limits.
Details of the financial risk management objectives and policies followed by the Directors can be found on pages 103 to 104.
The likely future developments of the Company are contained in the strategic report on pages 9 to 50.
Biographical details of the Directors, all of whom are non-executive, can be found on page 52.
The Directors do not have service contracts, but each new Director is provided with a letter of appointment. The Directors' letters of appointment are available on request at the Company's registered office during business hours.
The Articles of Association require that each Director retires by rotation and be re-elected every three years. The Board has agreed that, in accordance with governance best practice and the Provisions of the AIC Code, Directors will stand for election annually at each AGM.
The Directors' appointment dates are shown below:
| Date of original appointment |
|
|---|---|
| Richard Davidson (Chair) | 31 August 2021 |
| Sarika Patel | 31 August 2021 |
| Josephine Bush | 31 August 2021 |
| Christopher Sutton | 31 August 2021 |
The Directors believe that the Board has an appropriate balance of skills, experience, independence and knowledge of the Company and the sector in which it operates to enable it to provide effective strategic leadership and proper guidance to the Company. The Board confirms that, following the evaluation process set out in the report of the Nomination and Remuneration Committee on pages 66 and 67, the performance of each Director is and continues to be effective and demonstrates commitment to the role. The Board believes therefore, that it is in the interests of Shareholders that each of the Directors be re-elected.
Under the Companies Act 2006, a Director must avoid a situation where he or she has, or could have, a direct or indirect interest that conflicts, or possibly may conflict, with the Company's interests. This could also apply where a Director becomes a director of another company or trustee of another organisation. The Companies Act 2006 allows directors of public companies to authorise conflicts and potential conflicts, where appropriate, where the Articles of Association contain a provision to this effect. The Company's Articles of Association give the Directors authority to approve such situations.
The Company maintains a register of Directors' conflicts of interest which have been disclosed and approved by the other Directors. This register is kept up to date and the Directors are required to disclose to the Company Secretary any changes to conflicts or any potential new conflicts.
The Company's Investment Manager, Foresight Group LLP, is responsible for the acquisition and management of the Company's assets, including the sourcing and structuring of new acquisitions and advising on the Company's borrowing strategy. Foresight Group is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority.
Foresight Group was founded in 1984 and is a leading listed infrastructure and private equity investment manager. With a long-established focus on ESG and sustainability-led strategies, it aims to provide attractive returns to its institutional and private investors from hard-to-access private markets.
Foresight manages over 400 infrastructure assets with a focus on solar and onshore wind assets, bioenergy and waste, as well as renewable energy enabling projects, energy efficiency management solutions, social and core infrastructure projects and sustainable forestry assets. Its private equity team manages 11 regionally focused investment funds across the UK and an SME impact fund supporting Irish SMEs. This team reviews close to 2,500 business plans each year and currently supports more than 250 SMEs. Foresight Capital Management manages four listed strategies across seven investment vehicles.
Foresight operates in eight countries across Europe, Australia and the United States with AUM of £12.1 billion (unaudited as at 30 September 2023). Foresight Group Holdings Limited listed on the Main Market of the London Stock Exchange in February 2021.
Foresight's Infrastructure team consisted of 160+ full-time employees as at 30 September 2023. The team is comprised of:
The Foresight Group Infrastructure team has substantial experience in sourcing and executing all required elements of the capital structure of an investment across geographies, including project-level debt finance and other required forms of finance.
The key strengths of the infrastructure investment team include:
The Foresight portfolio management team consists of individuals with engineering, accountancy, consulting and operations backgrounds and is responsible for the process of "on-boarding", managing and reporting on the acquired assets. Members of these teams work closely with the Investment Manager together throughout the investment lifecycle.
The portfolio management services provided ensure the day-to-day operation of the forestry assets is robust, with commercial and strategic decisions clearly communicated to the various counterparties involved.
The services also include:
The AIFMD was implemented across the EU on 22 July 2013 and aims to harmonise the regulation of Alternative Investment Fund Managers ("AIFMs"). It imposes obligations on managers who manage or distribute Alternative Investment Funds ("AIFs") in the EU or who market shares in such funds to EU investors. Foresight Group LLP acts as AIFM to the Company and ensures compliance with regulation under the UK AIFMD and the UK National Private Placement Regime.
Information on the Company's share capital, including voting rights, as at 30 September 2023 can be found in note 13 to the financial statements.
As at 30 September 2023, the Company had received notification of the following holdings of voting rights (under the Financial Conduct Authority's Disclosure Guidance and Transparency Rules):
| 30 September 2023 | ||
|---|---|---|
| Investor | Number of Ordinary Shares held |
Percentage held1 |
| Blackmead Infrastructure | 51,503,762 | 29.93 |
| Aviva Investors | 14,876,607 | 8.65 |
| Rathbones | 13,382,175 | 7.78 |
| East Riding of Yorkshire | 13,238,318 | 7.69 |
| Equilibrium Asset Management | 11,802,000 | 6.86 |
| West Yorkshire PF | 11,000,000 | 6.39 |
| Cantor Fitzgerald Ireland | 8,852,145 | 5.14 |
| Privium Fund Management | 7,896,299 | 4.59 |
| Hargreaves Lansdown stockbrokers (EO) | 6,105,288 | 3.55 |
There have been no changes notified to the Company in respect of the above holdings, and no other new holdings notified, since the year end.
Related party transactions during the year to 30 September 2023 can be found in note 21 to the financial statements.
Information on the Directors' shareholdings as at 30 September 2023 can be found in the Directors' remuneration report on page 69.
The Company has maintained a Directors' and Officers' liability insurance policy on behalf of the Directors, indemnifying them in respect of certain liabilities that may be incurred by them in connection with the activities of the Company. This policy does not provide cover for fraudulent or dishonest actions by the Directors.
These are available on the Company's website or by application to the Company Secretary. Any amendment to the Company's Articles of Association may only be made by passing a special resolution of the Shareholders of the Company.
The Company does not have any branches outside the UK.
No political donations were made during the year.
The Company has no employees and therefore no employee share scheme or policies for the employment of disabled persons or employee engagement.
There are no disclosures required in accordance with Listing Rule 9.8.4R.
The Board recognises the importance of regular and effective communication with the Company's stakeholders. Further information on engagement with stakeholders during the year can be found in the Section 172 statement on pages 13 and 14.
Shareholders are invited to attend the Company's AGM to be held at The Shard, 32 London Bridge Street, London SE1 9SG on 21 February 2024. The AGM notice is contained in the circular dated 6 December 2023 which was published alongside this Annual Report.
Those Shareholders who are unable to attend the AGM in person are encouraged to raise any questions in advance with the Company Secretary at [email protected] (please include "FSF AGM" in the subject heading). Questions must be received by 5.30pm on 7 February 2024. Any questions received will be replied to by either the Investment Manager or the Board via the Company Secretary before the AGM. A Shareholder presentation will be made on the day and later made available on the Company's website updating Shareholders on the activities of the year.
To receive the Annual Report and Accounts of the Company for the year ended 30 September 2023.
To approve the Directors' Remuneration Report included in the Annual Report for the year ended 30 September 2023.
To re-elect Richard Davidson as a Director of the Company
To re-elect Sarika Patel as a Director of the Company
To re-elect Christopher Sutton as a Director of the Company
To re-elect Josephine Bush as a Director of the Company
To re-elect Ernst & Young LLP as external auditor to the Company.
To authorise the Directors to fix the auditor's remuneration until the conclusion of the next Annual General Meeting of the Company.
That, in addition to all existing authorities, the Directors be generally and unconditionally authorised to allot shares in the Company. Read more in the Circular dated 6 December 2023.
To adopt the Amended Investment Policy. Read more in the Circular dated 6 December 2023.
That, in addition to all existing authorities, the Directors be generally and unconditionally authorised to allot equity securities in the Company. Read more in the Circular dated 6 December 2023.
To authorise the Company to make market purchases of its own shares. Read more in the Circular dated 6 December 2023.
That a general meeting, other than an AGM, may be called on not less than 14 clear days' notice.
The Directors consider the passing of the resolutions to be proposed at the AGM to be in the best interests of the Company and its Shareholders and likely to promote the success of the Company for the benefit of its Shareholders as a whole. Accordingly, the Directors unanimously recommend that Shareholders should vote in favour of the resolutions, as they intend to in respect of their own beneficial shareholdings.
As an investment vehicle the Company does not provide goods or services in the normal course of business and does not have customers. Accordingly, the Directors consider that the Company does not fall within the scope of the Modern Slavery Act 2015 and is not, therefore, obliged to make a slavery and human trafficking statement. The Company's SPVs which hold its assets have their own policies in place related to modern slavery, as well as anti-bribery and corruption, sustainability and ESG, and health and safety. In any event, the Company considers its supply chains to be low risk for modern slavery.
In line with the requirements of The Criminal Finances Act 2017, the Directors confirm that the Company has a commitment to zero tolerance towards the criminal facilitation of tax evasion.
In order to ensure compliance with the UK Bribery Act 2010, the Directors confirm that the Company has zero tolerance towards bribery and a commitment to carry out business openly, honestly and fairly.
In considering the appointment of Directors, the Company will continue to show no bias for age, gender, race, sexual orientation, marital status, religion, nationality, ethnic or national origins, or disability.
INFORMATION
The Directors, in their consideration of going concern, have reviewed comprehensive cash flow forecasts prepared by the Company's Investment Manager, Foresight Group, which are based on prudent market data, a reasonable worst case and a stress test scenario and believe, based on those forecasts and an assessment of the Company's subsidiary's banking facilities, that it is appropriate to prepare the financial statements of the Company on the going concern basis.
In arriving at their conclusion, the Directors assessed the current macroeconomic situation, the RCF, liquidity position and the potential impact of the principal risks documented in the strategic report. In addition to these principal risks, the Directors have also considered the sustainability-related risks covering environmental, social and governance factors, including climate change (in line with the recommendations of the Task Force on Climate-related Financial Disclosures ("TCFD")), outlined on page 38. The Investment Manager has reviewed the portfolio's exposure to these risks in the period under review and has concluded that it is currently not material to the Fund, although it continues to monitor the market attentively.
The Directors have also considered scenario analysis on the impact of different levels of harvesting across the portfolio, over varying timescales, on the Company's financial position and the Company's ability to reduce outflows were liquid resources to be required.
The Directors also considered that the Company has adequate financial resources, and were mindful that the Group had unrestricted cash of £1.2 million as at 30 September 2023 and a revolving credit and accordion facility (available for investment in new or existing projects and working capital) of £30 million. As at 30 September 2023, the Company's wholly owned subsidiary FSFC Holdings 2 Limited had borrowed £10.4 million under the facility, leaving £19.6 million available to draw. All key financial covenants under this facility are forecast to continue to be complied with for the duration of the going concern assessment period.
The Investment Manager and Directors have assessed the headroom available to meet the revolving credit covenants. The covenants have been tested on downside risk scenarios and in all scenarios run, including the combined downside case, the Company remained compliant with its key covenants.
The Directors are satisfied that the Company has sufficient resources to continue to operate for the foreseeable future, a period of not less than 12 months from the date of this report. Accordingly, they continue to adopt the going concern basis in preparation of these financial statements.
In accordance with the UK Corporate Governance Code, the Board of Directors has assessed the viability of the Company over a five-year period to 30 September 2028, taking account of the Company's current position, the long-term nature of the assets in the portfolio and the potential impact of the principal risks documented on pages 41 to 45.
In addition to the principal risks, the Directors have also considered the sustainability-related risks covering environmental, social and governance factors, including climate change (in line with the recommendations of TCFD, outlined on page 38).
Sensitivity analysis has also been undertaken to consider the potential impact of principal and emerging risks that could threaten the business model, future performance, solvency and liquidity over the period. In particular, this has considered the inability to access sufficient funding in the debt and equity markets and deploy capital to complete growth expectations, timber price volatility and a reduction in demand for users of timber, continued government support for voluntary carbon credits market and the impact of a proportion of the portfolio not harvesting due to adverse weather conditions.
The Directors have determined that a five-year look forward to September 2028 is an appropriate period over which to provide its viability statement. This is consistent with the outlook period used in economic and other medium-term forecasts regularly prepared for the Board by the Investment Manager and the discussion of any new strategies undertaken by the Board in its normal course of business. These reviews consider both the market opportunity and the associated risks, principally the ability to raise third-party funds and invest capital, or mitigating actions taken, such as sale of forestry assets and utilisation of additional borrowings available under the RCF.
The Group's risk management processes outlined on pages 39 to 45 set out the key risks for the next five years and beyond. These include rising debt costs and persistently high inflation, financing capital risks and timber market volatility. Risks presented by the current macro environment also include Russia's invasion of Ukraine. Whilst these risks are deemed significant to the Group's ability to operate its projects, generate revenue and to the value of the Company's investments, the Directors believe that this has had limited impact on the business to date as it is invested in real assets, principally freeholds of UK land and forest stock. The forest stock enjoys biological growth regardless of fluctuations in financial markets. UK freeholds, real assets and commodities like timber have a track record of good performance during periods of inflation and instability of equity markets. Risk mitigating activities (as outlined on pages 39 to 45) have also aided in the reduction of the impact.
Timber prices can be volatile periodically and demand over the medium to long term has historically created real-term price growth. In the context of global under-supply and increasing demand, this reduces market risk for FSF's key revenue streams. Should timber prices be less attractive at the point of felling, FSF is in a position to mitigate the impact by postponing parts of its harvesting programme and delay felling, allowing trees to continue to grow until the underlying imbalance between supply and demand begins to be reflected in market prices again.
FSF is focused on growing its portfolio as a newly listed entity and will require additional financing to take full advantage of opportunities in its pipeline. The existing borrowing policy enables the use of gearing that must not exceed 30% of Gross Asset Value.
There is a risk that FSF will be unable to access sufficient funding to complete operations. This is mitigated by using brokers to conduct market research ahead of any future funding rounds to gauge demand from new and existing investors. FSF has also set budgets with sufficient cash buffers to ensure liquidity.
There is a risk of reputational damage due to negative PR generated by the resistance to change of land use by the public. This could in turn negatively impact investor sentiment and ultimately the ability to raise more capital. This is mitigated by independent community risk assessments during the due diligence phase of afforestation investments. This ensures that afforestation only takes place in low community risk areas where the likelihood of community resistance is low. FSF also actively pursues a co-ordinated programme of community engagement and recently launched a Forestry Skills Training Programme.
The risk of changing weather patterns and more extreme weather events can cause direct damage to the portfolio, leading to a market flooded with windblow timber and the subsequent price depreciation. This is mitigated by a prudent acquisition strategy for sheltered area, silviculture management and a diverse portfolio to create natural resilience. Where appropriate, windthrow insurance cover is taken out.
The Company's wholly owned subsidiary FSFC Holdings 2 Limited has a three-year £30 million RCF (agreed in July 2022) with two one-year extension options, increasing the liquidity of the Group, of which a proportion can be deployed as working capital. It also has an accordion feature that allows for another £30 million. The Company utilises the investments' cash flows from operations and proceeds from equity fundraises to repay the RCF.
In order to repay the RCF at the maturity date (July 2025 or 2027 with extensions), the Company would be required to renew the RCF and/or perform an equity raise, under the base case assumptions included in the viability forecasts. In conjunction with this, the Company could consider strategic disposals as appropriate.
Based on this assessment, the Directors have a reasonable expectation that FSF will be able to continue in operation and meet its liabilities as they fall due over the five-year period to September 2028. In making this statement, the Directors have considered and challenged the reports of the Investment Manager in relation to the resilience of the Group, taking into account its current position, the principal risks facing it in reasonable downside scenarios, the effectiveness of any mitigating actions and the Group's risk appetite.
Listing Rule 9.8.4 requires the Company to include specified information in a single identifiable section of the Annual Report or a cross-reference table indicating where the information is set out. The Directors confirm that there are no disclosures required in relation to Listing Rule 9.8.4.
By order of the Board
Company Secretary 5 December 2023
The Directors are responsible for preparing the strategic report, the Directors' report, the Directors' remuneration report and the financial statements in accordance with applicable laws and regulations.
These financial statements have been prepared in accordance with UK-adopted International Accounting Standards ("IAS") in conformity with the requirements of the Companies Act 2006 and in accordance with International Financial Reporting Standards ("IFRS"). Company law in the United Kingdom requires the Directors to prepare financial statements for each financial year. Under this law the Directors must not approve the financial statements unless they are satisfied that they give a true and fair view of the state of affairs and profit or loss of the Company for that period. In preparing these financial statements, the Directors are required to:
The Directors are responsible for keeping adequate accounting records that are sufficient to show and explain the Company's transactions, disclose with reasonable accuracy at any time the financial position of the Company, and enable the Directors to ensure that the financial statements and the Directors' remuneration report comply with the Companies Act 2006 and Article 4 of the IAS Regulation. They are also responsible for safeguarding the assets of the Company and thus for taking reasonable steps for the prevention and detection of fraud and other irregularities.
The Directors are responsible for the maintenance and integrity of the corporate and financial information included on the Company's website. Legislation in the United Kingdom governing the preparation and dissemination of financial statements may differ from legislation in other jurisdictions.
The Directors are responsible for preparing the Annual Report in accordance with applicable law and regulations. The Directors consider the Annual Report and financial statements, taken as a whole, provide the information necessary to assess the Company's performance, business model and strategy and are fair, balanced and understandable.
To the best of our knowledge:
The Directors confirm that:
Chair 5 December 2023
| INDEPENDENT AUDITOR'S REPORT | 81 | |
|---|---|---|
| STATEMENT OF COMPREHENSIVE INCOME |
88 | |
| STATEMENT OF FINANCIAL POSITION | 89 | |
| STATEMENT OF CHANGES IN EQUITY 90 | ||
| STATEMENT OF CASH FLOWS | 91 | |
| NOTES TO THE AUDITED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS |
92 |
| 107 |
|---|
| 108 |
| 109 |
| 111 |
TO THE MEMBERS OF FORESIGHT SUSTAINABLE FORESTRY COMPANY PLC
We have audited the financial statements of Foresight Sustainable Forestry Company Plc ('the Company') for the year ended 30 September 2023 which comprise Statement of Comprehensive Income, the Statement of Financial Position, the Statement of Changes in Equity, the Statement of Cash Flows and the related notes 1 to 22.
The financial reporting framework that has been applied in their preparation is applicable law and UK-adopted International Accounting Standards.
In our opinion, the financial statements:
We conducted our audit in accordance with International Standards on Auditing (UK) (ISAs (UK)) and applicable law. Our responsibilities under those standards are further described in the Auditor's responsibilities for the audit of the financial statements section of our report. We believe that the audit evidence we have obtained is sufficient and appropriate to provide a basis for our opinion.
We are independent of the Company in accordance with the ethical requirements that are relevant to our audit of the financial statements in the UK, including the FRC's Ethical Standard as applied to listed public interest entities, and we have fulfilled our other ethical responsibilities in accordance with these requirements.
The non-audit services prohibited by the FRC's Ethical Standard were not provided to the Company and we remain independent of the Company in conducting the audit.
In auditing the financial statements, we have concluded that the directors' use of the going concern basis of accounting in the preparation of the financial statements is appropriate. Our evaluation of the directors' assessment of the Company's ability to continue to adopt the going concern basis of accounting included:
ADDITIONAL INFORMATION
TO THE MEMBERS OF FORESIGHT SUSTAINABLE FORESTRY COMPANY PLC
Based on the work we have performed, we have not identified any material uncertainties relating to events or conditions that, individually or collectively, may cast significant doubt on the Company's ability to continue as a going concern for the period covered by the directors to 31 March 2025.
In relation to the Company's reporting on how they have applied the UK Corporate Governance Code, we have nothing material to add or draw attention to in relation to the directors' statement in the financial statements about whether the directors considered it appropriate to adopt the going concern basis of accounting.
Our responsibilities and the responsibilities of the directors with respect to going concern are described in the relevant sections of this report. However, because not all future events or conditions can be predicted, this statement is not a guarantee as to the Company's ability to continue as a going concern.
| Key audit matters | • Risk of inaccurate valuation of investments held through profit and loss and the resulting impact on the Statement of Comprehensive Income • Risk of inaccurate valuation of carbon credits and the resulting impact on the Statement of Comprehensive Income |
|---|---|
| Materiality | • Overall materiality of £1.70m (2022: £1.81m) which represents 1% (2022: 1%) of net assets. |
Our assessment of audit risk, our evaluation of materiality and our allocation of performance materiality determine our audit scope for the Company. This enables us to form an opinion on the financial statements. We take into account size, risk profile, the organisation of the Company and effectiveness of controls, the potential impact of climate change and changes in the business environment when assessing the level of work to be performed.
There has been increasing interest from stakeholders as to how climate change will impact companies. The Company has determined that the impact of climate change could affect the Company's investments and their valuations. This is explained in the principal risk section on page 40 which forms part of the "Other Information" rather than the audited financial statements. Our procedures on these disclosures therefore consisted solely of considering whether they are materially inconsistent with the financial statements or our knowledge obtained in the course of the audit or otherwise appear to be materially misstated.
Our audit effort in considering climate change was focused on the adequacy of the Company's disclosures in the financial statements as set out in note 10 and conclusion that there was no material impact of climate change on the valuation of investments. We also challenged the Directors' considerations of climate change in their assessment of going concern and viability and associated disclosures.
For the avoidance of doubt the confirmation made in appendix one in respect of the Company's continuing obligations as an Eligible Issuer with a Voluntary Carbon market designation has not been audited and is not considered 'Other Information' for the purposes of this opinion.
Key audit matters are those matters that, in our professional judgment, were of most significance in our audit of the financial statements of the current period and include the most significant assessed risks of material misstatement (whether or not due to fraud) that we identified. These matters included those which had the greatest effect on: the overall audit strategy, the allocation of resources in the audit; and directing the efforts of the engagement team. These matters were addressed in the context of our audit of the financial statements as a whole, and in our opinion thereon, and we do not provide a separate opinion on these matters.
TO THE MEMBERS OF FORESIGHT SUSTAINABLE FORESTRY COMPANY PLC
| Risk | Our response to the risk | Key observations communicated to the Audit Committee |
|---|---|---|
| Inaccurate valuation of investments held through profit and loss and the resulting impact on the Statement of Comprehensive Income Refer to the Audit Committee Report (page 56 to 59); Accounting policies (pages 92 to 95); and Notes 1-22 of the Financial Statements. The value of the investments held through profit and losses at 30 September 2023 was £166.04m (2022: £146.29m) consisting of forestry assets held through special purpose vehicles ('SPVs'). The Company has seven subsidiary undertakings held at fair value under IFRS 10, which invest into forestry assets. The valuation of the underlying forestry assets held through SPVs is the key driver of the Company's net asset value and total return. Incorrect valuation of the forestry assets, or a failure to maintain proper legal title to the forestry assets held through the SPVs could have a significant impact on the portfolio valuation and the return generated for shareholders. The underlying forestry assets are valued at fair value by the Directors following a detailed review and appropriate challenge of the valuations proposed by Savills Advisory Services Limited ("Savills"). The investment policy applies methodologies consistent with the Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors ("RICS") Valuation – Global Standards July 2017 ("the Red Book"). |
We performed the following procedures: We obtained an understanding of the processes and controls around the underlying forestry asset valuations by performing walkthrough procedures. We obtained and reviewed the Investment Manager's accounting paper and assessment that the Company meets the IFRS 10 definition of an investment entity. We reconciled the fair value of the SPV at 30 September 2023 to the investment fair value through profit and loss reported in the financial statements of the Company. We engaged our team of EY valuation specialists to review the valuations of a sample of underlying forestry assets and this included completing the following procedures: • Obtained and reviewed the valuation papers prepared by Savills for the period to 30 September 2023 to gain an understanding of the valuation methodologies and assumptions used; • Determined whether the valuations have been performed in line with the general valuation approaches as set out in IFRS 13 and the Red Book guidelines; • Assessed the appropriateness of data inputs and assumptions used to support the valuations for the selected sample of underlying forestry assets held through the SPVs; • Assessed other facts and circumstances, such as other comparative market transactions, comparative company information, afforestation, carbon credit potential, winter storm vulnerability, seasonality, geographical location and developmental milestones that may have an impact on the fair market value of the underlying forestry assets; and We recalculated the unrealised gains/losses on the unquoted investments as at the year end using the book-cost reconciliation and reviewing the level 3 fair value hierarchy disclosure For purchases of all unquoted investments as at year end, we obtained supporting documents from the Investment Manager such as land registry title deeds and purchase contracts and agreed these to the purchase cost per the accounting records and to bank statements. |
The results of our procedures identified no material misstatements in relation to the risk of inaccurate valuation of carbon credits and the resulting impact on the Statement of Comprehensive Income. |
STATEMENTS
TO THE MEMBERS OF FORESIGHT SUSTAINABLE FORESTRY COMPANY PLC
| Risk continued | Our response to the risk continued | Key observations communicated to the Audit Committee continued |
|---|---|---|
| The valuation of the underlying forestry assets held through the SPVs, and the resultant impact on the unrealised gains/(losses), is the area requiring the most significant judgement and estimation in the preparation of the financial statements and has been classified as an area of fraud risk as highlighted below on page 87. |
We gained an understanding as to how this risk is considered and managed by the Directors, the Investment Manager and the Administrator, and an understanding of the processes and controls surrounding the recognition of realised and unrealised gains/(losses) on investments by performing a walkthrough We recalculated the unrealised gain/loss in the financial statements based on changes in investment values, purchases and realisations |
|
| Risk of inaccurate valuation of carbon credits and the resulting impact on the Statement of Comprehensive Income (refer to the Report of the Audit Committee set out on pages 56 to 59 and the accounting policy set out on page 92 to 95) The value ascribed by management to the progress towards the creation of carbon credits amounted to £2.70m (2022: £0.60m). This amount is not included in the independent valuation of the underlying forestry assets held through the SPVs performed by Savills. |
We performed the following procedures; We have gained an understanding of Foresight Group LLP (the 'Investment Manager') and the Directors' processes and controls surrounding the recognition and valuation of carbon credits, by performing a walkthrough to evaluate the design and implementation of controls; We reviewed the Investment Manager's carbon credit accounting paper and providing feedback on the accounting assumptions adopted, including additional considerations which will need to be made going forward; We obtained an understanding of the Investment Manager's due diligence process to assess the index provider and independent validation against other public sources of trade; Considered provenance of information in meeting relevant audit evidence thresholds; We obtained evidence for the PIU transactional prices quoted by the Investment Manager in estimating the fair value at the year end date; We assessed the appropriateness of data inputs and assumptions used to support the fair value and searching for contrary evidence; We reviewed unrealised gain/loss in the financial statements based on changes in the values ascribed to existing carbon credits; We recalculated the value ascribed towards the creation of carbon credits and reviewing the reasonability of the discount applied; and We agreed the number of number of PIUs subject to validation at the year end date to the UK Land Carbon Registry. |
The results of our procedures identified no material misstatements in relation to the risk of inaccurate valuation of carbon credits and the resulting impact on the Statement of Comprehensive Income. |
TO THE MEMBERS OF FORESIGHT SUSTAINABLE FORESTRY COMPANY PLC
We apply the concept of materiality in planning and performing the audit, in evaluating the effect of identified misstatements on the audit and in forming our audit opinion.
The magnitude of an omission or misstatement that, individually or in the aggregate, could reasonably be expected to influence the economic decisions of the users of the financial statements. Materiality provides a basis for determining the nature and extent of our audit procedures.
We determined materiality for the Company to be £1.70 million (2022: £1.81 million), which is 1% (2022: 1%) of net assets. We believe that net assets provides us with the most important financial metric on which shareholders would judge the performance of the Company.
The application of materiality at the individual account or balance level. It is set at an amount to reduce to an appropriately low level the probability that the aggregate of uncorrected and undetected misstatements exceeds materiality.
On the basis of our risk assessments, together with our assessment of the Company's overall control environment, our judgement was that performance materiality was 50% (2022: 50%) of our planning materiality, namely £0.86m (2022: £0.90m). We have set performance materiality at this percentage due to our past experience of the audit that indicated that a higher risk of misstatements, both corrected and uncorrected.
An amount below which identified misstatements are considered as being clearly trivial.
We agreed with the Audit Committee that we would report to them all uncorrected audit differences in excess of £0.08m (2022: £0.09m), which is set at 5% of planning materiality, as well as differences below that threshold that, in our view, warranted reporting on qualitative grounds.
We evaluate any uncorrected misstatements against both the quantitative measures of materiality discussed above and in light of other relevant qualitative considerations in forming our opinion.
The other information comprises the information included in the annual report, other than the financial statements and our auditor's report thereon. The directors are responsible for the other information contained within the annual report.
Our opinion on the financial statements does not cover the other information and, except to the extent otherwise explicitly stated in this report, we do not express any form of assurance conclusion thereon.
Our responsibility is to read the other information and, in doing so, consider whether the other information is materially inconsistent with the financial statements or our knowledge obtained in the course of the audit or otherwise appears to be materially misstated. If we identify such material inconsistencies or apparent material misstatements, we are required to determine whether this gives rise to a material misstatement in the financial statements themselves. If, based on the work we have performed, we conclude that there is a material misstatement of the other information, we are required to report that fact.
We have nothing to report in this regard.
In our opinion the part of the directors' remuneration report to be audited has been properly prepared in accordance with the Companies Act 2006.
In our opinion, based on the work undertaken in the course of the audit:
In the light of the knowledge and understanding of the Company and its environment obtained in the course of the audit, we have not identified material misstatements in the strategic report or directors' report.
STATEMENTS
TO THE MEMBERS OF FORESIGHT SUSTAINABLE FORESTRY COMPANY PLC
We have nothing to report in respect of the following matters in relation to which the Companies Act 2006 requires us to report to you if, in our opinion:
We have reviewed the directors' statement in relation to going concern, longerterm viability and that part of the Corporate Governance Statement relating to the Company's compliance with the provisions of the UK Corporate Governance Code specified for our review by the Listing Rules.
Based on the work undertaken as part of our audit, we have concluded that each of the following elements of the Corporate Governance Statement is materially consistent with the financial statements or our knowledge obtained during the audit:
As explained more fully in the directors' responsibilities statement set out on page 79, the directors are responsible for the preparation of the financial statements and for being satisfied that they give a true and fair view, and for such internal control as the directors determine is necessary to enable the preparation of financial statements that are free from material misstatement, whether due to fraud or error.
In preparing the financial statements, the directors are responsible for assessing the Company's ability to continue as a going concern, disclosing, as applicable, matters related to going concern and using the going concern basis of accounting unless the directors either intend to liquidate the Company or to cease operations, or have no realistic alternative but to do so.
Our objectives are to obtain reasonable assurance about whether the financial statements as a whole are free from material misstatement, whether due to fraud or error, and to issue an auditor's report that includes our opinion. Reasonable assurance is a high level of assurance, but is not a guarantee that an audit conducted in accordance with ISAs (UK) will always detect a material misstatement when it exists. Misstatements can arise from fraud or error and are considered material if, individually or in the aggregate, they could reasonably be expected to influence the economic decisions of users taken on the basis of these financial statements.
TO THE MEMBERS OF FORESIGHT SUSTAINABLE FORESTRY COMPANY PLC
Irregularities, including fraud, are instances of non-compliance with laws and regulations. We design procedures in line with our responsibilities, outlined above, to detect irregularities, including fraud. The risk of not detecting a material misstatement due to fraud is higher than the risk of not detecting one resulting from error, as fraud may involve deliberate concealment by, for example, forgery or intentional misrepresentations, or through collusion. The extent to which our procedures are capable of detecting irregularities, including fraud is detailed below.
However, the primary responsibility for the prevention and detection of fraud rests with both those charged with governance of the Company and management.
A further description of our responsibilities for the audit of the financial statements is located on the Financial Reporting Council's website at https://www.frc.org.uk/auditorsresponsibilities. This description forms part of our auditor's report.
This report is made solely to the Company's members, as a body, in accordance with Chapter 3 of Part 16 of the Companies Act 2006. Our audit work has been undertaken so that we might state to the Company's members those matters we are required to state to them in an auditor's report and for no other purpose. To the fullest extent permitted by law, we do not accept or assume responsibility to anyone other than the Company and the Company's members as a body, for our audit work, for this report, or for the opinions we have formed.
(Senior statutory auditor) for and on behalf of Ernst & Young LLP, Statutory Auditor London
5 December 2023
FOR THE YEAR ENDED 30 SEPTEMBER 2023
| Notes | Revenue £'000 |
Capital £'000 |
Year ended 30 September 2023 (Audited) £'000 |
Period from 31 August 2021 to 30 September 2022 (Audited) £'000 |
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Return on investment | 4 | 2,605 | (11,279) | (8,674) | 11,042 |
| Total income | 2,605 | (11,279) | (8,674) | 11,042 | |
| Investment management fees | 5 | (1,562) | — | (1,562) | (1,071) |
| Operating expenses | 6 | (1,102) | — | (1,101) | (1,166) |
| Total expenses | (2,664) | — | (2,663) | (2,237) | |
| (Loss)/profit before tax | (59) | (11,279) | (11,338) | 8,787 | |
| Tax | 8 | — | — | — | — |
| (Loss)/profit for the period | (59) | (11,279) | (11,338) | 8,787 | |
| Earnings per share (pence) | 9 | — | (6.6) | (6.6) | 6.2 |
All results are derived from continuing operations.
The supplementary revenue and capital columns are presented for information purposes in accordance with the Statement of Recommended Practice issue by the Association of Investment Companies ("AIC").
There are no items of other comprehensive income in the current period, other than the profit for the period, and therefore no separate statement of comprehensive income has been presented.
The accompanying notes on pages 92 to 106 form an integral part of the financial statements.
FOR THE YEAR ENDED 30 SEPTEMBER 2023
| Notes | 30 September 2023 (Audited) £'000 |
30 September 2022 (Audited) £'000 |
|---|---|---|
| Non-current assets | ||
| Investments at fair value through profit or loss 10 |
166,039 | 146,291 |
| Total non-current assets | 166,039 | 146,291 |
| Current assets | ||
| Trade and other receivables 11 |
2,796 | 852 |
| Cash and cash equivalents 16 |
1,217 | 34,326 |
| Total current assets | 4,013 | 35,178 |
| Total assets | 170,052 | 181,469 |
| Current liabilities | ||
| Trade and other payables 12 |
(803) | (886) |
| Total current liabilities | (803) | (886) |
| Total liabilities | (803) | (886) |
| Net assets | 169,249 | 180,583 |
| Equity | ||
| Called up share capital 13 |
1,721 | 1,721 |
| Share premium 13 |
43,820 | 170,075 |
| Revenue reserve | (2,550) | (1,333) |
| Capital reserve 14 |
126,258 | 10,120 |
| Shareholders' funds 14 |
169,249 | 180,583 |
| Net assets per share (pence per share) 15 |
98.4 | 105.0 |
The accompanying notes form an integral part of the financial statements.
The financial statements were approved by the Board of Directors and authorised for issue on 5 December 2023.
They were signed on its behalf by:
Chair
FOR THE YEAR ENDED 30 SEPTEMBER 2023
| Notes | Called up share capital £'000 |
Share premium £'000 |
Capital reserve £'000 |
Revenue reserve £'000 |
Total £'000 |
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Balance at 31 August 2021 | — | — | — | — | — | |
| Gross proceeds from share issue | 1,721 | 173,279 | — | — | 175,000 | |
| Share issue costs | 13 | — | (3,204) | — | — | (3,204) |
| Dividends | 7 | — | — | — | — | — |
| Total comprehensive income for the period | 14 | — | — | 10,120 | (1,333) | 8,787 |
| Net assets attributable to Shareholders at 30 September 2022 | 1,721 | 170,075 | 10,120 | (1,333) | 180,583 |
| Notes | Called up share capital £'000 |
Share premium £'000 |
Capital reserve £'000 |
Revenue reserve £'000 |
Total £'000 |
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Balance at 1 October 2022 | 1,721 | 170,075 | 10,120 | (1,333) | 180,583 | |
| Gross proceeds from share issue | — | — | — | — | — | |
| Share issue costs | 13 | — | 3 | — | — | 3 |
| Dividends | 7 | — | — | — | — | — |
| Share premium cancellation | 13 | — | (126,258) | 126,258 | — | — |
| Total comprehensive income for the period | 14 | — | — | (11,279) | (58) | (11,338) |
| Net assets attributable to Shareholders at 30 September 2023 | 1,721 | 43,820 | 125,099 | (1,391) | 169,249 |
The Company's reserves consist of the capital reserve attributable to fair value unrealised gains on the Fund portfolio's valuation.
There have been no realised gains or losses at the reporting date.
FOR THE YEAR ENDED 30 SEPTEMBER 2023
| Year ended 30 September 2023 (Audited) £'000 |
Period from 31 August 2021 to 30 September 2022 (Audited) £'000 |
|
|---|---|---|
| (Loss)/profit for the period from continuing operations | (11,338) | 8,787 |
| Adjustments for: | ||
| Net (loss)/profit on investments at fair value through profit and loss | 11,279 | (10,120) |
| Operating cash flows before movements in working capital | (59) | (1,333) |
| Cash flows from operating activities | ||
| Increase in trade and other receivables | (1,944) | (852) |
| (Decrease)/increase in trade and other payables | (83) | 886 |
| Net cash outflow from operating activities | (2,086) | (1,299) |
| Cash flows from investing activities | ||
| Investing activities | ||
| Purchase of investments | (15,513) | (114,350) |
| Loans to subsidiaries | (15,513) | (21,821) |
| Net cash used in investing activities | (31,026) | (136,171) |
| Cash flows from financing activities | ||
| Financing activities | ||
| Gross proceeds from share issue | — | 175,000 |
| Share issue costs | 3 | (3,204) |
| Net cash inflow from financing activities | 3 | 171,796 |
| Net (decrease)/increase in cash and cash equivalents | (33,109) | 34,326 |
| Cash and cash equivalents at beginning of period | 34,326 | — |
| Cash and cash equivalents at end of period | 1,217 | 34,326 |
The accompanying notes form an integral part of the financial statements.
ADDITIONAL INFORMATION
FOR THE YEAR ENDED 30 SEPTEMBER 2023
Foresight Sustainable Forestry Company Plc (the "Company" or "FSF") is a public limited company limited by shares and was incorporated and registered in England and Wales on 31 August 2021 with registered number 13594181 pursuant to the Companies Act 2006. The Company's registered address is The Shard, 32 London Bridge Street, London, United Kingdom, SE1 9SG.
The Company has one investment, FSFC Holdings Limited, and FSFC Holdings Limited in turn has one investment, FSFC Holdings 2 Limited; together this is the "Group".
FSFC Holdings 2 Limited has three investments: FSFC Company 1 Limited, Blackmead Forestry Limited and Blackmead Forestry II Limited. Blackmead Forestry Limited has two investments: Coull Forestry Limited and Fordie Estates Limited. These five entities together are the special purpose vehicles or "SPVs".
The Group's principal activity is investing in UK forestry, afforestation and natural capital assets.
The financial statements of the Company are for the year to 30 September 2023 and have been prepared on the basis of the accounting policies set out below. The financial statements comprise only the results of the Company, as its direct investments in FSFC Holdings Limited, FSFC Holdings 2 Limited, and all underlying SPVs thereafter, are measured at fair value as detailed in the significant accounting policies below.
This set of financial statements has been prepared in accordance with UK adopted International Accounting Standards. The financial statements have been prepared under the historical cost convention as modified by the revaluation of certain assets and on a going concern basis. The accounting policies set out below have, unless otherwise stated, been applied consistently to the period presented in these financial statements.
These annual financial statements have also been prepared in accordance with the Statement of Recommended Practice: Financial Statements of Investment Trust Companies and Venture Capital Trusts ("SORP") issued in April 2021 by the Association of Investment Companies ("AIC").
The same accounting policies and standards have been observed in these annual financial statements as were applied in the last annual financial statements, with no change to the nature or effect of these standards' application.
These financial statements are presented in sterling (£) and rounded to the nearest thousand unless otherwise stated. They have been prepared on accounting policies, significant judgements, key assumptions and estimates set out below.
These financial statements intend to constitute statutory accounts as defined in Section 434(3) of the Companies Act 2006. As such, these statutory accounts in respect of the year to 30 September 2023 have been audited and reported on by the Company's auditors and delivered to the Registrar of Companies and included the Report of Auditors.
No statutory accounts in respect of any period after 30 September 2023 have been reported on by the Company's auditors or delivered to the Registrar of Companies.
Any estimates and underlying assumptions are reviewed on a regular basis and revisions to accounting estimates are recognised in the period when they occur and in any future period affected. The significant estimates, judgements or assumptions are set out in note 10.
These annual financial statements comprise the results for the year to 30 September 2023 as well as comparatives to the audited period ended 30 September 2022.
ADDITIONAL INFORMATION
FOR THE YEAR ENDED 30 SEPTEMBER 2023
The Directors have adopted the going concern basis in preparing the financial statements. In their assessment of going concern they have reviewed comprehensive cash flow forecasts prepared by the Investment Manager and believe, based on the forecasts and an assessment of the Company's cash position and liquidity of the investment portfolio, that the Company will continue in operational existence for at least 12 months from the date of approval of the financial statements and therefore consider it appropriate to prepare the financial statements on a going concern basis. As at 30 September 2023, the Company had net current assets of £3.2 million, including £1.2 million of cash; it also had access to £19.6 million that remained undrawn on the Revolving Credit Facility, held by its indirect subsidiary, which can be utilised for the Company's working capital requirements. As such, with all factors mentioned above, the Company's cash position is considered sufficient to meet all current obligations as they fall due.
The Directors have also assessed the impact of significant potential risks to the operations of the Company since incorporation and the principal risks in the UK forestry and afforestation markets including the various risk mitigation measures in place and do not consider this to have a material impact on the assessment of the Company as a going concern.
The Company has assessed its potential exposure to being negatively impacted by a sudden loss of revenue stream. The relevance of this risk has been significant given the recent impacts of the Ukraine-Russia conflict on the forestry industry.
The Company has assessed these risks alongside the potential risk of similar events having a negative impact on revenue recoverability. The potential impacts of such market risks include, but are not limited to:
Each of the above potential impacts could have a direct influence on the amount that can be distributed to the Company by its subsidiaries. Foresight has reviewed the portfolio's exposure to these risks and has concluded that if, even in the unlikely case, these adverse impacts on revenue recoverability are material, the Company should still have sufficient funds to continue operations for the foreseeable future. If such impacts were to continue on a long-term basis, continued monitoring processes would need to be actioned.
Due to the nature of the Company's operation and deployment strategy, there could be potential exposure to liquidity risk, whereby the entity would encounter difficulties in paying its financial liabilities. The Directors have considered this risk and are satisfied that FSF has adequate financial resources to settle its recurring expenses for the foreseeable future, based on evidence provided from cash flow forecasting and sensitivity testing to satisfy both the Investment Manager and the Directors that the Company has sufficient funds available.
The Directors are satisfied that FSF has sufficient resources to continue to operate for the foreseeable future, a period of no less than 12 months from the date of this report. Accordingly, they have adopted the going concern basis in preparation of these financial statements.
The Directors are of the opinion that the Company is engaged in a single segment of business, being an investor in UK forestry and afforestation assets, to generate real returns for investors as well as capital appreciation. The financial information used by the Board to allocate resources and manage the Company presents the business as a single segment comprising a homogeneous portfolio.
The Company conducts a judgement in relation to its status as an investment entity by satisfying the three criteria below:
The Company assesses its compliance with the requirements of being an investment entity in note 3 in more detail.
ADDITIONAL INFORMATION
FOR THE YEAR ENDED 30 SEPTEMBER 2023
Fair valuation of investment assets – Red Book valuation
The market value of the Company's underlying investment portfolio held through its SPVs consisting of forestry, afforestation and non-core assets (investment portfolio/ properties) is determined by an external valuer (see note 10) to be the estimated amount for which an asset should exchange on the date of the valuation in an arm's-length transaction. Properties have been valued on an individual basis. The external valuer prepares their valuations in accordance with the RICS Valuation – Global Standards July 2017 (the "Red Book"). Factors reflected comprise current market conditions, including the comparable market value of similar freehold forestry assets, the potential uplift in land value above current in-use value (relevant to planting land), the location and situation of individual assets, potential vulnerability to winter storms and the developmental status of properties (if afforestation). The market conditions stated are assessed on a bi-annual basis. These are also subject to an accounting estimate that the Directors are satisfied with. The significant methods and assumptions used by the external valuers in estimating the fair value of investment assets are set out in note 10.
The carbon credit valuations are not determined by an external valuer but are currently based on the Ecosystem Marketplace collected trade data from UK Woodland Carbon Code and Peatland Code market participants who are project developers and resellers through the Ecosystem Marketplace Global Carbon Markets Hub. These are also subject to an accounting estimate that the Directors are satisfied with.
Income taxes represent the sum of the tax currently payable, withholding taxes suffered and deferred tax. Tax is charged or credited in the statement of comprehensive income, except where it relates to items charged or credited directly to equity, in which case the tax is also dealt with in equity.
The tax currently payable is based on the taxable profit for the year. This may differ from the profit included in the statement of comprehensive income because it excludes items of income or expense that are taxable or deductible in other years and it further excludes items that are never taxable or deductible. To enable the tax charge to be based on the profit for the year, deferred tax is provided in full on temporary timing differences, at the rates of tax expected to apply when these differences crystallise.
Deferred tax assets are recognised only to the extent that it is probable that sufficient taxable profits will be available against which temporary differences can be set off. In practice, some assets that are likely to give rise to timing differences will be treated as capital for tax purposes. Given capital items are exempt from tax under the Investment Trust Company rules, deferred tax is not expected to be recognised on these balances.
All deferred tax liabilities are offset against deferred tax assets, where appropriate, in accordance with the provisions of IAS 12. The carrying amount of deferred tax assets is reviewed at each balance sheet date and reduced to the extent that it is no longer probable that sufficient taxable profits will be available to allow all or part of the asset to be recovered.
There were no new standards, amendments or interpretations effective for the first time for periods beginning on or after incorporation that had a material effect on the Company's financial statements. The Company has explored to what extent these new standards have an immaterial impact on the financial statements, as below.
The standard requires an entity to reasonably identify and recognise any contract in which an entity accepts significant insurance risk from another party as a combination of a financial instrument and a service contract, in order to help users of the financial statements to assess the effect on the Company's financial position. The Company does not deem this standard to have a material effect on its financial statements as the Company is not party to any such contract in which it accepts any insurance risk from or for another party.
FOR THE YEAR ENDED 30 SEPTEMBER 2023
The standard now defines an accounting estimate as "monetary amounts in financial statements that are subject to measurement uncertainty". Despite the Company using accounting estimates (see note 2(d) Key judgements and estimates) in its assessment of carbon credit validation and Red Book valuation, the Directors would not deem this amendment to have any material effect on the Company's results for the current or prior period(s). The Company maintains that, at each reporting date, the latest available and reliable information was used to arrive at its accounting estimates, with no instances requiring a restatement of information due to error.
The IASB issued amendments to IAS 1 Presentation of Financial Statements in which they require disclosure of "material" accounting policies, instead of what was "significant" accounting policies. The aim of this amendment is to enhance the usefulness of financial statements for users and in turn to enhance their effectiveness overall. The Company has not chosen to apply an early adoption of this standard as the threshold of materiality needs to be considered in more depth. The Company, however, plans to adopt this standard in its next reporting cycle.
The Company's objective is to invest in UK forestry and afforestation assets through its holding companies, which will typically issue equity and loans to finance the investments.
IFRS 10 Consolidated Financial Statements sets out the following essential criteria, necessary for a company to be considered as an investment entity.
Definition of an investment entity/trust:
In assessing whether the Company meets the definition of an investment entity set out in IFRS 10, the Directors note that:
ADDITIONAL INFORMATION
FOR THE YEAR ENDED 30 SEPTEMBER 2023
The Directors have concluded that the Company meets the definition of an investment entity in accordance with IFRS 10 after evaluation of the relevant criteria.
The Directors continue to consider the Company demonstrates the characteristics and meets the requirements to be considered an investment entity.
IFRS 10 states that investment entities are required to hold subsidiaries at fair value through profit or loss rather than consolidation on a line-by-line basis; this means that the Group's cash, debt and working capital balances are included in the fair value of the investment instead of in the Company's assets and liabilities. The Company has one investee, namely FSFC Holdings Limited, which invests the funds of the FSF investors on its behalf and is effectively performing investment management services on behalf of several unrelated beneficiary investors.
| Period from | ||
|---|---|---|
| Year ended | 31 August 2021 | |
| 30 September | to 30 September | |
| 2023 | 2022 | |
| (Audited) | (Audited) | |
| £'000 | £'000 | |
| Unrealised fair value movement of investments | (11,279) | 10,120 |
| Interest income – Loans to direct subsidiary | 2,364 | 852 |
| Interest income – Bank | 241 | 52 |
| Total | (8,674) | 11,024 |
| Total | 1,562 | 1,071 |
|---|---|---|
| Investment management fee | 1,562 | 1,071 |
| £'000 | £'000 | |
| (Audited) | (Audited) | |
| 2023 | 2022 | |
| 30 September | to 30 September | |
| Year ended | 31 August 2021 | |
| Period from |
Foresight Group LLP was appointed as the Investment Manager for the Company under an Investment Management Agreement. Under the terms of the agreement, the Investment Manager is entitled to a management fee from the Company, which is calculated quarterly in arrears at 0.85% per annum of NAV up to £500 million and 0.75% per annum of NAV in excess of £500 million.
The Company paid £1.2 million during the period. A further £0.4 million investment management fees were accrued and remained unpaid at the year end.
| Total | 1,102 | 1,166 |
|---|---|---|
| Other expenses1 | 782 | 922 |
| Directors' fees | 191 | 140 |
| Administration services fee | 129 | 104 |
| £'000 | £'000 | |
| (Audited) | (Audited) | |
| 2023 | 2022 | |
| 30 September | 30 September | |
| Year ended | 31 August 2021 to | |
| Period from |
Details of Directors' fees are set out in note 21.
The Company did not pay any dividend in the year to 30 September 2023 (30 September 2022: £nil).
ADDITIONAL INFORMATION
FOR THE YEAR ENDED 30 SEPTEMBER 2023
The Company received notice on 11 November 2021 confirming it is an approved investment trust for accounting periods commencing on or after 23 November 2021. The approval is subject to the Company continuing to meet the eligibility conditions of Section 1158 Corporation Taxes Act 2010. Furthermore, there are also ongoing requirements for approved companies in Chapter 3 of Part 2 Investment Trust (Approved Company) (Tax) Regulations 2011 (Statutory Instrument 2011/2999). To maintain its ITC status, the Company must adhere to the following conditions throughout an accounting period:
The Company regularly monitors the conditions required to maintain ITC status.
| 30 September 2023 £'000 |
30 September 2022 £'000 |
|
|---|---|---|
| Income taxes | — | — |
| 30 September 2023 £'000 |
30 September 2022 £'000 |
|
| (Loss)/profit before tax | (11,338) | 8,787 |
| (Loss)/profit before tax multiplied by the rate of corporation tax in the UK of 19.0% |
(2,154) | 1,670 |
| Effects of: | ||
| Non-taxable capital profits due to UK approved investment trust company status |
2,143 | (1,923) |
| Non-taxable dividend income | — | — |
| Dividend designated as interest distributions | — | — |
| Prior period deferred tax | — | — |
| Temporary differences on which deferred tax is not recognised |
11 | 253 |
| Total income tax charge in the statement of comprehensive income |
— | — |
The tax charge for the period is different from the standard rate of corporation tax in the UK, currently 19.0% (2022: 19.0%), and the difference is explained below:
The Company's affairs are directed so as to allow it to meet the requisite conditions to continue to operate as an approved investment trust company for UK tax purposes. The approved investment trust status allows certain capital profits of the Company to be exempt from tax in the UK and also permits the Company to designate the dividends it pays, wholly or partly, as interest distributions. These features enable approved investment trust companies to ensure that their investors do not ultimately suffer double taxation of their investment returns, i.e. once at the level of the investment fund vehicle and then again in the hands of the investors.
FOR THE YEAR ENDED 30 SEPTEMBER 2023
There was no corporation tax payable during the year to 30 September 2023. As a result, the tax charge for the period is £nil. Investment gains are exempt from tax owing to the Company's status as an investment trust.
Under the UK Finance Act 2021, the UK corporation tax rate increased for large companies from the current rate of 19.0% to 25.0% with effect from 1 April 2023. Should the Company recognise any deferred tax assets and liabilities, a rate of 19.0% or 25.0% would be used depending on when the assets and liabilities are expected to be crystallised. The Company is recognised as a UK investment trust and is taxed at the main rate of 19.0%, prevalent at the reporting period end.
At the period end, there is a potential deferred tax asset of £264,320 carried forward (30 September 2022: £253,194). The deferred tax asset is unrecognised at the period end in line with the Company's stated accounting policy.
| 2023 (pence) | (6.6) | 0.0 | (6.6) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Earnings per share at 30 September | |||
| Average number of Ordinary Shares | 172,056 | 172,056 | 172,056 |
| Revenue and capital profit attributable to equity holders of the Company |
(11,279) | (59) | (11,338) |
| Capital reserve £'000 |
Revenue reserve £'000 |
Total £'000 |
| Capital reserve £'000 |
Revenue reserve £'000 |
Total £'000 |
|
|---|---|---|---|
| Revenue and capital profit attributable to equity holders of the Company |
10,120 | (1,333) | 8,787 |
| Average number of Ordinary Shares | 142,847 | 142,847 | 142,847 |
| Earnings per share at 30 September 2022 (pence) |
7.1 | (0.9) | 6.2 |
| 30 September 2023 £'000 |
30 September 2022 £'000 |
|
|---|---|---|
| Fair value at start of the period | 146,291 | — |
| Loans to intermediate holding companies | 15,513 | 21,821 |
| Equity investment in holding companies | 15,513 | 114,350 |
| Unrealised gain on investments at fair value | (11,278) | 10,120 |
| Total | 166,039 | 146,291 |
STATEMENTS
As at 30 September 2023, there was a loan between Foresight Sustainable Forestry Company Plc and FSFC Holdings Limited for £37,334,413. The loan is repayable on demand. The rate of interest on the loan has been set at 7% per annum. Interest accrued at the year end was £2,796,336.
The Company owns 12,986,337,835 shares in FSFC Holdings Limited at a nominal value of £0.01 each.
The Investment Manager has carried out fair value market valuations of the underlying SPV investments as at 30 September 2023 independently administered by Savills. The Directors have approved the methodology used, as well as confirming their understanding of all underlying key assumptions applicable. All SPV investments are at fair value through profit or loss and are valued using the IFRS 13 framework for fair value measurement.
Savills includes all investments under ownership by FSF in their portfolio valuation, for both afforestation and forestry properties. The valuations have been prepared in accordance with the RICS Valuation – Global Standards July 2017 (the "Red Book") and incorporate the recommendations of the International Valuation Standards which are consistent with the principles set out in IFRS 13.
STATEMENTS
FOR THE YEAR ENDED 30 SEPTEMBER 2023
Savills, in forming its opinion, makes various assumptions on the basis of current market conditions; the following are the key assumptions made:
• Savills employs a "comparable approach" by analysing comparable market value(s) of similar freehold forestry and afforestation assets from recent transactions, when assessing what fair value is reasonable to attribute to assets with similar features, held by subsidiaries of FSF.
• Due to the assets under ownership being located across the UK (Scotland, Northern England and Wales), Savills accounts for the potential differences in market interest associated in different locations.
• Savills makes assessments on the basis of the extent of damage suffered by sites due to extreme windblow incidents. Where damage is extensive, Savills will make prudent adjustments to the value of the site, if it is evident that some of the affected timber may be challenging to recover.
• Due to the nature of operations for the afforestation assets, Savills applies reassessments as to the value of an asset when a new developmental milestone occurs.
The value associated with the carbon credits attached with the Establishment Stage Afforestation properties is excluded from the RICS Red Book valuation of these properties. As previously mentioned in the report, value recognition for carbon credits is ascribed using the Investment Manager's assessment. For further detail, please see an explanation of the methodology on page 32.
The Group considers that all of its investments fall within Level 3 of the fair value hierarchy as defined by IFRS 13. There have been no transfers between Level 1 and Level 2 during any of the periods, nor have there been any transfers between Level 2 and Level 3 during any of the periods.
The valuations have been prepared on the basis of market value ("MV"), which is defined in the RICS Valuation Standards as: "The estimated amount for which an asset should exchange on the date of valuation between a willing buyer and a willing seller in an arm's-length transaction after proper marketing wherein the parties had each acted knowledgeably, prudently and without compulsion."
Market value as defined in the RICS Valuation Standards meets the requirements of fair value defined under IFRS.
| 30 September | 30 September | |
|---|---|---|
| 2023 | 2022 | |
| £'000 | £'000 | |
| Interest receivable from subsidiaries | 2,796 | 852 |
| Total | 2,796 | 852 |
| 803 | 886 |
|---|---|
| — | 24 |
| 348 | 385 |
| 455 | 477 |
| 2023 £'000 |
30 September 2022 £'000 |
| 30 September |
STATEMENTS
FOR THE YEAR ENDED 30 SEPTEMBER 2023
| Allotted share capital, issued and fully paid | Number of shares |
|---|---|
| Opening balance at 1 October 2022 | 172,056,075 |
| Allotted/redeemed (since 1 October 2022) | |
| Ordinary Shares issued | — |
| Total number of Ordinary Shares at 30 September 2023 | 172,056,075 |
| Share capital £'000 |
Share premium £'000 |
30 September 2023 £'000 |
30 September 2022 £'000 |
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Opening balance | 1,721 | 170,075 | 171,796 | — |
| Shares issued | — | — | — | 175,000 |
| Costs associated with share issuance |
— | 3 | 3 | 3,204 |
| Cancellation of share premium |
— | (126,258) | (126,258) | — |
| Total | 1,721 | 43,820 | 45,541 | 171,796 |
At the beginning of the period, the total number of Ordinary Shares in issue was 172,056,075. Each Ordinary Share has equal rights to dividends and has equal rights to participate in a distribution arising from a winding up of the Company. The Company has not issued any further Ordinary Shares.
On 28 February 2023, there was a special resolution to cancel the share premium account which was confirmed by court order and registered by Companies House. The amount cancelled was £126,258,589, with the objective of creating distributable reserves.
| 30 September | 30 September | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Revenue | Capital | 2023 | 2022 | |
| £'000 | £'000 | £'000 | £'000 | |
| Opening balance | (1,333) | 10,120 | 8,787 | — |
| (Loss)/profit for | ||||
| the period | (58) | (11,279) | (11,337) | 8,787 |
| Dividends paid | — | — | — | — |
| Closing balance | (1,391) | (1,159) | (2,550) | 8,787 |
The nature and purpose of each of the reserves within the Retained Earnings as at 30 September 2023 are as follows:
The total Net Asset Value per Ordinary Share is based on the net assets attributable to equity Shareholders as at 30 September 2023 of £169.2 million and Ordinary Shares in issue of 172,056,075.
| 30 September 2023 |
30 September 2022 |
|
|---|---|---|
| NAV (£m) | 169.2 | 180.6 |
| Number of Ordinary Shares issued (million) | 172.1 | 172.1 |
| Net Asset Value per Ordinary Share (pence) | 98.4 | 105.0 |
At the period end, the Company held cash and cash equivalents of £1.2 million. This balance was held by HSBC Bank plc.
| 30 September 2023 |
30 September 2022 |
|
|---|---|---|
| Cash and cash equivalents: | ||
| HSBC Bank plc – current account | 855 | 4,283 |
| HSBC Bank plc – liquidity fund | 362 | 30,043 |
| Total cash and cash equivalents | 1,217 | 34,326 |
STATEMENTS
FOR THE YEAR ENDED 30 SEPTEMBER 2023
The Company held the following financial instruments at 30 September 2023. There have been no transfers of financial instruments between levels of the fair value hierarchy. There are no non-recurring fair value measurements.
| Financial assets | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cash and | Financial assets | at fair value | Financial | ||
| bank | held at | through profit | liabilities at | ||
| balances | amortised cost | or loss | amortised cost | Total | |
| £'000 | £'000 | £'000 | £'000 | £'000 | |
| Non-current assets | |||||
| Investments at fair value through profit or loss (Level 3) | — | — | 166,039 | — | 166,039 |
| Current assets | |||||
| Trade and other receivables | — | 2,796 | — | — | 2,796 |
| Cash and cash equivalents | 1,217 | — | — | — | 1,217 |
| Total financial assets | 1,217 | 2,796 | 166,039 | — | 172,052 |
| Current liabilities | |||||
| Trade and other payables | — | — | — | (803) | (803) |
| Total financial liabilities | — | — | — | (803) | (803) |
| Net financial instruments | 1,217 | 2,796 | 166,039 | (803) | 169,249 |
The Company holds its portfolio of assets at fair value. These assets are held through the Company's underlying subsidiaries/intermediate holding companies (the "Group"). The assets in the Group are valued in accordance with RICS Valuation – Global Standards July 2017 (the "Red Book") methodology, with inspections conducted by an independent valuer ("Savills") at the end of the period.
Savills' fair value assessment of the assets has been completed on a comparable basis by looking at recent transactions of similar assets, to assess current market value, outlined in note 10. As a management review control, the Investment Manager applies a discounted cash flow approach ("DCF") to value the assets and provide a precision level for validation of the fair value presented by Savills. Whilst the two methodologies differ, the Investment Manager has recorded an immaterial difference between the respective portfolio valuation results in both the interim period and the year-end period.
The Directors consider the DCF methodology used by the Investment Manager to validate the Red Book valuation to be appropriate. The Board and Investment Manager annually review the valuation inputs and, where possible, make use of observable market data to ensure valuations reflect fair value of the assets. A broad range of assumptions are used in the valuation, which are based on long-term forecasts and are not affected by short-term fluctuations in inputs, be it economic or operational.
For management control purposes of comparing the two valuations on a like-for-like basis, neither the DCF valuation nor RICS valuation conducted by Savills include explicit recognition of Verified Carbon ("VC") value. The Manager has therefore calculated an estimated value on the progress made on obtaining the rights to PIUs. To date, no PIUs have been authorised by the Woodland Carbon Code.
FOR THE YEAR ENDED 30 SEPTEMBER 2023
The sensitivity of the portfolio to changes in mature forestry asset valuation is as follows:
The portfolio valuation of mature forestry and afforestation assets is based on the RICS Red Book valuation approach. The Directors consider the Red Book market value of the assets, which is a combination of several factors, including timber growth rates, weighted age distribution and yield class, to be the most important unobservable input underpinning the valuation methodology described on page 32. The Directors believe that the provision of market value sensitivity analysis of mature forestry, afforestation and mixed forestry and afforestation assets is appropriate to align with the Company's portfolio composition.
The sensitivity of the portfolio to changes in mature forestry asset valuation is as follows:
The independent valuer conducts inspections of all mature forestry assets on a semi-annual basis, then provides a valuation based on RICS methodology. The base case used for forestry asset value as at 30 September 2023 was £75.5 million. Due to this asset class forming significantly more than 10% of the current portfolio valuation, this was deemed an appropriate sensitivity to sample.
| Changes in | ||
|---|---|---|
| portfolio | NAV | |
| Forestry assets sensitivity | valuation | per share |
| Forestry assets value increases by 10% | +£7.53m/+4.3% | +4.4p |
| Forestry assets value decreases by 10% | -£7.53m/-4.3% | -4.4p |
The sensitivity of the portfolio to changes in afforestation asset valuation is as follows:
The independent valuer conducts inspections of all afforestation assets on a semi-annual basis, then provides a valuation based on RICS methodology. The base case used for afforestation asset value as at 30 September 2023 was £67.1 million. Due to this asset class forming more than 10% of the current portfolio valuation, this was deemed an appropriate sensitivity to sample.
| Changes in | Changes in | |
|---|---|---|
| portfolio | NAV | |
| Afforestation assets sensitivity | valuation | per share |
| Afforestation assets value increases by 10% | +£6.71m/+3.8% | +3.9p |
| Afforestation assets value decreases by 10% | -£6.71m/-3.8% | -3.9p |
The sensitivity of the portfolio to changes in mixed forestry and afforestation asset valuation is as follows:
The independent valuer conducts inspections of all mixed assets on a semi-annual basis, then provides a valuation based on RICS methodology. The base case used for the asset value of mixed forestry and afforestation assets as at 30 September 2023 was £23.9 million. Due to this asset class forming more than 10% of the current portfolio valuation, this was deemed an appropriate sensitivity to sample.
| Changes in | Changes in | |
|---|---|---|
| portfolio | NAV | |
| Mixed forestry and afforestation assets sensitivity | valuation | per share |
| Mixed assets value increases by 10% | +£2.39m/+1.4% | +1.4p |
| Mixed assets value decreases by 10% | -£2.39m/-1.4% | +1.4p |
FOR THE YEAR ENDED 30 SEPTEMBER 2023
Due to the relatively small size of the non-core assets in the Company's valuation, the sensitivity to movement in this part of the portfolio is deemed immaterial, so no sensitivity analysis has been conducted.
The Group, which comprises the Company and its non-consolidated subsidiaries, manages its capital to ensure that it will be able to continue as a going concern while maximising the return to Shareholders through the optimisation of the debt and equity balances. The capital structure of the Group principally consists of the share capital account and retained earnings as detailed in notes 13 and 14. The Group aims to deliver its objective by investing available cash and using leverage whilst maintaining sufficient liquidity to meet ongoing expenses.
The Company's Investment Manager reviews the capital structure of the Company and the Group on a semi-annual basis. The Company and its subsidiaries intend to make prudent use of leverage for financing acquisitions of investments and working capital purposes. Under the Company's Articles, and in accordance with the Company's borrowing policy, the Company's outstanding borrowings, excluding the debts of underlying assets, will be limited to 30% of the Company's Gross Asset Value.
As at 30 September 2023, the Company had no outstanding debt. The Company's subsidiary FSFC Holdings 2 Limited has a £30 million Revolving Credit Facility, of which £10.4 million had been drawn at 30 September 2023.
The Group's activities expose it to a variety of financial risks: capital risk, liquidity risk, market risk (including interest rate risk, inflation risk and power price risk) and credit risk. The Group's overall risk management programme focuses on the unpredictability of financial markets and seeks to minimise potential adverse effects on the Group's financial performance.
For the Company and the intermediate holding companies, financial risks are managed by the Investment Manager, which operates within the Board-approved policies. All risks continue to be managed by the Investment Manager. The various types of financial risk are managed as follows:
STATEMENTS
The Company accounts for its investments in its subsidiaries at fair value; to the extent there are changes as a result of the risks set out below, these may impact the fair value of the Company's investments.
The Company has implemented an efficient financing structure that enables it to manage its capital effectively. The Company's capital structure comprises equity only (refer to the statement of changes in equity). As at 30 September 2023, the Company had no recourse to debt, although as set out in the Company structure chart, the Company's subsidiary FSFC Holdings Limited is a guarantor for the Revolving Credit Facility of FSFC Holdings 2 Limited.
The Directors monitor the Company's liquidity requirements to ensure there is sufficient cash to meet the Company's operating needs. The Company's liquidity management policy involves projecting cash flows and forecasting the level of liquid assets necessary to meet these. Due to the nature of its investments, the timing of cash outflows is reasonably predictable and, therefore, is not a major risk to the Company. The Company was in a net cash position and had no outstanding debt at the balance sheet date.
ADDITIONAL INFORMATION
FOR THE YEAR ENDED 30 SEPTEMBER 2023
Financial risk management continued
Market risk – foreign currency exchange rate risk
All the cash flows and investments are denominated in pounds sterling.
The following risks impact the Company's subsidiaries and in turn may impact the fair value of investments held by the Company.
Interest rate risk arises in the Company's subsidiaries on the Revolving Credit Facility borrowings and floating rate deposits. Borrowings issued at variable rates expose those entities to variability of interest payment cash flows. Interest rate hedging may be carried out to seek to provide protection against increasing costs of servicing debt drawn down by the holding company as part of its Revolving Credit Facility. This may involve the use of interest rate derivatives and similar derivative instruments.
Each investment hedges their interest rate risk at the inception of a project. This will either be done by issuing fixed rate debt or variable rate debt which will be swapped into fixed rate by the use of interest rate swaps.
Some of the Company's investments will have part of their revenue and some of their costs linked to a specific inflation index at inception of the project. In most cases this creates a natural hedge, meaning a derivative does not need to be entered into in order to mitigate inflation risk.
Timber revenue forms a significant majority of forecasted revenues for the Company's investments. Whilst projections suggest a steady income flow through the sale of timber, there is a risk that timber prices will drop due to market forces and minimise the revenues the Fund will receive. This risk is mitigated by the ability of the Company and underlying investments to sustain its liquidity, even in the event of withholding from timber sales, given sub-optimal pricing.
Credit risk is the risk that a counterparty of the Company or its subsidiaries will default on its contractual obligations it entered into with the Company or its subsidiaries. Credit risk arises from cash and cash equivalents, derivative financial instruments and deposits with banks and financial institutions, as well as credit exposures to customers.
The Company and its subsidiaries place cash in authorised deposit takers and are therefore potentially at risk from the failure of such institutions. In respect of credit risk arising from other financial assets and liabilities, which mainly comprise of cash and cash equivalents, exposure to credit risk arises from default of the counterparty with a maximum exposure equal to the carrying amounts of these instruments. In order to mitigate such risks, cash is maintained with major international financial institutions. During the period and at the reporting date, the Company maintained relationships with HSBC Bank plc.
| Moody's | 30 September | 30 September | |
|---|---|---|---|
| credit | 2023 | 2022 | |
| rating | £'000 | £'000 | |
| HSBC Bank plc | P1 | 1,217 | 34,326 |
| Total cash and cash equivalents | 1,217 | 34,326 |
STATEMENTS
The following subsidiaries have not been consolidated in these financial statements as a result of applying the requirements of "Investment Entities: Applying the Consolidation Exception (Amendments to IFRS 10)". The Company is not contractually obligated to provide financial support to the subsidiaries and there are no restrictions in place in passing monies up the structure.
| Name | Direct or indirect holding |
Country of incorporation |
Registered address |
Principal activity |
Proportion of shares and voting rights held |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| FSFC Holdings Limited | Direct | UK | C/O Foresight Group LLP, The Shard, 32 London Bridge Street, London, England, SE1 9SG |
Holding company | 100% |
| FSFC Holdings 2 Limited | Indirect | UK | C/O Foresight Group LLP, The Shard, 32 London Bridge Street, London, England, SE1 9SG |
Holding company | 100% |
| FSFC Company 1 Limited | Indirect | UK | C/O Foresight Group LLP, The Shard, 32 London Bridge Street, London, England, SE1 9SG |
SPV | 100% |
| Blackmead Forestry Limited | Indirect | UK | C/O Foresight Group LLP, The Shard, 32 London Bridge Street, London, England, SE1 9SG |
SPV | 100% |
| Blackmead Forestry II Limited | Indirect | UK | C/O Foresight Group LLP, The Shard, 32 London Bridge Street, London, England, SE1 9SG |
SPV | 100% |
| Coull Forestry Limited | Indirect | UK | C/O Foresight Group LLP, The Shard, 32 London Bridge Street, London, England, SE1 9SG |
SPV | 100% |
| Fordie Estates Limited | Indirect | UK | C/O Foresight Group LLP, Clarence House, 133 George Street, Edinburgh, Scotland, EH2 4JS |
SPV | 100% |
The Company is governed by an independent and non-executive Board of Directors. There are four Non-Executive Directors. Please refer to the Directors' remuneration report for details of the Directors' emoluments.
The Company has no guarantees or significant capital commitments as at 30 September 2023.
ADDITIONAL INFORMATION
FOR THE YEAR ENDED 30 SEPTEMBER 2023
Following admission of the Ordinary Shares (refer to note 13), the Company and the Directors are not aware of any person who, directly or indirectly, jointly, or severally, exercises or could exercise control over the Company. As per the Director's report on pages 71 to 78, it is however noted that Blackmead Infrastructure Limited's substantial interest in share capital (29.93%) constitutes a party with significant influence on the Company. The Company does not have an ultimate controlling party.
The transactions between the Company and its subsidiaries, which are related parties of the Company, and fair values, are disclosed in note 10. Details of transactions between the Company and related parties are disclosed below
This note also details the terms of the Company's engagement with Foresight Group LLP, the Investment Manager.
The Investment Manager, Foresight Group LLP, is entitled to a base fee on the following basis:
The investment management fees incurred during the year to 30 September 2023 were £1,561,930, of which £399,781 remained unpaid as at 30 September 2023.
Additionally, the Company incurred fees during the year to 30 September 2023 of £128,623, which related to administration services provided by the Investment Manager, in its capacity as Administrator for the Company. £32,564 of the fees incurred remained unpaid as at 30 September 2023.
The amount incurred in respect of Directors' fees during the year to 30 September 2023 was £160,000. The Directors also received £2,336 in relation to miscellaneous Director expenses. These amounts had been fully paid as at 30 September 2023. The amounts paid to individual Directors were as follows:
| Director | Taxable benefits £ |
Basic and Committee fees £ |
Total £ |
|---|---|---|---|
| Richard Davidson (Chair) | — | 48,000 | 48,000 |
| Sarika Patel | 357 | 40,500 | 40,857 |
| Christopher Sutton | 1,617 | 35,500 | 37,117 |
| Josephine Bush | 362 | 36,000 | 36,362 |
| Total | 2,336 | 160,000 | 162,336 |
The Directors held the following shares in the Company:
| Director | Number of Ordinary Shares |
% of issued Ordinary Share capital |
|---|---|---|
| Richard Davidson (Chair) | 100,000 | 0.06 |
| Sarika Patel | 24,000 | 0.01 |
| Christopher Sutton | 25,000 | 0.01 |
| Josephine Bush | 19,000 | 0.01 |
The above transactions were undertaken on an arm's-length basis.
The Directors have evaluated the need for disclosures and/or adjustments resulting from post balance sheet events through the financial statements were available to be issued.
On 19 October 2023, one of the Company's SPVs, FSFC Company 1 Limited, completed the acquisition of a site in Scotland for £0.7million.
On 1 December 2023, one of the Company's SPVs, Fordie Estates Limited, completed the acquisition of a site in Scotland for £0.5million.
There are no other significant events since period end which would require to be disclosed. There were no adjusting post balance sheet events and, as such, no adjustments have been made to the valuation of assets and liabilities as at 30 September 2023.
Below are the Company key facts, advisers and other information (which have not been audited).
Foresight Sustainable Forestry Company Plc ("FSF") is the first and only UK listed investment trust focused on UK forestry, afforestation and natural capital (registered number 13594181) with a premium listing on the London Stock Exchange.
The Shard, 32 London Bridge Street, London, SE1 9SG
GB00BMDPKM71
30 September
Foresight Group LLP, No OC300878, registered in England and Wales and authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority
£140.2 million at 30 September 2023
0.85% per annum of the NAV up to £500 million, falling to 0.75% per annum of NAV in excess of £500 million.
The Ordinary Shares are eligible for inclusion in PEPs and ISAs (subject to applicable subscription limits) provided that they have been acquired in the market, and they are permissible assets for SIPPs.
The Company is classed as an externally managed Alternative Investment Fund under the Alternative Investment Fund Managers Regulations 2013 and the European Union's Alternative Investment Fund Managers Directive.
Approved UK Investment Trust subject to the Company continuing to meet the eligibility conditions in Section 1158 of the Corporation Taxes Act 2010 and the ongoing requirements for approved companies in Chapter 3 of Part 2 Investment Trust (Approved Company) (Tax) Regulations 2011 (Statutory Instrument 2011/2999).
The Company has registered for FATCA and has a GIIN number 191P2V.99999.SL.826
The Company's investment policy is set out on pages 71 and 72.
https://fsfc.foresightgroup.eu/
The Shard 32 London Bridge Street London SE1 9SG
The Pavilions Bridgwater Road Bristol BS99 6AH
150 Cheapside London EC2V 6ET
14 Greville Street London EC1N 8SB
4 More London Riverside London SE1 2AU
25 Churchill Place London E14 5EY
Earn House Broxden Business Park Perth PH11 1RA
| AGM | Annual General Meeting | H&S | Health and safety |
|---|---|---|---|
| AIC | The Association of Investment Companies | HMRC | HM Revenue & Customs |
| AIFs | Alternative Investment Funds | IAS | International Accounting Standard |
| AIFMs | Alternative Investment Fund Managers | ICVCM | Integrity Council for Voluntary Carbon |
| AIFMD | Alternative Investment Fund Managers Directive |
IFRS | Markets International Financial Reporting Standards as |
| APMs | Alternative Performance Measures | adopted by the EU | |
| Asset Manager | The Company's underlying investments have appointed Foresight Group LLP, a subsidiary of Foresight Group CI, to act as Asset Manager |
Intermediate holding companies | Companies within the Group which are used to invest in afforestation and forestry assets, namely FSFC Holdings Limited and FSFC Holdings 2 Limited |
| Company | Foresight Sustainable Forestry Company Plc | Investment Manager | Foresight Group LLP, appointed by Foresight Group CI Limited |
| EJDF | E.J. Downs Forestry, who have significant experience in the forestry management space |
IPO | Initial Public Offering |
| and advise the Company on silvicultural | ITC | Investment Trust Company | |
| decisions | KPI | Key performance indicator | |
| Ernst & Young LLP | Ernst & Young is the Company's auditor | LSE | London Stock Exchange |
| ESG | Environmental, Social and Governance | Main Market | The main securities market of the London |
| FCA | Financial Conduct Authority | Stock Exchange | |
| FITF | Foresight Inheritance Tax Fund | NAV | Net Asset Value |
| Foresight | Foresight Group LLP | PEFC | Programme for the Endorsement of Forest |
| FSC | Forest Stewardship Council | Certification | |
| FSF | Foresight Sustainable Forestry Company Plc | PIU | Pending Issuance Units |
| FTE | Full-time equivalent | Portfolio | The 68 assets in which FSF had a shareholding as at 30 September 2023 |
| Fund | Foresight Sustainable Forestry Company Plc | Proposed Project | |
| Fund Managers | Richard Kelly and Robert Guest | A project in which the Fund is investing, or the Operating Company is directly or indirectly funding, with the reasonable expectation that it will be a Qualifying Project. |
|
| GAV | Gross Asset Value on investment basis including debt held at Company and subsidiary level |
| Qualifying Body(ies) | A standards body for the certification | SPHN | Statutory plant health notifications |
|---|---|---|---|
| of Qualifying Projects and/or Carbon Credits, which is publicly endorsed, without conditionality, by a Voluntary Carbon Industry Body A project which has been Independently |
SPV | The special purpose vehicles which hold the Company's investment portfolio of underlying operating assets |
|
| SSSI | Sites of special scientific interest | ||
| Qualifying Project | tCO2e | Tonnes of carbon dioxide equivalent | |
| Certified and appears on the register of the relevant Qualifying Body |
TCFD | Task Force on Climate-related Financial | |
| RCF | Revolving Credit Facility | Disclosures | |
| Red Book Valuation or the Red Book | the Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors Valuation – Global Standards July 2017 |
UK | The United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland |
| VCM | Voluntary Carbon Market | ||
| RICS | Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors | VCU | Verified carbon units |
| RIDDOR | Reporting of Injuries, Diseases and Dangerous Occurrences Regulations |
WCC | UK Woodland Carbon Code |
| RNS | Regulatory News Services | ||
| RPI | The Retail Price Index | ||
| S&ESG | Sustainability and ESG | ||
| SAC | Special area of conservation | ||
| Savills | Savills Advisory Services Limited | ||
| SDGs | United Nations Sustainable Development Goals |
||
| SDR | UK Green Taxonomy and UK Sustainable Disclosure Requirements |
||
| SFDR | The EU Sustainable Finance Disclosure Regulation |
||
| SORP | Statement of Recommended Practice: Financial Statements of Investment Trust Companies and Venture Capital Trusts |
STATEMENTS
ADDITIONAL INFORMATION
Reference period: 01 October 2022 – 30 September 2023 (noting the Company was awarded the Voluntary Carbon Market designation in December 2022).
As an Eligible Issuer under the LSE's Voluntary Carbon Market designation, the Company confirms that this audited annual report and financial statements include:
| VCM Designation Disclosure | Issuer comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| A | a statement confirming that there has been no change in the investments held by the Fund or the funding arrangements of the Operating Company (as the case may be) in the Proposed Projects and/or Qualifying Projects or, in the event that there has been a change, details of the change; |
During the year to 30 September, the Company has made 18 investments, adding a total of 2,929 hectares to its portfolio. In addition, it disposed of five properties within its portfolio. Please refer to pages 22 – 23 for full details on investment activity during the year. |
|
| The Company confirms that beyond its investment activity, in pursuit of its investment and sustainable investment objectives, there have been no changes. |
|||
| B | in respect of a Fund, which is not fully invested, confirmation of the expected timing of any further investments in Proposed Projects and/or Qualifying Projects; |
The Company announced that it completed the investment of its June 2022 fundraise in January 2023. Please refer to page 25 for a forecast of when afforestation schemes in development are expected to achieve planting completion. |
|
| C | an update in respect of the stage of each Proposed Project in relation to the standards of the relevant Qualifying Body including, without limitation: i. the expected timing of achieving key milestones to achieve the status of a Qualifying Project; or ii. a statement of the likelihood that the relevant Proposed Project will or will not become a Qualifying Project; |
Please refer to pages 24 – 26 for a forecast of when the Company's afforestation schemes in development are expected to their achieve planting completion milestones. |
|
| D | a restatement of its expected Carbon Credit target yield and a description of how the Eligible Issuer has | Please refer to pages 11 and 12 for details on the Company's objectives for 2023/24. | |
| performed in relation to the previously stated expected target Carbon Credit yield; | As at 30 September the Company's current afforestation portfolio is expected to create up to 1.0-1.2 million voluntary carbon credits. |
||
| E | a statement confirming the percentage of the Eligible Issuer's gross assets, which are invested (directly or indirectly) in Qualifying Projects and Proposed Projects |
Please refer to pages 19 – 32 for a breakdown of the Company's portfolio and progress towards the creation of carbon credits. |
|
| At 30 September 2023, the Company's afforestation portfolio comprised a 45% allocation (by value). | |||
| F | for a Fund, confirmation that, to the extent the Fund is not invested in Proposed Projects and/or Qualifying Projects, the revenues from its investments (other than in cash or cash equivalents) can be mapped to the Tier 1 or Tier 2 micro sectors within FTSE Russell's Green Revenues Classification System; |
As part of transactions to acquire forestry assets, the Company may end up owning ancillary non-forestry related assets such as residential land and buildings and small-scale renewable energy assets. The Company classifies these as "non-core" and at any point these will account for no more than 10% of the Company's assets (by value). Where appropriate and beneficial to the overall strategy, the GroupCompany will look to realise the value of any Non-Core Assets over time for the benefit of Shareholders. |
|
| As at 30 September 2023 non-core assets , not expected to align with FTSE Russell's Green Revenues Classification System accounted for 3.52% of the Company's Gross Asset Value ("GAV."). The remaining 96.48% of the Company's GAV as at 30 September 2023, was invested into sustainable forestry and afforestation assets that can be mapped onto Tier 1 or Tier 2 micro sectors within FTSE Russell's Green Revenues Classification System. |
|||
| G | for an Operating Company, confirmation that the revenues from any other business activity conducted can be mapped to the Tier 1 or Tier 2 micro sectors within FTSE Russell's Green Revenues Classification System; |
N/A | |
| H | details (including the number) of any Carbon Credits received by the Eligible Issuer in the period, including: i. the Qualifying Body and the Voluntary Carbon Industry Body; ii. certification standard name; iii. type (reduction and/or removal); iv. project name; v. identification number; vi. issuing Registry for each Carbon Credit issued; vii. host country; viii. Carbon Credit vintage; ix. methodology/project type; and; whether or not the Carbon Credit is associated with corresponding adjustments (as evidenced by authorisation and authorised use) by the host and/or buyer country; |
In the period to 30 September 2023, the Company has not received or owned any Carbon Credits. | |
| I | details (including the number) of any Carbon Credits that have been retained, retired on behalf of shareholders, distributed or sold onwards by the Eligible Issuer in the period; |
N/A |
STATEMENTS
ADDITIONAL INFORMATION
| VCM Designation Disclosure | Issuer comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| J | in respect of cash equivalents, how such investments are compatible with the principle of climate change mitigation; and |
The Company may hold cash reserve for the purposes of ancillary liquidity and ongoing portfolio management to enable the continued attainment of the Company's sustainable investment objective. At any point, this cash reserve will account for no more than 5% of the Company's assets. As at 30 September, cash reserves comprised 0.72% of the Company's GAV. |
|
| The Company utilises the following responsible bank reserves: | |||
| • HSBC Sterling Liquidity Fund Class F; and |
|||
| • HSBC Sterling ESG Liquidity Fund Class F |
|||
| These are aligned with the principles of climate change mitigation and sustainable investment. | |||
| K | an update in respect of the disclosure required pursuant to paragraph 6(e) in respect of the United Nation's Sustainable Development Goals ("SDGs") |
Please refer to the Company's sustainable impact reporting on pages 33 – 36. This outlines the specific SDG indicators used for the FSF portfolio. |
This report is printed on Nautilus which is made from FSC® recycled certified post-consumer waste pulp. The FSC® label on this report ensures responsible use of the world's forest resources. Printed sustainably in the UK by Pureprint, a CarbonNeutral® company with FSC® chain of custody and an ISO 14001 certified environmental management system recycling over 100% of all dry waste.
Foresight Sustainable Forestry Company Plc The Shard 32 London Bridge Street London SE1 9SG fsfc.foresightgroup.eu
This report is printed on Nautilus which is made from FSC® recycled certified post-consumer waste pulp. The FSC® label on this report ensures responsible use of the world's forest resources. Printed sustainably in the UK by Pureprint, a CarbonNeutral® company with FSC® chain of custody and an ISO 14001 certified environmental management system recycling over 100% of all dry waste.
Building tools?
Free accounts include 100 API calls/year for testing.
Have a question? We'll get back to you promptly.