AI assistant
FAIRVEST LIMITED — M&A Activity 2021
Dec 10, 2021
48720_rns_2021-12-10_24085112-d651-4790-991e-b5fa0490b7f1.pdf
M&A Activity
Open in viewerOpens in your device viewer
Arrowhead Properties Limited
(Incorporated in the Republic of South Africa) (Registration number 2007/032604/06) JSE share code: AHA ISIN: ZAE000275491 JSE share code: AHB ISIN: ZAE000275509 (Approved as a REIT by the JSE) ("Arrowhead" or the "Company")
REVISED LISTING PARTICULARS
PREPARED IN TERMS OF THE JSE LISTINGS REQUIREMENTS
The definitions commencing on page 6 of these Revised Listing Particulars apply throughout this document, including this cover page, except where the context indicates a contrary intention.
These Revised Listing Particulars are not an invitation to the public to subscribe for Arrowhead Shares but are issued in compliance with the Listings Requirements of the JSE Limited for purposes of providing information to the public with regard to the Company. Although still subject to a number of conditions, these Revised Listing Particulars have been prepared on the assumption that the Transaction has been implemented, and therefore this document has been prepared in relation to the Combined Group, being the Arrowhead Group as enlarged by the acquisition of the entire issued share capital of Fairvest.
Post implementation of the Scheme, Arrowhead will change its name to "Fairvest Limited".
As at the Last Practicable Date:
- the authorised share capital of Arrowhead comprises 1 000 000 000 AHA Shares and 2 000 000 000 AHB Shares;
- the issued share capital of Arrowhead comprises 62 718 658 AHA Shares and 951 422 029 AHB Shares; and
- 655 032 AHB Shares held in treasury.
Pursuant to the implementation of the Scheme, assuming that no Fairvest Shares are to be repurchased by Fairvest pursuant to an appraisal rights process in terms of section 164 of the Companies Act, 545 045 125 AHB Shares will be issued in respect of the Scheme Consideration Shares, with the result that:
- the authorised share capital of Arrowhead will comprise 1 000 000 000 AHA Shares and 2 000 000 000 AHB Shares;
- the issued share capital of Arrowhead will comprise 62 718 658 AHA Shares and 1 496 467 154 AHB Shares; and
- 10 973 096 AHB Shares will be held in treasury.
The AHB Shares to be issued pursuant to the implementation of the Transaction will rank pari passu in all respects with existing AHB Shares in issue. There are no convertibility or redemption provisions relating to any of the AHB Shares to be issued.
Arrowhead Shareholders are referred to the Scheme Circular which is available on Fairvest's website (https://fairvest.co.za/ news/notices) for information regarding the Scheme. In this regard, a scheme of arrangement in terms of section 114 of the Companies Act has been proposed by the Fairvest Board between Fairvest and the Fairvest Shareholders and to which Arrowhead is a party. In the event of the Conditions Precedent being fulfilled or waived (to the extent permissible) and the Scheme becoming operative, Arrowhead will by operation of law become the sole shareholder of Fairvest and Scheme Participants will, against surrender of their relevant Documents of Title (if applicable) in accordance with the provisions of the Scheme Circular, become entitled to receive the Scheme Consideration in respect of each Fairvest Share held by them.
Upon implementation of the Scheme, the Fairvest Shares will be delisted from the Main Board of the JSE.
Scheme Participants should note that the Scheme Consideration comprises AHB Shares which shall be listed on the Main Board of the JSE, and trade on the JSE in electronic format through the Strate system.
The directors, whose names appear on page 14, collectively and individually accept full responsibility for the accuracy of the information contained in this document which relates to Arrowhead and, in this regard, certify that, to the best of their knowledge and belief, there are no facts that have been omitted which would make any statement false or misleading, and that all reasonable enquiries to ascertain such facts have been made and that these Revised Listing Particulars contain all information required by the Companies Act and the JSE Listings Requirements.
All advisors whose names and/or reports are contained in these Revised Listing Particulars have consented in writing to act in the capacity stated and to their names being included in these Revised Listing Particulars and, if applicable, to the inclusion of their respective reports in these Revised Listing Particulars in the form and context in which they appear and have not withdrawn their written consents prior to publication hereof.

Date of issue: 10 December 2021
These Revised Listing Particulars are available in English only. Hard copies of this document will be available at the Registered Office of the Company and on the Company's website (https://www.arrowheadproperties.co.za/prospectus-and-circular.php) from 10 December 2021.
SPECIAL NOTES WITH REGARD TO THE SCHEME
This document does not constitute an offer to the public to subscribe for Arrowhead Shares or other securities in the Company and only constitutes an offer as it relates to the issue of the Scheme Consideration Shares to the Scheme Participants in South Africa and is only addressed to persons to whom it may lawfully be made.
The release, publication or distribution of these Revised Listing Particulars in certain jurisdictions may be restricted by law and therefore persons in any such jurisdictions into which this document is released, published or distributed should inform themselves about and observe any such restrictions. Any failure to comply with the applicable restrictions may constitute a violation of the securities laws of any such jurisdiction.
These Revised Listing Particulars do not constitute an offer or an invitation to elect to receive the Scheme Consideration Shares in any jurisdiction in which such an offer or election would be unlawful. No one has taken any action that would permit a public offering of the Scheme Consideration Shares to occur outside South Africa.
Forward-looking statements
These Revised Listing Particulars contain statements that are or may be forward-looking statements. All statements, other than statements of historical fact are, or may be deemed to be, forward-looking statements, including, without limitation, those concerning strategy; the economic outlook for the industry; production; cash costs and other operating results; growth prospects and outlook for operations, individually or in the aggregate; liquidity and capital resources and expenditure, and the outcome and consequences of any pending litigation proceedings. These forward-looking statements are not based on historical facts, but rather reflect current expectations concerning future results and events and generally may be identified by the use of forward-looking words or phrases such as "believe", "aim", "expect", "anticipate", "intend", "foresee", "forecast", "likely", "should", "planned", "may", "estimated", "potential" or similar words and phrases.
Examples of forward-looking statements include statements regarding a future financial position or future profits, cash flows, corporate strategy, anticipated levels of growth, estimates of capital expenditures, acquisition strategy, expansion prospects or future capital expenditure levels and other economic factors, such as, inter alia, interest rates.
By their nature, forward-looking statements involve risks and uncertainties because they relate to events and depend on circumstances that may or may not occur in the future. Arrowhead cautions that forward-looking statements are not guarantees of future performance. Actual results, financial and operating conditions, liquidity and the developments within the industry in which Arrowhead operates may differ materially from those made in, or suggested by, the forward-looking statements contained in these Revised Listing Particulars.
All these forward-looking statements are based on estimates and assumptions, as regards to Arrowhead and Fairvest, made by Arrowhead and made by Fairvest as communicated in publicly available documents issued by Arrowhead and Fairvest, all of which estimates and assumptions, although Arrowhead believes them to be reasonable, are inherently uncertain. Such estimates, assumptions or statements may not eventuate. Factors which may cause the actual results, performance or achievements to be materially different from any future results, performance or achievements expressed or implied in those statements or assumptions include other matters not yet known to Arrowhead or not currently considered material by Arrowhead.
Arrowhead Shareholders should keep in mind that any forward-looking statement made in these Revised Listing Particulars or elsewhere is applicable only at the date on which such forward-looking statement is made. New factors that could cause the business of Arrowhead or Fairvest not to develop as expected may emerge from time to time and it is not possible to predict all of them. The extent to which any factor or combination of factors may cause actual results to differ materially from those contained in any forward-looking statement are not known. Arrowhead has no duty to, and does not intend to, update or revise the forward-looking statements contained in these Revised Listing Particulars after the date of hereof, except as may be required by law.
Dates and times
The dates and times referred to in these Revised Listing Particulars are subject to change. Any such changes will be published on SENS. All dates and times referred to in this document are South African dates and times.
CORPORATE INFORMATION AND ADVISORS
Arrowhead Company Secretary and Registered Office Fairvest Registered Office
Vicki Turner Arrowhead Properties Limited (Registration number 2007/032604/06) 3rd Floor, Upper Building 1 Sturdee Avenue Rosebank, 2196 (PO Box 685, Melrose Arch, 2076)
Date of incorporation: 13 November 2007 Place of incorporation: Republic of South Africa
Joint Corporate Advisor and Transaction Sponsor Lead Corporate Advisor
Nedbank Corporate and Investment Banking, a division of Nedbank Limited (Registration number 1951/000009/06) 3rd Floor, Corporate Place, Nedbank Sandton 135 Rivonia Road Sandton, 2196 (PO Box 1144, Johannesburg, 2000)
Attorney and Competition Law Advisor Independent Reporting Accountant
Cliffe Dekker Hofmeyr Incorporated (Registration number 2008/018923/21) 11 Buitengracht Street Cape Town, 8001 (PO Box 695, Cape Town, 8000)
Transfer Secretary to Arrowhead Transfer Secretary to Fairvest
JSE Investor Services South Africa Proprietary Limited (Registration number 2000/007239/07) 13th Floor, 19 Ameshoff Street Braamfontein, 2001 (PO Box 4844, Johannesburg, 2000)
Fairvest Property Holdings Limited (Registration number 1998/005011/06) 8th Floor, The Terraces 34 Bree Street Cape Town, 8001 (Postnet Suite 30, Private Bag X3, Roggebaai, 8012)
Date of incorporation: 17 March 1998 Place of incorporation: Republic of South Africa
Ferryman Capital Partners Proprietary Limited (Registration number 2017/026566/07) 3rd Floor, Upper Building 1 Sturdee Avenue Rosebank, 2196
BDO South Africa Incorporated (Registration number: 1995/002310/21) Wanderers Office Park 52 Corlett Drive Illovo, 2196 (Private Bag X60500, Houghton, 2041)
Computershare Investor Services Proprietary Limited (Registration number 2004/003647/07) Rosebank Towers 15 Biermann Avenue Rosebank, 2196 (Private Bag X9000, Saxonwold, 2132)
Independent Property Valuers Bankers
Broll Valuation and Advisory Services Proprietary Limited (Registration number 1968/003515/07) Sixty One Katherine 61 Katherine Street Sandown Ext. 54 Sandton, 2196 (PO Box 1455, Saxonwold, 2132)
De Leeuw Valuers Cape Town (RF) Proprietary Limited (Registration number 2015/285229/07) Jan de Waalhuis 93 Bree Street Cape Town, 8001 (PO Box 1278, Cape Town, 8000)
DDP Valuation and Advisory Services Proprietary Limited (Registration number 2007/018821/07) Menlyn Square Office Park North West Suite 1st Floor, East Block 134 Aramist Avenue Menlyn, Pretoria, 0181 (PO Box 40408, Moreleta Park, 0044)
The Standard Bank of South Africa Limited (Registration number 1969/017128/06) 30 Baker Street, Rosebank, Johannesburg, 2001
Nedbank Limited (Registration number 1951/000009/06) 135 Rivonia Road Sandton, 2196 (PO Box 1144, Johannesburg, 2000)
FirstRand Bank Limited (Registration number 1929/001225/06) 25th Floor, Portside, 5 Buitengracht Street Cape Town, 8001 (PO Box 367, Cape Town, 8000)
Investec Bank Limited (Registration number 1969/004763/06) 100 Grayston Drive, Sandown Sandton, 2196 (PO Box 785700, Sandton, 2146)
TABLE OF CONTENTS
The definitions and interpretations commencing on page 6 these Revised Listing Particulars apply, mutatis mutandis, to this "Table of Contents" (unless the context requires otherwise).
| Page | ||
|---|---|---|
| CORPORATE INFORMATION AND ADVISORS | 2 | |
| DEFINITIONS AND INTERPRETATION | 6 | |
| REVISED LISTING PARTICULARS | 13 | |
| SECTION 1 – COMPANY INFORMATION | 14 | |
| 1. | NAME, ADDRESS, INCORPORATION | 14 |
| 2. | DIRECTORS, OTHER OFFICE HOLDERS OR MATERIAL THIRD PARTIES | 14 |
| 3. | HISTORY, STATE OF AFFAIRS AND PROSPECTS | 23 |
| 4. | CORPORATE GOVERNANCE | 26 |
| 5. | MATERIAL CHANGES | 26 |
| 6. | PROPERTY PORTFOLIO OF THE COMBINED GROUP | 26 |
| 7. | SHARE CAPITAL OF THE COMBINED GROUP | 28 |
| 8. | OPTIONS OR PREFERENTIAL RIGHTS IN RESPECT OF ARROWHEAD SHARES | 31 |
| 9. | COMMISSIONS PAID OR PAYABLE | 31 |
| 10. 11. |
MATERIAL CONTRACTS INTERESTS OF DIRECTORS AND PROMOTERS |
32 32 |
| 12. | MATERIAL BORROWINGS AND LOANS RECEIVABLE | 32 |
| 13. | SHARES ISSUED OR TO BE ISSUED OTHER THAN FOR CASH | 33 |
| 14. | PROPERTY AND BUSINESS UNDERTAKINGS | 33 |
| 15. | AMOUNTS PAID OR PAYABLE TO PROMOTERS | 33 |
| 16. | PRELIMINARY EXPENSES AND ISSUE EXPENSES | 33 |
| 17. | PERCEIVED CONFLICTS OF INTEREST | 34 |
| SECTION 2 – INFORMATION ABOUT THE OFFERED SECURITIES | 35 | |
| 1. | PURPOSE OF THE SCHEME | 35 |
| 2. | TIMES AND DATES | 36 |
| 3. | PARTICULARS OF THE SCHEME | 36 |
| 4. | PREVIOUS ISSUES OF SECURITIES | 40 |
| SECTION 3 – STATEMENTS AND REPORTS | 41 | |
| 1. | STATEMENT AS TO ADEQUACY OF CAPITAL | 41 |
| 2. | REPORT BY DIRECTORS AS TO MATERIAL CHANGES | 41 |
| 3. | STATEMENT AS TO LISTING ON A STOCK EXCHANGE | 41 |
| 4. | HISTORICAL FINANCIAL INFORMATION | 41 |
| 5. | FORECAST STATEMENTS OF COMPREHENSIVE INCOME ON THE COMBINED GROUP | 41 |
| 6. | PRO FORMA EFFECTS OF THE TRANSACTION | 42 |
| 7. | DIVIDENDS | 42 |
| SECTION 4 – ADDITIONAL MATERIAL INFORMATION | 43 | |
| 1. | RELATIONSHIP INFORMATION | 43 |
| 2. | VENDORS OF MATERIAL ASSETS | 43 |
| 3. | LITIGATION STATEMENT | 44 |
| 4. | TRADING HISTORY OF SHARES | 44 |
| 5. | GOVERNMENT PROTECTION AND INVESTMENT ENCOURAGEMENT LAW | 44 |
| 6. | DIRECTORS' RESPONSIBILITY STATEMENT | 44 |
| 7. 8. |
CONSENTS DOCUMENTS INCORPORATED BY REFERENCE |
44 44 |
| 9. | DOCUMENTS AVAILABLE FOR INSPECTION | 45 |
Page
ANNEXURES
| ANNEXURE 1 | GROUP STRUCTURE | 46 |
|---|---|---|
| ANNEXURE 2 | DETAILS OF SUBSIDIARIES | 48 |
| ANNEXURE 3 | DETAILS OF CURRENT AND PROPOSED DIRECTORS OF THE COMBINED GROUP AND ITS MAJOR SUBSIDIARIES |
50 |
| ANNEXURE 4 | CURRENT AND PAST DIRECTORSHIPS | 59 |
| ANNEXURE 5 | EXTRACTS OF MEMORANDUM OF INCORPORATION OF ARROWHEAD | 65 |
| ANNEXURE 6 | DETAILS OF THE PROPERTY MANAGERS | 76 |
| ANNEXURE 7 | INDEPENDENT PROPERTY VALUERS' SUMMARY VALUATION REPORTS ON THE FAIRVEST PROPERTY PORTFOLIO |
79 |
| ANNEXURE 8 | DETAILS OF THE ARROWHEAD PROPERTY PORTFOLIO | 126 |
| ANNEXURE 9 | ACQUISITIONS AND VENDORS, DISPOSALS AND MATERIAL CONTRACTS | 131 |
| ANNEXURE 10 | FORECAST STATEMENTS OF COMPREHENSIVE INCOME OF THE COMBINED GROUP | 138 |
| ANNEXURE 11 | INDEPENDENT REPORTING ACCOUNTANTS' ASSURANCE REPORT ON THE FORECAST FINANCIAL INFORMATION OF THE COMBINED GROUP |
143 |
| ANNEXURE 12 | PRO FORMA FINANCIAL INFORMATION OF THE ARROWHEAD GROUP | 145 |
| ANNEXURE 13 | INDEPENDENT REPORTING ACCOUNTANTS' ASSURANCE REPORT ON THE COMPILATION OF THE PRO FORMA FINANCIAL INFORMATION OF THE ARROWHEAD GROUP |
152 |
| ANNEXURE 14 | INDEPENDENT REPORTING ACCOUNTANTS' REVIEW CONCLUSION ON THE VALUATION AND EXISTENCE OF THE ASSETS AND LIABILITIES ACQUIRED BY ARROWHEAD |
154 |
| ANNEXURE 15 | CAPITAL STRUCTURE | 156 |
| ANNEXURE 16 | MATERIAL BORROWINGS AND LOANS RECEIVABLE | 162 |
| ANNEXURE 17 | TRADING OF SHARES | 177 |
| ANNEXURE 18 | MATERIAL RISKS | 181 |
| ANNEXURE 19 | CORPORATE GOVERNANCE STATEMENT | 185 |
DEFINITIONS AND INTERPRETATIONS
In these Revised Listing Particulars and its annexures, unless otherwise stated or the context otherwise indicates, the words in the first column shall have the meanings stated opposite them in the second column and words in the singular shall include the plural and vice versa, natural persons shall include corporations and associations of persons and an expression denoting any gender shall include the other genders:
| "A2X" | the exchange operated by A2X Proprietary Limited (Registration number 2014/147138/07), a private company incorporated and registered in accordance with the laws of South Africa, and licensed as an exchange under the Financial Markets Act; |
|---|---|
| "AHA Shares" | an A ordinary share of no par value in the share capital of Arrowhead; |
| "AHA Shareholders" | holders of AHA Shares; |
| "AHB Shares" | a B ordinary share of no par value in the share capital of Arrowhead; |
| "AHB Shareholders" | holders of AHB Shares; |
| "ANS" | A2X News Service; |
| "appraisal rights" | the rights afforded to Arrowhead Shareholders in terms of section 164 of the Companies Act; |
| "Arrowhead" or the "Company" | Arrowhead Properties Limited (Registration number 2007/032604/06), a public company duly incorporated in accordance with the laws of South Africa, the shares of which are listed on the JSE; |
| "Arrowhead Board" or "Board" | the board of directors of Arrowhead at the Last Practicable Date; |
| "Arrowhead Group" | Arrowhead and its Subsidiaries; |
| "Arrowhead Shareholders" | registered holders of Arrowhead Shares; |
| "Arrowhead Shares" | collectively, AHA Shares and AHB Shares, and "Arrowhead Share" refers to any one of them, as the context may require; |
| "Associate" | has the meaning ascribed to it in the Listings Requirements; |
| "Attorneys and Competition Law Advisors" or "CDH" |
Cliffe Dekker Hofmeyr Incorporated, (Registration number 2008/018923/21), a private company duly incorporated in accordance with the laws of South Africa; |
| "Broker" | any person registered as a "broking member (equities)" in accordance with the provisions of the Financial Markets Act; |
| "Broll" | Broll Valuation and Advisory Services, Registration number 1968/003515/07, a private company duly incorporated in accordance with the laws of South Africa; |
| "Business Day" | means any day other than a Saturday, Sunday or official public holiday in South Africa; |
| "cents" | South African cents in the official currency of South Africa; |
| "CEO" | Chief Executive Officer; |
| "Circular" | the category 1 circular to Arrowhead Shareholders dated 10 December 2021, including all annexures and attachments, the Notice of General Meeting and Form of Proxy; |
| "Clean-out Distribution" | the cash distribution by each of Arrowhead and Fairvest of all its distributable income in respect of the applicable Pre-Transaction Financial Period; |
| "Combined Group" | the Arrowhead Group as enlarged by the acquisition of the Fairvest Group pursuant to the Transaction; |
| "Commercial Effective Date" | the date upon which the Scheme, should it become operative in accordance with its terms, will have commercial effect, which is intended to be on 1 October 2021; |
|---|---|
| "Companies Act" | the South African Companies Act, 2008 (Act 71 of 2008), as amended; |
| "Companies Regulations" | the Companies Regulations, 2011, promulgated in terms of section 223 of the Companies Act as amended; |
| "Comparable Offer" | in addition to the Mandatory Offer, the comparable offer required to be made by Fairvest to acquire the AHA Shares in terms of section 125 of the Companies Act, which requirement shall be triggered pursuant to the implementation of the Fairvest Acquisition Agreements (if such implementation were to occur); |
| "Competition Act" | the Competition Act, 1998 (Act 89 of 1998), as amended; |
| "Competition Authorities" | the commission established pursuant to Chapter 4, Part A of the Competition Act or the tribunal established pursuant to Chapter 4, Part B of the Competition Act or the appeal court established pursuant to Chapter 4, Part C of the Competition Act, as the case may be; |
| "Conditions Precedent" | the conditions precedent to which the Scheme is subject, as set out in paragraph 3.6, Section 2 of these Revised Listing Particulars; |
| "Court" | any South African Court with competent jurisdiction to approve the implementation of the special resolution set out in the notice convening the Scheme Meeting pursuant to section 115 of the Companies Act and/or to determine the fair value of Arrowhead Shares and Fairvest Shares and make an order pursuant to section 164(14) of the Companies Act; |
| "CSDP" | a Central Securities Depository Participant, accepted as a participant in terms of the Financial Markets Act; |
| "DDP" | DDP Valuation & Advisory Services Proprietary Limited, (Registration number 2007/018821/07), a private company duly incorporated in accordance with the laws of South Africa; |
| "De Leeuw Valuers" | De Leeuw Valuers Cape Town (RF) Proprietary Limited, Registration number 2015/285229/07, a private company duly incorporated in accordance with the laws of South Africa; |
| "Dematerialised Arrowhead Shares" |
Arrowhead Shares which have been dematerialised in terms of the requirements of Strate; |
| "Departing Executive(s)" | Mark Kaplan and Junaid Limalia; |
| "Departing Executive Termination Agreements" |
the agreements entered into between the Company and each of Mark Kaplan and Junaid Limalia on 17 November 2021, in terms of which each of Mark Kaplan and Junaid Limalia have accepted an agreed exit in accordance with the key terms set out in paragraph 5 of Annexure 3; |
| "Departing Executive Termination Date" |
the date upon which the employment of each of Mark Kaplan and Junaid Limalia with the Company will terminate, being on the earlier of five business days after the Transaction becomes unconditional or on the last day of the month in which the Scheme Operative Date occurs; |
| "Dissenting Fairvest Shareholder" |
a Fairvest Shareholder that has validly exercised its appraisal rights in accordance with section 164(3) and section 164(5) to (8) of the Companies Act, and (i) has not withdrawn its demand made in terms of section 164(5) to (8) of the Companies Act; and (ii) has not allowed an offer made to it by Fairvest in terms of section 164(11) of the Companies Act to lapse; |
| "Document(s) of Title" | share certificate(s), transfer deed(s) or form(s), balance receipt(s) or any other document(s) of title acceptable to Arrowhead in respect of Certificated Arrowhead Shareholder(s); |
| "Fairvest" | Fairvest Property Holdings Limited, (Registration number 1998/005011/06), a public company duly incorporated in accordance with the laws of South Africa, the shares of which are listed on the Main Board of the JSE and the securities exchange operated by A2X; |
|---|---|
| "Fairvest Acquisition" | collectively, the proposed acquisition by Fairvest of 507 778 681 AHB Shares (50.1% of issued Arrowhead Shares) from various AHB Shareholders in terms of the Fairvest Acquisition Agreements, the acquisition by Fairvest of further AHB Shares pursuant to acceptances, if any, of the Mandatory Offer and the acquisition by Fairvest of AHA Shares pursuant to acceptances, if any, of the Comparable Offer; |
| "Fairvest Acquisition Agreements" |
the agreements entered into on 18 May 2021 between Fairvest and various AHB Shareholders, holding, in aggregate, 507 778 681 (50.1% of issued Arrowhead Shares) AHB Shares, to acquire their AHB Shares in exchange for Fairvest Shares, at a share swap ratio of 1.85 Fairvest Shares for each AHB Share held; |
| "Fairvest Board" | the board of directors of Fairvest; |
| "Fairvest Circular" | the circular to Fairvest shareholders dated Tuesday, 10 August 2021, including all annexures, a notice of general meeting and form of proxy, which details, inter alia, the Fairvest Acquisition and the Fairvest Manco Internalisation; |
| "Fairvest Group" | Fairvest and its Subsidiaries; |
| "Fairvest Independent Board" | the Fairvest independent board comprising Louis Andrag, Khegu Nkuna, Ndabezinhle Mkhize, Jacob Wiese and Trevor Cohen, all of whom are independent non-executive directors of Fairvest, which has been specifically constituted in terms of Regulation 108 of the Companies Regulations to appraise the Transaction on behalf of the Fairvest Board; |
| "Fairvest Manco Internalisation" | the internalisation of Fairvest's asset management function by way of the acquisition of the entire issued share capital of New Star by Fairvest, as fully detailed in the Fairvest Circular, as approved by Fairvest Shareholders on 7 September 2021, and which transaction became effective on 1 October 2021; |
| "Fairvest Manco Internalisation Agreement" |
the agreement entered into between Fairvest, New Star and the Old New Star Shareholders on 30 July 2021 in respect of the Fairvest Manco Internalisation; |
| "Fairvest Revised Listing Particulars" |
the revised listing particulars document accompanying the Fairvest Circular, dated Tuesday, 10 August 2021, including all annexures thereto; |
| "Fairvest Shares" | no par value ordinary shares in the issued share capital of Fairvest; |
| "Fairvest Shareholders" | holders of Fairvest Shares; |
| "Finalisation Date" | the date on which all the Conditions Precedent have been fulfilled or waived (where applicable), as the case may be; |
| "Financial Markets Act" | the Financial Markets Act, 2012 (Act 19 of 2012), as amended; |
| "Financial Year" | the financial year of Arrowhead, ending on 30 September of each year; |
| "Form of Proxy" | the form of proxy incorporated into the Circular for use only by (i) Certificated Arrowhead Shareholders and (ii) Dematerialised Arrowhead Shareholders with own name registration, for purposes of appointing a proxy to represent such Arrowhead Shareholder at the General Meeting; |
| "Gemgrow" | the former name of Arrowhead, being "Gemgrow Properties Limited", which changed its name to "Arrowhead Properties Limited" with effect from 9 October 2019; |
| "Gemgrow Arrowhead Merger" | the acquisition by the Company, by way of scheme of arrangement in terms of section 114(1) of the Companies Act, of the entire issued share capital of Old Arrowhead, effective 9 October 2019, but as at the Last Practicable Date, excluding the 3 298 466 (c. 0.3%) of the issued shares in Old Arrowhead still held by dissenting shareholders and subject to an appraisal rights process in terms of section 164 of the Companies Act; |
|---|---|
| "General Meeting" | the combined General Meeting of AHA Shareholders and AHB Shareholders to be held at 11:00 on Friday, 14 January 2022, at 3rd Floor Upper Building, 1 Sturdee Avenue, Rosebank, 2196 and through electronic participation by way of telephone conferencing or by way of MS Teams, including any postponement or adjournment or a reconvening thereof; |
| "GLA" | gross lettable area, being the total area of a property that can be rented to a tenant, measured in m²; |
| "IFRS" | International Financial Reporting Standards; |
| "Implementation Agreement" | the Scheme Implementation Agreement dated 23 September 2021 and the addenda thereto dated 27 September 2021, 29 October 2021 and 15 November 2021 entered into between Arrowhead and Fairvest, which regulates, inter alia, the basis on which the Scheme will be proposed and, if applicable, implemented; |
| "Income Tax Act" | the Income Tax Act, 1962 (Act 58 of 1962), as amended; |
| "Independent Property Valuers" | collectively, Broll, De Leeuw Valuers and DDP; |
| "Independent Reporting Accountants" or "BDO" |
BDO South Africa Incorporated (Registration number 1995/002310/21), company duly incorporated in accordance with the laws of South Africa; |
| "Indluplace" | Indluplace Properties Limited (Registration number 2013/226082/06), a public company duly incorporated in accordance with the laws of South Africa, the shares of which are listed on the JSE; |
| "JHI" | Excellerate Real Estate Services Proprietary Limited (Registration number 2007/021131/07), a private company duly incorporated in South Africa; |
| "Joint Corporate Advisor and Transaction Sponsor" or "Nedbank" |
Nedbank Limited, (Registration number 1951/000009/06), a public company duly incorporated and registered in accordance with the laws of South Africa, acting through its Corporate and Investment Banking division; |
| "Joint Firm Intention Announcement" |
the joint firm intention announcement released on SENS and ANS by Arrowhead and Fairvest on 27 September 2021, setting out the terms of the Transaction; |
| "JSE" | JSE Limited, (Registration number 2005/022939/06), a public company duly registered and incorporated under the laws of South Africa and licensed as an exchange under the Financial Markets Act; |
| "Last Practicable Date" | the last practicable date prior to the finalisation of these Revised Listing Particulars, being Tuesday, 23 November 2021; |
| "Lead Corporate Advisor" or "Ferryman" |
Ferryman Capital Partners Proprietary Limited, (Registration number 2017/026566/07), a private company duly incorporated in accordance with the laws of South Africa; |
| "Listings Requirements" | the listings requirements of the JSE, as amended; |
| "m2 " |
square metre; |
| "Major Subsidiary" | a Subsidiary that represents 25% or more of total assets or revenue of the consolidated group based on the latest published interim or year-end financial results, as defined in the Listings Requirements; |
| "Mandatory Offer" | the mandatory offer in terms of section 123 of the Companies Act that may be required to be made by Fairvest to the AHB Shareholders (other than the counterparties to the Fairvest Acquisition Agreements) to acquire their AHB Shares, which obligation shall be triggered by the implementation of the Fairvest Acquisition Agreements, should the acquisitions contemplated therein be implemented, which Mandatory Offer will be in addition to the Comparable Offer; |
|---|---|
| "MOI" | the memorandum of incorporation of Arrowhead; |
| "NAV" | net asset value; |
| "New Star" | New Star Asset Management Propriety Limited (Registration number 2005/029006/07), a private company duly incorporated in accordance with the laws of South Africa which company was responsible for Fairvest's asset management function prior to the completion of the Fairvest Manco Internalisation; |
| "NCA" | the National Credit Act, 2005 (Act 34 of 2005) as amended; |
| "Notice of General Meeting" | the notice convening the General Meeting, which is attached to and forms part of the Circular; |
| "Old Arrowhead" | Arrowgem Limited (Registration number 2011/000308/06), formerly known as Arrowhead Properties Limited, being a public company duly incorporated in South Africa, the shares of which were delisted from the JSE pursuant to the implementation of the Gemgrow Arrowhead Merger; |
| "Old New Star Shareholders" | collectively, Hilton Datnow, the Trustees for the time being of the Marcus Family Trust, the Trustees for the time being of the Wilder Family Trust, the Trustees for the time being of the Labora Trust, the Trustees for the time being of the Gelz Trust and the Trustees for the time being of the Universal Long Term Investment Trust; |
| "Parties" | jointly, Arrowhead and Fairvest, and "Party" shall refer to either one of them, as the context requires; |
| "Pre-Transaction Financial Period" |
in respect of Arrowhead, the financial period commencing on 1 October 2020 and ending on 30 September 2021; and in respect of Fairvest, the financial period commencing on 1 January 2021 and ending on 30 September 2021; |
| "R" | South African Rands, the currency of South Africa; |
| "Registered Office" | Arrowhead's registered office, situated at 3rd Floor Upper Building, 1 Sturdee Avenue, Rosebank, Johannesburg, 2196; |
| "REIT" | a Real Estate Investment Trust as defined in the Income Tax Act; |
| "Revised Listing Particulars" or "this document" |
this document accompanying the Circular, including its annexures, dated 10 December 2021; |
| "Scheme" | the scheme of arrangement in terms of section 114(1) of the Companies Act (read with section 115 of the Companies Act), proposed by the Fairvest Board (on recommendation by the Fairvest Independent Board) between Fairvest and Fairvest Shareholders, and to which Arrowhead shall be a party, in terms of which, if the Scheme becomes operative, Arrowhead will acquire all of the Scheme Shares held by the Scheme Participants for the Scheme Consideration and the Scheme Participants will by operation of the Scheme transfer their rights, title and interest in and to the Scheme Shares to Arrowhead on and subject to the terms and conditions contained in the Scheme Circular; |
| "Scheme Circular" | the circular issued jointly by Arrowhead and Fairvest on 19 November 2021 to Fairvest Shareholders in respect of inter alia, the Scheme, which document has been incorporated by reference as per paragraph 8 of Section 4; |
| "Scheme Consideration" | means the consideration payable by Arrowhead to Scheme Participants for their Fairvest Shares acquired in terms of the Scheme, being a consideration of 0.54054 AHB Shares to be issued and allotted to Scheme Participants for every one Fairvest Share disposed of by a Scheme Participant, which consideration shall be settled on the Scheme Consideration Settlement Date; |
|---|---|
| "Scheme Consideration Record Date" |
the third Business Day after the Scheme Last Day to Trade, being the date on which holders of Fairvest Shares are required to be registered as such in the register in order to receive the Scheme Consideration, which date is expected to be 28 January 2022; |
| "Scheme Consideration Settlement Date" |
the date on which Fairvest Shareholders are expected to receive the Scheme Consideration in settlement of the consideration under the Scheme; |
| "Scheme Consideration Shares" | 545 045 125 AHB Shares, being the aggregate number of AHB Shares to be issued to the Scheme Participants in respect of the Scheme Consideration; |
| "Scheme Last Day to Trade" | the last day to trade in Fairvest Shares in order to be recorded in the Fairvest share register in order to receive the Scheme Consideration, which date is expected to be 25 January 2022; |
| "Scheme Meeting" | the meeting of Fairvest Shareholders to be held at 10:00 on Tuesday, 21 December 2021 or any other adjourned or postponed date and time, to be convened for the purposes of considering and, if deemed fit, approving, inter alia, the Scheme Resolution, including any adjournment or postponement thereof; |
| "Scheme Operative Date" | means the Business Day on which the Scheme becomes operative and is implemented in accordance with its terms, which is expected to be 31 January 2022; |
| "Scheme Participants" | the Fairvest Shareholders who are registered as the holders of Fairvest Shares in the securities register of Fairvest on the Scheme Consideration Record Date, but excluding (i) any Subsidiary of Fairvest which holds any Fairvest Shares (such Fairvest Shares constituting treasury shares) and (ii) any Dissenting Fairvest Shareholders; |
| "Scheme Resolution" | the special resolution, as contemplated in section 115(2) of the Companies Act, in terms of which Fairvest Shareholders approve the Scheme, which resolution is to be tabled at the Scheme Meeting; |
| "Scheme Shares" | all the Fairvest Shares held by Scheme Participants on the Scheme Consideration Record Date, which Fairvest Shares shall be acquired by Arrowhead pursuant to the Scheme; |
| "SENS" | the Stock Exchange News Service of the JSE; |
| "Share Swap Ratio" | a share swap ratio of 0.54054 AHB Shares for every Fairvest Share; |
| "South Africa" | the Republic of South Africa; |
| "Strate" | Strate Proprietary Limited, (Registration number 1998/022242/07), a private company duly incorporated and registered in accordance with the laws of South Africa, and the electronic settlement system for transactions that take place on the JSE and off-market transactions; |
| "Subsidiary" | a subsidiary as defined in Section 1 and read with Section 3 of the Companies Act and in the Listings Requirements; |
| "Synergy" | Synergy Income Fund, being the former name of Gemgrow; |
| "Synergy Transaction" | the strategic repositioning of the Company (formerly Synergy) as a specialist high yielding, high growth fund with a portfolio comprising retail, office and industrial assets as more fully detailed in a circular to shareholders dated 26 September 2016; |
| "Termination Date" | the date upon which the first of the Conditions Precedent is not timeously fulfilled or waived, as applicable, in which case the Scheme and the Implementation Agreement, and as a result, the Transaction, will terminate; |
| "Transaction" | the proposed acquisition by Arrowhead of the Scheme Shares pursuant to the Scheme, in consideration for the issue to Scheme Participants of the Scheme Consideration Shares, as fully detailed in this Circular; |
|---|---|
| "Transaction Costs" | any and all fees, costs and expenses incurred by any Party in connection with the Transaction; |
| "Transfer Secretaries" or "JSE Investor Services" |
the transfer secretaries of Arrowhead being JSE Investor Services South Africa Proprietary Limited (Registration number 2000/007239/07), a private company duly incorporated and registered in accordance with the laws of South Africa; |
| "TRP" | the Takeover Regulation Panel, established in terms of section 196 of the Companies Act; |
| "Valid Demand" | means a demand/s made in terms of section 164(5) of the Companies Act, within the time period contemplated in section 164(7), by one or more Fairvest Shareholders, which shareholder/s comply with the requirements of section 164(5)(a) and (c) of the Companies Act, in terms of which such shareholder/s demand that Fairvest pay such shareholder/s the fair value for all of the Fairvest Shares such shareholder/s hold; |
| "VAT" | value added tax as defined in the Value Added Tax Act, 1991, as amended; and |
| "VWAP" | volume weighted average price. |
Arrowhead Properties Limited
(Incorporated in the Republic of South Africa) (Registration number 2007/032604/06) JSE share code: AHA ISIN: ZAE000275491 JSE share code: AHB ISIN: ZAE000275509 (Approved as a REIT by the JSE)
("Arrowhead" or the "Company")
ARROWHEAD DIRECTORS
Executive
M Kaplan (Chief Executive Officer) J Limalia (Chief Financial Officer)
Independent Non-Executive
G Kinross (Chairman) T Adler A Basserabie N Makhoba S Mokorosi
REVISED LISTING PARTICULARS
These Revised Listing Particulars are issued in compliance with the Listings Requirements for the purpose of providing information with regard to the Combined Group, as the implementation of the Transaction will result in a reverse takeover of Arrowhead in terms of paragraph 9.5(c) of the Listings Requirements.
This document does not constitute an invitation to the public to subscribe for Arrowhead Shares or other securities in Arrowhead.
SECTION 1 – COMPANY INFORMATION
1. NAME, ADDRESS, INCORPORATION
1.1 Name and registration number
Arrowhead Properties Limited,(Registration number 2007/032604/06).
Post the implementation of the Scheme, Arrowhead will change its name to "Fairvest Limited".
1.2 Addresses
- 1.2.1 Registered office address: 3rd Floor Upper Building, 1 Sturdee Avenue, Rosebank, Johannesburg, 2196.
- 1.2.2 Primary place of business address: 3rd Floor Upper Building, 1 Sturdee Avenue, Rosebank, Johannesburg, 2196.
- 1.2.3 Address of Company's transfer secretary: JSE Investor Services South Africa Proprietary Limited (Registration number 2000/007239/07), 13th Floor, 19 Ameshoff Street, Braamfontein, 2001.
1.3 Date and place of incorporation of Arrowhead
Incorporated in the Republic of South Africa on 13 November 2007.
1.4 Details of the subsidiaries of Arrowhead
The name, date and place of incorporation of each of Arrowhead's subsidiaries immediately after the implementation of the Scheme are set out in Annexure 2.
2. DIRECTORS, OTHER OFFICE HOLDERS OR MATERIAL THIRD PARTIES
2.1 Details of directors
2.1.1 As at the Last Practicable Date, the Arrowhead Board comprises:
Executive M Kaplan (Chief Executive Officer) J Limalia (Chief Financial Officer)
Independent non-executive G Kinross (Chairman) T Adler A Basserabie N Makhoba S Mokorosi
2.1.2 The full names, positions, dates of appointment, ages, business addresses, qualifications and experience of the directors are set out below.
| Name | Mark Jonathan Kaplan |
|---|---|
| Age | 41 |
| Business address | 1 Sturdee Avenue, Rosebank, Johannesburg |
| Qualifications | BBusSc, Finance (Hons) |
| Position | CEO |
| Experience | Mark is the CEO of Arrowhead. Mark was the co-founder of Old Arrowhead (renamed "Arrowgem"), which was acquired by Arrowhead with effect from 23 September 2019. Mark was previously involved in managing a large residential portfolio focused on affordable student housing. |
| Name | Junaid Limalia |
|---|---|
| Age | 49 |
| Business address | 1 Sturdee Avenue, Rosebank, Johannesburg |
| Qualifications | CA (SA), BCom, (Hons) BAcc, PG dip in International Taxation |
| Position | Chief Financial Officer |
| Experience | Junaid began his career over 20 years ago as a chartered accountant at PricewaterhouseCoopers. He spent two years in the United Kingdom, whereafter he moved to IBM South Africa's IT outsourcing division. From 2003, he held various positions at the South African Revenue Service ("SARS"), from tax auditor to executive of the investigative audit division for large business. He worked on redesigning the operating model of SARS's large business centre, project managed its implementation and represented SARS on IRBA's Committee for auditing standards. |
| Name | Gregory Stephen Kinross |
| Age | 47 |
| Business address | 1 Sturdee Avenue, Rosebank, Johannesburg |
| Qualifications | BCom, BAcc, CA(SA) |
| Position | Independent non-executive director |
| Experience | Gregory qualified as a chartered accountant in 1997. The following year, he founded his own private equity business. In 2005, he became CEO and President of Tau Capital Corp., a mining and resource finance business. In 2013, he formed Innovo Capital Proprietary Limited to pursue private equity opportunities. Gregory is currently a partner in Evolve Capital Partners Proprietary Limited, a private equity and investment holding business. |
| Name | Taffy Monty Adler |
| Age | 71 |
| Business address | 1 Sturdee Avenue, Rosebank, Johannesburg |
| Qualifications | BA, BPhil in African Studies, MSc in Building Science |
| Position | Independent non-executive director |
| Experience | Taffy is the director of the Property Revitalisation Programme for the University of the Witwatersrand. He was previously CEO of the Housing Development Agency and the Johannesburg Housing Company. He is also the non-executive Chairman of Indluplace. |
| Name | Arnold Basserabie |
| Age | 77 |
| Business address | 1 Sturdee Avenue, Rosebank, Johannesburg |
| Qualifications | BSc (Mathematics and Statistics), ASA, CFP |
| Position | Independent non-executive director |
| Experience | After graduating with a BSc, Arnold joined Fedsure Financial Services Group. In 1988 he was appointed Group CEO, and its asset base grew from R2 billion to R40 billion during his 13-year tenure. In the 1990s, Arnold contributed to the advancement of a number of emerging businesses in South Africa. Since the early 2000s he has practised as a strategic consultant, focusing on strategy, business development and related activities, across a diverse range of industries. Arnold sits on the board of a number of companies and is, inter alia, Chairman of the Wits University Foundation's Board of Governors and Past Chairman of Wits University's Investment Committee. |
| Name | Nozipho Makhoba |
|---|---|
| Age | 44 |
| Business address | 1 Sturdee Avenue, Rosebank, Johannesburg |
| Qualifications | CA(SA), BCom Accounting, Post-graduate Diploma: Accounting (Honours) |
| Position | Independent non-executive director |
| Experience | Nozipho qualified as a chartered accountant in 2003. She completed her articles at KPMG and gained both local and UK audit experience. She has extensive experience in the real estate sector and has a strong finance, investments and operations background. |
| Nozipho is currently the Portfolio and Business Manager at STANLIB Limited, responsible for a property development portfolio in the Rest of Africa. Previously she held the role of Chief Financial Officer and Acting CEO for STANLIB Fahari I-REIT, a REIT listed on the Nairobi Securities Exchange. She has previously served in various roles within the Liberty Group Limited, including Manager: Group Corporate Finance; Executive Assistant to the Liberty Holdings Limited Managing Director; Executive Assistant to the STANLIB Limited CEO; and Project Manager at Liberty Properties Limited. From 2005 to 2010, Nozipho was the Finance and Operations Manager at the Public Investment Corporation where she helped manage a R26 billion property fund and spearheaded the establishment of an in-house property management function. |
|
| Name | Sam Mokorosi |
| Age | 42 |
| Business address | 1 Sturdee Avenue, Rosebank, Johannesburg |
| Qualifications | BCom Honours in Economics |
| Position | Independent non-executive director |
| Experience | Sam is the Head of Origination and Deals at JSE Limited. He is a seasoned financial services executive, with 20 years' experience in property finance, the bond market, corporate finance and private equity. He has successfully executed corporate finance and private equity transactions worth R40 billion. He has worked at Vunani Capital, Standard Bank, Quartile Capital, IHS Investments and Cadiz Corporate Solutions. |
All of the directors of Arrowhead are South African nationals.
2.1.3 The full names, positions, dates of appointment, ages, business addresses, qualifications and experience of the key executives responsible for the day to day running of the Arrowhead Group's business are set out below.
| Name | Alon Isaac Kirkel |
|---|---|
| Age | 38 |
| Business address | 1 Sturdee Avenue, Rosebank, Johannesburg |
| Qualifications | BCom |
| Position | Chief Investment Officer |
| Experience | Alon completed a BCom at the University of the Witwatersrand, majoring in accounting and human resources. He worked in the diamond industry for 15 years at Diacore, formerly the Steinmetz Group. His role included purchasing and analysing high quality investment diamonds for the Group. Alon has also been successful in purchasing neglected commercial and industrial buildings and turning them into quality, high yielding assets. |
| Name | Riaz Kader | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Age | 39 | |||
| Business address | 1 Sturdee Avenue, Rosebank, Johannesburg | |||
| Qualifications | BCom | |||
| Position | Chief Operating Officer | |||
| Experience | Riaz has a BCom from the University of the Witwatersrand and has 13 years of property experience in residential, retail, office and industrial property. He was previously a director of Excellerate Real Estate Services Proprietary Limited t/a JHI. Riaz has been involved in the management of Arrowgem's property portfolio since inception. His responsibilities include overseeing the performance of the property portfolio of the Arrowhead Group, with particular focus on leveraging efficiencies at the national level, debt management, lease negotiations and ensuring that income is optimised. |
All of the above persons are South African nationals.
2.2 Details of the proposed directors of Arrowhead
2.2.1 The Arrowhead Board will be reconstituted on and with effect from the Scheme Operative Date. Resolutions to elect the new directors to the Arrowhead Board will be put to Arrowhead Shareholders at the General Meeting. Subject to the approval by Arrowhead Shareholders of the newly appointed directors to the board of the Combined Group, at the General Meeting, the board of directors of the Combined Group, will, with effect from the Implementation Date of the Transaction, comprise:
Executive
Darren Wilder (Chief Executive Officer) Jacques Kriel (Chief Financial Officer)
Independent non-executive Ndabe Mkhize (Chairman) Jacques du Toit Louis Andrag Khegu Nkuna Advocate Jacob Wiese Nozipho Makhoba Arnold Basserabie
- 2.2.2 Nozipho Makhoba and Arnold Basserabie will remain as directors on the Arrowhead Board.
- 2.2.3 Gregory Kinross, Taffy Adler and Sam Mokorosi will resign from the Arrowhead Board.
- 2.2.4 In terms of the Departing Executive Termination Agreements entered into between Mark Kaplan (currently Chief Executive Officer of Arrowhead) and Junaid Limalia (currently Chief Financial Officer of Arrowhead), each of Mark Kaplan and Junaid Limalia have agreed to resign from the Arrowhead Board with effect from the Departing Executive Termination Date, further details of which are set out in paragraph 5 of Annexure 3.
2.2.5 Other than the details of Arnold Basserabie and Nozipho Makhoba which are contained in paragraph 2.1.1 above, the full names, positions, dates of appointment, ages, business addresses, qualifications and experience of the proposed directors (which are currently directors of the Fairvest Group) of Arrowhead are set out below.
| Name | Darren Wilder |
|---|---|
| Age | 53 |
| Business address | 8th Floor, The Terraces, 34 Bree Street, Cape Town, 8001 |
| Qualifications | – |
| Position | CEO |
| Experience | Darren worked for Seeff Properties in various positions from 1991 until 1997. During 1997 he was appointed to the board of the then JSE-listed company, Capital Alliance Properties, and was a participant in its management buy out. Darren co-founded Spearhead Property group and was part of the team that listed the company on the JSE. He was appointed COO in 1999. Darren's work experience also includes national leasing director for Madison Properties, business development director of the V&A Waterfront and also a consultant to the CEO of the V&A Waterfront |
| Name | Jacques Kriel |
| Age | 42 |
| Business address | 8th Floor, The Terraces, 34 Bree Street, Cape Town, 8001 |
| Qualifications | CA (SA) |
| Position | Chief Financial Officer |
| Experience | Jacques is a qualified Chartered Accountant with 18 years' experience in audit, finance and operational management, eleven of which have been in the listed property sector. Jacques completed his articles at LDP Inc in South Africa and thereafter spent four years in the United Kingdom working at Ernst and Young and The Bank of England. Jacques joined Fairvest in 2010. |
| Name | Ndabezinhle Mkhize |
| Age | 43 |
| Business address | EPPF Office Park, 24 Georgian Crescent East, Bryanston East, Johannesburg, 2191 |
| Qualifications | BSc Actuarial Science, CFA |
| Position | Chairman and independent non-executive director |
| Experience | Ndabe is the Chief Investment Officer of the Eskom Pension and Provident Fund. He is also chairman of IG Markets South Africa and of the Asset Owners Forum South Africa. Previous positions include co-portfolio manager at Coronation Fund Managers and STANLIB Asset Management and equity analyst at Prudential Investment Managers. Ndabe holds a BSc (Actuarial Science) degree from the University of Cape Town and the designations of Chartered Financial Analyst and Chartered Alternative Investment Analyst. He completed the Property Development Programme at the UCT Graduate School of Business. |
| Name | Jacques du Toit |
| Age | 50 |
| Business address | 46 Orange Street, Gardens, Cape Town, 8001 |
| Qualifications | CFA |
| Position | Independent non-executive director |
| Experience | Jacques is a chartered financial analyst and has been involved in the financial services industry since joining HSBC Simpson McKie as a stockbroker in 1998. He joined the portfolio management side at HSBC in 2003 and headed up the investment process until 2005 when he joined Investec Securities Limited as senior portfolio manager. In August 2008 he jointly set up a financial services company, Cohesive Capital. He serves as a director on the boards of a number of private companies. |
| Name | Louis Andrag | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Age | 48 | |||
| Business address | Edward 2 Building, Edward Street, Bellville, Cape Town, 7530 | |||
| Qualifications | BEng (Industrial Mechanical), MBA | |||
| Position | Independent non-executive director | |||
| Experience | Louis is a qualified engineer with a B.Engineering (Industrial Mechanical) degree and he also obtained his Honours and MBA degrees from the University of Stellenbosch. On qualifying Louis worked in the US and Germany as an engineer and on returning to South Africa he joined Stellenbosch Farmers' Winery as site engineer. In 2009 Louis founded Leggato Investments specialising in property investment and residential development. He serves as chairman and director on the boards of a number of private companies. |
|||
| Name | Khegu Nkuna | |||
| Age | 34 | |||
| Business address | 41 West Street, Houghton Estate, Johannesburg 7490 | |||
| Qualifications | CA(SA) | |||
| Position | Independent non-executive director | |||
| Experience | Khegu qualified as a Chartered Accountant after completing her articles with Deloitte in 2013. She is currently the Group Financial Director of the Masingita Group. Masingita specialises in retail property development in similar LSM categories as Fairvest, resulting in Khegu being a valuable board member with retail property specific knowledge. Khegu has experience in both private and public companies spanning across diverse industries. She has professional experience in auditing, strategic financial management, strategy development, financial risk analysis and corporate governance. |
|||
| Name | Advocate Jacob Wiese | |||
| Age | 40 | |||
| Business address | 36 Stellenberg Road, Parow Industria, Cape Town, 7490 | |||
| Qualifications | BA, LLB, Masters in International Economics and Management | |||
| Position | Independent non-executive director | |||
| Experience | Jacob holds a BA (Value and Policy studies) and an LLB degree. He completed his Master's degree in International Economics and Management from Universita Commerciale Luigi Bocconi in Italy. In 2009 Jacob completed his pupillage at the Cape Bar and was subsequently admitted as an Advocate of the High Court. Jacob is a non-executive director of Invicta Holdings. He is involved with the management of Lourensford Wine Estate, one of South Africa's most prestigious wine farms. |
All of the proposed directors are South African nationals.
2.2.6 The appointment of the proposed directors is conditional on the Scheme becoming operative.
2.3 Additional information related to the directors
- 2.3.1 Annexure 3 contains the following information in relation to the existing and proposed directors of Arrowhead:
- 2.3.1.1 emoluments of directors;
- 2.3.1.2 terms of employment of directors;
- 2.3.1.3 borrowing powers of the directors;
- 2.3.1.4 interests of directors and promoters;
- 2.3.1.5 declarations of the directors; and
-
2.3.1.6 directors' interests in Arrowhead Shares and transactions.
-
2.3.2 Annexure 4 contains details of the current and past directorships and partnerships of the existing and proposed directors of Arrowhead.
- 2.3.3 The provisions of the MOI with regard to the following are set out in Annexure 5:
- 2.3.3.1 qualification of directors;
- 2.3.3.2 remuneration of directors;
- 2.3.3.3 any power enabling the directors to vote on remuneration to themselves or any member of the Arrowhead Board;
- 2.3.3.4 the borrowing powers exercisable by the directors and how such borrowing powers can be varied; and
- 2.3.3.5 retirement or non-retirement of directors under an age limit.
2.4 Details of directors of Major Subsidiaries of Arrowhead
Prior to, and post implementation of the Transaction, Indluplace will be the only Major Subsidiary of Arrowhead. The full names, ages, business addresses, qualifications, position and experience of each director of Indluplace are set out below:
| Name | Petrus Carel de Wit | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Age | 53 | |||
| Business address | 2nd Floor, 158 Jan Smuts Building, 9 Walters Street, Rosebank, Johannesburg, 2196 |
|||
| Qualifications | BSc Building Science | |||
| Position | CEO | |||
| Experience | Carel joined Indluplace in 2014. He has extensive experience in commercial and residential property investment, development and management. His career in property includes time spent with Sanlam Properties, Metcash Trading, TAG Angola and the Johannesburg Housing Company. Carel has been the CEO of Indluplace since March 2016. |
|||
| Name | Terence Kaplan | |||
| Age | 45 | |||
| Business address | 2nd Floor, 158 Jan Smuts Building, 9 Walters Street, Rosebank, Johannesburg, 2196 |
|||
| Qualifications | BCom, BAcc, CA(SA) | |||
| Position | Financial director | |||
| Experience | Terry joined Indluplace as financial director in March 2016. Prior to this he was group finance executive at Massmart Holdings Limited. Terry previously worked for Redefine Properties Limited and lived and worked in the United Kingdom for eight years where he gained experience in both the banking and healthcare sectors. He began his career with Grant Thornton, where he qualified as a Chartered Accountant. |
| Name | Grant Harris | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| Age | 40 | ||
| Business address | 2nd Floor, 158 Jan Smuts Building, 9 Walters Street, Rosebank, Johannesburg, 2196 |
||
| Qualifications | – | ||
| Position | Chief Operating Officer | ||
| Experience | Grant joined Indluplace as Chief Operating Officer in July 2019. Prior to his appointment to Indluplace, Grant was the Managing Director of IHS Property Management, where he was responsible for the property management operations of multiple portfolios consisting of approximately 10 000 residential units. Prior to this, Grant was the CEO of Citiq, a privately held real estate investment business, focused on the affordable housing market, with assets under management in excess of two billion rand. Grant has more than 12 years of senior and executive management experience in property operations and asset management. |
||
| Name | Selwyn Noik | ||
| Age | 74 | ||
| Business address | 2nd Floor, 158 Jan Smuts Building, 9 Walters Street, Rosebank, Johannesburg, 2196 |
||
| Qualifications | CA(SA) | ||
| Position | Independent non-executive director | ||
| Experience | Selwyn is a Chartered Accountant. After qualifying, he spent 11 years in a managerial position with listed property company, Pioneer Holdings and Finance Corporation Limited. He was an executive director of the listed trade finance company Reichmans Limited for 10 years and after its acquisition by Investec Limited, he assumed the role of group secretary of Investec, a position he held for 13 years until his retirement in 2007. Thereafter he filled a company secretarial and compliance role with Investec Property until the end of 2011. He was a non-executive director of Arrowhead. |
||
| Name | Ayesha Rehman | ||
| Age | 71 | ||
| Business address | 2nd Floor, 158 Jan Smuts Building, 9 Walters Street, Rosebank, Johannesburg, 2196 |
||
| Qualifications | Diploma in Financial Accounting, Certificate in Management, Certificate in Project Management, Certificate in Property Development |
||
| Position | Lead independent non-executive director | ||
| Experience | Ayesha was the Chief Financial Officer of the Johannesburg Housing Company until her retirement in 2015, and prior to that she was an accountant at the Joint Education Trust. |
| Name | Clifford Laurence Abrams | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| Age | 52 | ||
| Business address | 138 Athol Street, Highlands North, Johannesburg | ||
| Qualifications | BCom, BAcc, CA(SA), Registered auditor | ||
| Position | Independent non-executive director | ||
| Experience | Clifford is a Chartered Accountant and has been in private practice for the past 17 years. He is proprietor of Clifford Abrams and Associates. He has held various positions in communal organisations and is Chairman of the Mizrachi Synagogue. |
||
| Name | Nindiphiwe Tetyana | ||
| Age | 40 | ||
| Business address | 2nd Floor, 158 Jan Smuts Building, 9 Walters Street, Rosebank, Johannesburg, 2196 |
||
| Qualifications | BCom, CA(SA) | ||
| Position | Independent non-executive director | ||
| Experience | Nindiphiwe has more than 17 years' experience in finance and auditing with expertise across a range of industries. She currently serves as the Financial Director of Lesedi and Letsatsi Power Projects. Prior to joining Lesedi and Letsatsi Power Projects in 2014, Nindiphiwe was a senior audit manager at Ernst and Young, Fund Chief Financial Officer at Brait and financial analyst at ABSA Retail Banking. She began her auditing and finance career at SNG Grant Thornton. |
||
| Name | Taffy Monty Adler – As per paragraph 2.1.2 above. |
All of the above Indluplace directors are South African nationals.
2.5 Asset management
- 2.5.1 Following the implementation of the Fairvest Manco Internalisation, New Star became a wholly-owned subsidiary of Fairvest and the services previously performed by New Star is now performed internally within Fairvest.
- 2.5.2 Following the implementation of the Scheme, in terms of which Fairvest will become a wholly owned subsidiary of Arrowhead, the property portfolio of the Combined Group will continue to be internally managed by a strongly incentivised, dedicated and proven executive management team, further details of which are set out in paragraphs 2.1 and 2.2 above.
2.6 Property management
- 2.6.1 Following the implementation of the Scheme, the day-to-day management of the Arrowhead property portfolio will continue to be outsourced to JHI on market-related terms in terms of the relevant property management agreements.
- 2.6.2 Following the implementation of the Scheme, the day-to-day management of the Fairvest property portfolio will continue to be outsourced to the property managers detailed in Annexure 6 on market-related terms and in terms of the relevant property management agreements.
- 2.6.3 Details of the property managers outlined above, and the function they perform set out in Annexure 6.
- 2.6.4 The property management agreements will lie open for inspection in accordance with paragraph 9 of Section 4.
2.7 Name and business address of Company Secretary
- 2.7.1 Vicki Turner will be appointed as Company Secretary of the Combined Group with effect from the Scheme Operative Date.
- 2.7.2 The business addresses of the Company Secretary is set out in the Corporate Information section.
- 2.7.3 The Arrowhead Board and the Fairvest Board have considered the competence, qualifications and experience of the Company Secretary and she is deemed fit to be appointed in the role as Company Secretary of the Combined Group.
2.7.4 The Company Secretary has the following qualifications: BA, LLB, LLM and PG Dip Cyber Law.
2.8 Name and business addresses of the auditors, attorneys and bankers
The names and business addresses of the auditors, attorney and bankers to Arrowhead are set out in the Corporate Information section.
3. HISTORY, STATE OF AFFAIRS AND PROSPECTS
3.1 History, state of affairs and nature of business of the Arrowhead Group
- 3.1.1 The Company, originally known as Synergy, was incorporated as a public company on 13 November 2007 as a registered property loan stock company and listed on the Main Board of the JSE under the "Real Estate–Real Estate Holdings and Development" sector on 14 December 2011. On listing, Synergy owned a portfolio of properties valued at R280 million. With effect from 1 July 2013, Synergy converted from a property loan stock company to a REIT and accordingly changed its sector classification to the "Retail REITs" sector on the JSE.
- 3.1.2 Synergy operated as a specialist retail property fund with a specific focus on medium-sized community and small regional shopping centres in high-growth nodes, serving South Africa's high-growth, lower-LSM retail sector. The Company's portfolio emphasis was on commuter-oriented centres located in township and rural areas.
- 3.1.3 On 27 July 2015, the authorised capital of Synergy converted from a linked unit capital structure to an all-share capital structure. The share capital of Synergy comprised "A" shares and "B" shares. The "A" shares have a preferential claim to earnings with capped growth, while the "B" shares receive the balance of the Company's earnings.
- 3.1.4 2015 brought about considerable changes to the Company and its business, with Vukile acquiring 65.0% of Synergy in the period to February of that year. This was followed in May 2015 by Vukile's acquisition of Synergy's property and asset manager, Capital Land Asset Management (subsequently renamed Vukile Asset Management ("VAM") and thereafter renamed "Gemgrow Asset Management"). In terms of the VAM asset management agreement, Vukile assumed effective day-to-day management of Synergy's portfolio of properties, with the property management function externally managed.
- 3.1.5 With effect from 1 October 2016, following the implementation of multiple simultaneous transactions, the Company changed its name from "Synergy Income Fund Limited" to "Gemgrow Properties Limited" and re-positioned itself as a specialist high-yielding, high-growth diversified REIT with a portfolio comprising retail, office and industrial assets. Gemgrow owned 163 properties across South Africa's nine provinces valued in excess of R5.6 billion as at 31 March 2019.
- 3.1.6 With effect from 9 October 2019, Gemgrow concluded a merger with Old Arrowhead, in terms of which Gemgrow acquired 100% of the issued shares of Old Arrowhead via a scheme of arrangement in terms of section 114(1) of the Companies Act, and in terms of which Gemgrow changed its name from "Gemgrow Properties Limited" to "Arrowhead Properties Limited".
3.2 General description of the business, strategy and prospects of the Arrowhead Group
- 3.2.1 Arrowhead is a diversified South African REIT listed on the JSE's Main Board focused on creating longterm shareholder value. The Company holds a diverse portfolio of office, retail and industrial properties. As at 30 September 2021, Arrowhead owned a direct property portfolio with an aggregate value of R8.3 billion comprising approximately 106 properties with a combined GLA of 941 691m2 spread across all nine provinces of South Africa. Retail assets accounted for 50% of income, office for 35% and industrial assets the remaining 15% respectively. By GLA the portfolio comprises 35% retail, 33% office and 32% industrial properties. As at 30 September 2021, Arrowhead held a 61% interest in Indluplace and an 8.6% interest in Dipula Income Fund Limited.
- 3.2.2 Arrowhead's strategic focus has shifted from sales to (i) strengthening its portfolio by retaining and enhancing those properties that meet its investment criteria; and (ii) enhancing the returns on those properties through a tenant centric approach that puts tenants at the heart of all property management decisions.
3.2.3 Prospects of the Arrowhead Group
Arrowhead has made significant progress over the past few years in delivering on its strategy of stabilising its portfolio and strengthening its balance sheet and the Company believes it is now well positioned to deliver sustainable income over the medium to long-term. The trade off in taking and implementing the decision to strengthen the balance sheet is that, in the current market, disposals typically dilute distributable income, and the full impact of this dilution will be felt in the upcoming financial year to end September 2022. This dilution is likely to be exacerbated by a number of factors including anticipated negative rental reversions in what remains a very difficult office market and a likely reduction in distributions from Dipula (as a consequence of either their recently announced proposed capital restructuring or the potential changes to the distribution policy highlighted in their recent results announcement).
3.2.4 Arrowhead Group structure
The group structure of Arrowhead prior to and post the implementation of the Transaction is set out in Annexure 1.
3.2.5 Financial year-end
Arrowhead's financial year-end is 30 September and will remain as such post implementation of the Transaction.
3.2.6 Major Subsidiaries
- 3.2.6.1 Arrowhead currently has, and will have, post the implementation of the Transaction, one Major Subsidiary as defined in the Listings Requirements, being Indluplace.
- 3.2.6.2 Indluplace is a proud South African property investor, owning a portfolio primarily focused on the affordable end of the rental residential market. The company was listed on the Main Board of the JSE in June 2015 and currently owns a portfolio of 9 199 residential units and 16 058 m² of associated retail space. The portfolio is valued at approximately R3,5 billion as at 30 September 2021, with properties situated mainly in Gauteng.
- 3.2.6.3 The name, registration number, place of incorporation, date of incorporation, nature of business, issued share capital and date of becoming a Subsidiary for each of the Subsidiaries of the Combined Group are set out in Annexure 2.
- 3.2.6.4 Other than as disclosed in Annexure 16, there are no material inter-company financial and other transactions.
3.3 History, state of affairs and nature of business of the Fairvest Group
- 3.3.1 Fairvest was incorporated on 17 March 1998 under the name Basfour 429 Proprietary Limited. The company converted to a public company and changed its name to Fairvest Property Holdings Limited on 13 December 2001. Fairvest is listed on the Main Board of the JSE in the "Real estate and Development" sector of the JSE and has been classified as a REIT since 1 July 2013. On 31 October 2019, Fairvest listed on the A2X as a secondary listing.
- 3.3.2 To align its capital structure with the REIT standard in South Africa and to comply with Listings Requirements for REITs, Fairvest converted its linked unit capital structure into an all-share capital structure during June 2015.
- 3.3.3 Fairvest's invests primarily in retail assets weighted toward non-metropolitan and rural shopping centres, as well as convenience and community shopping centres servicing the lower LSM market, in high-growth nodes, close to commuter networks.
- 3.3.4 Fairvest maintains a predominately retail portfolio across South Africa, with the four largest provinces, Gauteng, KwaZulu-Natal, Western Cape and Free State contributing 75.4% of the revenue. The properties are predominately blue-chip tenanted, grocery-anchored shopping centres. The high national tenant component of 73.1% of the portfolio provides shareholders with a low-risk investment profile with national food retailers occupying 35.3% of the portfolio in terms of GLA.
- 3.3.5 To date, yield accretive acquisitions have been part of Fairvest's strategy with a focus on quality retail assets with sustainable income streams in order to extract maximum value, whilst disposals have been
in line with the company's focus on value extraction and maintaining a focus on retail assets in favour of non-metropolitan areas and the lower LSM market.
- 3.3.6 During the nationwide lockdown due to the COVID-19 pandemic, Fairvest's strategy was to focus on its cash flow planning and liquidity management, whilst finding sustainable solutions for tenants who were adversely impacted by COVID-19. Fairvest remained cash flow positive throughout the lockdown period and continues to generate positive cash flows. Fairvest was able to fund all operational expenditure and interest payments from cash flows without having to utilise undrawn debt facilities.
- 3.3.7 During May 2021, Fairvest concluded the Fairvest Acquisition Agreements, further details of which are contained in Annexure 9. As further detailed in Section 2, paragraph 1.1, the Transaction is intended to be undertaken as an alternative to the Fairvest Acquisition, however if the Transaction does not succeed for any reason, the Fairvest Acquisition will be implemented.
- 3.3.8 The Fairvest Board approved and declared a final gross dividend of 11.473 cents per Fairvest Share for the year ended 30 June 2021, which was paid to Fairvest Shareholders on Friday, 11 October 2021, from income.
- 3.3.9 Fairvest does not have any Major Subsidiaries as defined in the Listings Requirements.
- 3.3.10 As at the Last Practicable Date, Fairvest does not have a controlling shareholder and has not had a controlling shareholder in the past five years. Post implementation of the Transaction, Arrowhead will become the controlling shareholder of Fairvest.
3.4 General description of the business of the Fairvest Group
Fairvest is a South African REIT listed on the JSE's Main Board and the A2X with a focus on retail assets weighted toward non-metropolitan and rural shopping centres, as well as convenience and community shopping centres servicing the lower LSM market, in high-growth nodes, close to commuter networks. It has a property portfolio of 43 properties across South Africa, with 250 896m² of GLA and valued at R3.44 billion. The portfolio is predominantly focused in the retail sector (c. 95%), with selective exposure to office properties (c.5%) by both rentable area and income. Fairvest is well diversified across the main provinces of South Africa, with a regional income split of KwaZulu-Natal (21.9%), Western Cape (18.9%), Gauteng (23.1%), Free State (11.8%), Northern Cape (8.7%), Limpopo (4.7%), Eastern Cape (8.5%) and Mpumalanga (2.4%).
3.5 Prospects of the Fairvest Group
The uncertain global macro-outlook and the uncertainty around the lasting impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on the South African economy, coupled with record local unemployment, will likely result in muted economic growth in the short-to-medium term. The vaccine rollout in South Africa has gained traction over the past few months, however further waves of infections could continue, with trading restrictions for certain tenants being a possibility. Fairvest however remains well positioned, with a clearly focused strategy of mainly investing in grocery anchored assets, servicing non-metropolitan and lower-LSM markets. These assets proved more resilient during the COVID-19 pandemic with the recovery being quicker than anticipated, without significant increases in vacancies.
3.6 Strategy and prospects of the Combined Group
- 3.6.1 The Combined Group's investment strategy is to create a portfolio of significant critical mass predominately comprising convenience, community, and regional shopping centres, as well as standalone retail stores that service the lower LSM markets.
- 3.6.2 Assets within this sub-sector, managed by an experienced team, have proven to be defensive during poor macroeconomic conditions and have a long-term positive growth outlook.
- 3.6.3 In order to achieve its strategic objectives, the Combined Group, within the constraints of disciplined, conservative financial management will:
- 3.6.3.1 continue to recycle capital generated from sales of both non-core assets and mature core assets into acquisitions of assets within its specialist sub-sector; and
- 3.6.3.2 explore avenues to create greater scale, as well as improved liquidity of its shares, including by M&A activity in order to drive consolidation within the South African REIT sector, which may increase the holding of non-core assets pending restructuring and disposals.
4. CORPORATE GOVERNANCE
- 4.1 Given that the Transaction is Fairvest-led, and that the proposed executive directors, the majority of the proposed non-executive directors and the majority of the members of the board committees of the Combined Group will comprise existing Fairvest directors, the corporate governance report as contained in the integrated annual report of Fairvest in respect of the year ended 30 June 2021 forms the basis of the corporate governance statement of the Combined Group post implementation of the Transaction.
- 4.2 Should the Transaction be successful, updates or amendments, if any, to the corporate governance statement in respect of the Combined Group will be contained in the integrated annual report of the Combined Group in respect of the year ending 30 September 2022.
- 4.3 Extracts of the Combined Group's corporate governance statement is contained in Annexure 19.
5. MATERIAL CHANGES
Regarding Arrowhead, save for the Transaction, the Gemgrow Arrowhead Merger and the Synergy Transaction:
- 5.1 there have been no material changes to the financial or trading position of the Arrowhead Group since Arrowhead published its reviewed condensed consolidated results for the year ended 30 September 2021 and the Last Practicable Date;
- 5.2 there has been no change in the business or trading objects of Arrowhead during the past five years;
- 5.3 there has been no major change in the nature of property, plant and equipment and in the policy regarding the use thereof;
- 5.4 there has been no material change in the nature of the business of Arrowhead; and
- 5.5 there has been no material fact or circumstance that has occurred between 30 September 2021, being the last financial year-end and the Last Practicable Date, other than as disclosed in these Revised Listing Particulars.
Regarding Fairvest, save for the Transaction, Fairvest Manco Internalisation and the impact that the recent civil unrest and protest action during July 2021 has had on Fairvest's portfolio as further detailed in the Fairvest Circular:
- 5.6 there have been no material changes to the financial or trading position of the Fairvest Group since the published audited results for the year ended 30 June 2021 and the Last Practicable Date;
- 5.7 there has been no change in the business or trading objects of Fairvest during the past five years;
- 5.8 there has been no material change in the nature of the business of Fairvest; and
- 5.9 there has been no material fact or circumstance that has occurred between 30 June 2021, being the financial year ended, and the Last Practicable Date, other than as disclosed in these Revised Listing Particulars.
6. PROPERTY PORTFOLIO OF THE COMBINED GROUP
Set out below is a summary of the property portfolio and listed property securities of the Combined Group, post implementation of the Transaction.
6.1 Analysis of the Combined Group's property portfolio
An analysis of the Combined Group's property portfolio as at 30 September 2021 (in respect of the Arrowhead property portfolio) and as at 30 June 2021 (in respect of the Fairvest property portfolio) in relation to the geographic, sectoral and tenant spread as well as the vacancy and lease expiry profile is provided in the tables below:
6.1.1 Geographic profile
| Based on GLA (%) | Based on revenue (%) | |
|---|---|---|
| Gauteng | 51 | 36 |
| Free State | 3 | 4 |
| North West | 4 | 6 |
| Mpumalanga | 1 | 2 |
| Limpopo | 7 | 6 |
| Based on GLA (%) | Based on revenue (%) | |
|---|---|---|
| Eastern Cape | 7 | 10 |
| KwaZulu-Natal | 11 | 13 |
| Western Cape | 13 | 19 |
| Northern Cape | 3 | 4 |
| Total | 100 | 100 |
6.1.2 Sectoral profile
| Based on GLA (%) |
Based on revenue (%) |
Vacancy by GLA (%) |
Weighted average rental (R/m²) |
Weighted average rental escalation (%) |
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Retail | 48 | 64 | 4.7 | 133 | 7.0 |
| Office | 27 | 25 | 14.6 | 120 | 6.5 |
| Industrial | 25 | 11 | 4.5 | 43 | 7.1 |
| Portfolio | 100 | 100 | 7.4 | 107 | 6.9 |
6.1.3 Tenant profile
| % | |
|---|---|
| A Grade | 52 |
| B Grade | 12 |
| C Grade | 36 |
| Total | 100 |
For the table above, the following key is applicable:
A. Large national tenants, large listed tenants, government and major franchisees.
B. National tenants, listed tenants, franchisees, medium to large professional firms.
C. Other comprising of smaller SME's and startup companies' tenants.
6.1.4 Lease expiry profile
| By GLA (%) | Portfolio | Office | Retail | Industrial |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Vacant | 7 | 15 | 5 | 4 |
| Monthly | 5 | 4 | 6 | 4 |
| 2022 | 22 | 27 | 20 | 22 |
| 2023 | 24 | 26 | 22 | 26 |
| 2024 | 18 | 14 | 14 | 27 |
| 2025 | 8 | 6 | 11 | 5 |
| 2026 and beyond | 16 | 8 | 22 | 12 |
| Total | 100 | 100 | 100 | 100 |
| By gross rental (%) | ||||
| Vacant | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| Monthly | 4 | 4 | 4 | 4 |
| 2022 | 25 | 31 | 22 | 24 |
| 2023 | 26 | 34 | 23 | 29 |
| 2024 | 18 | 17 | 17 | 26 |
| 2025 | 10 | 7 | 12 | 4 |
| 2026 and beyond | 17 | 7 | 22 | 13 |
| Total | 100 | 100 | 100 | 100 |
6.2 Property yield
The average annualised property yield for the Combined Group's property portfolio is 9.5%.
6.3 Valuation of the Combined Group's direct property portfolio
- 6.3.1 Annexure 8 contains the property schedules and valuations in relation to each and every individual property within the Arrowhead Group's direct property portfolio, as extracted from Arrowhead's reviewed condensed consolidated results in respect of the year ended 30 September 2021.
- 6.3.2 The Fairvest Group's direct property portfolio was valued by Broll, De Leeuw Valuers and DPP, independent external professional property valuers registered in terms of Section 19 of the Property Valuers Professional Act (Act No. 47 of 2000). Detailed valuation reports have been prepared in respect of each of the properties within the Fairvest Group's direct property portfolio and are available for inspection as per paragraph 9 of Section 4. A summary of the detailed valuation reports, including property schedules and valuations in relation to each and every individual property within the Fairvest Group's direct property portfolio has been included in Annexure 7.
- 6.3.3 The Arrowhead Group's direct property portfolio was valued at R8.3 billion as at 30 September 2021, and the aggregate valuations prepared by the Independent Property Valuers has valued the entire Fairvest Group's direct property portfolio at R3.4 billion, resulting in a combined value of R11.7 billion in respect of the Combined Group's property portfolio:
| June 2021 (R'000) |
September 2021 (R'000) |
Total (R'000) |
|
|---|---|---|---|
| Arrowhead | – | 8 288 255 | 8 288 255 |
| Broll valuation | 366 900 | 404 800 | 771 700 |
| DDP valuation | 327 900 | 933 900 | 1 261 800 |
| De Leeuw valuation | 537 000 | 868 300 | 1 405 300 |
| Total | 11 727 055 |
6.4 Listed property securities
In addition, the Combined Group will have interests in the following listed property securities as at the Last Practicable Date:
| Number of shares | Market value (R'000) |
% held |
|
|---|---|---|---|
| Indluplace ordinary shares | 191 581 362 | 639 882 | 61.0 |
| Dipula B shares | 45 581 239 | 222 436 | 8.6 |
6.5 Material commitments, lease payments and contingent liabilities
Neither Arrowhead nor Fairvest have any estimated material commitments, lease payments or contingent liabilities as at the Last Practicable Date.
7. SHARE CAPITAL OF THE COMBINED GROUP
7.1 The authorised and issued share capital of Arrowhead as at the Last Practicable Date, before the Transaction is set out below:
| R'000 | |
|---|---|
| Authorised share capital | |
| 1 000 000 000 AHA Shares | – |
| 2 000 000 000 AHB Shares | – |
| Issued share capital | |
| 62 718 658 AHA Shares | 556 731 |
| 951 422 029 AHB Shares | 6 604 137 |
| Stated capital | 7 160 868 |
| 655 032 AHB Shares held in treasury |
7.2 The authorised and issued share capital of Arrowhead after the Transaction, in other words, of the Combined Group is set out below:
| R'000 | |
|---|---|
| Authorised share capital | |
| 1 000 000 000 AHA Shares | – |
| 2 000 000 000 AHB Shares | – |
| Issued share capital | |
| 62 781 658 AHA Shares | 556 731 |
| 1 496 467 154 AHB Shares | 4 672 230 |
| Stated capital | 5 228 961 |
10 973 096 AHB Shares held in treasury¹
Note:
- Calculated as 655 032 treasury shares plus 10 318 064 AHB Shares held by Fairvest as at the Last Practicable Date, which will become treasury shares post implementation of the Transaction.
7.3 The authorised and issued share capital of Fairvest as at the Last Practicable Date is set out below:
| R'000 | |
|---|---|
| Authorised share capital 6 000 000 000 Fairvest Shares |
– |
| Issued share capital 1 046 421 089 Fairvest Shares |
788 651 |
| Stated capital | 788 651 |
| 38 086 599 Fairvest Shares held in treasury | – |
7.4 Annexure 15 contains the following salient information relating to the authorised and issued share capital of Arrowhead and Fairvest:
- 7.4.1 authorisations;
- 7.4.2 voting rights;
- 7.4.3 rights attaching to shares;
- 7.4.4 alterations to authorised share capital during the preceding three years;
- 7.4.5 options and preferential rights in respect of shares; and
- 7.4.6 issues and repurchases of shares in the preceding three years.
7.5 Issues of Shares
- 7.5.1 There have been no issues or offers of AHA Shares and/or AHB Shares or of shares in Major Subsidiaries of Arrowhead in the three years preceding the Last Practicable Date other than as set out in Annexure 15.
- 7.5.2 There have been no issues or offers of Fairvest Shares or of shares in Major Subsidiaries of Fairvest in the three years preceding the Last Practicable Date other than as set out in Annexure 15.
7.6 Major and controlling Arrowhead Shareholders
7.6.1 Set out below are the names of Arrowhead Shareholders, other than the directors of Arrowhead, who, directly or indirectly, are beneficially interested in 5% or more of the issued AHA Shares as at the Last Practicable Date:
| AHA Shareholder | Direct beneficial AHA Shares held |
Indirect beneficial AHA Shares held |
Total AHA Shares held |
% of total AHA Shares1 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 36One Asset Management Proprietary Limited | 7 809 753 | 2 092 626 | 9 902 379 | 15.79 |
| Catalyst Fund Managers SA Proprietary Limited | – | 5 669 691 | 5 669 691 | 9.04 |
| Old Mutual Group | – | 3 222 388 | 3 222 388 | 5.14 |
| Total | 7 809 753 10 984 705 18 794 458 | 29.97 |
Note:
- Based on 62 718 658 AHA Shares in issue (net of treasury shares) as at the Last Practicable Date.
7.6.2 Set out below are the names of Arrowhead Shareholders, other than the directors of Arrowhead, who, directly or indirectly, are beneficially interested in 5% or more of the issued AHB Shares as at the Last Practicable Date:
| AHB Shareholder | Direct beneficial AHB Shares held |
Indirect beneficial AHB Shares held |
Total AHB Shares held |
% of total AHB Shares1 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 36One Asset Management | ||||
| Proprietary Limited | 90 341 882 | 49 475 538 | 139 817 420 | 14.71 |
| Vukile Property Fund Limited | 114 438 564 | – | 114 438 564 | 12.04 |
| Catalyst Fund Managers SA | ||||
| Proprietary Limited | – | 94 456 571 | 94 456 571 | 9.93 |
| Visio Fund Management | ||||
| Proprietary Limited | – | 81 817 528 | 81 817 528 | 8.61 |
| Old Mutual Group | – | 79 050 216 | 79 050 216 | 8.31 |
| Total | 204 780 446 | 304 799 853 | 509 580 299 | 53.60 |
Note:
-
Based on 950 766 997 AHB Shares in issue (calculated as 951 422 029 less 655 032 treasury shares) as at the Last Practicable Date.
-
7.6.3 There will be no change in the holdings of AHA Shareholders, other than the directors of Arrowhead, who, directly or indirectly, are expected to be beneficially interested in 5% or more of the issued AHA Shares post the implementation of the Transaction.
- 7.6.4 Set out below are the names of Arrowhead Shareholders, other than the directors of Arrowhead, who, directly or indirectly, are expected to be beneficially interested in 5% or more of the issued AHB Shares post the implementation of the Transaction:
| AHB Shareholder | Direct beneficial AHB Shares held |
Indirect beneficial AHB Shares held |
Total AHB Shares held |
% of total AHB Shares¹ |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Vukile Property Fund Limited | 190 323 856 | – | 190 323 856 | 12.81 |
| 36One Asset Management Proprietary Limited |
92 847 902 | 50 491 669 | 143 339 571 | 9.65 |
| Catalyst Fund Managers SA Proprietary Limited |
– | 114 324 069 | 114 324 069 | 7.70 |
| Visio Fund Management Proprietary Limited |
– | 109 135 405 | 109 135 405 | 7.35 |
| AHB Shareholder | Direct beneficial AHB Shares held |
Indirect beneficial AHB Shares held |
Total AHB Shares held |
% of total AHB Shares¹ |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Counterpoint Asset Management | ||||
| Proprietary Limited | – | 85 274 620 | 85 274 620 | 5.74 |
| Old Mutual Group | – | 79 050 216 | 79 050 216 | 5.32 |
| Total | 283 171 758 | 438 275 979 | 721 447 737 | 48.57 |
Note:
- Based on 1 485 494 058 AHB Shares in issue (calculated as 1 496 467 154 less 655 032 treasury shares and 10 318 064 AHB Shares acquired by Fairvest which will become treasury shares) post implementation of the Transaction.
7.6.5 Save as set out below, there has been no material change in controlling Arrowhead Shareholders over the last five years:
- 7.6.5.1 Prior implementation of the Synergy Transaction, which was undertaken in 2016, Vukile Property Fund Limited was a controlling shareholder in Synergy, holding 61.96% of its issued share capital at the time. Post implementation of the Synergy Transaction, Old Arrowhead became a controlling shareholder in Synergy, holding 55.22% of its issued share capital, and which resulted in Synergy changing its name from "Synergy Income Fund Limited" to "Gemgrow Properties Limited".
- 7.6.5.2 Prior to the Gemgrow Arrowhead Merger which was undertaken during 2019, Old Arrowhead held 61.5% of the total issued share capital of Gemgrow. In terms of the Gemgrow Arrowhead Merger, Gemgrow acquired, by way of scheme of arrangement in terms of section 114(1) of the Companies Act, the entire issued share capital of Old Arrowhead but as at the Last Practicable Date, excluding 0.3% of the issued shares in Old Arrowhead still held by dissenting shareholders who exercise appraisal rights in terms of section 164 of the Companies Act. Post the Gemgrow Arrowhead Merger, Old Arrowhead became a 99.7% held subsidiary of Gemgrow, and which resulted in Old Arrowhead's name being changed from "Arrowhead Properties Limited" to "Arrowgem Limited". The Gemgrow Arrowhead Merger further resulted in Gemgrow no longer having a controlling shareholder, and in Gemgrow changing its name from "Gemgrow Properties Limited" to "Arrowhead Properties Limited".
- 7.6.6 The Transaction will not result in the Combined Group having a controlling shareholder.
8. OPTIONS OR PREFERENTIAL RIGHTS IN RESPECT OF ARROWHEAD SHARES
Other than as disclosed in Annexure 3, there are no options or preferential rights to subscribe for Arrowhead Shares which are capable of being exercised at the Last Practicable Date.
9. COMMISSIONS PAID OR PAYABLE
In relation to Arrowhead:
- 9.1 No amounts have been paid, or accrued as payable, within the three years preceding the Last Practicable Date as commission to any person, including commission paid or payable to any sub-underwriter or a promoter or director or officer of the Arrowhead Group, for subscribing or agreeing to subscribe, or procuring, or agreeing to procure, subscriptions for any Arrowhead securities.
- 9.2 No commissions, discounts or brokerages have been paid nor have any other special terms been granted in connection with the issue or sale of any Arrowhead Shares in the capital of the Company in the three years preceding the Last Practicable date.
- 9.3 The Arrowhead Group is not subject to any royalty agreements and no royalties are payable by the Arrowhead Group.
- 9.4 Save for the property management agreements referred to in paragraph 2.6, Section 1, the Arrowhead Group is not subject to any other management agreements.
In relation to Fairvest:
9.5 No amounts have been paid, or accrued as payable, within the three years preceding the Last Practicable Date as commission to any person, including commission paid or payable to any sub-underwriter or a promoter or director or officer of the Fairvest Group, for subscribing or agreeing to subscribe, or procuring, or agreeing to procure, subscriptions for any Fairvest securities.
- 9.6 No commissions, discounts or brokerages have been paid nor have any other special terms been granted in connection with the issue or sale of any Fairvest Shares in the capital of the Fairvest in the three years preceding the Last Practicable date.
- 9.7 The Fairvest Group is not subject to any royalty agreements and no royalties are payable by the Fairvest Group.
- 9.8 Save for the property management agreements referred to in paragraph 2.6, Section 1, the Fairvest Group is not subject to any other management agreements.
10. MATERIAL CONTRACTS
- 10.1 In respect of Arrowhead, save for:
- 10.1.1 the Implementation Agreement, the salient features of which are set out in Section 2, paragraph 3;
- 10.1.2 the undertakings of support received from Arrowhead and Fairvest Shareholders in relation to the Transaction referred to in Section 2 paragraph 3.7;
- 10.1.3 the acquisitions and disposals of assets by Arrowhead, details of which are set out in Annexure 9; and
- 10.1.4 the agreements in respect of material borrowings and loans receivable detailed in Annexure 16; and
- 10.2 In respect of Fairvest, save for:
- 10.2.1 the Implementation Agreement, the salient features of which are set out in Section 2, paragraph 3;
- 10.2.2 the undertakings of support received from Arrowhead and Fairvest Shareholders in relation to the Transaction referred to in Section 2 paragraph 3.7;
- 10.2.3 the Fairvest Manco Internalisation Agreement, details of which are set out in Annexure 9;
- 10.2.4 the Fairvest Acquisition Agreements;
- 10.2.5 the acquisitions and disposals of assets by Fairvest, details of which are set out in Annexure 9; and
- 10.2.6 the agreements in respect of material borrowings and loans receivable detailed in Annexure 16.
- 10.3 the Combined Group has not entered into any material contract, being restrictive funding arrangements and/or contracts entered into otherwise than in the ordinary course of business, within the two years prior to the Last Practicable Date or at any time containing an obligation or settlement that is material to the Combined Group at the Last Practicable Date.
- 10.4 In respect of the property management agreements referred to in Annexure 6 and the loan agreements as set out in Annexure 16 are contracts that are entered into in the ordinary course of business and are material to the Combined Group.
11. INTERESTS OF DIRECTORS AND PROMOTERS
Details of the directors' and promoters' interests in Arrowhead are set out in Annexure 3.
12. MATERIAL BORROWINGS AND LOANS RECEIVABLE
Save as set out in Annexure 16, which contains details of material borrowings advanced to the Arrowhead Group and the Fairvest Group, material loans receivable by the Arrowhead Group and the Fairvest Group, and loans granted by the Arrowhead Group and the Fairvest Group for the benefit of a director, manager or Associate of any director or manager of Arrowhead or Fairvest:
- 12.1 none of the material borrowings listed in Annexure 16 have any redemption or conversion rights attaching to them;
- 12.2 the Combined Group has no loan capital outstanding;
- 12.3 the Combined Group has no debentures outstanding;
- 12.4 the Combined Group has not entered into any other material inter-company loans;
-
12.5 as at the Last Practicable date, Arrowhead and Fairvest have not undertaken any off-balance sheet financing;
-
12.6 Arrowhead and Fairvest have not entered into any other loan arrangements; and
- 12.7 save for as set out above and as at the Last Practicable Date, no loans have been made or security furnished by the Arrowhead Group or the Fairvest Group for the benefit of any director, manager or associate of any director or manager of Arrowhead or Fairvest.
13. SHARES ISSUED OR TO BE ISSUED OTHER THAN FOR CASH
There are no securities that were issued or agreed to be issued by Arrowhead or Fairvest, or a Subsidiary of Arrowhead or Fairvest, within the three years immediately before the Last Practicable Date, to any person other than for cash other than as set out in Annexure 15.
14. PROPERTY AND BUSINESS UNDERTAKINGS
14.1 Properties and business undertakings acquired or to be acquired
- 14.1.1 Details of material immovable properties, fixed assets and/or business undertakings acquired by the Arrowhead Group and the Fairvest Group within the three years preceding the Last Practicable Date are set out in Annexure 9.
- 14.1.2 Save as set out in Annexure 9 and in respect of the Transaction, no material immovable properties, fixed assets and/or business undertakings are in the process of being or are proposed to be acquired by the Arrowhead Group or the Fairvest Group (or which the either group has an option to acquire).
14.2 Properties and business undertakings disposed of or to be disposed of
- 14.2.1 Details of material immovable properties, fixed assets and/or business undertakings that have been disposed of by the Arrowhead Group and the Fairvest Group within the three years preceding the Last Practicable Date, are set out in Annexure 9.
- 14.2.2 Save as set out in Annexure 9, no material immovable properties, fixed assets and/or business undertakings have been disposed of by the Arrowhead Group or the Fairvest Group in the three years preceding the Last Practicable Date.
15. AMOUNTS PAID OR PAYABLE TO PROMOTERS
No cash or securities have been paid or any benefit given by either Arrowhead or Fairvest within the three years preceding these Revised Listing Particulars is proposed to be paid or given to any promoter of either company.
16. PRELIMINARY EXPENSES AND ISSUE EXPENSES
16.1 The preliminary expenses and issue expenses (exclusive of VAT) incurred by the Arrowhead Group within 3 (three) years prior to the Last Practicable Date or that are expected to be incurred are presented in the table below:
| Arrowhead | Payable to | Rand ('000) |
|---|---|---|
| Joint Corporate Advisor and Transaction Sponsor fees Nedbank | 9 500 | |
| Strategic Advisor fees | Ferryman Capital Partners | 9 000 |
| Competition Commission filing and legal fees | CDH | 1 937 |
| Independent Reporting Accountants fees | BDO | 1 162 |
| Independent Property Valuers fees | Broll | 127 |
| Independent Property Valuers fees | De Leeuw Valuers | 158 |
| Independent Property Valuers fees | DDP | 222 |
| Competition Commission filing fee | Competition Commission | 275 |
| JSE documentation and rulings | JSE | 146 |
| JSE listing fee | JSE | 478 |
| Printing and related costs | INCE | 429 |
| Sundry costs | – | 100 |
| Total | 23 534 |
- 16.2 In respect of the Gemgrow Arrowhead Merger, the Company incurred expenses of R25.89 million (exclusive of VAT).
- 16.3 The following cumulative preliminary and issue expenses (exclusive of VAT) have already been, or are expected to be payable by Fairvest in connection with the Transaction and the Fairvest Acquisition is presented in the table below:
| Fairvest | Payable to | Rand ('000) |
|---|---|---|
| Corporate adviser fees | Java Capital Proprietary Limited | 28 700 |
| Transaction sponsor fees | Java Capital Trustees and Sponsors Proprietary Limited | 2 550 |
| Competition Commission filing | ||
| and legal fees | Werksmans Incorporated | 2 000 |
| Independent Reporting Accountants fees BDO | 660 | |
| Independent expert fees in respect | ||
| of the Scheme | Mazars Corporate Finance Proprietary Limited | 1 100 |
| TRP documentation fees | TRP | 200 |
| JSE documentation fees | JSE | 150 |
| Competition Commission filing fee | Competition Commission | 275 |
| Printing and other costs | INCE | 220 |
| Sundry costs | – | 100 |
| Total | 35 955 |
17. PERCEIVED CONFLICTS OF INTEREST
In terms of paragraph IV of the Appendix to Schedule 16 contained in the Listings Requirements, a sponsor is required to disclose details of all matters that might reasonably be expected to impair its independence and objectivity in its professional dealings with Arrowhead:
- 17.1 Nedbank has been appointed as Arrowhead's Transaction Sponsor ("Nedbank Sponsor") in relation to the Transaction. Nedbank Sponsor's key responsibilities include the drafting of the Circular and these Revised Listing Particulars, obtaining the JSE's approval of the Circular and these Revised Listing Particulars and the release of related announcements.
- 17.2 Nedbank Sponsor confirms that acting in its capacity as Transaction Sponsor to Arrowhead in respect of the Transaction does not affect Nedbank Sponsor's independence to Arrowhead. Nedbank Sponsor does not have a vested interest in the successful implementation of the Transaction, other than the agreed fee charged for the preparation of the Circular, these Revised Listing Particulars and ancillary documentation. This fee is not impacted by the success or otherwise of the Transaction.
- 17.3 Nedbank Sponsor confirms that the following matters may be perceived to influence its independence in relation to its role as Transaction Sponsor to Arrowhead in connection with the Transaction: (i) Nedbank Sponsor's continuing obligations sub-business unit ("Nedbank Continuing Obligations") fulfils the role of the Company's ongoing JSE sponsor; (ii) Nedbank's Corporate Finance Advisory business unit ("Nedbank Advisory") has been appointed as Joint Corporate Advisor in respect of the Transaction and (iii) currently, Arrowhead has funding with Nedbank's Property Finance division ("Nedbank Property Finance"), which funding is immaterial in relation to Nedbank's total advances to clients.
- 17.4 The following procedures are in place in order to ensure Nedbank Sponsor exercises reasonable care and judgement to achieve independence and objectivity in its professional dealings in relation to Arrowhead: Nedbank Sponsor, Nedbank Continuing Obligations, Nedbank Advisory and Nedbank Property Finance are separate and distinct business units within Nedbank, and Nedbank, as a strictly regulated entity, has significant compliance procedures in place to ensure that the activities of Nedbank Sponsor, Nedbank Continuing Obligations, Nedbank Advisory and Nedbank Property Finance are monitored and that effective Chinese Walls are in place between these divisions.
SECTION 2 – INFORMATION ABOUT THE OFFERED SECURITIES
1. PURPOSE OF THE SCHEME
1.1 Introduction
- 1.1.1 In the Joint Firm Intention Announcement, Arrowhead and Fairvest Shareholders were referred to the cautionary announcements released by Arrowhead and Fairvest on SENS, the latest being on 9 September 2021 and 17 September 2021, respectively, and the SENS announcement released by Fairvest on 7 September 2021. In those announcements Fairvest and Arrowhead Shareholders were advised that:
- (i) at the general meeting of Fairvest Shareholders held on Tuesday, 7 September 2021, all the resolutions required to be passed by Fairvest Shareholders in order to authorise and approve, inter alia, (i) the Fairvest Acquisition and (ii) the Fairvest Manco Internalisation were passed by the requisite majority of Fairvest Shareholders; and
- (ii) as an alternative to the Fairvest Acquisition, Arrowhead and Fairvest were engaging regarding the possibility of a single-step merger. In line with what was communicated in the Fairvest Circular, if Arrowhead and Fairvest agree on the terms of a merger, they would work together on the appropriate process to obtain the required approvals. However, a merger may succeed or fail and accordingly, Fairvest proceeded to seek Fairvest Shareholder approval for, inter alia, the Fairvest Acquisition but will only implement this transaction, once unconditional, if a merger does not succeed for any reason.
- 1.1.2 Although the Transaction remains Fairvest-led, the Parties have, for structural reasons, agreed that it would be preferable for Arrowhead to be the acquiror of Fairvest. Accordingly, in the Joint Firm Intention Announcement, Arrowhead and Fairvest Shareholders were advised that Fairvest and Arrowhead had concluded the Implementation Agreement, in terms of which Arrowhead has offered to acquire the Scheme Shares from Scheme Participants, to be effected by way of a Scheme, to be proposed by the Fairvest Board, on recommendation of the Fairvest Independent Board, to Fairvest Shareholders, and to which Arrowhead is a party.
- 1.1.3 As consideration for the Scheme Shares acquired in terms of the Scheme, Arrowhead shall issue to the Scheme Participants the Scheme Consideration Shares, which consideration has been calculated based on the Share Swap Ratio, which ratio is the inverse of the ratio that was previously agreed by Fairvest with certain of the AHB Shareholders in terms of the Fairvest Acquisition Agreements.
- 1.1.4 The Scheme is conditional upon the fulfilment or waiver (where appropriate) of the Conditions Precedent set out in paragraph 3.6 below. For the Scheme to be implemented, at least 75% of the votes cast by Fairvest Shareholders in respect of the Scheme Resolution need to be in favour of the Scheme.
- 1.1.5 Following the implementation of the Scheme, Fairvest will become a wholly owned subsidiary of Arrowhead and the listing of all the Fairvest Shares on the Main Board of the JSE and A2X will be terminated. Arrowhead shall remain listed on the Main Board of the JSE and subject to the necessary shareholder approval, will change its name to "Fairvest Limited".
- 1.1.6 In the event that the Transaction is not approved by Arrowhead and/or Fairvest Shareholders, or does not proceed for any other reason, Fairvest will proceed to implement the Fairvest Acquisition. Fairvest has, therefore, proceeded to obtain Fairvest Shareholder approval in respect of, inter alia, the Fairvest Acquisition including the authority to acquire further AHB Shares and AHA Shares as may be required in respect of the Mandatory Offer and Comparable Offer that would be triggered as a result of the implementation of the Fairvest Acquisition.
1.2 Rationale for the Transaction
1.2.1 The Transaction was agreed to between Fairvest and Arrowhead as an alternative to the implementation of the Fairvest Acquisition approved by Fairvest Shareholders on Tuesday, 7 September 2021.
- 1.2.2 The Transaction is expected to unlock value for shareholders of both Arrowhead and Fairvest and is an initiative that has been widely supported by shareholders of both companies. Investors generally favour larger REITs in which their investment is liquid. In addition, key shareholders have expressed confidence in Fairvest's ability to unlock value both operationally and through capital allocation within its traditional low-income retail focus as well as from other sub-classes of investment property.
- 1.2.3 The implementation of the Transaction will accelerate the new management team's access to the combined portfolio and brings forward the ability to realise operational cost savings, as well as cost savings attributable to a single listing, a single board of directors, and a reduced number of executives across the two businesses.
- 1.2.4 Both Fairvest and Arrowhead's property portfolios are exclusively focused within South Africa and the Combined Group will be the largest listed exclusively South African focused REIT.
2. TIMES AND DATES
| 2021/2022 | |
|---|---|
| Date on which the offer contemplated in these Revised Listing Particulars will be open is the same date on which the Scheme Circular is posted to Fairvest Shareholders |
19 November 2021 |
| Date on which offer contemplated in these Revised Listing Particulars will close is the Scheme | 28 January 2022 |
| Consideration Record Date Listing date of the Scheme Consideration Shares |
31 January 2022 |
3. PARTICULARS OF THE SCHEME
3.1 Scheme Consideration
Arrowhead shall issue the Scheme Consideration Shares to the Scheme Participants as consideration for each Scheme Share acquired.
3.2 Treatment of fractions
If the aggregate number of Scheme Consideration Shares to be issued to a Scheme Participant under the Scheme Consideration yields a decimal result, then the number of Scheme Consideration Shares to be issued to such Scheme Participant shall be rounded down to the nearest whole AHB Share, and the resultant fraction shall be cash settled. The quantum of the applicable cash payment in respect of the fractional entitlement will be determined with reference to the VWAP of an AHB Share as at the trading day immediately succeeding the Scheme Consideration Record Date, discounted by 10%.
3.3 Provisions of the Clean-out Distributions
- 3.3.1 The intention of the Parties is for the Scheme, should it become operative in accordance with its terms, to have commercial effect as from the Commercial Effective Date, to give commercial effect to this intention:
- (i) the Scheme Consideration Shares will be issued on the basis that Scheme Participants will not in respect of their Scheme Consideration Shares participate in the distributable income of Arrowhead in respect of Arrowhead's Pre-Transaction Financial Period, but will be entitled to participate in Arrowhead's distributable income for the period commencing on the Commercial Effective Date; and
- (ii) the Scheme Shares will be acquired by Arrowhead on the basis that Arrowhead will not participate in the distributable income of Fairvest in respect of Fairvest's Pre-Transaction Financial Period but will be entitled to participate in Fairvest's distributable income for the period commencing on the Commercial Effective Date.
-
3.3.2 Accordingly, in terms of the Implementation Agreement the Parties have agreed that each of Arrowhead and Fairvest shall effect a Clean-out Distribution by way of a cash distribution of all its distributable income for the applicable Pre-Transaction Financial Period.
-
3.3.3 The Clean-out Distributions shall be effected on the basis that:
- 3.3.3.1 the distributable income shall be determined in accordance with the accounting and financial reporting practices adopted for purposes of Fairvest's and Arrowhead's respective most recent published unaudited interim financial statements;
- 3.3.3.2 the Transaction Costs shall have been funded out of the available capital of the applicable Party and not by reducing the distributable income for the applicable Pre-Transaction Financial Period, and any Transaction Costs incurred by any Party that would otherwise reduce the distributable income of that Party will accordingly be added back for the purposes of determining the amount of the applicable Clean-out Distribution;
- 3.3.3.3 the Chief Financial Officer of each of Fairvest and Arrowhead duly mandated by their respective boards, shall consult each other fully and transparently regarding the detailed calculation of each proposed Clean-Out Distribution and shall endeavour in good faith, both undertaking to act reasonably, to ensure that each Clean-Out Distribution reflects principles and is calculated as far as practical on a like for like basis between Fairvest and Arrowhead such that the quantums of each Clean-Out Distribution are agreed; and
- 3.3.3.4 the Scheme Operative Date shall not (unless otherwise agreed in writing between the Parties) occur until at least 1 Business Day following the later of the record date for participating in the Clean-out Distribution relating to each of Arrowhead and Fairvest; and
- 3.3.4 In relation to Arrowhead:
- 3.3.4.1 the amount of the Clean-out Distribution shall, as required by the MOI, in the first instance be applied as a distribution in respect of the AHA Shares with the balance being applied as a distribution in respect of the AHB Shares;
- 3.3.4.2 there shall be excluded from the Arrowhead distributable income any income attributable to Indluplace or Dipula for any financial period which overlaps with the financial period to which the Arrowhead Clean-out Distribution relates (being, in the case of Indluplace the 12-month period ended 31 September 2021, and, in respect of Dipula, the 6-month period ended 31 August 2021) and which has not at the time of declaration of the Clean-out Distribution relating to Arrowhead been declared by Indluplace or Dipula, as applicable, as a distribution;
- 3.3.4.3 there shall be included in Arrowhead's distributable income a pro rata portion of any distribution which has, before the date of declaration of Arrowhead's Clean-out Distribution, been declared (even if it may not yet have been received by Arrowhead) in respect of Arrowhead's shareholding in Indluplace and/or Dipula in respect of its distributable income for the applicable overlapping financial period;
- 3.3.4.4 the respective payments made or to be made to the Departing Executives as contemplated in the Implementation Agreement and as set out in paragraph 5 of Annexure 3 shall be paid out of cash reserves, and will not impact Arrowhead's Clean-out Distribution as provided for in the Implementation Agreement,
and save for (i) the Clean-out Distributions (and, if applicable, any distribution made by Fairvest in the ordinary course of its business in respect of its financial period ended 30 June 2021), (ii) any distribution in respect of AHA Shares which is made in accordance with the terms of the AHA Shares and which relates to the financial period commencing on 1 October 2021, neither Fairvest nor Arrowhead shall be entitled to declare or effect any distribution until after the earlier of the Termination Date and the Scheme Consideration Settlement Date.
- 3.3.5 The dates and times applicable to the Clean-out Distribution relating to Fairvest have been included in the Scheme Circular.
- 3.3.6 As per Arrowhead's reviewed condensed consolidated results in respect of the year ended 30 September 2021, published on 24 November 2021, the Arrowhead Board has resolved to declare a combined gross interim and final dividend of 120.21124 cents per AHA Share and 47.71936 cents per AHB Share for the year ended 30 September 2021 ("2021 Dividend"), which will be paid to Arrowhead Shareholders on Monday, 20 December 2021. Due to the timing of Arrowhead's 30 September financial year end in relation to the Commercial Effective Date, which commenced on 1 October 2021, Arrowhead's Cleanout Distribution is effectively the 2021 Dividend declared and to be paid out in the ordinary course, in respect of the Company's financial year ended 30 September 2021.
3.4 Reconstitution of the Arrowhead Board and Arrowhead executive team
Upon the Scheme becoming operative, the Arrowhead Board shall immediately be reconstituted to comprise members of each of the existing Arrowhead Board and the existing Fairvest Board, as follows:
- 3.4.1 5 of the existing non-executive directors on the Fairvest Board shall have been elected or co-opted as directors of Arrowhead.
- 3.4.2 2 of the existing non-executive directors on the Arrowhead Board shall remain in office.
- 3.4.3 The executive members of the reconstituted Arrowhead Board will include:
- 3.4.3.1 Mr. Darren Wilder (currently Chief Executive Officer of Fairvest), to be appointed as Chief Executive Officer of the Combined Group; and
- 3.4.3.2 Mr Jacques Kriel (currently Chief Financial Officer of Fairvest), to be appointed as Chief Financial Officer of the Combined Group, or such other such other composition as may be agreed between the Parties in writing at any time before the Scheme Operative Date.
- 3.4.4 The Parties have undertaken that all members of the Arrowhead Board and the Fairvest Board who are not to serve as members of the reconstituted Arrowhead Board will resign from office as directors on the applicable board on and with effect from the Scheme Operative Date.
- 3.4.5 In terms of the Departing Executive Termination Agreements entered into between Mark Kaplan (currently Chief Executive Officer of Arrowhead) and Junaid Limalia (currently Chief Financial Officer of Arrowhead), each of Mark Kaplan and Junaid Limalia have agreed to resign from the Arrowhead Board with effect from the Departing Executive Termination Date, further details of which are set out in paragraph 5 of Annexure 3.
- 3.4.6 Arrowhead's existing Chief Operating Officer, Riaz Kader and Chief Investment Officer, Alon Kirkel will be retained in their current capacities in the Combined Group.
- 3.4.7 The details of the directors of the Combined Group, including a brief curriculum vitae of each such director is set out on in Section 1, paragraph 2.
3.5 Change of name
- 3.5.1 The Arrowhead Board proposes that the name of the Company be changed from "Arrowhead Properties Limited" to "Fairvest Limited" on and with effect from the Scheme Operative Date (or as soon as practicable thereafter). The JSE will implement such name change by:
- (i) reclassifying the AHA Shares under share code "AHA", short name "AWAPropA" and ISIN ZAE000275491 to share code "FTA", short name "FTAPropA" and ISIN ZAE000304788; and
- (ii) reclassifying the AHB Shares under share code "AHB", short name "AWAPropB" and ISIN ZAE000275509 to share code "FTB", short name "FTBPropB" and ISIN ZAE000304796.
- 3.5.2 Should the Transaction be implemented, Arrowhead Shareholders will have their accounts held at their CSDP or Broker updated to reflect the change of name.
- 3.5.3 For a period of not less than one year, the Company will reflect the former name "Arrowhead Properties Limited" on all Documents of Title beneath the new name of "Fairvest Limited". In addition, for a period of not less than a year, the Company will reflect the former name "Arrowhead Properties Limited" on all circulars beneath the new name "Fairvest Limited" in accordance with the Listings Requirements.
- 3.5.4 In terms of clause 7.4 of the MOI and section 16 of the Companies Act, a special resolution to approve the change of the Company's name as set out above will be put to Arrowhead Shareholders at the General Meeting.
- 3.5.5 The Company will retain all previous trading history following the change of name.
3.6 Conditions Precedent to the Scheme
Arrowhead Shareholders are advised that the unconditional approval by the relevant Competition Authorities, has been obtained in respect of the Transaction.
The implementation of the Scheme is subject to the fulfilment or waiver, as the case may be, of the following remaining Conditions Precedent:
- 3.6.1 by not later than 17:00 on 31 January 2022, the approval of the relevant Fairvest Shareholder resolutions required to approve and implement the Transaction by the requisite majority of Fairvest Shareholders is obtained at the Scheme Meeting;
- 3.6.2 by not later than 17:00 on 31 January 2022, the approval of the relevant Arrowhead Shareholder resolutions required to approve and implement the Transaction by the requisite majority of Arrowhead Shareholders is obtained the General Meeting;
- 3.6.3 by not later than 17:00 on 31 January 2022, to the extent required under section 115(3) of the Companies Act, approval by the Court of the implementation of the Scheme Resolution is obtained, and Fairvest not having treated the Scheme Resolution as a nullity (which it may not do unless agreed by both Fairvest and Arrowhead);
- 3.6.4 as at 12:00 on the Business Day immediately following the last day on which a Valid Demand may be made by a Fairvest Shareholder in respect of the Scheme in terms of section 164(7) of the Companies Act, Fairvest has not received Valid Demands from Fairvest Shareholder/s holding in aggregate more than 1% of all the issued Fairvest Shares;
- 3.6.5 by not later than 17:00 on 31 January 2022, the providers of debt funding to Fairvest and Arrowhead have, to the extent required, provided such consents or approvals, in writing, as may be required under the relevant funding agreements in order for the Scheme to be able to be effected without triggering any event of default or other potential adverse consequence under the relevant agreements;
- 3.6.6 as at 17:00 on the date on which the last of the conditions in paragraphs 3.6.2 to 3.6.5 has been fulfilled or, where appropriate, waived, none of the following events shall have occurred in respect of Fairvest or Arrowhead:
- 3.6.6.1 any corporate action, legal proceedings or other procedure or other step (including an application to Court, proposal of a resolution or convening of a meeting of shareholders, members, directors or other officers) is taken by any person with a view to:
- 3.6.6.1.1 a moratorium, compromise, composition, business rescue or similar arrangement with any of its creditors;
- 3.6.6.2.2 its winding-up, dissolution or commencement of business rescue proceedings, or for the seeking of relief under any applicable bankruptcy, insolvency, company or similar law, or any such resolution; or
- 3.6.6.2 the value of its assets is less than its liabilities (taking into account of contingent and prospective liabilities) or it is unable to pay its debts as they fall due;
- 3.6.7 by not later than 17:00 on 31 January 2022, all outstanding regulatory approvals legally necessary for the implementation of the Scheme have been obtained; and
- 3.6.8 by not later than 17:00 on 31 January 2022, the TRP has issued a compliance certificate in relation to the Scheme.
The conditions precedent contemplated in paragraphs 3.6.4 to 3.6.6 shall be capable of waiver or relaxation by written agreement between Fairvest and Arrowhead prior to the expiry of the applicable time periods set out in paragraph 3.6 (or such extended time period as may be agreed in writing between the Fairvest and Arrowhead).
3.7 Shareholder support
3.7.1 The following Arrowhead Shareholders have provided undertakings of support, in respect of which they have agreed to, inter alia, vote all of their Arrowhead Shares which they own or control in favour of the Arrowhead Shareholder resolutions required to implement the Transaction.
| Arrowhead Shareholder | Number of AHA Shares held |
Number of AHB Shares held |
Total Arrowhead Shares held |
% of total issued Arrowhead Shares1 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 36ONE Asset Management | ||||
| Proprietary Limited | 9 902 379 | 139 817 420 | 149 719 799 | 14.8 |
| Vukile Property Fund Limited | – | 114 438 564 | 114 438 564 | 11.3 |
| Catalyst Fund Managers SA | ||||
| Proprietary Limited | 5 546 053 | 90 050 346 | 95 596 399 | 9.4 |
| Visio Fund Management Proprietary Limited |
– | 84 000 000 | 84 000 000 | 8.3 |
| Counterpoint Asset Management | ||||
| Proprietary Limited | – | 27 393 699 | 27 393 699 | 2.7 |
| Ninety One SA Proprietary Limited | – | 20 193 735 | 20 193 735 | 2.0 |
| Catalyst Fund Managers Alternative | ||||
| Investments Proprietary Limited | – | 14 357 152 | 14 357 152 | 1.4 |
| Knight Capital Proprietary Limited | – | 2 279 900 | 2 279 900 | 0.2 |
| Cohesive Capital Proprietary | ||||
| Limited | – | 1 600 000 | 1 600 000 | 0.2 |
| Total | 15 448 432 | 494 130 816 | 509 579 248 | 50.2 |
Notes:
-
Total Arrowhead shares in issue of 1 014 140 687 calculated as 62 718 658 AHA Shares plus 951 422 029 AHB Shares.
-
The above holdings are as disclosed in the Joint Firm Intention Announcement.
3.7.2 The following Fairvest Shareholders have provided undertakings of support, in respect of which they have agreed to, inter alia, vote all their Fairvest Shares which they own or control in favour of the Fairvest Shareholder resolutions required to implement the Transaction.
| FairvestShareholder | Number of Fairvest Shares held |
% of total issued Fairvest Shares 1 |
|---|---|---|
| Vukile Property Fund Limited | 140 387 931 | 14.2 |
| MICC Properties Proprietary Limited, a subsidiary of Vukile Property | ||
| Fund Limited | 130 006 881 | 13.1 |
| Counterpoint Asset Management Proprietary Limited | 104 787 410 | 10.6 |
| Stanlib Asset Management Proprietary Limited | 79 439 019 | 8.0 |
| Visio Fund Management Proprietary Limited | 52 800 000 | 5.3 |
| Ninety One SA Proprietary Limited | 44 574 642 | 4.5 |
| Cohesive Capital Proprietary Limited | 34 837 653 | 3.5 |
| Catalyst Fund Managers SA Proprietary Limited | 31 023 859 | 3.1 |
| Catalyst Fund Managers Alternative Investments Proprietary Limited | 14 000 000 | 1.4 |
| 36ONE Asset Management Proprietary Limited | 6 515 986 | 0.7 |
| Knight Capital Proprietary Limited | 4 480 331 | 0.5 |
| Total | 642 853 712 | 65.0 |
Notes:
-
Total Fairvest Shares in issue of 989 246 076 calculated as 1 027 332 675 less 38 086 599 treasury shares.
-
The above holdings are as disclosed in the Joint Firm Intention Announcement.
4. PREVIOUS ISSUES OF SECURITIES
There have been no issues or offers of Arrowhead Shares or Fairvest Shares in the three years preceding the Last Practicable Date other than as set out in Annexure 14.
SECTION 3: STATEMENTS AND REPORTS
1. STATEMENT AS TO ADEQUACY OF CAPITAL
- 1.1 Assuming the Transaction is implemented, the Arrowhead Board is of the opinion that the issued share capital of the Combined Group will be adequate for the purposes of the business of the Combined Group, for at least the next 12 months from the date of issue of these Revised Listing Particulars.
- 1.2 The Arrowhead Board is of the opinion that, should the Transaction be implemented, taking into account the bank and other facilities available to Arrowhead and Fairvest, the working capital of the Combined Group will be sufficient for its present requirements, that is for at least 12 months from the date of issue of these Revised Listing Particulars.
2. REPORT BY DIRECTORS AS TO MATERIAL CHANGES
- 2.1 The Arrowhead Board confirms that there have been no material changes to the financial or trading position of the Arrowhead Group since Arrowhead published its reviewed condensed consolidated results for the year ended 30 September 2021 and the Last Practicable Date.
- 2.2 The Arrowhead Board confirms that, after having made all reasonable enquiries to ascertain such facts, to the best of its knowledge and belief, there have been no material changes to the financial or trading position of the Fairvest Group since Fairvest published its audited results for the year ended 30 June 2021 and the Last Practicable Date.
3. STATEMENT AS TO LISTING ON A STOCK EXCHANGE
The Arrowhead Shares are listed on the JSE, and the Fairvest Shares are currently listed on the JSE and on the A2X. Post implementation of the Scheme, the Fairvest Shares will be delisted from the JSE and the A2X.
4. HISTORICAL FINANCIAL INFORMATION
4.1 Historical financial information of Arrowhead
The reviewed condensed consolidated historical financial information of Arrowhead in respect of the financial year ended 30 September 2021 and the audited historical financial information of Arrowhead in respect of the financial years ended 30 September 2020 and 2019, along with the audit reports thereto are incorporated by reference as per Section 4, paragraph 8 and is available for inspection as per Section 4, paragraph 9. The historical financial information of Arrowhead is the responsibility of the directors of Arrowhead.
4.2 Historical financial information of Fairvest
The audited historical financial information of Fairvest in respect of the financial years ended 30 June 2021, 2020 and 2019, along with the audit reports thereto are incorporated by reference as per Section 4, paragraph 8 and is available for inspection as per Section 4, paragraph 9. The audited historical financial information of Fairvest is the responsibility of the directors of Fairvest.
5. FORECAST STATEMENTS OF COMPREHENSIVE INCOME OF THE COMBINED GROUP
- 5.1 Arrowhead's year end is currently 30 September and will remain 30 September in relation to the Combined Group post implementation of the Transaction. As a result of the implementation of the Transaction, Fairvest will become a Subsidiary of Arrowhead and its financial year end will change to 30 September to align with the year end of the Combined Group.
- 5.2 The forecast statements of comprehensive income in respect of the Combined Group have been prepared for the year ending 30 September 2022 and the year ending 30 September 2023 (collectively, the "Forecasts"), and are set out in Annexure 10.
- 5.3 The Forecasts, including the assumptions on which they are based and the financial information from which they are prepared, are the responsibility of the directors of Arrowhead.
5.4 The Forecasts must be read in conjunction with the Independent Reporting Accountants' limited assurance report on the forecasts contained in Annexure 11.
6. PRO FORMA EFFECTS OF THE TRANSACTION
- 6.1 The pro forma statement of comprehensive income for the year ended 30 September 2021 and the pro forma consolidated statement financial position as at 30 September 2021 of the Arrowhead Group before and after the Transaction, including the assumptions on which it is based and notes thereto ("Pro Forma Financial Information") are set out in Annexure 12.
- 6.2 The Pro Forma Financial Information is the responsibility of the directors of Arrowhead.
- 6.3 The Independent Reporting Accountants' report on the Pro Forma Financial Information is set out in Annexure13.
- 6.4 The Independent Reporting Accountants' review conclusion regarding the assets and liabilities acquired in terms of the Transaction, as reflected in the adjustment column of the pro forma consolidated statement of financial position to the Pro Forma Financial Information is set out in Annexure 14.
7. DIVIDENDS
- 7.1 In compliance with paragraph 13.47 of the Listings Requirements, the Company must distribute at least 75% of its total distributable profits as a distribution to Arrowhead Shareholders at least annually, within four months after its financial year end, subject to the relevant solvency and liquidity test as defined in the Companies Act and applied in section 46 of the Companies Act.
- 7.2 If considered appropriate, and subject to compliance with Section 46 of the Companies Act, Arrowhead declares semi-annual dividends for the six-month periods ending 31 March and 30 September.
- 7.3 Any distributions remaining unclaimed for a period of three years from the declaration date thereof may be forfeited by resolution of the Arrowhead Board for the benefit of Arrowhead.
- 7.4 There are no arrangements in terms of which future dividends or interest distributions are waived or agreed to be waived.
- 7.5 Further details in respect of dividends and distributions are contained in Annexure 5.
SECTION 4: ADDITIONAL MATERIAL INFORMATION
1. RELATIONSHIP INFORMATION
- 1.1 None of the directors of Arrowhead and Fairvest, promoters, or property managers have had any beneficial interest, direct or indirect, in relation to any property held or property to be acquired by Arrowhead or Fairvest nor are they contracted to become a tenant of any part of the property of the Combined Group.
- 1.2 There is no relationship between any of the parties mentioned in the above paragraph and another person that may conflict with a duty to the Combined Group.
- 1.3 The asset management function is currently internalised within each of Arrowhead and Fairvest, and will continue to be internally performed in respect of the Combined Group.
- 1.4 Details of the property management agreements for Arrowhead and Fairvest are set out in Annexure 6 and the property management agreements will lie open for inspection in accordance with Section 4, paragraph 9.
- 1.5 None of the property managers, or their directors had any beneficial interest, direct or indirect, in any securities or participatory interests issued or to be issued by Arrowhead or Fairvest in order to finance the acquisition of any properties in Arrowhead or Fairvest's property portfolios.
- 1.6 The property portfolio of the Combined Group will continue to be managed by a strongly incentivised, dedicated and proven executive management team, further details of which are set out in Section 1, paragraph 2.
- 1.7 Save as disclosed in respect of the acquisitions as set out in Annexure 9, the vendors of the properties acquired or to be acquired by the Arrowhead Group and the Fairvest Group did not have any beneficial interest, direct or indirect, in any securities or participatory interests issued or to be issued by Arrowhead or Fairvest in order to finance the acquisition of any properties in Arrowhead or Fairvest's property portfolios.
- 1.8 The directors of Arrowhead and Fairvest, the property managers and the promoters have not had a material beneficial interest, whether directly or indirectly, in the acquisition or disposal of any properties of Arrowhead or Fairvest during the two years preceding the Last Practicable Date.
2. VENDORS OF MATERIAL ASSETS
- 2.1 Details relating to the vendors of all material immovable properties, fixed assets and/or business undertakings ("Vendors") acquired or to be acquired by the Arrowhead Group and the Fairvest Group within the three years preceding the Last Practicable Date are set out in Annexure 9.
- 2.2 No Vendor has guaranteed book debts or other assets. The agreements in terms of which the relevant material assets were or are to be acquired (the "Vendor Agreements") contain warranties standard for transactions of their nature.
- 2.3 The Vendor Agreements do not preclude the Vendors from carrying on business in competition with the Arrowhead Group or the Fairvest Group, nor do they impose any other similar restrictions on the Vendors. No payment in cash or otherwise has been made in this regard.
- 2.4 There are no liabilities for accrued taxation that are required to be settled in terms of the Vendor Agreements.
- 2.5 Save for the directors' interests as set out in Annexure 3, no director, proposed director or promoter of the Arrowhead Group or the Fairvest Group (or any partnership, syndicate or other association in which a promoter or director had an interest) had any direct or indirect beneficial interest in the acquisition of the material assets from the Vendors.
- 2.6 No cash or securities have been paid or any benefit given within the three years preceding the Last Practicable Date or is proposed to be paid or given to any promoter of either the Arrowhead Group or the Fairvest Group (not being a director).
- 2.7 Other than the Scheme Shares which are to be acquired by Arrowhead in relation to the Transaction, the material assets which are the subject of this paragraph have all been transferred into the name of the Arrowhead Group and/or the Fairvest Group.
- 2.8 Save where such assets have been provided as security for borrowings as set out in Annexure 16, no such assets have been ceded or pledged.
3. LITIGATION STATEMENT
There are no legal or arbitration proceedings which may have or have during the 12 months preceding the Last Practicable Date, had a material effect on the financial position of either the Arrowhead Group or the Fairvest Group. The Combined Group is not aware of any other proceedings that would have a material effect on the financial position of the Combined Group or which are pending or threatened against the Combined Group.
4. TRADING HISTORY OF SHARES
A table of the aggregate volumes and values traded and the highest and lowest prices traded in Arrowhead Shares and Fairvest Shares for each month over the 12 months preceding to, and for each day over the 30 days preceding, the Last Practicable Date is set out in Annexure 17.
5. GOVERNMENT PROTECTION AND INVESTMENT ENCOURAGEMENT LAW
There is no government protection or any investment encouragement law pertaining to any of the businesses operated by the Arrowhead Group or by the Fairvest Group.
6. DIRECTORS' RESPONSIBILITY STATEMENT
The Arrowhead Board, whose names are set out in page 13, collectively and individually accept full responsibility for the accuracy of the information given in these Revised Listing Particulars and certify that to the best of their knowledge and belief there are no facts that have been omitted which would make any statement false or misleading and that they have made all reasonable enquiries to ascertain such facts and that these Revised Listing Particulars contains all information required by law and the Listings Requirements.
7. CONSENTS
Each of the Strategic Corporate Advisor, Joint Corporate Adviser and Transaction Sponsor, the Independent Reporting Accountants, the Independent Property Valuers, the Transfer Secretaries and the Attorneys and Competition Law Advisors have consented in writing to act in the capacities stated and to their names appearing in these Revised Listing Particulars and have not withdrawn their consent prior to the publication of this document.
The Independent Reporting Accountants and Independent Property Valuers and have consented to the inclusion of their reports in the form and context in which they are included in these Revised Listing Particulars, which consents have not been withdrawn prior to the publication of this document.
8. DOCUMENTS INCORPORATED BY REFERENCE
The following information has been incorporated by reference and is available for viewing on the Company and Fairvest's websites as set out below.
| Information incorporated by reference | Website link |
|---|---|
| Arrowhead's integrated annual report for the year ended 30 September 2020 |
https://arrowheadproperties.co.za/annual-reports.php |
| Arrowhead's reviewed condensed consolidated results for the year ended 30 September 2021 and Arrowhead's audited financial results in respect of the years ended 30 September 2020 and 2019 ("Arrowhead HFI") |
2021: https://senspdf.jse.co.za/documents/2021/jse/isse/AHAE/FY2021.pdf 2020 and 2019: https://www.arrowheadproperties.co.za/results.php |
| Auditor reports in respect of the Arrowhead HFI |
2021: https://senspdf.jse.co.za/documents/2021/jse/isse/AHAE/ FY2021.pdf 2020: https://arrowheadproperties.co.za/cmsAdmin/uploads/interim results/afs-2020.pdf 2019: https://www.arrowheadproperties.co.za/cmsAdmin/uploads/ annual-reports/arrowhead-integrated-annual-report-2019.pdf |
| Fairvest's integrated annual report for the year ended 30 June 2021 |
https://fairvest.co.za/news/reports |
| Information incorporated by reference | Website link |
|---|---|
| Fairvest's audited financial results in respect of the years ended 30 June 2021, 2020 and 2019 ("Fairvest HFI") |
https://fairvest.co.za/news/results |
| Audit reports in respect of the Fairvest HFI | 2021: https://fairvest.co.za/news/results 2020: https://fairvest.co.za/news/results 2019: https://fairvest.co.za/news/reports |
| Fairvest Circular | https://fairvest.co.za/news/notices |
| Fairvest Revised Listing Particulars | https://fairvest.co.za/news/notices |
| Scheme Circular | https://fairvest.co.za/news/notices |
9. DOCUMENTS AVAILABLE FOR INSPECTION
Copies of the following documents will be available for inspection electronically and may be obtained from the Company by sending a request to [email protected] from the date of issue of these Revised Listing Particulars up to and including the date of the General Meeting, during normal business hours:
- 9.1 the signed Circular;
- 9.2 the signed Revised Listing Particulars;
- 9.3 the MOI of Arrowhead and its Major Subsidiaries;
- 9.4 a standard directors' letter of engagement;
- 9.5 the Implementation Agreement;
- 9.6 the letters of undertaking by Arrowhead and Fairvest Shareholders in relation to the Transaction;
- 9.7 the property management agreements detailed in Annexure 6;
- 9.8 the summary valuation reports, prepared by the Independent Property Valuers and as set out in Annexure 7, together with the detailed valuation reports;
- 9.9 service agreements with directors, managers or secretary/ies, underwriters, vendors and promoters entered into during the three years preceding the Last Practicable Date;
- 9.10 the written consents of advisors, whose names are set out in the "Corporate Information and Advisors" section of the Circular and these Revised Listing Particulars, to the inclusion of their names in the Circular and these Revised Listing Particulars in the context and form in which they appear; and
- 9.11 Arrowhead's integrated annual report for the year ended 30 September 2020;
- 9.12 the reviewed condensed consolidated results of Arrowhead in respect of the year ended 30 September 2021;
- 9.13 audited annual financial statements of Arrowhead in respect of the years ended 30 September 2020 and 2019;
- 9.14 the Independent Reporting Accountants' limited assurance report on the forecast financial information of the Combined Group as contained in Annexure 11;
- 9.15 the Independent Reporting Accountants' limited assurance report on the pro forma statement of financial position of the Arrowhead Group contained in Annexure 13; and
- 9.16 the Independent Reporting Accountant's review conclusion regarding the assets and liabilities being acquired contained in Annexure 14.
For and on behalf of Arrowhead
These Revised Listing Particulars was signed in Johannesburg on behalf of all the directors of Arrowhead in terms of powers of attorney granted on or about 30 November 2021.
GROUP STRUCTURE

Set out below is the Arrowhead Group structure as at the Last Practicable Date:
Notes:
-
- Dormant entity
-
- 0.3% still held by dissenting shareholders from Gemgrow Arrowhead Merger
Set out below is the Combined Group structures post implementation of the Transaction:

Notes:
-
- Dormant entity.
-
- 0.3% still held by dissenting shareholders from Gemgrow Arrowhead Merger.
DETAILS OF SUBSIDIARIES
Subsidiaries of the Arrowhead Group
The following table contains a list of Arrowhead's subsidiaries post-implementation of the Transaction.
| Name of Subsidiary |
Main business |
Listed/ unlisted |
Registration number |
Date and place of incorporation and date became a subsidiary |
Issued share capital |
Effective holding by Arrowhead |
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. | Fairvest Property Holdings Limited |
Property owning company |
Unlisted | 1998/005011/06 | 17 March 1998 South Africa January 2022 |
1 046 421 089 Fairvest Shares |
100% |
| 2. Arrowgem Limited |
Property owning company |
Unlisted | 2011/000308/06 | 5 January 2011 South Africa 23 September 2019 |
1 047 677 943 ordinary no par value shares |
99.7% | |
| 3. | Indluplace Properties Limited |
Property owning company |
Listed | 2013/226082/06 3 December 2013 South Africa June 2015 |
319 356 799 ordinary shares of no par value |
60% | |
| 4. | Cumulative Properties Limited |
Property owning company |
Unlisted | 2015/335578/06 | 21 September 2015 South Africa December 2016 |
416 845 546 no par value shares |
100% |
| 5. | Moolgem Proprietary Limited |
Property owning company |
Unlisted | 2017/174691/07 | 20 April 2017 South Africa December 2018 |
10 000 ordinary shares and 31 010 A ordinary shares |
100% of the A ordinary shares and 75.62% of the total issued share capital |
| 6. | Vividend Income Fund Limited |
Property owning company |
Unlisted | 2010/003232/06 | 17 February 2010 South Africa August 2014 |
268 331 668 linked units comprising of debentures of R4.9999 each and ordinary shares of 0.001 cent each |
99.7% |
| 7. | Gemgrow Asset Management Proprietary Limited¹ |
Asset management company |
Unlisted | 2007/016890/07 | 21 June 2007 South Africa December 2016 |
10 000 ordinary shares of R0.01 each |
100% |
Notes:
-
Gemgrow Asset Management is a dormant entity.
-
None of the above Subsidiaries have altered its share capital during the past three years.
Subsidiaries of the Fairvest Group
| Subsidiary | Main business |
Listed/ unlisted |
Registration number |
Date and place of incorporation and date became a subsidiary |
Issued Share capital |
Effective holding by Fairvest |
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. | Fairvest Property Management Proprietary Limited |
Property owning company |
Unlisted | 2001/020298/07 | 28 August 2001 South Africa 19 November 2001 |
100 shares of no par value |
100% |
| 2. | Fairvest Properties Two Proprietary Limited |
Property owning company |
Unlisted | 2000/009837/07 | 24 May 2000 South Africa 19 November 2001 |
1000 shares of no par value |
100% |
| 3. | FPP Property Venture 103 Proprietary Limited |
Property owning company |
Unlisted | 2015/229619/07 | 9 July 2015 South Africa 1 January 2016 |
100 shares of no par value |
80% |
| 4. | Macassar Retail Centre Proprietary Limited |
Property owning company |
Unlisted | 2014/209218/07 | 24 October 2014 South Africa 29 July 2016 |
100 shares of no par value |
100% |
| 5. | Libode Shopping Centre Proprietary Limited |
Property owning company |
Unlisted | 2017/273514/07 | 26 June 2017 South Africa 1 October 2018 |
100 shares of no par value |
55% |
| 6. | Parow Valley Centre Proprietary Limited |
Property owning company |
Unlisted | 2015/229676/07 | 9 July 2015 South Africa 1 January 2016 |
100 shares of no par value |
100% |
| 7. | FPP Property Venture 102 Proprietary Limited |
Property owning company |
Unlisted | 2015/229521/07 | 9 July 2015 South Africa 18 July 2017 |
100 shares of no par value |
51% |
| 8. | Southview Shopping Centre Proprietary Limited |
Property owning company |
Unlisted | 2015/229521/07 | 26 June 2017 South Africa 2 October 2017 |
100 shares of no par value |
50% |
| 9. | Bara Precinct Proprietary Limited |
Property owning company |
Unlisted | 2016/323469/07 | 28 July 2016 South Africa 12 December 2017 |
301 'A' class ordinary shares, 199 'B' ordinary shares and 100 ordinary shares of no par value |
50.17% |
| 10. Diepkloof Leaseholder Proprietary Limited¹ |
Property owning company |
Unlisted | 1979/007051/07 | 3 December 1979 South Africa 12 December 2017 |
100 shares of no par value |
50.17% | |
| 11. Qumbu Plaza Proprietary Limited |
Property owning company |
Unlisted | 2017/471706/07 | 23 October 2017 South Africa 15 August 2019 |
100 shares of no par value |
51% | |
| 12. New Star Asset Management Proprietary Limited |
Asset manager |
Unlisted | 2005/029006/07 | 18 August 2005 South Africa 1 October 2021 |
1 250 ordinary shares | 100% |
Notes:
- Bara Precinct Proprietary Limited owns 100% of the issued share capital in Diepkloof Leaseholder Proprietary Limited.
DETAILS OF CURRENT AND PROPOSED DIRECTORS OF THE COMBINED GROUP AND ITS MAJOR SUBSIDIARIES
1. Directors' interests in Arrowhead Shares
The following information in relation to the direct and indirect beneficial interests of the directors of the Company and their Associates in Arrowhead Shares, which includes the interests of persons who were directors during the last 18 months is set out below.
1.1 The interests of directors in AHA Shares at the Last Practicable Date:
| Director | Direct beneficial | Indirect beneficial | Total AHA Shares | Total (%)¹ |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| A Basserabie | 215 000 | – | 215 000 | 0.34 |
| Total | 215 000 | – | 215 000 | 0.34 |
Note:
- Based on 62 718 658 AHA Shares in issue (net of treasury shares) as at the Last Practicable Date.
1.2 The interests of directors in AHB Shares at the Last Practicable Date:
| Director | Direct beneficial | Indirect beneficial | Total AHB Shares | Total (%)³ |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| M Kaplan | 14 575 063 | 9 853 309 | 24 428 372 | 2.57 |
| J Limalia | 3 025 000 | 3 846 577 | 6 871 577 | 0.72 |
| R Kader¹ | 1 264 528 | 1 332 500 | 2 597 028 | 0.27 |
| A Kirkel¹ | 3 000 000 | 3 960 425 | 6 960 425 | 0.73 |
| M Nell² | – | 304 769 | 304 769 | 0.03 |
| N Makhoba | 22 239 | – | 22 239 | 0.00 |
| Total | 21 886 830 | 19 297 580 | 41 184 410 | 4.33 |
Notes:
-
Resigned as a director with effect 1 October 2020.
-
- Passed away as announced on SENS on 3 September 2021.
-
- Based on 950 766 997 AHB Shares in issue (calculated as 951 422 029 shares less 655 032 treasury shares) as at the Last Practicable Date.
- 1.3 There were no trades in AHA Shares entered into by the directors of the Company or by their Associates during the period commencing on 30 September 2021 and ending on the Last Practicable Date.
- 1.4 There were no trades in AHB Shares entered into by directors of the Company or by their Associates during the period commencing on 30 September 2021 and ending on the Last Practicable Date.
- 1.5 There will be no change to the direct or indirect beneficial interests in AHA Shares by Arrowhead directors post implementation of the Transaction.
1.6 Post implementation of the Transaction, the directors of Arrowhead will hold the following interests in AHB Shares:
| Director | Direct beneficial | Indirect beneficial | Total AHB Shares | Total (%)4 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| M Kaplan¹ | 14 575 063 | 9 853 309 | 24 428 372 | 1.64 |
| J Limalia¹ | 3 025 000 | 3 846 577 | 6 871 577 | 0.46 |
| R Kader² | 1 264 528 | 1 332 500 | 2 597 028 | 0.17 |
| A Kirkel² | 3 000 000 | 3 960 425 | 6 960 425 | 0.47 |
| M Nell³ | – | 304 769 | 304 769 | 0.02 |
| N Makhoba | 22 239 | – | 22 239 | 0.00 |
| Total | 21 886 830 | 19 297 580 | 41 184 410 | 2.77 |
Notes:
-
- Director will step down from the Arrowhead Board post implementation of the Scheme.
-
- Resigned as a director of Arrowhead with effect 1 October 2020.
-
- Passed away as announced on SENS on 3 September 2021.
-
- Based on 1 485 494 058 AHB Shares in issue (calculated as 1 496 467 154 shares less 655 032 treasury shares and 10 318 064 AHB Shares acquired by Fairvest which will become treasury shares) post implementation of the Transaction.
- 1.7 Apart from Arnold Basserabie's holding of AHA Shares as set out in paragraph 1.1 above, the proposed directors of the Combined Group will not have a direct or indirect beneficial interest in AHA Shares post implementation of the Transaction.
- 1.8 Set out below are the anticipated interests of the proposed Directors of the Combined Group in AHB Shares post implementation of the Transaction:
| Director | Direct beneficial | Indirect beneficial | Total AHB Shares | Total (%)¹ |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| DM Wilder | – | 5 405 610 | 5 405 610 | 0.36 |
| BJ Kriel | – | 12 820 389 | 12 820 389 | 0.86 |
| N Mkhize | – | – | – | – |
| J du Toit | – | – | – | – |
| L Andrag | – | – | – | – |
| K Nkuna | – | – | – | – |
| J Wiese | – | – | – | – |
| N Makhoba | 22 239 | – | 22 239 | 0.00 |
| A Basserabie | – | – | – | – |
| Total | 22 239 | 18 225 999 | 18 248 238 | 1.22 |
Note:
- Based on 1 485 494 058 AHB Shares in issue (calculated as 1 496 467 154 shares less 655 032 treasury shares and 10 318 064 AHB Shares acquired by Fairvest which will become treasury shares) post implementation of the Transaction.
2. Directors' interests in transactions and properties acquired or disposed of
- 2.1 The following Fairvest directors, whom are proposed directors, are beneficial holders of Fairvest Shares:
- 2.1.1 DM Wilder holding 9 978 190 (indirect beneficial) Fairvest Shares (0.99% of total issued Fairvest Shares); and
- 2.1.2 BJ Kriel holding 23 717 745 (indirect beneficial) Fairvest Shares (2.35% of total issued Fairvest Shares; and
therefore they are beneficially interested in the Transaction.
- 2.2 Save as:
- 2.2.1 disclosed above, in relation to their holding of Fairvest Shares; and
- 2.2.2 DM Wilder's interest in the Fairvest Manco Internalisation as detailed in the Fairvest Circular;
none of the directors of Arrowhead and proposed directors of the Combined Group, including a director who was a director during the last 18 months, has or had any material beneficial interest, direct or indirect, in any transactions that were effected by Arrowhead during the current or immediately preceding financial year or during any earlier financial year and which remain in any respect outstanding or unperformed.
- 2.3 None of the directors of Arrowhead, nor any promotor of Arrowhead have been beneficially interested, whether directly or indirectly, in the acquisition or disposal of any properties by the Arrowhead Group during the two years preceding the Last Practicable Date.
- 2.4 None of the directors of Fairvest, nor New Star (which prior to the Fairvest Manco Internalisation, preformed the asset management function for Fairvest), nor any promotor of Fairvest have been beneficially interested, whether directly or indirectly, in the acquisition or disposal of any properties by the Fairvest Group during the two years preceding the Last Practicable Date.
3. Directors' emoluments
- 3.1 Executive directors of Arrowhead do not receive directors' or sub-committee fees. Non-executive directors' remuneration consists of an annual fee plus sub-committee membership fees. The non-executive directors' remuneration is approved by Arrowhead Shareholders at each annual general meeting and is considered to be market related.
- 3.2 The remuneration of the directors of Arrowhead for the year ended 30 September 2020 is as follows:
| Emoluments/ Directors' fees |
Bonus | Total | |
|---|---|---|---|
| R'000 | R'000 | R'000 | |
| Executive | |||
| M Kaplan | 4 963 | 5 663 | 10 625 |
| J Limalia | 3 055 | 3 520 | 6 575 |
| R Kader¹ | 3 055 | 3 580 | 6 635 |
| A Kirkel¹ | 3 055 | 3 505 | 6 560 |
| Subtotal | 14 129 | 16 268 | 30 396 |
| Non-executive | – | ||
| M Nell² | 564 | – | 564 |
| T Adler | 821 | – | 821 |
| A Basserabie | 444 | – | 444 |
| G Kinross | 490 | – | 490 |
| N Makhoba3 | 370 | – | 370 |
| S Mokorosi | 407 | – | 407 |
| S Noik4 | 791 | – | 791 |
| Subtotal | 3 887 | – | 3 887 |
| Total | 18 016 | 16 268 | 34 283 |
Notes:
-
Resigned as a director of Arrowhead with effect 1 October 2020.
-
Passed away as announced on SENS on 3 September 2021.
-
Appointed 1 November 2019.
-
Resigned as a director of Arrowhead with effect 25 February 2021.
3.3 Share based payments to directors
- 3.3.1 Arrowhead's Conditional Share Plan ("CSP") provides for the annual award of AHB Shares ("Performance Shares") which vest after three years, subject to the achievement of strategically important performance conditions and the participant remaining employed with Arrowhead. The Performance Shares will vest in December 2022 and December 2023 respectively subject to the achievement of performance targets for the three-year period 1 October 2019 to 30 September 2022 and 1 October 2020 to September 2023. The awards are equity settled.
- 3.3.2 The CSP was approved by Arrowhead (previously Gemgrow) shareholders and Arrowgem (Old Arrowhead) shareholders respectively on 5 February 2019. However, as Gemgrow and Old Arrowhead were either in prohibited or closed periods following receipt of approval of the CSPs, no awards were made in terms of either CSP to the executive directors in respect of the 2019 financial year.
- 3.3.3 To rectify the inability to grant awards under the various long-term incentive ("LTl") schemes and that there was a period of two years during which no LTl awards vested, the Arrowhead Board approved the implementation of a "Phantom Scheme" to put the executive directors in the position they would have been in, had awards been capable of being granted in respect of the 2018 and 2019 financial years.
- 3.3.4 The Phantom Scheme awards are subject to all the same terms and vesting conditions as equivalent awards under the CSP would have been, with the sole exception that, if and to the extent that the vesting conditions are satisfied, the value of the awards are settled in cash as opposed to by the award of AHB Shares.
- 3.3.5 The Phantom Scheme awards will vest in December 2021 subject to the achievement of performance targets for the period 1 October 2018 to 30 September 2021. The awards are cash settled.
| Number of AHB Shares awarded under the CSP |
Number of equivalent AHB Shares awarded under the Phantom Scheme |
|
|---|---|---|
| M Kaplan | 1 964 753 | 1 962 718 |
| J Limalia | 1 209 620 | 417 656 |
| R Kader¹ | 1 209 620 | 660 493 |
| A Kirkel¹ | 1 209 620 | 417 656 |
3.3.6 The total number of awards which have been made under both the CSP and the Phantom Scheme at 30 September 2021 are as follows:
Notes:
-
Resigned as Arrowhead Director with effect 1 October 2020.
-
3.4 Save as set out above, the directors of Arrowhead as at the Last Practicable Date did not receive any emoluments for the twelve months ended 30 September 2020 in the form of:
- 3.4.1 management, consulting, technical or other fees paid for such services rendered, directly or indirectly, including payments to management companies, a part of which is then paid to a director of the Company;
- 3.4.2 basic salaries;
- 3.4.3 bonuses and performance-related payments;
- 3.4.4 sums paid by way of expense allowance;
- 3.4.5 any other material benefits;
- 3.4.6 contributions paid under any pension scheme; or
- 3.4.7 any commission, gain or profit-sharing arrangements.
- 3.5 The table below sets out the estimated remuneration of the proposed directors of the Combined Group (including from the Subsidiaries of the Combined Group) for the year ending 30 September 2022, which estimate has been based on the remuneration disclosed in Fairvest's June 2021 integrated annual report. The updated remuneration of the proposed directors of the Combined Group (including from the Subsidiaries of the Combined) group for the year ending 30 September 2022 will be approved by the shareholders of the Combined Group at the Company's next annual general meeting to be held on or about 10 February 2022.
| Directors' fees R'000 |
Salary R'000 |
Total R'000 |
|
|---|---|---|---|
| Executive | |||
| DM Wilder | – | 3 045 | 3 045 |
| BJ Kriel | – | 1 930 | 1 930 |
| Subtotal | – | 4 975 | 4 975 |
| Non-executive | |||
| N Mkhize | 279 | – | 190 |
| JF Du Toit | 190 | – | 190 |
| LW Andrag | 190 | – | 190 |
| KR Nkuna | 190 | – | 190 |
| JD Wiese | 190 | – | 190 |
| N Makhoba | 190 | – | 190 |
| A Basserabie | 190 | – | 190 |
| Subtotal | 1 419 | – | 1 419 |
| Total | 1 419 | 4 975 | 6 394 |
Notes:
-
All amounts are exclusive of VAT.
-
An in-depth review of the Remuneration Policy will be undertaken during the 2022 Financial Year.
-
Attendance at board committee meetings are remunerated per meeting attended in the amount of R19 024.75 payable to the chairperson and R12 960.09 payable to board committee members for each board committee meeting.
-
Bonus payments to executive directors are not included in the above table as these are discretionary amounts to be determined during the 2022 Financial Year.
-
3.6 No share options or any other right has been given to a director or proposed director in respect of providing a right to subscribe for Arrowhead Shares.
- 3.7 All directors and proposed directors will be remunerated by Arrowhead.
- 3.8 Save as disclosed in this paragraph 3, no director received any remuneration or benefit in any form from any Subsidiary, Associate, joint venture or other third party management or advisory company.
- 3.9 There will be no fees payable or accrued as payable by Arrowhead to a third party in lieu of directors' fees.
- 3.10 Save as set out in paragraph 4 and 5 below (in relation to the departing directors of Arrowhead), the remuneration of directors and proposed directors will not be varied as a consequence of the Transaction.
- 3.11 Save as disclosed in Annexure 6 and CIS Company Secretaries Proprietary Limited, which manages Arrowhead's back-end administrative secretarial services, the business of Arrowhead, or any part thereof, is not managed or proposed to be managed by any third party under contract or arrangement.
- 3.12 Save for the service agreements as set out in paragraph 9 of this Annexure 3, Arrowhead has not entered into any contracts relating to the proposed directors' and managerial remuneration, secretarial and technical fees and restraint payments.
- 3.13 Non-executive directors are not subject to fixed terms of employment other than the conditions contained in the MOI and, as such, no service contracts have been entered into between the non-executive directors and the Company. Non-executive directors' fees are approved in advance by Arrowhead Shareholders by special resolution at the Company's annual general meeting, at intervals of no longer than two years at a time. Onethird of all executive and non-executive directors retire from office by rotation at the Company's annual general meeting and, if eligible, may offer themselves for re-election.
- 3.14 No restraints of trade have been imposed on any of the executive or non-executive directors and no payments will be made in this regard.
4. Principles to be applied in relation to departing Arrowhead directors
The below agreed principles, which are intended to come into effect post implementation of the Transaction, are contained in the Implementation Agreement.
- 4.1 Alon Kirkel and Riaz Kader will continue in their existing roles and accordingly their current terms and conditions of employment will remain unchanged.
- 4.2 Mark Kaplan and Junaid Limalia will have the option to accept a mutually agreed exit, subject to the terms set out below. Refer to paragraph 5 below which sets out the terms of the Departing Executive Termination Agreements concluded post signature of the Implementation Agreement.
- 4.3 All executives will be entitled to receive their short-term incentives ("STIs") for the financial year ended 30 September 2021. The calculation of the STIs in question will be done by the current Arrowhead Board, prior to the implementation of the Scheme, based on achievement of the pre-determined key performance indicators and will not include any additional discretionary amounts or payments. The cost of the STIs will reduce the distributable income for the financial year ended 30 September 2021, as it would in the ordinary course (and accordingly will reduce the Clean-out Distribution payable by Arrowhead). Refer to paragraph 5 below which sets out the terms of the Departing Executive Termination Agreements concluded post signature of the Implementation Agreement in relation to the STIs awarded to Mark Kaplan and Junaid Limalia.
- 4.4 All executives will, in accordance with the terms of the current long-term incentive ("LTI") schemes, be entitled to receipt of any LTI awards that vest prior to or on the implementation of the Transaction. This will include, in the case of Mark Kaplan and Junaid Limalia the pro rata portions of any LTI awards that vest under the terms of the LTI scheme as a result of, and on the date, of the termination of their employment (recognising that they will, for the purpose of the LTI scheme, be deemed to be 'good leavers'). The determination of the amount of the vested LTI awards in question will be done by the current Arrowhead Board prior to the implementation of the Scheme. Refer to paragraph 5 below which sets out the terms of the Departing Executive Termination Agreements concluded post signature of the Implementation Agreement in relation to the LTIs awarded to Mark Kaplan and Junaid Limalia.
- 4.5 For non-exiting executives, any historic LTI awards that only vest at a future date, will remain in place subject to the terms and conditions of the LTI scheme. The cost of the portions of LTI awards that vest or are received by Mark Kaplan and Junaid Limalia as result of being good leavers under the LTI scheme will (except to the extent that such cost relates to any period after 30 September 2021) reduce the distributable income for the financial year ended 30 September 2021, as it would in the ordinary course (and accordingly will reduce the Clean-out Distribution payable by Arrowhead).
- 4.6 The determination of any new LTI awards; the terms and conditions of any STI in respect of the 2022 financial year as well as any salary increases in respect of the 2022 financial year, will be the responsibility of the reconstituted Arrowhead Board post the implementation of the Scheme.
- 4.7 Mark Kaplan and Junaid Limalia (if applicable) shall on the agreed date of termination of their employment, be entitled to a termination pay out equivalent to the remuneration they would have been paid had they remained employed for the minimum retention period provided for in their employment contracts (being the period up to 31 August 2024) - this comprises basic pay, allowances and contributions to any company benefit scheme, but expressly excludes any discretionary bonuses. Refer to paragraph 5 below which sets out the terms of the agreed Exit Payments (as defined in paragraph 5 below) in relation to the Departing Executive Termination Agreements concluded post signature of the Implementation Agreement.
- 4.8 The Exit Payments referred to in paragraph 4.7 above, will be paid out of the cash reserves of the Combined Group and will not impact distributions for the period ended 30 September 2021 (and accordingly will not reduce the Clean-out Distributions).
5. Agreed terms in relation to the Exit Payments, STI and LTI awards payable to the exiting executive directors of Arrowhead
Mark Kaplan and Junaid Limalia (the "Executive(s)"), the existing Chief Executive Officer and Chief Financial Officer of Arrowhead, have, post signature of, and in accordance with the principles contained in the Implementation Agreement as outlined in paragraph 4 above, entered into the Departing Executive Termination Agreements in terms of which they have accepted a mutually agreed exit in accordance with the below key terms:
5.1 The Executive's employment with the Company (and any other contractual relationship with any other company within the Arrowhead Group, if applicable) shall terminate by mutual agreement on the Departing Executive Termination Date.
- 5.2 The Executive unconditionally resigns from the Arrowhead Board and/or any committees of the Arrowhead Board and any other company within the Arrowhead Group's board of directors on which he has a seat.
- 5.3 The Company shall pay the Executive a termination payment in a gross amount of ZAR 11 716 053 in relation to Mark Kaplan and ZAR 8 610 653 in relation to Junaid Limalia (the "Exit Payment(s)"), being an amount equivalent to the guaranteed remuneration the Executive would have been paid had he remained employed by the Company up to 31 August 2024 (calculated based on the Executive's remuneration package as at the Departing Executive Termination Date).
- 5.4 Tax will be deducted from the Exit Payments in accordance with an income tax directive to be obtained by the Company from the South African Revenue Service.
- 5.5 The Executive shall be entitled to his STI in the ordinary course for the financial year ended 30 September 2021.
- 5.6 The Executive shall be entitled to receipt of any LTI awards that vest prior to or on the implementation of the Transaction, including the pro rata portions of any LTI award that, as at the Departing Executive Termination Date, vests under the terms of the LTI scheme as a result of the Transaction.
The Departing Executive Termination Agreements are necessary to record and reflect the Executives' agreement to terminate their employment with the Company with effect from the Departing Executive Termination Date. However, the financial implications of the termination of the Executives' employment are not a function of these agreements to depart, but a function of the Executive's existing employment agreements (as well as the terms of the Arrowhead Shareholder approved LTI scheme) that set out the amounts to which an Executive is entitled in the circumstances. These terms have been recorded in the Departing Executive Termination Agreements for completeness and to avoid any future dispute as to these financial implications.
6. Borrowing powers of the directors
- 6.1 The directors may from time to time, borrow for the purpose of the Company such sums as they think fit, secure the payment or repayment of any such sums or any other sum, as they think fit, whether by the creation and issue of debentures, mortgage or charge upon all or any of the property or assets of the Company, make such regulations regarding the issue and transfer of debentures and all such other matters incidental to the debentures as the directors think fit provided that the directors shall not, without the consent of a resolution of Arrowhead Shareholders in a combined general meeting which resolution will require at least 75% of the votes exercisable by AHA Shareholders and AHB Shareholders entitled to vote at such combined general meeting be cast in favour thereof, permit the Company's debt gearing levels to exceed 50% of the value of its property portfolio as independently valued from time to time.
- 6.2 The aggregate principal amount at any one time outstanding in respect of moneys borrowed or raised by the Company (other than by way of debentures) and Subsidiaries of the Company (excluding moneys borrowed or raised from any other Subsidiary but including amounts secured by outstanding guarantees or suretyships by the Company or any of its Subsidiaries), shall not exceed the aggregate amount at that time authorised to be borrowed or secured by the directors of the Company's listed holding company in respect of that holding company.
- 6.3 Further information related to the borrowing powers of the directors are set out in Annexure 5.
- 6.4 The directors' borrowing powers have never been exceeded during the previous three years.
- 6.5 There are no exchange control or other restrictions on the borrowing powers of Arrowhead.
7. Interests of directors and promoters
- 7.1 Save as in relation to their holding of Fairvest Shares as disclosed in paragraph 2 above, none of the other directors of Arrowhead will benefit directly or indirectly, in any manner as a consequence of the implementation of the Transaction.
- 7.2 Other than as set out in paragraph 2 above, no directors or proposed directors of Arrowhead, including a director who resigned during the last 18 months, has or had any material beneficial interest, direct or indirect, in any transactions that were effected by Arrowhead during the current or immediately preceding financial year or during any earlier financial year and which remain in any respect outstanding or unperformed.
-
7.3 No amount has been paid, or is accrued as payable, within the preceding three years, or proposed to be paid to any promoter or to any partnership, syndicate or other association of which he is or was a member and no other benefit has been given or proposed to be given to such promoter, partnership, syndicate or other association within the said period.
-
7.4 None of the directors or promoters of Arrowhead have received any material beneficial interest, direct or indirect, in the promotion of the Company and its properties during the three years preceding the Last Practicable Date. This includes a partnership, company, syndicate or other association.
- 7.5 No amount has been paid, or agreed to be paid, within the three years preceding the Last Practicable Date, to any director of Arrowhead or Fairvest, or to any company in which he or she is beneficially interested, directly or indirectly, or of which he or she is a director (the "Associate Company") or to any partnership, syndicate or other association of which he is a member (the "Associate Entity"), in cash, securities or otherwise, by any person, either to induce him to become, or to qualify him as a director or otherwise for services rendered by him or by the Associate Company or the Associate Entity in connection with the promotion of Arrowhead.
8. Directors and proposed directors' declarations
- 8.1 None of the directors of Arrowhead or proposed directors of the Combined Group have been involved in:
- 8.1.1 any bankruptcies, insolvencies or individual voluntary compromise arrangements of such person;
- 8.1.2 any business rescue plans and/or resolution proposed by any entity to commence business rescue proceedings, application having been made for any entity to begin business rescue proceedings, notices having been delivered in terms of section 129(7) of the Companies Act, receiverships, compulsory liquidations, creditors' voluntary liquidations, administrations, company voluntary arrangements or any compromise or arrangement with creditors generally or any class of creditors of any company; where such person is or was a director, with an executive function within such company at the time of, or within the 12 months preceding, any such event(s);
- 8.1.3 any compulsory liquidations, administrations or partnership voluntary arrangements of any partnerships where such person is or was a partner at the time of or within the 12 months preceding such event(s);
- 8.1.4 receiverships of any asset(s) of such person or of a partnership of which the person is or was a partner at the time of, or within the 12 months preceding, such event;
- 8.1.5 any public criticisms of such person by statutory or regulatory authorities, including recognised professional bodies, and whether such person has ever been disqualified by a court from acting as a director of a company or from acting in the management or conduct of the affairs of any company;
- 8.1.6 any offence involving dishonesty committed by such person;
- 8.1.7 a removal from an office of trust, on the grounds of misconduct and involving dishonesty; and
- 8.1.8 any court order declaring such person delinquent or placing him under probation in terms of section 162 of the Act and/or section 47 of the Close Corporations Act, No. 69 of 1984 or disqualifying him to act as a director in terms of section 219 of the Companies Act.
- 8.2 None of the directors of Arrowhead or proposed directors of the Combined Group have been:
- 8.2.1 disqualified by a court from acting as a director of a company, or from acting in the management or conduct of the affairs of any company as described in section 7.B of the Listings Requirements;
- 8.2.2 put into liquidation or been placed under business rescue proceedings or had an administrator or other executor appointed during the period when he/she was (or within the preceding 12 months had been) one of its directors, or alternate directors or equivalent position;
- 8.2.3 adjudged bankrupt or sequestrated in any jurisdiction;
- 8.2.4 a party to a scheme of arrangement or made any other form of compromise with his/her creditors;
- 8.2.5 found guilty in disciplinary proceedings, by an employer or regulatory body, due to dishonest activities;
- 8.2.6 barred from entry into any profession or occupation; and
- 8.2.7 convicted in any jurisdiction of any criminal offence, or an offence under legislation relating to the Companies Act.
9. Terms of office
9.1 A summary of the existing service arrangements between Darren Wilder and Jacques Kriel and Fairvest is set out below:
9.1.1 Darren Wilder
Pursuant to the Fairvest Manco internalisation, Darren Wilder became employed directly by Fairvest as the CEO of Fairvest pursuant to a letter of appointment between Darren Wilder and Fairvest in terms of which, inter alia, the parties agreed to a 24-month lock-in in that employment is terminable on six months' notice but neither party will give notice in the 18 months after commencement of employment.
9.1.2 Jacques Kriel
Jacques Kriel is currently employed by Fairvest as Chief Financial Officer of Fairvest, however currently has no formal written service contract in place with Fairvest.
- 9.2 Details of the remuneration payable to the proposed directors of the Combined Group is set out in paragraph 3.5 of this Annexure 3.
- 9.3 With regards to Darren Wilder and Jacques Kriel, it is anticipated that their existing employment arrangements detailed above with the Combined Group will remain unchanged.
CURRENT AND PAST DIRECTORSHIPS
Current directors of Arrowhead and proposed directors of the Combined Group
The table below lists the companies and partnerships of which each director and proposed director of Arrowhead is currently a director or partner as well as the companies and partnerships of which each such director or proposed director was a director or partner over the five years preceding the Last Practicable Date.
| Current director | Current directorships and partnerships | Past directorships and partnerships held in the last five years |
|---|---|---|
| Mark Kaplan | Arrowhead Properties Limited, Arrowgem Limited, Cumulative Properties Limited, Moolgem Proprietary Limited, Gemgrow Asset Management |
Arrowhead Nominees Proprietary Limited |
| Proprietary Limited, Arrowhead Prop I Proprietary Limited, Vividend Income Fund Limited, Vividend Management Group Proprietary Limited, Clearwater Crossing Proprietary Limited, Fluxrab Investments No. 196 Proprietary Limited, 18FKF Investments Proprietary Limited, ERF 493-497 Morningside Homeowners Association NPC |
Indluplace Properties Limited |
|
| Junaid Limalia | Arrowhead Properties Limited, Arrowgem Limited, Cumulative Properties Limited, Gemgrow Asset Management Proprietary Limited, Moolgem Proprietary Limited, Vividend Income Fund Limited, Educomm Solutions Proprietary Limited, Limalia Property Holdings Proprietary Limited |
– |
| Taffy Adler | Indluplace Properties Limited, Arrowhead Properties Limited, Makhulong a Matala Community Development Services NPC, TUHF21 Proprietary Limited, Braamfontein Improvement District NPC, Umastandi Proprietary Limited, TUFH Limited, TUHF Holdings Limited, TUHF Equity Proprietary Limited, TUHF Bridge Proprietary Limited, Arrowhead Nominees Proprietary Limited |
Arrowgem Limited |
| Arnold Basserabie | Arrowhead Properties Limited, Derbit SA Proprietary Limited, Kalon Venture Partners Proprietary Limited, Kalon Management Company Limited, Kalon Venture Partners Fund II Limited, Kalon Management Company II Limited, Kanvestic Proprietary Limited, Afrika Tikkun NPC, Hard Racquets No. 3 Investments Proprietary Limited, Houghton Community Active Protection NPC, Oak Properties Proprietary Limited, Beyachad Properties Proprietary Limited, Cobra COVID Business Rescue Assistance NPC |
Wits University Donald Gordon Medical Centre Proprietary Limited |
| Gregory Kinross | Arrowhead Properties Limited, Cell Network Proprietary Limited, Copper Sunset Trading 329 Proprietary Limited, Evolve Biosciences SA 1 Proprietary Limited, Evolve Biosciences SA 2 Proprietary Limited, Innovate Strategic Investments 7 Proprietary Limited, Spring Tide Trading Proprietary Limited, Zendascape Proprietary Limited, ERF 774 Morningside Extension 64 Home Owners Association, Impact Plus Trading 150 Proprietary Limited, Innovo Capital Proprietary Limited, Merchant Capital Advisory Services Proprietary Limited, Merchant Capital Debtco (RF) Proprietary Limited, Strongo Proprietary Limited, Lepidocarpodendron CC |
Indluplace Properties Limited, South African Zionist Federation NPC, Genesis Innovo Capital Proprietary Limited, Southern Palace Genesis Proprietary Limited, SP Access Proprietary Limited, Khumo Africa Capital Proprietary Limited |
| Current director | Current directorships and partnerships | Past directorships and partnerships held in the last five years |
|---|---|---|
| Nozipho Makhoba | Arrowhead Properties Limited, Phumelela Real Estate Investments Proprietary Limited, Phumelela Real Estate Holdings Proprietary Limited, Phumelela Real Estate Developments Proprietary Limited, Noz Squared Properties Proprietary Limited, Swiss RE Africa Limited, Acuturex Proprietary Limited |
JHI Retail Proprietary Limited |
| Sam Mokorosi | Arrowhead Properties Limited, Makhulong A Matala Community Development Services Proprietary Limited, JSE Private Placements Proprietary Limited, Asili Beauty Proprietary Limited, Mokorosi Financial Consulting Proprietary Limited, Johannesburg Housing Company |
Arrowgem Limited, Vunani Sponsors Proprietary Limited, Mergence Corporate Solutions Proprietary Limited, Southern Energy Trading Proprietary Limited, Karsam Property Investments Proprietary Limited, Barakabora Products Proprietary Limited |
| Alon Kirkel | Moolgem Proprietary Limited, Kesef Investments Proprietary Limited, Exceptional Diamonds Proprietary Limited, Elancerz Proprietary Limited, Acuity Art Advisory Proprietary Limited, Gemgrow Asset Management Proprietary Limited |
Arrowhead Properties Limited, Arrowgem Limited, K2012190864 Proprietary Limited, Cumulative Properties Limited |
| Riaz Kader | Vividend Income Fund Limited, Arrowhead Prop I Proprietary Limited, Cumulative Properties Limited, Clearwater Crossing Proprietary Limited, Vividend Management Group Proprietary Limited, Fluxrab Investments No. 196 Proprietary Limited, Arrowgem Limited |
Arrowhead Properties Limited |
| Proposed Director | Current directorships and partnerships | Past directorships and partnerships held in the last five years |
|---|---|---|
| Darren Wilder | Erf 4383 Murray House CC, FPP Property Venture 103 Proprietary Limited, Riverside Property Syndication Limited, Fairvest Property Holdings Limited, New Star Asset Management Proprietary Limited, Before The Wind Investments 94 Proprietary Limited |
Bara Precinct Proprietary Limited |
| Jacques Kriel | Qumbu Plaza Proprietary Limited, South View Shopping Centre Proprietary Limited, Libode Shopping Centre Proprietary Limited, Bara Precinct Proprietary Limited, FPP Property Venture 102 Proprietary Limited, FPP Property Venture 103 Proprietary Limited, Parow Valley Centre Proprietary Limited, Macassar Retail Centre Proprietary Limited, Fairvest Property Management Proprietary Limited, Fairvest Properties Two Proprietary Limited, Fairvest Property Holdings Limited, Channelprops 29 Proprietary Limited, Polpoint Share Block Limited, RW Boerdery Proprietary Limited |
Mount Frere Shopping Centre Proprietary Limited |
| Jacques du Toit | Cohesive Capital Proprietary Limited, New Star Asset Management Proprietary Limited, Fairvest Property Management Proprietary Limited, Cohesive Capital CC, Fairvest Properties Two Proprietary Limited, Eight Roses Properties Proprietary Limited, Fairvest Property Holdings Limited, Charlia Eiendomme CC, Spotprops 48 Proprietary Limited, Syndicate 607 CC, Henren Beleggings Proprietary Limited, Panama Holdings Proprietary Limited |
– |
| Louis Andrag | Scarlet Sun 56 Proprietary Limited, Tygervalley Improvement District NPC, Protolith Properties Proprietary Limited, Bellville Church of the Cross Proprietary Limited, Agrico Machinery Proprietary Limited, Ferreira Broers Proprietary Limited, Darling Cellars Proprietary Limited, Drivequip Proprietary Limited, Spotprops 48 Proprietary Limited, Darling Cellars Holdings Proprietary Limited, Fairvest Property Holdings Limited, Anicol Properties Proprietary Limited, Andlou Trading Proprietary Limited, Green Earth Energy Efficient Lighting Manufacturing Proprietary Limited |
Basson Farming Proprietary Limited |
| Ndabezinhle Mkhize |
Fairvest Property Holdings Limited Busamed Proprietary Limited Sire Capital Proprietary Limited IG Markets South Africa Limited (Incorporated in England and Wales) |
– |
| Khegu Nkuna | Phyro Business Investments CC, Izintsikelelo Online Marketing CC, Sunlark High Props Proprietary Limited, Masingita Towers Proprietary Limited, Masingita Facilities Management Services Proprietary Limited, Masingita Jacobs Burnard Proprietary Limited, Eris Masingita Proprietary Limited, Amelocel Proprietary Limited, Zoviblox Proprietary Limited, Izintsikelelo Online Marketing Proprietary Limited, Mahahlwa Debt Collectors Proprietary Limited, Reboni Furniture Factory Proprietary Limited, Sindawonye Granulators and Processors Proprietary Limited, Vlaming Proprietary Limited, Fairvest Property Holdings Limited, Italite Investments Proprietary Limited, Xitlati Investments Holdings Proprietary Limited, Masingita Property Investment Holdings Proprietary Limited, Capstone 632 Proprietary Limited, Marble Gold 182 Proprietary Limited, Ama Casa Props 64 Proprietary Limited, Concl-Usive Mining Components Proprietary Limited, Centuria 368 Proprietary Limited, Masingita Properties No 2 Proprietary Limited, Masingita Property Services Proprietary Limited |
Spring Lights 1184 CC |
Past directorships and partnerships held in the last five years
Proposed Director Current directorships and partnerships
Jacob Wiese Caro Art Proprietary Limited, Southern View Finance SA Holdings Proprietary Limited, Navy Sky Investments 201 Proprietary Limited, Ceta Trading Proprietary Limited, Coala Bear Trading Proprietary Limited, Carbide Resources VC 1 Proprietary Limited, Zenco Investments Proprietary Limited, Fundex Investments Proprietary Limited, JDW Vintage Collection Proprietary Limited, 12 Apostles Properties Proprietary Limited, K2019197451 (South Africa) Proprietary Limited, Shoprite Holdings Limited, VRE Investments Proprietary Limited, Schonegevel Holdings Proprietary Limited, FI Operations Proprietary Limited, Invicta Holdings Limited, Lourensford Fruit Company Proprietary Limited, Dorsland Diamante Proprietary Limited, Titan Share Dealers Proprietary Limited, Wiesfam Trust Proprietary Limited, Tradehold Limited, Toerama Proprietary Limited, Titan Manor Proprietary Limited, Titan Nominees Proprietary Limited, Titan Premier Investments Proprietary Limited, Titan Group Investments Proprietary Limited, Titan Asset Management Proprietary Limited, Worldquest Investment Resources Proprietary Limited, Matrix Development Proprietary Limited, Tomil Holdings Proprietary Limited, Wikalox Investments Proprietary Limited, Titan Global Investments Proprietary Limited, Granadino Investments Proprietary Limited, Cenfund Investments Proprietary Limited, Thibault Square Financial Services Proprietary Limited, Titan Portfolio Proprietary Limited, Titan Financial Services Proprietary Limited, FI Funding And Investments Holdco Proprietary Limited, Brisktrade 113 Proprietary Limited, Fairvest Property Holdings Limited, Lourensford Leasing Proprietary Limited, Lourensford Properties Proprietary Limited, Lourensford Holdings Proprietary Limited, FI Funding And Investments Finance Proprietary Limited, Lourensford Sawmills Proprietary Limited, Radaj 2 Proprietary Limited, Metcap 5 Proprietary Limited, Lourensford Financial Services Proprietary Limited, Lourensford Events Proprietary Limited, Oryx Management Services Proprietary Limited, Oryx Game Farming Proprietary Limited, Luna Group Proprietary Limited, Lourensford Marketing Proprietary Limited, Titan Trademarks Proprietary Limited, Lourensford Winery Proprietary Limited, CWP Wine Brands Proprietary Limited, Xantium Trading 326 Proprietary Limited, Frejen Proprietary Limited, Titan Funding (RF) Proprietary Limited, Seven Seasons Trading 144 Proprietary Limited, Move-On-Up 289 Proprietary Limited, Misty Mountain Trading 86 Proprietary Limited, Afropulse 500 Proprietary Limited, Auburn Avenue Trading 142 Proprietary Limited, Auburn Avenue Trading 144 Proprietary Limited, Alenti 254 Proprietary Limited, Alenti 252 Proprietary Limited, Incaprox Investments Proprietary Limited, Incapart Investments Proprietary Limited, Lavender Sky Investments 38 Proprietary Limited, Lavender Sky Investments 37 Proprietary Limited, Mayborn Investments 143 Proprietary Limited
International Mining and Dredging Holdings Proprietary Limited, Bish Proprietary Limited, Mettle Solar (RF) Proprietary Limited, Amalinde Technologies Proprietary Limited, Steinhoff International Holdings N.V., Cape Town 7 Properties Proprietary Limited, Mettle Solar Investments Proprietary Limited, Tefco Investments Proprietary Limited, Own My Ride Proprietary Limited, Pepkor Holdings Limited, K2019197451 (South Africa) Proprietary Limited, K2020711324 (South Africa) Proprietary Limited, Greenpoint Specialised Lending Proprietary Limited, TTM SA Investments Proprietary Limited, Lourensford Trout Farming Proprietary Limited, Pepkor Holdco Proprietary Limited, Texton Property Fund Limited, Greenpoint Capital Proprietary Limited, Premier Group Proprietary Limited, Auburn Avenue Trading 143 Proprietary Limited, Bon View Trading 164 Proprietary Limited
| Nozipho Makhoba | As above | As above |
|---|---|---|
| Arnold Basserabie | As above | As above |
Current and past directorships of directors of Major Subsidiaries
The table below lists the companies and partnerships of which each director of Indluplace, being a Major Subsidiary of Arrowhead, is currently a director or partner as well as the companies and partnerships of which each such director was a director or partner over the five years preceding the Last Practicable Date.
| Director | Current directorships and partnerships | Past directorships and partnerships held in the last five years |
|---|---|---|
| Petrus Carel de WitIndluplace Properties Limited, Indluplace Property Services Proprietary Limited, Aloegate Proprietary Limited, Aptotrim Proprietary Limited, Barvicarl Investments Proprietary Limited, Helen Joy Holdings Proprietary Limited, NDF Investment and Trading Proprietary Limited, Pondos Investments Proprietary Limited, Sunnyshore Trade and Investment 103 Proprietary Limited, Erf 737 Rosettenville Proprietary Limited, G and N Tarn Enterprises Proprietary Limited, Jika Properties Proprietary Limited, Karavas Proprietary Limited, Kenwyn Flats Proprietary Limited, Earls Den Proprietary Limited, Radzyn Investments Shareblock Proprietary Limited, Teaca Properties Proprietary Limited, Erf 427 Windsor Proprietary Limited, Indluprop I Proprietary Limited, Indluprop II Proprietary Limited, Diluculo Properties Proprietary Limited, Yieldex 7 Proprietary Limited, Yieldex 12 Proprietary Limited, Yieldex 11 Proprietary Limited, Yieldex 10 Proprietary Limited, Unlocked Properties 21 Proprietary Limited, Resico Proprietary Limited, Myso Holdings Proprietary Limited, Ekhaya Neighbourhood City Improvement District NPC, Windsor Community Support Services NPC |
Houghton Mansions Proprietary Limited, Monks Court Proprietary Limited, Park Chambers Share Block Proprietary Limited, Triad Proprietary Limited |
|
| Terence Kaplan | Indluplace Properties Limited, Indluplace Property Services Proprietary Limited, Aloegate Proprietary Limited, Aptotrim Proprietary Limited, Barvicarl Investments Proprietary Limited, Helen Joy Holdings Proprietary Limited, NDF Investment and Trading Proprietary Limited, Pondos Investments Proprietary Limited, Sunnyshore Trade and Investment 103 Proprietary Limited, Erf 737 Rosettenville Proprietary Limited, G and N Tarn Enterprises Proprietary Limited, Jika Properties Proprietary Limited, Karavas Proprietary Limited, Kenwyn Flats Proprietary Limited, Earls Den Proprietary Limited, Radzyn Investments Shareblock Proprietary Limited, Teaca Properties Proprietary Limited, Erf 427 Windsor Proprietary Limited, Indluprop I Proprietary Limited, Indluprop II Proprietary Limited, Diluculo Properties Proprietary Limited, Yieldex 7 Proprietary Limited, Yieldex 12 Proprietary Limited, Yieldex 11 Proprietary Limited, Yieldex 10 Proprietary Limited, Unlocked Properties 21 Proprietary Limited, Resico Proprietary Limited, Myso Holdings Proprietary Limited |
Houghton Mansions Proprietary Limited, Monks Court Proprietary Limited, Park Chambers Share Block Proprietary Limited, Triad Proprietary Limited |
| Grant Harris | Indluplace Properties Limited; Indluplace Property Services Proprietary Limited, Realty Worx Trade and Invest Proprietary Limited, K2015338682 (South Africa) Proprietary Limited, 2015339280 (South Africa) Proprietary Limited |
Wildfire Trading 137 Proprietary Limited, IHS Property Management Proprietary Limited, Anlumax Investments Proprietary Limited, |
| Taffy Adler | As per previous table | As per previous table |
| Selwyn Noik | Indluplace Properties Limited | Arrowhead Properties Limited, Arrowgem Limited |
| Director | Current directorships and partnerships | Past directorships and partnerships held in the last five years |
|---|---|---|
| Ayesha Rehman | Indluplace Properties Limited, Just Toys CC | Arrowhead Properties Limited, ApexHi Properties Limited, Makhulong A Matla Community Development Services, Terrace Road Housing Co-Operative, Dzulani Housing Company Proprietary Limited, Johannesburg Housing Company, Chair of Mitja Investments |
| Clifford Abrams | Indluplace Properties Limited, DEE WhyAre Textiles CC, Alig Financial Services CC, LAS Tax and Secretarial Services CC, Oxbridge Online Limited, RJCA Administration CC, Voltex SA CC, Gemgrow Properties Limited |
Arrowhead Properties Limited, Explorer Group Proprietary Limited, Industrial Credit Company Africa Holdings Limited, Old Co-Fire Control Systems Proprietary Limited |
| Nindiphiwe Tetyana |
Indluplace Properties Limited, Kuhle Konke Primary Agricultural Co operative Limited, Biginsolar Proprietary Limited, Biginsolar OM Proprietary Limited, Lesedi ED NPC, Letsatsi ED NPC, Sankovest Proprietary Limited, Zini Consulting Services Proprietary Limited |
– |
EXTRACTS OF MEMORANDUM OF INCORPORATION OF ARROWHEAD
The salient terms of the MOI are set out below. The details below are a direct extract from the MOI, as amended.
1. Interpretation
- 1.1 "Act" means the Companies Act, No. 71 of 2008, as amended, consolidated or re-enacted from time to time, and includes all schedules to such Act and the regulations;
- 1.2 "A ordinary share" means an A ordinary share of no par value in the share capital of the company having the rights and restrictions set out, inter alia, in clauses 7.2, 34 and 40;
- 1.3 "A ordinary share distribution(s)" means a distribution declared in respect of an A ordinary share calculated with reference to clause 34.4;
- 1.4 "A ordinary shareholder" means the holder of an issued A ordinary share who is entered as such in the securities register, subject to the provisions of section 57;
- 1.5 "B ordinary share" means a B ordinary share of no par value in the share capital of the company having the rights and restrictions set out, inter alia, in clauses 7.2, 34 and 40;
- 1.6 "B ordinary shareholder" means the holder of an issued B ordinary share who is entered as such in the securities register, subject to the provisions of section 57;
- 1.7 "board" means the board of directors from time to time of the company or if there is only one director, then that director;
- 1.8 "business day" means any day excluding a Saturday, Sunday or public holiday in South Africa;
- 1.9 "certificated securities" means securities issued by the company that are not uncertificated securities;
- 1.10 "Central Securities Depositary" has the meaning set out in section 1 of the Financial Markets Act;
- 1.11 "Commission" means the Companies and Intellectual Property Commission established by section 185;
- 1.12 "company" means the company named on the first page of this document, duly incorporated under the registration number endorsed thereon;
- 1.13 "CPI" means the Consumer Price Index for all income groups for all items as published by Statistics South Africa (or its successor-in-title), provided that if the aforesaid Index is discontinued or modified it shall be replaced by such index as determined by the company's auditors from time to time;
- 1.14 "designated date" means either the first designated date or the second designated date as the case may be;
- 1.15 "director" means a member of the board of the company as contemplated in section 66, or an alternate director, and includes any person occupying the position of a director or alternate director, by whatever name designated;
- 1.16 "electronic communication" has the meaning set out in section 1 of the Electronic Communications and Transactions Act, No 25 of 2002;
- 1.17 "file" or "filed" when used as a verb, means to deliver a document to the Commission in the manner and form, if any, prescribed for that document;
- 1.18 "Financial Markets Act" means the Financial Markets Act, 19 of 2012, including any amendment, consolidation or re-enactment thereof;
- 1.19 "financial year" means the twelve month period from 1 October to the last day of September, incorporating the first income period and the second income period;
- 1.20 "first designated date" means 31 March in each year, being the end of the first six months of the financial year;
-
1.21 "first income period" means the six-month period from 1 October to 31 March of each calendar year or such other period as may be determined by the board of directors of the company from time to time;
-
1.22 "IFRS" means the International Financial Reporting Standards, as adopted from time to time by the board of the International Accounting Standards Board from time to time;
- 1.23 "income period" means the first income period or the second income period as the case may be;
- 1.24 "JSE" means the exchange, licensed under the Financial Markets Act, operated by the JSE Limited (Registration number 2005/022939/06), a public company duly incorporated in South Africa;
- 1.25 "JSE Listings Requirements" means the Listings Requirements of the JSE applicable from time to time;
- 1.26 "participant" has the meaning set out in section 1 of the Financial Markets Act;
- 1.27 "prescribed officer" means a person who, within the company, performs any function that has been designated by the Minister in terms of section 66(10), as defined in the Act;
- 1.28 "prime rate" means the publicly quoted prime overdraft rate of interest of the bankers of the company (the "bank") from time to time, nominal annual, compounded monthly as certified by any branch or more senior manager of that bank, whose appointment and designation it shall not be necessary to prove, and whose determination of the rate shall be proof of that rate until the contrary is established;
- 1.29 "redeemable share" means an ordinary redeemable of no par value share in the share capital of the company, having the preferences, rights, limitations and other terms associated with such share, as set out in schedule 1 hereto;
- 1.30 "regulations" means the regulations published in terms of the Act from time to time;
- 1.31 "rules" means any rules made in respect of the company from time to time as contemplated in section 15(3) to (5);
- 1.32 "second designated date" means 30 September in each year, being the end of the second six month period of the financial year;
- 1.33 "second income period" means the six-month period from 1 April to 30 September of each calendar year or such other period as may be determined by the board of directors of the company from time to time;
- 1.34 "securities" means: any share, notes, bonds, debentures or other instruments, irrespective of their form or title, issued, or authorised to be issued, by a profit company for the purpose of raising capital; or anything falling within the meaning of "securities" as set out in section 1 of the Financial Markets Act and includes shares held in a private company;
- 1.35 "securities register" means the register contemplated in section 50(1) and referred to in clause 7.21 hereof;
- 1.36 "SENS" means the Stock Exchange News Service established and operated by the Issuer Regulation Division of the JSE provided that, in the event that the shares or other securities of the company are not listed on the JSE, all the provisions of this Memorandum of Incorporation relating to the publication of notices via SENS shall no longer apply and such notices shall thereafter only be published in accordance with the provisions of the Act;
- 1.37 "share" means one of the units into which the proprietary interest in the company is divided, and includes an "A" ordinary share and/or a "B" ordinary share and/or a "redeemable share" as indicated by the context;
- 1.38 "shareholder" means the holder of a share and who is entered as such in the securities register, subject to the provisions of section 57;
- 1.39 "solvency and liquidity test" has the meaning attributed thereto in section 4;
- 1.40 "South Africa" means the Republic of South Africa;
- 1.41 "sub-register" means the record of uncertificated securities administered and maintained by a participant, which forms part of the company's register of shareholders in terms of the Act;
- 1.42 "trading day" means any day on which the JSE (or any other exchange on which the securities of the company are listed) is open and available for trading;
- 1.43 "uncertificated securities" means any "securities" defined as such in the Financial Markets Act; and
- 1.44 "uncertificated securities register" means the record of uncertificated securities administered and maintained by a participant or Central Securities Depositary, as determined in accordance with the rules of the Central Securities Depositary, and which forms part of the company's securities register established and maintained in terms of the Act.
7. Issue of shares and variation of rights
- 7.1 Subject to any relevant provisions of this Memorandum of Incorporation and without prejudice to any special rights previously conferred on the holders of any existing shares or class of shares in the company, any shares whether in the initial or in any increased capital may be issued with such preferred, deferred, or other special rights or such restrictions, whether in regard to dividend, voting, return of capital or otherwise, as the company may from time to time determine provided however that there shall be no restriction on the transfer of shares, subject to the remaining provisions of this clause 7. Preference shares may be issued and existing shares may, subject to the provisions of clause 7.4.5, be converted into preference shares on the basis that they are, or at the option of the company are liable, to be redeemed on such terms and in such manner as shall be prescribed in this Memorandum of Incorporation or the resolution authorising or effecting such issue or conversion.
- 7.2 The company is authorised to issue:
- 7.2.1 1 000 000 000 A ordinary shares each of which ranks pari passu in respect of all rights with the other A ordinary shares;
- 7.2.2 2 000 000 000 B ordinary shares, each of which ranks pari passu in respect of all rights with the other B ordinary shares; and
- 7.2.3 such number of each of such further classes of shares as are set out in schedule 1 hereto subject to the preferences, rights, limitations and other terms associated with each such class set out therein.
- 7.3 Save as provided in this clause 7, clause 34 and clause 40 of this Memorandum of Incorporation, all issued shares shall rank pari passu in all respects.
- 7.4 The board shall not have the power to:
- 7.4.1 create any class of shares; or
- 7.4.2 increase or decrease the number of authorised shares of any class of the company's shares; or
- 7.4.3 consolidate and reduce the number of the company's issued and authorised shares of any class; or
- 7.4.4 subdivide its shares of any class by increasing the number of its issued and authorised shares of that class without an increase of its capital; or
- 7.4.5 convert one class of shares into one or more other classes, save where a right of conversion attaches to the class of shares created; or
- 7.4.6 reclassify any classified shares that have been authorised but not issued; or
- 7.4.7 classify any unclassified shares that have been authorised but not issued; or
- 7.4.8 change the name of the company; or
- 7.4.9 vary any preferences, rights, limitations or other terms of any shares, and such powers shall only be capable of being exercised by the shareholders by way of a special resolution of the shareholders in general meeting, which for the avoidance of doubt shall be a combined general meeting of all shareholders, subject to the statutes, the JSE and the remaining provisions of this Memorandum of Incorporation.
- 7.5 Each share issued by the company has associated with it an irrevocable right of the shareholder to vote on any proposal to amend the preferences, rights, limitations and other terms associated with that share.
-
7.6 Subject to and without limitation to the provisions of clause 7.4, 7.8 and 7.20, the authorisation and classification of shares, the creation of any class of shares, the conversion of one class of shares into one or more other classes (unless otherwise provided by the terms of issue of the shares of that class), the consolidation of securities, the sub-division of securities, the change of the name of the company, the increase of number of shares, and the variation of any preferences, rights, limitations and other terms associated with each class of shares as set out in this Memorandum of Incorporation may be changed only by an amendment of this Memorandum of Incorporation by special resolution of the shareholders at a combined general meeting and in accordance with the JSE Listings Requirements, to the extent required, save if such an amendment is ordered by a court in terms of section 16(1)(a) and 16(4).
-
7.7 Notwithstanding anything to the contrary contained herein, the variation of any preference, rights, limitations and other terms associated with any class of shares as set out in this Memorandum of Incorporation may be enacted only by an amendment of this Memorandum of Incorporation by special resolution of the shareholders at a combined general meeting and such amendments shall not be implemented without a special resolution taken by the holders of shares in that class at a separate meeting. In such instances the holders of such shares will also be allowed to vote at the combined general meeting of shareholders, subject to clause 20.2.
- 7.8 No shares may be authorized in respect of which the preferences, rights, limitations or any other terms of any class of shares may be varied in response to any objectively ascertainable external fact or facts as provided for in sections 37(6) and 37(7) and the powers of the board are limited accordingly.
- 7.9 The company may only issue shares which are fully paid up and freely transferable and only within the classes and to the extent that those shares have been authorised by or in terms of this Memorandum of Incorporation.
- 7.10 The board may, subject to clauses 7.11 and 7.16, resolve to issue shares of the company at any time, but only within the classes and to the extent that those shares have been authorised by or in terms of this Memorandum of Incorporation.
- 7.11 Subject to clauses 7.10 and 7.16, the board may not issue unissued shares unless such shares have first been offered to existing shareholders of the shares of that class in proportion to their shareholding of that class of shares (on such terms and in accordance with such procedures as the board may determine), unless the relevant issue of shares:
- 7.11.1 is a capitalisation issue to all shareholders in accordance with the provisions of clause 13; or
- 7.11.2 is for the acquisition of assets, is a vendor consideration placing related to an acquisition of assets, or is an issue for the purposes of an amalgamation or merger; or
- 7.11.3 is an issue pursuant to options or conversion rights; or
- 7.11.4 is an issue in terms of an approved share incentive scheme; or
- 7.11.5 is an issue of shares for cash (as contemplated in the JSE Listings Requirements), which has been approved by the shareholders by ordinary resolution, either by way of a general authority (which may be either conditional or unconditional) to issue shares in its discretion or a specific authority in respect of any particular issue of shares, in accordance with the JSE Listings Requirements, provided that, if such approval is in the form of a general authority to the directors, it shall be valid only until the next annual general meeting of the company or for 15 months from the date of the passing of the ordinary resolution, whichever is the earlier, and it may be varied or revoked by any general meeting of the shareholders prior to such annual general meeting or the expiry of the aforesaid 15-month period; or
- 7.11.6 otherwise falls within a category in respect of which it is not, in terms of the JSE Listings Requirements, a requirement for the relevant shares to be so offered to existing shareholders of that class; or
- 7.11.7 is otherwise undertaken in accordance with an authority approved by ordinary shareholders in general meeting, provided that if any fraction of a share will have to be issued pursuant to such an offer, the treatment of such fraction of a share and any associated payment to shareholders will be governed by the JSE Listings Requirements.
- 7.16 Notwithstanding anything to the contrary contained in this Memorandum of Incorporation, any issue of shares, securities convertible into shares, or rights exercisable for shares in a transaction, or a series of integrated transactions shall, in accordance with the provisions of section 41(3), require the approval of the shareholders by special resolution if the voting power of the class of shares that are issued or are issuable as a result of the transaction or series of integrated transactions will be equal to or exceed 30% (thirty percent) of the voting power of all the shares of that class held by shareholders immediately before that transaction or series of integrated transactions.
- 7.17 Except to the extent that any such right is specifically included as one of the rights, preferences or other terms upon which any class of shares is issued or otherwise provided in this Memorandum of Incorporation, no shareholder shall have any pre-emptive or other similar preferential right to be offered or to subscribe for any additional shares in the unissued share capital of the company.
-
7.18 For so long as there are both A and B ordinary shares in issue by the company, unless otherwise agreed to by ordinary resolution of the holders of A ordinary shares in general meeting, the total number of A ordinary shares in issue may never exceed the total number of B ordinary shares in issue.
-
7.19 In addition to the provisions of clause 7.7 and notwithstanding anything to the contrary contained in this Memorandum of Incorporation, no resolution of shareholders or resolution of the board of directors either converting A ordinary shares to B ordinary shares or vice versa or into any other class of shares, or in terms of which any class of shares is redeemed in whole or in part, shall be of any force or effect, unless with the consent or resolution passed in the same manner as a special resolution of both the holders of the A ordinary shares and the B ordinary shares taken at a separate general meeting of the A ordinary shareholders and a separate general meeting of the B ordinary shareholders. The provisions of this Memorandum of Incorporation relating to a general meeting shall mutatis mutandis apply to any such separate general meeting except that:
- 7.19.1 the necessary quorum shall be a shareholder or shareholders of the class present in person, or represented by proxy and holding in excess of 50% of the capital paid or credited as paid on the issued shares of that class;
- 7.19.2 if at any adjourned meeting of such holders a quorum as above defined is not present, those holders who are present shall be a quorum; and
- 7.19.3 any holder of shares of the class present in person or represented by proxy may demand a poll and, on a poll, shall have 1 vote for each share of the class of which he is the holder.
- 7.20 Securities in each class for which a listing is applied on the JSE must rank pari passu in respect of all rights.
- 7.21 The A ordinary shares may be redeemed, in whole or in part, pro rata or otherwise, on or after 14 December 2016, by way of a resolution of the board of directors (the "redemption resolution"), provided that the board shall not be authorised to pass a redemption resolution without the consent of a resolution of shareholders at a combined general meeting, which resolution will require at least 75% of the combined votes exercisable by A ordinary shareholders and B ordinary shareholders present in person or by proxy or representative and entitled to vote at such combined general meeting being cast in favour thereof. If so redeemed by way of redemption resolution, the A ordinary shares shall be redeemed by the company at the volume weighted average sales price of an A ordinary share (as shown by the official price list published by the JSE) over the 60 trading days immediately preceding the date on which the redemption resolution is passed. The procedure to be followed by the company in regard to the redemption shall be determined by the company at the appropriate time and be approved by the JSE. Not less than 6 weeks' notice of redemption shall be given to all A ordinary shareholders prior to any redemption being effected. Any redemption of the A ordinary shares shall be effected in accordance with the timetable determined in terms of the JSE Listings Requirements.
18. Meetings of shareholders
- 18.7 Each annual general meeting of the company contemplated in clause 18.5 or any special general meeting of the Company may provide for the passing and adoption of special resolutions, contemplated in clauses 27.1 and 27.4 of this Memorandum of Incorporation, relating to the following business:
- 18.7.1 the determination of Directors' remuneration for the 2 (two) year period following the annual general meeting or special general meeting at which the resolution is approved; and
- 18.7.2 the granting of financial assistance in terms of section 45.
- 18.11 Not less than 15 business days' notice shall be delivered to all shareholders registered at the date of issue of the notice of meetings called for the passing of a special resolution and not less than 15 business days' notice shall be delivered to all shareholders for the passing of an ordinary resolution, calculated as of the record date for the meeting as determined under clause 16. Notices of general or annual general meetings are to be delivered to each person entitled to vote at such meeting who has elected to receive such documents.
- 18.12 The quorum requirement for a meeting of shareholders to begin or for a matter to be considered are at least three shareholders present in person. In addition, the quorum requirement for a meeting of shareholders is as set out in section 64(1) and accordingly:
- 18.12.1 a meeting of shareholders may not begin until sufficient persons are present at the meeting to exercise, in aggregate, at least 25% of the voting rights that are entitled to be exercised in respect of at least one matter to be decided at the meeting; and
- 18.12.2 a matter to be decided at a meeting of shareholders may not begin to be considered unless sufficient persons are present at the meeting to exercise, in aggregate, at least 25% of all of the voting rights that are entitled to be exercised in respect of that matter at the time the matter is called on the agenda.
20. Votes of shareholders
- 20.1 Subject to any special rights or restrictions as to voting attached to any shares by or in accordance with this Memorandum of Incorporation, at a meeting of the company:
- 20.1.1 every shareholder present and entitled to exercise voting rights shall be entitled to one vote on a show of hands, irrespective of the number of voting rights that shareholder would otherwise be entitled to exercise; and
- 20.1.2 on a poll any person who is present at the meeting, whether as a shareholder or as proxy for a shareholder, has the number of votes determined in accordance with the voting rights associated with the shares held by that shareholder. No objection shall be raised to the admissibility of any vote except at the meeting or adjourned meeting at which the vote objected to is or may be given or tendered and every vote not disallowed at such meeting shall be valid for all purposes. Any such objection shall be referred to the chairperson of the meeting, whose decision shall be final and conclusive;
- 20.1.3 the holders of securities other than "A" and "B" ordinary shares shall not be entitled to vote on any resolution at a meeting of shareholders, except as provided in clause 20.2.
- 20.2 The holders of shares, other than "A" and "B" ordinary shares or any shares created for the purpose of black economic empowerment in terms of the Broad-Based Black Economic Empowerment Act, 53 of 2003 or the Broad-Based Black Economic Empowerment Codes of Good Practice, ("affected shareholders") shall not be entitled to vote on any resolution taken by the company other than:
- 20.2.1 during any special period, as provided for in clause 20.2.3 below, during which any dividend, any part of any dividend on such shares or any redemption payment thereon remains in arrears and unpaid; and/or
- 20.2.2 in regard to any resolution proposed for the winding-up of the company or the reduction of its capital;
- 20.2.3 the period referred to in clause 20.2.1 above shall be the period commencing on a day specified in this Memorandum of Incorporation, if any, not being more than six months after the due date of the dividend or redemption payment in question or, where no due date is specified, after the end of the financial year of the company in respect of which such dividend accrued or such redemption payment became due;
and provided that where the shares held by such affected shareholders ("affected shares") are entitled to vote, they shall not carry any special rights or privileges and the affected shareholder shall be entitled to one vote for every affected share held provided that the total voting rights of the affected shareholders in respect of the affected shares shall not be more than 24,99% (twenty-four comma ninety-nine percent) of the total voting rights of all shareholders at such meeting.
- 20.3 Voting shall be conducted by means of a polled vote in respect of any matter to be voted on at a meeting of shareholders if a demand is made for such a vote by:
- 20.3.1 at least five persons having the right to vote on that matter, either as shareholders or as proxies representing shareholders; or
- 20.3.2 a shareholder who is, or shareholders who together are, entitled, as shareholders or proxies representing shareholders, to exercise at least 10% of the voting rights entitled to be voted on that matter; or
- 20.3.3 the chairperson of the meeting.
22. Resolutions of shareholders
- 22.1 For an ordinary resolution to be approved it must be supported by more than 50% of the voting rights of shareholders exercised on the resolution, as provided in section65(7), unless otherwise stated in this Memorandum of Incorporation. Notwithstanding the aforegoing, to the extent that the JSE Listings Requirements requires the support of a higher percentage of voting rights to be exercised in respect of any ordinary resolution, the company shall not implement such ordinary resolution unless such ordinary resolution is supported by the higher percentage of voting rights of shareholders required to be exercised on that resolution in terms of the JSE Listings Requirements.
- 22.2 For a special resolution to be approved it must be supported by the holders of at least 75% of the voting rights exercised on the resolution, as provided in section 65(9).
- 22.3 No matters, except
-
22.3.1 those matters set out in section 65(11); and
-
22.3.2 any other matter required by the Act or this Memorandum of Incorporation to be resolved by means of a special resolution; or
- 22.3.3 for so long as the company's securities are listed on the JSE, any other matter required by the JSE Listings Requirements to be resolved by means of a special resolution in terms of the JSE Listings Requirements, require a special resolution adopted at a meeting of shareholders of the company.
- 22.4 In the event that any shareholder abstains from voting in respect of any resolution, such shareholder will, for the purposes of determining the number of votes exercised in respect of that resolution, be deemed not to have exercised a vote in respect thereof (i.e. that shareholders' votes will neither be included in the aggregate number of votes cast nor in the total number of votes exercised in favour of or against that resolution).
24. Composition and powers of the board of directors
- 24.1 The board must comprise at least four directors (or such greater number of directors, if any, that the company must have to satisfy any requirement in terms of the Act to appoint an audit committee and a social and ethics committee), and the shareholders shall be entitled to determine such maximum number of directors as they from time to time shall consider appropriate.
- 24.2 Subject to clauses 24.3, 24.4 and 24.5, all directors shall be elected by an ordinary resolution of the shareholders at a general or annual general meeting of the company and no appointment of a director in accordance with a resolution passed in terms of section 60 shall be valid.
- 24.9 Apart from satisfying the qualification and eligibility requirements set out in section 69 of the Act, a person need not satisfy any eligibility requirements or qualifications to become or remain a director or a prescribed officer of the company.
- 24.10 A director shall cease to hold office as such if:
- 24.10.1 he becomes insolvent, or assigns his estate for the benefit of his creditors, or suspends payment or files a petition for the liquidation of his affairs, or compounds generally with his creditors;
- 24.10.2 he becomes of unsound mind;
- 24.10.3 in the case of an executive director who is an employee of the company, his employment relationship with the company is terminated for whatsoever reason, including but not limited to, resignation, retirement, misconduct or otherwise;
- 24.10.4 he is prohibited from being, is removed as or is disqualified from acting as a director of a company in terms of the Act;
- 24.10.5 he is required to do so in terms of the JSE Listings Requirements;
- 24.10.6 subject to section 71, he absents himself from meetings of the board for 6 (six) consecutive months without the leave of the other directors and is not represented at such meetings during such 6 (six) months by an alternate director, and the directors resolve that his office shall be vacated, provided that the directors shall have the power to grant any director leave of absence for an indefinite period;
- 24.10.7 he has given 1 (one) month's (or with the permission of the directors, a lesser period) notice in writing of his intention to resign;
- 24.10.8 he is removed under clause 24.11; or
- 24.10.9 the board resolved to remove him in accordance with section 71(3).
- 24.11 The company may by ordinary resolution in accordance with clause 24.10.8 and section 71(2), remove any director before the expiration of his period of office and by an ordinary resolution elect another person in his stead. The person so elected shall hold office until the next annual general meeting of the company and shall then retire and be eligible for re-election.
- 24.12 The directors shall rotate in accordance with the following provisions of this clause 24.12:
- 24.12.1 at each annual general meeting referred to in clause 18.5, 1⁄3 (one third) of the directors for the time being, or if their number is not 3 or a multiple of 3, the number nearest to 1⁄3 (one third), but not less than 1⁄3 (one third), shall retire from office;
-
24.12.2 the directors to retire in every year shall be those who have been longest in office since their last election, but as between persons who became directors on the same day, those to retire shall, unless they otherwise agree among themselves, be determined by lot;
-
24.12.3 a retiring director shall be eligible for re-election;
- 24.12.4 a retiring director shall act as a director throughout the annual general meeting at which he retires;
- 24.12.5 the company, at the general meeting at which a director retires in the above manner, or at any other general meeting, may fill the vacancy by electing a person thereto, provide that the company shall not be entitled to fill the vacancy in accordance with clause 23;
- 24.12.6 if at any meeting at which an election of directors ought to take place the offices of the retiring directors are not filled, unless it is expressly resolved not to fill such vacancies, the meeting shall stand adjourned and the further provisions of this Memorandum of Incorporation, including clauses 18.13 to 18.16 (inclusive) will apply, mutatis mutandis, to such adjournment, and if at such adjourned meeting the vacancies are not filled, the retiring directors, or such of them as have not had their offices filled, shall be deemed to have been re-elected at such adjourned meeting.
- 24.20 A director may hold any other office or place of profit under the company (except that of auditor or company secretary) or any subsidiary of the company in conjunction with the office of director, provided that the appointment, duration and remuneration (in addition to the remuneration to which he may be entitled as a director) in respect of such other office must be determined by a disinterested quorum of directors.
- 24.21 A director of the company may be employed in any other capacity in the company or as a director or employee of a company controlled by or itself a major subsidiary of the company and, in such event, his appointment and remuneration in respect of such other office must be determined by a disinterested quorum of directors.
27. Directors' compensation and financial assistance
- 27.1 The company may pay remuneration to the directors for their services as directors in accordance with a special resolution approved by the company's shareholders within the previous two years, as set out in section 66(8) and (9), and the power of the company in this regard is not limited or restricted by this Memorandum of Incorporation.
- 27.2 Any director who:
- 27.2.1 serves on any executive or other committee; or
- 27.2.2 devotes special attention to the business of the company; or
- 27.2.3 goes or resides outside South Africa for the purpose of the company; or
- 27.2.4 otherwise performs or binds himself to perform services which, in the opinion of the directors, are outside the scope of the ordinary duties of a director, may be paid such extra remuneration or allowances in addition to or in substitution of the remuneration to which he may be entitled as a director, as a disinterested quorum of the directors may from time to time determine.
- 27.3 The directors may also be paid all their travelling and other expenses necessarily incurred by them in connection with:
- 27.3.1 the business of the company; and
- 27.3.2 attending meetings of the directors or of committees of the directors of the company.
- 27.4 The board may, as contemplated in section 45, authorise the company to provide financial assistance to a director, prescribed officer or other person referred to in section 45(2), and the power of the board in this regard is not limited or restricted by this Memorandum of Incorporation.
28. Chief executive officer
- 28.1 The directors may from time to time appoint one or more of their body to the office of chief executive officer for such term and at such remuneration as they may think fit, and may revoke such appointment subject to the terms of any agreement entered into in any particular case, provided that the period of office of a chief executive officer appointed in terms of an agreement shall be for a maximum period of five years at any one time. A director so appointed shall be subject to retirement in the same manner as the other directors, and his appointment shall terminate if he ceases for any reason to be a director.
- 28.2 Subject to the provisions of any contract between himself and the company, a chief executive officer shall be subject to the same provisions as to disqualification and removal as the other directors of the company.
28.3 The directors may from time to time entrust to and confer upon a chief executive officer for the time being such of the powers exercisable in terms of this Memorandum of Incorporation by the directors as they may think fit, and may confer such powers for such time and to be exercised for such objects and purposes, and upon such terms and conditions, and with such restrictions, as they think expedient; and they may confer such powers either collaterally with or to the exclusion of and in substitution for all or any of the powers of the directors in that behalf, and may from time to time revoke, withdraw, alter or vary all or any of such powers.
30. Borrowing powers
- 30.1 Subject to the provisions of clause 30.3, all other provisions of this Memorandum of Incorporation the directors may from time to time:
- 30.1.1 borrow for the purpose of the company such sums as they think fit;
- 30.1.2 secure the payment or repayment of any such sums or any other sum, as they think fit, whether by the creation and issue of debentures, mortgage or charge upon all or any of the property or assets of the company;
- 30.1.3 make such regulations regarding the issue and transfer of debentures and all such other matters incidental to the debentures as the directors think fit, provided that the directors shall not, without the consent of a resolution of shareholders in a combined general meeting which resolution will require at least 75% of the votes exercisable by A ordinary shareholders and B ordinary shareholders entitled to vote at such combined general meeting be cast in favour thereof, permit the company's debt gearing levels to exceed 50% of the value of its property portfolio as independently valued from time to time.
- 30.2 No special privileges as to:
- 30.2.1 allotment of shares in the company; or
- 30.2.2 the attending and voting at general meetings; or
- 30.2.3 the appointment of directors, or otherwise, shall be given to the holders of debentures of the company except with the sanction of the shareholders in general meeting.
- 30.3 The directors shall procure (but as regards subsidiaries of the company only insofar as by the exercise of voting and other rights or powers of control exercisable by the company they can procure) that the aggregate principal amount at any one time outstanding in respect of moneys so borrowed or raised by -
- 30.3.1 the company (other than by way of debentures); and
- 30.3.2 all the subsidiaries for the time being of the company (excluding moneys borrowed or raised by any of such companies from any other of such companies but including the principal amount secured by any outstanding guarantees or suretyships given by the company or any of its subsidiaries for the time being for the share capital or indebtedness of any other company or companies whatsoever and not already included in the aggregate amount of the moneys so borrowed or raised), shall not exceed the aggregate amount at that time authorised to be borrowed or secured by the directors of the company's listed holding company (if any) in respect of that holding company.
34. Distributions
- 34.1 If the company resolves to declare a distribution to shareholders in respect of any income period, no such distribution may be declared by the company in respect of the B ordinary shares for such income period until the A ordinary share distribution has been declared in respect of the A ordinary shares for that income period, and no such distribution shall be paid by the company in respect of the B ordinary shares for such income period unless the relevant A ordinary share distribution has been paid.
- 34.2 The A ordinary shares shall not confer on the A ordinary shareholders the right to any distributions other than the A ordinary share distributions.
- 34.3 If the company resolves to declare a distribution to shareholders in respect of any income period, such distribution shall be paid no later than four months after the designated date in question or such shorter period as may be prescribed in terms of the JSE Listings Requirements.
- 34.4 The A ordinary share distribution for the A ordinary shares shall be calculated as follows:
-
34.4.1 in respect of the financial year ending 30 September 2018:
-
34.4.1.1 for the three months commencing 1 January 2018 and ending 31 March 2018, a distribution per A ordinary share equivalent to 105% of the distribution in respect of the equivalent period for the immediately preceding financial year;
- 34.4.1.2 for the second income period ending 30 September 2018, a distribution per A ordinary share equivalent to the A ordinary share distribution for the 6 months ended 30 September 2017 escalated by an amount equal to the lesser of 5% and the most recently available CPI figure;
- 34.4.2 in respect of the financial year ending 30 September 2019 and thereafter:
- 34.4.2.1 for the first income period, a distribution per A ordinary share equivalent to the prior year's A ordinary share distribution for the first income period, escalated by an amount equal to the lesser of 5% and the most recently available CPI figure;
- 34.4.2.2 for the second income period, a distribution per A ordinary share equivalent to the prior year's A ordinary share distribution for the second income period, escalated by an amount equal to the lesser of 5% and the most recently available CPI figure;
- 34.4.3 In the event that the company declares a distribution in an amount less than those amounts as determined in clauses 34.4.1 and/or 34.4.2 then in such event that lesser amount shall be paid for that period, apportioned pro rata to each "A" ordinary share in issue on the relevant record date. In the event that the "A" ordinary share distribution is less than the amount provided in clauses 34.4.1 and/or 34.4.2, as the case may be the difference in the amount paid and that which would have been payable in terms of clauses 34.4.1 and/or 34.4.2 as applicable, shall not accrue or accumulate to the "A" ordinary shareholders and there shall be no right to claim any shortfall.
- 34.4.4 In determining the A ordinary share distribution with reference to any prior period's distribution, the prior period's distribution shall be the determined or calculated distribution for the equivalent period in the prior year calculated in terms of clauses 34.4.1 and/or 34.4.2 , whether or not such amount was paid having regard to the availability of funds.
- 34.5 The directors of the company shall for the purposes of calculation, be entitled in their discretion (subject to the statutes and the JSE Listings Requirements) to ignore or round off downward fractions of a cent in effecting payment of any A ordinary share distribution.
- 34.6 If there is any change in the financial year of the company, the company shall be and it is hereby authorised to change the dates from which A ordinary share distributions are calculated, fall due, accrue and/or become payable, provided that:
- 34.6.1 the rights of A ordinary shareholders to A ordinary share distributions on their A ordinary shares shall not be diminished or adversely affected by such changes; and
- 34.6.2 the company shall forthwith notify A ordinary shareholders of any changes made by notice in terms of clause 37 or if the A ordinary shares are listed on the JSE or any other exchange, on SENS (if listed on the JSE) or any other news service of the relevant exchange and in such other manner prescribed by the relevant exchange.
- 34.7 Any A ordinary share distribution declared but not paid on the due date therefor, shall bear interest from such date up to the date of payment (excluding date of payment), calculated and compounded on a daily basis at the Prime Rate plus 2%.
- 34.8 Distributions shall be declared by the directors in accordance with the Act.
- 34.9 Distributions may be declared either free of or subject to the deduction of income tax and any other tax or duty in respect of which the company may be chargeable.
- 34.10 Subject to clause 34.7 above, no distribution shall bear interest against the company, except as otherwise provided under the conditions of issue of the shares in respect of which such distribution is payable.
- 34.11 Subject to clause 34.4, the directors may from time to time declare and pay to the shareholders such interim distributions as the directors consider to be justified by the profits of the company.
-
34.12 All unclaimed dividends will be held by or on behalf of the company in trust for the benefit of the shareholder concerned until claimed, provided that, subject to the provisions of the Prescription Act, 68 of 1969, as amended from time to time and any other applicable laws of prescription, monies unclaimed for a period of 3 (three) years from the date on which they were declared (or such longer period as may be required under the laws of prescription) may be declared forfeited by the directors for the benefit of the company. The directors may at any time annul such forfeiture upon such conditions (if any) as they think fit.
-
34.18 A distribution may also be paid in any other way determined by the directors, and if the directives of the directors in that regard are complied with, the company shall not be liable for any loss or damage which a shareholder may suffer as a result thereof.
- 34.19 Any distribution may be paid wholly or in part:
- 34.19.1 by the distribution of specific assets; or
- 34.19.2 by the issue of shares, debentures or securities of the company or of any other company; or
- 34.19.3 in cash; or
- 34.19.4 in any other way which the directors or the company in general meeting may at the time of declaring the distribution determine.
- 34.20 Subject to the remaining provisions of this clause 34, where any difficulty arises in regard to such distribution, the directors may settle that difficulty as they think expedient, and in particular may fix the value which shall be placed on such specific assets on distribution.
- 34.21 The directors may:
- 34.21.1 determine that cash payments shall be made to any shareholder on the basis of the value so fixed in order to secure equality of distribution; and
- 34.21.2 vest any such assets in trustees upon such trusts for the benefit of the persons entitled to the distribution as the directors deem expedient.
- 34.22 All dividends must be made payable to shareholders registered as at a date subsequent to the date of declaration of the dividend or the date of confirmation of the dividend, whichever is the later date.
- 34.23 Payments to shareholders shall be made in accordance with the JSE Listings Requirements and must not provide that capital shall be repaid upon the basis that it may be called up again.
40. Subordination of B ordinary shares and repayment waterfall on winding-up of the company
If the company is wound up, the assets remaining after payment of debts and liabilities of the company and the costs of the liquidation shall be applied as follows:
Firstly:
40.1 each of the A ordinary shareholders shall be entitled to an amount equal to the volume weighted average traded sales price of an A ordinary share (as shown by the official price list published by the JSE) over the 60 trading days immediately preceding the date of publication of any announcement detailing events relating to such winding up;
thereafter:
40.2 each of the B ordinary shareholders shall be entitled to receive any surplus of such monies available for distribution.
DETAILS OF THE PROPERTY MANAGERS
1. Property managers of the Arrowhead property portfolio
| Name: | Excellerate Real Estate Services Proprietary Limited (Registration number 2007/021131/07) trading as JHI, part of Cushman and Wakefield Excellerate |
|---|---|
| Address: | Excellerate on Summit, 3A Summit Road, Dunkeld West, 2196 |
| Shareholder(s): | Excellerate Property Services Proprietary Limited (Registration number 2007/014372/07) |
| Directors: | Marna van der Walt, James Ernst Wellsted and Nomfundo Nomkosi Nomzamo Radebe |
| Functions performed: | JHI performs all duties that may be reasonably required of a manager and administrator of a property portfolio, including without limitation: • Budgets • Collectible income • Credit control • Leasing management • Maintenance and technical management • Account payments • Reporting and • Control procedures |
The property management agreements will be available for inspection in terms of paragraph 9 of Section 4.
2. Property managers of the Fairvest property portfolio
| Name: Address: |
Broll Property Group Proprietary Limited (Registration number 2008/027519/07) Sixty One Katherine, 61 Katherine St, Sandown, Johannesburg, 2196 (PO Box 1455, Saxonwold, Gauteng, 2132) |
|---|---|
| Shareholder(s): | Malcolm Horne (as to 4%) BPG Seventy Four Proprietary Limited (as to 76%) K2019597625 (South Africa) (RF) Proprietary Limited (as to 20%) |
| Directors: | Jonathan David Broll Malcolm Jeffrey Horne Elscke Badenhorst Fariyal Mukaddam Royden David du Plooy |
| Functions performed: | To oversee, report on and manage the following processes and procedures: • Strategies, management and mandates • Control procedures • Leasing management and strategy • Deposits • Leases • Tenant installations • Invoices and monthly statements • Local authorities, electricity, water, refuse and sanitation • Expenses and disbursements • Credit control • Inspections, building works, maintenance, repairs and supervision • Compliance with laws and regulations • Arrears and legal matters • Records, financial reports, reporting and budgets • Receipting • Books of account • Tenants, tenant's association, rules and promotions |
| Name: Address: Shareholder(s): Directors: |
Mainstream Property Group Proprietary Limited (Registration number: 2006/002364/07) 73 Richefond Circle, Ridgeside, Umhlanga, 4319 David Button (as to 30%) Ivan Morris (as to 30%) Lee-Ann Reid (as to 30%) Khanyi Mthethwa (as to 10%) David Thurston Lee-Ann Reid Ivan Henry Morris Cornelia Nokanyiso Mthethwa |
|---|---|
| Functions performed: | To oversee, report on and manage the following processes and procedures: • Strategies, management and mandates • Control procedures • Leasing management and strategy • Deposits • Leases • Tenant installations • Invoices and monthly statements • Local authorities, electricity, water, refuse and sanitation • Expenses and disbursements • Credit control • Inspections, building works, maintenance, repairs and supervision • Compliance with laws and regulations • Arrears and legal matters • Records, financial reports, reporting and budgets • Receipting • Books of account • Tenants, tenants' association, rules and promotions |
| Name: Address: Shareholder(s): |
Axis Asset Management Proprietary Limited (Registration number: 2011/102928/07) 125 Buitengracht Street, Cape Town, 8000 Gregor Klotz (as to 50%) Ronen Mazor (as to 50%) |
| Directors: Functions performed: |
Gregor Klotz To oversee, report on and manage the following processes and procedures: • Strategies, management and mandates • Control procedures • Leasing management and strategy • Deposits • Leases • Tenant installations • Invoices and monthly statements • Local authorities, electricity, water, refuse and sanitation • Expenses and disbursements • Credit control • Inspections, building works, maintenance, repairs and supervision • Compliance with laws and regulations • Arrears and legal matters • Records, financial reports, reporting and budgets • Receipting • Books of account • Tenants, tenants' association, rules and promotions |
| Name: | Abreal Proprietary Limited (Registration number: 1991/004365/07) |
|---|---|
| Address: | Abcon House, Fairway Office Park, 52 Grosvenor Road, Bryanston, 2021 |
| Shareholder(s): | Abman Proprietary Limited Cert No. 18 (as to 25%) |
| Abman Proprietary Limited Cert No. 21 (as to 24%) | |
| Abman Proprietary Limited Cert No. 22 (as to 51%) | |
| Directors: | Christiaan Johannes de Wet |
| David Stanley Savage | |
| Functions performed: | To oversee, report on and manage the following processes and procedures: |
| • Strategies, management and mandates |
|
| • Control procedures |
|
| • Leasing management and strategy |
|
| • Deposits • Leases |
|
| • Tenant installations |
|
| • Invoices and monthly statements |
|
| • Local authorities, electricity, water, refuse and sanitation |
|
| • Expenses and disbursements |
|
| • Credit control |
|
| • Inspections, building works, maintenance, repairs and supervision |
|
| • Compliance with laws and regulations |
|
| • Arrears and legal matters |
|
| • Records, financial reports, reporting and budgets |
|
| • Receipting |
|
| • Books of account |
|
| • Tenants, tenants' association, rules and promotions |
|
| Name: | AJ Property Holdings Proprietary Limited (Registration number: 2017/168593/07) |
| Address: | Suite 2, Block B, Albert Lourens Park 793 King Cetshwayo Highway Sherwood, |
| Durban, 4000 | |
| Shareholder(s): | Ibex Property Holdings (as to 50%) |
| Yakov Yehohanan (as to 50%) | |
| Directors: | Jaco Odendaal |
| Shaun Welgemoed | |
| Albert Lourens | |
| Functions performed: | To oversee, report on and manage the following processes and procedures: |
| • Strategies, management and mandates |
|
| • Control procedures |
|
| • Leasing management and strategy |
|
| • Deposits |
|
| • Leases |
|
| • Tenant installations • Invoices and monthly statements |
|
| • Local authorities, electricity, water, refuse and sanitation |
|
| • Expenses and disbursements |
|
| • Credit control |
|
| • Inspections, building works, maintenance, repairs and supervision |
|
| • Compliance with laws and regulations |
|
| • Arrears and legal matters |
|
| • Records, financial reports, reporting and budgets |
|
| • Receipting |
|
| • Books of account |
|
| • Tenants, tenants' association, rules and promotions |
The property management agreements will be available for inspection in terms of paragraph 9 of Section 4.
INDEPENDENT PROPERTY VALUERS' SUMMARY VALUATION REPORTS ON THE FAIRVEST PROPERTY PORTFOLIO
BROLL VALUATION AND ADVISORY SERVICES SUMMARY VALUATION REPORT
The Directors Arrowhead Properties Limited 3rd Floor Upper Building 1 Sturdee Avenue Rosebank 2196
30 November 2021
BROLL VALUATION AND ADVISORY SERVICES SUMMARY VALUATION REPORT IN RESPECT OF CERTAIN PROPERTIES WITHIN THE FAIRVEST PROPERTY PORTFOLIO
Dear Sirs,
RE: INDEPENDENT PROPERTY VALUERS' REPORT OF THE PROPERTY PORTFOLIO FOR ARROWHEAD PROPERTIES LIMITED AS DETAILED IN THE SUMMARY SCHEDULE ATTACHED AND FOR WHICH THERE ARE DETAILED VALUATION REPORTS HELD BY ARROWHEAD PROPERTIES LIMITED
In accordance with your instruction dated the 27 September 2021, we confirm that we have visited and inspected the 11 properties listed in the attached schedule (the "Properties") during June, July and October 2021 and have received all necessary details required to perform an independent valuation in order to provide you with our opinion of the Market Value (as defined in paragraph 2 below) of each of the Properties as at the 30 June 2021 and 30 September 2021.
1. INTRODUCTION
This summary valuation report ("Summary Valuation Report") has been prepared in compliance with section 13.20 of the JSE Listings Requirements ("Listings Requirements") for inclusion in the revised listing particulars ("Revised Listing Particulars") accompanying a circular to shareholders of Arrowhead Properties Limited ("Arrowhead") in respect of the proposed acquisition of 100% of the issued share capital of Fairvest Property Holdings Limited ("Fairvest") by Arrowhead via a scheme of arrangement in terms of Section 114 of the Companies Act 2008 (Act 71 of 2008) ("Transaction"), in terms of the general provisions of Section 13 of the Listings Requirements ("Section 13").
Formal detailed written valuation reports ("Valuation Reports") have been compiled for each of the Properties and these reports have been issued to the nominated representatives of Arrowhead and are available for inspection as set out in Section 4, paragraph 9 of the Revised Listing Particulars.
The valuation of each of the Properties has been carried out by the nominated property valuer, Broll Valuation and Advisory Services Proprietary Limited ("Broll" or the "Valuer"), and the valuation process has been overseen by Roger Long, Registered Professional Valuer (No. 2649).
Employees of the Valuer having relevant valuation qualifications have inspected each of the Properties and careful consideration has been given to all matters pertaining to the requirements of Section 13 for the purposes of these valuations.
Each of the Valuation Reports submitted includes commentary on the nature of the Properties, locality, tenancy, risk profile, forward rent projections, earning capability and exposure to future expenses and property risk.
The Valuation Reports have further addressed the estimated income capability and expenditure for each Property taking into account contractual income at the date of valuation, annual escalations in contractual income and also expenditure estimates based on current recorded information and considered projections as to future increases in running and operating costs.
The values thus determined for each of the Properties indicates our opinion of the Market Value thereof at the date of valuation.
2. BASIS OF VALUATION
The basis of valuation for the Properties is Market Value.
Market Value is defined by the Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors, The South African Institute of Valuers and the International Valuations Standards Committee as:
"The estimated amount for which a property should exchange on the date of Valuation between a willing buyer and a willing seller in an arm's length transaction after proper marketing, wherein the parties had acted knowledgeably, prudently and without compulsion."
3. VALUATION METHODOLOGY
We have used the traditional and internationally recognised Discounted Cash Flow ("DCF") method of valuation using the MRI Global Valuations (Previously Cougar 2006) to reach our opinion of value as outlined in this report.
This approach is generally considered the most applicable valuation technique for income-producing properties, where sufficient market data exists to supply the necessary inputs and parameters for this approach.
The DCF valuation method takes into account the time value of money between the Valuation Date (as defined in paragraph 20 below) and the date when the income stream theoretically reverts to market levels and is described as follows: The property is valued by discounting the expected future net income for a specific period at an appropriate discount rate (or total rate of return) to give the present value ("PV") of the expected net income cash flow. To this figure an applicable final discounted residual or reversionary value is added.
The reversionary value is calculated by the following method: The net market related income prevailing at the end of the cash flow projection period is capitalised at the appropriate rate and discounted to the present value by the discount rate.
The approach to determine the value of the solar PV installation at Sebokeng Plaza, Cosmos Centre and at Masingita Shopping Centre is also based on the DCF methodology, however the projected electricity savings or income is projected for the estimated life span of the installation of twenty-five (25) year period less forecast expenses (which include routine maintenance as well as inverter replacement) are then deducted from the income projections to arrive at the net annual income stream throughout the cash flow period.
This net annual income stream is then discounted and aggregated to determine an estimated net present value of the cash flow. No revisionary value is attributed at the end of the cash flow period as the installation would have reached the end of its useful life.
4. SPARE LAND
- Additional land/bulk land is available at Orange Farm and at Cosmos Centre.
- Orange Farm the site includes additional bulk of 2,500m²;
- Cosmos Centre the previous Erf 230, measuring 2,855m² in extent
The additional land/bulk land is valued using the comparable sales method, which is based on comparing the subject asset with identical or similar assets for which price information is available, such as a comparison with market sales transactions in the same, or closely similar, type of asset within an appropriate time horizon.
5. BRIEF DESCRIPTION
From visual inspection only, the improvements appear to be well built from quality robust traditional construction materials and finishes and are more fully described in the Valuation Reports.
6. VALUATION QUALIFICATIONS
Qualifications to our reported Market Values are usually detailed as a consequence of:
- leases under negotiation that have not yet been formalised;
- leases of a large nature where the premises are difficult to re-let;
- specialised properties;
- large exposure to a single tenant;
-
potential tenant failure due to over-rent;
-
expenses required for major repairs;
- maintenance or other exposure to maintain the lettability of the building;
- contingent expropriations or servitudes that may be enforced;
- poor lease recordals whereby the lease may be disputed or rendered invalid;
- Novel Coronavirus (COVID-19) and recent riots.
The outbreak of COVID-19, declared by the World Health Organisation as a "Global Pandemic" on 11 March 2020, has and continues to impact many aspects of daily life and the global economy – with some real estate markets having experienced lower levels of transactional activity and liquidity. Travel, movement and operational restrictions have been implemented by many countries. In some cases, "lockdowns" have been applied to varying degrees and to reflect further "waves" of COVID-19; although these may imply a new stage of the crisis, they are not unprecedented in the same way as the initial impact.
In addition, the recent riots and political unrest in KZN and Gauteng during the week of 11 July 2021 have served to cause further uncertainty in the property market.
In respect of the retail sector, as at the Valuation Date, we continue to be faced with an unprecedented set of circumstances caused by a combination of COVID-19 and the riots. This has resulted in an absence of relevant/ sufficient market evidence on which to base our judgements. Our valuation of the property is therefore reported as being subject to "material valuation uncertainty" as set out in VPS 3 and VPGA 10 of the RICS Valuation –Global Standards. Consequently, in respect of this valuations less certainty –and a higher degree of caution – should be attached to our valuation than would normally be the case. For the avoidance of doubt this explanatory note, including the 'material valuation uncertainty' declaration, does not mean that the valuation cannot be relied upon. Rather, this explanatory note has been included to ensure transparency and to provide further insight as to the market context under which the valuation opinion was prepared.
In recognition of the potential for market conditions to move rapidly in response to changes in the control or future spread of COVID-19 we highlight the importance of the Valuation Date.
Red Book Global Standards define material uncertainty as 'where the degree of uncertainty in a valuation falls outside any parameters that might normally be expected and accepted' (VPS 3.2.2 (o)). It also explains circumstances of material uncertainty to assist the valuation process (with additional guidance in VPGA 10), but the decision to declare it remains with the independent valuer'.
• The Build it and Standard Bank units were damaged during the recent riots and as these tenants are not trading, we have made the assumption that the damage as well as the loss of income is covered by SASRIA insurance and that the terms of the contractual leases will continue.
The Valuer is however not responsible for the competent daily management of these Properties that will ensure that this status is maintained, or for the change of any laws, services by local authority or economic circumstances that may adversely impact on the integrity of the buildings or the tenant profile.
7. OPTIONS OR BENEFIT/DETRIMENT OF CONTRACTUAL ARRANGEMENTS
To our knowledge there are no contractual arrangements on the Properties other than the leases as detailed in this report that have a major benefit or are detrimental to the fundamental value base of the Properties.
We reserve the right to amend our valuation should any findings alter or bring the validity of the lease/s into question.
To the best of our knowledge there are no options in favour of any parties for any purchase of the Properties.
8. INTRA-GROUP LEASES
Having inspected all the tenant schedules and leases it is noted that there are no intra-group or related party leases.
9. CURRENT STATE OF DEVELOPMENT
Not applicable.
10. PROPERTIES HELD FOR DEVELOPMENT
Fairvest has informed us that they are considering doing a redevelopment of the Orange Farm property by connecting the two freestanding buildings. This is still subject to letting and a feasibility study and we have therefore not taken this into consideration.
11. EXTERNAL PROPERTY
None of the Properties are situated outside the Republic of South Africa.
12. ALTERNATIVE USE FOR A PROPERTY
We have valued the Properties in accordance with their existing use which represents their Market Value. Thus alternative use values have not been reported for any of the Properties.
13. VALUATION ASSUMPTIONS
Generally, we are of the opinion that contractual rentals passing are market related for each Property. Certain reversions of market rentals have been determined by comparing the current contractual rentals of the various trading categories and sizes of shops available at each centre to various published indices including the South African Property Owners Association index, Rode Retail Report and the MSCI/IPD index. The rental rates have also been checked against our own database of similar centres previously valued. Please refer to our detailed reports, Appendix – Tenancy Schedules for a breakdown of our estimate of market rentals per Property.
We also provided for a structural vacancy of between 1 to 3% per Property, depending on historic vacancy, location, accommodation and existing tenant profile. This vacancy factor is a provision against possible tenant failure, sourcing of new tenants and or tenant relocations during the term of the cash flow. Provisions have been made for the letting up of space presently vacant within a sensible and reasonable time frame at an appropriate market rental.
Our estimates of current market rentals are based on our research of the latest available market letting transactions in the areas where the properties are situated. Where such information is either unavailable or limited, we have relied on our knowledge of the market and have also, where appropriate, had regard to rental statistics published by recognised organisations.
The assumptions regarding vacancy allowances and void periods for income lost due to the letting or re-letting of space for a particular node or centre have been made with reference to vacancy statistics published by recognised organisations as well as discussions with property managers and any negotiations that are currently underway with prospective tenants.
We have, to the best of our knowledge, considered all of these aspects in the valuation of all the Properties. There are no Properties that are prejudiced in value by the influence of the above factors.
The Valuer is however not responsible for the competent daily management of these Properties that will ensure that this status is maintained, or for the change of any laws, services by local authority or economic circumstances that may adversely impact on the integrity of the buildings or the tenant profile.
14. UNLET SPACE
Assumptions have been made in our valuations as to the likely letting up tempo of vacant accommodation generally and the estimated loss of income during the letting up periods of the affected properties is reflected in the DCF methodology adopted for the Properties.
15. INSPECTIONS, AREAS AND DIMENSIONS
All the Properties were inspected during the month of June, July and October 2021. No measured surveys have been carried out by us and we have relied on the floor and/or lettable areas provided to us by the nominated representatives of Fairvest. We have assumed that these areas are correct unless otherwise stated in the Valuation Report for a specific Property.
16. MATERIAL CONTRAVENTION OF STATUTORY REQUIREMENTS
We are not aware of any material contravention of any statutory requirement relating to the Properties.
17. FUTURE RENTALS
Save for considered assumptions being made with regard to vacant space and the renewal of leases, we confirm that the current rental income being achieved in the Properties does not materially differ from the estimated future rental income. Rentals used in our DCF valuations are based on the terms and conditions contracted in the leases. On expiry of each lease, we have assumed that they will revert to market related rentals. The market related rentals have been determined by comparing similar buildings in comparable areas to the Properties valued. Due consideration was given to the extent of the lettable areas, their location within the buildings, and tenant profile in the determination of the reversionary market rentals. The market rentals have also been compared with rentals listed in various published benchmarking indices. Assumptions regarding the take up of vacant space at the assumed market rental follows a similar methodology as the assumptions made at lease renewal or expiry. These assumptions are detailed in our Valuation Reports and cash flows.
18. GENERAL PRINCIPLES OF VALUATIONS AND REPORTS
We list below the general principles upon which valuations and reports undertaken by Broll in South Africa are normally prepared and confirm that such principles shall apply in respect of the Properties forming the subject of the Valuation Reports, unless specifically mentioned otherwise:
Standards
We confirm our Valuation Reports have been completed in accordance with both international and local standards, namely:
- The Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors, RICS Valuation and Appraisal Standards (the Red Book as amended).
- International Accounting Standards (IAS).
- International Valuation Standards Committee (IVSC, White Book).
- The rules and guidelines laid down by the South African Council for the Property Valuers Profession in accordance with the Valuers Act 2000.
Source of information and verification
Information on the Properties regarding rental income, recoveries, turnovers and other income detail has been provided to us by the current owners and their managing agents. Each valuation is based on the information which has been supplied to us or which we have obtained in response to our enquiries. We have relied on this information provided as being correct and complete and there being no undisclosed matters which would affect each valuation.
We have further compared certain expenditures given to us to market norms of similar properties and the historic expenditure levels of the properties themselves. Historical contractual expenditures and municipal services.
Full disclosure
The Valuation Reports have been prepared on the basis that full disclosure of all information and factors which may affect the valuations, has been made to ourselves and we cannot accept any liability or responsibility whatsoever for the valuations, unless such full disclosure has been made.
Freehold and leasehold title
In the case of both freehold and leasehold Properties we have inspected the relevant title deed documents made available to us. Where, as a result of our inspections, some points have caused us concern as to the title, we have referred specifically to them in the relevant Valuation Reports. Where the title deeds were not available we have assumed that good title can be shown and that the Property is not subject to any unusual or especially onerous restrictions, encumbrances or outgoings.
Leases
Paragraph 13.23(ix) of the Listings Requirements provides that a summary of the valuation report to be included in a pre-listing statement/prospectus or circular must include a "high level summary of the actual tenant's leases or sub leases".
We have had sight of anchor and large lease documentation as well as a standard line shop lease and high level summaries of these are included in our Valuation Reports. In preparing our cash flows we have had regard to the tenancy schedules provided and also to our assessment of current market rentals and escalation rates for the various elements of accommodation. Below are high level comments for each Property:
- Sebokeng Plaza: Approximately 74% of the GLA is let to National or National Franchise represented Tenant's with 26% being let to Local Tenant's. 66% of the income is generated by these National tenants, 34% from Local Tenants. Certain contractual rents have escalated above market.
- 212 Church Street: The property is single tenanted by Truworths. The contractual rent is market related.
-
425 West Street: Approximately 29% of the GLA is let to National or National Franchise represented Tenant's with 43% being let to Office Tenant's. One office unit is vacant. The contractual rents are market related.
-
Cosmos Centre: Approximately 90% of the GLA is let to National or National Franchise represented Tenant's with 10% being let to Local Tenant's. Approximately 88% of the income is generated by these National tenants, 12% from Local Tenants. It is noted that there is one ATM vacancy of 6m². Certain contractual rents have escalated above market.
- Kim Park: Approximately 73% of the GLA is let to National or National Franchise represented Tenant's with 7% being let to Local Tenant's. Approximately 81% of the income is generated by these National tenants, 13% from Local Tenants. Certain contractual rents have escalated above market.
- Coronation Walk: Almost 35% of the GLA is let to National or National Franchise represented tenants with 59% being let to local tenants and 6% are offices. 33% of the income is generated by these National Tenants, 59% from Local Tenants with 8% from the offices. Certain contractual rents have escalated above market.
- Masingita Shopping Centre: Approximately 79% of the GLA is let to National or National Franchise represented Tenants with 15% being let to Local Tenants. 5.29 is currently vacant. 79% of the income is generated by these National Tenants, 19% from Local Tenants. Certain contractual rents have escalated above market.
- Orange Farm: The centre is currently let to two tenants Pick 'n Pay Boxer, Build it and Standard Bank ATM. We highlighted the Build it and Standard Bank units were damaged during the recent riots and as these tenants are not trading, we have made the assumption that the damage as well as the loss of income is covered by SASRIA insurance and that the terms of the contractual leases will continue. The contractual rents are market related.
- Qualbert Centre: Approximately 65% of the GLA is let to National or National Franchise represented Tenants with 35% being let to Local Tenants. 70% of the income is generated by these National Tenants, 25% from Local Tenants with 5% from the casual and monthly parkers. The contractual rents are market related. Approximately 78.01% of the GLA is let to National or National Franchise represented Tenant's with 21.99% being let to Local Tenant's.
- The Ridge Shopping Centre: Certain contractual rents have escalated above market. 55% of the GLA is let to National or National Franchise represented Tenants with 38% being let to Local Tenants. 49% of the income is generated by these National Tenants, 51% from Local Tenants. Certain contractual rents have escalated above market.
Outgoings
In estimating the applicable Property expenses we have relied on the budgets which have been provided to us by Fairvest for the forward 12 months commencing 1 July 2021. Thereafter we have assumed an expense growth rate of 6.0% per annum from 1 July 2022.
It is assumed, except where otherwise stated, that the Properties are subject to the normal landlord's outgoings and that there are no onerous restrictions or unusual covenants of which we have no knowledge.
Lessee's credibility
In arriving at our valuations, cognizance has been taken of the lessee's security and rating. In some cases this has influenced the capitalisation rate by way of a risk consideration.
Mortgage bonds, loans or other charges
The Properties have been valued as if wholly owned with no account being taken of any outstanding monies due in respect of mortgage bonds, loans or other charges. No deductions have been made in our valuations for the cost of acquisition or disposal of the asset. Our valuations exclude Value Added Tax ("VAT").
Calculation of areas
All areas quoted within the Valuation Reports are as provided.
Plans
All plans included within the Valuation Reports are supplied for the purpose of identification only and are not necessarily to scale.
Property boundaries
The site boundaries, as indicated to us by the instructing client or appointed agent, or the boundaries as indicated on plans supplied by others are assumed to be the legal extent of the Property. We do not take responsibility for any variation of these boundaries either by extension or omission, and the resultant inclusion or omission of any improvements as a result of any such variations.
Site conditions
Unless specifically requested, we do not carry out investigations on site in order to determine the suitability of ground conditions and services, nor do we undertake environmental, archaeological, or geo-technical surveys. Unless notified to the contrary, our valuations are on the basis that these aspects are satisfactory and also that the Properties are clear of underground mineral or other workings, or other hazardous or noxious substances.
Structural condition
In preparing our valuations we have had regard to the apparent state and condition of the improvements at the Properties but have not carried out structural surveys of the same and have not inspected those areas of the improvements which were covered, unexposed or inaccessible and neither have we arranged for the testing of electrical and mechanical equipment such as that installed in connection with reticulation of wiring for artificial lighting and power, heating, air conditioning and ventilation systems, elevators or any other engineering services at the Property. Unless otherwise stated in our reports the valuation assumes that the services and structures are in a satisfactory state of repair and condition.
Materials of construction
The valuations assume that no deleterious or hazardous materials or techniques were used in the construction of the improvements at the Property or have since been incorporated by way of extensions or additions thereto.
Contamination
In preparing our valuations we have assumed that no contaminative or potentially contaminative use is, or has been, carried out at the Property. Unless specifically instructed, we do not undertake any investigation into the past or present uses of either the Property or any adjoining or nearby land, to establish whether there is any potential for contamination from these uses and assume that none exist. However, should it subsequently be established that such contamination exists at any of the Properties or on any adjoining land or that any of the Properties have been, or is being put to, a contaminative use, then the value which we have reported may be detrimentally affected.
Statutory notice and unlawful use
We have assumed that the Properties and their values are unaffected by any statutory notice, and that neither the condition of the Properties, nor their use, nor their intended use, is or will be unlawful.
Town planning
Full town planning details have been supplied in the summary table attached to this Summary Valuation Report as well as the Valuation Reports including conditions and restrictions and the Properties have been checked against such conditions. This is to ensure that they comply with town planning regulations and title deeds. There do not appear to be any infringements of local authority regulations or deeds by any of the Properties.
The valuations have further assumed that the improvements at the properties have been erected in accordance with the relevant building and town planning regulations.
Certificate of compliance
We have assumed that Fairvest will, at its own expense, provide a certificate of compliance in terms of SANS 10142-1 – Code of Practice for Wiring Premises, issued by an accredited person certifying that the electrical installation of the premises is reasonably safe.
High voltage electricity supply apparatus and mobile phone installations
Research findings which have been the subject of media coverage in the last few years indicate that the health of the public occupying buildings located in close proximity to high voltage electrical supply equipment installations may be put at risk due to the presence of electromagnetic fields and radiation. Public perception may, therefore, affect marketability and future value of a property so located.
Synergistic value
We have not reflected in our valuations any element of "synergistic value" or "special purchaser value" which could possibly be realised by merger of the freehold and leasehold interests or by sale to an owner or occupier of an adjoining property.
Individual Properties
The values reported are for the individual Properties. No allowance is made for any premium which may be applicable for an assembled portfolio of Properties, nor is a discount allowed for any flooding of the market which might exist if all or a majority of the Properties were offered for sale simultaneously.
Confidentiality
The Valuation Reports are produced exclusively for Arrowhead and for the specific purposes to which they refer. They may be disclosed to your other professional advisers assisting you in respect of that purpose. We accept no responsibility whatsoever to any parties other than yourselves who make use of these valuations.
Partial holdings
The value of a partial holding is expressed as the percentage of the whole Property held. No premium or discount has been made for such partial holding.
Plant and machinery
Our valuation takes account of those items of plant and machinery normally associated with the valuation of land and buildings, such as standard air-conditioning plant, boilers, heating, sprinklers, ventilation systems and the like. Our valuation excludes information technology and process plant, machinery and fixtures and fittings that would normally be taken to be the property of the occupier.
Tax
No allowance is made in our valuation for liability to taxation, which may arise on acquisition or on disposal, whether actual or notional, e.g. VAT and Capital Gains Tax.
All rental and valuation calculations and figures reported are exclusive of VAT.
Transactional costs
Fairvest and Arrowhead's ("Parties") costs (such as agent's commission, legal fees, transfer fees etc) will differ from each other depending on the individual and specific circumstances of each Party.
No allowance has therefore been made in our valuation to reflect any Party's costs of sale or realisation of the Property asset.
Independent valuers' clause
Neither the employees of the Valuer, nor Broll, have any present or contemplated interest in the Properties valued or in any other Properties or other interests which would affect the statements or values contained in this Summary Valuation Report. The valuation enclosed herewith was therefore undertaken on a completely independent basis by an external valuer employed by Broll, a company which specialises in the valuation of real estate and plant and machinery assets, but which does not trade in any of those assets.
Non-publication
Neither the whole nor any part of this Summary Valuation Report, nor any reference thereto may be included in any published document, nor published in any way without our prior written approval as to the form or context in which it may appear. We do however, consent to the inclusion of this Summary Valuation Report, in the form and context in which they appears, in the Revised Listing Particulars.
Third party
This Summary Valuation Report is provided for the stated purpose and for the sole use of Arrowhead and Arrowhead shareholders. It is confidential to these parties and their professional advisors and consultants, and the Valuer accepts no responsibility whatsoever to any other person or third party.
19. VALUER FOR THE TRANSACTION
The valuation of each of the Properties has been carried out by the Valuer, and the valuation process has been overseen by Roger Long, Registered Professional Valuer No 2649/5.
Employees of the Valuer having relevant qualifications have inspected each of the Properties and careful consideration has been given to all matters pertaining to the requirements for the purposes of the valuations.
20. AGGREGATE MARKET VALUE OF THE SCHEDULED PROPERTIES
We are of the opinion that the aggregate Market Value of the 5 (five) income producing Properties, as detailed in Annexure A, as at 30 June 2021 ("June Valuation Date") is:
• R366 900 000 (three hundred and sixty-six million, nine hundred thousand Rand), excluding VAT.
We are of the opinion that the aggregate Market Value of the 6 (six) income producing Properties, as detailed in Annexure A, as at 30 September 2021 ("September Valuation Date") is:
• R404 800 000 (four hundred and four million, eight hundred thousand Rand), excluding VAT),
(the June Valuation Date and the September Valuation Date, jointly, the ("Valuation Date").
We confirm that to the best of our knowledge and belief there have been no material changes between the Valuation Date and the last practicable date of the Revised Listing Particulars, being 23 November 2021 in any circumstances relating to the Properties, which would affect the valuation thereof.
We confirm that we have no pecuniary or other related interest that would conflict with a proper valuation of the Properties, other than normal professional fees.
With 30 years' experience in property valuation, the undersigned is qualified to express a professional and independent opinion on the value of the Properties.
For and on behalf of
BROLL VALUATION AND ADVISORY SERVICES (PTY) LIMITED Reg No. 1968/003515/07 61 Katherine Street, Sandton, 2196
ROGER LONG FRICS MIV (SA) Chartered Valuation Surveyor
RICS Registered Valuer (59664)
Professional Valuer (2649/5)
Professional Valuer registered with the South African Council for the Professional Valuers Profession (SACPVP).
| No. | description Registered |
Name | Type | Address | inspection physical Date of |
Effective valuation date of |
Market value | Site/Section (hectares) Area |
GLA (m²) | Description existing and use |
building Age of |
Tenure | Tenure of leasehold |
contravention Zoning, town planning and statutory (if any) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. | Portions 3, 4 and 7 Sebokeng Unit 10 Gauteng Province of Erf 65558 Ext. 1, |
Sebokeng Plaza |
Neighbourhood Centre |
Moshoeshoe Street, Along an unnamed of Vanderbijl Park in the Sebokeng street off the arterial route township |
2 July 2021 | 30 June 2021 |
R72 000 000 | 24 085.00 | 11 386.50 | Building – Retail |
~20 years | Freehold | n/a | Business |
| 2. | Erf 5169, Bethal, Mpumalanga Province |
Cosmos Centre |
Other Retail | 39 Du Plooy Street, on the corner of Du Plooy and Eufees Streets, in central Bethal |
24 June 2021 |
30 June 2021 |
R80 800 000 | 12 800.00 | 4 692.00 | Building – Retail |
Built in 2006 15 years. |
Freehold | n/a | General Mixed Use |
| 3. | Pietermaritzburg, of Erf 2564 and KwaZulu-Natal of Erf 2521 Portion 18 Portion 1 Province |
212 Church Street |
High Street Retail |
Corner of Church and Pietermaritzburg Timber Street, |
1 June 2021 | 30 June 2021 |
R36 800 000 | 840 000.00 | 1 980.00 | Building – Retail |
Refurbished ~50 years. in 2005 |
Freehold | n/a | Business1 Sub-zone General |
| 4. | Portions 1, 2 And 3 Durban, KwaZulu Re And Portion 1 Erf 11016 And Natal Province of Erf 11014, of Erf 11017 |
425 West Street |
Mixed Use | Kaseme Street, Durban 425 West Street also known as Dr Pixley |
1 June 2021 | 30 June 2021 |
R59 900 000 | 3 511.00 | 8 736.85 | Building – Retail/ Office |
~60 years. façade on Dr Pixley Kaseme historic Street 1934 |
Freehold | n/a | General Business Central Zone |
| 5. | Northern Cape Kimberley, Erf 16428 Province |
Kim Park | Neighbourhood Centre |
R64 – Lennox Street, Chapel Street in the Sydney Street and Kimberley CBD |
1 July 2021 | 30 June 2021 |
R117 400 000 | 11 715.00 | 9 301.52 | Building – Retail |
Built in 1985, refurbished 35 Years. in 2012 |
Freehold | n/a | Business 1 |
| TOTAL | R366 900 000 |
88ANNEXURE A: INCOME-PRODUCING PROPERTIES – 30 JUNE 2021
| contravention Zoning, town planning and |
General Business | Business 1 Use | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| statutory (if any) |
Commercial General |
Zone 6 | Business 1 | Business 1 | Special | ||
| Tenure of leasehold |
n/a | n/a | n/a | n/a | n/a | n/a | |
| Tenure | Freehold | Freehold | Freehold | Section title |
Freehold | Freehold | |
| building Age of |
~20 years | ~ 50 years | ~30 years | ~20 years | 17 years. built in 2004 |
Three years. Built in 2018 |
|
| Description existing and use |
Buildings – Retail |
Buildings – Retail |
Buildings – Retail/ Office |
Buildings – Retail/ Office |
Buildings – Retail |
Buildings – Retail |
|
| GLA (m²) | 3 047.40 | 4 683.60 | 5 364.27 | 4 663.31 | 2 685.00 | 7 689.00 | |
| (hectares) section area Site/ |
6 599.00 | 3 172.00 | 13 552.00 | 4 767.00 | 17 479.00 | 18 635.00 | |
| Market value | R51 300 000 | R77 900 000 | R74 600 000 | R67 100 000 | R27 500 000 | R106 400 000 | R404 800 000 |
| Effective valuation date of |
September | September | September | September | September | September | |
| 2021 30 |
2021 30 |
2021 30 |
2021 30 |
2021 30 |
2021 30 |
||
| inspection physical Date of |
13 June 2021 |
13 June 2021 |
1 October 2021 |
11 October 2021 |
8 October 2021 |
6 October 2021 |
|
| Address | and Coronation Road, Corner Main Road Queensburgh |
(Bertha Mkhize) Street, (Ingcube) and Victoria Corner Albert Road Durban |
Corner of R81 and Main Road, Giyani-D |
Corner of Paul Kruger Mozart Avenue in Honeydew Ridge, Avenue and Roodepoort |
Corner of Link Road and Palm Drive, Orange Farm |
Barret Minnon Street Dwarf Sanjika Street (to the south) and (to the north), Umlola Street Pisolite Street (to the west), (to the east), Shoshanguve |
|
| Type | Other Retail | Other Retail | Other Retail | Neighbourhood Centre |
Other Retail | Neighbourhood Centre |
|
| Name | Coronation Walk |
Qualbert Centre |
Masingita Shopping Centre |
The Ridge Shopping Centre |
Orange Farm |
Southview Shopping Centre |
TOTAL |
| Registered description No. |
Erf 971, 974, 975 KwaZulu-Natal Queensburgh, and 976, Province |
Remaining Extent of Erf 12025 and 12025, Durban, Portion 1 of Erf KwaZulu-Natal Province |
Portion 1 of Erf 566, Limpopo Province Giyani-D, |
Known As The Ridge Known As The Ridge Gauteng Province Sections 4 and 6 of The Scheme 143/2003 and The Scheme 271/2005, Section 8 |
Orange Farm Ext. 4, Gauteng Province Erf 15800, |
Shoshanguve South Gauteng Province Erf 21188, Ext. 7, |
ANNEXURE A: INCOME-PRODUCING PROPERTIES – 30 SEPTEMBER 2021
ANNEXURE B: INCOME-PRODUCING PROPERTIES – 30 JUNE 2021
Zoning, town planning and statutory contravention
| No. Name | Zoning, town planning and statutory contravention (if any) | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. | Sebokeng Plaza | Business | ||||
| Permitted uses: Shops, business purposes (including a Bookmaker shop and five limited gambling machines), residential buildings, places of public worship, places of instruction, social halls, sports and recreational purposes, institutions. |
||||||
| Floor Area Ratio: n/a | ||||||
| Coverage: 70% | ||||||
| Height: 3 storeys | ||||||
| Parking: 4 spaces per 100m² of shopping floor area | ||||||
| Building Lines: 2m on all boundaries | ||||||
| 2. | Cosmos Centre | General Mixed Use | ||||
| Floor Area Ratio: 4 Coverage: 80% |
||||||
| Height: 6 | ||||||
| Parking: As per Scheme | ||||||
| Building Lines: 0 meters | ||||||
| 3. | 212 Church Street | General Business 1 Sub-zone | ||||
| Floor Area Ratio: Four storeys | ||||||
| Coverage: 100% | ||||||
| Height: Controlled by 60-degree light angle | ||||||
| Parking: No statutory on-site requirement and no access is permitted save with the special consent of the Council |
||||||
| Building Lines: All Buildings and structures shall be established on the street boundary or the indicated road widening lane |
||||||
| 4. | 425 West Street | General Business Central Zone | ||||
| Floor Area Ratio: 8 | ||||||
| Coverage: Not applicable | ||||||
| Height: 59 degrees from opposite side of road 110m with 5m setback at 15m | ||||||
| Parking: Maximum of 1 bay per 100m2 of gross floor area, no minimum |
||||||
| Building Lines: None | ||||||
| 5. | Kim Park | Business 1 | ||||
| Permitted uses: Hotels, guest houses, places of refreshment, shops, business premises, dwelling units, residential building, place of amusement, places of worship including funeral parlours with chapels, places of instruction, dry cleaners, public garages, parking, car wash, social halls. |
||||||
| Floor Area Ratio: 6 | ||||||
| Coverage: 90% | ||||||
| Height: 12.2. No building or structure of whatever nature may be erected on any Erf situated within the Southern Big Hole Height Restriction Area, shall exceed a height forming a greater incline than 0°57´20˝, measured from the Big Hole Pivot Point as demonstrated in the sketch in Clause 12.3. below, unless approved by the controlling authority. |
||||||
| Parking: 6 parking spaces per 100m2 of gross leasable floor area. The municipality may relax this on approval of a site development plan. |
||||||
| Building Lines: Street 4.5m; Rear 2m; Side 2m |
ANNEXURE B: INCOME PRODUCING PROPERTIES – 30 SEPTEMBER 2021
Zoning, town planning and statutory contravention
| No. Name | Zoning, town planning and statutory contravention (if any) | |
|---|---|---|
| 1. | Coronation Walk | General Commercial |
| Permitted uses: Primary: Action Sports Bar, Arts and Crafts Workshop, Betting Depot, Crèche, Conservation Area, Display Area, Dwelling House, Educational Establishment, Flat, Flea Market, Health and Beauty Clinic, Health Studio, Hotel, Laundry, Motor Display Area, Museum Office, Office – Medical, Parkade, Pet Grooming Parlour, Place of Public Entertainment, Private Open Space, Public Open Space, Restaurant/Fast Food Outlet, Shop, Veterinary Clinic |
||
| Floor Area Ratio: 1.0 | ||
| Coverage: 80% | ||
| Height: 4 storeys | ||
| Parking: As per scheme | ||
| Building Lines: 0m | ||
| Side Space: 3m | ||
| Rear Space: 3m | ||
| 2. | Qualbert Centre | General Business |
| Action Sports Bar, Adult Premises, Arts and Crafts Workshop, Betting Depot, Boarding House, Conservation Area, Convention Centre, Crèche, Display Area, Educational Establishment, Escort Agency, Exhibition Centre,Flat, Flea Market, Fuelling and Service Station, Government/ Municipal, Health and Beauty Clinic, Health Studio, Hotel, Utility Facility, Industrial – Light, Institution, Laundry, Market, Massage Parlour, Motor Display Area, Museum, Night Club, Office, Offices – Medical, Parkade, Pet Grooming Parlour, Place of Public Entertainment, Private Open Space, Public Open Space, Restaurant/Fast Food Outlet, Shop, Sport and Recreation, Veterinary Clinic, Warehouse |
||
| Floor Area Ratio: 8.0 of which residential may be either 4.0 or 2.0 dependant on its locality in CBD or 3.0 in the areas bounded by (i) Berea Road; Richards Road; Lancers Road; Warwick Avenue. (ii) Berea Road; Umbilo Road; Moore Road; (iii) Roughly in the area bounded by Epsom Road; Mansell Road; Umgeni Road; First Avenue; Crabbe Road; Argyle Road and Ascot Street. |
||
| Coverage: n/a | ||
| Height: 59 degree angle from opposite side of street (max width 30m) or 110m with a 5.0m setback at 15.0m |
||
| Parking: As per scheme | ||
| Building Lines: 4.5m from centre line of vehicular street or 2.0m from centre line of non-vehicular street |
||
| 3. | Masingita Shopping Centre |
Business 1 Use Zone 6 |
| Permitted uses: Dwelling units, residential flats, hotel, institution, multi-purpose centre, offices/medical consulting rooms, parking garage, place of instruction, public place of worship, restaurant, shops, social hall, tavern, vehicle sales lot. |
||
| Floor Area Ratio: 3.0 | ||
| Coverage: 1) 90% | ||
| 2) 45 units/ha (Residential) | ||
| Height: As per Scheme | ||
| Parking: As per scheme | ||
| Building Lines: 4.0m at Main street boundary |
| No. Name | Zoning, town planning and statutory contravention (if any) | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| 4. | The Ridge | RE of Erf 49 (Previous Erven 15 and 16) | |
| Shopping Centre | Zoning: Business 1 | ||
| Permitted Uses: Not specified | |||
| Floor Area Ratio: The floor area ratio shall not exceed 0.6 | |||
| Coverage: The coverage shall not exceed 60%. | |||
| Height: The height of buildings shall not exceed two storeys | |||
| Parking: not specified | |||
| Building Lines: not specified | |||
| Erf 50 | |||
| Zoning: Business 1 | |||
| Permitted uses: The erven shall be used for "Business 1" purposes including a drive-through restaurant Floor Area Ratio: The floor area ratio shall not exceed 0.4 |
|||
| Coverage: The coverage shall not exceed 60%. | |||
| Height: The height of buildings shall not exceed two storeys | |||
| Parking: 6 parking spacer per 100 m2 gross leasable shop floor area; |
|||
| 4 parking spaces per 100m2 gross leasable office floor area; |
|||
| 8 parking spaces per 100m2 gross leasable medical floor area; |
|||
| 10 parking spaces per 100m2 nett restaurant floor area; 2 parking spaces per 100m2 for all other restaurant floor area; |
|||
| All other land uses shall be provided for to the satisfaction of the Council | |||
| Building Lines: not specified | |||
| 5. | Orange Farm | Business 1 | |
| Permitted uses: Not Specified | |||
| Floor Area Ratio: Not Specified | |||
| Coverage: 70% | |||
| Height: Three Storeys | |||
| Parking: As per Scheme | |||
| Building Lines: 1m at the back and sides | |||
| 6 | Southview | Special | |
| Shopping Centre | Shops, Office, place of refreshment, retail industry, medical consulting room, place of amusement, institution, dwelling units, block of tenements, business buildings, banks, motor dealership, motor workshop, vehicle sales mart and vehicle sales showroom |
||
| Floor Area Ratio: 0.5 | |||
| Coverage: According to Site Development Plan | |||
| Height: Two Storeys | |||
| Parking: 3 bays per 100/m2 of GLA |
|||
| Building Lines: Road 31 (K63) and Road K6: 16m. |
DDP VALUATION AND ADVISORY SERVICES PROPRIETARY LIMITED SUMMARY VALUATION REPORT
The Directors
Arrowhead Properties Limited 1 Sturdee Avenue Rosebank Johannesburg South Africa
30 November 2021
Dear Sirs
RE: INDEPENDENT PROPERTY VALUER'S REPORT OF THE PROPERTY PORTFOLIO FOR FAIRVEST PROPERTY HOLDINGS LIMTED AND ARROWHEAD PROPERTIES LIMITED ("ARROWHEAD") AS DETAILED IN THE SUMMARY SCHEDULE ATTACHED AND FOR WHICH THERE ARE DETAILED VALUATION REPORTS HELD BY ARROWHEAD
1. INTRODUCTION
The valuation of the properties has been carried out by DDP Valuation and Advisory Services Proprietary Limited ("DDP" or the "Valuer") who has carefully considered all aspects of all the properties. These properties each have a detailed valuation report ("Valuation Report") which has been given to the management of Arrowhead. The detailed reports include commentary on the current economy, nature of the properties, locality, tenancy, risk profile, current and rent, earning capability and exposure to future expenses and property risk. All these aspects have been considered in the individual Valuation Reports of the properties. The detailed reports have further addressed the tenancy income capability and expenditure for each property and tenant. Historic expenditure profile as well as future expenditure increases have been considered. The value thus indicates the fair market value for each property which is detailed in the report, and which has been summarised in an executive summary schedule, attached hereto. There are 17 properties and the important aspects of the detailed Valuation Report including the property market value for all of the properties have been summarised in the attached schedule.
2. BASIS OF VALUATION
The value of the properties is based on market value which is defined as, "The estimated amount for which an asset or liability should exchange on the valuation date between a willing buyer and a willing seller in an arm's length transaction, after proper marketing and where the parties had each acted knowledgeably, prudently and without compulsion".
3. VALUE CALCULATION
The calculation of the market value of these properties has been based on the discounted cash flow of contracted income and the income capitalisation of reversionary market rentals.
This is the fundamental basis on which commercial income producing properties are traded on the market in South Africa. This is also due to there being strong supporting evidence of open market rental rates and capitalisation rates which are evidenced by sales in the market.
Properties traded in the current market reflect a yield rate relationship between revenue and capital value. This rate is an accurate determinant of the capitalisation rate.
The considerations for the discounted cash flow valuations are as follows:
- 3.1 Calculating the forward cash flow of all contractual and other income from the properties;
- 3.2 Calculating the forward contractual and other expenditure as well as provisions for various expenses in order to provide for void or future capital expenditure to which the property may be exposed;
-
3.3 The current area vacancy as a percentage of the property portfolio (17 properties valued by DDP) is approximately 4.23%. In order to apply a conservative approach, we have allowed a reversionary vacancy provision of between 1% and 3% of the gross income into perpetuity as a provision for rental that may not be collected as a consequence of vacancy, tenant failure or tenant refitting during the course of the coming years. In addition to the terminal vacancy provision, we have allowed for letting uptake periods on expiry of existing agreements and vacancies within the cash flows. The current vacancy is market related. The void provision used in the valuation is therefore adequate;
-
3.4 There is no loss of rental due to renovations or refurbishments currently being carried out on the buildings. There is, however, ongoing external and internal maintenance work and some tenant installation fitting out that is currently in progress. There is no loss of rental as a result of these activities.
- 3.5 Generally, the rentals are market related. This has been determined by comparing similar buildings in comparable areas to the properties valued, in terms of rental per square metre. The rental rate has also been verified against various published indices including the Rode and SAPOA Reports. There are some properties that are overrented, or that cannot be re-rented at the same or higher rental rate should such property become vacant. Where a rental has been identified as being above market, we have allowed for a reversion to a market related rental within our cash flows. There is potential for rental flow reversion which has been allowed for within the discounted cash flows. There is however, potential for positive upside real growth in rental rates subsequent to the pandemic, but should be viewed with some caution. This is provided that the economy remains in a slow recovery pattern as currently being experienced as that there are no major economic fluctuations which may upset the economy.
- 3.6 Capitalising the net contractual income derived from the properties for a period of one year in advance, calculated from 1 October 2021;
- 3.7 The valuation has considered published market statistics regarding rental rates, expenditure, market rental growth, current and terminal capitalisation rates for the different types of properties. It is also considered numerous other portfolios of similar properties in order to determine if any properties are over rented or have excessive expenditure; and
- 3.8 Various provisions for capital contingencies were deducted from the capitalised value.
4. SPARE LAND
With the exception of Stretford Spar, there are no properties with large tracts of vacant zoned land. The additional land, measuring 4 434 00m2 , for Stretford Spar has been valued on the basis of comparable sales.
5. BRIEF DESCRIPTION
The properties have been well constructed and generally have acceptable architectural merit, aesthetic appeal and sufficient parking facilities and enjoy healthy occupancy rates. The leases tend to be of a general short to medium term contractual rental nature with provision for the recovery of utility services consumed by the lessees. Escalations are market related but are high enough to ensure that a more than positive growth rate is ensured without creating an over rent potential in the medium term. The properties are generally highly visible and dominate their environment. In respect of the properties, the current net annual rental and the estimated future net annual rentals at specified dates and for specified periods are included in each individual Valuation Report.
6. VALUATION QUALIFICATIONS
Qualifications are usually detailed as a consequence of: leases under negotiation that have not yet been formalised; leases of a large nature where the premises are difficult to re-let; specialised properties; large exposure to a single tenant; potential tenant failure due to over-rent; expenses required for major repairs; maintenance or other exposure to maintain the lettability of the building; contingent expropriations or servitudes that may be enforced; poor lease records whereby the lease may be disputed or rendered invalid.
We have, to the best of our knowledge, considered all of these aspects in the valuation of all the properties. There are no properties that are prejudiced in value by the influence of the above factors. The Valuer is however not responsible for the competent daily management of these properties that will ensure that this status is maintained, or for the change of any laws, services by local authority or economic circumstances that may adversely impact on the integrity of the buildings or the tenant profile.
In accordance with your instruction of 1 October 2021, I confirm that we have visited and inspected the 17 properties listed in the attached schedule ("the properties") during June and October 2021 and have received all necessary details required to perform a valuation in order to provide you with my opinion of the properties' market values as at 30 June 2021 (five properties values) and 30 September 2021 (12 properties valued).
7. OPTIONS OR BENEFITS/DETRIMENT OF CONTRACTUAL ARRANGEMENTS
To my knowledge there are no contractual arrangements on the properties other than the leases as detailed in the report that have a major benefit or are detrimental to the fundamental value base of the properties. The properties located in the Eastern Cape areas of Libode, Tabankulu, Mqanduli, Qumbu and Elliotdale are subject to land leases. These leases are not seen as detrimental, and the lease amount payable has been included in the discounted cash flows as a monthly expense.
To the best of my knowledge, there are no options in favour of any parties for any purchase of any of the properties.
8. INTRA-GROUP OR RELATED PARTY LEASES
Having inspected all the tenant schedules and leases it is noted that there are no intra-group or related party leases.
9. LEASES AND SUB LEASES
As per Listing Requirements a high-level summary of the actual tenant leases or sub leases, are required to be reflected in this summary report.
Herewith a high-level summary of each property as reflected by tenancy schedules provided.
Mala Plaza: Is anchored by Pick 'n Pay, occupying approximately 20.9% of the centre GLA and is supported by several national tenants occupying approximately 54.4%. The rest of the centre is occupied by local tenants with a small contingent vacant space of 3.9%.
Mega Park: This large box size centre has various national tenants to a total occupation of 82.4%. The only vacancy is an ATM.
Bradlows: A fully let building occupied by two national tenants.
Mkuze Corner: A small centre, anchored by Spar and Tops occupying 57.3% and a vacancy of 1.5%. The rest of the centre is occupied by local tenants.
Richmond Centre: This centre has a vacancy of 3.9% and is anchored by Spar that occupies approximately 27.6% of the total GLA. The supporting national tenants occupies a space of approximately 36.2% of the GLA. This entails that the centre has a large contingent of local tenants.
Paddagat centre – St Georges Square: This fully let centre is anchored by Checkers that occupies approximately 39.3% of the total GLA of the centre. National tenants' occupation contributes to approximately 20.5% of the GLA. The rest is occupied by local tenants.
Boxer Centre, Elliotdale: A fully let centre with the anchor tenant Boxer Superstore occupying 35% of the total GLA. In addition to the anchor, the national tenants are currently occupying 26% of the GLA.
Qumbu Plaza: This centre has a large vacancy contingent of 15.5% of the total GLA and is anchored by Boxer Superstore that occupies 31.6% of the total GLA. The national tenants occupy 41.1% of the GLA.
Boxer Centre, Mqanduli: A centre anchored by Boxer Superstores that occupy approximately 41.8% of the total GLA and has a vacancy of 2.9% of the GLA. The national tenant contingent occupies 25.6% of the GLA.
Boxer Centre, Tabankulu: A fully let centre with the anchor tenant Boxer Superstore occupying 49.2% of the total GLA. In addition to the anchor, the national tenants are currently occupying 21.8% of the GLA.
Middestad Centre: A centre with several national tenants that occupies approximately 62% with Checkers the anchor at an occupancy of 20.2% of the GLA. The centre has a vacancy of 2.4% of the GLA.
Sibilo Shopping Centre: This centre has a vacancy of 4.4% and is anchored by Shoprite that occupies approximately 32.6% of the total GLA. The supporting national tenants occupies a space of approximately 44.6% of the GLA.
Libode Shopping Centre: A small centre, anchored by Boxer Superstores occupying 33.5% and only an ATM vacant. The supporting national tenants occupies a space of approximately 46.5% of the GLA. The rest of the centre is occupied by local tenants.
Zamdela: A small fully tenanted centre, anchored by Boxer Superstores occupying 46.7%. The rest of the centre is occupied by three national tenants.
Sharpeville: A small fully tenanted centre occupied by a Spar and Tops and ATM only.
Stretford: A small fully tenanted centre occupied by a Spar and Tops and ATM only.
The Palms: A poorly tenanted office block with a vacancy of 37.9% of the GLA.
10. CURRENT STATE OF THE DEVELOPMENT
There is no property which is currently being re-developed.
11. RENTALS USED IN THE VALUATIONS
Note that all these properties are all generally rented out. The current annual rental and future annual rentals have been calculated in a separate discounted cash flow schedule. It is noted that there are no material rental reversions and that the rentals for all the properties increase on average by approximately 5% – 10% compounding per annum.
12. EXTERNAL PROPERTY
None of the properties are situated outside the Republic of South Africa.
13. OTHER GENERAL MATTERS AND VALUATION SUMMARY
A full Valuation Report is available on a property by property basis detailing tenancy, town planning, valuer's commentary, expenditure and other details. This has been given to the directors of Arrowhead.
14. ALTERNATIVE USE FOR A PROPERTY
The properties have been valued in accordance with their existing use which represents their market value. No alternative use for the properties has been considered in determining their value.
15. OTHER COMMENTS
Our valuation excludes any amounts of Value-added Tax, transfer duty, or securities transfer duty.
16. CAVEATS
16.1 Full Disclosure
This valuation has been prepared on the basis that full disclosure of all information and factors that could affect the valuation ('all relevant factors') have been made to us. We accept no liability or responsibility whatsoever for the valuation if it should transpire that a full disclosure of all relevant factors was not made.
16.2 Third Party Involvement
Where reliance was placed on information supplied by third parties in undertaking the evaluation, we have assumed such information to be substantially correct. We accept no liability or responsibility whatsoever for the valuation if it should transpire that the information supplied was substantially incorrect.
16.3 Valuation Standard
This valuation has been prepared in accordance with the International Valuation Standards Committee requirements as adopted by the South African Council for the Property Valuers Profession and the South African Institute of Valuers.
16.4 Freehold Property
In the case of freehold properties we have inspected the relevant title deed documents when available. Whenever perusal of the title deed caused concern, we made specific reference to this in the Valuation Report. Where the Title Deeds were not available we have assumed that good title can be shown and that the property is not subject to any unusual or especially onerous restrictions, encumbrances or outgoings.
16.5 Mortgage Bonds, Loans or Other Charges
The properties have been valued as if wholly owned with no allowance made for any outstanding monies due in respect of mortgage bonds, loans or other charges. No deductions have been made in our valuation for the cost of acquisition, such as legal or transfer fees, or the costs involved in the disposal of the assets.
16.6 Calculation of Areas
Where Arrowhead (or his/her representative) has provided all surface areas quoted within the Valuation Report, we assume such surface areas have been calculated in accordance with the SAPOA standard method of measurement. Where a valuer on site measures the surface areas, the SAPOA standard method of measurement shall be employed.
16.7 Plans
All plans included in the Valuation Report are supplied for the purpose of identification and orientation only and are not necessarily to scale.
16.8 Property Boundaries
The farm or property boundaries, as indicated to the Valuer by the instructing client or his appointed agent, or the boundaries as indicated by plans supplied by the client, are assumed to be the legal extent of the property. Any variation of these boundaries by extension or omission, and the resultant inclusion or omission of any improvements because of this or these variations, cannot therefore be regarded as the responsibility of the Valuer. We accept no liability or responsibility whatsoever for the valuation should it transpire that any boundaries were incorrectly pointed out.
16.9 Outgoings
It is assumed, except where otherwise stated, that the properties are subject to the normal property owner's outgoings and that there are no onerous restrictions or unusual covenants of which we have no knowledge. In preparing our valuation, we have formed our opinion of outgoings, having had reference to the various schedules of outgoings supplied by Arrowhead or a representative thereof.
16.10 Structural Condition
The properties have been valued in their existing state. In the event of its ownership or use changing in such a manner that the local authority will require the upgrading of the premises to comply with fire protection and other regulations, it may be necessary to reduce the valuation by the amount covering the cost of such compliance. We have had regard to the apparent state and condition of the properties but have not carried out a structural survey, nor inspected those areas, which were covered, unexposed or inaccessible, neither have we arranged for the testing of electrical, heating or other services. The valuation assumes that the services and structures are in a satisfactory state of repair and condition, unless otherwise stated in our report. The valuation further assumes that the improvements have been erected in accordance with the relevant Building and Town Planning Regulations as well as the Local Authority by-laws. We have not inspected woodwork or other parts of the structures, and we are therefore unable to repost that such parts of the properties are free from rot, beetle or other defects. We have assumed that no deleterious or hazardous materials or techniques were used in the construction of the properties nor have since been incorporated.
16.11 Contamination
Our valuation assumes that a formal environmental assessment is not provided and further that the properties are not environmentally impaired nor contaminated, unless otherwise stated in our Valuation Report.
16.12 Vacant Land
No soil or substratum tests on the properties have been undertaken and it is assumed that the properties are suitable for the intended purpose, without having to provide excessive reinforcement to any structure built thereon.
16.13 Statutory Notice and Unlawful Use
We have assumed that the properties and its value are unaffected by any statutory notice, and that neither the properties nor its condition, nor its use, nor its intended use, is or will be unlawful.
16.14 Individual Properties
The values reported are for the individual properties. No allowance is made for any premium, which may be applicable for an assembled portfolio of properties, nor is a discount allowed for any flooding of the market, which might exist if all, or a majority of the properties were offered for sale simultaneously.
16.15 Confidentiality
DDP accepts no liability for any loss, damages and/or expenses of any nature which may arise as a result of, or which may be attributable directly or indirectly from information made available to us, or actions or transactions resulting therefrom. Please refer to our Privacy Policy for more information (https://ddp.co.za/legal/).
In the event of any changes to your personal information, you have an obligation to inform DDP within 30 days.
For more information regarding DDP, please refer to our website (https://ddp.co.za/legal/).
16.16 Independent Valuers Clause
Neither the Valuer, nor any employee, have any present or contemplated interest in this or any other properties or any other interests, which could affect the statements or values, contained in this Summary Valuation Report. The valuation enclosed herewith was therefore undertaken on a completely independent basis by valuers employed by the Valuer, a company which specialises in valuation and which does not trade in these assets.
16.17 Value Added Tax
All figures quoted are exclusive of Value Added Tax.
16.18 Court Cases
Please note that if this Summary Valuation Report or any portions thereof are used in a court case, additional fees will be applicable.
17. MARKET VALUE
We are of the opinion that the aggregate market value of the properties (including solar installations) as at 30 June 2021 is R327 900 000.00 (five properties valued) and R933 900 000.00 as at 30 September 2021 (12 properties valued) (excluding VAT). A summary of the individual valuations and details of each of the properties is attached.
To the best of our knowledge and belief there have been no material changes in circumstances between the effective date of the valuations and the date of this Summary Valuation Report which would affect the valuation.
Combined, we have more than twenty-seven years' experience in the valuation of all property types and we are qualified to express an opinion on the fair market value of the properties.
We trust that we have carried out all instructions to your satisfaction and thank you for the opportunity of undertaking this valuation on your behalf.
SIGNED BY:
Ashton Eckler
Professional Valuer registered with the South African Council for the Professional Valuers Profession (SACPVP). Registration Number 6022/8
and
Beukes Kuit
Professional Valuer registered with the South African Council for the Professional Valuers Profession (SACPVP). Registration Number 7331/2 For and on behalf of DDP Valuation and Advisory Services (Proprietary) Limited.
Ashton Eckler
Beukes Kuit
DDP Valuation and Advisory Services (Proprietary) Limited
Company Registration (2007/018821/07) [email protected]
Menlyn Square Office Park 134 Aramist Avenue, Menlyn, Pretoria 012 369 9100
| ANNEXURE A: PROPERTY SCHEDULE | |||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Building name | Property description | Address | Property use | Inspection date | Freehold/ Leasehold |
Tenure of leasehold |
Approximate age of building (years) |
| Mkuze Corner | Portion 1 Erf 59 Mkuze, KwaZulu Natal | Cnr Eagle Ave and Falcon Street, Mkuze |
|||||
| Shopping Centre Richmond |
Erf 824 Richmond, KwaZulu Natal | Cnr Nelson, Benjamin and Chilley Streets, Richmond |
|||||
| Bradlows | Remaining Extent Erf 814 Bloemfontein, Free State |
37 Maitland Street, Bloemfontein |
|||||
| Mega Park | Remaining Extent Erf 27819 Bloemfontein, Free State |
30 Curie Avenue, Hospital Park, Bloemfontein |
|||||
| Mala Plaza | Erf 936 Malamulele-A, | Main Road, Malamulele | Retail Centre | 15 June 2021 | Freehold | N/A | 25 |
| Qumbu Plaza | Erf 30 Qumbu, Eastern Cape Province | Aubert Street, Qumbu | Retail Centre | 18 October 2021 | Leasehold | R25 440,00/month with 6% escalation |
8 |
| Boxer Elliotdale | Remaining Extent Erf 93 Elliotdale, Eastern Cape Province |
Main Road, Elliotdale | Retail Centre | 18 October 2021 | Leasehold | 8% of Gross income | 10+ |
| ANNEXURE A: PROPERTY SCHEDULE |
|---|
Classification/building
| Building name | Property description | Address | Property use | Inspection date | Leasehold | leasehold | of building (years) | grade |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mkuze Corner | Portion 1 Erf 59 Mkuze, KwaZulu Natal | Cnr Eagle Ave and Falcon Street, Mkuze |
Retail Centre | 25 June 2021 | Freehold | N/A | 20 | Local Convenience Centre |
| Shopping Centre Richmond |
Erf 824 Richmond, KwaZulu Natal | Cnr Nelson, Benjamin and Chilley Streets, Richmond |
Retail Centre | 29 June 2021 | Freehold | N/A | 13 | Neighbourhood Centre |
| Bradlows | Remaining Extent Erf 814 Bloemfontein, Free State |
37 Maitland Street, Bloemfontein |
Retail Centre | 28 June 2021 | Freehold | N/A | 50+ | Stand Alone Retail |
| Mega Park | Remaining Extent Erf 27819 Bloemfontein, Free State |
30 Curie Avenue, Hospital Park, Bloemfontein |
Retail Centre | 28 June 2021 | Freehold | N/A | 25 | Neighbourhood Centre/ Retail Warehousing |
| Mala Plaza | Erf 936 Malamulele-A, | Main Road, Malamulele | Retail Centre | 15 June 2021 | Freehold | N/A | 25 | Neighbourhood Centre |
| Qumbu Plaza | Erf 30 Qumbu, Eastern Cape Province | Aubert Street, Qumbu | Retail Centre | 18 October 2021 | Leasehold | R25 440,00/month with 6% escalation |
8 | Neighbourhood Centre |
| Boxer Elliotdale | Remaining Extent Erf 93 Elliotdale, Eastern Cape Province |
Main Road, Elliotdale | Retail Centre | 18 October 2021 | Leasehold | 8% of Gross income | 10+ | Neighbourhood Centre |
| Boxer Mqanduli | Erf 871 Mqanduli, Eastern Cape Province Main Street, Mqanduli | Retail Centre | 18 October 2021 | Leasehold | R53 725,43/month with 6% escalation |
11 | Local Convenience Centre |
|
| Boxer Tabankulu | Erf 93 Tabankulu, Eastern Cape Province | Main Road, Tabankulu | Retail Centre | 18 October 2021 | Leasehold | 6,5% of Gross income |
8 | Local Convenience Centre |
| Shopping Centre Libode |
Erf 1294, Libode, Nyandeni Municipality, Eastern Cape Province |
Along Main Road, Libode | Retail Centre | 18 October 2021 | Leasehold | R10 135,00/month with 6% escalation |
4 | Local Convenience Centre |
| Shopping Centre Zamdela |
Portion 1 Erf 4000 Zamdela, Free State Province |
Somerspost Street, Zamdela (Sasolburg) |
Retail Centre | 13 October 2021 | Freehold | N/A | 16 | Local Convenience Centre |
| Score Stretford | Erf 16145 Stretford Extension 9, City of Johannesburg |
Falcon Road, Stretford | Retail Centre | 13 October 2021 | Freehold | N/A | 17 | Local Convenience Centre |
| Score Sharpeville | Erf 9189 and 9190 Sharpeville, Emfuleni Local Municipality |
Seeiso Street, Sharpeville | Retail Centre | 15 October 2021 | Freehold | N/A | 16 | Local Convenience Centre |
| The Palms | Erf 215, 216 and 217 Halfway House, City of Johannesburg |
519 – 523 Nupen Crescent, Halway House Extension 12 |
Offices | 5 October 2021 | Freehold | N/A | 26 | C-Grade Offices |
| Shopping Centre Sibilo |
Erf 7362 Postmasburg, Northern Cape Province |
Corner Cam Street and R385 | Retail Centre | 7 October 2021 | Freehold | N/A | 11 | Neighbourhood Centre |
| Middestad Mall | Erf 15942 Bloemfontein, Free State Province |
Charles Street, Bloemfontein Corner West Burger and |
Retail Centre | 11 October 2021 | Freehold | N/A | 40 | Neighbourhood Centre |
| Paddagat Centre | Erf 1951 George, Western Cape ProvinceKnysna Street, George | Retail Centre | 23 September 2021 | Freehold | N/A | 22 | Neighbourhood Centre |
| Building name | Rentable area 2 |
2021 Exit cap rate % |
2021 Discount rate % |
missions) 2021 Net income for the initial 12 Month period (after leasing Rand com |
2021 Solar Value Rand |
2021 Valuation Rand |
2021 Valuation including solar Rand |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mkuze Corner | 3 388 | 10.50 | 14.75 | 2 899 192 | – | 32 200 000 | 32 200 000 |
| mond Shopping Centre Rich |
9 214 | 10.50 | 14.75 | 8 137 990 | 8 200 000,00 | 91 000 000 | 99 200 000 |
| Bradlows | 2 562.81 | 10.50 | 14.50 | 1 140 338 | – | 11 600 000 | 11 600 000 |
| Mega Park | 6 743.98 | 10.50 | 15.00 | 8 154 045 | – | 83 900 000 | 83 900 000 |
| Mala Plaza | 6 207.57 | 11.00 | 15.50 | 8 718 137 | 5 600 000,00 | 95 400 000 | 101 000 000 |
| Qumbu Plaza | 5 470 | 10.50 | 15.25 | 6 492 799 | 7 000 000,00 | 62 300 000 | 69 300 000 |
| Boxer Elliotdale | 7 360 | 10.50 | 15.25 | 8 678 984 | 82 500 000 | 82 500 000 | |
| Boxer Mqanduli | 4 689 | 10.50 | 15.25 | 5 244 568 | 49 800 000 | 49 800 000 | |
| Boxer Tabankulu | 4 117 | 10.50 | 15.25 | 4 195 136 | 43 400 000 | 43 400 000 | |
| Libode Shopping Centre | 4 991 | 10.50 | 15.25 | 6 521 808 | 4 600 000,00 | 63 300 000 | 67 900 000 |
| Zamdela Shopping Centre | 2 247 | 10.25 | 14.75 | 2 912 148 | 29 700 000 | 29 700 000 | |
| Score Stretford | 1 508 | 10.25 | 14.75 | 1 433 920 | 15 800 000 | R15 800 000 | |
| Score Sharpeville | 1 145 | 10.25 | 14.75 | 1 396 021 | 14 100 000 | 14 100 000 | |
| The Palms | 2 501 | 12.00 | 14.50 | 906 620 | 13 300 000 | 13 300 000 | |
| Sibilo Shopping Centre | 8 476 | 10.25 | 14.75 | 13 193 522 | 132 200 000 | 132 200 000 | |
| Middestad Mall | 10 775 | 10.00 | 14.50 | 27 291 184 | 11 200 000,00 | 282 100 000 | 293 300 000 |
| Paddagat Centre | 11 001 | 10.50 | 15.25 | 11 955 943 | 8 000 000,00 | 116 200 000 | 124 200 000 |
ANNEXURE B: ZONING INFORMATION
Erf 30 Qumbu – Zoning Information
| Name of Local Authority | Mhlontlo Local Municipality | |
|---|---|---|
| Permissible | Actual | |
| Zoning | General Business | Retail Centre |
| Coverage | 80% | Complies |
| Height | 2 Storeys | Complies |
| FAR, FSR, Bulk | No restriction | Complies |
| Setback | None Noted | Complies |
| Building Line | Front of building – 0mt Rear of building – 0mt |
Complies |
| Parking Ratio | 1/100m2 GLA |
Ample parking provided |
| Comments | Property is seen to comply with zoning restrictions |
Erf 93 Tabankulu – Zoning Information
| Name of Local Authority | Ntabankulu Local Municipality | |
|---|---|---|
| Permissible | Actual | |
| Zoning | Business 1 | Retail Centre |
| Coverage | 66.66% | Complies |
| Height | 2 Storeys | Complies |
| FAR, FSR, Bulk | No restriction | Complies |
| Setback | None Noted | Complies |
| Building Line | Front of building – 0mt Rear of building – 0mt |
Complies |
| Parking Ratio | 4/100m2 GLA |
Ample parking provided |
| Comments | information is proven to be incorrect. | We could not reach the zoning officer of the Municipality to confirm zoning due to the COVID-19 pandemic. We reserve the right to amend the report if the above |
Erf 871 Mqanduli – Zoning Information
| Name of Local Authority | King Sabata Dalindyebo Local Municipality | |
|---|---|---|
| Permissible | Actual | |
| Zoning | Business 1 | Retail Centre |
| Coverage | 66.66% | Complies |
| Height | 2 Storeys | Complies |
| FAR, FSR, Bulk | No restriction | Complies |
| Setback | None Noted | Complies |
| Building Line | Front of building – 0mt Rear of building – 0mt |
Complies |
| Parking Ratio | 4/100m2 GLA |
Ample parking provided |
| Comments | information is proven to be incorrect. | We could not reach the zoning officer of the Municipality to confirm zoning due to the COVID-19 pandemic. We reserve the right to amend the report if the above |
Erf 1294 Libode – Zoning Information
| Name of Local Authority | Nyandeni Local Municipality | |
|---|---|---|
| Permissible | Actual | |
| Zoning | Not obtained | Retail Centre |
| Coverage | Not obtained | TBC |
| Height | Not obtained | TBC |
| FAR, FSR, Bulk | Not obtained | TBC |
| Setback | Not obtained | TBC |
| Building Line | Not obtained | TBC |
| Parking Ratio | Not obtained | Ample parking provided |
| Comments | proven to be incorrect. | We could not reach the zoning officer of the Municipality to confirm zoning at the time of valuation. We reserve the right to amend the report if the above information is |
Remainder Erf 93 Elliotdale – Zoning Information
| Name of Local Authority | Mbhashe Local Municipality | |
|---|---|---|
| Permissible | Actual | |
| Zoning | General Business | Retail Centre |
| Coverage | 80% | Complies |
| Height | 2 Storeys | Complies |
| FAR, FSR, Bulk | No restriction | Complies |
| Setback | None Noted | Complies |
| Building Line | 0mt for shops | Complies |
| Parking Ratio | No parking ratio restrictions | Ample parking provided |
| Comments | with zoning restrictions. | Zoning information as supplied by Mbhashe Municipality. Property is seen to comply |
Erf 215, 216 and 217 Halfway House (The Palms)
| Name of Local Authority | Thulamela Local Municipality | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| Permissible | Actual | ||
| Zoning | Residential 2 | Offices | |
| Coverage | 40% | Complies | |
| Height | 3 Storeys | Double Storey | |
| FAR, FSR, Bulk | 0.8 | 0.53 | |
| Setback | None Noted | N/A | |
| Building Line | Building lines shall be to the satisfaction of the local authority |
As per town planning scheme | |
| Parking Ratio | Office: 4 bays/100m² gross floor area | 68 Parking bays provided | |
| Comments | The use zone is noted as Residential 2. This use includes business buildings, offices, places of instruction, institutions, public garage and dwelling home offices. The subject sites seem to comply with Town Planning requirements. |
Erf 9189 and 9190 Sharpeville
| Name of Local Authority | Emfuleni Local Municipality | |
|---|---|---|
| Permissible | Actual | |
| Zoning | Business 1 | Retail – Supermarket |
| Coverage | 70% – 1 836.10m2 | 65% – 1 186.00m2 |
| Height | 3 Storeys, including a Ground Floor | 1 Storey |
| FAR, FSR, Bulk | As per town planning scheme | 0.45 |
| Setback | None Noted | Not applicable |
| Building Line | As per town planning scheme | 10m street boundary, 4m rear, 3m left and 10m right |
| Parking Ratio | As per Town Planning Scheme | 14 open parking bays inside the property and 7 parking bays outside the property. |
| Comments | Property is seen to comply with zoning restrictions |
Erf 16145 Stretford
| Name of Local Authority | City of Johannesburg Metropolitan Municipality | |
|---|---|---|
| Permissible | Actual | |
| Zoning | Institutional | Retail (Supermarket) |
| Coverage | 70% – 6 259.40m2 | 20% – 1 825.00m2 |
| Height | 3 Storeys | 1 Storey |
| FAR, FSR, Bulk | As per town planning scheme | 0.45 |
| Setback | None Noted | Not applicable |
| Building Line | As per town planning scheme | 10m street boundary, 4m rear, 3m left and 10m right |
| Parking Ratio | As per Town Planning Scheme | 41 open parking bays inside the property |
| Comments | On the zoning certificate received from the City of Johannesburg, the subject property is zoned Institutional. The primary usage of a property zoned Institutional is an institution, a place of instruction, social halls, religious purposes and the secondary use is as medical consulting rooms, dwelling units, residential buildings, sport and recreation club and public or private parking areas. The current use as retail does not conform to the permitted use as per the zoning certificate. This valuation is made on condition that the subject property be rezoned to Business 1. |
Portion 1 Erf 4000 Zamdela
| Name of Local Authority | Metsimaholo Local Municipality | |
|---|---|---|
| Permissible | Actual | |
| Zoning | Business | Commercial – Retail |
| Coverage | 70% | 30.71% |
| Height | 3 Storeys | 1 Storey |
| FAR, FSR, Bulk | Not Applicable | Not applicable |
| Setback | None Noted | Not applicable |
| Building Line | Minimum of one metre for rear and side boundaries and three meters from the street |
Complies |
| Parking Ratio | 300.00m2 and over – 4 Bays per 100.00m2 of shopping floor area |
38 Open bays provided |
| Comments | Property is seen to comply with zoning restrictions |
Erf 1951 George (Paddagat Centre)
| Name of Local Authority | George Local Municipality | |
|---|---|---|
| Permissible | Actual | |
| Zoning | Business Zone 1 | Retail Centre |
| Coverage | 100% | Complies |
| Height | 15.0mt | Complies |
| FAR, FSR, Bulk | 3.0 | Complies |
| Setback | None Noted | Complies |
| Building Line | Street, Side and Rear: 0mt | Complies |
| Parking Ratio | 4/100m2 GLA |
446 parking bays supplied and therefore comply with town planning regulations. |
| Comments | The current improvements are considered to comply with council requirements. |
Erf 7362 Postmasburg (Sibilo Shopping Centre)
| Name of Local Authority | Tsantsabane Local Municipality | |
|---|---|---|
| Permissible | Actual | |
| Zoning | Business 1 | Retail Centre |
| Coverage | No restriction | 33% |
| Height | No restriction | 2 Storeys |
| FAR, FSR, Bulk | No restriction | 0.35 |
| Setback | None noted | 14.0mt from street |
| Building Line | None noted | 3mt from nearest boundary |
| Parking Ratio | 4/100m2 GLA |
264 Open parking bays supplied |
| Comments | The zoning information was obtained from previous report and could not be confirmed with the local authority. The property appears to conform to the zoning requirements with the exception of the parking. The total parking bays as per zoning should be 344. However, on the day of inspection, although not over the end of the month or weekend, the available parking appears to be more than sufficient. Condition is held for the compliance of the properties to town planning restrictions. |
Erf 15942 Bloemfontein
| Name of Local Authority | Mangaung Metropolitan Municipality | |
|---|---|---|
| Permissible | Actual | |
| Zoning | Business Subzone H | Retail Centre |
| Coverage | No restriction | Complies |
| Height | 28 Metres | Complies |
| FAR, FSR, Bulk | 6.0 | Complies |
| Setback | None noted | Complies |
| Building Line | None noted | Complies |
| Parking Ratio | 4/100m2 GLA |
Ample parking bays supplied |
| Comments | requirements. | Zoning information as utilised in a previous report and is seen to comply with council |
Erf 27819 Bloemfontein (Mega Park)
| Name of Local Authority | Mangaung Metropolitan Municipality | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| Permissible | Actual | ||
| Zoning | Business | Retail Centre | |
| Coverage | 100% | Seen to comply | |
| Height | 9.2m | Seen to comply | |
| FAR, FSR, Bulk | No restriction | Seen to comply | |
| Setback | None Noted | N/A | |
| Building Line | None noted | Seen to comply | |
| Parking Ratio | 4 bays/100m2 GLA |
Ample parking provided | |
| Comments | Property is seen to comply with zoning restrictions |
Erf 814 Bloemfontein (Bradlows Building)
| Name of Local Authority | Mangaung Metropolitan Municipality | |
|---|---|---|
| Permissible | Actual | |
| Zoning | Business | Retail |
| Coverage | Not obtained | Seen to comply |
| Height | Not obtained | Seen to comply |
| FAR, FSR, Bulk | Not obtained | Seen to comply |
| Setback | Not obtained | N/A |
| Building Line | Not obtained | Seen to comply |
| Parking Ratio | Not obtained | Ample parking provided |
| Comments | The zoning was not obtained at the time of the valuation. Property is seen to comply with zoning restrictions |
Portion 1 Erf 59 Mkuze (Mkuze Corner)
| Name of Local Authority | Jozini Local Municipality |
|---|---|
| Comments | I have been unable to gather any town planning information from the Jozini Municipality relating to the subject property. However if one considers that the adjoining properties are similar in the sense that all are utilised for some commercial use, I would be of the assumption that the subject property conforms to the existing town planning controls for the area. |
Erf 824 Richmond
| Name of Local Authority | Richmond Local Municipality |
|---|---|
| Comments | I have been unable to gather any town planning information from the Richmond Municipality relating to the subject property. However if one considers that the adjoining properties are similar in the sense that all are utilised for some commercial use, I would be of the assumption that the subject property conforms to the existing town planning controls for the area. |
Erf 936 Malamulele-A
| Name of Local Authority | Thulamela Local Municipality | |
|---|---|---|
| Permissible | Actual | |
| Zoning | Business | Retail Centre |
| Coverage | Not obtained | Seen to comply |
| Height | Not obtained | Seen to comply |
| FAR, FSR, Bulk | Not obtained | Seen to comply |
| Setback | Not obtained | N/A |
| Building Line | Not obtained | Seen to comply |
| Parking Ratio | Not obtained | Ample parking provided |
| Comments | with zoning restrictions | The zoning was not obtained at the time of the valuation. Property is seen to comply |
DE LEEUW VALUERS SUMMARY VALUATION REPORT
The Directors
Arrowhead Properties Limited 3rd Floor Upper Building 1 Sturdee Avenue Rosebank 2196
30 November 2021
Dear Sirs
INDEPENDENT PROPERTY VALUERS' REPORT OF THE PROPERTY PORTFOLIO FOR ARROWHEAD PROPERTIES LIMITED AS DETAILED IN THE SUMMARY SCHEDULE ATTACHED AND FOR WHICH THERE ARE DETAILED VALUATION REPORTS HELD BY ARROWHEAD PROPERTIES LIMITED
This summary report comprises two portfolios valued for internal use.
Firstly, in accordance with the instruction received on 24 May 2021, we confirm that we have visited and inspected the six (6) properties listed in the attached schedule ("the properties") during June and July 2021 and have received all necessary details required to perform a valuation in order to provide you with our opinion of the properties' Market Values (as defined in paragraph 2 below) as at 30 June 2021.
Secondly, in accordance with your instruction of 28 September 2021, we confirm that we have visited and inspected the seven (7) properties listed in the attached schedule ("the properties") during October 2021 and have received all necessary details required to perform a valuation in order to provide you with our opinion of the properties' Market Values (as defined in paragraph 2 below) as at 30 September 2021.
1. INTRODUCTION
The valuation of the properties has been carried out by the valuer who has carefully considered all aspects of all the properties. These properties each have a detailed valuation report which has been given to the management of Arrowhead Properties Limited. The detailed reports include commentary on the current economy, nature of the properties, locality, tenancy, risk profile, forward rent and earning capability and exposure to future expenses and property risk. All these aspects have been considered in the individual valuation reports of the properties. The detailed reports have further addressed the tenancy income capability and expenditure for each property and tenant. Historic expenditure profile as well as future expenditure increases have been considered.
The value thus indicates the Market Value for each property which is detailed in the detailed report, and which has been summarised on a summary schedule, attached hereto, for each property. There are seven (7) properties and the important aspects of the detailed valuation report including the property Market Value for all of the properties have been summarised in the attached schedule.
2. BASIS OF VALUATION
The valuation is based on Market Value. Market Value means "The estimated amount for which an asset or liability should exchange on the valuation date assuming:
- 2.1 a willing buyer and a willing seller in an arm's length transaction,
- 2.2 after proper marketing; and
- 2.3 the parties had each acted knowledgeably, prudently and without compulsion.
3. VALUE CALCULATION
The calculation of the Market Value of the properties has been prepared using one, or a combination of, the methods listed below which is deemed to be the most appropriate, taking into consideration the quality and accuracy of information available.
Independent enquiries were made in relation to market conditions and outlook, pricing, and sales using a variety of sources including agents, developers and other active participants in the local property market. In addition, regard was had to reputable publications and published data.
3.1 Income Approach (Discounted Cash Flow method – DCF)
- 3.1.1 The calculation of the Market Value of the properties was based on the Discounted Cash Flow ("DCF") method of valuation.
- 3.1.2 The DCF valuation approach is used by many international and institutional investors to be able to compare the internal rate of return ("IRR") on different classes of investments. Using the DCF approach, an asset is valued by discounting the expected future net income for a holding period at an appropriate discount rate to give the present value ("PV") of the expected cash flows and the PV of the disposal price/exit value at the end of the cash-flow period. This PV is effectively the Market Value a purchaser would bid for the asset if s/he assumed they required the IRR/discount rate inputted into the model. Market rental growth is projected over the DCF horizon and applied to the income stream whenever current leases end and revert to market. The exit value is calculated by taking the income in the final year of the cash flow projection period and capitalising it at an appropriate all risks yield and then discounting the capital value produced to a present value by the discount rate.
4. SPARE LAND
There are no properties with large tracts of vacant zoned land.
5. BRIEF DESCRIPTION
The first portfolio, with the date of valuation as at 30 June 2021 include five retail properties and one office property. The second portfolio, with the date of valuation as at 30 September 2021 comprises of six retail properties and one single tenanted office property. The properties are in a good condition and have been well maintained. The tenant profile is considered well suited to each asset, with a favourable retail synergy and limited vacancies. The leases tend to be of a general short to medium term contractual rental nature with provision for the recovery of utility services consumed by the lessees. Escalations are market related. In respect of the properties, the current net annual rental and the estimated future net annual rentals at specified dates and for specified periods are included in each individual detailed property valuation report.
6. VALUATION QUALIFICATIONS
Qualifications are usually detailed as a consequence of: leases under negotiation that have not yet been formalised; leases of a large nature where the premises are difficult to re-let; specialised properties; large exposure to a single tenant; potential tenant failure due to over-renting; expenses required for major repairs; maintenance or other exposure to maintain the lettability of the building; contingent expropriations or servitudes that may be enforced; poor lease records whereby the lease may be disputed or rendered invalid.
We have, to the best of our knowledge, considered all of these aspects in the valuation of all the properties. There are no properties that are prejudiced in value by the influence of the above factors.
The valuer is however not responsible for the competent daily management of these properties that will ensure that this status is maintained, or for the change of any laws, services by local authority or economic circumstances that may adversely impact on the integrity of the buildings or the tenant profile.
7. OPTIONS OR BENEFIT/DETRIMENT OF CONTRACTUAL ARRANGEMENTS
To our knowledge there are no contractual arrangements on the properties other than the leases as detailed in the report that have a major benefit or are detrimental to the fundamental value base of the properties.
To the best of my knowledge, there are no options in favour of any parties for any purchase of any of the properties.
No allowance is included in the valuation reports for income lost due to time delays to complete refurbishments for existing or new tenants.
8. INTRA-GROUP OR RELATED PARTY LEASES
Having inspected all the tenant schedules it is noted that there are no intra-group or related party leases.
9. CURRENT STATE OF DEVELOPMENT
There is no property which is currently being re-developed.
10. RENTALS USED IN VALUATIONS
Note that all these properties are all generally rented out. The current annual rental and future annual rentals have been calculated in a separate discounted cash flow schedule. It is noted that there are no material rental reversions and that the rentals for all the properties increase on average by approximately 6 – 8% compounding per annum.
11. EXTERNAL PROPERTY
None of the properties are situated outside the Republic of South Africa.
12. OTHER GENERAL MATTERS AND VALUATION SUMMARY
A full valuation report is available on a property-by-property basis detailing tenancy, town planning, valuer's commentary, expenditure and other details. This has been given to the directors of Arrowhead Properties Limited.
Contamination: upon inspection of the properties, no contamination related aspects were brought to our attention. Commenting on environmental matters and possible contamination falls outside our field of expertise as Valuers and therefore we are unable to express a professional opinion on this matter.
13. ALTERNATIVE USE FOR A PROPERTY
The properties have been valued in accordance with their existing use which represents their Market Value. No alternative use for the properties has been considered in determining their value.
14. OTHER COMMENTS
Our valuation excludes any amounts of Value-added Tax, transfer duty, or securities transfer duty.
15. CAVEATS
15.1 Source of information and verification
Information on the properties regarding rental income, recoveries and other income detail has been provided to us by the current owners and their managing agents.
We have received copies of the tenancy schedules and where there were queries regarding new tenancies, discussions were held with management in order to verify the information provided.
We have further compared certain expenditures given to us to the market norms of similar properties. This has also been compared to historic expenditure levels of the properties themselves. Historical contractual expenditures and municipal utility services were compared to the past performance of the properties in order to assess potential expenditure going forward.
The specifics of each asset were benchmarked against the following, where applicable:
- 15.1.1 Own Records
- 15.1.2 Rode Report 2021:2 and Rode Report 2021:2
- 15.1.3 SAPOA Market Research Reports
- 15.1.3.1 SAPOA Capitalisation and Discount Rate Survey November 2020 and May 2021
- 15.1.3.2 SAPOA Office Vacancy Survey Q1 2021
- 15.1.3.3 SAPOA Retail Trends Quarter Ended March 2021
- 15.1.3.4 SAPOA Operating Costs Q4 2020
Information on the properties regarding rental income, recoveries and other income detail has been provided to us by the current owners and their managing agents.
15.2 Full disclosure
We accept as being accurate and complete the information provided to us by the sources detailed in our report, relating to items such as tenure, tenancies, tenants' improvements and all other relevant matters.
Where valuations are carried out of properties fully equipped as an operational trading entity, we have assumed that the information received is accurate and reliable and can be substantiated by independent audit.
15.3 Inspections
We undertake such inspections and conduct investigations as are, in our opinion, correct, appropriate and possible in the particular circumstances applying.
15.4 Leases
Unless disclosed to us, it is assumed that all properties are subject to normal outgoings and that landlords are responsible for all repairs, the cost of insurance and payment of rates and other usual outgoings, either directly or by means of service charge provisions.
Unless we state otherwise, it is further assumed that rent reviews are on an upward-only basis to the open market rent and that no questions of doubt arise as to the interpretation of the rent review provisions in the lease. We assume that neither the landlord nor the tenant may terminate the lease prematurely.
15.5 Lessees' credibility
Unless specifically requested, we do not make detailed enquiries into the covenant strength of occupational tenants but rely on our judgement of the market's perception of them. Any comments on covenant strength should therefore be read in this context. Furthermore, we assume, unless otherwise advised, that the tenant is capable of meeting its financial obligations under the lease and that there are no arrears of rent or other payments or undisclosed breaches of covenant.
15.6 Mortgage bonds, loans, etc.
The properties have been valued as if wholly owned with no account being taken of any outstanding monies due in respect of mortgage bonds, loans and other charges. No deductions have been made in our valuation for costs of acquisition.
The valuation is detailed in a completed state and no deductions have been made for retention or any other set-off or deduction for any purposes which may be made at the discretion of the purchaser when purchasing the properties.
15.7 Calculation of areas
All property measurement is carried out in accordance with the SAPOA Method of Measuring Floor Areas unless we specifically state that we have relied upon another source of information or method. Unless specifically instructed, we do not undertake a measured site survey but rely on the information provided to us.
15.8 Structural condition
Unless specifically instructed, we do not undertake structural surveys, nor do we inspect those parts that are covered, unexposed or inaccessible, or test any of the electrical, heating, drainage or other services. Any readily apparent defects or items of disrepair noted during our inspection will, unless otherwise stated, be reflected in our valuation, but no assurance is given that any property is free from defect. We assume that those parts which have not been inspected would not reveal material defects which would cause us to alter our valuation.
15.9 Contamination
Unless specifically instructed, we do not carry out investigations to ascertain whether any building has been constructed or altered using deleterious materials or methods. Unless specifically notified, our valuation assumes that no such materials or methods have been used. Common examples include high alumina cement concrete, calcium chloride, asbestos and wood wool slabs used as permanent shuttering.
15.10 Town planning
Wherever possible, we undertake informal enquiries to obtain town planning and highway information from the relevant Local Authority and we rely on such information obtained verbally. If specifically instructed, we will undertake to obtain written verification of the position, as stated in our report.
Our valuations are prepared on the assumption that the premises comply with all relevant statutory enactments and Building Acts and Regulations and that a valid and up-to-date Fire Certificate has been issued. We also assume that all necessary consents, licences and authorisations for the use of the property and the process carried out therein have been obtained and will continue to subsist and are not subject to any onerous conditions.
Unless disclosed to us, we assume that there are no outstanding statutory breaches or impending litigation in respect of the property.
15.11 Documentation and Title
We assume that each property has a good and marketable title and is free from any pending litigation.
We further assume that all documentation is satisfactorily drawn and that unless disclosed to us, there are no unusual or onerous restrictions, easements, covenants or other outgoings which would adversely affect the value of the relevant interest(s).
16. MARKET VALUE
We are of the opinion that the aggregate market value of the properties is as follows:
| Number of Properties | Date of Valuation | Value (ex VAT) | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1) | 6 | 30 June 2021 | R537 000 000 |
| 2) | 7 | 30 September 2021 | R868 300 000 |
A summary of the individual valuations and details of each of the properties are attached.
To the best of our knowledge and belief there have been no material changes in circumstances between the date of the valuation and the date of the valuation report which would affect the valuation.
We have more than 30 years' experience in the valuation of all nature of property and we are qualified to express an opinion on the Market Value of the properties.
We trust that we have carried out all instructions to your satisfaction and thank you for the opportunity of undertaking this valuation on your behalf.
SIGNED BY: RICS Registered Valuer RICS Registered Valuer
Registered Professional Valuer (SACPVP) Registered Professional Valuer (SACPVP) SACPVP Registration: 7273 SACPVP Registration: 3575 Director Director
Gemma Moore MRICS, Pr Val Pieter Venter MRICS, Pr Val, MIVSA
for and on behalf of De Leeuw Valuers Cape Town (RF) Proprietary Limited Jan de Waalhuis, 93 Bree Street, Cape Town, 8001
112PORTFOLIO 1
Income
DATE OF VALUATION: 30 JUNE 2021
| as at Valuation 30 June 2021 |
R30 200 000 | R4 900 000 | R23 800 000 | R81 300 000 | R28 700 000 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| July Projection for the period 2021 to 30 June 2022 1 |
R3 189,011 | R525 434 | R2 289 801 | R8 282 323 | R2 476 108 |
| vacancy perpetual void/ Assumed |
3% | 5% | 3% | 2% | 3% |
| Planning Statutory contravention (if any) Zoning Town and |
Local Business 2 |
General Business 4 |
Business 1 | Business 1 & Special |
Not confirmed |
| Building Grading |
Offices B-grade |
Stand-alone retail |
Stand-alone retail |
bourhood shopping Neigh centre |
bourhood shopping Neigh centre |
| imate age of building Approx |
14 | 18 | 32 | 22 | 40 |
| area (m²) Rentable |
2 627 | 1 242 | 2 139 | 6 074 | 3 538 |
| Tenure of Leasehold |
N/A | N/A | N/A | N/A | N/A |
| Freehold/ Leasehold |
Freehold | Freehold | Freehold | Freehold | Freehold |
| Valuers Date Inspection |
08 July 2021 | 08 July 2021 | 10 June 2021 | 10 June 2021 | 10 June 2021 |
| Property Use |
Offices | Retail | Retail | Retail | Retail |
| Address | Street, Rosenpark, 24 Bella Rosa City of Cape Town |
Street, Nyanga, 12704 Sombo City of Cape Town |
Jan Niemandpark, Corner of Swaan Coetzee Street, Street and Jan Pretoria |
Road, Centurion, 180 Harvard Gauteng |
Railway Street, Vereeniging, 8 Vereeniging Pick n Pay |
| Description Property |
City of Cape Town, Erf 31291, Bellville, Western Cape |
Erf 12704, Nyanga, City of Cape Town, Western Cape |
Extent of Erf 345 City of Tshwane 114, Remaining Portion 1 of Erf of Erf 114, Jan Niemandpark, and Portion 3 Metropolitan Municipality, Gauteng |
356 Zwartkop Reg Portion 527 Farm Div: JR Gauteng |
Emfuleni Local Municipality, Vereeniging, Erf 1440 Gauteng |
| Property Name |
Omniplace | Shopping Nyanga Centre |
Jan Niemand Spar |
Clubview Corner |
Vereeniging Pick n Pay |
| No | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 |
| as at Valuation 30 June 2021 |
R368 100 000 |
|---|---|
| July Income Projection for the period 2021 to 30 June 2022 1 |
R33 522 969 |
| vacancy perpetual void/ Assumed |
2% |
| Planning Statutory contravention (if any) Zoning Town and |
Business 1 |
| Building Grading |
Community shopping centre |
| age of Approx imate building |
9 32 32 32 41 41 41 |
| area (m²) Rentable |
24 486 |
| Tenure of Leasehold |
N/A |
| Freehold/ Leasehold |
Freehold |
| Valuers Inspection Date |
10 June 2021 |
| Property Use |
Retail |
| Address | Khambule Street, Chris Hani Road Street, Soweto, Bara Precinct, and Mohlala Corners of Gauteng |
| Description Property |
of Johannesburg, of Johannesburg, of Johannesburg, of Johannesburg, of Johannesburg, of Johannesburg, of Johannesburg, Diepkloof City Diepkloof City Diepkloof City Diepkloof City Diepkloof City Diepkloof City Diepkloof City Portion 52 Portion 55 Erf 24459 Erf 24464 Erf 24463 Erf 25170 Erf 24470 Erf 25170 Erf 24462 Gauteng; Gauteng; Gauteng; Gauteng; Gauteng; Gauteng; Gauteng |
| Property Name |
Bara Precinct, Soweto |
| No | 6 |
114PORTFOLIO 2
Income
DATE OF VALUATION: 30 SEPTEMBER 2021
| No | Property Name |
Description Property |
Address | Property Use |
Valuers Date Inspection |
Freehold/ Leasehold |
Tenure of Leasehold |
area (m²) Rentable |
imate age of building Approx |
Building Grading |
Planning Statutory contravention (if any) Zoning Town and |
vacancy void/ Assumed perpetual |
2021 to 1 October September Projection for the period 30 2022 |
September Valuation as at 30 2021 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | CHEP Building Section 6 | "Westville Junction (1 770m²), Section Section 8 (16m²), Sectional Scheme 7 (1,659m²), and together with an undivided share in the common property of the (SS 224/2013)" |
7 Westville Road, Dawncliffe, Durban |
Offices | 19 October 2021 |
Freehold | N/A | 3 260 | ±8 | A-Grade Offices |
General Commercial |
2% | R8 650 715 | R67 900 000 |
| 2 | Nonkgubela Mall |
13435, Khayelitsha, City of Cape Town, Erf 50261 and Erf Western Cape |
99 Sulani Drive, Nonkqubela, Khayelitsha |
Retail | 19 October 2021 |
Freehold | N/A | 10 775 | ±19 | bourhood Shopping Neigh Centre |
General Business 4 |
3% | R17,308,740 | R173 300 000 |
| 3 | Retail Centre Macassar |
City of Cape Town, Erf 7355 Macassar, Western Cape |
Avenue and Burg Street, Macassar, Corner Link |
Retail | 19 October 2021 |
Freehold | N/A | 5 516 | ±13 | General Business 4 |
2% | R7 894 250 | R89 300 000 |
| as at 30 September Valuation 2021 |
R97 700 000 |
|---|---|
| 30 | |
| 2021 to Income for the 1 October September 2022 Projection period |
R9 040 811 |
| vacancy Assumed perpetual void/ |
5% |
| Planning Statutory contravention (if any) Zoning Town and |
General Commercial |
| Building Grading |
|
| age of building Approx imate |
±8 |
| area (m²) Rentable |
6 357 |
| Tenure of Leasehold |
N/A |
| Freehold/ Leasehold |
Freehold |
| Valuers Inspection Date |
19 October 2021 |
| Property Use |
Retail |
| Address | 7 Westville Road, Dawncliffe |
| Description Property |
"Westville Junction 1,682m², Section 9 extent of 5 576m², Section 3 in extent extent of 1,782m², Exclusive Use Area 1,663m², Exclusive Exclusive Use Area with each sections in extent of 59m², 2,181m², together Sectional Scheme undivided share 348m², Section in the common property of the P1 in extent of P3 in extent of Use Area P2 in 24m², Section 4 in extent of 5 in extent of Section 2 in |
| Property Name |
Westville Junction |
| No | 4 |
(224/2013), KwaZulu-Natal
| as at 30 September Valuation 2021 |
R177 100 000 | R233 200 000 |
|---|---|---|
| 2021 to Income for the 1 October 30 September Projection period 2022 |
R16 716 292 | R21 957 231 |
| vacancy perpetual void/ Assumed |
5% | 4.5% |
| Planning Statutory contravention (if any) Zoning Town and |
Transport Use 1 (TR1) - Erf 113702 & 113308: Transport Use 1 Land subject to section 13 of the Legal Succession of the South African Transport Services Act 9 of 1989. Erf 10316: Erf 10172: Single Open Space 2 Residential 2 (TR1) |
Core Mixed Use 1 |
| Building Grading |
bourhood shopping Neigh centre |
|
| age of building Approx imate |
±27 | ±37 |
| area (m²) Rentable |
10 683 | 1 366 |
| Tenure of Leasehold |
Expiry 31 August 2043 |
N/A |
| Freehold/ Leasehold |
Leasehold | Freehold |
| Valuers Inspection Date |
21 October 2021 |
19 October 2021 |
| Property Use |
Retail | Retail |
| Address | Duinefontein Rd, Heideveld, City of Cape Town |
Rd and Biyela Commercial Corner of Streets, |
| Description Property |
Lease Area No. 1 Lease Area No. 1 Lease Area No. 2 Lease Area No. 1 Cape Town, City Cape Town, City over Erf 113702 over Erf 113308 Gugulethu, City Gugulethu, City over Erf 10316 over Erf 10172 of Cape Town, of Cape Town, of Cape Town, of Cape Town, Western Cape Western Cape Western Cape Western Cape |
Municipality, uMhlathuze Empangeni, Erf 3217 |
| Property Name |
Nyanga Junction |
Empangeni Shoprite |
| No | 5 | 6 |
KwaZulu-Natal
Empangeni
| September Valuation as at 30 2021 |
R29 800 000 |
|---|---|
| 2021 to 1 October 30 September Income Projection for the period 2022 |
R3 808 402 |
| vacancy perpetual void/ Assumed |
2% |
| Planning Statutory contravention (if any) Zoning Town and |
General Business |
| Building Grading |
|
| age of building Approx imate |
±99 |
| area (m²) Rentable |
1 897 |
| Tenure of Leasehold |
N/A |
| Freehold/ Leasehold |
Freehold |
| Valuers Inspection Date |
20 October 2021 |
| Property Use |
Retail |
| Address | Pietermaritzburg 210 Church Street, |
| Description Property |
KwaZulu-Natal; and Pietermaritzburg, Pietermaritzburg, KwaZulu-Natal Municipality, Municipality, of Erf 2521, of Erf 2564, Portion 18 Msunduzi Msunduzi Portion 1 |
| Property Name |
210 Church Street |
| No | 7 |
DATE OF VALUATION: 30 JUNE 2021
| No | Property Name | Zoning Town Planning and Statutory contravention (if any) |
Parameters | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Omniplace | Local Business 2 | Coverage:75% Height: FAR, FSR: Building Lines: Parking Ratio: Comments: |
12m 1.0 Street 0m, side 0m Offices: 4 bays per 100m² GLA The building predates the zoning scheme. It is assumed it complies. |
| 2 | Nyanga Shopping Centre | General Business 4 | Coverage:100% Height: FAR, FSR: Building Lines: Parking Ratio: Comments: |
25m 3.0 0m up to 10m; common boundary 0m Supermarket: 6 bays per 100m² GLA The building predates the zoning scheme. It is assumed it complies. |
| 3 | Jan Niemand Spar | Business 1 | Coverage: Height: FAR, FSR: Building Lines: Parking Ratio: Comments: |
N/A 13m 0.75 4.5m To the satisfaction of the Local Authority. The building predates the zoning scheme. It is assumed it complies. |
| 4 | Clubview Corner | Business 1 & Special | Coverage: Height: FAR, FSR: Building Lines: Parking Ratio: Comments: |
80% 18.0m 3.0 5.0m To the satisfaction of the Local Authority. It is assumed the improvements complies. |
| 5 | Pick n Pay Vereeniging | Not confirmed | that the improvements comply. | Despite numerous requests from the local authority, the zoning of the subject property could not be confirmed. It is assumed |
| 6 | Bara Precinct, Soweto | Business 1 | Coverage: Height: FAR, FSR: Building Lines: Parking Ratio: Comments: |
To the satisfaction of the Local Authority. To the satisfaction of the Local Authority. To the satisfaction of the Local Authority. To the satisfaction of the Local Authority. 3.0 bays per 100m² GLA It is assumed the improvements complies. |
TOWN PLANNING RESTRICTIONS
NOTE: The information is as per the public records of the Local Authority's. A Town Planners report has not been provided confirming the accuracy of the information.
DATE OF VALUATION: 30 SEPTEMBER 2021
| No | Property Name | Zoning Town Planning and Statutory contravention (if any) |
Parameters | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | CHEP Building | General Commercial | Coverage: Height: FAR, FSR: Building Lines: |
80% 4 Levels 1.0 Front: 7.5m, side and rear: 3.0m |
| Parking Ratio: | A minimum of two car parking spaces shall be provided on-site for each 100m² of gross floor area of development. |
|||
| Comments: | The above controls were adapted from the eThekwini Inner West Scheme. |
|||
| 2 | Nonkqubela Mall | General Business 4 | Coverage: | Transport Use 1 (TR1): 75% (refer to item 83(b) of City of Cape Town Municipal By Law, 2015) |
| Open Space 2: | As determined by SDP (refer to item100 of City of Cape Town Municipal By-Law, 2015) |
|||
| Single Residential 2: Not Applicable. | ||||
| Height: | Transport Use 1 (TR1): 18.0m (refer to item 83(c) of City of Cape Town Municipal By Law, 2015) |
|||
| Open Space 2: | As determined by SDP (refer to item100 of City of Cape Town Municipal By-Law, 2015) |
|||
| Single Residential 2: 11,0m | ||||
| FAR, FSR: | Transport Use 1 (TR1): 2,0 (refer to item 83(a) of City of Cape Town Municipal By Law, 2015) |
|||
| Open Space 2: | As determined by SDP (refer to item100 of City of Cape Town Municipal By-Law, 2015) |
|||
| Single Residential 2: Not Applicable. | ||||
| Building Lines: | Transport Use 1 (TR1): Street: 0,0m; Boundary: 3,0m (refer to item 83(d) of City of Cape Town Municipal By-Law, 2015) |
|||
| Open Space 2: | As determined by SDP (refer to item100 of City of Cape Town Municipal By-Law, 2015) |
|||
| Single Residential 2: Street: 6,0m; Boundary: 6,0m | ||||
| Parking Ratio: | Transport Use 1 (TR1): 6 bays per 100m² GLA (to be read in conjunction with item 137 of City of Cape Town Municipal By-Law, 2015) |
|||
| Open Space 2: | As determined by SDP (refer to item100 of City of Cape Town Municipal By-Law, 2015) |
|||
| Single Residential 2: Not Applicable. | ||||
| Comments: | The above must be read in conjunction with Section 83 of the City of Cape Town Municipal By-Law, 2015. |
TOWN PLANNING RESTRICTIONS
| No | Property Name | Zoning Town Planning and Statutory contravention (if any) |
Parameters | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 3 | Macassar Retail Centre | General Business 4 | Coverage: | 100% |
| Height: | 25,0m | |||
| FAR, FSR: | 3.0 | |||
| Building Lines: | Street: 0m up to 10m height; 4.5m above 10m |
|||
| Common: | 0m | |||
| Parking Ratio: | 6 bays per 100m² GLA | |||
| Comments: | The subject property is assumed to comply with the zoning scheme provisions. |
|||
| 4 | Westville Junction | General Commercial | Coverage: | 80% |
| Height: | 4 Levels | |||
| FAR, FSR: | 1.0 | |||
| Building Lines: | Front: 7.5m, side and rear: 3.0m | |||
| Parking Ratio: | A minimum of two car parking spaces shall be provided on-site for each 100m² of gross floor area of development. |
|||
| Comments: | The above controls were adapted from the eThekwini Inner West Scheme. |
| No | Property Name | Zoning Town Planning and Statutory contravention (if any) |
Parameters | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 5 | Nyanga Junction | Transport Use 1 (TR1) - Erf 113702 & 113308: Transport Use 1 (TR1) |
Coverage: | Transport Use 1 (TR1): 75% (refer to item 83(b) of City of Cape Town Municipal By Law, 2015) |
| Land subject to section 13 of the Legal Succession of |
Open Space 2: | As determined by SDP (refer to item100 of City of Cape Town Municipal By-Law, 2015) |
||
| the South African Transport Services Act 9 of 1989. |
Single Residential 2: Not Applicable. | |||
| Erf 10316: Open Space 2 | Height: | Transport Use 1 (TR1): 18.0m (refer to item | ||
| Erf 10172: Single Residential 2 | 83(c) of City of Cape Town Municipal By Law, 2015) |
|||
| Open Space 2: | As determined by SDP (refer to item100 of City of Cape Town Municipal By-Law, 2015) |
|||
| Single Residential 2: 11,0m | ||||
| FAR, FSR: | Transport Use 1 (TR1): 2,0(refer to item 83(a) of City of Cape Town Municipal By Law, 2015) |
|||
| Open Space 2: | As determined by SDP (refer to item100 of City of Cape Town Municipal By-Law, 2015) |
|||
| Single Residential 2: Not Applicable. | ||||
| Building Lines: | Transport Use 1 (TR1): Street: 0,0m; Boundary: 3,0m (refer to item 83(d) of City of Cape Town Municipal By-Law, 2015) |
|||
| Open Space 2: | As determined by SDP (refer to item100 of City of Cape Town Municipal By-Law, 2015) |
|||
| Single Residential 2: Street: 6,0m; Boundary: 6,0m | ||||
| Parking Ratio: | Transport Use 1 (TR1): 6 bays per 100m² GLA (to be read in conjunction with item 137 of City of Cape Town Municipal By-Law, 2015) |
|||
| Open Space 2: | As determined by SDP (refer to item100 of City of Cape Town Municipal By-Law, 2015) |
|||
| Single Residential 2: Not Applicable. | ||||
| Comments: | The above must be read in conjunction with Section 83 of the City of Cape Town Municipal By-Law, 2015. |
|||
| 6 | Shoprite Empangeni | Core Mixed Use 1 | Coverage: | 100% |
| Height: | UR | |||
| FAR, FSR: | 3 | |||
| Building Lines: | Side and Rear space: Not Applicable | |||
| Parking Ratio: | 1 Bay for every 15m² (Excluding Warehouse/Storage) and 1 Bay per 140m² of Warehousing/Storage. The required number of bays is subject to approval by Council. |
|||
| There are currently 151 bays excluding the number of parking bays that are occupied by the taxi rank. |
||||
| Comments: | Information retrieved from the City of uMhlathuze Land Use Scheme Regulations – 25 September 2019. |
|||
| It is assumed that the existing improvements comply with the Local Authority regulations and that the servitudes on the property do not affect the value of the property. |
| No | Property Name | Zoning Town Planning and Statutory contravention (if any) |
Parameters | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 7 | 210 Church Street | General Business | Coverage: | 3/4 |
| Height: | 3 Levels | |||
| FAR, FSR: | 1.5 | |||
| Building Lines: | Front: 6m, side and rear: as per scheme | |||
| Parking Ratio: | 1 bay per 15m² | |||
| Comments: | The subject property is a pre-scheme development; hence the controls were not applicable at the time of its construction. |
NOTE: The information is as per the public records of the Local Authority's. A Town Planners report has not been provided confirming the accuracy of the information.
DATE OF VALUATION: 30 JUNE 2021
TENANCY SUMMARY
| No | Property Name | Property Use | Tenancy Summary |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Omniplace | Offices | The subject property is currently let by various tenants, with the Centurion Academy occupying 63% of the GLA. This tenancy commenced on 01 August 2019 and will terminate on 31 December 2024. The property is currently 7% vacant. The lease expiry profile is favourable. |
| 2 | Nyanga Shopping Centre | Retail | The subject property is currently let by a single tenant, KTC Family Liquor Store, who has been in occupation for many years. An offer to renew for a further five-year period was provided by the client with the rental being R32.31/m² with 8% annual escalation. |
| 3 | Jan Niemand Spar | Retail | The subject property is currently let by Spar and Tops. A new corporate head lease is being signed with Spar HQ effective as of 01 July 2021, for a seven-year period. Spar rental has decreased to R193,500 (R90.46/ m²), expiring 30 July 2028. Escalation of 6% applied in July each year. It must be commented that the Spar decrease in rental equates to 34%. When discussing the details with the client it was noted that the performance is flat and the rental had escalated above market norms. |
| The residential dwelling is let by Mr Joseph Pududu and he has been in occupation for 3 to 4 years. The residential rental is based on the budget amount of R5,544 in July 2021 increasing to R5,987.52 from August 2021, as confirmed with the client. |
|||
| 4 | Clubview Corner | Retail | The subject property is currently let by multiple tenants. The centre is anchored by Spar, with other tenants including Mica, The Queen Petshop, Tops Liquor, Pharmacy to name a few. The centre offers a favourable tenant mix with good synergies. At the time of preparing this report |
| 5 | Pick n Pay Vereeniging | Retail | The subject property is currently let by two tenants, Pick n Pay and Pep. The Pick n Pay lease expires 31 March 2026 and it is assumed that it will be renewed at R95/m² with 5% escalation (in line with current). Pep have renewed for an additional 2 years at a rental of R70/m² with only 5% escalation. This rental is 14% lower than the expiry rental and the escalation was previously 6.5%. There is first floor accommodation which was previously occupied by a church and has been mothballed. This space is not considered easily lettable and zero rental has been assigned for the purpose of this valuation. |
| The lease expiry profile is considered favourable. | |||
| 6 | Bara Precinct, Soweto | Retail | The subject property is currently let by multiple tenants, with nationals and line shops. The tenant mix is well suited to the profile of the area with tenants such as Pick n Pay, JAM Clothing, McDonalds, Fish & Chips Co as well as many smaller independent retailers. The overall mix of tenants is considered well suited to the node, with offerings such as a pharmacy, banks, ATMS, hairdressers, tailors and fashion, funeral service, gambling and a hotel. The subject property comprises various buildings and the overall offering is considered favourable with strong synergies. The demand for retail units is good and this is expected to continue going forward. At the time of preparing the report, the centre was 6% vacant. |
DATE OF VALUATION: 30 SEPTEMBER 2021
TENANCY SUMMARY
| No | Property Name | Property Use | Tenancy Summary |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | CHEP Building | Offices | The property is let by a single tenant, namely CHEP. The lease expires on 31 November 2022 and the current rental is R278.50/m² for the offices and R117.02/m² for the balconies with 7.8& escalation. It must be noted that the client provided a copy of the letter intention of renewal from the property manager noting the proposed lease terms from the current tenant. The tenant has advised that they wish to renew the lease agreement, 8 months early with the lease renewal date being 01 March 2022. Chep will be leasing the building in its entirety, which is considered a very favourable consideration given the current market conditions and downsizing of many other corporate offices. The proposed terms are a 6-year renewal from 01 March 2022, with a reduced rental. The current rental is exceptionally high and above market norms; therefore, a rental reversion was anticipated. The proposed rental per the letter is R145/m² gross for the offices. However, the landlord indicated that this proposal will not be accepted, and they will counteroffer. At the time of preparing this report the negotiations were underway and the outcome not yet known. |
| For the purpose of this market valuation, a market rental has been applied. The lease is a single tenancy, with a strong corporate profile. |
|||
| 2 | Nonkqubela Mall | Retail | The subject property is multi-tenanted, with minimal vacancies evident just short of 3% at present. There are retail, ATM, and office units comprising the centre. It is worth reiterating that the centre comprises two discrete portions, one on either side of the pedestrian arcade. One portion is anchored by Shoprite (who recently renewed their lease for a 5 year term), and the other is anchored by Pick n Pay. It is considered important to note that over 70% of the total GLA at the subject property is occupied by national retailers/franchises which is considered a positive feature. The lease expiry profile is staggered which is considered favourable. |
| 3 | Macassar Retail Centre | Retail | The subject property comprises the Shoprite Macassar Centre, anchored by Shoprite and there are a number of line shops. The centre was recently expanded including the expansion of the Shoprite premises and the addition of a number of line shops. The centre is fully let, with strong demand. The lease expiry profile is staggered with leases expiry from 2021 to 2026. The lease expiry profile is considered favourable. |
| 4 | Westville Junction | Retail | The subject property is subject to various independent leases with varying lease periods. Pick 'n Pay anchor the centre occupying 2 323m² at a current rental of R124/m². The lease and its reviews will run till 30 April 2043. A Pick 'n Pay liquor lease runs alongside the main lease agreement. The lease expiry profile is considered good with a long anchor lease. At the time of preparing the report, the centre was 8% vacant. |
| No | Property Name | Property Use | Tenancy Summary |
|---|---|---|---|
| 5 | Nyanga Junction | Retail | The subject property is considered ideally located adjacent to the Nyanga train station (although not currently operating), is easily accessible and there is good footfall through the centre due to the train station being directly accessible from the first floor of the centre. Shoprite is the anchor tenant and the centre offers a number of line shops as well as a food court. There are a number of national tenants occupying the centre. |
| Nyanga Junction currently has a 5% vacancy rate as at the time of preparing this report. This is attributed to tenant churn as the demand remains strong. |
|||
| 7 | Shoprite Empangeni | Retail | The subject property has various independent leases with varying lease periods. The centre is anchored by Shoprite, with various line shops. The lease expiry profile is considered favourable with the anchor lease expiring in 2026 and a staggered lease profile. At the time of preparing this report there were no vacancies. |
| 8 | 210 Church Street | Retail | The subject property is let by a single tenant, Mr Price and the lease expires on 31 August 2022. The current rental equates to R187/m² with 7% annual escalation. |
| ANNEXURE 8 | ||
|---|---|---|
| 126 |
DETAILS OF THE ARROWHEAD PROPERTY PORTFOLIO
Details of the Arrowhead property portfolio
| The table below sets out the details of the properties within the Arrowhead Group's property portfolio as at 30 September 2021. | |||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Property name | Physical address and province |
Sector | GLA (m²) | (R'000) Valuation |
consideration Purchase (R'000)³ |
Effective date of acquisition |
Weighted average rental per square metre (R/m²) |
| KwaZulu-Natal | |||||||
| Lakeview Terrace | Richards Bay | Commercial | 13 079 | 84 233 | 71 700 | 01 December 2011 | 120 |
| Absa Cash Centre | Durban | Commercial | 2 359 | 21 600 | 30 120 | 20 August 2012 | 119 |
| Durban Receiver of Revenue | Durban | Commercial | 23 105 | 229 900 | 180 000 | 04 August 2014 | 119 |
| Westmead Kyalami Park Pinetown |
Pinetown | Industrial | 16 914 | 103 700 | 89 800 | 01 December 2016 | 68 |
| Mkuze Plaza | Mkuza | Retail | 8 535 | 60 211 | 39 800 | 01 December 2011 | 90 |
| Montclair Mall | Durban | Retail | 12 652 | 194 937 | 138 000 | 04 August 2014 | 145 |
| 76 644 | 694 581 | ||||||
| Western Cape | |||||||
| RCS | Goodwood | Commercial | 7 143 | 94 300 | 59 000 | 10 July 2014 | 127 |
| Parc Du Bel | Belville | Commercial | 2 299 | 13 000 | 11 800 | 01 April 2016 | 89 |
| Philippi Court | Cape Town | Commercial | 1 357 | 14 800 | 13 500 | 01 April 2016 | 141 |
| Cape Town Bellville Suntyger | Belville | Commercial | 6 344 | 83 800 | 63 600 | 01 December 2016 | 138 |
| Cape Town Bellville Tijger Park | Belville | Commercial | 20 157 | 302 200 | 241 300 | 01 December 2016 | 150 |
| 1 Range Road | Cape Town | Industrial | 15 450 | 60 523 | 41 000 | 04 October 2012 | 40 |
| Westgate Mall Shops Cape Town |
Weltevreden Valley | Retail | 28 951 | 467 096 | 252 000 | 04 August 2014 | 137 |
| Access Park | Claremont | Retail | 20 481 | 810 000 | 640 395 | 04 August 2014 | 358 |
| Oudehuis Centre | West Somerset |
Retail | 4 182 | 31 925 | 28 200 | 01 April 2016 | 104 |
| 106 364 | 1 877 644 | ||||||
| Free State | |||||||
| Odendaalsrus Shopping Centre | Odendaalsrus | Retail | 3 683 | 55 538 | 31 100 | 01 April 2016 | 132 |
| 3 689 | 55 538 |
| Property name | Physical address and province |
Sector | GLA (m²) | (R'000) Valuation |
consideration Purchase (R'000)³ |
Effective date of acquisition |
Weighted average rental per square metre (R/m²) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Gauteng | |||||||
| Selby Building | Selby | Commercial | 16 346 | 40 000 | 112 298 | 04 October 2012 | 170 |
| Bridge On Bond | Ferndale | Commercial | 12 243 | 75 924 | 111 792 | 30 November 2012 | 85 |
| The District | Sunninghill | Commercial | 3 888 | 25 721 | 51 450 | 10 December 2012 | 101 |
| Crownwood Office Park | Northern Parkway | Commercial | 13 347 | 96 604 | 112 000 | 01 March 2013 | 96 |
| Lynnwood The Atrium | Lynnwood Glen | Commercial | 5 037 | 31 421 | 44 369 | 28 October 2013 | 98 |
| Urban Brew | Ferndale | Commercial | 9 804 | 58 109 | 105 000 | 14 January 2014 | 45 |
| 1 Sturdee5 | Rosebank | Commercial | 13 350 | 189 752 | 250 000 | 01 February 2014 | 140 |
| MetalBox | Auckland Park | Commercial | 14 984 | 96 169 | 103 000 | 04 August 2014 | 104 |
| Jhb Rosebank 158 Offices | Rosebank | Commercial | 19 510 | 171 800 | 204 000 | 04 August 2014 | 120 |
| Media Shop | Morningside Manor | Commercial | 2 522 | 13 140 | 49 300 | 01 April 2016 | – |
| Bedfordview | Bedfordview | Commercial | 9 221 | 66 800 | 82 200 | 01 April 2016 | 114 |
| Lynnwood Botco Place | Lynnwood Glen | Commercial | 493 | 2 800 | 7 700 | 01 April 2016 | – |
| Endemol - Kent | Ferndale | Commercial | 2 526 | 26 100 | 23 300 | 01 April 2016 | 122 |
| The Main Change | City and Suburban | Commercial | 5 268 | 19 451 | 44 300 | 01 April 2016 | 82 |
| Sandton Bryanston St Andrews | Bryanston | Commercial | 10 184 | 81 307 | 86 900 | 01 December 2016 | 81 |
| Sandton Rivonia 36 Homestead | Rivonia | Commercial | 2 410 | 23 629 | 32 000 | 01 December 2016 | 155 |
| Sandton Sunninghill Place | Sunninghill | Commercial | 8 139 | 83 871 | 85 900 | 01 December 2016 | 116 |
| Jhb Isle of Houghton | Houghton Estate | Commercial | 27 249 | 201 216 | 283 000 | 01 December 2016 | 96 |
| Midrand IBG | Midrand | Commercial | 8 515 | 74 936 | 71 100 | 01 December 2016 | 105 |
| Pretoria Hatfield Festival Str | Pretoria | Commercial | 5 317 | 37 803 | 55 000 | 01 December 2016 | 123 |
| Pretoria High Court Chambers | Pretoria | Commercial | 12 093 | 104 638 | 143 900 | 01 December 2016 | 192 |
| Pretoria Lynnwood Excel Park | Lynnwood | Commercial | 3 529 | 15 918 | 27 900 | 01 December 2016 | 102 |
| Pretoria Lynnwood Sanlynn | Lynwood Manor | Commercial | 8 316 | 124 428 | 145 000 | 01 December 2016 | 189 |
| Pretoria Lynnwood Sunwood Park | Queen's Crescent | Commercial | 6 412 | 46 415 | 66 000 | 01 December 2016 | 112 |
| Waterworld | North Riding | Industrial | 6 524 | 29 700 | 35 344 | 01 June 2013 | 50 |
| MCG | Malvern | Industrial | 13 995 | 48 800 | 53 236 | 28 January 2014 | 33 |
| Access City | New Doornfontein | Industrial | 24 932 | 38 303 | 42 059 | 01 June 2014 | 31 |
| Spark Schools | New Doornfontein | Industrial | 6 278 | 23 558 | 25 483 | 01 June 2014 | 40 |
| BEKA Candela | Olifantsfontein | Industrial | 20 338 | 127 506 | 133 302 | 04 August 2014 | 59 |
| 46 Steel Road | Spartan | Industrial | 3 790 | 15 400 | 16 000 | 01 April 2016 | 35 |
| Diesel Road | Isando | Industrial | 7 923 | 15 900 | 25 600 | 01 April 2016 | 39 |
| Property name | Physical address and province |
Sector | GLA (m²) | (R'000) Valuation |
consideration Purchase (R'000)³ |
Effective date of acquisition |
Weighted average rental per square metre (R/m²) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Creston | Spartan | Industrial | 6 546 | 24 393 | 24 600 | 01 April 2016 | 41 |
| JM Investments | Stormill | Industrial | 2 700 | 6 400 | 10 700 | 01 April 2016 | 37 |
| Virgin Active Benoni | Kleinfontein Lake | Industrial | 3 154 | 11 821 | 25 800 | 01 April 2016 | – |
| McCarthy Centre - Turffontein | City and Suburban | Industrial | 5 935 | 15 986 | 26 700 | 01 April 2016 | – |
| Kolbenco | Alrode | Industrial | 12 660 | 21 029 | 27 200 | 01 April 2016 | 27 |
| Lea Glen | Lea Glen | Industrial | 3 411 | 11 300 | 12 600 | 01 April 2016 | 39 |
| Simgold | Industria | Industrial | 8 026 | 15 852 | 19 700 | 01 April 2016 | 26 |
| Maverick Corner | Jeppestown | Industrial | 1 570 | 9 500 | 13 000 | 01 April 2016 | 140 |
| Germiston Route 24 | Germiston | Industrial | 35 016 | 186 000 | 177 800 | 01 December 2016 | 47 |
| Randburg Trevallyn 1 | Kya Sands | Industrial | 32 006 | 152 635 | 144 000 | 01 December 2016 | 47 |
| Roodepoort Robertville Indus | Roodepoort | Industrial | 28 226 | 107 392 | 92 900 | 01 December 2016 | 35 |
| Pretoria Silverton 22 Axle Str | Silverton | Industrial | 1 817 | 9 826 | 11 300 | 01 December 2016 | 59 |
| Pretoria Silverton 34 Bearing | Silverton | Industrial | 5 000 | 27 900 | 26 200 | 01 December 2016 | 60 |
| Pretoria Silverton 294 Battery | Silverton | Industrial | 5 787 | 31 188 | 23 600 | 01 December 2016 | 51 |
| Pretoria Silverton 301 Battery | Silverton | Industrial | 3 784 | 18 100 | 18 500 | 01 December 2016 | 52 |
| Pretoria Silverton 309 Battery | Silverton | Industrial | 3 770 | 22 200 | 20 900 | 01 December 2016 | 60 |
| Pretoria Silverton 330 Alwyn | Waltloo | Industrial | 1 185 | 7 275 | 4 700 | 01 December 2016 | 51 |
| Lyndhurst Square | Lyndhurst | Retail | 6 352 | 62 345 | 60 000 | 17 February 2014 | 103 |
| Clearwater Crossing | Roodepoort | Retail | 10 092 | 65 951 | 76 000 | 04 August 2014 | 73 |
| Pta Eersterust Shopping Centre | Eersterust | Retail | 7 910 | 65 200 | 33 000 | 04 August 2014 | 83 |
| Mall@TheJunction | Rosettenville | Retail | 14 198 | 81 813 | 47 000 | 04 August 2014 | 70 |
| Town Centre Boksburg | Boksburg | Retail | 6 883 | 26 300 | 22 900 | 01 April 2016 | 54 |
| Wonderboom Carvenience Centre | Annlin | Retail | 10 526 | 88 500 | 54 200 | 20 November 2017 | 94 |
| Alberton Voortrekker Rd | Alberton | Retail | 5 099 | 26 501 | 26 000 | 05 December 2017 | 58 |
| Boxer Boksburg | Boksburg | Retail | 3 678 | 42 240 | 36 000 | 15 December 2017 | 127 |
| Shoprite Brakpan | Brakpan | Retail | 6 954 | 31 359 | 29 500 | 18 December 2017 | 60 |
| Vereeniging Voortrekker Str | Vereeniging | Retail | 2 539 | 16 284 | 13 000 | 21 December 2017 | 83 |
| 539 307 | 3 192 409 |
| Property name | Physical address and province |
Sector | GLA (m²) | (R'000) Valuation |
consideration Purchase (R'000)³ |
Effective date of acquisition |
Weighted average rental per square metre (R/m²) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Limpopo | |||||||
| West Building Mae |
Pietersburg | Commercial | 2 922 | 26 000 | 16 700 | 01 December 2011 | 131 |
| 18 Thabo Mbeki | Polokwane | Commercial | 3 931 | 29 127 | 39 980 | 01 November 2018 | 106 |
| 79 Hans Van Rensburg | Polokwane | Commercial | 875 | 2 558 | 8 400 | 01 November 2018 | 94 |
| 54 Schoeman | Polokwane | Commercial | 2 001 | 12 000 | 14 560 | 01 November 2018 | 75 |
| Trador | Polokwane | Industrial | 15 001 | 53 953 | 45 100 | 01 November 2018 | 40 |
| 5 Sapphire | Polokwane | Industrial | 1 840 | 4 530 | 4 090 | 01 November 2018 | 35 |
| 41 Emerald | Polokwane | Industrial | 1 362 | 6 084 | 7 500 | 01 November 2018 | 76 |
| Ellerines Thohoyandou | Thohoyandou | Retail | 829 | 9 250 | 6 800 | 01 April 2016 | 120 |
| Noor Centre | Louis Trichard | Retail | 8 117 | 63 597 | 78 618 | 20 November 2017 | 122 |
| Checkers Centre Louis Trichardt | Louis Trichard | Retail | 7 894 | 105 300 | 72 397 | 20 November 2017 | 145 |
| Hawarna Noor Centre | Louis Trichard | Retail | 9 817 | 129 499 | 116 838 | 20 November 2017 | 170 |
| Ellerines - Northam | Northam | Retail | 877 | 6 500 | 7 036 | 01 October 2018 | 90 |
| Thompsons Building | Makhado | Retail | 3 727 | 18 500 | 31 500 | 01 November 2018 | 45 |
| Game Centre | Thohoyandou | Retail | 7 934 | 139 900 | 122 100 | 01 November 2018 | 171 |
| FNB Building | Polokwane | Retail | 2 370 | 27 866 | 31 400 | 01 November 2018 | 147 |
| 71 Biccard | Polokwane | Retail | 877 | 5 900 | 5 950 | 01 November 2018 | 85 |
| 68 Hans van Rensburg | Polokwane | Retail | 2 697 | 25 000 | 23 500 | 01 November 2018 | 109 |
| 73 071 | 665 564 | ||||||
| West North |
|||||||
| 127 Bethlehem Street | Rustenburg | Commercial | 6 997 | 69 126 | 22 700 | 01 December 2011 | 153 |
| Terminus Shopping Centre | Klerksdorp | Retail | 11 377 | 105 400 | 57 600 | 01 July 2012 | 87 |
| Midtown Mall | Rustenburg | Retail | 17 456 | 234 510 | 178 000 | 01 September 2012 | 145 |
| Transforum Centre | Rustenburg | Retail | 4 777 | 202 200 | 72 000 | 01 March 2013 | 376 |
| Impala Centre | Rustenburg | Retail | 3 604 | 76 016 | 53 000 | 21 June 2013 | 220 |
| OK Klerksdorp | Klerksdorp | Retail | 7 931 | 15 499 | 22 400 | 01 April 2016 | 23 |
| 52 142 | 702 751 |
| Property name | Physical address and province |
Sector | GLA (m²) | (R'000) Valuation |
consideration Purchase (R'000)³ |
Effective date of acquisition |
Weighted average rental per square metre (R/m²) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Kathu Shopping Centre Northern Cape |
Kathu | Retail | 5 088 | 51 500 | 30 000 | 01 December 2011 | 104 |
| Taung Forum | Taung | Retail | 10 231 | 109 800 | 67 200 | 01 December 2011 | 113 |
| 15 319 | 161 300 | ||||||
| Eastern Cape | |||||||
| The Arches | Williams Town King |
Commercial | 2 707 | 11 700 | 21 400 | 01 April 2016 | 115 |
| Sterkspruit | Sterkspruit | Retail | 6 733 | 71 600 | 46 500 | 13 September 2012 | 120 |
| Williams Town Market Sq King |
Williams Town King |
Retail | 13 264 | 133 962 | 86 000 | 04 August 2014 | 100 |
| Cleary Park | Port Elizabeth | Retail | 36 294 | 594 679 | 466 027 | 01 December 2015 | 150 |
| Tsolo | Tsolo | Retail | 4 097 | 30 000 | 30 000 | 01 April 2016 | 105 |
| 63 095 | 841 941 | ||||||
| Mpumalanga | |||||||
| Simunye Shopping Centre | Hazyview | Retail | 6 538 | 23 176 | 28 600 | 01 December 2011 | 99 |
| Matsulu Shopping Centre | Matsulu-A | Retail | 6 087 | 73 351 | 60 500 | 12 August 2015 | 112 |
| 12 625 | 96 527 | ||||||
| TOTAL | 942 250 | 8 288 255 | |||||
Notes:
-
- Not applicable as property is vacant.
-
- The table above excludes properties that were sold after 30 September 2020.
-
- The purchase consideration of the above properties excludes additional costs such as agent's commission and transfer costs. The Company was not able to obtain this information as the various acquisitions were undertaken several years ago. However, the Company confirms that these costs would have been immaterial in relation to the acquisition cost, and most acquisitions were done via package deals not subject additional costs such as agent's commission and transfer costs.
-
- In line with the accounting policy of the Arrowhead Group, one third of the Arrowhead property portfolio is valued annually by independent valuers. In respect of the year ended 30 September 2021, one third of the properties were valued by each of Real Insight (Proprietary) Limited and Yield Enhancement Solutions (Proprietary) Limited (who are independent external registered professional valuers in terms of the Property Valuers Profession Act, No. 47 of 2000), with the remainder valued by the directors of Arrowhead as at reporting date on an open market basis. All properties are valued by independent external valuers at least once every three years.
-
- This property is occupied by Arrowhead.
ACQUISITIONS AND VENDORS, DISPOSALS AND MATERIAL CONTRACTS
1. Acquisitions and vendors
Details of the vendors of material assets, including immovable properties, subsidiaries and investments, acquired by the Combined Group during the three years preceding the Last Practicable Date, or proposed to be purchased or acquired are detailed in the table below.
1.1 Assets acquired by Arrowhead
Reconciliation of consideration to net asset value:
| Description: | Acquisition by Arrowhead of the entire issued share capital of Fairvest via the Scheme |
|
|---|---|---|
| Date of acquisition: | Scheme Operative Date | |
| Consideration: | Scheme Consideration Shares | |
| Valuation: | R2 097 335 171 (based on a share price of R2.08 per Fairvest Share at the Last Practicable Date) |
|
| Reconciliation of consideration to net asset value: |
Value of consideration paid Value of the net assets attributable to the securities acquired¹ Differential ¹ As per Fairvest's audited results in respect of the year ended 30 June 2021 |
R2 097 335 171 R2 441 524 000 R344 188 829 |
| Goodwill paid and manner in which was accounted for: |
N/A as the Transaction gives rise to a gain on bargain purchase | |
| Loans incurred to finance acquisition: |
Nil – the Scheme Consideration comprises AHB Shares | |
| Nature of asset acquired: | Fairvest Shares | |
| Name of vendor: | Scheme Participants | |
| Address of vendor: | Various – addresses of Fairvest Shareholders | |
| Name and address of the vendor shareholder: |
N/A – The Scheme Shares are held by Fairvest Shareholders | |
| Price paid by vendor and date of acquisition by vendor if within preceding three years: |
N/A – Fairvest is a public company listed on the JSE and the A2X, the shares of which are publicly traded |
|
| Description: | Acquisition by Gemgrow of the entire issued share capital of Old Arrowhead | |
| Date of acquisition: | 16 September 2019 | |
| Consideration: | 862 972 109 Gemgrow B shares | |
| Valuation: | R3 339 704 613 (based on share price of R3.87 as per Old Arrowhead's 2019 audited |
Value of consideration paid R3 339 704 613 Value of the net assets attributable to the securities acquired¹ R3 882 105 000 Differential (R524 400 387)
¹ As per Gemgrow's audited results in respect of the interim period ended 31 March 2019
annual financial statements)
| Description: | Acquisition by Gemgrow of the entire issued share capital of Old Arrowhead | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Goodwill paid and manner in which was accounted for: |
N/A as the transaction gave rise to a gain on bargain purchase | ||||
| Loans incurred to finance acquisition: |
N/A – No loans were incurred | ||||
| Nature of asset acquired: | Ordinary shares | ||||
| Name of vendor: | The shareholders of Old Arrowhead | ||||
| Address of vendor: | Various | ||||
| Name and address of the vendor shareholder: |
N/A – Old Arrowhead was a public company listed on the JSE, the shares of which were held by thousands of shareholders |
||||
| Price paid by vendor and date of acquisition by vendor if within preceding three years: |
N/A – Old Arrowhead was a public company listed on the JSE, the shares of which are publicly traded |
||||
| Description and name of vendor: |
Gemgrow and Cumulative entered into a subscription agreement with entities in the Moolman Group of companies ("Moolgem"), being Luvon Investments Proprietary Limited ("Luvon"), East and West Investments Proprietary Limited ("East and West"), Louis Trichardt ("Louis Trichardt") in terms of which Cumulative subscribed for 31 010 A ordinary shares in Moolgem, valued at R628 565 20. |
Bousentrum | Proprietary Limited |
||
| Date of acquisition: | 1 November 2018 | ||||
| Consideration: | The consideration payable by Cumulative for the subscription shares was equal to 95% of the agreed value of the properties as at the effective date. The subscription consideration was settled as follows: • by way of the allotment and issue by Gemgrow of 10 264 434 fully paid up |
||||
| Gemgrow A shares at an issue price of R9.74 to Moolgem; and • the balance in the amount of R529 631 667, in cash. |
|||||
| Valuation: | Name of Property | Agreed value (R) |
Valuation (R) |
||
| Property owned by Orion | |||||
| Jane Furse Crossing, Limpopo Property owned by Orion |
153 200 000 | 158 200 000 | |||
| Game Centre, Thohoyandou, Limpopo | 122 100 000 | 122 100 000 | |||
| Properties owned by East and West | |||||
| Trador, Limpopo | 43 200 000 | 45 100 000 | |||
| Thohoyandou CBD, Limpopo | 38 990 000 | 39 500 000 | |||
| Thompsons Building, Makhado, Limpopo | 32 800 000 | 31 500 000 | |||
| 20 Trichardt, Makhado, Limpopo | 27 900 000 | 28 900 000 | |||
| FNB Building, Limpopo | 27 700 000 | 31 400 000 | |||
| 68 Hans van Rensburg, Polokwane, Limpopo | 17 000 000 | 23 500 000 | |||
| 70 Landdros Mare, Polokwane, Limpopo | 15 000 000 | 20 500 000 | |||
| 79 Market, Polokwane, Limpopo | 18 200 000 | 18 800 000 | |||
| The Crossing, Polokwane | 18 000 000 | 18 720 000 | |||
| Geen and Richards, Tzaneen, Limpopo | 16 626 000 | 16 600 000 | |||
| 31 Nikkel, Polokwane, Limpopo | 8 500 000 | 9 800 000 | |||
| 79 Hans van Rensburg, Polokwane, Limpopo | 8 400 000 | 8 400 000 |
| Description and name of vendor: |
Gemgrow and Cumulative entered into a subscription agreement with entities in the Moolman Group of companies ("Moolgem"), being Luvon Investments Proprietary Limited ("Luvon"), East and West Investments Proprietary Limited ("East and West"), Louis Trichardt ("Louis Trichardt") in terms of which Cumulative subscribed for 31 010 A ordinary shares in Moolgem, valued at R628 565 20. |
Bousentrum | Proprietary Limited |
|---|---|---|---|
| 41 Emerald, Polokwane, Limpopo | 7 200 000 | 7 500 000 | |
| 85 Kruger, Makhado, Limpopo | 6 400 000 | 6 600 000 | |
| 99 Agatha, Tzaneen, Limpopo | 5 900 000 | 7 700 000 | |
| 71 Biccard, Polokwane, Limpopo | 5 900 000 | 5 950 000 | |
| 54 Jones, Kimberly, Northern Cape | 5 600 000 | 5 500 000 | |
| 65 Silikon, Polokwane, Limpopo | 4 500 000 | 4 500 000 | |
| 5 Sapphire, Polokwane Limpopo | 3 800 000 | 4 090 000 | |
| Properties owned by Louis Trichardt | |||
| 18 Thabo Mbeki, Polokwane, Limpopo | 34 900 000 | 39 980 000 | |
| 55 Voortrekker, Mokopane, Limpopo | 21 800 000 | 21 000 000 | |
| 54 Schoeman, Polokwane, Limpopo | 11 400 000 | 14 560 000 | |
| 54 Agatha, Tzaneen, Limpopo | 7 600 000 | 7 830 000 | |
| 908 Hoofweg, Marble Hall, Limpopo | 3 000 000 | 6 390 000 | |
| Total | 665 616 000 | 704 620 000 | |
| Reconciliation of consideration to net asset value: |
N/A – The acquisition did not relate to securities purchased in a company that would become a subsidiary of Gemgrow |
||
| Goodwill paid and manner in which was accounted for: |
N/A – No goodwill was paid | ||
| Loans incurred to finance acquisition: |
R529 631 667 | ||
| Nature of asset acquired: | Rental enterprise | ||
| Address of vendor: | Baobab House, Eastwood Office Park, 290 Lynwood Service Road | ||
| Name and address of the vendor shareholder: |
Moolman Group | ||
| Price paid by vendor and date of acquisition by vendor if within preceding three years: |
Unavailable, as this information is in relation to a vendor which is a private company and is not legally obliged to provide the information |
1.2 Assets acquired by Fairvest
Save as set out below, Fairvest did not acquire any material assets, including immovable properties, subsidiaries or investments during the three years preceding the Last Practicable Date.
| Description: | Acquisition by Fairvest of 100% of the issued share capital of New Star | |
|---|---|---|
| Date of acquisition: | The Manco Internalisation Agreement was concluded on 30 July 2021, and the acquisition became effective on 1 October 2021 |
|
| Consideration: | R133 000 000 | |
| Valuation: | New Star's last reported net asset value for the year ended 28 February 2021 was R1 586 595 |
|
| Reconciliation of consideration to net asset value: |
Value of consideration paid Value of the net assets attributable to the securities acquired Differential |
R133 000 000 R1 586 595 R131 413 405 |
| Goodwill paid and manner in which was accounted for: |
N/A – No goodwill was paid. | |
| Loans incurred to finance acquisition: |
N/A – The consideration was cash-settled | |
| Nature of asset acquired: | 100% of the issued share capital in a property asset management company | |
| Name of vendor: | New Star Asset Management Proprietary Limited | |
| Address of vendor: | 8th Floor, The Terraces, 34 Bree Street, Cape Town, 8001 (PO Box 50742, Waterfront, Cape Town, 8012) |
|
| Name and address of the vendor shareholder: |
Hilton Datnow (Address: 14/12 Brandels Street, Raanana, Israel) Marcus Family Trust (Address: 8th Floor, The Terraces, 34 Bree Street, Cape Town, 8001) Wilder Family Trust (Address: 8th Floor, The Terraces, 34 Bree Street, Cape Town, 8001) Labora Trust (Address: 46 Orange Street, Cape Town, 8001) Gelz Trust (Address: 46 Orange Street, Cape Town, 8001) Universal Long Term Investment Trust (Address: 6th Floor, Park Lane, Wierda Valley, Sandton, 2196) |
|
| Price paid by vendor and date of acquisition by vendor if within preceding three years: |
N/A – The shareholders of the vendor were the founders of New Star |
| Description: | Acquisition of Qumbu Shopping Centre |
|---|---|
| Date of acquisition: | 15 August 2019 |
| Consideration: | Acquired at nominal amount and the property was developed |
| Valuation: | R68 800 000 as at 30 June 2020 |
| Reconciliation of consideration to net asset value: |
N/A – The acquisition did not relate to securities purchased in a company that would become a subsidiary of Fairvest |
| Goodwill paid and manner in which was accounted for: |
N/A – No goodwill was paid |
| Loans incurred to finance acquisition: |
Funded through shareholder loans in Qumbu Plaza (Pty) Ltd |
| Nature of asset acquired: | Retail property asset |
| Name of vendor: | Lease concluded with various owners of the property |
| Address of vendor: | – |
| Name and address of the vendor shareholder: |
Stilopro (Pty) Ltd |
| Price paid by vendor and date of acquisition by vendor if within preceding three years: |
Unavailable, as this information is in relation to a vendor which is a private company and is not legally obliged to provide the information |
| Description: | Acquisition of Nonkqubela Plaza |
| Date of acquisition: | 23 August 2019 |
| Consideration: | R82 876 181 |
| Valuation: | R180 100 000 as at 30 June 2020 |
| Reconciliation of consideration to net asset value: |
N/A – The acquisition did not relate to securities purchased in a company that would become a subsidiary of Fairvest |
| Goodwill paid and manner in which was accounted for: |
N/A – No goodwill was paid |
| Loans incurred to finance acquisition: |
R80 000 000 |
| Nature of asset acquired: | Retail property asset |
| Name of vendor: | Investec Property Fund Limited |
| Address of vendor: | 100 Grayston Drive, Sandown, Sandton, 2196 |
| Name and address of the vendor shareholder: |
N/A – Investec Property Fund Limited is a public company listed on the JSE, the shares of which are held by thousands of shareholders |
| Price paid by vendor and date of acquisition by vendor if within preceding three years: |
R150 000 000 |
1.3 Assets acquired by Indluplace
Indluplace did not acquire any material assets, including immovable properties, subsidiaries or investments during the three years preceding the Last Practicable Date.
2. Disposals
2.1 Assets disposed of by Arrowhead
Other than as set out below, Arrowhead has not disposed of any material immovable properties and/or fixed assets and/or business undertakings (being immovable properties, fixed assets or business undertakings) in the three years preceding the Last Practicable Date.
Sales and disposal of various property letting enterprises
On 8 October 2020, Arrowhead announced that the Company, through various Subsidiaries, had entered into the following sale agreements to dispose of certain immovable properties:
- (i) Sale by Arrowhead of the rental enterprise comprising Parow Industrial Park to Lemil Property Holdings Close Corporation, for an aggregate disposal consideration of R95 million on 3 September 2020 (the "Parow Industrial Park Transaction").
- (ii) Sale by Vividend Income Fund Limited, a Subsidiary of Arrowhead, of the rental enterprise comprising Durban Receiver of Revenue to Vtech Properties Proprietary Limited for an aggregate disposal consideration of R235 million on 22 September 2020 (the "Durban Receiver of Revenue Transaction"). The Durban Receiver of Revenue Transaction did not proceed as the relevant conditions precedent thereto were not fulfilled.
- (iii) Sale by Arrowhead of the property comprising Durban Valley View Industrial Park and assignment of the lease agreement in respect of Durban Valley View Industrial Park to Colkru Investments Proprietary Limited for an aggregate disposal consideration of R119 million on 30 August 2020 (the "Durban Valley View Transaction").
- (iv) Sale by Cumulative Properties Limited, a wholly-owned Subsidiary of Arrowhead, of the rental enterprise comprising Thohoyandou Shopping Centre for a disposal consideration of R39 million, together with the rental enterprise comprising Thohoyandou Centre for a disposal consideration of R32.5 million to Madiba Property Investments Proprietary Limited ("Madiba Investments") and sale by Arrowgem Limited, a wholly owned Subsidiary of Arrowhead, of the rental enterprise comprising Sibasa Shopping Centre to Madiba Investments for an aggregate disposal consideration of R37 million on 6 October 2020 (collectively, the "Thohoyandou Transactions").
The immovable properties disposed of comprised rental enterprises including the immovable properties and the respective rights and obligations in terms of existing lease agreements between Arrowhead (or its Subsidiaries) and the existing tenants occupying the immovable properties used in the operation of the rental enterprises.
Each of the Parow Industrial Park Transaction, the Durban Receiver of Revenue Transaction, the Durban Valley View Transaction and the Thohoyandou Transactions were classified as category 2 transactions in terms of the Listings Requirements, which did not require approval by Arrowhead Shareholders.
Disposal of Jane Furse Crossing to Depoway Proprietary Limited
On 7 September 2020, Arrowhead announced that Moolgem Proprietary Limited, a Subsidiary of Cumulative Properties Limited, which is a wholly owned Subsidiary of the Company, had, on 3 September 2020, entered into an agreement with Depoway Proprietary Limited to dispose of the rental enterprise comprising Jane Furse Crossing in Limpopo, as a going concern, for an aggregate disposal consideration which was finalised as R172 000 000 post the announcement (the "Transaction").
The Transaction was classified as a category 2 transaction in terms of the Listings Requirements which did not require approval by Arrowhead Shareholders.
2.2 Assets disposed of by Fairvest
Other than as set out below, Fairvest has not disposed of any material immovable properties and/or fixed assets and/or business undertakings (being immovable properties, fixed assets or business undertakings) in the three years preceding the Last Practicable Date.
Disposal of Tokai Junction
On 6 April 2020, Fairvest announced that it had entered into an agreement with FPG Holdings Proprietary Limited (the "Purchaser") on 3 April 2020, in terms of which the Fairvest had agreed to dispose of the shopping centre rental enterprise operated by Fairvest, commonly known as Tokai Junction ("Rental Enterprise"), including the property on which the Rental Enterprise is being conducted on situated at Erf 10800, Constantia, Cape Town to the Purchaser, as a going concern, for a disposal consideration of R190 000 000 ("Disposal").
The Disposal was classified as a category 2 transaction in terms of the Listings Requirements which did not require approval by Fairvest Shareholders.
3. Other material contracts entered into by Arrowhead and Fairvest
Other than as set out in paragraphs 1 to 2 above, there are no material contracts entered into by the Combined Group, any of its Major Subsidiaries or by any Subsidiary where it is material to the Combined Group, being restrictive funding arrangements and/or a contract entered into otherwise than in the ordinary course of the business carried on, or proposed to be carried on, by Combined Group or any of its Subsidiaries, and entered into within the two years prior to the Last Practicable Date, or entered into at any time and containing an obligation or settlement that is material to the Combined Group or its Subsidiaries at the Last Practicable Date.
FORECAST STATEMENTS OF COMPREHENSIVE INCOME OF THE COMBINED GROUP
Set out below are the forecast statements of comprehensive income for the Combined Group ("Forecasts") for the year ending 30 September 2022 and 2023 ("Forecast Periods").
The Forecasts, including the assumptions on which they are based and the financial information from which they are prepared, are the responsibility of the directors of Arrowhead. The Forecasts must be read in conjunction with the independent Reporting Accountants' assurance report thereon which is presented in Annexure 11.
The Forecasts have been complied in full compliance with Arrowhead's IFRS accounting policies and on an aggregated basis for the Combined Group's property portfolio, with the exception of Indluplace, a Major Subsidiary of Arrowhead. Indluplace, was not consolidated into the Forecasts in respect of the Forecast Periods on the basis that the forecast financial information of Indluplace was not readily available, due to the information being restricted unpublished price sensitive information.
The expected distribution to be received from Indluplace was included in the forecast earnings under listed security income as the actual distribution to be paid by Indluplace in respect of the year ended 30 September 2021 of 28.13 cents per share, plus an assumed 5% in respect of each of the Forecast Periods ending 30 September 2022 and 30 September 2023.
| Forecast for the year ending |
Forecast for the year ending |
||
|---|---|---|---|
| R'000 | Notes | 30-Sep-22 | 30-Sep-23 |
| Contractual rental income | 3,4,5,6,7,8,18 | 1 827 582 | 1 902 690 |
| Straight line rental income accrual | 10 | (19 498) | (33 503) |
| Dividends received and Listed securities income | 16,17 | 88 152 | 88 152 |
| Other income | – | – | |
| Total revenue | 1 896 236 | 1 957 339 | |
| Operating costs | 9,10, 11 | (729 996) | (784 635) |
| Administration costs | (101 427) | (105 861) | |
| Profit from operations | 1 064 813 | 1 066 843 | |
| Finance charges | 12 | (392 229) | (388 841) |
| Finance income | 13 | 28 886 | 16 553 |
| Contracted lease cancelation fees | 19 | (133 663) | – |
| Profit before capital expenses | 567 807 | 694 555 | |
| Capital expenses | 20 | (79 165) | – |
| Profit before taxation | 488 642 | 694 555 | |
| Taxation | 21 | – | – |
| Total comprehensive income for the year | 488 642 | 694 555 | |
| Income for the year attributable to | |||
| Equity shareholders of Arrowhead Properties Limited | 453 643 | 679 903 | |
| Non-controlling interests | 34 999 | 14 652 | |
| 488 642 | 694 555 |
| Forecast for the year ending |
Forecast for the year ending |
||
|---|---|---|---|
| R'000 | Notes | 30-Sep-22 | 30-Sep-23 |
| Reconciliation of earnings and headline earnings | |||
| Loss for the year attributable to Group's shareholders | 453 643 | 679 903 | |
| Adjusted for: | |||
| No adjustments | |||
| Headline profit attributable to shareholders: | 453 643 | 679 903 | |
| Number of AHA Shares in issue | 62 718 658 | 62 718 658 | |
| Number of AHB Shares in issue | 1 462 912 452 | 1 467 164 467 | |
| Total weighted average number of Arrowhead Shares in issue | 1 525 631 110 | 1 529 883 125 | |
| Total weighted average number of Arrowhead Shares in issue (including dilutive) | 1 535 941 972 | 1 535 941 972 | |
| Basic earnings per combined Arrowhead Shares in issue (cents) | 29.73 | 44.44 | |
| Basic diluted earnings per combined Arrowhead Shares in issue (cents) | 29.54 | 44.27 | |
| Headline earnings per combined Arrowhead Shares in issue (cents) | 29.73 | 44.44 | |
| Headline diluted earnings per combined Arrowhead Shares in issue (cents) | 29.54 | 44.27 | |
| Distributable earnings calculation | |||
| Net property income | 1 078 089 | 1 084 552 | |
| Straight-line rental income adjustment | 19 498 | 33 503 | |
| Corporate administrative expenses | (101 428) | (105 861) | |
| Dividend received and Listed securities income | 88 152 | 88 152 | |
| Finance costs | (392 229) | (388 841) | |
| Finance and other investment income | 28 886 | 16 553 | |
| Non-controlling interest share of distribution | (34 999) | (14 652) | |
| Distributable earnings | 24 | 685 969 | 713 406 |
| Distributable income per Arrowhead Share (cents) | |||
| – AHA Share (cents) | 126.22 | 132.53 | |
| – AHB Share (cents) | 41.48 | 42.96 |
An analysis of the contractual nature of rental revenue is set out below:
| Notes | Forecast for the year ending 30-Sep-22 % |
Forecast for the year ending 30-Sep-23 % |
|
|---|---|---|---|
| Contracted/uncontracted revenue split by rental income: | |||
| % contracted rental revenue | 4 | 85 | 63 |
| % short-term rental revenue | 4 | 2 | 0 |
| % near-contracted revenue | 5 | 12 | 35 |
| % uncontracted rental revenue | 6 | 1 | 2 |
| 100 | 100 |
Forecast Notes and Assumptions
The Forecasts incorporate the following material assumptions in respect of revenue and expenses that can be influenced by the directors of Fairvest and Arrowhead:
-
- The Forecasts for the years ending 30 September 2022 and 30 September 2023 are based on information derived from lease contracts, information provided by the property managers and historic information.
-
- Fairvest and Arrowhead will not acquire any properties during the forecast periods, however, properties have been earmarked for disposal within the forecast periods. No revenues or related expenditure have been included in the Forecast Periods past the intended date of sale of each property. Per the forecast results presented, the disposal proceeds will be applied in reducing the borrowings of Arrowhead and consequently an overall comparable interest saving.
-
- Revenue and recoveries include rental income and recoveries, of which the portion relating to basic rental income amounts to R1.353 billion for the year ending 30 September 2022 and R1.381 billion for the year ending 30 September 2023.
-
- Contracted revenue is based on existing lease agreements, including stipulated increases, all of which are valid and enforceable. 85% and 63% of the rental income for the years ending 30 September 2022 and 30 September 2023 relates to contracted rental income respectively. No new leases have been taken into consideration in the Forecasts for the periods ending 30 September 2022 and 30 September 2023, with current vacant space assumed to remain vacant over the forecast period.
-
- Near contracted rental income comprising revenue for leases that expire during the Forecast Periods which have a reasonable expectation of renewal represents 12% and 35% of rental revenue for the years ending 30 September 2022 and 30 September 2023 respectively. In determining the forecast renewal rental, management have assessed each lease individually with reference to the specific tenant and the current rental in comparison to the prevailing market rental rates. This assessment results in both decrease and increases in the forecast near contractual rental when compared to the last month contractual rental, however where an increase is forecast this is inflationary in nature.
-
- Uncontracted rental revenue comprising revenue for leases that have expired before the start of the Forecast Period starts and where tenants currently occupy the premises on a month-to-month basis. This represents 1% for both the years periods ending 30 September 30 and 30 September 2023. Uncontracted rental revenue is assumed to escalate at the rental escalation stipulated in the expired contract, which typically ranges from 6% to 8%.
-
- Turnover rental (rental income based on the actual turnover of the tenant) has been forecast based on management's income budget for each property and given the trivial nature has been pro rata apportioned between contractual, near contractual and uncontracted rental income.
-
- Current vacant space has been forecast on a property-by-property basis and has been assumed to remain vacant for the duration of the Forecast Period unless a tenant has been identified and a legally binding agreement has been finalised.
-
- Property operating expenditure has been forecast by the property managers on a line-by-line basis based on management's review of historical expenditure, where available, and discussions with the property managers. On average these increases are inflation driven, but in certain cases are more than inflation based on specific circumstances, the increases range from 5% to 10%. The following tables presents the material expense at an account level over the forecast period:
| R'000 | Forecast 12 months to 30-Sep-22 |
Forecast 12 months to 30-Sep-23 |
|---|---|---|
| Electricity | 301 718 | 332 404 |
| Rates and taxes | 147 702 | 160 335 |
| Salaries – head office and director remuneration | 72 097 | 75 125 |
| Security service contract | 57 182 | 60 228 |
| Property management fee | 31 956 | 33 013 |
- The following material expense items have increased or decreased by more than 15%:
| Expense | % Change | Management reason |
|---|---|---|
| Property management fees | 42% | Fairvest's property management fees were previously charged by New Star. In terms of the Fairvest Manco Internalisation, Fairvest has acquired New Star resulting in no management fee being paid, but instead Fairvest will incur the cost directly that New Star incurred. |
No other material expense items increased or decreased by more than 15%.
-
- Certain cost savings as a result of the Transaction are expected. These costs savings relate to savings as a result of Fairvest no longer being listed and certain Arrowhead executive and non-executive directors not being employed by the new merged entity. These cost saving are estimated at R10m for the year ending 30 September 2021 and R12 million for the year ending 30 September 2022.
-
- Existing interest-bearing liabilities of R4.8 billion bear interest at a weighted average rate of 8.1% per annum, and for the purposes of the Forecasts, given the difficulty in forecasting variable rate interest due to the rates being linked to interbank rates outside the control of management, it is assumed that interest rates remain the same. In order to assist the reader to assess the impact of either an increase or decrease in the interbank rates, the below table is presented showing the impact of a 100 basis point increase and decrease in rates.
| R'000 | Forecast 12 months to 30-Sep-22 |
Forecast 12 months to 30-Sep-23 |
|---|---|---|
| 100 basis point increase in interest rates | ||
| Increase in finance cost | 14 883 | 16 768 |
| Decrease in total comprehensive income | 14 883 | 16 768 |
| 100 basis point decrease in interest rates | ||
| Decrease in finance cost | 14 883 | 16 768 |
| Increase in total comprehensive income | 14 883 | 16 768 |
- Finance income predominantly relates to interest received on loans to participants of Arrowhead's group share purchase option schemes and interest received from loans receivable.
The Forecasts incorporate the following material assumptions in respect of revenue and expenses that cannot be influenced by the directors of Fairvest and Arrowhead:
-
- The Forecasts have assumed no vis majeure (acts of God, riots, political instability).
-
- There will be no unforeseen economic factors that will affect the lessee's ability to meet their commitments in terms of existing lease agreements.
-
- The Forecasts have been compiled in full compliance with Arrowhead's IFRS accounting policies and on an aggregated basis for the property portfolio, with the exception of Indluplace, a Major Subsidiary (61% held) of Arrowhead. Indluplace was not consolidated into the Forecasts. On the basis that the forecast financial information of Indluplace was not readily available, due to the information being restricted unpublished price sensitive information, rather the expected distribution to be received from Indluplace was included in the forecast earnings under 'Listed security income' and prepared based on Arrowhead management's best estimate of Indluplace's distribution. The expected distribution to be received from Indluplace was included in the forecast earnings under listed security income as the actual distribution to be paid by Indluplace in respect of the year ended 30 September 2021 of 28.13 cents per share, plus an assumed 5% in respect of each of the Forecast Periods ending 30 September 2022 and 30 September 2023.
-
- A dividend contribution is forecast to be received from Dipula, a company in which Arrowhead has an investment (8.6%) and has been included in 'Listed security income' in the forecasts based on management's best estimate of Dipula's distribution.
-
- Consumption based recoveries are consistent with the independent property valuers' property income statements.
-
- In terms of the Fairvest Manco Internalisation, Fairvest management have accounted for the acquisition of New Star as a payment for the cancellation of the asset management agreement. This once off cost amounts to R133 million and has been included in the year ending 30 September 2022.
-
- R79.2 million of once off transaction costs have been included in relation to the Fairvest Acquisition. These transaction costs are cumulative and include the transaction costs referred to in the Fairvest Circular.
-
- The assumption was made that the pay-out ratio for the years ending 30 September 2022 and 30 September 2023 will be substantial enough to mitigate any income tax liabilities.
-
- Reconciliation of total comprehensive income for the period to distributable earnings from the period:
| R'000 | Forecast 12 months to 30-Sep-22 |
Forecast 12 months to 30-Sep-23 |
|---|---|---|
| Total comprehensive income for the period | 488 642 | 694 555 |
| Straight line rental income adjustment | 19 498 | 33 503 |
| Contracted lease cancellation fees | 133 663 | – |
| Capital expenses | 79 165 | – |
| Non-controlling interest share of distribution | (34 999) | (14 652) |
| Distributable earnings | 685 969 | 713 406 |
INDEPENDENT REPORTING ACCOUNTANTS' ASSURANCE REPORT ON THE FORECAST FINANCIAL INFORMATION OF THE COMBINED GROUP
The Directors 3rd Floor Upper Building 1 Sturdee Avenue Rosebank Johannesburg South Africa
30 November 2021
Dear Sirs
Independent Reporting Accountants' Assurance Report on the Combined Forecast Statements of Comprehensive Income for the combined Arrowhead Properties Limited ("Arrowhead")/Fairvest Property Holdings Limited ("Fairvest") group ("Combined Group")
Report on the identified property forecast information
We have undertaken a reasonable assurance engagement in respect of the accompanying combined property forecast of the Combined Group for the years ending 30 September 2022 and 30 September 2023 set out in Annexure 10 of the revised listing particulars accompanying the circular to Arrowhead shareholders dated 10 December 2021 ("Revised Listing Particulars") , comprising the forecast statement of profit or loss and other comprehensive income and the vacancy and lease expiry profile of the property portfolio as a whole ("the forecast information"), as required by paragraph 13.15 of the JSE Limited ("JSE") Listings Requirements.
We have also undertaken a limited assurance engagement in respect of the directors of Arrowhead and Fairvest's ("Directors") assumptions used to prepare and present the forecast information, disclosed in Annexure 10 to the Revised Listing Particulars, as required by paragraph 13.15 of the JSE Listings Requirements.
Directors' responsibility for the forecast information and for the assumptions used to prepare the forecast information
The Directors are responsible for the preparation and presentation of the forecast information and for the reasonableness of the assumptions used to prepare the forecast information as set out in Annexure 10 to the Revised Listing Particulars in accordance with paragraphs 13.12 - 13.14 of the JSE Listings Requirements (JSE Limited Listings Requirements for forecast information). This responsibility includes the design, implementation and maintenance of internal control relevant to the preparation and presentation of the forecast information on the basis of those assumptions that is free from material misstatement, whether due to fraud or error.
Inherent Limitations
Actual results are likely to be different from the forecast information since anticipated events frequently do not occur as expected and the variation may be material. Consequently, readers are cautioned that this forecast may not be appropriate for purposes other than described in the purpose of the report paragraph below.
Our independence and quality control
We have complied with the independence and other ethical requirements of the Code of Professional Conduct for Registered Auditors issued by the Independent Regulatory Board for Auditors (IRBA Code), which is founded on fundamental principles of integrity, objectivity, professional competence and due care, confidentiality and professional behaviour. The IRBA Code is consistent with the International Ethics Standards Board for Accountants Code of Ethics for Professional Accountants (Part A and B).
The firm applies International Standard on Quality Control 1 and, accordingly, maintains a comprehensive system of quality control including documented policies and procedures regarding compliance with ethical requirements, professional standards and applicable legal and regulatory requirements.
Limited assurance conclusion on the reasonableness of the Directors' assumptions
Based on the procedures we have performed and evidence we have obtained, nothing has come to our attention that causes us to believe that the Directors' assumptions do not provide a reasonable basis for the preparation and presentation of the forecast information for the years ending 30 September 2022 and 30 September 2023.
Reasonable assurance engagement on the forecast information
Reporting accountant's responsibility
Our responsibility is to express an opinion based on the evidence we have obtained about whether the forecast information is properly prepared and presented on the basis of the Directors' assumptions disclosed in the notes to the forecast information (the assumptions) and in accordance with the JSE Listings Requirements for forecast information. We conducted our reasonable assurance engagement in accordance with International Standard on Assurance Engagements (ISAE) 3400, The Examination of Prospective Financial Information (ISAE 3400), issued by the International Auditing and Assurance Standards Board. That standard requires that we plan and perform this engagement to obtain reasonable assurance about whether such forecast information is properly prepared and presented on the basis of the Directors' assumptions disclosed in the notes to the forecast information and in accordance with the JSE Listings Requirements for forecast information.
A reasonable assurance engagement in accordance with ISAE 3400 involves performing procedures to obtain evidence that the forecast information is properly prepared and presented on the basis of the assumptions and in accordance with the JSE Listings Requirements for forecast information. The nature, timing and extent of procedures selected depend on the reporting accountant's judgement, including the assessment of the risks of material misstatement, whether due to fraud or error, of the forecast information. In making those risk assessments, we considered internal control relevant to the Combined Group's preparation and presentation of the forecast information.
Our procedures included:
- inspecting whether the forecast information is properly prepared on the basis of the assumptions;
- inspecting whether the forecast information is properly presented and all material assumptions are adequately disclosed, including a clear indication as to whether they are best-estimate assumptions; and
- inspecting whether the forecast statement of profit or loss and other comprehensive income is prepared on a consistent basis with the historical financial statements, using appropriate accounting policies.
We believe that the evidence we have obtained is sufficient and appropriate to provide a basis for our opinion.
Opinion on the forecast information
In our opinion, the forecast information is properly prepared and presented on the basis of the assumptions and in accordance with the JSE Listings Requirements for forecast information for the years ending 30 September 2022 and 30 September 2023.
Purpose of the report
This report has been prepared for the purpose of satisfying the requirements of paragraph 13.15 of the JSE Listings Requirements and for no other purpose.
Report on other legal and regulatory requirements
In accordance with our responsibilities set out in the JSE Listings Requirements, paragraph 13.15(b), we have performed the procedures set out therein. If, based on the procedures performed, we detect any exceptions; we are required to report those exceptions. We have nothing to report in this regard.
Yours faithfully
BDO South Africa Incorporated Chartered Accountants (SA) Registered Auditors
J Barradas Director Registered Auditor
30 November 2021
Wanderers Business Park 52 Corlett Drive Illovo
PRO FORMA FINANCIAL INFORMATION OF THE ARROWHEAD GROUP
The definitions and interpretations commencing on page 6 of the Revised Listing Particulars dated 10 December 2021 have been used throughout this Annexure. The pro forma financial information should be read in conjunction with Section 3, paragraph 6 of the Revised Listing Particulars.
Basis of preparation
The pro forma financial information has been prepared using the most recent financial period of Arrowhead, in terms of the JSE Listings Requirements and guidelines issued by the South African Institute of Chartered Accountants.
The published numbers have been extracted, without adjustment, from Arrowhead's reviewed condensed consolidated for the year ended 30 September 2021 as published on SENS on 24 November 2021, which can be accessed on Arrowhead's website at www.arrowheadproperties.co.za, and will be available for inspection as set out in Section 4, paragraph 9 of the Revised Listing Particulars.
The consolidated pro forma financial information, including the assumptions on which it is based and the financial information from which it has been prepared, is the responsibility of the Board. The consolidated pro forma financial information has been prepared in accordance with the JSE Listings Requirements, the Guide on Pro forma Financial Information issued by the South African Institute of Chartered Accountants and the accounting policies that comply with IFRS and that are consistent with those applied in the reviewed condensed consolidated results of Arrowhead for the year ended 30 September 2021 (the "Consolidated Pro forma Financial Information").
The Consolidated Pro forma Financial Information has been prepared for illustrative purposes only, based on current information available to management of Arrowhead, in order to provide information about the financial results and position of Arrowhead. Due to its nature, the Consolidated Pro forma Financial Information may not fairly present Arrowhead's financial position, changes in equity and results of operations or cash flows after accounting for the Fairvest Manco Internalisation and the Transaction, and are based on the assumptions that:
- (i) the effective date of the Transaction and the Fairvest Manco Internalisation are assumed to be 1 October 2020 for the purposes of the statement of profit and loss and other comprehensive income and 30 September 2021 for the purposes of the statement of financial position;
- (ii) for the purpose of calculating basic earnings per Arrowhead Share, diluted earnings per Arrowhead Share, headline earnings per Arrowhead Share and diluted headline earnings per Arrowhead Share, the Fairvest Manco Internalisation and the Transaction were implemented on 1 October 2020; and
- (iii) for the purpose of calculating net asset value per Arrowhead Share and net tangible asset value per Arrowhead Share, the Fairvest Manco Internalisation and the Transaction were implemented on 30 September 2021.
The accounting policies of Arrowhead that were applied in the reviewed condensed consolidated results for the year ended 30 September 2021 have been used in calculating the pro forma financial effects.
The independent reporting accountant's assurance report on the Consolidated Pro forma Financial Information is set out in Annexure 13 of the Revised Listing Particulars.
146Arrowhead Properties Limited
Pro forma Statement of Financial Position as at 30 September 2021
| R'000 | Arrowhead as at 30 September 2021 |
Fairvest as at 30 June 2021 |
Fairvest – Acquisition of AHB Shares |
Fairvest Manco Internalisation |
Pro forma after Manco Fairvest Internalisation the Fairvest |
Acquisition of Fairvest by Arrowhead |
Deemed disposal of existing investment |
Transaction fees and associated costs |
Consolidation bargain adjustment – gain on purchase and minority movement |
position after Fairvest consolidation Pro forma |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Note 1 | Note 2 | Note 3 | Note 4 | Note 5 | Note 5.7.2 | Note 6 | Note 7 | |||
| Non-current assets ASSETS |
11 914 978 | 3 612 219 | 41 788 | 109 | 3 654 116 | 4 436 699 | 1 032 | – | (4 479 519) | 15 527 306 |
| Investment property | 11 297 977 | 3 319 421 | – | – | 3 319 421 | – | – | – | – | 14 617 398 |
| Right-of-use asset | – | 3 794 | – | – | 3 794 | – | – | – | – | 3 794 |
| Loans receivable | – | 215 833 | – | – | 215 833 | – | – | – | – | 215 833 |
| Investments | 195 490 | 4 533 | 41 788 | – | 46 321 | – | (41 788) | – | – | 200 023 |
| Share scheme loans receivable | 236 504 | – | – | – | – | – | – | – | – | 236 504 |
| Property, plant and equipment | 5 060 | 161 | – | 109 | 270 | – | – | – | – | 5 330 |
| Deferred tax | 38 678 | – | – | – | – | – | – | – | – | 38 678 |
| Operating lease and other receivables | – | 2 137 | – | – | 2 137 | – | – | – | – | 2 137 |
| Investment in subsidiary | – | – | – | – | – | 4 436 699 | 42 820 | – | (4 479 519) | – |
| Operating lease asset | 141 269 | 66 340 | – | – | 66 340 | – | – | – | – | 207 609 |
| Current assets | 429 552 | 174 430 | – | 3 629 | 178 059 | – | – | – | – | 607 611 |
| Current tax receivable | 632 | – | – | – | – | – | – | – | – | 632 |
| Loans receivables | – | 69 245 | – | – | 69 245 | – | – | – | – | 69 245 |
| Amounts owing by non-controlling interests | – | 20 326 | – | – | 20 326 | – | – | – | – | 20 326 |
| Operating lease and other receivables | 246 967 | 69 597 | – | 1 008 | 70 605 | – | – | – | – | 317 572 |
| Cash and cash equivalents | 181 953 | 15 262 | – | 2 621 | 17 883 | – | – | – | – | 199 836 |
| Non-current assets held for sale | 387 261 | 36 200 | – | – | 36 200 | – | – | – | – | 423 461 |
| Total assets | 12 731 791 | 3 822 849 | 41 788 | 3 738 | 3 868 375 | 4 436 699 | 1 032 | – | (4 479 519) | 16 558 378 |
| R'000 | Arrowhead as at 30 September 2021 |
Fairvest as at 30 June 2021 |
Fairvest – Acquisition of AHB Shares |
Fairvest Manco Internalisation |
Pro forma after Manco Fairvest the Fairvest Internalisation |
Acquisition of Fairvest by Arrowhead |
Deemed disposal of existing investment |
Transaction fees and associated costs |
Consolidation bargain adjustment – gain on purchase and minority movement |
position after Pro forma Fairvest consolidation |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| EQUITY AND LIABILITIES Total equity |
7 246 671 | 2 441 524 | 41 788 | (132 076) | 2 351 236 | 4 436 699 | 1 032 | (79 165) | (4 479 519) | 9 476 955 |
| Stated capital | 7 160 453 | 750 474 | 41 788 | – | 792 262 | 4 436 699 | – | – | (7 160 453) | 5 228 961 |
| Retained earnings | (789 357) | 1 524 458 | – | (132 076) | 1 392 382 | – | 1 032 | (79 165) | 789 357 | 1 314 249 |
| Non-controlling interest Share based payments |
10 199 865 376 |
– 166 592 |
– – |
– – |
– 166 592 |
– – |
– – |
– – |
– – |
10 199 1 031 968 |
| Gain on bargain purchase (Retained Earnings) |
– | – | – | – | – | – | – | – | 1 891 577 | 1 891 577 |
| Non-current liabilities Liabilities |
3 976 133 | 689 557 | – | – | 689 557 | – | – | – | 4 665 690 | |
| Interest-bearing borrowings | 3 775 728 | 491 650 | – | – | 491 650 | – | – | – | 4 267 378 | |
| Amounts owing to non-controlling interests | – | 121 384 | – | – | 121 384 | – | – | – | – | 121 384 |
| Lease liability | 39 177 | 19 480 | – | – | 19 480 | – | – | – | – | 58 657 |
| Financial instrument liabilities | 161 228 | 39 715 | – | – | 39 715 | – | – | – | – | 200 943 |
| Deposits received | – | 15 870 | – | – | 15 870 | – | – | – | – | 15 870 |
| Deferred tax liability | – | 1 458 | – | – | 1 458 | – | – | – | – | 1 458 |
| Current liabilities | 1 508 987 | 691 768 | – | 135 814 | 827 582 | – | – | 79 165 | – | 2 415 733 |
| Interest-bearing borrowings | 858 628 | 592 172 | – | 133 663 | 725 835 | – | – | 79 165 | – | 1 663 627 |
| Amounts owing to non-controlling interests | – | 8 429 | – | – | 8 429 | – | – | – | – | 8 429 |
| Lease liabilities | 5 359 | 1 340 | – | – | 1 340 | – | – | – | – | 6 699 |
| Trade and other payables Tax payable |
– 645 000 |
– 89 827 |
– – |
– 2 151 |
– 91 978 |
– – |
– – |
– – |
– – |
– 736 978 |
| Total equities and liabilities | 12 731 791 | 3 822 849 | 41 788 | 3 738 | 3 868 375 | 4 436 699 | 1 032 | – | (4 479 519) | 16 558 378 |
| Number of AHB Shares in issue (Note 7) NAV attributable to AHB Shares NAV attributable to AHA Shares Number of AHB Shares in issue |
62 718 658 951 422 029 |
545 045 125 | 62 718 658 (10 318 064) 1 486 149 090 733 181 |
|||||||
| (Note 8) | 11.69 | 7 711 805 11.69 |
||||||||
| Net asset value per AHA Share (R) Net asset value per AHB Share (R) |
5.94 | 5.19 | ||||||||
| Tangible net asset value per AHA Share (R) |
11.69 | 11.69 | ||||||||
| Tangible net asset value per AHB Share (R) |
5.90 | 5.16 | ||||||||
Notes and assumptions:
-
- Presents the consolidated statement of financial position extracted, without adjustment, from Arrowhead's reviewed condensed consolidated results for the year ended 30 September 2021 as published on SENS on 24 November 2021.
-
- Presents the consolidated statement of financial position extracted, without adjustment, from Fairvest's audited published results for the year ended 30 June 2021.
-
- On 13 October 2021 issued 19 088 414 Fairvest Shares to acquire 10 318 064 AHB Shares. The investment was recognised at the fair value of the AHB Shares on date of issue which was R4.05 per Fairvest Share.
In terms of paragraph 8.26 of the Listings Requirements no adjustment may be made to the pro forma financial information in respect of a post statement of financial position event unless it would be misleading not to make an adjustment. It is the Company's view that it would be misleading not to make the adjustment detailed in this note, given that:
- the 19 088 414 shares that Fairvest issued to acquire the AHB Shares will increase the number of AHB Shares Arrowhead will need to issue to acquire Fairvest; and
- the consideration determined with reference to IFRS 3 as set out in Note 5 below, will be impacted by the 10 318 064 AHB Shares and the deemed disposal of the investment in Arrowhead.
This has not been adjusted on the pro forma income statement as the dividend income on the AHB Shares that Fairvest would earn would eliminate in the Combined Entity.
- In terms of the Fairvest Manco Internalisation, Fairvest acquires 100% of New Star shares in issue for a cash consideration of R133 million ("Cancellation Price"), of which R1.6 million is specifically for the acquisition of New Star's NAV and the remainder of R131.4 million is for the cancellation of the management contract. In assessing the accounting treatment of the acquisition, management have concluded that IFRS 3 should not be applied as the payment is in substance a payment for the cancellation of a contract, and even if IFRS 3 was to be applied this would only be an acquisition of a single asset being the management contract and not the acquisition of a business.
The Cancellation Price has been calculated on the basis that the cancellation will be neutral to forecast forward distributable earnings. The Cancellation Price will be fully funded with debt bearing interest at JIBAR plus 215 basis points, assumed to be 5.83% for the purpose of preparing the pro forma. The net pro forma results from the acquisition of New Star (in substance cancellation of a contract) is accounted for as follows:
- 4.1 Net assets of New Star of R1.6 million, being the sum of New Star's assets of R3.7 million less New Star liabilities of R2.1 million (before the assumption of R133.6 million interest bearing debt to fund the Cancellation Price and transaction costs of R662 500), are brought into Fairvest's statement of financial position at their carrying value as at 28 February 2021. The net assets have been extracted, without adjustment, from New Star's reviewed financial results for the year ended 28 February 2021, on which BDO issued an unqualified review opinion.
- 4.2 Retained earnings is adjusted for transaction costs of R662 500 and cancellation expense of R131.4 million being the Cancellation Price less the transaction costs of R662 500 less the New Star net asset value of R1.6 million as at 28 February 2021.
- 4.3 Short-term interest-bearing debt raised equal to the Cancellation Price and transaction costs expensed of R662 500.
-
- Arrowhead will acquire 100% of the issued share capital of Fairvest by issuing the Scheme Consideration Shares to Fairvest Shareholders at the Share Swap Ratio, being 0.54054 AHB Shares for 1 Fairvest Share, resulting in Arrowhead issuing 545 045 125 new AHB Shares to acquire 1 008 334 490 Fairvest Shares.
For accounting purposes under IFRS 3: Business Combinations, the Transaction will be treated as the acquisition of Arrowhead by Fairvest even though, legally, Arrowhead is the acquirer and will be the entity which will issue the Scheme Consideration Shares to Fairvest Shareholders. Applying the guidance contained in IFRS 3: B15-B17 the acquirer was identified as Fairvest. The following factors were considered in identifying the acquirer:
- 5.1 The acquirer is usually the combining entity whose owners as a group retain or receive the largest portion of the voting rights in the combined entity. Due to the commonality in shareholders across Arrowhead and Fairvest, there will be no change in the specific shareholders who will have the largest portion of voting rights in the Combined Group.
- 5.2 After the implementation of the Scheme, Fairvest's Chief Executive Officer and Chief Financial Officer will continue in their respective roles in the Combined Group. Furthermore, 5 of the 8 proposed non-executive directors will be selected from the Fairvest Board.
- 5.3 Arrowhead is significantly greater in net asset value, revenue and profit than Fairvest.
- 5.4 The Transaction was initiated by Fairvest and the current Scheme is an alternative to the implementation of the Fairvest Acquisition approved by Fairvest Shareholders at the Fairvest general meeting held on 7 September 2021. The Transaction is both led by Fairvest and controlled by Fairvest in that Fairvest can ultimately revert to the Fairvest Acquisition to obtain control of Arrowhead.
Irrespective of who the acquirer is, there would be a bargain purchase on acquisition due to both companies trading at a discount to their NAV. Therefore, neither entity would be paying a premium.
While the fact that Arrowhead is the legal acquirer and is relatively larger than Fairvest in terms of NAV, revenue, and profit, Fairvest is of the view that these factors are overridden by the fact that Fairvest controls the appointment of the board of directors of the Combined Group through the Implementation Agreement, Fairvest initiated the Transaction and Fairvest controls the terms of the Transaction as they can revert to the alternative Fairvest Acquisition approved by Fairvest Shareholders which would result in Fairvest obtaining control of Arrowhead, and the senior management of Fairvest will replace the senior management of Arrowhead.
- The Transaction is accounted for as follows:
- 5.5 On acquisition date, an investment in Arrowhead is recognised at the fair value of the Scheme Consideration transferred by the accounting acquirer (Fairvest) and a corresponding increase in the stated capital by way of the issue of the Scheme Consideration Shares by Arrowhead.
- 5.6 In accordance with IFRS 3, the Scheme Consideration is calculated as the number of equity interest the legal subsidiary (Fairvest) would have had to issue to give the owners of the legal parent (Arrowhead) the same percentage equity interest in the Combined Group that results from a reverse acquisition (IFRS 3: B20).
The percentage equity interest of the legal parent (Arrowhead) will have in the Combined Group was calculated based on the economic rights of the AHA Shares and the AHB Shares with reference to their spot price on the Last Practicable Date. As a result, existing Arrowhead Shareholders will own 68% and the Fairvest Shareholders will own 32% of the equity interest of the Combined Group.
Therefore, Fairvest would have to issue 2 152 116 962 Fairvest Shares for Arrowhead Shareholders to own a 68% economic interest in the legal subsidiary (Fairvest).
However, as Fairvest hold 10 318 064 AHB Shares, Fairvest will be issued 19 088 414 Fairvest Shares, which are deemed treasury shares for the purposes of calculating the deemed purchase price in 5.7.1.
- 5.7 The fair value of the Scheme Consideration transferred was calculated as R4.47 billion, being:
- 5.7.1 R4.43 billion being the deemed issue of 2 133 028 524 (2 152 116 962 total Fairvest Shares less the 19 088 414 Fairvest Shares deemed to be treasury) Fairvest Shares multiplied by R2.08, the Fairvest closing share spot price on the Last Practicable Date; plus
R42.82 million being the deemed disposal of the existing investment in AHB Shares at their fair value of R42.82 million calculated at the spot price of R4.15 per AHB Share at the Last Practicable Date, with the difference between the original acquisition fair value of R41.78 million and the fair value of R42.82 million resulting in a fair value gain of R1.032 million.
-
- Transaction and share issue costs of R58.9 million, as well as the exit payments totalling R20.3 million to be paid to the Departing Executives in terms of the Departing Executive Termination Agreements (as agreed between the Arrowhead Board and the Departing Executives), are all funded by interest bearing debt, and are treated as follows:
- 6.1 Transaction costs of R58.9 million directly attributable to the deemed acquisition of Arrowhead have been recognised as an expense in the statement of comprehensive income.
- 6.2 These transaction costs are cumulative and include the transaction costs of R23.8 million referred to in the Fairvest Circular.
- 6.3 The Arrowhead Board reached agreement with each of Mr Mark Kaplan and Mr Junaid Limalia on the terms on which they will resign as Arrowhead's Chief Executive Officer and Chief Financial Officer, respectively, should the Scheme become operative. The agreed cash payments to the departing executives are:
- 6.3.1 R11.7 million in respect of Mr Mark Kaplan; and
- 6.3.2 R8.6 million in respect of Mr Junaid Limalia.
The terms of the executives' departure are in accordance with the principles set out in the Implementation Agreement, which principles include that any termination payments will not exceed the amounts to which they would have been entitled in terms of their existing employment contracts, in the case of a change of control resulting in their removal or replacement and as formalised in the Departing Executive Termination Agreements.
-
- The consolidated financial statements represent the continuation of the financial statements of the legal subsidiary (Fairvest) except for its capital structure. In accordance with IFRS 3: Business Combinations, the following consolidation adjustments are passed:
- 7.1 Elimination of the investment in subsidiary of R4.47 billion.
- 7.2 No adjustment applied to bring the NAV of Arrowhead to fair value as the assets and liabilities already approximate fair value in the statement of financial position.
- 7.3 Elimination of Fairvest's share of the remaining retained earnings and stated capital.
- 7.4 Recognition of R1.89 billion gain on bargain purchase being the difference between the Consideration and Arrowhead's retained earnings and stated capital attributable to parent shareholders.
- 7.5 The 10 318 064 AHB Shares owned by Fairvest become treasury shares in the Combined Group.
-
- The ordinary shares of the Combined Entity reflect the equity structure of the Arrowhead, including the equity interest of Arrowhead issued to effect the combination.
-
- AHB Shares in issue of 951 422 029 plus 545 045 125 AHB Shares issued in consideration for Fairvest Shares, excluding treasury shares, minus 10 318 064 AHB Shares already owned by Fairvest resulting in total ordinary shares in issue of 1 486 149 090 used in calculating the NAV and tangible NAV per AHB Share for the Combined Group.
-
- There are no material subsequent events that require adjustments to the pro forma financial information.
150Arrowhead Properties Limited
Pro forma Statement of profit or loss and other comprehensive income for the year ended 30 September 2021
| Arrowhead for the |
Fairvest pro forma |
|||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| ended 12 months |
for the Fairvest |
Manco Fairvest |
after the Fairvest Manco |
Consolidation | disposal of Deemed |
Adjustments fees and for transaction |
position after Fairvest Pro forma |
|
| R'000 | 30 September 2021 |
year ended 30 June 2021 |
Internalisation | Internalisation | adjustment | existing investment |
finance costs | consolidation |
| Note 1 | Note 2 | Note 3 | Note 4 | Note 5 | Note 6 | |||
| Property revenue | 1 976 752 | 550 113 | – | 550 113 | – | – | – | 2 526 865 |
| Rental income – contractual and tenant recoveries/revenue | 2 000 708 | 541 348 | – | 541 348 | – | – | – | 2 542 056 |
| Straight-line adjustment | (23 956) | 8 765 | – | 8 765 | – | – | – | (15 191) |
| Sundry income | 20 557 | 3 541 | 2 436 | 5 977 | – | – | – | 26 534 |
| Property expenses | (884 032) | (198 759) | 463 | (198 296) | – | – | – | (1 082 328) |
| Net property income | 1 113 277 | 354 895 | 2 899 | 357 794 | – | – | – | 1 471 071 |
| Corporate administrative expenses | (134 346) | (31 079) | (6 436) | (37 515) | – | – | (79 165) | (251 025) |
| Operating profit | 978 931 | 323 816 | (3 537) | 320 279 | – | – | (79 165) | 1 220 046 |
| Fair value adjustment to investment property | (818 246) | 72 882 | 3 008 | 75 890 | – | – | – | (742 356) |
| Fair value adjustment to derivative financial instruments | 197 058 | 27 863 | – | 27 863 | – | – | – | 224 921 |
| Fair value adjustment to investments | 118 644 | (285) | – | (285) | – | 1 032 | – | 119 391 |
| Fair value adjustments – other | 108 868 | – | – | – | – | – | – | 108 868 |
| Gain on bargain purchase | – | – | – | – | 1 891 577 | – | – | 1 891 577 |
| Finance costs | (427 786) | (99 485) | (7 797) | (107 282) | – | – | (4 618) | (539 685) |
| Contract cancellation fees | – | – | (131 413) | (131 413) | – | – | – | (131 413) |
| Finance and other investment income | – | 25 912 | 1 | 25 913 | – | – | – | 25 913 |
| Impairment of loan receivable | – | (15 765) | – | (15 765) | – | – | – | (15 765) |
| Profit before capital expenses | 157 469 | 334 938 | (139 737) | 195 201 | 1 891 577 | 1 032 | (83 782) | 2 161 496 |
| Capital expenses | – | (2 385) | – | (2 385) | – | – | – | (2 385) |
| Profit before taxation | 157 469 | 332 553 | (139 737) | 192 816 | 1 891 577 | 1 032 | (83 782) | 2 159 111 |
| Income tax expense | (18 791) | 107 | (38) | 69 | – | – | – | (18 722) |
| Total comprehensive profit/(loss) for the period | 138 678 | 332 660 | (139 775) | 192 885 | 1 891 577 | 1 032 | (83 782) | 2 140 389 |
| Profit and total comprehensive income attributable to: | ||||||||
| Owners of the parent | 181 197 | 289 342 | (139 775) | 149 567 | 1 891 577 | 1 032 | (83 782) | 2 139 590 |
| Non-controlling interests | (42 519) | 43 318 | – | 43 318 | – | – | – | 799 |
| Total comprehensive profit/(loss) for the period | 138 678 | 332 660 | (139 775) | 192 885 | 1 891 577 | 1 032 | (83 782) | 2 140 389 |
| Weighted average number of Arrowhead Shares | ||||||||
| Basic earnings per Arrowhead Share (cents) (excluding treasury shares) |
1 020 940 673 17.75 |
545 045 125 | (10 318 064) | 137.54 1 555 667 734 |
||||
| Diluted earnings per Arrowhead Share (cents) | 17.57 | 136.63 | ||||||
| Headline earnings per Arrowhead Share (cents) (Note 7) | 90.33 | 59.64 | ||||||
| Diluted headline earnings per Arrowhead Share (cents) (Note 7) | 89.43 | 59.25 | ||||||
| Distribution per AHB Share (cents) | 47.72 | 44.10 |
Notes and assumptions:
-
- Presents the consolidated statement of profit and loss and other comprehensive income extracted, without adjustment, from Arrowhead's reviewed condensed consolidated results for the year ended 30 September 2021 as published on SENS on 24 November 2021.
-
- Presents the consolidated statement of profit and loss and other comprehensive income extracted, without adjustment, from Fairvest's published audited results for the year ended 30 June 2021.
-
- Per note 2 in the pro forma statement of financial position, in terms of the Fairvest Manco Internalisation, Fairvest management have accounted for the acquisition of New Star as a payment for the cancellation of the asset management agreement. The accounting to give effect to this in the statement of profit and loss and other comprehensive income is as follows:
- 3.1 The income and expenses have been extracted, without adjustment, from New Star's reviewed financial results for the year ended 28 February 2021, on which BDO issued an unqualified review opinion.
- 3.2 Additional income of R2.4 million accruing to Fairvest in respect of third-party fees earned by New Star.
- 3.3 Reversal of R463 071 letting commission previously capitalised and amortised.
- 3.4 Assumption of additional corporate administrative costs of R6.4 million calculated as follows:
- 3.4.1 New Star's total expenses of R20.7 million less corporate expense savings of R14.9 million attributable to Fairvest; and
- 3.4.2 recognition of transaction costs of R662 500 directly attributable to the Fairvest Manco Internalisation.
- 3.5 Fair value adjustments of R3 million to investment property in respect of expenses capitalised.
- 3.6 Additional finance cost at an assumed interest rate of 5.83% (JIBAR plus 215 basis points) on debt of R133.7 million utilised to fund the Fairvest Manco Internalisation and associated transaction costs.
- 3.7 Cancellation cost of R131.4 million equal to the difference between the Cancellation Price and the carrying value of New Star's net assets as at 28 February 2021.
-
- Recognition of bargain purchase on acquiring a controlling interest in Arrowhead. Details provided in note 7 to the pro forma statement of financial position.
-
- Refer note 5.7.2 in the notes to the pro forma statement of financial position.
-
- R58.59 million of transaction costs, as well as the exit payments to be paid to the Departing Executives totalling R20.3 million, and R4.6 million of finance costs on debt utilised to fund transaction costs associated with the Fairvest Acquisition and issue of AHB Shares in relation thereto. These transaction costs are cumulative and include the transaction costs of R23.8 million referred to in the Fairvest Circular.
-
- Reconciliation between profit attributable to Arrowhead Shareholders and headline earnings per Arrowhead Share:
| R'000 | |
|---|---|
| Comprehensive income attributable to owners of the parent | 2 139 590 |
| Adjusted for: | |
| Fair value adjustments | 742 356 |
| Non-controlling interest portion of the fair value adjustments | (92 754) |
| Loss on sale of investment property | 30 246 |
| Loss on sale of investment property – non-controlling interest | |
| Gain on bargain purchase | (1 891 577) |
| Headline profit attributable to Arrowhead Shareholders | 927 681 |
| Headline earnings per Arrowhead Share (cents) | 59.64 |
| Diluted headline earnings per Arrowhead Share (cents) | 59.25 |
INDEPENDENT REPORTING ACCOUNTANTS' ASSURANCE REPORT ON THE COMPILATION OF THE PRO FORMA FINANCIAL INFORMATION OF THE ARROWHEAD GROUP
The Directors Arrowhead Properties Limited 3rd Floor Upper Building 1 Sturdee Avenue Rosebank Johannesburg South Africa
30 November 2021
Dear Sirs/Mesdames
INDEPENDENT REPORTING ACCOUNTANTS' ASSURANCE REPORT ON THE COMPILATION OF THE PRO FORMA FINANCIAL INFORMATION OF Arrowhead properties Limited ("ARROWHEAD" OR "THE COMPANY")
We have completed our assurance engagement to report on the compilation of the pro forma financial information of Arrowhead by the directors of Arrowhead (the "Directors"). The pro forma financial information, as set out in Annexure 12 of the revised listing particulars to be issued on or about 10 December 2021 ("the RLP"), consists of the pro forma statement of financial position, the pro forma statement of comprehensive income and related notes. The applicable criteria on the basis of which the Directors have compiled the pro forma financial information are specified in the JSE Listing Requirements and described in Annexure 12.
The pro forma financial information has been compiled by the Directors to illustrate the impact of the corporate actions or events, described in Section 3, paragraph 6 of the RLP, on the Company's financial position and performance as at 30 September 2021, as if the corporate action or event had taken place at 30 September 2021 for statement of financial position and 1 October 2020 for statement of comprehensive income purposes. As part of this process, information about the Company's financial position and performance has been extracted by the Directors from the Company's published reviewed condensed consolidated results for the period ended 30 September 2021.
Directors' responsibility for the pro forma financial information
The Directors are responsible for compiling the pro forma financial information on the basis of the applicable criteria specified in the JSE Listing Requirements and described in Annexure 12 of the RLP and as described in the notes to the consolidated pro forma statement of financial position and pro forma statement of comprehensive income.
Our independence and quality control
We have complied with the independence and other ethical requirements of Sections 290 and 291 of the Independent Regulatory Board for Auditors' Code of Professional Conduct for Registered Auditors (Revised January 2018) and parts 1 and 3 of the Independent Regulatory Board for Auditors' Code of Professional Conduct for Registered Auditors (Revised November 2018) (together the "IRBA Codes"), which are founded on fundamental principles of integrity, objectivity, professional competence and due care, confidentiality and professional behaviour. The IRBA Codes are consistent with the International Ethics Standards Board for Accountants Code of Ethics for Professional Accountants (Parts A and B).
The firm applies the International Standard on Quality Control 1, Quality Control for Firms that Perform Audits and Reviews of Financial Statements, and Other Assurance and Related Services Engagements and accordingly maintains a comprehensive system of quality control including documented policies and procedures regarding compliance with ethical requirements, professional standards and applicable legal and regulatory requirements.
Reporting accountants' responsibility
Our responsibility is to express an opinion about whether the pro forma financial information has been compiled, in all material respects, by the Directors on the basis specified in the JSE Listing Requirements based on our procedures performed.
We conducted our engagement in accordance with the International Standard on Assurance Engagements (ISAE) 3420, Assurance Engagements to Report on the Compilation of Pro Forma Financial Information included in a Prospectus issued by the International Auditing and Assurance Standards Board. This standard requires that we plan and perform procedures to obtain reasonable assurance about whether the pro forma financial information has been compiled, in all material respects, on the basis specified in the JSE Listings Requirements.
For purposes of this engagement, we are not responsible for updating or reissuing any reports or opinions on any historical financial information used in compiling the pro forma financial information, nor have we, in the course of this engagement, performed an audit or review of the financial information used in compiling the pro forma financial information.
As the purpose of pro forma financial information included in the RLP is solely to illustrate the impact of a significant corporate action or event on unadjusted financial information of the entity as if the corporate action or event had occurred or had been undertaken at an earlier date selected for purposes of the illustration, we do not provide any assurance that the actual outcome of the event or transaction would have been as presented.
A reasonable assurance engagement to report on whether the pro forma financial information has been compiled, in all material respects, on the basis of the applicable criteria involves performing procedures to assess whether the applicable criteria used in the compilation of the pro forma financial information provides a reasonable basis for presenting the significant effects directly attributable to the corporate action or event, and to obtain sufficient appropriate evidence about whether:
- the related pro forma adjustments give appropriate effect to those criteria; and
- the pro forma financial information reflects the proper application of those adjustments to the unadjusted financial information.
Our procedures selected depend on our judgment, having regard to our understanding of the nature of the Company, the corporate action or event in respect of which the pro forma financial information has been compiled, and other relevant engagement circumstances.
Our engagement also involves evaluating the overall presentation of the pro forma financial information.
We believe that the evidence we have obtained is sufficient and appropriate to provide a basis for our opinion.
Opinion
In our opinion, the pro forma financial information has been compiled, in all material respects, on the basis of the applicable criteria specified by the JSE Listing Requirements and described in Annexure 12 of the RLP.
Consent
This report on the pro forma statement of financial position and pro forma statement of comprehensive income is included solely for the information of the shareholders of the Company. We consent to the inclusion of our report on the pro forma statement of financial position, pro forma statement of comprehensive income and the references thereto, in the form and context in which they appear.
Yours faithfully
BDO South Africa Incorporated Chartered Accountants (SA) Registered Auditors
per B van der Walt Chartered Accountant (SA) Registered Auditor JSE Reporting Accountant Specialist
119 – 123 Hertzog Boulevard, Foreshore, Cape Town, 8001
INDEPENDENT REPORTING ACCOUNTANTS' REVIEW CONCLUSION ON THE VALUATION AND EXISTENCE OF THE ASSETS AND LIABILITIES ACQUIRED BY ARROWHEAD
The Directors Arrowhead Properties Limited 3rd Floor Upper Building 1 Sturdee Avenue Rosebank Johannesburg South Africa
30 November 2021
Dear Sirs/Mesdames
INDEPENDENT REPORTING ACCOUNTANTS' REVIEW CONCLUSION ON THE VALUATION AND EXISTENCE OF THE ASSETS AND LIABILITIES ACQUIRED BY ARROWHEAD PROPERTIES LIMITED ("ARROWHEAD" OR "THE COMPANY")
We have reviewed the assets and liabilities acquired by Arrowhead reflected in the Fairvest Property Holdings Limited net of disposals and adjustments columns ("the adjustment columns") of the pro forma statement of financial position included in Annexure 12 of the revised listing particulars to be issued on or about 10 December 2021 ("the RLP") as required by paragraph 13.16(e) of the JSE Limited Listings Requirements.
Directors' responsibility for the pro forma financial information
The directors of Arrowhead ("Directors") are responsible for the preparation and presentation of the financial information in accordance with paragraph 13.16 (a)-(d) of the JSE Limited Listing Requirements (the JSE Limited Listings Requirements for the adjustment columns of the pro forma statement of financial position), as set out in Note 2 of the pro forma statement of financial position, and for such internal controls as the Directors determine is necessary to enable the preparation of the financial information that is free from material misstatement, whether due to fraud or error.
Reporting accountants' responsibility
Our responsibility is to express a conclusion on the financial information. We conducted our review in accordance with the International Standard on Review Engagements (ISRE) 2400 (Revised), Engagements to Review Historical Financial Statements (ISRE 2400 (Revised)). ISRE 2400 (Revised) requires us to conclude whether anything has come to our attention that causes us to believe that the financial information, taken as a whole, is not prepared in all material respects in accordance with the JSE Limited Listings Requirements and that the assets and liabilities are not fairly valued, do not exist and are not fairly presented, in all material respects, in accordance with the accounting policies adopted by Fairvest and the recognition and measurement criteria of IFRS for the adjustment column of the pro forma statement of financial position. This Standard also requires us to comply with relevant ethical requirements.
A review of financial information in accordance with ISRE 2400 (Revised) is a limited assurance engagement. The reporting accountant performs procedures, primarily consisting of making inquiries of management and others within the entity, as appropriate, and applying analytical procedures, and evaluates the evidence obtained.
The procedures performed in a review are substantially less than those performed in an audit conducted in accordance with International Standards on Auditing. Accordingly, we do not express an audit opinion on the financial information.
Opinion
Based on our review, nothing has come to our attention that causes us to believe that the financial information is not prepared, in all material respects, in accordance with the JSE Limited Listings Requirements and that the assets and liabilities are not fairly valued, do not exist and are not fairly presented, in all material respects, in accordance with the accounting policies adopted by Fairvest and the recognition and measurement criteria of IFRS for the adjustment columns of the pro forma statement of financial position, as set out in the notes to the pro forma statement of financial position.
Purpose of the report
This report has been prepared for the purpose of satisfying the requirement of paragraph 13.16(e) of the JSE Limited Listing Requirements, and for no other purpose.
Yours faithfully
BDO South Africa Incorporated Chartered Accountants (SA) Registered Auditors
per B van der Walt Chartered Accountant (SA) Registered Auditor JSE Reporting Accountant Specialist
119 – 123 Hertzog Boulevard, Foreshore, Cape Town, 8001
CAPITAL STRUCTURE
1. Alterations to authorised share capital
In respect of Arrowhead:
- i. There have been no sub-divisions or consolidations of Arrowhead Shares during the three years preceding the Last Practicable Date.
- ii. There have been no other alterations to the authorised share capital of the Company in the three years preceding the Last Practicable Date.
In respect of Fairvest:
- i. There have been no sub-divisions or consolidations of Fairvest Shares during the three years preceding the Last Practicable Date.
- ii. On 7 September 2021, Fairvest Shareholders approved the increase of Fairvest's authorised share capital from 3 000 000 000 ordinary shares of no par value to 6 000 000 ordinary shares of no par value, ranking pari passu in all respects with the existing ordinary shares in the authorised share capital of Fairvest.
- ii. Save as set out above, there have been no other alterations to the authorised share capital of Fairvest in the three years preceding the Last Practicable Date.
2. Voting rights and other rights attached to shares
In respect of Arrowhead:
The voting rights and other rights attached to Arrowhead Shares are detailed in paragraph 20 of the MOI and in paragraph 20 of Annexure 5.
In respect of Fairvest:
- i. The rights attaching to Fairvest Shares are set out in Annexure 5 of the Fairvest Revised Listing Particulars, which document is incorporated by reference in accordance with paragraph 8 of Section 4.
- ii. In accordance with Fairvest's memorandum of incorporation, during any vote at any general meeting every person present and entitled to exercise voting rights shall be entitled to one vote on a show of hands, irrespective of the number of voting rights that person would otherwise be entitled to exercise or on a poll any person who is present at the meeting, whether as a shareholder or as proxy for a shareholder, has the number of votes determined in accordance with the voting rights associated with the securities held by that shareholder.
- ii. Fairvest Shareholders are entitled to participate proportionally in any distribution made by Fairvest and to receive proportionally the net assets of Fairvest upon its liquidation.
- iv. Any variation in rights attaching to Fairvest Shares will require the consent of 75% of Fairvest Shareholders in a general meeting in accordance with Fairvest's memorandum of incorporation.
- v. Only such members that are registered in share register of Fairvest on the day when a distribution is declared or on such other day as may be determined by the Fairvest Board as the last date for registration for the distribution, will be entitled to receive the distribution so declared.
3. Options and preferential rights in respect of Shares
In respect of Arrowhead:
Save as set out in the table below, there are no contracts or arrangements, either actual or proposed, whereby any option or preferential right of any kind has been or will be given to any person to subscribe for any Arrowhead Shares.
| Date | Nature | Counterparty | Number of shares | Price per share |
Vesting date |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 23 December | Award and acceptance | M Kaplan | 1 313 837 AHB Shares | Nil | 30 September |
| 2020 | of performance shares in | J Limalia | 696 827 AHB Shares | Nil | 2023 |
| terms of the Conditional Share Plan |
R Kader | 696 827 AHB Shares | Nil | ||
| 23 December 2020 |
Award and acceptance of performance shares in terms of the Conditional Share Plan |
Arrowhead employees |
2 836 529 AHB Shares | Nil | 30 September 2023 |
| 18 December | Award and acceptance of | A Kirkel | 512 793 AHB Shares | Nil | 30 September |
| 2019 | conditional rights to AHB | R Kader | 512 793 AHB Shares | Nil | 2022 |
| Shares in terms of the Conditional Share Plan |
M Kaplan | 823 916 AHB Shares | Nil | ||
| J Limalia | 512 793 AHB Shares | Nil | |||
| 18 December 2019 |
Award and acceptance of conditional rights to AHB Shares in terms of the Conditional Share Plan |
Arrowhead employees |
1 918 653 AHB Shares | Nil | 30 September 2022 |
In respect of Fairvest:
Fairvest is not party to any contract or arrangement (or proposed contract or arrangement), whereby an option or preferential right of any kind is (or is proposed to be) given to any person to subscribe for any shares in Fairvest or any subsidiary of Fairvest. There are no preferential conversion and/or exchange rights in respect of any Fairvest Shares.
4. Issues and repurchases of shares
In respect of Arrowhead:
Save as set out in the tables below:
- i. There have been no repurchases or issues of Arrowhead Shares or shares of Arrowhead's Major Subsidiaries in the three years preceding the Last Practicable Date.
- ii. There were no assets acquired or to be acquired out of the proceeds of any issues of shares by Arrowhead and its Major Subsidiaries.
- iii. All share issues and repurchases were effected at a price which the Arrowhead Board considered to represent the fair value for the Company's shares, which may have resulted in the Company's shares being issued at a premium or discount.
| Date | Nature | Counterparty | Number of Arrowhead Shares |
Price per Arrowhead Share |
Reason for repurchase or issue |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Issues | |||||
| 27 August 2018 | Issue | Moolgem Pty Ltd | 10 264 434 AHA Shares |
R9,74 | Shares issued in part payment of portfolio of immovable properties |
| 5 December 2018 | Issue | A Kirkel | 1 571 428 AHB Shares |
R6,30 | Shares issued to employees in terms of the Gemgrow |
| J Limalia | 1 571 428 AHB Shares |
R6,30 | share purchase and option scheme |
| Date | Nature | Counterparty | Number of Arrowhead Shares |
Price per Arrowhead Share |
Reason for repurchase or issue |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 16 September 2019 | Issue | Old Arrowhead shareholders |
862 972 109 AHB Shares |
N/A – Consideration via share swap |
Shares issued pursuant to the implementation of the Gemgrow Arrowhead Merger |
| Repurchases | |||||
| 27 November to 27 January 2020 |
Repurchase | Various – general repurchase in the open market |
19 132 488 AHB Shares |
R3,84 | Part of proceeds of disposal program used for the repurchase |
| 12 February 2021 | Repurchase | Mr. I Suleman and the Suleman Family Trust |
18 385 147 AHB shares |
R2,47 | The AHB Shares were sold to reduce loan amounts outstanding by Mr. I Suleman and the Suleman Family Trust in terms of various share schemes. |
| 14 July 2021 | Repurchase | Arrowhead Charitable Trust |
25 534 700 AHB Shares |
R3,41 | The loan advanced to the Arrowhead Charitable Trust became due on 30 June 2021 and the Arrowhead Charitable Trust was not able to repay its loan. The AHB Shares were repurchased to reduce the loan outstandings due by the Arrowhead Charitable Trust to Arrowgem. |
In respect of Fairvest:
Save as set out in the table below:
- i. There have been no repurchases or issues of Fairvest Shares or shares of Fairvest's Major Subsidiaries in the three years preceding the Last Practicable Date.
- ii. There were no assets acquired or to be acquired out of the proceeds of any issues of shares by Fairvest and its Major Subsidiaries.
- iii. All share issues and repurchases were effected at a price which the Fairvest Board considered to represent the fair value for Fairvest Shares, which may have resulted in such Fairvest Shares being issued at a premium or discount.
| Date | Nature | Counterparty | Number of Fairvest Shares |
Price per Fairvest Share |
Reason for repurchase or issue |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Issues | |||||
| 8 October 2018 | Dividend reinvestment alternative |
Fairvest Shareholders |
14 919 845 | R2,13686 | Fairvest Shareholders who elected the dividend reinvestment alternative to reinvest the cash dividend of 10.34400 cents per Fairvest share, in return for Fairvest Shares |
| Date | Nature | Counterparty | Number of Fairvest Shares |
Price per Fairvest Share |
Reason for repurchase or issue |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 8 April 2019 | Dividend reinvestment alternative |
Fairvest Shareholders |
12 185 043 | R2,08868 | Fairvest Shareholders who elected the dividend reinvestment alternative to reinvest the cash dividend of 10.61600 cents per Fairvest Share, in return for Fairvest Shares |
| 12 April 2021 | Dividend reinvestment alternative |
Fairvest shareholders |
9 207 234 | R1,85082 | Fairvest Shareholders who elected the dividend reinvestment alternative to reinvest the cash dividend of 10.59000 cents per Fairvest Share, in return for Fairvest Shares |
| 13 October 2021 | Fairvest Shares issued in exchange for AHB Shares in terms of the Fairvest Acquisition |
Ninety One SA (Pty) Ltd |
19 088 414 | N/A | 19 088 141 Fairvest Shares were issued in exchange for 10 318 064 AHB Shares pursuant to the Fairvest Acquisition whereby the counterparty was, as a result of events outside of its control, not able to defer the implementation of a portion their holding in AHB Shares |
| Repurchases | Nature | Counterparty | Number of Fairvest Shares |
Price per Fairvest Share |
Reason for repurchase or issue |
| 5 September 2019 | General repurchase |
Repurchased on the open market |
2 377 481 | R1,90769 | General repurchase |
| 6 September 2019 | General repurchase |
Repurchased on the open market |
446 888 | R1,98851 | General repurchase |
| 9 September 2019 | General repurchase |
Repurchased on the open market |
1 411 531 | R2,00812 | General repurchase |
| 10 September 2019 | General repurchase |
Repurchased on the open market |
3 074 660 | R2,00808 | General repurchase |
| 17 September 2019 | General repurchase |
Repurchased on the open market |
3 100 000 | R1,95788 | General repurchase |
| 17 September 2019 | General repurchase |
Repurchased on the open market |
778 917 | R2,00817 | General repurchase |
| 18 September 2019 | General repurchase |
Repurchased on the open market |
2 000 000 | R2,00810 | General repurchase |
| 27 September 2019 | General repurchase |
Repurchased on the open market |
1 599 344 | R2,00179 | General repurchase |
| 30 September 2019 | General repurchase |
Repurchased on the open market |
41 827 | R2,00831 | General repurchase |
| Date | Nature | Counterparty | Number of Fairvest Shares |
Price per Fairvest Share |
Reason for repurchase or issue |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 3 October 2019 | General repurchase |
Repurchased on the open market |
1 937 581 | R1,80730 | General repurchase |
| 1 November 2019 | General repurchase |
Repurchased on the open market |
602 645 | R1,85717 | General repurchase |
| 4 November 2019 | General repurchase |
Repurchased on the open market |
900 000 | R1,85755 | General repurchase |
| 27 November 2019 | General repurchase |
Repurchased on the open market |
1 000 000 | R1,87762 | General repurchase |
| 28 November 2019 | General repurchase |
Repurchased on the open market |
150 000 | R1,85757 | General repurchase |
| 3 December 2019 | General repurchase |
Repurchased on the open market |
1 514 743 | R1,83723 | General repurchase |
| 5 December 2019 | General repurchase |
Repurchased on the open market |
982 659 | R1,85755 | General repurchase |
| 2 March 2020 | General repurchase |
Repurchased on the open market |
372 329 | R1,80034 | General repurchase |
| 3 March 2020 | General repurchase |
Repurchased on the open market |
224 000 | R1,78488 | General repurchase |
| 4 March 2020 | General repurchase |
Repurchased on the open market |
1 100 000 | R1,81417 | General repurchase |
| 9 March 2020 | General repurchase |
Repurchased on the open market |
805 000 | R1,80446 | General repurchase |
| 10 March 2020 | General repurchase |
Repurchased on the open market |
10 000 000 | R1,76710 | General repurchase |
| 11 March 2020 | General repurchase |
Repurchased on the open market |
3 032 | R1,80034 | General repurchase |
| 11 March 2020 | General repurchase |
Repurchased on the open market |
468 156 | R1,78729 | General repurchase |
| 12 March 2020 | General repurchase |
Repurchased on the open market |
1 000 000 | R1,70695 | General repurchase |
| 13 March 2020 | General repurchase |
Repurchased on the open market |
254 019 | R1,70616 | General repurchase |
| 17 March 2020 | General repurchase |
Repurchased on the open market |
600 000 | R1,65675 | General repurchase |
| 19 March 2020 | General repurchase |
Repurchased on the open market |
1 025 515 | R1,37631 | General repurchase |
| 20 March 2020 | General repurchase |
Repurchased on the open market |
93 997 | R1,36477 | General repurchase |
| 20 November 2020 | General repurchase |
Repurchased on the open market |
212 275 | R1,60575 | General repurchase |
| 23 November 2020 | General repurchase |
Repurchased on the open market |
10 000 | R1,60739 | General repurchase |
5. Authorisations
In respect of Arrowhead:
At the Company's annual general meeting held on 25 February 2021 ("AGM") in respect of the year ended 30 September 2021, Arrowhead Shareholders resolved that:
- i. subject to the restrictions set out in the notice to the AGM and subject to the provisions of the Companies Act, the Listings Requirements and the MOI, the directors of the Company are authorised until the next annual general meeting of the Company, provided that this authority shall not extend beyond 15 months, to allot and issue up to 3 135 933 AHA Shares and 49 767 094 AHB Shares for cash at a maximum discount of 5% of the VWAP of such Arrowhead Shares measured over the 30 Business Days prior to the date that the price of the issue is agreed between the Company and the party subscribing for the Arrowhead Shares adjusted for a dividend where the "ex" date of the dividend occurs during the 30-day period in question.
- ii. the Company or any of its Subsidiaries are authorised by way of a general approval to acquire Arrowhead Shares issued by the Company, in terms of sections 46 and 48 of the Companies Act and in terms of the Listings Requirements being that the authorised but unissued Arrowhead Shares be placed under the control of the directors of the Company until the next annual general meeting, who are authorised to allot or issue any such Arrowhead Shares at their discretion, subject at all times to the provisions of the Companies Act, the MOI and the Listings Requirements.
- iii. The acquisitions of Arrowhead Shares in the aggregate in any one financial year may not exceed 20% (or 10% where the acquisitions are effected by a Subsidiary) of the Company's issued share capital of that class as at the date of passing the special resolution. Arrowhead Shares issued by the Company may be acquired at a maximum premium of 10% of the VWAP over the five Business Days immediately preceding the repurchase of such Arrowhead Shares.
- iv. the Company is authorised by way of a specific authority in terms of and subject to the applicable provisions of the Companies Act, the Listings Requirements and the MOI to repurchase 25 534 700 AHB Shares from the trustees for the time being of the Arrowhead Charitable Trust (IT number 4179/2012) at a price per share equal to the volume weighted average price per AHB Share over the 30 business days immediately preceding the repurchase.
In respect of Fairvest:
- i. On 7 September 2021, Fairvest Shareholders approved the increase of Fairvest's authorised share capital from 3 000 000 000 ordinary shares of no par value to 6 000 000 ordinary shares of no par value, ranking pari passu in all respects with the existing ordinary shares in the authorised share capital of Fairvest.
- ii. In the notice of the annual general meeting of Fairvest Shareholders held on 23 November 2021 ("Fairvest AGM") in respect of the year ended 30 June 2021, Fairvest Shareholders resolved, subject to the restrictions set out in the notice to the Fairvest AGM and subject to the provisions of the Companies Act, the Listings Requirements and the Fairvest memorandum of incorporation that:
- (a) the directors of Fairvest are authorised, by way of a general authority, until the next annual general meeting of Fairvest, provided that this authority shall not extend beyond 15 months, to allot and issue up to 98 924 607 Fairvest Shares for cash at a maximum discount of 5% of the VWAP of such Fairvest Shares measured over the 30 Business Days prior to the date that the price of the issue is agreed between Fairvest and the party subscribing for the Fairvest Shares;
- (b) the directors of Fairvest are authorised, by way of general authority, until the next annual general meeting of Fairvest, provided that this authority shall not extend beyond 15 months, to the extent that any treasury shares may be acquired and held by any subsidiary of Fairvest, to sell any or all such treasury shares for cash at a maximum discount of 5% of the VWAP of a Fairvest Share measured over the 30 Business Days prior to the sale of such treasury shares, to such person/s on such terms and conditions and at such times as the directors of Fairvest may, from time to time, in their discretion deem fit; and
- (c) Fairvest and its subsidiaries are authorised, by way of a general authority, until the next annual general meeting of Fairvest, provided that this authority shall not extend beyond 15 months, to repurchase up to 20% in aggregate in any one financial year of the issued Fairvest Shares at the time the authority was granted, and at a price not greater than 10% above the VWAP of the market value of the Fairvest Shares for the five business days immediately preceding the date that the transaction is effected, upon such terms and conditions and in such amounts as the directors of Fairvest may from time to time determine, but subject to the provisions of sections 46 and 48 of the Companies Act.
| ANNEXURE 16 | ||
|---|---|---|
| 162 |
MATERIAL BORROWINGS AND LOANS RECEIVABLE
Material loans made to Arrowhead and its Subsidiaries
Set out below are the material loans that were made to Arrowhead and its Subsidiaries as at the Last Practicable Date.
| Loan amount outstanding |
Interest | Terms and conditions of repayment or |
Borrowing | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lender | Description | Origination | (R'000) | Rate | renewal | Security provided | Maturity date | entity |
| Standard Bank | Loan number Property loan 264534 – |
To fund property acquisitions |
300 000 | 3-Month JIBAR plus 1.85% |
N/A – to be renewed at maturity date |
investment properties Mortgage bond over |
31 December 2021 (Note 1) |
Arrowgem |
| Standard Bank | Loan number Property loan 525107 – |
To fund property acquisitions |
330 000 | 3-Month JIBAR plus 1.89% |
N/A – to be renewed at maturity date |
investment properties Mortgage bond over |
30 April 2022 (Note 1) |
Arrowgem |
| Standard Bank | Loan number Property loan 459394 – |
To fund property acquisitions |
200 000 | 3-Month JIBAR plus 2.05% |
N/A – to be renewed at maturity date |
investment properties Mortgage bond over |
30 November 2022 (Note 2) |
Arrowgem |
| Standard Bank | Loan number Property loan 148164 – |
To fund property acquisitions |
280 000 | 3-Month JIBAR plus 2.05% |
N/A – to be renewed at maturity date |
investment properties Mortgage bond over |
30 November 2022 (Note 2) |
Arrowgem |
| Standard Bank | Loan number Property loan 249812 – |
To fund property acquisitions |
– | Prime less 1.15% | N/A – to be renewed at maturity date |
investment properties Mortgage bond over |
30 December 2022 (Note 2) |
Arrowgem |
| Standard Bank | Loan number Property loan 600607– |
To fund property acquisitions |
191 002 | 3-Month JIBAR plus 2.10% |
N/A – to be renewed at maturity date |
investment properties Mortgage bond over |
31 July 2023 | Arrowgem |
| Standard Bank | Loan number Property loan 146374– |
To fund property acquisitions |
28 796 | % Prime less 1 |
N/A – to be renewed at maturity date |
investment properties Mortgage bond over |
30 September 2024 | Arrowhead |
| Standard Bank | Loan number Property loan 144727 – |
To fund property acquisitions |
96 500 | 3-Month JIBAR plus 2.20% |
N/A – to be renewed at maturity date |
investment properties Mortgage bond over |
30 September 2024 | Arrowhead |
| Lender | Description | Origination | Loan amount outstanding (R'000) |
Interest Rate |
Terms and conditions of repayment or renewal |
Security provided | Maturity date | Borrowing entity |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Nedbank | – Property loan Loan number 30171756 |
To fund property acquisitions |
661 000 | 3-Month JIBAR plus 2.05% |
N/A – to be renewed at maturity date |
investment properties Mortgage bond over |
4 July 2023 | Vividend |
| Nedbank | – Property loan Loan number 30176950 |
To fund property acquisitions |
– | 3-Month JIBAR plus 2.25% |
N/A – to be renewed at maturity date |
investment properties Mortgage bond over |
4 December 2023 | Arrowhead |
| ABSA Bank | – Property loan Guarantee B1 |
To fund property acquisitions |
302 143 | 3-Month JIBAR plus 2.20% |
N/A – to be renewed at maturity date |
investment properties Mortgage bond over |
5 October 2022 (Note 2) |
Indluplace |
| ABSA Bank | – Property loan Facility B2 |
To fund property acquisitions |
307 979 | 3-Month JIBAR plus 2.40% |
N/A – to be renewed at maturity date |
investment properties Mortgage bond over |
16 November 2023 | Indluplace |
| ABSA Bank | – Property loan Facility B3 |
To fund property acquisitions |
78 101 | 3-Month JIBAR plus 2.55% |
N/A – to be renewed at maturity date |
investment properties Mortgage bond over |
16 November 2024 | Indluplace |
| ABSA Bank | – Property loan Facility B4 |
To fund property acquisitions |
71 937 | 3-Month JIBAR plus 2.70% |
N/A – to be renewed at maturity date |
investment properties Mortgage bond over |
16 November 2025 | Indluplace |
| Investec | facility – General revolving credit Arrowhead funding |
General funding | 100 000 | 3-Month JIBAR plus 2.75% |
N/A – to be renewed at maturity date |
investment properties Mortgage bond over |
30 September 2024 | Arrowgem |
| Investec | 00002 – Share Loan number Arrowhead cover loan |
To fund listed securities |
31 095 | 3-Month JIBAR plus 2.10% |
N/A – to be renewed at maturity date |
Mortgage bond over listed securities |
30 September 2024 | Arrowgem |
| Investec | 00003 – Share Loan number Arrowhead cover loan |
To fund listed securities |
97 533 | 3-Month JIBAR plus 2.10% |
N/A – to be renewed at maturity date |
Mortgage bond over listed securities |
30 September 2024 | Arrowgem |
| Investec | – Property loan Guarantee A1 |
To fund property acquisitions |
302 143 | 3-Month JIBAR plus 2.20% |
N/A – to be renewed at maturity date |
investment properties Mortgage bond over |
5 October 2022 (Note 2) |
Indluplace |
| Investec | – Property loan Loan number Gemgrow 1 |
To fund property acquisitions |
350 854 | 3-Month JIBAR plus 2.15% |
N/A – to be renewed at maturity date |
investment properties Mortgage bond over |
31 October 2022 (Note 2) |
Arrowhead |
| Loan amount outstanding |
Interest | Terms and conditions of repayment or |
Borrowing | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lender | Description | Origination | (R'000) | Rate | renewal | Security provided | Maturity date | entity |
| Investec | – Property loan Loan number Gemgrow 2 |
To fund property acquisitions |
353 086 | 3-Month JIBAR plus 2.20% |
N/A – to be renewed at maturity date |
investment properties Mortgage bond over |
15 November 2022 (Note 2) |
Arrowhead |
| Investec | Gemgrow RCF Property loan Facility – |
To fund property acquisitions |
– | 3-Month JIBAR plus 2.20% |
N/A – to be renewed at maturity date |
investment properties Mortgage bond over |
16 November 2023 | Arrowhead |
| Investec | – Property loan Facility A2 |
To fund property acquisitions |
164 254 | 3-Month JIBAR plus 2.30% |
N/A – to be renewed at maturity date |
investment properties Mortgage bond over |
16 November 2023 | Indluplace |
| Investec | – Property loan Facility A3 |
To fund property acquisitions |
78 101 | 3-Month JIBAR plus 2.40% |
N/A – to be renewed at maturity date |
investment properties Mortgage bond over |
16 November 2024 | Indluplace |
| Investec | – Property loan Facility A4 |
To fund property acquisitions |
937 71 |
3-Month JIBAR plus 2.50% |
N/A – to be renewed at maturity date |
investment properties Mortgage bond over |
16 November 2025 | Indluplace |
| FirstRand Bank Ltd ("RMB") |
Gemgrow 11054 – Property loan |
To fund property acquisitions |
110 000 | 3-Month JIBAR plus 2.35% |
N/A – to be renewed at maturity date |
investment properties Mortgage bond over |
4 December 2023 | Arrowhead |
| FirstRand Bank Ltd ("RMB") |
Gemgrow 9496 – Property loan |
To fund property acquisitions |
87 947 | 3-Month JIBAR plus 2.35% |
N/A – to be renewed at maturity date |
investment properties Mortgage bond over |
4 December 2023 | Arrowhead |
| Total debt | 4 594 408 |
Notes:
-
Another funder has agreed to renew these facilities for a further 3 and 4 years respectively. The formal legal agreements with respect thereto are currently being drawn up.
-
Negotiations for the refinance of these loans has not yet begun.
| Lender | Description | Origination | (R'000) Facility |
Interest Rate |
repayment or conditions of Terms and renewal |
Security provided | how repayment is to be financed Maturity date/ |
Borrowing entity |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| ABSA Bank | Term loan | acquisition of Fund the |
38 000 | Prime less 1.40% |
36 months | 1st covering mortgage bond over Erf 7362 Postmasburg |
10 October 2021 with refinance facility |
Fairvest |
| ABSA Bank | Term loan | Shopping Centre Sibilo Plaza |
9 500 | Prime less 1.40% |
48 months | 1st covering mortgage bond over Erf 7362 Postmasburg |
10 August 2022 with refinance facility |
Fairvest |
| Nedbank | Term loan | Shopping Centre, Shopping Centre, Qualbert Centre acquisition of and Kimpark Mala Plaza Masingita Fund the Centre |
127 584 | JIBAR plus 3-Month 1.90% |
60 months | Portion 1 of Erf 12025 Durban (R70m) Erf 16428 Kimberley (R50m) Portion 1 of Erf 566 Giyani-D, Limpopo (R50m) (R70m) Remainder of Erf 12025 and Erf 936 Malamulele-A, Limpopo |
1 August 2022 with refinance facility |
Fairvest |
| Standard Bank | Term loan | Middestad Mall, Mega Park and Cosmos Centre acquisition of Fund the |
165 000 | JIBAR plus 3-Month 1.85% |
36 months | Bloemfontein Erf 4861, Bethal Erven Erf 15942 Bloemfontein, Erf 27819 50261 and 13435 Khayelitsha |
refinance facility 30 November 2021 with |
Fairvest |
| Standard Bank | Term loan | Shopping Centre acquisition of Nonkqubela Fund the |
80 000 | Prime less 1.40% |
36 months | Erven 50261 and 13435 Khayelitsha | 31 March 2023 with refinance facility |
Fairvest |
Set out below are the material loans that were made to Fairvest and its Subsidiaries as at the Last Practicable Date.
Material loans made to Fairvest and its Subsidiaries
| Borrowing entity |
Fairvest | Fairvest | Fairvest | Fairvest | Fairvest | Proprietary Property Venture FPP102 Limited¹ |
South View Proprietary Shopping Limited² Centre |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| how repayment is to be financed Maturity date/ |
with refinance 31 May 2022 facility |
with revolving 31 May 2022 credit |
with refinance 31 May 2022 facility |
with refinance 31 May 2022 facility |
refinance facility 31 December 2023 with |
10 August 2023 with refinance facility |
1 May 2022 with refinance facility |
| Security provided | Erf 4000 Zamdela, Erf 1951 George, Erf 13291 Bellville, Portion 527 of |
Sharpville, Erf 15800 Orange Farm, Erf 1440 Vereeniging, Erf 65558 Stretford, Erven 9189 and 9190 Farm 356 Zwartkop, Erf16145 |
Sebokeng (50% of Portion 3/4/7), (Portion 1), Erven 2520 and 2521 Erf 12704 Nyanga, Erf 59 Mkuze |
Pietermaritzburg (Portion 7 and 18), Erven 1107, 11014, 11016 Durban, The Ridge (Unit 4/6/8 in Sectional Title) |
Erven 215 and 216 and 217 Halfway Erven 971 and 974 Queensburgh, House, Erf 814 Bloemfontein, Westville Junction (Sections 2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,P1,P2,P3) |
ERF 3217 Empangeni (R100m) | ERF 21188 Soshanguve South Ext 7 (R80m) |
| repayment or conditions of Terms and renewal |
36 months | 36 months | 36 months | 36 months | 36 months | 36 months | 36 months |
| Interest Rate |
JIBAR plus 1 Month 2.00% |
JIBAR plus 1 Month 2.00% |
JIBAR plus 1 Month 2.00% |
JIBAR plus 1 Month 2.00% |
Prime less 0.75% |
1 month JIBAR + 1.85% |
Prime less 1.40% |
| (R'000) Facility |
808 8 |
30 000 | 182 250 | 122 000 | 128 000 | 86 000 | 50 000 |
| Origination | acquisition of 210 and 212 Church Fund the |
West Street, Clubview, Square, Nyanga Street, 425 St Georges |
Farm, Vereeniging, Junction, Orange The Ridge, |
Nyanga, Zamdela Sebokeng Plaza, Mkuze Corner, Stretford, KTC Sharpville, |
Westville Junction development of Fund the |
Shopping Centre acquisition of Empangeni Fund the Shoprite |
Shopping Centre acquisition of South View Fund the |
| Description | Facility A | Revolving facility | Facility B | Facility C | Term loan | Term loan | Term loan |
| Lender | RMB | RMB | RMB | RMB | Investec | ABSA Bank | ABSA Bank |
| Lender | Description | Origination | Facility (R'000) |
Interest Rate |
repayment or conditions of Terms and renewal |
Security provided | how repayment is to be financed Maturity date/ |
Borrowing entity |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Nedbank | Term loan | acquisition of Bara Precinct Fund the |
160 000 | 3-Month JIBAR + 1.87% |
24 months | m) First covering bond over notarial lease over erven 24457 and Erven 24459, 24463, 24464, 24470 and Portion of Erf 25170 Diepkloof lease over erven 24457 and 24462 Erf 25170 Diepkloof over notarial 24462 Diepkloof (R9.99m) First Leaseholder over Portion 55 of covering bond by Diep Kloof Diepkloof (R16m) (R134.01 |
refinance facility 10 December 2022 with |
Bara Precinct Limited and Leaseholder Proprietary Proprietary Diepkloof Limited |
| Nedbank | Term loan | Shopping Centre acquisition of Macassar Fund the |
40 500 | JIBAR plus 3 Month 1.95% |
36 months | ERF 7355 Macassar (R60m) | with refinance 10 June 2022 facility |
Proprietary Shopping Macassar Centre Limited |
| ABSA Bank | Term loan | Mqanduli and acquisition of Tabankulu, Fund the Elliotdale |
75 000 | 1 month JIBAR + 1.87% |
36 months | ERF871 Mqanduli (R38m), Erf 93 Elliotdale (R60m), Erf 87 Tabankulu (R32m) |
2 May 2023 with refinance facility |
Proprietary Property Venture Limited³ FPP103 |
| ABSA Bank | Term loan | acquisition of Qumbu Plaza Fund the Centre |
29 000 | 1 month JIBAR + 2.15% |
36 months | Erf 30 Qumbu (R45m), | 26 July 2024 with refinance facility |
Qumbu Plaza Proprietary Limited4 |
| Investec | Term loan | Libode Shopping acquisition of Fund the Centre |
30 000 | Prime less 0.75% |
36 months | Erf 1390 Libode (R30m) | 24 November refinance of 2024 with facility |
Proprietary Shopping Limited7 Centre Libode |
| Total | 1 | 361 642 |
168Notes:
-
- Fairvest has provided a limited guarantee of R86 million.
-
- Fairvest has provided a limited guarantee of R50 million.
-
- Fairvest has provided a limited guarantee of R75 million.
-
- Fairvest has provided a limited guarantee of R29 million.
-
- None of the above material loans are the subject of any conversion or redemption rights.
-
- The material loans made to Fairvest and/or to any of its Subsidiaries as set out above will remain outstanding following implementation of the Transaction.
-
- Fairvest has provided a limited guarantee of R25 million.
| Group. | Set out below are the details of material loans made to parties other than directors, by Arrowhead, its Subsidiaries and any subsidiary where such loans are material to the Arrowhead | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Date loan granted |
Borrower | Origination | amount outstanding (R'000) |
Interest rate Loan |
repayment or conditions of Terms and renewal |
Security held/reason for unsecured loan |
Fair value and security held valuation of method of |
Maturity date | |
| 16 September 2019 |
Arrowgem Ltd | Arrowgem external debt settled by Arrowhead |
318 161 1 |
9.85% | Repayable on or after maturity date |
Unsecured, as the loan is to a controlled subsidiary in the Arrowhead Group, thus risk managed |
N/A – Unsecured | October 2022 | |
| Total | 318 161 1 |
||||||||
| Material loans receivable by Fairvest and its Subsidiaries | Set out below are the details of material loans made by Fairvest, its Subsidiaries and any subsidiary where such loans are material to the Fairvest Group. | ||||||||
| Date loan granted |
Borrower | Origination | Loan amount outstanding (R'000) |
Interest rate |
repayment or conditions of Terms and renewal |
Security held/reason for unsecured loan |
of security method of Fair value valuation held and |
Maturity date | |
| 1 November 2017 | Centre Proprietary Limited controlling shareholder in Southview Shopping Proprietary Limited GGP Investments GGP is the non ("GGP") |
Development of Shopping Centre the Southview |
8 267 | Prime + 1.50% |
Repayable on maturity date |
Cession and pledge of GGP's Shopping Centre Proprietary shares in Southview Limited |
N/A | 18 June 2023 | |
| 18 July 2017 | FPP 102 Property Venture controlling shareholder in Propsky 31 Properties Proprietary Limited Proprietary Limited. Propsky is the non ("Propsky") |
Shoprite | Acquisition of the Empangeni asset |
48 357 | Prime + 4.50% |
Repayable on maturity date |
Property Venture Proprietary Propsky's shares in FPP 102 the shareholders of Propsky Limited and suretyships by Cession and pledge of |
N/A | 19 July 2022 |
Material loans receivable by Arrowhead and its Subsidiaries
| Date loan granted |
Borrower | Origination | Loan amount outstanding (R'000) |
Interest rate |
repayment or conditions of Terms and renewal |
Security held/reason for unsecured loan |
of security method of Fair value valuation held and |
Maturity date |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 18 December 2017 | Buffshelfco 17 Proprietary Buffshelfco 17 is the non controlling shareholder in Bara Precinct Proprietary Limited ("Buffshelfco Limited 17") |
Precinct Proprietary Subscription of shares in Bara Limited |
90 098 | Prime + 4.50% |
Repayable on maturity date |
Limited and suretyships by Buffshelfco 17's shares in Bara Precinct Proprietary Cession and pledge of the shareholders of Buffshelfco 17 |
N/A | 19 December 2022 |
| 4 October 2018 | controlling shareholder in Libode Shopping Centre Lonisign Proprietary Limited ("Lonisign") Lonisign is the non Proprietary Limited |
Acquisition of the Libode Shopping Centre |
25 729 | Prime + 2.00% |
Repayable on maturity date |
Shopping Centre Proprietary the shareholders of Lonisign Limited and suretyships by Lonisign's shares in Libode Cession and pledge of |
N/A | 31 August 2023 |
| 26 August 2019 | controlling shareholder in Qumbu Plaza Proprietary Stilopro Proprietary Limited ("Stilopro") Stilopro is the non Limited |
the Qumbu Plaza Development of Centre |
29 112 | Prime + 2.00% |
Repayable on maturity date |
Stilopro's shares in Qumbu Plaza Proprietary Limited shareholders of Stilopro and suretyships by the Cession and pledge of |
N/A | 1 December 2024 |
| Total | 201 563 |
1. Loans receivable in respect of group share purchase and option schemes by the Arrowhead Group as at the Last Practicable Date
Set out below are the material loans receivable in respect of group share purchase and option schemes that were provided to directors, past directors and employees of Arrowhead, by Arrowhead and its Major Subsidiaries as at the Last Practical Date.
| Name of director, former director or employee | Loan balance (R) |
|---|---|
| M. Kaplan (Arrowhead director) | 95 035 345 |
| Loans were granted by the Arrowhead Group on 17 November 2015, 17 November 2016 and 18 December 2017 in relation to the subscription for shares. 9 853 309 AHB Shares are held as security against the loans. Fair value (i.e market value) of the AHB Shares held as security: R40 891 232 |
|
| I. Suleman (former director) | 70 697 673 |
| Loans were granted by the Arrowhead Group on 17 November 2015, 17 November 2016 and 18 December 2017 in relation to the subscription for shares. The AHB Shares previously held as security against the loans were sold to repay a portion of the original loan amount, therefore no security is currently held against the loans. |
|
| R. Kader (former director) | 10 110 631 |
| A loan was granted by the Arrowhead Group on 18 December 2017 in relation to the acquisition of shares. 1 332 500 AHB Shares are held as security against the loan. Fair value (i.e market value) of the AHB Shares held as security: R5 529 875 |
|
| V. Turner (Arrowhead company secretary) | 3 203 200 |
| A loan was granted by the Arrowhead Group on 18 December 2017 in relation to the acquisition of shares. 422 156 AHB Shares are held as security against the loan. Fair value (i.e market value) of the AHB Shares held as security: R1 751 947 |
|
| N. Kaplan (Arrowhead employee) | 2 072 069 |
| A loan was granted by the Arrowhead Group on 18 December 2017 in relation to the acquisition of shares. 273 082 AHB Shares are held as security against the loan. Fair value (i.e market value) of the AHB Shares held as security: R1 133 290 |
|
| A. de Kock (Arrowhead employee) | 1 117 573 |
| A loan was granted by the Arrowhead Group on 18 December 2017 in relation to the acquisition of shares. 147 317 AHB Shares are held as security against the loan. Fair value (i.e market value) of the AHB Shares held as security: R611 366 |
|
| Total | 182 236 491 |
1.1 Loans to participants of the Arrowgem Unit Purchase and Option Scheme ("Arrowgem UPOS")
- 1.1.2 The Arrowhead Shares have been pledged to the Company as security against the outstanding loans and the Company has recourse against the participants for any amounts unpaid under the scheme.
- 1.1.3 The loans incur interest at an amount equal to the dividends declared in respect of the AHB Shares held as security against the loans.
1.1.1 The loans were granted to juristic entities of the executive directors and employees of the Arrowhead Group for the purpose of subscribing for or purchasing Arrowhead Shares and in terms of the Companies Act.
- 1.1.4 The loans will mature ten years from date of issue.
- 1.1.5 As the loans were granted to juristic entities of the applicable director or employee, Old Arrowhead's remuneration and nomination committee determined that, in respect of loans granted during the 2018 Financial Year, the participants were required to provide sureties for the loans in their personal capacity, which is equal to 13% of the loan debt.
1.2 Loans to participants of Indluplace Share Purchase and Option Scheme Name of director, former director or employee Loan balance (R) G. Leissner (former Indluplace director, deceased) 52 738 090 A loan was granted by Indluplace on 19 June 2015 in relation to the acquisition of 5 273 809 Indluplace Shares, which are held as security for the loan. Fair value (i.e market value) of the Indluplace Shares held as security: R17 614 522 M. Kaplan (former Indluplace director and current Arrowhead director) 52 738 090 A loan was granted by Indluplace on 19 June 2015 in relation to the acquisition of 5 273 809 Indluplace Shares, which are held as security against the loan. Fair value (i.e market value) of the Indluplace Shares held as security: R17 614 522 I. Suleman (former director) 52 738 090 A loan was granted by Indluplace on 19 June 2015 in relation to the acquisition of 5 273 809 Indluplace Shares, which are held as security against the loan. The Indluplace Shares previously held as security against the loan were sold to repay a portion of the original loan amount, therefore no security is currently held against the loans. C. de Wit (Indluplace director) 44 821 550 Loans were granted by Indluplace on 19 June 2015, 12 December 2016 and 6 December 2017 in relation to the acquisition of 5 020 301 Indluplace Shares which are held as security against the loans. Fair value (i.e market value) of the Indluplace Shares held as security: R 16 767 805 T. Kaplan (Arrowhead employee) 25 995 421 Loans were granted by Indluplace on 6 February 2017, 6 December 2017, and 7 December 2018 in relation to the acquisition of 2 933 291 Indluplace Shares which are held as security against the loans. Fair value (i.e market value) of the Indluplace Shares held as security: R9 797 192 Total 229 031 241 1.2.1 The loans were granted to juristic entities of the directors, former directors or employees for the purpose of subscribing for Indluplace ordinary shares ("Indluplace Shares") as per the lndluplace Share
- 1.2.2 The loans bear interest at a rate equal to the dividends declared, and interest is calculated at 31 March and 30 September of each year and is repayable at any time by the juristic person of the executive director or employee but not later than 10 years from the granting of the loan.
- 1.2.3 The dividends received on the Indluplace Shares are used to repay the interest accumulated on the loans and Indluplace has recourse against the applicable juristic entity for any amounts unpaid under the scheme.
- 1.2.4 The Indluplace Shares have been pledged as security to Indluplace for the outstanding loans.
Purchase and Option Scheme and in terms of the Companies Act.
1.2.5 The loans mature within 10 years of date of issue.
1.3 Arrowhead Share Purchase and Option Scheme ("Arrowhead SPOS")
| Name of director, former director or employee | Loan balance (R) |
|---|---|
| A. Kirkel (former director) | 23 146 128 |
| Loans were granted by the Arrowhead Group during 2017 and 2018 in relation to the acquisition of shares. |
|
| 3 742 925 AHB Shares are held as security against the loans. | |
| Fair value (i.e market value) of the AHB Shares held as security: R15 533 139 | |
| J. Limalia (director) | 23 076 905 |
| Loans were granted by the Arrowhead Group during 2017 and 2018 in relation to the acquisition of shares. |
|
| 3 371 577 AHB Shares are held as security against the loans. | |
| Fair value (i.e market value) of the AHB Shares held as security: R15 486 045 | |
| Total | 46 223 033 |
- 1.3.1 The loans bear interest at a rate equal to the dividends declared on the corresponding scheme shares, and interest is calculated bi-annually at 31 March and 30 September. The loans are repayable at any time by the juristic person of the executive or employee but no later than 10 (ten) years from the granting of the loan.
- 1.3.2 The loans have been granted to the juristic entities of A Kirkel and J Limalia. Arrowhead's remuneration and nomination committee determined that the executive management team were required to provide surety in their personal capacity, in relation to the loans granted during the 2018 and 2019 Financial Years, which is equal to 13% of the loan debt.
2. Restitution of performance in relation to purchase offers implemented in terms of the Arrowgem Unit Purchase Scheme ("UPS") and Cumulative Loans
- 2.1 Loan funding was advanced to certain identified:
- 2.1.1 employees of the Arrowhead Group, whom are participants in the UPS ("UPS Participants") in order to finance the acquisition by the UPS Participants of Arrowhead Shares ("UPS Scheme Shares"); and
- 2.1.2 executives of the Arrowhead Group by Cumulative Properties Limited (a wholly owned subsidiary of Arrowhead) ("Cumulative") ("Cumulative Participants") in order to ultimately finance the acquisition of AHB Shares by the Cumulative Participants ("Cumulative Scheme Shares")
(each a "Scheme Loan").
- 2.2 In respect of the UPS, the Scheme Loans were advanced by a trust established in accordance with the rules of the UPS ("UPS Trust").
- 2.3 As security for the Scheme Loans, the UPS Scheme Shares and the Cumulative Scheme Shares (collectively "Scheme Shares") were pledged and ceded in securitatem debiti to the UPS Trust and Cumulative, respectively (each a "Lender").
- 2.4 The Scheme Shares are currently registered in a nominee account at Investec Bank Limited ("Security Nominee") for the beneficial interest of the UPS Participants and the Cumulative Participants (collectively, the "Participants").
- 2.5 The Arrowhead Board was recently furnished with a formal legal opinion ("NCA Opinion") regarding the applicability of the NCA to the Scheme Loans. The conclusions reached in the NCA Opinion are that:
- (i) in terms of the NCA, the Lenders were required to be registered as a credit provider in terms of section 40(1) of the NCA ("Credit Provider") at the time of making the purchase offers and advancing the Scheme Loans;
-
(ii) given that the Lenders were not registered as a Credit Provider at the relevant time, the purchase offers and the Scheme Loans provided thereunder are void ab initio, meaning that the agreements in terms thereof are invalid from the outset; and
-
(iii) given the invalidity of the agreements, restitution of the performance which took place under the invalid agreements should, to the extent practically possible in the circumstances, be effected.
- 2.6 The Lenders have resolved (having taken legal advice on the matter), that the just and equitable manner of regularising the position is for the Participants to tender restitution of the performance which took place under those invalid agreements, to the extent practically possible in the circumstances.
- 2.7 Accordingly, the Lenders have resolved to give effect to such restitution by derecognising the Scheme Loans and having the Scheme Shares placed at the disposal of the Lenders, in terms of which the Scheme Shares shall, from 30 November 2021 ("Restitution Effective Date"):
- 2.7.1 be placed under the control and at the disposal of the Lenders to be disposed of in a responsible manner at an appropriate time by way of an on-market disposal, a sale by private treaty, a sale to Arrowhead or one of its subsidiaries or otherwise ("Restitution"), with the proceeds of such disposal accruing to the being for the benefit of the Lenders; and
- 2.7.2 any benefits accruing to or in favour of the Scheme Shares shall accrue to and be for the benefit of the Lenders; and the voting rights attaching to the Scheme Shares shall be exercisable by the Lenders (provided that such exercise is permitted in terms of the Listings Requirements, the Companies Act, Arrowhead's MOI or otherwise).
- 2.8 The Lenders shall instruct the Security Nominees, as the registered holder of the Scheme Shares in a nominee capacity, to take all such steps as may be required in order to give effect to the Restitution.
- 2.9 The Scheme Loans in relation to which the Restitution measures are to be effected are summarised in the tables below.
| Name of director, former director or employee | Loans void ab initio (R) |
|---|---|
| M. Kaplan (Arrowhead director) | 78 532 411 |
| Loans were granted by the Arrowhead Group on 7 December 2012, 13 November 2013 and on 10 November 2014 in relation to the acquisition of 8 575 063 AHB Shares with a current market value of R35 586 511. |
|
| I. Suleman (former director) | 53 551 336 |
| Loans were granted by the Arrowhead Group on 7 December 2012, 13 November 2013 and on 10 November 2014 in relation to the acquisition of AHB Shares. There is no current market value attributable to the shares as the AHB Shares previously held as security have been sold. |
|
| R. Kader (former director) | 15 551 336 |
| Loans were granted by the Arrowhead Group on 10 November 2014 and 17 November 2015 in relation to the acquisition of 1 252 487 AHB Shares with a current market value of R5 197 821. |
|
| C. de Wit (Arrowhead employee) | 2 836 127 |
| A loan was granted by the Arrowhead Group on 10 November 2014 in relation to the acquisition of 324 393 AHB Shares with a current market value of R1 346 231. |
|
| V. Turner (Arrowhead company secretary) | 462 922 |
| A loan was granted by the Arrowhead Group on 10 November 2015 in relation to the acquisition of 63 067 AHB Shares with a current market value of R261 728. |
|
| N. Kaplan (Arrowhead employee) | 794 110 |
| A loan was granted by the Arrowhead Group on 10 November 2014 in relation to the acquisition of 90 829 AHB Shares with a current market value of R376 940. |
|
| Total | 151 728 242 |
2.9.1 Scheme Loans under the UPS
| Name of director, former director or employee | Loans void ab initio (R) |
|---|---|
| M. Kaplan (director) | 41 003 769 |
| A loan was granted by the Arrowhead Group on during 2016 in relation to the acquisition of 6 000 000 AHB Shares with a current market value of R24 900 000. |
|
| I. Suleman (former director) | 24 803 769 |
| A loan was granted by the Arrowhead Group on during 2016 in relation to the acquisition of AHB Shares. There is no current market value attributable to the shares as the AHB Shares previously held as security against the loan have been sold. |
|
| A. Kirkel (former director) | 20 501 904 |
| A loan was granted by the Arrowhead Group during 2016 in relation to the acquisition of 3 000 000 AHB Shares with a current market value of R12 450 000. |
|
| J. Limalia (director) | 20 501 904 |
| A loan was granted by the Arrowhead Group during 2016 in relation to the acquisition of 3 000 000 AHB Shares with a current market value of R12 450 000. |
|
| Total | 106 811 346 |
3. Arrangements in relation to scheme loans in accordance with the rules of the Arrowgem UPOS and the Arrowhead SPOS in relation to the Departing Designated Employees
- 3.1 As contemplated in paragraph 5 of Annexure 3, Mark Kaplan and Junaid Limalia, the Departing Executive(s), have, by mutual agreement with the Company in terms of the Departing Executive Termination Agreements, agreed to the termination of their employment with Arrowhead with effect from the Departing Executive Termination Date.
- 3.2 In accordance with the rules ("Scheme Rules") of the Arrowgem UPOS and the Arrowhead SPOS (collectively, the "Schemes"), the Departing Executives participate in the Schemes via juristic entities established by them. Mark Kaplan's entity is Arrowplay Trust, which is a participant in the Arrowgem UPOS and Junaid Limalia's entities, Laysuha Trust and Junaid Limalia Family Trust, are a participant in the Arrowhead SPOS (each a "Departing Executive's Scheme Participant").
- 3.3 Pursuant to their participation in the Schemes, the Departing Executives, via their Departing Executive's Scheme Participants, acquired 13 584 886 AHB Shares (comprising 9 853 309 AHB Shares held by Mark Kaplan's entity and 3 731 577 AHB Shares held by Junaid Limalia's entities) (collectively the "Scheme Shares") and have received loans from Arrowhead with aggregate outstanding balances of R118 112 250 (comprising R95 035 345 owing by Mark Kaplan's entity and R23 076 905 owing by Junaid Limalia's entities) (collectively the "Scheme Loans"). The applicable Scheme Loans were granted by Arrowhead and Arrowgem Limited (a wholly owned subsidiary of Arrowhead) ("Lenders"), in relation to the Arrowhead SPOS and the Arrowgem UPOS, respectively.
- 3.4 As security for the Scheme Loans, the Scheme Shares were pledged and ceded in securitatem debitito Arrowhead ("Pledge").
- 3.5 In terms of the Scheme Rules in respect of:
- 3.5.1 The Arrowgem UPOS, pursuant to the Departing Executives ceasing to be employed by the Arrowhead Group (i) no further purchase offers may be made to such Departing Executives under the Arrowgem UPOS; and (ii) save for the prohibition on making further purchase offers, the Scheme Rules continue to apply, without amendment, to the Scheme Loans, Scheme Shares and the Pledge notwithstanding the cessation of employment of the Departing Executives; and
- 3.5.2 the Arrowhead SPOS, pursuant to the Departing Executives ceasing to be employed by the Arrowhead Group, the Scheme Loans owing by the Departing Executive's Scheme Participants will become due and payable 12 months after such cessation of employment unless alternative arrangements are reached.
3.6 To align the treatment of the Scheme Loans under the Arrowhead SPOS with the treatment of the Scheme Loans under the Arrowgem UPOS, Arrowhead has, in accordance with rule 8.6.2 of the Scheme Rules, resolved that the original maturity dates of the Scheme Loans under the Arrowhead SPOS will be maintained, being 10 years from the date on which such Scheme Loans were granted, and the Scheme Shares acquired under the Arrowhead SPOS shall remain subject to the Pledge.
4. Loans granted to the directors of Fairvest by the Fairvest Group
- 4.1 Fairvest has no long-term incentive schemes in place, therefore no loans have been granted by Fairvest to any directors of Fairvest in respect of any long term incentive schemes.
- 4.2 No loans have been made or security furnished by the Fairvest Group for the benefit of any director or manager or Associate of any director or manager of the Fairvest Group.
TRADING OF SHARES
Set out below is the aggregate volumes and values traded, closing price and the highest and lowest prices traded in Arrowhead Shares and Fairvest Shares for:
- each month over the 12 months preceding the Last Practicable Date; and
- each day over the 30 days preceding the Last Practicable Date.
Trading of AHA Shares
| Period | High (cents) |
Low (cents) |
Close (cents) |
Volume | Value (R) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Monthly | |||||
| 2021 | |||||
| October | 14.00 | 13.99 | 14.00 | 95 030 | 1 329 850 |
| September | 13.99 | 11.60 | 13.99 | 2 429 010 | 30 420 220 |
| August | 12.49 | 10.70 | 12.45 | 360 450 | 4 160 780 |
| July | 11.45 | 10.51 | 11.44 | 2 399 700 | 26 331 740 |
| June | 11.48 | 10.00 | 10.99 | 1 781 440 | 19 605 050 |
| May | 11.00 | 9.60 | 10.00 | 4 102 840 | 40 805 550 |
| April | 11.00 | 9.27 | 9.80 | 109 130 | 1 065 910 |
| March | 11.00 | 9.01 | 11.00 | 260 180 | 2 458 200 |
| February | 9.70 | 9.00 | 9.01 | 446 850 | 4 077 440 |
| January | 9.64 | 8.50 | 9.11 | 159 150 | 1 435 790 |
| 2020 | |||||
| December | 10.00 | 8.76 | 9.59 | 584 650 | 5 744 670 |
| November | |||||
| Daily | |||||
| 2021 | |||||
| Monday, 22 November 2021 | – | – | 14.05 | – | – |
| Friday, 19 November 2021 | 14.95 | 13.51 | 14.05 | 48 690 | 684 140 |
| Thursday, 18 November 2021 | 15.00 | 14.00 | 14.00 | 49 920 | 698 920 |
| Wednesday, 17 November 2021 | – | – | 14.99 | – | – |
| Tuesday, 16 November 2021 | 15.00 | 14.99 | 14.99 | 2 380 | 35 600 |
| Monday, 15 November 2021 | – | – | 15.00 | – | – |
| Friday, 12 November 2021 | 15.00 | 15.00 | 15.00 | 1 250 | 18 810 |
| Thursday, 11 November 2021 | 15.00 | 15.00 | 15.00 | 2 956 080 | 44 341 130 |
| Wednesday, 10 November 2021 | 14.50 | 14.10 | 14.10 | 21 080 | 297 270 |
| Tuesday, 9 November 2021 | 15.00 | 14.10 | 14.10 | 600 | 8 390 |
| Monday, 8 November 2021 | 15.00 | 15.00 | 15.00 | 3 980 | 59 690 |
| Friday, 5 November 2021 | – | – | 14.07 | 5 430 | 76 340 |
| Thursday, 4 November 2021 | 15.00 | 14.07 | 14.07 | 4 040 | 56 840 |
| Wednesday, 3 November 2021 | 15.00 | 14.50 | 14.50 | 25 780 | 373 830 |
| Tuesday, 2 November 2021 | 15.00 | 15.00 | 15.00 | 5 030 | 75 470 |
| Monday, 1 November 2021 | – | – | – | – | – |
| Friday, 29 October 2021 | 14.30 | 14.00 | 14.30 | 71 210 | 1 018 330 |
| Thursday, 28 October 2021 | 14.00 | 13.19 | 14.00 | 706 370 | 9 889 180 |
| Wednesday, 27 October 2021 | 15.00 | 13.76 | 14.20 | 575 910 | 8 177 890 |
| Tuesday, 26 October 2021 | 15.00 | 13.00 | 14.79 | 7 680 | 113 570 |
| Period | High | Low | Close | Volume | Value (R) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| (cents) | (cents) | (cents) | |||
| Monday, 25 October 2021 | 14.00 | 12.10 | 13.99 | 14 510 | 203 020 |
| Friday, 22 October 2021 | – | – | 14.00 | – | – |
| Thursday, 21 October 2021 | 14.00 | 14.00 | 14.00 | 6 070 | 84 990 |
| Wednesday, 20 October 2021 | 14.00 | 13.95 | 14.00 | 1 580 | 22 090 |
| Tuesday, 19 October 2021 | 14.00 | 14.00 | 14.00 | 120 | 1 680 |
| Monday, 18 October 2021 | – | – | 14.00 | 360 | 5 070 |
| Friday, 15 October 2021 | – | – | 14.00 | 1 550 | 21 670 |
| Thursday, 14 October 2021 | – | – | 14.00 | 2 370 | 33 240 |
| Wednesday, 13 October 2021 | – | – | 14.00 | 1 640 | 22 930 |
| Tuesday, 12 October 2021 | 14.00 | 14.00 | 14.00 | 2 990 | 41 860 |
Source: S&P Capital IQ
Trading of AHB Shares
| Period | High (cents) |
Low (cents) |
Close (cents) |
Volume | Value Traded (R) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Monthly | |||||
| 2021 | |||||
| October | 4.13 | 4.03 | 4.13 | 6 911 160 | 32 157 260 |
| September | 4.25 | 3.16 | 4.11 | 12 899 960 | 50 748 430 |
| August | 3.38 | 3.15 | 3.23 | 4 902 640 | 16 024 840 |
| July | 3.70 | 3.05 | 3.20 | 15 273 750 | 49 820 340 |
| June | 3.90 | 3.21 | 3.65 | 13 459 740 | 46 208 140 |
| May | 3.54 | 3.20 | 3.35 | 21 142 920 | 72 645 560 |
| April | 3.30 | 2.70 | 3.30 | 11 076 940 | 32 777 150 |
| March | 2.87 | 2.65 | 2.70 | 15 930 960 | 43 970 660 |
| February | 2.80 | 2.27 | 2.73 | 15 590 000 | 39 853 870 |
| January | 2.52 | 2.23 | 2.43 | 64 342 310 | 149 078 890 |
| 2020 | |||||
| December | 2.87 | 2.05 | 2.32 | 41 306 440 | 111 708 960 |
| November | 2.05 | 1.40 | 2.05 | 42 968 870 | 74 148 950 |
| Daily | |||||
| 2021 | |||||
| Monday, 22 November 2021 | 4.18 | 4.09 | 4.15 | 423 570 | 1 757 820 |
| Friday, 19 November 2021 | 4.22 | 4.01 | 4.17 | 848 540 | 3 538 390 |
| Thursday, 18 November 2021 | 4.24 | 4.09 | 4.20 | 676 900 | 2 842 980 |
| Wednesday, 17 November 2021 | 4.13 | 4.01 | 4.11 | 280 880 | 1 154 410 |
| Tuesday, 16 November 2021 | 4.24 | 4.06 | 4.13 | 63 400 | 261 830 |
| Monday, 15 November 2021 | 4.11 | 4.03 | 4.10 | 452 200 | 1 854 010 |
| Friday, 12 November 2021 | 4.11 | 4.01 | 4.11 | 462 630 | 1 901 420 |
| Thursday, 11 November 2021 | 4.15 | 4.00 | 4.09 | 622 270 | 2 545 080 |
| Wednesday, 10 November 2021 | 4.31 | 4.13 | 4.15 | 151 350 | 628 100 |
| Tuesday, 9 November 2021 | 4.41 | 4.19 | 4.31 | 1 346 230 | 5 802 260 |
| Monday, 8 November 2021 | 4.28 | 3.97 | 4.25 | 1 348 010 | 5 729 040 |
| Friday, 5 November 2021 | 4.02 | 3.94 | 3.99 | 456 670 | 1 822 120 |
| Thursday, 4 November 2021 | 3.99 | 3.96 | 3.98 | 230 910 | 919 010 |
| Wednesday, 3 November 2021 | 3.98 | 3.90 | 3.90 | 2 287 060 | 8 919 530 |
| Tuesday, 2 November 2021 | 4.00 | 3.90 | 3.90 | 4 184 320 | 16 318 850 |
| Monday, 1 November 2021 | – | – | – | – | – |
| Friday, 29 October 2021 | 3.98 | 3.85 | 3.98 | 389 210 | 1 549 060 |
| Thursday, 28 October 2021 | 3.90 | 3.85 | 3.88 | 303 130 | 1 176 140 |
| Wednesday, 27 October 2021 | 4.04 | 3.85 | 3.86 | 248 230 | 958 150 |
| Tuesday, 26 October 2021 | 4.08 | 3.55 | 3.80 | 351 760 | 1 336 700 |
| Monday, 25 October 2021 | 4.10 | 4.05 | 4.05 | 128 620 | 520 920 |
| Friday, 22 October 2021 | 4.12 | 3.95 | 4.12 | 832 850 | 3 431 350 |
| Thursday, 21 October 2021 | 4.07 | 3.93 | 4.07 | 212 180 | 863 580 |
| Wednesday, 20 October 2021 | 4.14 | 4.06 | 4.13 | 1 029 400 | 4 251 440 |
| Tuesday, 19 October 2021 | 4.13 | 4.05 | 4.13 | 185 140 | 764 630 |
| Monday, 18 October 2021 | 4.11 | 4.02 | 4.06 | 148 110 | 601 310 |
| Friday, 15 October 2021 | 4.07 | 4.06 | 4.06 | 180 300 | 732 030 |
| Thursday, 14 October 2021 | 4.07 | 4.06 | 4.07 | 1 296 290 | 5 275 900 |
| Wednesday, 13 October 2021 | 4.14 | 4.01 | 4.05 | 49 840 | 201 850 |
| Tuesday, 12 October 2021 | 4.08 | 4.03 | 4.03 | 757 160 | 3 051 340 |
Source: S&P Capital IQ
Period High Low Close Volume Value Traded (R) (cents) (cents) (cents) Monthly 2021 October 2.10 1.95 1.95 14 908 310 29 984 680 September 2.10 1.75 2.10 13 024 250 26 427 590 August 1.92 1.75 1.75 9 060 530 16 660 100 July 1.95 1.65 1.75 18 041 080 32 692 840 June 1.95 1.80 1.89 36 288 710 67 171 920 May 1.98 1.80 1.88 61 617 500 113 874 070 April 2.00 1.78 1.82 12 808 560 23 740 360 March 2.04 1.75 1.99 12 582 950 23 562 020 February 1.90 1.70 1.75 9 881 640 17 437 330 January 1.90 1.67 1.80 3 129 530 5 573 770 2020 December 1.80 1.65 1.77 7 233 020 12 442 390 November 1.70 1.58 1.66 42 968 870 74 148 950 Daily 2021 Monday, 22 November 2021 2.09 2.00 2.06 582 640 1 200 230 Friday, 19 November 2021 2.08 2.01 2.06 745 950 1 536 660 Thursday, 18 November 2021 2.05 2.00 2.01 71 880 144 470 Wednesday, 17 November 2021 2.05 2.02 2.02 109 730 221 650 Tuesday, 16 November 2021 2.08 2.01 2.08 41 060 85 400 Monday, 15 November 2021 2.04 2.00 2.02 103 910 209 890 Friday, 12 November 2021 2.01 2.01 2.01 270 540 Thursday, 11 November 2021 2.01 2.00 2.00 155 570 311 140 Wednesday, 10 November 2021 2.10 2.01 2.01 308 860 620 800 Tuesday, 9 November 2021 2.05 2.00 2.05 293 820 602 320 Monday, 8 November 2021 2.09 1.95 2.03 1 149 020 2 332 510 Friday, 5 November 2021 1.99 1.95 1.95 1 093 440 2 132 210 Thursday, 4 November 2021 1.97 1.95 1.97 25 200 49 640 Wednesday, 3 November 2021 1.97 1.95 1.95 1 658 810 3 234 690 Tuesday, 2 November 2021 1.99 1.92 1.95 3 024 840 5 898 450 Monday, 1 November 2021 – – – – – Friday, 29 October 2021 2.00 1.91 2.00 2 273 500 4 547 000 Thursday, 28 October 2021 1.98 1.97 1.98 113 210 224 150 Wednesday, 27 October 2021 1.98 1.98 1.98 20 000 39 600 Tuesday, 26 October 2021 2.00 1.91 1.97 63 070 124 250 Monday, 25 October 2021 2.00 1.90 2.00 2 806 300 5 612 600 Friday, 22 October 2021 1.99 1.95 1.99 10 500 20 900 Thursday, 21 October 2021 1.96 1.95 1.95 160 830 313 630 Wednesday, 20 October 2021 1.99 1.95 1.95 32 810 63 980 Tuesday, 19 October 2021 2.00 1.90 1.96 207 760 407 200 Monday, 18 October 2021 – – 1.96 – – Friday, 15 October 2021 2.00 1.95 1.96 279 640 548 100 Thursday, 14 October 2021 2.00 1.98 1.98 8 939 560 17 700 340 Wednesday, 13 October 2021 2.00 1.96 2.00 229 080 458 150
Tuesday, 12 October 2021 2.00 1.96 2.00 15 960 31 920
Trading of Fairvest Shares
| MATERIAL RISKS | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A description of the material risks which are specific to the Combined Group, its shareholders and the property sector within which Arrowhead and Fairvest operates are set out below. | |||||
| References to the "Board", the "Company", the "Group" referred to in this Annexure should be interpreted in relation to the Combined Group, being the merged Arrowhead and Fairvest entity post implementation of the Transaction. |
|||||
| Key risk | Severity | Potential impact | Key focus area | Action taken to mitigate risk | Opportunity |
| Macroeconomic outlook |
High | spending and the lasting effect increased arrears and vacancies Increased tenant failures and affecting lease negotiations of the COVID-19 lockdown Continued slow consumer negatively, resulting in and tenant retention bad debts • • |
through vacancies and rental national tenants with strong Solid collections and arrears department, limiting losses balance sheets and proven Strong and effective lease Engage financially sound business models process rates • • • |
Monthly leasing meetings with Monthly arrears meetings with direction on high-risk tenants Executive consideration and Monthly performance the executive team the executive team reporting • • • • |
retention, arrears motivations and asset management reporting Continued focus on tenant |
| Increased cost of funding |
High | Higher cost of funding and a decrease in distributable earnings • |
where beneficial interest rates throughout COVID-19 period Regular interaction with debt debt to manage refinancing debt and swap agreements and staggered maturity of Diversified funding base Proactive refinancing of concentration risk were seen providers • • • |
management to the Board Reporting on treasury |
relationships with funders, and of debt to manage refinancing Explore alternative sources of Continue to stagger maturity Continue regular interaction debt providers strengthens Reducing funding rates on Increased interaction with certain debt facilities with debt providers concentration risk shareholders funding • • • • • |
| 182 | Key risk | Severity | Potential impact | Key focus area | Action taken to mitigate risk | Opportunity |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| with rioting and unrest Political instability |
High | Prolonged closure of properties Decreased investor confidence and tenants unable to trade Damage to properties and Physical injuries asset base • • • • |
Increased security measures Continued monitoring of Insurance policy reviews economic and political landscapes • • • |
Increased security measures Insurance policy reviews communication plan Implement crisis • • • |
Improve stakeholder relationships with communities, government, and law enforcement |
|
| contract the virus and employees, and other Continued outbreaks Occupational health COVID-19 increases service providers to of new variants of become too ill to and safety risk: the risks for operate |
High | to work decreases operational providers falling ill and unable market could impact trading market, or a wary consumer Key employees or service Increasingly ill consumer efficiencies density • • |
health and safety and Department practices at offices and properties with compliance to occupational Reviewing health and safety of Labour requirements |
Employees on rotational shifts Increased health and safety and equipped to work from Regular COVID-19 testing measures implemented at offices and at properties Encouragement to be vaccinated home done • • • • |
Through continued responsible practices and compliance with health and safety regulations, service providers to vaccinate responsible corporate citizen. the Company is considered a Encouraging employees and This boosts stakeholder and to develop herd immunity shareholder confidence • • |
|
| Increased competition and tenant retention |
High | Discounted rental to retain distributable earnings Loss of revenue and Increased vacancies tenants • • • |
Strong broker relationships and function performed in-house a dedicated internal broker Good tenant relationships Full leasing and renewal liaison • • • |
Monthly leasing meetings with Monthly performance the executive team reporting • • |
tenants' reputation and brand, Building strong relationships and make the Company the understand their tenancy Strong relationships with with national retailers to landlord of choice requirements • • |
|
| occupancy for tenants from increased rates, taxes and utilities Rising cost of |
High | Inability of tenants to absorb Increase in rental reversions Increase in our net cost to on renewals, or vacancies the costs income • • • |
Municipal valuation objections building including common Monitoring of utilities per Energy saving initiatives through solar projects to rates adjustments areas • • • |
Internalised annual review of increases in rates and taxes and the need for municipal Energy Management valuation objections Assessments • • |
Installation of smart meters to recovery thereof from tenants Continue to review increases need for municipal valuation monitor accuracy of council Monitoring of utilities and in rates and taxes and the Identifying further solar objections initiatives billings • • • • |
| Key risk | Severity | Potential impact | Key focus area | Action taken to mitigate risk | Opportunity |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Volatility in interest rate risk |
High | earnings and limiting the ability to Increase or volatility of funding cost reducing distributable fund acquisitions growth |
partnerships linked to interest Interest rate fixes and swaps rate as an effective hedge Funding in strategic • • |
management to the Board Reporting on treasury |
Continue to target a fixed debt Strong relationships with funders and shareholders Reduce funding rates on component above 70% certain debt facilities improve trust • • • |
| strong performance of Over-reliance on external service providers |
High | Inaccurate information and risk of misstatements in relation to Reputational risk associated with tenant dissatisfaction Volatility of earnings financial reporting • • • |
Standard Procedures applicable management and information providers are complete and Reviewing and refining the Implementation of checks information from service to property management to monitor and ensure Implement MDA as an integrated property accurate system • • • |
Formal report on the outcome of external audit to the Audit Annual external audit by BDO Monthly performance and Risk Committee reporting • • • |
refine the Company Standard Continuously review and Annual internal audit Procedures • • |
| Climate Change | Medium to High |
Increased heat and drought are Flooding and erosion in coastal resulting in increased wildfires Declining water supplies may areas are additional concerns all linked to climate change impact health due to heat • • • |
awareness though-out the Group Improving and increasing ESG opportunities presented by so as to identity risks and Climate Change |
ESG oversight delegated by the Board to the Social and Ethics Disclosures in alignment with ESG considerations to inform Committee which will report related Financial Disclosures (TCFD) will be implemented footprint and impact on the implementing processes to reduce the Group's carbon comparable and necessary the Task Force on Climate to provide investors with staff members to begin Increased training of strategic decisions environment to the Board information • • • • |
acquisition and/or disposal of ESG considerations could be management could result in Investment in solar, water useful in informing future strategic decisions on the reduction and waste future cost savings properties • • |
| Opportunity Action taken to mitigate risk Key focus area |
Continue to assess mandated and perform extensive due performance can directly asset base (disposals and acquisitions parameters assessment of property impact cash flow and Continued proactive diligence procedures acquisitions) • • Acquisitions approved by the Investment Committee and presented to the Board for approval extensive due diligence procedures Acquisitions assessed against mandated parameters and Increased potential of diminished |
Enhanced technology to improve data security and ease of doing business information technology systems employees on means to identity and awareness campaigns to Continuous assessment of and prevent data breaches technology system which can Implementing an information withstand malware and ransomware attacks Financial and reputational damage |
processes with minimal business Seamless implementation of interruption advisors remain abreast of current Company Secretary, internal legal and future legislation so that the necessary steps may be taken to division together with external All current and future legislation assessed for applicability |
|---|---|---|---|
| Potential impact | returns with sub-optimal investments/acquisitions |
Financial penalties and reputational damage |
|
| Severity | Medium | Medium | Low |
| Key risk | Sub-optimal investments/ acquisitions |
Group's information Unauthorised users gain access to the compromised or information is systems and withheld |
Non-compliance with Legislation and regulations |
CORPORATE GOVERNANCE STATEMENT
1. Introduction
Arrowhead's corporate governance report and Arrowhead's application of the principles of King IV as detailed on pages 29 to 37 and pages 39 to 45, respectively, of Arrowhead's 2020 integrated annual report can be accessed via https://www.arrowheadproperties.co.za/annual-reports.php.
Given that the Transaction is Fairvest-led, and that the proposed executive directors, the majority of the proposed non-executive directors and the majority of the members of the board committees of the Combined Group will comprise Fairvest directors, the corporate governance report as contained in the integrated annual report of Fairvest in respect of the year ended 30 June 2021 forms the basis of the corporate governance statement of the Combined Group post implementation of the Transaction.
Should the Transaction be successful, updates or amendments, if any, to the corporate governance statement in respect of the Combined Group will be contained in the integrated annual report of the Combined Group in respect of the year ending 30 September 2022.
References to "Board", "Directors", the "Company", the "Group", the "Business", the "Memorandum of Incorporation", "Shareholders" and "Financial Year" referred to in the remainder of this Annexure should be interpreted in relation to the Combined Group, being the merged Arrowhead and Fairvest entity post implementation of the Transaction.
2. Application of King IVTM
The Board fully subscribes to the principles of good corporate governance, the principles set out in the King IV™ Report and regards these as fundamentally important to business success and sustainability of the Company. The Group's application register of the King IV™ principles is detailed on the website (https://fairvest.co.za/img/pdf/ Fairvest-King-IV-Application-Register.pdf)
This report is a summary of the Company's corporate governance matters and should be read in conjunction with the King IV™ application register. The company secretary assists with strengthening the Board's effectiveness as well as continually enhancing the corporate governance processes and structures.
3. Roles and responsibilities of the Board
The Board is responsible for the overall strategic direction and leadership of the Company towards the achievement of an ethical culture, good performance, effective control, and legitimacy. The Company is committed to the promotion of good corporate governance and to following the principles of fairness, accountability, responsibility, and transparency as advocated in King IV™. The Board recognises the need to conduct the business of the Group with integrity and in accordance with generally accepted corporate governance practices.
The Board is elected by Shareholders and the Directors are accountable to Shareholders for the governance of the Group. The Board is led by an independent non-executive Chairman, Ndabezinhle Mkhize. The Board charter requires a clear division of responsibilities between the Chairman and the Chief Executive Officer to ensure a balance of power and authority, so that no one individual has unfettered powers of decision making.
The Company's executive directors, Darren Wilder (Chief Executive Officer) and Jacques Kriel (Chief Financial Officer) are involved in the day-to-day operations of the Business and assess strategy, performance, risks and opportunities and key performance areas and report to the Board at least quarterly.
The Company's independent non-executive Directors are appointed to provide an independent perspective with the relevant industry experience and to complement the skills and experience of the executive Directors, assessing strategy, performance, risk, key performance areas and conduct. The independent non-executive Directors are fully independent of management and are free to make their own decisions. They are free from any Business or other relationship which could be seen to materially interfere with the individual's capacity to act in an independent manner. The independence of Directors is assessed at least annually through the Remuneration and Nomination Committee and deliberated at Board level.
4. Appointments to the Board
The Board charter requires there to be a sufficient number of Directors with the appropriate mix and balance of knowledge, skills, qualifications and experience to ensure that the Board is able to carry out its duties and responsibilities.
Appointments to the Board are formal and transparent and are a matter for the Board as a whole, through recommendations from the Remuneration and Nomination Committee. Input from material stakeholders and external references, combined with experience levels, qualifications and skill sets are considered given the Board's requirements at the time before a candidate is submitted for nomination and appointment.
The Board promotes transformation at a Board level and will consider the promotion of diversity attributes as set out in the Broad Board Diversity Policy for any new Board appointments to create a more diverse Board.
Broad diversity of Directors on the Board enables robust debate and ensures that the Board considers the interests of its diverse stakeholders.
5. Rotation of Directors
In line with the current provisions of the Memorandum of Incorporation, one-third of all Directors are required to retire annually at the Company's Annual General Meeting ("AGM") and if eligible, may be re-elected.
6. Broad Board diversity
The Board has approved and adopted the Broad Board Diversity Policy and subscribes to the benefits of diversity on the Board that leads to diverse thinking and deliberations. The elements of diversity included in the Broad Board Diversity Policy include gender, race, culture, age, field of knowledge, skills and experience. The knowledge, skills and experience of the Board members include the following:
- Accounting
- Actuarial science
- Asset and portfolio management
- Business management
- Corporate governance
- Environmental sustainability
- Entrepreneurship and business development
- Engineering
- Financial analysis and stockbroking
- Investment
- Leadership
- Logistics management
- Listed company environment
- Property investment and development
- Retail real estate
- Retail and office leasing
- Strategic financial management
- Stakeholder management
- Regulatory compliance
- Risk management
- Technology and information management
7. Independence
The Board comprises a balance of executive (two Directors) and non-executive Directors (eight Directors), with a majority of Non-Executive Directors (seven Directors) being independent.
The independence of all independent non-executive Directors is assessed on an annual basis with specific focus on the independence of non-executive Directors who have served for more than nine years. Factors which could impact on the independence of Directors are considered, including those contained in King IV™ and the Listings Requirements.
8. Board committees
The Board is assisted in the performance of its duties by four committees, an Audit and Risk Committee, a Remuneration and Nomination Committee, an Investment Committee and a Social and Ethics Committee.
The Board is conscious of the fact that such delegation of duties is not an abdication of the Board members' responsibilities.
The various committees' terms of reference are reviewed annually and have been aligned to the key principles of King IV™. Each of the Board Committees' terms of reference clearly regulates membership and key responsibilities of the respective committees.
8.1 Audit and Risk Committee
Minimum number of Committee meetings to be held in each Financial Year: 4
Composition:
Nozipho Makhoba (Chair)
Khegu Nkuna
Jacob Wiese
Invitees:
The external auditor and executive management attend the meetings by invitation.
The Audit and Risk Committee comprise independent non-executive Directors, and the members are annually nominated by the Board and elected by Shareholders at the AGM. All members satisfied the requirements of section 94(4) of the Companies Act and have the appropriate financial and related qualifications, skills, financial expertise, and experience required to discharge their responsibilities.
Roles and responsibilities
General
The Committee is an independent statutory committee and, in addition to having specific statutory responsibilities to the shareholders in terms of the Companies Act, also assists the Board through advising and making recommendations on financial reporting, risk management and internal financial controls, the external and internal audit functions as well as the statutory and regulatory compliance of the Group.
The Committee has adopted formal terms of reference, delegated to it by the Board of its scope and responsibilities. The Committee follows an annual work plan to ensure all its duties and responsibilities as set out in its terms of reference are dealt with.
Responsibilities of the Committee include:
Audit
- Assisting the Board by providing an objective and independent view on the organisation's finance, accounting and control mechanisms and reporting procedures.
- Providing additional assurance regarding the efficiency and reliability of the financial information used by the Directors in the discharge of their duties.
- Reviewing the effectiveness of the Group's system of internal financial controls and establishing that the Group has appropriate financial reporting procedures and that those procedures are operating and comply, in all material respects, with the requirements of the Companies Act and International Financial Reporting Standards.
- Recommending the reappointment of BDO South Africa as the external auditor at the AGM.
- Reviewing the interim and annual financial statements and the integrated annual report for recommendation to the Board and ensuring compliance with International Financial Reporting Standards, the Listing Requirements and the requirement of the Companies Act.
- Interacting with and review the findings of the external auditors.
Risk
- Risk management is regarded as a key driver for the Company to achieve its strategic objectives and the Committee monitors the significant risks to the Business and strategy.
- Overview of the enhancement of risk management processes, policies and procedures.
- Monitoring the risk management framework adopted by the Group.
External audit
The Committee assesses the independence, expertise and objectivity of BDO South Africa as the external auditor, as well as approves the fees paid to BDO South Africa. The Committee receives confirmation from the external auditor that the partners and staff responsible for the audit comply with all legal and professional requirements with regard to independence. The Committee assesses the key audit matters as presented by BDO South Africa and agree that these items are the most significant for the audit.
The Committee reviews the information detailed in paragraph 22.15(h) of the Listings Requirements in arriving at a conclusion as to whether the external auditor and the engagement audit partner are suitable and have the requisite competence, expertise and experience to discharge their responsibilities.
The Committee intend to recommend BDO South Africa for reappointment as group auditors. The Committee has taken note of the introduction of mandatory audit firm rotation rule effective from 1 April 2023 in terms of which an audit firm may only serve a maximum of 10 years as auditor, with a five-year cooling-off period.
Evaluation of the Chief Financial Officer
The Committee satisfied itself as to the appropriateness of the expertise and experience of the Group's Chief Financial Officer, Jacques Kriel. This is based on the qualifications, levels of experience, continuing professional development, education and the Board's assessment of the financial knowledge of the Chief Financial Officer.
Chief Executive Officer and Chief Financial Officer's responsibility statements
In line with paragraph 3.84(k) of the Listings Requirements the Chief Executive Officer and Chief Financial Officer have confirmed in the Fairvest 2021 integrated annual report:
- the annual financial statements set out on pages 65 to 104 of the Fairvest 2021 integrated annual report, fairly present in all material respects the financial position, financial performance and cash flows of the issuer in terms of IFRS;
- no facts have been omitted or untrue statements made that would make the annual financial statements false or misleading;
- internal financial controls have been put in place to ensure that material information relating to the issuer and its consolidated subsidiaries have been provided to effectively prepare the financial statements of the issuer; and
- the internal financial controls are adequate and effective and can be relied upon in compiling the annual financial statements, having fulfilled our role and function within the combined assurance model pursuant to principle 15 of King IV™. Where we are not satisfied, we have disclosed to the Audit and Risk Committee and the auditor the deficiencies in design and operational effectiveness of the internal financial controls and any fraud that involves directors, and have taken the necessary remedial action.
The above statement required to be made by the Chief Executive Officer and Chief Financial Offer in compliance with paragraph 3.84(k) of the Listings Requirements will be included in the 2021 integrated annual report of Arrowhead and in the 2022 integrated annual report of the Combined Group.
8.2 Remuneration and Nomination Committee
Minimum number of Committee meetings to be held in each Financial Year: 2
Composition:
Louis Andrag (Chair) Jacques du Toit Ndabezinhle Mkhize
Invitees:
The executive Directors will attend meetings by invitation.
The Committee is appointed by the Board and has delegated authority, in accordance with its terms of reference, to review and make decisions regarding the Group's remuneration policies and the implementation thereof.
Due to the size and nature of the Business and the Board, the Remuneration and Nomination Committee is a combined Committee.
Remuneration
- The remuneration approach of the Company is to remunerate fairly, responsibly and transparently to promote the achievement of strategic objectives and positive outcomes in the short, medium, and long term.
- The Company will continue with the independent benchmarking exercise, by Deloitte Consulting, and further work has been requested in this regard.
- Remuneration is steered with the remuneration policy and the responsibility of monitoring remuneration has been delegated to the Committee.
- The current remuneration structure in the Company is regarded as fit for purpose and the Company remains committed to remunerate so as to encourage growth and sustainability of the Business.
Nomination
- The Committee has adopted and approved a Broad Board Diversity Policy and it has been approved by the Board.
- The Company remains committed to achieving enhanced board diversity, especially relating to gender and race representation of the Board over time, in line with its Diversity Policy. The Board is satisfied that its composition reflects an appropriate mix of knowledge, skills, experience and independence.
- The evaluation of the performance of the Board, Committees, Chairman and the Board's individual members is managed through the Committee. There were no areas of material concerns identified during the evaluation process. The Board is committed to continuous improvement with a focus on performance and effectiveness and have identified areas of enhancement to further strengthen the Board.
- The independence of Directors is considered by the Committee.
Voting and shareholder engagement
The Company encourages engagement with Shareholders on remuneration related matters to promote fair and transparent remuneration policies, implementation and reporting. The Remuneration Policy as well as the Implementation Report will be proposed as separate nonbinding advisory resolutions for consideration by Shareholders at the AGM each year.
In the event that 25% or more of Shareholders vote against either the Remuneration Policy or the Implementation Report, or both, at the AGM, the Company will engage with shareholders through dialogue, requesting written submissions or otherwise, in order to address Shareholder concerns, always with due regard to meeting the Company's stated business objectives while being fair and responsible toward both the employees and Shareholders.
8.3 Investment Committee
Minimum number of Committee meetings to be held in each Financial Year: 2
Members:
Ndabezinhle Mkhize (Chair) Jacques du Toit Louis Andrag Jacob Wiese Khegu Nkuna Nozipho Makhoba Arnold Basserabie Darren Wilder Jacques Kriel
The Committee meets when decisions are required to acquire, dispose of or significantly redevelop property assets. A full due diligence is undertaken before any property is considered for acquisition and is circulated to all members of the Committee and Board in advance of meetings. Decisions of the Committee and Board require consensus. The Investment Committee will meet not less than twice in each Financial Year, however, will in addition meet as and when required to approve acquisitions, disposals and other matters falling within its mandate.
8.4 Social and Ethics Committee
Minimum number of Committee meetings to be held in each Financial Year: 2
Members:
Louis Andrag (Chair)
Riaz Kader (Prescribed Officer)
Nadine Smith (Standing Invitee)
In compliance with applicable legislation and regulations, the Company has an established Social and Ethics Committee. The Committee operates independently of management and is free of any organisational impairment. The Committee is governed by formal terms of reference that include the Committee's responsibilities in terms of the Companies Act, the Listings Requirements, King IV™ and its duties as delegated by the Board.
The Social and Ethics Committee assists the Board in monitoring and oversight of matters that include the social, ethics, employment, health and safety, environmental, corporate citizenship, stakeholder relationships and sustainable development of the Group.
The role and responsibilities of the Committee, include, inter alia:
- Monitor the Group's activities relating to social and economic development, stakeholder and consumer relationships, labour and employment issues, and health and safety in accordance with applicable legislation and standards.
- Monitor adherence to corporate citizenship principles and ethical behaviour.
- Ensure the Group's interactions with stakeholders are guided by legislation and regulation.
- Oversee and monitor the B-BBEE strategy of the Company.
9. The Company Secretary
The Company Secretary of the Company is Vicki Turner.
The Board is of the opinion that the Company Secretary is suitably qualified and experienced to carry out her duties as stipulated under section 84 of the Companies Act. The Company Secretary provides Board members with guidance in respect of their statutory duties and ensures that they are up to date on all relevant statutory requirements. All Directors have unfettered access to management and management information, to the advice and services of the Company Secretary and in appropriate circumstances they may seek independent professional advice about the affairs of the Group at the Company's expense.
The Board has reviewed, through discussion and assessment, the qualifications, experience, and competence of Vicki Turner and has noted that the Company Secretary performed all formalities and substantive duties timeously and in an appropriate manner. The Board is satisfied that an arm's length relationship exists.