Legal Proceedings Report • May 23, 2013
Preview not available for this file type.
Download Source FileWith reference to announcement no. 8, 2012, the European Patent Office (EPO)
has set the date of processing of the appeal concerning rejection of BioPorto’s
NGAL cutoff patent, issued in Europe. The case is set at the EPO Boards of
Appeal on August 27, 2013.
The decision specifying that the patent is to be withdrawn is based on an
assessment by the EPO’s Opposition Division that the patent is insufficiently
described (Art. 83 of the EPC). The EPO’s Opposition Division justifies this by
also stating that:
This argument is still based on an erroneous calculation of the specificity,
which results in the diagnosis of much too large a share of patients who do not
have a renal affection as having a renal affection. This same calculation error
was found in the Opposition Division’s preliminary and non-binding opinion and
has not been changed, despite BioPorto’s information stating that this error
leads to a completely erroneous result.
It is not the purpose of the invention to differentiate between different types
of renal affection as the decision implies. The method is capable of diagnosing
a renal affection, regardless of the type of renal affection, with sufficient
probability for a diagnostic assay.
On the other hand, the Opposition Division finds that there is sufficient basis
in the patent for:
-- not having to specify a certain point in time for sample-taking in relation
to when the initiation of insult has occurred;
-- not requiring the method used for carrying out an assay of the NGAL
concentration to be specified in the claim.
Additional material has been submitted and the EPO Boards of Appeal can issue a
preliminary and non-binding opinion prior to the proceedings. If so, BioPorto
will evaluate the preliminary opinion when it has been issued.
For further information, please contact:
Christina Thomsen, Investor Relations
Thea Olesen, CEO
Tel. +45 4529 0000, e-mail [email protected]
Building tools?
Free accounts include 100 API calls/year for testing.
Have a question? We'll get back to you promptly.